Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:01:10,530 --> 00:01:18,382
In October 2014, Dilma Rousseff was
reelected President of Brazil
2
00:01:18,483 --> 00:01:26,536
potentially extending to 16 years the consecutive
rule by the left-wing Worker's Party.
3
00:01:27,098 --> 00:01:31,176
Months before, a judicial investigation
known as 'Operation Car Wash'
4
00:01:31,277 --> 00:01:35,895
unveiled a vast corruption scheme
involving state-run oil company Petrobras.
5
00:01:35,996 --> 00:01:39,288
Senior politicians from the
three main parties were accused,
6
00:01:39,389 --> 00:01:42,340
including Vice President
Michel Temer and the
7
00:01:42,441 --> 00:01:47,643
House Speaker Eduardo Cunha, both a driving
force behind the impeachment proceedings.
8
00:01:47,744 --> 00:01:50,272
President Rousseff was not implicated.
9
00:02:38,671 --> 00:02:46,029
The ones who want turmoil
are those who don't want to vote.
10
00:02:46,130 --> 00:02:48,995
So I ask you to...
11
00:02:51,338 --> 00:02:54,404
I ask security to intervene.
12
00:02:54,505 --> 00:02:55,829
Keep calm!
13
00:02:57,505 --> 00:02:59,495
Keep calm, leader!
14
00:03:00,338 --> 00:03:01,404
Leader!
15
00:03:01,505 --> 00:03:03,904
Banners are not allowed up here.
16
00:03:04,005 --> 00:03:07,404
Actually,
banners aren't allowed anywhere.
17
00:03:07,505 --> 00:03:10,237
There will be no coup,
we will fight!
18
00:03:10,338 --> 00:03:13,829
There will be no coup,
we will fight...
19
00:03:17,005 --> 00:03:20,737
There will be no coup!
20
00:03:20,838 --> 00:03:22,737
There will be no coup.
21
00:03:22,838 --> 00:03:29,404
We will fight
for our beloved homeland, Brazil.
22
00:03:29,505 --> 00:03:36,070
Dilma out! Dilma out!
23
00:03:36,171 --> 00:03:43,537
Take your feet off the ground,
if you want Lula in prison!
24
00:03:47,671 --> 00:03:50,404
I declare the voting session open.
25
00:03:50,505 --> 00:03:53,862
I will begin to call the deputies.
26
00:03:53,963 --> 00:03:58,195
For my family,
for my beloved Chapec�...
27
00:03:58,296 --> 00:04:01,070
for my state of Santa Catarina...
28
00:04:01,171 --> 00:04:05,904
and for breaking
the backbone of this gang...
29
00:04:06,005 --> 00:04:07,904
I vote yes.
30
00:04:08,005 --> 00:04:13,612
For my family,
but mainly for my father Cesar Maia...
31
00:04:13,713 --> 00:04:18,404
run over by the Worker's Party (PT)
when he was the mayor.
32
00:04:18,505 --> 00:04:22,170
PT rips apart the Constitution
in Rio and here.
33
00:04:22,271 --> 00:04:23,570
I vote yes!
34
00:04:23,671 --> 00:04:28,070
For democracy,
for the sovereignty of the popular vote,
35
00:04:28,171 --> 00:04:30,362
for human dignity,
36
00:04:30,463 --> 00:04:33,987
for those who fought against
the military dictatorship,
37
00:04:34,088 --> 00:04:38,404
I vote no to this coup
and say yes to Brazil!
38
00:04:38,505 --> 00:04:40,862
For my family, for my daughter...
39
00:04:40,963 --> 00:04:44,287
for my wife,
yes to the impeachment!
40
00:04:49,671 --> 00:04:54,904
For the families and for the children
in schools who PT never cared about.
41
00:04:55,005 --> 00:04:59,695
For the memory of Colonel
Carlos Alberto Brilhante Ustra...
42
00:04:59,796 --> 00:05:02,570
the nightmare of Dilma Rousseff.
43
00:05:02,671 --> 00:05:04,112
How do you vote?
44
00:05:04,213 --> 00:05:08,070
For the army of Caxias,
for our Armed Forces...
45
00:05:08,171 --> 00:05:15,329
Brazil above everything and
God above everyone, I vote yes!
46
00:05:17,130 --> 00:05:19,862
How does
Deputy Feghali vote?
47
00:05:19,963 --> 00:05:24,070
I would like to express my outrage,
Deputy Eduardo Cunha...
48
00:05:24,171 --> 00:05:29,404
at seeing you in that chair
with no moral fiber.
49
00:05:29,505 --> 00:05:35,237
Second, my indignation at seeing you
embracing a traitor of democracy...
50
00:05:35,338 --> 00:05:38,237
who tries to usurp
the President's seat.
51
00:05:38,338 --> 00:05:42,404
Vice-President Michel Temer,
who has no vote.
52
00:05:42,505 --> 00:05:46,612
Third, it's very clear
to Brazilian society...
53
00:05:46,713 --> 00:05:49,195
what the impeachment alliance is.
54
00:05:49,296 --> 00:05:54,862
It brings together Corrupt politicians,
torturers like Jair Bolsonaro...
55
00:05:54,963 --> 00:05:59,570
and traitors of our country.
And I vote no, against the coup.
56
00:05:59,671 --> 00:06:03,237
For the military of 1964,
today and always.
57
00:06:03,338 --> 00:06:07,612
For the police, God and
the Brazilian family, I vote yes!
58
00:06:07,713 --> 00:06:11,070
How does Deputy Jean Wyllys
from the PSOL vote?
59
00:06:11,171 --> 00:06:14,737
I am embarrassed
at participating in this farce,
60
00:06:14,838 --> 00:06:19,529
this indirect election
conducted by a thief,
61
00:06:19,630 --> 00:06:24,237
devised by a traitor, a conspirator,
and supported by torturers...
62
00:06:24,338 --> 00:06:28,070
cowards, political illiterates,
and crooks.
63
00:06:28,171 --> 00:06:30,070
This sexist farce.
64
00:06:30,171 --> 00:06:35,695
For the rights of the LGBT population,
blacks exterminated in the favelas...
65
00:06:35,796 --> 00:06:39,862
the right of artists,
the homeless, the landless...
66
00:06:39,963 --> 00:06:41,987
I vote no to the coup!
67
00:06:42,088 --> 00:06:45,570
And sleep with that,
you bastards!
68
00:06:45,671 --> 00:06:49,404
Deputy Eduardo Cunha,
how do you vote?
69
00:06:49,505 --> 00:06:52,654
May God have mercy
on this nation.
70
00:06:52,755 --> 00:06:54,620
I vote yes.
71
00:06:56,755 --> 00:06:58,904
In honor of the working people...
72
00:06:59,005 --> 00:07:02,737
who took to the streets today
to resist the coup.
73
00:07:02,838 --> 00:07:08,987
I agree with you when you say
"may God have mercy on this country".
74
00:07:09,088 --> 00:07:14,237
I hope so, because you are
the head of corruption in this country...
75
00:07:14,338 --> 00:07:19,904
presiding over a court
that will judge an honorable woman.
76
00:07:20,005 --> 00:07:23,737
And, President, don't kid yourself
with that smirk...
77
00:07:23,838 --> 00:07:26,820
You're up in the
Federal Supreme Court. I vote no!
78
00:07:26,921 --> 00:07:28,320
Against a party...
79
00:07:28,421 --> 00:07:33,695
which uses national foreign policy
to employ the country's resources
80
00:07:33,796 --> 00:07:38,070
to fund bloodthirsty
Bolivarian dictatorships.
81
00:07:38,171 --> 00:07:43,904
Against those who use education
to indoctrinate and harass our children.
82
00:07:44,005 --> 00:07:46,029
For better days for our country...
83
00:07:46,130 --> 00:07:50,404
free from this gang that
embedded itself in our core.
84
00:07:50,505 --> 00:07:54,695
And with all my heart...
Yes! Dilma out!
85
00:07:54,796 --> 00:07:58,904
I'm Brazilian,
86
00:07:59,005 --> 00:08:05,537
I'm proud, with lots of love...
87
00:08:06,338 --> 00:08:11,487
I'm Brazilian,
88
00:08:11,588 --> 00:08:17,070
I'm proud
with lots of love...
89
00:08:17,171 --> 00:08:21,904
The impeachment proceedings
are authorized..
90
00:08:22,005 --> 00:08:27,570
against the Madam President due to
the accusation of impeachable offense...
91
00:08:27,671 --> 00:08:31,487
offered by H�lio Bicudo...
92
00:08:31,588 --> 00:08:35,695
Miguel Reale Junior
and Jana�na Paschoal...
93
00:08:35,796 --> 00:08:43,495
for the opening of additional budget
without Congress authorization.
94
00:08:49,671 --> 00:08:53,070
The placid banks
of the Ipiranga heard
95
00:08:53,171 --> 00:08:57,362
The resounding cry
of a heroic folk
96
00:08:57,463 --> 00:09:01,570
And the sun of Liberty
in shining beams
97
00:09:01,671 --> 00:09:05,570
Shone in the homeland's sky
in this instant
98
00:09:05,671 --> 00:09:10,237
If the pledge of this equality
99
00:09:10,338 --> 00:09:13,862
We managed to conquer
with strong arm
100
00:09:13,963 --> 00:09:18,204
In thy bosom, o Freedom...
101
00:09:22,630 --> 00:09:28,329
THE TRIAL
102
00:10:39,296 --> 00:10:43,162
Yes, then we'll have
six months before the trial.
103
00:10:50,505 --> 00:10:53,954
Don't mention it.
Goodbye.
104
00:10:55,505 --> 00:10:57,237
- Dai!
- What?
105
00:10:57,338 --> 00:11:02,404
- You may transfer the other call.
- Do you have a copy, senator?
106
00:11:02,505 --> 00:11:05,737
No, I have one here
from the UOL guy.
107
00:11:05,838 --> 00:11:07,570
I have no copy here.
108
00:11:07,671 --> 00:11:09,904
Wait, I'm printing.
109
00:11:10,005 --> 00:11:14,870
But go ahead and call.
I have to go to the Committee.
110
00:11:20,630 --> 00:11:22,862
Where is the causality?
111
00:11:22,963 --> 00:11:27,404
Revenue fell due to the crisis.
Or is it the other way around?
112
00:11:27,505 --> 00:11:32,537
He says the President spent more
and that led to a crisis...
113
00:11:32,838 --> 00:11:36,195
What is the best excerpt to quote?
114
00:11:36,296 --> 00:11:40,495
What is the best part
for me to highlight?
115
00:11:41,796 --> 00:11:45,487
Here. "According to the message..."
116
00:11:45,588 --> 00:11:49,862
"According to the message,
the evaluation takes into account
117
00:11:49,963 --> 00:11:54,487
the effects of the bill
that changes the annual budget."
118
00:11:54,588 --> 00:11:56,654
This is a Congress decision!
119
00:11:56,755 --> 00:12:01,070
And in addition, he says,
"I am aware of the message..."
120
00:12:01,171 --> 00:12:02,570
I don't have time.
121
00:12:02,671 --> 00:12:06,362
Just say that he dismissed it
with no reservations.
122
00:12:06,463 --> 00:12:09,987
And it was approved unanimously
by Congress.
123
00:12:10,088 --> 00:12:12,987
The key issue
is that the Senator analyzed...
124
00:12:13,088 --> 00:12:17,529
knowing that the Executive
was using a new annual budget...
125
00:12:17,630 --> 00:12:19,862
and he approved it.
That's it.
126
00:12:19,963 --> 00:12:22,695
Those two things
are the key issue.
127
00:12:22,796 --> 00:12:26,320
The Executive acted
in accordance with Congress.
128
00:12:26,421 --> 00:12:28,495
Now it's a crime?
129
00:12:37,505 --> 00:12:40,404
I'm ready. I'll go to war!
130
00:12:40,505 --> 00:12:43,204
The bad thing is
that we don't eat!
131
00:12:46,106 --> 00:12:51,009
April 28th, 2016.
A Senate Committee examines the charges:
132
00:12:51,110 --> 00:12:56,405
1. the issuing of six fiscal decrees
without Congress approval.
133
00:12:56,506 --> 00:13:00,639
2. the so-called "pedaladas":
a delayed repayment
134
00:13:00,740 --> 00:13:05,418
of the agricultural subsidies
spent by state banks.
135
00:13:07,088 --> 00:13:10,237
Dilma has been accused
of two things.
136
00:13:10,338 --> 00:13:14,154
Delaying payment of the Farm Subsidies
to the Bank of Brazil...
137
00:13:14,255 --> 00:13:16,820
and six additional budget decrees.
138
00:13:16,921 --> 00:13:19,029
We've been explaining...
139
00:13:19,130 --> 00:13:25,320
that there's a 1992 law
which shows that the Farm Subsidies...
140
00:13:25,421 --> 00:13:29,695
are managed by four ministries
and the Monetary Council.
141
00:13:29,796 --> 00:13:34,529
The President takes no part.
So we're asking for documentation.
142
00:13:34,630 --> 00:13:37,904
From the Bank of Brazil,
Ministry of Agriculture...
143
00:13:38,005 --> 00:13:41,487
Ministry of Finance,
Ministry of Planning.
144
00:13:41,588 --> 00:13:45,904
And another thing.
Six additional budget decrees.
145
00:13:46,005 --> 00:13:50,279
A widespread practice
not considered illegal.
146
00:13:50,380 --> 00:13:54,737
We need documents from the departments
which requested funds.
147
00:13:54,838 --> 00:13:57,737
The Federal and Electoral
Justice departments...
148
00:13:57,838 --> 00:14:02,029
the Ministry of Education.
I plead with you.
149
00:14:02,130 --> 00:14:05,487
You're curtailing
our right of defense.
150
00:14:05,588 --> 00:14:10,487
We said that a rapporteur
from the opposition would be biased.
151
00:14:10,588 --> 00:14:12,529
It seems true!
152
00:14:12,630 --> 00:14:17,695
Article 45 of Law 1,079 states:
153
00:14:17,796 --> 00:14:21,904
"Within the period,
the committee may carry out
154
00:14:22,005 --> 00:14:25,529
the verifications
it deems necessary."
155
00:14:25,630 --> 00:14:28,529
The rapporteur has a view,
the committee will vote.
156
00:14:28,630 --> 00:14:31,654
Mr. President R. Lira...
157
00:14:31,755 --> 00:14:37,070
I put to the vote
request 16 of 2016.
158
00:14:37,171 --> 00:14:41,362
The senators who agree
with the rapporteur's assessment...
159
00:14:41,463 --> 00:14:44,029
should remain as they are.
160
00:14:44,130 --> 00:14:46,487
Dismissed.
161
00:14:46,588 --> 00:14:52,237
Mr. President, but it's sad to see
how this session is being led.
162
00:14:52,338 --> 00:14:56,362
I feel like we're lambs
led to the slaughter.
163
00:14:56,463 --> 00:14:58,737
This committee
has made up its mind.
164
00:14:58,838 --> 00:15:04,529
Whatever we say,
it's already been decided.
165
00:15:04,630 --> 00:15:10,529
The rapporteur knows what he's going to
report and most of us know how well vote.
166
00:15:10,630 --> 00:15:17,195
That's sad. These requests
aren't meant for a later stage...
167
00:15:17,296 --> 00:15:22,904
but for us to examine
the admissibility of the accusation.
168
00:15:23,005 --> 00:15:24,904
Where's the just cause?
169
00:15:25,005 --> 00:15:30,487
Because it shows President Dilma
did not commit any crimes...
170
00:15:30,588 --> 00:15:34,570
relating to the six budget decrees...
171
00:15:34,671 --> 00:15:43,162
since they were supported
by a law voted in by the Congress.
172
00:16:10,838 --> 00:16:12,995
Get him and Dalmo.
173
00:16:13,671 --> 00:16:18,237
Before the report we should
bring up preliminary statements.
174
00:16:18,338 --> 00:16:24,070
Lindbergh will bring up
the Government of Minas Gerais.
175
00:16:24,171 --> 00:16:27,904
We have Z� Eduardo's appeal
which also states..
176
00:16:28,005 --> 00:16:32,904
the rapporteur should be suspect
because of his party, PSDB.
177
00:16:33,005 --> 00:16:36,737
- He replied the same day...
- But not at the committee.
178
00:16:36,838 --> 00:16:40,529
He just published it.
179
00:16:40,630 --> 00:16:43,529
We need to discuss it
in the committee...
180
00:16:43,630 --> 00:16:47,404
"You used accounting tricks
in Minas Gerais." That's it.
181
00:16:47,505 --> 00:16:55,237
We're not trying to win the point of order,
but to discredit him as rapporteur.
182
00:16:55,338 --> 00:17:00,904
It's just a matter of time
until the President is removed.
183
00:17:01,005 --> 00:17:04,695
This game is rigged.
It's make believe.
184
00:17:04,796 --> 00:17:10,404
But in this rigged game,
we also have politics, gestures.
185
00:17:10,505 --> 00:17:14,237
PMDB party, the greatest beneficiary
of the coup...
186
00:17:14,338 --> 00:17:20,154
appointed five names
which are already dirty.
187
00:17:20,255 --> 00:17:23,029
That's a crime, not a trial.
188
00:17:23,130 --> 00:17:28,904
The report by the opposition PSDB
was without surprises.
189
00:17:29,005 --> 00:17:32,654
We're not going to endorse
a rigged game.
190
00:17:32,755 --> 00:17:36,995
I'm asking you to think about
a political gesture.
191
00:18:00,796 --> 00:18:08,329
Dilma, a fighter
for the Brazilian nation!
192
00:18:59,222 --> 00:19:07,703
April 29th, 2016.
Opening statements of the prosecutor and defense.
193
00:20:07,463 --> 00:20:10,820
Ladies and gentlemen senators.
194
00:20:10,921 --> 00:20:14,620
We will now pass the floor...
195
00:20:15,963 --> 00:20:18,862
to Jana�na Paschoal...
196
00:20:18,963 --> 00:20:24,029
the lawyer and
professor of criminal law...
197
00:20:24,130 --> 00:20:28,029
at the University of S�o Paulo.
198
00:20:28,130 --> 00:20:30,237
It was my moral obligation...
199
00:20:30,338 --> 00:20:35,029
to bring this to Your Excellencies
who are judging this matter.
200
00:20:35,130 --> 00:20:42,529
Your Excellencies
can be absolutely confident...
201
00:20:42,630 --> 00:20:44,737
in admitting the complaint.
202
00:20:44,838 --> 00:20:49,195
As a plaintiff,
I ask that you admit it fully.
203
00:20:49,296 --> 00:20:51,862
Because this is part of a whole...
204
00:20:51,963 --> 00:20:56,237
which shows the coup
my country fell victim to.
205
00:20:56,338 --> 00:21:03,654
Don't Your Excellencies think
I'd be happy to see a woman...
206
00:21:03,755 --> 00:21:09,120
be successful as President
regardless of her party?
207
00:21:10,588 --> 00:21:12,995
I'm a Brazilian woman!
208
00:21:14,296 --> 00:21:19,162
I love this land
more than anything.
209
00:21:23,796 --> 00:21:28,995
I'm here because I'm Brazilian,
that's my party.
210
00:21:32,838 --> 00:21:35,695
I've never voted for PT
(Workers' Party).
211
00:21:35,796 --> 00:21:39,695
But when President Dilma
gave an interview
212
00:21:39,796 --> 00:21:44,904
and said she used to dream of being
a ballet dancer, I cried.
213
00:21:45,005 --> 00:21:47,454
That ballerina got lost.
214
00:21:50,838 --> 00:21:54,329
She got lost and left me no alternative.
215
00:21:55,421 --> 00:21:59,362
As a Brazilian, as a lawyer...
216
00:21:59,463 --> 00:22:05,529
as a teacher of criminal law,
as a lover...
217
00:22:05,630 --> 00:22:10,904
for I am in love
with the Federal Constitution...
218
00:22:11,005 --> 00:22:13,287
I had no choice.
219
00:22:15,005 --> 00:22:17,237
After my first big speech...
220
00:22:17,338 --> 00:22:20,862
I received calls
even from foreign journalists...
221
00:22:20,963 --> 00:22:24,329
asking if I'm a priestess or a shaman.
222
00:22:25,130 --> 00:22:32,029
And I tell them
"I'm not enlightened enough...
223
00:22:32,130 --> 00:22:35,029
to be either a priestess
or a shaman."
224
00:22:35,130 --> 00:22:41,029
And if I were a priestess
or a shaman in a secular state...
225
00:22:41,130 --> 00:22:44,404
my legal work
wouldn't be diminished.
226
00:22:44,505 --> 00:22:47,362
A secular state
is not an atheist state.
227
00:22:47,463 --> 00:22:50,029
It's a state which allows...
228
00:22:50,130 --> 00:22:54,529
all religions to coexist peacefully.
229
00:22:54,630 --> 00:23:00,237
If I was a priestess
or a catechism teacher...
230
00:23:00,338 --> 00:23:04,195
I'd be honored to verify it.
But I'm not those things.
231
00:23:04,296 --> 00:23:06,995
I'm just a law professor.
232
00:23:07,963 --> 00:23:09,954
And in a republic...
233
00:23:12,755 --> 00:23:15,120
this is the sacred book.
234
00:23:16,505 --> 00:23:19,404
This is the sacred book
which allows...
235
00:23:19,505 --> 00:23:24,204
every other sacred book
to be respected and coexist.
236
00:23:28,130 --> 00:23:31,495
What I want is that
the little children...
237
00:23:34,421 --> 00:23:38,954
the little Brazilians
who can hear me...
238
00:23:39,921 --> 00:23:43,120
I want them to believe...
239
00:23:44,296 --> 00:23:49,029
this sacred book
is worth fighting for...
240
00:23:49,130 --> 00:23:52,329
PT never signed this book!
241
00:23:58,796 --> 00:24:04,829
I pass the floor to Jose Eduardo Cardozo,
Attorney General of the Union.
242
00:24:07,963 --> 00:24:10,029
This impeachment trial...
243
00:24:10,130 --> 00:24:12,904
does not comply with the Constitution.
244
00:24:13,005 --> 00:24:16,362
There's no impeachable offense,
it was a pretext...
245
00:24:16,463 --> 00:24:20,529
a glaring illegality
in the proceedings in the House...
246
00:24:20,630 --> 00:24:26,579
and if this impeachment is carried out,
it will be a coup.
247
00:24:27,463 --> 00:24:31,987
It's notorious and thoroughly
recorded by the press...
248
00:24:32,088 --> 00:24:35,195
and if it's notorious,
it doesn't require proof...
249
00:24:35,296 --> 00:24:38,695
that Speaker Cunha
began this action...
250
00:24:38,796 --> 00:24:42,362
the very second after the Workers' Party...
251
00:24:42,463 --> 00:24:47,987
denied him the votes he needed
to elude the Ethics Committee.
252
00:24:48,088 --> 00:24:50,862
He was the subject
of proceedings...
253
00:24:50,963 --> 00:24:55,820
lost the support of the opposition,
which was publicly against him..
254
00:24:55,921 --> 00:25:00,862
and, as the press reported
several days earlier...
255
00:25:00,963 --> 00:25:06,529
he threatened the Government.
"Give me the votes I need...
256
00:25:06,630 --> 00:25:09,195
or I'll start the impeachment."
257
00:25:09,296 --> 00:25:11,195
PT turned him down...
258
00:25:11,296 --> 00:25:15,362
and he immediately
started the impeachment.
259
00:25:15,463 --> 00:25:19,695
Secondly, there's no criminal intent
because there's no action.
260
00:25:19,796 --> 00:25:25,695
The Farm Subsidies are managed by the
Minister of Finance, not the President!
261
00:25:25,796 --> 00:25:29,320
How do the plaintiffs overcome this?
262
00:25:29,421 --> 00:25:35,862
First, they said the President had
frequent conversations with Arnon.
263
00:25:35,963 --> 00:25:39,529
Are conversations a legal fact?
264
00:25:39,630 --> 00:25:42,695
If I talk to a senator
and he murders someone...
265
00:25:42,796 --> 00:25:46,737
will I be an accessory?
266
00:25:46,838 --> 00:25:49,695
Where do you get this kind of thing?
267
00:25:49,796 --> 00:25:53,695
To deem a conversation a legal fact?
268
00:25:53,796 --> 00:25:58,029
They don't know its content.
It was based on a news article...
269
00:25:58,130 --> 00:26:02,654
which reported that she and
the treasury secretary talked.
270
00:26:02,755 --> 00:26:07,195
On top of it, they say:
Listen to the alternative.
271
00:26:07,296 --> 00:26:10,695
If it's not this, it's omission.
272
00:26:10,796 --> 00:26:15,529
Omission?
To have a situation of omission,
273
00:26:15,630 --> 00:26:19,904
a specific duty must be neglected,
and did this happen? No.
274
00:26:20,005 --> 00:26:25,570
They use Article 84 of the Constitution
to say the President manages everything.
275
00:26:25,671 --> 00:26:30,529
So I can impeach her
if someone steals a stapler.
276
00:26:30,630 --> 00:26:32,237
Is that right?
277
00:26:32,338 --> 00:26:35,695
It's the President's duty...
278
00:26:35,796 --> 00:26:39,737
to manage the top layers
of the federal administration.
279
00:26:39,838 --> 00:26:46,654
And we are discussing
the upper management of Brazilian state...
280
00:26:46,755 --> 00:26:53,454
where, for some years, a wicked,
irresponsible management...
281
00:26:53,755 --> 00:26:58,195
led Brazil into the worst crisis ever.
282
00:26:58,296 --> 00:27:06,029
It was all part of a large scheme,
or a great fiscal fraud...
283
00:27:06,130 --> 00:27:12,862
perpetrated deliberately by the Government
to try to win the 2014 elections.
284
00:27:12,963 --> 00:27:16,829
It's not just a set of mistakes,
285
00:27:17,130 --> 00:27:19,620
but a complete destruction.
286
00:27:20,296 --> 00:27:24,029
We're discussing this destruction.
287
00:27:24,130 --> 00:27:28,487
It was all prepared with
the knowledge and authorization...
288
00:27:28,588 --> 00:27:32,195
of the President,
who lied to the Brazilian people.
289
00:27:32,296 --> 00:27:37,695
I confess, I don't know if
President Dilma Rousseff is honest.
290
00:27:37,796 --> 00:27:40,370
But I'm sure she lies.
291
00:27:40,796 --> 00:27:45,570
Do you know how
to remove a President?
292
00:27:45,671 --> 00:27:48,820
With elections.
You go on TV and say...
293
00:27:48,921 --> 00:27:51,737
"Dilma ruined us.
Don't vote for PT."
294
00:27:51,838 --> 00:27:56,695
But in order to impeach her,
there must be a legal reason!
295
00:27:56,796 --> 00:28:00,829
All the literature
and case law states that!
296
00:28:04,032 --> 00:28:05,437
May 5th, 2016.
297
00:28:05,538 --> 00:28:10,067
House Speaker Eduardo Cunha is
removed by the Supreme Court
298
00:28:10,168 --> 00:28:16,181
on charges of corruption and obstruction
of justice in "Operation Car Wash",
299
00:28:16,282 --> 00:28:20,818
which investigates the
corruption scheme at Petrobras.
300
00:29:07,221 --> 00:29:09,495
I agree with your assessment.
301
00:29:09,596 --> 00:29:15,995
Brazil was already expecting
the removal of the House Speaker...
302
00:29:16,096 --> 00:29:18,495
but it was too late.
303
00:29:18,596 --> 00:29:23,704
We could have avoided
most of these crises.
304
00:29:23,805 --> 00:29:30,162
Not just the President's impeachment
but the intentionally harmful bills...
305
00:29:30,263 --> 00:29:35,995
the delays on votes for crucial
measures to our economy.
306
00:29:36,096 --> 00:29:41,120
We could have avoided many things
that led the country to this.
307
00:29:41,221 --> 00:29:46,162
It is clearly a good thing
for Vice-President Michel Temer,
308
00:29:46,263 --> 00:29:52,204
because the Speaker of the House
would replace him
309
00:29:52,305 --> 00:29:55,662
if he was removed from office.
310
00:29:55,763 --> 00:30:01,995
It eliminates the possibility
of us having as President...
311
00:30:02,096 --> 00:30:07,129
someone as compromised
as Speaker Eduardo Cunha.
312
00:30:14,430 --> 00:30:18,629
Thank you. My best
to everyone at Radio Nacional.
313
00:30:19,430 --> 00:30:21,295
Have a nice day.
314
00:30:26,430 --> 00:30:28,045
Good morning.
315
00:30:32,471 --> 00:30:34,545
Good morning, how are you?
316
00:30:41,763 --> 00:30:45,295
Good morning, how are you?
317
00:30:49,721 --> 00:30:54,995
The fact that I conducted the session,
which culminated in the voting...
318
00:30:55,096 --> 00:30:58,495
led to an expected reaction.
319
00:30:58,596 --> 00:31:05,537
From then on, they convinced everyone
to take me to trial in their company.
320
00:31:05,638 --> 00:31:08,329
But this will end next Wednesday.
321
00:31:08,430 --> 00:31:14,662
If it is God's will, the President will
be removed and consequently tried.
322
00:31:14,763 --> 00:31:16,662
Are you not going to resign?
323
00:31:16,763 --> 00:31:18,829
No, I will not resign.
324
00:31:18,930 --> 00:31:20,870
The mandate or...
325
00:31:20,971 --> 00:31:23,954
Neither the mandate
nor as House Speaker.
326
00:31:24,055 --> 00:31:26,995
I will appeal, and I hope to succeed.
327
00:31:27,096 --> 00:31:29,962
Thank you!
328
00:31:32,763 --> 00:31:39,962
Cunha, you thief, your place is in jail!
329
00:31:49,971 --> 00:31:51,620
Is that it?
330
00:31:51,721 --> 00:31:55,120
Do you mind if we shoot
a video for Londrina?
331
00:31:55,221 --> 00:31:58,295
Ready?
Is it recording?
332
00:31:58,763 --> 00:32:03,454
Hi, I'm Felipe Barros here in Brasilia...
333
00:32:03,555 --> 00:32:06,454
with the great Jana�na Paschoal...
334
00:32:06,555 --> 00:32:09,037
who has been brave and fearless.
335
00:32:09,138 --> 00:32:13,287
An excellent lawyer, moving
the impeachment forward...
336
00:32:13,388 --> 00:32:17,829
for us to remove President Dilma
and all those criminals.
337
00:32:17,930 --> 00:32:20,954
Can you send a message to Londrina?
338
00:32:21,055 --> 00:32:24,329
Hi, everyone. Thanks for your support...
339
00:32:24,430 --> 00:32:27,662
for your positive thoughts and prayers.
340
00:32:27,763 --> 00:32:35,537
The most important part is not to win,
but what takes place during this trial.
341
00:32:35,638 --> 00:32:40,454
People should see that
they're powerful and capable.
342
00:32:40,555 --> 00:32:45,287
They shouldn't give authorities
control over our fate...
343
00:32:45,388 --> 00:32:47,662
and just accept everything.
344
00:32:47,763 --> 00:32:52,495
Young people should study hard
and enter politics.
345
00:32:52,596 --> 00:32:56,329
Politics is about doing good for others.
346
00:32:56,430 --> 00:33:00,829
We need to change
the concepts of our society.
347
00:33:00,930 --> 00:33:02,995
It's a time for renewal.
348
00:33:03,096 --> 00:33:07,787
All my best to Londrina,
God bless you.
349
00:33:07,888 --> 00:33:11,162
Thank you very much.
Congratulations.
350
00:33:11,263 --> 00:33:13,620
- Thank you.
- I've been praying for you.
351
00:33:13,721 --> 00:33:15,254
Thank you very much.
352
00:33:25,930 --> 00:33:29,162
Think about what you would ask.
353
00:33:29,263 --> 00:33:31,962
I made a note there.
354
00:34:42,263 --> 00:34:47,995
Notwithstanding political differences,
I believe senators should have...
355
00:34:48,096 --> 00:34:54,204
respectful relationships with their peers
but mainly, a commitment to the truth.
356
00:34:54,305 --> 00:35:00,870
I take seriously the issue
with the post I saw this morning...
357
00:35:00,971 --> 00:35:06,287
which attributed to A�cio Neves
words he never spoke...
358
00:35:06,388 --> 00:35:13,662
in circumstances which never happened.
I believe it was an unfortunate oversight...
359
00:35:13,763 --> 00:35:16,329
by Senator Lindbergh's advisers...
360
00:35:16,430 --> 00:35:20,287
since it was posted
on his page.
361
00:35:20,388 --> 00:35:25,370
I posted about Senator A�cio Neves
and the taking away of labor rights...
362
00:35:25,471 --> 00:35:29,329
and the senator won't be able to hide it.
363
00:35:29,430 --> 00:35:32,795
You're reiterating your insult!
364
00:35:32,896 --> 00:35:35,079
I want my time!
365
00:35:35,430 --> 00:35:37,620
You're repeating...
366
00:35:37,721 --> 00:35:39,620
- I want my time.
- The lie...
367
00:35:39,721 --> 00:35:42,329
posted on your page.
368
00:35:42,430 --> 00:35:46,162
If your advisers did it,
they're accomplices!
369
00:35:46,263 --> 00:35:48,662
Let him speak!
370
00:35:48,763 --> 00:35:50,454
I've heard it...
371
00:35:50,555 --> 00:35:54,579
I asked them to replace the buzzer.
372
00:35:54,680 --> 00:35:57,870
It's not worthy
of this impeachment committee.
373
00:35:57,971 --> 00:35:59,545
I just want my time.
374
00:36:01,055 --> 00:36:05,454
The session is adjourned for 5 minutes
to replace the buzzer.
375
00:36:05,555 --> 00:36:09,420
It's not worthy of this historic moment.
376
00:36:55,430 --> 00:37:01,162
I'd like Senator Lindbergh
to have the floor all to himself.
377
00:37:01,263 --> 00:37:09,162
That senator can't hide from Brazil the
fact that this is a parliamentary coup...
378
00:37:09,263 --> 00:37:12,495
because there's
no impeachable offense.
379
00:37:12,596 --> 00:37:20,329
Your excellency should stick
to the subject at hand.
380
00:37:20,430 --> 00:37:22,995
The subject is labor rights.
381
00:37:23,096 --> 00:37:27,662
This is "Bridge to the Future",
by Vice-President Michel Temer...
382
00:37:27,763 --> 00:37:30,595
He has the right to speak!
383
00:37:30,696 --> 00:37:32,829
Point of order!
384
00:37:32,930 --> 00:37:35,829
You're an arrogant opportunist!
385
00:37:35,930 --> 00:37:39,329
- Your Excellency, calm down!
- I'm too calm.
386
00:37:39,430 --> 00:37:44,162
- Recompose yourself.
- Senator Lindbergh Farias has the floor.
387
00:37:44,263 --> 00:37:48,995
It's in "Bridge to the Future"
I'm not making it up.
388
00:37:49,096 --> 00:37:51,579
"No more minimum wage policies."
389
00:37:51,680 --> 00:37:54,995
"No more indexing it to welfare."
390
00:37:55,096 --> 00:37:59,454
You will answer to the Ethics
Committee for your insult!
391
00:37:59,555 --> 00:38:02,870
Is it an insult
to say A�cio and Temer...
392
00:38:02,971 --> 00:38:05,995
want to take away labor rights?
393
00:38:06,096 --> 00:38:09,495
"Bridge to the Future"
destroys the legacies...
394
00:38:09,596 --> 00:38:13,370
of Presidents Lula
and Get�lio Vargas.
395
00:38:13,471 --> 00:38:18,829
They want to privatize everything,
to give our reserves to big oil companies.
396
00:38:18,930 --> 00:38:21,662
They'll end the sharing of oil revenues.
397
00:38:21,763 --> 00:38:25,662
They want to make concessions.
398
00:38:25,763 --> 00:38:32,162
They don't want to hear
about BRICS or Mercosur.
399
00:38:32,263 --> 00:38:37,787
They want to realign our foreign
policy with North-American interests...
400
00:38:37,888 --> 00:38:41,162
this is why
they're attempting a coup...
401
00:38:41,263 --> 00:38:45,954
because nobody would be elected
President with this program!
402
00:38:46,055 --> 00:38:50,329
If social programs are at risk today...
403
00:38:50,430 --> 00:38:56,329
it's because they're leaving us
a country in shambles.
404
00:38:56,430 --> 00:39:03,037
If labor rights are being abolished...
405
00:39:03,138 --> 00:39:08,995
it's because our country
has 11,100,000 unemployed.
406
00:39:09,096 --> 00:39:14,662
We can either make a quick decision...
407
00:39:14,763 --> 00:39:19,995
while following the proceedings
determined by the Supreme Court...
408
00:39:20,096 --> 00:39:24,204
or face the steadily worsening conditions...
409
00:39:24,305 --> 00:39:29,329
of the country's political
and economic landscape.
410
00:39:29,430 --> 00:39:34,329
We will now vote on
Senator Anastasia's report.
411
00:39:34,430 --> 00:39:40,795
The senators can vote
with the electronic voting system.
412
00:39:47,596 --> 00:39:50,995
What is the result,
Mr. President?
413
00:39:51,096 --> 00:39:53,704
- Open it up.
- Let's see the results.
414
00:39:53,805 --> 00:39:56,795
Has everyone voted?
415
00:39:57,888 --> 00:40:00,129
The results.
416
00:40:02,596 --> 00:40:05,012
The official results are
417
00:40:05,113 --> 00:40:08,495
Yes, 15.
No, 5.
418
00:40:08,596 --> 00:40:11,120
The voting is closed.
419
00:40:11,221 --> 00:40:18,337
The Committee voted
to accept the accusation.
420
00:40:23,115 --> 00:40:27,489
May 12th, 2016.
The Senate Committee accepts the charges.
421
00:40:27,590 --> 00:40:31,201
Rousseff is suspended
from office for 180 days.
422
00:40:31,302 --> 00:40:35,584
Vice President Michel Temer
assumes the presidency.
423
00:40:37,930 --> 00:40:44,962
Dilma, a fighter
for the Brazilian nation!
424
00:40:52,805 --> 00:40:59,287
Temer out! Temer out!
425
00:40:59,388 --> 00:41:02,329
One, two, three, four, five!
426
00:41:02,430 --> 00:41:05,662
Stop this coup
or we will stop Brazil!
427
00:41:05,763 --> 00:41:08,870
One, two, three, four, five!
428
00:41:08,971 --> 00:41:12,462
Stop this coup
or we will stop Brazil!
429
00:41:15,930 --> 00:41:23,879
Dilma, a fighter
for the Brazilian nation!
430
00:41:28,263 --> 00:41:34,254
Fate has always presented me
with many challenges.
431
00:41:35,055 --> 00:41:38,162
They were many and they were great.
432
00:41:38,263 --> 00:41:43,620
Some seemed insurmountable.
433
00:41:43,721 --> 00:41:46,662
But I managed to overcome them.
434
00:41:46,763 --> 00:41:51,246
I've suffered the
indescribable pain of torture,
435
00:41:51,347 --> 00:41:54,495
the agonizing pain of illness...
436
00:41:54,596 --> 00:41:59,254
and now I suffer, once again...
437
00:41:59,805 --> 00:42:04,920
the equally unspeakable pain of injustice.
438
00:42:05,430 --> 00:42:09,254
What hurts the most right now
is the injustice...
439
00:42:09,596 --> 00:42:17,254
realizing I'm a victim
of a legal and political farce.
440
00:42:26,638 --> 00:42:33,370
Prosecutor Janot is after you
and he thinks I'll help.
441
00:42:33,471 --> 00:42:38,329
We need a new Government
to stop this bleeding.
442
00:42:38,430 --> 00:42:43,662
The easiest solution
would be to put Vice-President Michel.
443
00:42:43,763 --> 00:42:46,204
Renan is the only one
against it!
444
00:42:46,305 --> 00:42:49,162
He doesn't like Michel,
who's with Cunha.
445
00:42:49,263 --> 00:42:51,829
Forget Cunha.
He's as good as dead.
446
00:42:51,930 --> 00:42:56,954
We need to put Michel up there,
with a great national pact.
447
00:42:57,055 --> 00:43:00,204
- With the Supreme Court and all.
- It would stop it.
448
00:43:00,305 --> 00:43:03,879
Right, it would stop where it is.
449
00:43:05,763 --> 00:43:08,204
"A pact with the Supreme Court and all."
450
00:43:08,305 --> 00:43:11,829
Sergio Machado says,
"It would stop it."
451
00:43:11,930 --> 00:43:16,370
Juc� continues,
"It would stop where it is."
452
00:43:16,471 --> 00:43:20,329
It continues, there's more.
Senator Juc� says,
453
00:43:20,430 --> 00:43:23,329
"I talked to some
Supreme Court Justices."
454
00:43:23,430 --> 00:43:26,620
He must tell us
who those Justices are.
455
00:43:26,721 --> 00:43:30,995
"They said it's only possible
without her there.
456
00:43:31,096 --> 00:43:36,162
While she's there, the press,
the guys will want to get her out.
457
00:43:36,263 --> 00:43:39,370
This thing will never end."
458
00:43:39,471 --> 00:43:45,162
It is clear that their objective
is to stop the Car Wash investigation.
459
00:43:45,263 --> 00:43:48,662
It is a denial of due process...
460
00:43:48,763 --> 00:43:55,037
to prevent those recordings
from reaching this Impeachment Committee.
461
00:43:55,138 --> 00:43:58,954
It so happens that
those recordings don't interfere...
462
00:43:59,055 --> 00:44:02,204
directly or indirectly,
with the impeachment.
463
00:44:02,305 --> 00:44:09,662
After all, we were defeated
on the thesis that we should consider...
464
00:44:09,763 --> 00:44:12,995
operation Car Wash
in our debates.
465
00:44:13,096 --> 00:44:17,454
These tapes aren't being brought in
to discuss Car Wash...
466
00:44:17,555 --> 00:44:20,454
but to show they want
the impeachment
467
00:44:20,555 --> 00:44:25,120
to remove a President
who protected the investigation.
468
00:44:25,221 --> 00:44:29,995
Furthermore, it's curious
how Senator Anastasia refers...
469
00:44:30,096 --> 00:44:33,870
to the examination
of the Court of Auditors,
470
00:44:33,971 --> 00:44:41,870
"A request for international audit wouldn't
be efficient as the defense requests...
471
00:44:41,971 --> 00:44:45,870
since that task
has already been carried out."
472
00:44:45,971 --> 00:44:49,162
The Court of Auditors didn't do that.
473
00:44:49,263 --> 00:44:52,495
The accounts weren't even
the object of a report.
474
00:44:52,596 --> 00:44:54,995
The report claims...
475
00:44:55,096 --> 00:44:59,329
the Court of Auditors
has done something it hasn't.
476
00:44:59,430 --> 00:45:05,329
And I can't debate this.
I can't discuss each request...
477
00:45:05,430 --> 00:45:10,954
or the witnesses brought in
by the prosecution.
478
00:45:11,055 --> 00:45:15,620
I can't prove anything.
All I can do is speak.
479
00:45:15,721 --> 00:45:20,537
So I speak, and I analyze
80 requests in ten minutes.
480
00:45:20,638 --> 00:45:25,329
I tell you
the President's right of defense...
481
00:45:25,430 --> 00:45:30,495
has had its substance replaced by form,
because form guarantees appearances.
482
00:45:30,596 --> 00:45:35,162
As someone said, "It's not a coup,
due process is assured."
483
00:45:35,263 --> 00:45:40,287
Due process doesn't mean
the right of defense has substance.
484
00:45:40,388 --> 00:45:46,670
It gives apparent legitimacy
to something illegitimate.
485
00:46:31,180 --> 00:46:33,995
It's absurd not to have
an expert examination.
486
00:46:34,096 --> 00:46:39,037
We have the testimony
of one prosecutor.
487
00:46:39,138 --> 00:46:45,620
But the Government didn't even
inform the Court about the facts.
488
00:46:45,721 --> 00:46:50,504
Practically every point
we bring up is rejected.
489
00:46:50,930 --> 00:46:54,829
The people are curious,
and they ask...
490
00:46:54,930 --> 00:46:58,162
"Why do you keep insisting?
491
00:46:58,263 --> 00:47:02,120
You lose almost every time."
492
00:47:02,221 --> 00:47:07,495
I am concerned about how
the population sees this...
493
00:47:07,596 --> 00:47:12,162
considering how the press
publishes it.
494
00:47:12,263 --> 00:47:18,662
It might become
even more discouraging.
495
00:47:18,763 --> 00:47:24,995
I'd like you to consider
if it's not adequate to tone it down.
496
00:47:25,096 --> 00:47:30,662
- But why?
- One thing is the political debate...
497
00:47:30,763 --> 00:47:33,329
and another is to stall like this.
498
00:47:33,430 --> 00:47:38,995
We know we'll lose at the committee.
But we have to resist.
499
00:47:39,096 --> 00:47:43,537
If we get soft, they'll get it done
before they expected...
500
00:47:43,638 --> 00:47:49,787
and we need time for politics.
We need to do whatever we can.
501
00:47:49,888 --> 00:47:54,829
Present appeals, petitions,
points of order.
502
00:47:54,930 --> 00:47:57,787
And if we have more people,
all the better.
503
00:47:57,888 --> 00:48:00,870
Other people can speak too.
504
00:48:00,971 --> 00:48:03,995
You might be right
about Justice Lewandowski.
505
00:48:04,096 --> 00:48:08,537
When he denies something,
it's a strong statement.
506
00:48:08,638 --> 00:48:11,704
So we need to be foolproof.
507
00:48:11,805 --> 00:48:19,454
If we need the expert examination,
let's consider our appeals.
508
00:48:19,555 --> 00:48:24,495
And in everything we do,
we need to explain...
509
00:48:24,596 --> 00:48:29,662
that the President is being denied
her right of defense.
510
00:48:29,763 --> 00:48:34,037
I don't think that,
when we present an appeal...
511
00:48:34,138 --> 00:48:40,995
and it is denied,
we're legitimizing the process.
512
00:48:41,096 --> 00:48:45,495
They started
presenting appeals too...
513
00:48:45,596 --> 00:48:48,995
so that Lewandowski
denies theirs as well.
514
00:48:49,096 --> 00:48:51,662
We need to consider again.
515
00:48:51,763 --> 00:48:55,620
- I disagree.
- If we're denied, we legitimize it.
516
00:48:55,721 --> 00:48:57,662
But the witness?
517
00:48:57,763 --> 00:49:01,495
It would be bad to lose.
518
00:49:01,596 --> 00:49:04,162
We'll end up legitimizing it.
519
00:49:04,263 --> 00:49:07,787
Let's talk later.
520
00:49:07,888 --> 00:49:11,037
I'm not sure if these strategies
are the best.
521
00:49:11,138 --> 00:49:16,962
Well suspend it.
We'll make a second appeal.
522
00:49:28,721 --> 00:49:31,454
Her nickname is Penelope Pitstop.
523
00:49:31,555 --> 00:49:34,129
It's perfect.
524
00:49:42,930 --> 00:49:46,295
She is known as Penelope Pitstop.
525
00:50:36,471 --> 00:50:39,037
Congress is so beautiful.
526
00:50:39,138 --> 00:50:43,704
It is the most beautiful building
in Bras�lia.
527
00:50:43,805 --> 00:50:47,829
- Is that the Senate?
- The House.
528
00:50:47,930 --> 00:50:50,787
- We were there?
- The Senate is there.
529
00:50:50,888 --> 00:50:56,087
No, those are the offices.
530
00:51:35,763 --> 00:51:40,129
Come, F�tima.
531
00:51:47,430 --> 00:51:51,295
Good evening.
532
00:51:54,638 --> 00:51:58,995
People want
to end this process very quickly...
533
00:51:59,096 --> 00:52:03,870
It seems the clock is ticking.
I don't know what's behind it.
534
00:52:03,971 --> 00:52:10,495
Some might fear new facts
may bring imbalance to the trial.
535
00:52:10,596 --> 00:52:17,162
Can an eventual accusation bring
problems? We don't have that concern.
536
00:52:17,263 --> 00:52:22,537
We want a fair, balanced trial.
Justice Lewandowski will decide the date...
537
00:52:22,638 --> 00:52:26,754
but this cannot be done in haste.
538
00:53:20,471 --> 00:53:22,587
Hi, dear.
I'm Carol Proner.
539
00:53:32,305 --> 00:53:35,704
In France, where I am a senator...
540
00:53:35,805 --> 00:53:40,537
the expression
"institutional coup d'etat"...
541
00:53:40,638 --> 00:53:47,995
when we refer to Brazil,
is also rejected by some politicians...
542
00:53:48,096 --> 00:53:52,037
and what makes me "sadder",
and this is a euphemism...
543
00:53:52,138 --> 00:53:54,870
is the fact that, unfortunately...
544
00:53:54,971 --> 00:53:59,670
the French Government
has not shown its support.
545
00:54:00,471 --> 00:54:05,329
And I must confess that the French press
also finds difficulties...
546
00:54:05,430 --> 00:54:09,745
because there are few
independent media in France...
547
00:54:09,846 --> 00:54:13,912
as here, but I must admit
that the French media today...
548
00:54:14,013 --> 00:54:18,037
I am sorry for that,
is more focused on the Olympics...
549
00:54:18,138 --> 00:54:21,495
and the Government remains silent.
550
00:54:21,596 --> 00:54:23,370
Thank you, madam.
551
00:54:23,471 --> 00:54:27,037
This may come as a surprise,
but recently..
552
00:54:27,138 --> 00:54:36,704
in a conversation with a deputy.
I was struck when told me...
553
00:54:36,805 --> 00:54:41,462
that he thought I was a cold,
calculating, insensitive person.
554
00:54:43,096 --> 00:54:48,537
Because I did not resign
and I'm not sure why.
555
00:54:48,638 --> 00:54:53,037
This version given by the media
has been incorporated.
556
00:54:53,138 --> 00:54:55,829
But the media has another version too.
557
00:54:55,930 --> 00:55:00,795
Which is very common
when it comes to us women.
558
00:55:00,930 --> 00:55:05,537
That I was out of my mind...
559
00:55:05,638 --> 00:55:10,370
taking prescription medicine.
560
00:55:10,471 --> 00:55:15,495
I'm not on meds
and I'm not out of my mind.
561
00:55:15,596 --> 00:55:19,037
So they don't get it right.
562
00:55:19,138 --> 00:55:21,704
The version oscillates.
563
00:55:21,805 --> 00:55:26,995
I am either cold and insensitive
because I don't resign.
564
00:55:27,096 --> 00:55:29,662
I don't cry and
I don't play the victim...
565
00:55:29,763 --> 00:55:32,962
or I'm having a nervous breakdown
566
00:55:35,846 --> 00:55:38,004
Thank you.
567
00:55:42,763 --> 00:55:45,129
Come on, Carol.
568
00:55:46,305 --> 00:55:48,704
Come on, Madam Senator.
569
00:55:48,805 --> 00:55:52,162
The denial of things is typical of coups.
570
00:55:52,263 --> 00:55:59,079
In Brazil, for a long time,
we political prisoners did not exist.
571
00:55:59,180 --> 00:56:04,870
"No. There are no political prisoners
in Brazil." And we were in jail.
572
00:56:04,971 --> 00:56:07,745
That was our struggle.
573
00:56:07,846 --> 00:56:10,629
Yes, so that we could exist.
574
00:56:10,971 --> 00:56:16,370
We are on the right side
and we will win as we did then.
575
00:56:16,471 --> 00:56:20,662
Back then there was no Internet.
It took twenty years.
576
00:56:20,763 --> 00:56:22,962
Now we have the Internet.
577
00:56:25,471 --> 00:56:28,587
Take a picture with my cell phone.
578
00:56:36,596 --> 00:56:38,829
I'm counting on you.
579
00:56:38,930 --> 00:56:41,537
Requi�o, if they don't absolve me...
580
00:56:41,638 --> 00:56:44,004
You'll have to get on board!
581
00:57:15,323 --> 00:57:16,971
June 14th, 2016.
582
00:57:17,072 --> 00:57:23,045
Congressional Ethics Committee
votes to expel House Speaker
583
00:57:23,146 --> 00:57:27,878
Eduardo Cunha from the
Chamber of Deputies.
584
00:57:30,430 --> 00:57:33,412
PT imagines I did this
to get back at them...
585
00:57:33,513 --> 00:57:37,245
as they didn't support me
in the Ethics Committee.
586
00:57:37,346 --> 00:57:42,870
I met the chief of staff three times...
587
00:57:42,971 --> 00:57:49,037
and every time Jaques Wagner
offered the PT votes...
588
00:57:49,138 --> 00:57:53,495
in the Ethics Committee.
He even offered...
589
00:57:53,596 --> 00:57:57,829
to keep my wife and daughter
out of this...
590
00:57:57,930 --> 00:58:01,370
since they were
under a separate investigation.
591
00:58:01,471 --> 00:58:07,204
The Government offered the votes from PT.
I didn't ask.
592
00:58:07,305 --> 00:58:11,870
Not only did it sound like
blackmail, it involved my family.
593
00:58:11,971 --> 00:58:16,079
I didn't think
they had that prerogative.
594
00:58:16,180 --> 00:58:19,412
Why didn't you report it
when it happened...
595
00:58:19,513 --> 00:58:24,870
as should be done by a politician
as righteous as you claim to be?
596
00:58:24,971 --> 00:58:28,662
Because I refused it.
597
00:58:28,763 --> 00:58:33,370
It's part of politics,
of political conversations.
598
00:58:33,471 --> 00:58:37,662
There's a rumor
you could consider a plea bargain...
599
00:58:37,763 --> 00:58:42,704
to decrease your wife's
possible sentence.
600
00:58:42,805 --> 00:58:46,662
I didn't commit any crime,
I have nothing to say.
601
00:58:46,763 --> 00:58:50,662
I have nothing on me
or on anyone else.
602
00:58:50,763 --> 00:58:53,495
I'm from "Correio Brasiliense".
603
00:58:53,596 --> 00:58:56,995
You're a defendant
at the Supreme Court...
604
00:58:57,096 --> 00:59:01,745
in the Car Wash investigations,
accused of taking bribes abroad...
605
00:59:01,846 --> 00:59:05,579
and having secret accounts.
606
00:59:05,680 --> 00:59:10,162
You lied to the investigators.
607
00:59:10,263 --> 00:59:14,329
Do you really think you have political...
608
00:59:14,430 --> 00:59:19,662
ethical and moral authority
to continue as Speaker of the House?
609
00:59:19,763 --> 00:59:22,495
You're making a political speech.
610
00:59:22,596 --> 00:59:26,162
It's a question...
611
00:59:26,263 --> 00:59:28,754
I won't answer. Next.
612
00:59:31,180 --> 00:59:40,662
Vice-President Temer must dirty his hands
to try and save Cunha's neck.
613
00:59:40,763 --> 00:59:44,537
If he's removed from office,
Temer is going down.
614
00:59:44,638 --> 00:59:51,079
Cunha is destructive.
He's concerned with his wife.
615
00:59:51,180 --> 00:59:54,495
He's desperate
about his wife and daughter.
616
00:59:54,596 --> 01:00:02,870
- He will inform on anyone.
- Judge Moro blocked his assets.
617
01:00:02,971 --> 01:00:06,079
- Now?
- Half an hour ago.
618
01:00:06,180 --> 01:00:10,745
In Congress,
the mood is one of expectation.
619
01:00:10,846 --> 01:00:16,920
Nobody knows what will happen.
Even Marina was mentioned today.
620
01:00:19,096 --> 01:00:23,579
And we're not having it easy either.
621
01:00:23,680 --> 01:00:27,254
Not at all!
622
01:00:29,096 --> 01:00:35,829
We only see their misfortunes,
but what about us? What about Lula?
623
01:00:35,930 --> 01:00:39,745
PT's reputation has already
been damaged enough...
624
01:00:39,846 --> 01:00:44,537
even though it can get worse.
They might arrest Lula.
625
01:00:44,638 --> 01:00:48,877
The country's reaction might be strong,
626
01:00:48,978 --> 01:00:53,870
but it can be really
bad if Lula is arrested.
627
01:00:53,971 --> 01:00:58,912
They can try to convict Lula...
628
01:00:59,013 --> 01:01:05,162
to prevent him
from joining the elections.
629
01:01:05,263 --> 01:01:08,337
In all likelihood...
630
01:01:08,471 --> 01:01:14,662
plea bargains will do more harm
to them than to us.
631
01:01:14,763 --> 01:01:17,662
At least we have that.
632
01:01:17,763 --> 01:01:21,495
Cunha's downfall
benefits us a lot more.
633
01:01:21,596 --> 01:01:25,245
There's a good side
to them being targeted.
634
01:01:25,346 --> 01:01:30,995
It shows it's systemic.
635
01:01:31,096 --> 01:01:35,745
The feeling the people might have
in a couple of months is:
636
01:01:35,846 --> 01:01:38,995
"Screw them,
they�re all corrupt!"
637
01:01:39,096 --> 01:01:42,162
It's in the last opinion poll.
638
01:01:42,263 --> 01:01:46,337
Everyone has low ratings,
Lula and others.
639
01:01:46,513 --> 01:01:53,495
We need a political reform.
After all the parties being hit.
640
01:01:53,596 --> 01:01:57,662
The people who took to the streets
in 2013, and still do...
641
01:01:57,763 --> 01:02:01,662
aren't defending our Government...
642
01:02:01,763 --> 01:02:04,995
but opposing another movement...
643
01:02:05,096 --> 01:02:08,912
resisting the establishment,
conservatism.
644
01:02:09,013 --> 01:02:12,662
The youth takes to the street,
but not under our banner.
645
01:02:12,763 --> 01:02:17,495
Some are under Dilma's banner
because it represents something...
646
01:02:17,596 --> 01:02:22,495
represents resistance,
but we have no control.
647
01:02:22,596 --> 01:02:24,745
Just like the women's movement.
648
01:02:24,846 --> 01:02:29,662
Dilma, as much as she represents them,
doesn't lead those women.
649
01:02:29,763 --> 01:02:36,662
Her Government was
too conservative on some things...
650
01:02:36,763 --> 01:02:38,329
which was bad.
651
01:02:38,430 --> 01:02:41,995
We need to understand this movement...
652
01:02:42,096 --> 01:02:46,495
that's been resisting
a conservative offensive.
653
01:02:46,596 --> 01:02:50,995
We shouldn't be separated from it,
fighting only the impeachment.
654
01:02:51,096 --> 01:02:55,537
We can talk about a referendum
that's great...
655
01:02:55,638 --> 01:02:58,829
but this is not their everyday lives.
656
01:02:58,930 --> 01:03:03,245
I agree that a referendum
is the solution.
657
01:03:03,346 --> 01:03:05,495
Speaking candidly here.
658
01:03:05,596 --> 01:03:10,245
There's no governability
if we go back to power.
659
01:03:10,346 --> 01:03:15,995
She doesn't have support here,
no structure in the Government.
660
01:03:16,096 --> 01:03:20,370
We need to speak to the people.
661
01:03:20,471 --> 01:03:24,454
If we're not clear
on what's at stake...
662
01:03:24,555 --> 01:03:30,420
if we don't align ourselves
with civil society, we'll be adrift.
663
01:05:02,138 --> 01:05:06,495
Why did she commit
an impeachable offense?
664
01:05:06,596 --> 01:05:13,120
She has issued additional budget decrees
in conflict with the law...
665
01:05:13,221 --> 01:05:17,162
which authorizes those decrees
under one condition.
666
01:05:17,263 --> 01:05:19,495
the annual budget must be met.
667
01:05:19,596 --> 01:05:25,495
The annual budget was not being met,
and from the second half of the year...
668
01:05:25,596 --> 01:05:29,579
the Government
began to count on a bill...
669
01:05:29,680 --> 01:05:33,662
that was still being processed
by Congress...
670
01:05:33,763 --> 01:05:38,079
and which was only approved
on December 3rd.
671
01:05:38,180 --> 01:05:42,745
And the biggest
fiscal fraud in Brazilian history...
672
01:05:42,846 --> 01:05:50,412
when, using subterfuge, the Government
obtains loans from State Banks
673
01:05:50,513 --> 01:05:55,212
which is forbidden by law.
674
01:06:07,888 --> 01:06:11,370
He replies: "The budget
was approved by such law...
675
01:06:11,471 --> 01:06:18,162
and is Valid for 2015, with no stipulation
for partial use of these values."
676
01:06:18,263 --> 01:06:22,579
They claim it's an impeachable offense...
677
01:06:22,680 --> 01:06:26,329
not due to the annual budget,
but to the decree.
678
01:06:26,430 --> 01:06:28,370
He's wrong.
679
01:06:28,471 --> 01:06:31,662
That's why we need to dismantle it.
680
01:06:31,763 --> 01:06:36,162
It's so easy we can laugh in their faces.
681
01:06:36,263 --> 01:06:39,495
Are you out of your mind?
682
01:06:39,596 --> 01:06:44,495
You're saying she met
the target at the end of the year...
683
01:06:44,596 --> 01:06:47,495
but when she signed the decree...
684
01:06:47,596 --> 01:06:52,162
the target was not being met.
685
01:06:52,263 --> 01:06:55,662
And she could only
have done it through a law.
686
01:06:55,763 --> 01:06:59,037
How can I pass a law
to break another law?
687
01:06:59,138 --> 01:07:06,245
The Budget Office says the target
was met, as does the legal adviser.
688
01:07:06,346 --> 01:07:09,662
The Minister of Planning too.
689
01:07:09,763 --> 01:07:14,329
Besides, the experts say
there was a presumption of legality...
690
01:07:14,430 --> 01:07:17,412
on behalf of the person who acted.
691
01:07:17,513 --> 01:07:22,162
Nobody thought it would be illegal...
692
01:07:22,263 --> 01:07:25,962
since it had been done
for all those years.
693
01:07:26,096 --> 01:07:30,912
I have several documents:
the Federal Budget Office...
694
01:07:31,013 --> 01:07:35,537
stating that the decree was compatible
with the annual budget.
695
01:07:35,638 --> 01:07:39,329
In his reasons,
the Minister of Planning...
696
01:07:39,430 --> 01:07:44,829
also said the decree
was compatible with the budget.
697
01:07:44,930 --> 01:07:50,037
All agencies said it was compatible.
The Minister, the Budget Office,
698
01:07:50,138 --> 01:07:53,462
the legal adviser,
the chief of staff.
699
01:07:53,596 --> 01:07:58,245
I pass the floor
to the Minister of Finance.
700
01:07:58,346 --> 01:08:01,667
These six decrees
signed by the President
701
01:08:01,768 --> 01:08:05,495
at no time authorize the
increase in expenses.
702
01:08:05,596 --> 01:08:09,495
They only modified the alternatives...
703
01:08:09,596 --> 01:08:12,495
on which the same amount
could be spent.
704
01:08:12,596 --> 01:08:16,704
This was established
in the contingency decree.
705
01:08:16,805 --> 01:08:23,412
Most of these funds went
to the Ministry of Education.
706
01:08:23,513 --> 01:08:26,870
For instance,
the Ministry of Education...
707
01:08:26,971 --> 01:08:32,579
requested this financial surplus
to support early childhood education...
708
01:08:32,680 --> 01:08:36,829
as authorized by the Budget Law.
709
01:08:36,930 --> 01:08:44,704
Before the decrees were issued,
the Government had cut expenses sharply.
710
01:08:44,805 --> 01:08:50,162
So we can't say that those decrees
increased expenditures.
711
01:08:50,263 --> 01:08:57,495
On the contrary, those decrees came
after a reduction of R$ 8.5 billion.
712
01:08:57,596 --> 01:09:04,704
They don't conflict the annual budget
because they do not increase expenditure.
713
01:09:04,805 --> 01:09:08,162
Responding to inquiries
by several senators...
714
01:09:08,263 --> 01:09:17,329
it's clear the Government deliberately
used the approval of Bill 5...
715
01:09:17,430 --> 01:09:22,829
which characterizes
a disregard for the Budget Law...
716
01:09:22,930 --> 01:09:28,412
therefore an impeachable offense
since the Government approved a target...
717
01:09:28,513 --> 01:09:32,204
which was still being
processed by Congress...
718
01:09:32,305 --> 01:09:38,745
and was only approved
at the end of the year...
719
01:09:38,846 --> 01:09:42,204
as if to clean
the crime scene.
720
01:09:42,305 --> 01:09:44,162
This is crazy.
721
01:09:44,263 --> 01:09:49,295
This is "The Trial" by Kafka,
President Dilma is Joseph K...
722
01:09:49,430 --> 01:09:51,329
They can't prove anything.
723
01:09:51,430 --> 01:09:56,920
We don't spend one cent more
with these budget decrees!
724
01:11:06,096 --> 01:11:10,995
The Federal Police had arrest
and search warrants in five states.
725
01:11:11,096 --> 01:11:15,162
They also searched the flat
of Senator Gleisi Hoffmann
726
01:11:15,263 --> 01:11:18,495
and her husband,
former Minister Paulo Bernardo.
727
01:11:18,596 --> 01:11:23,162
He was arrested in Bras�lia
and taken to S�o Paulo,
728
01:11:23,263 --> 01:11:27,495
where he will be held
under preventive detention.
729
01:11:27,596 --> 01:11:32,329
According to the investigation,
the law firm linked to Paulo Bernardo
730
01:11:32,430 --> 01:11:35,962
received about R$ 7 million
from the scheme.
731
01:11:40,638 --> 01:11:44,704
What happened to my husband
is inexplicable.
732
01:11:44,805 --> 01:11:49,662
If he was being investigated,
why didn't they call him to testify?
733
01:11:49,763 --> 01:11:53,162
He never refused to do that.
734
01:11:53,263 --> 01:11:57,204
He has always been
living with me in Bras�lia.
735
01:11:57,305 --> 01:12:00,995
They didn't have to spend money
on helicopters, cars...
736
01:12:01,096 --> 01:12:06,162
and police equipment.
They just had to summon him.
737
01:12:06,263 --> 01:12:10,329
If he had to go at that moment,
he would go anyway.
738
01:12:10,430 --> 01:12:14,329
This investigation started
one year ago.
739
01:12:14,430 --> 01:12:21,037
It's not as if his freedom
would jeopardize the investigation.
740
01:12:21,138 --> 01:12:26,329
Nothing justifies
his preventive detention.
741
01:12:26,430 --> 01:12:28,329
I didn't understand.
742
01:12:28,430 --> 01:12:34,129
We never refuse to testify.
743
01:12:48,096 --> 01:12:54,162
Within the Farm Subsidies,
we have a program for family farming...
744
01:12:54,263 --> 01:12:57,662
which has been growing every year.
745
01:12:57,763 --> 01:13:02,995
In 2002,
it was worth about R$ 2 billion.
746
01:13:03,096 --> 01:13:05,954
Since last year, 2015...
747
01:13:06,055 --> 01:13:10,495
this program has received
up to R$ 30 billion.
748
01:13:10,596 --> 01:13:15,162
These are funds
going into family farming.
749
01:13:15,263 --> 01:13:20,662
And there are Farm Subsidies,
investing in corporate farming.
750
01:13:20,763 --> 01:13:25,287
The Government and the President
don't take part.
751
01:13:25,388 --> 01:13:31,120
These funds are transferred
from the Bank of Brazil to the farmers.
752
01:13:31,221 --> 01:13:35,662
It's a loan
with subsidized interest...
753
01:13:35,763 --> 01:13:40,254
because agriculture worldwide
deserves attention.
754
01:13:41,138 --> 01:13:47,204
The accusation states the accounting tricks
were not just operational delays...
755
01:13:47,305 --> 01:13:50,829
as the debts accumulated for a long time...
756
01:13:50,930 --> 01:13:53,662
and became very large sums.
757
01:13:53,763 --> 01:13:59,870
They were true loan transactions
prohibited by the Fiscal Law.
758
01:13:59,971 --> 01:14:05,495
The defense argues that the delays
cannot be considered loans...
759
01:14:05,596 --> 01:14:10,537
because the money is lent to farmers,
not to the Government.
760
01:14:10,638 --> 01:14:17,162
I consider it burdensome
that the President...
761
01:14:17,263 --> 01:14:23,829
was aware of the irregularities
that were being practiced.
762
01:14:23,930 --> 01:14:27,995
If I delay paying
my family's supermarket bill...
763
01:14:28,096 --> 01:14:32,787
they're not lending me money.
There's no loan contract.
764
01:14:32,888 --> 01:14:37,537
No money was transferred
from the bank to the Treasury.
765
01:14:37,638 --> 01:14:41,329
The bank shifts
the resource to the farmer...
766
01:14:41,430 --> 01:14:45,370
and the Treasury shifts
the subsidy to the banks.
767
01:14:45,471 --> 01:14:49,454
What is a loan?
What farmers do with the bank:
768
01:14:49,555 --> 01:14:53,329
they sign a contract,
borrow money and grow their crop.
769
01:14:53,430 --> 01:15:00,629
Agriculture could be at risk if
we were to regard farm subsidies as loans.
770
01:15:03,221 --> 01:15:07,454
Many people asked me
if I would come back here...
771
01:15:07,555 --> 01:15:11,754
after my husband's arrest,
and I said I would.
772
01:15:12,055 --> 01:15:18,495
I return with my head held high
to defend President Dilma's mandate.
773
01:15:18,596 --> 01:15:21,787
And I'm pleased
with the examination...
774
01:15:21,888 --> 01:15:27,662
regarding the so-called
Bank of Brazil accounting tricks.
775
01:15:27,763 --> 01:15:32,162
Item seven states
that the Ministry of Finance...
776
01:15:32,263 --> 01:15:38,495
doesn't define a deadline for payment
to be made to the Bank of Brazil.
777
01:15:38,596 --> 01:15:41,662
If there's no deadline
there's no delay.
778
01:15:41,763 --> 01:15:47,954
And item 12 states
that nothing the president has done...
779
01:15:48,055 --> 01:15:53,995
contributed directly or indirectly
to the delays.
780
01:15:54,096 --> 01:15:57,662
If there's no action,
there's no criminal intent.
781
01:15:57,763 --> 01:16:01,829
I'd like to ask
if the Ministry of Agriculture...
782
01:16:01,930 --> 01:16:05,870
was warned by the Bank of Brazil,
the Court of Auditors...
783
01:16:05,971 --> 01:16:10,329
or any other supervisory agency
about the defaulting...
784
01:16:10,430 --> 01:16:14,662
on the interests
of these subsidies.
785
01:16:14,763 --> 01:16:20,587
Mr. Patrus Ananias has the floor
as witness. Three minutes.
786
01:16:21,263 --> 01:16:23,495
Excuse me, please.
787
01:16:23,596 --> 01:16:26,162
Later you'll be given more time.
788
01:16:26,263 --> 01:16:29,037
I have to defend my honor.
789
01:16:29,138 --> 01:16:34,329
Your Excellency mentioned me
after the committee on Friday.
790
01:16:34,430 --> 01:16:37,537
When I left here,
journalists asked me...
791
01:16:37,638 --> 01:16:40,662
- You're talking about me?
- Yes.
792
01:16:40,763 --> 01:16:44,829
- But...
- It was Your Excellency.
793
01:16:44,930 --> 01:16:51,329
You were with me all morning
and didn't bring it up.
794
01:16:51,430 --> 01:16:56,329
I didn't know what was being said
about me around the Senate.
795
01:16:56,430 --> 01:17:01,037
A journalist asked me, "What do
you think about the accusation?"
796
01:17:01,138 --> 01:17:02,704
"What accusation?"
797
01:17:02,805 --> 01:17:09,287
"Senator Lindbergh stated that
the judge who ordered the arrest...
798
01:17:09,388 --> 01:17:15,454
of Senator Gleisi's husband
is being supervised by you."
799
01:17:15,555 --> 01:17:21,329
Is it a crime to be a student
or to be a supervisor?
800
01:17:21,430 --> 01:17:25,620
The entire weekend
was full of inferences...
801
01:17:25,721 --> 01:17:30,454
corroborated by Senator Gleisi
today at the plenary...
802
01:17:30,555 --> 01:17:33,662
implying I might be involved...
803
01:17:33,763 --> 01:17:37,662
- Wrap it up.
- This is serious.
804
01:17:37,763 --> 01:17:40,329
This is very important.
805
01:17:40,430 --> 01:17:44,454
I have to defend my honor and the judge's.
806
01:17:44,555 --> 01:17:48,162
She's not here to defend her honor.
807
01:17:48,263 --> 01:17:51,620
Not here.
808
01:17:51,721 --> 01:17:55,162
You can't infer anything about my honor.
809
01:17:55,263 --> 01:17:59,495
- And you can infer what you want?
- No, listen...
810
01:17:59,596 --> 01:18:03,495
Dr. Jana�na has the floor,
but she should conclude.
811
01:18:03,596 --> 01:18:05,704
I'll be quick.
812
01:18:05,805 --> 01:18:10,662
People judge each other
by their own rules.
813
01:18:10,763 --> 01:18:16,829
The members of PT
have vassals, not students.
814
01:18:16,930 --> 01:18:24,329
They think other professors
also demand that people kneel!
815
01:18:24,430 --> 01:18:29,162
My students are judges,
prosecutors, researchers...
816
01:18:29,263 --> 01:18:32,037
of all ideological orientations.
817
01:18:32,138 --> 01:18:37,829
They never subjected themselves to me,
they answer to me in their research.
818
01:18:37,930 --> 01:18:42,162
My role is to teach people
to have an open mind...
819
01:18:42,263 --> 01:18:46,329
that's why I even supervise
people who support PT.
820
01:18:46,430 --> 01:18:49,454
But you're judging me
by your own rules.
821
01:18:49,555 --> 01:18:54,287
- Conclude.
- You want them to be your vassals!
822
01:18:54,388 --> 01:18:59,329
Senator Lindbergh has two minutes
to reply since he was mentioned.
823
01:18:59,430 --> 01:19:04,162
It's funny,
that lawyer infers everything she can.
824
01:19:04,263 --> 01:19:09,329
She's always accusing without proof!
She infers everything she can!
825
01:19:09,430 --> 01:19:15,287
What I said was true.
She is the judge's supervisor!
826
01:19:15,388 --> 01:19:17,287
"Don't mess with her."
827
01:19:17,388 --> 01:19:21,329
Madam, you're not here for idealism.
828
01:19:21,430 --> 01:19:24,870
You came to this trial for R$ 45 thousand.
829
01:19:24,971 --> 01:19:27,995
For R$45 thousand!
830
01:19:28,096 --> 01:19:30,537
She was hired by PSDB Party!
831
01:19:30,638 --> 01:19:35,829
Now she's an idealist! Don't give me that!
832
01:19:35,930 --> 01:19:40,829
I told the truth.
He was supervised by her!
833
01:19:40,930 --> 01:19:43,995
She should restrain herself.
834
01:19:44,096 --> 01:19:48,287
As if she didn't know
what impeachable offenses are.
835
01:19:48,388 --> 01:19:52,037
She's always making political speeches!
836
01:19:52,138 --> 01:19:56,329
I can see you running for office
in the next elections.
837
01:19:56,430 --> 01:20:01,829
Don't pretend you're an idealist.
You came for R$ 45 thousand!
838
01:20:01,930 --> 01:20:05,829
Mr. President, no personal attacks!
839
01:20:05,930 --> 01:20:08,995
Mr. Patrus Ananias has the floor.
840
01:20:09,096 --> 01:20:13,629
Mr. President, excuse me.
841
01:21:07,305 --> 01:21:10,662
I found some pictures
842
01:21:10,763 --> 01:21:13,829
This is the march against abortion.
843
01:21:13,930 --> 01:21:16,704
He's fifth
in the Pope's line of succession.
844
01:21:16,805 --> 01:21:20,204
The Spiritualists and Catholics
are more active than us.
845
01:21:20,305 --> 01:21:22,995
- Really?
- More than the Evangelicals.
846
01:21:23,096 --> 01:21:24,537
I didn't know.
847
01:21:24,638 --> 01:21:28,537
Catholics actively raise this flag...
848
01:21:28,638 --> 01:21:31,829
But there are pro-abortion Catholics.
849
01:21:31,930 --> 01:21:34,537
Some groups within Catholicism.
850
01:21:34,638 --> 01:21:36,495
And they're united.
851
01:21:36,596 --> 01:21:43,329
But some Catholics are against it.
There are many groups.
852
01:21:43,430 --> 01:21:47,704
She's the president of the
Evangelical Singers' Federation.
853
01:21:47,805 --> 01:21:50,295
Wow, congratulations!
854
01:21:50,430 --> 01:21:54,537
Those doctors who perform abortions...
855
01:21:54,638 --> 01:21:58,662
reach a point in their lives
when they get depressed.
856
01:21:58,763 --> 01:22:03,870
There's a case in Mato Grosso,
and I can show it to you later...
857
01:22:03,971 --> 01:22:07,954
of a doctor who performed
many abortions.
858
01:22:08,055 --> 01:22:12,037
She couldn't take it anymore
and killed herself.
859
01:22:12,138 --> 01:22:14,420
That's so sad.
860
01:22:14,763 --> 01:22:20,995
She was a woman and a mother
and you're a mother too.
861
01:22:21,096 --> 01:22:28,462
Spilling the blood of innocents
has spiritual consequences.
862
01:22:29,263 --> 01:22:32,287
Even though they say
it's natural.
863
01:22:32,388 --> 01:22:37,829
They say it's normal, but
we know there's no pact for that.
864
01:22:37,930 --> 01:22:40,370
That's true, that's true.
865
01:22:40,471 --> 01:22:44,829
- I'm your ally.
- Amen, go with God.
866
01:22:44,930 --> 01:22:47,870
Thank you, you're just great.
867
01:22:47,971 --> 01:22:51,670
- You won't forget us.
- Never.
868
01:22:52,721 --> 01:22:58,004
- Thank you
- Thanks. See you later.
869
01:23:11,263 --> 01:23:13,587
Hi, sweetie, how are you?
870
01:23:14,388 --> 01:23:15,920
Sure.
871
01:23:20,430 --> 01:23:21,920
Why?
872
01:23:28,721 --> 01:23:30,129
Right.
873
01:23:31,430 --> 01:23:35,420
No way. It's not a problem at all.
874
01:23:38,763 --> 01:23:40,920
She did.
875
01:23:41,930 --> 01:23:48,087
None of them question her guilt,
be it for not speaking or not supervising.
876
01:23:49,263 --> 01:23:51,204
That's the point.
877
01:23:51,305 --> 01:23:56,587
She blames you so
she could be absolved.
878
01:23:59,305 --> 01:24:01,704
But don't worry about that.
879
01:24:01,805 --> 01:24:05,620
Stick to that strategy.
It's great.
880
01:24:05,721 --> 01:24:08,587
No problem, kisses.
881
01:24:13,763 --> 01:24:15,787
The committee will start.
882
01:24:15,888 --> 01:24:18,295
Shall we go back to hell?
883
01:24:20,721 --> 01:24:23,920
- Let's do it.
- Let's go.
884
01:24:25,596 --> 01:24:28,129
Nothing better to do.
885
01:24:29,263 --> 01:24:32,254
This is why we're here.
886
01:24:37,512 --> 01:24:44,911
August 2nd, 2016.
Senator Anastasia reads his final report.
887
01:24:47,596 --> 01:24:51,454
We reiterate the admissibility report.
888
01:24:51,555 --> 01:24:57,829
We are not contrasting the President's
mandate, nor her abysmal unpopularity...
889
01:24:57,930 --> 01:25:01,954
that spreads through all kinds
of social networks...
890
01:25:02,055 --> 01:25:05,954
with eventual audio recordings
and plea bargains,
891
01:25:06,055 --> 01:25:10,662
or with any conduct unrelated
to her presidential duty.
892
01:25:10,763 --> 01:25:17,579
I vote in favor of the accusation
declaring Dilma Rousseff guilty...
893
01:25:17,680 --> 01:25:22,829
of issuing additional budget
decrees without Congress authorization...
894
01:25:22,930 --> 01:25:26,745
and performing loan transactions
with state banks...
895
01:25:26,846 --> 01:25:31,008
leading her to be tried
by the Federal Senate
896
01:25:31,109 --> 01:25:34,420
as determined by the Constitution.
897
01:25:35,096 --> 01:25:37,787
Anastasia...
898
01:25:37,888 --> 01:25:42,120
has used many accounting tricks!
899
01:25:42,221 --> 01:25:45,579
To fight corruption...
900
01:25:45,680 --> 01:25:49,162
is to fight the corrupt!
901
01:25:49,263 --> 01:25:52,162
And one of the most corrupt...
902
01:25:52,263 --> 01:25:56,995
is the current rapporteur...
903
01:25:57,096 --> 01:26:01,995
of the Senate Impeachment committee!
904
01:26:02,096 --> 01:26:05,454
There won't be a coup.
We will fight!
905
01:26:05,555 --> 01:26:08,912
There won't be a coup.
We will fight!
906
01:26:09,013 --> 01:26:15,212
No violence!
907
01:26:18,355 --> 01:26:23,087
HONK PT OUT
908
01:26:24,513 --> 01:26:28,712
Goodbye, darling!
909
01:26:37,096 --> 01:26:43,004
DILMA OUT
910
01:27:21,096 --> 01:27:24,212
- Do you have any paper?
- Sure.
911
01:27:28,055 --> 01:27:32,954
We can gather up what we have now.
I'll read it at home.
912
01:27:33,055 --> 01:27:37,995
If someone has a brilliant idea,
even in the middle of the night...
913
01:27:38,096 --> 01:27:40,920
about what we should say,
call me.
914
01:27:45,721 --> 01:27:49,587
Look at this piece of paper!
915
01:27:50,346 --> 01:27:52,829
It's a disrespect!
916
01:27:52,930 --> 01:27:56,829
Let's raise bullet points.
I need emblematic mistakes.
917
01:27:56,930 --> 01:27:58,829
To discredit the report.
918
01:27:58,930 --> 01:28:03,162
- Like you did with Arantes.
- That's it.
919
01:28:03,263 --> 01:28:07,829
There's no point in hammering on
what people don't understand.
920
01:28:07,930 --> 01:28:11,287
I need to be straightforward.
921
01:28:11,388 --> 01:28:15,495
But these are the divergences.
922
01:28:15,596 --> 01:28:17,620
But what is the legal basis?
923
01:28:17,721 --> 01:28:21,954
He says we're taking
power away from Congress...
924
01:28:22,055 --> 01:28:25,120
but it doesn't make sense...
925
01:28:25,221 --> 01:28:32,120
since Article 4 allows
the executive to do so.
926
01:28:32,221 --> 01:28:39,087
He distorts the argument that we ignore the
annual budget because it's a neutral decree.
927
01:28:45,721 --> 01:28:48,912
Pay attention to this part, Gabriel.
928
01:28:49,013 --> 01:28:52,787
You're going to e-mail it to me,
but print it too.
929
01:28:52,888 --> 01:28:55,120
For tomorrow. Is it at 9 am?
930
01:28:55,221 --> 01:29:01,120
At 11 am. So print it.
We'll meet early to prepare it.
931
01:29:01,221 --> 01:29:04,995
Let's go over
the accounting tricks.
932
01:29:05,096 --> 01:29:12,329
I didn't read it. I'll go home to read it,
and you send it to me tonight.
933
01:29:12,430 --> 01:29:17,329
Don't you want to go over
the annual budget?
934
01:29:17,430 --> 01:29:19,620
No, that's his creation.
935
01:29:19,721 --> 01:29:23,329
He mentions
a "theory of the bank teller."
936
01:29:23,430 --> 01:29:25,995
And he's like
Plato's theory of ideas.
937
01:29:26,096 --> 01:29:31,079
He creates a fantasy
to talk about the annual budget.
938
01:29:31,180 --> 01:29:36,620
The annual budget
is not in the plane of ideas.
939
01:29:36,721 --> 01:29:44,454
The form matters little to the world,
just how much was spent.
940
01:29:44,555 --> 01:29:46,879
God bless you, kids.
941
01:29:51,721 --> 01:29:53,129
Bye.
942
01:29:55,721 --> 01:29:59,795
Personally,
I had great expectations
943
01:30:00,430 --> 01:30:04,712
regarding Senator Anastasia's report.
944
01:30:05,346 --> 01:30:08,454
For one simple reason.
I know the Senator.
945
01:30:08,555 --> 01:30:13,162
He's a righteous man,
a scholar of law.
946
01:30:13,263 --> 01:30:16,620
Due to the evidence
and what had been proven...
947
01:30:16,721 --> 01:30:21,920
by the examination, witnesses
and documents, I had expectations.
948
01:30:22,346 --> 01:30:27,662
Would he manage to free himself
of his party passion
949
01:30:27,763 --> 01:30:31,079
and look at the evidence?
950
01:30:31,180 --> 01:30:33,045
Look at the law?
951
01:30:33,430 --> 01:30:36,920
Would he be able
to use all his potential...
952
01:30:37,096 --> 01:30:44,295
to seek the truth
instead of following passion?
953
01:30:45,596 --> 01:30:52,087
With all due respect,
the rapporteur did not achieve that.
954
01:30:52,430 --> 01:30:57,712
He achieved his usual brilliance
in defending his party's thesis.
955
01:30:58,721 --> 01:31:04,620
But he was not able to grasp
the truth of the files.
956
01:31:04,721 --> 01:31:09,745
And influenced by his passion,
not with malice or intent..
957
01:31:09,846 --> 01:31:14,420
he made concessions
to the evidence gathered herein.
958
01:31:15,096 --> 01:31:20,829
You say that our system should be
called "The Bank-Teller Empire".
959
01:31:20,930 --> 01:31:23,868
The budget cannot be
spent because it is
960
01:31:23,969 --> 01:31:27,495
provisioned and requires
a compatibility target.
961
01:31:27,596 --> 01:31:30,829
That reminds me
of Plato's "Theory of Ideas".
962
01:31:30,930 --> 01:31:35,287
In your report, ideas conquer reality.
963
01:31:35,388 --> 01:31:40,420
What matters to the target
is not the ideal.
964
01:31:40,930 --> 01:31:44,754
What matters to the target
is how much is spent.
965
01:31:44,888 --> 01:31:48,243
If we are working in the
"Bank-Teller Empire",
966
01:31:48,344 --> 01:31:50,954
you work in the "Empire of Ideas".
967
01:31:51,055 --> 01:31:53,745
Where form prevails over substance.
968
01:31:53,846 --> 01:31:57,329
Where the annual budget leads
to a President's Impeachment...
969
01:31:57,430 --> 01:32:00,995
even if no extra cent
was spent via decrees...
970
01:32:01,096 --> 01:32:03,829
according to the expert's table...
971
01:32:03,930 --> 01:32:09,295
not the one
you wrongfully indicated in the report.
972
01:32:10,346 --> 01:32:15,120
Regarding the accounting tricks,
and I don't have time to comment...
973
01:32:15,221 --> 01:32:18,745
you assume it is a loan transaction.
974
01:32:18,846 --> 01:32:23,495
You didn't repeal my closing arguments,
and you forgot the main thing.
975
01:32:23,596 --> 01:32:30,120
How does something not a loan transaction
become one by default? Is it dialectical?
976
01:32:30,221 --> 01:32:35,912
Not even Hegel and Marx could explain how
one legal relation can turn into another.
977
01:32:36,013 --> 01:32:38,401
Default begets a loan transaction.
978
01:32:38,502 --> 01:32:41,662
You say it doesn't happen
in all instances...
979
01:32:41,763 --> 01:32:48,912
only between a state bank
and the public administration.
980
01:32:49,013 --> 01:32:52,954
It is an odd case when
a legal mutation takes place...
981
01:32:53,055 --> 01:32:57,120
outside of what is natural
in the legal world.
982
01:32:57,221 --> 01:33:00,495
An innovative argument.
And I respect those.
983
01:33:00,596 --> 01:33:04,079
But I can't accept criminalization
of those who differ.
984
01:33:04,180 --> 01:33:07,704
That's authoritarian.
Especially when it's retroactive.
985
01:33:07,805 --> 01:33:13,379
It never existed before
and the evidence is very clear.
986
01:33:14,096 --> 01:33:18,287
Your Excellency states something
that astounds me.
987
01:33:18,388 --> 01:33:21,745
"The President acted negligently."
988
01:33:21,846 --> 01:33:25,329
But the law says, that
the management is not hers.
989
01:33:25,430 --> 01:33:32,212
You say she was negligent for it's
her duty to uphold all financial laws.
990
01:33:32,555 --> 01:33:36,495
The President must uphold
all financial laws?
991
01:33:36,596 --> 01:33:38,579
Then you say:
992
01:33:38,680 --> 01:33:42,245
"A mother who kills a child
can do so directly...
993
01:33:42,346 --> 01:33:46,412
or can kill it by letting
the child starve to death."
994
01:33:46,513 --> 01:33:50,079
If the mother does not have custody...
995
01:33:50,180 --> 01:33:54,162
if the mother was away,
if she put the kid in day-care...
996
01:33:54,263 --> 01:33:56,329
the murder is not hers.
997
01:33:56,430 --> 01:34:01,787
I'd like to commend Senator Anastasia.
He is a brilliant, intelligent man.
998
01:34:01,888 --> 01:34:06,579
It's a shame that this time
his passion did not allow him...
999
01:34:06,680 --> 01:34:11,045
to seek justice, truth and democracy.
1000
01:34:21,539 --> 01:34:23,659
August 4th, 2016.
1001
01:34:23,760 --> 01:34:34,311
Vote on the final report, one day before
the opening of the Rio Olympic Games 2016.
1002
01:34:37,055 --> 01:34:42,412
This crisis has led to over
12 million being unemployed in Brazil.
1003
01:34:42,513 --> 01:34:46,454
Not only did it offend against financial
and budget laws...
1004
01:34:46,555 --> 01:34:50,579
but also against
the principle of good administration...
1005
01:34:50,680 --> 01:34:55,662
by using intent, malice
and fraud to govern.
1006
01:34:55,763 --> 01:35:01,287
That's why I can say I am very sure
of what I'm doing...
1007
01:35:01,388 --> 01:35:04,329
and of what is best for Brazil.
1008
01:35:04,430 --> 01:35:09,954
That's why I'll vote "yes"
to the report...
1009
01:35:10,055 --> 01:35:15,920
on Senator Anastasia,
which is as clear as day.
1010
01:35:16,930 --> 01:35:23,412
My vote is "no". Against this coup
and this fraudulent report.
1011
01:35:23,513 --> 01:35:27,745
And I shall repeat ten times.
It's a fraud!
1012
01:35:27,846 --> 01:35:30,620
I determine, as per my usual rulings...
1013
01:35:30,721 --> 01:35:35,579
the suppression of the expression
fraudulent report".
1014
01:35:35,680 --> 01:35:37,162
Why?
1015
01:35:37,263 --> 01:35:40,495
The opinion of each Senator is free.
1016
01:35:40,596 --> 01:35:44,620
We can't accept,
under any circumstances...
1017
01:35:44,721 --> 01:35:50,995
that Senator Anastasia's work
be called fraudulent.
1018
01:35:51,096 --> 01:35:54,287
But that's our opinion!
1019
01:35:54,388 --> 01:35:57,579
You can't censor our opinion.
1020
01:35:57,680 --> 01:36:00,162
I want it to be recorded for history!
1021
01:36:00,263 --> 01:36:05,579
When PT was called a gang,
I had it stricken.
1022
01:36:05,680 --> 01:36:11,995
When they said PT should all
be in jail, I had it stricken!
1023
01:36:12,096 --> 01:36:16,495
That's not censorship,
that's balance.
1024
01:36:16,596 --> 01:36:21,412
Yesterday a Senator called PT
a criminal organization...
1025
01:36:21,513 --> 01:36:24,495
and you didn't have it stricken.
1026
01:36:24,596 --> 01:36:29,412
Maybe a word slipped by
or I didn't see it...
1027
01:36:29,513 --> 01:36:33,287
because I've been
talking to senators...
1028
01:36:33,388 --> 01:36:36,995
and I eventually need
to use the restroom.
1029
01:36:37,096 --> 01:36:41,829
Something may have gone unnoticed.
1030
01:36:41,930 --> 01:36:45,329
A word for a question of order.
1031
01:36:45,430 --> 01:36:52,162
No questions of order now!
1032
01:36:52,263 --> 01:36:55,837
The results are:
1033
01:36:56,055 --> 01:36:59,537
Yes, 14.
1034
01:36:59,638 --> 01:37:01,162
No, 5.
1035
01:37:01,263 --> 01:37:07,795
Senator Anastasia's report is approved
and is now this committee�s opinion.
1036
01:37:25,263 --> 01:37:27,579
We have 673 pages now.
1037
01:37:27,680 --> 01:37:29,120
673?
1038
01:37:29,221 --> 01:37:33,162
Keep it with you because
if anything bad happens...
1039
01:37:33,263 --> 01:37:36,004
we'll file this one.
1040
01:37:50,055 --> 01:37:51,920
Let's go, Gabriel.
1041
01:38:35,430 --> 01:38:37,254
Just press here.
1042
01:38:44,263 --> 01:38:45,879
Another one.
1043
01:38:48,430 --> 01:38:51,254
Eventually you'll take it, right?
1044
01:38:52,096 --> 01:38:54,087
Dear God.
1045
01:38:55,721 --> 01:38:57,754
You got it?
1046
01:39:03,346 --> 01:39:05,545
Another one.
Got it?
1047
01:39:33,221 --> 01:39:39,045
We know it is difficult,
but we must fight till the end.
1048
01:39:39,763 --> 01:39:45,087
I believe in a positive surprise
to defeat the coup.
1049
01:39:46,388 --> 01:39:49,620
I truly believe that.
We can't give up.
1050
01:39:49,721 --> 01:39:53,045
When you stop believing,
we are doomed!
1051
01:39:57,346 --> 01:40:01,987
Not believing in the fight
means accepting defeat.
1052
01:40:02,088 --> 01:40:05,262
This is a very important
battlefront for us. Very important.
1053
01:40:05,363 --> 01:40:11,454
We need to report what's happening
with democracy the social setbacks...
1054
01:40:11,555 --> 01:40:15,954
what this scenario that led us
to impeachment meant...
1055
01:40:16,055 --> 01:40:20,329
the deconstruction of PT,
Lula and Dilma.
1056
01:40:20,430 --> 01:40:22,787
It was a big deal!
1057
01:40:22,888 --> 01:40:28,454
Of course it is upsetting to realize
some people are against us.
1058
01:40:28,555 --> 01:40:32,829
But it was systematic.
The TV went into people's homes...
1059
01:40:32,930 --> 01:40:39,120
to say we're no good, PT is no good
and that we weren't in a position to govern.
1060
01:40:39,221 --> 01:40:43,545
We allowed it to happen.
It made up people's minds.
1061
01:40:44,388 --> 01:40:48,912
70 years ago, Get�lio Vargas had
the clarity of mind we never had.
1062
01:40:49,013 --> 01:40:52,245
Get a guy and have him start
a newspaper...
1063
01:40:52,346 --> 01:40:58,579
and make it vibrant
and a weapon of the people.
1064
01:40:58,680 --> 01:41:04,579
We chose to line
their pockets with money...
1065
01:41:04,680 --> 01:41:07,662
and fill them with public concessions.
1066
01:41:07,763 --> 01:41:11,620
We had the Secretariat and
Ministry of Communication.
1067
01:41:11,721 --> 01:41:17,495
So we were handing out
many radio and TV licenses...
1068
01:41:17,596 --> 01:41:21,287
and giving the big media
a lot of money.
1069
01:41:21,388 --> 01:41:24,162
I'm not sure I ever told you this...
1070
01:41:24,263 --> 01:41:29,162
but Lula's Government shut down
the most community radio stations.
1071
01:41:29,263 --> 01:41:31,454
Then it becomes difficult.
1072
01:41:31,555 --> 01:41:35,120
It is hard to communicate
with the people...
1073
01:41:35,221 --> 01:41:39,954
unless it's election time
or through the President's charisma.
1074
01:41:40,055 --> 01:41:44,162
If we do fall, it will be mostly
because of what we got right.
1075
01:41:44,263 --> 01:41:50,162
Because we went against
the interests of big money.
1076
01:41:50,263 --> 01:41:54,329
However, it's undeniable
1077
01:41:54,430 --> 01:41:59,120
that we made their path easier
with our own grave mistakes.
1078
01:41:59,221 --> 01:42:03,620
You have no idea how hard it was
to get a PT minister...
1079
01:42:03,721 --> 01:42:06,120
to receive the social movements
1080
01:42:06,221 --> 01:42:10,995
It was as if they
would only get in our way.
1081
01:42:11,096 --> 01:42:18,995
Almost a pleasure to say no to our own
and a sad submission to the powerful.
1082
01:42:19,096 --> 01:42:22,162
That needs to be
thoroughly addressed.
1083
01:42:22,263 --> 01:42:27,162
Not to mention the acceptance
of methods of doing politics...
1084
01:42:27,263 --> 01:42:32,662
which we assimilated
strongly and uncritically...
1085
01:42:32,763 --> 01:42:36,120
and didn't lead us
to political reform...
1086
01:42:36,221 --> 01:42:42,495
even after the scandal that put
several of our comrades in jail.
1087
01:42:42,596 --> 01:42:47,329
All of this is part of a process
that is not self-flagellation...
1088
01:42:47,430 --> 01:42:52,337
but it's about having the clarity
to break with our mistakes.
1089
01:42:56,627 --> 01:43:03,977
August 29th, 2016.
President Dilma testifies.
1090
01:45:33,930 --> 01:45:40,662
We will now commence the testimony...
1091
01:45:40,763 --> 01:45:45,329
of President Dilma Vana Rousseff...
1092
01:45:45,430 --> 01:45:52,787
whom I greet for coming
to this illustrious plenary...
1093
01:45:52,888 --> 01:45:57,120
to present her explanations
regarding the facts...
1094
01:45:57,221 --> 01:46:01,587
the accusation against her.
1095
01:46:02,388 --> 01:46:07,579
The natural judges, the senators...
1096
01:46:07,680 --> 01:46:13,162
will formulate
their questions objectively...
1097
01:46:13,263 --> 01:46:17,287
soberly, impartially...
1098
01:46:17,388 --> 01:46:23,329
and restricted to the accusations...
1099
01:46:23,430 --> 01:46:27,495
in the prosecutor's opening statement.
1100
01:46:27,596 --> 01:46:31,954
I give the floor to the illustrious
Senator Simone Tebet.
1101
01:46:32,055 --> 01:46:37,579
The decrees and accounting tricks
weren't simple accounting operations...
1102
01:46:37,680 --> 01:46:40,120
but part of a fiscal strategy...
1103
01:46:40,221 --> 01:46:43,662
to artificially boost the primary result...
1104
01:46:43,763 --> 01:46:46,620
and spend resources
you didn't have...
1105
01:46:46,721 --> 01:46:50,162
illegally borrowing
from state banks.
1106
01:46:50,263 --> 01:46:54,829
If Your Excellency
returns to the Presidency...
1107
01:46:54,930 --> 01:47:00,162
what wild you do
to block this fiscal-hole...
1108
01:47:00,263 --> 01:47:04,120
and win back the trust
of the Brazilian people?
1109
01:47:04,221 --> 01:47:06,620
Regarding the state banks...
1110
01:47:06,721 --> 01:47:09,912
it's impossible to see it like that.
1111
01:47:10,013 --> 01:47:13,412
You're criminalizing
the fiscal policies.
1112
01:47:13,513 --> 01:47:17,287
Why do I say that?
1113
01:47:17,388 --> 01:47:22,954
Because it wasn't Brazil
that went through a crisis.
1114
01:47:23,055 --> 01:47:29,995
You claim we've been
covering up this crisis since 2009.
1115
01:47:30,096 --> 01:47:35,579
No, Senator, since 2009
we started to face...
1116
01:47:35,680 --> 01:47:40,912
the world's greatest
crisis since 1929.
1117
01:47:41,013 --> 01:47:44,162
It started in the developed countries...
1118
01:47:44,263 --> 01:47:47,829
when Lehman Brothers collapsed.
1119
01:47:47,930 --> 01:47:51,287
I should remind you
that in 2011, 2012, 2013...
1120
01:47:51,388 --> 01:47:54,829
there was the Euro-Zone crisis.
1121
01:47:54,930 --> 01:47:59,079
We didn't make the crisis up...
1122
01:47:59,180 --> 01:48:04,620
but it hit us hard.
1123
01:48:04,721 --> 01:48:08,995
Unfortunately, as of October 2014...
1124
01:48:09,096 --> 01:48:15,829
the super-cycle
of the commodities ended.
1125
01:48:15,930 --> 01:48:22,787
The United States ended
its credit expansion policy...
1126
01:48:22,888 --> 01:48:26,995
three days after the second round
of the elections.
1127
01:48:27,096 --> 01:48:32,287
It created tremors that reached
every currency in the world...
1128
01:48:32,388 --> 01:48:37,162
and they plummeted.
The foreign exchange crashed.
1129
01:48:37,263 --> 01:48:43,454
We had one of the largest energy crises
in Brazil due to a water shortage.
1130
01:48:43,555 --> 01:48:48,412
Senator, I'm sorry, but to say
the country's fiscal crisis...
1131
01:48:48,513 --> 01:48:53,620
is due to three decrees...
1132
01:48:53,721 --> 01:48:58,329
and a subsidy operation...
1133
01:48:58,430 --> 01:49:03,245
not a loan transaction,
from Bank of Brazil to fawners...
1134
01:49:03,346 --> 01:49:06,620
is to reverse causality completely!
1135
01:49:06,721 --> 01:49:10,162
I don't know
what our world would be like...
1136
01:49:10,263 --> 01:49:16,829
if these were the reasons
for such a major crisis!
1137
01:49:16,930 --> 01:49:21,829
I have the honor to invite
Senator A�cio Neves...
1138
01:49:21,930 --> 01:49:26,662
to address his questions
to the President.
1139
01:49:26,763 --> 01:49:31,495
First, it's not dishonorable
to lose the elections...
1140
01:49:31,596 --> 01:49:36,079
especially when defending ideas
and complying with the law.
1141
01:49:36,180 --> 01:49:40,287
I wouldn't say the same
about winning elections...
1142
01:49:40,388 --> 01:49:43,995
with no truth
and perpetrating illegalities.
1143
01:49:44,096 --> 01:49:48,787
I see that you permanently
resorts to your votes...
1144
01:49:48,888 --> 01:49:52,329
as justification for all your actions.
1145
01:49:52,430 --> 01:49:57,045
The vote, we all know,
is not a safe-conduct.
1146
01:49:59,013 --> 01:50:03,212
This impeachment
wasn't born in Congress.
1147
01:50:03,596 --> 01:50:07,954
This impeachment was born
on the streets of Brazil.
1148
01:50:08,055 --> 01:50:12,620
So I salute the representation
of the Brazilian people...
1149
01:50:12,721 --> 01:50:16,495
made up of young, fearless...
1150
01:50:16,596 --> 01:50:20,412
selfless, non-partisan men and women.
1151
01:50:20,513 --> 01:50:25,162
They took to the streets
to show their indignation.
1152
01:50:25,263 --> 01:50:30,620
A coup is to win an election
lying to a country.
1153
01:50:30,721 --> 01:50:36,912
I disagree
that this impeachment process...
1154
01:50:37,013 --> 01:50:40,287
was spontaneous, from the streets.
1155
01:50:40,388 --> 01:50:45,287
None of us in here
is so naive not to know...
1156
01:50:45,388 --> 01:50:50,495
who is responsible for admitting
this impeachment accusation.
1157
01:50:50,596 --> 01:50:54,454
The admission
of the request for my impeachment...
1158
01:50:54,555 --> 01:50:59,329
came from a clear blackmail
by Mr. Eduardo Cunha...
1159
01:50:59,430 --> 01:51:03,912
with whom you unfortunately
made an alliance.
1160
01:51:04,013 --> 01:51:09,287
And this is confirmed
since I'm not on trial...
1161
01:51:09,388 --> 01:51:13,287
for money laundering,
for offshore bank accounts...
1162
01:51:13,388 --> 01:51:16,912
or for the misappropriation
of public funds.
1163
01:51:17,013 --> 01:51:23,162
I'm a defendant at the final stage
of an impeachment trial...
1164
01:51:23,263 --> 01:51:31,454
while someone who publicly
committed crimes is protected.
1165
01:51:31,555 --> 01:51:34,995
This is something to
be deeply ashamed of.
1166
01:51:35,096 --> 01:51:39,329
It's about this,
not movements on the streets.
1167
01:51:39,430 --> 01:51:45,162
Unfortunately, those same leaders,
some, not all...
1168
01:51:45,263 --> 01:51:51,120
some of them were
most emphatic and cheerful..
1169
01:51:51,221 --> 01:51:55,329
when taking pictures
with Deputy Eduardo Cunha.
1170
01:51:55,430 --> 01:51:57,462
In addition...
1171
01:51:58,388 --> 01:52:01,712
This is life, Senator. It's hard.
1172
01:52:14,180 --> 01:52:16,662
So, Senator...
1173
01:52:16,763 --> 01:52:23,295
we can't say that
this process is spontaneous.
1174
01:52:27,570 --> 01:52:30,231
Now speaking Senator Roberto Requi�o.
1175
01:52:31,139 --> 01:52:36,118
I will not suppress the
indignation that consumes me.
1176
01:52:37,141 --> 01:52:38,540
Bastard!
1177
01:52:39,388 --> 01:52:40,634
Bastard!
1178
01:52:41,653 --> 01:52:42,884
Bastard!
1179
01:52:43,528 --> 01:52:48,960
Thus Tancredo Neves
referred to Moura Andrade
1180
01:52:49,135 --> 01:52:56,440
who declared vacant the presidency
with Jango still in national territory.
1181
01:52:56,714 --> 01:53:00,211
Thus consuming the
military coup of 1964.
1182
01:53:01,028 --> 01:53:05,004
I doubt that just one of us
1183
01:53:05,190 --> 01:53:07,234
be convinced
1184
01:53:07,505 --> 01:53:12,440
that President Dilma should be
removed from committing crimes.
1185
01:53:13,171 --> 01:53:20,074
It is not the "Pedaladas" or such fiscal
responsibility that excommunicate her.
1186
01:53:20,286 --> 01:53:27,417
The accuser's own rapporteur
himself practiced them at length.
1187
01:53:27,573 --> 01:53:30,492
Only, that there in Minas,
1188
01:53:30,679 --> 01:53:35,254
there was no providential
and enjoyable Eduardo Cunha.
1189
01:53:35,980 --> 01:53:41,314
Let no one later claim
ignorance or be cheated
1190
01:53:41,415 --> 01:53:45,099
because the intentions
of the Vice are clear:
1191
01:53:45,437 --> 01:53:47,177
Privatization as a rule,
1192
01:53:47,278 --> 01:53:50,995
and radical alienation of
all the energy patrimony,
1193
01:53:51,096 --> 01:53:54,211
mineral, forestry and
agrarian sector of Brazil.
1194
01:53:54,881 --> 01:54:00,000
After the delivery of the Pre-Salt,
from the sale of land to foreigners,
1195
01:54:00,131 --> 01:54:03,388
they even want to deliver
the Guarani Aquifer,
1196
01:54:03,489 --> 01:54:07,064
the largest reservoir of
drinking water on the planet.
1197
01:54:07,514 --> 01:54:12,042
Freeze for two decades
the spending with health,
1198
01:54:12,328 --> 01:54:18,325
education, public safety, sanitation
and infrastructure, housing...
1199
01:54:18,678 --> 01:54:21,691
But guarantee the payment of interest.
1200
01:54:22,172 --> 01:54:28,335
It is like prohibiting,
for 20 years, that children are born,
1201
01:54:28,436 --> 01:54:31,136
young people have
access to schools,
1202
01:54:31,399 --> 01:54:34,584
that Brazilians get old or sick.
1203
01:54:34,892 --> 01:54:36,561
It's scary
1204
01:54:36,877 --> 01:54:41,952
that some human being have
granted such a barbarity a day.
1205
01:56:31,221 --> 01:56:34,587
Yes. It's Sophie's Choice.
1206
01:56:37,346 --> 01:56:38,754
Exactly.
1207
01:56:40,388 --> 01:56:42,045
It's void.
1208
01:56:48,930 --> 01:56:51,795
No. It has to be done.
Exactly.
1209
01:56:52,513 --> 01:56:54,712
Professional. Sure.
1210
01:56:56,888 --> 01:56:57,995
Exactly.
1211
01:56:58,096 --> 01:57:05,120
I'm only wondering if we should
do it now or right after.
1212
01:57:05,221 --> 01:57:09,829
We could wait to file this lawsuit...
1213
01:57:09,930 --> 01:57:13,587
and the one for lack of cause
right after.
1214
01:57:36,888 --> 01:57:40,087
Attorney Jana�na Paschoal
has the floor.
1215
01:57:41,388 --> 01:57:49,254
The world needs to know that
we're not debating accounting issues.
1216
01:57:50,180 --> 01:57:53,787
That is why I asked
one of the professors:
1217
01:57:53,888 --> 01:57:58,162
"What were your fellow
foreign colleagues told...
1218
01:57:58,263 --> 01:58:00,829
to convince them it was a coup?
1219
01:58:00,930 --> 01:58:06,620
That the President is being
removed based on three decrees?
1220
01:58:06,721 --> 01:58:11,162
That she's getting removed
because of an accounting issue?
1221
01:58:11,263 --> 01:58:16,787
If that's so, it's only reasonable
they deem it a coup.
1222
01:58:16,888 --> 01:58:22,212
Or were they told the Brazilian
people were victim of a fraud?"
1223
01:58:22,888 --> 01:58:25,412
That's how PT works.
1224
01:58:25,513 --> 01:58:30,329
PT denies facts and reality.
1225
01:58:30,430 --> 01:58:34,995
We can no longer stand
the politics of marketing.
1226
01:58:35,096 --> 01:58:38,162
We want leaders
who stare us in the eyes.
1227
01:58:38,263 --> 01:58:45,045
I trust in your judgment to make
Brazil better for our children.
1228
01:58:45,555 --> 01:58:50,329
Even though I'm convinced I'm right.
1229
01:58:50,430 --> 01:58:56,579
Even when I'm right, I realize
my actions might hurt others.
1230
01:58:56,680 --> 01:59:00,795
So, even though I'm right,
I apologize.
1231
01:59:05,680 --> 01:59:07,954
Finish your train of thought.
1232
01:59:08,055 --> 01:59:10,295
I conclude...
1233
01:59:11,221 --> 01:59:14,412
by apologizing to President Dilma.
1234
01:59:14,513 --> 01:59:17,454
Not because I did
what had to be done...
1235
01:59:17,555 --> 01:59:19,995
because I couldn't omit myself.
1236
01:59:20,096 --> 01:59:24,120
I apologize because I know
her situation is not easy.
1237
01:59:24,221 --> 01:59:28,620
I apologize because I know,
even though that was not my intent...
1238
01:59:28,721 --> 01:59:32,545
I've caused her grief.
And I ask that she...
1239
01:59:36,888 --> 01:59:40,995
one day might understand...
1240
01:59:41,096 --> 01:59:46,837
that I also did it
for the sake of her grandchildren.
1241
01:59:48,221 --> 01:59:52,712
Please, no manifestations.
1242
01:59:55,721 --> 02:00:01,412
I pass the floor to the eminent
attorney and also professor...
1243
02:00:01,513 --> 02:00:07,379
Jos� Eduardo Martins Cardozo.
1244
02:00:10,721 --> 02:00:15,120
During the military dictatorship,
Dilma Vana Rousseff...
1245
02:00:15,221 --> 02:00:18,879
sat on the defendant's bench
three times.
1246
02:00:19,930 --> 02:00:22,587
She spent three years in jail.
1247
02:00:23,346 --> 02:00:26,545
Her political rights were suspended.
1248
02:00:27,846 --> 02:00:31,045
She was brutally tortured.
1249
02:00:32,430 --> 02:00:36,212
Her very dignity was attacked.
1250
02:00:38,180 --> 02:00:42,662
It is possible that
some of her accusers...
1251
02:00:42,763 --> 02:00:47,579
overcome by a fit of sentimentality,
said to her:
1252
02:00:47,680 --> 02:00:53,162
"Girl, we are arresting and torturing you
for the sake of the country.
1253
02:00:53,263 --> 02:00:56,920
For the sake of your kids
and grandkids.
1254
02:01:02,180 --> 02:01:07,212
We're annihilating your life.
But it is for your sake.
1255
02:01:08,555 --> 02:01:14,420
We are destroying and crushing you,
but it is for your own good."
1256
02:01:15,596 --> 02:01:18,662
Sometimes
that happens to accusers.
1257
02:01:18,763 --> 02:01:21,954
They suddenly grow a conscience.
1258
02:01:22,055 --> 02:01:26,454
But they can't eliminate
the injustice of their accusation.
1259
02:01:26,555 --> 02:01:31,287
They might even try to fake
a feeling of humanity.
1260
02:01:31,388 --> 02:01:34,045
But, objectively, they fail.
1261
02:01:36,596 --> 02:01:42,129
Today, Dilma Rousseff sits again
on the defendant's bench.
1262
02:01:43,763 --> 02:01:48,995
After the Constitution of 1988,
after the return of democracy...
1263
02:01:49,096 --> 02:01:52,629
after we affirmed the rule of law.
1264
02:01:54,013 --> 02:01:58,587
She is no longer a girl.
She is a mother and a grandmother.
1265
02:02:00,221 --> 02:02:06,545
Today, she is a woman
elected President of Brazil...
1266
02:02:06,846 --> 02:02:10,954
with over 54 million votes.
1267
02:02:11,055 --> 02:02:15,920
The first woman elected
President of Brazil.
1268
02:02:17,263 --> 02:02:19,495
And what is she accused of?
1269
02:02:19,596 --> 02:02:23,995
Today we know.
But, maybe in some time...
1270
02:02:24,096 --> 02:02:28,629
nobody will remember
the charges she's accused of.
1271
02:02:28,930 --> 02:02:33,504
Much like nobody remembers
the accusations of the past.
1272
02:02:33,930 --> 02:02:35,629
What will they say?
1273
02:02:36,013 --> 02:02:41,920
She was accused because
she dared to win an election...
1274
02:02:42,721 --> 02:02:48,254
affronting the interests of those who
sought to change the country's course.
1275
02:02:49,221 --> 02:02:55,620
She was convicted
because she dared not stop...
1276
02:02:55,721 --> 02:03:00,379
the investigations against corruption.
1277
02:03:02,221 --> 02:03:06,620
The pretexts?
Those will remain in the files.
1278
02:03:06,721 --> 02:03:08,754
Turned to dust.
1279
02:03:09,263 --> 02:03:11,079
The dust of time.
1280
02:03:11,180 --> 02:03:16,129
I have nothing further to say.
The files speak on my behalf.
1281
02:03:20,096 --> 02:03:25,295
This session is finished.
1282
02:03:53,087 --> 02:03:59,625
August 31st, 2016.
The Senate votes.
1283
02:04:50,013 --> 02:04:54,995
Madam Senators and Senators...
1284
02:04:55,096 --> 02:05:00,962
I start this session,
or, rather, resume it.
1285
02:05:05,388 --> 02:05:09,920
The table clarifies...
1286
02:05:11,388 --> 02:05:14,662
as it pertains
to the vote in question...
1287
02:05:14,763 --> 02:05:18,454
"yes" means you approve
the conviction...
1288
02:05:18,555 --> 02:05:24,454
that is, the loss
of the President's office.
1289
02:05:24,555 --> 02:05:29,954
Those who vote "no",
vote for absolution...
1290
02:05:30,055 --> 02:05:35,620
and consequent dismissal
of the charges against the President.
1291
02:05:35,721 --> 02:05:40,587
Senators, you may start your vote.
1292
02:06:20,930 --> 02:06:25,120
61 Senators voted "yes".
1293
02:06:25,221 --> 02:06:29,045
20 Senators voted "no".
1294
02:06:31,263 --> 02:06:34,504
20 "no". Zero abstentions.
1295
02:07:13,055 --> 02:07:18,754
IT'S FRAUD! IT'S A COUP!
1296
02:07:39,055 --> 02:07:46,129
I SHALL NOT PUT MY NAME
TO THIS INFAMY.
1297
02:07:52,055 --> 02:07:54,162
You won, but didn't take it.
1298
02:07:54,263 --> 02:08:00,462
Because you're doing it
against the constitution.
1299
02:08:16,846 --> 02:08:18,879
President Dilma!
1300
02:08:20,055 --> 02:08:23,379
History's already absolved you, Dilma!
1301
02:08:29,180 --> 02:08:33,495
Fighter! Brazilian woman!
1302
02:08:33,596 --> 02:08:37,087
Fighter of the Brazilian People!
1303
02:08:52,388 --> 02:08:57,212
Today, the Senate made a decision
1304
02:08:57,346 --> 02:09:00,829
that enters History
as a great injustice.
1305
02:09:00,930 --> 02:09:07,162
The Senators who voted for impeachment
chose to rip the Constitution to shreds.
1306
02:09:07,263 --> 02:09:11,620
They decided for the interruption
of the term of a President
1307
02:09:11,721 --> 02:09:15,420
who did not commit
any impeachable offense.
1308
02:09:15,763 --> 02:09:20,912
They convicted an innocent woman
and performed a parliamentary coup.
1309
02:09:21,013 --> 02:09:24,829
By approving my definitive removal...
1310
02:09:24,930 --> 02:09:30,620
the politicians who desperately
seek to escape justice...
1311
02:09:30,721 --> 02:09:35,829
shall take power along with
those defeated in the last four elections.
1312
02:09:35,930 --> 02:09:41,579
The progressive, democratic
and inclusive project I represent...
1313
02:09:41,680 --> 02:09:47,412
is being interrupted by a powerful
and conservative force.
1314
02:09:47,513 --> 02:09:50,454
With the support
of a biased press...
1315
02:09:50,555 --> 02:09:55,787
they will take the institutions
of the state and employ them...
1316
02:09:55,888 --> 02:10:01,120
in the service of extreme economic
liberalism and social regression.
1317
02:10:01,221 --> 02:10:04,329
This coup is against
the people and the nation,
1318
02:10:04,430 --> 02:10:08,787
It is the imposition of intolerance,
prejudice and violence.
1319
02:10:08,888 --> 02:10:13,329
As I take my leave, I share with you
the beautiful solace found...
1320
02:10:13,430 --> 02:10:16,495
in the words of
the Russian poet Mayakovski.
1321
02:10:16,596 --> 02:10:19,745
"We are not happy,
that much is certain.
1322
02:10:19,846 --> 02:10:23,829
But why should we also be sad?
1323
02:10:23,930 --> 02:10:26,454
The sea of history is agitated.
1324
02:10:26,555 --> 02:10:30,662
Threats and wars
we are bound to overcome...
1325
02:10:30,763 --> 02:10:35,620
break them in half,
cutting through them as a keel would."
1326
02:10:35,721 --> 02:10:39,079
My kindest regards
to the Brazilian people.
1327
02:10:39,180 --> 02:10:43,162
To the women
and men of my country.
1328
02:10:43,263 --> 02:10:48,579
Specially to the men
and women who share with me...
1329
02:10:48,680 --> 02:10:50,954
a belief in democracy...
1330
02:10:51,055 --> 02:10:56,287
and in the dream of justice
in all its dimensions.
1331
02:10:56,388 --> 02:10:58,295
Thank you.
1332
02:11:03,596 --> 02:11:09,420
You represent me!
You represent me!
1333
02:11:17,596 --> 02:11:24,545
Dilma, a fighter
for the Brazilian nation!
1334
02:11:33,180 --> 02:11:38,379
Temer out! Temer out!
1335
02:12:18,451 --> 02:12:23,111
Nine months later, on May 22nd,
2017, Michel Temer is formally
1336
02:12:23,212 --> 02:12:26,803
accused of corruption by
the attorney general.
1337
02:12:26,904 --> 02:12:32,686
He becomes Brazil's first head of state
to be formally charged with a crime.
1338
02:12:32,787 --> 02:12:34,914
Temer refuses to resign.
1339
02:12:38,513 --> 02:12:42,745
You came with us to shout "Temer out!"
1340
02:12:42,846 --> 02:12:46,454
And "Direct elections now!"
1341
02:12:46,555 --> 02:12:50,745
Pension reform, labor reform...
1342
02:12:50,846 --> 02:12:55,254
and outsourcing
are the continuation of the coup!
1343
02:12:57,555 --> 02:13:02,420
Police, please retreat.
This space belongs to the workers.
1344
02:13:10,596 --> 02:13:13,829
One, two, three, four, five!
1345
02:13:13,930 --> 02:13:17,495
Stop the reforms
or we will stop Brazil!
1346
02:13:17,596 --> 02:13:21,079
One, two, three, four, five!
1347
02:13:21,180 --> 02:13:24,745
Stop the reforms
or we will stop Brazil!
1348
02:13:24,846 --> 02:13:31,920
Direct elections now!
1349
02:13:41,221 --> 02:13:46,495
I can't believe the police are firing
and throwing bombs at demonstrators...
1350
02:13:46,596 --> 02:13:50,879
who came from all over Brazil
in an organized fashion!
1351
02:14:01,596 --> 02:14:05,795
Help me! Help me!
1352
02:14:07,221 --> 02:14:10,420
They're trying to throw me out!
1353
02:14:31,013 --> 02:14:33,829
No one will throw anyone out!
1354
02:14:33,930 --> 02:14:39,379
No one leaves! No one leaves!
1355
02:15:42,122 --> 02:15:49,852
On August 2, 2017, the Congress voted not to put
President Michel Temer on trial for corruption.
1356
02:15:50,856 --> 02:15:54,867
After taking office, Temer has
overseen a spree of privatizations,
1357
02:15:54,968 --> 02:15:57,498
austerity measures and spending freezes.
1358
02:15:57,599 --> 02:16:00,659
His ruling coalition passed
a radical austerity law
1359
02:16:00,760 --> 02:16:04,125
that bars the increase of
public spending for 20 years
1360
02:16:04,226 --> 02:16:08,142
and a controversial labour reform
that weakens worker's rights.
1361
02:16:08,243 --> 02:16:10,574
Restrictions on foreign oil companies
1362
02:16:10,675 --> 02:16:14,718
looking to drill for lucrative
offshore deposits were lifted.
1363
02:16:16,744 --> 02:16:20,067
On April 4, 2018,
the Supreme Court rejected
1364
02:16:20,168 --> 02:16:25,002
the habeas corpus filed by the
defense of former President Lula.
1365
02:16:25,103 --> 02:16:29,890
The next day, Judge S�rgio Moro
ordered the arrest of Lula.
1366
02:16:31,875 --> 02:16:38,064
THE TRIAL
1367
02:16:38,865 --> 02:16:44,065
Subtitles ripped by gooz
karagarga, 2019
115578
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.