All language subtitles for Last.Week.Tonight.with.John.Oliver.S07E15.June.14.2020.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DD+2.0.H.264-monkee_track2_[eng]_DELAY 0ms

af Afrikaans
ak Akan
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bem Bemba
bn Bengali
bh Bihari
bs Bosnian
br Breton
bg Bulgarian
km Cambodian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
chr Cherokee
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
da Danish
nl Dutch
en English
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
ee Ewe
fo Faroese
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gaa Ga
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
gn Guarani
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ia Interlingua
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
rw Kinyarwanda
rn Kirundi
kg Kongo
ko Korean
kri Krio (Sierra Leone)
ku Kurdish
ckb Kurdish (Soranî)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Laothian
la Latin
lv Latvian
ln Lingala
lt Lithuanian
loz Lozi
lg Luganda
ach Luo
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mfe Mauritian Creole
mo Moldavian
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
sr-ME Montenegrin
ne Nepali
pcm Nigerian Pidgin
nso Northern Sotho
no Norwegian
nn Norwegian (Nynorsk)
oc Occitan
or Oriya
om Oromo
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt-BR Portuguese (Brazil)
pt Portuguese (Portugal)
pa Punjabi
qu Quechua
ro Romanian
rm Romansh
nyn Runyakitara
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
sh Serbo-Croatian
st Sesotho
tn Setswana
crs Seychellois Creole
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhalese
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish
es-419 Spanish (Latin American)
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
tt Tatar
te Telugu
th Thai
ti Tigrinya
to Tonga
lua Tshiluba
tum Tumbuka
tr Turkish
tk Turkmen
tw Twi
ug Uighur
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
wo Wolof
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu

Original subtitles

Hi there!

Welcome to the show. Still taking place in this white antiseptic room filled

with one increasingly weak adult. It's like a hospital, only sadder.

It's been a week of continued Black Lives Matter protests across the

country, which have managed to generate far-reaching effects, both big and

small. For instance, Cops was cancelled after 33 years of being that show your

dad falls asleep to. And Sesame Street and CNN held a town hall to explain the

current moment to children, which didn't please all kids. In fact, just wait for

one giant baby's reaction.

Across the country, people of color, especially in the black community, are

being treated unfairly because of how they look.

It's a children's show. Got that, Bobby? America is a very bad place, and it's

your fault. So no matter what happens, no matter what they do to you when you

grow up, you have no right to complain.

First, obviously... Fuck off, Tucker, you one-man homeowners association.

And second, that unspecified they in what they do to you when you grow up is

doing a lot of heavy lifting there. There's basically two options for what

that could mean. One, that Tucker and his viewers have benefited from a racist

system that renders any specifications of who they are unnecessary.

Or two, that his show is a badly written piece of garbage. So, which is it,

Tucker? Are you a racist or are you a total fucking moron? The answer can be,

and indeed is, both.

But the momentum wasn't just confined to television.

The Minneapolis City Council has pledged to dismantle that city's police force,

while New York lawmakers voted to make police disciplinary records public and

passed a law criminalizing the use of chokeholds by police, both of which seem

like common sense and the bare minimum.

And yet, police union leaders have continued to freak out.

Stop treating us like animals and thugs, and start treating us with some respect.

That's what we're here today to say.

We've been left out of the conversation.

We've been vilified.

It's disgusting.

It's disgusting.

Yeah, you have been left out of the conversation, but I'll tell you why.

It's because you've been fucking terrible at conversing. If a high school

debate team argued their rebuttals by tear gassing the other team, they

probably wouldn't be invited back to regionals.

Now, meanwhile, some have taken dismantling symbols of white supremacy

into their own hands.

Statues across the world are being torn down. A slave trader in Bristol, England

was hurled into the harbor.

King Leopold II in Belgium was spray painted and ultimately removed.

And statues of Christopher Columbus have been toppled, beheaded, and in one case,

thrown into a lake, where, and this is true, its location was quickly updated

on Google Maps. Because, unlike Christopher Columbus himself, Google

knows how... to read a fucking map.

And these protests have given momentum to official campaigns, like Virginia's

effort to remove a statue of Robert E. Lee, an effort that some, like this

state senator, have been troubled by.

It's all about shoving this down people's throats and erasing the

history of the white people. And I think that's wrong. Wow.

I mean, setting aside her almost clinical ability to miss the point, you

cannot erase the history of white people.

It's like the skid marks on the arse of your favorite shorts. No matter how hard

you try, that shit's never coming out.

And statues aren't the only tributes to a horrifying past now being

reconsidered. NASCAR... banned the Confederate flag, which prompted one

part-time driver to announce he's quitting after this season. Although, to

be fair, that driver had never won a race, so he can kind of understand why a

flag for losers might have been important to him. And the country group

Lady Antebellum changed their name to just Lady A, which is a solid fix, as

long as nobody ever asks what the A stands for, or points out that that

name's been used by a Black Blue singer for the last 20 years.

And then, there was this.

Gone with the Wind is gone from HBO.

It's one of the most popular films of all time, but it's also been condemned

for ignoring the horrors of slavery.

Today, White House Press Secretary Kayleigh McEnany tore into HBO, making

it clear she was speaking on behalf of the president.

Where do you draw the line here? I'm told that no longer can you find on HBO

Gone with the Wind because somehow that is now offensive.

Where do you draw the line? Is it to George Washington? and Thomas Jefferson

and James Madison be erased from history?

Okay. First, as I've said before, the answer to where do you draw the line is

literally always somewhere.

You draw it somewhere.

Also, HBO is not permanently pulling the movie. It's going back up with

additional context. And finally, who gives a shit if something's not on HBO

Max? In fact, there may be no better way to obliterate all evidence of

something's existence than to put it on HBO Max, the only ash heap of history

that costs $15 a month.

And look, obviously, symbolic progress is progress, and a lot of these changes

have been a long time coming. But this week also brought stubborn reminders of

the institutional inertia that is going to make real change so difficult, like

Joe Biden sticking by his plan to invest an additional...

$300 million into community policing efforts, which is an example of whatever

the precise opposite of reading the room is.

And also, we saw yet more footage of police handcuffing black teens for

jaywalking, as well as a newly released video of Oklahoma officers responding to

a man saying, I can't breathe, by saying, I don't care.

That man, incidentally, Derek Scott, would go on to die at the hospital of a

collapsed lung.

And perhaps most infuriatingly of all...

As protesters continued to demand justice for Breonna Taylor, who was

killed in her own home by police executing a no-knock warrant, the

Louisville Police Department responded with this.

Police in Louisville are releasing the incident report from the night officers

shot and killed Breonna Taylor.

As the Courier-Journal reports, it's almost entirely blank.

The four-page report says Taylor had no injuries, even though police shot her at

least eight times.

Holy shit! That is appalling!

And when it comes to erasing history, this seems a fuck of a lot worse than

leaving a bunch of statues toppled, cracked and beheaded, or, as that would

probably be described on a Louisville police report, no injuries.

So, yes, it's important that we deal honestly with the uncomfortable aspects

of our past, but there's also hard, necessary work to be done in changing

the unacceptable conditions of our present.

And the only hope for that... as if to say something that has never once been

said about the offerings on HBO Max.

People don't take their fucking eyes off this.

And now, this.

And now, C-SPAN callers have some thoughts on the coronavirus for the

second most patient man on television.

I only have one question. I wanted to know, who was the last politician or

ex-politician to visit China before this?

Virus.

And why it matters?

I'm curious.

Okay. I've seen a guy walking down through a grocery store with a jockey

strap on his face.

I practiced physical distancing long before anybody tried to tell me I had to

because I don't like people.

Sam is in Seattle, Washington.

Sam, go ahead.

So, how are you doing? Fine, thanks. Go ahead.

What do you want to ask me?

Richard in Maryland.

Hello. I would just like to thank you for taking my call, number one. Number

two, you should go back to town.

Who the hell is he? He's nobody.

He's just a man from Brooklyn, Rachi.

Who cares about what he thinks? He's the lead epidemiologist on the White House

task force team.

Get easy.

You got somebody at the door. Who's that?

Okay. But anyway, I hope you guys have a great day.

Stay safe and Baba Booey.

Moving on. Our main story tonight concerns facial recognition, the thing

that makes sure my iPhone won't open unless it sees my face or the face of

any toucan.

But that is it.

Facial recognition technology has been showcased in TV shows and movies for

years. Denzel Washington even discovered a creative use for it in the 2006 action

movie, Deja Vu.

We have facial recognition software?

Yeah.

Let's use it on the bag, cross-mask it to all the bags on the south side of the

city in the 48 hours leading up to the explosion, alright?

Don't think it's ever been used this way.

Look, same thing.

Bingo.

Bingo indeed, Denzel.

With smart, believable plot development like that, it's frankly no wonder that

Deja Vu received such glowing IMDB reviews as an insult to anybody who

finished elementary school, worst movie of all time, more like deja poo, and my

personal favorite, a one-star review that reads, Bruce Greenwood, as always,

is great and so sexy, and there's a cat who survives.

A review that was clearly written either by Bruce Greenwood or that cat.

Now, the technology behind facial recognition has been around for years,

but recently, as it's grown more sophisticated, its applications have

expanded greatly.

For instance, it's no longer just humans who can be the targets.

The eye farm sensor scans each fish and uses automatic image processing

to uniquely identify each individual.

A number of symptoms are recognized, including loser fish.

Yes, loser fish.

Which, by the way, is an actual industry term.

Now, that company says it can detect which fish are losers by facial scan,

which is important, because can you tell which one of these fish is a loser and

which one is a winner?

Are you sure about that? Because they're the same fish.

This is why you need a computer.

But the growth of facial recognition and what it's capable of brings with it a

host of privacy and civil liberties issues. Because if you want a sense of

just how terrifying this technology could be if it becomes part of everyday

life, just watch as a Russian TV presenter demonstrates an app called

FindFace. If you find yourself in a cafe with an attractive girl and you don't

have the guts to approach her, no problem.

All you need is a smartphone and the application FindFace.

Find new friends.

take a picture, and wait for the result. Now you're already

looking at her profile page.

Burn it all down. Burn everything down.

I realize that this is a sentence that no one involved in creating that app

ever once thought, but just imagine that from a woman's perspective.

You're going about your day when suddenly you get a random message from a

guy you don't know that says, hello, I saw you in cafe earlier and used fine

face app to learn your name and contact information.

I'll pick you up from your place at eight. Don't worry, I already know where

you live.

But one of the biggest uses of facial recognition is perhaps unsurprisingly,

law enforcement.

Since 2011, the FBI has logged more than 390,000 facial recognition searches.

And the databases law enforcement are pulling from include over 117 million

American adults and incorporate, among other things, driver's license photos

from residents of all these states.

So roughly one in two of us have had our photos searched this way. And the police

will argue that this is all for the best. In fact, here is an official with

the London police explaining why they use it there.

Here in London, we've had the London Bridge attack, the Westminster Bridge

attack. The suspects involved in that, the people who were guilty of those

offenses, were often known by the authorities.

Had they been on some database, had they been picked up by cameras beforehand, we

may have been able to prevent those atrocities, and that would definitely be

a price worth paying. Okay, look, it's hard to come out against the prevention

of atrocities. This show is, and always has been, anti-atrocity. But the key

question there is, what's the trade-off?

If the police could guarantee that they could prevent all robberies, but the

only way to do that is by having an officer stationed in every bathroom

watching you every time you take a shit, I'm not sure everyone would agree that

it's worth it, and the people who do might want that for reasons other than

preventing crime.

And now is actually a very good time to be looking at this issue, because there

are currently serious concerns that facial recognition is being used to

identify Black Lives Matter protesters.

And if that's true, it wouldn't actually be the first time.

As this senior scientist at Google, Timnit Gebru, will tell you. There was

an example with the Baltimore police and the Freddie Gray marches where they use

face recognition to identify protesters.

And then they try to link them up with their social media profiles and then

target them for arrest. So right now, a lot of people are actually urging people

not to put... images of protesters on social media, because there are people

out there whose job is just to look up these people and target them.

It's true.

During the Freddie Gray protests, police officers used facial recognition

technology to look for people with outstanding warrants and arrest them,

which is a pretty sinister way to undermine the right to assemble.

So tonight...

Let's take a look at facial recognition. Let's start with the fact that even as

big companies like Microsoft, Amazon and IBM have been developing it, and

governments all over the world have been happily rolling it out, there haven't

been many rules or a framework in place for how it is used.

In Britain, they've actually been experimenting with facial recognition

zones, even putting up signs alerting you to the fact that you're about to

enter one, which seems polite, but watch what happens when one man decided he

didn't actually want his face scanned.

This man didn't want to be caught by the police cameras, so he covered his face.

Police stopped him.

They photographed him anyway.

An argument followed.

What's your suspicion?

The fact that he walked past.

I would do the same.

I would do the same.

So I walked past like that.

It's a cold day as well.

As I've done that, the police officers asked me to come to him. So I've got me

back up.

I said to him, I've got a now £90 fine.

There you go. Look at that.

Thanks, Lex.

90 pound.

Well done.

Yeah, that Guy Ritchie character was rightly mad about that. And

incidentally, if you are not British, and you're looking at that man, then at

me, and wondering how we both came from the same island, let me quickly explain.

British people come in two variations.

So emotionally stunted that they're practically comatose, and cheerfully

telling large groups of policemen to fuck off and do one if you're gonna take

a photo of me face!

There's absolutely nothing in between the two.

And the UK is by no means alone in building out a system.

Australia is investing heavily in a national facial biometric system called

The Capability, which sounds like the name of a Netflix original movie,

although that's actually perfect if you want people to notice it, think, huh,

that seems interesting, and then forget it ever existed.

And you don't have to imagine what this technology would look like in the hands

of an authoritarian government because China is, unsurprisingly, embracing it

in a big way.

We can match every face with an ID card and trace all your movements back one

week in time.

We can match your face with your car, match you with your relatives and the

people you're in touch with.

With enough cameras, we can know who you frequently meet.

That is a terrifying level of surveillance.

Imagine the eye of Sauron, but instead of scouring Middle-earth for the One

Ring, he was just really into knowing where all his orcs like to go to dinner.

And some state-funded developers in China seem weirdly oblivious to just how

sinister their projects sound.

That's the difference, is it? You know, it's not exactly reassuring that you

called your massive, all-encompassing AI network Skynet, but a good version.

Because it would be like if the Today Show built a robot journalist and called

it Matt Lauer, but good.

Oh, yeah, this one's completely different. Sure, he does also have a

button under his office desk, but all it does is release lilac air freshener.

This is the good version.

The point is, this technology raises troubling philosophical questions about

personal freedom. And right now, there are also some very immediate practical

issues. Because even though it is currently being used, this technology is

still very much a work in progress.

And its error rate is particularly high when it comes to matching faces in real

time. In fact, in the UK, when human rights researchers watched police put

one such system to the test, they found that only eight out of 42 matches were

verifiably correct.

And that's even before we get into the fact that these systems can have some

worrying blind spots, as one MIT researcher found out when testing out

numerous algorithms including Amazon's own recognition system. At first glance,

MIT researcher Joy Buolamwini says the overall accuracy rate was high, even

though all companies better detected and identified men's faces than women's.

but the error rate grew as she dug deeper.

Lighter male faces were the easiest to guess the gender on, and darker female

faces were the hardest.

One system couldn't even detect if she had a face, and the others misidentified

her gender.

White guy, no problem.

Yeah. White guy, no problem. Which, yes, is the unofficial motto of history. But

it's not like what we needed right now was for computers to somehow find a way

to exacerbate the problem.

And it gets worse.

In one test, Amazon's system even failed on the face of Oprah Winfrey, someone so

recognizable, her magazine only had to type the first letter of her name, and

your brain auto-completed the rest.

And that's not all. A federal study of more than 100 facial recognition

algorithms found that Asian and African American people were up to 100 times

more likely to be misidentified than white men.

So that is clearly concerning.

And on top of all of this, some law enforcement agencies have been using

these systems in ways they weren't exactly designed to be used.

In 2017, police were looking for this beer thief.

The surveillance image wasn't clear enough for facial recognition software

to identify him. So instead, police used a picture of a lookalike, which happened

to be actor Woody Harrelson. That produced names of several possible

suspects and led to an arrest.

Yeah. they used a photo of Woody Harrelson to catch a beer thief. And how

dare you drag Woody Harrelson into this?

This is the man that once got drunk at Wimbledon in this magnificent hat, made

this facial expression in the stands, and in doing so, accidentally made

tennis interesting for a day. He doesn't deserve prison for that. He deserves the

Wimbledon trophy.

And there have been multiple instances where investigators have had such

confidence in a match, they've made disastrous mistakes.

A few years back, Sri Lankan authorities mistakenly targeted this Brown

University student as a suspect in a heinous crime, which made for a pretty

awful finals week.

On the morning of April 25th, in the midst of finals season, I woke up in my

dorm room to 35 missed calls.

all frantically informing me that I had been falsely identified as one of the

terrorists involved in the recent Easter attacks in my beloved motherland, Sri

Lanka. That's terrible.

Finals week is already bad enough, what with staying up all night alternating

shots of five-hour energy and Java monster Mean Bean while trying to push

your brain to remember the differences between Baroque and Rococo architecture

without waking up to find out that you've also been accused of terrorism

because a computer sucks at faces.

Now... On the one hand, these technical issues could get smoothed out over time,

but even if this technology eventually becomes perfect, we should really be

asking ourselves how much we're comfortable with it being used by

police, by governments, by companies, or indeed, by anyone.

And we should be asking that right now, because we're about to cross a major

line. For years, many tech companies approached facial recognition with

caution. In fact, in 2011, the then chairman of Google said it was the one

technology the company had held back because it could be used in a very bad

way. And think about that. It was too Pandora's boxy for Silicon Valley, the

world's most enthusiastic Pandora's box openers. And even some of the big

companies that have developed facial recognition algorithms have designed it

for use on limited data sets like mug shots or driver's license photos.

Something important has changed, and it is because of this guy, Juan Tontat and

his company Clearview AI.

And I'll let him describe what it does.

Quite simply, Clearview is basically a search engine for faces. So anyone in

law enforcement can upload a face to the system and it finds any other publicly

available material that matches that particular face.

Okay, so the key phrase there is publicly available material, because

Clearview says it's collected a database of three billion images.

That is larger than any other facial recognition database in the world, and

it's done that by scraping them from public-facing social media like

Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter, and Instagram.

So, for instance, Clearview's system would theoretically include this

publicly available photo of Tom Tatt at what appears to be Burning Man, or this

one of him wearing a suit from the exclusive Santa Claus After Dark

collection at Men's Warehouse, and... of this very real photo of him shirtless

and lighting a cigarette with blood-covered hands, which, by the way,

is his profile photo on Tidal, because yes, of course, he's also a musician.

I can only assume that that's the cover of an album called Automatic Skip, if

this ever comes up on a Pandora station.

And Tom Tatt's willingness to do what others have not been willing to do, and

that is scrape the whole internet for photos, has made his company a genuine

game changer in the worst possible way.

Just watch as he impresses a journalist by running a sample search.

So here's the photo you uploaded of me, a headshot from CNN.

So first few images it's found, it's found a few different versions of that

same picture. But now as we scroll down, we're starting to see pictures of me

that are not from that original image.

Oh, go to, wow, oh my God.

So this photograph is from my local newspaper where I lived in Ireland.

And this photo would have been taken when I was like 16.

Wow. That's crazy.

Yeah, it is. Although, here is some advice.

If there is an embarrassing photo of you from when you were a teenager, don't run

away from it. Make it the centre of your television show's promotional campaign

and own it. Use the fact that your teenage years were a hormonal

Stalingrad. Harness the pain.

But the notion that someone can take your picture and immediately find out

everything about you is alarming enough, even before you discover that over 600

law enforcement agencies have been using Clearview's service.

And you're probably in that database, even if you don't know it. If a photo of

you has been uploaded to the internet, there is a decent chance that Clearview

has it, even if someone uploaded it without your consent, even if you

untagged yourself or later set your account to private. And if you're

thinking, hold on... Isn't this against the terms of service for internet

companies? You should know, Clearview actually received cease and desist

orders from Twitter, YouTube, and Facebook earlier this year, but it has

refused to stop arguing that it has a First Amendment right to harvest data

from social media, which is just not at all how the First Amendment works.

You might as well argue that you have an Eighth Amendment right to dress up

rabbits like John Lennon. That amendment does not cover what I think you think it

does. And yet, Tom Tapp insists that this was all inevitable, so we should

all frankly be glad that he's the one who did it.

I think the choice now is not between, like, no facial recognition and facial

recognition. It's between, you know, bad facial recognition and responsible

facial recognition. And we want to be in the responsible category.

Well, sure, you want to be, but are you?

Because there are a lot of red flags here. For starters, apps he developed

before this included one called Trump Hair, which would just add Trump's hair

to a user's photo, and another called Videho that phished its own users,

tricking them into sharing access to their Gmail account and then spanning

all their contacts. So, I'm not sure that I would want to trust my privacy to

this guy.

If, however, I was looking for someone to build an app that let me put Ron

Swanson's mustache on my face as my checking account was quietly drained,

sure, then he'd be the top of my list.

And despite Clearview's repeated reassurances that its product is

intended only for law enforcement, as if that is inherently a good thing, he's

already put it in a lot of other people's hands, because in addition to

users like the DEA and the FBI, he's also made it available to employees at

Kohl's... Walmart, and Macy's, which has alone completed more than 6,000 facial

searches. And it gets worse, because they've also reportedly tried to pitch

their service to congressional candidate and white supremacist, Paul Nealon,

suggesting that they could help him use unconventional databases for extreme

opposition research, which is a terrifying series of words to share a

sentence with white supremacists.

Now, Clearview says that that offer was... unauthorized. But when questioned

about who else he might be willing to work with, Tontat's answer hasn't been

reassuring. There's some countries that would never sell to that are very

adverse to the US. For example? Like China and Russia, Iran, North Korea. So

those are the things that are definitely off the table.

What about countries that think that being gay should be illegal, it's a

crime?

So like I said, you know... We want to make sure that we do everything

correctly, mainly focused on the U.S. and Canada. And the interest has been

overwhelming, to be honest. Just so much interest that, you know, we're taking it

one day at a time.

Yeah, that's not terribly comforting.

When you ask a farmer if he'd let foxes into the hen house, the answer you hope

for is no, not the interest from foxes has been overwhelming, to be honest.

Just so much interest. So, you know, we're taking it one day at a time.

And unsurprisingly, reporters for BuzzFeed have found that Clearview has

quietly offered its services to entities in Saudi Arabia and the United Arab

Emirates, countries that view human rights laws with the same level of

respect that Clearview seems to have for Facebook's terms of service.

So facial recognition technology is already here. The question is, what can

we do about it? Well, some are trying to find ways to thwart the cameras

themselves.

Hi guys, it's me Jillian again with a new makeup tutorial.

Today's topic is how to hide from cameras.

Okay, first, that's probably not a scalable solution.

And second, I'm not sure if that makes you less identifiable or the most

identifiable person on earth.

Officers are on the lookout for a young woman, dark hair, medium build, looks

like a mime who went through a shredder. Look, clearly, what we really need to do

is put limits on how this technology can be used. And some locations have laws in

place already.

San Francisco banned facial recognition last year, but the scope of that is

limited to city law enforcement. It doesn't affect state and federal use or

private companies. Meanwhile, Illinois has a law requiring companies to obtain

written permission before collecting a person's fingerprints, facial scans, or

other identifying biological characteristics. And that is good, but

we also need a comprehensive nationwide policy, and we need it... Right now.

Because again, there are worries that it is being used in the protests that we

are seeing now. And the good news is that just this week, thanks to those

protests and to years of work by activists, some companies did pull back

from facial recognition.

For instance, IBM says they'll no longer develop facial recognition. Meanwhile,

Amazon said it was putting a one-year hold on working with law enforcement.

And Microsoft said it wouldn't sell its technology to police without federal

regulation. But...

There is nothing to stop those companies from changing their mind if people's

outrage dies down.

And for the record, while Clearview says it's canceling its private contracts,

it's also said it will keep working with the police, just as it will keep

harvesting your photos from the internet.

So, if Clearview is gonna keep grabbing our photos, at the very least, there may

be a way to let them know what you think about that. So, the next time you feel

the need to upload a photo, maybe throw in an extra one.

for them to collect. Maybe hold up a sign that says, these photos were taken

unwillingly and I'd rather you not be looking at them. Or if that feels too

complicated, just fuck Clearview.

That really does get the message across.

And remember, these photos are often being searched by law enforcement, so

you may want to take this opportunity to talk to the investigators looking

through your photos. Maybe something like, I don't look like Woody Harrelson,

but while I have your attention, defund the police.

Really, whatever you feel is most important to tell them, you should put

on a sign.

That's our show. Thank you so much for watching. We'll see you next week. Good

night.

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.