All language subtitles for Juice.How.Electricity.Explains.The.World.2019.720p.WEBRip.x264.AAC-[YTS.MX]

af Afrikaans
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bn Bengali
bs Bosnian
bg Bulgarian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
da Danish
nl Dutch
en English
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
km Khmer
ko Korean
ku Kurdish (Kurmanji)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Lao
la Latin
lv Latvian
lt Lithuanian
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
ne Nepali
no Norwegian
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt Portuguese Download
pa Punjabi
ro Romanian
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
st Sesotho
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhala
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish Download
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
te Telugu
th Thai
tr Turkish
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu
or Odia (Oriya)
rw Kinyarwanda
tk Turkmen
tt Tatar
ug Uyghur
Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated: 1 00:00:02,000 --> 00:00:07,000 Downloaded from YTS.MX 2 00:00:08,000 --> 00:00:13,000 Official YIFY movies site: YTS.MX 3 00:00:10,401 --> 00:00:13,100 What if I told you all the things we care about 4 00:00:13,143 --> 00:00:16,016 can be tied back to one simple question, 5 00:00:16,668 --> 00:00:18,279 can you turn your lights on in the morning? 6 00:00:28,071 --> 00:00:31,509 Electricity is all around us, but we rarely notice it. 7 00:00:38,342 --> 00:00:40,779 It's something I think about every day. 8 00:00:41,432 --> 00:00:44,087 I'm a numbers guy, when I look at the world 9 00:00:44,131 --> 00:00:45,784 I see stats and spread sheets. 10 00:00:56,665 --> 00:00:58,841 My house is filled with electric stuff. 11 00:00:58,884 --> 00:01:01,061 I have my personal fire cooking device, 12 00:01:01,626 --> 00:01:05,065 a spiffy teapot, a dishwasher, toaster, an oven 13 00:01:05,108 --> 00:01:07,937 and the ultimate gadget, the entirety of the world's 14 00:01:07,980 --> 00:01:10,244 information, and it fits in the palm of my hand. 15 00:01:10,287 --> 00:01:14,117 Nearly everything we touch, almost everything we read, 16 00:01:14,161 --> 00:01:18,339 eat or wear, has in one way or another been electrified. 17 00:01:18,382 --> 00:01:21,037 When I look at my refrigerator, I see a device 18 00:01:21,081 --> 00:01:23,126 that uses more electricity per year 19 00:01:23,170 --> 00:01:25,520 than roughly three billion people. 20 00:01:28,131 --> 00:01:30,568 Having electricity doesn't guarantee wealth, 21 00:01:31,134 --> 00:01:34,050 but not having it almost always means poverty. 22 00:01:39,099 --> 00:01:41,144 I'm Robert Bryce, and the way I see it, 23 00:01:41,840 --> 00:01:44,191 electricity explains the world. 24 00:01:55,854 --> 00:01:57,639 P.G and E presents REDDY, 25 00:01:57,682 --> 00:01:59,293 your tireless household service. 26 00:01:59,336 --> 00:02:00,990 ♪ I wash and dry your clothes 27 00:02:01,033 --> 00:02:02,426 ♪ Play your radios 28 00:02:02,470 --> 00:02:04,820 ♪ I can heat your coffee pot 29 00:02:05,342 --> 00:02:06,604 ♪ I am always there 30 00:02:06,648 --> 00:02:08,128 ♪ With lots of power to spare 31 00:02:08,171 --> 00:02:10,913 ♪ 'Cause I'm Reddy Kilowatt 32 00:02:11,348 --> 00:02:14,134 Remember, just plug in, I'm Reddy. 33 00:02:15,744 --> 00:02:17,398 You know, it's funny how we take things 34 00:02:17,441 --> 00:02:18,834 like electricity for granted. 35 00:02:20,488 --> 00:02:22,185 Electricity is different from every other 36 00:02:22,229 --> 00:02:25,014 form of energy, because, for the first time in history, 37 00:02:25,057 --> 00:02:27,799 we're controlling forces we can't see or feel. 38 00:02:27,843 --> 00:02:30,193 Thanks to the electric grid, we're harnessing the motion 39 00:02:30,237 --> 00:02:32,761 of zillions upon zillions of electrons, 40 00:02:32,804 --> 00:02:34,806 and we can unleash those electrons whenever 41 00:02:34,850 --> 00:02:37,069 and wherever we want. 42 00:02:37,113 --> 00:02:38,897 Hey, wait a minute, Jim, I need some facts. 43 00:02:39,376 --> 00:02:43,946 The national academies of engineering ranked the electric grid 44 00:02:43,989 --> 00:02:46,949 as the most important engineering innovation 45 00:02:46,992 --> 00:02:48,733 of the 20th century. 46 00:02:48,777 --> 00:02:50,779 Not just for a wealthy privileged class, 47 00:02:50,822 --> 00:02:52,302 but for everyone. 48 00:02:52,346 --> 00:02:53,651 Promotional literature 49 00:02:53,695 --> 00:02:55,131 from the '30s and the '40s, 50 00:02:55,175 --> 00:02:57,873 it's all aimed at the woman of the household. 51 00:02:57,916 --> 00:03:00,092 "Make your life easier with an electric washer, 52 00:03:00,136 --> 00:03:01,964 with an electric stove." 53 00:03:02,399 --> 00:03:03,748 Electricity has allowed people 54 00:03:03,792 --> 00:03:05,881 and, in particular, women and girls, 55 00:03:05,924 --> 00:03:08,449 to escape the drudgery of past eras. 56 00:03:08,492 --> 00:03:11,843 It has liberated them from the pump, the stove and the washtub. 57 00:03:12,279 --> 00:03:14,150 Electricity has changed how we communicate, 58 00:03:14,194 --> 00:03:17,022 how we travel and where we live. 59 00:03:17,066 --> 00:03:18,676 Our nation was stirring with new ideas, 60 00:03:18,720 --> 00:03:20,156 new wants, new needs. 61 00:03:21,984 --> 00:03:23,246 Modern life and electricity 62 00:03:23,290 --> 00:03:25,379 are synonymous with one another. 63 00:03:25,422 --> 00:03:28,730 Your refrigerator, your lights, your microwave, 64 00:03:29,296 --> 00:03:31,254 those are all part of the grid. 65 00:03:31,298 --> 00:03:32,908 To realize how much our lives 66 00:03:32,951 --> 00:03:34,823 have changed in just two generations. 67 00:03:35,302 --> 00:03:37,260 It's amazing innovation. 68 00:03:37,304 --> 00:03:40,959 To me it's like a co-creation with nature. 69 00:03:42,222 --> 00:03:43,875 Naturally, we got the sunlight, 70 00:03:44,485 --> 00:03:47,096 but rest of the time it is dark, 71 00:03:47,139 --> 00:03:51,840 but you have co-created, so you have light 24 hours. 72 00:03:56,323 --> 00:03:57,541 Life has been on this planet for about 73 00:03:57,585 --> 00:03:58,629 four and a half billion years, 74 00:03:58,673 --> 00:04:00,065 Homo sapiensfor 75 00:04:00,109 --> 00:04:01,893 maybe half a million years, 76 00:04:01,937 --> 00:04:04,635 civilization only began 40,000 years ago, 77 00:04:04,679 --> 00:04:07,334 humanity advanced through fire and the wheel 78 00:04:07,377 --> 00:04:10,946 and levers and building ships, very, very slowly advancing. 79 00:04:10,989 --> 00:04:16,386 Give me a lever long enough and I can move the world. 80 00:04:16,430 --> 00:04:19,171 And there've really been two major revolutions 81 00:04:19,215 --> 00:04:21,826 that have increased the rate of this change. 82 00:04:21,870 --> 00:04:24,307 First was the industrial revolution with mechanics, 83 00:04:24,351 --> 00:04:27,397 only 150 years ago, human civilization 84 00:04:27,441 --> 00:04:29,007 went under radical transformation. 85 00:04:29,051 --> 00:04:31,445 As grand as that was, that pales in comparison 86 00:04:31,488 --> 00:04:33,316 to the rate of change we've seen 87 00:04:33,360 --> 00:04:35,492 since the emergence of electricity. 88 00:04:36,014 --> 00:04:38,234 Archaeological records show that our hominid 89 00:04:38,278 --> 00:04:42,064 ancestors began using fire about one million years ago. 90 00:04:42,107 --> 00:04:45,981 Fire use became common some 400,000 years ago. 91 00:04:46,851 --> 00:04:48,679 By contrast, we have only been putting 92 00:04:48,723 --> 00:04:51,160 electricity to work since the 1880s. 93 00:04:51,595 --> 00:04:54,903 Therefore, if we could compress the 400,000 years 94 00:04:54,946 --> 00:04:59,081 that humans have been using fire into one 24 hour period, 95 00:04:59,124 --> 00:05:00,778 the electric age would span 96 00:05:00,822 --> 00:05:03,303 only the last 30 seconds before midnight. 97 00:05:05,087 --> 00:05:07,916 Now the rate of change is so fast, 98 00:05:07,959 --> 00:05:10,875 it is very difficult, for even those of us 99 00:05:10,919 --> 00:05:12,399 working within it are trying to track it 100 00:05:12,442 --> 00:05:14,836 and trying to plan it, we are constantly surprised 101 00:05:14,879 --> 00:05:18,405 by how much faster change happens 102 00:05:18,448 --> 00:05:20,407 than we can predict ourselves. 103 00:05:21,103 --> 00:05:22,583 If we're going to talk about electricity, 104 00:05:22,626 --> 00:05:24,628 we should probably start at the beginning. 105 00:05:25,412 --> 00:05:28,502 To do that, we went to the birth place of the electric age. 106 00:05:33,463 --> 00:05:35,378 We're here in lower Manhattan. 107 00:05:35,422 --> 00:05:37,511 It was in this region where Thomas Edison began 108 00:05:37,554 --> 00:05:39,687 the electric age with the first electric grid, 109 00:05:39,730 --> 00:05:41,689 and within a mile of where I'm standing 110 00:05:41,732 --> 00:05:43,125 right here in the battery, 111 00:05:43,168 --> 00:05:46,128 was also the cradle of the skyscraper. 112 00:05:46,171 --> 00:05:48,435 For centuries, humans have built tall structures 113 00:05:48,478 --> 00:05:50,001 like the statue of liberty. 114 00:05:50,437 --> 00:05:52,961 But the electric age fundamentally changed the city. 115 00:05:53,004 --> 00:05:55,050 Just plug in, I'm ready. 116 00:05:55,093 --> 00:05:56,834 As the technology came into being, 117 00:05:56,878 --> 00:06:00,011 it behaved like every other technology. 118 00:06:00,055 --> 00:06:02,013 We had some successful entrepreneurs, 119 00:06:02,449 --> 00:06:06,496 they saw a market, and they started out small. 120 00:06:06,975 --> 00:06:09,630 Edison, he wanted a demonstration plant, 121 00:06:09,673 --> 00:06:11,719 where he's going to supply electric light 122 00:06:11,762 --> 00:06:13,329 to anyone who wants it. And he wanted 123 00:06:13,373 --> 00:06:15,157 to be near Wall Street, because he felt he needed 124 00:06:15,200 --> 00:06:17,333 the bankers on his side. 125 00:06:17,812 --> 00:06:19,640 The first commercial power plant in the United States, 126 00:06:19,683 --> 00:06:22,338 the Pearl Street Station in New York City reached out 127 00:06:22,382 --> 00:06:24,558 and served a small number of customers. 128 00:06:24,601 --> 00:06:26,473 Pearl Street does not make a profit. 129 00:06:26,516 --> 00:06:30,738 And Edison saw that if he were going to be successful, 130 00:06:31,216 --> 00:06:33,305 you need some way to distribute this over a large area, 131 00:06:33,349 --> 00:06:36,483 it's the only way to make it economical for the common user. 132 00:06:36,526 --> 00:06:39,181 Most of us have heard names like Edison, 133 00:06:39,224 --> 00:06:42,663 Tesla and Westinghouse, they were key pioneers, 134 00:06:42,706 --> 00:06:46,057 but Frank Sprague changed the way we use juice. 135 00:06:46,101 --> 00:06:49,234 Before Sprague, electricity was used almost exclusively 136 00:06:49,278 --> 00:06:51,933 for lighting, his innovations forced electric companies 137 00:06:51,976 --> 00:06:53,891 to focus on providing power. 138 00:06:53,935 --> 00:06:57,765 Well, Frank Sprague was a graduate of the Naval Academy, 139 00:06:57,808 --> 00:07:00,115 and the Navy had the first electrical school, 140 00:07:00,158 --> 00:07:02,639 and when Sprague comes into the Edison company, 141 00:07:02,683 --> 00:07:05,468 he immediately starts seeing places for improvement. 142 00:07:05,512 --> 00:07:10,604 Edison doesn't see motors as something that's important. 143 00:07:10,647 --> 00:07:13,041 Sprague comes up with a motor, he needed something efficient, 144 00:07:13,084 --> 00:07:14,608 he needed something compact, 145 00:07:14,651 --> 00:07:16,740 he needed something that was economically viable 146 00:07:16,784 --> 00:07:20,091 and he delivered on all three, he gets Edison's approval. 147 00:07:20,527 --> 00:07:23,225 The Pearl Street plant becomes profitable for the first time, 148 00:07:23,268 --> 00:07:26,097 and that changes the future of electric power, 149 00:07:26,141 --> 00:07:27,708 because the early companies are all called 150 00:07:27,751 --> 00:07:29,971 lighting companies, you go ten years to the future, 151 00:07:30,537 --> 00:07:32,364 they're all power and light companies. 152 00:07:32,408 --> 00:07:34,932 The power customer becomes the most important customer, 153 00:07:34,976 --> 00:07:36,020 not the light customer. 154 00:07:39,763 --> 00:07:42,984 In 1894, Frank Sprague completed the first bank 155 00:07:43,027 --> 00:07:46,030 of electric elevators inside the Postal Telegraph building 156 00:07:46,074 --> 00:07:47,597 at 253 Broadway. 157 00:07:48,642 --> 00:07:51,209 Powered by Sprague's compact electric motors, 158 00:07:51,732 --> 00:07:54,561 those elevators were faster, cheaper and cleaner 159 00:07:54,604 --> 00:07:55,866 than ever before. 160 00:07:56,911 --> 00:07:59,304 Frank Sprague, because of the project 161 00:07:59,348 --> 00:08:02,351 that they posed in Telegraph building at 250 Broadway, 162 00:08:02,394 --> 00:08:07,791 really casts the mold for all future skyscrapers, 163 00:08:07,835 --> 00:08:11,229 large urban buildings or, as you go in any large building 164 00:08:11,273 --> 00:08:13,449 anywhere in the world today, you've got banked elevators, 165 00:08:13,493 --> 00:08:15,277 but this is sort of a new idea. 166 00:08:15,320 --> 00:08:17,932 Basically, height is electrical, 167 00:08:17,975 --> 00:08:21,762 from the time of the caves, 30,000 or 40,000 years ago. 168 00:08:21,805 --> 00:08:23,633 Humanity was essentially flat. 169 00:08:23,677 --> 00:08:25,287 Cities, on the one hand, are old, uh, 170 00:08:25,330 --> 00:08:27,419 Rome 2,000 years ago had a million people. 171 00:08:27,463 --> 00:08:29,639 But, essentially, cities remained the same 172 00:08:30,118 --> 00:08:32,033 for hundreds, thousands of years. 173 00:08:32,076 --> 00:08:34,383 And then, electricity came along, 174 00:08:34,426 --> 00:08:37,517 and suddenly cities had become three-dimensional. 175 00:08:38,126 --> 00:08:41,782 The urge to go skyward that you saw in New York 176 00:08:41,825 --> 00:08:44,741 through the whole 20th century, was a manifestation 177 00:08:44,785 --> 00:08:48,310 of the tremendous amount of concentrated energy. 178 00:08:48,353 --> 00:08:50,573 If you look at the greatest buildings 179 00:08:50,617 --> 00:08:52,662 of the Middle Ages, the cathedrals, 180 00:08:52,706 --> 00:08:54,534 they were small by modern standards. 181 00:08:54,577 --> 00:08:55,926 In the history of architecture there were 182 00:08:55,970 --> 00:08:58,407 symbolic structures which used height 183 00:08:58,450 --> 00:09:01,366 in order to signify their importance, 184 00:09:01,410 --> 00:09:02,890 their spirituality. 185 00:09:03,368 --> 00:09:07,459 But New York, a kind of capital of capitalism 186 00:09:07,503 --> 00:09:11,551 found in the skyscraper, a way to exploit the demand 187 00:09:11,594 --> 00:09:14,597 for central locations and cities, and the ability 188 00:09:14,641 --> 00:09:18,122 to use the elevator in order to go above the normal height 189 00:09:18,166 --> 00:09:20,734 that people feel comfortable to walk upstairs, 190 00:09:20,777 --> 00:09:22,823 which is about five or six stories. 191 00:09:22,866 --> 00:09:24,999 The ability to rise in space, 192 00:09:25,042 --> 00:09:28,176 even 100 feet or 200 feet, which doesn't seem like much, 193 00:09:28,219 --> 00:09:30,308 completely transformed the structure, 194 00:09:30,352 --> 00:09:32,963 the geography, the geometry of cities. 195 00:09:33,007 --> 00:09:35,052 It made possible, office buildings 196 00:09:35,096 --> 00:09:37,011 in which you could have hundreds, 197 00:09:37,054 --> 00:09:39,709 thousands of people working for the same firm. 198 00:09:39,753 --> 00:09:41,798 Hundreds of relays had transferred 199 00:09:41,842 --> 00:09:44,975 10,000 electrical impulses to motivate the cars. 200 00:09:45,019 --> 00:09:47,935 Once you have a tall building, if you look down from space, 201 00:09:47,978 --> 00:09:51,373 you can calculate the watts per square meter 202 00:09:51,416 --> 00:09:53,288 that that building consumes. 203 00:09:53,331 --> 00:09:55,551 The spatial density of the consumption 204 00:09:55,595 --> 00:09:58,206 in a city like New York is extremely high. 205 00:09:58,728 --> 00:10:00,861 And here's the deal, vertical cities reduce 206 00:10:00,904 --> 00:10:02,689 the human footprint on the natural world. 207 00:10:02,732 --> 00:10:05,256 Small footprints are good. 208 00:10:05,300 --> 00:10:07,650 Density, whether it involves energy production, 209 00:10:07,694 --> 00:10:10,610 food production or urban living, is green. 210 00:10:11,088 --> 00:10:14,657 The process of human progress is also a process 211 00:10:14,701 --> 00:10:17,834 of environmental progress in that it's comprised 212 00:10:17,878 --> 00:10:20,184 centrally, of energy transitions. 213 00:10:20,707 --> 00:10:23,405 From energy diffused fuels to energy dense ones. 214 00:10:23,448 --> 00:10:26,321 With electricity being the most important ultimate carrier 215 00:10:26,364 --> 00:10:28,845 of energy for modern societies. 216 00:10:28,889 --> 00:10:31,848 Energy is often referred to as the master resource. 217 00:10:31,892 --> 00:10:34,634 Electricity is the master of the master resources. 218 00:10:35,156 --> 00:10:38,333 Without electricity, you are effectively going back 219 00:10:38,376 --> 00:10:41,075 in time to a world that we have been able 220 00:10:41,118 --> 00:10:43,120 to innovate away from. 221 00:10:43,686 --> 00:10:45,557 There was a point when we were relying heavily 222 00:10:45,601 --> 00:10:49,083 on wooden dung and also horse and carriages in cities, 223 00:10:49,126 --> 00:10:52,086 and cities, just after a while, became unlivable. 224 00:10:52,129 --> 00:10:54,436 You have to understand the energy ladder. 225 00:10:54,479 --> 00:10:58,005 There's a broad pattern for how people become prosperous, 226 00:10:58,048 --> 00:11:00,572 but also how we protect the natural environment. 227 00:11:00,616 --> 00:11:02,574 Cities from my point of view, 228 00:11:02,618 --> 00:11:04,098 as a green, as an environmentalist, 229 00:11:04,141 --> 00:11:06,535 are the salvation of nature. 230 00:11:06,578 --> 00:11:10,017 It's only by concentrating a significant portion 231 00:11:10,060 --> 00:11:13,107 of humanity in livable attractive cities, 232 00:11:13,150 --> 00:11:15,413 that we have the chance to spare the rest of nature 233 00:11:15,457 --> 00:11:18,547 for the lions and the tigers and the eagles. 234 00:11:22,072 --> 00:11:25,249 We know that there are about 1.2 billion people 235 00:11:25,293 --> 00:11:28,470 in the world today who have no access to electricity at all. 236 00:11:28,513 --> 00:11:30,777 What's missing in that statistic is that there are a couple 237 00:11:30,820 --> 00:11:35,782 of billion more whose access to electricity is inadequate, 238 00:11:35,825 --> 00:11:38,480 intermittent, the system doesn't work all the time. 239 00:11:40,395 --> 00:11:42,527 The defining inequality in the world today 240 00:11:42,571 --> 00:11:45,095 is the disparity between the electricity rich 241 00:11:45,139 --> 00:11:48,055 and the electricity poor, what does that mean? 242 00:11:48,098 --> 00:11:50,144 Let's go back to my refrigerator. 243 00:11:50,187 --> 00:11:54,148 It uses about 1,000 kilowatt hours of electricity per year. 244 00:11:54,191 --> 00:11:57,194 By my count, there are about three billion people today 245 00:11:57,238 --> 00:11:58,979 who, on an individual basis, 246 00:11:59,022 --> 00:12:01,590 use less electricity than my fridge. 247 00:12:02,199 --> 00:12:05,376 India, a country as ancient as it is modern. 248 00:12:05,899 --> 00:12:09,250 Moving as history moves across the threshold of the past. 249 00:12:22,829 --> 00:12:25,962 About a third of all Indians live in poverty 250 00:12:26,006 --> 00:12:28,573 and about 300 million of them, a population 251 00:12:28,617 --> 00:12:31,620 nearly the size of the United States, don't have access 252 00:12:31,663 --> 00:12:33,143 to any electricity at all. 253 00:12:46,548 --> 00:12:48,506 When electricity isn't readily available, 254 00:12:48,550 --> 00:12:50,508 people will do whatever it takes 255 00:12:50,552 --> 00:12:52,989 to get it, and that includes theft. 256 00:12:53,903 --> 00:12:58,386 People are using wires to put a hook in the wires 257 00:12:58,429 --> 00:13:01,955 and draw the electricity, that is un-metered supply. 258 00:13:01,998 --> 00:13:03,434 That is theft. 259 00:13:04,348 --> 00:13:07,308 In central Calcutta, where hooking has been going on, 260 00:13:07,351 --> 00:13:09,745 T and C losses, technical and commercial losses. 261 00:13:10,180 --> 00:13:13,836 We have around 11.5% where the national average 262 00:13:13,880 --> 00:13:16,796 is around 40, 45, 50, it's as high as that. 263 00:13:16,839 --> 00:13:18,841 If I can interrupt you and have you repeat that, 264 00:13:18,885 --> 00:13:22,671 because these numbers kind of stagger the mind. 265 00:13:22,714 --> 00:13:26,022 We... our, our loss figures, T and C losses, 266 00:13:26,066 --> 00:13:27,807 technical and commercial losses total, 267 00:13:28,285 --> 00:13:32,246 it's around 11.5%, whereas the national average 268 00:13:32,289 --> 00:13:34,248 is around 40%, 40. 269 00:13:38,208 --> 00:13:40,907 - That's a staggering number. - That's a staggering loss. 270 00:13:47,304 --> 00:13:49,263 So, if you look above me here to the right, 271 00:13:49,306 --> 00:13:51,091 there's some hooks on the electric line 272 00:13:51,134 --> 00:13:52,875 which is, uh, common, 273 00:13:52,919 --> 00:13:54,398 but the locals don't want to talk about it. 274 00:14:07,890 --> 00:14:10,893 It's one of the conundrums of electricity service, 275 00:14:10,937 --> 00:14:13,113 to make electricity available to everyone, 276 00:14:13,156 --> 00:14:16,594 it has to be cheap, but it can't be cheap when the system 277 00:14:16,638 --> 00:14:19,467 lacks integrity, whether it's customers stealing 278 00:14:19,510 --> 00:14:22,818 from the utility or the utility ripping off customers, 279 00:14:22,862 --> 00:14:26,256 integrity is as important to the grid as engineering. 280 00:14:29,129 --> 00:14:32,088 You can have food and not have a modern life. 281 00:14:32,132 --> 00:14:34,090 There are plenty of people who don't have electricity 282 00:14:34,134 --> 00:14:38,225 and have food, but whose standard of living is really 283 00:14:38,268 --> 00:14:40,401 not up to what we would think 284 00:14:40,444 --> 00:14:42,272 of as a modern standard of living. 285 00:14:42,316 --> 00:14:44,971 This is a biomass stove, this is rice straw, 286 00:14:45,014 --> 00:14:48,931 called paddy, and then they feed it into the bottom of the... 287 00:14:48,975 --> 00:14:50,367 - Yeah. - ...the, the pit here and then, 288 00:14:50,411 --> 00:14:51,847 put the pots on the top so this is 289 00:14:52,456 --> 00:14:54,502 uh, just a traditional method of cooking. 290 00:14:55,024 --> 00:14:57,940 There's a methodic correlation found between those people 291 00:14:57,984 --> 00:15:00,856 who are using the conventional biomass for their cooking 292 00:15:00,900 --> 00:15:03,467 and their health, and what happens is that cooking is done 293 00:15:03,511 --> 00:15:06,731 by the women, and that woman actually inhales all 294 00:15:06,775 --> 00:15:08,385 the pollutant during cooking. 295 00:15:08,429 --> 00:15:12,215 Cooking in that environment for four to five hours 296 00:15:12,259 --> 00:15:14,783 has a serious health impact. 297 00:15:14,826 --> 00:15:17,873 Every year in India, more than one million people 298 00:15:17,917 --> 00:15:20,920 die from indoor air pollution, the use of biomass 299 00:15:20,963 --> 00:15:23,966 in cooking causes horrifying damage to human health. 300 00:15:24,010 --> 00:15:25,881 Especially, to that of women and girls. 301 00:15:25,925 --> 00:15:28,840 University of California, Berkeley, professor Kirk Smith 302 00:15:28,884 --> 00:15:31,365 estimates the health impact of cooking with biomass 303 00:15:31,408 --> 00:15:33,889 is akin to burning 400 cigarettes 304 00:15:33,933 --> 00:15:35,847 an hour in your kitchen. 305 00:15:35,891 --> 00:15:38,938 Women take up the brunt of domestic work 306 00:15:39,503 --> 00:15:41,331 and in the absence of electricity, 307 00:15:41,897 --> 00:15:43,943 that domestic work is more difficult, more time 308 00:15:43,986 --> 00:15:45,509 consuming, less productive, 309 00:15:45,553 --> 00:15:48,164 and it's women and girls who deal with it. 310 00:15:48,208 --> 00:15:51,124 The mothers are spending all day long 311 00:15:51,167 --> 00:15:54,257 just doing the basic household chores. 312 00:15:54,301 --> 00:15:55,824 Women and girls are sort of 313 00:15:55,867 --> 00:15:57,869 the managers of household energy, 314 00:15:57,913 --> 00:15:59,741 the way they get that is labor intensive. 315 00:15:59,784 --> 00:16:02,135 Women spend a lot of time fetching firewood 316 00:16:02,178 --> 00:16:04,572 because there's no energy for actual light. 317 00:16:04,615 --> 00:16:07,357 It's, you know, collecting wood, collecting dung. 318 00:16:07,401 --> 00:16:09,664 - Collecting water. - You don't have a fridge, 319 00:16:09,707 --> 00:16:10,926 so you have to cook every evening. 320 00:16:10,970 --> 00:16:13,320 Kitchens are five degrees warmer 321 00:16:13,363 --> 00:16:14,930 when you are cooking there. 322 00:16:14,974 --> 00:16:18,064 Suppose the temperature outside is 35 degrees, 323 00:16:18,107 --> 00:16:19,979 so your kitchen is 40 degrees. 324 00:16:20,022 --> 00:16:22,024 You need air conditioning. 325 00:16:22,068 --> 00:16:24,896 Oftentimes people will talk about energy poverty 326 00:16:24,940 --> 00:16:27,203 in very abstract terms without thinking about, 327 00:16:27,247 --> 00:16:29,727 "Okay, what do we want this energy to achieve 328 00:16:29,771 --> 00:16:32,556 "once people have it?" When you're able to transform the economy 329 00:16:33,035 --> 00:16:36,082 from just being based off of raw materials, 330 00:16:36,125 --> 00:16:38,040 you put women on the path 331 00:16:38,084 --> 00:16:40,782 to participate in an economy that is richer, 332 00:16:40,825 --> 00:16:43,393 in an economy that is more just for women and girls. 333 00:17:08,940 --> 00:17:13,293 And in India, sun is down by 6:00, 6:30, max. 334 00:17:13,336 --> 00:17:16,209 In the summer, your time becomes short 335 00:17:16,252 --> 00:17:19,995 and it's all dark, you can't see anything. 336 00:17:20,517 --> 00:17:23,085 This is an old style kerosene lamp. 337 00:17:23,129 --> 00:17:28,395 This is the centuries old now version of what we use, 338 00:17:28,438 --> 00:17:31,441 and we use LED lights, incandescents, fluorescents, 339 00:17:32,138 --> 00:17:34,705 but in villages like this one, this is what they use here. 340 00:17:37,447 --> 00:17:40,711 If you are absorbed in the dark, 341 00:17:41,408 --> 00:17:43,584 darkness absorbs you too, 342 00:17:44,063 --> 00:17:46,108 so you do not see the light 343 00:17:46,152 --> 00:17:48,328 and you cannot bring the light to others. 344 00:17:48,893 --> 00:17:50,591 Electricity has allowed us to conquer 345 00:17:50,634 --> 00:17:53,072 our oldest foe, darkness. 346 00:17:53,115 --> 00:17:56,292 For millennia, the cost of having well-lit spaces at night 347 00:17:56,336 --> 00:17:59,165 was so high that only the very rich could afford it. 348 00:17:59,687 --> 00:18:02,298 Those well-lit spaces matter more than you think. 349 00:18:02,907 --> 00:18:05,127 A few months before our visit, an elephant invaded 350 00:18:05,171 --> 00:18:07,216 the tiny village of Chargora. 351 00:18:07,260 --> 00:18:10,393 Turns out well-lit spaces help keep unwanted guests 352 00:18:10,437 --> 00:18:12,961 out of the village, when the lights are out and you live 353 00:18:13,004 --> 00:18:15,137 in rural West Bengal, you risk 354 00:18:15,181 --> 00:18:17,487 getting trampled by roaming elephants. 355 00:18:18,271 --> 00:18:20,577 Like my friend Joyashree, I had a moment 356 00:18:20,621 --> 00:18:23,319 in which I finally understood what darkness means. 357 00:18:23,972 --> 00:18:27,323 In the small agricultural settlement of Majalesh Pukur, 358 00:18:27,367 --> 00:18:31,414 located southeast of Calcutta, I met Rehena Jamadar. 359 00:18:31,458 --> 00:18:33,329 So, Rehena, can you tell me how your life is different 360 00:18:33,808 --> 00:18:35,679 with electricity versus before? 361 00:18:39,422 --> 00:18:42,164 She is saying that there is still much to happen. 362 00:18:42,208 --> 00:18:44,166 - Sure. - But at least some help 363 00:18:44,210 --> 00:18:47,865 is happening, so in the home they have entertainment system 364 00:18:47,909 --> 00:18:49,606 and they have the grinding systems, 365 00:18:49,650 --> 00:18:51,391 so things are happening there. 366 00:18:51,434 --> 00:18:53,958 But also your children can read at, at night? 367 00:18:55,830 --> 00:18:58,485 The, the girl goes to college. 368 00:18:58,963 --> 00:19:00,269 But, but could she go to college 369 00:19:00,313 --> 00:19:01,488 when she couldn't read at night? 370 00:19:01,531 --> 00:19:03,011 - No. - No. 371 00:19:03,446 --> 00:19:04,447 - No. - Straight answer is no. 372 00:19:04,491 --> 00:19:06,057 If you had electricity 373 00:19:06,101 --> 00:19:07,494 when you were small, 374 00:19:07,537 --> 00:19:09,060 could you have gone to university? 375 00:19:14,805 --> 00:19:17,156 Yes, she would have gone. 376 00:19:18,287 --> 00:19:20,637 Darkness had kept this gracious and intelligent 377 00:19:20,681 --> 00:19:22,335 woman from achieving something 378 00:19:22,378 --> 00:19:24,511 that she knew was within her grasp. 379 00:19:24,554 --> 00:19:27,253 Here was a person who, had she been born in one of India's 380 00:19:27,296 --> 00:19:30,517 cities instead of Magalesh Pukur, would've gone to college. 381 00:19:31,082 --> 00:19:33,433 With a college education, she could've been a doctor, 382 00:19:33,476 --> 00:19:35,826 a lawyer or maybe a nurse or engineer. 383 00:19:35,870 --> 00:19:38,655 By the time I met Rehena, I knew plenty of facts 384 00:19:38,699 --> 00:19:40,701 and statistics, the average resident of India 385 00:19:40,744 --> 00:19:44,661 uses about 800 kilowatt hours of electricity per year, 386 00:19:44,705 --> 00:19:46,881 which is about a quarter of the global average. 387 00:19:47,360 --> 00:19:50,058 I understood the myriad correlations between electricity, 388 00:19:50,101 --> 00:19:52,626 availability and health and wealth. 389 00:19:53,322 --> 00:19:56,238 But that 15 minute conversation with Rehena and Joyashree 390 00:19:56,282 --> 00:19:57,892 made me see the light. 391 00:20:09,120 --> 00:20:10,209 ...in Accra, 392 00:20:10,687 --> 00:20:12,515 they used to happen quite often. 393 00:20:12,559 --> 00:20:14,778 We grew up in a place in the mountains and it was 394 00:20:14,822 --> 00:20:17,041 normal to us that we're going to have 395 00:20:17,085 --> 00:20:19,566 some yellow electricity and some white electricity. 396 00:20:19,609 --> 00:20:21,132 And I remember I was in the first grade, 397 00:20:21,176 --> 00:20:23,134 I was six, and there was going to be 398 00:20:23,178 --> 00:20:25,093 a pop quiz the next morning. 399 00:20:25,136 --> 00:20:28,052 In our house, we used to have the yellow lights on, 400 00:20:28,096 --> 00:20:29,663 and this indicates that this electricity 401 00:20:29,706 --> 00:20:31,447 is being supplied by the EDL. 402 00:20:33,101 --> 00:20:36,409 So I go home and I'm studying, I'm really excited 403 00:20:36,452 --> 00:20:38,672 but also very nervous, and in the middle 404 00:20:38,715 --> 00:20:40,151 of my study session, the power goes off. 405 00:20:42,284 --> 00:20:44,895 And I began crying inconsolably, because there's no way 406 00:20:44,939 --> 00:20:49,248 I'm going to go finish memorizing this times table 407 00:20:49,291 --> 00:20:50,684 when there's no power. 408 00:20:51,641 --> 00:20:54,644 And then every six hours the lights will go off 409 00:20:54,688 --> 00:20:58,431 and then we will turn on the UPS, so we used to communicate 410 00:20:58,474 --> 00:21:01,303 with my, with my father, tell him that, "I need to study now 411 00:21:01,347 --> 00:21:04,219 for the school, shall I study when the yellow lights are on 412 00:21:04,263 --> 00:21:05,873 or when the white lights are on?" 413 00:21:05,916 --> 00:21:08,049 So the white lights, we use them using the UPS, 414 00:21:08,092 --> 00:21:09,311 the fluorescent lamp. 415 00:21:09,355 --> 00:21:11,400 And, uh, my mother got 416 00:21:11,444 --> 00:21:14,534 a kerosene lantern, lit it up for me 417 00:21:14,577 --> 00:21:17,972 and sat by me while I studied my times table, 418 00:21:18,015 --> 00:21:21,454 and I think that was my first recollection of 419 00:21:21,497 --> 00:21:24,370 just how important that basic infrastructure is. 420 00:21:24,413 --> 00:21:27,547 So, to us this was normal, it was like, we lived with it, 421 00:21:27,590 --> 00:21:29,810 that we're going to be having two different types 422 00:21:29,853 --> 00:21:31,855 of power and sometimes we're not going to be having power, 423 00:21:31,899 --> 00:21:34,380 this was normal to us, we didn't know 424 00:21:34,423 --> 00:21:37,557 that, actually, people get 100% electricity. 425 00:21:38,122 --> 00:21:40,908 You know, we have this classic image of someone in a poor village 426 00:21:40,951 --> 00:21:43,389 who finally has light, getting an education. 427 00:21:43,432 --> 00:21:45,216 Let's say there's a, a solar panel on the roof, 428 00:21:45,260 --> 00:21:47,741 it's brought light, and in the evening now, 429 00:21:47,784 --> 00:21:49,873 they can s... they can be safe and they can study. 430 00:21:49,917 --> 00:21:51,571 And then the kid turns 16 and they've got an education. 431 00:21:53,268 --> 00:21:54,269 What are they going to do? 432 00:21:54,704 --> 00:21:56,010 Is our expectation that they... 433 00:21:56,053 --> 00:21:57,707 The extent of their ambition 434 00:21:58,360 --> 00:22:00,667 is to remain a subsistence farmer with an education? 435 00:22:00,710 --> 00:22:03,278 I don't think so, they're going to want a job. 436 00:22:03,322 --> 00:22:05,324 They're going to want to do something clever, become a better farmer, 437 00:22:05,367 --> 00:22:06,847 maybe an agronomic scientist. 438 00:22:06,890 --> 00:22:09,893 When we top out our energy expectations 439 00:22:09,937 --> 00:22:12,200 for the developing world, all we're really saying is, 440 00:22:12,243 --> 00:22:15,464 "We expect that you can have enough energy 441 00:22:16,422 --> 00:22:18,511 to stay poor in a little more comfort... 442 00:22:19,903 --> 00:22:22,689 maybe, and maybe to be educated enough 443 00:22:22,732 --> 00:22:24,168 "to know that you are poor." 444 00:22:24,212 --> 00:22:27,128 Incrementalism is good, but is dangerous 445 00:22:27,171 --> 00:22:30,436 when we view it as the only paradigm, what makes you think 446 00:22:30,479 --> 00:22:33,787 that an African's need for power is inferior 447 00:22:33,830 --> 00:22:35,310 to an American's need for power? 448 00:22:36,920 --> 00:22:38,792 I think that rest of the world 449 00:22:38,835 --> 00:22:41,055 who is enjoying modernity 450 00:22:41,577 --> 00:22:45,015 and we are not allowing others to be modern 451 00:22:45,059 --> 00:22:47,322 is a crime, is a major crime. 452 00:22:47,366 --> 00:22:49,890 Mutual respect for the humanity of people who live 453 00:22:49,933 --> 00:22:52,283 in other continents, that should guide 454 00:22:52,327 --> 00:22:55,069 global energy policy discussions. 455 00:22:55,112 --> 00:22:57,071 Today, billions of people are living 456 00:22:57,114 --> 00:22:58,812 in conditions like those in rural 457 00:22:58,855 --> 00:23:01,205 India and sub-Saharan Africa. 458 00:23:01,249 --> 00:23:04,426 Collectively, those billions make up the low watt world. 459 00:23:04,470 --> 00:23:06,341 Those with intermittent or insufficient 460 00:23:06,385 --> 00:23:08,474 access to electricity. 461 00:23:09,126 --> 00:23:13,435 In 1989, less than 20% of the country had access 462 00:23:13,479 --> 00:23:16,656 to electricity, it was a military government 463 00:23:16,699 --> 00:23:18,440 that had come in power through a coup d'etat, 464 00:23:18,962 --> 00:23:22,531 and the government decided that by the year 2020, 465 00:23:23,010 --> 00:23:25,839 everyone in this country will have power. 466 00:23:25,882 --> 00:23:28,842 Ghana transitioned into democratic rule in '92 467 00:23:28,885 --> 00:23:31,627 and every government that has come since then 468 00:23:31,671 --> 00:23:35,457 has stayed on the promise of universal electricity access. 469 00:23:35,501 --> 00:23:38,982 So, now in 2017, access is at 83% in Ghana. 470 00:23:40,723 --> 00:23:43,465 To date, whenever Ghana is about to have elections, 471 00:23:43,509 --> 00:23:46,337 you see a lot of infrastructure projects going up and down 472 00:23:46,381 --> 00:23:49,079 all over the country. So, in this case, democracy has really 473 00:23:49,123 --> 00:23:52,126 been the tool that has propelled the electrification project. 474 00:23:52,909 --> 00:23:55,651 Keeping the electricity flowing day after day, 475 00:23:55,695 --> 00:23:59,350 year after year, requires constant infusions of cash 476 00:23:59,394 --> 00:24:02,092 which is then used to buy fuel, repair wires 477 00:24:02,136 --> 00:24:03,703 and replace poles. 478 00:24:04,094 --> 00:24:06,793 Electricity systems have to pay for themselves. 479 00:24:06,836 --> 00:24:08,751 If there's any kind of leakage, like theft 480 00:24:08,795 --> 00:24:11,058 or corruption, the system fails. 481 00:24:13,060 --> 00:24:15,932 In the year 2050, most of the world's population 482 00:24:15,976 --> 00:24:18,108 will live in Africa or will be African. 483 00:24:18,152 --> 00:24:20,676 How are we going to have a population 484 00:24:21,155 --> 00:24:24,201 of all these bright young minds, if you're not plugged in? 485 00:24:24,245 --> 00:24:25,942 What is going to be their function? 486 00:24:25,986 --> 00:24:28,902 It's a huge demographic crisis staring us in the face. 487 00:24:28,945 --> 00:24:31,774 I think that one of the first things to do now, 488 00:24:31,818 --> 00:24:35,386 to ensure that by 2050, the young Africans on the continent 489 00:24:35,430 --> 00:24:38,215 and around the world, are people who are productive, 490 00:24:38,259 --> 00:24:41,480 self-reliant, empowered, people who will be free 491 00:24:41,523 --> 00:24:45,484 from poverty, we have to plug them in now, it begins now. 492 00:24:47,355 --> 00:24:49,488 While scores of low watt countries around 493 00:24:49,531 --> 00:24:51,925 the globe struggle to bring their people out of the dark 494 00:24:51,968 --> 00:24:54,318 and into the light, the U.S. enjoys 495 00:24:54,362 --> 00:24:56,843 an almost embarrassment of riches. 496 00:24:56,886 --> 00:25:00,542 Electricity abounds, so much so that the high watt world 497 00:25:00,586 --> 00:25:02,675 keeps stumbling into new ways 498 00:25:02,718 --> 00:25:04,851 of using massive amounts of juice. 499 00:26:17,227 --> 00:26:18,315 Take me back to sea level. 500 00:26:22,058 --> 00:26:24,017 Electricity does, in fact, explain the world. 501 00:26:24,060 --> 00:26:25,801 That's why I'm here in Boulder, Colorado. 502 00:26:25,845 --> 00:26:29,239 Arguably, the world capital of legal weed cultivation 503 00:26:29,283 --> 00:26:32,286 and retailing, within about five miles of where I'm standing 504 00:26:32,329 --> 00:26:34,505 here in Chautauqua Park, there are about a dozen 505 00:26:34,549 --> 00:26:37,247 and a half legal weed dispensaries selling brands 506 00:26:37,291 --> 00:26:40,555 like Purple Haze, but to produce Purple Haze 507 00:26:40,599 --> 00:26:42,992 and other brands of cannabis sativa, they are using 508 00:26:43,036 --> 00:26:45,908 lots of electricity, in fact, marijuana cultivation 509 00:26:45,952 --> 00:26:47,867 is the world's single most electricity 510 00:26:47,910 --> 00:26:50,696 intensive agricultural business. 511 00:26:50,739 --> 00:26:52,654 All over this town, entrepreneurs are busy 512 00:26:52,698 --> 00:26:54,700 turning watts into weed. 513 00:27:02,011 --> 00:27:05,667 We're, we're looking for a dispensary. It's not that hard to find them, 514 00:27:05,711 --> 00:27:08,844 but there are about 20 of them in the city 515 00:27:08,888 --> 00:27:11,238 or at least a dozen and a half of them, but, you know, 516 00:27:11,281 --> 00:27:13,196 we're bagging dispensaries. 517 00:27:14,676 --> 00:27:18,027 So to speak, uh, all these buildings, though, have big signs 518 00:27:18,071 --> 00:27:20,551 on them, but the grow operations don't have any signs 519 00:27:20,595 --> 00:27:22,423 and they usually only have the street number. 520 00:27:22,466 --> 00:27:25,818 You just look at the exterior of the building, no signs. 521 00:27:25,861 --> 00:27:28,211 And look at the long electrical conduit lines 522 00:27:28,255 --> 00:27:30,083 that are on the outside, look at the size 523 00:27:30,126 --> 00:27:31,519 of the three phase conduit 524 00:27:31,562 --> 00:27:34,174 going into that gray box, and then how many meters 525 00:27:34,217 --> 00:27:35,828 they've got right behind it. 526 00:27:35,871 --> 00:27:38,526 That's all new conduit on the outside of the building. 527 00:27:38,569 --> 00:27:40,354 Why else would you need that much electricity 528 00:27:40,397 --> 00:27:41,703 in such a nondescript warehouse. 529 00:27:41,747 --> 00:27:43,923 Look at this, this is all brand new. 530 00:27:43,966 --> 00:27:47,230 This is new electrical service, 500 kilovolt amps. 531 00:27:47,274 --> 00:27:49,580 That's a brand new transformer put in just 532 00:27:49,624 --> 00:27:52,671 for a marijuana grow operation in this, in this warehouse. 533 00:27:53,454 --> 00:27:55,804 Marijuana growers don't want people to know they're growing 534 00:27:55,848 --> 00:27:59,199 marijuana, but you know what to look for, you can find them. 535 00:27:59,242 --> 00:28:01,941 It's certainly keeping the energy company busy. 536 00:28:01,984 --> 00:28:04,030 Operating transformers, all sorts of equipment, 537 00:28:04,073 --> 00:28:05,205 upgrades like that that are needed 538 00:28:05,248 --> 00:28:07,424 for high energy use facilities. 539 00:28:07,468 --> 00:28:09,775 Electricity used by the cannabis industry 540 00:28:09,818 --> 00:28:12,821 has been increasing sharply over the past several years. 541 00:28:12,865 --> 00:28:16,085 I believe the average has been about 34% per year. 542 00:28:16,129 --> 00:28:18,653 The electricity intensity of marijuana cultivation 543 00:28:18,697 --> 00:28:21,525 is 23 times that of a hospital 544 00:28:21,569 --> 00:28:24,790 and about 130 times that of an average U.S. residence. 545 00:28:25,355 --> 00:28:26,487 That's a lot of juice. 546 00:28:26,922 --> 00:28:28,663 Want to know the real buzz kill? 547 00:28:28,707 --> 00:28:31,492 About half of Colorado's electricity comes from 548 00:28:31,535 --> 00:28:35,148 coal fired power plants. As a result, Boulder dispensaries 549 00:28:35,191 --> 00:28:37,324 are required by city ordinance, to prove 550 00:28:37,367 --> 00:28:39,805 they're growing polar bear friendly ganja. 551 00:28:40,457 --> 00:28:43,460 Colorado's had a number of different mandates 552 00:28:43,504 --> 00:28:46,550 and opportunities for using renewable technologies. 553 00:28:46,594 --> 00:28:48,465 So, for example, I live in Boulder, 554 00:28:48,509 --> 00:28:50,076 I get my, my electricity 555 00:28:50,119 --> 00:28:53,122 from Xcel Energy, I can pay a little bit more 556 00:28:53,688 --> 00:28:55,385 to have that energy come from wind power. 557 00:28:55,908 --> 00:28:58,475 It's important for a lot of people because of politics 558 00:28:58,519 --> 00:29:00,608 and wealth to be able to feel like you're doing something 559 00:29:00,651 --> 00:29:03,306 environmental while you're living like everyone else does. 560 00:29:03,350 --> 00:29:05,613 It has not led to an appreciable 561 00:29:05,656 --> 00:29:07,789 decarbonization of the Colorado economy. 562 00:29:07,833 --> 00:29:09,965 A lot of the offsetting provisions, 563 00:29:10,009 --> 00:29:11,662 whether it's for the cannabis industry, 564 00:29:11,706 --> 00:29:13,926 for individual homeowners, it's simply accounting. 565 00:29:13,969 --> 00:29:15,710 The number that really matters is, 566 00:29:15,754 --> 00:29:18,626 where does the energy come from. And so long as Colorado 567 00:29:18,669 --> 00:29:21,847 gets 85% of its energy from fossil fuels, 568 00:29:21,890 --> 00:29:25,111 85% of the economic activity in Colorado is from fossil fuels, 569 00:29:25,154 --> 00:29:26,895 no matter which we assign to the 15% 570 00:29:26,939 --> 00:29:28,418 and which we assign to the 85%. 571 00:29:29,071 --> 00:29:33,815 We're going to a black market grower in Denver. 572 00:29:33,859 --> 00:29:36,426 He has decided that it's far easier to operate 573 00:29:36,470 --> 00:29:38,559 in the black market and more profitable 574 00:29:38,602 --> 00:29:41,344 to do it in the black market than in the regulated market. 575 00:29:42,911 --> 00:29:44,478 Okay. 576 00:29:45,131 --> 00:29:46,828 My name is Daniel, I'm currently driving 577 00:29:46,872 --> 00:29:50,179 an Uber and I also grow marijuana. 578 00:29:50,223 --> 00:29:54,618 I was arrested for growing marijuana in 2003 579 00:29:54,662 --> 00:29:57,143 and I received a felony conviction for that. 580 00:29:57,186 --> 00:30:00,320 As a result of that, I'm not allowed to participate 581 00:30:00,363 --> 00:30:02,278 in the legitimate marijuana industry. 582 00:30:02,322 --> 00:30:04,106 If you were going to tell me what are 583 00:30:04,150 --> 00:30:05,978 the three key things you need to know 584 00:30:06,021 --> 00:30:08,458 to set up a clandestine operation. 585 00:30:08,502 --> 00:30:10,896 You have to have buyers for your product, 586 00:30:10,939 --> 00:30:13,507 you need to have good knowledge of botany 587 00:30:13,550 --> 00:30:15,770 and you need to have a good knowledge 588 00:30:15,814 --> 00:30:17,990 of setting up an electrical system 589 00:30:18,033 --> 00:30:19,861 that will support an operation like that. 590 00:30:19,905 --> 00:30:21,994 What about stealing electricity, what about that? 591 00:30:22,037 --> 00:30:23,734 That's something I would never do 592 00:30:23,778 --> 00:30:25,736 because if you are caught doing that, 593 00:30:25,780 --> 00:30:27,434 you're probably going to be in more trouble 594 00:30:27,477 --> 00:30:29,784 for stealing the electricity than you are going to be 595 00:30:29,828 --> 00:30:31,481 in trouble for growing the weed. 596 00:30:31,525 --> 00:30:35,616 They have ways of detecting leakage in electricity, 597 00:30:36,051 --> 00:30:39,750 and they do that by scanning each part of the grid, 598 00:30:39,794 --> 00:30:43,624 periodically. That could bring down the operation in itself. 599 00:30:43,667 --> 00:30:47,019 In 2013, indoor pot farms in Denver 600 00:30:47,062 --> 00:30:50,587 were consuming about 100 gigawatt hours of electricity. 601 00:30:50,631 --> 00:30:52,894 By 2016, that figure had almost 602 00:30:52,938 --> 00:30:56,158 tripled to about 275 gigawatt hours. 603 00:30:56,202 --> 00:30:58,769 To put that in perspective, businesses in Denver 604 00:30:58,813 --> 00:31:02,686 are using nearly as much electricity just to grow weed 605 00:31:02,730 --> 00:31:05,472 as what's consumed by the entire country of Burundi. 606 00:31:06,168 --> 00:31:09,476 Colorado, which had a 2020 target for renewable energy 607 00:31:09,519 --> 00:31:12,305 and emissions reduction, now has a 2025 target, 608 00:31:12,348 --> 00:31:15,221 so we've moved our targets off into the future 609 00:31:15,264 --> 00:31:16,352 because we're not hitting them. 610 00:31:16,396 --> 00:31:17,745 Right now we're working towards 611 00:31:17,788 --> 00:31:20,748 a long-term goal, a very significant goal 612 00:31:20,791 --> 00:31:23,882 of 80% reduction in emissions by 2050. 613 00:31:23,925 --> 00:31:27,233 Obviously, if the emissions from this industry continue 614 00:31:27,276 --> 00:31:31,019 to increase exponentially, that could have a major impact, 615 00:31:31,063 --> 00:31:33,413 but right now we don't think that it is going to 616 00:31:33,456 --> 00:31:35,371 cause us to be derailed from our goal. 617 00:31:36,851 --> 00:31:39,245 To be sure, it's easy to snicker at the amount 618 00:31:39,288 --> 00:31:41,290 of electricity needed to grow marijuana, 619 00:31:41,856 --> 00:31:44,511 but the fact that people in rich countries are using electricity 620 00:31:44,554 --> 00:31:47,949 to grow cannabis while people in poor ones are stealing it 621 00:31:47,993 --> 00:31:51,213 solely to survive, provides a stark reminder of the vast 622 00:31:51,257 --> 00:31:54,086 disparity between the people who live high watt lives 623 00:31:54,129 --> 00:31:55,652 and those who live mostly in the dark. 624 00:34:04,781 --> 00:34:06,740 - Keep running. - Keep, keep going... 625 00:34:06,783 --> 00:34:09,221 - So this is, this is normal for... - Now, now you have the problem 626 00:34:09,264 --> 00:34:10,918 that we have here in Puerto Rico. 627 00:34:10,961 --> 00:34:12,615 So, please, keep going if you don't mind 628 00:34:12,659 --> 00:34:14,443 because we'll just ignore the lights 629 00:34:14,487 --> 00:34:15,705 - for now and just keep going. - Yeah, 630 00:34:15,749 --> 00:34:16,880 let's put the batteries on the LEDs. 631 00:34:17,446 --> 00:34:18,795 We just had a black out, 632 00:34:18,839 --> 00:34:20,449 this could be for an hour or two hours, 633 00:34:20,493 --> 00:34:21,668 - could be the rest of the day. - Yeah, 634 00:34:21,711 --> 00:34:23,452 yeah, probably two hours. 635 00:34:23,496 --> 00:34:24,627 - Two hours. - Yeah. 636 00:35:17,376 --> 00:35:19,639 So, right now we're stuck in traffic, 637 00:35:19,682 --> 00:35:23,164 and in the middle of a black out in Puerto Rico. 638 00:35:23,208 --> 00:35:24,992 And, obviously, the lights aren't working 639 00:35:25,035 --> 00:35:27,125 because the electricity is out. 640 00:35:27,168 --> 00:35:29,910 So, you have all these cars trying to merge 641 00:35:29,953 --> 00:35:34,262 through the intersection and it's kind of a, a little 642 00:35:34,306 --> 00:35:36,308 game of chicken about who's going to stop 643 00:35:36,351 --> 00:35:39,049 and who's going to play, and right now I'm winning. 644 00:35:41,835 --> 00:35:44,054 And here's the good part, we're heading 645 00:35:44,751 --> 00:35:47,188 right over there to see the power plant 646 00:35:47,232 --> 00:35:50,017 that is owned by PREPA, that is not working 647 00:35:50,496 --> 00:35:52,933 because no one knows exactly why. 648 00:35:56,458 --> 00:35:58,199 - We're going in this way. - Yeah, 649 00:35:58,243 --> 00:36:00,419 private property, that's... 650 00:36:00,462 --> 00:36:02,464 Hi, we're doing a documentary on the corruption. 651 00:36:02,508 --> 00:36:04,118 Well... 652 00:36:04,162 --> 00:36:05,728 ...yeah, you might have heard. 653 00:36:07,774 --> 00:36:09,210 - This is Robert Bryce, people like him a lot. - Let's not push it. 654 00:36:09,254 --> 00:36:11,125 I'm standing on the Bay of San Juan. 655 00:36:11,169 --> 00:36:13,171 Puerto Rico now has the distinction of having 656 00:36:13,214 --> 00:36:15,738 the longest blackout in American history. 657 00:36:15,782 --> 00:36:20,003 And today, April 18th, 2018, that blackout record 658 00:36:20,047 --> 00:36:23,006 is getting even longer, in fact, the entire island 659 00:36:23,050 --> 00:36:25,835 of Puerto Rico today, is in blackout. 660 00:36:25,879 --> 00:36:29,099 And this power plant behind me, the Palo Seco Power Station, 661 00:36:29,143 --> 00:36:31,798 rated at 600 megawatts, appears to be producing 662 00:36:31,841 --> 00:36:32,973 no electricity at all. 663 00:37:14,362 --> 00:37:17,060 There's still 300,000 people that don't have power. 664 00:37:19,237 --> 00:37:23,023 We are U.S. citizens and we do deserve to have 665 00:37:23,066 --> 00:37:26,287 the same level of support that any U.S. citizen 666 00:37:26,331 --> 00:37:28,071 has anywhere in the world. 667 00:37:42,042 --> 00:37:44,392 There is no production without electricity. 668 00:37:44,436 --> 00:37:47,221 I mean, there is no economic movement 669 00:37:47,265 --> 00:37:49,702 without access to power. 670 00:37:49,745 --> 00:37:52,661 My name is Miguel Colón, I'm the vice president 671 00:37:52,705 --> 00:37:55,795 of Model Offset Printing, we do mostly printing 672 00:37:55,838 --> 00:37:59,407 for our manufacturing industry in Puerto Rico. 673 00:38:00,060 --> 00:38:04,194 The business has been in the family since the last 30 years. 674 00:38:04,717 --> 00:38:07,937 Right after the hurricane, it was like a war zone. 675 00:38:07,981 --> 00:38:10,897 Passage through the roads was difficult 676 00:38:10,940 --> 00:38:13,769 because there was a lot of trees on the roads. 677 00:38:14,248 --> 00:38:17,295 A lot of power posts were on the floor. 678 00:38:17,817 --> 00:38:21,951 It was a total devastation, inside the business 679 00:38:21,995 --> 00:38:25,825 there was a lot of water, a lot of equipment damaged 680 00:38:25,868 --> 00:38:31,178 by the water, our solar infrastructure was gone. 681 00:38:31,221 --> 00:38:35,356 It was messy. We were without electrical power 682 00:38:35,400 --> 00:38:38,664 for about three months, we are still operating 683 00:38:38,707 --> 00:38:43,277 without AC, in... on the whole plant. And before the hurricane 684 00:38:43,321 --> 00:38:48,195 we were paying about 30,000 dollars per month on electricity. 685 00:38:48,630 --> 00:38:51,329 I pay more for the electricity than I do for paper. 686 00:39:01,556 --> 00:39:03,776 I understand time, I understand we're an island, 687 00:39:03,819 --> 00:39:06,953 I understand it takes time to get things here, but does it take 688 00:39:06,996 --> 00:39:09,390 seven months, is there really a plan? 689 00:39:11,000 --> 00:39:12,219 Some people still don't have water. 690 00:39:28,801 --> 00:39:33,327 I cannot envision or imagine living without access to power, 691 00:39:33,371 --> 00:39:36,069 it's like water, it's a necessity. 692 00:41:03,156 --> 00:41:05,506 While visiting with Iris Ortiz and her family, 693 00:41:05,550 --> 00:41:07,900 she shared a story about how one of her daughters 694 00:41:07,943 --> 00:41:10,250 wanted to have her hair done for school pictures. 695 00:41:10,293 --> 00:41:12,078 She was distraught, how could she use 696 00:41:12,121 --> 00:41:14,036 a hair dryer without electricity? 697 00:41:14,080 --> 00:41:17,170 How would she iron her clothes without electricity? 698 00:41:17,213 --> 00:41:20,086 The luxuries we so often take for granted on the mainland 699 00:41:20,129 --> 00:41:23,263 had disappeared, their world had been turned upside down. 700 00:41:23,306 --> 00:41:25,352 They were now living low watt lives 701 00:41:25,395 --> 00:41:27,441 and they're American citizens. 702 00:41:28,268 --> 00:41:29,878 The grid looked like it was being held up 703 00:41:29,922 --> 00:41:31,010 by clothes pins. 704 00:41:32,315 --> 00:41:33,360 Irma comes in, who was our sparring partner, 705 00:41:34,666 --> 00:41:36,842 and, obviously, the grid suffered damage there, 706 00:41:36,885 --> 00:41:38,757 and some of the resources were used, 707 00:41:39,540 --> 00:41:41,673 and two weeks later we get the knock-out punch. 708 00:41:41,716 --> 00:41:44,763 So, the clothes pins were all over the island 709 00:41:45,372 --> 00:41:46,721 and everything just fell apart. 710 00:41:47,200 --> 00:41:50,464 There was a lot of competition for resources. 711 00:41:50,508 --> 00:41:55,382 FEMA came very quickly, but it took control of all 712 00:41:55,425 --> 00:42:00,430 the resources, there was no gas for the whole population. 713 00:42:00,474 --> 00:42:03,172 The gas was for the military and for FEMA. 714 00:42:03,216 --> 00:42:06,132 Drinking water supply was reserved 715 00:42:06,175 --> 00:42:08,047 for the military and for FEMA. 716 00:42:32,245 --> 00:42:35,335 How long do you think New Yorkers 717 00:42:35,378 --> 00:42:37,903 would accept being without power? 718 00:42:40,209 --> 00:42:45,824 A day, a week, a month before you would have massive 719 00:42:47,042 --> 00:42:50,219 demonstrations, there's people here that today 720 00:42:50,263 --> 00:42:51,656 still don't have power. 721 00:42:52,526 --> 00:42:55,398 Seven months after the hurricane. 722 00:42:57,662 --> 00:42:58,576 It is unacceptable. 723 00:43:01,970 --> 00:43:04,190 Two months after our trip to Puerto Rico, 724 00:43:04,233 --> 00:43:07,280 Iris Ortiz sent me an email, "One minute ago 725 00:43:07,323 --> 00:43:08,673 we got electricity to our neighborhood." 726 00:43:08,716 --> 00:43:09,935 She wrote in Spanish: 727 00:43:15,418 --> 00:43:18,204 "Thank you for your prayers, God bless you very much." 728 00:43:19,248 --> 00:43:21,816 I replied touched that she'd shared her family story 729 00:43:21,860 --> 00:43:24,819 with someone who was a stranger only two months prior. 730 00:43:27,648 --> 00:43:30,782 I wrote, "You're going back to the modern world." 731 00:44:58,870 --> 00:45:01,263 We're here in Iceland, at Gullfoss Falls. 732 00:45:01,786 --> 00:45:03,483 As you can see, this country has enormous 733 00:45:03,526 --> 00:45:05,180 hydro power potential. 734 00:45:05,224 --> 00:45:09,054 About 75% of the electricity here comes from hydro. 735 00:45:09,097 --> 00:45:12,057 The other 25% comes from geothermal. 736 00:45:12,100 --> 00:45:14,276 This abundant electricity is attracting industries 737 00:45:14,320 --> 00:45:16,365 from all over the world and, in particular, 738 00:45:16,409 --> 00:45:18,628 data centers and cryptocurrency miners. 739 00:45:32,425 --> 00:45:33,731 You know, the Pirate Party said, 740 00:45:33,774 --> 00:45:35,428 "Just come in, they'll let you in." 741 00:45:35,471 --> 00:45:37,517 You'll find the security situation is not anything 742 00:45:37,560 --> 00:45:39,519 - "like what's on Capitol Hill." - So, this is your left. 743 00:45:39,562 --> 00:45:44,306 From the... 744 00:45:45,133 --> 00:45:46,482 It sure looks way too small 745 00:45:46,526 --> 00:45:48,006 to be the Parliament House. 746 00:45:48,963 --> 00:45:50,922 There are only 330,000 people in this... 747 00:45:50,965 --> 00:45:53,359 No, I got it, but even still. 748 00:45:54,099 --> 00:45:56,928 More than a third of Iceland's citizens live in Reykjavik, 749 00:45:56,971 --> 00:45:59,017 the country's spotless capital city. 750 00:45:59,060 --> 00:46:01,802 It's politically stable and has been for centuries. 751 00:46:01,846 --> 00:46:04,109 In fact, Iceland's Parliament, the Althing, 752 00:46:04,152 --> 00:46:06,372 was founded in 930, making it one 753 00:46:06,415 --> 00:46:08,156 of the world's oldest parliaments. 754 00:46:08,200 --> 00:46:10,463 Among the newest political parties in Iceland 755 00:46:10,506 --> 00:46:13,248 is the Pirate Party, which views itself as something 756 00:46:13,292 --> 00:46:15,207 of a Robin Hood of politics. 757 00:46:15,860 --> 00:46:19,211 The Pirate Party was created to make sure that 758 00:46:19,254 --> 00:46:22,562 Iceland would become a safe haven for freedom of information, 759 00:46:22,605 --> 00:46:24,782 expression and, uh, privacy. 760 00:46:25,391 --> 00:46:27,045 I want transparency. 761 00:46:27,088 --> 00:46:28,873 Taking the power from the powerful 762 00:46:28,916 --> 00:46:30,700 and giving it to the powerless. 763 00:46:30,744 --> 00:46:33,268 I created the Pirate Party to make sure that these laws 764 00:46:33,312 --> 00:46:35,140 would be written and implemented, 765 00:46:35,183 --> 00:46:38,883 and Iceland could resurrect as a Switzerland of bits. 766 00:46:38,926 --> 00:46:41,320 A digital safe haven where you could host, 767 00:46:41,363 --> 00:46:43,191 among other things, all the forbidden 768 00:46:43,235 --> 00:46:44,453 knowledge in our world. 769 00:46:44,976 --> 00:46:47,108 This vision is responsible for a lot 770 00:46:47,152 --> 00:46:48,849 of the data centers in Iceland. 771 00:47:10,349 --> 00:47:11,480 Um. 772 00:47:12,873 --> 00:47:15,658 Electricity and money are becoming the same thing. 773 00:47:16,181 --> 00:47:18,270 The transfer of money is the transfer of information. 774 00:47:18,313 --> 00:47:21,882 Money is constantly becoming more and more electrified. 775 00:47:21,926 --> 00:47:24,102 When you have cheap electricity available, 776 00:47:24,145 --> 00:47:25,755 you can turn it into money. 777 00:47:25,799 --> 00:47:28,584 That's why we need stable electricity, 778 00:47:28,628 --> 00:47:30,935 stable power supply, reliable partners 779 00:47:30,978 --> 00:47:32,458 like we have here in Iceland. 780 00:47:32,501 --> 00:47:34,242 We are seeing cryptocurrency 781 00:47:34,286 --> 00:47:36,462 disrupt the financial industry, 782 00:47:36,505 --> 00:47:39,378 or at least gaining a lot of traction. 783 00:47:39,421 --> 00:47:42,685 Banks have, for many years, been trading currency 784 00:47:42,729 --> 00:47:44,687 only electronically, when you store your money in the bank, 785 00:47:44,731 --> 00:47:46,646 they don't have a vault with cash in it, they just have 786 00:47:46,689 --> 00:47:48,474 a digital register themselves. 787 00:47:48,517 --> 00:47:51,520 One of the reasons I became fascinated with cryptocurrency 788 00:47:51,564 --> 00:47:55,916 was, I heard a story about migrant workers could move money 789 00:47:55,960 --> 00:47:59,267 back to their families without Western Union chipping in 790 00:47:59,311 --> 00:48:00,486 a big chunk of that. 791 00:48:00,529 --> 00:48:02,444 I also became fascinated 792 00:48:02,488 --> 00:48:04,620 by it because I don't want somebody 793 00:48:04,664 --> 00:48:07,232 to have access to every transaction I make. 794 00:48:07,275 --> 00:48:09,974 I don't care if I make normal transactions, 795 00:48:10,017 --> 00:48:12,933 I just don't want anybody to know exactly everything I do. 796 00:48:12,977 --> 00:48:16,806 We have to develop ways to regain our privacy, 797 00:48:16,850 --> 00:48:20,158 and cryptocurrency is certainly one way to do that. 798 00:48:20,201 --> 00:48:22,334 Iceland has some of the strictest privacy laws 799 00:48:22,377 --> 00:48:25,772 in the world, and when you consider their views on privacy 800 00:48:25,815 --> 00:48:29,080 along with a cool climate and cheap, abundant electricity, 801 00:48:29,123 --> 00:48:31,691 it makes perfect sense that Iceland has become a hotbed 802 00:48:31,734 --> 00:48:33,475 of cryptocurrency production. 803 00:48:33,954 --> 00:48:37,218 This is an industry that relies on high tensity 804 00:48:37,262 --> 00:48:40,004 with their infrastructure that is consuming a lot of energy. 805 00:48:40,047 --> 00:48:42,484 Here in Iceland we have free air cooling. 806 00:48:42,528 --> 00:48:47,054 We can rely on the cool air outside to cool down 807 00:48:47,098 --> 00:48:48,708 the servers in our data centers. 808 00:48:49,143 --> 00:48:51,841 Electricity intensity will definitely increase 809 00:48:51,885 --> 00:48:55,367 because it takes more hash power to mine one bitcoin. 810 00:48:55,410 --> 00:48:57,369 The more bitcoins are mined, more difficult 811 00:48:57,412 --> 00:48:59,240 it gets to mine one bitcoin. 812 00:48:59,719 --> 00:49:02,678 There are studies and predictions that say that 813 00:49:02,722 --> 00:49:05,464 the bitcoin network is going to consume 814 00:49:05,507 --> 00:49:08,989 as much power as Denmark in 2020. 815 00:49:09,033 --> 00:49:12,036 The deployed power behind that is massive. 816 00:49:21,306 --> 00:49:23,482 So, you've been your whole career with HS Orka then? 817 00:49:23,961 --> 00:49:25,571 Not the whole career, no. 818 00:49:26,180 --> 00:49:29,575 I've been here for around... or with HS Orka 819 00:49:29,618 --> 00:49:31,229 - for almost ten years. - I see. 820 00:49:32,056 --> 00:49:33,405 In terms of electricity, then, 821 00:49:33,448 --> 00:49:35,885 for all the geothermal 822 00:49:35,929 --> 00:49:38,018 in Iceland, about how much is produced here? 823 00:49:38,062 --> 00:49:42,544 We are producing, in total, 175 megabytes. 824 00:49:42,588 --> 00:49:44,851 Iceland has gone from undeveloped to developed. 825 00:49:44,894 --> 00:49:47,375 I've also been to Africa, to Ethiopia 826 00:49:47,419 --> 00:49:49,377 where, where they have very unstable electricity 827 00:49:49,421 --> 00:49:50,552 and you could see it. 828 00:49:51,075 --> 00:49:53,555 Where we were 50 years ago. 829 00:49:54,034 --> 00:49:55,601 So it's really only 50 years 830 00:49:55,644 --> 00:49:57,646 that Iceland's gone from completely dependent 831 00:49:57,690 --> 00:49:59,692 - on cod and diesel fuel... - Yeah. 832 00:49:59,735 --> 00:50:02,173 ...to one now where your electricity's all renewable. 833 00:50:02,216 --> 00:50:03,478 - Yeah. - And you're attracting 834 00:50:03,522 --> 00:50:04,523 industry from all over the world. 835 00:50:04,566 --> 00:50:05,654 Yeah. 836 00:50:06,133 --> 00:50:07,091 It's a simple question, 837 00:50:07,134 --> 00:50:08,092 what does electricity mean? 838 00:50:09,963 --> 00:50:10,877 Technology. 839 00:50:11,312 --> 00:50:12,139 Technology? 840 00:50:13,836 --> 00:50:14,837 Innovation 841 00:50:16,013 --> 00:50:18,798 and higher standards for living people. 842 00:50:19,494 --> 00:50:21,801 The evolution of Iceland's economy was due, 843 00:50:21,844 --> 00:50:24,673 in large part, to its ability to tap into its natural 844 00:50:24,717 --> 00:50:27,763 resources, like, geothermal and hydroelectric power. 845 00:50:27,807 --> 00:50:30,636 Just 50 years ago, the country's main export was cod. 846 00:50:30,679 --> 00:50:33,465 Today, Iceland has the world's highest per capita 847 00:50:33,508 --> 00:50:36,903 electricity consumption, over 53,000 kilowatt hours 848 00:50:36,946 --> 00:50:38,731 per year. And its main exports 849 00:50:38,774 --> 00:50:40,515 are things made with electricity. 850 00:50:40,559 --> 00:50:44,302 For us to survive, much less thrive as humanity, 851 00:50:44,345 --> 00:50:49,872 we have got to dramatically step up the energy availability 852 00:50:49,916 --> 00:50:52,049 and the cleanliness of that energy. 853 00:50:52,571 --> 00:50:56,314 Wars are fought over profound disparities 854 00:50:56,357 --> 00:50:59,360 in access to natural resources and access to information, 855 00:50:59,404 --> 00:51:01,971 and almost all of that goes back to the availability 856 00:51:02,015 --> 00:51:03,712 of cheap and plentiful electricity. 857 00:51:29,303 --> 00:51:30,739 Where history began, 858 00:51:30,783 --> 00:51:33,133 history today has made anew. 859 00:51:33,177 --> 00:51:35,788 In lands at once timeless and changing, 860 00:51:36,441 --> 00:51:40,532 fabled and mysterious, yet as sharply real as a headline, 861 00:51:40,575 --> 00:51:42,142 the lands of the Middle East. 862 00:51:54,589 --> 00:51:56,852 It's going to take 10 to 15 minutes to be in the hotel. 863 00:51:56,896 --> 00:51:58,506 - Thank you. - Oh, very welcome. 864 00:51:59,203 --> 00:52:00,421 Where are you coming from? 865 00:52:00,465 --> 00:52:02,858 - Texas. - Texas, America. 866 00:52:04,730 --> 00:52:08,037 I'm American, guys, I'm from Michigan. 867 00:52:08,081 --> 00:52:09,778 - No kidding? - I swear to God. 868 00:52:09,822 --> 00:52:11,389 I've wanted to come here my whole life. 869 00:52:11,432 --> 00:52:14,261 I've heard about Beirut my whole life. 870 00:52:14,305 --> 00:52:16,350 Enjoy then, enjoy, you going to be enjoyed. 871 00:52:31,800 --> 00:52:35,369 For 1975, the state of electric utility in Lebanon 872 00:52:35,413 --> 00:52:38,024 was so good that they were selling electricity to Syria. 873 00:52:38,067 --> 00:52:39,591 We didn't have any shortage, we didn't have 874 00:52:39,634 --> 00:52:41,201 any problem with the quality. 875 00:52:41,245 --> 00:52:43,464 And during the war, things started deteriorating. 876 00:52:44,857 --> 00:52:47,120 Stuck in the world's toughest neighborhood, 877 00:52:47,164 --> 00:52:50,079 Lebanon was once the crown jewel of the region. 878 00:52:50,123 --> 00:52:52,212 Its capital, Beirut, was called 879 00:52:52,256 --> 00:52:54,083 the Paris of the Middle East. 880 00:52:54,606 --> 00:52:57,522 But a 15 year civil war coupled with constant skirmishes 881 00:52:57,565 --> 00:52:59,567 with its neighbors, has left ordinary 882 00:52:59,611 --> 00:53:02,440 Lebanese living low watt lives. 883 00:53:02,483 --> 00:53:05,312 They were bombing roads, they were bombing, eh, power plants, 884 00:53:05,356 --> 00:53:08,359 so they were trying to break the infrastructure 885 00:53:08,402 --> 00:53:10,796 of the country, break the Lebanese economy 886 00:53:10,839 --> 00:53:14,365 to try, to somehow, make Lebanese give up on their government. 887 00:53:14,408 --> 00:53:17,237 Destroying electric infrastructure is a staple 888 00:53:17,281 --> 00:53:19,935 of modern warfare, the U.S. military bombed power plants 889 00:53:19,979 --> 00:53:23,156 in North Korea, in North Vietnam and in Iraq. 890 00:53:23,200 --> 00:53:25,332 Knocking out electricity supplies is considered 891 00:53:25,376 --> 00:53:28,466 a strategic move, like destroying bridges or roads. 892 00:53:29,031 --> 00:53:31,773 The Israelis were in conflict with Hezbollah 893 00:53:31,817 --> 00:53:34,994 and they actually wanted to penalize the Lebanese people 894 00:53:35,037 --> 00:53:38,519 because Hezbollah was and has been, and I think will continue 895 00:53:38,563 --> 00:53:40,347 to be, part of the Lebanese government. 896 00:53:40,391 --> 00:53:42,436 They are represented in the Parliament, they are represented 897 00:53:42,480 --> 00:53:43,785 in the Cabinet of Ministers. 898 00:53:43,829 --> 00:53:47,485 You have certain factions in this nation 899 00:53:47,528 --> 00:53:50,836 that do not care about the progression of the life 900 00:53:50,879 --> 00:53:52,359 of the ordinary Lebanese citizen. 901 00:53:52,403 --> 00:53:54,231 We lost a lot of, uh, infrastructure 902 00:53:54,753 --> 00:53:56,450 and we haven't recovered yet, 903 00:53:56,494 --> 00:53:58,670 why haven't we recovered? I think because 904 00:53:58,713 --> 00:54:01,020 we had lack of political will. 905 00:54:01,063 --> 00:54:03,762 The one reason in Lebanon that we do not have electricity 906 00:54:03,805 --> 00:54:06,808 is corruption, plain and simple. 907 00:54:06,852 --> 00:54:09,637 In Lebanon, you need to schedule life 908 00:54:09,681 --> 00:54:12,161 depending on electricity, you schedule your shower, 909 00:54:12,205 --> 00:54:15,426 you schedule when your washing machine, your washing time, 910 00:54:15,469 --> 00:54:17,166 you schedule everything depending 911 00:54:17,210 --> 00:54:18,777 on electricity in our daily lives. 912 00:54:18,820 --> 00:54:19,865 Do you pay two electric bills? 913 00:54:19,908 --> 00:54:21,040 As all Lebanese people, 914 00:54:21,083 --> 00:54:22,563 we pay two power electric bills, 915 00:54:22,607 --> 00:54:24,522 we pay one power electric bill to EDL 916 00:54:24,565 --> 00:54:25,958 and you pay like the double of that 917 00:54:26,001 --> 00:54:28,221 to the private generators in general. 918 00:54:28,265 --> 00:54:30,310 Let's be frank of this, so the average Lebanese, 919 00:54:30,354 --> 00:54:33,052 they need electricity, they need power, they don't need 920 00:54:33,095 --> 00:54:35,228 to live in the dark, so they don't care 921 00:54:35,272 --> 00:54:36,708 where this comes from, 922 00:54:37,230 --> 00:54:40,189 we can't live without electricity for 12 hours a day, 923 00:54:40,233 --> 00:54:43,932 so we have to rely on private generators or diesel generators, 924 00:54:43,976 --> 00:54:47,066 and we can't all afford it. So, the idea of having 925 00:54:47,109 --> 00:54:49,416 what we call a neighborhood generator evolved. 926 00:54:49,460 --> 00:54:51,592 Where every powerful person in the neighborhood, 927 00:54:52,071 --> 00:54:55,770 will buy a private generator, produce electricity 928 00:54:55,814 --> 00:54:57,598 and sell electricity to the neighborhood. 929 00:54:58,077 --> 00:55:00,166 That's we call the generator mafia. 930 00:55:00,209 --> 00:55:02,951 Do you know this term, the generator mafia? 931 00:55:03,430 --> 00:55:05,302 100%. 932 00:55:05,345 --> 00:55:07,173 - Um, 100%, yeah. - Everybody knows 933 00:55:07,216 --> 00:55:09,697 - about generator mafia? - Oh, yes, it's the mafia. 934 00:55:10,219 --> 00:55:12,918 They don't want to, to fix the electrical... 935 00:55:12,961 --> 00:55:14,136 They don't want the grid to work. 936 00:55:14,180 --> 00:55:15,312 Exactly. 937 00:55:15,747 --> 00:55:17,792 Because, you know, if they do the work 938 00:55:17,836 --> 00:55:20,012 and they give it to us, 24 hours, 939 00:55:20,055 --> 00:55:21,492 those mafias going to close. 940 00:55:21,535 --> 00:55:23,015 - Yeah. - They not going to make money. 941 00:55:23,058 --> 00:55:24,582 And this business is 942 00:55:24,625 --> 00:55:26,888 a very, it's a very big business, and it's hundreds 943 00:55:26,932 --> 00:55:28,890 and hundreds of billions of dollars. 944 00:55:28,934 --> 00:55:32,459 I don't think they would be happy if this business stops. 945 00:55:32,503 --> 00:55:35,636 Look, I am a positive person, I don't like to call 946 00:55:35,680 --> 00:55:38,639 these mafias, I, I would say 947 00:55:38,683 --> 00:55:42,034 these are companies or business men 948 00:55:42,077 --> 00:55:44,645 that were created by necessity. 949 00:55:44,689 --> 00:55:46,908 If the national utility was supplying electricity, 950 00:55:46,952 --> 00:55:49,171 reliably, 24 hours, this wouldn't have existed. 951 00:55:49,607 --> 00:55:51,565 I live, my parents live in a village, and I know, 952 00:55:51,609 --> 00:55:53,872 without those generators, life would have been 953 00:55:53,915 --> 00:55:55,352 much, much more difficult. 954 00:55:56,135 --> 00:55:58,920 They need the money, they taking the money from the people 955 00:55:58,964 --> 00:56:01,488 just to put in his... their, their pocket, government. 956 00:56:01,532 --> 00:56:03,185 First, the government. 957 00:56:03,229 --> 00:56:05,100 I'm talking about the government in Lebanon. 958 00:56:05,710 --> 00:56:09,975 The mafia, who's the government, the mafia, who's the government. 959 00:56:10,497 --> 00:56:14,936 EDL produces around 20 to 25 cents per kilowatt hour, 960 00:56:14,980 --> 00:56:17,461 and they are selling it around 10 to 11 cents, 961 00:56:17,504 --> 00:56:20,072 so the more they generate, the more they lose. 962 00:56:20,594 --> 00:56:23,423 At the time, the private generators, they generate 963 00:56:23,467 --> 00:56:26,948 at around 20 cents and they sell it around 27 cents. 964 00:56:26,992 --> 00:56:29,342 So, the more they generate, the more they make profit. 965 00:56:29,386 --> 00:56:31,605 So, if you look at this very simple equation, 966 00:56:31,649 --> 00:56:35,000 you would immediately conclude that EDL would lose money 967 00:56:35,043 --> 00:56:37,568 by producing electricity, whereas the private generators 968 00:56:37,611 --> 00:56:40,397 would, would make money by producing electricity so. 969 00:56:42,486 --> 00:56:44,401 Throughout our travels in Lebanon, 970 00:56:44,444 --> 00:56:47,229 I asked people what they thought of the generator mafia. 971 00:56:47,273 --> 00:56:50,363 The best answer, by far, came from an advisor 972 00:56:50,407 --> 00:56:51,799 to the Energy Minister. 973 00:56:52,583 --> 00:56:54,628 He paused for a moment and then replied, 974 00:56:54,672 --> 00:56:58,415 dead serious, "Well, they're not all mafia." 975 00:57:07,859 --> 00:57:10,470 We're here in Jounieh, Lebanon, just north of Beirut. 976 00:57:11,036 --> 00:57:12,994 My right over here is the old power plant. 977 00:57:13,038 --> 00:57:15,910 You can see the big fuel tanks and the old smoke stacks. 978 00:57:15,954 --> 00:57:18,826 It's not operating right now, but if you look over here, 979 00:57:18,870 --> 00:57:20,872 that's one of the Turkish power ships. 980 00:57:20,915 --> 00:57:23,091 Why are they leasing these power plants from the Turks? 981 00:57:23,135 --> 00:57:26,138 Because the power grid here in Lebanon is so fragile, 982 00:57:26,181 --> 00:57:28,401 they can't meet demand with the power generation 983 00:57:28,445 --> 00:57:31,012 stations that they have, so they're leasing them 984 00:57:31,056 --> 00:57:34,146 from the Turks. And what happens if they don't pay the bill? 985 00:57:34,189 --> 00:57:36,888 The Turks just take the power ship and sail back to Turkey. 986 00:57:44,765 --> 00:57:46,506 My name is Mustafa Baalbaki. 987 00:57:46,550 --> 00:57:48,943 I'm 30 years old, software engineer, 988 00:57:48,987 --> 00:57:50,510 living in Beirut, Lebanon. 989 00:57:50,554 --> 00:57:52,860 So, the cool feature of my app, Beirut Electricity, 990 00:57:52,904 --> 00:57:55,515 is that it provides you push notifications 991 00:57:55,559 --> 00:57:57,735 ten minutes ahead of time when the electricity will be off, 992 00:57:57,778 --> 00:58:00,477 so that you can maybe grab that elevator 993 00:58:00,520 --> 00:58:04,219 or just save your work before shutting down your computer. 994 00:58:04,263 --> 00:58:06,918 I'm not fixing the electricity issue here in Lebanon. 995 00:58:06,961 --> 00:58:09,790 I'm just trying to help people to cope with it. 996 00:58:11,270 --> 00:58:15,143 I returned to Lebanon in 2011 after a long career in energy, 997 00:58:15,187 --> 00:58:18,495 and I brought with me a coffee machine that I had purchased 998 00:58:18,538 --> 00:58:22,281 in Canada, and I love that machine because I'm used to it. 999 00:58:22,324 --> 00:58:25,240 It, it, it's fantastic, it grinds you fresh beans 1000 00:58:25,676 --> 00:58:28,417 at exactly at the time where it's brewing the coffee. 1001 00:58:28,461 --> 00:58:30,594 And you can program it to wake you up at seven o'clock 1002 00:58:30,637 --> 00:58:32,770 in the morning. And when I plugged it in Lebanon, 1003 00:58:32,813 --> 00:58:35,076 it woke me up at ten, and I realized they had 1004 00:58:35,120 --> 00:58:36,861 the power cut off three hours the same night. 1005 00:58:36,904 --> 00:58:40,778 My wife that actually I met in Canada, 1006 00:58:40,821 --> 00:58:43,476 she said, "Look, either you solve this problem, or I'm going back." 1007 00:58:43,520 --> 00:58:45,173 So, had to fix it. 1008 00:58:59,448 --> 00:59:01,581 Still going backwards. 1009 00:59:02,843 --> 00:59:04,192 Hey, E24, rock on. 1010 00:59:13,245 --> 00:59:16,422 The reason we are in Lebanon is because it's a great lab. 1011 00:59:16,857 --> 00:59:19,033 The first problem is environment. 1012 00:59:19,077 --> 00:59:22,428 We are breathing our own fumes. 1013 00:59:22,950 --> 00:59:25,518 The second issue is, I know households who are paying 1014 00:59:25,562 --> 00:59:27,607 800 dollars for their mortgage 1015 00:59:27,651 --> 00:59:30,958 and another 700 or 800 dollars for electricity. 1016 00:59:31,002 --> 00:59:34,396 It is overall a catastrophe on both economical 1017 00:59:34,440 --> 00:59:35,876 and environmental aspect. 1018 00:59:36,355 --> 00:59:40,402 The tendency today is for consumers to buy more iPhones, 1019 00:59:40,446 --> 00:59:44,711 more laptops, more ACs, more equipment in general. 1020 00:59:44,755 --> 00:59:46,757 All of those require electricity. 1021 00:59:47,235 --> 00:59:50,021 The infrastructure that every country on the planet has 1022 00:59:50,064 --> 00:59:52,414 is basically fixed, and it takes time. 1023 00:59:52,458 --> 00:59:54,939 And the larger the country, the more time it takes 1024 00:59:54,982 --> 00:59:56,331 to upgrade that infrastructure. 1025 00:59:57,506 --> 00:59:58,769 Micro-grids are the future. 1026 01:00:00,901 --> 01:00:02,860 In spite of Lebanon's many challenges, 1027 01:00:02,903 --> 01:00:06,341 corruption, war and a reliance on diesel generators 1028 01:00:06,385 --> 01:00:09,997 that are both expensive and dirty, along came E24. 1029 01:00:11,085 --> 01:00:14,262 Theirs was a two-fold solution, one part solar, 1030 01:00:14,306 --> 01:00:18,571 Lebanon has plenty of sunshine, and the other part, storage. 1031 01:00:18,615 --> 01:00:22,923 At a resort called, Qirzai, E24 is using lead acid batteries 1032 01:00:22,967 --> 01:00:26,666 designed in Bulgaria and manufactured in India 1033 01:00:26,710 --> 01:00:29,930 to store electricity produced by panels made in China. 1034 01:00:30,409 --> 01:00:33,325 It's a true micro-grid, unplugged from EDL 1035 01:00:33,368 --> 01:00:35,806 and beyond the reach of the generator mafia. 1036 01:00:36,807 --> 01:00:39,374 There's a lot of different sources of clean energy. 1037 01:00:39,810 --> 01:00:41,812 We need to be pursuing all of them. 1038 01:00:41,855 --> 01:00:43,683 There is an idea that, wouldn't it be great 1039 01:00:43,727 --> 01:00:45,990 if we could get the electricity for free? 1040 01:00:46,033 --> 01:00:47,687 Free in terms of its cost, 1041 01:00:47,731 --> 01:00:49,254 free in terms of its environmental impacts. 1042 01:00:49,297 --> 01:00:51,865 The idea of renewable energy 1043 01:00:51,909 --> 01:00:53,388 meets that need for some people, 1044 01:00:53,432 --> 01:00:54,912 because there's sunshine, there's wind. 1045 01:00:54,955 --> 01:00:57,436 We don't have to dirty the world to get that. 1046 01:00:57,479 --> 01:01:00,787 The idea that we can power the world on 100% 1047 01:01:00,831 --> 01:01:03,964 renewables, particularly wind and solar, is powerful 1048 01:01:04,008 --> 01:01:07,664 because it's pure and simple, it's sort of wholesome, 1049 01:01:07,707 --> 01:01:10,754 like your grandma's energy. People see, you know, 1050 01:01:10,797 --> 01:01:13,539 solar panels on a roof and that feels good to them. 1051 01:01:13,582 --> 01:01:16,107 We have to focus on cost, reliability 1052 01:01:16,150 --> 01:01:17,848 and environmental attributes. 1053 01:01:17,891 --> 01:01:22,200 We can't develop a system for decarbonization 1054 01:01:22,243 --> 01:01:23,941 that doesn't accomplish those goals. 1055 01:01:24,332 --> 01:01:25,812 Why do we care about climate change? It's not 1056 01:01:25,856 --> 01:01:27,901 because we care about the number, 1057 01:01:27,945 --> 01:01:31,426 the atmospheric CO2, it's because we're trying to protect 1058 01:01:31,470 --> 01:01:32,863 ourselves and protect the world we have around us 1059 01:01:32,906 --> 01:01:34,734 from the impact of climate change. 1060 01:01:34,778 --> 01:01:37,345 So why in the name of doing that would you flood a river forest? 1061 01:01:37,389 --> 01:01:39,043 Why would you cover the landscape with wind turbines? 1062 01:01:39,086 --> 01:01:41,610 Why would you take sensitive desert area for solar 1063 01:01:41,654 --> 01:01:43,830 if those were the values that we were seeking to protect 1064 01:01:43,874 --> 01:01:46,006 by the low carbon system, why would we go and interfere 1065 01:01:46,050 --> 01:01:48,879 with those values in the name of bringing down carbon? 1066 01:01:49,618 --> 01:01:51,359 One of the defining characteristics of debate 1067 01:01:51,403 --> 01:01:53,361 over energy and climate is, 1068 01:01:53,405 --> 01:01:54,885 it's vitriolic, it's nasty, 1069 01:01:54,928 --> 01:01:56,756 um, people have very strong views, 1070 01:01:56,800 --> 01:01:58,366 they also have very strong beliefs 1071 01:01:58,410 --> 01:01:59,977 that their views are the right ones. 1072 01:02:00,847 --> 01:02:05,156 We want to have broad access to a wide variety of 1073 01:02:05,199 --> 01:02:08,725 energy sources that meet the needs of modern life 1074 01:02:08,768 --> 01:02:12,206 for as much of the world's population as we can achieve, 1075 01:02:12,685 --> 01:02:15,993 cheaply, reliably and with attention paid 1076 01:02:16,036 --> 01:02:18,386 to the environmental impacts of producing their power. 1077 01:02:19,518 --> 01:02:22,869 That's the goal, should renewables be a part of that 1078 01:02:22,913 --> 01:02:25,219 solution, I think the answer is yes. 1079 01:02:25,829 --> 01:02:27,787 And then people start talking about things like, 1080 01:02:27,831 --> 01:02:30,834 "Okay, well, maybe instead of expanding the grid, 1081 01:02:30,877 --> 01:02:32,357 maybe we should give people solar lamps." 1082 01:02:32,400 --> 01:02:33,750 No, it doesn't work that way. 1083 01:02:33,793 --> 01:02:36,013 People are not going to eat solar lamps. 1084 01:02:36,056 --> 01:02:39,364 People are not going to be transformed by solar lamps. 1085 01:02:39,407 --> 01:02:43,324 I think the idea that we can move the entire economy 1086 01:02:43,368 --> 01:02:45,805 to a set of renewable energy resources, 1087 01:02:45,849 --> 01:02:48,286 it's really framing the objective in the wrong way 1088 01:02:48,329 --> 01:02:50,984 because it makes renewables the objective. 1089 01:02:51,680 --> 01:02:54,074 It turns the means into the end itself. 1090 01:02:54,683 --> 01:02:58,470 By creating this brand, renewable, which has put in the same basket, 1091 01:02:58,513 --> 01:03:01,908 a massive hydroelectric dam, a wind turbine 1092 01:03:02,387 --> 01:03:05,172 and a solar PV panel. They're remarkably different ways 1093 01:03:05,216 --> 01:03:07,784 of getting energy, each with respective advantages 1094 01:03:07,827 --> 01:03:10,134 and disadvantages. It's the opposite of what we actually 1095 01:03:10,177 --> 01:03:11,788 want in the system we're trying to provide. 1096 01:03:11,831 --> 01:03:13,702 We're not trying to create something chaotic. 1097 01:03:13,746 --> 01:03:16,053 We're trying to create something stable, predictable, 1098 01:03:16,096 --> 01:03:18,359 that can give people what they want, when they want it 1099 01:03:18,403 --> 01:03:20,797 at a low cost every hour of the year. 1100 01:03:21,449 --> 01:03:23,843 Preferably, you wouldn't do that with something that was driven by the weather. 1101 01:03:26,628 --> 01:03:28,543 If you care about the natural environment, 1102 01:03:28,587 --> 01:03:30,371 you're not going to create a power plant 1103 01:03:30,415 --> 01:03:31,851 that requires 1104 01:03:31,895 --> 01:03:33,984 150 times more land, 1105 01:03:34,027 --> 01:03:35,855 per unit of energy, than a nuclear plant. 1106 01:03:35,899 --> 01:03:40,294 Nuclear power was 50, 60 years ago, thought of as 1107 01:03:40,860 --> 01:03:43,210 our energy future, it was going to provide energy that was too 1108 01:03:43,254 --> 01:03:46,474 cheap to meter, and that everyone would have free energy. 1109 01:03:46,518 --> 01:03:49,303 Nuclear power became perceived as risky, 1110 01:03:49,347 --> 01:03:52,480 and high profile events like Chernobyl and Fukushima have contributed 1111 01:03:52,524 --> 01:03:54,178 to that public perception. 1112 01:03:54,221 --> 01:03:55,483 May I say something? 1113 01:03:55,527 --> 01:03:56,658 Go ahead. 1114 01:03:58,399 --> 01:04:00,053 The energy in the atom is the most 1115 01:04:00,097 --> 01:04:02,664 destructive force the world has ever seen. 1116 01:04:03,448 --> 01:04:05,580 It can also be one of the greatest blessings. 1117 01:04:05,624 --> 01:04:08,018 God has ever given us, which is it to be? 1118 01:04:08,496 --> 01:04:10,847 When people consider environmental protection, 1119 01:04:10,890 --> 01:04:13,240 nuclear energy is likely one of the last things 1120 01:04:13,284 --> 01:04:17,201 to come to mind, it seems divorced from nature. 1121 01:04:17,244 --> 01:04:18,985 I understand that sentiment. 1122 01:04:19,029 --> 01:04:20,465 The first article I ever published 1123 01:04:20,508 --> 01:04:22,336 was an anti-nuclear piece. 1124 01:04:22,380 --> 01:04:25,426 I was in high school, and like many people from that era, 1125 01:04:25,470 --> 01:04:27,820 I associated anything having to do with nuclear 1126 01:04:27,864 --> 01:04:29,822 with the war effort and the military. 1127 01:04:29,866 --> 01:04:32,738 Fear of nuclear, and especially, from environmental 1128 01:04:32,781 --> 01:04:36,133 organizations is really a long standing tradition. 1129 01:04:36,176 --> 01:04:38,918 Most of these environmental organizations really came out 1130 01:04:38,962 --> 01:04:42,356 of anti-war organizations, they benefited a lot 1131 01:04:42,400 --> 01:04:45,925 from conflating nuclear power with nuclear weapons. 1132 01:04:45,969 --> 01:04:48,667 You know, early nuclear designs did come out of the military, 1133 01:04:48,710 --> 01:04:50,364 so I think there's that association for people 1134 01:04:50,408 --> 01:04:53,367 who don't like that big, military industrial complex. 1135 01:04:57,284 --> 01:05:00,200 - So, where we going, Robert? - We're at the Indian Point Energy Center 1136 01:05:00,244 --> 01:05:02,072 in the village of Buchanan, New York. 1137 01:05:02,724 --> 01:05:06,032 This is the largest nuclear plant in the state of New York. 1138 01:05:22,092 --> 01:05:24,007 Today I'm at the Indian Point Energy Center, 1139 01:05:24,050 --> 01:05:26,531 located about 40 miles north of New York City. 1140 01:05:26,574 --> 01:05:29,577 This plant has been operating since 1962 1141 01:05:29,621 --> 01:05:32,929 and today it produces about 25% of all the electricity 1142 01:05:32,972 --> 01:05:34,931 consumed in the city of New York. 1143 01:05:35,453 --> 01:05:37,716 These two reactors behind me produce more than 2,000 1144 01:05:37,759 --> 01:05:39,544 megawatts of electricity. 1145 01:05:40,066 --> 01:05:41,807 The amazing thing about this plant is that is sits on 1146 01:05:41,850 --> 01:05:43,983 about one square kilometer of land. 1147 01:05:44,984 --> 01:05:47,160 As uranium atoms in the nuclear reactor 1148 01:05:47,204 --> 01:05:50,033 disintegrate, tremendous amounts of heat are generated. 1149 01:05:50,511 --> 01:05:52,818 When the heat is transferred to a liquid 1150 01:05:52,861 --> 01:05:54,298 and the liquid has circulated from 1151 01:05:54,341 --> 01:05:55,952 the reactor to a boiler room, 1152 01:05:55,995 --> 01:05:57,736 it can produce steam. 1153 01:05:58,171 --> 01:06:01,218 Steam drives a generator to produce electricity. 1154 01:06:01,740 --> 01:06:04,090 Getting into Indian Point wasn't easy. 1155 01:06:04,134 --> 01:06:06,571 We went through multiple security checkpoints 1156 01:06:06,614 --> 01:06:10,227 and multiple ID checks, but once inside I was, 1157 01:06:10,270 --> 01:06:13,143 as the Brits like to say, gobsmacked. 1158 01:06:13,186 --> 01:06:15,972 I've seen oil fields, coal mines, gas plants, 1159 01:06:16,015 --> 01:06:18,365 hydro plants, refineries and all kinds of factories, 1160 01:06:18,931 --> 01:06:21,064 but Indian Point was an engineering marvel. 1161 01:06:21,542 --> 01:06:23,240 A relic from another era. 1162 01:06:24,110 --> 01:06:26,983 Indian Point covers one square kilometer. 1163 01:06:27,026 --> 01:06:29,768 Replacing its output with wind energy would require 1164 01:06:29,811 --> 01:06:32,814 covering more than 13 hundred square kilometers 1165 01:06:32,858 --> 01:06:34,860 with wind turbines. That's one and half 1166 01:06:34,903 --> 01:06:36,340 times the size of New York City. 1167 01:06:37,950 --> 01:06:40,387 This pad will hold about 75 years' worth 1168 01:06:40,431 --> 01:06:42,041 of nuclear fuel. 1169 01:06:42,085 --> 01:06:43,521 - So, the spent fuel. - Of spent fuel. 1170 01:06:43,564 --> 01:06:45,958 So, in eight decades of reactor years, 1171 01:06:46,002 --> 01:06:47,394 - right? - Right. 1172 01:06:47,438 --> 01:06:48,787 You can fit all of the waste 1173 01:06:48,830 --> 01:06:51,311 from all of that in this area 1174 01:06:51,355 --> 01:06:53,313 which, I don't know, a couple tennis courts, maybe? 1175 01:06:53,357 --> 01:06:55,054 The likelihood of somebody coming along 1176 01:06:55,098 --> 01:06:56,490 and carrying one of these off is... 1177 01:06:56,534 --> 01:06:58,405 It's impossible, each cast weighs 1178 01:06:58,449 --> 01:07:00,712 about 230,000 pounds when loaded. 1179 01:07:04,020 --> 01:07:05,978 You can see our equipment that moves it, it moves 1180 01:07:06,022 --> 01:07:09,329 at about one mile an hour, it's, you know, a tank, basically. 1181 01:07:11,592 --> 01:07:14,204 So, the original plan was for the federal government 1182 01:07:14,247 --> 01:07:18,034 to come in and take that fuel off the hands of the utilities, 1183 01:07:18,077 --> 01:07:20,558 and when the utilities realized that that... that wasn't 1184 01:07:20,601 --> 01:07:23,343 going to happen, they basically invented dry cast storage, 1185 01:07:23,387 --> 01:07:25,432 so they could safely store it on site. 1186 01:07:25,476 --> 01:07:27,652 Just really a political issue about 1187 01:07:27,695 --> 01:07:29,828 what to do with it long-term. 1188 01:07:29,871 --> 01:07:31,656 Indian Point is suffering a fate similar 1189 01:07:31,699 --> 01:07:33,484 to that of many nuclear facilities 1190 01:07:33,527 --> 01:07:36,965 throughout the U.S., premature closure. 1191 01:07:37,009 --> 01:07:40,578 Since 2013, U.S. utilities have closed or announced 1192 01:07:40,621 --> 01:07:43,624 the closure of 15 nuclear power plants. 1193 01:07:44,234 --> 01:07:46,845 In many cases, those reactors including the ones 1194 01:07:46,888 --> 01:07:49,891 at Indian Point, could've obtained license extensions 1195 01:07:49,935 --> 01:07:52,155 that would've allowed them to continue operating 1196 01:07:52,198 --> 01:07:53,591 for decades into the future. 1197 01:08:06,169 --> 01:08:08,867 So, we've been known for many years as the smallest 1198 01:08:08,910 --> 01:08:11,609 municipality with nuclear power plants in it. 1199 01:08:11,652 --> 01:08:14,090 And there's generations of people 1200 01:08:14,133 --> 01:08:15,743 who have worked at that plant, 1201 01:08:15,787 --> 01:08:17,397 continue to work at that plant. 1202 01:08:17,876 --> 01:08:20,531 Entergy is the largest employer here, 1203 01:08:20,574 --> 01:08:22,663 they employ over 1,000 people. 1204 01:08:22,707 --> 01:08:25,623 Our budget in the village Buchanan is approximately 1205 01:08:25,666 --> 01:08:28,104 six million dollars, we're looking at losing half 1206 01:08:28,147 --> 01:08:30,323 of our budget when Entergy closes. 1207 01:08:30,367 --> 01:08:32,934 When you talk about replacing three million dollars 1208 01:08:32,978 --> 01:08:35,720 and replacing 1,000 jobs, 1209 01:08:35,763 --> 01:08:38,723 that's, that's a pretty s... steep hill to climb. 1210 01:08:51,475 --> 01:08:53,738 We're seeing a lot of these nuclear power plants close 1211 01:08:53,781 --> 01:08:56,871 prematurely in the U.S. and almost everywhere, 1212 01:08:56,915 --> 01:08:59,047 when they closed, they're being replaced by natural gas. 1213 01:08:59,091 --> 01:09:00,919 That's the first choice for utilities. 1214 01:09:01,876 --> 01:09:04,140 For Indian Point, they are planning to replace 1215 01:09:04,183 --> 01:09:06,707 the generation from Indian Point with natural gas, 1216 01:09:06,751 --> 01:09:10,798 which is a huge loss for the state of New York, 1217 01:09:10,842 --> 01:09:14,715 because New York has a very ambitious climate target 1218 01:09:14,759 --> 01:09:18,632 to reduce emissions, and Indian Point is about 25% 1219 01:09:18,676 --> 01:09:20,373 of the electricity for New York City. 1220 01:09:20,417 --> 01:09:24,203 So, taking that offline and replacing it with natural gas, 1221 01:09:24,247 --> 01:09:27,206 that's a big step backwards if you're concerned 1222 01:09:27,250 --> 01:09:29,252 about climate and trying to reduce emissions. 1223 01:09:29,295 --> 01:09:32,559 Indian Point is a built system, there are a lot of assets 1224 01:09:32,603 --> 01:09:35,301 that have already been invested in Indian Point. 1225 01:09:35,345 --> 01:09:38,957 It's zero carbon emitting, so if we want to reduce 1226 01:09:39,000 --> 01:09:42,090 carbon emissions in New York City, then we really don't want 1227 01:09:42,134 --> 01:09:45,529 to be removing a source of power 1228 01:09:45,572 --> 01:09:47,270 when it's not emitting carbon. 1229 01:09:47,313 --> 01:09:50,708 I commend reforming the energy vision as a vision, 1230 01:09:50,751 --> 01:09:53,624 as an ambitious plan, Indian Point 1231 01:09:53,667 --> 01:09:55,452 contributes to that vision. 1232 01:09:55,495 --> 01:09:58,368 To me, it just doesn't seem to really make good 1233 01:09:58,411 --> 01:10:00,544 economic or environmental sense. 1234 01:10:01,240 --> 01:10:03,590 It's a premature political decision. 1235 01:10:03,634 --> 01:10:06,550 Reducing carbon emissions, fighting climate change 1236 01:10:06,593 --> 01:10:09,640 is a big challenge, and you don't want to take anything off 1237 01:10:09,683 --> 01:10:12,338 the table, I think we're going to need a lot 1238 01:10:12,382 --> 01:10:15,428 more wind and solar, for sure, but we're also going to need 1239 01:10:15,472 --> 01:10:18,257 a lot more nuclear and a lot more natural gas to replace coal. 1240 01:10:19,780 --> 01:10:21,652 You're either a climate change denier 1241 01:10:21,695 --> 01:10:24,524 or a believer, it's drill baby drill 1242 01:10:24,568 --> 01:10:26,613 or save the spotted owl. 1243 01:10:26,657 --> 01:10:29,137 Like most things in life, especially with something 1244 01:10:29,181 --> 01:10:33,359 as complex as electricity, it just isn't that simple. 1245 01:10:33,838 --> 01:10:36,797 But here's what we know, there are over three billion 1246 01:10:36,841 --> 01:10:40,323 people in the world today without adequate access 1247 01:10:40,366 --> 01:10:43,630 to electricity, in order to empower the low watt world 1248 01:10:43,674 --> 01:10:45,893 and keep up with the ever increasing power demand 1249 01:10:45,937 --> 01:10:49,723 from high watt citizens, we're going to need a lot more juice. 1250 01:10:50,202 --> 01:10:52,030 What's the iron law of climate? 1251 01:10:52,073 --> 01:10:55,120 So, the iron law of climate is based on the idea that... 1252 01:10:55,163 --> 01:10:57,688 There, there's really only two ways that we can reduce emissions. 1253 01:10:57,731 --> 01:10:59,994 One is we could become poorer, 1254 01:11:00,038 --> 01:11:01,692 the other is that we can use technology 1255 01:11:01,735 --> 01:11:04,129 through how we source and use energy. 1256 01:11:04,172 --> 01:11:06,392 The iron law says we're not going to reduce emissions 1257 01:11:06,436 --> 01:11:08,612 by willingly getting poorer, 1258 01:11:08,655 --> 01:11:10,309 rich people aren't going to want to get poorer, 1259 01:11:10,353 --> 01:11:12,268 poor people aren't going to want to get poorer. 1260 01:11:12,311 --> 01:11:15,227 If there's one thing that we can count on, it's that policy makers 1261 01:11:15,271 --> 01:11:18,578 will be rewarded by populations if they make people 1262 01:11:18,622 --> 01:11:21,320 wealthier, so GDP is going to go up, we're doing everything 1263 01:11:21,364 --> 01:11:24,062 we can to try to get richer as nations, as communities, 1264 01:11:24,105 --> 01:11:27,805 as individuals, so if we want to reduce emissions, 1265 01:11:27,848 --> 01:11:30,895 we really have only one place to go, and that's technology. 1266 01:11:35,682 --> 01:11:37,467 I think the reason that nuclear is special is that 1267 01:11:37,510 --> 01:11:40,687 it's the only way to lift everybody out of poverty 1268 01:11:40,731 --> 01:11:42,646 and solve climate change. 1269 01:11:43,168 --> 01:11:45,301 People don't appreciate the quantum of difference. 1270 01:11:45,344 --> 01:11:47,215 We've seen a step up of energy density in the fields 1271 01:11:47,259 --> 01:11:50,131 that we've used today, going from wood to charcoal, 1272 01:11:50,175 --> 01:11:54,919 coal, oil, gas... and then suddenly you step up 1273 01:11:55,398 --> 01:11:59,053 two orders of a magnitude to uranium. 1274 01:11:59,097 --> 01:12:01,273 In a piece of uranium the size of a walnut, 1275 01:12:01,317 --> 01:12:04,058 there's as much potential energy as in the amount 1276 01:12:04,102 --> 01:12:06,670 of coal to fill a 100 car train. 1277 01:12:06,713 --> 01:12:08,585 We're not going to get a better battery than that. 1278 01:12:08,628 --> 01:12:11,370 So, here's the only way to make electricity production 1279 01:12:11,414 --> 01:12:15,069 that contains all of its toxic waste, all of it. 1280 01:12:15,592 --> 01:12:17,376 I was raised in the environmental school of thought 1281 01:12:17,420 --> 01:12:19,160 that was telling me the world was getting worse, 1282 01:12:19,204 --> 01:12:21,554 and then I hit my 30's and started doing my own research 1283 01:12:21,598 --> 01:12:24,078 and realized, actually, on, on so many metrics the world 1284 01:12:24,122 --> 01:12:26,472 has got better, we're just stuck in an energy paradox 1285 01:12:26,516 --> 01:12:29,649 that the energy that's helping us make the world get better 1286 01:12:29,693 --> 01:12:31,956 has this horrible side effect, let's get rid 1287 01:12:31,999 --> 01:12:34,350 of the side effect, let's not get rid of the energy. 1288 01:12:35,176 --> 01:12:38,310 This idea that there's too many people and that we all 1289 01:12:38,354 --> 01:12:42,140 have to reduce our energy consumption, the only people 1290 01:12:42,183 --> 01:12:43,750 in the world who say that are rich people. 1291 01:12:43,794 --> 01:12:45,796 I, I go around the world, I interview small farmers 1292 01:12:45,839 --> 01:12:48,146 everywhere, India, Africa, Latin America, Asia, 1293 01:12:48,189 --> 01:12:50,017 I've never had a small farmer 1294 01:12:50,061 --> 01:12:52,411 tell me that there's too many people and that 1295 01:12:52,455 --> 01:12:56,720 we consume too much, never, you know, um, never had that happen. 1296 01:12:58,069 --> 01:12:59,853 Whenever we think about electricity, 1297 01:12:59,897 --> 01:13:02,421 if we think about it at all, we tend to think 1298 01:13:02,465 --> 01:13:05,990 of it on our own terms, as long as we can flip on 1299 01:13:06,033 --> 01:13:08,819 the air conditioner, charge our phone, watch TV 1300 01:13:08,862 --> 01:13:11,778 and surf the web, we take it for granted. 1301 01:13:11,822 --> 01:13:15,173 Electricity's just there, ever present, invisible, 1302 01:13:15,216 --> 01:13:17,480 making our high watt lives richer. 1303 01:13:18,263 --> 01:13:20,091 That's why we hit the road. 1304 01:13:20,787 --> 01:13:23,486 It's why we traveled over 60,000 miles and interviewed 1305 01:13:23,529 --> 01:13:26,271 more than 50 people over a three-year period. 1306 01:13:26,793 --> 01:13:29,230 We talked to professors and authors, engineers 1307 01:13:29,274 --> 01:13:31,798 and activists, and, of course, to people who grapple 1308 01:13:31,842 --> 01:13:34,453 with electricity poverty on a daily basis. 1309 01:13:35,149 --> 01:13:36,934 Their answers and observations 1310 01:13:36,977 --> 01:13:38,805 were as varied as their backgrounds, 1311 01:13:39,545 --> 01:13:43,114 but they could, on occasion, find common ground. 1312 01:13:43,941 --> 01:13:45,203 What does electricity mean? 1313 01:13:45,246 --> 01:13:47,640 Electricity means prosperity, 1314 01:13:47,684 --> 01:13:50,208 means good life, means business. 1315 01:13:50,251 --> 01:13:52,689 What does electricity mean? I feel like it means life. 1316 01:13:52,732 --> 01:13:54,865 Electricity means opportunity. 1317 01:13:54,908 --> 01:13:57,345 Electricity is the life blood of a modern society. 1318 01:13:57,389 --> 01:14:00,653 Modern society is hooked on electricity. 1319 01:14:00,697 --> 01:14:04,918 If we can't keep our hospitals open, our ventilators going, 1320 01:14:04,962 --> 01:14:08,487 our refrigeration going, it all requires electricity. 1321 01:14:08,531 --> 01:14:11,142 Electricity means you are a human being. 1322 01:14:11,185 --> 01:14:12,926 If you don't have food, you can't live. 1323 01:14:12,970 --> 01:14:14,275 In a modern world, if you don't have 1324 01:14:14,319 --> 01:14:16,060 electricity, you don't have food. 1325 01:14:16,103 --> 01:14:17,627 If you don't have electricity, 1326 01:14:17,670 --> 01:14:19,977 you're cut off from policy making, 1327 01:14:20,020 --> 01:14:22,545 if you are not plugged in, how will you know? 1328 01:14:22,588 --> 01:14:25,504 How will you have mobile money, how will you have a bank account? 1329 01:14:25,548 --> 01:14:28,986 Electricity is like gold to us, without electricity, 1330 01:14:29,552 --> 01:14:32,293 we're nowhere, we go backwards, not forward. 1331 01:14:32,337 --> 01:14:34,121 No human should live on this planet 1332 01:14:34,165 --> 01:14:36,472 without basic access to electricity. 1333 01:14:36,515 --> 01:14:39,518 I see electricity as a basic human right. 1334 01:14:39,562 --> 01:14:42,042 I think people have basic rights, 1335 01:14:42,086 --> 01:14:44,349 rights for water, rights for necessity. 1336 01:14:44,392 --> 01:14:46,351 It should be the universal access, 1337 01:14:46,394 --> 01:14:48,962 everybody at the same level, 1338 01:14:49,006 --> 01:14:51,443 imagine how much more we can do? 1339 01:14:51,487 --> 01:14:53,314 You think about the potential of that. 1340 01:14:53,358 --> 01:14:57,014 When you can marriage dense fuel, particularly electricity 1341 01:14:57,057 --> 01:15:00,104 with human ingenuity, we can do nearly anything. 1342 01:15:01,453 --> 01:15:03,542 As I drove home, I thought about the battles 1343 01:15:03,586 --> 01:15:06,197 that are waged in the name of electricity in the U.S., 1344 01:15:06,240 --> 01:15:08,329 and couldn't help but compare them to what I had seen. 1345 01:15:08,982 --> 01:15:11,898 While we bicker about our favorite electricity sources, 1346 01:15:11,942 --> 01:15:14,205 billions of people are still stuck in the dark. 1347 01:15:15,119 --> 01:15:17,643 Electricity explains the world because everywhere 1348 01:15:17,687 --> 01:15:20,864 we went we saw how the electric grid reflected the society 1349 01:15:20,907 --> 01:15:23,997 it was powering. In Reykjavik, they smelt aluminum 1350 01:15:24,041 --> 01:15:27,000 and mine bitcoin because their electricity's almost free. 1351 01:15:28,088 --> 01:15:30,308 In Beirut, people endure daily blackouts 1352 01:15:30,351 --> 01:15:32,223 because the city's grid has been hobbled 1353 01:15:32,266 --> 01:15:34,573 by endless war and corruption. 1354 01:15:35,052 --> 01:15:37,707 Electricity, or rather, electricity access, 1355 01:15:37,750 --> 01:15:39,056 pits two of the toughest challenges 1356 01:15:39,099 --> 01:15:41,275 of our day against each other. 1357 01:15:41,319 --> 01:15:43,582 Energy poverty versus climate change. 1358 01:15:44,061 --> 01:15:47,238 There is no easy, one size fits all solution. 1359 01:15:47,281 --> 01:15:49,545 The only certainty is that people will do whatever 1360 01:15:49,588 --> 01:15:52,635 they have to do to get the electricity they need. 1361 01:15:52,678 --> 01:15:55,507 The challenge, it's a daunting one, is this. 1362 01:15:56,203 --> 01:15:58,989 We have to double global electricity production 1363 01:15:59,032 --> 01:16:01,687 over the next three decades or so, and we're going to need 1364 01:16:01,731 --> 01:16:05,604 solar, nuclear, coal, gas, geothermal, wind and hydro, 1365 01:16:05,648 --> 01:16:07,693 all of it, to make that happen. 1366 01:16:08,564 --> 01:16:11,523 Governments aren't going to wait around for academics 1367 01:16:11,567 --> 01:16:14,134 to resolve their disputes, people around the world 1368 01:16:14,178 --> 01:16:16,397 are going to demand access to electricity. 1369 01:16:16,441 --> 01:16:18,791 Can we, the developed industrialized world, 1370 01:16:18,835 --> 01:16:20,967 help these countries 1371 01:16:21,011 --> 01:16:24,449 move towards a place of political stability 1372 01:16:24,971 --> 01:16:28,235 and help them along the road to electrification? 1373 01:16:28,279 --> 01:16:30,629 We are spending so much of time, how do we provide 1374 01:16:30,673 --> 01:16:33,110 sanitation, how do you provide... just provide 1375 01:16:33,153 --> 01:16:35,329 electricity and everything will come. 1376 01:16:35,373 --> 01:16:38,942 I think this is a wonderful opportunity to start fresh. 1377 01:16:38,985 --> 01:16:42,815 To look at new ideas, to experiment, I want to be totally 1378 01:16:42,859 --> 01:16:45,644 sustainable, I want to be off the grid, I want to be able 1379 01:16:45,688 --> 01:16:49,735 to take charge of my future and my business 1380 01:16:49,779 --> 01:16:52,172 and not depend on a third person. 1381 01:16:52,216 --> 01:16:56,176 It's both an opportunity, but also an impending challenge, 1382 01:16:56,220 --> 01:16:58,352 and it all goes back to electricity, 1383 01:16:58,396 --> 01:17:02,182 it shouldn't be an either or trade off, we can't afford 1384 01:17:02,226 --> 01:17:05,621 to choose electricity over climate change. 1385 01:17:05,664 --> 01:17:07,187 I mean, the moment we start trying to trade 1386 01:17:07,231 --> 01:17:10,538 these things off, something has to lose. 1387 01:17:10,582 --> 01:17:12,758 If people have a choice between either no energy 1388 01:17:12,802 --> 01:17:14,978 and dirty energy, they will take dirty energy every time. 1389 01:17:15,718 --> 01:17:17,110 By mid-century, 1390 01:17:17,154 --> 01:17:19,722 something, like, 75 to 80% of the world's 1391 01:17:19,765 --> 01:17:23,334 population is going to live in an urban or suburban setting. 1392 01:17:24,465 --> 01:17:28,382 It's going to be populated by people who really 1393 01:17:28,426 --> 01:17:31,211 don't want to have to think about their electricity. 1394 01:17:32,125 --> 01:17:34,388 They want to walk in a room, they want to flip on a light 1395 01:17:34,432 --> 01:17:36,826 and they want the light to work, just like us. 109911

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.