All language subtitles for O.Processo.2018.720p.WEBRip.x264-gooz.english

af Afrikaans
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bn Bengali
bs Bosnian
bg Bulgarian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
da Danish
nl Dutch
en English
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
km Khmer
ko Korean
ku Kurdish (Kurmanji)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Lao
la Latin
lv Latvian
lt Lithuanian
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
ne Nepali
no Norwegian
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt Portuguese Download
pa Punjabi
ro Romanian
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
st Sesotho
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhala
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
te Telugu
th Thai
tr Turkish
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu
or Odia (Oriya)
rw Kinyarwanda
tk Turkmen
tt Tatar
ug Uyghur
Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated: 1 00:01:10,530 --> 00:01:18,382 In October 2014, Dilma Rousseff was reelected President of Brazil 2 00:01:18,483 --> 00:01:26,536 potentially extending to 16 years the consecutive rule by the left-wing Worker's Party. 3 00:01:27,098 --> 00:01:31,176 Months before, a judicial investigation known as 'Operation Car Wash' 4 00:01:31,277 --> 00:01:35,895 unveiled a vast corruption scheme involving state-run oil company Petrobras. 5 00:01:35,996 --> 00:01:39,288 Senior politicians from the three main parties were accused, 6 00:01:39,389 --> 00:01:42,340 including Vice President Michel Temer and the 7 00:01:42,441 --> 00:01:47,643 House Speaker Eduardo Cunha, both a driving force behind the impeachment proceedings. 8 00:01:47,744 --> 00:01:50,272 President Rousseff was not implicated. 9 00:02:38,671 --> 00:02:46,029 The ones who want turmoil are those who don't want to vote. 10 00:02:46,130 --> 00:02:48,995 So I ask you to... 11 00:02:51,338 --> 00:02:54,404 I ask security to intervene. 12 00:02:54,505 --> 00:02:55,829 Keep calm! 13 00:02:57,505 --> 00:02:59,495 Keep calm, leader! 14 00:03:00,338 --> 00:03:01,404 Leader! 15 00:03:01,505 --> 00:03:03,904 Banners are not allowed up here. 16 00:03:04,005 --> 00:03:07,404 Actually, banners aren't allowed anywhere. 17 00:03:07,505 --> 00:03:10,237 There will be no coup, we will fight! 18 00:03:10,338 --> 00:03:13,829 There will be no coup, we will fight... 19 00:03:17,005 --> 00:03:20,737 There will be no coup! 20 00:03:20,838 --> 00:03:22,737 There will be no coup. 21 00:03:22,838 --> 00:03:29,404 We will fight for our beloved homeland, Brazil. 22 00:03:29,505 --> 00:03:36,070 Dilma out! Dilma out! 23 00:03:36,171 --> 00:03:43,537 Take your feet off the ground, if you want Lula in prison! 24 00:03:47,671 --> 00:03:50,404 I declare the voting session open. 25 00:03:50,505 --> 00:03:53,862 I will begin to call the deputies. 26 00:03:53,963 --> 00:03:58,195 For my family, for my beloved Chapec�... 27 00:03:58,296 --> 00:04:01,070 for my state of Santa Catarina... 28 00:04:01,171 --> 00:04:05,904 and for breaking the backbone of this gang... 29 00:04:06,005 --> 00:04:07,904 I vote yes. 30 00:04:08,005 --> 00:04:13,612 For my family, but mainly for my father Cesar Maia... 31 00:04:13,713 --> 00:04:18,404 run over by the Worker's Party (PT) when he was the mayor. 32 00:04:18,505 --> 00:04:22,170 PT rips apart the Constitution in Rio and here. 33 00:04:22,271 --> 00:04:23,570 I vote yes! 34 00:04:23,671 --> 00:04:28,070 For democracy, for the sovereignty of the popular vote, 35 00:04:28,171 --> 00:04:30,362 for human dignity, 36 00:04:30,463 --> 00:04:33,987 for those who fought against the military dictatorship, 37 00:04:34,088 --> 00:04:38,404 I vote no to this coup and say yes to Brazil! 38 00:04:38,505 --> 00:04:40,862 For my family, for my daughter... 39 00:04:40,963 --> 00:04:44,287 for my wife, yes to the impeachment! 40 00:04:49,671 --> 00:04:54,904 For the families and for the children in schools who PT never cared about. 41 00:04:55,005 --> 00:04:59,695 For the memory of Colonel Carlos Alberto Brilhante Ustra... 42 00:04:59,796 --> 00:05:02,570 the nightmare of Dilma Rousseff. 43 00:05:02,671 --> 00:05:04,112 How do you vote? 44 00:05:04,213 --> 00:05:08,070 For the army of Caxias, for our Armed Forces... 45 00:05:08,171 --> 00:05:15,329 Brazil above everything and God above everyone, I vote yes! 46 00:05:17,130 --> 00:05:19,862 How does Deputy Feghali vote? 47 00:05:19,963 --> 00:05:24,070 I would like to express my outrage, Deputy Eduardo Cunha... 48 00:05:24,171 --> 00:05:29,404 at seeing you in that chair with no moral fiber. 49 00:05:29,505 --> 00:05:35,237 Second, my indignation at seeing you embracing a traitor of democracy... 50 00:05:35,338 --> 00:05:38,237 who tries to usurp the President's seat. 51 00:05:38,338 --> 00:05:42,404 Vice-President Michel Temer, who has no vote. 52 00:05:42,505 --> 00:05:46,612 Third, it's very clear to Brazilian society... 53 00:05:46,713 --> 00:05:49,195 what the impeachment alliance is. 54 00:05:49,296 --> 00:05:54,862 It brings together Corrupt politicians, torturers like Jair Bolsonaro... 55 00:05:54,963 --> 00:05:59,570 and traitors of our country. And I vote no, against the coup. 56 00:05:59,671 --> 00:06:03,237 For the military of 1964, today and always. 57 00:06:03,338 --> 00:06:07,612 For the police, God and the Brazilian family, I vote yes! 58 00:06:07,713 --> 00:06:11,070 How does Deputy Jean Wyllys from the PSOL vote? 59 00:06:11,171 --> 00:06:14,737 I am embarrassed at participating in this farce, 60 00:06:14,838 --> 00:06:19,529 this indirect election conducted by a thief, 61 00:06:19,630 --> 00:06:24,237 devised by a traitor, a conspirator, and supported by torturers... 62 00:06:24,338 --> 00:06:28,070 cowards, political illiterates, and crooks. 63 00:06:28,171 --> 00:06:30,070 This sexist farce. 64 00:06:30,171 --> 00:06:35,695 For the rights of the LGBT population, blacks exterminated in the favelas... 65 00:06:35,796 --> 00:06:39,862 the right of artists, the homeless, the landless... 66 00:06:39,963 --> 00:06:41,987 I vote no to the coup! 67 00:06:42,088 --> 00:06:45,570 And sleep with that, you bastards! 68 00:06:45,671 --> 00:06:49,404 Deputy Eduardo Cunha, how do you vote? 69 00:06:49,505 --> 00:06:52,654 May God have mercy on this nation. 70 00:06:52,755 --> 00:06:54,620 I vote yes. 71 00:06:56,755 --> 00:06:58,904 In honor of the working people... 72 00:06:59,005 --> 00:07:02,737 who took to the streets today to resist the coup. 73 00:07:02,838 --> 00:07:08,987 I agree with you when you say "may God have mercy on this country". 74 00:07:09,088 --> 00:07:14,237 I hope so, because you are the head of corruption in this country... 75 00:07:14,338 --> 00:07:19,904 presiding over a court that will judge an honorable woman. 76 00:07:20,005 --> 00:07:23,737 And, President, don't kid yourself with that smirk... 77 00:07:23,838 --> 00:07:26,820 You're up in the Federal Supreme Court. I vote no! 78 00:07:26,921 --> 00:07:28,320 Against a party... 79 00:07:28,421 --> 00:07:33,695 which uses national foreign policy to employ the country's resources 80 00:07:33,796 --> 00:07:38,070 to fund bloodthirsty Bolivarian dictatorships. 81 00:07:38,171 --> 00:07:43,904 Against those who use education to indoctrinate and harass our children. 82 00:07:44,005 --> 00:07:46,029 For better days for our country... 83 00:07:46,130 --> 00:07:50,404 free from this gang that embedded itself in our core. 84 00:07:50,505 --> 00:07:54,695 And with all my heart... Yes! Dilma out! 85 00:07:54,796 --> 00:07:58,904 I'm Brazilian, 86 00:07:59,005 --> 00:08:05,537 I'm proud, with lots of love... 87 00:08:06,338 --> 00:08:11,487 I'm Brazilian, 88 00:08:11,588 --> 00:08:17,070 I'm proud with lots of love... 89 00:08:17,171 --> 00:08:21,904 The impeachment proceedings are authorized.. 90 00:08:22,005 --> 00:08:27,570 against the Madam President due to the accusation of impeachable offense... 91 00:08:27,671 --> 00:08:31,487 offered by H�lio Bicudo... 92 00:08:31,588 --> 00:08:35,695 Miguel Reale Junior and Jana�na Paschoal... 93 00:08:35,796 --> 00:08:43,495 for the opening of additional budget without Congress authorization. 94 00:08:49,671 --> 00:08:53,070 The placid banks of the Ipiranga heard 95 00:08:53,171 --> 00:08:57,362 The resounding cry of a heroic folk 96 00:08:57,463 --> 00:09:01,570 And the sun of Liberty in shining beams 97 00:09:01,671 --> 00:09:05,570 Shone in the homeland's sky in this instant 98 00:09:05,671 --> 00:09:10,237 If the pledge of this equality 99 00:09:10,338 --> 00:09:13,862 We managed to conquer with strong arm 100 00:09:13,963 --> 00:09:18,204 In thy bosom, o Freedom... 101 00:09:22,630 --> 00:09:28,329 THE TRIAL 102 00:10:39,296 --> 00:10:43,162 Yes, then we'll have six months before the trial. 103 00:10:50,505 --> 00:10:53,954 Don't mention it. Goodbye. 104 00:10:55,505 --> 00:10:57,237 - Dai! - What? 105 00:10:57,338 --> 00:11:02,404 - You may transfer the other call. - Do you have a copy, senator? 106 00:11:02,505 --> 00:11:05,737 No, I have one here from the UOL guy. 107 00:11:05,838 --> 00:11:07,570 I have no copy here. 108 00:11:07,671 --> 00:11:09,904 Wait, I'm printing. 109 00:11:10,005 --> 00:11:14,870 But go ahead and call. I have to go to the Committee. 110 00:11:20,630 --> 00:11:22,862 Where is the causality? 111 00:11:22,963 --> 00:11:27,404 Revenue fell due to the crisis. Or is it the other way around? 112 00:11:27,505 --> 00:11:32,537 He says the President spent more and that led to a crisis... 113 00:11:32,838 --> 00:11:36,195 What is the best excerpt to quote? 114 00:11:36,296 --> 00:11:40,495 What is the best part for me to highlight? 115 00:11:41,796 --> 00:11:45,487 Here. "According to the message..." 116 00:11:45,588 --> 00:11:49,862 "According to the message, the evaluation takes into account 117 00:11:49,963 --> 00:11:54,487 the effects of the bill that changes the annual budget." 118 00:11:54,588 --> 00:11:56,654 This is a Congress decision! 119 00:11:56,755 --> 00:12:01,070 And in addition, he says, "I am aware of the message..." 120 00:12:01,171 --> 00:12:02,570 I don't have time. 121 00:12:02,671 --> 00:12:06,362 Just say that he dismissed it with no reservations. 122 00:12:06,463 --> 00:12:09,987 And it was approved unanimously by Congress. 123 00:12:10,088 --> 00:12:12,987 The key issue is that the Senator analyzed... 124 00:12:13,088 --> 00:12:17,529 knowing that the Executive was using a new annual budget... 125 00:12:17,630 --> 00:12:19,862 and he approved it. That's it. 126 00:12:19,963 --> 00:12:22,695 Those two things are the key issue. 127 00:12:22,796 --> 00:12:26,320 The Executive acted in accordance with Congress. 128 00:12:26,421 --> 00:12:28,495 Now it's a crime? 129 00:12:37,505 --> 00:12:40,404 I'm ready. I'll go to war! 130 00:12:40,505 --> 00:12:43,204 The bad thing is that we don't eat! 131 00:12:46,106 --> 00:12:51,009 April 28th, 2016. A Senate Committee examines the charges: 132 00:12:51,110 --> 00:12:56,405 1. the issuing of six fiscal decrees without Congress approval. 133 00:12:56,506 --> 00:13:00,639 2. the so-called "pedaladas": a delayed repayment 134 00:13:00,740 --> 00:13:05,418 of the agricultural subsidies spent by state banks. 135 00:13:07,088 --> 00:13:10,237 Dilma has been accused of two things. 136 00:13:10,338 --> 00:13:14,154 Delaying payment of the Farm Subsidies to the Bank of Brazil... 137 00:13:14,255 --> 00:13:16,820 and six additional budget decrees. 138 00:13:16,921 --> 00:13:19,029 We've been explaining... 139 00:13:19,130 --> 00:13:25,320 that there's a 1992 law which shows that the Farm Subsidies... 140 00:13:25,421 --> 00:13:29,695 are managed by four ministries and the Monetary Council. 141 00:13:29,796 --> 00:13:34,529 The President takes no part. So we're asking for documentation. 142 00:13:34,630 --> 00:13:37,904 From the Bank of Brazil, Ministry of Agriculture... 143 00:13:38,005 --> 00:13:41,487 Ministry of Finance, Ministry of Planning. 144 00:13:41,588 --> 00:13:45,904 And another thing. Six additional budget decrees. 145 00:13:46,005 --> 00:13:50,279 A widespread practice not considered illegal. 146 00:13:50,380 --> 00:13:54,737 We need documents from the departments which requested funds. 147 00:13:54,838 --> 00:13:57,737 The Federal and Electoral Justice departments... 148 00:13:57,838 --> 00:14:02,029 the Ministry of Education. I plead with you. 149 00:14:02,130 --> 00:14:05,487 You're curtailing our right of defense. 150 00:14:05,588 --> 00:14:10,487 We said that a rapporteur from the opposition would be biased. 151 00:14:10,588 --> 00:14:12,529 It seems true! 152 00:14:12,630 --> 00:14:17,695 Article 45 of Law 1,079 states: 153 00:14:17,796 --> 00:14:21,904 "Within the period, the committee may carry out 154 00:14:22,005 --> 00:14:25,529 the verifications it deems necessary." 155 00:14:25,630 --> 00:14:28,529 The rapporteur has a view, the committee will vote. 156 00:14:28,630 --> 00:14:31,654 Mr. President R. Lira... 157 00:14:31,755 --> 00:14:37,070 I put to the vote request 16 of 2016. 158 00:14:37,171 --> 00:14:41,362 The senators who agree with the rapporteur's assessment... 159 00:14:41,463 --> 00:14:44,029 should remain as they are. 160 00:14:44,130 --> 00:14:46,487 Dismissed. 161 00:14:46,588 --> 00:14:52,237 Mr. President, but it's sad to see how this session is being led. 162 00:14:52,338 --> 00:14:56,362 I feel like we're lambs led to the slaughter. 163 00:14:56,463 --> 00:14:58,737 This committee has made up its mind. 164 00:14:58,838 --> 00:15:04,529 Whatever we say, it's already been decided. 165 00:15:04,630 --> 00:15:10,529 The rapporteur knows what he's going to report and most of us know how well vote. 166 00:15:10,630 --> 00:15:17,195 That's sad. These requests aren't meant for a later stage... 167 00:15:17,296 --> 00:15:22,904 but for us to examine the admissibility of the accusation. 168 00:15:23,005 --> 00:15:24,904 Where's the just cause? 169 00:15:25,005 --> 00:15:30,487 Because it shows President Dilma did not commit any crimes... 170 00:15:30,588 --> 00:15:34,570 relating to the six budget decrees... 171 00:15:34,671 --> 00:15:43,162 since they were supported by a law voted in by the Congress. 172 00:16:10,838 --> 00:16:12,995 Get him and Dalmo. 173 00:16:13,671 --> 00:16:18,237 Before the report we should bring up preliminary statements. 174 00:16:18,338 --> 00:16:24,070 Lindbergh will bring up the Government of Minas Gerais. 175 00:16:24,171 --> 00:16:27,904 We have Z� Eduardo's appeal which also states.. 176 00:16:28,005 --> 00:16:32,904 the rapporteur should be suspect because of his party, PSDB. 177 00:16:33,005 --> 00:16:36,737 - He replied the same day... - But not at the committee. 178 00:16:36,838 --> 00:16:40,529 He just published it. 179 00:16:40,630 --> 00:16:43,529 We need to discuss it in the committee... 180 00:16:43,630 --> 00:16:47,404 "You used accounting tricks in Minas Gerais." That's it. 181 00:16:47,505 --> 00:16:55,237 We're not trying to win the point of order, but to discredit him as rapporteur. 182 00:16:55,338 --> 00:17:00,904 It's just a matter of time until the President is removed. 183 00:17:01,005 --> 00:17:04,695 This game is rigged. It's make believe. 184 00:17:04,796 --> 00:17:10,404 But in this rigged game, we also have politics, gestures. 185 00:17:10,505 --> 00:17:14,237 PMDB party, the greatest beneficiary of the coup... 186 00:17:14,338 --> 00:17:20,154 appointed five names which are already dirty. 187 00:17:20,255 --> 00:17:23,029 That's a crime, not a trial. 188 00:17:23,130 --> 00:17:28,904 The report by the opposition PSDB was without surprises. 189 00:17:29,005 --> 00:17:32,654 We're not going to endorse a rigged game. 190 00:17:32,755 --> 00:17:36,995 I'm asking you to think about a political gesture. 191 00:18:00,796 --> 00:18:08,329 Dilma, a fighter for the Brazilian nation! 192 00:18:59,222 --> 00:19:07,703 April 29th, 2016. Opening statements of the prosecutor and defense. 193 00:20:07,463 --> 00:20:10,820 Ladies and gentlemen senators. 194 00:20:10,921 --> 00:20:14,620 We will now pass the floor... 195 00:20:15,963 --> 00:20:18,862 to Jana�na Paschoal... 196 00:20:18,963 --> 00:20:24,029 the lawyer and professor of criminal law... 197 00:20:24,130 --> 00:20:28,029 at the University of S�o Paulo. 198 00:20:28,130 --> 00:20:30,237 It was my moral obligation... 199 00:20:30,338 --> 00:20:35,029 to bring this to Your Excellencies who are judging this matter. 200 00:20:35,130 --> 00:20:42,529 Your Excellencies can be absolutely confident... 201 00:20:42,630 --> 00:20:44,737 in admitting the complaint. 202 00:20:44,838 --> 00:20:49,195 As a plaintiff, I ask that you admit it fully. 203 00:20:49,296 --> 00:20:51,862 Because this is part of a whole... 204 00:20:51,963 --> 00:20:56,237 which shows the coup my country fell victim to. 205 00:20:56,338 --> 00:21:03,654 Don't Your Excellencies think I'd be happy to see a woman... 206 00:21:03,755 --> 00:21:09,120 be successful as President regardless of her party? 207 00:21:10,588 --> 00:21:12,995 I'm a Brazilian woman! 208 00:21:14,296 --> 00:21:19,162 I love this land more than anything. 209 00:21:23,796 --> 00:21:28,995 I'm here because I'm Brazilian, that's my party. 210 00:21:32,838 --> 00:21:35,695 I've never voted for PT (Workers' Party). 211 00:21:35,796 --> 00:21:39,695 But when President Dilma gave an interview 212 00:21:39,796 --> 00:21:44,904 and said she used to dream of being a ballet dancer, I cried. 213 00:21:45,005 --> 00:21:47,454 That ballerina got lost. 214 00:21:50,838 --> 00:21:54,329 She got lost and left me no alternative. 215 00:21:55,421 --> 00:21:59,362 As a Brazilian, as a lawyer... 216 00:21:59,463 --> 00:22:05,529 as a teacher of criminal law, as a lover... 217 00:22:05,630 --> 00:22:10,904 for I am in love with the Federal Constitution... 218 00:22:11,005 --> 00:22:13,287 I had no choice. 219 00:22:15,005 --> 00:22:17,237 After my first big speech... 220 00:22:17,338 --> 00:22:20,862 I received calls even from foreign journalists... 221 00:22:20,963 --> 00:22:24,329 asking if I'm a priestess or a shaman. 222 00:22:25,130 --> 00:22:32,029 And I tell them "I'm not enlightened enough... 223 00:22:32,130 --> 00:22:35,029 to be either a priestess or a shaman." 224 00:22:35,130 --> 00:22:41,029 And if I were a priestess or a shaman in a secular state... 225 00:22:41,130 --> 00:22:44,404 my legal work wouldn't be diminished. 226 00:22:44,505 --> 00:22:47,362 A secular state is not an atheist state. 227 00:22:47,463 --> 00:22:50,029 It's a state which allows... 228 00:22:50,130 --> 00:22:54,529 all religions to coexist peacefully. 229 00:22:54,630 --> 00:23:00,237 If I was a priestess or a catechism teacher... 230 00:23:00,338 --> 00:23:04,195 I'd be honored to verify it. But I'm not those things. 231 00:23:04,296 --> 00:23:06,995 I'm just a law professor. 232 00:23:07,963 --> 00:23:09,954 And in a republic... 233 00:23:12,755 --> 00:23:15,120 this is the sacred book. 234 00:23:16,505 --> 00:23:19,404 This is the sacred book which allows... 235 00:23:19,505 --> 00:23:24,204 every other sacred book to be respected and coexist. 236 00:23:28,130 --> 00:23:31,495 What I want is that the little children... 237 00:23:34,421 --> 00:23:38,954 the little Brazilians who can hear me... 238 00:23:39,921 --> 00:23:43,120 I want them to believe... 239 00:23:44,296 --> 00:23:49,029 this sacred book is worth fighting for... 240 00:23:49,130 --> 00:23:52,329 PT never signed this book! 241 00:23:58,796 --> 00:24:04,829 I pass the floor to Jose Eduardo Cardozo, Attorney General of the Union. 242 00:24:07,963 --> 00:24:10,029 This impeachment trial... 243 00:24:10,130 --> 00:24:12,904 does not comply with the Constitution. 244 00:24:13,005 --> 00:24:16,362 There's no impeachable offense, it was a pretext... 245 00:24:16,463 --> 00:24:20,529 a glaring illegality in the proceedings in the House... 246 00:24:20,630 --> 00:24:26,579 and if this impeachment is carried out, it will be a coup. 247 00:24:27,463 --> 00:24:31,987 It's notorious and thoroughly recorded by the press... 248 00:24:32,088 --> 00:24:35,195 and if it's notorious, it doesn't require proof... 249 00:24:35,296 --> 00:24:38,695 that Speaker Cunha began this action... 250 00:24:38,796 --> 00:24:42,362 the very second after the Workers' Party... 251 00:24:42,463 --> 00:24:47,987 denied him the votes he needed to elude the Ethics Committee. 252 00:24:48,088 --> 00:24:50,862 He was the subject of proceedings... 253 00:24:50,963 --> 00:24:55,820 lost the support of the opposition, which was publicly against him.. 254 00:24:55,921 --> 00:25:00,862 and, as the press reported several days earlier... 255 00:25:00,963 --> 00:25:06,529 he threatened the Government. "Give me the votes I need... 256 00:25:06,630 --> 00:25:09,195 or I'll start the impeachment." 257 00:25:09,296 --> 00:25:11,195 PT turned him down... 258 00:25:11,296 --> 00:25:15,362 and he immediately started the impeachment. 259 00:25:15,463 --> 00:25:19,695 Secondly, there's no criminal intent because there's no action. 260 00:25:19,796 --> 00:25:25,695 The Farm Subsidies are managed by the Minister of Finance, not the President! 261 00:25:25,796 --> 00:25:29,320 How do the plaintiffs overcome this? 262 00:25:29,421 --> 00:25:35,862 First, they said the President had frequent conversations with Arnon. 263 00:25:35,963 --> 00:25:39,529 Are conversations a legal fact? 264 00:25:39,630 --> 00:25:42,695 If I talk to a senator and he murders someone... 265 00:25:42,796 --> 00:25:46,737 will I be an accessory? 266 00:25:46,838 --> 00:25:49,695 Where do you get this kind of thing? 267 00:25:49,796 --> 00:25:53,695 To deem a conversation a legal fact? 268 00:25:53,796 --> 00:25:58,029 They don't know its content. It was based on a news article... 269 00:25:58,130 --> 00:26:02,654 which reported that she and the treasury secretary talked. 270 00:26:02,755 --> 00:26:07,195 On top of it, they say: Listen to the alternative. 271 00:26:07,296 --> 00:26:10,695 If it's not this, it's omission. 272 00:26:10,796 --> 00:26:15,529 Omission? To have a situation of omission, 273 00:26:15,630 --> 00:26:19,904 a specific duty must be neglected, and did this happen? No. 274 00:26:20,005 --> 00:26:25,570 They use Article 84 of the Constitution to say the President manages everything. 275 00:26:25,671 --> 00:26:30,529 So I can impeach her if someone steals a stapler. 276 00:26:30,630 --> 00:26:32,237 Is that right? 277 00:26:32,338 --> 00:26:35,695 It's the President's duty... 278 00:26:35,796 --> 00:26:39,737 to manage the top layers of the federal administration. 279 00:26:39,838 --> 00:26:46,654 And we are discussing the upper management of Brazilian state... 280 00:26:46,755 --> 00:26:53,454 where, for some years, a wicked, irresponsible management... 281 00:26:53,755 --> 00:26:58,195 led Brazil into the worst crisis ever. 282 00:26:58,296 --> 00:27:06,029 It was all part of a large scheme, or a great fiscal fraud... 283 00:27:06,130 --> 00:27:12,862 perpetrated deliberately by the Government to try to win the 2014 elections. 284 00:27:12,963 --> 00:27:16,829 It's not just a set of mistakes, 285 00:27:17,130 --> 00:27:19,620 but a complete destruction. 286 00:27:20,296 --> 00:27:24,029 We're discussing this destruction. 287 00:27:24,130 --> 00:27:28,487 It was all prepared with the knowledge and authorization... 288 00:27:28,588 --> 00:27:32,195 of the President, who lied to the Brazilian people. 289 00:27:32,296 --> 00:27:37,695 I confess, I don't know if President Dilma Rousseff is honest. 290 00:27:37,796 --> 00:27:40,370 But I'm sure she lies. 291 00:27:40,796 --> 00:27:45,570 Do you know how to remove a President? 292 00:27:45,671 --> 00:27:48,820 With elections. You go on TV and say... 293 00:27:48,921 --> 00:27:51,737 "Dilma ruined us. Don't vote for PT." 294 00:27:51,838 --> 00:27:56,695 But in order to impeach her, there must be a legal reason! 295 00:27:56,796 --> 00:28:00,829 All the literature and case law states that! 296 00:28:04,032 --> 00:28:05,437 May 5th, 2016. 297 00:28:05,538 --> 00:28:10,067 House Speaker Eduardo Cunha is removed by the Supreme Court 298 00:28:10,168 --> 00:28:16,181 on charges of corruption and obstruction of justice in "Operation Car Wash", 299 00:28:16,282 --> 00:28:20,818 which investigates the corruption scheme at Petrobras. 300 00:29:07,221 --> 00:29:09,495 I agree with your assessment. 301 00:29:09,596 --> 00:29:15,995 Brazil was already expecting the removal of the House Speaker... 302 00:29:16,096 --> 00:29:18,495 but it was too late. 303 00:29:18,596 --> 00:29:23,704 We could have avoided most of these crises. 304 00:29:23,805 --> 00:29:30,162 Not just the President's impeachment but the intentionally harmful bills... 305 00:29:30,263 --> 00:29:35,995 the delays on votes for crucial measures to our economy. 306 00:29:36,096 --> 00:29:41,120 We could have avoided many things that led the country to this. 307 00:29:41,221 --> 00:29:46,162 It is clearly a good thing for Vice-President Michel Temer, 308 00:29:46,263 --> 00:29:52,204 because the Speaker of the House would replace him 309 00:29:52,305 --> 00:29:55,662 if he was removed from office. 310 00:29:55,763 --> 00:30:01,995 It eliminates the possibility of us having as President... 311 00:30:02,096 --> 00:30:07,129 someone as compromised as Speaker Eduardo Cunha. 312 00:30:14,430 --> 00:30:18,629 Thank you. My best to everyone at Radio Nacional. 313 00:30:19,430 --> 00:30:21,295 Have a nice day. 314 00:30:26,430 --> 00:30:28,045 Good morning. 315 00:30:32,471 --> 00:30:34,545 Good morning, how are you? 316 00:30:41,763 --> 00:30:45,295 Good morning, how are you? 317 00:30:49,721 --> 00:30:54,995 The fact that I conducted the session, which culminated in the voting... 318 00:30:55,096 --> 00:30:58,495 led to an expected reaction. 319 00:30:58,596 --> 00:31:05,537 From then on, they convinced everyone to take me to trial in their company. 320 00:31:05,638 --> 00:31:08,329 But this will end next Wednesday. 321 00:31:08,430 --> 00:31:14,662 If it is God's will, the President will be removed and consequently tried. 322 00:31:14,763 --> 00:31:16,662 Are you not going to resign? 323 00:31:16,763 --> 00:31:18,829 No, I will not resign. 324 00:31:18,930 --> 00:31:20,870 The mandate or... 325 00:31:20,971 --> 00:31:23,954 Neither the mandate nor as House Speaker. 326 00:31:24,055 --> 00:31:26,995 I will appeal, and I hope to succeed. 327 00:31:27,096 --> 00:31:29,962 Thank you! 328 00:31:32,763 --> 00:31:39,962 Cunha, you thief, your place is in jail! 329 00:31:49,971 --> 00:31:51,620 Is that it? 330 00:31:51,721 --> 00:31:55,120 Do you mind if we shoot a video for Londrina? 331 00:31:55,221 --> 00:31:58,295 Ready? Is it recording? 332 00:31:58,763 --> 00:32:03,454 Hi, I'm Felipe Barros here in Brasilia... 333 00:32:03,555 --> 00:32:06,454 with the great Jana�na Paschoal... 334 00:32:06,555 --> 00:32:09,037 who has been brave and fearless. 335 00:32:09,138 --> 00:32:13,287 An excellent lawyer, moving the impeachment forward... 336 00:32:13,388 --> 00:32:17,829 for us to remove President Dilma and all those criminals. 337 00:32:17,930 --> 00:32:20,954 Can you send a message to Londrina? 338 00:32:21,055 --> 00:32:24,329 Hi, everyone. Thanks for your support... 339 00:32:24,430 --> 00:32:27,662 for your positive thoughts and prayers. 340 00:32:27,763 --> 00:32:35,537 The most important part is not to win, but what takes place during this trial. 341 00:32:35,638 --> 00:32:40,454 People should see that they're powerful and capable. 342 00:32:40,555 --> 00:32:45,287 They shouldn't give authorities control over our fate... 343 00:32:45,388 --> 00:32:47,662 and just accept everything. 344 00:32:47,763 --> 00:32:52,495 Young people should study hard and enter politics. 345 00:32:52,596 --> 00:32:56,329 Politics is about doing good for others. 346 00:32:56,430 --> 00:33:00,829 We need to change the concepts of our society. 347 00:33:00,930 --> 00:33:02,995 It's a time for renewal. 348 00:33:03,096 --> 00:33:07,787 All my best to Londrina, God bless you. 349 00:33:07,888 --> 00:33:11,162 Thank you very much. Congratulations. 350 00:33:11,263 --> 00:33:13,620 - Thank you. - I've been praying for you. 351 00:33:13,721 --> 00:33:15,254 Thank you very much. 352 00:33:25,930 --> 00:33:29,162 Think about what you would ask. 353 00:33:29,263 --> 00:33:31,962 I made a note there. 354 00:34:42,263 --> 00:34:47,995 Notwithstanding political differences, I believe senators should have... 355 00:34:48,096 --> 00:34:54,204 respectful relationships with their peers but mainly, a commitment to the truth. 356 00:34:54,305 --> 00:35:00,870 I take seriously the issue with the post I saw this morning... 357 00:35:00,971 --> 00:35:06,287 which attributed to A�cio Neves words he never spoke... 358 00:35:06,388 --> 00:35:13,662 in circumstances which never happened. I believe it was an unfortunate oversight... 359 00:35:13,763 --> 00:35:16,329 by Senator Lindbergh's advisers... 360 00:35:16,430 --> 00:35:20,287 since it was posted on his page. 361 00:35:20,388 --> 00:35:25,370 I posted about Senator A�cio Neves and the taking away of labor rights... 362 00:35:25,471 --> 00:35:29,329 and the senator won't be able to hide it. 363 00:35:29,430 --> 00:35:32,795 You're reiterating your insult! 364 00:35:32,896 --> 00:35:35,079 I want my time! 365 00:35:35,430 --> 00:35:37,620 You're repeating... 366 00:35:37,721 --> 00:35:39,620 - I want my time. - The lie... 367 00:35:39,721 --> 00:35:42,329 posted on your page. 368 00:35:42,430 --> 00:35:46,162 If your advisers did it, they're accomplices! 369 00:35:46,263 --> 00:35:48,662 Let him speak! 370 00:35:48,763 --> 00:35:50,454 I've heard it... 371 00:35:50,555 --> 00:35:54,579 I asked them to replace the buzzer. 372 00:35:54,680 --> 00:35:57,870 It's not worthy of this impeachment committee. 373 00:35:57,971 --> 00:35:59,545 I just want my time. 374 00:36:01,055 --> 00:36:05,454 The session is adjourned for 5 minutes to replace the buzzer. 375 00:36:05,555 --> 00:36:09,420 It's not worthy of this historic moment. 376 00:36:55,430 --> 00:37:01,162 I'd like Senator Lindbergh to have the floor all to himself. 377 00:37:01,263 --> 00:37:09,162 That senator can't hide from Brazil the fact that this is a parliamentary coup... 378 00:37:09,263 --> 00:37:12,495 because there's no impeachable offense. 379 00:37:12,596 --> 00:37:20,329 Your excellency should stick to the subject at hand. 380 00:37:20,430 --> 00:37:22,995 The subject is labor rights. 381 00:37:23,096 --> 00:37:27,662 This is "Bridge to the Future", by Vice-President Michel Temer... 382 00:37:27,763 --> 00:37:30,595 He has the right to speak! 383 00:37:30,696 --> 00:37:32,829 Point of order! 384 00:37:32,930 --> 00:37:35,829 You're an arrogant opportunist! 385 00:37:35,930 --> 00:37:39,329 - Your Excellency, calm down! - I'm too calm. 386 00:37:39,430 --> 00:37:44,162 - Recompose yourself. - Senator Lindbergh Farias has the floor. 387 00:37:44,263 --> 00:37:48,995 It's in "Bridge to the Future" I'm not making it up. 388 00:37:49,096 --> 00:37:51,579 "No more minimum wage policies." 389 00:37:51,680 --> 00:37:54,995 "No more indexing it to welfare." 390 00:37:55,096 --> 00:37:59,454 You will answer to the Ethics Committee for your insult! 391 00:37:59,555 --> 00:38:02,870 Is it an insult to say A�cio and Temer... 392 00:38:02,971 --> 00:38:05,995 want to take away labor rights? 393 00:38:06,096 --> 00:38:09,495 "Bridge to the Future" destroys the legacies... 394 00:38:09,596 --> 00:38:13,370 of Presidents Lula and Get�lio Vargas. 395 00:38:13,471 --> 00:38:18,829 They want to privatize everything, to give our reserves to big oil companies. 396 00:38:18,930 --> 00:38:21,662 They'll end the sharing of oil revenues. 397 00:38:21,763 --> 00:38:25,662 They want to make concessions. 398 00:38:25,763 --> 00:38:32,162 They don't want to hear about BRICS or Mercosur. 399 00:38:32,263 --> 00:38:37,787 They want to realign our foreign policy with North-American interests... 400 00:38:37,888 --> 00:38:41,162 this is why they're attempting a coup... 401 00:38:41,263 --> 00:38:45,954 because nobody would be elected President with this program! 402 00:38:46,055 --> 00:38:50,329 If social programs are at risk today... 403 00:38:50,430 --> 00:38:56,329 it's because they're leaving us a country in shambles. 404 00:38:56,430 --> 00:39:03,037 If labor rights are being abolished... 405 00:39:03,138 --> 00:39:08,995 it's because our country has 11,100,000 unemployed. 406 00:39:09,096 --> 00:39:14,662 We can either make a quick decision... 407 00:39:14,763 --> 00:39:19,995 while following the proceedings determined by the Supreme Court... 408 00:39:20,096 --> 00:39:24,204 or face the steadily worsening conditions... 409 00:39:24,305 --> 00:39:29,329 of the country's political and economic landscape. 410 00:39:29,430 --> 00:39:34,329 We will now vote on Senator Anastasia's report. 411 00:39:34,430 --> 00:39:40,795 The senators can vote with the electronic voting system. 412 00:39:47,596 --> 00:39:50,995 What is the result, Mr. President? 413 00:39:51,096 --> 00:39:53,704 - Open it up. - Let's see the results. 414 00:39:53,805 --> 00:39:56,795 Has everyone voted? 415 00:39:57,888 --> 00:40:00,129 The results. 416 00:40:02,596 --> 00:40:05,012 The official results are 417 00:40:05,113 --> 00:40:08,495 Yes, 15. No, 5. 418 00:40:08,596 --> 00:40:11,120 The voting is closed. 419 00:40:11,221 --> 00:40:18,337 The Committee voted to accept the accusation. 420 00:40:23,115 --> 00:40:27,489 May 12th, 2016. The Senate Committee accepts the charges. 421 00:40:27,590 --> 00:40:31,201 Rousseff is suspended from office for 180 days. 422 00:40:31,302 --> 00:40:35,584 Vice President Michel Temer assumes the presidency. 423 00:40:37,930 --> 00:40:44,962 Dilma, a fighter for the Brazilian nation! 424 00:40:52,805 --> 00:40:59,287 Temer out! Temer out! 425 00:40:59,388 --> 00:41:02,329 One, two, three, four, five! 426 00:41:02,430 --> 00:41:05,662 Stop this coup or we will stop Brazil! 427 00:41:05,763 --> 00:41:08,870 One, two, three, four, five! 428 00:41:08,971 --> 00:41:12,462 Stop this coup or we will stop Brazil! 429 00:41:15,930 --> 00:41:23,879 Dilma, a fighter for the Brazilian nation! 430 00:41:28,263 --> 00:41:34,254 Fate has always presented me with many challenges. 431 00:41:35,055 --> 00:41:38,162 They were many and they were great. 432 00:41:38,263 --> 00:41:43,620 Some seemed insurmountable. 433 00:41:43,721 --> 00:41:46,662 But I managed to overcome them. 434 00:41:46,763 --> 00:41:51,246 I've suffered the indescribable pain of torture, 435 00:41:51,347 --> 00:41:54,495 the agonizing pain of illness... 436 00:41:54,596 --> 00:41:59,254 and now I suffer, once again... 437 00:41:59,805 --> 00:42:04,920 the equally unspeakable pain of injustice. 438 00:42:05,430 --> 00:42:09,254 What hurts the most right now is the injustice... 439 00:42:09,596 --> 00:42:17,254 realizing I'm a victim of a legal and political farce. 440 00:42:26,638 --> 00:42:33,370 Prosecutor Janot is after you and he thinks I'll help. 441 00:42:33,471 --> 00:42:38,329 We need a new Government to stop this bleeding. 442 00:42:38,430 --> 00:42:43,662 The easiest solution would be to put Vice-President Michel. 443 00:42:43,763 --> 00:42:46,204 Renan is the only one against it! 444 00:42:46,305 --> 00:42:49,162 He doesn't like Michel, who's with Cunha. 445 00:42:49,263 --> 00:42:51,829 Forget Cunha. He's as good as dead. 446 00:42:51,930 --> 00:42:56,954 We need to put Michel up there, with a great national pact. 447 00:42:57,055 --> 00:43:00,204 - With the Supreme Court and all. - It would stop it. 448 00:43:00,305 --> 00:43:03,879 Right, it would stop where it is. 449 00:43:05,763 --> 00:43:08,204 "A pact with the Supreme Court and all." 450 00:43:08,305 --> 00:43:11,829 Sergio Machado says, "It would stop it." 451 00:43:11,930 --> 00:43:16,370 Juc� continues, "It would stop where it is." 452 00:43:16,471 --> 00:43:20,329 It continues, there's more. Senator Juc� says, 453 00:43:20,430 --> 00:43:23,329 "I talked to some Supreme Court Justices." 454 00:43:23,430 --> 00:43:26,620 He must tell us who those Justices are. 455 00:43:26,721 --> 00:43:30,995 "They said it's only possible without her there. 456 00:43:31,096 --> 00:43:36,162 While she's there, the press, the guys will want to get her out. 457 00:43:36,263 --> 00:43:39,370 This thing will never end." 458 00:43:39,471 --> 00:43:45,162 It is clear that their objective is to stop the Car Wash investigation. 459 00:43:45,263 --> 00:43:48,662 It is a denial of due process... 460 00:43:48,763 --> 00:43:55,037 to prevent those recordings from reaching this Impeachment Committee. 461 00:43:55,138 --> 00:43:58,954 It so happens that those recordings don't interfere... 462 00:43:59,055 --> 00:44:02,204 directly or indirectly, with the impeachment. 463 00:44:02,305 --> 00:44:09,662 After all, we were defeated on the thesis that we should consider... 464 00:44:09,763 --> 00:44:12,995 operation Car Wash in our debates. 465 00:44:13,096 --> 00:44:17,454 These tapes aren't being brought in to discuss Car Wash... 466 00:44:17,555 --> 00:44:20,454 but to show they want the impeachment 467 00:44:20,555 --> 00:44:25,120 to remove a President who protected the investigation. 468 00:44:25,221 --> 00:44:29,995 Furthermore, it's curious how Senator Anastasia refers... 469 00:44:30,096 --> 00:44:33,870 to the examination of the Court of Auditors, 470 00:44:33,971 --> 00:44:41,870 "A request for international audit wouldn't be efficient as the defense requests... 471 00:44:41,971 --> 00:44:45,870 since that task has already been carried out." 472 00:44:45,971 --> 00:44:49,162 The Court of Auditors didn't do that. 473 00:44:49,263 --> 00:44:52,495 The accounts weren't even the object of a report. 474 00:44:52,596 --> 00:44:54,995 The report claims... 475 00:44:55,096 --> 00:44:59,329 the Court of Auditors has done something it hasn't. 476 00:44:59,430 --> 00:45:05,329 And I can't debate this. I can't discuss each request... 477 00:45:05,430 --> 00:45:10,954 or the witnesses brought in by the prosecution. 478 00:45:11,055 --> 00:45:15,620 I can't prove anything. All I can do is speak. 479 00:45:15,721 --> 00:45:20,537 So I speak, and I analyze 80 requests in ten minutes. 480 00:45:20,638 --> 00:45:25,329 I tell you the President's right of defense... 481 00:45:25,430 --> 00:45:30,495 has had its substance replaced by form, because form guarantees appearances. 482 00:45:30,596 --> 00:45:35,162 As someone said, "It's not a coup, due process is assured." 483 00:45:35,263 --> 00:45:40,287 Due process doesn't mean the right of defense has substance. 484 00:45:40,388 --> 00:45:46,670 It gives apparent legitimacy to something illegitimate. 485 00:46:31,180 --> 00:46:33,995 It's absurd not to have an expert examination. 486 00:46:34,096 --> 00:46:39,037 We have the testimony of one prosecutor. 487 00:46:39,138 --> 00:46:45,620 But the Government didn't even inform the Court about the facts. 488 00:46:45,721 --> 00:46:50,504 Practically every point we bring up is rejected. 489 00:46:50,930 --> 00:46:54,829 The people are curious, and they ask... 490 00:46:54,930 --> 00:46:58,162 "Why do you keep insisting? 491 00:46:58,263 --> 00:47:02,120 You lose almost every time." 492 00:47:02,221 --> 00:47:07,495 I am concerned about how the population sees this... 493 00:47:07,596 --> 00:47:12,162 considering how the press publishes it. 494 00:47:12,263 --> 00:47:18,662 It might become even more discouraging. 495 00:47:18,763 --> 00:47:24,995 I'd like you to consider if it's not adequate to tone it down. 496 00:47:25,096 --> 00:47:30,662 - But why? - One thing is the political debate... 497 00:47:30,763 --> 00:47:33,329 and another is to stall like this. 498 00:47:33,430 --> 00:47:38,995 We know we'll lose at the committee. But we have to resist. 499 00:47:39,096 --> 00:47:43,537 If we get soft, they'll get it done before they expected... 500 00:47:43,638 --> 00:47:49,787 and we need time for politics. We need to do whatever we can. 501 00:47:49,888 --> 00:47:54,829 Present appeals, petitions, points of order. 502 00:47:54,930 --> 00:47:57,787 And if we have more people, all the better. 503 00:47:57,888 --> 00:48:00,870 Other people can speak too. 504 00:48:00,971 --> 00:48:03,995 You might be right about Justice Lewandowski. 505 00:48:04,096 --> 00:48:08,537 When he denies something, it's a strong statement. 506 00:48:08,638 --> 00:48:11,704 So we need to be foolproof. 507 00:48:11,805 --> 00:48:19,454 If we need the expert examination, let's consider our appeals. 508 00:48:19,555 --> 00:48:24,495 And in everything we do, we need to explain... 509 00:48:24,596 --> 00:48:29,662 that the President is being denied her right of defense. 510 00:48:29,763 --> 00:48:34,037 I don't think that, when we present an appeal... 511 00:48:34,138 --> 00:48:40,995 and it is denied, we're legitimizing the process. 512 00:48:41,096 --> 00:48:45,495 They started presenting appeals too... 513 00:48:45,596 --> 00:48:48,995 so that Lewandowski denies theirs as well. 514 00:48:49,096 --> 00:48:51,662 We need to consider again. 515 00:48:51,763 --> 00:48:55,620 - I disagree. - If we're denied, we legitimize it. 516 00:48:55,721 --> 00:48:57,662 But the witness? 517 00:48:57,763 --> 00:49:01,495 It would be bad to lose. 518 00:49:01,596 --> 00:49:04,162 We'll end up legitimizing it. 519 00:49:04,263 --> 00:49:07,787 Let's talk later. 520 00:49:07,888 --> 00:49:11,037 I'm not sure if these strategies are the best. 521 00:49:11,138 --> 00:49:16,962 Well suspend it. We'll make a second appeal. 522 00:49:28,721 --> 00:49:31,454 Her nickname is Penelope Pitstop. 523 00:49:31,555 --> 00:49:34,129 It's perfect. 524 00:49:42,930 --> 00:49:46,295 She is known as Penelope Pitstop. 525 00:50:36,471 --> 00:50:39,037 Congress is so beautiful. 526 00:50:39,138 --> 00:50:43,704 It is the most beautiful building in Bras�lia. 527 00:50:43,805 --> 00:50:47,829 - Is that the Senate? - The House. 528 00:50:47,930 --> 00:50:50,787 - We were there? - The Senate is there. 529 00:50:50,888 --> 00:50:56,087 No, those are the offices. 530 00:51:35,763 --> 00:51:40,129 Come, F�tima. 531 00:51:47,430 --> 00:51:51,295 Good evening. 532 00:51:54,638 --> 00:51:58,995 People want to end this process very quickly... 533 00:51:59,096 --> 00:52:03,870 It seems the clock is ticking. I don't know what's behind it. 534 00:52:03,971 --> 00:52:10,495 Some might fear new facts may bring imbalance to the trial. 535 00:52:10,596 --> 00:52:17,162 Can an eventual accusation bring problems? We don't have that concern. 536 00:52:17,263 --> 00:52:22,537 We want a fair, balanced trial. Justice Lewandowski will decide the date... 537 00:52:22,638 --> 00:52:26,754 but this cannot be done in haste. 538 00:53:20,471 --> 00:53:22,587 Hi, dear. I'm Carol Proner. 539 00:53:32,305 --> 00:53:35,704 In France, where I am a senator... 540 00:53:35,805 --> 00:53:40,537 the expression "institutional coup d'etat"... 541 00:53:40,638 --> 00:53:47,995 when we refer to Brazil, is also rejected by some politicians... 542 00:53:48,096 --> 00:53:52,037 and what makes me "sadder", and this is a euphemism... 543 00:53:52,138 --> 00:53:54,870 is the fact that, unfortunately... 544 00:53:54,971 --> 00:53:59,670 the French Government has not shown its support. 545 00:54:00,471 --> 00:54:05,329 And I must confess that the French press also finds difficulties... 546 00:54:05,430 --> 00:54:09,745 because there are few independent media in France... 547 00:54:09,846 --> 00:54:13,912 as here, but I must admit that the French media today... 548 00:54:14,013 --> 00:54:18,037 I am sorry for that, is more focused on the Olympics... 549 00:54:18,138 --> 00:54:21,495 and the Government remains silent. 550 00:54:21,596 --> 00:54:23,370 Thank you, madam. 551 00:54:23,471 --> 00:54:27,037 This may come as a surprise, but recently.. 552 00:54:27,138 --> 00:54:36,704 in a conversation with a deputy. I was struck when told me... 553 00:54:36,805 --> 00:54:41,462 that he thought I was a cold, calculating, insensitive person. 554 00:54:43,096 --> 00:54:48,537 Because I did not resign and I'm not sure why. 555 00:54:48,638 --> 00:54:53,037 This version given by the media has been incorporated. 556 00:54:53,138 --> 00:54:55,829 But the media has another version too. 557 00:54:55,930 --> 00:55:00,795 Which is very common when it comes to us women. 558 00:55:00,930 --> 00:55:05,537 That I was out of my mind... 559 00:55:05,638 --> 00:55:10,370 taking prescription medicine. 560 00:55:10,471 --> 00:55:15,495 I'm not on meds and I'm not out of my mind. 561 00:55:15,596 --> 00:55:19,037 So they don't get it right. 562 00:55:19,138 --> 00:55:21,704 The version oscillates. 563 00:55:21,805 --> 00:55:26,995 I am either cold and insensitive because I don't resign. 564 00:55:27,096 --> 00:55:29,662 I don't cry and I don't play the victim... 565 00:55:29,763 --> 00:55:32,962 or I'm having a nervous breakdown 566 00:55:35,846 --> 00:55:38,004 Thank you. 567 00:55:42,763 --> 00:55:45,129 Come on, Carol. 568 00:55:46,305 --> 00:55:48,704 Come on, Madam Senator. 569 00:55:48,805 --> 00:55:52,162 The denial of things is typical of coups. 570 00:55:52,263 --> 00:55:59,079 In Brazil, for a long time, we political prisoners did not exist. 571 00:55:59,180 --> 00:56:04,870 "No. There are no political prisoners in Brazil." And we were in jail. 572 00:56:04,971 --> 00:56:07,745 That was our struggle. 573 00:56:07,846 --> 00:56:10,629 Yes, so that we could exist. 574 00:56:10,971 --> 00:56:16,370 We are on the right side and we will win as we did then. 575 00:56:16,471 --> 00:56:20,662 Back then there was no Internet. It took twenty years. 576 00:56:20,763 --> 00:56:22,962 Now we have the Internet. 577 00:56:25,471 --> 00:56:28,587 Take a picture with my cell phone. 578 00:56:36,596 --> 00:56:38,829 I'm counting on you. 579 00:56:38,930 --> 00:56:41,537 Requi�o, if they don't absolve me... 580 00:56:41,638 --> 00:56:44,004 You'll have to get on board! 581 00:57:15,323 --> 00:57:16,971 June 14th, 2016. 582 00:57:17,072 --> 00:57:23,045 Congressional Ethics Committee votes to expel House Speaker 583 00:57:23,146 --> 00:57:27,878 Eduardo Cunha from the Chamber of Deputies. 584 00:57:30,430 --> 00:57:33,412 PT imagines I did this to get back at them... 585 00:57:33,513 --> 00:57:37,245 as they didn't support me in the Ethics Committee. 586 00:57:37,346 --> 00:57:42,870 I met the chief of staff three times... 587 00:57:42,971 --> 00:57:49,037 and every time Jaques Wagner offered the PT votes... 588 00:57:49,138 --> 00:57:53,495 in the Ethics Committee. He even offered... 589 00:57:53,596 --> 00:57:57,829 to keep my wife and daughter out of this... 590 00:57:57,930 --> 00:58:01,370 since they were under a separate investigation. 591 00:58:01,471 --> 00:58:07,204 The Government offered the votes from PT. I didn't ask. 592 00:58:07,305 --> 00:58:11,870 Not only did it sound like blackmail, it involved my family. 593 00:58:11,971 --> 00:58:16,079 I didn't think they had that prerogative. 594 00:58:16,180 --> 00:58:19,412 Why didn't you report it when it happened... 595 00:58:19,513 --> 00:58:24,870 as should be done by a politician as righteous as you claim to be? 596 00:58:24,971 --> 00:58:28,662 Because I refused it. 597 00:58:28,763 --> 00:58:33,370 It's part of politics, of political conversations. 598 00:58:33,471 --> 00:58:37,662 There's a rumor you could consider a plea bargain... 599 00:58:37,763 --> 00:58:42,704 to decrease your wife's possible sentence. 600 00:58:42,805 --> 00:58:46,662 I didn't commit any crime, I have nothing to say. 601 00:58:46,763 --> 00:58:50,662 I have nothing on me or on anyone else. 602 00:58:50,763 --> 00:58:53,495 I'm from "Correio Brasiliense". 603 00:58:53,596 --> 00:58:56,995 You're a defendant at the Supreme Court... 604 00:58:57,096 --> 00:59:01,745 in the Car Wash investigations, accused of taking bribes abroad... 605 00:59:01,846 --> 00:59:05,579 and having secret accounts. 606 00:59:05,680 --> 00:59:10,162 You lied to the investigators. 607 00:59:10,263 --> 00:59:14,329 Do you really think you have political... 608 00:59:14,430 --> 00:59:19,662 ethical and moral authority to continue as Speaker of the House? 609 00:59:19,763 --> 00:59:22,495 You're making a political speech. 610 00:59:22,596 --> 00:59:26,162 It's a question... 611 00:59:26,263 --> 00:59:28,754 I won't answer. Next. 612 00:59:31,180 --> 00:59:40,662 Vice-President Temer must dirty his hands to try and save Cunha's neck. 613 00:59:40,763 --> 00:59:44,537 If he's removed from office, Temer is going down. 614 00:59:44,638 --> 00:59:51,079 Cunha is destructive. He's concerned with his wife. 615 00:59:51,180 --> 00:59:54,495 He's desperate about his wife and daughter. 616 00:59:54,596 --> 01:00:02,870 - He will inform on anyone. - Judge Moro blocked his assets. 617 01:00:02,971 --> 01:00:06,079 - Now? - Half an hour ago. 618 01:00:06,180 --> 01:00:10,745 In Congress, the mood is one of expectation. 619 01:00:10,846 --> 01:00:16,920 Nobody knows what will happen. Even Marina was mentioned today. 620 01:00:19,096 --> 01:00:23,579 And we're not having it easy either. 621 01:00:23,680 --> 01:00:27,254 Not at all! 622 01:00:29,096 --> 01:00:35,829 We only see their misfortunes, but what about us? What about Lula? 623 01:00:35,930 --> 01:00:39,745 PT's reputation has already been damaged enough... 624 01:00:39,846 --> 01:00:44,537 even though it can get worse. They might arrest Lula. 625 01:00:44,638 --> 01:00:48,877 The country's reaction might be strong, 626 01:00:48,978 --> 01:00:53,870 but it can be really bad if Lula is arrested. 627 01:00:53,971 --> 01:00:58,912 They can try to convict Lula... 628 01:00:59,013 --> 01:01:05,162 to prevent him from joining the elections. 629 01:01:05,263 --> 01:01:08,337 In all likelihood... 630 01:01:08,471 --> 01:01:14,662 plea bargains will do more harm to them than to us. 631 01:01:14,763 --> 01:01:17,662 At least we have that. 632 01:01:17,763 --> 01:01:21,495 Cunha's downfall benefits us a lot more. 633 01:01:21,596 --> 01:01:25,245 There's a good side to them being targeted. 634 01:01:25,346 --> 01:01:30,995 It shows it's systemic. 635 01:01:31,096 --> 01:01:35,745 The feeling the people might have in a couple of months is: 636 01:01:35,846 --> 01:01:38,995 "Screw them, they�re all corrupt!" 637 01:01:39,096 --> 01:01:42,162 It's in the last opinion poll. 638 01:01:42,263 --> 01:01:46,337 Everyone has low ratings, Lula and others. 639 01:01:46,513 --> 01:01:53,495 We need a political reform. After all the parties being hit. 640 01:01:53,596 --> 01:01:57,662 The people who took to the streets in 2013, and still do... 641 01:01:57,763 --> 01:02:01,662 aren't defending our Government... 642 01:02:01,763 --> 01:02:04,995 but opposing another movement... 643 01:02:05,096 --> 01:02:08,912 resisting the establishment, conservatism. 644 01:02:09,013 --> 01:02:12,662 The youth takes to the street, but not under our banner. 645 01:02:12,763 --> 01:02:17,495 Some are under Dilma's banner because it represents something... 646 01:02:17,596 --> 01:02:22,495 represents resistance, but we have no control. 647 01:02:22,596 --> 01:02:24,745 Just like the women's movement. 648 01:02:24,846 --> 01:02:29,662 Dilma, as much as she represents them, doesn't lead those women. 649 01:02:29,763 --> 01:02:36,662 Her Government was too conservative on some things... 650 01:02:36,763 --> 01:02:38,329 which was bad. 651 01:02:38,430 --> 01:02:41,995 We need to understand this movement... 652 01:02:42,096 --> 01:02:46,495 that's been resisting a conservative offensive. 653 01:02:46,596 --> 01:02:50,995 We shouldn't be separated from it, fighting only the impeachment. 654 01:02:51,096 --> 01:02:55,537 We can talk about a referendum that's great... 655 01:02:55,638 --> 01:02:58,829 but this is not their everyday lives. 656 01:02:58,930 --> 01:03:03,245 I agree that a referendum is the solution. 657 01:03:03,346 --> 01:03:05,495 Speaking candidly here. 658 01:03:05,596 --> 01:03:10,245 There's no governability if we go back to power. 659 01:03:10,346 --> 01:03:15,995 She doesn't have support here, no structure in the Government. 660 01:03:16,096 --> 01:03:20,370 We need to speak to the people. 661 01:03:20,471 --> 01:03:24,454 If we're not clear on what's at stake... 662 01:03:24,555 --> 01:03:30,420 if we don't align ourselves with civil society, we'll be adrift. 663 01:05:02,138 --> 01:05:06,495 Why did she commit an impeachable offense? 664 01:05:06,596 --> 01:05:13,120 She has issued additional budget decrees in conflict with the law... 665 01:05:13,221 --> 01:05:17,162 which authorizes those decrees under one condition. 666 01:05:17,263 --> 01:05:19,495 the annual budget must be met. 667 01:05:19,596 --> 01:05:25,495 The annual budget was not being met, and from the second half of the year... 668 01:05:25,596 --> 01:05:29,579 the Government began to count on a bill... 669 01:05:29,680 --> 01:05:33,662 that was still being processed by Congress... 670 01:05:33,763 --> 01:05:38,079 and which was only approved on December 3rd. 671 01:05:38,180 --> 01:05:42,745 And the biggest fiscal fraud in Brazilian history... 672 01:05:42,846 --> 01:05:50,412 when, using subterfuge, the Government obtains loans from State Banks 673 01:05:50,513 --> 01:05:55,212 which is forbidden by law. 674 01:06:07,888 --> 01:06:11,370 He replies: "The budget was approved by such law... 675 01:06:11,471 --> 01:06:18,162 and is Valid for 2015, with no stipulation for partial use of these values." 676 01:06:18,263 --> 01:06:22,579 They claim it's an impeachable offense... 677 01:06:22,680 --> 01:06:26,329 not due to the annual budget, but to the decree. 678 01:06:26,430 --> 01:06:28,370 He's wrong. 679 01:06:28,471 --> 01:06:31,662 That's why we need to dismantle it. 680 01:06:31,763 --> 01:06:36,162 It's so easy we can laugh in their faces. 681 01:06:36,263 --> 01:06:39,495 Are you out of your mind? 682 01:06:39,596 --> 01:06:44,495 You're saying she met the target at the end of the year... 683 01:06:44,596 --> 01:06:47,495 but when she signed the decree... 684 01:06:47,596 --> 01:06:52,162 the target was not being met. 685 01:06:52,263 --> 01:06:55,662 And she could only have done it through a law. 686 01:06:55,763 --> 01:06:59,037 How can I pass a law to break another law? 687 01:06:59,138 --> 01:07:06,245 The Budget Office says the target was met, as does the legal adviser. 688 01:07:06,346 --> 01:07:09,662 The Minister of Planning too. 689 01:07:09,763 --> 01:07:14,329 Besides, the experts say there was a presumption of legality... 690 01:07:14,430 --> 01:07:17,412 on behalf of the person who acted. 691 01:07:17,513 --> 01:07:22,162 Nobody thought it would be illegal... 692 01:07:22,263 --> 01:07:25,962 since it had been done for all those years. 693 01:07:26,096 --> 01:07:30,912 I have several documents: the Federal Budget Office... 694 01:07:31,013 --> 01:07:35,537 stating that the decree was compatible with the annual budget. 695 01:07:35,638 --> 01:07:39,329 In his reasons, the Minister of Planning... 696 01:07:39,430 --> 01:07:44,829 also said the decree was compatible with the budget. 697 01:07:44,930 --> 01:07:50,037 All agencies said it was compatible. The Minister, the Budget Office, 698 01:07:50,138 --> 01:07:53,462 the legal adviser, the chief of staff. 699 01:07:53,596 --> 01:07:58,245 I pass the floor to the Minister of Finance. 700 01:07:58,346 --> 01:08:01,667 These six decrees signed by the President 701 01:08:01,768 --> 01:08:05,495 at no time authorize the increase in expenses. 702 01:08:05,596 --> 01:08:09,495 They only modified the alternatives... 703 01:08:09,596 --> 01:08:12,495 on which the same amount could be spent. 704 01:08:12,596 --> 01:08:16,704 This was established in the contingency decree. 705 01:08:16,805 --> 01:08:23,412 Most of these funds went to the Ministry of Education. 706 01:08:23,513 --> 01:08:26,870 For instance, the Ministry of Education... 707 01:08:26,971 --> 01:08:32,579 requested this financial surplus to support early childhood education... 708 01:08:32,680 --> 01:08:36,829 as authorized by the Budget Law. 709 01:08:36,930 --> 01:08:44,704 Before the decrees were issued, the Government had cut expenses sharply. 710 01:08:44,805 --> 01:08:50,162 So we can't say that those decrees increased expenditures. 711 01:08:50,263 --> 01:08:57,495 On the contrary, those decrees came after a reduction of R$ 8.5 billion. 712 01:08:57,596 --> 01:09:04,704 They don't conflict the annual budget because they do not increase expenditure. 713 01:09:04,805 --> 01:09:08,162 Responding to inquiries by several senators... 714 01:09:08,263 --> 01:09:17,329 it's clear the Government deliberately used the approval of Bill 5... 715 01:09:17,430 --> 01:09:22,829 which characterizes a disregard for the Budget Law... 716 01:09:22,930 --> 01:09:28,412 therefore an impeachable offense since the Government approved a target... 717 01:09:28,513 --> 01:09:32,204 which was still being processed by Congress... 718 01:09:32,305 --> 01:09:38,745 and was only approved at the end of the year... 719 01:09:38,846 --> 01:09:42,204 as if to clean the crime scene. 720 01:09:42,305 --> 01:09:44,162 This is crazy. 721 01:09:44,263 --> 01:09:49,295 This is "The Trial" by Kafka, President Dilma is Joseph K... 722 01:09:49,430 --> 01:09:51,329 They can't prove anything. 723 01:09:51,430 --> 01:09:56,920 We don't spend one cent more with these budget decrees! 724 01:11:06,096 --> 01:11:10,995 The Federal Police had arrest and search warrants in five states. 725 01:11:11,096 --> 01:11:15,162 They also searched the flat of Senator Gleisi Hoffmann 726 01:11:15,263 --> 01:11:18,495 and her husband, former Minister Paulo Bernardo. 727 01:11:18,596 --> 01:11:23,162 He was arrested in Bras�lia and taken to S�o Paulo, 728 01:11:23,263 --> 01:11:27,495 where he will be held under preventive detention. 729 01:11:27,596 --> 01:11:32,329 According to the investigation, the law firm linked to Paulo Bernardo 730 01:11:32,430 --> 01:11:35,962 received about R$ 7 million from the scheme. 731 01:11:40,638 --> 01:11:44,704 What happened to my husband is inexplicable. 732 01:11:44,805 --> 01:11:49,662 If he was being investigated, why didn't they call him to testify? 733 01:11:49,763 --> 01:11:53,162 He never refused to do that. 734 01:11:53,263 --> 01:11:57,204 He has always been living with me in Bras�lia. 735 01:11:57,305 --> 01:12:00,995 They didn't have to spend money on helicopters, cars... 736 01:12:01,096 --> 01:12:06,162 and police equipment. They just had to summon him. 737 01:12:06,263 --> 01:12:10,329 If he had to go at that moment, he would go anyway. 738 01:12:10,430 --> 01:12:14,329 This investigation started one year ago. 739 01:12:14,430 --> 01:12:21,037 It's not as if his freedom would jeopardize the investigation. 740 01:12:21,138 --> 01:12:26,329 Nothing justifies his preventive detention. 741 01:12:26,430 --> 01:12:28,329 I didn't understand. 742 01:12:28,430 --> 01:12:34,129 We never refuse to testify. 743 01:12:48,096 --> 01:12:54,162 Within the Farm Subsidies, we have a program for family farming... 744 01:12:54,263 --> 01:12:57,662 which has been growing every year. 745 01:12:57,763 --> 01:13:02,995 In 2002, it was worth about R$ 2 billion. 746 01:13:03,096 --> 01:13:05,954 Since last year, 2015... 747 01:13:06,055 --> 01:13:10,495 this program has received up to R$ 30 billion. 748 01:13:10,596 --> 01:13:15,162 These are funds going into family farming. 749 01:13:15,263 --> 01:13:20,662 And there are Farm Subsidies, investing in corporate farming. 750 01:13:20,763 --> 01:13:25,287 The Government and the President don't take part. 751 01:13:25,388 --> 01:13:31,120 These funds are transferred from the Bank of Brazil to the farmers. 752 01:13:31,221 --> 01:13:35,662 It's a loan with subsidized interest... 753 01:13:35,763 --> 01:13:40,254 because agriculture worldwide deserves attention. 754 01:13:41,138 --> 01:13:47,204 The accusation states the accounting tricks were not just operational delays... 755 01:13:47,305 --> 01:13:50,829 as the debts accumulated for a long time... 756 01:13:50,930 --> 01:13:53,662 and became very large sums. 757 01:13:53,763 --> 01:13:59,870 They were true loan transactions prohibited by the Fiscal Law. 758 01:13:59,971 --> 01:14:05,495 The defense argues that the delays cannot be considered loans... 759 01:14:05,596 --> 01:14:10,537 because the money is lent to farmers, not to the Government. 760 01:14:10,638 --> 01:14:17,162 I consider it burdensome that the President... 761 01:14:17,263 --> 01:14:23,829 was aware of the irregularities that were being practiced. 762 01:14:23,930 --> 01:14:27,995 If I delay paying my family's supermarket bill... 763 01:14:28,096 --> 01:14:32,787 they're not lending me money. There's no loan contract. 764 01:14:32,888 --> 01:14:37,537 No money was transferred from the bank to the Treasury. 765 01:14:37,638 --> 01:14:41,329 The bank shifts the resource to the farmer... 766 01:14:41,430 --> 01:14:45,370 and the Treasury shifts the subsidy to the banks. 767 01:14:45,471 --> 01:14:49,454 What is a loan? What farmers do with the bank: 768 01:14:49,555 --> 01:14:53,329 they sign a contract, borrow money and grow their crop. 769 01:14:53,430 --> 01:15:00,629 Agriculture could be at risk if we were to regard farm subsidies as loans. 770 01:15:03,221 --> 01:15:07,454 Many people asked me if I would come back here... 771 01:15:07,555 --> 01:15:11,754 after my husband's arrest, and I said I would. 772 01:15:12,055 --> 01:15:18,495 I return with my head held high to defend President Dilma's mandate. 773 01:15:18,596 --> 01:15:21,787 And I'm pleased with the examination... 774 01:15:21,888 --> 01:15:27,662 regarding the so-called Bank of Brazil accounting tricks. 775 01:15:27,763 --> 01:15:32,162 Item seven states that the Ministry of Finance... 776 01:15:32,263 --> 01:15:38,495 doesn't define a deadline for payment to be made to the Bank of Brazil. 777 01:15:38,596 --> 01:15:41,662 If there's no deadline there's no delay. 778 01:15:41,763 --> 01:15:47,954 And item 12 states that nothing the president has done... 779 01:15:48,055 --> 01:15:53,995 contributed directly or indirectly to the delays. 780 01:15:54,096 --> 01:15:57,662 If there's no action, there's no criminal intent. 781 01:15:57,763 --> 01:16:01,829 I'd like to ask if the Ministry of Agriculture... 782 01:16:01,930 --> 01:16:05,870 was warned by the Bank of Brazil, the Court of Auditors... 783 01:16:05,971 --> 01:16:10,329 or any other supervisory agency about the defaulting... 784 01:16:10,430 --> 01:16:14,662 on the interests of these subsidies. 785 01:16:14,763 --> 01:16:20,587 Mr. Patrus Ananias has the floor as witness. Three minutes. 786 01:16:21,263 --> 01:16:23,495 Excuse me, please. 787 01:16:23,596 --> 01:16:26,162 Later you'll be given more time. 788 01:16:26,263 --> 01:16:29,037 I have to defend my honor. 789 01:16:29,138 --> 01:16:34,329 Your Excellency mentioned me after the committee on Friday. 790 01:16:34,430 --> 01:16:37,537 When I left here, journalists asked me... 791 01:16:37,638 --> 01:16:40,662 - You're talking about me? - Yes. 792 01:16:40,763 --> 01:16:44,829 - But... - It was Your Excellency. 793 01:16:44,930 --> 01:16:51,329 You were with me all morning and didn't bring it up. 794 01:16:51,430 --> 01:16:56,329 I didn't know what was being said about me around the Senate. 795 01:16:56,430 --> 01:17:01,037 A journalist asked me, "What do you think about the accusation?" 796 01:17:01,138 --> 01:17:02,704 "What accusation?" 797 01:17:02,805 --> 01:17:09,287 "Senator Lindbergh stated that the judge who ordered the arrest... 798 01:17:09,388 --> 01:17:15,454 of Senator Gleisi's husband is being supervised by you." 799 01:17:15,555 --> 01:17:21,329 Is it a crime to be a student or to be a supervisor? 800 01:17:21,430 --> 01:17:25,620 The entire weekend was full of inferences... 801 01:17:25,721 --> 01:17:30,454 corroborated by Senator Gleisi today at the plenary... 802 01:17:30,555 --> 01:17:33,662 implying I might be involved... 803 01:17:33,763 --> 01:17:37,662 - Wrap it up. - This is serious. 804 01:17:37,763 --> 01:17:40,329 This is very important. 805 01:17:40,430 --> 01:17:44,454 I have to defend my honor and the judge's. 806 01:17:44,555 --> 01:17:48,162 She's not here to defend her honor. 807 01:17:48,263 --> 01:17:51,620 Not here. 808 01:17:51,721 --> 01:17:55,162 You can't infer anything about my honor. 809 01:17:55,263 --> 01:17:59,495 - And you can infer what you want? - No, listen... 810 01:17:59,596 --> 01:18:03,495 Dr. Jana�na has the floor, but she should conclude. 811 01:18:03,596 --> 01:18:05,704 I'll be quick. 812 01:18:05,805 --> 01:18:10,662 People judge each other by their own rules. 813 01:18:10,763 --> 01:18:16,829 The members of PT have vassals, not students. 814 01:18:16,930 --> 01:18:24,329 They think other professors also demand that people kneel! 815 01:18:24,430 --> 01:18:29,162 My students are judges, prosecutors, researchers... 816 01:18:29,263 --> 01:18:32,037 of all ideological orientations. 817 01:18:32,138 --> 01:18:37,829 They never subjected themselves to me, they answer to me in their research. 818 01:18:37,930 --> 01:18:42,162 My role is to teach people to have an open mind... 819 01:18:42,263 --> 01:18:46,329 that's why I even supervise people who support PT. 820 01:18:46,430 --> 01:18:49,454 But you're judging me by your own rules. 821 01:18:49,555 --> 01:18:54,287 - Conclude. - You want them to be your vassals! 822 01:18:54,388 --> 01:18:59,329 Senator Lindbergh has two minutes to reply since he was mentioned. 823 01:18:59,430 --> 01:19:04,162 It's funny, that lawyer infers everything she can. 824 01:19:04,263 --> 01:19:09,329 She's always accusing without proof! She infers everything she can! 825 01:19:09,430 --> 01:19:15,287 What I said was true. She is the judge's supervisor! 826 01:19:15,388 --> 01:19:17,287 "Don't mess with her." 827 01:19:17,388 --> 01:19:21,329 Madam, you're not here for idealism. 828 01:19:21,430 --> 01:19:24,870 You came to this trial for R$ 45 thousand. 829 01:19:24,971 --> 01:19:27,995 For R$45 thousand! 830 01:19:28,096 --> 01:19:30,537 She was hired by PSDB Party! 831 01:19:30,638 --> 01:19:35,829 Now she's an idealist! Don't give me that! 832 01:19:35,930 --> 01:19:40,829 I told the truth. He was supervised by her! 833 01:19:40,930 --> 01:19:43,995 She should restrain herself. 834 01:19:44,096 --> 01:19:48,287 As if she didn't know what impeachable offenses are. 835 01:19:48,388 --> 01:19:52,037 She's always making political speeches! 836 01:19:52,138 --> 01:19:56,329 I can see you running for office in the next elections. 837 01:19:56,430 --> 01:20:01,829 Don't pretend you're an idealist. You came for R$ 45 thousand! 838 01:20:01,930 --> 01:20:05,829 Mr. President, no personal attacks! 839 01:20:05,930 --> 01:20:08,995 Mr. Patrus Ananias has the floor. 840 01:20:09,096 --> 01:20:13,629 Mr. President, excuse me. 841 01:21:07,305 --> 01:21:10,662 I found some pictures 842 01:21:10,763 --> 01:21:13,829 This is the march against abortion. 843 01:21:13,930 --> 01:21:16,704 He's fifth in the Pope's line of succession. 844 01:21:16,805 --> 01:21:20,204 The Spiritualists and Catholics are more active than us. 845 01:21:20,305 --> 01:21:22,995 - Really? - More than the Evangelicals. 846 01:21:23,096 --> 01:21:24,537 I didn't know. 847 01:21:24,638 --> 01:21:28,537 Catholics actively raise this flag... 848 01:21:28,638 --> 01:21:31,829 But there are pro-abortion Catholics. 849 01:21:31,930 --> 01:21:34,537 Some groups within Catholicism. 850 01:21:34,638 --> 01:21:36,495 And they're united. 851 01:21:36,596 --> 01:21:43,329 But some Catholics are against it. There are many groups. 852 01:21:43,430 --> 01:21:47,704 She's the president of the Evangelical Singers' Federation. 853 01:21:47,805 --> 01:21:50,295 Wow, congratulations! 854 01:21:50,430 --> 01:21:54,537 Those doctors who perform abortions... 855 01:21:54,638 --> 01:21:58,662 reach a point in their lives when they get depressed. 856 01:21:58,763 --> 01:22:03,870 There's a case in Mato Grosso, and I can show it to you later... 857 01:22:03,971 --> 01:22:07,954 of a doctor who performed many abortions. 858 01:22:08,055 --> 01:22:12,037 She couldn't take it anymore and killed herself. 859 01:22:12,138 --> 01:22:14,420 That's so sad. 860 01:22:14,763 --> 01:22:20,995 She was a woman and a mother and you're a mother too. 861 01:22:21,096 --> 01:22:28,462 Spilling the blood of innocents has spiritual consequences. 862 01:22:29,263 --> 01:22:32,287 Even though they say it's natural. 863 01:22:32,388 --> 01:22:37,829 They say it's normal, but we know there's no pact for that. 864 01:22:37,930 --> 01:22:40,370 That's true, that's true. 865 01:22:40,471 --> 01:22:44,829 - I'm your ally. - Amen, go with God. 866 01:22:44,930 --> 01:22:47,870 Thank you, you're just great. 867 01:22:47,971 --> 01:22:51,670 - You won't forget us. - Never. 868 01:22:52,721 --> 01:22:58,004 - Thank you - Thanks. See you later. 869 01:23:11,263 --> 01:23:13,587 Hi, sweetie, how are you? 870 01:23:14,388 --> 01:23:15,920 Sure. 871 01:23:20,430 --> 01:23:21,920 Why? 872 01:23:28,721 --> 01:23:30,129 Right. 873 01:23:31,430 --> 01:23:35,420 No way. It's not a problem at all. 874 01:23:38,763 --> 01:23:40,920 She did. 875 01:23:41,930 --> 01:23:48,087 None of them question her guilt, be it for not speaking or not supervising. 876 01:23:49,263 --> 01:23:51,204 That's the point. 877 01:23:51,305 --> 01:23:56,587 She blames you so she could be absolved. 878 01:23:59,305 --> 01:24:01,704 But don't worry about that. 879 01:24:01,805 --> 01:24:05,620 Stick to that strategy. It's great. 880 01:24:05,721 --> 01:24:08,587 No problem, kisses. 881 01:24:13,763 --> 01:24:15,787 The committee will start. 882 01:24:15,888 --> 01:24:18,295 Shall we go back to hell? 883 01:24:20,721 --> 01:24:23,920 - Let's do it. - Let's go. 884 01:24:25,596 --> 01:24:28,129 Nothing better to do. 885 01:24:29,263 --> 01:24:32,254 This is why we're here. 886 01:24:37,512 --> 01:24:44,911 August 2nd, 2016. Senator Anastasia reads his final report. 887 01:24:47,596 --> 01:24:51,454 We reiterate the admissibility report. 888 01:24:51,555 --> 01:24:57,829 We are not contrasting the President's mandate, nor her abysmal unpopularity... 889 01:24:57,930 --> 01:25:01,954 that spreads through all kinds of social networks... 890 01:25:02,055 --> 01:25:05,954 with eventual audio recordings and plea bargains, 891 01:25:06,055 --> 01:25:10,662 or with any conduct unrelated to her presidential duty. 892 01:25:10,763 --> 01:25:17,579 I vote in favor of the accusation declaring Dilma Rousseff guilty... 893 01:25:17,680 --> 01:25:22,829 of issuing additional budget decrees without Congress authorization... 894 01:25:22,930 --> 01:25:26,745 and performing loan transactions with state banks... 895 01:25:26,846 --> 01:25:31,008 leading her to be tried by the Federal Senate 896 01:25:31,109 --> 01:25:34,420 as determined by the Constitution. 897 01:25:35,096 --> 01:25:37,787 Anastasia... 898 01:25:37,888 --> 01:25:42,120 has used many accounting tricks! 899 01:25:42,221 --> 01:25:45,579 To fight corruption... 900 01:25:45,680 --> 01:25:49,162 is to fight the corrupt! 901 01:25:49,263 --> 01:25:52,162 And one of the most corrupt... 902 01:25:52,263 --> 01:25:56,995 is the current rapporteur... 903 01:25:57,096 --> 01:26:01,995 of the Senate Impeachment committee! 904 01:26:02,096 --> 01:26:05,454 There won't be a coup. We will fight! 905 01:26:05,555 --> 01:26:08,912 There won't be a coup. We will fight! 906 01:26:09,013 --> 01:26:15,212 No violence! 907 01:26:18,355 --> 01:26:23,087 HONK PT OUT 908 01:26:24,513 --> 01:26:28,712 Goodbye, darling! 909 01:26:37,096 --> 01:26:43,004 DILMA OUT 910 01:27:21,096 --> 01:27:24,212 - Do you have any paper? - Sure. 911 01:27:28,055 --> 01:27:32,954 We can gather up what we have now. I'll read it at home. 912 01:27:33,055 --> 01:27:37,995 If someone has a brilliant idea, even in the middle of the night... 913 01:27:38,096 --> 01:27:40,920 about what we should say, call me. 914 01:27:45,721 --> 01:27:49,587 Look at this piece of paper! 915 01:27:50,346 --> 01:27:52,829 It's a disrespect! 916 01:27:52,930 --> 01:27:56,829 Let's raise bullet points. I need emblematic mistakes. 917 01:27:56,930 --> 01:27:58,829 To discredit the report. 918 01:27:58,930 --> 01:28:03,162 - Like you did with Arantes. - That's it. 919 01:28:03,263 --> 01:28:07,829 There's no point in hammering on what people don't understand. 920 01:28:07,930 --> 01:28:11,287 I need to be straightforward. 921 01:28:11,388 --> 01:28:15,495 But these are the divergences. 922 01:28:15,596 --> 01:28:17,620 But what is the legal basis? 923 01:28:17,721 --> 01:28:21,954 He says we're taking power away from Congress... 924 01:28:22,055 --> 01:28:25,120 but it doesn't make sense... 925 01:28:25,221 --> 01:28:32,120 since Article 4 allows the executive to do so. 926 01:28:32,221 --> 01:28:39,087 He distorts the argument that we ignore the annual budget because it's a neutral decree. 927 01:28:45,721 --> 01:28:48,912 Pay attention to this part, Gabriel. 928 01:28:49,013 --> 01:28:52,787 You're going to e-mail it to me, but print it too. 929 01:28:52,888 --> 01:28:55,120 For tomorrow. Is it at 9 am? 930 01:28:55,221 --> 01:29:01,120 At 11 am. So print it. We'll meet early to prepare it. 931 01:29:01,221 --> 01:29:04,995 Let's go over the accounting tricks. 932 01:29:05,096 --> 01:29:12,329 I didn't read it. I'll go home to read it, and you send it to me tonight. 933 01:29:12,430 --> 01:29:17,329 Don't you want to go over the annual budget? 934 01:29:17,430 --> 01:29:19,620 No, that's his creation. 935 01:29:19,721 --> 01:29:23,329 He mentions a "theory of the bank teller." 936 01:29:23,430 --> 01:29:25,995 And he's like Plato's theory of ideas. 937 01:29:26,096 --> 01:29:31,079 He creates a fantasy to talk about the annual budget. 938 01:29:31,180 --> 01:29:36,620 The annual budget is not in the plane of ideas. 939 01:29:36,721 --> 01:29:44,454 The form matters little to the world, just how much was spent. 940 01:29:44,555 --> 01:29:46,879 God bless you, kids. 941 01:29:51,721 --> 01:29:53,129 Bye. 942 01:29:55,721 --> 01:29:59,795 Personally, I had great expectations 943 01:30:00,430 --> 01:30:04,712 regarding Senator Anastasia's report. 944 01:30:05,346 --> 01:30:08,454 For one simple reason. I know the Senator. 945 01:30:08,555 --> 01:30:13,162 He's a righteous man, a scholar of law. 946 01:30:13,263 --> 01:30:16,620 Due to the evidence and what had been proven... 947 01:30:16,721 --> 01:30:21,920 by the examination, witnesses and documents, I had expectations. 948 01:30:22,346 --> 01:30:27,662 Would he manage to free himself of his party passion 949 01:30:27,763 --> 01:30:31,079 and look at the evidence? 950 01:30:31,180 --> 01:30:33,045 Look at the law? 951 01:30:33,430 --> 01:30:36,920 Would he be able to use all his potential... 952 01:30:37,096 --> 01:30:44,295 to seek the truth instead of following passion? 953 01:30:45,596 --> 01:30:52,087 With all due respect, the rapporteur did not achieve that. 954 01:30:52,430 --> 01:30:57,712 He achieved his usual brilliance in defending his party's thesis. 955 01:30:58,721 --> 01:31:04,620 But he was not able to grasp the truth of the files. 956 01:31:04,721 --> 01:31:09,745 And influenced by his passion, not with malice or intent.. 957 01:31:09,846 --> 01:31:14,420 he made concessions to the evidence gathered herein. 958 01:31:15,096 --> 01:31:20,829 You say that our system should be called "The Bank-Teller Empire". 959 01:31:20,930 --> 01:31:23,868 The budget cannot be spent because it is 960 01:31:23,969 --> 01:31:27,495 provisioned and requires a compatibility target. 961 01:31:27,596 --> 01:31:30,829 That reminds me of Plato's "Theory of Ideas". 962 01:31:30,930 --> 01:31:35,287 In your report, ideas conquer reality. 963 01:31:35,388 --> 01:31:40,420 What matters to the target is not the ideal. 964 01:31:40,930 --> 01:31:44,754 What matters to the target is how much is spent. 965 01:31:44,888 --> 01:31:48,243 If we are working in the "Bank-Teller Empire", 966 01:31:48,344 --> 01:31:50,954 you work in the "Empire of Ideas". 967 01:31:51,055 --> 01:31:53,745 Where form prevails over substance. 968 01:31:53,846 --> 01:31:57,329 Where the annual budget leads to a President's Impeachment... 969 01:31:57,430 --> 01:32:00,995 even if no extra cent was spent via decrees... 970 01:32:01,096 --> 01:32:03,829 according to the expert's table... 971 01:32:03,930 --> 01:32:09,295 not the one you wrongfully indicated in the report. 972 01:32:10,346 --> 01:32:15,120 Regarding the accounting tricks, and I don't have time to comment... 973 01:32:15,221 --> 01:32:18,745 you assume it is a loan transaction. 974 01:32:18,846 --> 01:32:23,495 You didn't repeal my closing arguments, and you forgot the main thing. 975 01:32:23,596 --> 01:32:30,120 How does something not a loan transaction become one by default? Is it dialectical? 976 01:32:30,221 --> 01:32:35,912 Not even Hegel and Marx could explain how one legal relation can turn into another. 977 01:32:36,013 --> 01:32:38,401 Default begets a loan transaction. 978 01:32:38,502 --> 01:32:41,662 You say it doesn't happen in all instances... 979 01:32:41,763 --> 01:32:48,912 only between a state bank and the public administration. 980 01:32:49,013 --> 01:32:52,954 It is an odd case when a legal mutation takes place... 981 01:32:53,055 --> 01:32:57,120 outside of what is natural in the legal world. 982 01:32:57,221 --> 01:33:00,495 An innovative argument. And I respect those. 983 01:33:00,596 --> 01:33:04,079 But I can't accept criminalization of those who differ. 984 01:33:04,180 --> 01:33:07,704 That's authoritarian. Especially when it's retroactive. 985 01:33:07,805 --> 01:33:13,379 It never existed before and the evidence is very clear. 986 01:33:14,096 --> 01:33:18,287 Your Excellency states something that astounds me. 987 01:33:18,388 --> 01:33:21,745 "The President acted negligently." 988 01:33:21,846 --> 01:33:25,329 But the law says, that the management is not hers. 989 01:33:25,430 --> 01:33:32,212 You say she was negligent for it's her duty to uphold all financial laws. 990 01:33:32,555 --> 01:33:36,495 The President must uphold all financial laws? 991 01:33:36,596 --> 01:33:38,579 Then you say: 992 01:33:38,680 --> 01:33:42,245 "A mother who kills a child can do so directly... 993 01:33:42,346 --> 01:33:46,412 or can kill it by letting the child starve to death." 994 01:33:46,513 --> 01:33:50,079 If the mother does not have custody... 995 01:33:50,180 --> 01:33:54,162 if the mother was away, if she put the kid in day-care... 996 01:33:54,263 --> 01:33:56,329 the murder is not hers. 997 01:33:56,430 --> 01:34:01,787 I'd like to commend Senator Anastasia. He is a brilliant, intelligent man. 998 01:34:01,888 --> 01:34:06,579 It's a shame that this time his passion did not allow him... 999 01:34:06,680 --> 01:34:11,045 to seek justice, truth and democracy. 1000 01:34:21,539 --> 01:34:23,659 August 4th, 2016. 1001 01:34:23,760 --> 01:34:34,311 Vote on the final report, one day before the opening of the Rio Olympic Games 2016. 1002 01:34:37,055 --> 01:34:42,412 This crisis has led to over 12 million being unemployed in Brazil. 1003 01:34:42,513 --> 01:34:46,454 Not only did it offend against financial and budget laws... 1004 01:34:46,555 --> 01:34:50,579 but also against the principle of good administration... 1005 01:34:50,680 --> 01:34:55,662 by using intent, malice and fraud to govern. 1006 01:34:55,763 --> 01:35:01,287 That's why I can say I am very sure of what I'm doing... 1007 01:35:01,388 --> 01:35:04,329 and of what is best for Brazil. 1008 01:35:04,430 --> 01:35:09,954 That's why I'll vote "yes" to the report... 1009 01:35:10,055 --> 01:35:15,920 on Senator Anastasia, which is as clear as day. 1010 01:35:16,930 --> 01:35:23,412 My vote is "no". Against this coup and this fraudulent report. 1011 01:35:23,513 --> 01:35:27,745 And I shall repeat ten times. It's a fraud! 1012 01:35:27,846 --> 01:35:30,620 I determine, as per my usual rulings... 1013 01:35:30,721 --> 01:35:35,579 the suppression of the expression fraudulent report". 1014 01:35:35,680 --> 01:35:37,162 Why? 1015 01:35:37,263 --> 01:35:40,495 The opinion of each Senator is free. 1016 01:35:40,596 --> 01:35:44,620 We can't accept, under any circumstances... 1017 01:35:44,721 --> 01:35:50,995 that Senator Anastasia's work be called fraudulent. 1018 01:35:51,096 --> 01:35:54,287 But that's our opinion! 1019 01:35:54,388 --> 01:35:57,579 You can't censor our opinion. 1020 01:35:57,680 --> 01:36:00,162 I want it to be recorded for history! 1021 01:36:00,263 --> 01:36:05,579 When PT was called a gang, I had it stricken. 1022 01:36:05,680 --> 01:36:11,995 When they said PT should all be in jail, I had it stricken! 1023 01:36:12,096 --> 01:36:16,495 That's not censorship, that's balance. 1024 01:36:16,596 --> 01:36:21,412 Yesterday a Senator called PT a criminal organization... 1025 01:36:21,513 --> 01:36:24,495 and you didn't have it stricken. 1026 01:36:24,596 --> 01:36:29,412 Maybe a word slipped by or I didn't see it... 1027 01:36:29,513 --> 01:36:33,287 because I've been talking to senators... 1028 01:36:33,388 --> 01:36:36,995 and I eventually need to use the restroom. 1029 01:36:37,096 --> 01:36:41,829 Something may have gone unnoticed. 1030 01:36:41,930 --> 01:36:45,329 A word for a question of order. 1031 01:36:45,430 --> 01:36:52,162 No questions of order now! 1032 01:36:52,263 --> 01:36:55,837 The results are: 1033 01:36:56,055 --> 01:36:59,537 Yes, 14. 1034 01:36:59,638 --> 01:37:01,162 No, 5. 1035 01:37:01,263 --> 01:37:07,795 Senator Anastasia's report is approved and is now this committee�s opinion. 1036 01:37:25,263 --> 01:37:27,579 We have 673 pages now. 1037 01:37:27,680 --> 01:37:29,120 673? 1038 01:37:29,221 --> 01:37:33,162 Keep it with you because if anything bad happens... 1039 01:37:33,263 --> 01:37:36,004 we'll file this one. 1040 01:37:50,055 --> 01:37:51,920 Let's go, Gabriel. 1041 01:38:35,430 --> 01:38:37,254 Just press here. 1042 01:38:44,263 --> 01:38:45,879 Another one. 1043 01:38:48,430 --> 01:38:51,254 Eventually you'll take it, right? 1044 01:38:52,096 --> 01:38:54,087 Dear God. 1045 01:38:55,721 --> 01:38:57,754 You got it? 1046 01:39:03,346 --> 01:39:05,545 Another one. Got it? 1047 01:39:33,221 --> 01:39:39,045 We know it is difficult, but we must fight till the end. 1048 01:39:39,763 --> 01:39:45,087 I believe in a positive surprise to defeat the coup. 1049 01:39:46,388 --> 01:39:49,620 I truly believe that. We can't give up. 1050 01:39:49,721 --> 01:39:53,045 When you stop believing, we are doomed! 1051 01:39:57,346 --> 01:40:01,987 Not believing in the fight means accepting defeat. 1052 01:40:02,088 --> 01:40:05,262 This is a very important battlefront for us. Very important. 1053 01:40:05,363 --> 01:40:11,454 We need to report what's happening with democracy the social setbacks... 1054 01:40:11,555 --> 01:40:15,954 what this scenario that led us to impeachment meant... 1055 01:40:16,055 --> 01:40:20,329 the deconstruction of PT, Lula and Dilma. 1056 01:40:20,430 --> 01:40:22,787 It was a big deal! 1057 01:40:22,888 --> 01:40:28,454 Of course it is upsetting to realize some people are against us. 1058 01:40:28,555 --> 01:40:32,829 But it was systematic. The TV went into people's homes... 1059 01:40:32,930 --> 01:40:39,120 to say we're no good, PT is no good and that we weren't in a position to govern. 1060 01:40:39,221 --> 01:40:43,545 We allowed it to happen. It made up people's minds. 1061 01:40:44,388 --> 01:40:48,912 70 years ago, Get�lio Vargas had the clarity of mind we never had. 1062 01:40:49,013 --> 01:40:52,245 Get a guy and have him start a newspaper... 1063 01:40:52,346 --> 01:40:58,579 and make it vibrant and a weapon of the people. 1064 01:40:58,680 --> 01:41:04,579 We chose to line their pockets with money... 1065 01:41:04,680 --> 01:41:07,662 and fill them with public concessions. 1066 01:41:07,763 --> 01:41:11,620 We had the Secretariat and Ministry of Communication. 1067 01:41:11,721 --> 01:41:17,495 So we were handing out many radio and TV licenses... 1068 01:41:17,596 --> 01:41:21,287 and giving the big media a lot of money. 1069 01:41:21,388 --> 01:41:24,162 I'm not sure I ever told you this... 1070 01:41:24,263 --> 01:41:29,162 but Lula's Government shut down the most community radio stations. 1071 01:41:29,263 --> 01:41:31,454 Then it becomes difficult. 1072 01:41:31,555 --> 01:41:35,120 It is hard to communicate with the people... 1073 01:41:35,221 --> 01:41:39,954 unless it's election time or through the President's charisma. 1074 01:41:40,055 --> 01:41:44,162 If we do fall, it will be mostly because of what we got right. 1075 01:41:44,263 --> 01:41:50,162 Because we went against the interests of big money. 1076 01:41:50,263 --> 01:41:54,329 However, it's undeniable 1077 01:41:54,430 --> 01:41:59,120 that we made their path easier with our own grave mistakes. 1078 01:41:59,221 --> 01:42:03,620 You have no idea how hard it was to get a PT minister... 1079 01:42:03,721 --> 01:42:06,120 to receive the social movements 1080 01:42:06,221 --> 01:42:10,995 It was as if they would only get in our way. 1081 01:42:11,096 --> 01:42:18,995 Almost a pleasure to say no to our own and a sad submission to the powerful. 1082 01:42:19,096 --> 01:42:22,162 That needs to be thoroughly addressed. 1083 01:42:22,263 --> 01:42:27,162 Not to mention the acceptance of methods of doing politics... 1084 01:42:27,263 --> 01:42:32,662 which we assimilated strongly and uncritically... 1085 01:42:32,763 --> 01:42:36,120 and didn't lead us to political reform... 1086 01:42:36,221 --> 01:42:42,495 even after the scandal that put several of our comrades in jail. 1087 01:42:42,596 --> 01:42:47,329 All of this is part of a process that is not self-flagellation... 1088 01:42:47,430 --> 01:42:52,337 but it's about having the clarity to break with our mistakes. 1089 01:42:56,627 --> 01:43:03,977 August 29th, 2016. President Dilma testifies. 1090 01:45:33,930 --> 01:45:40,662 We will now commence the testimony... 1091 01:45:40,763 --> 01:45:45,329 of President Dilma Vana Rousseff... 1092 01:45:45,430 --> 01:45:52,787 whom I greet for coming to this illustrious plenary... 1093 01:45:52,888 --> 01:45:57,120 to present her explanations regarding the facts... 1094 01:45:57,221 --> 01:46:01,587 the accusation against her. 1095 01:46:02,388 --> 01:46:07,579 The natural judges, the senators... 1096 01:46:07,680 --> 01:46:13,162 will formulate their questions objectively... 1097 01:46:13,263 --> 01:46:17,287 soberly, impartially... 1098 01:46:17,388 --> 01:46:23,329 and restricted to the accusations... 1099 01:46:23,430 --> 01:46:27,495 in the prosecutor's opening statement. 1100 01:46:27,596 --> 01:46:31,954 I give the floor to the illustrious Senator Simone Tebet. 1101 01:46:32,055 --> 01:46:37,579 The decrees and accounting tricks weren't simple accounting operations... 1102 01:46:37,680 --> 01:46:40,120 but part of a fiscal strategy... 1103 01:46:40,221 --> 01:46:43,662 to artificially boost the primary result... 1104 01:46:43,763 --> 01:46:46,620 and spend resources you didn't have... 1105 01:46:46,721 --> 01:46:50,162 illegally borrowing from state banks. 1106 01:46:50,263 --> 01:46:54,829 If Your Excellency returns to the Presidency... 1107 01:46:54,930 --> 01:47:00,162 what wild you do to block this fiscal-hole... 1108 01:47:00,263 --> 01:47:04,120 and win back the trust of the Brazilian people? 1109 01:47:04,221 --> 01:47:06,620 Regarding the state banks... 1110 01:47:06,721 --> 01:47:09,912 it's impossible to see it like that. 1111 01:47:10,013 --> 01:47:13,412 You're criminalizing the fiscal policies. 1112 01:47:13,513 --> 01:47:17,287 Why do I say that? 1113 01:47:17,388 --> 01:47:22,954 Because it wasn't Brazil that went through a crisis. 1114 01:47:23,055 --> 01:47:29,995 You claim we've been covering up this crisis since 2009. 1115 01:47:30,096 --> 01:47:35,579 No, Senator, since 2009 we started to face... 1116 01:47:35,680 --> 01:47:40,912 the world's greatest crisis since 1929. 1117 01:47:41,013 --> 01:47:44,162 It started in the developed countries... 1118 01:47:44,263 --> 01:47:47,829 when Lehman Brothers collapsed. 1119 01:47:47,930 --> 01:47:51,287 I should remind you that in 2011, 2012, 2013... 1120 01:47:51,388 --> 01:47:54,829 there was the Euro-Zone crisis. 1121 01:47:54,930 --> 01:47:59,079 We didn't make the crisis up... 1122 01:47:59,180 --> 01:48:04,620 but it hit us hard. 1123 01:48:04,721 --> 01:48:08,995 Unfortunately, as of October 2014... 1124 01:48:09,096 --> 01:48:15,829 the super-cycle of the commodities ended. 1125 01:48:15,930 --> 01:48:22,787 The United States ended its credit expansion policy... 1126 01:48:22,888 --> 01:48:26,995 three days after the second round of the elections. 1127 01:48:27,096 --> 01:48:32,287 It created tremors that reached every currency in the world... 1128 01:48:32,388 --> 01:48:37,162 and they plummeted. The foreign exchange crashed. 1129 01:48:37,263 --> 01:48:43,454 We had one of the largest energy crises in Brazil due to a water shortage. 1130 01:48:43,555 --> 01:48:48,412 Senator, I'm sorry, but to say the country's fiscal crisis... 1131 01:48:48,513 --> 01:48:53,620 is due to three decrees... 1132 01:48:53,721 --> 01:48:58,329 and a subsidy operation... 1133 01:48:58,430 --> 01:49:03,245 not a loan transaction, from Bank of Brazil to fawners... 1134 01:49:03,346 --> 01:49:06,620 is to reverse causality completely! 1135 01:49:06,721 --> 01:49:10,162 I don't know what our world would be like... 1136 01:49:10,263 --> 01:49:16,829 if these were the reasons for such a major crisis! 1137 01:49:16,930 --> 01:49:21,829 I have the honor to invite Senator A�cio Neves... 1138 01:49:21,930 --> 01:49:26,662 to address his questions to the President. 1139 01:49:26,763 --> 01:49:31,495 First, it's not dishonorable to lose the elections... 1140 01:49:31,596 --> 01:49:36,079 especially when defending ideas and complying with the law. 1141 01:49:36,180 --> 01:49:40,287 I wouldn't say the same about winning elections... 1142 01:49:40,388 --> 01:49:43,995 with no truth and perpetrating illegalities. 1143 01:49:44,096 --> 01:49:48,787 I see that you permanently resorts to your votes... 1144 01:49:48,888 --> 01:49:52,329 as justification for all your actions. 1145 01:49:52,430 --> 01:49:57,045 The vote, we all know, is not a safe-conduct. 1146 01:49:59,013 --> 01:50:03,212 This impeachment wasn't born in Congress. 1147 01:50:03,596 --> 01:50:07,954 This impeachment was born on the streets of Brazil. 1148 01:50:08,055 --> 01:50:12,620 So I salute the representation of the Brazilian people... 1149 01:50:12,721 --> 01:50:16,495 made up of young, fearless... 1150 01:50:16,596 --> 01:50:20,412 selfless, non-partisan men and women. 1151 01:50:20,513 --> 01:50:25,162 They took to the streets to show their indignation. 1152 01:50:25,263 --> 01:50:30,620 A coup is to win an election lying to a country. 1153 01:50:30,721 --> 01:50:36,912 I disagree that this impeachment process... 1154 01:50:37,013 --> 01:50:40,287 was spontaneous, from the streets. 1155 01:50:40,388 --> 01:50:45,287 None of us in here is so naive not to know... 1156 01:50:45,388 --> 01:50:50,495 who is responsible for admitting this impeachment accusation. 1157 01:50:50,596 --> 01:50:54,454 The admission of the request for my impeachment... 1158 01:50:54,555 --> 01:50:59,329 came from a clear blackmail by Mr. Eduardo Cunha... 1159 01:50:59,430 --> 01:51:03,912 with whom you unfortunately made an alliance. 1160 01:51:04,013 --> 01:51:09,287 And this is confirmed since I'm not on trial... 1161 01:51:09,388 --> 01:51:13,287 for money laundering, for offshore bank accounts... 1162 01:51:13,388 --> 01:51:16,912 or for the misappropriation of public funds. 1163 01:51:17,013 --> 01:51:23,162 I'm a defendant at the final stage of an impeachment trial... 1164 01:51:23,263 --> 01:51:31,454 while someone who publicly committed crimes is protected. 1165 01:51:31,555 --> 01:51:34,995 This is something to be deeply ashamed of. 1166 01:51:35,096 --> 01:51:39,329 It's about this, not movements on the streets. 1167 01:51:39,430 --> 01:51:45,162 Unfortunately, those same leaders, some, not all... 1168 01:51:45,263 --> 01:51:51,120 some of them were most emphatic and cheerful.. 1169 01:51:51,221 --> 01:51:55,329 when taking pictures with Deputy Eduardo Cunha. 1170 01:51:55,430 --> 01:51:57,462 In addition... 1171 01:51:58,388 --> 01:52:01,712 This is life, Senator. It's hard. 1172 01:52:14,180 --> 01:52:16,662 So, Senator... 1173 01:52:16,763 --> 01:52:23,295 we can't say that this process is spontaneous. 1174 01:52:27,570 --> 01:52:30,231 Now speaking Senator Roberto Requi�o. 1175 01:52:31,139 --> 01:52:36,118 I will not suppress the indignation that consumes me. 1176 01:52:37,141 --> 01:52:38,540 Bastard! 1177 01:52:39,388 --> 01:52:40,634 Bastard! 1178 01:52:41,653 --> 01:52:42,884 Bastard! 1179 01:52:43,528 --> 01:52:48,960 Thus Tancredo Neves referred to Moura Andrade 1180 01:52:49,135 --> 01:52:56,440 who declared vacant the presidency with Jango still in national territory. 1181 01:52:56,714 --> 01:53:00,211 Thus consuming the military coup of 1964. 1182 01:53:01,028 --> 01:53:05,004 I doubt that just one of us 1183 01:53:05,190 --> 01:53:07,234 be convinced 1184 01:53:07,505 --> 01:53:12,440 that President Dilma should be removed from committing crimes. 1185 01:53:13,171 --> 01:53:20,074 It is not the "Pedaladas" or such fiscal responsibility that excommunicate her. 1186 01:53:20,286 --> 01:53:27,417 The accuser's own rapporteur himself practiced them at length. 1187 01:53:27,573 --> 01:53:30,492 Only, that there in Minas, 1188 01:53:30,679 --> 01:53:35,254 there was no providential and enjoyable Eduardo Cunha. 1189 01:53:35,980 --> 01:53:41,314 Let no one later claim ignorance or be cheated 1190 01:53:41,415 --> 01:53:45,099 because the intentions of the Vice are clear: 1191 01:53:45,437 --> 01:53:47,177 Privatization as a rule, 1192 01:53:47,278 --> 01:53:50,995 and radical alienation of all the energy patrimony, 1193 01:53:51,096 --> 01:53:54,211 mineral, forestry and agrarian sector of Brazil. 1194 01:53:54,881 --> 01:54:00,000 After the delivery of the Pre-Salt, from the sale of land to foreigners, 1195 01:54:00,131 --> 01:54:03,388 they even want to deliver the Guarani Aquifer, 1196 01:54:03,489 --> 01:54:07,064 the largest reservoir of drinking water on the planet. 1197 01:54:07,514 --> 01:54:12,042 Freeze for two decades the spending with health, 1198 01:54:12,328 --> 01:54:18,325 education, public safety, sanitation and infrastructure, housing... 1199 01:54:18,678 --> 01:54:21,691 But guarantee the payment of interest. 1200 01:54:22,172 --> 01:54:28,335 It is like prohibiting, for 20 years, that children are born, 1201 01:54:28,436 --> 01:54:31,136 young people have access to schools, 1202 01:54:31,399 --> 01:54:34,584 that Brazilians get old or sick. 1203 01:54:34,892 --> 01:54:36,561 It's scary 1204 01:54:36,877 --> 01:54:41,952 that some human being have granted such a barbarity a day. 1205 01:56:31,221 --> 01:56:34,587 Yes. It's Sophie's Choice. 1206 01:56:37,346 --> 01:56:38,754 Exactly. 1207 01:56:40,388 --> 01:56:42,045 It's void. 1208 01:56:48,930 --> 01:56:51,795 No. It has to be done. Exactly. 1209 01:56:52,513 --> 01:56:54,712 Professional. Sure. 1210 01:56:56,888 --> 01:56:57,995 Exactly. 1211 01:56:58,096 --> 01:57:05,120 I'm only wondering if we should do it now or right after. 1212 01:57:05,221 --> 01:57:09,829 We could wait to file this lawsuit... 1213 01:57:09,930 --> 01:57:13,587 and the one for lack of cause right after. 1214 01:57:36,888 --> 01:57:40,087 Attorney Jana�na Paschoal has the floor. 1215 01:57:41,388 --> 01:57:49,254 The world needs to know that we're not debating accounting issues. 1216 01:57:50,180 --> 01:57:53,787 That is why I asked one of the professors: 1217 01:57:53,888 --> 01:57:58,162 "What were your fellow foreign colleagues told... 1218 01:57:58,263 --> 01:58:00,829 to convince them it was a coup? 1219 01:58:00,930 --> 01:58:06,620 That the President is being removed based on three decrees? 1220 01:58:06,721 --> 01:58:11,162 That she's getting removed because of an accounting issue? 1221 01:58:11,263 --> 01:58:16,787 If that's so, it's only reasonable they deem it a coup. 1222 01:58:16,888 --> 01:58:22,212 Or were they told the Brazilian people were victim of a fraud?" 1223 01:58:22,888 --> 01:58:25,412 That's how PT works. 1224 01:58:25,513 --> 01:58:30,329 PT denies facts and reality. 1225 01:58:30,430 --> 01:58:34,995 We can no longer stand the politics of marketing. 1226 01:58:35,096 --> 01:58:38,162 We want leaders who stare us in the eyes. 1227 01:58:38,263 --> 01:58:45,045 I trust in your judgment to make Brazil better for our children. 1228 01:58:45,555 --> 01:58:50,329 Even though I'm convinced I'm right. 1229 01:58:50,430 --> 01:58:56,579 Even when I'm right, I realize my actions might hurt others. 1230 01:58:56,680 --> 01:59:00,795 So, even though I'm right, I apologize. 1231 01:59:05,680 --> 01:59:07,954 Finish your train of thought. 1232 01:59:08,055 --> 01:59:10,295 I conclude... 1233 01:59:11,221 --> 01:59:14,412 by apologizing to President Dilma. 1234 01:59:14,513 --> 01:59:17,454 Not because I did what had to be done... 1235 01:59:17,555 --> 01:59:19,995 because I couldn't omit myself. 1236 01:59:20,096 --> 01:59:24,120 I apologize because I know her situation is not easy. 1237 01:59:24,221 --> 01:59:28,620 I apologize because I know, even though that was not my intent... 1238 01:59:28,721 --> 01:59:32,545 I've caused her grief. And I ask that she... 1239 01:59:36,888 --> 01:59:40,995 one day might understand... 1240 01:59:41,096 --> 01:59:46,837 that I also did it for the sake of her grandchildren. 1241 01:59:48,221 --> 01:59:52,712 Please, no manifestations. 1242 01:59:55,721 --> 02:00:01,412 I pass the floor to the eminent attorney and also professor... 1243 02:00:01,513 --> 02:00:07,379 Jos� Eduardo Martins Cardozo. 1244 02:00:10,721 --> 02:00:15,120 During the military dictatorship, Dilma Vana Rousseff... 1245 02:00:15,221 --> 02:00:18,879 sat on the defendant's bench three times. 1246 02:00:19,930 --> 02:00:22,587 She spent three years in jail. 1247 02:00:23,346 --> 02:00:26,545 Her political rights were suspended. 1248 02:00:27,846 --> 02:00:31,045 She was brutally tortured. 1249 02:00:32,430 --> 02:00:36,212 Her very dignity was attacked. 1250 02:00:38,180 --> 02:00:42,662 It is possible that some of her accusers... 1251 02:00:42,763 --> 02:00:47,579 overcome by a fit of sentimentality, said to her: 1252 02:00:47,680 --> 02:00:53,162 "Girl, we are arresting and torturing you for the sake of the country. 1253 02:00:53,263 --> 02:00:56,920 For the sake of your kids and grandkids. 1254 02:01:02,180 --> 02:01:07,212 We're annihilating your life. But it is for your sake. 1255 02:01:08,555 --> 02:01:14,420 We are destroying and crushing you, but it is for your own good." 1256 02:01:15,596 --> 02:01:18,662 Sometimes that happens to accusers. 1257 02:01:18,763 --> 02:01:21,954 They suddenly grow a conscience. 1258 02:01:22,055 --> 02:01:26,454 But they can't eliminate the injustice of their accusation. 1259 02:01:26,555 --> 02:01:31,287 They might even try to fake a feeling of humanity. 1260 02:01:31,388 --> 02:01:34,045 But, objectively, they fail. 1261 02:01:36,596 --> 02:01:42,129 Today, Dilma Rousseff sits again on the defendant's bench. 1262 02:01:43,763 --> 02:01:48,995 After the Constitution of 1988, after the return of democracy... 1263 02:01:49,096 --> 02:01:52,629 after we affirmed the rule of law. 1264 02:01:54,013 --> 02:01:58,587 She is no longer a girl. She is a mother and a grandmother. 1265 02:02:00,221 --> 02:02:06,545 Today, she is a woman elected President of Brazil... 1266 02:02:06,846 --> 02:02:10,954 with over 54 million votes. 1267 02:02:11,055 --> 02:02:15,920 The first woman elected President of Brazil. 1268 02:02:17,263 --> 02:02:19,495 And what is she accused of? 1269 02:02:19,596 --> 02:02:23,995 Today we know. But, maybe in some time... 1270 02:02:24,096 --> 02:02:28,629 nobody will remember the charges she's accused of. 1271 02:02:28,930 --> 02:02:33,504 Much like nobody remembers the accusations of the past. 1272 02:02:33,930 --> 02:02:35,629 What will they say? 1273 02:02:36,013 --> 02:02:41,920 She was accused because she dared to win an election... 1274 02:02:42,721 --> 02:02:48,254 affronting the interests of those who sought to change the country's course. 1275 02:02:49,221 --> 02:02:55,620 She was convicted because she dared not stop... 1276 02:02:55,721 --> 02:03:00,379 the investigations against corruption. 1277 02:03:02,221 --> 02:03:06,620 The pretexts? Those will remain in the files. 1278 02:03:06,721 --> 02:03:08,754 Turned to dust. 1279 02:03:09,263 --> 02:03:11,079 The dust of time. 1280 02:03:11,180 --> 02:03:16,129 I have nothing further to say. The files speak on my behalf. 1281 02:03:20,096 --> 02:03:25,295 This session is finished. 1282 02:03:53,087 --> 02:03:59,625 August 31st, 2016. The Senate votes. 1283 02:04:50,013 --> 02:04:54,995 Madam Senators and Senators... 1284 02:04:55,096 --> 02:05:00,962 I start this session, or, rather, resume it. 1285 02:05:05,388 --> 02:05:09,920 The table clarifies... 1286 02:05:11,388 --> 02:05:14,662 as it pertains to the vote in question... 1287 02:05:14,763 --> 02:05:18,454 "yes" means you approve the conviction... 1288 02:05:18,555 --> 02:05:24,454 that is, the loss of the President's office. 1289 02:05:24,555 --> 02:05:29,954 Those who vote "no", vote for absolution... 1290 02:05:30,055 --> 02:05:35,620 and consequent dismissal of the charges against the President. 1291 02:05:35,721 --> 02:05:40,587 Senators, you may start your vote. 1292 02:06:20,930 --> 02:06:25,120 61 Senators voted "yes". 1293 02:06:25,221 --> 02:06:29,045 20 Senators voted "no". 1294 02:06:31,263 --> 02:06:34,504 20 "no". Zero abstentions. 1295 02:07:13,055 --> 02:07:18,754 IT'S FRAUD! IT'S A COUP! 1296 02:07:39,055 --> 02:07:46,129 I SHALL NOT PUT MY NAME TO THIS INFAMY. 1297 02:07:52,055 --> 02:07:54,162 You won, but didn't take it. 1298 02:07:54,263 --> 02:08:00,462 Because you're doing it against the constitution. 1299 02:08:16,846 --> 02:08:18,879 President Dilma! 1300 02:08:20,055 --> 02:08:23,379 History's already absolved you, Dilma! 1301 02:08:29,180 --> 02:08:33,495 Fighter! Brazilian woman! 1302 02:08:33,596 --> 02:08:37,087 Fighter of the Brazilian People! 1303 02:08:52,388 --> 02:08:57,212 Today, the Senate made a decision 1304 02:08:57,346 --> 02:09:00,829 that enters History as a great injustice. 1305 02:09:00,930 --> 02:09:07,162 The Senators who voted for impeachment chose to rip the Constitution to shreds. 1306 02:09:07,263 --> 02:09:11,620 They decided for the interruption of the term of a President 1307 02:09:11,721 --> 02:09:15,420 who did not commit any impeachable offense. 1308 02:09:15,763 --> 02:09:20,912 They convicted an innocent woman and performed a parliamentary coup. 1309 02:09:21,013 --> 02:09:24,829 By approving my definitive removal... 1310 02:09:24,930 --> 02:09:30,620 the politicians who desperately seek to escape justice... 1311 02:09:30,721 --> 02:09:35,829 shall take power along with those defeated in the last four elections. 1312 02:09:35,930 --> 02:09:41,579 The progressive, democratic and inclusive project I represent... 1313 02:09:41,680 --> 02:09:47,412 is being interrupted by a powerful and conservative force. 1314 02:09:47,513 --> 02:09:50,454 With the support of a biased press... 1315 02:09:50,555 --> 02:09:55,787 they will take the institutions of the state and employ them... 1316 02:09:55,888 --> 02:10:01,120 in the service of extreme economic liberalism and social regression. 1317 02:10:01,221 --> 02:10:04,329 This coup is against the people and the nation, 1318 02:10:04,430 --> 02:10:08,787 It is the imposition of intolerance, prejudice and violence. 1319 02:10:08,888 --> 02:10:13,329 As I take my leave, I share with you the beautiful solace found... 1320 02:10:13,430 --> 02:10:16,495 in the words of the Russian poet Mayakovski. 1321 02:10:16,596 --> 02:10:19,745 "We are not happy, that much is certain. 1322 02:10:19,846 --> 02:10:23,829 But why should we also be sad? 1323 02:10:23,930 --> 02:10:26,454 The sea of history is agitated. 1324 02:10:26,555 --> 02:10:30,662 Threats and wars we are bound to overcome... 1325 02:10:30,763 --> 02:10:35,620 break them in half, cutting through them as a keel would." 1326 02:10:35,721 --> 02:10:39,079 My kindest regards to the Brazilian people. 1327 02:10:39,180 --> 02:10:43,162 To the women and men of my country. 1328 02:10:43,263 --> 02:10:48,579 Specially to the men and women who share with me... 1329 02:10:48,680 --> 02:10:50,954 a belief in democracy... 1330 02:10:51,055 --> 02:10:56,287 and in the dream of justice in all its dimensions. 1331 02:10:56,388 --> 02:10:58,295 Thank you. 1332 02:11:03,596 --> 02:11:09,420 You represent me! You represent me! 1333 02:11:17,596 --> 02:11:24,545 Dilma, a fighter for the Brazilian nation! 1334 02:11:33,180 --> 02:11:38,379 Temer out! Temer out! 1335 02:12:18,451 --> 02:12:23,111 Nine months later, on May 22nd, 2017, Michel Temer is formally 1336 02:12:23,212 --> 02:12:26,803 accused of corruption by the attorney general. 1337 02:12:26,904 --> 02:12:32,686 He becomes Brazil's first head of state to be formally charged with a crime. 1338 02:12:32,787 --> 02:12:34,914 Temer refuses to resign. 1339 02:12:38,513 --> 02:12:42,745 You came with us to shout "Temer out!" 1340 02:12:42,846 --> 02:12:46,454 And "Direct elections now!" 1341 02:12:46,555 --> 02:12:50,745 Pension reform, labor reform... 1342 02:12:50,846 --> 02:12:55,254 and outsourcing are the continuation of the coup! 1343 02:12:57,555 --> 02:13:02,420 Police, please retreat. This space belongs to the workers. 1344 02:13:10,596 --> 02:13:13,829 One, two, three, four, five! 1345 02:13:13,930 --> 02:13:17,495 Stop the reforms or we will stop Brazil! 1346 02:13:17,596 --> 02:13:21,079 One, two, three, four, five! 1347 02:13:21,180 --> 02:13:24,745 Stop the reforms or we will stop Brazil! 1348 02:13:24,846 --> 02:13:31,920 Direct elections now! 1349 02:13:41,221 --> 02:13:46,495 I can't believe the police are firing and throwing bombs at demonstrators... 1350 02:13:46,596 --> 02:13:50,879 who came from all over Brazil in an organized fashion! 1351 02:14:01,596 --> 02:14:05,795 Help me! Help me! 1352 02:14:07,221 --> 02:14:10,420 They're trying to throw me out! 1353 02:14:31,013 --> 02:14:33,829 No one will throw anyone out! 1354 02:14:33,930 --> 02:14:39,379 No one leaves! No one leaves! 1355 02:15:42,122 --> 02:15:49,852 On August 2, 2017, the Congress voted not to put President Michel Temer on trial for corruption. 1356 02:15:50,856 --> 02:15:54,867 After taking office, Temer has overseen a spree of privatizations, 1357 02:15:54,968 --> 02:15:57,498 austerity measures and spending freezes. 1358 02:15:57,599 --> 02:16:00,659 His ruling coalition passed a radical austerity law 1359 02:16:00,760 --> 02:16:04,125 that bars the increase of public spending for 20 years 1360 02:16:04,226 --> 02:16:08,142 and a controversial labour reform that weakens worker's rights. 1361 02:16:08,243 --> 02:16:10,574 Restrictions on foreign oil companies 1362 02:16:10,675 --> 02:16:14,718 looking to drill for lucrative offshore deposits were lifted. 1363 02:16:16,744 --> 02:16:20,067 On April 4, 2018, the Supreme Court rejected 1364 02:16:20,168 --> 02:16:25,002 the habeas corpus filed by the defense of former President Lula. 1365 02:16:25,103 --> 02:16:29,890 The next day, Judge S�rgio Moro ordered the arrest of Lula. 1366 02:16:31,875 --> 02:16:38,064 THE TRIAL 1367 02:16:38,865 --> 02:16:44,065 Subtitles ripped by gooz karagarga, 2019 115578

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.