Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
When you're not happy, will you still have living kindness?
No, I don't think so.
But true, living kindness is regardless of what condition we are in.
We still maintain it. We still have a peaceful mind, field of love.
That is the true love and kindness.
Welcome to our closing panel of the conference.
Is the modern world ready for Metta? Loving kindness.
Speaking today in order will be Venerable Bram.
Venerable Paniakara.
Venerable Ariadamika and
Venerable Karonika.
After their presentation, the panel will open into a discussion moderated by
Venerable Mudito.
Please welcome our speakers on the final panel of the conference.
Thank you.
Mr. Zorn, yes.
Beautiful. So this is the last event for this beautiful weekend. It's been
amazing.
And it's such a beautiful way to end this. It's about talking about meta in
the modern world.
We have monastics here who are professionals in this subject.
How difficult it is to find professionals in loving kindness in this
world. There are so many songs and movies made out about it, but to
actually find professionals in loving kindness in this world, how rare is
that?
Not rare at all.
I actually create them in monasteries.
So that's what we do in a monastery.
We create loving-kindness professionals.
That's it.
And you're in my monastery.
Have you got lots of loving-kindness?
Yeah, well, you know.
Well, give me a break.
I was raised in this kind of tradition as good enough.
Good.
That's loving-kindness.
Okay, right.
But Ajahn, I was thinking, okay... That's not loving kindness. Okay, that's
a mistake.
Thinking is a mistake. Ajahn Brahm always, I go, Ajahn Brahm, I have been
thinking. He said, that's a problem.
So stop now.
Okay, as a moderator, I can change things slightly.
So as we all know now, what happened yesterday, there was a not very kind
event happened just a few kilometers from here. So I was thinking...
If Ajahn Brahm could lead us now, just to get us into this mood of loving
kindness. Could you lead a short, short Ajahn, short.
Let's say the medium.
Loving kindness meditation for the audience here to get us into this
subject and think about these people who have passed away yesterday.
It's a really, we know for your locals, we haven't had this kind of...
event in Poland ever happening and it's it is a something which will everybody's
talking about so we need to have a little bit of loving kindness for locals
for everybody this kind of shootings happen right here right next to us
people were meditating yesterday whilst this happened literally a few kilometers
away so could you lead Ajahn Brahm just few minutes a medium-sized loving
kindness for all of these people who were involved in this and for all of us.
Okay.
The whole reason why people do those acts is to try and destroy loving
kindness.
That's what they really want to kill.
And so now, each one of you, if you can just close your eyes for a couple of
minutes and to realize not sadness,
but the joy.
that so many people see that, experience that and find it disgusting
and feel for whoever perpetrated those shameful
events.
Now we can give love and kindness to them, to the person who passed
away, to the police who had to react.
not to decide to kill anybody, but to save people.
And as I heard it, I'm not sure if I got it correct, but even the perpetrator
actually survived.
And so with loving kindness, can they not feel love?
When they feel loving kindness, that heals people.
Many of you who have come here have told me that you heard a monk or a nun
say some beautiful words which change your life.
Life can be changed.
So let's start changing our life and everybody's life
with a beautiful loving kindness.
First of all, start with your own body and mind and give loving kindness to
yourself.
This being, if you've known since you were born,
to remember even those first months, you may not remember
it specifically, but you understand you had a mother who would care for you.
Even if you did crazy things, poo in your pants, they would never criticize
you.
They would care for you for all your mistakes.
I take that example from my own mother.
When other people do crazy things, I still can care for them
in the way that my mother loved me.
And my father, all my teachers, was their kindness
which cured my stupidities.
And it's the kindness which cures your stupidities too.
Just like a mother loves her child, her only child,
so do you regard all beings
with the same level of care and kindness.
How do you feel when I start practicing
kindness?
My own body relaxes and heals and feels
energized.
I spent a very busy afternoon with lots of kindness.
It never tires me out, as long as I do it with fun, with a smile, with
kindness.
As you feel your own body, and as you think of the body
of your friends and relations who may not be here today,
as you think of those fellow visitors to Krakow, or residents,
who lost their life today or yesterday, please give them kindness.
That kindness is what heals.
What started off as a tragedy becomes a
thing which starts a loving kindness inside of us.
The spark which ignites the ability
to see a tragedy, and instead of being part of that tragedy, becomes part of
the solution.
To be kind to all beings, not just humans,
but animals, and all parts of nature, and all parts
of beings which once scared us.
Dangerous beasts.
diseases which we can hardly see.
Be kind to everything.
I'll finish off with a tiny story.
One of my monks went for a swim in the ocean for
health.
He always does loving kindness beforehand in Australia.
Because he's careful about sharks.
If he swam in the ocean, the sharks saw him.
He'd get eaten.
So this morning, having done loving kindness, he swam in the ocean. This is
a true story.
Only about a week or ten days ago.
He swam in the ocean. He never met sharks.
he met this massive whale and her calf,
who both swam right towards him, not to eat him,
but to welcome him.
Loving kindness has this beautiful result, that no animals,
even massive whales, come within two meters of him.
just to say hello, then they swam away.
That's what unites us with nature, with even dangerous animals.
We feel, why don't more people do that?
Even dangerous terrorists.
And loving kindness, can you feel it?
When it gets roused up, You start feeling it.
Don't worry about the object of the loving kindness.
It goes to all beings.
Every living being that lives, in Krakow and beyond,
may all beings be happy and well.
And then you realize you are one of those beings.
The loving kindness goes equally to oneself as well.
Thank you.
Sadhu, Sadhu, Sadhu.
Was that short enough?
That was the medium size.
Okay, thank you.
Well done.
Hang on. I'm supposed to be introducing these monastics here.
So, what's your name again? Ajahn Brahm, sorry.
No.
Metta Brahm.
Metta Brahm.
No, my full name.
That's correct.
I've got many names.
It drives the police mad.
Okay. So we go with that.
Then we have Venerable Arya Dhammika with also a lot of loving kindness
hailing from Austria.
Very good. How long have you been practicing loving kindness, Venerable?
I don't exactly remember the first time I did loving-kindness, I guess, maybe 25
years ago.
25 years?
That's a good amount of loving-kindness. Still beginner level.
You have to start somewhere, so it's like getting better and better. You feel
your loving-kindness is getting stronger over the years?
Yeah, definitely.
Practice helps.
Practice makes master, isn't it?
U.S. Texas, is that correct? That's where you, Bhante, live these days? And
you're originally from Vietnam?
And how's your loving-kindness going, Bhante?
It's like... Jan, not anywhere near.
I practice my loving-kindness, but still feeling like I'm just starting.
Just starting. You reckon there's a lot of, like, you can go higher and higher.
So we are, I think we're just beginners.
You have to start somewhere. Perfect.
And then we have Venerable Karunika.
Venerable Karunika, how do you feel your loving kindness?
How has this weekend been going with your loving kindness here?
Sorry? Your loving kindness this weekend.
What have you felt here?
I had felt more joy, which is an aspect of loving-kindness. Right. Not just
loving-kindness, but more joy. Joy. And more gratitude, which is also an aspect
of loving-kindness. Perfect. Beautiful.
Thank you so much.
And this is our team.
So we're going to start here now for giving a little speeches about is the
modern world ready for loving-kindness? Metta, who wants to start?
Aya Karunika. Aya Karunika, here we go. The most senior monk here, Ajahn Brahm,
will tell us, like, please, go ahead.
Stage is yours. I award you.
Ajahn Brahm is... Ajahn volunteered you.
Yeah. Ajahn volunteered you.
Yeah. That's because at the backstage I was saying to Ajahn Brahm, I want to be
his true disciple, and usually he encouraged to be rebellious. I said,
Ajahn, then if whatever you are going to say, I will say the opposite.
So...
Then he just asked me to start, then I can't actually disagree with him. So
it's difficult now.
But anyway, so I will still say, the title is, Is the World Ready
for Loving Kindness?
And when I heard that, my answer was, actually no.
do we need loving kindness should be ready for loving kindness yes and why do
i say this because how many of you have had this old-fashioned radios where you
had that dial and you had to really tune it into the channel like maybe long time
ago i have certainly tried that out and sometimes there's so much static and you
can't really hear the song right it's frustrating you can't really make it to
come because of the static.
So the modern minds are like this, static, right? We have so much going on.
People are constantly watching things, hearing things, eating, talking,
feeling, everything.
So, so much static.
We are full of, you know, all kinds of emotions, a lot of negativity as well,
tiredness. So when it is full of static like that, it is really hard to
actually receive.
Now I am not imagining this, I am not thinking about this, I am speaking from
my own experience which I am going to tell you.
So there was a time that I...
had, you know, been really silly, done stupid things, you know, and have gone
to see Ajahn Brahm to talk about it and tell, you know, been really this and
that and the other, whatever it is.
And Ajahn Brahm had said whatever, but he didn't say what I wanted to hear,
right? I expected to him, I expected something, but he didn't say. He said
something else and I got really upset.
I sort of fell from, you know, we say from the frying pan into the fire.
My mood was even worse after having gone to speak to him for, you know, feeling
better.
So, and, but the person who was with me said, the person with me said,
You know, couldn't you feel he was giving you so much loving kindness?
He was blasting you with so much loving kindness.
I said, no, I didn't feel anything what I'm talking about.
And everybody said, no, he was so kind to you.
Wow, you know, you were so in front of him. And I said, I never felt anything.
And that was because I had so much all this negativity, difficult emotions, all
that. I was so close, like that static in the radio.
receive even such big loving kindness like Ajahn Brahm's loving kindness is
really big I have felt it in other times when I was actually ready there have
been other times where I have actually been on retreat in Jana Grove and have
had opportunity to go to see Ajahn Brahm also at a time when I could feel he has
also come out of good meditation really powerful loving kindness I have received
this so I know how much it is but Still, when I am or anybody is not ready, when
you're not open, even though you need it, we can't receive it. That's actually
how I feel it. So we need loving kindness.
We need to receive it and we need to be able to give it as well. But we have to
make it ready. We have to make our mind a little bit ready to be able to
receive. Not perfect, but enough, a little crack to allow it to come
through.
So the second thing is, I'm still, I'm not an expert in loving kindness, I'm
still trying to figure out and learn loving kindness.
So there was a time, some time ago, I was on a long retreat at Jana Grove for
about four months.
And I thought, oh, I really need to learn loving kindness.
And what was going on in my head is, I have no idea what is loving kindness. I
can't do meditation on loving kindness.
There is no loving kindness inside of me. What is loving kindness?
I've read all the books, listened to so many stories.
Couldn't get it. So I thought, okay, I'm with Ajahn Brahm. Let me ask him. I can
have my personal interview one-on-one and ask some special instructions.
So I had my time. So I asked Ajahn Brahm, please, you know, teach me how to
do loving kindness.
And he gave me a very special teaching.
And I know how he usually teach loving kindness in a...
on a retreat to public, and this teaching that I got was nothing like
that. I'm not sure whether he has ever taught anybody like this, maybe a few
people. Are you ready? Are you interested to hear about my personal
instruction?
Okay.
So he told me, okay, close your eyes.
So I closed my eyes, and then he said, say, love.
Love.
And when I heard that, I got really upset.
I really got, love, I'm a monastic, don't tell me to bring up love. Love is
dangerous, it's scary.
Because for me, love and lust goes together, or love comes always with
attachment. Any kind of love, don't talk to me. So I rejected it mentally.
I didn't say anything, but I rejected it.
So immediately, so I could not benefit from it. And that's the only instruction
he gave me. So what to do? I expected again, you know, I wanted him to tell me
something, but he told me something else.
But anyway, so I thought, okay, I'll just meditate how I know how to
meditate. Forget about loving kindness.
So I was meditating for a while because it was a long retreat.
And one day...
There was a beautiful sunny morning. I was watching outside the window and I
saw these tiny little birds.
Like they were playing and drinking honey.
And as I was watching that, I felt a very sweet feeling come up in my heart.
Really, really sweet, soft feeling and wishing these birds well or may they
enjoy, may they be safe, may they be happy kind of feeling.
And when I felt that, I also recalled a couple of days ago, I had the same
feeling, and that time it was my tiny little niece.
She was only two years of age, just started to walk and barely talking, came
to visit me with her family, and she got out of her car and came running because
she's learned a new thing to do when she meets a visitor.
So that was to give a hug. So she had her arms really out. So I knew what she
was going to do. So I went all the way down to the floor to meet her. And she
gave me this beautiful hug and held me for a long time, right? In a really
sweet two-year-old, right?
And I could feel, I received really sweet feelings, similar kind of feeling.
And I also recall a similar kind of feeling generated inside of me.
And at that moment I realized, oh, that's what Ajahn Brahm was referring
to. He was using the word love, which I got upset about, but it is a form of
love, which I choose to call as affection.
Whatever it is, it is a really sweet kind of feeling, a very base form of
liking, loving, caring for somebody. Very simple form. Because I imagined
loving kindness to be some kind of really I don't know what. But it is a
very simple form.
And then I also realized, well, I never read any books.
or listen to any Dhamma talks or anything to get angry. I knew how to get
angry from I can't remember from when.
But this is the opposite. It is also a very simple form that we all have.
My tiny little niece never listened to any Dhamma talks or read any books. She
knew I would have had the same when I grew up. It is all my intellectual
things that has covered up my loving kindness.
But I could feel that, and that was it.
So sometimes, you know, you go in front of, I've learned my lesson, expecting
Ajahn Brahm to tell you what you want to hear, but he tells you what you need to
hear. So that was also a lesson for me, but that's how I actually learned what
loving kindness was, and to be able to give that.
And now I'm also going to say, now that I've recognized what loving kindness is,
but then again, try to send loving kindness is not always possible.
So some time ago, like a long time ago, I did the big building project at
Dhammasara Monastery, the main monastery complex, which lasted like four years,
pretty involved, pretty hectic, kind of really long days for me.
And sometimes, one day I particularly remember feeling really, really yucky in
my mind, really unbearable in my mind. And I was thinking, oh, I can't bear to
have this mind. I want to change it, change my emotion, you know. We had the
session yesterday, we can, we are empowered to change our emotions.
So I thought, what should I do? So I thought, oh, maybe do Buddha Anusati,
recollecting the Buddha.
No way, nothing comes.
Then I thought, oh, I've done lots of service, right? So I can do chaganusati,
recollect my good service. Surely that will bring a lot of joy.
No way, nothing coming.
Maybe metta meditation.
Not possible.
So I went to bed.
I was so exhausted, so tired.
And at that time, my mind was so small, so, you know, not in a good state. And I
could not bring up my metta.
But the next morning, I had a really long night, like slept for maybe 10 or
12 hours.
Woke up a bit more energized.
Then... I was able to meditate I was able to bring up a little bit of loving
kindness so also to remember not to force yourself so we have to make our
mind ready for loving kindness so a little bit of readiness is necessary
otherwise when we are not making putting in the right conditions and then we try
to do it and when we can't do it we think oh I am no good
I can't do it. I don't have the merit. Maybe next life.
It's not like that. Every mind, everybody is able, is capable of doing
this. But we need to sort of, you know, put in the right kind of courses and
then it is a very simple thing to do.
So this is just about loving kindness and my struggles and my path of learning
loving kindness.
Maybe some of you will be able to relate to it.
and I would like to also talk about something else.
So during the time of the Buddha, this comes up in the Sangyutta Nikaya,
Connected Discourses, Chapter 46, Sutta No. 54 called Metta Sahagatena Sutta.
In this sutta, some of the Buddhist monks try to go to alms round and it's a
little bit too early for them. So they go into another place where there's
another religious sect is there. So they have discussions.
So when the Buddhist monks went there, this other group was asking, hey, you
know, you guys practice loving kindness.
We also practice loving kindness. We also spread loving kindness to all ten
directions. You guys also do the same. So what's the difference between us, our
religions, you know? And the monks were like, sure, I don't know. So they kept
quiet. And then after the meal, they went back to the Buddha and asked the
Buddha, the people are said like this you know they are practicing the same
thing so what's actually the difference between Buddhism and Buddhist way of
practicing loving kindness at that the Buddha said if somebody ask you this
question next time ask them four questions so that you can understand but
only somebody from the Buddha's dispensation will be able to give you
the answers in this way So the four questions is Kim Gatika, Kim Parama, Kim
Pala, Kim Pariyosana. So Kim Gatika, what is the way of your practice leading
to loving kindness?
What does it have as a leader?
What fruits do you get from metta meditation?
And what is its final end?
So the answer the Buddha gives is that the way to leading loving kindness is
the way of developing the seven factors of enlightenment, right? So I'm not
going to go into detail, but that gives away the meaning. So factors of
enlightenment leads to what?
To enlightenment, right? So the metta in the Buddha's dispensation is developed
into...
develop to get enlightened to lead to enlightenment right to ending of all of
your defilements to overcome suffering and the leader for this is
the sign of beauty so the way that we develop metta meditation is also to see
the beauty the good qualities in people and in things when we focus our
attention into the goodness of somebody it is easier to feel that feeling of
care, friendliness, and build up that very simple form of like, love, care,
friendliness. But in the modern world, we often try to be very fault-finding,
even with our family, with our partners, with anybody.
But a fault-finding mind struggles with this. So always remember, metta
meditation has the sign of beauty as the leader.
And the final fruit is very interesting.
Final fruit that you get is the ability that you become master of perceptions.
The way I put this into other people is in a very gross form.
I'm sorry, I excuse myself for saying this, but it is like you can
have ice cream, you can perceive ice cream as vomit,
Or vomit as ice cream.
Simple way to put it. So you have mastery over perception.
Whether whatever it is repulsive, you can take it as repulsive or non
-repulsive. So both ways. Very nice thing to have, right? Very good ability.
So that's the fruit, according to the sutta.
And the last thing, pariyosana, the end is the final liberation, enlightenment.
So in short, in the Buddha's dispensation, the metta meditation is
all about healing our own defilements.
It's a path to eradicate the defilements and hindrances. Really beautiful thing,
right? And a byproduct of that is that spreading of loving kindness to all. So
it has a good outcome, but the main thing is to actually...
heal your own heart, purify your own heart and when the heart and mind is
purified that is a mind that is capable of spreading really powerful metta
meditation. Really powerful metta comes from a mind that is purified.
So we don't have to wait until that, but the whole path, even as we develop
wherever we are, starting from wherever we are, we can do that, and as we have
that metta mindset.
That can bring your mind into one peak, into deep meditation.
You can take that path all the way to deep meditation.
But it is after deep meditation the radiation of the metta is most powerful.
So it's kind of really nice to understand the purpose of our meditation
as a Buddhist, as the practice of our metta.
It is not just to heal the world, make our difficult people better.
Not like that.
But that's a good byproduct.
But the main thing is to heal our own heart.
And this is really beautiful, really, really beautiful way to understand this.
And this is what I would like to say for now.
Perfect. Sounds beautiful.
I really like the idea of getting a loving kindness from your niece or your
nephew. It's such a beautiful thing when children, they give you a hug, you know,
they come and they like up to your knee and they go like, oh.
You don't need to learn this in the schools.
Yeah, but you know, Ajahn Brahm's kind of like that, right? Even though he's
kind of really, really old, but he doesn't feel like. He also feels like my
little niece sometimes. You want to go and hug him in this case? Yeah, I can't
hug him, but you know.
He also feels like that. Yeah, that's true.
And when somebody has this kind of, like, this ability to give, and I think
that's why people love animals, dogs and cats and whatever.
It's just so easy to have loving kindness. Some people don't even have
that, so then they have houseplants. We're trying to find something to love.
Okay, so next one. Venerable Panyakara, is the modern world ready for loving
kindness? What do you think? Could you give us a speech about this?
Namo Buddhaya, respected Mahasangha.
Before I start, I would like all of us to do one thing.
Let us all close our eyes gently.
Gently close our eyes, but before we close our eyes, let's do this.
With your left hand over your heart, and then the right hand on top of your left
hand, remember your face expression must be relaxed.
and a gentle smile.
Okay?
Feel each and every heartbeat.
And let us start with that.
Take a deep breath.
Alright, thank you.
Were you able to feel your heartbeat?
Yes?
How many times in life that you actually feel your heartbeat?
Not often.
When we talk about loving kindness, if you don't love yourself, there's no love
to share.
Is that right?
So we often listen to big speech about loving kindness
and world peace and all those things.
Big conference about loving kindness and end wars.
But look at us.
Do we really love ourself?
Not really.
Because we totally forgot about ourself.
We only talked about loving kindness and we wanted to radiate loving kindness
towards the others.
But what about us? We need it.
If we don't have loving kindness, there's no way and there's nothing for
us to give.
And in order for us to have loving kindness, of course, there's a practice
that we already heard Ajahn talk about it. And of course, I believe that you
heard many speeches about loving kindness already.
But then when you don't feel it,
You cannot give to anybody.
So always we have to start to love ourselves first.
And in order for us to feel that we have living kindness means whenever you feel
yourself just like this glass of water, that you're in it,
smush yourself in it, that you feel fresh and relaxed and so happy and
everything.
That is when you have loving kindness.
This is when you'll be able to share.
Okay, I want to give you this, but if you don't have the glass of water in
your hands, how can you give?
Right? You have to have something in order for you to give it to the others.
So, we always have to start with ourselves.
And then when we talk about the modern world, is it ready for loving kindness?
Yes, but...
Not really.
We should ask ourselves, are we ready like Cha Chan just mentioned?
Are we ready for it?
It's because whenever we talk about loving kindness, we are happy,
we are in harmony, then we can talk about loving kindness.
But what about when you get mad?
When you are not satisfied?
When you're not happy?
Will you still have loving kindness?
No, I don't think so.
But true loving kindness is regardless of what condition we are in.
We still maintained it. We still have a peaceful mind.
Field of love.
That is the true loving kindness.
And it's always start with us.
And of course, in our own families.
I believe, because I have mothers, father, all of us do.
But ask ourselves, when our parents getting old, when
they cannot take care of themselves anymore, when they act up, when they
forget things,
When you have to take care of them, when you have to let go of your work, when
you have to sacrifice a lot of things to take care of your parents, how you react
when they are not listening to you, when they do the things that they like, and
then when they talk all night and you couldn't sleep?
When you ask your parents to eat and they won't eat, they just sit in there
all day long.
how you react to it.
That tells us that we have love and kindness or not.
Right?
When I went to the prison to teach, there's one of the inmates asked me a
question.
Venerable Panyagara, I started to learn about Buddhism.
And I love the way Buddha taught and lived.
Can I become a Buddha while I still have family?
That's the question he asked me. And I asked him, let me ask you one question.
If you can answer me this, then you can become a Buddha while you can live with
your family.
When your wife is saying something that you're not happy,
Will you still be able to give her a smile and say thanks
without reacting?
And then when your children are acting up, not listening to you, they don't
want to go to school, they want to play games, they want to sleep up late and
then get up very late, how would you react? Would you still...
Have loving kindness towards them.
Or you're going to get mad and angry.
And he said. That's very difficult.
I can't be the Buddha.
I said exactly.
So whenever you can live that life.
That you're not reacting to your loved one first.
Let's not talk about the others. You have to love the persons around you.
Many of us, when we talk about loving kindness, we can love many other people
outside, but not your relatives.
Why?
How come?
Because we always have this mentality of thinking, you are my father, you are my
mother, you are my wife, you are my brother and sister. You should know me
well.
have that expectation and so we go out and then we work we do all the thing and
you we are so kind to the others and friends and so on and so on you don't
want to react to them you don't want to get mad at them because they are higher
than you or you want to keep that relationship and then you build up all
those frustration then when you go home there you go family members
Put it all on them.
Because you are my parents. You are my relatives.
You should know me. That's how I am.
That is our life.
We always do that.
So when we do that, where is loving kindness?
If we don't start with our own family,
What can we do for the others?
Right? In order for us to love our family, we have to love ourselves first.
That's why earlier I asked you to hold your heart.
We totally abandon us, ourself.
We just want to chase for the materialities, the outside world.
barely, barely coming back within to see ourselves, to see how much suffering
our inner child has been crying.
It's asking for help every single day.
The inner child, inside of us, but we still not care.
Abandon it.
Keep on chasing the outside world and materialities.
And then when you're overwhelmed, you put it all on your loved ones.
Sadly.
So this world is always ready, but it cannot
be at peace.
And filled with loving kindness when we are not ready, when we are not getting
our heart open up and ready for it.
You know, how many of you write an email and letters and at the end of your
signature say, with Metta?
Please raise your hand.
Or not a child.
We already know he's a professional, so it's excluded.
So us, we're talking about with metta, with loving kindness, really?
We have to ask ourselves again, do we really have that kind of heart
with metta?
But when your wife opens her mouth to say something, you shout at her right
away.
And then when your boss says something, you give them a long face right away.
And when your mom and your dad forget them things, mess up the things in the
house, you get mad, so mad.
And I experienced this because I saw my siblings.
I lost my mother already.
I still have my father. He cannot see.
He's 80-something, almost 90.
And at nighttime, he keeps on talking.
And he remembers the past, not this present moment. He doesn't remember
anything about now, but remembers the past vividly.
That's how we're going to be in the future.
So imagine one day,
We're going to beat them.
How would you feel?
Would you want your kids to share loving kindness with you?
When we don't do it, we didn't do it with our parents, how could we expect
the future generation to radiate that towards us?
It's difficult.
It makes no sense.
So we could sit here and talk about loving kindness all day long. But if we
don't take action, if we don't work towards it, if we don't practice it and
live with it, only saying it, then we're going to be the same. Nothing change.
That is why this world is so chaos right now.
Because it's easy to say but difficult to do it.
And so during the Walk for Peace, you know, we encountered a lot, a lot of
problems, a lot of difficulties.
There are people driving a big truck, passed by all the venerable monks, and
they step on the gas pedal, all that black smoke covered the venerable monks,
and they give a middle finger to us.
And people are along the road, they talk about it, they say, You're so rude and
so on. Why? How could you do that to the monks?
And I also react too.
You know how I react?
I smile and I say, may you be well, may you be happy and peaceful.
And protesters, and those people come and curse at us and point a gun at us,
say, may you be well, be happy and be peaceful.
They say, if you believe in the Buddha, Buddha will take you to hell.
I say, may you be well, be happy and be peaceful.
I'm okay to go to hell.
And so I hope that we can say it, we have to live with it.
And one of the ways that I always, now that I have many global metta
meditation, how we do it, when I practice with Pao Tse Do Chi
in Myanmar, we do like this.
We close our eyes.
and imagine that we are sitting in front and then we give a gentle smile looking
at us, may I be well, be happy and be peaceful, be free from all kind of
sufferings and things like that.
If we keep on doing this within this far, if we keep doing this, keep doing
this, sooner or later our living kindness will keep on
increasing and increasing and increasing.
then that's how we start to radiate that out towards the others.
But one thing that you could see the benefits from this
metta meditation is this.
In our tradition, Vietnamese, Asian, we often say that I would like to share
my merit to you, and then when our parents get sick, when somebody gets
sick, We share the merit to them. But is it really that they can receive it or
not?
Probably they died already.
Before the merit arrived, they already died.
But one thing that you could do with this metta meditation is that you spread
loving kindness towards yourself first, and then you radiate that metta towards
the person who gets sick.
That's how we could help with your loved ones, with the people around you.
But at the end, I still have to come back and encourage you to double check
again. If you don't have metta, please don't say it.
If we don't have metta, please don't say it. But we have to practice first.
Fulfill it.
Submerge yourself in this glass of cool water.
Okay? When you feel it, now you can share it, especially your loved ones
first. If we can start with that, from yourself to your family members and to
your neighbors, to your society, that's how we radiate it out for the world to
be at peace and filled with love and kindness.
May you all be well, be happy, and be peaceful. Thank you so much.
Very good.
Sounds like you've been giving loving-kindness speeches beforehand,
Bhante.
I like this very practical approach.
It always reminds us like, yeah, there's these feelings, but no, you really have
to practice. It comes down to the practice.
One of my teachers said one time, he says, it's like money in a bank.
You always have to have money in a bank, then you can give.
Otherwise, what happens?
You go to debt.
If you don't have money in the bank, you cannot give.
That's why we need to put money in the loving-kindness bank ourselves.
Keep banking and banking, and then it naturally starts flowing out of that
bank account.
So I think I like that simile of having a loving-kindness bank account, and then
you have something to give.
So thank you. It was like a good reminder that we start from ourselves,
keep at it, keep at it, and then it flows.
Beautiful. Thank you, Pantai.
Venerable Aryadhammika, could you please tell us, is the world ready for loving
-kindness?
It's a difficult job to speak after him, you know.
But I do have to say, I'm intrigued by this question.
Is the world ready for matter?
It's quite a provocative question, I feel.
Maybe not.
Or at least in the sight of recent events, with wars going on nowadays in
the world, political conflict, societal uproar and
instability, religious fanatics.
Not here, not here.
But having said that, you know, even among meditators, sometimes after an
hour of metta meditation, then we spend three hours arguing who is doing metta
meditation properly, who is doing it correctly.
That can happen.
So many things in the world are going on, and I think there are two core
problems underlying many of them.
We call them nowadays ADD.
and ADHD.
Or in English, ADD stands for attention deficit disorder.
Not being able to pay proper attention.
But what I mean with ADD is affection deficit disorder.
A lack of affection, a lack of empathy, compassion, loving kindness.
That creates a lot of problems in the world.
And ADHD
usually stands for attention deficit and hyperactivity disorder.
But again, what I mean with ADHD is affection deficit and humility
disorder.
A lack of humility, conceit, arrogance. I think these things cause a lot of
problems in our world.
But there's a good news.
There's an antidote. There's hope.
Why? Because the Buddha was speaking about loving kindness, metta.
And metta is the ideal tool to overcome ill will, the lack of
empathy, the ill will, the anger, frustration.
Loving kindness is the opposite.
And these two things cannot coexist in the heart.
At the time when there is anger, there is no loving kindness.
At the time when there is loving kindness, compassion, empathy, there is
no room for anger, ill will.
So through the cultivation of metta, we can put that poison aside,
the poison of the heart.
So what is metta then?
Well, generally we understand it as the wish.
the hope, the intention for other beings to be happy, to be well.
Isn't that a very beautiful wish?
Just imagine everyone in the world would have this as their main priority.
May all beings be well and happy.
How would the world look like?
Sometimes I meet people who practice loving kindness for many years.
Not everyone finds it easy.
In fact, sometimes people come to me and say, Bhante, loving kindness, I tried it
many times, doesn't work with me.
Maybe they've never met Ajahn Brahm.
But then when I asked them, so how you do it? And they said, yeah, yeah, I
don't feel anything.
There's nothing going on.
And then I asked them, so you mean, are you able to maintain the intention, the
wish for others to be happy?
Yes, of course. For how long? Half an hour.
You see, you're doing it.
What are you worrying about?
Yeah, I don't have any special feelings in my chest.
I'm not supposed to feel any fuzzy feelings and a sense of connection and
joy and pleasure.
I mean, sure, these are good by-products of loving-kindness.
Like a bonus.
But the loving-kindness itself, in the Noble Eightfold Path, It's the second
path factor.
Right intention.
The intention of non-ill will.
It's an intention, it's a thought, it's a wish for others to be happy.
Can you do that?
Oh yes, that I can do.
So sometimes we worry so much about a certain feeling, a meta-feeling, which
indeed can be the by-product of loving kindness.
Good, nothing wrong with that.
But this is not the main thing.
The main thing, loving-kindness itself, is the intention for others to be well
and happy.
So don't worry so much in case you've tried loving-kindness and you don't feel
any fuzzy feelings in your chest.
Nothing to worry.
Maintaining that kind intention for the well-being of others, that's good
enough.
And in the suttas, in the discourses, the Buddha often speaks about loving
-kindness in terms of directing it in different directions.
Starting out to the east, to the south, you can say to the right side, behind
you, left and in front, up and below, around and everywhere.
May all beings be well and happy.
And this is very nice. It goes to all beings.
And I tried that many times, but somehow, the way I have learned it
actually, is that we start with ourselves.
And then go to a dear person.
And somehow, that method always works better for me. I don't know why.
But then I see also, every time I read the sutta, it says, no, no, you should
go into directions and all beings all around and everywhere.
So I have to confess here, it's a little bit my guilty pleasure that I still
sometimes start with myself and then I go to a dear person, then to a neutral
person.
but then eventually, of course, also to all beings.
So I felt always a bit bad about it, because I really tried to practice
according to the words of the Buddha, even though that practice here is also
mentioned, but in one of the later texts, the Visuddhimagga and other
Buddhist texts.
Until one time, I stumbled across a little study by Professor
Paul Slovich from the University of Oregon.
And he wrote a very nice little book or an essay.
The title is, If I look at the masses, I will never act.
About genocide and psychic numbing. It's the subtitle.
If I look at the mass of people, I will not act.
So what is this all about?
So they did ask people to fill out a little questionnaire.
And wanting to find out how high is their generosity.
and empathy when we think of other people in need who don't have resources.
So to find out how they can give a score, how high is your level of
empathy.
And then they, with a control group, they let them first fill out some math
equations.
So they did some mathematics and then afterwards also asked them whether they
want to contribute to that cause of those poor people.
And interestingly, those people who filled out, did some math beforehand,
their empathy was lower.
So it seems the rational mind has been
activated, the mathematical mind, the physicists, the mathematicians.
All hope is lost.
No loving-kindness for them, I don't know.
But according to their statistics, it doesn't look good.
But Ajahn, don't worry.
You don't have to do math before. You can go straight to loving-kindness, then
the chances are much better.
So nonetheless, they did similar experiments.
They showed people a little girl.
A picture of Rokia is her name.
A little girl from West Africa, completely emaciated, nothing to
eat, very lean, no flesh, only skin and bones,
and also this typical belly, but it's not from overeating.
And then, showing people the picture, they asked him, would you like to
support that little girl?
And of course, you can imagine, compassion, empathy is skyrocketing.
People are very willing to donate, and then also they ask them to fill out a
questionnaire. You can see from the answers, full of compassion.
And then with another group, same picture, the little girl, Rokia, you can
see her, and her brother together.
Again, people can donate something if they like.
but interestingly yes of course people will still want to support but a little
bit less and then you add another 10 children 100 children
less and less and less hundred thousand children in west africa
suffering from malnutrition nobody brings with an eye it's just a statistic
normally we would think If one person suffers, we have compassion.
Two people suffer, our compassion should be double.
Three people suffering, our compassion should be triple.
But it's the opposite.
It goes down and down and down.
Why?
Well, it seems, we don't know for sure, but the current explanation is,
evolutionary speaking, in history of humankind, we were living in small
tribes.
100 people, 150 people, we know each other, we support each other.
Somebody gets sick, we take care of him.
Somebody has a problem, we look after him.
We protect each other.
50, 100, 150 people.
But nowadays we live in a global world.
Never in history of humankind was it important that we have a lot of
compassion for people on the other side of the globe.
We wouldn't even know what's going on over there.
So, evolutionarily speaking, we are not yet ready for the modern world.
We are still like cavemen.
We are not equipped for having compassion for people far away, where we
don't see their faces, but we can very well have compassion, loving kindness,
for people that have a face, where we hear their story, and in this way,
arouse. the loving-kindness, the matter.
So what's the takeaway from this study?
Why am I sharing this with you?
Well, it really helped me to make peace with a type of practice that I
always felt intuitively works much better for me by starting out the loving
-kindness practice with a dear person, somebody I know, I can imagine the face,
the person smiling, happy, cheerful.
And only then, when the loving-kindness is strong and well-developed, then let
me move on to all beings.
May all beings be well and happy.
Indeed, loving-kindness should become universal, unconditioned.
But to start out with an individual can be very helpful on the way to get there.
How much time do I have left?
A lot of ten minutes.
Well, there's a small method I will share with you in this case, just a
short one.
Because in formal meditation, we already have heard all the instructions from
Ajahn Brahmavangsa and so many teachers nowadays.
You go online, you find so many instructions about loving-kindness.
But then how to practice loving-kindness in daily life or when we walk around?
There's a little method I came up with many years ago, which I call the Metta
Radha.
Metarader. Maybe somebody else might also have discovered that. I don't know.
But what I mean with the metarader is imagine myself like a radar station in
the military.
And my radar is the six senses.
Seeing, hearing, smelling, tasting, touching, and thinking.
Especially the first five, I would have to say.
And whenever anyone, a human being, an animal, crosses my way,
Oh, I will direct.
My radar station is blinking up, you know, alert.
And I will shoot.
I will direct my loving kindness towards that one person.
May you be well. May you be happy.
May you be free from suffering.
And then, of course, I keep walking, and then another person drives by on a
bicycle. Oh, let me catch him too.
Direct the matter to that person.
And then I hear a few birds chirping somewhere in the distance.
Oh, let me not miss out on them.
So it becomes like a little game, you know.
You can gamify your practice.
It's actually quite entertaining. I don't want to miss out on anyone.
And then whenever I don't notice anyone, I just go back to universal loving
kindness. May all beings be well and happy.
And then a small little ant walks by. Oh, okay, it's time to shoot again.
To direct the loving kindness to the little ant.
So in this way, we can bring the loving-kindness quite easily into our
daily life, on the commute, on the workplace, anywhere, whenever we
encounter other beings.
So, coming back to the original question, is the modern world ready for
loving-kindness?
Yeah.
Well, earlier I was inclined to say, maybe not.
But then,
I also feel, on the other hand, we do not wait for people who,
let's say, who don't have enough to eat, or somebody
sick, for example. We do not wait for a sick person to recover first, and then
we introduce them to medicine, right?
In the same way, we do not wait for humans who have conflict.
and only afterwards we introduce them to methods of conflict resolution.
We do not wait for people who are hostile to each other and only
afterwards teach them about loving-kindness.
So therefore, my question for you, both our panelists here and also all of us
here, are we ready for META?
Yes!
Is Krakow ready for loving-kindness?
Is Poland ready for loving-kindness?
I
can
also see that This panther has also done this before. He can work the audience.
It's always a great idea. Work the audience. Are you ready? Yes.
Ready for better? Yes.
But be careful. You know, we Austrians, Austrians are dangerous. In history of
Europe, don't follow the Austrian leaders too much.
Fair enough, fair enough. But if you're leading with loving kindness, it
shouldn't be too bad.
If you see a short Austrian with a small mustache, Yeah, be careful.
But coming back to a little bit what Panta said,
it's sometimes difficult.
Sometimes it's like you forget.
I heard this story about this one meditator. He's been very diligent
Vipassana meditator sitting all day in this hall.
And then he got up and then he just realized, I haven't been even, I didn't
realize how much hatred, I had to watch one fly in this Dhamma hall.
I've been sitting here all day, practicing mindfulness, meditation,
brewing about one fly.
How difficult it is. You should have shot the loving kind of that.
And also, I do feel for all these engineers,
mathematicians, Pali scholars.
who are really struggling with loving kindness.
It always comes as a teacher. I don't feel anything. I feel for you.
But now we're going to go to another mathematician, Ajahn Brahm, who loves
mathematics.
I have such loving kindness towards mathematics.
He truly does.
And I know it. I've lived with him so long.
He sees a mathematical equation.
His eyes lit up. And he's like, oh, give me a pen. He wants to do something. He
loves mathematics.
For me, it's bizarre.
I don't know anything.
You know what I'm going to do, Ajahn? I'm going to show you what loving
kindness we have in our meditation retreat center.
What we do.
Which one?
Okay.
So we have these things.
These little toys, right?
How many of these we have in our meditation center in China? It overflows
with toys, more toys than actual meditators.
Why do we have these kind of things in our meditations? Because they're lovely.
Because they're lovely? Yeah. Is that where loving kindness comes from?
That's the result of loving kindness.
So now we have... Yeah, sure. Yeah. Yeah.
Oops, don't. Careful.
And this is what we also do with loving, out of loving kindness to our teacher
Ajahn Brahm. He tends to have this problem with this robe.
It's not a problem.
It's a feature.
But this is loving kindness in practice, isn't it? Sometimes it comes from good
things. But what do you think, Ajahn? Is this modern world, is it ready for
loving kindness? First of all, I have to defend mathematics and science.
Many of you who are skilled in the discoveries of science and math
know that this universe in which we live is
contained.
It doesn't go on forever physically.
It's like a big ball.
I remember one of my lecturers taking a football and said, this is a
two-dimensional example of what life is, what the universe is.
We're like the surface of the football.
Whichever way we go, we can keep on going, we never reach the end. We just
go round and round and round.
That's the same with this universe in three dimensions.
Whichever way you go, if I go in that direction, don't go left, don't go
right, go straight on, you know where I will end up?
In Krakow.
And that's a truth which I learned in science lessons.
So much so,
that when I learnt the loving-kindness meditation, spread loving-kindness
infinitely in that direction, in that direction, in that direction, whichever
direction I spread loving-kindness to, it always ends up in Krakow.
Yeah, into the person who sent it.
And that's the truth of science.
Though I don't mind how the Buddha taught, send it to the east, the west,
the north, the south, whichever direction you send it, it always ends up
to you.
It comes from here, goes out over there, and eventually comes around straight
back to you.
And it's also, I want to explain why I asked Ajahn Karunika
to start.
Because all of these
panel discussions, if they do have a nun on them, they're always sitting at the
end and they always do the last talk.
Why is that?
Why to discriminate against things which you don't think are important?
I also remember one other story of loving kindness.
When I often give the simile of the five fingers in my hand,
which of these five fingers is the most important?
Sometimes we think the thumb.
When you say, wonderful, great, yes, I approve, you put your thumb up. It's
also the opposable finger.
and you can hold things with it. Without the thumb, you're in big trouble.
So the thumb is the most important, somebody said.
Someone else said, no, this finger is more important.
This is the index finger.
It points things out.
It's how we find our insight.
Over there is a photographer.
Over there is a door.
This is finger.
is the most important. It's a symbol of insight.
And then this one said, I'm more important.
And the venerable monk over there knows that truth.
How powerful is this?
When you put it out the other way.
And this finger said, no, I'm the most important finger.
When you fall in love and get engaged, I get one ring.
When you get married and commit to love another person for life, I get the
second ring.
I am the symbol of love.
Therefore, I am the most important.
And they left this little one.
What does this do?
And this one said, yes, even though I'm small, I'm the most important finger.
Every time I... I'm the one you use to take away
your suffering.
That's when you have loving kindness.
You always...
feel for and help support those people at the end of the line and
now at this particular time the Bhikkhunis who don't get enough support.
So loving kindness.
I don't use you to clean the wax out of my ears. I will always support you.
Those are the kind of similes I like. You understand them easily.
But is the world ready for loving kindness? And you said a brilliant
answer. Yes, of course it is.
It's like, are you ready to get cured from diseases, to get educated, to learn
loving kindness?
And in my life I've heard so many beautiful, unexpected stories of loving
kindness. The first one I'm going to begin with,
It's during the Vietnam War.
In Laos,
I had one of my friends, he was English, and he went to Laos before the war
erupted, and he lived there quite safely.
But then one thing he noticed, he went to a restaurant in Luang Prabang.
It was delicious food and he thought he was safe because he saw the
Laotian soldiers, the government soldiers, they were sitting at
a table and their M16 guns were against the wall.
They were having their lunch and he thought he was safe
until the enemy, the Patek Lao, soldiers came in.
The rebellious soldiers, you know what they did?
They sat at another table, put their machine guns by the
wall. They didn't fight because in those days in Laos,
war stopped for lunch.
They had different set of priorities.
And so he was actually very safe.
So what happened after they finished their lunch?
And he said the government soldiers went out first and they went to the right.
The socialist and rebellious soldiers, they went in the other direction to the
left. They made sure they never met each other.
There is some of our conditioning.
And it was a funny story, but it was true.
In those days, Laos was a Buddhist country.
And they'd learned enough about Buddhism and loving kindness.
Yeah, we have to have a war, but let's make sure we never meet each other so we
don't have to fight.
As one of the organizers of this conference told me today,
when we had a meeting beforehand about what we're going to do next and how
we're going to build a monastery.
And he said in the old days that we would, apparently in Poland, you
were just so submissive to kings and queens.
If they said, get on your horse, go that direction, you just go in that
direction. You wouldn't question.
Times have changed now.
You do have loving kindness.
You don't just follow orders.
But what is worthwhile doing?
And that's why many people in Poland are confused by modern life.
They certainly are ready for loving kindness. They need loving kindness.
Something to do which is very beautiful, very wonderful.
And that's the same in most parts of the world.
What sort of politics should you follow in the future?
You follow the politics which has the most loving kindness.
The world is hungry for loving kindness.
And it's wonderful when you spread that loving kindness.
It has to go to yourself a lot.
In meditation, monks spend hours meditating.
What do we meditate on?
That's one of the things we do, and it's a gorgeous meditation.
You get so happy.
It builds up so strong.
One of the things which I advise when I teach lots of loving kindness
meditation,
Yeah, you can spread it on one thing or yourself, but after a while, disembody
the loving kindness.
So it's not focused on anything.
It's just loving kindness without a focus, independent by itself.
And it can be very, very strong.
Then afterwards, when you come out of the meditation, you'll focus it on
yourself, you can focus it on the ant.
So many beautiful stories which you hear.
There's one of my favorite monks.
He's passed away now.
When he was on what we call Thu Dong, just wandering in the forest in
Thailand, he just arrived at a certain village.
The villagers saw him and said, please stay tonight here. He said, yes,
certainly.
And so he said, we're going to have our dinner now. You don't have dinner.
Can we come and see you afterwards when we're finished to have a talk?
He said, yeah, of course.
So he sat down, waited for the villagers.
And as he sat down, he realized he sat in the wrong place.
And he felt these red ants crawling up his leg
and biting him.
Not one, hundreds.
And he said, it really hurt.
And so the next thing he noticed, he was running away.
He said he never realized that moment when he had so much pain, he jumped up
and started running.
And then he thought, that's not what a forest monk is supposed to do.
So he went straight back and sat in the same place, right
in the middle.
of these swarming red ants.
I know how much those red ants have hurt.
I've been by them many times myself when I was a monk in Thailand.
So he sat right back in the middle of them.
But then he changed his meditation to a loving kindness.
And then, after a couple of minutes, he felt those red ants climb down
his...
crawl down his legs and away from him. They stopped biting him.
Loving kindness has amazing power.
Then he meditated peacefully with no bites for a couple of hours.
And then he heard a noise, so he opened his eyes.
The villagers were coming.
And the villagers, as they came, he couldn't believe the culture of that
particular village.
They danced when they came to see him.
That's what he thought.
But when he looked more clearly, they weren't dancing.
They were being bitten like hell by those red ants.
He saw those red ants had made a no man's land around him and never allowed
anybody to come close.
They were protecting him, not biting him.
And I've seen that so many times in life.
It shows the power of loving kindness.
Imagine if you were an animal, an ant, how frightful life is. There's big
people going through the forest and you're just a tiny little ant, part of a
colony, just trying to have a nice peaceful life.
Can't we share loving kindness with the animal kingdom?
Animal kingdom? Why do I call it kingdom?
Animal community.
We do have problems in our retreat centers in Australia.
One thing Australia is famous for is its snakes.
Many of them are very venomous.
And in our retreat center in Perth, we have a friendly
doogite, one of the most dangerous snakes in Western Australia.
Who lives in our monastery?
I don't know if Eileen is still there.
She's from Singapore.
She's been on my retreat. Yes, she's waving her hand.
Have you seen our dookite?
The snake.
Yeah.
It's a big dookite.
It just stays there. It never harms anybody.
And people give it loving kindness.
I give loving kindness to the kangaroos.
One of the reasons why when I make Anjali, I do this.
That's Australian Anjali, not this.
Everyone does that.
But the kangaroos, they're just so friendly.
So much so, that sometimes we get given so much food and I have to just
pour it out onto the ground.
And that's where I found out what natural kangaroos really like the most.
I poured out the contents of my bowl onto the ground.
On top was an apple, a cut apple.
The kangaroo just pushed that aside with its nose.
Underneath that was some broccoli.
He pushed that aside.
He pushed aside other healthy food because in the bottom of the pile was
his favorite food.
This is a natural kangaroo.
Pizza.
He picked up the pizza in his two hands and started eating it.
It's true, of course it's true. Yeah, you've done that as well.
Out of loving kindness.
Imagine being a kangaroo.
Just eating grass all day.
Grass in the morning, grass at lunchtime, grass in the evening.
Do you think a kangaroo likes that?
Having a treat is a wonderful thing to do. But the best part
of that is its loving kindness.
And the kangaroo decides what it wants to eat.
And it makes the monk so happy.
It makes me happy. It makes our visitors happy.
It's loving kindness spread to so far and that people see that, they enjoy
that, they love that.
Loving kindness creates harmony between animals who live in our modern history.
Even the birds.
You know, we had a... You remember the... Not just the magpies, but the
kookaburras?
The kookaburras would like to eat, believe it or not.
chicken legs.
Now once it's been fried or boiled or something.
But when they got one from someone, they would fry it up to a branch of the tree.
And it was, that's right, it's a chicken egg in their mouth.
They would kill it first of all. Bang, bang, bang on the tree.
And all the meat would fall off.
And the other birds would be underneath.
waiting to eat all what was edible.
So the kookaburra got nothing.
The other birds got a good feast.
It gave us a lot of happiness and fun just actually to see how animals behave.
So each one of these experiences, seeing how loving kindness is not
just for human beings.
It's for the animal world.
We share our monasteries, our lands, our time with animals.
And they become our friends.
When the animals become your friends in the monasteries where you live, I really
mean your friends,
then you understand the importance of spreading that loving kindness to human
beings as well.
That is why I've come to Krakow.
out of loving kindness, sharing it, not just with my mind, with my body,
to see how much I can help you and how honestly it hurts when you
ask me to sign your books and someone else pulls me away.
Ajahn Brahm, it's time for the next panel.
I apologize for that.
I really try my best to serve you as much as I possibly can.
and serve myself, serve the nuns, serve the monks.
I don't matter where you are born, don't matter sort of what disability you have.
Okay, my disability is I talk too much.
Thank you for listening.
Sharing the loving kindness, that's good, beautiful.
So maybe there is hope for mathematicians and engineers and
politicians in this world.
Somewhere there.
But it's interesting, you were just talking about the snake, and it was just
last week, the Vasa was ending, and next to my cootie I have a new friend.
I don't think it's a ducat, it's one of those other black ones with the yellow
belly, but it's really big.
It looks dangerous, the snake.
It might have been a tiger snake.
Yeah, it might have been. I wasn't looking because it was moving so fast
and I was moving in the other direction.
And it was literally just, somehow it was in a bad mood.
It was like literally next to my walking path. And it was one of these, because
it's starting to be sunny now.
And it was just like squirming there. And it was like, so I started to do this
loving kindness. You know, we have this different chant for loving kindness for
the creepy crawlies.
So it's interesting. We have this chanting.
We never really get to do it. So I was doing it and it was just starting to
relax. Yes, of course. Even the snake. Snakes cannot hear.
But I felt that it was like, I think it was bad mood.
So I was giving it loving kindness.
And it was just sort of starting to relax.
So now we're friends.
Yes. But I still look very carefully when I'm stepping.
That's because you care.
You don't want to make the snakes scared.
Yeah, right.
That's, honestly, that's true.
So many animals, you know, we've harmed so many animals in our lives.
And so, just to be with ants and say, I care about you, make sure that they're
not stepped on.
Snakes, that they have their little place, they can stay there as long as
they like.
Birds, so they can nest on any tree.
And they can have any food which they find.
And if they don't find any food, we'll give them some.
And it's interesting, actually, even these big snakes, which, and they're
very, very dangerous where we live.
They always squirm away, always, they don't run away, but we say run away. But
when they get close to humans, they always, you know, run off. No way.
But now that you're like, I'm friends with it. Yes, they stay.
They stay.
Yeah. and you realize that now they have a nice place, they can feel safe.
Many of, especially the bhikkhunis, have talked about safety.
They can go to monasteries, even monks' monasteries, and they can feel welcome.
The gay community, the queer community can feel welcome.
And the snake community feels welcome in our monasteries. Yeah.
Absolutely. They never harm you.
So I would like to go for a little questions now. So I don't... Yeah, okay.
Let's put the rope up. My feature. Yeah, it's your feature. Okay.
You know, one thing sometimes I think... I come from... We come from forest
tradition, Thai forest tradition. And is there such a thing as...
Tough love.
Ayah Karunika, what do you think? Ajahn Brahm. Could you, let's give to others.
Ayah Karunika, what do you reckon?
Is there such thing as tough love?
We have some of our teachers in our tradition, they're pretty tough, but at
the same time they say they have a lot of loving kindness. What is tough love
and does it exist?
I don't know. I would like to pass it on.
Okay, so, right, good.
Venerable Paniyakara.
Is there tough love? If somebody gets angry at you, does it sometimes, do you
have to give love like that?
I'm not quite sure, but I didn't know why we talk about snakes.
But here I have a snake story.
One time there's a...
Master and a disciple live in India on the mountain.
A snake is the disciple.
And then after a long period of time training, then the master saying that,
okay, this is now the time for you to go down to experience it yourself.
Okay, remember you are a snake. You have to have loving kindness towards the
others. Okay, so don't bite anyone.
And the snake was so happy that been staying with the master long enough, and
this is the time when he get to go down and, you know, explore.
So when the snake was so enjoying going down the mountain and then meet with the
people, before he meet with the people, then he get to the forest.
And he come to the forest and then the sun go down and then he cannot see the
lady. There was a lady.
An old lady, she go collect like wood for fire.
And then she collect a bunch of wood and things like that. But she have no rope
to tie the wood so she can carry home.
And then she was just, you know, touch around to find some rope. And then
finally she found one.
And then she tied it up with all those wood.
And then she put it on her shoulder and walk home, carry home. And then she,
it's so late, and then she tossed that bundle of wood into the storage and
waiting for the morning so she can come and get it.
And the snake was so exhausted and bleeding everywhere because that rope
was a snake.
Okay?
And then tomorrow when she came in the early morning, she untied it, and then
the snake was so tired, he couldn't do anything.
And then he was disappointed, and he crawled back to the mountain.
When he got back to the mountain and he saw the master, the master, what's going
on?
And the snake reported, there's an old lady, she tied me up because she thought
I was a rope.
And then she tossed me into the storage and the whole night I was exhausted and
hungry and thirsty and so on and so on.
Because of you, Master, you told me not to bite anyone. I have to have loving
kindness towards the others.
And the Master shook his head.
You know, loving kindness, yes.
But you should have let her know that you are a snake.
Like that.
So that she can stop tightening you up with the bundles of wood and stuff like
that. You don't have to bite her.
You don't have to bite her.
Things like that story, you know, I always tell to the kids and things like
that. So sometimes, sometimes there's a lot of things that is out of control.
There's a lot of people nowadays, we talk about the modern world with loving
kindness, you know.
We are in advance of technologies, isn't it?
So the Waffle Piece page, you know, a lot of time I receive messages
from our team saying that, Pan De, there are people commented on our page saying
that you're a stupid monk.
Why you cover a loka up? He cannot breathe.
Because sometimes I cover a loka in the blanket because he's cold.
Things like that. And people comment, stupid monk, why you do that?
Aloka cannot breathe.
And then sometimes when people give me umbrella under the heat, they say,
stupid monk, why you walk and you have people to hold the umbrella for you?
Any of you commented like that online?
A lot of things like that is very hard, very tough online that now we live in
this society.
That we get to see so many things. But what if we just, if we don't have
anything better, anything nice to say, why is it better if we can just stay
silent?
And of course, sometimes, sometimes incidents like that, and my team asks
me, what can I do?
I say, block it.
Because loving kindness doesn't mean that you let people do whatever they
want to affect so many other people, right?
But you don't give hate to them.
You don't hate them. You just let them know that, hey, you need to calm down.
You need to be nice to the others because there are so many people up
here, right?
So same thing.
We are here in this conference these days.
Have you bumped into anybody and you gave them a long face?
How about the organizers?
The volunteers?
Did they make you happy?
If you are not, if something happened, if you're not satisfied, if you're not
happy, please...
Give them love and kindness because they try the best and they are the same with
us as us that we are practicing love and kindness. So in a tough way, in a hard
way, we still have to maintain our peace and love and kindness. Okay? Thank you.
But don't let people ruin your day, basically.
Very good. So I will, third time I will ask. Now it's been a boy.
Is there such a thing as tough love? Do you sometimes have to get angry with
your students to care about them?
I know in our tradition there are some teachers, and sometimes they're pretty
tough. Maybe not so much in Brahm, not so much, but I know in the Thai forest
tradition sometimes they are pretty tough monks.
Yeah, I've definitely witnessed that, and some have also been the victim of
that, maybe.
Not too often, luckily.
But I do recall an instance where I was staying with Long Po in the Thai forest
tradition. It's actually quite well known to be pretty tough on his
students. And unfortunately also there's a bit of a language barrier because my
Thai at that time was not very good.
It still is not very good.
But nonetheless, so I was staying with, I think I can say his name, Long Po Tui.
And he's quite a well-known Krua Chan.
And so one time I was doing my walking meditation, not far from the place where
he stays.
And so he could see me from the veranda.
So I was doing my walking meditation up and down.
And at some point, after maybe 20 minutes, another monk comes over. He
calls me.
Hey, Lung Po is calling you.
Go over.
Ajahn needs you.
Uh-oh.
Lung Po called me over.
It's the first time.
So I went over, and then luckily the other monk was there to translate.
And then on number two he said to me, this is not how we do walking
meditation.
This is not right, the way I was doing walking meditation.
I thought, okay, what did I do wrong?
So then he explained, when you do walking meditation, you have to have
your hands in front of you. You cross the hands in front of you, like this.
And you walk up and down.
But then for me, after a while of doing walking meditation like this, my
shoulders get a bit tense, and I want to relax a little bit. So I take my hands
down sometimes, and then I cross them a little bit behind me.
Maybe I can show you.
So then I was doing the walking meditation more like this.
He didn't like that at all.
He said, when you do walking meditation, you're supposed to be ready to punch the
kilesas, the defilements.
But then if you walk like this, how are you going to punch the defilements?
This is not the right way to do it. You're supposed to walk like this.
So, of course, at first it was a bit...
Actually, he added something. I didn't even know from where he knew that. He
said, this is the Prince Charles walk.
The Prince Charles walk with the hands crossed behind.
Is this a way that royalty walks?
No.
The last time I saw that Prince Charles, now King Charles, was
dancing.
Dancing. That's the way he walks.
That's the way he walks.
According to him, this is the Prince Charles Walks, and you better keep your
hands in front so that you can punch the defilements when they come.
So anyway, that was my little admonishment from him, but actually he
was quite kind. He was not tough, or he was not rude.
In fact,
I think I felt quite honored, to be honest, that he calls me over, because
it's also a sign that a teacher shows interest, and he cares enough for you to
give you some little tips.
So, actually, it took it more as a really good sign. I was quite happy that
he called me over and gave me this little advice and little admonishment.
So, I think that's as far as I can go with the tough love. Tough love, right.
That's it.
It's how you perceive it. So, what do you think, Ajahn Brahm?
Did Buddha have sometimes, like, did he, was he a bit tough with his students
sometimes? Because sometimes in the suttas, it seems, he had to, like,
really correct somebody quite firmly. Do you think that was, like, a tough love
or a bit of a, like that? Didn't the Buddha use sometimes, like, quite harsh
words with people? I think it was only to his brother.
Brother? To Devadatta. So his cousin, yes.
Cousin, okay.
And what do you think is like, was that like, did he still have compassion or
loving kindness?
Oh certainly, because he was trying to prevent his cousin Devadatta from doing
wrong things.
Right. And that was the only thing which worked.
But most of the time, even the forest monks, even Luang Por Thuy, you know he
came to Bodhinyana Monastery several times, I know him very well.
He was always really kind when he came to our monastery.
And I was really impressed when he travelled to Bodhinyana Monastery in
Australia, he'd just have his bowl and his yam. He had such few possessions
when he travelled.
And I saw other monks come and they had so much stuff they carried.
And I thought I was being so kind to the flight attendants who had to help him
get on the aircraft.
and so kind to the people like me who met him at the airport.
I never needed to carry very much.
He was one of those great examples of a good monk.
There were some other monks who they started off with tough love and when you
don't accept that, you know, you don't need that.
So all those great forest monks I saw, they never practiced tough love,
especially Ajahn Chah.
Funny love, enjoyable love, like if you missed your girlfriend, a little bottle
of poo.
That wasn't tough.
That was enjoyable to hear.
But there are a lot of stories like that, that the old monks were quite
tough. But you never had experienced that?
No, and I travelled around to see most of them.
They were always really kind.
Even I still remember one of the monks there, Ajahn Ben.
he was supposed to be a tough monk, but he just got over a heart attack.
And so his doctor just gave him western sandwiches to eat, you know, to
save his heart.
And he saw me arrive and straight away he passed the sandwiches to me.
I was a westerner.
He was so kind.
I just thought...
kindness in all the monks who have come to my monastery, Bodhinyana Monastery,
how many times have I ever shouted at you, Ajahn Mudita?
Oh, zero times.
Sometimes there's a little bit of, well, maybe you shouldn't do it that way, but
yeah, no shouting.
Indeed, and how many monks have actually grown in that monastery?
You almost ordained almost 100 monks by now. Yeah, how many nuns?
Have I ever shouted at you?
Never. That was the problem maybe.
That was the problem?
I just can't do tough love, honestly.
Each one of you, have you ever said the right thing, the correct thing?
Always done that for me?
Have you always been stupid sometimes?
Have I ever shouted at you?
Tough love I don't think is the best way at all.
Kindness. When you practice kindness rather than tough love, people will do
anything for you.
It's a much better teaching method.
Good. Yeah, it just reminds me. You know, in the suttas... And
it's true. If you want to get somebody to respect you, you don't tell them you
need to respect me.
It doesn't work that way. You cannot sort of...
artificially create respect.
Respect comes first because people want to respect you and that really is when
you feel the loving kindness yourself.
Now, while I was coming to these questions, Ayah Karunaka, you would
know, sometimes the Buddha gave this simile of, can you hear me okay?
You know, like sometimes you have to draw blood to save a child, you know, if
they put a stick in their mouth.
It was that simile.
I was, you know, referring to. You want to say something about that?
I do. I actually remember tough life, tough luck situation now with Ajahn
Ganha, Lompo Ganha. I was visiting him some years ago and he recognized
some of my...
Actually, I had in my mind, you know, I'm here to really find out.
Sometimes you don't see your own things.
It's hard to see. So I was really honest. I really wanted to see what are
the things that was blocking me.
But what happened was it was a public display.
I had a lot of people with me, like my mother, even Ajahn Brahmali was there.
And it was on record. Somebody was videoing it.
And Longpo Ganha really brought out some things about me.
And it was really painful to hear this. I mean, one-on-one is one thing,
but in public, this is really tough, right?
But the way he was speaking was really, really kind. So the thing he was brought
up was that, you know, People with Ditti Mana is really bad, really ugly, really
horrible.
With bad mind, just translating the Pali with titimana.
Means like people with views and conceit or something like this. You would think,
oh, everybody has that, but that's not what he was referring to. He was
referring more like, I think, people who are insensitive a little bit in their
speech, maybe cut people off too quickly or something like that, whatever it is.
So anyway, and then he, to make sure that was for me, he said, oh, he asked
me to come over and gave me this really delicious chocolate.
So it was very obvious it was for me. This is to cure your dittimana.
So this was really tough.
But for me, because my mind was really, really, I really had a lot of respect
and I really wanted to take it on board even though it was not really obvious
straight away what it meant.
It stayed because he said it with so much kindness.
The tough part was it was like in front of everybody and what he said was hard
to take.
But the way he said it, I realized that he was saying this out of
kindness to help me.
So actually I cried many days because it was really painful for me. And slowly,
slowly I started to understand, but not fully.
And then when I came back, I came to see Ajahn Brahm.
And then Ajahn Brahm was asking me as well, like, you know... Who knows you
better, Lumpurgana or me? Because he knows me for like 20 years.
So I said, you know, but still, you know, and Ajahn Brahm was trying to
balance it out because it was too much for me to show the other side.
But I really did take to my heart what Lumpur said.
And it took me years and still to this day I realize.
aspects of what he was telling that are actually within me that I need to
overcome and they are important and I'm really really glad that he brought it up
but he didn't do it in a really rough way in that sense because he had so much
loving kindness the painful part was for me to see my own problem but saying it
like that was really I don't know whatever it has helped me good
And for me, being the moderator, I have to keep in with the times and having
loving kindness for all the organizers, the cleaners coming afterwards,
everybody who has to close the doors.
We have to end at some point.
And now we're coming to an end, even this last panel, which has been about
loving kindness.
What a shame it is. I would still ask all of our four presenters here, because
we have the loving kindness pros here.
What are we going to leave here as a little legacy, as a little sweet thing
for people to remind us to keep going in this practice of
loving kindness?
How do you keep at it?
Every morning.
Every morning.
Push-ups. We call them push-ups.
So this is how you practice loving-kindness. Look at the mirror and
do push-ups.
Very good.
What do you reckon?
Some kind of short practical tip for everybody to take with them. With every
breath.
Every breath, loving-kindness.
And we breathe a lot.
So every day, there's so many breaths. You start in the morning, you wake up,
loving-kindness in, loving-kindness out.
Okay, good. Yes.
Venerable Punyakara, please give us a practical nice tip for day-to-day loving
-kindness. Well, my message that I share everywhere, Ajahn, today is going to be
my peaceful day.
And that is the message that practice about mindfulness and loving-kindness,
that every morning when we wake up, remember that do not touch your phone,
which is your lover.
When you go to make your bed and then go to the toilet, don't carry your lover
with you to the toilet.
And then after you finish, come out, get a piece of paper and a pen out, write
down the statement, say, today is going to be my peaceful day.
Write it down mindfully.
Okay, and then read it over and over with your eyes. Eyes and mind pairing
with each other. You know pairing mode, right?
When you're pairing your phone with your earpiece, you connect together and say,
pairing, isn't it?
So you are pairing your eyes with your mind together, practicing mindfulness.
And then after that, read it out loud with your mouth. Mouth pairing with your
mind. To practice it, say it out loud. Today is going to be my peaceful day.
to say that to the universe that today is my peaceful day, that no one in this
world can mess it up except ourselves.
You do it mindfully and with a smile.
That is how you practice mindfulness and loving kindness. Thank you.
Aya Karunaka, we need another practical tip for day-to-day loving kindness.
I encourage everybody to have the courage to stop, relax,
and really take care of yourself.
Whatever you need to do to eat well, sleep in, whatever it is,
just taking care of yourself every day.
Good.
And that was our panel for Is the Modern World Ready for Meta-Loving
Kindness? And that ends the last panel. Please applaud again for our beautiful
guests.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.