Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:00,071 --> 00:00:03,007
It's hard to explain
how this case made me feel.
2
00:00:04,706 --> 00:00:07,275
It showed me the depths
that people can go
3
00:00:07,309 --> 00:00:09,710
to manipulate others.
4
00:00:09,745 --> 00:00:13,414
And it quickly became one of the
strangest cases of my career.
5
00:00:15,661 --> 00:00:17,995
A lovely mother and daughter come home
6
00:00:18,030 --> 00:00:21,899
from an evening in Niagara Falls...
7
00:00:28,607 --> 00:00:29,719
What?
8
00:00:36,582 --> 00:00:38,916
What's wrong?
9
00:00:38,951 --> 00:00:41,586
Tell me! What's happening?
10
00:00:41,620 --> 00:00:45,089
It's Bruce. I think he's been attacked.
11
00:00:45,124 --> 00:00:47,358
- Bruce?
- No. no. no.
12
00:00:47,393 --> 00:00:50,027
What if they're still inside?
13
00:00:50,062 --> 00:00:51,896
It made me sick.
14
00:00:51,930 --> 00:00:53,870
What kind of a person would attack
15
00:00:53,981 --> 00:00:56,434
an elderly gentleman in his own home?
16
00:00:56,468 --> 00:00:59,036
There's all kinds of evil out there.
17
00:01:06,939 --> 00:01:13,386
- Sync and corrections by ByDem -
- www.addic7ed.com -
18
00:01:18,814 --> 00:01:22,059
I was the first female investigator
19
00:01:22,094 --> 00:01:25,062
in our homicide unit with
Niagara Regional Police.
20
00:01:25,716 --> 00:01:30,571
This case was my first
as a lead investigator.
21
00:01:31,069 --> 00:01:34,305
Being a woman adds
a little bit of pressure.
22
00:01:34,339 --> 00:01:36,808
I'm not gonna lie. I certainly felt it.
23
00:01:36,842 --> 00:01:38,376
- Hey.
- Hey.
24
00:01:39,689 --> 00:01:41,723
You want me to canvass
while you check the scene?
25
00:01:41,757 --> 00:01:43,725
It's your call.
26
00:01:43,759 --> 00:01:45,660
The boss wants you as lead.
Says you're ready.
27
00:01:45,695 --> 00:01:47,221
I'll be your file manager.
28
00:01:49,554 --> 00:01:50,765
Victim's in the garage.
29
00:01:54,237 --> 00:01:56,471
The crime itself occurred
30
00:01:56,505 --> 00:02:00,257
in this cute little house
on this quiet street.
31
00:02:00,828 --> 00:02:04,383
Nice place to live,
a wonderful community.
32
00:02:04,994 --> 00:02:07,449
Not a lot of crime.
33
00:02:07,483 --> 00:02:11,286
And yet, here we have
34
00:02:11,320 --> 00:02:16,791
an elderly gentleman attacked
in his own garage.
35
00:02:17,827 --> 00:02:22,330
It's shocking to see
someone die like this.
36
00:02:22,365 --> 00:02:24,566
Do we know who he is?
37
00:02:26,350 --> 00:02:28,703
Bruce Firman, 72.
38
00:02:28,738 --> 00:02:30,105
Cause of death?
39
00:02:30,139 --> 00:02:31,706
Coroner's not here yet.
40
00:02:31,741 --> 00:02:33,736
It looks like a blunt force
trauma to the head.
41
00:02:33,761 --> 00:02:35,243
- You saw the pipe wrench.
- Yeah.
42
00:02:35,278 --> 00:02:37,712
Whose car is this?
43
00:02:37,747 --> 00:02:40,448
The victim's step-daughter,
Elizabeth Gatenby,
44
00:02:40,483 --> 00:02:43,318
visiting from BC. It's a rental.
45
00:02:43,352 --> 00:02:46,655
Well, it's part of the crime
scene now so let's impound it,
46
00:02:46,689 --> 00:02:48,923
get a warrant and then
start the canvass.
47
00:02:48,958 --> 00:02:51,393
- Will do.
- And who found the body?
48
00:02:51,427 --> 00:02:54,785
Elizabeth and her mother.
Um, Margaret Benesch.
49
00:02:54,810 --> 00:02:58,366
Bruce's wife. They're at a neighbor.
50
00:02:58,968 --> 00:03:01,870
Were they inside the house
when it happened?
51
00:03:01,904 --> 00:03:03,672
Apparently not.
52
00:03:03,706 --> 00:03:06,408
Well, let's make sure.
So take them to the station,
53
00:03:06,442 --> 00:03:10,545
test them for blood spatter
and I'll talk to them there.
54
00:03:17,015 --> 00:03:19,537
Somebody killed this elderly gentleman
55
00:03:19,562 --> 00:03:21,070
in his own home.
56
00:03:21,205 --> 00:03:22,891
And they're still out there.
57
00:03:24,208 --> 00:03:26,761
What has happened here?
58
00:03:29,799 --> 00:03:33,722
Elizabeth had seen Bruce Firman
lying on the floor
59
00:03:33,747 --> 00:03:37,035
which is a difficult thing to see.
60
00:03:37,615 --> 00:03:41,810
Margaret was kind of in shock.
61
00:03:43,779 --> 00:03:47,749
There was no blood spatter
on either of them.
62
00:03:47,783 --> 00:03:50,752
If they were at the scene,
there would have been.
63
00:03:50,786 --> 00:03:53,755
Please have a seat.
64
00:04:00,496 --> 00:04:03,264
Was there anything
missing from the house?
65
00:04:03,299 --> 00:04:05,266
We haven't... been inside yet.
66
00:04:05,301 --> 00:04:10,105
We ran next door as soon as I
saw what had happened to Bruce.
67
00:04:10,916 --> 00:04:14,919
It was horrible. It could've been us!
68
00:04:16,305 --> 00:04:18,194
It's traumatic for anybody
69
00:04:18,219 --> 00:04:22,150
to come home to find a loved one dead.
70
00:04:22,184 --> 00:04:26,654
I felt like Elizabeth was
very protective of her mom.
71
00:04:29,343 --> 00:04:34,175
She shielded her mother from
seeing the body on the floor.
72
00:04:36,682 --> 00:04:39,740
That's what somebody
should do for their mother.
73
00:04:40,035 --> 00:04:44,018
You know, it's that bond
between a mother and daughter.
74
00:04:45,957 --> 00:04:48,635
- Was it a robbery?
- We don't know yet.
75
00:04:49,879 --> 00:04:52,714
Was the garage door tampered
with when you entered?
76
00:04:55,284 --> 00:04:59,271
Is there any other way to get inside
the house without breaking in?
77
00:04:59,374 --> 00:05:03,393
There's a key hidden
in the flower pot in the back.
78
00:05:03,862 --> 00:05:06,494
Do you think that's how it happened?
79
00:05:06,529 --> 00:05:09,931
Don't worry. We'll figure it out.
80
00:05:10,560 --> 00:05:13,429
I'm very sorry for your loss.
81
00:05:20,075 --> 00:05:22,595
The picture that we get of Bruce
82
00:05:22,620 --> 00:05:24,212
is that he's a decent guy,
83
00:05:24,246 --> 00:05:28,316
JUST DOING WHAT HE DID EVERY SINGLE DAY:
84
00:05:28,350 --> 00:05:32,420
coming home, putting his bike away
85
00:05:32,455 --> 00:05:36,291
before he went in to watch
the news and then go to bed.
86
00:05:36,325 --> 00:05:41,429
And on this day, he never
got into the house.
87
00:05:54,877 --> 00:05:56,911
The fact that the key is there,
88
00:05:56,946 --> 00:06:00,381
well, it either tells us
that somebody used the key
89
00:06:00,416 --> 00:06:03,585
to get in and then they went
through the trouble
90
00:06:03,619 --> 00:06:04,919
to put it back.
91
00:06:05,279 --> 00:06:07,380
Or the key wasn't in play at all.
92
00:06:15,464 --> 00:06:17,866
We're looking for signs.
We're looking for signs
93
00:06:17,900 --> 00:06:21,803
of forced entry, broken
window, jimmied door,
94
00:06:21,837 --> 00:06:25,773
but there was none of that in this case.
95
00:06:27,576 --> 00:06:31,479
The house was secure.
There weren't signs
96
00:06:31,514 --> 00:06:34,761
of someone ransacking the house
or anything like that.
97
00:06:43,325 --> 00:06:47,028
I felt that uh, this was
maybe not going to be
98
00:06:47,062 --> 00:06:48,930
an easy case to solve.
99
00:06:59,341 --> 00:07:01,776
- Hi.
- There you are!
100
00:07:01,810 --> 00:07:03,811
Find anything?
101
00:07:03,846 --> 00:07:05,647
The key was still in the flower box.
102
00:07:05,681 --> 00:07:08,616
There was a laptop in the kitchen.
103
00:07:09,468 --> 00:07:11,135
Did they find his wallet last night?
104
00:07:11,352 --> 00:07:14,672
Yeah, back pocket. Cash
and cards were still inside.
105
00:07:15,371 --> 00:07:18,371
The door to the house was still locked.
106
00:07:24,233 --> 00:07:25,611
No marks.
107
00:07:26,569 --> 00:07:28,202
I don't think this was a robbery.
108
00:07:28,237 --> 00:07:30,972
Look, from the position of the body,
109
00:07:31,695 --> 00:07:33,611
I'm guessing he was
standing right inside
110
00:07:33,636 --> 00:07:35,161
the garage door when he was hit.
111
00:07:35,224 --> 00:07:37,328
Yeah, I agree.
112
00:07:37,431 --> 00:07:39,814
Maybe a few steps in.
113
00:07:39,848 --> 00:07:43,217
So the killer was
probably already inside.
114
00:07:43,720 --> 00:07:45,788
Bruce might've been targeted.
115
00:07:48,357 --> 00:07:52,707
Has somebody targeted
this older gentleman
116
00:07:52,985 --> 00:07:55,905
and why would they want
to do this to him?
117
00:07:59,902 --> 00:08:03,171
Because I was the first
female investigator
118
00:08:03,205 --> 00:08:07,208
in our homicide unit,
I want to show that, you know,
119
00:08:07,242 --> 00:08:10,244
I'm dedicated. I can do this.
I wanna do a good job.
120
00:08:10,961 --> 00:08:12,895
In some sense,
121
00:08:13,128 --> 00:08:16,384
you're wanting to prove
to the others that...
122
00:08:16,418 --> 00:08:17,852
I can do this.
123
00:08:21,577 --> 00:08:24,192
Um, isn't that your job, Harrison?
124
00:08:26,295 --> 00:08:28,168
Very funny, Gamble. Sit down.
125
00:08:28,509 --> 00:08:30,264
Congratulations.
126
00:08:30,299 --> 00:08:33,468
OK, so here's what we know so far.
127
00:08:33,502 --> 00:08:36,371
Bruce Firman, 72, retired
real estate agent,
128
00:08:36,405 --> 00:08:40,044
returned home after his
nightly bike ride at around
129
00:08:40,069 --> 00:08:43,077
8 pm. Bludgeoned to death upon entry.
130
00:08:43,112 --> 00:08:45,380
Bruce had the same routine every night.
131
00:08:45,414 --> 00:08:47,293
Gone at seven on the bike,
back at eight.
132
00:08:47,539 --> 00:08:49,350
Neighbors say you could set
a watch to him.
133
00:08:49,385 --> 00:08:51,886
So what are we thinking? Robbery?
134
00:08:51,920 --> 00:08:53,354
Sounds like an easy mark.
135
00:08:53,389 --> 00:08:55,256
Yeah, that's what I was thinking too but
136
00:08:55,290 --> 00:08:58,559
there were no signs of forced
entry. His wallet was untouched.
137
00:08:58,594 --> 00:09:00,061
There was nothing missing
from the house.
138
00:09:00,095 --> 00:09:01,729
There's a laptop in the kitchen
139
00:09:01,764 --> 00:09:03,097
and the hidden key was still there.
140
00:09:03,132 --> 00:09:04,932
So it's a targeted attack.
141
00:09:04,967 --> 00:09:07,568
It sure looks that way.
142
00:09:07,603 --> 00:09:10,171
Someone was waiting
for Bruce inside the house.
143
00:09:10,205 --> 00:09:12,507
What do we know about him?
144
00:09:12,541 --> 00:09:14,108
Uh, Bruce was living in the house
145
00:09:14,143 --> 00:09:16,402
with his common-law wife,
Margaret Benesch.
146
00:09:16,481 --> 00:09:19,414
She has a daughter, Elizabeth
Gatenby. She lives in B.C.,
147
00:09:19,448 --> 00:09:22,268
but she's in town visiting.
They found the body...
148
00:09:22,538 --> 00:09:24,252
after having dinner in Niagara.
149
00:09:24,286 --> 00:09:26,654
How do we know
they weren't in the house?
150
00:09:26,689 --> 00:09:29,624
Forensic tests found no blood
spatter on either of them.
151
00:09:29,658 --> 00:09:30,925
So, it's unlikely.
152
00:09:30,959 --> 00:09:32,860
And we'll be checking their alibi.
153
00:09:32,895 --> 00:09:35,376
Did you pull up his record?
154
00:09:35,456 --> 00:09:39,767
Yeah. No criminal record, no
previous calls to that address.
155
00:09:39,802 --> 00:09:42,981
But... Bruce and Margaret
were suing each other.
156
00:09:44,209 --> 00:09:45,810
Court records go back months.
157
00:09:45,835 --> 00:09:47,375
Looks like they were on the outs.
158
00:09:50,112 --> 00:09:53,757
Margaret's
withholding important information here.
159
00:09:53,782 --> 00:09:55,249
And I wondered why.
160
00:09:55,284 --> 00:09:58,252
Firman had two sons and a daughter
161
00:09:58,287 --> 00:10:01,752
from a previous marriage.
Have they been notified?
162
00:10:03,959 --> 00:10:05,159
They're all out of town.
163
00:10:05,194 --> 00:10:06,694
One of the sons is close by.
164
00:10:06,729 --> 00:10:08,129
I'll go.
165
00:10:08,163 --> 00:10:10,028
No! I'll take care of it.
166
00:10:16,338 --> 00:10:18,310
Don Firman, he had a close
167
00:10:18,335 --> 00:10:19,994
relationship with his dad.
168
00:10:20,264 --> 00:10:22,489
He knew that it wasn't a good situation
169
00:10:22,514 --> 00:10:26,354
between Margaret and Bruce.
170
00:10:27,180 --> 00:10:28,816
He knew something bad was gonna happen.
171
00:10:28,851 --> 00:10:32,653
Their relationship had fallen
apart months ago.
172
00:10:32,688 --> 00:10:35,590
- What happened?
- He met someone else.
173
00:10:35,624 --> 00:10:37,792
He was up front about it
with her, though.
174
00:10:37,826 --> 00:10:39,160
Told her he wanted
out of the relationship.
175
00:10:39,757 --> 00:10:41,825
Then why were they still
living together?
176
00:10:42,792 --> 00:10:45,434
Dad was scared if he moved
out, she'd change the locks
177
00:10:45,459 --> 00:10:47,183
and he'd never see any
of his things again.
178
00:10:47,208 --> 00:10:50,236
They were suing each other over
the house, everything inside it,
179
00:10:50,261 --> 00:10:53,307
spousal support. It was ugly.
180
00:10:53,342 --> 00:10:55,643
I mean, he wanted out,
but she wanted everything.
181
00:10:57,499 --> 00:10:59,924
Did Margaret ever threaten your father?
182
00:11:01,810 --> 00:11:03,551
You kidding?
183
00:11:03,585 --> 00:11:05,820
After the last court hearing?
She was so furious,
184
00:11:05,854 --> 00:11:08,856
when they got home, she threw
an ashtray at his head.
185
00:11:08,891 --> 00:11:10,925
Said she'd kill him before
she ever paid him a dime.
186
00:11:12,648 --> 00:11:14,328
His dad actually said to him
187
00:11:14,363 --> 00:11:16,531
"if something happens to me,
188
00:11:16,565 --> 00:11:19,066
you need to look at Margaret."
189
00:11:28,024 --> 00:11:30,020
When Don talked about Margaret,
190
00:11:30,084 --> 00:11:32,085
he talked about her as a cruel woman.
191
00:11:32,945 --> 00:11:34,554
She was so furious, when they got home,
192
00:11:34,588 --> 00:11:36,222
she threw an ashtray at his head.
193
00:11:36,257 --> 00:11:38,558
Said she'd kill him before
she ever paid him a dime.
194
00:11:38,592 --> 00:11:40,852
I knew there was more to
195
00:11:40,877 --> 00:11:43,534
this story than what she was telling me.
196
00:11:46,300 --> 00:11:48,577
Yes, we had our problems, we fought.
197
00:11:48,602 --> 00:11:51,204
I couldn't wait to get out
of the relationship.
198
00:11:51,238 --> 00:11:52,739
But I wouldn't kill him.
199
00:11:52,773 --> 00:11:54,010
You threatened to.
200
00:11:54,424 --> 00:11:56,821
I said a lot of things I didn't mean.
201
00:11:57,837 --> 00:12:00,496
And he deserved to hear
every one of them.
202
00:12:00,530 --> 00:12:04,709
Bruce Firman was a cheat,
a liar and a con artist.
203
00:12:05,034 --> 00:12:08,094
He started off so charming and romantic.
204
00:12:08,610 --> 00:12:10,272
And then he turned on me.
205
00:12:10,306 --> 00:12:13,430
And all he wanted was
my money, my things.
206
00:12:14,446 --> 00:12:16,673
He didn't care about me.
207
00:12:19,049 --> 00:12:22,016
Is that what happened?
The money ran out?
208
00:12:24,587 --> 00:12:28,874
He met some woman in the neighborhood
209
00:12:29,271 --> 00:12:31,210
and then he decided to leave.
210
00:12:31,384 --> 00:12:33,562
But he wanted me to pay him first.
211
00:12:33,596 --> 00:12:35,754
He said he owned half the house.
212
00:12:37,419 --> 00:12:38,586
He didn't?
213
00:12:38,611 --> 00:12:40,335
No! I paid for it in full.
214
00:12:40,370 --> 00:12:44,206
But he made me put his name on the deed.
215
00:12:44,240 --> 00:12:47,676
Said it would prove I trusted him.
216
00:12:47,710 --> 00:12:50,012
I can see he made you pretty angry.
217
00:12:50,046 --> 00:12:51,930
Well, I wasn't gonna
let him get away with it.
218
00:12:54,612 --> 00:12:57,619
I was going to drag through the courts.
219
00:12:59,489 --> 00:13:01,342
Not kill him.
220
00:13:02,292 --> 00:13:05,928
That woman he was seeing...
she could have him.
221
00:13:05,962 --> 00:13:07,930
Do you know her name?
222
00:13:07,964 --> 00:13:10,432
Of course! Joan.
223
00:13:10,467 --> 00:13:13,135
She lives three blocks away.
224
00:13:13,169 --> 00:13:17,206
Where do you think he was going
every night on his "bike ride"?
225
00:13:17,240 --> 00:13:19,875
Ask her if you want
to know what happened.
226
00:13:19,909 --> 00:13:25,280
Better still, ask the ex-wives.
There were eight of them.
227
00:13:25,959 --> 00:13:28,427
What? I don't know anybody
228
00:13:28,452 --> 00:13:30,487
who had eight wives.
229
00:13:32,288 --> 00:13:35,791
Margaret's anger towards
Bruce bordered on hatred.
230
00:13:38,595 --> 00:13:40,246
Maybe he was walking away
231
00:13:40,271 --> 00:13:45,167
from every relationship with a
significant amount of assets.
232
00:13:45,201 --> 00:13:50,939
Is he lovin' 'em and leavin' 'em
and takin' half of their stuff.
233
00:13:51,933 --> 00:13:55,711
Bruce and I had a real connection.
234
00:13:55,745 --> 00:13:58,823
At my age, that isn't easy to come by.
235
00:13:59,768 --> 00:14:00,782
So when he left,
236
00:14:01,508 --> 00:14:04,286
I got depressed.
237
00:14:04,320 --> 00:14:06,321
I couldn't understand it.
238
00:14:06,356 --> 00:14:09,391
As I've gotten older,
I've come to appreciate
239
00:14:09,425 --> 00:14:12,565
the importance of having
someone there for you.
240
00:14:13,240 --> 00:14:15,931
For a while, I thought
I'd found that with Bruce.
241
00:14:15,965 --> 00:14:17,799
But I guess he didn't.
242
00:14:17,834 --> 00:14:19,401
Why not?
243
00:14:20,524 --> 00:14:23,311
He said he didn't feel
the spark anymore.
244
00:14:23,555 --> 00:14:25,107
And he met someone else.
245
00:14:25,141 --> 00:14:26,808
Why did he leave?
246
00:14:26,843 --> 00:14:30,345
Why does anyone leave a relationship?
247
00:14:31,545 --> 00:14:34,983
I think he'd just had enough. Moved on.
248
00:14:35,947 --> 00:14:38,554
There's nothing malicious about it.
249
00:14:38,588 --> 00:14:41,623
He was honest about it.
He told me what had happened
250
00:14:41,658 --> 00:14:45,671
and that he wanted out.
And so we moved on.
251
00:14:46,179 --> 00:14:48,555
Were there ever any issues with money?
252
00:14:48,990 --> 00:14:52,334
No. We took good care of each other.
253
00:14:52,368 --> 00:14:54,102
I didn't get that love 'em and leave 'em
254
00:14:54,137 --> 00:14:56,598
and take everything sense from him.
255
00:14:57,440 --> 00:15:01,703
The women had nothing but
nice things to say about him
256
00:15:01,728 --> 00:15:04,813
and it just so happened that the
relationships didn't work out.
257
00:15:06,333 --> 00:15:10,623
We went and met Bruce's
girlfriend, Joan.
258
00:15:11,354 --> 00:15:13,222
Can you tell me about Bruce?
259
00:15:13,256 --> 00:15:16,558
What can I tell you?
260
00:15:16,593 --> 00:15:19,027
He was a wonderful man.
261
00:15:19,062 --> 00:15:23,599
So kind. We'd just started
seeing each other.
262
00:15:23,633 --> 00:15:26,101
You really loved him.
263
00:15:28,320 --> 00:15:31,022
Joan was the woman that he was seeing
264
00:15:31,047 --> 00:15:32,941
at the time of his death.
265
00:15:32,976 --> 00:15:35,976
My impression was that
she was smitten with Bruce.
266
00:15:36,365 --> 00:15:38,880
He saw you that night, didn't he?
267
00:15:38,915 --> 00:15:41,416
Every night. He used to come over,
268
00:15:41,451 --> 00:15:44,219
we ate dinner together
and then he'd leave.
269
00:15:44,254 --> 00:15:48,223
Did anything seem strange or off?
270
00:15:48,258 --> 00:15:52,227
No. It was like every other night.
271
00:15:52,262 --> 00:15:54,630
How did you two meet?
272
00:15:54,664 --> 00:15:56,498
I was walking the dog in the park
273
00:15:56,532 --> 00:16:00,702
four years ago. Just like that.
274
00:16:00,737 --> 00:16:02,371
We became best of friends.
275
00:16:02,405 --> 00:16:04,873
Confidantes.
276
00:16:06,661 --> 00:16:10,541
And then, when things started
to get difficult with Margaret,
277
00:16:11,612 --> 00:16:14,416
we became something other.
278
00:16:14,450 --> 00:16:17,953
Did he ever talk to you about Margaret?
279
00:16:17,987 --> 00:16:19,643
All the time.
280
00:16:20,040 --> 00:16:22,983
He was frightened of her, Detective.
281
00:16:23,078 --> 00:16:25,240
To sleep, he'd prop up a chair against
282
00:16:25,265 --> 00:16:27,996
the bedroom door just in case.
283
00:16:30,059 --> 00:16:34,303
When I think of what that poor
man must've gone through.
284
00:16:42,278 --> 00:16:45,855
You can call me...
every day if you like.
285
00:16:54,390 --> 00:16:58,093
Joan was the total opposite of Margaret.
286
00:16:58,127 --> 00:17:01,229
It seemed pretty clear
she didn't have any reason
287
00:17:01,264 --> 00:17:03,999
to kill Bruce.
288
00:17:06,035 --> 00:17:09,037
We checked the laptop.
It belongs to Elizabeth.
289
00:17:09,072 --> 00:17:11,373
- Find anything?
- Nothing much.
290
00:17:11,407 --> 00:17:13,442
What about Bruce's real estate clients?
291
00:17:13,476 --> 00:17:15,844
Everyone we spoke to
seemed happy with him.
292
00:17:15,878 --> 00:17:18,947
Besides, he hasn't worked
as an agent in years.
293
00:17:18,981 --> 00:17:22,320
Bruce seemed to leave
things off amicably.
294
00:17:22,571 --> 00:17:24,439
Except with Margaret.
295
00:17:25,209 --> 00:17:27,356
That fits with the case files.
296
00:17:27,390 --> 00:17:31,193
Bruce's lawyer sent them in.
It's a lot to go through,
297
00:17:31,227 --> 00:17:33,772
but they definitely were not amicable.
298
00:17:34,184 --> 00:17:36,198
In the end, it seems like
he was just trying to get back
299
00:17:36,232 --> 00:17:39,267
a few things that he paid for.
She wouldn't accept.
300
00:17:39,302 --> 00:17:41,269
Margaret made it sound
like he was trying
301
00:17:41,304 --> 00:17:43,157
to take everything from her.
302
00:17:45,908 --> 00:17:48,410
- Where you going?
- To check on their alibi.
303
00:17:48,444 --> 00:17:51,010
We don't even know for sure
they were actually in Niagara
304
00:17:51,035 --> 00:17:52,472
the night Bruce was killed.
305
00:17:52,497 --> 00:17:55,684
You look at Margaret and she's a petite,
306
00:17:55,718 --> 00:17:58,854
older lady.
307
00:17:58,888 --> 00:18:01,857
So you kind of wonder
how could she have done this,
308
00:18:01,891 --> 00:18:06,443
but definitely wondering if
she had something to do with it.
309
00:18:06,996 --> 00:18:08,830
I do remember her.
310
00:18:08,865 --> 00:18:11,633
They sat right over there.
The mom was facing outside.
311
00:18:11,667 --> 00:18:14,035
I'll have a tea.
312
00:18:14,070 --> 00:18:16,883
Coffee for me and a tea
for my mother, please.
313
00:18:16,908 --> 00:18:18,111
OK.
314
00:18:18,136 --> 00:18:19,908
Do you remember all
your tables that well?
315
00:18:19,942 --> 00:18:22,544
No, they were just...
316
00:18:22,578 --> 00:18:24,907
the daughter needed a lot of attention.
317
00:18:24,970 --> 00:18:27,783
Oh, and by the way, um,
about the water for the tea,
318
00:18:27,817 --> 00:18:29,651
is it freshly boiled
or is it from a spout?
319
00:18:29,685 --> 00:18:31,420
It's from the machine.
320
00:18:31,454 --> 00:18:33,188
Oh, well, that's not acceptable.
321
00:18:33,222 --> 00:18:35,056
The water needs to be freshly boiled
322
00:18:35,091 --> 00:18:36,391
before you put a tea bag in it.
323
00:18:36,426 --> 00:18:39,127
She wanted the water freshly boiled
324
00:18:39,162 --> 00:18:41,748
instead of from a machine.
Something like that.
325
00:18:42,248 --> 00:18:44,201
Do you remember what time
they were here?
326
00:18:44,511 --> 00:18:46,594
They left around... 7:45 pm?
327
00:18:49,305 --> 00:18:51,506
Thank you.
328
00:18:53,245 --> 00:18:55,889
We clearly know that
they were in Niagara Falls...
329
00:19:00,831 --> 00:19:04,166
but we also needed to look
at how long it would take
330
00:19:04,271 --> 00:19:06,425
to get back to St. Catharines.
331
00:19:08,925 --> 00:19:12,214
So I timed the drive from
the restaurant to Bruce's home.
332
00:19:13,841 --> 00:19:16,919
And we did the drive
a few times actually.
333
00:19:17,872 --> 00:19:21,282
We wanted to make sure that
the time line we were looking at
334
00:19:21,307 --> 00:19:23,505
was accurate.
335
00:19:27,104 --> 00:19:30,569
There is no way that Elizabeth
and Margaret could have been
336
00:19:30,594 --> 00:19:32,581
in St. Catharines at the time
of the homicide.
337
00:19:32,615 --> 00:19:34,549
It was impossible.
338
00:19:39,898 --> 00:19:45,214
At this point, the investigation
is not really progressing.
339
00:19:46,071 --> 00:19:48,906
We don't have a strong suspect.
340
00:19:48,940 --> 00:19:52,151
Margaret has a solid alibi.
341
00:19:52,349 --> 00:19:54,183
She couldn't have been at the scene.
342
00:19:54,218 --> 00:19:56,591
But something still wasn't
sitting right with me.
343
00:19:56,758 --> 00:19:58,321
Where do we go from here?
344
00:20:00,624 --> 00:20:02,309
I want to bring Elizabeth in.
345
00:20:02,532 --> 00:20:04,600
Why lean on her?
346
00:20:04,634 --> 00:20:08,270
It isn't gonna look great, a
family member with a solid alibi?
347
00:20:08,305 --> 00:20:10,606
Something isn't right about it.
348
00:20:10,640 --> 00:20:13,042
I thought several
witnesses saw them there.
349
00:20:13,076 --> 00:20:17,095
Well, that's just it. Everyone I
spoke to in Niagara remembered them.
350
00:20:17,120 --> 00:20:18,689
Even though they were strangers.
351
00:20:18,935 --> 00:20:20,970
Especially Elizabeth.
352
00:20:21,004 --> 00:20:23,530
They all said she needed
a lot of attention.
353
00:20:24,123 --> 00:20:25,212
Attention.
354
00:20:25,237 --> 00:20:29,274
Yeah, it's like... it's like
she was putting on a show.
355
00:20:29,472 --> 00:20:31,790
Well, that's not acceptable.
The water needs to be
356
00:20:31,815 --> 00:20:33,983
freshly boiled before
you put a tea bag in it.
357
00:20:34,017 --> 00:20:38,120
It's like she wanted to be remembered.
358
00:20:38,622 --> 00:20:41,008
You can't always explain the hunch,
359
00:20:41,059 --> 00:20:43,637
but you can never discount it.
360
00:20:44,589 --> 00:20:47,191
I think you have to trust your gut.
361
00:20:47,225 --> 00:20:48,993
So we brought her in.
362
00:20:49,027 --> 00:20:52,763
Detective Sergeant Gamble was
a former polygraph analyst.
363
00:20:52,798 --> 00:20:55,032
You're in from BC, right?
364
00:20:55,067 --> 00:20:57,068
I run a youth center there.
365
00:20:57,102 --> 00:20:59,003
Good at reading people.
366
00:20:59,037 --> 00:21:00,347
That must be demanding.
367
00:21:00,372 --> 00:21:02,406
It's a 24h a day, that's for sure.
368
00:21:02,441 --> 00:21:05,104
There's always someone in crisis.
369
00:21:05,160 --> 00:21:09,190
Always someone who needs help.
But we do what we can.
370
00:21:09,872 --> 00:21:14,468
I was interested in what
he felt she was all about.
371
00:21:14,595 --> 00:21:17,688
Is she trustworthy?
Is she telling the truth?
372
00:21:17,723 --> 00:21:20,271
I can't imagine it was easy
getting time off
373
00:21:20,311 --> 00:21:21,511
for a trip out here.
374
00:21:21,545 --> 00:21:23,647
But still, you made that happen.
375
00:21:23,681 --> 00:21:25,015
My mother needed me.
376
00:21:25,049 --> 00:21:28,351
Enough for you to drop everything and...
377
00:21:28,386 --> 00:21:31,855
get on a bus for what? Three days?
378
00:21:33,564 --> 00:21:38,061
I was um, a tough kid to handle.
379
00:21:39,067 --> 00:21:41,631
I got into drugs young.
380
00:21:42,823 --> 00:21:45,302
It was really rough on my mom.
381
00:21:46,547 --> 00:21:49,973
I got clean a few years ago now, but uh,
382
00:21:50,007 --> 00:21:51,775
I'm trying to make it up to her.
383
00:21:51,809 --> 00:21:55,512
That's why I came. I need her
to know that I'm here for her
384
00:21:55,546 --> 00:21:57,480
when she needs me.
385
00:21:59,483 --> 00:22:02,786
But still, it must've been
pretty important for you
386
00:22:02,820 --> 00:22:05,141
to get away from the youth center,
387
00:22:05,166 --> 00:22:08,358
spend three days on a bus.
388
00:22:09,297 --> 00:22:13,968
Elizabeth, if there's something
you're not telling us, anything.
389
00:22:22,807 --> 00:22:26,443
My mother is a strong woman.
390
00:22:28,412 --> 00:22:29,746
But this whole situation
391
00:22:29,780 --> 00:22:33,427
with Bruce, it was just
too much for her.
392
00:22:34,485 --> 00:22:36,419
She couldn't cope.
393
00:22:39,924 --> 00:22:42,100
She tried to kill herself.
394
00:22:45,496 --> 00:22:48,131
Have you ever tried to kill
yourself, Detective?
395
00:22:48,165 --> 00:22:51,267
No.
396
00:22:51,302 --> 00:22:53,476
Me neither.
397
00:22:54,195 --> 00:22:56,196
But can you imagine?
398
00:22:58,642 --> 00:23:01,311
The desperation you must feel?
399
00:23:01,345 --> 00:23:03,838
I was scared!
400
00:23:04,782 --> 00:23:08,318
I got here as quickly as I could
before anything worse could happen.
401
00:23:08,352 --> 00:23:12,655
She was very upset, almost distraught.
402
00:23:12,690 --> 00:23:15,592
But something still wasn't
sitting right with me.
403
00:23:16,912 --> 00:23:20,238
And, I, I can't tell you
exactly what it is.
404
00:23:20,452 --> 00:23:23,466
But Gamble was the guy
with the experience.
405
00:23:23,501 --> 00:23:26,302
His opinion mattered a lot.
406
00:23:26,337 --> 00:23:30,106
As far as I can tell, she's
being truthful. She's being
407
00:23:30,141 --> 00:23:31,308
a good daughter and trying to make up
408
00:23:31,333 --> 00:23:33,777
for what she put her mother through
when she was young.
409
00:23:33,811 --> 00:23:35,945
And she's got a rock-solid alibi.
410
00:23:35,980 --> 00:23:39,482
And the fact that Margaret
attempted suicide also tells me
411
00:23:39,517 --> 00:23:41,184
she's got nothing to do with this.
412
00:23:41,218 --> 00:23:42,886
Inward violence.
413
00:23:42,920 --> 00:23:46,456
Exactly. She's more likely to
kill herself than anyone else.
414
00:23:48,059 --> 00:23:51,194
I'm sorry. I know it's not what
you want to hear, but here's
415
00:23:51,228 --> 00:23:52,662
my advice.
416
00:23:52,696 --> 00:23:56,332
Get them on your side.
They're the victims.
417
00:23:56,367 --> 00:23:59,462
And you're gonna need
their trust to solve this case.
418
00:24:00,538 --> 00:24:02,778
Good luck.
419
00:24:05,409 --> 00:24:08,578
Being a lead
investigator, you really do need
420
00:24:08,612 --> 00:24:10,680
to trust your basic instincts.
421
00:24:10,714 --> 00:24:15,919
There was just something that still
troubled me about Elizabeth.
422
00:24:22,426 --> 00:24:23,560
How are you holding up?
423
00:24:23,594 --> 00:24:25,195
It's been hard.
424
00:24:25,229 --> 00:24:28,164
I still haven't been in the garage.
425
00:24:29,218 --> 00:24:31,234
Thank God for Elizabeth!
426
00:24:31,268 --> 00:24:32,936
She really cares about you.
427
00:24:32,970 --> 00:24:35,371
She's come so far.
428
00:24:35,406 --> 00:24:37,273
So far?
429
00:24:37,308 --> 00:24:41,578
She had addiction problems.
She had it tough growing up.
430
00:24:41,612 --> 00:24:44,245
But she's turned her life around and uh,
431
00:24:44,324 --> 00:24:46,015
she's learned from her mistakes.
432
00:24:46,050 --> 00:24:51,262
Ah! My angel. Angel.
433
00:24:53,657 --> 00:24:54,844
Is that my laptop?
434
00:24:54,869 --> 00:24:57,060
Yeah. I thought you might want it back.
435
00:24:57,094 --> 00:24:58,995
Thank you.
436
00:25:00,631 --> 00:25:04,400
The house must seem a lot
quieter now that Bruce is gone.
437
00:25:05,402 --> 00:25:08,179
I guess we didn't interact much.
438
00:25:08,639 --> 00:25:11,608
He spent most of his time
in the basement,
439
00:25:11,642 --> 00:25:14,878
with the door locked.
Watching television.
440
00:25:14,912 --> 00:25:18,181
Mmmm. That's uncomfortable.
Living that way.
441
00:25:18,215 --> 00:25:21,284
I tried playing mediator.
I tried to get them to agree
442
00:25:21,318 --> 00:25:22,785
on how to move on with their lives.
443
00:25:22,820 --> 00:25:25,331
But it was impossible.
444
00:25:25,657 --> 00:25:27,524
He was so bull-headed.
445
00:25:27,558 --> 00:25:29,225
That must've been frustrating.
446
00:25:29,260 --> 00:25:32,896
Try travelling three days
on a bus to find that out.
447
00:25:32,930 --> 00:25:34,128
Now that's frustrating.
448
00:25:34,255 --> 00:25:36,900
Ah, I get antsy spending
an hour on the bus,
449
00:25:36,934 --> 00:25:39,035
so I can't imagine what
three days must be like.
450
00:25:39,456 --> 00:25:41,543
It's not great, but you get used to it.
451
00:25:41,568 --> 00:25:42,968
Mmm.
452
00:25:43,633 --> 00:25:45,742
Did you make any friends along the way?
453
00:25:45,776 --> 00:25:49,245
Well, there was this um, young cowboy.
454
00:25:49,280 --> 00:25:50,760
I think he got on in Calgary.
455
00:25:50,785 --> 00:25:52,248
He sat with me the whole way here.
456
00:25:52,870 --> 00:25:54,570
This cowboy have a name?
457
00:25:54,882 --> 00:25:55,919
Dell.
458
00:25:55,953 --> 00:25:57,487
Last name?
459
00:25:57,521 --> 00:26:00,123
Ah, I don't remember.
I belong to an anonymous group,
460
00:26:00,157 --> 00:26:01,558
I don't really do last names.
461
00:26:01,592 --> 00:26:04,561
What else can you tell me about Dell?
462
00:26:04,595 --> 00:26:05,662
How old was he?
463
00:26:05,696 --> 00:26:09,632
Uh, he was eighteen, I think.
464
00:26:09,667 --> 00:26:11,246
I remember he needed a bath.
465
00:26:12,193 --> 00:26:15,432
He had this big cowboy hat on
with metal studs in it.
466
00:26:15,940 --> 00:26:17,440
What did you talk about?
467
00:26:17,474 --> 00:26:20,777
Well, you know, we
covered a lotta ground.
468
00:26:21,796 --> 00:26:24,256
It seemed like he was having
a bit of a tough time.
469
00:26:24,815 --> 00:26:27,250
He sounded a lot like me at his age.
470
00:26:27,284 --> 00:26:28,585
Mmm.
471
00:26:28,619 --> 00:26:30,453
Did you tell him about Bruce?
472
00:26:30,822 --> 00:26:32,823
I might've told him a little bit about
473
00:26:32,848 --> 00:26:34,490
some of the troubles Bruce was causing.
474
00:26:35,315 --> 00:26:38,494
All the arguments over money with Mom.
475
00:26:38,529 --> 00:26:40,618
You have any idea where I can find Dell?
476
00:26:40,643 --> 00:26:42,632
Why are you asking so many
questions about this kid?
477
00:26:42,666 --> 00:26:43,915
He has nothing to do with this.
478
00:26:43,940 --> 00:26:46,970
Of course. I'm just
gathering information.
479
00:26:47,004 --> 00:26:48,738
Any idea where he is?
480
00:26:48,772 --> 00:26:51,600
No!
481
00:26:51,862 --> 00:26:54,410
According to Elizabeth, Dell was
482
00:26:54,445 --> 00:26:58,361
a young kid that had fallen
on some hard times.
483
00:26:59,274 --> 00:27:03,386
He fit that mold of the kind of
person that could take advantage
484
00:27:03,420 --> 00:27:06,556
of a vulnerable senior.
485
00:27:12,062 --> 00:27:14,831
What's this? Is this Dell?
486
00:27:15,261 --> 00:27:16,428
The one and only.
487
00:27:18,802 --> 00:27:20,370
Suddenly, when we saw the hat
488
00:27:20,404 --> 00:27:23,206
on the video, you know,
from the bus terminal,
489
00:27:23,240 --> 00:27:27,064
we were thrilled because
"There he is! There's Dell!"
490
00:27:27,302 --> 00:27:32,081
Dell and Elizabeth left
in the rental car together.
491
00:27:32,116 --> 00:27:34,017
I certainly was very surprised by that.
492
00:27:34,051 --> 00:27:35,718
We pull any prints off the vehicle?
493
00:27:35,753 --> 00:27:38,296
Yeah. Several. It's a rental.
494
00:27:38,321 --> 00:27:40,425
A rental we now know
Dell's been inside of.
495
00:27:41,075 --> 00:27:43,153
Send them all in,
see if we can get an ID.
496
00:27:43,354 --> 00:27:47,797
Send this out to every hotel
and motel in the area.
497
00:27:47,831 --> 00:27:50,867
Dell's from out of town.
He's gotta stay somewhere.
498
00:27:50,901 --> 00:27:52,735
Elizabeth wasn't telling me everything.
499
00:27:52,770 --> 00:27:56,072
We needed to find Dell.
500
00:28:02,325 --> 00:28:08,207
Elizabeth and this young man
named Dell got into a vehicle
501
00:28:08,232 --> 00:28:09,595
together.
502
00:28:10,785 --> 00:28:14,537
We knew that he was coming to
St. Catharines to look for work,
503
00:28:14,633 --> 00:28:18,078
so we began checking
every motel in the area.
504
00:28:18,808 --> 00:28:20,252
It's the off season.
505
00:28:20,427 --> 00:28:22,444
You tend to remember your
customers' faces better.
506
00:28:22,478 --> 00:28:25,413
Especially a kid in a cowboy hat.
507
00:28:25,448 --> 00:28:26,970
Was he with a woman?
508
00:28:27,073 --> 00:28:28,883
Nah. He was with some guy.
509
00:28:28,918 --> 00:28:31,553
Actually, they both
looked like teenagers.
510
00:28:31,587 --> 00:28:36,091
So, two young
men were staying in this room,
511
00:28:36,125 --> 00:28:39,199
but at this point,
they have left, checked out.
512
00:28:39,810 --> 00:28:41,963
What did the other guy look like?
513
00:28:41,998 --> 00:28:44,099
Big fella. Had a baby face.
514
00:28:44,133 --> 00:28:45,867
Any names?
515
00:28:45,901 --> 00:28:47,669
I'd have to check the receipts.
516
00:28:47,703 --> 00:28:51,006
It's been a couple of days.
The room's been cleaned out.
517
00:28:51,040 --> 00:28:53,375
They left a lotta stuff behind, though.
518
00:28:54,545 --> 00:28:56,044
You still have it?
519
00:28:56,078 --> 00:28:58,346
Could be with housekeeping.
520
00:29:02,927 --> 00:29:04,561
Thanks.
521
00:29:05,063 --> 00:29:07,489
Would you mind getting
those receipts while I do this?
522
00:29:07,553 --> 00:29:09,090
Sure.
523
00:29:16,332 --> 00:29:18,600
The containers were exactly the same
524
00:29:18,634 --> 00:29:22,883
as in Bruce Firman's house.
What the hell was goin' on here?
525
00:29:26,442 --> 00:29:28,476
Found it. Here.
526
00:29:28,511 --> 00:29:30,879
The room was paid for
by an Elizabeth Gatenby.
527
00:29:31,484 --> 00:29:35,254
So she clearly
rented a room in her own name,
528
00:29:35,279 --> 00:29:37,385
using her own credit card.
529
00:29:37,420 --> 00:29:39,451
I was thinking "OK, we got ya!"
530
00:29:40,006 --> 00:29:42,357
I told you, Detective, I
don't know much about Dell.
531
00:29:42,391 --> 00:29:44,596
We just sat together
on the bus. That's all.
532
00:29:45,728 --> 00:29:49,698
He was coming looking for work, he
seemed friendly, we got chatting.
533
00:29:49,732 --> 00:29:51,066
He seemed like a really good kid,
534
00:29:51,100 --> 00:29:52,600
just needed a little help, that's all.
535
00:29:53,106 --> 00:29:55,741
Do you know where he went
after the bus station?
536
00:29:55,766 --> 00:29:57,205
The QE motel.
537
00:29:57,239 --> 00:29:59,733
- How do you know?
- Cause I drove him.
538
00:29:59,758 --> 00:30:00,909
You drove him.
539
00:30:00,943 --> 00:30:02,552
Yeah, he needed a ride.
540
00:30:02,577 --> 00:30:05,080
I paid for his motel room, too.
541
00:30:05,114 --> 00:30:07,916
Poor kid didn't have a credit card,
so I got him checked into his room.
542
00:30:07,950 --> 00:30:09,851
Brought him some food, too.
543
00:30:09,885 --> 00:30:12,887
Elizabeth, very calmly and clearly,
544
00:30:12,922 --> 00:30:17,592
told me, yes, she did rent
that motel room for Dell.
545
00:30:17,816 --> 00:30:19,784
And I was kind of shocked at that.
546
00:30:20,245 --> 00:30:23,598
And you didn't think any
of this was worth telling me.
547
00:30:24,715 --> 00:30:28,470
Look. Dell had just gotten clean.
548
00:30:28,504 --> 00:30:31,239
He was looking for a fresh start.
549
00:30:31,273 --> 00:30:34,242
All right? So I just didn't want to
get him mixed up in all of this.
550
00:30:34,276 --> 00:30:36,444
So you lied.
551
00:30:36,479 --> 00:30:40,215
No! I was just trying to help.
552
00:30:40,249 --> 00:30:41,549
Where's Dell now?
553
00:30:41,584 --> 00:30:43,852
I don't know.
554
00:30:46,528 --> 00:30:48,957
I work for a youth center.
That's what I do.
555
00:30:48,991 --> 00:30:51,359
I see kids like Dell all the time.
556
00:30:51,393 --> 00:30:53,695
Kids who are running from something
557
00:30:53,729 --> 00:30:54,896
and need a fresh start.
558
00:30:54,930 --> 00:30:58,233
If I can help, I do.
559
00:30:58,267 --> 00:30:59,934
So I did.
560
00:31:00,306 --> 00:31:02,707
Her whole life was this youth center
561
00:31:02,732 --> 00:31:06,975
that she runs and I thought,
maybe she's not only
562
00:31:07,009 --> 00:31:09,644
talking the talk, but
she's walking the walk, too.
563
00:31:09,678 --> 00:31:14,289
Yeah, well sometimes kids like
Dell hurt the people that help them.
564
00:31:15,684 --> 00:31:19,187
If you hear from Dell,
let me know right away.
565
00:31:20,393 --> 00:31:23,591
Elizabeth is very convincing.
566
00:31:23,626 --> 00:31:25,960
You know, this is kind of
her mission in life
567
00:31:25,995 --> 00:31:29,864
right now, is to help young
people who are down and out.
568
00:31:29,899 --> 00:31:33,301
She was just carrying on in her role.
569
00:31:33,335 --> 00:31:34,836
Maybe she was a nice person.
570
00:31:37,006 --> 00:31:39,440
Or maybe she was lying.
571
00:31:40,442 --> 00:31:41,592
Harrison!
572
00:31:43,078 --> 00:31:44,846
The prints came back from the rental.
573
00:31:44,880 --> 00:31:46,080
And?
574
00:31:46,115 --> 00:31:48,416
Only one hit, but it's a good one.
575
00:31:48,450 --> 00:31:49,655
Tommy Nicol!
576
00:31:49,687 --> 00:31:52,353
Male teenager. And look where he's from.
577
00:31:52,388 --> 00:31:57,292
Kimberly, BC. That's just east
of where Elizabeth lives.
578
00:31:57,326 --> 00:32:00,328
It doesn't look much like Dell.
579
00:32:00,362 --> 00:32:03,264
Could be the other guy
from the hotel room.
580
00:32:05,334 --> 00:32:07,735
It was really
a turning point for the case.
581
00:32:07,770 --> 00:32:10,700
Not only did we get a print,
but we ran it
582
00:32:10,725 --> 00:32:13,241
through the fingerprint
identification system
583
00:32:13,275 --> 00:32:16,644
and we got a hit.
584
00:32:16,679 --> 00:32:19,547
Tommy Nicol.
585
00:32:23,786 --> 00:32:26,054
So why'd you bring me here?
586
00:32:26,088 --> 00:32:28,189
To St. Catharines?
587
00:32:28,224 --> 00:32:31,125
You mean, why did we bring you back?
588
00:32:31,160 --> 00:32:34,429
Never been here before.
589
00:32:34,463 --> 00:32:37,398
He denied ever being in St. Catharines,
590
00:32:37,433 --> 00:32:40,735
which was good for our investigation
591
00:32:40,769 --> 00:32:43,771
because we have his fingerprint
on the rental car.
592
00:32:43,806 --> 00:32:46,441
So, we clearly know he was lying.
593
00:32:46,475 --> 00:32:48,276
We know that's not true, Tommy.
594
00:32:48,310 --> 00:32:50,378
We have your fingerprints.
595
00:32:52,715 --> 00:32:54,582
How old are you? Seventeen?
596
00:32:54,617 --> 00:32:56,551
Eighteen in a few weeks.
597
00:32:56,585 --> 00:32:58,386
Well, that's pretty close.
598
00:32:58,420 --> 00:33:01,456
Especially for a judge
deciding whether or not
599
00:33:01,490 --> 00:33:04,158
to try you as an adult.
600
00:33:04,193 --> 00:33:06,160
There's a big difference.
601
00:33:09,164 --> 00:33:11,266
Telling the truth now
could go a long way.
602
00:33:15,629 --> 00:33:19,073
Were you robbing the old man and
then he came home and found you?
603
00:33:20,547 --> 00:33:22,405
Were you alone?
604
00:33:24,313 --> 00:33:26,514
Was it Dell's idea to kill him?
605
00:33:26,548 --> 00:33:28,383
Dell?
606
00:33:28,417 --> 00:33:30,479
Remember the kid
you were with at the motel?
607
00:33:30,504 --> 00:33:31,538
Pfft.
608
00:33:31,563 --> 00:33:33,421
The one with the cowboy hat?
609
00:33:33,455 --> 00:33:35,523
That's not his name.
610
00:33:36,964 --> 00:33:38,854
No? What is it?
611
00:33:40,365 --> 00:33:41,729
Byron.
612
00:33:41,764 --> 00:33:43,064
Byron who?
613
00:33:43,098 --> 00:33:45,400
Byron Gatenby.
614
00:33:45,434 --> 00:33:48,770
Dell was actually Elizabeth's son.
615
00:33:49,301 --> 00:33:51,876
Unbelievable. This was becoming one
616
00:33:51,901 --> 00:33:54,199
of the strangest cases of my career.
617
00:33:56,011 --> 00:33:57,660
Him and I, we uh...
618
00:33:59,448 --> 00:34:01,316
we killed that old man.
619
00:34:08,475 --> 00:34:12,679
Tommy identified Dell as Byron Gatenby,
620
00:34:12,713 --> 00:34:14,213
Elizabeth's son.
621
00:34:15,117 --> 00:34:16,958
Byron was in Whistler.
622
00:34:16,983 --> 00:34:20,452
We picked him up and brought him back.
623
00:34:22,300 --> 00:34:25,507
Just to look at Byron,
he's not a big guy.
624
00:34:25,745 --> 00:34:31,216
He seems pretty meek and mild.
Just doesn't fit the character
625
00:34:31,251 --> 00:34:34,219
of someone who could kill somebody.
626
00:34:34,254 --> 00:34:37,656
I hate flying. It terrifies me.
627
00:34:38,993 --> 00:34:41,096
Is that why you took
a bus to kill Bruce?
628
00:34:42,718 --> 00:34:45,164
You're gonna tell us, Byron.
629
00:34:45,198 --> 00:34:46,832
And you know how I know that?
630
00:34:46,866 --> 00:34:48,901
When I met you, I thought
I was gonna meet a killer,
631
00:34:48,935 --> 00:34:50,669
but you're not a killer.
632
00:34:50,703 --> 00:34:53,439
A killer wouldn't leave that
much proof around. There was
633
00:34:53,473 --> 00:34:56,665
the surveillance video
from the bus depot.
634
00:34:57,681 --> 00:34:59,409
Fingerprints in the rental car.
635
00:34:59,735 --> 00:35:01,214
There was Tommy's confession.
636
00:35:02,946 --> 00:35:05,918
And there was the receipt from the motel
637
00:35:05,952 --> 00:35:09,388
that was paid for by your mom.
638
00:35:11,257 --> 00:35:14,126
I met your mom. You know that?
639
00:35:14,160 --> 00:35:15,658
I got to know her, actually.
640
00:35:16,173 --> 00:35:19,424
I think she did what she
thought she had to do.
641
00:35:20,266 --> 00:35:22,234
I think she thought she had two choices:
642
00:35:22,268 --> 00:35:28,006
she could either sit back and
watch your grandma get destroyed
643
00:35:28,041 --> 00:35:29,714
by Bruce
644
00:35:31,144 --> 00:35:32,578
or do what she thought was right.
645
00:35:32,612 --> 00:35:35,681
And you know, she wasn't
good at sitting back.
646
00:35:35,715 --> 00:35:38,050
She has nothing to do with this.
647
00:35:39,377 --> 00:35:44,389
Yeah, good. Then you're gonna
have to tell us who does, Byron.
648
00:35:46,652 --> 00:35:47,926
It was hard to believe
649
00:35:47,961 --> 00:35:51,730
that an 18-year-old kid is gonna
come up with this whole plan
650
00:35:51,764 --> 00:35:54,733
on his own just to help his grandmother.
651
00:35:54,767 --> 00:35:58,047
It certainly looked like Elizabeth
was pulling the strings.
652
00:35:58,499 --> 00:36:02,107
But I needed to get more evidence.
653
00:36:04,277 --> 00:36:06,645
You're not gonna believe this.
654
00:36:06,679 --> 00:36:09,248
I got the receipts from the bus company.
655
00:36:09,282 --> 00:36:11,650
Elizabeth used her credit card
to buy three tickets
656
00:36:11,684 --> 00:36:14,985
from BC to St. Catharines,
two of them under the name Dell.
657
00:36:16,499 --> 00:36:18,941
One from Whistler.
658
00:36:18,989 --> 00:36:21,527
The other one from Kimberly.
659
00:36:21,561 --> 00:36:23,428
It's where Byron and Tommy are from.
660
00:36:23,463 --> 00:36:24,770
Yeah.
661
00:36:29,536 --> 00:36:31,741
Elizabeth made it all happen.
662
00:36:31,868 --> 00:36:35,315
But she clearly was not
at the scene of the murder.
663
00:36:36,547 --> 00:36:39,211
For us to get a first-degree
murder conviction,
664
00:36:39,245 --> 00:36:42,648
Byron had to come clean
and tell the truth.
665
00:36:42,682 --> 00:36:46,414
We needed him to testify
against his mother.
666
00:36:54,260 --> 00:36:55,827
Who killed Bruce Firman?
667
00:36:55,862 --> 00:36:59,698
Me and Tommy. We killed Bruce.
668
00:36:59,732 --> 00:37:04,036
Why? Did your mother put you up to it?
669
00:37:04,070 --> 00:37:07,105
No, it was my idea. All of it.
670
00:37:07,140 --> 00:37:11,577
I saw Bruce was hurting Grandma, so
I decided to do something about it.
671
00:37:11,611 --> 00:37:14,746
I'm sorry, Byron. I know
that that's just not true.
672
00:37:20,959 --> 00:37:23,696
I already know that your mother
was involved in this.
673
00:37:28,928 --> 00:37:30,829
You see, Byron?
674
00:37:30,863 --> 00:37:34,633
Your mother used her credit card
to purchase your ticket.
675
00:37:36,085 --> 00:37:37,519
And Tommy's too.
676
00:37:46,279 --> 00:37:48,413
I'm going to hell for this.
677
00:37:54,387 --> 00:37:58,056
My mom told me to kill Bruce
678
00:37:58,845 --> 00:38:00,345
and she paid me.
679
00:38:01,589 --> 00:38:04,718
She got our bus tickets.
Put me in the hotel.
680
00:38:04,866 --> 00:38:06,398
Tommy too.
681
00:38:06,650 --> 00:38:10,335
She told us to wait until the right
time. And then one night, she...
682
00:38:12,939 --> 00:38:14,643
she called me.
683
00:38:15,960 --> 00:38:18,228
And she said that she was having
dinner with Grandma.
684
00:38:21,247 --> 00:38:24,416
Me and Tommy drove to Grandma's house.
685
00:38:24,450 --> 00:38:26,918
How'd you get in?
686
00:38:26,953 --> 00:38:28,420
Hidden key in the back.
687
00:38:29,017 --> 00:38:31,786
Went inside the garage and waited.
688
00:38:37,096 --> 00:38:39,689
When Bruce walked in, Tommy just...
689
00:38:40,333 --> 00:38:42,434
whacked him in the face
with a pipe wrench.
690
00:38:44,532 --> 00:38:46,872
And I was supposed to strangle him
691
00:38:46,906 --> 00:38:48,877
with a guitar string I brought.
692
00:38:50,043 --> 00:38:53,545
But... But I just started kicking him.
693
00:38:55,096 --> 00:38:57,691
- Why?
- I don't know.
694
00:38:58,975 --> 00:39:01,253
Felt good?
695
00:39:04,724 --> 00:39:06,325
As I'm kicking him,
696
00:39:06,359 --> 00:39:10,095
he just rolled over and
looked me straight in the eye.
697
00:39:12,119 --> 00:39:13,844
I just froze.
698
00:39:14,701 --> 00:39:18,906
Tommy just started yelling
"Finish him! Toast him!"
699
00:39:19,358 --> 00:39:23,942
And I couldn't so Tommy hit him
in the head until it was done.
700
00:39:25,678 --> 00:39:28,761
While her son was killing Mr. Firman,
701
00:39:28,952 --> 00:39:33,185
Elizabeth was sitting in this
restaurant in Niagara Falls
702
00:39:33,219 --> 00:39:38,161
with her mom, complaining
about the tea, making a scene.
703
00:39:38,186 --> 00:39:41,023
She was concerned
with covering her tracks.
704
00:39:41,048 --> 00:39:44,463
And she let her son take the fall.
705
00:39:44,497 --> 00:39:48,633
I told her that Bruce wouldn't
be bothering Grandma anymore.
706
00:39:49,659 --> 00:39:52,761
She kissed me and she paid me 400 bucks.
707
00:39:59,624 --> 00:40:01,892
- Did your grandmother see you?
- No.
708
00:40:07,019 --> 00:40:10,188
I'm going to hell for this, aren't I?
709
00:40:11,090 --> 00:40:14,098
Byron said his
mother paid him to kill Bruce.
710
00:40:16,562 --> 00:40:17,896
It was unbelievable.
711
00:40:17,930 --> 00:40:20,532
I don't know that I
could ever understand
712
00:40:20,566 --> 00:40:23,135
how a mother could ask that of her son.
713
00:40:31,544 --> 00:40:33,779
- Hello.
- We found him.
714
00:40:33,813 --> 00:40:37,549
Byron. We interviewed him. He confessed.
715
00:40:37,583 --> 00:40:40,385
We know you planned the murder.
716
00:40:40,420 --> 00:40:43,121
We know you paid him, too.
Four hundred dollars.
717
00:40:43,156 --> 00:40:45,724
Elizabeth Gatenby, you're under arrest
718
00:40:45,758 --> 00:40:48,360
for the murder of Bruce Firman.
719
00:40:49,562 --> 00:40:51,463
You destroyed his life.
720
00:40:51,497 --> 00:40:53,732
Byron did what he did because
he loves his grandmother.
721
00:40:53,766 --> 00:40:55,434
No, he did it because of you!
722
00:40:56,285 --> 00:40:58,688
Because he looked up to you
for the right thing to do.
723
00:40:58,713 --> 00:41:00,038
And you manipulated him.
724
00:41:00,552 --> 00:41:03,288
You tapped into his weaknesses
until you succeeded
725
00:41:03,313 --> 00:41:05,143
in turning your own son into a murderer.
726
00:41:08,241 --> 00:41:10,463
How do you even call yourself a mother?
727
00:41:20,159 --> 00:41:23,728
Elizabeth never confesses to the murder.
728
00:41:23,763 --> 00:41:30,135
From that point on, she really
never says anything to us again.
729
00:41:34,974 --> 00:41:38,109
I had closed my first case as a lead,
730
00:41:38,144 --> 00:41:41,401
but I felt terribly sorry
for Bruce's family.
731
00:41:42,815 --> 00:41:46,562
For Mr. Firman to meet his end this way
732
00:41:46,587 --> 00:41:50,021
is... is really tragic.
733
00:41:52,878 --> 00:41:59,452
- Sync and corrections by ByDem -
- www.addic7ed.com -
55603
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.