Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
This film contains scenes which some viewers may find disturbing
STAIRLIFT BEEPS
Really fun and games, isn't it?
OK.
- KATHARINA OTTO-BERNSTEIN: - Do you feel all your work in the CIA
made a difference?
I don't think all my work made a difference,
but I think some of it made a great difference.
MARTIAL MUSIC PLAYS
I grew up in a very, very privileged position.
The Sichel family were merchants
in the back country of the Rhine.
My great-grandfather moved
with three of his sons to Mainz
in the late 19th century...
...established a wine business,
became extremely successful...
...established a business in Bordeaux...
...another one in London,
and another one in New York.
We were one of the families in Mainz everybody knew.
Very early in my life,
I found basically that I'm a happy person.
Because my mother was always a happy person.
My father was always insecure.
He was insecure financially.
And when my mother served chicken
during the week, he said, "We can't afford it.
"We should eat chicken only on Sundays."
HE LAUGHS
And my sister believed it, and I didn't.
I knew we were Jewish.
It didn't make any difference
because we were not observant Jews, in that way.
We went to the synagogue on New Year's.
We went on the synagogue on Yom Kippur.
I stopped going there when my father said,
"Peter, you either go to school or you go to Yom Kippur."
And I said, "I'd rather go to school."
I did not believe in God very early in life.
So when was sort of the first indication that, in your happy life,
that something is going terribly wrong?
My mother made it clear from the day Hitler took over.
CROWD ROARS
My mother wanted to leave Germany in '34.
She said, "All the Jews are going to get killed.
"Get out while you can take money out."
And they all thought she was mad.
But she said, "These people are different.
"These people are willing to kill to stay in power."
She always told my father, "You must read the enemy's press."
She also had read Mein Kampf.
She was politically very conscious. My father was not.
My father finally came around in '35, after the Nuremberg laws,
where the Jews lost their civil rights...
...and when my father agreed with my mother
that you cannot live in a country
where you don't have civil rights.
And at the same time,
my parents made an application to be permitted to leave Germany.
You couldn't leave without a permission.
It never came to a resolution.
So, how did you manage to leave?
Well, we left illegally.
And then my parents went to Bordeaux
to take over the management of the Bordeaux company.
And then the war started.
- - Poland, September, 1939.
The German foe begins its ruthless march of conquest
and sets the stage for World War II.
My mother said, "We must get out, the French are going to collapse."
And obviously my father said, "Don't be silly.
"I mean, the French are rich, they have resources,
"they have an army," they have this, they have that.
My mother said, "The world has changed."
In any case, they did not leave.
We were not interned right away.
But when the Germans started to invade France,
we were interned because we were enemy aliens.
My father and I in a man's camp,
and my sister and my mother in Gurs, in the Pyrenees.
Who else was in the internment camp? Everybody German?
There were Germans, both Nazis and Jewish refugees.
Well, when finally the Germans got within one or two days of the camp,
we went to the commander and said,
"You know, if you don't let us go,
"the Germans are going to get us, and that'll be the end of us."
So he gave us a pass to leave the camp
and go anywhere we wanted to
in the rest of France,
and just let us run.
We saw tens of thousands of people streaming down south,
the main road from Bordeaux to the Pyrenees.
And then we had the German Stukas
who came and strafed the refugees on the road.
And when we heard the Stukas coming down,
we jumped up to the side of the road and hid in the ditch.
PLANE ROARS, BULLETS RATTLE
We didn't know where we were going to sleep.
We didn't know where we were going to get the next meal.
We didn't know if we were going to survive.
And that whole feeling
of being totally kicked out of society,
basically, we don't know what tomorrow is going to be.
It would be, ultimately, to be able to get out of France.
It was at that stage that I became the support of my father.
The relationship between father and son changed right then.
My father lost his nerves...
...because everything that my mother
had told him for years was happening.
And he was without any hope.
And I said, "You know, we've got to go on.
"We've got to find my mother, we've got to..." Etc.
- How old were you? - I was 19.
And how did you meet up with your mother and your sister?
My father and I found them on the street in Gurs.
They were released as we were.
The French were extremely well organised,
so we were assigned to be lodged
in a chateau, a little town called Escot.
And that's where we spent the next four or five months.
When we finally got a visa to the United States,
we arrived to New York. It was very...
It was a nice, sunny day.
There was a feeling of security.
We were extremely well received by relatives.
They couldn't have been nicer.
And then we subleased an apartment
on 80th Street and Lexington Avenue.
And we found out very quickly that we were
near the concentration of Nazis
in New York, in Yorktown.
86th Street was a Nazi-dominated street in New York,
where they all loved Hitler.
There were German restaurants, German cafes...
...German movies, where they showed Sieg Im Westen,
the movie made by the Nazis of the conquest of France.
MILITARY MUSIC
We had parades of the German Bund.
You had this enormous demonstration
the Bund was organising at the Madison Square Gardens.
MARTIAL MUSIC
And then you had the America First movement,
where Lindbergh was one of the main organisers,
talking about America not getting into the war.
If you believe that this country should not enter the war in Europe,
we ask you to join the America First Committee in its stand.
PEOPLE CHEER
It was not a very nice atmosphere.
There was great discrimination against Jews.
They couldn't belong to certain clubs,
they couldn't go to certain hotels,
they couldn't go to certain restaurants.
But after a while, I got used to it.
DRONE OF PLANE ENGINES
- - No American will ever
forget this Sunday morning in Hawaii.
Pearl Harbor was a very happy day for us.
Finally, America was getting into the war.
Number one, we could get rid of all those German Bund and what-have-you.
You will now take the solemn oath of allegiance
to your flag and to your country.
Number two,
we could concentrate on defeating Nazi Germany.
- - I...
And I volunteered the day after Pearl Harbor for the Army,
and my parents were proud that I did it.
Well, here I am, a GI Joe, and it ain't bad.
MILITARY MUSIC PLAYS
- - One. Two. Three. Four.
One. Two. Three. Four. One. Two...
And then, one day, I was asked to join
two gentlemen in civilian clothes
who knew that I had lived in the Pyrenees,
who spoke with me in French
to find out how good my French was,
and then asked me if I was willing
to be dropped behind the enemy lines in France.
And I said, "I'm a soldier. I joined the Army to defeat Hitler."
And that is where my career in OSS started.
The United States never had a peacetime intelligence service.
Now, with war going on, we're going to need a secret service.
And President Franklin Roosevelt
created what became known as the Office of Strategic Services.
The Russians had an intelligence service,
Britain had one, France had one,
so America needed one, too.
If it's going to enter a global war, it needs a global reach.
So the OSS was founded by people who were drawn
from the traditional elites of American society...
...partly because these people had some international experience -
they knew how the world works - so they were natural recruits.
But then they recruited anybody that specialised
and was knowledgeable
in the many areas of the world we were working in -
foreign-born experts.
I was put on a truck to
a training camp.
- - The identities of the recruits remain
a carefully guarded secret,
which explains the use of masks in this film.
We were trained in unconventional warfare,
in how to pick locks,
how to start a car if you don't have keys,
how to kill people with a knife.
- - In this phase of the instruction period,
the student is taught the gentle art of murder,
the technique of killing
or crippling his opponent with his two hands.
The most valuable offensive blow at close quarters is the chin jab.
As the blow is launched, the knee comes up to the testicles
and the fingers close on the opponent's eyes.
If your adversary holds you up from the rear,
pin his gun arm and lock it with your left,
bringing the knee up to his testicles.
Any one of these blows will put a man out of action.
And then, after three or four weeks,
I was sent back to Washington and informed
that the mission for which I had been recruited had been scrubbed,
and that is when they found me a job in Algiers.
What were the Americans actually doing in Algiers?
We trained the agents
for the Resistance groups in France,
and also trained intelligence agents to be sent into France.
When the planning started for the invasion of southern France,
I was assigned to the OSS unit with the Seventh Army.
But we soon found out that whereas everybody spoke French,
nobody spoke German.
And suddenly I was very much needed
in recruiting German prisoners of war and finding out
if they're willing to serve as American agents.
The thing that's shocking about Peter Sichel,
he became the chief of the OSS detachment for the Seventh Army,
which is about 100 men,
at the age of 22.
At that age,
he's kind of calling the shots,
which is really quite remarkable.
One of your operations was made into a movie.
Did that movie sort of define that period for you?
Yeah.
We ended up going to POW camps,
showing the file of the person they recommended,
and then meeting them face-to-face
and discussing their life.
- Good morning, sir. - You wanted to see me?
- What's it all about? - I want to work for you,
and I thought you might be able to help me.
- You know what you're getting into? - It doesn't matter.
And you get a fingerspitzengefuhl -
a sensitivity to what that person really is.
Hold it!
We gave the man a new identity in the German army...
Let's go over it once more. What name are you travelling under?
Steiner, Karl, Luftwaffe medic, number 843587.
...and gave him marching orders
to find out the disposition of the enemy.
Target! BELL RINGS
The OSS was the only agency
that handled clandestine operations
with the support of the Army.
I mean, we had the Army providing planes
to drop agents into enemy territories.
We had the Army supply planes in order to send weapons
and other material to Resistance groups.
It was a cooperative arrangement.
And the only person who didn't want to deal with the OSS
was Patton.
He considered all intelligence shit.
He's considered a hero, but he was a bad general.
He was a very... a very stupid man.
- - The long, slippery roads.
The infantry of the American Seventh Army slugs toward
battle through the Ardennes forest.
He advanced the Seventh Army
and ended up in the Ardennes in the winter
and was cut off by the German army
and lost an enormous amount of people.
If he had listened to intelligence, he would have known before.
- Did you meet him? - Once.
It was on the subject of briefing him
that he could not advance
any further because his flanks were being endangered.
- And what did he say? - "It's a lot of shit."
I was north of Munich...
...maybe 15km north of Dachau,
when the war ended.
At that time, did you know about the Holocaust?
No, I did not know about the Holocaust...
...until, at the end of the war, we overran Dachau.
Very late.
It was known at another level, but not at my level.
- So... - It wasn't a conversation piece.
- It wasn't a conversation piece? - It wasn't.
I mean, people have to get used to it.
It was known, but only to the people in charge.
It wasn't publicised.
So nobody ever talked, as you moved forward, about the fact
that Jewish families had been picked up,
- had been transported to...? - No, that Jewish families
had been transported into labour camps, yes.
That they were killed methodically? No.
It was more than you could absorb and accept.
You know, it was so fantastic, so awful,
so... inhuman
that you somehow couldn't... absorb it.
And it remained that for a long time.
A certain number of Germans knew,
but we made them conscious of it.
So films were made of the death camps,
and the population was forced to go to see these films...
...to see what had been done...
...to see the extent of the destruction of the Jews.
And where the population centres were close enough
to concentration camps,
the population was sent by bus
and forced to go through these camps.
And that was a policy that Eisenhower,
as the supreme commander, instigated
the minute Germany gave up.
Re-education was a very important part of the occupation.
EXPLOSION
He never, ever, ever talked about the Holocaust.
There are many times when, you know, something
would trigger a memory and, you know, it usually was a negative one.
It's very rare to see him emotional,
and this was kind of an emotional moment.
But he told me a story about
the internment camp he was in,
and he saw his relative there, a cousin,
and Peter tried to convince him to leave.
Then, after about an hour, he had to go, and he left
and didn't make his cousin come with him.
And the next day he went to the camps... and died.
But that was a story I'd never heard before.
There were a lot of people
who came to me to tell me how much they hated the Nazis,
and what they had all done to help Jews.
And I had one reaction - "I don't want to know.
"You must live with your conscience.
"I don't want to know what you did or didn't do.
"But don't try to get favour
"from... something where you are the only witness."
BELLS RING
- - The war in Europe has ended.
The hour for which the world has been six years waiting has come.
Unconditionally and finally,
our German enemy has surrendered to Russia,
to Britain and her Commonwealth, to America,
to the millions who fought with their hearts and souls...
The way World War II ended
told Americans that we were now the dominant power in the world.
Now, the Russians might not have seen it this way.
Certainly, the exclamation point with which we ended the war,
the dropping of atomic bombs on Japan,
served not only to hasten the end of the war,
but to signal the fact that the United States now had
a weapon that no other power had.
Symbolically, this was almost as powerful as the weapon itself.
EXPLOSION
- - This is our job at Potsdam today,
to erect a structure for permanent peace upon
the cornerstones already laid by the Big Three.
The Potsdam Conference spelled out in detail that we were
going to administer Germany with the Russians.
- - The Allies split up Germany into four
occupation zones - French, British, American and Russian.
Berlin, the capital,
was to be administered jointly until a peace treaty, permitting
all Germans to decide their own government, could be arranged.
I went to Berlin on the 1st of October '45.
Dick Helms picked me up at the airport...
...and he drove me through
all the totally destroyed parts of Berlin.
And everybody looked beaten down.
The lack of any men, basically, except old men,
or children, and largely women
cleaning up the streets and wearing the most extraordinary clothing.
I was introduced to Allen Dulles.
He was in Berlin.
He was nominal head of OSS Germany.
And he asked me, "Peter, we'd like you to be on our team,
"so will you work in Germany with us to take over
"a unit in Berlin called the Peter Unit?"
I said, "Fine." End of sentence.
Richard Helms and Allen Dulles
wanted him to stay in Germany,
both because of his language and
because at that point he'd already been recognised
as one of the best and the brightest of the OSS.
I think around late November, early December...
...Allen went home...
...as did Dick Helms...
...and I was asked to head a
combined OSS presence,
and we moved into our headquarters in Dahlem.
One of the first targets we got from Washington...
...is to check on
the Russian-occupied area in Germany.
We were contacted by the so-called bourgeois parties
about what was happening in East Germany.
The Russians had their own plan
to merge the Communists and the Socialist Party,
and to have a one-party system,
like in Russia, in their region.
And that was the first time
when we on the intelligence side were conscious
that a cooperation with the Russians was impossible.
As of December 1945,
we no longer considered the Russians friendly.
- - Charged with carrying out our policies
in Germany is Lieutenant General Clay,
deputy military governor.
But General Clay did not accept it yet.
What was very interesting is that the American military governor,
Lucius Clay, his whole approach was
that he wanted to make nice with the Soviets.
So the more reports that came in from Peter talking about
what the Soviets were up to and how they were taking over, the more
Clay pushed them to the sideline.
It was incredibly frustrating on Peter's part
to get people to pay attention.
And you met with Clay?
We met with Clay and he did not accept it.
What was the dialogue?
There was no dialogue.
We supplied information. He could accept it,
or he could opine that it was not reliable.
We... You know, you take... don't take a position.
He did not like the intelligence service, period.
There was a communist threat.
Yugoslavia had gone communist,
the Soviet Union had occupied Poland,
Hungary, Czechoslovakia, Romania and Bulgaria.
So I think it would have
been very foolish to ignore that threat.
Peter was the one
who really lobbied Washington to say,
"Look, you know, the real game are the Soviets."
And so he was the one who was kind of instrumental
in redirecting the American intelligence community
towards the Soviets.
I was asked to go to Washington,
where I spelled out in detail
what the Russians were doing in East Germany.
It was the beginning of the Cold War.
From Stettin in the Baltic to Trieste in the Adriatic,
an iron curtain has descended across the Continent.
Behind that line lie all the capitals
of the ancient states of Central and Eastern Europe.
It's very interesting because Peter really brought
sort of the first information
back to America that rang in the Cold War.
I didn't know that.
And all the books he's mentioned in,
he's always mentioned, for one thing, in the Cold War.
- - Peter Sichel had the experience and sophistication
which was to be the hallmark of many successful CIA strategies.
The key people in CIA, all were old OSS officers.
There was a reason for it. They had the experience,
they had the know-how,
they also had the enormous
amount of motivation
which carried over into
the initially anti-communist war.
So the anti-fascist movement
automatically became anti-communist...
Yes. It was an anti-totalitarian
movement, ideologically,
which started with fascism
and then rolled over
to anti-communism.
Anything... Because after all,
we saw the Eastern European
experience of being absorbed
by Russia, and it was very easy,
ideologically, to follow
from one to the other.
You went into the CIA.
What did you do there?
Uh, I was in Germany
for a number of years, in Berlin.
- What were you doing there? - I was,
uh, the top CIA man there.
- You were station chief... - In Berlin.
So, just to imagine this - you are 23 years old,
you are looking at rubble between the two fronts of the Cold War,
and you're asked to build a spy network, right?
Yeah. Everybody who worked
for Berlin Operations Base
operated out of one office.
When my father first arrived in Berlin,
Peter was the head of station, chief of station,
and this was the first Berlin station.
And this was right after the transition from OSS to CIA.
...and was one of my main case officers in Berlin.
They would recruit agents by putting
an ad in the paper, and then they would just interview them,
and one out of 20, they would try them out.
So you always had to go through a testing period.
...how best to exploit his potential.
Was it successful right away?
- I mean, where would you find all...? - It was highly unsuccessful.
One of the officials, the Americans,
had fallen in love with one of his agents.
This is a no-no...
...because if she gets caught, they went in on the case officer.
So we told the case officer to get rid of her...
...and he wasn't very discreet about it.
He didn't pay her off, as he should have,
and make sure that she was happy.
And she was mad.
And so she went about watching him go to work, to this safe house,
this big complex where they went, called Fohrenweg.
And so she goes, "OK, that's their headquarters."
And then she took down the licence plate
of every car that went in and out of Fohrenweg.
And in a few weeks, she knew everybody,
and she had their addresses and their families
and everybody in a big notebook.
Then we told him, "We've got to make a deal."
And they said, "Oh, of course, of course.
"We'll meet you at so-and-so and we'll have the money."
And they were taking her to jail.
They wanted to put her away.
And a priest came on the phone and said,
"I think you better come here and settle it peacefully."
And we paid a tidy sum to keep her mouth shut.
That's the thing about spies. You never know,
you have to assume that they're...
If things change, that they'll turn.
The mission was to...
...to recruit the Nazis and to get...
Because the Nazis had an excellent overview of
all the Soviet operations.
And to find out, as much as possible,
what the Soviets were up to.
And he and the other informants ended up
in long prison sentences in Russia.
But they were lucky not to get shot.
Some people... Some people probably were shot.
TRAIN HORN BLARES
My father lost a few agents...
...and I think that was very painful for him.
I mean, there was one
who was laid on a train track, and they found his head.
Did it make you uncomfortable, working with Nazis?
They were like the backdrop in a play.
No emotional involvement.
- - The Soviet Union and its agents have destroyed
the independent and democratic character
of a whole series of nations in Eastern and Central Europe.
It is this ruthless course of action,
and the clear design to extend it to
the remaining free nations of Europe, that have brought about
the critical situation in Europe today.
Truman stated that
wherever a free society
was being threatened,
America would interfere and
defend that free society.
And this containment philosophy developed
to prevent any other further expansion of
the Soviet empire.
Interfering in the politics of other countries can
be both beneficial and counterproductive.
Take Italy.
If we had not interfered in those
elections after the war...
...Italy would have become communist
and destabilised the rest of Europe.
Italy was absolutely crucial
to the future of Europe,
and on the verge and constantly on
the edge of becoming a communist country.
And clearly, the CIA kept that from happening.
The whole idea of fighting the Soviets was done covertly.
That was the policy. There's no question about that.
And it was the object of huge amounts of money,
huge amounts of propaganda,
huge amounts of covert operations,
infiltration of the foreign political parties...
...and so that's what we did in the Cold War.
How did the Soviets react to all that CIA build-up?
They wanted us out of Berlin, almost at any price.
Their fright was,
you had a non-controllable element
in the centre of East Germany...
...that made East Germany insecure to govern.
They considered West Berlin like an ulcer in a body
they otherwise could control...
...and that is why they started the blockade.
The Berliners lived in a state of siege.
We could accept it
and agree to abandon Berlin,
which, for a time, part of the American government wanted to do.
Or we could try to supply Berlin by air.
The West took up the challenge.
Each day now, our aeroplanes are carrying in
a little more than Berlin's minimum needs,
thus building up a stockpile
for the most severe winter months yet ahead.
The great irony is that Lucius Clay, the American military governor
who had for two years summarily dismissed
all the warnings from Peter
and from other people about what were the Soviet intentions,
sends this cable
to the Joint Chiefs of Staff in Washington,
saying that the Soviets might attack at any moment,
and naturally set off these alarm bells,
and Peter was one of the people
sent out to figure out, was this really going to happen?
Was the Red Army in a position to come across the border?
They assumed the Soviets would attack.
They assumed that there would be a Third World War.
And my father kept that assumption for years.
We were afraid that somebody in the Soviet hierarchy...
...would dream of using East German so-called "soldiers"
to spearhead an attempt to take over West Germany.
Not Europe, West Germany.
And use the East Germans as a first wave,
then supported by freedom fighters from Russia.
They could have easily put Russian soldiers into
East German soldiers' uniforms.
They sent hundreds of spies on tourist missions.
People just going into the countryside on bicycles,
or taking a train to another city to visit their sister.
It did not require sophisticated methodology.
So, by agents placed all over East Germany,
we were able to find out
that their intentions were not aggressive,
because you don't march without supplies,
you don't march without troops,
you don't march without the railways,
you don't march without tanks and armaments and planes.
There was never any preparation to march.
- - Then the Soviet gave up.
Their blockade was lifted. For 15 months,
the Berlin airlift carried nearly 2.5 million tons
of food and fuel on 277,264 separate flights.
What do you feel was the most important achievement of
US Station Chief in Berlin?
I think the most important achievement
was to find out that the Russians
had no intention to marching west, period.
Why was there even a Cold War?
Good question.
EXPLOSION
- archive: - President Truman's dramatic announcement
that Russia had the atom secret caused state departments
all over the world to stir uneasily.
Will the atom be a grim vision of an atomic war?
1950 may tell the tale.
The Cold War is defining in terms of who we are
and were as a country.
And it is the most complex of all
policy, cultural,
political events of my lifetime.
It was a time of the un-American Committee,
it was a time of Joe McCarthy. It's a turbulent time.
Are you a member of the Communist Party,
or have you ever been a member of the Communist Party?
It's unfortunate and tragic that I have to teach this committee
- the basic principles of Americanism. - That's not the question!
For instance, in grammar school, we would have
air-raid drills every couple of days in which the sirens would
sound all over town... AIR—RAID SIREN BLARES
...simultaneously. They were some scary, loud sirens.
It's a bomb. Duck and cover!
And we would go under our desks
and we would put our hands over our heads...
You might be eating your lunch when the flash comes.
Duck and cover under the table.
...and wait for the Russians to come bomb us,
until there was an all-clear.
What was the reaction in the CIA to the Soviets
testing and producing nuclear weapons?
Surprise that they were able to do it so quickly,
and basically a certain amount of fright,
what they're going to do with the new toys.
We did not know about it,
and that was an intelligence failure.
How come you didn't know about it?
We didn't have the agent to tell us.
And Soviet agents, we got very much later.
We had a whole slew of Soviet agents later on,
after they lost faith in their country.
Motivation is the most important thing
in high-level spies.
What does he have that makes a good spy?
Well, I mean, he is definitely good at keeping secrets.
He's also... He is also good at getting people to talk. You know,
he's got a very charming way about him.
People, you know, like him. You know,
he's sort of good at, um,
you know, generating confidences.
Um...
Yeah. He's... And, you know, he's a smart cookie.
Would I really want to know if he killed somebody?
I've asked him, and he never has answered.
And that might be kind of a gruesome thing to say,
but it is something you think about when your parent has lived through
what my dad has lived through.
What areas do you think he feels or shows his vulnerability?
You know, that's a complicated question because he's older now.
So when you're that old, when you're 100,
you tend to show vulnerability more.
What was your greatest vulnerability?
My lack of knowledge of women.
HE CHUCKLES
UPBEAT MUSIC, CHATTER
I was famous for giving a good New Year's Eve party.
SHE LAUGHS
I had lots of liquor.
One of my friends brought a young lady...
...a blonde, by the name of Cuy Hottler.
I was 28, she was 24,
and I fell in love with her.
A coup de foudre.
Love at first sight.
I insisted on marrying her.
She said, "Why don't we just continue being lovers?
"I'm not the marrying type."
But I insisted,
so we got married in Kussnacht, in Switzerland...
...and I had the wedding reception at the Hotel Dolder.
Then came to the States and I worked in Washington.
I bought a house on Western Avenue with a nice garden,
and I lived there for the next four years.
We had a very active social life within the CIA family.
And we often had dinner at the F Club.
The F Club was called Spy Club,
because a lot of the CIA people were in it.
We drank an enormous amount of liquor,
a couple of cocktails before lunch,
another drink after lunch.
America was awash in alcohol,
and we had our fair share of alcoholics in the CIA.
We were useful in the morning,
we went back to our desks,
they slept for an hour to get rid of the alcohol,
and they worked again maybe two hours later.
There was a family feeling in the CIA.
It was very much smaller.
It was composed of people of similar backgrounds,
similar beliefs,
similar ethics.
And you felt absolutely at home.
I think the experience of being, you know, a refugee and a Jew
was very important to him, to assimilate.
And hearing him talk about the people of those early days,
I get the feeling they were, you know, a very sort of
blue-blooded bunch, you know,
graduates of the top universities in this country.
Um, and I think he really
liked the company of those,
that type of person.
He was so young, but he was old enough to kind of be
an independent person,
and I think he kind of treated it all like a big adventure.
With the election of Eisenhower in 1952,
you had something that had never happened before in American history
and never happened afterwards.
Two siblings, brothers,
controlling the overt and the covert
sides of American foreign policy.
That was something new in American and world history.
When Eisenhower came in as president,
John Foster Dulles, he was appointed Secretary of State.
And Allen Dulles, who had been number two man in CIA,
became the Director.
It was a prominent family.
Two members of the family had been Secretary of State.
Their father was a Presbyterian minister.
John Foster very early developed
a total hate of the communist system.
He believed they were evil...
...with a religious fervour
because, besides everything else,
John Foster was also very prominent in the council,
in the National Council of Churches.
So it became a mission in his life...
...to prevent communist takeovers.
The more they played up the propaganda of... of... of,
um, you know, the communists or atheists, and,
"They're going to take away your Bibles and they're going
"to burn your churches down,"
the more it sort of fuelled this kind of revival of Christianity.
It's like, "They're the godless, atheist communists,
"and here we are, the good Christian people."
It was part of the whole Red Scare thing.
Today, into this interdependent world
has come a threatening force -
the force of aggressive communism.
It is cunning, it is godless.
It aims to destroy all freedom,
and most of all, yours and mine
because America is its final and chief target.
Clearly, their goals were American leadership
in a united world.
Political, ideological, ethical leadership.
This fit in with Foster's religion ideas
with all... with Allen's just, uh, pragmatic ideas.
Foster was
virulently anti-communist.
Allen was operationally anti-communist.
Everybody in the CIA hated John Foster...
...for two reasons.
Number one, for his unsophisticated opposition
to communism in Russia.
And number two, because during the McCarthy time,
he fired everybody in the State Department
who was accused by McCarthy,
even if they had done nothing.
Even if there were only one communist in the State Department,
that would still be one communist too many.
And Allen never fired one person identified by McCarthy.
So I spent quite a lot of time with him
and we became very good friends.
Allen was endlessly charming.
I mean, the man had charm.
You could eat it with a spoon.
And he was charming to everybody.
He was not only interested in intelligence,
but he was romantically involved in loving it.
It's bad when you love intelligence
and the art of spying...
...and your judgment is influenced by that love.
It had been a principle of Western intelligence services
to separate the collection and analysis of intelligence
from covert action.
Allen Dulles decided,
as he was helping to draft the law that created the CIA,
that he would build an agency that did both.
He wanted to run an agency that collected and analysed intelligence
and also acted on intelligence.
That was something new in the world of espionage,
and it gave the CIA tremendous power.
What was your new job, specifically?
My new job, specifically, was Head of Eastern Europe.
He was kind of the overseer
of CIA operations.
Sort of a coordinator.
The interesting thing about when the Eisenhower administration came in
is he came to power saying that, "We're going to roll back.
"We're going to do a rollback of the Soviet satellite states."
That's obviously much more proactive than sort of containment.
Rollback means
not only being confrontational to the Russians,
but to try and change the political make-up
in the border countries like Czechoslovakia, Poland...
...and take them out of the Soviet world and make them democracies.
That's what rollback is -
get the Russians out.
Our nation must stand as a solid rock in a storm-tossed world.
To all those who are suffering under communist slavery,
to the timid and to the intimidated,
let us say this -
you can count upon us.
The first operation that I know of was into Albania,
where they were actually air-dropping and sneaking in
on boats at night anti-communist partisans,
to use these men with the ultimate hope that it might lead
to an internal insurrection.
They lost dozens of men in Albania by doing this.
Probably even more in Ukraine, and even more in Poland.
Virtually every time,
the KGB knew exactly where these guys were coming ashore.
Sometimes they'd let them run for a week or two and then capture them.
When I said to the government it was impossible
to get an organised group
to so-call conspire against the Russian government,
I was asked, "What makes you so smart to know this?"
And I said, "I'm not too smart,
"but the Russians have such a control...
..."as far as security is concerned,
"that it is impossible to mount any real resistance in their country."
And I turned out to be perfectly correct,
because nobody who was ever sent in ever survived.
The amount of people that lost their lives in Albania is unbelievable.
I mean, the preoccupation we had with Albania,
we thought this was going to be the country we were going
to turn into a Western democracy.
A little country of sheep's herds
with nothing but mountains.
Collecting reliable intelligence is difficult enough,
but people in high places
have an idea of what it should be.
And if the intelligence doesn't fit,
they don't believe the intelligence.
Clearly, the covert action programme,
the Operation Rollback programme,
was a failure.
And John Foster Dulles,
one could argue,
was the last person to realise that.
Peter Sichel,
along with a lot of other CIA policymakers,
had realised that this method of covert action
that we've been doing isn't working.
"We've got to go back to square one
"and think about it in a different way."
Throughout your career, a lot of intelligence
has been ignored and people were sent into harm's way.
Aren't you frustrated?
You're even shocked...
...because it is a waste of human beings.
It is extremely difficult on your personal life...
...and it leads to frustration...
...and it leads to alcoholism or some other way of...
...of making up for the loneliness.
Living in a world where your work
can never be discussed,
even with your wife...
...where your contacts are largely people
who are doing the same thing...
...where your social contacts are almost circumscribed
by your job,
did not give you access to the real world.
So why did you stay?
It's very... It's a...
It's like... it's like being on a drug.
It is a fascinating game.
And if you feel that that fascinating game
is important to your country,
it makes it doubly so.
Stalin died and we all noticed it, obviously,
and we all hoped that it would lead to a better relationship
between the Russians and us.
But basically,
the Russians don't change.
- - Thousands of German workers riot in the streets
of East Berlin, burning Soviet flags and buildings
in defiance of their red overlords.
A small-scale strike, which began as a protest against
an order for more work, quickly developed into an all-out rebellion
by more than 15,000 East Berliners.
A complete Russian armoured division moves in as martial law is declared.
During the workers' uprising in eastern Germany,
we did not anticipate it.
Once it started,
we had no idea it was going to be as serious
as it ultimately turned out to be.
I know that during those riots,
he was running around, trying to save people.
Now, I don't know whether he was able to grab agents
and run them to safe houses,
but I know that he did his best.
Why didn't the Americans go in?
All of a sudden they realised they couldn't go in
because if they go into East Berlin, if they go into Poland,
if they go into Hungary,
um, it could... it could start a nuclear war.
So what the perceived threat of nuclear war essentially did
was freeze it... freeze in place
the Iron Curtain, if you want to call it,
the line drawn through Europe.
What it simultaneously did, the second thing it did,
was that it made the entire rest of the world
a playground for mischief-making.
The United States adopted a narrative -
there are two forces in the world,
one run from Moscow, the other run from Washington.
They are in mortal combat.
Everything that happens in the world
is a small piece of that larger conflict.
Eisenhower had a defence policy called the New Look,
and it had two legs.
One leg was a smaller army -
Eisenhower was a budget-cutter -
and the other leg was nuclear deterrent.
That was the New Look.
What we didn't know is that the New Look actually had a third leg,
which was covert action.
When the CIA came to him and said,
"We can overthrow governments and change the directions
"of entire nations without ever sending the American military,"
naturally, someone like Eisenhower would have said,
"Tell me more."
This was their view.
Moscow has seized certain countries, the ones in Eastern Europe,
but there are other countries in the world that it can't seize yet,
they're not yet ripe for takeover.
They looked around the world and tried to find the countries
that they thought were the most endangered.
And the first one they fixated on was Iran.
Mohammad Mossadegh, the nationalist leader in Iran, was overthrown.
Iran was seen as a potential Cold War battleground,
and Allen Dulles had definitely picked the Shah as our man.
So, any person or movement
that threatened the Shah's position
became, in Allen Dulles's view, an enemy of the United States.
We were involved in getting rid of Mosaddegh.
It was largely done because Mosaddegh made very plain
that he would nationalise the British-Iranian oil company.
So the operation was in order to maintain
the Western ownership and interest in the oil production.
The Brits were involved, but we were the action part of it.
The Dulles brothers correctly saw this as a threat to the position
of big corporations all over the world.
If Mosaddegh could get away with this in Iran,
it could mean that countries anywhere, who controlled resources
that the US wanted, could say,
"We're nationalising our resources,
"and we're going to charge whatever price we want."
To prevent that and to give a lesson to rising nationalists,
Mossadegh was overthrown.
Who sanctioned this?
The president.
I did not approve of removing
a government which had been voted in by the population,
which did not present to us
a national security threat.
I thought it was not only illegal but ill-advised.
Because had we not got rid of Mosaddegh in Iran,
Iran today would be a good member
of the family of nations,
a socialist democratic country.
And that did not happen because the Shah went back,
suppression took place,
dictatorship abused the public.
It then caused a revolution.
SHOUTING AND CHANTING
We don't think it through to the end,
that an action we take today
may, in the long run, be against our interests.
We indirectly caused
the arrival of the mullahs.
After Iran, they went directly into the project to overthrow
the nationalist government of Guatemala.
And that was President Arbenz.
June 17th, 1954.
Why was the coup engineered?
United Fruit.
Guatemala was under a dictatorship until 1944.
People were being employed by the United Fruit Company
under terrible, terrible circumstances.
Before my grandfather came into power,
there was no code of labour.
They were being treated as slaves.
It was cheap labour
for the United Fruit Company.
Um, and that's why they were so successful at bringing
cheap bananas to the United States.
He came in,
he, um, gave the poor land,
he started a socialist country.
And he would have ended by taking
the farms away from United Fruit
that dominated the market down there,
and where Guatemala was a large part of their wealth.
Bananas are a very important economic factor.
He knew right away there would be trouble with the agrarian reform.
So he went and bought the land
that was not being used
by the United Fruit Company.
That's when the Dulles brothers decided to call this a communism.
United Fruit was able to convince Eisenhower
that we get rid of Arbenz.
I knew about it because some of the people who worked for me in Berlin
were involved in the Arbenz operation.
It was extremely badly handled.
It was extremely doubtful that it would succeed.
My grandfather continued to use diplomacy,
then, to move to the United Nations.
We had talked to governments from several countries -
erm, France, Britain.
We knew that they were supporting us.
We knew Winston Churchill was supporting us.
But also we knew that we were up against something bigger.
The Dulles brothers told Winston Churchill,
"You need to stay in your backyard."
Doublethink is part of statecraft.
Doublethink means that...
...you...
...enunciate a policy of wanting to create democracy worldwide...
...and then, from a realpolitikal point of view...
...you realise that unless some of these dictatorships continue,
you are endangering your own position.
The entire family had to leave Guatemala under the threat of death.
As soon as they got into the airport,
my grandfather was forced to undress in front of the cameras.
The excuse was that maybe he was hiding something.
That's how much of a threat
my grandfather was.
The CIA had picked up already Castillo Armas
to be the replacement,
and all of a sudden, the new dictator, Armas, came in
and completely destroyed the Constitution,
dissolved Congress
and repressed people back into a dictatorship
after they had learned what freedom was like.
The need for vigilance has not passed.
Communism is still a menace everywhere,
but the people of the United States
and of the other American republics
can feel that at least one grave danger has been averted.
There was no basis to any communist conspiracy in Guatemala.
It was neither communism in Guatemala nor in Iran.
It was socialist.
It was countries getting back their own
after being exploited almost colonially.
John Foster Dulles was the guy
who spearheaded the whole idea of, "This is going to be the..."
You know, "We're going to roll back communism."
And what is communism? In John Foster Dulles's mind,
it was anybody who sort of opposed, you know,
American hegemony around the world. It wasn't about communism anymore.
The Guatemala coup firmly established the view
that the United States would not tolerate
any defiance in Central America,
and it set off a horrific civil war inside Guatemala
that lasted for more than 30 years
and took something like 200,000 lives.
It destroyed, partially, Guatemala.
It's a beautiful country, beautiful people,
and we destroyed it for a long time.
Unforgivable.
Though I was American,
I also felt very strongly my European origins.
I had opinions,
some of them based on not necessarily
American pre-judgements.
I was quite outspoken about it.
And it may have been that
had somebody accuse me of being not really a patriotic American.
Did you ever talk about the FBI investigation of him?
No. Never.
- Have you heard about it before? - No. Never heard about it.
THEY CHUCKLE
Sorry, I haven't. KATHARINA LAUGHS
- I guess I'm... - Mm-hm. - Yeah.
If he was a communist or not.
No. When?
We had a colonel in Berlin
who was collecting intelligence in East Germany,
and we identified his sources
as having no access to the targets he reported on.
This didn't happen once, it happened a number of times,
and I finally told him that he should drop it,
and we had a big fight.
He then accused me of being disloyal...
...a Soviet agent...
...and wrote a report to Washington
about me being a danger to security.
And those reports were followed up by the FBI investigating me.
I was questioned, my friends were questioned,
they looked into it, and I was cleared.
Now, to make the story a little...
...more fun, that particular colonel
was then sent as military attache to Japan...
...and I had been planned
as the CIA chief for Japan.
When that happened, Dick Helms called me and said,
"Look, Peter, you better not go to Japan.
"You better go to Hong Kong." HE LAUGHS
Hong Kong was an island in a red sea...
...so we couldn't go away for the weekend
unless we flew out of Hong Kong.
We were limited to be there all the time.
The social life was extremely active.
There was a cocktail party or a dinner party
you could go to, any day of the week,
and there was an active exchange of wives and husbands.
And everybody drank too much.
He went, I believe, in '56.
He was the CIA station chief in Hong Kong, and at that point
certainly Hong Kong would have been the Berlin of that part of Asia.
China was an important target,
but it was basically not accessible to us
for espionage.
The US had no relationship with China at all.
We didn't have a diplomatic relationship,
we did not recognise Communist China,
and we regarded it as an unfriendly country.
There were no senior specialists in Chinese
in the CIA...
...so they used people
who knew about communism
and communist takeover of governments
to put in assignments like Hong Kong.
Southeast Asia had enormous natural resources...
...and the Soviets were competing with us for them.
And it was an area where the colonial power left
and the societies were not in a good shape
to form themselves as nation states...
...so it was possible that they would rather go for communism
than a democratic solution.
Now, the leaders of these emerging countries were not interested
in the Cold War.
In fact, they weren't interested in foreign policy.
Their principal interest was domestic development.
The United States insisted that countries take sides.
As Foster Dulles put it, "Our policy is global now.
"Neutralism is immoral."
Neutrality meant you're in danger of falling to the Soviets.
Here is Indochina.
If Indochina falls, Thailand is put in an almost impossible position.
The same is true of Indonesia.
If this whole part of Southeast Asia
goes under communist domination or communist influence...
My father was the first president of Indonesia.
He fought for independence to fight against the Dutch colonial rule.
Sukarno was the father of modern Indonesia.
He was also an autocrat,
and at one stage
it looked as if he was going to be very sympathetic to the communists.
So we were rather anxious to know more about him.
His ambition was really to unite the country.
CHEERING
People loved his speeches.
He had a standing ovation in Washington, D.C.,
when he visited in 1956.
- - America says welcome in a big way to President Sukarno.
Vice President Nixon and State Secretary Dulles
are on hand at Washington's National Airport.
Although newly independent, Indonesia is neutralist.
He had come to the United States. He had been welcomed.
He addressed a joint session of Congress.
May God give us, America and Indonesia,
the best friendship
which has ever existed between two nations.
Thank you. APPLAUSE
Then, after he went home to Indonesia,
a few months later he went to visit China.
He saw this as neutralism.
We saw it as a stab in the back.
My father's foreign policy goals was for Indonesia to be accepted
as an independent country who didn't have to take, really, any sides,
whether it was for the Americans or for the Soviets,
and to keep their resources for themselves.
Indonesia is by far the richest country in natural resources.
They have copper, rubber, oil, palm oil, gold.
And he had nationalised many American companies, yes.
I actually ran an operation personally...
...through an American air hostess who worked for Pan Am...
...in the plane that Sukarno had rented,
with a crew...
...and her only job was to get Sukarno's...
..."caca"...
...because we had heard that he was very sick
and we wanted to find out if this was true or not.
So, you can imagine, it wasn't easy to first find the woman willing
to do that, to convince her to do it,
to get that "caca" to the right people.
And then we found out he was perfectly all right.
We tried several other things against Sukarno,
including trying to work with a number of colonels
who conspired against him.
We sent a plane in, in order to supply them.
The plane was shot down.
The pilot admitted that he worked for the CIA
and, ultimately, we brought him out.
It was below the radar. Nobody ever found out about these things.
I mean, of course there is the story of Allen Pope,
who's bombing civilians, as well as trying to bomb
the military forces which were loyal to my father.
His plane went down and his parachute got caught on a tree
and he was arrested by the Indonesian army,
and it was a huge embarrassment
because he was obviously an American pilot working for the CIA.
Allen Pope had made this statement, actually, that when he was bombing
the civilians in the name of eliminating communism,
that actually the civilians probably did not even know
what communism meant.
Ultimately, it turned out that Sukarno
would not have given the country over to the communists.
He was too much of a nationalist.
And the CIA...
...had a lot of egg on its face.
The Americans fought also for their freedom
against the colonialism from the British,
so they should have understood better, yes.
WHISTLING
- - How is it that the CIA misjudged so many situations?
And you - why did you misjudge the situation?
It's burn-out and losing... and losing...
...and losing reality.
You're living in a world of mirrors
and you,
after a while, don't know what is true and what is not true.
It is unhealthy for anybody to spend more than 15 years
in the clandestine service
because you're no longer able to think straight
because you've lived in a protected and different world
for so long that you have no...
...relationship anymore with the society you live in...
...and it's likely that you're burned out
and really no longer creative.
Allen Dulles went on an extensive trip
to visit CIA stations in the Far East in...
I believe it was probably '59.
He started in Singapore,
went to Malay, went to Thailand,
went to Pakistan, India,
and then came to Hong Kong.
And I arranged a dinner party...
...with the head of government in Hong Kong
and the secretary and the head of MI5 and MI6,
and we discussed the situation in Hong Kong
and in Southeast Asia.
I think that there was this idea that you might be able to do
kind of a rollback against Mao,
because Richard Bissell showed up and announced that now the CIA
was going to do the same thing in Communist China that they had done
and failed so miserably at in Eastern Europe -
this massive campaign of sending anti-communist partisans
across into China -
and Peter knew it was going to be a disaster.
The CIA sent freedom fighters into China
to contact so-called "resistance groups"...
...and we knew that there was a considerable amount of money
committed to that effort.
We had a conference of station chiefs in Manila,
and by that time I knew quite a bit about
what they were doing in China,
and I had a talk with Dick Bissell and I said,
"Look, Dick, we sent people into Ukraine
"to resistance groups that didn't exist and they went to their death.
"We sent people in Albania to resistance groups
"that didn't exist and they went to their death.
"We're now doing the same thing in China,
"and I don't want to be associated with a company
"that is responsible for the death of people
"because they refuse to learn from their own experience."
It was, for me, the... the cutting-off point.
And it was that thing which ultimately caused me
to... to resign from the CIA.
And what did he say?
He did not say anything.
He accepted it. Period.
Mr Bissell, it's a truism in our society
that moral ends don't justify immoral means,
and yet you and your colleagues in the CIA must, on many occasions,
have had to abandon that principle. How do you deal with it?
I think the morality of, shall we call it for short the Cold War...
...is so infinitely easier...
...than the morality of almost any kind of a hot war...
...that I never encountered this
as a serious problem.
Did you apply, for example, moral standards
to what you did when you were director of the CIA?
Yes, I did. Why?
Because I don't think...
...erm, given the calibre of the men and women I had working for me,
I didn't want to ask them to do a thing that I wouldn't do.
One or two said that even what I assigned them,
they preferred not to do.
That was all right with me.
I didn't ask them to do it.
Obviously, I discussed it with Allen.
Well, he was sorry to see me go.
And he was convinced I was going to come back.
He could not envisage anybody living
without being in the CIA.
I mean, these people served...
...served a god,
and the god was intelligence.
When I left the CIA,
they gave me the Distinguished Intelligence Medal,
which is not given freely.
I was given a luncheon by Allen Dulles.
My departure was made easier and faster...
...because I disapproved of so many things that were happening.
My own marriage was not... was on the rocks.
My first wife, though extremely charming,
had a roving eye...
...and the first time we had a major crisis
was when she had an affair in Washington
with a colleague of mine in the CIA.
And in Hong Kong she had an affair with an Englishman
who ran the classical music section
of Hong Kong Radio.
We decided to separate for good.
When I finally wanted to marry Stella,
my first wife decided she wanted to come back
and see if we couldn't get together again,
and of course, it was unrealistic.
I took over a small import company
that tried to sell Sichel German wines,
both in New York and nationally.
And since we had a brand which was easy to drink,
it was slightly sweet, it would go with almost any dish.
You want a really fine wine. One you can drink with any kind of food.
Blue Nun.
Blue Nun, sir. It's exquisite.
Blue Nun - an exquisite wine. Honestly.
At one point, we were one of the biggest wine brands worldwide.
When I first joined OSS,
I was extremely young and extremely innocent.
I never went to college
and I found the need to educate myself
by reading history and philosophy,
and I became more conscious
and more responsive
to the effect of action
of certain types
to the larger world.
We've never been in a foreign affairs situation
where we weren't happy to have enemies.
Somehow, that competition
of facing an enemy
is in our nature.
We're dealing with 20th-century mindsets
that have not thought of the future
and how things can change between nations.
We're not thinking of the underlying problems of poverty,
disease, overpopulation...
...climate change, which today are much more important
than getting the upper hand over somebody else.
Peter's life has been so diversified,
it's really the stuff of movies.
We call him the Jewish James Bond.
Ladies and gentlemen, I give you our beloved friend, Peter Sichel.
APPLAUSE
Will spying ever become obsolete?
No.
Spying will never become obsolete.
People will always want to find out what the other people are doing.
How does one leave the CIA?
LAUGHTER
You self-destruct.
RAUCOUS LAUGHTER
Have you told us all your secrets?
They probably can hang me for some of the things I've told you.
PETER CHUCKLES
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.