All language subtitles for The Bit Player (2018 - Biography - Documentary - English Subtitles)

(trumpet jazz music)

Advertise your product or brand here
contact www.OpenSubtitles.org today

- The flaming trumpet.

Once when I was in junior high school,

preparing to perform in
the school talent show,

my father asked me if I thought
it would be a good effect

to have fire shooting out
of the trumpet as I played.

(trumpet jazz music)

Of course, I had to admit

that that would indeed be very impressive.

He then went into his workshop
and began tinkering around.

(trumpet jazz music)

And by the very next day,
I found myself holding

in my hands a flaming trumpet.
And by the very next day,
I found myself holding

in my hands a flaming trumpet.

(cheerful piano music)

- Who's Claude Shannon?

- Who's Claude Shannon?

- Claude Shannon?

- You're asking me this question?

- I often go back to this...

Well, you've probably heard the word bit.
- I often go back to this...

Well, you've probably heard the word bit.

- We live in the information age
Well, you've probably heard the word bit.

- We live in the information age

and he's the father of
the information theory.

- Doesn't everybody know
who Claude Shannon is?

- If you value the fact
that your iPhone can contact
- Doesn't everybody know
who Claude Shannon is?

- If you value the fact
that your iPhone can contact

and call for you an Uber,
and then place a phone call,

and then text a friend,
and then check your email,

all of those things you owe to
Claude Shannon and his work.

- I truly believe he's at the same level

as Newton or Einstein.
- I truly believe he's at the same level

as Newton or Einstein.

- Why don't people know about him?

They know about Alexander Graham Bell,

they know about Henry Ford,
but so few people have heard
They know about Alexander Graham Bell,

they know about Henry Ford,
but so few people have heard

of Claude Shannon, and his
impact is bigger than all

of the household names.

- I didn't know that that was one person,

and whoever that one person was

is probably the most
important person in our time.

- What would the world look like

if Claude Shannon hadn't done what he did?

(piano key boings)

(gentle instrumental music)

- By the 1980s, the revolution
(gentle instrumental music)

- By the 1980s, the revolution

that he started is in full swing,
- By the 1980s, the revolution

that he started is in full swing,

but he is nowhere to be found.

He's a founding father,

but he's a distant historical figure,

sort of like George Washington.

And nobody really knows what he's doing.

(gentle instrumental music)

(Claude clears throat)

- Is this where
you want me to sit?

- Yes, please.

Let's see...

- Here we go.

- Thank you again for agreeing

to see me, Dr. Shannon.
- Thank you again for agreeing

to see me, Dr. Shannon.

This is an amazing room.

- I guess it must seem
pretty funny a grown man

has a room full of toys. (chuckles)

My life's work. (laughs)
has a room full of toys. (chuckles)

My life's work. (laughs)

- I don't
think you need to worry

about just being remembered for your toys.

- Claude doesn't overly worry
about how he'll be remembered.

- No.
- Claude doesn't overly worry
about how he'll be remembered.

- No.

How'd you uncover me again, Michelle?

- As I said
on the phone, I'm working

on a project about the
founders of the modern age,

and I kept seeing over and over again,

"Claude Shannon, the father
of Information Theory."

(Claude chuckles)

But nobody seemed to know
what you're doing now.

Your 1948 paper was a blueprint

for what people are calling
The Information Age.

- Well, I wrote that nearly 40 years ago.
for what people are calling
The Information Age.

- Well, I wrote that nearly 40 years ago.

- Yes.

In a sense you saw the future.
- Yes.

In a sense you saw the future.

How did you do that?

(Betty chuckles)

(Claude chuckles)
(Betty chuckles)

(Claude chuckles)

- How long do you plan on being here?

(Claude and Betty laugh)
- How long do you plan on being here?

(Claude and Betty laugh)

- Maybe I should get some coffee.

- Oh, good.

(Claude and Betty laugh)

The fact is, Michelle,
that my mind wanders around

and conceives of different
things day and night.

Well, like a science
fiction writer, I think,

"What if it were like this?"

And I never particularly cared

whether anybody was interested
in it or wanted to work on it

or thought I was right.

(dramatic music)
or thought I was right.

(dramatic music)

I was always interested in
communication things, whether

or not people thought that's
what I should be working on.
I was always interested in
communication things, whether

or not people thought that's
what I should be working on.

(dramatic music)
or not people thought that's
what I should be working on.

(dramatic music)

(man shouts)

- Shannon
thought about the problem

of communication in a way that nobody else

had ever thought of.

The basic problem is
how do you get a message

from one place to another?
The basic problem is
how do you get a message

from one place to another?

The challenge was always how to go faster,

how to go farther, and
how to be more accurate.

(horse neighs)

The huge advance was the discovery

of how to use electricity to communicate.

(phone ringing)

- Hello?

Hello? - Hello?

Hello?

- But initially it was very unreliable,
Hello?

- But initially it was very unreliable,

and efforts to improve
things were just haphazard.

And then, Shannon came
along and asked a question

that hadn't even occurred to anyone,

"Could you construct a universal
theory of communication

"that could allow perfect communication?"

He drew a very simple diagram.

You have some information you wanna send

and you have to convert it
into something like sound waves

or electrical pulses or
light that can be sent

over a channel or medium,
like air or wires.

There's things that can disrupt
the signal on that medium,

like static or smoke or noise
There's things that can disrupt
the signal on that medium,

like static or smoke or noise

before it gets to the receiver.
Like static or smoke or noise

before it gets to the receiver.

And then the receiver
converts the signal back

into something that's
hopefully really close
And then the receiver
converts the signal back

into something that's
hopefully really close

to the original message.

The diagram looked trivial,
but it allowed Shannon

to break the problem of communication down

into its essential parts and
create a universal theory

that you can apply to anything you want.

- This is a calculator I
built to do calculations

with Roman numerals.

I call it THROBAC:

Thrifty Roman Numeral
Backward Looking Computer.
I call it THROBAC:

Thrifty Roman Numeral
Backward Looking Computer.

- Did you make that here at MIT?

- No, I made it when I
was at Bell Laboratories
- Did you
make that here at MIT?

- No, I made it when I
was at Bell Laboratories

when I should've been working
on communication things.

- It didn't have a big commercial market.

(Claude chuckles)

- There are some important things

that made Claude Shannon the thinker

and the mind that he was.
That made Claude Shannon the thinker

and the mind that he was.

I believe it was important that he grew up

in Gaylord, Michigan, I
think it was important

that he came of age in the Midwest,

and I think it was equally
important that he came of age
that he came of age in the Midwest,

and I think it was equally
important that he came of age

in a town that built things,
where a boy like him could,

with his best friend, go
to his friend's backyard

and build an elevator in a barn.

- My mother was a principal

at the high school.
- My mother was a principal

at the high school.

My father had a bunch of jobs.

He had a furniture store.

He was a probate judge.

And he was also an undertaker.

He got me an erector set.

It's still one of my favorite toys.

My grandfather was a very
interesting character,

he was always inventing things.

He was intent on determining if the turn

of the century was 1900 or 1901.

I was very impressed he spent so much time

on something most people
thought was totally useless.

(cheerful pianola music)

- So, would you
say your first experiment

in communication was a failure?

- No, but
there was a lot of noise

on the line.
- No, but
there was a lot of noise

on the line.

- Motivation to
come up with something better?

- A little error could turn
- Motivation to
come up with something better?

- A little error could turn

"Do you like me?" into "Do you hear me?"

And which she was answering
was very important to me.
"Do you like me?" into "Do you hear me?"

And which she was answering
was very important to me.

- So, you used Morse code?

- Oh, you bet.

Morse already invented the binary code,

with dots and dashes, and he
had the great idea of going
Morse already invented the binary code,

with dots and dashes, and he
had the great idea of going

to a print shop to find out
which letters we use the most.
with dots and dashes, and he
had the great idea of going

to a print shop to find out
which letters we use the most.

E, the most common letter,
gets the shortest code, dot.
to a print shop to find out
which letters we use the most.

E, the most common letter,
gets the shortest code, dot.

T, the second most common,
gets the dash, and so on.

Exactly the sort of things I was thinking

about 100 years later.

- He had what we would probably call now

a free range childhood,

even though there wasn't
really a term for it back
a free range childhood,

even though there wasn't
really a term for it back

in the 1910s and '20s;
but these were things

like rigging up a barbed wire telegraph

to connect his house
to his neighbors house
like rigging up a barbed wire telegraph

to connect his house
to his neighbors house

along the fences, things like
learning wigwag signaling,

which is the idea of sending
Morse code with flags

so that your body kind of becomes a sort
which is the idea of sending
Morse code with flags

so that your body kind of becomes a sort

of Morse code telegraph,

things like solving math puzzles.

Shannon's favorite story growing up

was Edgar Allan Poe's "The Goldbug."

(gentle clavichord music)

- Poe loved codes and
cryptography, just like me.

He even invited his readers

to send him their own
cryptograms that he'd solve.
He even invited his readers

to send him their own
cryptograms that he'd solve.

In "The Goldbug," a man
finds a scrap of paper

with a coded message that
tells where the pirate,

Captain Kidd, buried his treasure.

(gentle instrumental music)

The message is written
in invisible ink though

and only appears when
it's held up to a flame.
The message is written
in invisible ink though

and only appears when
it's held up to a flame.

Poe shows how you can break the code

by connecting the most used symbols

to the most used letters in English.

(gentle instrumental music)

It's just like Morse did, in reverse.

Just like Alan Turing
did, too, during the war,

looking for patterns to
break the German codes.
Just like Alan Turing
did, too, during the war,

looking for patterns to
break the German codes.

Finding patterns, that's the key.

- The foremost characteristic
of my father was playfulness.

Play infused everything he did.

And you can see that in
all the machines he made,

like, who makes a flaming trumpet?

Making a chair lift to go
down to lake and come back,

that was a playful thing that
he did with Marvin Minsky.

Nothing was sacred.

My brother, Andrew, had an idea
for a rocket-powered Frisbee

and my father loved that.
My brother, Andrew, had an idea
for a rocket-powered Frisbee

and my father loved that.

(Frisbee buzzing)

If we had a tray of coffee cake, somebody,

if they were cutting a piece,

they usually wouldn't
cut a piece off the end,

they would cut a piece out of the middle.

And they might cut it out
in an interesting shape,

it wouldn't just be a square.

It might be an octagon,
it might be a pentagon,
it wouldn't just be a square.

It might be an octagon,
it might be a pentagon,

something like that.

He tried to fool with
everything a little bit

and see if he could make it more fun.
He tried to fool with
everything a little bit

and see if he could make it more fun.

- I was a big fan of "Alice in Wonderland"

and "Through the Looking-Glass."

You know, Lewis Carroll
was a mathematician, too.

(rabbit sneezes)

Wonderland is full of word games and codes

and mathematical ideas.

"Through the Looking" is
almost like a big chess game

with crazy rules of logic.

- Stop, stop, stop,
stop, stop, stop, stop.

- Carroll liked

to invent funny word puzzles

that you could solve with mathematics.

He used something called Boolean algebra

to convert the words into equations.

The only numbers in
Boolean algebra are zero

and one, nothing and everything.

And you could reach a conclusion by adding

and multiplying the equations.
And you could reach a conclusion by adding

and multiplying the equations.

- So, what's the answer?

- Babies cannot manage crocodiles.

- He couldn't do mental
arithmetic any better

than the average person.
- He couldn't do mental
arithmetic any better

than the average person.

And if he had two numbers
to multiply, 26 times 42,

he'd go on the blackboard, 26, 42,

and do long multiplication, which was...

You'd think he'd just be,
you know, a numbers genius.

No, he was much bigger than that.

- I got two Bachelor's
degrees at Michigan.

One in electrical engineering,
the other in mathematics.

I really wasn't sure what to do at all,

and I saw a little postcard on the wall

that said MIT was looking
for a research assistant

to run a machine that
could solve equations.
that said MIT was looking
for a research assistant

to run a machine that
could solve equations.

They called it The Thinking Machine.

That sounded interesting.

Vannevar Bush (chuckles)

right over there, he invented it.

He was pretty famous in the
world of engineering by then,

so I applied and spent the
next four years at MIT.

(intense instrumental music)

- The electromechanical
Differential Analyzer
(intense instrumental music)

- The electromechanical
Differential Analyzer

performs scientific and industrial marvels
- The electromechanical
Differential Analyzer

performs scientific and industrial marvels

at the Massachusetts
Institute of Technology.

Perforated tape introduces the
data to the 100-ton marvel,

which solves problems
Perforated tape introduces the
data to the 100-ton marvel,

which solves problems

beyond the ordinary
methods of calculation.

- The Thinking Machine,

which officially was called
the Differential Analyzer,
- The Thinking Machine,

which officially was called
the Differential Analyzer,

was the smartest calculating
machine of the time.

All sorts of gears and rotating
shafts and wheels and so on,

it must've weighed 100 tons.

My job was to set the different wheels

and things to solve equations.

The heart of the machine
though was electric switches,

just like the switches you find
The heart of the machine
though was electric switches,

just like the switches you find

in a telephone network to route calls.

It occurred to me,

because I'd taken the Boolean
algebra course in Michigan,
It occurred to me,

because I'd taken the Boolean
algebra course in Michigan,

that there was a beautiful parallel

between electric switches,
which are just on or off,

and Boolean algebra
which reduced everything

to true and false.

I used one for true and zero for false.

I worked out the mathematics,

which had some funny things like,

if a true statement plus a true statement
which had some funny things like,

if a true statement plus a true statement

equals true statement, that
means one plus one equals one.

I wrote it all up for my Master's thesis

and that was the beginning
of my great career. (laughs)

- So, his Master's thesis is considered

the most important Master's
thesis of all time.

And he writes this at the age of 21.
the most important Master's
thesis of all time.

And he writes this at the age of 21.

He even wins a prize.

It's the Noble Prize.

Now, that's not Noble,
it's N-O-B-L-E is the prize

that he wins.

It's very prestigious, it's
given to the top engineer.

He's the youngest recipient
ever, and he gets prize money,

a certificate, he's
invited to give the paper
He's the youngest recipient
ever, and he gets prize money,

a certificate, he's
invited to give the paper

to an audience of engineers
in Washington D.C.

and, best part, he gets written
up in the New York Times.

- Shannon's Master's thesis

is his first fundamental leap of insight.
- Shannon's Master's thesis

is his first fundamental leap of insight.

George Boole came up with laws of thought,

and they were nice and beautiful,

but Shannon was looking at
electromechanical switches,

and what is the connection between laws

of thought and switches?

(clinking)

Well, Shannon realized
they are the same thing.

(clinking)

And that was just mind-boggling,

because if the laws of
thought could be implemented

in switches then it's not outlandish
because if the laws of
thought could be implemented

in switches then it's not outlandish

to surmise that at some
point machines could think.

(gentle instrumental music)

- No, no, not that way.

Back up, back up a little bit.

Theseus would've figured this out already.
Back up, back up a little bit.

Theseus would've figured this out already.

- I've heard people say
that your Master's thesis

was the most important
Master's thesis of the century.

Did you have a eureka moment?
was the most important
Master's thesis of the century.

Did you have a eureka moment?

- (chuckles) I might have,
if I'd known how to spell it.

I had a lot of fun
figuring that thing out.

I had a great time.

(gentle instrumental music)

- I was going to Radcliffe,
the girls' part of Harvard,

and I had two friends who
said, "Oh, Norma, come with us.

"We know some nice guys over at MIT."

I said, "Okay," and we went.

And it was a living room
with three bedrooms off it.

Now, two of the guys
who lived there came out

and talked to my friends,
and the door was open
Now, two of the guys
who lived there came out

and talked to my friends,
and the door was open

to the third bedroom.

(cheerful jazz music)

And I could see someone
in it not coming forth,

but what came forth from
there was Bix Beiderbecke.

(cheerful jazz music)

So, I walked over that way

and said, "Why don't you come out?"

And he came just sort of halfway out.

(cheerful jazz music)

And he said, "Why don't you come in?"

(cheerful jazz music)
And he said, "Why don't you come in?"

(cheerful jazz music)

He was so funny and charming,
and delicious and cute,

and saw things, I mean, his comments

about things were like an artist.

He didn't sound like a
scientist, not at all.

He liked poetry, and
he liked E.E. Cummings.

He wrote a poem to my
bosom and I tore it up.

Yes, I'm ashamed and unhappy
that I did, but there you are.

(gentle guitar music)

He wanted to learn to fly, and he did.

He had just done his
one plus one equals one,

it was his Master's thesis,
and he had to prepare French

to get his PhD.

(gentle instrumental music)

And I had to teach him enough
French to pass the doctorate.

(gentle instrumental music)

I love it that he wasn't
that good at that.

(big band music)
I love it that he wasn't
that good at that.

(big band music)

- "Dear Dr. Bush, I did not,

"as you may have anticipated,
marry a lady scientist,

"but rather a writer.

"She was helping me with my French

"and apparently it ripened into
something more than French."

(big band music)

- So, you turned
to biology for your PhD?

(Claude laughs)

- Vann Bush.

Vann liked how I used my
queer algebra so much,

that's what he called it,
that he suggested I try

to apply it to genetics.

I didn't know anything about genetics.

This was in 1940, before Watson

and Crick had even
figured out DNA structure.

But, you know, DNA might be

the ultimate information storage device.

So, I read all the
introductory genetic text books

that I could find, and
what I discovered was

that you could represent
different genetic possibilities

mathematically in matrices.

And then you could just use matrix algebra

to make predictions of
how traits were passed on

through generations.
to make predictions of
how traits were passed on

through generations.

But I don't think the biologists
knew what to make of it.

Maybe it was too far out for them.

- He'd got a national research
fellowship in mathematics

to the Institute for
Advanced Study in June 1940,

and that's when we moved to Princeton.

(gentle instrumental music)

Claude liked my taste.

What he liked particularly
was a painting that I loved,

the Seurat, Dimanche a la Grande
Jatte, Sunday in the Park.

He liked the timelessness of it.

(intense instrumental music)

I looked at that a million times

and I didn't think it was a
painting about time, but he did.

- I met Einstein, Gödel, von Neumann,

but you've got to get the
picture right, Michelle,

I said I met them but they
probably wouldn't say they met me

because they wouldn't remember.

But I remember being very impressed

when I met Einstein, for example.

He always walked to work,
when I met Einstein, for example.

He always walked to work,

and when I drove by I'd wave at him.

I don't think he had any idea who I was,

but he probably thought I
was some kind of weirdo.

- Did you try to
talk to them about your ideas,

about information and...

Dr. Shannon?

- Oh, I...

I had a couple of good
conversations with Hermann Weyl,

who was my supervisor, about
the revolutions taking place
I had a couple of good
conversations with Hermann Weyl,

who was my supervisor, about
the revolutions taking place

in science: quantum mechanics,

the Heisenberg uncertainty principle

saying things couldn't
be measured precisely,

Kurt Gödel showing the
limitations in mathematics.

But the people at the institute

were very pure mathematics-oriented

and not so interested in
more practical things.

(gentle clarinet music)

I didn't run across anyone
who was much interested

in the things I was trying to do.

- The last six months in Princeton,

something was going wrong.

When he came home from
there, he was unhappy

and he didn't even wanna talk about it.

And it wasn't going well.

(gentle clarinet music)

He stayed home, he didn't wanna go out,

he talked less and less,

he played the clarinet more and more.
He talked less and less,

he played the clarinet more and more.

- Was it possibly
related to what was going on

in the world?

The build up to the war?

- Not at all.

He didn't wanna know
about anything political.

I thought he was just unhappy

with his work at the institute.

- Is that why
he left the institute

after two months?

- No. after two months?

- No.

We got there in September - No.

We got there in September

and I was living in
Princeton through July.
We got there in September

and I was living in
Princeton through July.

- But he was only working

at the institute for two months.

- Are you telling me that
when I thought he was

at the Institute for Advanced
Study he wasn't there?

When I was with him?

You mean he resigned
and he didn't tell me?

Was he going somewhere else?

What was he doing?

- He was working
What was he doing?

- He was working

for the National Defense
Research Committee

through Princeton University.
for the National Defense
Research Committee

through Princeton University.

- Well, that's interesting.

Listen, something funny was going on

because he looked different,

he was a completely different guy.

Something peculiar was happening.

It was hard living with him.

I said, "You know, I can't live this way,

"and I've got to get a divorce."

(gentle clarinet music)

- Uh.

About halfway through
the year at Princeton,

I could smell the...

I could smell the war coming along.

It occurred to me that
I would be more useful

and safer working full-time
for the war effort.

Safer against the draft,
which I didn't exactly fancy.

So, what I did was I resigned
my fellowship halfway through,

and I went down and asked if I
could get a job at Bell Labs.

(blues music)

♪ I went to the restaurant monday ♪

- He played the blues day and night.

Teddy Grace was the singer that he adored.

Oh, I loved her, too.

I still love her.
Oh, I loved her, too.

I still love her.

Very sad blues that he
played, but beautiful ones.

He had a very big record player.

And you could hear it through the ceiling.
He had a very big record player.

And you could hear it through the ceiling.

He played it day and night,
that's how I met him.

I said, you know, "Even
though I'm up all night,

"a good part of the
night, but you keep me up.

"I can't even study.

"It's too noisy."

He said, "Well, I'll move it."

And then he asked me
would I go out with him.

He was very good-looking, really striking.

He had this black thing, you know, a curl

that came over his forehead always,
He had this black thing, you know, a curl

that came over his forehead always,

that he had to shake off.

He loved jazz.

I mean, it was a passion
with him, a real passion.

He said the improvisation,
the unpredictability

of it is what he loved about it, he said.

When I asked him, "What are you doing?

"How are you making a living?"

He said, "I work with numbers."

And I thought, "Oh, he's an accountant."

You know, I think it was a suffering time.

I had German measles, and
Claude was trying to get them.

He said if he got it then he
wouldn't have to go to work,

because he hated the work he was doing.

- Initially they had me working
on missile firing systems,

but there was another group
at Bell working on systems

to scramble the communications

between Churchill and Roosevelt.
To scramble the communications

between Churchill and Roosevelt.

That was the sort of thing

I was interested in, communications.

So, I asked if I could go work with them.

Most of the cryptography group were trying

to figure out how to
crack specific messages,

very practical stuff,
code breaking things,

like Sherlock Holmes and so forth.

But nobody seemed to be very interested
like Sherlock Holmes and so forth.

But nobody seemed to be very interested

in theoretical questions.
But nobody seemed to be very interested

in theoretical questions.

Like, how many messages
you needed to intercept

before you could get a solution?

Or, could you create a
completely unbreakable code?

That was the sort of thing
I was more interested

in trying to do.

- Norma had told
him to get in analysis,

because he must've been
very depressed already

when he was with her.

- I didn't get as much response

to my cryptography work as I expected.
- I didn't get as much response

to my cryptography work as I expected.

I guess it wasn't very useful,

practically speaking, to cryptographers.

But after the war though, I
was called in as a consultant
practically speaking, to cryptographers.

But after the war though, I
was called in as a consultant

to the National Security
Agency in Washington.
But after the war though, I
was called in as a consultant

to the National Security
Agency in Washington.

So, I guess someone...

I probably better...

Even though this was a long time ago,

I guess I shouldn't tell you about that.

- I asked him, "How is
it going in analysis?"

He said, "The guy's
finally learned something

"about mathematics and
how to think properly."
He said, "The guy's
finally learned something

"about mathematics and
how to think properly."

He said that what had
hurt him so in life was

that there was certainty
until a certain time,

that once he knew a thing to
be true it would remain true,

and everything had changed.

Everything became sort
of relative, he said.

He had believed in black and
white truth, absolute truth.

And those had gone for him.

He had to adjust to that.

(gentle instrumental music)

"With love and kisses
and curses and hisses.
(gentle instrumental music)

"With love and kisses
and curses and hisses.

"Claude, 1944."

That was a long time ago.

(gentle instrumental music)

It doesn't seem to be
that long ago, really not.

I didn't know how much
I cared for him, really.

I should've known.

That secret life, I think,
really got between us.

- I found this 1945
cryptography report you wrote.

And it uses the words
"information theory".

And I think that that's the
first time that phrase appeared,
And it uses the words
"information theory".

And I think that that's the
first time that phrase appeared,

those two words together
in print, anywhere.

- Is that so?

- Yes.

See?

And I'm wondering, your monumental paper

on information theory
didn't come out until 1948.

- Hmm.

- So is it accurate to say

that information theory came
out of your cryptography work?

- No.

Look, Michelle, you're
looking for a simple...
- No.

Look, Michelle, you're
looking for a simple...

It would be more accurate
to say they were going on

at the same time.
It would be more accurate
to say they were going on

at the same time.

In my mind, they're connected.

How you make something unintelligible

or how you make it
intelligible are two sides

of the same coin.

- But officially
you were just working

on cryptography, right?

- Are you looking to work
on cryptography, right?

- Are you looking to work

for the district attorney's
office? (chuckles)

- No.
for the district attorney's
office? (chuckles)

- No.

No, I'm just...

- The cryptography work was just a way
No, I'm just...

- The cryptography work was just a way

of legitimizing the other work I was doing

at home outside office hours, so to speak,

to make it look like I
was working on decent,

worthwhile things, if
you know what I mean.

- Did you feel like you had
worthwhile things, if
you know what I mean.

- Did you feel like you had

to hide the other work?

- Not hide exactly, but I didn't know
to hide the other work?

- Not hide exactly, but I didn't know

if it would all work out.

- Shannon works on his universal theory

of communication for 10 years.

He works on it through a failed marriage

and through this war work
that he really dislikes.

He works at nights, he
works on the weekends,

he collects snatches
of time here and there,

and he works alone.
he collects snatches
of time here and there,

and he works alone.

He doesn't tell anyone
what he's working on.
and he works alone.

He doesn't tell anyone
what he's working on.

What he realizes is that in order

to understand communication,
he needs a new understanding

of the thing you wanna communicate.

He needs a radical new
definition of information.

- Information, which they
called intelligence at the time,

was a slippery concept.

I wanted to try to find a
way to treat information
was a slippery concept.

I wanted to try to find a
way to treat information

like a physical thing, like
energy that you could measure.

(gentle instrumental music)

What I realized was,
to measure information,

you have to look at it
without regard to meaning.

That upsets a lot of people.

That content is irrelevant.
That upsets a lot of people.

That content is irrelevant.

(intense instrumental music)

The point of sending a message
is to remove uncertainty,

something you didn't
know but now you know.

Do you have a coin, Michelle?

- A coin?
- Yes, a coin.

I'd get up to get one myself,

but you'll just tell me to
sit back down. (chuckles)

- Um...

Yes.

- There.

(Claude clears throat)

Heads or tails?

- Tails.

- Heads.

A coin toss is an example
of the simplest form

of information to
communicate, a binary choice.
A coin toss is an example
of the simplest form

of information to
communicate, a binary choice.

True or false, heads or
tails, a one or a zero.

A bit.

(gentle instrumental music)

- Shannon's big idea number one:

convert all information to bits.

(coin clinking)

(gentle instrumental music)

(glass crashing)

(gentle instrumental music)

All information can be
represented as zeros and ones.

Pictures, music, (upbeat music)

video, all information can
be treated the same way.

(gentle instrumental music)

Which means the problem
of communication reduces

to just two things:
how do I convert things

to zeros and ones,

and how do I make sure that those zeros

and ones get through accurately?

- Is your coin legal?

- Sorry?
- Is your coin legal?

- Sorry?

- Your coin's not counterfeit, is it?

- Not that I know of.

- So, if I toss it 100 times,
- Not that I know of.

- So, if I toss it 100 times,

each time I toss it there's
an equal probability

that it's a head or tail.

I'd need 100 bits of
information, one for each toss,

to communicate the results.

Now, if it turns out you're
some sort of a con woman
to communicate the results.

Now, if it turns out you're
some sort of a con woman

and you thought it might
be fun to pull the wool

over some gullible old man's eyes...

Heads, right?

- It's heads on both sides.

- Yeah, I didn't need
any information from you

to know the result.

If something's completely predictable,

there's zero information.
If something's completely predictable,

there's zero information.

But, on the other hand, if
something's completely random,

you need the information about everything.

It's counterintuitive,

but gibberish contains more information
It's counterintuitive,

but gibberish contains more information

than great literature.

- Not if it's "Finnegans Wake."

(Claude laughs)
- Not if it's "Finnegans Wake."

(Claude laughs)

- No, James Joyce is
unpredictable. (chuckles)

- Or the Jabberwocky poem,

"Twas brillig, and the slithy toves.

"Did gyre and gimble in the wabe."

(Claude laughs)

- You could barely guess
the next letter of that.

But normal English though, I calculated,

is over 50% redundant.

You know if certain
words follow each other,

there's grammar rules.
You know if certain
words follow each other,

there's grammar rules.

When you learn a language,

you inherently know the statistics,

that's why you can drop
letters and even words

and still understand the message.

- Looking at the redundancy

in English gives Shannon
his big thought number two:

compress your information.

(gentle instrumental music)

Eliminate the redundancy.

Just send what you can't predict.

(gentle instrumental music)

And then he asked the question

that nobody had really thought of before,

is there a minimum size,
a minimum number of bits

that I can shrink my information to

and not lose anything essential?

(playful music)

He discovers there is a minimum

and he shows how to calculate it.

His formula is based on the
probabilities in the message.

It has a very intriguing
form, it's almost identical

to a fundamental quantity
in physics called entropy,

which is related to
randomness and disorder.

(intense instrumental music)

Shannon calls his quantity entropy, too.

And what he proves is that the entropy

is actually the answer to his question,
And what he proves is that the entropy

is actually the answer to his question,

"What's the best I can do?"

The entropy is the absolute minimum size

you can compress your
message without any loss.

(intense orchestral music)

Shannon's ideas that you
can compress a huge amount

of information into something very small

is what makes The
Information Age possible.
of information into something very small

is what makes The
Information Age possible.

- Do you know what the first
message was that was sent

on the Washington-Moscow hotline?
- Do you know what the first
message was that was sent

on the Washington-Moscow hotline?

- Uh...
on the Washington-Moscow hotline?

- Uh...

"Do you hear me?"

(Claude chuckles)
"Do you hear me?"

(Claude chuckles)

- "The quick brown fox jumped
over the lazy dog's back."

One, two, three, four, five,
six, seven, eight, nine, zero.

It uses every letter of the alphabet,

but it isn't the most efficient

because some of the letters are repeated.
But it isn't the most efficient

because some of the letters are repeated.

Betty and I had a grand
time trying to come up

with the shortest sentence that
uses every letter only once.
Betty and I had a grand
time trying to come up

with the shortest sentence that
uses every letter only once.

- We spent a lot of time
looking in the dictionary

for words heavy on consonants
and light on vowels.

- The hard part is that
there's only a few vowels

and every word needs to have one.

Squdgy Fez Blank Jimp Crwth Vox.

(intense orchestral music)

- Shannon's ideas that you
should first change everything

to zeros and ones and then
compress it is a huge step

towards the universal
theory of communication,

but it's not the end of the story,

because you still have to get those zeros

and ones across your channel,
because you still have to get those zeros

and ones across your channel,

and the channel has physical limitations,

whether it's a wire or a pipe
with water flowing through it.
and the channel has physical limitations,

whether it's a wire or a pipe
with water flowing through it.

And then, there's always noise, (static)

things like static or interference,

that can mix up or flip the
zeros and ones and wipe you out.

Shannon wonders, "Can I
calculate for any channel

"a speed limit beyond which you know

"things are gonna fall apart?"
"a speed limit beyond which you know

"things are gonna fall apart?"

He comes up with another formula,

it's a theoretical maximum speed,

an information speed limit,
like the speed of light.

We call it the Shannon limit.

You can't go faster
than the Shannon limit.

If you try, you go off a cliff.

- The idea that there was a speed limit

to information was so out of the blue.

I mean, even just
conceptually this was a shock.

It was like when Einstein said

that you couldn't make things go faster

than the speed of light.

But what Shannon showed is if you tried

to get past this limit,
above the Shannon limit,

you cannot recover any useful information.

(static)

- Shannon's third big idea, huge idea:

use mathematics to eliminate noise.

This seemed crazy, what
does that even mean?
use mathematics to eliminate noise.

This seemed crazy, what
does that even mean?

He proved that mathematics
could eliminate errors

from static and interference.

You could use mathematical
codes to overcome noise.

And then, as the icing on the cake,

Shannon claimed this could work right up

to the Shannon limit.

If you could find the right codes,

you could have perfect
communication with as little errors

as you wanted, and that
was the revolution.

(alarm-clock ringing)

(wrist-watch bleeping)

(telephone ringing)
(wrist-watch bleeping)

(telephone ringing)

(cell phone ringing)

(intense orchestral music)

(satellite bleeping)

- Suppose you wanted
to use Shannon's ideas

to help with one of the most
difficult known problems

in communication:
communicating with a spouse.

- One communication
scenario I can think of

applying Shannon's ideas to is
communication in a marriage,
- One communication
scenario I can think of

applying Shannon's ideas to is
communication in a marriage,

which, as we all know,
can be really difficult.
applying Shannon's ideas to is
communication in a marriage,

which, as we all know,
can be really difficult.

- This communication is often
prone to serious errors,
which, as we all know,
can be really difficult.

- This communication is often
prone to serious errors,

which sometimes lead to disasters.

- There's all this noise,
there's interference,
which sometimes lead to disasters.

- There's all this noise,
there's interference,

maybe they had a bad day or a good day,

you know, maybe the kids are
shouting in the background

or the dog's barking.

And so, how do you convey
exactly what you wanna say
or the dog's barking.

And so, how do you convey
exactly what you wanna say

to your spouse in a way
that they understand?

- One way of communicating is
repeating your message over

and over again.
- One way of communicating is
repeating your message over

and over again.

- And that probably will
eventually get through,

but your partner may get annoyed with you.

- And another way is to shout louder.

- But that could also be misconstrued.

- So, what Shannon really said is
- But that could also be misconstrued.

- So, what Shannon really said is

that nagging, you know,
doesn't really work,

or speaking louder doesn't work either.

- It's how you pick your words.
Or speaking louder doesn't work either.

- It's how you pick your words.

- So, we should say
things perhaps many times

but in different fashions,
in different presentations.

We should code them well,
but in different fashions,
in different presentations.

We should code them well,

and at the end of our communication
We should code them well,

and at the end of our communication

we should always add an
error-correcting code,

which in this case
could be something like,

"But I love you."

(bomb explodes)

- When Shannon's paper came
out, it was like a bombshell.
(bomb explodes)

- When Shannon's paper came
out, it was like a bombshell.

To be able to communicate with
as few errors as you wanted,

people couldn't believe it.

Some people couldn't understand the math.

Engineers thought it was so far removed

from anything they could build,
Engineers thought it was so far removed

from anything they could build,

they just basically thought
it was science fiction.

- But there were some people
who became big champions

and saw the potential in
what Shannon had done.
- But there were some people
who became big champions

and saw the potential in
what Shannon had done.

They became totally enamored
of this new field, information.

So, he's placed on a list
of the leading scientists

of the day, alongside Richard
Feynman and Watson and Crick.
So, he's placed on a list
of the leading scientists

of the day, alongside Richard
Feynman and Watson and Crick.

He's given write ups in Time
Magazine and Fortune Magazine

and Scientific American.

And he's even given a
spread in Vogue Magazine
and Scientific American.

And he's even given a
spread in Vogue Magazine

with a photo shoot from
Henri Cartier-Bresson,

the renowned photographer,

whose other photo shoots
included Mahatma Gandhi,

Chairman Mao's funeral,
Queen Elizabeth's coronation,

and Claude Shannon at his
home in Massachusetts.

- When Shannon's paper came out in 1948,

people embraced it far beyond
what Shannon ever envisioned

it would be embraced as,

which was a mathematical
theory of information.

So, it started being applied to philosophy

and pretty much almost
every field embraced it,
So, it started being applied to philosophy

and pretty much almost
every field embraced it,

"Oh, we're gonna use
this mathematical theory

"of information in what we do."

And it got a little bit out of control,

and it was being applied in
ways that didn't make any sense.

- Just a bit more.

- I found this wonderful T-shirt

(Claude laughs)

in the London airport.

(Michelle chuckles)

- Were you famous
when your paper came out?

- Not too much.

- He wrote a paper telling them

to get off the bandwagon.

- I was worried that there was still a lot

of hard slugging left to do
in our own professional house.

- I read that a
major American mathematician

criticized your paper

for not being mathematically
rigorous enough.

- Maybe it needed people a
little brighter to understand it.

- Russian mathematicians
got it right away.

- Yes, they did.

- But the codes that
you said had to exist,

you didn't show how to get them.

And now it's 35 or so years
later and all your ideas

about converting everything
to digital, compressing audio,

those things are all happening,

but as far as your fundamental
theorem, nobody's been able

to find codes that get anywhere
near the Shannon limit.

Do you think that...

Are you worried that
you'll be proven right?

- I knew what I was doing,
and it came out exactly right.

Some people question
whether the technology

will ever be powerful
enough to implement it, but

there's a lot of bright
young people trying

to find those codes.

(roulette rattling)

- The first few times I met him,

he was giving a lecture or something.

I was very young then,
very shy, very immature,

afraid to go up and talk to him.

I was working on a problem

that I thought was very important.

It was an information theoretic problem.
That I thought was very important.

It was an information theoretic problem.

I knew he would be interested in it also.

I started to talk to him about it.

And suddenly, the problem
seemed too complicated for him,

which surprised me, but he said,

"Let's simplify it a little bit."

So we took one piece out, then
we took another piece out,

and another piece out,

suddenly it was a silly little problem

and the answer became obvious.

And then we slowly put the pieces back in

and the problem was solved.

How do you do that?

How do you take pieces
out in the right way

so that when you get done taking them out

you can solve the problem?

He would build these little experiments

and his little experiments
would give him some insights

about whether the general
problem could be solved.

- Hello.

I'm Claude Shannon, a mathematician here

at the Bell Telephone Laboratories.

This is Theseus.

Theseus is an
electrically-controlled mouse.
This is Theseus.

Theseus is an
electrically-controlled mouse.

He has the ability to solve
a certain class of problems

by trial and error means, and
then remember the solution.

In other words, he can
learn from experience.

Like his classical namesake,
Theseus has a problem

with finding his way through a maze.

The mouse moves by this electromagnet.

And its brain are these switches,

just like the switches you'd find

in a telephone switch board.

Betty did most of the wiring, by the way.

I took it over to Bell
Labs one day to show them.
Betty did most of the wiring, by the way.

I took it over to Bell
Labs one day to show them.

They liked it very much,
they were very impressed.

They even wanted to use it in a film.

- When did you build this?

It must've been one

of the earliest artificial
intelligence devices.

- Um...
of the earliest artificial
intelligence devices.

- Um...

Uh...

Betty!

When did we make Theseus?

- 1950.
- Right.
When did we make Theseus?

- 1950.
- Right.

- He made a little turtle
first that would walk

around the house and bump
into things, and back off.

And then the mouse.
around the house and bump
into things, and back off.

And then the mouse.

- So, you said that you did most
And then the mouse.

- So, you said that you did most

of your information theory
work between 1943 and 1945,

so why didn't you publish
your paper until 1948?

- Laziness, I guess.

I have a number of papers
that are unpublished,
- Laziness, I guess.

I have a number of papers
that are unpublished,

they're even more tardy than that.

- Oh, we've got boxes and boxes

of unfinished papers upstairs.

Who knows what's in them?

Maybe we should punish you
and make you go through them.

(Claude laughs)

- Well, I never liked writing very much.

I liked ideas, but I was
lazy about putting them down

on paper, which is how
you get the acclaim.

- Hmm.

After we were married, he
would dictate his papers to me

and I would write them up.

- You were a mathematician

at Bell Labs, too, right?

- I married a computer.

- My mother was much, much better

at arithmetic than my father was.

She went to Douglas College, which is part

of Rutgers University,

which was a wonderful opportunity for her.

She was a math major, did
very well, and graduated just

at the beginning of World War II

when everybody was
looking for math majors.

And she had several job offers,
which was exciting for her.

She accepted the one at Bell Labs to be,

what they called, a computer.
She accepted the one at Bell Labs to be,

what they called, a computer.

Her term is, it was a
secretarial pool for math majors.

So, it was a room full of
women who had been math majors

who would then do the calculating

for the male mathematicians and engineers.

After Bell, my mother took up weaving,

which is very mathematical.
After Bell, my mother took up weaving,

which is very mathematical.

She became an accomplished weaver
which is very mathematical.

She became an accomplished weaver

and a pioneer in using
computers in hand-weaving.

My father, of course,
had to build her a loom.

My parents were a great partnership.
My father, of course,
had to build her a loom.

My parents were a great partnership.

They both appreciated
each other's intelligence,

and together they were a great team.

- But I didn't meet Claude
until after the 1948 paper,

so I couldn't make him
write that one quicker.

(Claude laughs)

- You have to understand, too,

that during the war this
wasn't a priority, this work.

And I didn't think in the early stages

it would have such an impact.
And I didn't think in the early stages

it would have such an impact.

(intense instrumental music)

- One of the most beautiful
things about Shannon's paper is
(intense instrumental music)

- One of the most beautiful
things about Shannon's paper is

that he reduced the general
problem of communication
- One of the most beautiful
things about Shannon's paper is

that he reduced the general
problem of communication

to just two numbers: the minimum size

you could compress a
message, it's entropy,
to just two numbers: the minimum size

you could compress a
message, it's entropy,

and the maximum rate you
could send it without errors,

the Shannon limit.

And it just started a race to find ways

to reach those limits,

and Bell Labs was at
the center of that race.

It was the top research institute

in the world for communications.

They just invented the
transistor right down the hall
in the world for communications.

They just invented the
transistor right down the hall

from Shannon's office in 1947,

the year before his paper came out.
From Shannon's office in 1947,

the year before his paper came out.

They were geniuses across many fields,

but even there Shannon stood out.

(gentle instrumental music)

- I would call it the grand puzzle,

that's what I call it, the Shannon puzzle.

All of this great stuff where he showed

that communicating
information is possible,

he proved it mathematically,

but he never told anyone
how to actually do it.

So, that is the puzzle.

It's tantalizing.

You know that those codes exist,

but Shannon gave really
almost no clue how to go
You know that those codes exist,

but Shannon gave really
almost no clue how to go

about finding them.

- Of course, that only means

that Theseus can solve any
problem that can be solved.
- Of course, that only means

that Theseus can solve any
problem that can be solved.

Like the rest of us, he
occasionally finds himself

in a situation something like this.

(intense instrumental music)

- Why did you
decide to leave Bell Labs

and come to MIT?

(Claude sighs)

- They gave me a lot of freedom at Bell,

but I started to feel a little stale.
- They gave me a lot of freedom at Bell,

but I started to feel a little stale.

I also always felt that the freedom

I took there was something
of a special favor.

I thought at MIT...

Well, the freedom in the
work hours that I took

might be a little less unusual.

(intense instrumental music)

- In the mid '50s, MIT is a powerhouse

in technology in general,

and especially in information theory.

They make a huge effort to
recruit Shannon and they get him.

And people expect he's gonna be the leader

in delivering the promise
of his 1948 paper.

He's not.

He writes some important
extensions of his work,

but he starts coming to
campus less and less.

And, in fact, at a certain point

he's coming in so infrequently

they actually put two graduate
students in his office.

And people are having trouble
finding the codes he said had

to exist, so there begins
to be some skepticism

about an information theory.

And everybody's wondering,
"Where's Claude Shannon?"

(cheerful piano music)

- When I was quite
young, he would dress up

and go to work the way other people did.

And then, at some point that diminished

and he was home more often.

At some point my mother explained

that he had taken a leave from MIT.

After he sort of moved on
from the more theoretical

and academic work that he did,

and more into things like
unicycling and juggling,

many people would consider
that he wasn't working anymore,

but I still think of that as his work.

My dad got interested
in building all kinds

of different unicycles, very small wheels,

very large wheels, very
tall, short, with pedals,

without pedals, with seat, without seat.

And we tried to ride them all.

He had an interest in unicycles

because my mother bought him one,

not so easy to come by
back in maybe 1950 or '51.

It was sort of a running
joke when I was a child

about how if I wasn't
doing too well in school

I could always run off
and join the circus,
about how if I wasn't
doing too well in school

I could always run off
and join the circus,

and my parents would love that.

(cheerful piano music)

Before I was born he knew how to juggle,

and he taught me how to
juggle when I was maybe eight
Before I was born he knew how to juggle,

and he taught me how to
juggle when I was maybe eight

or nine years old.
and he taught me how to
juggle when I was maybe eight

or nine years old.

He also started trying to
build machines to juggle.

- Juggling relates to patterns.

There's a topology and
a combinatorial aspect.

I wrote a paper for Scientific American.
There's a topology and
a combinatorial aspect.

I wrote a paper for Scientific American.

(cheerful piano music)
(toy rattling)
I wrote a paper for Scientific American.

(cheerful piano music)
(toy rattling)

Oh, come on, Mr. Fields.

(cheerful piano music)
(toy rattling)

Ah.

I came up with a formula for juggling

that relates the number
of balls you're juggling

to how long each is in the
air versus in the hand.
that relates the number
of balls you're juggling

to how long each is in the
air versus in the hand.

- Did you ever think

about commercializing your inventions?

- Oh, fiddle, we don't believe
in commercializing fun.

(Claude chuckles)

- You didn't worry
(Claude chuckles)

- You didn't worry

that they might not be practical?

- Well, that'd be the last thing.
That they might not be practical?

- Well, that'd be the last thing.

I built a lot of useless gadgets

just because they're fun to make.

I'm more interested in, is
this an interesting problem?

Is it an elegant problem?

I get a big bang out of proving a theory
Is it an elegant problem?

I get a big bang out of proving a theory

or seeing a clever way to do something.

I make my money in the stock market,

not by proving theorems.

- You play the stock market?

You're interested in making money?

- Oh, sure.

Aren't you?

- Were you ever successful?

- Beyond reasonable expectations.

(Claude chuckles)

- I even did some work
on the theory of stocks.
(Claude chuckles)

- I even did some work
on the theory of stocks.

In a certain way it's
like channel capacity

in a noisy channel.

- You found that you

could apply information
theory to the stock market?

- Inside information.

- We had good friends who
started good companies.

- Yeah.
- We had good friends who
started good companies.

- Yeah.

The bottom line is that
theories aren't as important

as products or people.

(gentle instrumental music)

- In the '60s and '70s
Shannon's ideas began

to have a lot of impact.

Computers are shrinking
from the size of rooms,

data is being compressed
and stored on drives

and CDs that could be
scratched and still play.
data is being compressed
and stored on drives

and CDs that could be
scratched and still play.

The Voyager satellite is
sending images billions

of miles back to Earth.

But when it comes to finding the codes

that could get you anywhere
near the Shannon limit,

there's a lot of frustration.

A lot of very talented
people, over decades,

tried and failed to find
the codes he said existed.

By the 1980s there's a sense

that maybe we've reached
a practical limit,

a real world boundary
you can't get through.

The Shannon limit is beautiful,
an elegant theoretical idea,

but it's unattainable.

So people began to lose faith and wonder,

"Is information theory dead?"

And they begin to abandon
information theory and,
"Is information theory dead?"

And they begin to abandon
information theory and,

in a sense, abandon Shannon too.

- It seems like after your big discoveries

you stopped really working
on information theory.

Is that because you just grew tired of it?

- Well, the first part is right,
that I didn't do much work

on it later, but, you know, most

of the great mathematicians
have done their finest work
on it later, but, you know, most

of the great mathematicians
have done their finest work

in their '20s and '30s and not so much

when they're older, like athletes.

Although, I've just recently
taken up jogging. (chuckles)

- But it seems like you
spend a lot more time working

on your gadgets now.

- I have a lot of things
I like to spend time on.

The intelligent machine
idea is my big interest now.

The transformation of information
that a human brain does,

not just the transmission, how
the brain works or doesn't.

I think that's the biggest challenge now.

(bleeping)

Simulating the human brain.

Alan Turing and I often had
lunch together and we'd talk

about if you could get a computer
the equivalent of a brain,
Alan Turing and I often had
lunch together and we'd talk

about if you could get a computer
the equivalent of a brain,

a human brain, or even a lot better.

I wrote a paper about how a
computer could play chess.
a human brain, or even a lot better.

I wrote a paper about how a
computer could play chess.

I have a standing bet

that a computer will beat
the grand champion by 2001.

(big band music)
that a computer will beat
the grand champion by 2001.

(big band music)

- Back in 1949, when computers were first

becoming available, Shannon had the vision

that it would be great to
program one of these contraptions
becoming available, Shannon had the vision

that it would be great to
program one of these contraptions

to play the complicated,
difficult game of chess.

He laid out a complete roadmap

of how to build a chess program.

- Of course, being Claude
Shannon, it's not enough

to just write a paper, he also builds one

of the world's first successful
chess-playing computers.

Now, computers weren't
powerful enough at the time

to play a full game of chess,

so his computer can only play
the last six moves of a game.
to play a full game of chess,

so his computer can only play
the last six moves of a game.

He calls it End Game, because
that's what it can play.

It took eight years from
when End Game was completed

to when someone else came
and used Shannon's ideas

to build a computer that could
play a full game of chess.

- Shannon observed that although chess

is incredibly complicated,
the astronomical number
- Shannon observed that although chess

is incredibly complicated,
the astronomical number

of possible chess games,
and he calculated those,

you don't have to look all
the way to the end of the game

to figure out what a good
move is, you only have
you don't have to look all
the way to the end of the game

to figure out what a good
move is, you only have

to look ahead a few moves
and conduct some sort

of evaluation about the
possible moves you could reach

and find the path that
leads to the best one.

This principle became the
basis for every chess program

that came after it.

(big band music)
that came after it.

(big band music)

- When you've done something
like Shannon did in '48

and then again, or earlier
in '45, I mean, cryptography

and information theory, what
do you do for an encore?
and then again, or earlier
in '45, I mean, cryptography

and information theory, what
do you do for an encore?

It's really hard.

And I think people are waiting
for either something good

to come out, or some
people who, maybe jealous,

are waiting for you to fall down and say,

"See, he's a has been."

- There is that small contusion
of people though who say,

"Well, you know, Shannon worked
on information theory alone

"in private for 10 years,
"Well, you know, Shannon worked
on information theory alone

"in private for 10 years,

"and then dropped this great
achievement on everyone's lap

"without telling a
soul, maybe, just maybe,
"and then dropped this great
achievement on everyone's lap

"without telling a
soul, maybe, just maybe,

"he's up to something again, like that,

"that he's working on something.

"Could it be that he just has
a project that he's working on

"that he hasn't told anyone about?"

- Do you wanna see the
first wearable computer?

- Okay.

- I built this with Ed Thorp,

who was a professor here at MIT.

Ed had a paper he wanted to
get published about blackjack

in the proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences.

Since I was the only member
of the academy at the time
in the proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences.

Since I was the only member
of the academy at the time

at MIT, he asked for my help.

We got to talking, and it turns out

he had some pretty interesting
ideas about roulette, too.
We got to talking, and it turns out

he had some pretty interesting
ideas about roulette, too.

(intense tropical music)

- My father was very
interested in gambling.
(intense tropical music)

- My father was very
interested in gambling.

He loved con men, he loved that sort

of shadier side of people.
He loved con men, he loved that sort

of shadier side of people.

Not interested in violence at all,

he was interested in cleverness.

So, movies that captured that
cleverness, like "Topkapi"

or "The Music Man", were favorites of his.

So, he ordered a roulette
wheel from Las Vegas

and they set it up in the
basement with a strobe light

and went to work on a wearable computer

that could try to improve
the odds for roulette.

- Our little computer could
time the speed of the wheel

and the speed of the ball
in the other direction.

It's a simple dynamic system
with very little friction.

We discovered that nearly
all roulette tables
It's a simple dynamic system
with very little friction.

We discovered that nearly
all roulette tables

are slightly tilted, so we
could predict two thirds

of the time which half of the
wheel the ball would fall in.

The computer would be in my pocket,
of the time which half of the
wheel the ball would fall in.

The computer would be in my pocket,

and these little wires
would run down my pant leg

into my shoe, and there was
a little switch in there
and these little wires
would run down my pant leg

into my shoe, and there was
a little switch in there

that I operated with my big toe.

And then these ran up to a
little loud speaker in my ear,

and the computer would send
one of the eight musical notes

of the scale to mark the
octants in the wheel.

Ed had a little loud
speaker in his ear, too,

and I operated the computer,
and Ed placed the bets

and pretended he didn't know me.
and I operated the computer,
and Ed placed the bets

and pretended he didn't know me.

(intense tropical music)

We had some practical problems
when we headed to Las Vegas.

The wires going down my
pant leg kept shorting

and giving me little shocks.

(all laugh)

- And Ed's speaker fell out of his ear,

and he nearly scared this lady to death,

because she thought it
was some alien insect.

(all laugh)
because she thought it
was some alien insect.

(all laugh)

We were lucky we didn't get arrested.

(all laugh)

(intense tropical music)

- He said this at one point,

he wasn't interested in practicality.
- He said this at one point,

he wasn't interested in practicality.

I don't think that was
quite what he meant.

He was very interested in
what's needed to be practical,

but he didn't wanna spend
his life starting a company.

He knew that that wasn't
the right thing for him.
but he didn't wanna spend
his life starting a company.

He knew that that wasn't
the right thing for him.

People who start companies have

to feel a very strong competitive
urge, they have to want

to beat other people, and he
was not a competitive person.

He was a person who,
whenever you talked to him,

he was not trying to
dominate you intellectually,

he was very much a
cooperator, not a competitor.

He really was interested
in practical things.

All the things he built
were very practical.
He really was interested
in practical things.

All the things he built
were very practical.

His maze, a toy, yes, but it was a toy

that illustrated some
very interesting things.

His chess-playing machine, again, a toy,

but artificial intelligence people

just learned so many things from that,
but artificial intelligence people

just learned so many things from that,

and it was highly useful.

His cryptography during
the second World War,

the fact that it wasn't
very practical then

is almost irrelevant.

He still wrote the best
paper on cryptography
is almost irrelevant.

He still wrote the best
paper on cryptography

that's been written yet.
He still wrote the best
paper on cryptography

that's been written yet.

- He asked questions that no one asked,

and that was an amazing thing.

The questions are very
meaningful, and he answered them,

and no one thought those questions
The questions are very
meaningful, and he answered them,

and no one thought those questions

could be answered that way.

- Practical or playful?

It's a silly question in most cases.

He was into understanding.

- What do
you think about the idea

that a machine might one
day outthink a human?

- Well, I'm
rooting for the machines.

- But do you think a
machine would ever come up

with the idea of a flaming trumpet?
- But do you think a
machine would ever come up

with the idea of a flaming trumpet?

(Claude chuckles)

- I think that creative
stuff is a long way off,

but in the meantime they
can be a boon to humanity.

(Claude sighs)

And I'd like to see that
happen as soon as possible.
(Claude sighs)

And I'd like to see that
happen as soon as possible.

- Shannon's Master's
thesis lays the foundation

for this idea that machines
could be made to think,

that they could capably
mimic a human brain.
for this idea that machines
could be made to think,

that they could capably
mimic a human brain.

And he himself invents
devices that mimic a brain.

There's Theseus, the mouse
that can navigate its way

through a maze, there's
End Game, the computer

that can play the last
six moves in a chess game,

but it's at precisely the time
when artificial intelligence

and computing is taking off
but it's at precisely the time
when artificial intelligence

and computing is taking off

that Shannon is on the sidelines.

Even though information
theory was being applied
that Shannon is on the sidelines.

Even though information
theory was being applied

in ways beyond what
Shannon could've imagined.
Even though information
theory was being applied

in ways beyond what
Shannon could've imagined.

- I heard that one
of your last papers proved

that you could make a reliable circuit

from faulty components.

Do you think that this
might have applications

for the brain?

(Claude chuckles)

- I hope so.

I mean, the brain can
suffer all kinds of damage

and still handle things pretty well,

which means there must be redundancy.

The fact that the brain
has 10 billion neurons

probably means that it
was cheaper for biology

to just make more components than

to figure out sophisticated circuits.
To just make more components than

to figure out sophisticated circuits.

Trying to work out all
the different connections
to figure out sophisticated circuits.

Trying to work out all
the different connections

would be astronomical, impossible,

but if we can find patterns,

well, there may be ways
to simplify things.

- If we look at the data in the brain,

all the data is
interrelated to each other.

So, there's a huge amount of redundancy.

If I have this type of
neuron there, it tells me

that there's another kind of neuron there,
If I have this type of
neuron there, it tells me

that there's another kind of neuron there,

and this kind of neuron,
and this one's not there,

and this one's not there.
and this kind of neuron,
and this one's not there,

and this one's not there.

So, we develop rules

that decide this is how neurons connect.

We take that brain model,

and we basically attach it
to a virtual mouse body.

The virtual mouse body has
simple models of the eyes

and the ears and the skin and the whiskers

so they can receive sensory input,
and the ears and the skin and the whiskers

so they can receive sensory input,

then you let the virtual mouse loose

to start running through the maze.
Then you let the virtual mouse loose

to start running through the maze.

So, in that way it's quite similar
to start running through the maze.

So, in that way it's quite similar

to what Shannon did nearly 60 years ago.

Einstein's theory of general relativity,

he had an enormous impact
on society and the world

and physics, and pretty
much how the world is today.

But I think that we haven't
even begun to see the kind

of impact that Shannon is
going to have on society,

because I think the more
we understand how...

Understanding entropy and
using information theory
because I think the more
we understand how...

Understanding entropy and
using information theory

to help us understand complex systems,

such as the brain or biology or diseases,
to help us understand complex systems,

such as the brain or biology or diseases,

I think that this is gonna
open an amazing new door.

- Most physicists didn't
really care about information

as a primary focus for many, many years.

Even most people thinking about abstruse,

esoteric questions in fundamental physics,

but that really changed in the 1980s

when a lot of people focused
but that really changed in the 1980s

when a lot of people focused

on the famous black hole
information paradox.

If you collide particles
with enough energy,

(whooshing)

they'll have so much mass that
they'll collapse the region

that they collided in into a black hole.

In a classical world, nothing
can get out of the black hole,

even something going at the
speed of light could not get out

of a black hole.
even something going at the
speed of light could not get out

of a black hole.

But Stephen Hawking showed

that quantum-mechanically
black holes leak,

but what came out of the black hole

is completely independent
of what made the black hole,
but what came out of the black hole

is completely independent
of what made the black hole,

and one was left with a major paradox.
is completely independent
of what made the black hole,

and one was left with a major paradox.

Where did the information about
what made the black hole go?
and one was left with a major paradox.

Where did the information about
what made the black hole go?

Right?

Because seemingly you
could make a black hole
Right?

Because seemingly you
could make a black hole

in a zillion different ways.

You could throw in an elephant,

you could throw in an encyclopedia,

but what came out always
looked exactly the same.
you could throw in an encyclopedia,

but what came out always
looked exactly the same.

It looked like information was lost.

And that is a no-no.

That cannot happen
according to any of the laws

of either classical or quantum mechanics.

And in order to decide whether
the information is lost

or not, one thing that
became apparent eventually is

that thinking more carefully
about what the information was

and very much making use of the ideas
that thinking more carefully
about what the information was

and very much making use of the ideas

of entropy ended up being very important.

What's clear is that information

in physics is more important

than you would naively have thought.

And many of the most
fundamental ideas really go back

to Shannon.
And many of the most
fundamental ideas really go back

to Shannon.

- In 1993, I was finishing up my PhD.

I was one year away from graduating,

and I went to a communications conference.

It wasn't an information
theory conference.

It was in Switzerland and
it's a very big conference,

so there's maybe 800 or
900 people that attend.

There's usually 10 to 12 parallel sessions

on everything from what's
the next generation
There's usually 10 to 12 parallel sessions

on everything from what's
the next generation

of cell phone standards gonna look like

to more mathematical types of talks

in more theoretical dimensions.

So, I went to this session
'cause there was nothing else

to see, and maybe there was
one person in the session
So, I went to this session
'cause there was nothing else

to see, and maybe there was
one person in the session

that I thought was a good speaker.

So I thought, "Okay, I'll
go listen to that talk."

And there was a presentation.
So I thought, "Okay, I'll
go listen to that talk."

And there was a presentation.

I didn't know any of the
authors, they were really unknown

to information theorists,
coding theorists,

nobody knew who they were.

And these guys that got up,
they were two French guys

and one guy from Thailand who nobody knew.

I mean, they were completely unknown.
And one guy from Thailand who nobody knew.

I mean, they were completely unknown.

And so, most people were probably
chatting with each other,

and maybe there were a few
people paying attention.
And so, most people were probably
chatting with each other,

and maybe there were a few
people paying attention.

And they get up and they say
and maybe there were a few
people paying attention.

And they get up and they say

they basically achieved the Shannon limit,

and everybody was incredibly skeptical.

We're like, "Oh, there must be a mistake
and everybody was incredibly skeptical.

We're like, "Oh, there must be a mistake

"in their simulations, or, you know,

"they don't know what
they're talking about,

"or their math is wrong."

- It was such a shock
that people were just,

"It doesn't make any
sense, this ugly thing."
- It was such a shock
that people were just,

"It doesn't make any
sense, this ugly thing."

- It was mostly an experimental result.
"It doesn't make any
sense, this ugly thing."

- It was mostly an experimental result.

And the idea was to take
multiple simple things

and combine them in a way

that created this very complex code.

And then they showed
their simulation results,
that created this very complex code.

And then they showed
their simulation results,

which basically hit the Shannon
limit, and it was amazing.

(intense instrumental music)

50 years on, the final
piece of Shannon's vision

of the future was proved to be true.

You could have perfect communication

with as little errors as you wanted.

- Actually, everything that
Shannon has predicted back

in 1948 came true.
- Actually, everything that
Shannon has predicted back

in 1948 came true.

He's completely vindicated.

- Anytime you store, process,

or transmit information in digital form,

every time you save a file
on a hard drive, play a CD

or DVD, talk on a cell phone,
send an email, Tweet, text,

Instagram, the wireless revolution,

you're relying on the concepts
in Shannon's 1948 paper.

- Millions of people spend huge chunks

of their day consuming the codes

that Claude Shannon said had to be there.

Information is everything to us.

- And today, everyone
carries Shannon around

in their pocket.

- Wow!

- My ultimate machine.

(machine buzzing)

(snapping)

- (chuckles) What?

- You know what Fats Waller
said about swing music,

don't you, Michelle?
- You know what Fats Waller
said about swing music,

don't you, Michelle?

- Oh, no.

- "Either you got it or you ain't."

- Uh.

(machine buzzing)

(gentle instrumental music)

- I often wonder if
Claude Shannon understood

how much information there would be

after his many discoveries.

I wonder, did he understand
after his many discoveries.

I wonder, did he understand

that we would have this
information explosion?

That in the last couple
that we would have this
information explosion?

That in the last couple

of years we've generated
more information than the sum
That in the last couple

of years we've generated
more information than the sum

of all human history.

Literally, he not only won the lottery,

he invented the lottery.
Literally, he not only won the lottery,

he invented the lottery.

(gentle instrumental music)

- When I was starting my
PhD program at Harvard,

and this would've been 1992,

so my father already had Alzheimer's

and was already fairly
compromised in terms

of his cognitive ability,
he asked me what I was going

to be working on, and at the
time I was working on a project

about how the magnetic
field of the earth flips

from time to time, approximately
every million years,

I was astonished at
how quickly he was able

to ask the very core
questions of the problem,
I was astonished at
how quickly he was able

to ask the very core
questions of the problem,

he cut right to it, and I was amazed.

And I thought, "This is fantastic.

"I'm going to have this fabulous
mind at my side (chuckles)

"while I go through graduate school.
"I'm going to have this fabulous
mind at my side (chuckles)

"while I go through graduate school.

"This is gonna be so
much fun for both of us."

Alas, he was not able to
continue that kind of questioning

or even thinking for very much longer,

so I didn't in fact have him
at my side for graduate school.

But I remember very clearly
that conversation and thinking,

"Wow!

"That's something."

(gentle instrumental music)
"That's something."

(gentle instrumental music)

- There's science fiction
books in which the dates

of things are so many years A.S.,

and the A.S. stands for After Shannon.
Of things are so many years A.S.,

and the A.S. stands for After Shannon.

In some sense, if you look
at the human civilization,

the sudden change in human
civilization that was created

by the digital revolution, computers,

happened at such a short period of time

that there's nothing else
like that in history.

So, it could very well be
that historically people

will look back and say,
"What happened there?"

And if you were going
to tie it to anybody,

Shannon is the one that gave us the tools

that people would still
be using in the future.

So, it's not so implausible
that people would still
be using in the future.

So, it's not so implausible

that people would start
measuring years after Shannon.

(gentle instrumental music)

- Inventing something

is like sending a message
in a bottle into the future.

(gentle jazz music)

- I think it was special

that he had both the ability and interest

in theoretical mathematics
and this passion for building.

In a way that a toddler
would explore the world,

he didn't lose that childlike
curiosity and delight

in learning things, discovering things,
he didn't lose that childlike
curiosity and delight

in learning things, discovering things,

putting things together,
making connections.

(gentle jazz music)

(intense instrumental music)

Subtitles Diego Moraes(oakislandtk)
www.opensubtitles.org

Support us and become VIP member
to remove all ads from OpenSubtitles.org