Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:25,421 --> 00:00:27,381
Anyone who is on the bus would
2
00:00:27,541 --> 00:00:29,981
have experienced
some level of trauma.
3
00:00:34,741 --> 00:00:37,061
Was there an attack on the bus?
Was it a member of the public?
4
00:00:37,221 --> 00:00:39,101
There were very few details.
5
00:00:40,301 --> 00:00:42,461
Anyone looking at that
from the outside,
6
00:00:42,621 --> 00:00:44,301
not knowing the true facts,
7
00:00:44,461 --> 00:00:47,581
it's almost inconceivable
that only hours before,
8
00:00:47,741 --> 00:00:50,741
together, they've taken part
in the most heinous crime
9
00:00:50,901 --> 00:00:54,141
and then taken part
in the most heinous attempt
10
00:00:54,301 --> 00:00:55,701
to cover that crime up.
11
00:00:58,581 --> 00:01:01,421
I feel for the detectives
in this particular case
12
00:01:01,581 --> 00:01:05,661
because, can have all logic in the
world, but you need that evidence.
13
00:01:05,821 --> 00:01:08,901
And many times it's just not there.
14
00:01:10,941 --> 00:01:13,581
It comes down to
where else was this child at?
15
00:01:13,741 --> 00:01:16,821
And again, it seems that
the only place this child was at
16
00:01:16,981 --> 00:01:18,621
was in the family residence.
17
00:01:20,021 --> 00:01:21,341
In all of these incidents,
18
00:01:21,501 --> 00:01:23,741
what ends up happening
is the mom blames the dad.
19
00:01:23,901 --> 00:01:25,421
Dad blames the mom.
20
00:01:26,621 --> 00:01:28,741
No one's going to make it out
of this trial
21
00:01:28,901 --> 00:01:30,421
without an emotional scar.
22
00:01:31,861 --> 00:01:34,861
This crime
and these two people's actions
23
00:01:35,021 --> 00:01:38,301
have done so much damage
to a lot of people.
24
00:01:38,461 --> 00:01:40,101
More people than they know.
25
00:01:58,781 --> 00:02:00,821
London's a very sprawling
metropolis.
26
00:02:00,981 --> 00:02:02,741
We've got a very diverse community.
27
00:02:02,901 --> 00:02:06,061
And we've got a certainly
a very diverse range of crimes,
28
00:02:06,221 --> 00:02:08,061
far, far more than
the rest of the country,
29
00:02:08,221 --> 00:02:09,501
in my experience.
30
00:02:10,981 --> 00:02:13,821
Violent crime, sadly,
is more prevalent in London.
31
00:02:17,021 --> 00:02:18,941
Stratford's in the borough
of Newham,
32
00:02:19,101 --> 00:02:23,221
which is one of the biggest
and fastest growing
33
00:02:23,381 --> 00:02:24,581
boroughs in London.
34
00:02:24,741 --> 00:02:27,221
And it's got
a very, very diverse population.
35
00:02:30,461 --> 00:02:32,261
Compared to the rest of London,
36
00:02:32,421 --> 00:02:34,701
it's got levels
of quite high deprivation.
37
00:02:35,821 --> 00:02:39,101
So with that I guess comes
some crime, petty crime,
38
00:02:39,261 --> 00:02:40,821
theft, robbery, stuff like that.
39
00:02:42,781 --> 00:02:46,541
There are significant pockets
of crime within Stratford,
40
00:02:46,701 --> 00:02:50,781
such as violent crime, drug dealing,
robbery and things of that nature.
41
00:03:01,181 --> 00:03:05,701
Rosalin Baker was known
to social services for many years.
42
00:03:05,861 --> 00:03:08,981
She kind of presented first,
I think, because she was homeless,
43
00:03:09,141 --> 00:03:11,621
like living in between
families and friends,
44
00:03:11,781 --> 00:03:14,221
but also known
to have a chaotic background.
45
00:03:15,941 --> 00:03:18,661
She lived very much kind of,
on the fringe,
46
00:03:18,821 --> 00:03:21,341
and that she didn't engage
in any kind of regular work,
47
00:03:21,501 --> 00:03:23,421
education, that type of thing.
48
00:03:25,381 --> 00:03:26,981
She was an addict,
49
00:03:27,141 --> 00:03:32,541
and she was with Jeffrey Wiltshire
who was 23 years her senior.
50
00:03:35,221 --> 00:03:39,181
He had been a rapper,
he'd fathered many children,
51
00:03:39,341 --> 00:03:41,341
23 children from 18 women.
52
00:03:42,581 --> 00:03:47,221
And he was also an addict,
he took heroin and cocaine daily.
53
00:03:48,781 --> 00:03:52,861
Rosalin Baker was 25,
and Jeffrey Wiltshire was 52.
54
00:03:55,261 --> 00:03:56,581
Because of the age gap
55
00:03:56,741 --> 00:03:58,781
there must have been some kind of
power imbalance
56
00:03:58,941 --> 00:04:00,621
between the two of them.
57
00:04:05,621 --> 00:04:09,461
Imani was born really prematurely,
aged 28 weeks.
58
00:04:09,621 --> 00:04:13,541
And so she spent her first 65 days
in an incubator
59
00:04:13,701 --> 00:04:15,701
under kind of intense supervision.
60
00:04:19,021 --> 00:04:20,901
When Amani was in the incubator,
61
00:04:21,061 --> 00:04:24,181
her mother didn't visit as much as
you would normally expect.
62
00:04:26,021 --> 00:04:27,861
Jeffrey didn't visit once.
63
00:04:28,021 --> 00:04:31,421
And Rosalin wouldn't tell
social services what his name was.
64
00:04:31,581 --> 00:04:34,061
So he was very much
not in the picture.
65
00:04:37,341 --> 00:04:38,661
When she was discharged,
66
00:04:38,821 --> 00:04:41,181
she went with her mother
to stay with her grandmother
67
00:04:41,341 --> 00:04:43,261
in Colchester, in Essex.
68
00:04:43,421 --> 00:04:48,581
And they stayed there until about
nine days before the bus incident.
69
00:04:51,781 --> 00:04:54,741
And then Rosalin left
her mother's house.
70
00:04:54,901 --> 00:04:57,421
She told people
she'd been kicked out,
71
00:04:57,581 --> 00:05:00,101
and travelled to Newham
to stay with Wiltshire
72
00:05:00,261 --> 00:05:02,421
in his bedsit
in the Manor Park area.
73
00:05:08,101 --> 00:05:11,141
When Rosalin and Imani
came to live with Wiltshire,
74
00:05:11,301 --> 00:05:13,781
neighbours didn't really see
much of them.
75
00:05:13,941 --> 00:05:16,541
They maybe saw them
coming and going once or twice,
76
00:05:16,701 --> 00:05:18,861
but it was very much they were
in the flat
77
00:05:19,021 --> 00:05:23,061
and it was
a very secret, private existence.
78
00:05:29,461 --> 00:05:32,101
I don't think Rosalin
would have had any interaction
79
00:05:32,261 --> 00:05:35,821
with friends
or potentially other women
80
00:05:35,981 --> 00:05:37,781
who could help her deal
with a newborn baby.
81
00:05:37,941 --> 00:05:41,341
It would have been a very isolated
existence for both her and the baby.
82
00:05:48,621 --> 00:05:52,501
On the day that Rosalin took Imani
on the 25 bus,
83
00:05:52,661 --> 00:05:54,861
she was seen with Wiltshire,
84
00:05:55,021 --> 00:05:56,781
they went into a newsagents...
85
00:05:58,861 --> 00:06:00,421
...and then she boarded the bus.
86
00:06:00,581 --> 00:06:03,141
She had Imani in a newborn sling
on her chest
87
00:06:03,301 --> 00:06:04,821
and she was pushing a pram.
88
00:06:04,981 --> 00:06:06,621
Wiltshire gave her a kiss goodbye.
89
00:06:06,781 --> 00:06:09,421
And then as she got on the bus,
he gave her a thumbs up.
90
00:06:13,541 --> 00:06:15,981
So that was
the initial starting point
91
00:06:16,141 --> 00:06:18,901
of how this whole thing began.
92
00:06:34,221 --> 00:06:37,021
Rosalin sat there
for about 20 minutes,
93
00:06:37,181 --> 00:06:39,181
texting quite a lot on her phone,
94
00:06:39,341 --> 00:06:41,261
and then she suddenly
raised the alarm,
95
00:06:41,421 --> 00:06:43,501
telling other passengers
that there was something wrong
96
00:06:43,661 --> 00:06:45,981
with her baby
and that she wasn't moving.
97
00:06:51,221 --> 00:06:53,381
The call was made to 999.
98
00:06:59,221 --> 00:07:02,181
And what happens
when you might call out to 999,
99
00:07:02,341 --> 00:07:04,101
you're explaining
that you've got a problem,
100
00:07:04,261 --> 00:07:06,941
there's a baby that's become ill
potentially on the bus,
101
00:07:07,101 --> 00:07:09,941
and the operator talks them
through a procedure.
102
00:07:40,101 --> 00:07:41,861
The other passengers
all stepped in,
103
00:07:42,021 --> 00:07:45,261
and several of them tried
to resuscitate Imani.
104
00:07:47,301 --> 00:07:51,181
All the while,
Rosalin was quite impassive,
105
00:07:51,341 --> 00:07:54,261
again, looking on her phone,
not saying anything
106
00:07:54,421 --> 00:07:57,301
to the extent that another passenger
thought that one of the passers by
107
00:07:57,461 --> 00:08:00,021
was actually the mother
because she was so distressed.
108
00:08:02,901 --> 00:08:05,061
And they tried and tried
to resuscitate her
109
00:08:05,221 --> 00:08:07,141
until an ambulance was called.
110
00:08:10,541 --> 00:08:13,221
The people on the bus are just
going about their ordinary day
111
00:08:13,381 --> 00:08:15,781
and all of a sudden
there's this emergency with a baby
112
00:08:15,941 --> 00:08:17,101
who might be dying.
113
00:08:21,501 --> 00:08:22,941
The scene was quite chaotic.
114
00:08:23,621 --> 00:08:25,621
And when
the ambulance service arrived,
115
00:08:25,781 --> 00:08:28,901
what you were greeted with was
a lot of trauma
116
00:08:29,061 --> 00:08:30,341
in members of the public,
117
00:08:30,501 --> 00:08:32,781
are the only person
hat didn't seem to be in trauma
118
00:08:32,941 --> 00:08:35,821
or any kind of upset,
was Rosalin Baker.
119
00:08:58,901 --> 00:09:00,901
Rosalin, obviously would have,
120
00:09:01,061 --> 00:09:04,501
at the very least known
she had a sick child.
121
00:09:05,821 --> 00:09:08,261
She should have been frantic
122
00:09:08,421 --> 00:09:11,781
when she's realising this child
is not responding,
123
00:09:11,941 --> 00:09:13,581
seems to be in distress.
124
00:09:15,861 --> 00:09:19,181
She herself should have been
calling 999.
125
00:09:22,221 --> 00:09:24,381
When emergency responders arrive,
126
00:09:24,541 --> 00:09:26,501
they're faced with a lot of people
on a bus,
127
00:09:26,661 --> 00:09:28,221
and time is of the essence.
128
00:09:28,381 --> 00:09:31,061
They don't know
if this baby is going to survive.
129
00:09:39,341 --> 00:09:41,781
First responders would
attend a scene.
130
00:09:42,581 --> 00:09:46,421
And it was at that point
when medical attention was brought,
131
00:09:46,581 --> 00:09:49,141
that obviously the temperature
of the baby
132
00:09:49,301 --> 00:09:53,301
was the first indicator that
that baby had not just died.
133
00:09:57,061 --> 00:09:58,501
An ambulance was called,
134
00:09:58,661 --> 00:10:01,221
and they reported
that the baby was cold,
135
00:10:01,381 --> 00:10:03,501
and they tried and tried
to resuscitate her.
136
00:10:10,141 --> 00:10:12,901
My suspicion in this case is that
any health professional
137
00:10:13,061 --> 00:10:16,101
who encountered this baby
around the time that she was found
138
00:10:16,261 --> 00:10:17,381
on the bus
139
00:10:17,541 --> 00:10:20,341
would immediately realise
that the baby had been dead
140
00:10:20,501 --> 00:10:21,821
for some time.
141
00:10:26,301 --> 00:10:29,501
You always start from
the first shred of information,
142
00:10:29,661 --> 00:10:31,061
evidence that you have.
143
00:10:31,221 --> 00:10:33,141
In this case,
what we were faced with
144
00:10:33,301 --> 00:10:36,701
was Rosalin Baker on the bus
with that baby.
145
00:10:36,861 --> 00:10:40,141
The baby, on the face of it,
according to her,
146
00:10:40,301 --> 00:10:43,061
becoming ill
and then the intervention
147
00:10:43,221 --> 00:10:46,181
of the London Ambulance Service
and the first responders.
148
00:10:49,541 --> 00:10:53,261
The child being on the bus
creates problems for investigators
149
00:10:53,421 --> 00:10:55,941
because you don't have
a crime scene.
150
00:10:56,101 --> 00:10:59,701
In this case, different people were
trying to render aid to the child,
151
00:10:59,861 --> 00:11:01,141
trying to help her.
152
00:11:01,301 --> 00:11:05,141
So the crime scene
is completely disrupted.
153
00:11:06,341 --> 00:11:11,101
And also it's questionable whether
the life saving attempts
154
00:11:11,261 --> 00:11:12,701
caused some of the injuries,
155
00:11:12,861 --> 00:11:15,181
or whether the injuries were there
already.
156
00:11:20,821 --> 00:11:23,421
Investigators are going to talk
to the mother.
157
00:11:24,541 --> 00:11:26,301
They're going to talk to the father.
158
00:11:27,101 --> 00:11:30,901
They're going to talk to anyone
who is directly involved
159
00:11:31,061 --> 00:11:32,341
with these two.
160
00:11:33,261 --> 00:11:35,101
Any relatives.
161
00:11:35,261 --> 00:11:39,581
Her mother was involved,
nurses for the child,
162
00:11:39,741 --> 00:11:40,741
doctors for the child.
163
00:11:40,901 --> 00:11:42,861
They're going to want to know
everything they can
164
00:11:43,021 --> 00:11:44,621
about this child.
165
00:11:44,781 --> 00:11:46,741
And have there been earlier reports
166
00:11:46,901 --> 00:11:49,261
of this child being abused
in any way.
167
00:11:55,661 --> 00:11:57,821
When the baby is brought
to the hospital,
168
00:11:57,981 --> 00:11:59,941
it appears to have been cold
for some time.
169
00:12:00,101 --> 00:12:02,861
And also to have injuries
that are well beyond
170
00:12:03,021 --> 00:12:06,141
what might have happened
with anybody trying to do CPR
171
00:12:06,301 --> 00:12:07,501
on this child.
172
00:12:10,101 --> 00:12:13,341
Babies don't just die.
There's a reason why they die.
173
00:12:13,501 --> 00:12:18,461
On a postmortem examination is
a quest to establish
174
00:12:18,621 --> 00:12:20,221
what that reason is
175
00:12:20,381 --> 00:12:22,661
and the sort of things you can find
176
00:12:22,821 --> 00:12:26,981
are injuries
or pathology that's in the body,
177
00:12:27,141 --> 00:12:29,341
organs that aren't working properly,
178
00:12:29,501 --> 00:12:31,421
bleeding and so on and so forth.
179
00:12:32,341 --> 00:12:36,221
What the postmortem in this case
encountered was
180
00:12:36,381 --> 00:12:39,941
a whole series of serious injuries.
181
00:12:43,741 --> 00:12:46,181
I don't think you need to be
a pathologist to realise
182
00:12:46,341 --> 00:12:48,501
that a baby
that has 40 rib fractures,
183
00:12:48,661 --> 00:12:51,421
a fractured skull,
a subarachnoid haemorrhage,
184
00:12:51,581 --> 00:12:55,981
and an injury to the brain stem -
these are not accidental injuries.
185
00:12:56,141 --> 00:12:58,981
These are injuries that have
been inflicted by someone,
186
00:12:59,141 --> 00:13:01,781
and they've been inflicted
over a period of time.
187
00:13:05,781 --> 00:13:08,101
It's almost hard to imagine
that anybody would inflict
188
00:13:08,261 --> 00:13:11,941
these kind of injuries
against 16 week old baby,
189
00:13:12,101 --> 00:13:15,341
and the injuries that we found
that had been inflicted
190
00:13:15,501 --> 00:13:18,381
was 40 fractured ribs
191
00:13:18,541 --> 00:13:21,141
that had been caused
through gripping that baby.
192
00:13:28,381 --> 00:13:29,741
When they get the results,
193
00:13:29,901 --> 00:13:33,181
what they see is signs
of chronic child abuse.
194
00:13:33,341 --> 00:13:36,421
This is not something that happened
just last night.
195
00:13:37,741 --> 00:13:41,181
Because are indications of injuries
that have healed
196
00:13:41,341 --> 00:13:42,821
or in the process of healing,
197
00:13:42,981 --> 00:13:45,421
which means they took place
a significant time
198
00:13:45,581 --> 00:13:47,101
before the child's death.
199
00:13:49,661 --> 00:13:52,861
Once they determine
that the child did not die
200
00:13:53,021 --> 00:13:54,421
simply of natural causes,
201
00:13:54,581 --> 00:13:56,621
that there was a physical means...
202
00:14:00,221 --> 00:14:02,341
...now the cops are looking
at homicide.
203
00:14:02,501 --> 00:14:06,541
So now it's what happened?
Where is it most likely to happen?
204
00:14:08,101 --> 00:14:09,261
This is a child.
205
00:14:09,421 --> 00:14:13,221
It's most likely to have happened
at the child's residence
206
00:14:13,381 --> 00:14:15,461
or at some other caregiver's.
207
00:14:17,621 --> 00:14:19,821
Who had control over the child?
208
00:14:19,981 --> 00:14:22,621
There any families
or a babysitter or whatever?
209
00:14:22,781 --> 00:14:24,461
They're all going to be looking
at that.
210
00:14:25,701 --> 00:14:27,901
It seems that the only place
this child was at
211
00:14:28,061 --> 00:14:29,541
was in the family residence.
212
00:14:29,701 --> 00:14:32,421
So now we're lucky in one sense,
we only have two suspects.
213
00:14:33,581 --> 00:14:34,981
The mom and the dad.
214
00:14:39,261 --> 00:14:42,941
If Rosalin doesn't look
as if she's really deeply affected
215
00:14:43,101 --> 00:14:46,781
by this baby's death
and there are other injuries
216
00:14:46,941 --> 00:14:48,901
on this child
that can't be explained
217
00:14:49,061 --> 00:14:51,061
by whatever happened on the bus,
218
00:14:51,221 --> 00:14:55,021
that would raise certainly questions
that maybe something has happened.
219
00:14:55,181 --> 00:14:58,341
She's already begun
to distance herself from the child
220
00:14:58,501 --> 00:15:02,501
because she knew the child had died
before she even got on the bus,
221
00:15:02,661 --> 00:15:04,901
or was at least about to die.
222
00:15:05,061 --> 00:15:08,741
And so something happened.
And she knows what it is.
223
00:15:13,541 --> 00:15:16,581
That's the problem
with all child abuse deaths
224
00:15:16,741 --> 00:15:21,101
is trying to figure out
who exactly caused the injuries
225
00:15:21,261 --> 00:15:24,221
and caused the injuries
that actually killed them.
226
00:15:28,941 --> 00:15:31,581
I feel for the detectives
in this particular case
227
00:15:31,741 --> 00:15:34,461
because you can have
all the logic in the world,
228
00:15:34,621 --> 00:15:38,141
but you need that evidence
to prove who exactly did it.
229
00:15:38,301 --> 00:15:41,141
And many times it's just not there.
230
00:15:44,461 --> 00:15:46,941
We know that the child was
in hospital
231
00:15:47,101 --> 00:15:49,981
for a extended period of time. OK.
232
00:15:50,141 --> 00:15:52,381
Well, how many times was
the child visited?
233
00:15:53,581 --> 00:15:54,821
I mean, it is normal.
234
00:15:54,981 --> 00:15:57,701
You know, I've seen this in
the past, where you have preemies,
235
00:15:57,861 --> 00:16:01,341
it's almost like you can't drag
the mother out of the hospital.
236
00:16:06,221 --> 00:16:07,581
Poor Imani,
237
00:16:07,741 --> 00:16:10,261
who was only 16 weeks old
at the time of her death,
238
00:16:10,421 --> 00:16:14,021
had been for the first 64 days
of her life,
239
00:16:14,181 --> 00:16:16,061
so effectively half her life,
240
00:16:16,221 --> 00:16:18,901
had been hospitalised
in a high dependency unit
241
00:16:19,061 --> 00:16:20,221
since birth.
242
00:16:20,381 --> 00:16:23,541
And the reason for that is
that she'd been born prematurely.
243
00:16:23,701 --> 00:16:28,821
However, when we looked
into the history of the parents,
244
00:16:28,981 --> 00:16:33,661
we found that Rosalin Baker
only visited 16 days out of that 64.
245
00:16:34,621 --> 00:16:37,781
So imagine that,
that if that's your newborn baby,
246
00:16:37,941 --> 00:16:41,621
knowing that baby is very ill
or very weak, may not survive,
247
00:16:41,781 --> 00:16:45,101
and you only visit her
16 days out of 64,
248
00:16:45,261 --> 00:16:47,261
that was a level of concern.
249
00:16:47,421 --> 00:16:50,501
And the next level of concern was
that there was a reluctance
250
00:16:50,661 --> 00:16:53,061
to name the father,
who was Jeffrey Wiltshire.
251
00:16:53,221 --> 00:16:56,461
Wiltshire, by the way,
had never visited Imani in hospital
252
00:16:56,621 --> 00:16:58,021
for all her 64 days.
253
00:16:58,181 --> 00:17:01,581
So here, from the very, very
inception of this inquiry,
254
00:17:01,741 --> 00:17:05,741
we could already identify
that both parents seemed
255
00:17:05,901 --> 00:17:08,821
very, very distant from that child
and her welfare.
256
00:17:13,781 --> 00:17:16,901
Although a forensic pathologist
can establish
257
00:17:17,061 --> 00:17:19,541
what these injuries are,
how serious they are,
258
00:17:19,701 --> 00:17:21,861
and whether
they're potentially fatal.
259
00:17:22,701 --> 00:17:25,141
It's very difficult for them
to establish
260
00:17:25,301 --> 00:17:27,141
who actually inflicted the injuries.
261
00:17:27,301 --> 00:17:29,541
And if there are two people
in the household,
262
00:17:29,701 --> 00:17:32,021
in theory,
it could be either one of them.
263
00:17:32,181 --> 00:17:36,821
And you're relying
on other investigative factors.
264
00:17:36,981 --> 00:17:41,501
It may even be that
friends or neighbours or relatives
265
00:17:41,661 --> 00:17:43,101
can shed some light,
266
00:17:43,261 --> 00:17:46,341
because they've seen
an individual treating the baby
267
00:17:46,501 --> 00:17:47,701
in a particular way.
268
00:17:47,861 --> 00:17:51,301
So that's something the police
would try to get to the bottom of.
269
00:17:56,861 --> 00:18:01,741
They were suspects simply because
the circumstances of Imani's death
270
00:18:01,901 --> 00:18:06,061
and the initial account given
by Baker just didn't tally.
271
00:18:08,461 --> 00:18:11,061
There was no way that she could
have dressed that baby,
272
00:18:11,221 --> 00:18:15,261
put that baby on a harness
and not know that she was dead.
273
00:18:15,421 --> 00:18:17,661
And obviously we later found out
with the injuries
274
00:18:17,821 --> 00:18:19,341
they were very, very severe.
275
00:18:20,501 --> 00:18:25,701
And then we needed to identify
who had access to Imani
276
00:18:25,861 --> 00:18:30,461
within the timeframe of her death,
to definitively rule anybody else.
277
00:18:30,621 --> 00:18:32,701
And Jeffrey Wiltshire was arrested.
278
00:18:35,101 --> 00:18:38,581
Well the approach was obviously
to get a first account from them.
279
00:18:38,741 --> 00:18:41,381
And in the case of both of them,
they were very cold,
280
00:18:41,541 --> 00:18:42,901
very emotionless.
281
00:18:43,061 --> 00:18:45,181
Bearing in mind,
you put that into context,
282
00:18:45,341 --> 00:18:48,261
you've just lost
your 16 week old baby.
283
00:18:48,421 --> 00:18:53,581
You say, in terrible circumstances,
that were nothing to do with you.
284
00:18:53,741 --> 00:18:55,381
You're suggesting
that baby's become ill.
285
00:18:55,541 --> 00:18:57,341
That is your defence at that time.
286
00:18:59,301 --> 00:19:00,781
In Baker's case,
287
00:19:00,941 --> 00:19:04,661
she gave a prepared statement
simply saying that Imani
288
00:19:04,821 --> 00:19:06,661
had an accident a little
while before,
289
00:19:06,821 --> 00:19:10,141
had falling over, but had not
sustained any serious injuries?
290
00:19:12,061 --> 00:19:13,661
And when we arrested
Jeffrey Wiltshire,
291
00:19:13,821 --> 00:19:16,261
he claimed to not even be
Imani's father
292
00:19:16,421 --> 00:19:18,221
and later he retracted
that statement
293
00:19:18,381 --> 00:19:21,021
and actually claimed
that the reason he told us that
294
00:19:21,181 --> 00:19:24,261
was because he was concerned
that he had mental health problems
295
00:19:24,421 --> 00:19:27,861
and drug abuse issues that would be
a concern to the authorities.
296
00:19:32,261 --> 00:19:35,421
Once you determine that
the time of death was
297
00:19:35,581 --> 00:19:39,261
at least one day prior
to the discovery,
298
00:19:39,421 --> 00:19:41,741
to me, and then I go back and say,
299
00:19:41,901 --> 00:19:44,861
well, what was
the mother's behaviour?
300
00:19:45,021 --> 00:19:46,181
What did she do?
301
00:19:46,341 --> 00:19:50,541
Well, she hit all the CCTV points
going in and going out.
302
00:19:50,701 --> 00:19:53,741
She's establishing an alibi,
because what they have to do,
303
00:19:53,901 --> 00:19:56,621
she has to cover
what exactly happened
304
00:19:56,781 --> 00:19:59,741
and how normal this trip on the bus
was going to be.
305
00:19:59,901 --> 00:20:01,261
How normal?
306
00:20:05,981 --> 00:20:08,741
Rosalin Baker went out with Imani,
307
00:20:08,901 --> 00:20:10,181
she was fully dressed
308
00:20:10,341 --> 00:20:14,101
and was in a baby harness
positioned with her face,
309
00:20:14,261 --> 00:20:15,781
and I believe
there's a reason for that,
310
00:20:15,941 --> 00:20:17,701
because there was an injury
to the eye,
311
00:20:17,861 --> 00:20:20,861
facing Rosalin's chest,
312
00:20:21,021 --> 00:20:24,501
again, covered up,
but they went out in public.
313
00:20:27,701 --> 00:20:30,501
So they've gone out in public
on the streets of London,
314
00:20:30,661 --> 00:20:33,461
deliberately putting themselves
in a position
315
00:20:33,621 --> 00:20:38,021
where they know they're going to be
subject to CCTV surveillance
316
00:20:38,181 --> 00:20:40,541
with the baby apparently well.
317
00:20:45,501 --> 00:20:47,781
Then getting on the bus,
318
00:20:47,941 --> 00:20:51,301
London busses are
very, very well catered for
319
00:20:51,461 --> 00:20:53,181
in terms of
closed circuit television.
320
00:20:53,341 --> 00:20:55,701
And once again
it's very high quality.
321
00:20:55,861 --> 00:20:59,981
So in this particular case,
what Baker and Wiltshire did,
322
00:21:00,141 --> 00:21:04,141
they walked together
almost projecting the persona
323
00:21:04,301 --> 00:21:07,541
that they were a happy family
with young innocent children.
324
00:21:07,701 --> 00:21:08,941
And when you look at it,
325
00:21:09,101 --> 00:21:10,861
if you didn't know
what had really happened,
326
00:21:11,021 --> 00:21:13,461
you'd think this is
quite a loving family.
327
00:21:14,421 --> 00:21:17,021
I say that because Wiltshire gives
Rosalin a kiss.
328
00:21:17,821 --> 00:21:20,821
He'd been a gentleman, helps her
with the buggy onto the bus,
329
00:21:20,981 --> 00:21:24,781
then gives her a thumbs up
as the doors close.
330
00:21:25,581 --> 00:21:27,861
So anyone looking at that
from the outside,
331
00:21:28,021 --> 00:21:29,941
not knowing the true facts,
332
00:21:30,101 --> 00:21:32,021
you'd think
it's almost inconceivable
333
00:21:32,181 --> 00:21:33,781
that only hours before,
334
00:21:33,941 --> 00:21:38,061
together, they've taken part
in the most heinous crime
335
00:21:38,221 --> 00:21:41,501
and then taken part
in the most heinous attempt
336
00:21:41,661 --> 00:21:43,021
to cover that crime up.
337
00:21:45,861 --> 00:21:50,101
They see her walking with her
partner, the father of the baby.
338
00:21:51,221 --> 00:21:54,541
And at that point,
the baby is very likely dead.
339
00:21:54,701 --> 00:21:58,141
And they know they're carrying
around a dead child.
340
00:22:00,341 --> 00:22:04,421
So it begins to appear
that they've made a plan
341
00:22:04,581 --> 00:22:09,581
to have this child appeared to have
gone into distress in a public place
342
00:22:09,741 --> 00:22:12,261
where other people
would be touching it, handling it,
343
00:22:12,421 --> 00:22:15,421
maybe inflicting the injuries on it,
344
00:22:15,581 --> 00:22:20,101
and, witnessing her being
in distress over it
345
00:22:20,261 --> 00:22:23,141
before, quote, unquote, it dies.
346
00:22:27,341 --> 00:22:28,781
They're in this together.
347
00:22:29,781 --> 00:22:31,661
They both know
that this child is dead
348
00:22:31,821 --> 00:22:33,581
and they have to do something
about it
349
00:22:33,741 --> 00:22:36,261
because people are aware
that they have this child.
350
00:22:36,421 --> 00:22:40,501
So they were planning how
they were going to make this look.
351
00:22:42,661 --> 00:22:44,781
I think it was very well
thought out.
352
00:22:45,981 --> 00:22:49,141
They wanted to have the child
out of the house,
353
00:22:49,301 --> 00:22:52,781
so there's no reason for the police
to come back to the house
354
00:22:52,941 --> 00:22:55,061
to search it and
see if there's anything there.
355
00:22:56,261 --> 00:22:58,701
When I studied that CCTV
on the bus,
356
00:22:58,861 --> 00:23:01,581
Baker's actively looking
at different members of the public
357
00:23:01,741 --> 00:23:03,021
getting on that bus.
358
00:23:03,181 --> 00:23:07,101
And now what know is going through
her mind for that 28 minutes was,
359
00:23:07,261 --> 00:23:08,821
who am I going to pick?
360
00:23:09,701 --> 00:23:14,741
What person is going to become
the third part of this conspiracy
361
00:23:14,901 --> 00:23:16,821
to stage this cover up?
362
00:23:37,661 --> 00:23:40,341
Because of the very conclusive
postmortem results
363
00:23:40,501 --> 00:23:43,181
which showed that Imani
had been dead for up to 24 hours
364
00:23:43,341 --> 00:23:47,381
before the bus, it was very clear
that this wasn't an accident.
365
00:23:49,621 --> 00:23:53,221
So police knew early on
that this was serious crime.
366
00:23:57,301 --> 00:24:01,861
What we've managed to determine
was that Rosalin Baker
367
00:24:02,021 --> 00:24:04,781
moved from her mother's house
in Colchester in Essex,
368
00:24:04,941 --> 00:24:09,261
into the Stratford area
where Wiltshire had small flat.
369
00:24:11,101 --> 00:24:14,541
And they were there for the week
leading up to the death of Imani.
370
00:24:18,061 --> 00:24:21,261
We knew then with this timeline
from the postmortem,
371
00:24:21,421 --> 00:24:25,941
that Imani had died 24 hours or so
prior to the discovery of the body
372
00:24:26,101 --> 00:24:29,981
on the bus. So we knew that
she'd been there for the week.
373
00:24:30,141 --> 00:24:33,581
So what was a very, very important
to determine was
374
00:24:33,741 --> 00:24:35,741
all that catalogue of injuries,
375
00:24:35,901 --> 00:24:38,141
could we determine
when they had occurred?
376
00:24:38,301 --> 00:24:42,021
So to determine this we actually
use some of the United Kingdom's
377
00:24:42,181 --> 00:24:44,581
foremost bone injury experts
378
00:24:44,741 --> 00:24:48,461
that could actually tell us,
through the postmortem examination
379
00:24:48,621 --> 00:24:49,941
and the findings
380
00:24:50,101 --> 00:24:54,021
that these injuries had occurred
at three different stages
381
00:24:54,181 --> 00:24:56,981
that could be timed
within that last week.
382
00:24:57,141 --> 00:25:00,861
That was within the week
that we knew Imani was in
383
00:25:01,021 --> 00:25:05,421
the so-called care of both parents,
Jeffrey Wiltshire and Rosalin Baker.
384
00:25:11,821 --> 00:25:15,501
They charged Rosalin and Jeffrey
very early on.
385
00:25:18,901 --> 00:25:21,901
When it came out that they'd been
charged on murder charges,
386
00:25:22,061 --> 00:25:23,421
there was a sense of real horror
387
00:25:23,581 --> 00:25:25,501
because there were so few details
that emerged.
388
00:25:25,661 --> 00:25:27,821
But what we were told
was really shocking,
389
00:25:27,981 --> 00:25:31,941
that a three month old baby
had died of head injuries on a bus.
390
00:25:32,101 --> 00:25:35,661
So without any more context,
you start to think
391
00:25:35,821 --> 00:25:38,621
was there an attack on the bus?
Was it a member of the public?
392
00:25:38,781 --> 00:25:41,021
Was it- You know,
there were very few details,
393
00:25:41,181 --> 00:25:43,141
but what we did know,
it was horrible.
394
00:25:48,301 --> 00:25:50,021
I can tell you, as a detective,
395
00:25:50,181 --> 00:25:52,661
and I've investigated
child deaths before,
396
00:25:52,821 --> 00:25:55,861
these are some of the most,
difficult cases to work.
397
00:25:56,861 --> 00:25:59,861
Particularly if you have kids
of your own at the house,
398
00:26:00,021 --> 00:26:03,101
because this is an absolutely
innocent person
399
00:26:03,261 --> 00:26:05,701
who cannot possibly
defend themselves.
400
00:26:05,861 --> 00:26:07,741
So you really have to take
a deep breath,
401
00:26:07,901 --> 00:26:10,381
because you can't allow all these
emotions that you're feeling
402
00:26:10,541 --> 00:26:13,261
to interfere
with your investigation.
403
00:26:16,941 --> 00:26:19,421
Whenever you investigate
the murder of a child,
404
00:26:19,581 --> 00:26:21,181
and I've investigated several,
405
00:26:21,341 --> 00:26:23,821
it's a very different kind of case
406
00:26:23,981 --> 00:26:27,741
to investigating the murder of
an adult in quite a number of ways.
407
00:26:27,901 --> 00:26:31,021
Firstly, on a personal level,
we're all humans.
408
00:26:31,181 --> 00:26:33,261
We all have emotions
and so do my team.
409
00:26:33,421 --> 00:26:35,461
It's quite a harrowing thing
to investigate
410
00:26:35,621 --> 00:26:39,341
when you're uncovering detail
of most unimaginable cruelty
411
00:26:39,501 --> 00:26:42,661
and unspeakable acts that you don't
think any human being could
412
00:26:42,821 --> 00:26:45,261
ever, ever perpetrate,
but these two did.
413
00:26:46,061 --> 00:26:47,221
So there's that element.
414
00:26:47,381 --> 00:26:49,821
But you put aside
any personal feelings,
415
00:26:49,981 --> 00:26:52,301
and then you look
at how you investigate it.
416
00:26:52,461 --> 00:26:56,061
Well, in a homicide of an adult,
they've got a background.
417
00:26:56,221 --> 00:26:58,781
And normally you're looking
for the motive
418
00:26:58,941 --> 00:27:01,061
as to why that murder
has taking place.
419
00:27:01,221 --> 00:27:06,101
In a case of a 16 week old baby,
that baby has had very little life.
420
00:27:06,261 --> 00:27:08,021
And half the life that she had
421
00:27:08,181 --> 00:27:10,741
was obviously in
a high dependency unit in hospital.
422
00:27:10,901 --> 00:27:14,301
So there's no background in terms
of that baby
423
00:27:14,461 --> 00:27:16,021
in any contact with anybody else.
424
00:27:21,741 --> 00:27:23,701
As soon as the trial started
425
00:27:23,861 --> 00:27:26,901
and as soon as the prosecution
delivered their opening statements,
426
00:27:27,061 --> 00:27:30,061
it was just immediately clear that
there was so much more to this case
427
00:27:30,221 --> 00:27:31,701
than was initially thought.
428
00:27:34,461 --> 00:27:36,941
The trial, I thought,
was a very interesting trial
429
00:27:37,101 --> 00:27:39,101
because bearing in mind
the engagement we'd had
430
00:27:39,261 --> 00:27:40,661
with Baker and Wiltshire,
431
00:27:40,821 --> 00:27:44,621
what we'd seen from them
was that they were very cold,
432
00:27:44,781 --> 00:27:49,301
very much in denial
of any wrongdoing.
433
00:27:50,101 --> 00:27:53,061
And so it's going to be interesting
to see, firstly,
434
00:27:53,221 --> 00:27:55,141
what they gave evidence
in their defence,
435
00:27:55,301 --> 00:27:57,181
and if so,
how would they come across.
436
00:27:57,341 --> 00:27:58,901
What were they going to say?
437
00:28:01,221 --> 00:28:03,221
They don't have to prove anything.
438
00:28:03,381 --> 00:28:05,461
It's for the prosecution to prove
their guilt
439
00:28:05,621 --> 00:28:07,021
beyond a reasonable doubt.
440
00:28:07,181 --> 00:28:08,981
So they, as defendants,
441
00:28:09,141 --> 00:28:11,701
they could have sat
in the defence box,
442
00:28:11,861 --> 00:28:13,341
deciding not to give evidence
443
00:28:13,501 --> 00:28:17,541
and to let the prosecution prove
or try to prove their guilt.
444
00:28:19,981 --> 00:28:23,141
Interestingly enough,
what both of them decided to do
445
00:28:23,301 --> 00:28:25,701
because they were charged
with the same crime,
446
00:28:25,861 --> 00:28:27,861
sitting in the dock together,
447
00:28:28,021 --> 00:28:29,821
they decided to engage in
448
00:28:29,981 --> 00:28:32,141
what is known in English law
as a cut throat defence.
449
00:28:32,301 --> 00:28:34,061
So they both blamed each other.
450
00:28:37,021 --> 00:28:40,661
I think that's a calculated gamble
as far as they were concerned.
451
00:28:40,821 --> 00:28:45,461
And thought the evidence is clear
that Amani has been murdered
452
00:28:45,621 --> 00:28:49,541
and we were her parents
and we were together with the baby.
453
00:28:53,021 --> 00:28:55,941
Baker decided to go
to the witness box.
454
00:28:56,101 --> 00:29:01,061
Her evidence essentially
was that she had woken up
455
00:29:01,221 --> 00:29:03,221
on the 28th of September
456
00:29:03,381 --> 00:29:07,421
and Jeffrey Wiltshire had said
to her I've killed the baby.
457
00:29:08,341 --> 00:29:10,421
Now,
this is what you're going to do.
458
00:29:10,581 --> 00:29:14,101
And she painted Wiltshire
as a coercive domestic offender
459
00:29:14,261 --> 00:29:16,301
that had abused her
over period of time.
460
00:29:17,781 --> 00:29:21,661
And she said that she went along
with it because she was in fear.
461
00:29:23,301 --> 00:29:26,661
Wiltshire, apparently,
according to her, had dressed Imani
462
00:29:26,821 --> 00:29:30,181
and then Baker then put
Imani in the harness
463
00:29:30,341 --> 00:29:33,101
and put Imani around herself,
464
00:29:33,261 --> 00:29:34,781
knowing her own daughter was dead,
465
00:29:34,941 --> 00:29:37,861
and then went along
with this facade, this charade,
466
00:29:38,021 --> 00:29:39,581
in the street.
467
00:29:39,741 --> 00:29:41,101
But here's the thing.
468
00:29:41,261 --> 00:29:43,421
If that were actually true,
469
00:29:43,581 --> 00:29:46,981
and it was imminent fear of danger
or harm to herself
470
00:29:47,141 --> 00:29:48,501
that she really feared,
471
00:29:48,661 --> 00:29:52,781
the moment she got on that bus,
knowing that she could give evidence
472
00:29:52,941 --> 00:29:55,021
against Wiltshire
and involve the police,
473
00:29:55,181 --> 00:29:56,501
why didn't she do that?
474
00:29:59,741 --> 00:30:03,621
We then heard a different side
to Rosalin's story,
475
00:30:03,781 --> 00:30:05,941
because at first
when she gave a police statement,
476
00:30:06,101 --> 00:30:07,301
she said, oh no, no,
477
00:30:07,461 --> 00:30:10,141
my partner wouldn't do
anything like that to her.
478
00:30:10,301 --> 00:30:14,101
She didn't notice any injuries,
just a small mark above her eye.
479
00:30:14,261 --> 00:30:16,821
And then we start to hear of details
that Wiltshire was abusive
480
00:30:16,981 --> 00:30:19,861
and controlling
or taking drugs every day.
481
00:30:20,021 --> 00:30:24,221
So it's a much bigger kind of
picture of neglect and depravity.
482
00:30:26,981 --> 00:30:29,981
The interesting part for me,
again with this,
483
00:30:30,141 --> 00:30:32,621
was her demeanour
this time around
484
00:30:32,781 --> 00:30:36,061
where she'd been cold before
and even on the bus CCTV,
485
00:30:36,221 --> 00:30:39,981
you could see that she had
no concern at any point.
486
00:30:40,141 --> 00:30:43,301
And now she's presenting herself
as is terrified victim
487
00:30:43,461 --> 00:30:44,741
that's been coerced.
488
00:30:44,901 --> 00:30:47,181
That was totally innocent.
I had no choice.
489
00:30:48,101 --> 00:30:49,501
All of a sudden,
490
00:30:49,661 --> 00:30:53,701
Baker became confrontational,
became a different person.
491
00:30:53,861 --> 00:30:55,541
And so really,
492
00:30:55,701 --> 00:30:59,821
once her bogus account was
properly probed in the witness box,
493
00:30:59,981 --> 00:31:01,421
it fell apart,
494
00:31:01,581 --> 00:31:04,621
as did Baker,
and her real character came out.
495
00:31:05,661 --> 00:31:08,101
That was seen by all,
including the jury.
496
00:31:13,021 --> 00:31:14,581
Wiltshire's account,
497
00:31:14,741 --> 00:31:16,741
was, again,
a very, very interesting one,
498
00:31:16,901 --> 00:31:19,861
the way that he decided
to go about defending himself.
499
00:31:20,021 --> 00:31:23,101
And he basically said
it was nothing to do with me.
500
00:31:24,741 --> 00:31:28,781
When he asked by his defence
counsel, did you murder Imani,
501
00:31:28,941 --> 00:31:32,181
he said, I'm a baby maker,
not a life taker.
502
00:31:33,221 --> 00:31:35,061
And the reason he said that,
503
00:31:35,221 --> 00:31:37,341
apart from the obvious attempt
to defend himself,
504
00:31:37,501 --> 00:31:41,221
was that he claimed to be the father
of 23 children by 18 women.
505
00:31:42,781 --> 00:31:47,981
So he was basically just refusing
any part, any knowledge in it,
506
00:31:48,141 --> 00:31:49,901
says it's nothing to do with me.
507
00:31:53,461 --> 00:31:55,421
Looking at
the two defendants themselves,
508
00:31:55,581 --> 00:31:56,781
there was lots of lying,
509
00:31:56,941 --> 00:31:58,661
lots of going back on
original statements,
510
00:31:58,821 --> 00:32:01,181
lots of trying to put the blame
on somebody else.
511
00:32:01,341 --> 00:32:05,421
I feel that Rosalin's statements
were the ones that
512
00:32:05,581 --> 00:32:07,821
was kind of- She was tripping
herself up the most.
513
00:32:07,981 --> 00:32:10,621
And it was clear that they weren't
in this together anymore.
514
00:32:10,781 --> 00:32:14,141
They definitely, you know, diverged
and were trying to blame each other.
515
00:32:20,501 --> 00:32:23,461
With both co-defendants
blaming the other,
516
00:32:23,621 --> 00:32:25,221
it can cause so much confusion
517
00:32:25,381 --> 00:32:30,901
that the jury is not able to decide
definitively who did what.
518
00:32:31,621 --> 00:32:35,701
And in that situation,
they can't convict either one.
519
00:32:38,141 --> 00:32:42,581
As more details of the abuse
emerged and the kind of the deceit
520
00:32:42,741 --> 00:32:44,261
around trying to cover i tup,
521
00:32:44,421 --> 00:32:47,581
there was a real sense of disgust
and a real hope that, you know,
522
00:32:47,741 --> 00:32:50,581
justice was going to be served
for this poor child.
523
00:32:52,501 --> 00:32:53,941
We looked at everything,
524
00:32:54,101 --> 00:32:57,461
but we were unable to definitively
say which one inflicted
525
00:32:57,621 --> 00:32:58,901
the fatal injury.
526
00:32:59,061 --> 00:33:01,021
But what we could say,
without a doubt,
527
00:33:01,181 --> 00:33:04,101
was that all of those injuries,
including the fatal injury
528
00:33:04,261 --> 00:33:06,541
had occurred within
that period of time
529
00:33:06,701 --> 00:33:10,501
when that baby
was in the care of Rosalin Baker,
530
00:33:10,661 --> 00:33:14,421
Jeffrey Wiltshire, in Wiltshire's
bedsit in east London.
531
00:33:18,221 --> 00:33:21,221
The public perception would be
532
00:33:21,381 --> 00:33:24,421
that it doesn't matter
who inflicted the death.
533
00:33:24,581 --> 00:33:28,661
Both of these people are
responsible, and it's murder.
534
00:33:28,821 --> 00:33:31,461
However, legally speaking,
535
00:33:31,621 --> 00:33:35,181
without being able to prove
an intent to kill the child
536
00:33:35,341 --> 00:33:39,261
or a cause of death,
you cannot prove murder.
537
00:33:39,421 --> 00:33:42,821
And that fact in itself
means the difference between
538
00:33:42,981 --> 00:33:44,661
ten years in jail
539
00:33:44,821 --> 00:33:47,461
or spending the rest of your life
in jail.
540
00:33:49,741 --> 00:33:51,301
And in this particular case,
541
00:33:51,461 --> 00:33:55,701
knowing that the jury may struggle
to reach a verdict on homicide,
542
00:33:55,861 --> 00:33:59,621
because we just couldn't prove which
person inflicted the fatal injury,
543
00:33:59,781 --> 00:34:03,341
the judge decided that it was better
to direct
544
00:34:03,501 --> 00:34:05,621
about an alternative charge.
545
00:34:18,301 --> 00:34:20,741
Some of the other passengers
on the bus actually gave
546
00:34:20,901 --> 00:34:22,821
really, really compelling evidence
at the trial,
547
00:34:22,981 --> 00:34:25,701
and they spoke of how
they were trying really hard
548
00:34:25,861 --> 00:34:29,021
to revive this little body,
this little girl,
549
00:34:29,181 --> 00:34:31,101
thinking that there might
be a chance
550
00:34:31,261 --> 00:34:32,621
that they could save her life.
551
00:34:32,781 --> 00:34:34,621
And then when she went off the bus,
552
00:34:34,781 --> 00:34:36,341
they thought that they'd failed
553
00:34:36,501 --> 00:34:39,141
and that maybe, perhaps there was
something else they could have done.
554
00:34:39,301 --> 00:34:42,341
And so to learn that, actually, this
baby had been dead the whole while
555
00:34:42,501 --> 00:34:45,021
and that her mother was sitting
there knowing this was happening,
556
00:34:45,181 --> 00:34:47,101
that must have just been horrifying.
557
00:34:48,101 --> 00:34:51,341
Some of them said that they actually
had kind of effects of trauma,
558
00:34:51,501 --> 00:34:54,461
were unable to sleep, had to take
medication because of it.
559
00:34:54,621 --> 00:34:57,141
It must have just been
so distressing for everybody
560
00:34:57,301 --> 00:34:58,501
on that bus.
561
00:35:13,381 --> 00:35:15,661
The prosecutor told jurors
562
00:35:15,821 --> 00:35:18,621
that Rosalin Baker enacted
what's been described
563
00:35:18,781 --> 00:35:20,461
as a nightmare charade,
564
00:35:20,621 --> 00:35:22,261
claiming her baby had fallen ill.
565
00:35:23,261 --> 00:35:24,701
Passengers tried to help.
566
00:35:24,861 --> 00:35:28,421
They were panicking and distressed,
compared to Baker,
567
00:35:28,581 --> 00:35:31,701
who was noted to be calm and cold.
568
00:35:35,621 --> 00:35:38,381
Many homicide cases I dealt with,
569
00:35:38,541 --> 00:35:41,941
when a jury goes out,
I was always nervous.
570
00:35:42,101 --> 00:35:45,981
I was always confident
in the evidence we presented,
571
00:35:46,141 --> 00:35:50,181
but always nervous
only because there's so much riding
572
00:35:50,341 --> 00:35:52,061
on that particular case.
573
00:35:52,221 --> 00:35:54,181
You know,
you've got a victim murdered,
574
00:35:54,341 --> 00:35:56,101
you've got a family wants justice.
575
00:35:56,261 --> 00:35:58,101
Justice for the victim themselves.
576
00:35:58,901 --> 00:36:01,221
And when you've worked hard
to get all of the evidence
577
00:36:01,381 --> 00:36:02,541
that you possibly can,
578
00:36:02,701 --> 00:36:05,741
and it's sufficient to present
that case to a jury,
579
00:36:05,901 --> 00:36:07,861
you obviously want to get
the right verdict.
580
00:36:11,221 --> 00:36:13,381
So I was nervous but confident.
581
00:36:20,861 --> 00:36:23,061
Very tense moments
when a jury return.
582
00:36:24,141 --> 00:36:27,581
And on this occasion, we got back
and were told there was a verdict.
583
00:36:27,741 --> 00:36:30,941
And then they're asked, do you find
the defendant guilty or not guilty?
584
00:36:32,821 --> 00:36:36,861
And in this case, it was guilty
of causing or allowing the death
585
00:36:37,021 --> 00:36:38,461
of Imani Baker.
586
00:36:41,421 --> 00:36:43,901
The jury deliberated
for 14 or so hours,
587
00:36:44,061 --> 00:36:46,261
but they couldn't agree
that the evidence was kind of
588
00:36:46,421 --> 00:36:47,781
beyond reasonable doubt,
589
00:36:47,941 --> 00:36:50,221
that they were both guilty of murder
or one of them.
590
00:36:50,381 --> 00:36:52,661
So they those charges
couldn't be upheld.
591
00:36:55,221 --> 00:36:58,421
Ultimately,
they're not able to prove murder.
592
00:36:58,581 --> 00:37:00,741
And that has to be
incredibly frustrating,
593
00:37:00,901 --> 00:37:05,501
because they have committed such
a heinous crime, multiple times.
594
00:37:05,661 --> 00:37:08,301
Inflicted terrible abuse
on this child,
595
00:37:08,461 --> 00:37:11,541
yet, because they're not able
to prove murder,
596
00:37:11,701 --> 00:37:14,061
it doesn't seem like justice
was served.
597
00:37:17,541 --> 00:37:19,861
Because it was difficult
to pinpoint
598
00:37:20,021 --> 00:37:22,061
who actually had delivered
the fatal blow,
599
00:37:22,221 --> 00:37:26,421
they ended up with lesser charges
and a lesser sentence of 11 years,
600
00:37:26,581 --> 00:37:28,061
which is reduced to ten.
601
00:37:28,981 --> 00:37:32,901
And that's not an adequate sentence
for what happened to this child.
602
00:37:34,141 --> 00:37:35,661
Their hands were tied.
603
00:37:37,341 --> 00:37:39,461
Had they been convicted
of the homicide,
604
00:37:39,621 --> 00:37:41,661
the actual substantive murder,
605
00:37:41,821 --> 00:37:44,501
they'd have probably gone to prison
for 30 years.
606
00:37:44,661 --> 00:37:48,461
The sentence they got was 11,
later reduced to ten on appeal.
607
00:37:50,101 --> 00:37:52,181
On the one hand,
justice has been done,
608
00:37:52,341 --> 00:37:55,421
that it's been proven
Imani was unlawfully killed
609
00:37:55,581 --> 00:37:57,141
at the hands of her parents.
610
00:37:58,421 --> 00:38:01,981
But it was just a shame
we couldn't have proved
611
00:38:02,141 --> 00:38:05,301
which one had administered
that fatal injury.
612
00:38:08,301 --> 00:38:09,581
When we got the sentencing,
613
00:38:09,741 --> 00:38:12,341
I definitely felt that
this was miscarriage of justice
614
00:38:12,501 --> 00:38:15,861
and it did not properly represent
the horror
615
00:38:16,021 --> 00:38:18,421
that this poor, innocent child
had to endure.
616
00:38:21,861 --> 00:38:25,141
They got 11 years, I think sentence
was then reduced by a year.
617
00:38:26,061 --> 00:38:28,941
And I don't think that is
a adequate punishment.
618
00:38:32,381 --> 00:38:36,581
This had to be a very difficult
case for not just the investigators,
619
00:38:36,741 --> 00:38:38,781
but also for the jury.
620
00:38:42,501 --> 00:38:44,661
Because this is an emotional case.
621
00:38:46,541 --> 00:38:48,581
No one's going to make
it out of this trial
622
00:38:48,741 --> 00:38:50,421
without an emotional scar.
623
00:38:52,621 --> 00:38:54,461
Because this is a baby.
624
00:38:54,621 --> 00:38:57,941
16 weeks old, vulnerable, small.
625
00:38:58,101 --> 00:39:01,941
Completely helpless
against the hands of her parents.
626
00:39:06,301 --> 00:39:08,181
It can be very frustrating,
627
00:39:08,341 --> 00:39:12,261
when you know that this particular
person did that crime,
628
00:39:12,421 --> 00:39:13,501
you know it.
629
00:39:14,381 --> 00:39:17,741
But they're let off with a lesser
offense than what they should have.
630
00:39:18,621 --> 00:39:21,181
Sometimes what you have to do
is you just got to suck it up
631
00:39:21,341 --> 00:39:22,901
because there's nothing
you can do about it.
632
00:39:23,061 --> 00:39:24,621
That is the justice system.
633
00:39:27,581 --> 00:39:30,621
Looking at
the whole, staged plot itself,
634
00:39:30,781 --> 00:39:34,421
it seemed that the reason they did
it in such a busy, public bus was
635
00:39:34,581 --> 00:39:36,621
because they wanted to bring
as many people as possible
636
00:39:36,781 --> 00:39:37,981
into their deceit.
637
00:39:39,821 --> 00:39:42,821
But in doing so, they've actually
affected so many people
638
00:39:42,981 --> 00:39:44,581
and traumatised so many people.
639
00:39:46,861 --> 00:39:48,901
Some of the people who are
on the bus say they can now
640
00:39:49,061 --> 00:39:51,901
no longer take buses because
they feel so scared
641
00:39:52,061 --> 00:39:53,861
about what happened that day.
642
00:39:55,181 --> 00:39:58,301
And also, this was an incident
where people of the community
643
00:39:58,461 --> 00:40:02,541
really did step in to help,
and it was all in vain.
644
00:40:02,701 --> 00:40:04,981
And there's a sense
that they might not do that again,
645
00:40:05,141 --> 00:40:08,661
because they don't want to be used
in someone else's horrible plot.
646
00:40:13,541 --> 00:40:17,261
The person who I think it
affected the most on that bus
647
00:40:17,421 --> 00:40:19,901
was the lady that administered CPR.
648
00:40:20,061 --> 00:40:24,181
And I spoke to that lady at length
after she gave evidence
649
00:40:24,341 --> 00:40:27,501
and she gave evidence
and she was from Italy.
650
00:40:27,661 --> 00:40:32,261
A lovely lady who was just
on her way to work that day.
651
00:40:32,421 --> 00:40:35,941
And that lady was totally innocent,
minding her own business
652
00:40:36,101 --> 00:40:37,621
wanted to do the best she could.
653
00:40:37,781 --> 00:40:42,941
And when she discovered
that this baby was cold as ice
654
00:40:43,101 --> 00:40:44,621
as she described it,
655
00:40:44,781 --> 00:40:47,341
and then saw the bruise
under the eye,
656
00:40:47,501 --> 00:40:51,341
you know,
and still administered CPR,
657
00:40:51,501 --> 00:40:54,221
even though she might well have
known that she was dead.
658
00:40:54,381 --> 00:40:56,061
But it was a terrific thing for her
659
00:40:56,221 --> 00:40:58,901
and her everlasting thoughts after
was that she could not get
660
00:40:59,061 --> 00:41:00,341
on a bus again.
661
00:41:00,501 --> 00:41:02,741
She did want to travel
on public transport again.
662
00:41:02,901 --> 00:41:05,861
If she saw a baby, you know,
she'd be upset
663
00:41:06,021 --> 00:41:08,221
because she was worried
the same thing would happen again.
664
00:41:08,381 --> 00:41:09,861
And that's the level of trauma
665
00:41:10,021 --> 00:41:12,901
that Rosalin Baker
subjected this lady to.
666
00:41:20,301 --> 00:41:23,301
Despite the fact that they thought
this was a means
667
00:41:23,461 --> 00:41:25,421
by which they could cover up
the crime...
668
00:41:26,381 --> 00:41:30,541
...they had no understanding of how
the pathology examination would work
669
00:41:30,701 --> 00:41:34,421
and the fact that it would reveal
overwhelming evidence
670
00:41:34,581 --> 00:41:37,301
that this child had died
due to abuse.
671
00:41:40,661 --> 00:41:43,861
This case stands out to me
for a number of reasons.
672
00:41:44,021 --> 00:41:46,181
Firstly, the callous nature,
673
00:41:46,341 --> 00:41:51,861
and the cruelty
that somebody can hurt a child.
674
00:41:52,741 --> 00:41:55,901
But let alone hurt a child,
murder a child,
675
00:41:56,061 --> 00:41:58,621
let alone a 16 week old child.
676
00:42:01,301 --> 00:42:03,381
We can identify the warning signs.
677
00:42:03,541 --> 00:42:05,501
And the warning signs
were there in this case.
678
00:42:05,661 --> 00:42:08,741
But unfortunately,
many of these systems are overloaded
679
00:42:08,901 --> 00:42:13,101
and they can't follow up
on every single difficult case.
680
00:42:13,261 --> 00:42:15,181
So lots of cases, you know,
681
00:42:15,341 --> 00:42:17,421
just don't get the attention
that they need.
682
00:42:17,581 --> 00:42:19,741
I think had there been
enough resources,
683
00:42:19,901 --> 00:42:22,581
this baby probably
would have been saved.
684
00:42:27,301 --> 00:42:29,381
I see death all the time.
685
00:42:29,541 --> 00:42:32,141
I don't like it, but I see it.
686
00:42:32,781 --> 00:42:36,301
But here's someone going on a ride
on a double decker bus.
687
00:42:36,461 --> 00:42:38,981
All of a sudden they're confronted
with a dead baby.
688
00:42:39,141 --> 00:42:42,061
What's the worst thing in the world
if you're a family person?
689
00:42:42,221 --> 00:42:44,181
Is what a dead, innocent baby?
690
00:42:44,941 --> 00:42:47,861
They're the ones that were really,
traumatised by all this.
691
00:42:48,021 --> 00:42:49,821
And I feel mostly for them.
692
00:42:56,861 --> 00:42:58,661
Looking back at this case,
693
00:42:58,821 --> 00:43:01,381
there's so many parts of it that
kind of ignites
694
00:43:01,541 --> 00:43:03,141
different emotions:
anger, frustration,
695
00:43:03,301 --> 00:43:06,261
but the overwhelming sense
of this just pure sadness
696
00:43:06,421 --> 00:43:09,061
and pain you feel
for this little girl.
697
00:43:10,221 --> 00:43:12,821
You know, she didn't have
the love and support of her parents.
698
00:43:12,981 --> 00:43:14,261
Definitely.
699
00:43:14,421 --> 00:43:18,181
She didn't have wider protection
from social services.
700
00:43:18,341 --> 00:43:21,341
Probably the safest she had been
was when she was in an incubator.
701
00:43:21,501 --> 00:43:25,221
And that's just a really, really
tragic start to any life.
702
00:43:53,981 --> 00:43:56,981
Subtitles by Sky Access Services
55785
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.