Original subtitles

[FOGHORN BLOWS]

_

[WATER LAPPING, BELL DINGING] _

[BIRDS SQUAWKING]

[SNOW CRUNCHING]

[WIND WHISTLING]

♪

[WOOD CREAKING]

♪

[CLANGING]

♪

[CLANGING CONTINUES]

[KNOCK ON DOOR]

♪

Just a moment.

[KNOCKING CONTINUES]

What is it, Mary?

♪

[BREATHING HEAVILY]

- What's happened? - STEVIE: Up on the new bridge,

he said something bad happened.

I found him down on the Bowery.

All right.

There you go.

♪

My name is Dr. Kreizler.

Can you tell me what you saw?

♪

It's all right.

Why was he wearin' a dress?

Sorry?

The dead kid.

He was dressed up like a girl.

Somebody cut him to pieces.

[CHAIR CREAKS]

♪

Are you sure it was a boy?

That's what the cops said.

Stevie? Ready the calash.

I need you to fetch Mr. Moore and bring him to the bridge.

Tell Moore to bring his drawing kit.

And tell him I need details!

[SOFT MUSIC PLAYING]

[WOMAN CHUCKLES]

♪

♪

♪

Where were you this evening?

At Mrs. Astor's.

Was Jack there?

♪

I don't recall.

[GRUNTS]

[MUSIC STOPS]

What is it?

Forgive me, John.

I love him.

[GASPS]

Oh, for God's sake!

Sorry to interrupt you, Mr. Moore,

but there is a young lad here to see you.

He says it's very important.

What? Flora, dégage! J'ai besion de la chambre.

[SINGING IN FRENCH]

♪

[INDISTINCT CONVERSATION]

WOMAN: Good evening, sir.

What can't possibly wait, Stevie?!

He said he needs you.

[HOOFBEATS]

- Hyah! - [HORSE WHINNIES]

♪

Where on earth are we going?

The cops is there, so he said he wanted you to go take a look.

- Get out the way! - Hyah! Move!

Take a look at what?!

- MAN: No! - [HORSE WHINNIES]

- My God! - Hey, watch it!

- Hang on! - [WHIP CRACKS]

Roosevelt's there.

You're gonna have to talk your way up!

For God's sake, Stevie, up where?!

♪

♪

[INDISTINCT SHOUTING]

♪

Ah. No further.

CONNOR: [IRISH ACCENT] And who might you be?

John Moore. I'm with the "New York Times."

No reporters.

I'm not a reporter. I'm an illustrator.

Well, then, there's two good reasons

for you not to be going up there.

Commissioner Roosevelt sent for me.

♪

Well... we sure wouldn't want to be disappointin'

the commissioner.

[WOOD CREAKING]

♪

♪

[WIND WHISTLING]

♪

ROOSEVELT: Moore? What the hell are you doing here?

Theodore.

I gave strict instructions not to allow anyone up.

He said you sent for him, Mr. Roosevelt.

Kreizler sent me.

I'm to capture an image. I know nothing more.

Then he's got no business being here, sir.

Especially if he's been sent by that quacksalver doctor.

Dr. Kreizler would not have made the request

had it not been important.

Very well, Moore, if you think you can stomach it.

[WOOD CREAKING]

♪

Git on, then.

[WIND WHISTLING]

[BREATHING HEAVILY]

♪

♪

♪

- [CRACKING] - [GAGS]

Where are her eyes?

'Twas birds got 'em or rats.

Somebody's done you up good, young Giorgio.

You're a hell of a mess.

You know this child?

I do.

Giorgio Santorelli.

He's a boy-whore, worked out of Paresis Hall.

'Twas was known as Gloria there, though.

Why must you call him "it"?

What else you call a degenerate who dresses himself

as a girl for the pleasure of grown men?

Enough! You say the boy worked out of Paresis Hall?

- Hmm. - Who is the proprietor?

That'd be Biff Ellison and Paul Kelly what own it, sir.

I want them in my office tomorrow.

But beggin' your pardon, Commissioner,

but summonin' a man like Paul Kelly

just because some little piece of dago trash has been found...

My office tomorrow or your badge on my desk, Captain Connor.

As you command, Mr. Roosevelt.

[WIND WHISTLING]

♪

[SHIVERING]

♪

What kind of devil could do such a thing?

♪

♪

♪

♪

♪

Synced & corrected by -robtor- www.addic7ed.com

Fire setting in children is often a sign of loneliness,

not malice.

FATHER: Then there's the bed-wetting.

The medical term is enuresis.

Bed-wetting has connotations of shame.

That is unhelpful to a child.

The people who recommended you said you treat adults, too.

That is correct.

But I've always found children's minds to be more interesting.

MOTHER: What we'd like to know, Doctor,

is if you can cure Ezra.

Before we end up in a heap of ash.

As an alienist, I treat mental and emotional disorders

in my patients, and I try to alleviate their condition.

I do not presume to cure them.

[CHILDREN GIGGLING]

The exercise room is over here.

CHILDREN: One, two, three, four.

WOMAN: Good, children. One, two, three, four.

One, two, three, four.

The music room is down the hall.

The dormitories are upstairs,

and you may have seen the playground.

[PIANO PLAYING, CHILDREN GIGGLING]

You look as if you like playing outdoors.

[HORSE WHINNIES]

The man's a fraud.

It's good to see you.

You've caused me a sleepless night, Laszlo.

The first of many, I suspect.

Forgive me, but I had no choice.

Roosevelt and his officers

would have never allowed me on that bridge

and I thought they might be better disposed to you.

Did you know the child?

Not this one.

Do you have the drawings?

Here.

Thank you.

♪

♪

♪

Tell me what you saw.

Tell you?

It's all right there. I've drawn it for you.

You've idealized it.

This looks like a martyred saint in a Renaissance painting,

not a mutilated child.

It's no use to me.

Well, if that's what you think of my work,

why did you drag me away from a perfectly good evening

to witness a sight that will probably stay with me

for the rest of my life?

Because I need to see what you saw.

I need your help in this matter, John.

I saw a boy,

dressed suggestively in girl's clothing,

who had been...

It was as if an animal had torn him apart.

More specific. Deep wounds or shallow?

Precisely executed or haphazard?

Were the viscera exposed? The guts, Moore.

I know what viscera are.

[SIGHS]

The boy's throat had been cut to the bone.

His right hand was severed.

His chest and abdomen ripped open,

and the innards were left by his feet...

a kidney and a lung, I think.

And his genitalia had been removed,

and birds plucked out his eyes.

And his dress?

A white dress.

The same as any little girl might wear.

♪

♪

You still haven't told me what this is about.

Are you supposed to interview the suspect?

What suspect?

[INDISTINCT SHOUTING]

I'm sorry, Dr. Kreizler.

I wasn't told you were consulting on these murders.

Please don't concern yourself, Dr. Fuller.

- [INDISTINCT SHOUTING] - I only just found out myself.

And how did Mr. Wolff come to be here?

He was discovered hiding in a warehouse down by the new bridge.

- [WOMAN LAUGHS] - The police had been looking

for him for a different murder.

And do they know who?

Another male prostitute like himself.

The police claimed he stabbed his friend

to death with a knife.

Then, crazed by blood lust,

went looking for his next victim.

- [SCREAMING] - No, no, no, no!

- [WOMAN SINGING INDISTINCTLY] - Has anyone questioned him,

aside from the police?

One of the wardens tried, but Wolff almost gauged his eyes out.

- Accompany them. - [SCREAMING IN DISTANCE]

Thank you, Dr. Fuller.

[MAN SCREAMING]

- Settle down. - [WATER SPLASHES]

[MAN WHIMPERS]

[THUDDING]

May I ask what you're hoping to achieve with this exercise,

Mr. Wolff?

The police have the lion's share.

My name is Dr. Kreizler.

I sometimes work as an alienist for the courts.

[BLOOD DRIPPING]

Tell me, Doctor...

can you cure this?

There's no cure for advanced syphilis.

[INDISTINCT SHOUTING IN DISTANCE]

[METAL CLANGING]

You have been charged with the murders of Edwin Band and...

Edwin deserved it!

- I'd kill him again if I could. - [MAN SHOUTING]

And the boy?

You're accused of cutting him to pieces.

Yes.

[WOMAN GIGGLES]

Police said you knew him from Paresis Hall.

[LAUGHS]

Do I look like a boy to you?

I wouldn't step foot in that molly house

full of rich pansies.

What are you looking at?

Do I stimulate you?

Does he remind you of Edwin?

[THUDDING]

Guard, please, open the door.

Open the door!

- Back up! - Laszlo.

- [MAN SCREAMS] - What are you doing?

Laszlo.

[CELL DOOR CLOSES]

♪

How do you know I won't hurt you?

You stabbed Edwin 20 times.

♪

He must have hurt you deeply.

[CHAINS CLANKING]

♪

What color were Edwin's eyes?

[SNIFFLES]

Green.

The color of envy. He found someone else.

[POUNDING]

What color were Giorgio's eyes?

[SNIFFLES]

♪

♪

You did not kill that boy, did you?

No, I didn't.

♪

♪

Doctor?

What'll take me first...

the gallows or the pox?

I'm afraid in New York State, it'll be the electric chair.

Either way... your pain will be gone soon.

[SHOUTING IN DISTANCE]

[BANGING]

[HORSE WHINNIES]

[INDISTINCT CHATTER]

Captain Connor?

Did he do it? Was there a confession?

Let's just say, Linc, we gave him a little bit

of the third degree, and he melted like butter.

[CHUCKLES]

Uh, Chief Byrnes?

You have anything to do with apprehending this Wolff fellow?

No.

I was just passing by to congratulate

Captain Connor here.

I'm retired, as you know, but I take great pride

in the achievement of my boys.

I'm Sergeant Doyle.

What do you think of the new commissioner's policies

on department reform?

I say we give Mr. Roosevelt all the rope he wants.

We'll see if he doesn't soon hang himself with it.

- [LAUGHTER] - A-And a quote, sir?

W-What have you been doing with your time

now that you're no longer chief of police?

Speculating on Wall Street.

Mr. Morgan and some of his associates

have been most generous with their advice.

- There's Kreizler. - Dr. Kreizler!

Dr. Kreizler, a moment of your time.

[INDISTINCT SHOUTING]

As an alienist, have you been asked to get another madman...

♪

[INDISTINCT SHOUTING]

Dr. Kreizler!

Dr. Kreizler!

[INDISTINCT CHATTER]

♪

WOMAN: Dr. Kreizler.

That's him. I've heard about him.

[CAMERA FLASH POPS]

[CHILDREN TALKING INDISTINCTLY]

[CAMERA FLASH POPS]

[DOG BARKING]

[TYPEWRITER KEYS CLACKING]

[TYPEWRITER DINGS]

Miss?

John Moore.

- Hello. - What are you doing here?

I've, um... W-We've come to see the commissioner.

- Sara and I... - I am Miss Howard,

an employee of the New York Police Department.

You will please accord me the respect

that my position demands.

Our families have long been acquainted.

Miss Howard is the first woman to hold a position

- with the police department. - KREIZLER: Excellent.

Perhaps Miss Howard can help arrange an impromptu meeting

with the commissioner?

And how should I help do that?

With my "especially rosy mouth" or my "sparkling blue eyes"?

- Sara, I did not... - Miss Howard.

Certainly, Miss Howard, it was a society feature,

and I only drew the illustration.

You don't have an appointment.

Let me introduce you to Dr. Laszlo Kreizler.

Dr. Kreizler.

I've read your work.

I found it fascinating. Most of it.

Laszlo and I attended Harvard together,

along with the commissioner.

KREIZLER: We're all old friends, you see,

which is why a surprise is in order.

Oh, no, but you can't just go in there without...

Hello, my friend.

Moore. I might have suspected you were behind this ambush.

I told them they needed an appointment.

Laszlo has something important he would like to s...

The man being held for the murder of the Santorelli boy

is quite innocent of the charge.

And just how would you know that?

Because I interviewed him.

On whose authority?

My own.

As usual, you've overstepped your bounds.

Stabbing a grown man in a heated argument

and the methodical disemboweling of a young boy

are very different things.

I'm well aware of your theories, Kreizler.

But at this juncture, your expertise is not required.

I took it upon myself to interview your suspect

because of an unsolved case three years ago.

The Zweig twins... Benjamin and Sofia.

The boy was a patient of mine.

His parents brought him in

because he wished to dress as his sister.

And one day, they both disappeared

while outside playing.

At first, it was thought they had run away,

but then their bodies were found in a rooftop water tank.

The body of the girl was unremarkable.

However, the boy was cut from sternum to pubis,

his innards displayed.

What are you suggesting?

That the Zweig murders and the present one

are works of theater,

inspired by the same imagination.

One person committed both crimes?

Yes.

Gentlemen, I think this may be a little indelicate.

Miss Howard.

- [DOOR CLOSES] - And what is it you want from me?

I shall need to look at the postmortem of the Zweig case

to see if there's a connection, if one indeed exists.

I cannot allow that. It is neither legal nor ethical.

Murderers like this exist whether you accept it or not.

If I'm correct, your men will be ill-equipped

to fathom the motives of a perpetrator

with an impulse to butcher young boys.

Furthermore, I should like access to additional police records

to see if there are other victims that you have missed.

I should have known when I let Moore up on that bridge,

I'd be inviting this sort of incursion.

I cannot permit you nor any other outsider

access to privileged information.

Just because you live by your own set of rules, Kreizler,

does not mean I do.

Wolff did not kill that boy.

And that won't change,

no matter how many times your men put a boot to him.

♪

♪

[DOOR CLOSES]

[INDISTINCT SHOUTING]

My God, Laszlo, sometimes you can be

as subtle as a blowtorch.

How long have you known Miss Howard?

- [HORSE WHINNIES] - Oh, no.

Long enough to ask her a favor?

I won't do it.

I will not ask Miss Howard

to get you the Zweig file.

Well...

someone has to illustrate the society pages, I suppose.

[DOOR OPENS, CLOSES]

[LAUGHTER, INDISTINCT CHATTER]

[DOOR OPENS, CLOSES]

[KNOCK ON DOOR]

[URINATING]

Excuse me.

Oh, no, no, c-come right in, Miss Howard.

We've nothing to hide here, huh? [CHUCKLES]

The commissioner would like a word.

Miss Howard? Mind yer petticoat.

There's a sizable, hairless rat

been spotted about the station house.

[LAUGHTER]

Funny, Captain Connor.

I see only a little pink mouse.

[LAUGHTER]

I like her even more now.

[LAUGHTER]

[INDISTINCT SHOUTING]

Miss Howard.

Now what?

I have something to ask you.

Yes?

May I address you as Sara?

You may, but exclusive of my official duties.

Sara, I would very much like to ask you

- to get me the file on the Zweig case. - [HORSE WHINNIES]

Have you lost your mind, John Moore? I mean, honestly.

It would only be to borrow it.

It will be returned with no one the wiser.

I'll be the wiser.

Kreizler needs the file.

Did he send you?

No.

Regardless, I will not betray the trust

the commissioner has shown in me.

Not for Dr. Kreizler, nor for anyone else.

Sara, please.

We need your help.

- [HORSE WHINNIES] - [GASPS]

[RUSTLING]

Our graft... paid for this building, Commissioner.

And lined the pockets of your men.

And now you drags us in here

like a couple of two-bit sneak thieves

when you already got your throat slitter behind bars.

Now, where's the decency, huh?

Might you have a pen, Mr. Ellison?

Thank you, Mr. Kelly.

I think what Mr. Ellison is trying to say here,

Commissioner, is that we are businessmen.

In fact, we have enjoyed an understanding

with the police over the years.

And after all the profit from your pandering, gambling,

and intimidation,

how much do you make from this understanding?

A great deal.

[CHUCKLES]

Well, here's something else for you to understand.

A child is dead.

A child exploited by you and your brothel.

No more. I want Paresis Hall shut down.

- Shut down? - You have until 6:00 today.

You can't do that.

I think the commissioner is right.

Best we close our doors on account

of this sad turn of events.

♪

- MAN: Here you go. - Watch yourself!

[THUDDING]

[INDISTINCT SHOUTING]

MAN: Get the hell out of here!

[GRUNTS]

Look out!

♪

Move your fannies now, girls.

We open for business in less than an hour.

MAN: And Jesus died on the cross for your sins!

WOMAN: Never seen a girl before?

[THUDDING]

♪

- Step right up! - Come on, put your backs into it!

I took out a ten-spot to cover the inconvenience

of closin' down.

But you're only shiftin' 'em across the street.

[INDISTINCT SHOUTING]

♪

♪

♪

♪

♪

[HAMMERING]

[LID RATTLING]

[CUTTING]

[CAT MEOWS]

[SIZZLING]

♪

[FIRE CRACKLING]

[DISHES CLATTERING]

♪

♪

Will that be all, miss?

♪

[BREATHING HEAVILY]

♪

I can't decide whether they abhor our shape

or crave another.

They believe us to be delicate creatures, miss.

[SIGHS] Then to hell with them.

♪

♪

♪

♪

[BOTH GRUNTING]

[COIN RATTLES]

[INDISTINCT CONVERSATION]

Miss Howard.

How did you find me?

Your grandmother didn't know where you were,

so I asked one of your sporting companions.

He told me you were particularly fond of this house

and could be found slumming it here most nights.

[LAUGHTER IN DISTANCE]

This is an unsavory neighborhood for a young lady.

I'm not here on savory business,

and every panderer, mawk, lush, and billy noodle in the city

pass through the doors of the police department,

not to mention the mutton shunters that I work with.

So please don't concern yourself with my blushes.

- [CLEARS THROAT] - I've come to return your work.

And to give you the file Dr. Kreizler asked for.

I don't know how to thank you.

If Dr. Kreizler finds anything of interest

in these particular documents, I should like to be told.

That is the only thanks I require.

[HORSE WHINNIES]

[DOOR OPENS]

I have it!

[PIANO PLAYING]

Laszlo!

I've got the Zweig file.

I do hope you thanked Miss Howard.

♪

♪

♪

Well, what have you found?

[SCOFFS] There's nothing here.

No details as to the kind of wounds,

no sense of how they were inflicted.

I... I need evidence.

[BIRD CAWING]

♪

[HORSE WHINNIES]

[CHILDREN SINGING "FRÈRE JACQUES" IN DISTANCE]

- [WIND WHISTLING] - ♪ Morning bells are ringing

♪ Ding, ding, dong

♪ Ding, ding, dong

♪ Are you sleeping?

♪ Are you sleeping?

♪ Brother John, Brother John

♪ Morning bells are ringing

♪ Morning bells are ringing

[WOOD CLATTERS]

♪ Frère Jacques ♪

♪ Frère Jacques ♪

♪ Dormez-vous, Dormez-vous

♪ Sonnez les matines

♪ Sonnez les matines

♪ Ding, ding, dong

♪ Ding, ding, dong

[DOOR OPENS, BELL CLANGING]

CYRUS: Ma'am?

Excuse me, ma'am. Ma'am.

I can only imagine how you must be feeling, but...

let me assure you that the disinterment was unfortunate,

but necessary, Mrs. Zweig.

Hmm.

I read about the boy on the bridge.

About what he was wearing.

Your son's desire to wear the same clothing as his sister

has little in common with the boy on the bridge.

You said there was no need for concern.

You said our acceptance of Benjamin was what mattered most.

And we believed you.

We trusted you.

Giorgio Santorelli dressed as he did

because he was a prostitute.

Benjamin was only following his nature.

♪

Mrs. Zweig...

your son was the victim of a very disturbed mind.

My Benjamin is dead.

Both my children are dead.

Because of you.

♪

♪

♪

♪

KREIZLER: Gentlemen, this is John Moore, friend and colleague.

Hello, Mr. Moore. I'm Detective Sergeant Marcus Isaacson.

This is my brother, Lucius.

Detective Sergeant Lucius Isaacson.

Theodore didn't trust the coroner's office

to keep silent about revisiting the Zweig case.

It was good of Commissioner Roosevelt to lend you to us.

May I ask how long we have the benefit of your expertise?

As long as you like, Doctor.

I doubt my brother and I will be missed at the police department.

I imagine your modern methods don't make you very popular.

That and the fact we're Jews.

Has the commissioner told you what this is about?

Only that we're to perform an autopsy

and keep the results strictly confidential.

Benjamin and Sofia Zweig. Their bodies were discovered...

Three years ago in a water tower on Suffolk Street.

- We read the file. - The injuries to the boy

are what interests me the most.

You've heard about the Santorelli murder, I assume?

Of course.

If you're looking for similarities,

there's only so much we can tell from a body in this state.

I want you to look at what remains...

each bone, each fragment for every detail, every mark...

no matter how insignificant.

Anything that may connect Benjamin Zweig

to the Santorelli boy.

We will do our best, Doctor.

[INDISTINCT CONVERSATION]

BOY: Get the "Tribune"! Get the "Tribune"!

Get the "Tribune"! Get the "Tribune"!

They won't be finished for quite some time.

I thought we might get an early dinner somewhere.

How can you think of eating now?

I don't recall you being so delicate.

I'm afraid once seen, those images

will remain forever in my head.

That's what I admire about you, John.

You represent the good that people want

to believe is in all of us.

It's why people like you more than they do me.

[LAUGHS]

[INDISTINCT SHOUTING]

[HORSE WHINNIES]

KREIZLER: Thank you, Cyrus.

♪

[PAPER RUSTLING]

BOY: Get the "Tribune"! Get the "Tribune"!

[HORSE WHINNIES]

MAN: Come!

[HOOFBEATS]

- Cyrus! - CYRUS: Sir?

Were you away from the carriage at any point?

No, sir.

What? Do you see something?

♪

♪

There.

Laszlo!

- [HORSE WHINNIES] - [GRUNTS]

Laszlo!

♪

[HORSE WHINNIES]

♪

♪

[BIRD WINGS FLAPPING]

♪

♪

Laszlo!

♪

♪

[CREAKING]

♪

♪

[DOOR CREAKS]

♪

♪

Laszlo!

♪

[BIRD WINGS FLAPPING]

♪

♪

[DOOR CREAKS]

♪

♪

[WIND WHISTLING]

♪

♪

Laszlo!

[BREATHING HEAVILY]

Where did he go?

[WIND WHISTLING]

[BREATHING HEAVILY]

♪

_

Did you see the Santorelli boy's mouth?

♪

[BELL DINGING]

♪

KREIZLER: I'm certain cold-blooded killers walk among us.

They're out there now, hidden,

yet their motives are understandable,

but this one is different.

His acts are so wretched, so evil that...

only if I become him,

if I cut the child's throat myself...

if I run my knife through the helpless body

and pluck innocent eyes from a horrified face,

only then will I come to truly understand what I am.

Only then will I recognize that what drives me

is not an absence of emotion at all.

Rather, a torrent of feeling.

The kind that gives meaning and purpose

to my own blackened soul.

I must see life as he sees it.

Feel pain as he feels it.

Take the same path he takes.

Yes.

I must follow this wherever it goes.

[GLASS SHATTERS]

Even if it leads me to the darkest pit of Hell.

♪

MAN: What's wrong, child?

Synced & corrected by -robtor- www.addic7ed.com