Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
MUSIC: Symphony No 9 in C Major by Schubert
This programme contains scenes which some viewers may find upsetting
Revisiting a castle in Northern Germany, George Ball -
adviser to two Presidents, Kennedy and Johnson,
a principal architect of American foreign policy since the war.
In 1945, George Ball headed the American Strategic Bombing Survey.
Germany was about to surrender,
the war against Japan remained unfinished.
To know how best to finish it quickly,
Ball's intelligence services were looking for one man, Albert Speer.
This is where they found him.
Hugh Trevor-Roper, now a distinguished Oxford don,
was then in British intelligence.
For him, too, Albert Speer was the man to see
for the reconstruction of the last days of Hitler.
Albert Speer himself is back home today in Heidelberg,
after 20 years in prison.
Trevor-Roper has pinpointed the basic fascination about him.
How is it that so intelligent a man
either did not see or, if he did see, was able to accept
the criminality of Adolf Hitler's regime?
CHEERING
As Hitler's architect, Speer personally stage-managed
spectacles like the Cathedral of Ice,
using over 400 searchlights -
great tableaux of adulation and mass hysteria,
in which Hitler bathed at the Nazi Party rallies.
Backdrops for the rise of a tyrant.
MILITARY BAND PLAYS
Speer became an intimate personal friend of Hitler
at the time he seized power. To the young, intelligent,
ambitious architect, Hitler gave patronage
and unlimited possibilities,
backed by the power to execute his dreams.
Together, they strode into Paris behind victorious German armies.
Albert Speer, architect and friend,
was commissioned to build for Hitler's Thousand-Year Reich.
He would design buildings on a scale
which matched Hitler's dreams of conquest,
to dwarf Napoleon's Paris.
Berlin would become capital of the Western world,
rebuilt on a scale which taxes belief.
A dome to crown the new city would stand 900ft high.
In all, 14 times the size of St Peter's in Rome.
Its corridors would be half-a-mile long.
This is what the Thousand-Year Reich would look like.
Hitler himself sketched this triumphal arch,
33 times as big as the Arc de Triomphe.
The Allied bombers crumbled the visions into dust.
They levelled the old order and, with it, dreams of the new order,
with its great soulless monoliths.
While the bombers were accomplishing this, Hitler intuitively promoted
his architect to take charge of all German war production.
Albert Speer was only 37 when he got the job of running
Germany's war economy.
He toured the blitzed factories,
organising and exhorting.
With no previous experience, he demonstrated
the remarkable powers of organisation which so intrigued
Allied intelligence after Germany's collapse.
Despite the mounting severity of the air raids,
Speer achieved striking increases in production,
without which, Hitler could never have continued the war.
# Markische Heide
# Markischer Sand
# Sind des Markers Freude
# Sind sein Heimatland
# Sind des Markers Freude
# Sind sein Heimatland
# Steige hoch
# Steige hoch, du roter Adler
# Hoch uber Sumpf und Sand
# Hoch uber dunkle Kiefernwalder
# Heil dir, mein Brandenburger Land
# Hoch uber dunkle Kiefernwalder
# Heil dir, mein Brandenburger Land... #
EXPLOSION
But Germany's war factories were also sustained
on the backs of armies of slaves.
Millions taken in cattle trucks to Germany to work like cattle.
This was not Speer's direct responsibility,
but his association with this black, inhuman chapter
earned him a sentence of 20 years at Nuremberg.
WHISTLE, STEAM TRAIN CHUGS
Even in 1944, with Allied bombing at its height,
Speer's 14 million workers continued to provide more armaments
than Germany's crumbling armies could use.
But despite increased production, when the Allied bombers
switched to sustained attacks on the synthetic oil plants,
they slowly paralysed the war economy and collapse was coming.
In their cities, Germans were either dead,
homeless or demoralised.
In July 1944, the German people
contemplated only mounting ruin.
The handful of men in the Resistance took action.
Count Claus von Stauffenberg plants a bomb in a briefcase beside Hitler
at his headquarters.
The Fuhrer miraculously survives.
Albert Speer has no part in this and, yet,
soon, he'll try to kill Hitler himself.
Russians from the east, the Allies from the west, pour into Germany.
Hitler orders demolitions to be carried out on a massive scale.
The last act of manic vengeance because, he says,
the German people are unworthy of him.
Speer openly opposes Hitler's orders
for the final destruction of Germany.
He's watched Nazism and Hitler with growing disenchantment
and, until now, has turned a blind eye to their corruptions.
Even now, he doesn't desert Hitler,
but with the Russians on the outskirts,
flies back into besieged Berlin,
and here, he takes a personal farewell of Hitler.
A few days before the Russians break in, he finds Hitler -
the man for whom he'd traded his soul - a palsied, broken wreck.
And so Speer came to trial at Nuremberg.
Nicht schuldig.
Albert Speer.
Nicht schuldig.
Norman Birkett, the British judge,
said later that Albert Speer
was the only one for whom he had any sympathy.
Speer was not implicated in the crimes of the SS,
but he accepted personally a collective moral guilt
for the Nazi period. He was sentenced to 20 years.
Long years of self-examination in prison.
Albert Speer...
..Hugh Trevor-Roper and George Ball
have not seen each other since the war.
They now meet again for the first time in 26 years in a Munich studio.
I feel that the period of your power
is separated by a gulf,
which must be very emphatic to you,
after this great activity and great prominence,
to have this long period of enforced meditation.
And I imagine that you look back across this gulf
with a certain objectivity towards a remote life.
And I would like to ask what you read in prison.
Did you read much? Yes.
We had every possibility to read all the books available
in the Central Library of Berlin town,
and it was really a very good library.
And I could read everything -
novels, English novels, French novels.
And I could read books of history,
I could read philosophy,
psychology and all those things. And, erm...
But we were not allowed to read books about our time,
so I couldn't read your book, for instance, but it was smuggled in.
So, you weren't able to give, as it were,
an outside dimension to your own experiences?
Well, erm, afterwards, when...
After seven years, we had a chance to read four newspapers,
and these four newspapers were only censored
when it was something in which was concerning our personal life
in Spandau. So then I read a lot of things about, erm,
some time in which I was minister,
now reflected by the newer, by the new time.
But as I said, not the books I would have liked to read.
But there were some wardens nice enough to provide me now and then,
when there was no Russian present, with one of the new books,
but it wasn't the time
to read them thoroughly, but just to skip them through.
20 years in prison.
20 years is a long time to think.
Why didn't that alter your perspectives?
Because the point is that throughout the book,
you say almost exactly the same thing
as you said in your interrogations in 1945. Mm-hm.
Did nothing change for you in prison?
Erm, it's...
Your remarks are, to me,
a little bit astonishing
because I was of the opinion
that I couldn't have written this book as it is
without all what I read
in Spandau Prison.
I often mentioning...mention that this man who wrote the book
after '66 was a changed man,
and he only was able to write it on a higher standard
because I had read so much
and was now...had now a wider circle of seeing and thinking.
Throughout your memoirs, you give a...
..an impression,
a very strong impression
of the dilettantism of Hitler's court.
And you give a very vivid picture
of the intrigues at Hitler's court
and the personalities.
But the history of Nazism
isn't only the history of personalities competing at court,
or what they, individually, as ministers,
did politically. Mm-hm.
There is also this phenomenon
which lies behind the whole Nazi experiment
and, compared with which,
the dilettantism seems to me relatively trivial,
what we can call the SS state. Mm-hm.
This gigantic organisation that lay, that was controlled,
in fact, by Himmler, which provided the force
on which the political superstructure rested.
And of that underworld,
you say in your book almost nothing. Mm-hm.
I merely am astonished at the lack of any reference
to this world of terror,
which was the essential condition
of the whole political system within which you worked,
within which you and the other
members of the court
competed for power at the centre.
Mm-hm. That staggers me.
Yes, because you are seeing it from outside.
If one sees it from inside,
when you are living inside such a system, it's...
Well, Malraux has, in his Musee Imaginaire,
he says, er, a fish can't see the outside of his aquarium.
And I think that is one of the things which are very wise,
because if you are inside such a thing,
you don't see and you don't feel what really is happening.
You are so in a world that seeks to describe
that it's, uh, that things are getting normal to you
which are absolutely abnormal to somebody who's seeing it
from outside. You mean, you, in effect, take it for granted?
Pardon? You take it for granted,
the conditions that exist.
I mean, these acquire a kind of normality because
you become so used to them. Is this what you're suggesting?
It was not normal, was it? Hmm?
It may have become normal by 1945,
but it grew...
These...
The Final Solution was only declared in 1941.
You had been with Hitler for ten years when that... Mm-hm.
..er, that happened. Mm-hm.
How can one regard this apparatus of terror and persecution
in one's own country, happening...caused by a government
of which one is a courtier at the very centre?
Yeah, but, er, you know that the Final Solution was a secret,
and it was a secret to me, too.
I just now, for preparing our discussion, I was reading through
the Table Talks, the first time, of Hitler's, and, er,
I just was seeing if there was some remark about the Jews,
which would be obviously hinting to the Final Solution,
but I didn't find any. And, er...
So, possibly, it was when I was sitting together with Hitler,
he didn't say any word about the Final Solution.
He... Of course, he certainly made hateful remarks about the Jews,
as they are in the Table Talks, but not more.
And it's very difficult to find out such a secret
in a...even if you are in the government.
That's one of... It's really... It's a problem.
We knew about it in England two years...
We knew the details of what was going on in Auschwitz,
apparently, before you did.
Is that not surprising? No, that's not surprising at all,
because you had about 300,000 prisoners in this time,
and certainly, some of the prisoners,
they were talking about it,
as you found out about Peenemunde
only by one prisoner.
And Peenemunde was kept a secret in Germany, too.
Not to me, of course, but it was kept a secret.
There must have been a great number of Germans
who were engaged, indirectly,
in the...
..organisation of concentration camps.
Himmler's vast empire...
..it must have been known, at the centre.
No, I doubt... I doubt... I don't know, but I doubt that they knew
because this was a separation of power,
and it was this order of Hitler that nobody should tell anybody
which is not concerned about anything
which he doesn't need knowing.
But I thought that you are prepared to admit
that you knew about Auschwitz... Well... ..but didn't pursue
your inquiries to discover the dimensions of what was happening.
No. No, no, no. Surely you knew about Auschwitz? No, that's not...
I didn't write that. I said I could have known because Hanke,
he told me, not mentioning the name of Auschwitz, but he could have...
I could have known if I would have asked...
And his hint was, though, that something is happening
somewhere in Upper Silesia, which is really very,
which is, to him, so exciting
that he almost didn't find the words.
But it was not more.
And, of course, I say now,
that was my biggest mistake,
not to ask.
Er, nowadays, I don't remember so in details
more than I was writing down in Spandau
when I was describing this scene,
but certainly, he was excited and he said,
"Never go in a concentration camp in Upper Silesia.
"Horrible things are happening there." That must have been
about the sense of what he was saying.
When you were...
..were working within this system,
obviously, you became aware, if you weren't immediately,
that Hitler's long-term objectives were world dominion.
I think it's perfectly clear on the record
that this was, in fact, the case,
and I've been rather amazed, actually, at the extent to which
he made this clear in conversations, in what he said, what he wrote,
during the period that he was in power.
In other words, you envisaged the possibility
that you might play a central or important role
in a Germany which would really dominate the world.
This, I suppose, was implicit, too,
in the kind of architectural conceptions that you had... Mm.
..because these were the architectural conceptions
of a capital which is the world capital. Mm.
Now, how did you conceive that a state
that was dominated by a single dictator,
which was a cruel state, which was a selfish state,
how could you conceive that it could possibly succeed
to maintain a world dominance,
even, granted, that it once achieved it?
Well, in this time, I was so glad to be architect
and to do this work,
and said, even if I thought about, which is doubtful,
thought about the cruelties of the system,
then, er, I put it aside
because I thought that this is the chance of my lifetime
to be the architect for a state who is making steps
for world dominion, and which, er...
And my buildings will be, for centuries,
the buildings which are, er,
proclaiming, or testifying, this time. Yeah.
You've said that in your memoirs,
you seek to present your experiences
without commentary,
leaving the reader to, er,
impose the interpretation. Is that right?
I didn't do always. No. Many exceptions.
Now...
I, as a reader,
have tried to understand,
er, your story.
May I tell you how I understand it? You will tell me if I am right. Mm.
Because it's still...
My understanding still leaves me with questions.
It seems to me that at the beginning, as you have just said,
you saw this great opportunity of patronage, as an architect. Mm.
Here was a patron who was a very powerful man,
and perhaps you adopted towards him the attitude
which artists have adopted in the past
towards great political patrons.
And they have said, we will accept the patronage of the Medici,
or whoever it might be, or the Sultan of Turkey,
and build great mosques, and we are not committed
to the particular politics which is this subject of politicians. Mm.
That seems to me an attitude which could, hypothetically, be adopted.
It seems, on your showing, the attitude which you did adopt
when you went in at the beginning.
So I can understand your coming into power,
coming into dependence on Hitler,
but I can't understand -
at least, I can't easily understand -
your acceptance of the change which you admit that you saw.
You saw, by 1939, that the whole programme had changed.
And when Hitler declared war in 1939,
one of the remarks which surprised me by its frankness,
er, as well as by its content,
was when you say in this book that you were in favour of the war.
That here were all the others,
Goebbels, Goering and the rest had cold feet.
They were frightened, and they had not, er, they didn't want war.
And you said that you and some others
thought that they were cowardly,
and that now was the great moment
when the war of aggression should begin,
and it was cowardly of them to value their privileges,
rather than risk them in this great and noble gamble.
That seems to me a very surprising remark. Mm-hm.
Er, of course, I knew,
when I was writing this down,
that I was in favour of the war,
that this is a point which will be criticised very much,
but I think it's necessary
for historians to know that a man
like me was in favour of war
and, er...
..it was not only recklessness,
it was some kind of, er...
Well, maybe the word is adventure, or such a thing of a young man.
I was then, '39, I was then 34.
To risk something,
to, er, to have a risky life,
a change, after such a long period of peace time, and all such things.
So I would say that this, er...
That's of course, today, to me, it's very astonishing,
and it's embarrassing, and I feel ashamed of it,
but it's necessary to note that it was so in this time.
So it would be fair to say
that in 1939, having seen
what you might interpret as a transformation in Hitler,
or you might interpret as a mere revelation of his real purpose,
but nevertheless, having seen that his plan was
a robber empire in Europe, to put it bluntly. Mm-hm.
Having seen this, nevertheless, you said,
a robber empire will give me an even greater area,
more resources, bigger buildings.
bigger patronage, greater glory,
I shall be the architect
of the new Alexander the Great, or the new Napoleon. Mm-hm.
But then a moment comes in the war when defeat is visible to you,
though not to everyone else, because you understand
more profoundly than they do the technical basis of war...
..and...
..people start, Germans start deserting Hitler.
They start saying it is better to destroy Hitler,
to make peace now, before it is too late.
And you, to put it bluntly,
are the last to draw these...
Although you're the first to draw the conclusion that the war is lost,
you are the last to detach yourself. Mm.
There are two points. One point, erm,
is, er, we forget that Hitler was obviously a person
which has shown not only tremendous willpower,
but also, kind of a gift of magnetism.
Er, of course, I don't want to use it as an excuse.
As I see it now, being out of this world,
it looks rather ridiculous for a man with a high education to be,
er, succumbing to such magnetism, what else it was.
And the second point is,
I mentioned it several times in speeches.
I ended my speeches as War Minister
never with the normal routine ending -
we are fighting for the National Socialist government,
or country, or our ideas -
but I was just saying,
we do our best to provide our sons and our fathers
and our brothers with the weapons which are necessary.
And this is very difficult,
if armies are fighting,
difficult for the generals and everybody who is concerned.
Even for Stauffenberg or Olbricht, which I knew quite well,
which were also trying to do as much as possible
to get as much weapons as possible, even in the time
when they were already on the way to plot against Hitler,
to get as much weapons done as possible.
And that was my own way, too. I remember my last talks with Olbricht
and Stauffenberg was just a few weeks before the plot of
20th of July, and there was still the question -
and I think it was serious, from their part -
what can we do to get as much weapons as possible?
And then this fact that I was on the list of this government
of the 20th of July also shows
they didn't do it because they liked me,
but possibly, they did it because they thought,
he's an able man and - at least, for a while -
he will be the best man to provide us with
as much weapons as we can get. Yes, I can see...
I can see the argument for going on providing the weapons,
in order to preserve the position from which to negotiate,
but I cannot see how to combine that
with loyal support to a dictator
who had, by this time, shown that he was never going to give up power,
that attempts to influence him were in vain,
that he remained permanently in control of politics
and that his policy was disastrous... Mm-hm. Yeah.
..as well as being corrupt to the core. Well, as historians,
you're absolutely right. As a human being, I have only excuses
I can offer you, but I have no real
reasonable things to tell you.
So, one excuse is that this system of Hitler's
to separate each one from the other one
and to say one is only, erm,
responsible for his own, er,
his own task...
..that was a kind of education which is going back,
possibly, also before Hitler's time.
We're speaking about technocrats nowadays,
and that's one of these problems,
which was, in Hitler's government,
er, developed to...to a level
which was maybe much more than we can think about nowadays.
I compare it sometimes... Because you can't, er...
Somebody who wasn't in this aquarium, he can't, er,
he can't, erm,
he can't realise how it was.
But if you are nowadays in a...in a big firm
like General Electric or so,
or in the Army,
which are authoritarian systems,
it's possible that - not the same, of course - things may happen,
but also, that people who are not satisfied
with what the chief is doing, then saying, "Well, let him do.
"I just am concerned about my own branch
"and try to do the best on my own branch."
Albert Speer said at Nuremberg,
"Insofar as Hitler had a friend, I should certainly have been
"his close friend." It was Hitler's passion for architecture
which made a meeting more or less inevitable.
Speer had joined the Nazi Party before it seized power.
He had heard Hitler speak and found him spellbinding.
A meeting with Hitler produced a commission
to rebuild the old Reich Chancellery.
"My position as Hitler's architect soon became indispensable to me,"
Speer says. "Not even 30, I saw before me
"the most exciting prospects an architect can dream of."
From the point of view of the... Just let me say that
from the point of view of anyone in my country,
or I think in Great Britain,
who had the experience of seeing motion pictures of Hitler
or hearing him on the radio, and...
..seeing the things that he wrote, the communiques that he issued,
the statements that he made, the speeches that he made,
it was totally incomprehensible to us how anyone could find
a particular charm in this man. And, again,
by your own accounts in your book of those very, very dreary, sterile
social evenings at the Berghof. Mm-hm. How do you explain this?
This is the ultimate mystery, I think, as far as we're concerned.
Yes. And it goes through the whole book, because even when I was, er,
when I was, for periods, free of his influence
and I came back in his influence again,
then I was thrown out again by something
and then I came back again, and then, even in the end,
I was, er, I was working against him,
against his scorched-earth policy,
but I visited him then in the last days in his bunker.
Erm, it's, er,
only explainable, erm, when you agree with me
that persons can have a kind of, really, magnetism,
or can hypnotise their people.
And you try to get out of this influence, but you always,
you are, you are in their...
You are... You depend on them.
What sort of an image...
..do you have? What do you see
when you hear his name mentioned? Now? Or in this time? Now.
Now? Yes. Well, now I think, er,
I feel that, er...
..he is, er, he did so much harm to the world and to Germany and to us,
that is out of any question
how to think about him. But what mental picture do you have of him?
Do you see him in uniform, at the height of his powers, in the '30s,
or do you see him in decline, in the bunker,
just before his suicide?
I don't see him at all.
I don't... I don't remember him in this way.
He doesn't disturb my thoughts or my dreams or so, in any case.
That's finished to me. But we've now been talking of him
for a few seconds. Now, recall a picture of him, what do you see?
Uh...
I really, I must reconstruct it, because I didn't see anything,
personally, so impersonal now to me, so far away.
But if I would think back,
I think I would see him in the first time,
when he was my colleague as architect,
because that was a more impressing thing than afterwards.
As a Minister, he was further away from me.
There was much more distance between us
and he, in his personality,
was...was no more so close to me.
Where did you have your most
interesting private moments
with Hitler? You paint a picture,
in the book, of these excruciatingly boring tea parties
on the Obersalzberg, in the Berghof,
Hitler's mountain retreat,
not far from us here, in Munich.
You make that look almost intolerably boring. Mm-hm.
So where did you have your private moments,
which were of such value to you?
It was when I was together with him, over the plans,
over the drawings, or when he was, er,
with other architects, together,
and was correcting their plans.
And, er, it was remarkable
how quick he could grasp the meaning of a plan,
how he was able to think in three dimensions,
which most people who are reading plans can't.
And, erm, how his memory was, er,
enabled him to think about corrections he made months ago
in some drawings, and now he got it from his architect
and he said, "No, I didn't say so. I made it so." So it was...
This was amazing to me because he was the head of the state
and he had many other worries and grievances
and, still, he could deal with such small details on his private field.
Was he always excited, or was he more relaxed at this time?
Was he aggressive and...? No, as a...
When he was, er...
When he was acting as an architect, he was really very much relaxed
and he was at his ease
and he was not, erm, raging,
and you could contradict him or tell him,
"I don't think that is right."
That was the privilege of his architects - to contradict him.
It was architecture, too, which I think, from the book,
provided you with the first and most obvious opportunity
to leave Hitler.
Because it threw up the first, what should have been,
I think you probably admit in the book,
properly should have awakened your moral conscience -
when you were sent to redesign the offices
of the Vice Chancellor, von Papen... Mm.
..and on the carpet in the building which was being torn down
under your orders to be rebuilt, you saw the blood stain... Mm.
..where von Papen's staff had been murdered by Hitler's men. Mm-hm.
Can you explain that today,
why you didn't see then that a criminal was in power?
Mm-hm.
Er, I can't give an explanation of my own
because now I'm perhaps a changed man from this time.
But in this time, I just was looking away.
And this was always the same thing.
I was always following this line of somebody who is not concerned
if it doesn't involve in his own matters.
If it would have happened to a colleague of mine,
to an architect, possibly, I would have reacted otherwise.
But so, I thought, well, it's not up to me, that's state affairs.
I want to be frank about that.
We don't come to the point
if I would make evasions
about these things. It was just like that.
What do you think of those buildings now, when you see them,
that you designed? Well, I'm glad that they weren't built.
THEY LAUGH
You've spoken of them
as "pure decadence in art".
Is that a judgment you arrived at in prison, or before that?
The start was already before.
When I was in Spain in '41 and have seen the Escorial,
built by the architect Herrera for Philip II,
and this more or less sombre but very, erm...
..pure...not pure, very serious architecture impressed me very much,
because that was, I think, that would have been the...
..so I thought in this time, that would have been
the right expression of National Socialism.
Not this rich, decadent architecture of the 19th century.
The death of this man, Fritz Todt,
in a plane crash in 1942,
changed Speer's life.
Hitler appointed him Todt's successor as Minister for Armaments.
So, after nine years as Hitler's architect,
he had the job on which Hitler's dreams of world dominion depended -
war production.
His astonishing achievements made him the second man in the state.
Speer says that Hitler's choice of him, an architect,
as Minister of Armaments was part of the dictator's dilettantism.
All his life, Hitler had distrusted professionals.
After all, he had appointed a former wine salesman,
Ribbentrop, Foreign Minister.
A former fighter pilot, Goering,
had charge of the economy.
Speer claims hardly to have noticed
the apparatus of Himmler's SS state,
by which, the dreams of Hitler's robber empire were to be sustained.
He was, he says, blindly preoccupied with immediate purpose
and his own responsibilities.
It was, he says, in retrospect, a grotesque illusion.
You say very little about Himmler,
who seems to me so important in Nazi Germany,
as being the head of the whole apparatus of terror
on which the regime ultimately rested.
You say that you thought
you had possibilities of getting on with Himmler.
This is a phrase which rather shook me when I read it. Mm.
You treat Himmler, when he becomes Minister of the Interior,
as simply being a Minister with whom you could make a deal.
You found it satisfactory to have relations with him.
He was the right kind of Minister for you.
To us, who see Himmler in this...
..this, er, not as a person,
but as the head of this and creator of this terrible organisation
of extermination and force, this is a shocking remark. Mm-hm.
Well, but, er...
He, as a Minister of Interior, he was some hope to me.
He said he's the only one who can get order
in the Gauleiters. He was...
Because he was a man who was feared by everybody,
even in the party, he could have done it. And it was...
In my position as a War Minister, it was one of the hopes I had,
because those Gauleiters were opposed to me,
to my ideas of total warfare.
And only with a strong Minister of Interior,
I could overwhelm them.
I was too much of a specialist
to think of the other side.
I would have, er...
Well, it was...
One sometimes makes a deal with the devil
to get to some end. So you looked cheerfully forward
to an extension of Himmler's control over Germany,
provided it were at the expense of that of Bormann?
Yes, I would have liked it if he would...
If he would have been a strong Minister of Interior,
also against the party, I would have liked it.
Herr Speer is regarded, certainly, immediately after the war,
as the organisational genius
who so organised German industry under the bombing
that the war was protracted
far beyond the length one might have assumed.
Do you believe that that stands up in the light of history,
Herr Speer's achievement?
Yes, I think it stands up, to a very considerable extent.
When the Bombing Survey -
of which, I was a director -
completed its work and we looked at the results,
there were two or three questions that we had.
One was a proper evaluation of what your predecessor,
Fritz Todt, had done, for example.
Because a great deal of the kind of infrastructure
which you built on seemed to us to have been established by him.
From the point of view of the total mobilisation
of the economy, however, I would think that, er...
..Germany never went as far as, for example,
the United Kingdom, or even the United States,
in the rationalisation of production and using all resources
that were available to it. I absolutely agree with you.
My point of view was that it wasn't done enough
and should have been done much more.
And I had, also, reports available,
what Bevin was doing in the United Kingdom.
And one could see that if it would be done
in this way in Germany, we could produce much more.
That was another point which is going apart from this first part,
from this first answer.
Hitler was always afraid to get too many sacrifices
from the German people.
He was afraid because he had the example
of the revolution in '18.
And he considered it best
to keep the German people in a good mood
and not to give him too much of a burden.
But isn't this perhaps a common,
or almost an implicit, er,
defect in a totalitarian system, the unwillingness of the dictator
to ask the people for the kind of sacrifices
that they couldn't be asked for in a democratic society?
I am not familiar with other authoritarian systems,
thank goodness, but I...
I should say in Hitler's system, it was quite obvious
that he was shrinking away
if it was getting too hard for the German people.
And I was sometimes saying that the words of Churchill -
"blood, tears and sweat" -
could be the better one for the German people, too.
It's this period of your life, of course,
that ultimately is to send you to prison for more than 20 years -
your association with the slave labour in the German factories.
How do you defend that to yourself now?
Erm, it can't really be defended,
but one should think that
I am not responsible, I wasn't responsible
to bring in those labourers,
and I was not responsible for their treatment
and for the time of working and so on.
Because my ministry was - I think it was similar in the United States,
with the Production Ministry - a new-founded ministry
and didn't take away from other ministries
which were, normally, in this state, working,
many of those, erm, of the...
..of their tasks.
So the Ministry for Labour was still responsible for labour conditions.
The Ministry for Interior Work was responsible
for behaviour and for punishments.
Also, Ministry of Justice, and so on.
But how do you think you might have conducted
these responsibilities if you had had them?
Would it have been different from the way Sauckel did?
It would definitely have been different
because, as it is in our files,
I was convinced that we had millions
of German women at our disposal,
which could have worked in the economy.
There was a plan formed
already before that time,
before wartime, when the war mobilisation was prepared,
and in this plan, there was more than five millions of women
due to be mobilised
when the war is starting, and nothing happened like that.
Were you completely unmoved by any compassionate feelings
for the condition of people in these factories?
Because you did tour them from time to time
and you must have seen the condition of the workers in them.
Erm, there were two points.
One point was an absolutely rational one.
Those workmen, when they came from abroad,
had to be learned,
and it needed about one or two months.
And until they were able to do their work,
one very good specialist of the firm had to teach them.
So he was lost, too, for this time.
So when the conditions of those workmen were bad
and they fell sick, it was really
doing much harm to our production.
If it happened very often in a factory,
it was the danger that the whole production would collapse.
That was one point. But the other point, of course,
was I was happy to help them,
but this was not a point which I stressed too much,
and I don't want to stress it now
because it would be too much in my favour, I guess,
if I was looking backwards to this period.
Can we come now to the final part, Herr Speer, of your story?
And before we deal with the last days of Adolf Hitler
comes this extraordinary volte-face of yours
from your pledged and total allegiance to him
throughout the '30s
and as Minister for Armaments during the war,
we come to an attempt by you to kill him.
Can you tell us why you felt that was necessary,
and whether we are to believe that it was a serious attempt
to kill Hitler? Mm.
Erm, it was just an attempt...
..and I was stopped
with the very first step, so it's not really true
to say it was getting serious.
And it can't be compared with the plot of the 20th of July
because these people of the 20th of July,
they really were going to do something against Hitler -
from an ideological point of view - and not me.
But how was your attempt to kill Hitler to be carried out?
What were you going to try and do?
We had two new sorts of gas - that was tabun and sarin.
And in Hitler's...
Hitler lived in this time in his bunker,
and the whole air was getting through air conducts...
Conditioning, yes. Yeah. ..and then through a gas filter.
A normal gas filter for normal gas. And, er...
But with this other gas,
this other gas would have went through this filter.
If I would have succeeded, then Hitler -
together with Bormann, Goebbels and Ley -
would have been killed immediately, a few seconds afterwards.
But it turned out, then - it was the first difficulty -
that this gas is only effective when it's exploding.
I tried to get a normal gas,
and I convinced
the engineer of the Chancellery,
which I knew well from the time
when I was building it, to build
the filter out. And it was just...
It was also quite, erm,
logical because Hitler complained
about the bad air in this bunker
in this time. Now it was really
no more in the filter, and my man
in charge of the whole ammunition,
he tried hard to get this gas,
but it was very difficult. He asked
somebody of the Armaments Office,
named Soyka, a Colonel. And then I went in the garden,
and there was no more the opening
on the level of the garden,
but it was a chimney built on order
of Hitler, and with this, it was
no more possible to do this attempt.
But it was quite the idea of a technocrat,
I guess, to do it this way.
But I couldn't, er,
I couldn't have killed Hitler with a pistol shot.
I think that's a question which is obvious.
His power to me, over me would have been too strong.
And so, in 1945, Hitler's Germany
is taking its final plunge to annihilation.
The fate which, in 1940, he had exulted
would be loosed on London and all his enemies
was now visited 100-fold
on every major city in Germany.
Hitler remained utterly indifferent to these miseries.
He delivered a final, brutal judgment
even on his own people.
If Germany lost the war, it need not
and should not survive.
He gave orders for a scorched-earth policy
that would finally destroy Germany
and the Germans.
Hitler's orders for final massive demolitions
were opposed and thwarted by Speer.
It led to a macabre face-to-face encounter with Hitler,
who demanded a retraction or the consequences of treachery.
Albert Speer, the one man with the intellectual integrity
to reject Hitler, could not.
It's proof of the grip that Hitler had to the very end
on the party he had created and the people in it.
CHEERING
Speer's personal contact with Hitler was broken
only by the leader's death.
With Berlin under Russian artillery fire,
Speer made a last trip back to Berlin to say goodbye
to the man, a few months earlier, he had tried to kill.
Well, there was a period
of almost two months
between when I had to fight Hitler's ideas of scorched-earth politics,
and I was betraying him in this time.
I was counter-ordering his orders, and...
..I didn't feel too well in this counteracting Hitler,
even in that time.
So it possibly was partly bad conscience.
Er, possibly, it was some other...
..moves that I regretted,
not to have said farewell to Hitler. Because he was...
His architect, everything was finished now. The whole period
was finished. And I was remembering the first years.
And...
But also, it's not so easy to explain,
I think there are two versions I mentioned
why I was going to Berlin,
and it's true that those two versions are true.
And I even could find a third version,
which I didn't mention yet.
Well, can you mention it now?
Well, some friend of mine, Roland, he said to me -
and it's true - he said,
"Your chances after the war were very low.
"You didn't know..." And we were talking about...
I didn't know what will happen with me.
Shall I be with the Russians? Shall I be tortured?
And so on, and so on.
And on the other hand, there was my family -
six children and my wife and my parents - living.
And if Hitler would have -
which was a chance, too - would have killed me,
as he did with his brother-in-law, Fegelein, a few days before...
Fegelein was the SS adjutant in the Hitler bunker? Yes.
Hitler had him killed just before the end? Mm-hm.
Yeah. Then I think it would have been, to me,
a good way out of the situation.
The family would have been a good, would have had
a good reputation, because it was known that I counteracted Hitler.
And I would have been...
..dead and would have been spared of many torturing things
which could have been ahead of me in future.
Are you...? I've not heard this before.
Are you asking us to believe that you went back to see Hitler...
..supposing that you might in fact be killed and that would solve...?
No, no, it's not consciously done.
It's unconsciously, and a possibility.
Incidentally, you hardly mention your family
throughout the course of this long book.
You don't mention your wife or your children.
Why?
Because my wife and the children were not a part of this,
of this political book I wanted to write. She was just...
She didn't want to interfere in my job, and she didn't ask.
When I was at home, I was so tired that I didn't talk
with her about such things.
And... You never discussed
politics with her, at home? No. No. Never? And she was no party member,
and was not in those suborganisations.
None of them. And a few weeks after the war,
she had got already her final papers that she wasn't involved.
Can we have from you a description of this last day?
You were, at this time, outside Berlin, in the north,
as the armies from the Soviet Union advanced from the east.
And at this time, the British armies, in the north,
were pushing the survivors of the German government
up to the north of Germany, near the Danish border.
Can you describe that last day?
You had to fly in, didn't you,
under heavy aircraft and artillery fire?
I had to fly in, not because Berlin was already surrounded
by the troops, there was just, there was one way out,
but because the traffic was so heavy
from Berlin, outside,
that the whole road was filled.
With refugees? With refugees, yes.
Trying to get to the west? Yeah.
And so I couldn't go any longer
to Berlin with my car. And I stopped and went to an airfield
where I knew the commander,
and he gave me then a plane to come to Berlin.
And in Berlin,
I went immediately to the Chancellery, and I was...
And the adjutant of Hitler, he asked Hitler,
and of course, after a few minutes, I was down there with Hitler
and had first a private talk with him.
What did he look like?
He looked like a very old man.
He was...
He looked... But he looked like that already,
the last weeks of the war.
He was worn out,
and he was absent-minded. And...
But this day, he was, er, he was...
..in some way, more peaceful than he was in other times.
He was not in a contradictory mood.
Now, there was only...
In these private talks, there was only the question
about survival of him or not survival,
and he told me that he will end his life.
And he told me in the words.
And so he told me that what then happened,
that he will shoot himself
and that Eva Braun will be killed, and so on.
Did he display any emotion to you?
How, for example, did he address you?
As usual, Herr Speer. He never called you by
your Christian name the whole time? No, no.
No, no, no. No, no, he wouldn't.
No, that was one of those things of Hitler's -
that he never wanted to have
a close approach of anybody.
Also, Bormann
or Goebbels, all were...
He always said to them Herr Goebbels,
or Herr Minister, even.
Even to the last time. And...
How long were you...?
How long were you with him on this last occasion?
Er, I don't know how long it lasted,
this private conversation,
but it didn't last too long. Maybe half an hour or so.
But then it was interrupted
by the conference of the situation, military situation,
which was a very poor one.
There was only a few officers present.
And then he asked me to leave.
I don't know what he did then.
And afterwards, I was free and visited Frau Goebbels
and Eva Braun and...
Eva Braun, you say, is not going to be a profitable field
for historians suspecting a great romantic figure,
she was certainly not that.
And, yet, you also go at some pains
to point out that she alone
in Hitler's bunker, at the very end,
was the calmest
and most rational person there.
She was, and certainly,
the wives of others,
like Frau Goebbels or Frau Goering,
were more reasonable than their husbands.
Maybe women are more rational sometimes than men
when they are coming in power.
Your final farewell of Hitler, was it cold?
Very correct? It was absolutely cold. It was...
I had two farewells.
I said farewell to him first
when we had finished our situation,
the military situation, and he said farewell,
as it was normally when I was going away
and coming back the next day, just without any emotion.
But the second one, then, in the morning,
at two o'clock, was obviously very cold
and very distant and...
Possibly, he expected that I stay with him.
I don't know. But in any case, he...
He... Would you have stayed?
If he had asked you, would you have stayed?
No, I wouldn't have liked to stay.
I... To make the thing sure,
I wrote to my wife before I went to Berlin,
a letter, and told her that I'm coming back,
that I just pay a call to Hitler. I...
I said... Maybe I wrote it - again, unconsciously -
to give her something in her hands
that I was not voluntarily staying with Hitler
to be killed
or to go to death with him.
After you left Hitler in the bunker on this last day -
and a few days later, of course, he commits suicide -
you're almost the last person to see him. Erm,
you go home and, in the book, you go back to the north.
You fly out again. By this time, the Chancellery
is under artillery fire. Mm.
And you unpack your bag and you take out of it...
Almost the first thing is Hitler's portrait.
Mm. And you tell us that you break down
and you sob uncontrollably when you see Hitler...
That's right. But I don't think that it was for pity. I was...
This day, I was...
..glad that Donitz was succeeding Hitler,
because I thought that it's a reasonable step.
It's not one of the party fanatics.
And I also was relieved that
the thing was coming to an end.
But I was living in such a high tension.
I was living in a kind of a schizoid state all these last months.
This breakdown was certainly the consequence of it.
But it was not pity with Hitler, certainly not.
I wonder if it was not a little more than that -
that you felt that the spell with Hitler had been broken?
It's possibly that.
I am not really a learned psychologist,
but I should say so. It was something I was getting...
With this weeping, I was getting rid of the whole thing.
I was still in connection with Hitler in some way.
But then, afterwards, I fell sound asleep,
and the world after this sleep was another one.
The next day? Possibly, yes.
It was, er, for a long time before, it was already another one,
but it was this controversial thing I can't explain
that I was trying to get away
and was again brought back in the influence.
But then this question was solved.
Didn't you seriously consider flying to Greenland and hiding there,
in an isolated bay, with supplies,
until the heat had blown over somewhat and then return?
Yeah, it was... That was...
Until now, I regret it because I think it must be, in this time -
May and June and July - in Greenland, it must have been
a wonderful time, and I always would have liked to be there for a while.
I had seen a film of Greenland once,
and it must be beautiful there.
And then I wanted to start to write my memoirs there.
Was that a serious proposal, though,
that people like you should get out of Germany
just before the final surrender and go to Greenland? Yes, yes.
The plane was already there. I have seen the plane, and it was...
And you refused to go, in the end? It was boarding in, er,
I think in Lubeck, it was. Mm.
Do you think, if you had gone to Greenland -
which was a colony of Denmark,
which was not neutral in the war -
that the Danish government would not have immediately given you up?
No. Greenland was impossible in this time,
without radar and what we have nowadays,
to find out some plane which is hiding in some of these...
Fjords. Fjords. Fjords, yeah.
Because we had... During wartime, we had always weather stations
there in Greenland which were never discovered.
They were there the whole year.
The weather... It was necessary for the weather,
for the weather forecast, when the offensive started,
it was very important to have there such a station.
And the station was always
flown there and back by the plane
which I had at my disposal.
After a few months, we were decided...
Because we would have run out of food,
we were decided to fly back and probably land on the Thames,
close to London - it would have been quite a surprise.
LAUGHTER
Schloss Glucksburg, the home of the Duke of Holstein,
near the Danish border, is where Albert Speer waited for capture
at the end of the war, and where he was interrogated by George Ball.
The British troops and tanks came one morning and took him
and the others to whom Hitler had handed power into custody.
At Nuremberg, Speer displayed a will to be honest
which then, and now, is impressive.
While he had opposed Himmler's plans for mass deportations
of slave labour on tactical grounds -
because it interfered with production -
it was his admitted co-responsibility
for its use in the factories
which earned Speer his sentence of 20 years.
Albert Speer's moral failure, he has said,
is not a matter of this item or that.
It resided on his active association with the whole course of events,
and for which, at Nuremberg, he assumed a collective moral guilt.
At the Nuremberg Trial,
you accept not only your own guilt,
but the guilt on behalf of all the top leadership
of Nazi Germany. And you tell us, too,
in the foreword to your book, how you are haunted by the memories
of those days today,
and particularly by a film they showed you
of Jewish inmates of a concentration camp
going to their deaths in Auschwitz.
Can you describe that for me, what you saw? It was not a film.
It was a description...
..from some report.
And this was really haunting
because they were marching to their deaths in a very...
..not only with courage,
but obviously,
like the martyrs of
the early Christian period.
And this gave us more than...
Also, numbers. You know, numbers
are practically not to realise...
If you say 10,000 are murdered,
or 100,000, or millions,
it's getting out of scale,
out of what you can really...
Comprehend? Comprehend, yes.
But... But this was something which I could really realise.
But in Nuremberg Trial,
I avoided the word "guilt",
I never mentioned once about guilt,
because I was... I only mentioned responsibility.
Because in my opinion, it was up to the judges to change
my responsibility in guilt.
And I didn't... I wouldn't have liked to, er,
to say, as in a show process in Moscow,
"I am guilty". I never said this.
Has your 20 years in jail
allowed you to accept
the burden of your own role in the Hitler period?
You mean the sentence, or...?
Yes, it was already after, erm,
after the Nuremberg Trial was finished.
And I accepted it not only during these 20 years.
Just now, a few months ago,
there was a 25th anniversary of the beginning of the trial,
and I had to stand before Belgique and German television,
and I said the same, that in my case, the judgment is right.
Because it has nothing to do with politics.
If, for instance, I would have succeeded to keep
a few workmen in far Alaska, North Alaska,
somewhere for a few years,
working for me against their own will...
..every tribunal would give me a sentence
of at least some years.
Or I guess 20 years, I would get,
just for this, keeping those few people there.
And now it was done by me a millionfold
and with grave consequences for people.
So, in my opinion -
and that's what I said on television, too -
every sentence would have been,
er, would have been right.
Nevertheless, of course,
I had nothing to do with the treatment and so on
of these people, but I was involved by asking to have them.
But is your life a tranquil life now,
or are you haunted by recollections all the time?
I think I got rid of this,
of what happened, by writing this book. This happens often.
And I'm not haunted at all.
I wasn't haunted in Spandau.
Sometimes, in Spandau, I still dreamt about Hitler,
but it was always in some way ridiculous,
what I dreamt about him.
And he never was to me, then, really a person I respected.
I don't know why.
But... But now I'm absolutely...
That is absolutely past. Also, to me,
it's a part of almost history.
I think that, er,
looking back on all of this,
you've painted a picture today
which is quite consistent
with, certainly, what you've said in your book
is quite consistent in the factual details
with what you told my colleagues and myself 26 years ago.
There are still many, many problems from the point of view
of one who didn't have your experience
and didn't, as you say, live within the aquarium.
Many problems of trying to comprehend, trying to understand.
I wouldn't want to say, for myself,
that you've cleared up all of those problems today.
I don't suppose that it's possible
to have that kind of ability
to transfer your own experience to somebody else,
so that things can be seen in those terms. But you're more a moralist
and a philosopher than I, Professor. No, no.
I...
..feel that I've learnt a great deal of detail,
that some minor problems
have been resolved.
But the great problem, to me, is insoluble.
I don't feel that I am capable
of understanding this, this...
..division of the mind
to which Herr Speer
frankly confesses
and doesn't seek to defend. Mm-hm.
Well, to me, nowadays,
it's incomprehensible, too.
But to try to explain it would only...
You would only get farther away
from the nucleus of the problem.
And the nucleus of the problem is really that, er,
I was thinking as a specialist
and not thinking as a human being,
and was so specialised in my job as an architect -
and other ones - that I forgot that humanity
is the most important part of life.
Today, the foundations Albert Speer designed
for Hitler's Thousand-Year Reich
are tombstones,
overgrown with weeds.
Of course, I can't say that
I am now, every day,
thinking about this burden.
I am normally quite serene
and I can laugh and can joke.
But it always comes back,
and it always will come back to me.
As we had it, for instance, in our conversation.
Such a conversation is not ended with this conversation.
It lasts for weeks and weeks,
until I overcome what we had to talk today.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.