All language subtitles for Staged Deadly Deception - S01E01 - Baby on the Bus.eng

af Afrikaans
ak Akan
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic Download
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bem Bemba
bn Bengali
bh Bihari
bs Bosnian
br Breton
bg Bulgarian
km Cambodian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
chr Cherokee
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
da Danish
nl Dutch
en English
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
ee Ewe
fo Faroese
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gaa Ga
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek
gn Guarani
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ia Interlingua
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
rw Kinyarwanda
rn Kirundi
kg Kongo
ko Korean
kri Krio (Sierra Leone)
ku Kurdish
ckb Kurdish (Soranî)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Laothian
la Latin
lv Latvian
ln Lingala
lt Lithuanian
loz Lozi
lg Luganda
ach Luo
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mfe Mauritian Creole
mo Moldavian
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
sr-ME Montenegrin
ne Nepali
pcm Nigerian Pidgin
nso Northern Sotho
no Norwegian
nn Norwegian (Nynorsk)
oc Occitan
or Oriya
om Oromo
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt-BR Portuguese (Brazil)
pt Portuguese (Portugal)
pa Punjabi
qu Quechua
ro Romanian
rm Romansh
nyn Runyakitara
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
sh Serbo-Croatian
st Sesotho
tn Setswana
crs Seychellois Creole
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhalese
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish
es-419 Spanish (Latin American)
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
tt Tatar
te Telugu
th Thai
ti Tigrinya
to Tonga
lua Tshiluba
tum Tumbuka
tr Turkish
tk Turkmen
tw Twi
ug Uighur
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
wo Wolof
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu
Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated: 1 00:00:25,421 --> 00:00:27,381 Anyone who is on the bus would 2 00:00:27,541 --> 00:00:29,981 have experienced some level of trauma. 3 00:00:34,741 --> 00:00:37,061 Was there an attack on the bus? Was it a member of the public? 4 00:00:37,221 --> 00:00:39,101 There were very few details. 5 00:00:40,301 --> 00:00:42,461 Anyone looking at that from the outside, 6 00:00:42,621 --> 00:00:44,301 not knowing the true facts, 7 00:00:44,461 --> 00:00:47,581 it's almost inconceivable that only hours before, 8 00:00:47,741 --> 00:00:50,741 together, they've taken part in the most heinous crime 9 00:00:50,901 --> 00:00:54,141 and then taken part in the most heinous attempt 10 00:00:54,301 --> 00:00:55,701 to cover that crime up. 11 00:00:58,581 --> 00:01:01,421 I feel for the detectives in this particular case 12 00:01:01,581 --> 00:01:05,661 because, can have all logic in the world, but you need that evidence. 13 00:01:05,821 --> 00:01:08,901 And many times it's just not there. 14 00:01:10,941 --> 00:01:13,581 It comes down to where else was this child at? 15 00:01:13,741 --> 00:01:16,821 And again, it seems that the only place this child was at 16 00:01:16,981 --> 00:01:18,621 was in the family residence. 17 00:01:20,021 --> 00:01:21,341 In all of these incidents, 18 00:01:21,501 --> 00:01:23,741 what ends up happening is the mom blames the dad. 19 00:01:23,901 --> 00:01:25,421 Dad blames the mom. 20 00:01:26,621 --> 00:01:28,741 No one's going to make it out of this trial 21 00:01:28,901 --> 00:01:30,421 without an emotional scar. 22 00:01:31,861 --> 00:01:34,861 This crime and these two people's actions 23 00:01:35,021 --> 00:01:38,301 have done so much damage to a lot of people. 24 00:01:38,461 --> 00:01:40,101 More people than they know. 25 00:01:58,781 --> 00:02:00,821 London's a very sprawling metropolis. 26 00:02:00,981 --> 00:02:02,741 We've got a very diverse community. 27 00:02:02,901 --> 00:02:06,061 And we've got a certainly a very diverse range of crimes, 28 00:02:06,221 --> 00:02:08,061 far, far more than the rest of the country, 29 00:02:08,221 --> 00:02:09,501 in my experience. 30 00:02:10,981 --> 00:02:13,821 Violent crime, sadly, is more prevalent in London. 31 00:02:17,021 --> 00:02:18,941 Stratford's in the borough of Newham, 32 00:02:19,101 --> 00:02:23,221 which is one of the biggest and fastest growing 33 00:02:23,381 --> 00:02:24,581 boroughs in London. 34 00:02:24,741 --> 00:02:27,221 And it's got a very, very diverse population. 35 00:02:30,461 --> 00:02:32,261 Compared to the rest of London, 36 00:02:32,421 --> 00:02:34,701 it's got levels of quite high deprivation. 37 00:02:35,821 --> 00:02:39,101 So with that I guess comes some crime, petty crime, 38 00:02:39,261 --> 00:02:40,821 theft, robbery, stuff like that. 39 00:02:42,781 --> 00:02:46,541 There are significant pockets of crime within Stratford, 40 00:02:46,701 --> 00:02:50,781 such as violent crime, drug dealing, robbery and things of that nature. 41 00:03:01,181 --> 00:03:05,701 Rosalin Baker was known to social services for many years. 42 00:03:05,861 --> 00:03:08,981 She kind of presented first, I think, because she was homeless, 43 00:03:09,141 --> 00:03:11,621 like living in between families and friends, 44 00:03:11,781 --> 00:03:14,221 but also known to have a chaotic background. 45 00:03:15,941 --> 00:03:18,661 She lived very much kind of, on the fringe, 46 00:03:18,821 --> 00:03:21,341 and that she didn't engage in any kind of regular work, 47 00:03:21,501 --> 00:03:23,421 education, that type of thing. 48 00:03:25,381 --> 00:03:26,981 She was an addict, 49 00:03:27,141 --> 00:03:32,541 and she was with Jeffrey Wiltshire who was 23 years her senior. 50 00:03:35,221 --> 00:03:39,181 He had been a rapper, he'd fathered many children, 51 00:03:39,341 --> 00:03:41,341 23 children from 18 women. 52 00:03:42,581 --> 00:03:47,221 And he was also an addict, he took heroin and cocaine daily. 53 00:03:48,781 --> 00:03:52,861 Rosalin Baker was 25, and Jeffrey Wiltshire was 52. 54 00:03:55,261 --> 00:03:56,581 Because of the age gap 55 00:03:56,741 --> 00:03:58,781 there must have been some kind of power imbalance 56 00:03:58,941 --> 00:04:00,621 between the two of them. 57 00:04:05,621 --> 00:04:09,461 Imani was born really prematurely, aged 28 weeks. 58 00:04:09,621 --> 00:04:13,541 And so she spent her first 65 days in an incubator 59 00:04:13,701 --> 00:04:15,701 under kind of intense supervision. 60 00:04:19,021 --> 00:04:20,901 When Amani was in the incubator, 61 00:04:21,061 --> 00:04:24,181 her mother didn't visit as much as you would normally expect. 62 00:04:26,021 --> 00:04:27,861 Jeffrey didn't visit once. 63 00:04:28,021 --> 00:04:31,421 And Rosalin wouldn't tell social services what his name was. 64 00:04:31,581 --> 00:04:34,061 So he was very much not in the picture. 65 00:04:37,341 --> 00:04:38,661 When she was discharged, 66 00:04:38,821 --> 00:04:41,181 she went with her mother to stay with her grandmother 67 00:04:41,341 --> 00:04:43,261 in Colchester, in Essex. 68 00:04:43,421 --> 00:04:48,581 And they stayed there until about nine days before the bus incident. 69 00:04:51,781 --> 00:04:54,741 And then Rosalin left her mother's house. 70 00:04:54,901 --> 00:04:57,421 She told people she'd been kicked out, 71 00:04:57,581 --> 00:05:00,101 and travelled to Newham to stay with Wiltshire 72 00:05:00,261 --> 00:05:02,421 in his bedsit in the Manor Park area. 73 00:05:08,101 --> 00:05:11,141 When Rosalin and Imani came to live with Wiltshire, 74 00:05:11,301 --> 00:05:13,781 neighbours didn't really see much of them. 75 00:05:13,941 --> 00:05:16,541 They maybe saw them coming and going once or twice, 76 00:05:16,701 --> 00:05:18,861 but it was very much they were in the flat 77 00:05:19,021 --> 00:05:23,061 and it was a very secret, private existence. 78 00:05:29,461 --> 00:05:32,101 I don't think Rosalin would have had any interaction 79 00:05:32,261 --> 00:05:35,821 with friends or potentially other women 80 00:05:35,981 --> 00:05:37,781 who could help her deal with a newborn baby. 81 00:05:37,941 --> 00:05:41,341 It would have been a very isolated existence for both her and the baby. 82 00:05:48,621 --> 00:05:52,501 On the day that Rosalin took Imani on the 25 bus, 83 00:05:52,661 --> 00:05:54,861 she was seen with Wiltshire, 84 00:05:55,021 --> 00:05:56,781 they went into a newsagents... 85 00:05:58,861 --> 00:06:00,421 ...and then she boarded the bus. 86 00:06:00,581 --> 00:06:03,141 She had Imani in a newborn sling on her chest 87 00:06:03,301 --> 00:06:04,821 and she was pushing a pram. 88 00:06:04,981 --> 00:06:06,621 Wiltshire gave her a kiss goodbye. 89 00:06:06,781 --> 00:06:09,421 And then as she got on the bus, he gave her a thumbs up. 90 00:06:13,541 --> 00:06:15,981 So that was the initial starting point 91 00:06:16,141 --> 00:06:18,901 of how this whole thing began. 92 00:06:34,221 --> 00:06:37,021 Rosalin sat there for about 20 minutes, 93 00:06:37,181 --> 00:06:39,181 texting quite a lot on her phone, 94 00:06:39,341 --> 00:06:41,261 and then she suddenly raised the alarm, 95 00:06:41,421 --> 00:06:43,501 telling other passengers that there was something wrong 96 00:06:43,661 --> 00:06:45,981 with her baby and that she wasn't moving. 97 00:06:51,221 --> 00:06:53,381 The call was made to 999. 98 00:06:59,221 --> 00:07:02,181 And what happens when you might call out to 999, 99 00:07:02,341 --> 00:07:04,101 you're explaining that you've got a problem, 100 00:07:04,261 --> 00:07:06,941 there's a baby that's become ill potentially on the bus, 101 00:07:07,101 --> 00:07:09,941 and the operator talks them through a procedure. 102 00:07:40,101 --> 00:07:41,861 The other passengers all stepped in, 103 00:07:42,021 --> 00:07:45,261 and several of them tried to resuscitate Imani. 104 00:07:47,301 --> 00:07:51,181 All the while, Rosalin was quite impassive, 105 00:07:51,341 --> 00:07:54,261 again, looking on her phone, not saying anything 106 00:07:54,421 --> 00:07:57,301 to the extent that another passenger thought that one of the passers by 107 00:07:57,461 --> 00:08:00,021 was actually the mother because she was so distressed. 108 00:08:02,901 --> 00:08:05,061 And they tried and tried to resuscitate her 109 00:08:05,221 --> 00:08:07,141 until an ambulance was called. 110 00:08:10,541 --> 00:08:13,221 The people on the bus are just going about their ordinary day 111 00:08:13,381 --> 00:08:15,781 and all of a sudden there's this emergency with a baby 112 00:08:15,941 --> 00:08:17,101 who might be dying. 113 00:08:21,501 --> 00:08:22,941 The scene was quite chaotic. 114 00:08:23,621 --> 00:08:25,621 And when the ambulance service arrived, 115 00:08:25,781 --> 00:08:28,901 what you were greeted with was a lot of trauma 116 00:08:29,061 --> 00:08:30,341 in members of the public, 117 00:08:30,501 --> 00:08:32,781 are the only person hat didn't seem to be in trauma 118 00:08:32,941 --> 00:08:35,821 or any kind of upset, was Rosalin Baker. 119 00:08:58,901 --> 00:09:00,901 Rosalin, obviously would have, 120 00:09:01,061 --> 00:09:04,501 at the very least known she had a sick child. 121 00:09:05,821 --> 00:09:08,261 She should have been frantic 122 00:09:08,421 --> 00:09:11,781 when she's realising this child is not responding, 123 00:09:11,941 --> 00:09:13,581 seems to be in distress. 124 00:09:15,861 --> 00:09:19,181 She herself should have been calling 999. 125 00:09:22,221 --> 00:09:24,381 When emergency responders arrive, 126 00:09:24,541 --> 00:09:26,501 they're faced with a lot of people on a bus, 127 00:09:26,661 --> 00:09:28,221 and time is of the essence. 128 00:09:28,381 --> 00:09:31,061 They don't know if this baby is going to survive. 129 00:09:39,341 --> 00:09:41,781 First responders would attend a scene. 130 00:09:42,581 --> 00:09:46,421 And it was at that point when medical attention was brought, 131 00:09:46,581 --> 00:09:49,141 that obviously the temperature of the baby 132 00:09:49,301 --> 00:09:53,301 was the first indicator that that baby had not just died. 133 00:09:57,061 --> 00:09:58,501 An ambulance was called, 134 00:09:58,661 --> 00:10:01,221 and they reported that the baby was cold, 135 00:10:01,381 --> 00:10:03,501 and they tried and tried to resuscitate her. 136 00:10:10,141 --> 00:10:12,901 My suspicion in this case is that any health professional 137 00:10:13,061 --> 00:10:16,101 who encountered this baby around the time that she was found 138 00:10:16,261 --> 00:10:17,381 on the bus 139 00:10:17,541 --> 00:10:20,341 would immediately realise that the baby had been dead 140 00:10:20,501 --> 00:10:21,821 for some time. 141 00:10:26,301 --> 00:10:29,501 You always start from the first shred of information, 142 00:10:29,661 --> 00:10:31,061 evidence that you have. 143 00:10:31,221 --> 00:10:33,141 In this case, what we were faced with 144 00:10:33,301 --> 00:10:36,701 was Rosalin Baker on the bus with that baby. 145 00:10:36,861 --> 00:10:40,141 The baby, on the face of it, according to her, 146 00:10:40,301 --> 00:10:43,061 becoming ill and then the intervention 147 00:10:43,221 --> 00:10:46,181 of the London Ambulance Service and the first responders. 148 00:10:49,541 --> 00:10:53,261 The child being on the bus creates problems for investigators 149 00:10:53,421 --> 00:10:55,941 because you don't have a crime scene. 150 00:10:56,101 --> 00:10:59,701 In this case, different people were trying to render aid to the child, 151 00:10:59,861 --> 00:11:01,141 trying to help her. 152 00:11:01,301 --> 00:11:05,141 So the crime scene is completely disrupted. 153 00:11:06,341 --> 00:11:11,101 And also it's questionable whether the life saving attempts 154 00:11:11,261 --> 00:11:12,701 caused some of the injuries, 155 00:11:12,861 --> 00:11:15,181 or whether the injuries were there already. 156 00:11:20,821 --> 00:11:23,421 Investigators are going to talk to the mother. 157 00:11:24,541 --> 00:11:26,301 They're going to talk to the father. 158 00:11:27,101 --> 00:11:30,901 They're going to talk to anyone who is directly involved 159 00:11:31,061 --> 00:11:32,341 with these two. 160 00:11:33,261 --> 00:11:35,101 Any relatives. 161 00:11:35,261 --> 00:11:39,581 Her mother was involved, nurses for the child, 162 00:11:39,741 --> 00:11:40,741 doctors for the child. 163 00:11:40,901 --> 00:11:42,861 They're going to want to know everything they can 164 00:11:43,021 --> 00:11:44,621 about this child. 165 00:11:44,781 --> 00:11:46,741 And have there been earlier reports 166 00:11:46,901 --> 00:11:49,261 of this child being abused in any way. 167 00:11:55,661 --> 00:11:57,821 When the baby is brought to the hospital, 168 00:11:57,981 --> 00:11:59,941 it appears to have been cold for some time. 169 00:12:00,101 --> 00:12:02,861 And also to have injuries that are well beyond 170 00:12:03,021 --> 00:12:06,141 what might have happened with anybody trying to do CPR 171 00:12:06,301 --> 00:12:07,501 on this child. 172 00:12:10,101 --> 00:12:13,341 Babies don't just die. There's a reason why they die. 173 00:12:13,501 --> 00:12:18,461 On a postmortem examination is a quest to establish 174 00:12:18,621 --> 00:12:20,221 what that reason is 175 00:12:20,381 --> 00:12:22,661 and the sort of things you can find 176 00:12:22,821 --> 00:12:26,981 are injuries or pathology that's in the body, 177 00:12:27,141 --> 00:12:29,341 organs that aren't working properly, 178 00:12:29,501 --> 00:12:31,421 bleeding and so on and so forth. 179 00:12:32,341 --> 00:12:36,221 What the postmortem in this case encountered was 180 00:12:36,381 --> 00:12:39,941 a whole series of serious injuries. 181 00:12:43,741 --> 00:12:46,181 I don't think you need to be a pathologist to realise 182 00:12:46,341 --> 00:12:48,501 that a baby that has 40 rib fractures, 183 00:12:48,661 --> 00:12:51,421 a fractured skull, a subarachnoid haemorrhage, 184 00:12:51,581 --> 00:12:55,981 and an injury to the brain stem - these are not accidental injuries. 185 00:12:56,141 --> 00:12:58,981 These are injuries that have been inflicted by someone, 186 00:12:59,141 --> 00:13:01,781 and they've been inflicted over a period of time. 187 00:13:05,781 --> 00:13:08,101 It's almost hard to imagine that anybody would inflict 188 00:13:08,261 --> 00:13:11,941 these kind of injuries against 16 week old baby, 189 00:13:12,101 --> 00:13:15,341 and the injuries that we found that had been inflicted 190 00:13:15,501 --> 00:13:18,381 was 40 fractured ribs 191 00:13:18,541 --> 00:13:21,141 that had been caused through gripping that baby. 192 00:13:28,381 --> 00:13:29,741 When they get the results, 193 00:13:29,901 --> 00:13:33,181 what they see is signs of chronic child abuse. 194 00:13:33,341 --> 00:13:36,421 This is not something that happened just last night. 195 00:13:37,741 --> 00:13:41,181 Because are indications of injuries that have healed 196 00:13:41,341 --> 00:13:42,821 or in the process of healing, 197 00:13:42,981 --> 00:13:45,421 which means they took place a significant time 198 00:13:45,581 --> 00:13:47,101 before the child's death. 199 00:13:49,661 --> 00:13:52,861 Once they determine that the child did not die 200 00:13:53,021 --> 00:13:54,421 simply of natural causes, 201 00:13:54,581 --> 00:13:56,621 that there was a physical means... 202 00:14:00,221 --> 00:14:02,341 ...now the cops are looking at homicide. 203 00:14:02,501 --> 00:14:06,541 So now it's what happened? Where is it most likely to happen? 204 00:14:08,101 --> 00:14:09,261 This is a child. 205 00:14:09,421 --> 00:14:13,221 It's most likely to have happened at the child's residence 206 00:14:13,381 --> 00:14:15,461 or at some other caregiver's. 207 00:14:17,621 --> 00:14:19,821 Who had control over the child? 208 00:14:19,981 --> 00:14:22,621 There any families or a babysitter or whatever? 209 00:14:22,781 --> 00:14:24,461 They're all going to be looking at that. 210 00:14:25,701 --> 00:14:27,901 It seems that the only place this child was at 211 00:14:28,061 --> 00:14:29,541 was in the family residence. 212 00:14:29,701 --> 00:14:32,421 So now we're lucky in one sense, we only have two suspects. 213 00:14:33,581 --> 00:14:34,981 The mom and the dad. 214 00:14:39,261 --> 00:14:42,941 If Rosalin doesn't look as if she's really deeply affected 215 00:14:43,101 --> 00:14:46,781 by this baby's death and there are other injuries 216 00:14:46,941 --> 00:14:48,901 on this child that can't be explained 217 00:14:49,061 --> 00:14:51,061 by whatever happened on the bus, 218 00:14:51,221 --> 00:14:55,021 that would raise certainly questions that maybe something has happened. 219 00:14:55,181 --> 00:14:58,341 She's already begun to distance herself from the child 220 00:14:58,501 --> 00:15:02,501 because she knew the child had died before she even got on the bus, 221 00:15:02,661 --> 00:15:04,901 or was at least about to die. 222 00:15:05,061 --> 00:15:08,741 And so something happened. And she knows what it is. 223 00:15:13,541 --> 00:15:16,581 That's the problem with all child abuse deaths 224 00:15:16,741 --> 00:15:21,101 is trying to figure out who exactly caused the injuries 225 00:15:21,261 --> 00:15:24,221 and caused the injuries that actually killed them. 226 00:15:28,941 --> 00:15:31,581 I feel for the detectives in this particular case 227 00:15:31,741 --> 00:15:34,461 because you can have all the logic in the world, 228 00:15:34,621 --> 00:15:38,141 but you need that evidence to prove who exactly did it. 229 00:15:38,301 --> 00:15:41,141 And many times it's just not there. 230 00:15:44,461 --> 00:15:46,941 We know that the child was in hospital 231 00:15:47,101 --> 00:15:49,981 for a extended period of time. OK. 232 00:15:50,141 --> 00:15:52,381 Well, how many times was the child visited? 233 00:15:53,581 --> 00:15:54,821 I mean, it is normal. 234 00:15:54,981 --> 00:15:57,701 You know, I've seen this in the past, where you have preemies, 235 00:15:57,861 --> 00:16:01,341 it's almost like you can't drag the mother out of the hospital. 236 00:16:06,221 --> 00:16:07,581 Poor Imani, 237 00:16:07,741 --> 00:16:10,261 who was only 16 weeks old at the time of her death, 238 00:16:10,421 --> 00:16:14,021 had been for the first 64 days of her life, 239 00:16:14,181 --> 00:16:16,061 so effectively half her life, 240 00:16:16,221 --> 00:16:18,901 had been hospitalised in a high dependency unit 241 00:16:19,061 --> 00:16:20,221 since birth. 242 00:16:20,381 --> 00:16:23,541 And the reason for that is that she'd been born prematurely. 243 00:16:23,701 --> 00:16:28,821 However, when we looked into the history of the parents, 244 00:16:28,981 --> 00:16:33,661 we found that Rosalin Baker only visited 16 days out of that 64. 245 00:16:34,621 --> 00:16:37,781 So imagine that, that if that's your newborn baby, 246 00:16:37,941 --> 00:16:41,621 knowing that baby is very ill or very weak, may not survive, 247 00:16:41,781 --> 00:16:45,101 and you only visit her 16 days out of 64, 248 00:16:45,261 --> 00:16:47,261 that was a level of concern. 249 00:16:47,421 --> 00:16:50,501 And the next level of concern was that there was a reluctance 250 00:16:50,661 --> 00:16:53,061 to name the father, who was Jeffrey Wiltshire. 251 00:16:53,221 --> 00:16:56,461 Wiltshire, by the way, had never visited Imani in hospital 252 00:16:56,621 --> 00:16:58,021 for all her 64 days. 253 00:16:58,181 --> 00:17:01,581 So here, from the very, very inception of this inquiry, 254 00:17:01,741 --> 00:17:05,741 we could already identify that both parents seemed 255 00:17:05,901 --> 00:17:08,821 very, very distant from that child and her welfare. 256 00:17:13,781 --> 00:17:16,901 Although a forensic pathologist can establish 257 00:17:17,061 --> 00:17:19,541 what these injuries are, how serious they are, 258 00:17:19,701 --> 00:17:21,861 and whether they're potentially fatal. 259 00:17:22,701 --> 00:17:25,141 It's very difficult for them to establish 260 00:17:25,301 --> 00:17:27,141 who actually inflicted the injuries. 261 00:17:27,301 --> 00:17:29,541 And if there are two people in the household, 262 00:17:29,701 --> 00:17:32,021 in theory, it could be either one of them. 263 00:17:32,181 --> 00:17:36,821 And you're relying on other investigative factors. 264 00:17:36,981 --> 00:17:41,501 It may even be that friends or neighbours or relatives 265 00:17:41,661 --> 00:17:43,101 can shed some light, 266 00:17:43,261 --> 00:17:46,341 because they've seen an individual treating the baby 267 00:17:46,501 --> 00:17:47,701 in a particular way. 268 00:17:47,861 --> 00:17:51,301 So that's something the police would try to get to the bottom of. 269 00:17:56,861 --> 00:18:01,741 They were suspects simply because the circumstances of Imani's death 270 00:18:01,901 --> 00:18:06,061 and the initial account given by Baker just didn't tally. 271 00:18:08,461 --> 00:18:11,061 There was no way that she could have dressed that baby, 272 00:18:11,221 --> 00:18:15,261 put that baby on a harness and not know that she was dead. 273 00:18:15,421 --> 00:18:17,661 And obviously we later found out with the injuries 274 00:18:17,821 --> 00:18:19,341 they were very, very severe. 275 00:18:20,501 --> 00:18:25,701 And then we needed to identify who had access to Imani 276 00:18:25,861 --> 00:18:30,461 within the timeframe of her death, to definitively rule anybody else. 277 00:18:30,621 --> 00:18:32,701 And Jeffrey Wiltshire was arrested. 278 00:18:35,101 --> 00:18:38,581 Well the approach was obviously to get a first account from them. 279 00:18:38,741 --> 00:18:41,381 And in the case of both of them, they were very cold, 280 00:18:41,541 --> 00:18:42,901 very emotionless. 281 00:18:43,061 --> 00:18:45,181 Bearing in mind, you put that into context, 282 00:18:45,341 --> 00:18:48,261 you've just lost your 16 week old baby. 283 00:18:48,421 --> 00:18:53,581 You say, in terrible circumstances, that were nothing to do with you. 284 00:18:53,741 --> 00:18:55,381 You're suggesting that baby's become ill. 285 00:18:55,541 --> 00:18:57,341 That is your defence at that time. 286 00:18:59,301 --> 00:19:00,781 In Baker's case, 287 00:19:00,941 --> 00:19:04,661 she gave a prepared statement simply saying that Imani 288 00:19:04,821 --> 00:19:06,661 had an accident a little while before, 289 00:19:06,821 --> 00:19:10,141 had falling over, but had not sustained any serious injuries? 290 00:19:12,061 --> 00:19:13,661 And when we arrested Jeffrey Wiltshire, 291 00:19:13,821 --> 00:19:16,261 he claimed to not even be Imani's father 292 00:19:16,421 --> 00:19:18,221 and later he retracted that statement 293 00:19:18,381 --> 00:19:21,021 and actually claimed that the reason he told us that 294 00:19:21,181 --> 00:19:24,261 was because he was concerned that he had mental health problems 295 00:19:24,421 --> 00:19:27,861 and drug abuse issues that would be a concern to the authorities. 296 00:19:32,261 --> 00:19:35,421 Once you determine that the time of death was 297 00:19:35,581 --> 00:19:39,261 at least one day prior to the discovery, 298 00:19:39,421 --> 00:19:41,741 to me, and then I go back and say, 299 00:19:41,901 --> 00:19:44,861 well, what was the mother's behaviour? 300 00:19:45,021 --> 00:19:46,181 What did she do? 301 00:19:46,341 --> 00:19:50,541 Well, she hit all the CCTV points going in and going out. 302 00:19:50,701 --> 00:19:53,741 She's establishing an alibi, because what they have to do, 303 00:19:53,901 --> 00:19:56,621 she has to cover what exactly happened 304 00:19:56,781 --> 00:19:59,741 and how normal this trip on the bus was going to be. 305 00:19:59,901 --> 00:20:01,261 How normal? 306 00:20:05,981 --> 00:20:08,741 Rosalin Baker went out with Imani, 307 00:20:08,901 --> 00:20:10,181 she was fully dressed 308 00:20:10,341 --> 00:20:14,101 and was in a baby harness positioned with her face, 309 00:20:14,261 --> 00:20:15,781 and I believe there's a reason for that, 310 00:20:15,941 --> 00:20:17,701 because there was an injury to the eye, 311 00:20:17,861 --> 00:20:20,861 facing Rosalin's chest, 312 00:20:21,021 --> 00:20:24,501 again, covered up, but they went out in public. 313 00:20:27,701 --> 00:20:30,501 So they've gone out in public on the streets of London, 314 00:20:30,661 --> 00:20:33,461 deliberately putting themselves in a position 315 00:20:33,621 --> 00:20:38,021 where they know they're going to be subject to CCTV surveillance 316 00:20:38,181 --> 00:20:40,541 with the baby apparently well. 317 00:20:45,501 --> 00:20:47,781 Then getting on the bus, 318 00:20:47,941 --> 00:20:51,301 London busses are very, very well catered for 319 00:20:51,461 --> 00:20:53,181 in terms of closed circuit television. 320 00:20:53,341 --> 00:20:55,701 And once again it's very high quality. 321 00:20:55,861 --> 00:20:59,981 So in this particular case, what Baker and Wiltshire did, 322 00:21:00,141 --> 00:21:04,141 they walked together almost projecting the persona 323 00:21:04,301 --> 00:21:07,541 that they were a happy family with young innocent children. 324 00:21:07,701 --> 00:21:08,941 And when you look at it, 325 00:21:09,101 --> 00:21:10,861 if you didn't know what had really happened, 326 00:21:11,021 --> 00:21:13,461 you'd think this is quite a loving family. 327 00:21:14,421 --> 00:21:17,021 I say that because Wiltshire gives Rosalin a kiss. 328 00:21:17,821 --> 00:21:20,821 He'd been a gentleman, helps her with the buggy onto the bus, 329 00:21:20,981 --> 00:21:24,781 then gives her a thumbs up as the doors close. 330 00:21:25,581 --> 00:21:27,861 So anyone looking at that from the outside, 331 00:21:28,021 --> 00:21:29,941 not knowing the true facts, 332 00:21:30,101 --> 00:21:32,021 you'd think it's almost inconceivable 333 00:21:32,181 --> 00:21:33,781 that only hours before, 334 00:21:33,941 --> 00:21:38,061 together, they've taken part in the most heinous crime 335 00:21:38,221 --> 00:21:41,501 and then taken part in the most heinous attempt 336 00:21:41,661 --> 00:21:43,021 to cover that crime up. 337 00:21:45,861 --> 00:21:50,101 They see her walking with her partner, the father of the baby. 338 00:21:51,221 --> 00:21:54,541 And at that point, the baby is very likely dead. 339 00:21:54,701 --> 00:21:58,141 And they know they're carrying around a dead child. 340 00:22:00,341 --> 00:22:04,421 So it begins to appear that they've made a plan 341 00:22:04,581 --> 00:22:09,581 to have this child appeared to have gone into distress in a public place 342 00:22:09,741 --> 00:22:12,261 where other people would be touching it, handling it, 343 00:22:12,421 --> 00:22:15,421 maybe inflicting the injuries on it, 344 00:22:15,581 --> 00:22:20,101 and, witnessing her being in distress over it 345 00:22:20,261 --> 00:22:23,141 before, quote, unquote, it dies. 346 00:22:27,341 --> 00:22:28,781 They're in this together. 347 00:22:29,781 --> 00:22:31,661 They both know that this child is dead 348 00:22:31,821 --> 00:22:33,581 and they have to do something about it 349 00:22:33,741 --> 00:22:36,261 because people are aware that they have this child. 350 00:22:36,421 --> 00:22:40,501 So they were planning how they were going to make this look. 351 00:22:42,661 --> 00:22:44,781 I think it was very well thought out. 352 00:22:45,981 --> 00:22:49,141 They wanted to have the child out of the house, 353 00:22:49,301 --> 00:22:52,781 so there's no reason for the police to come back to the house 354 00:22:52,941 --> 00:22:55,061 to search it and see if there's anything there. 355 00:22:56,261 --> 00:22:58,701 When I studied that CCTV on the bus, 356 00:22:58,861 --> 00:23:01,581 Baker's actively looking at different members of the public 357 00:23:01,741 --> 00:23:03,021 getting on that bus. 358 00:23:03,181 --> 00:23:07,101 And now what know is going through her mind for that 28 minutes was, 359 00:23:07,261 --> 00:23:08,821 who am I going to pick? 360 00:23:09,701 --> 00:23:14,741 What person is going to become the third part of this conspiracy 361 00:23:14,901 --> 00:23:16,821 to stage this cover up? 362 00:23:37,661 --> 00:23:40,341 Because of the very conclusive postmortem results 363 00:23:40,501 --> 00:23:43,181 which showed that Imani had been dead for up to 24 hours 364 00:23:43,341 --> 00:23:47,381 before the bus, it was very clear that this wasn't an accident. 365 00:23:49,621 --> 00:23:53,221 So police knew early on that this was serious crime. 366 00:23:57,301 --> 00:24:01,861 What we've managed to determine was that Rosalin Baker 367 00:24:02,021 --> 00:24:04,781 moved from her mother's house in Colchester in Essex, 368 00:24:04,941 --> 00:24:09,261 into the Stratford area where Wiltshire had small flat. 369 00:24:11,101 --> 00:24:14,541 And they were there for the week leading up to the death of Imani. 370 00:24:18,061 --> 00:24:21,261 We knew then with this timeline from the postmortem, 371 00:24:21,421 --> 00:24:25,941 that Imani had died 24 hours or so prior to the discovery of the body 372 00:24:26,101 --> 00:24:29,981 on the bus. So we knew that she'd been there for the week. 373 00:24:30,141 --> 00:24:33,581 So what was a very, very important to determine was 374 00:24:33,741 --> 00:24:35,741 all that catalogue of injuries, 375 00:24:35,901 --> 00:24:38,141 could we determine when they had occurred? 376 00:24:38,301 --> 00:24:42,021 So to determine this we actually use some of the United Kingdom's 377 00:24:42,181 --> 00:24:44,581 foremost bone injury experts 378 00:24:44,741 --> 00:24:48,461 that could actually tell us, through the postmortem examination 379 00:24:48,621 --> 00:24:49,941 and the findings 380 00:24:50,101 --> 00:24:54,021 that these injuries had occurred at three different stages 381 00:24:54,181 --> 00:24:56,981 that could be timed within that last week. 382 00:24:57,141 --> 00:25:00,861 That was within the week that we knew Imani was in 383 00:25:01,021 --> 00:25:05,421 the so-called care of both parents, Jeffrey Wiltshire and Rosalin Baker. 384 00:25:11,821 --> 00:25:15,501 They charged Rosalin and Jeffrey very early on. 385 00:25:18,901 --> 00:25:21,901 When it came out that they'd been charged on murder charges, 386 00:25:22,061 --> 00:25:23,421 there was a sense of real horror 387 00:25:23,581 --> 00:25:25,501 because there were so few details that emerged. 388 00:25:25,661 --> 00:25:27,821 But what we were told was really shocking, 389 00:25:27,981 --> 00:25:31,941 that a three month old baby had died of head injuries on a bus. 390 00:25:32,101 --> 00:25:35,661 So without any more context, you start to think 391 00:25:35,821 --> 00:25:38,621 was there an attack on the bus? Was it a member of the public? 392 00:25:38,781 --> 00:25:41,021 Was it- You know, there were very few details, 393 00:25:41,181 --> 00:25:43,141 but what we did know, it was horrible. 394 00:25:48,301 --> 00:25:50,021 I can tell you, as a detective, 395 00:25:50,181 --> 00:25:52,661 and I've investigated child deaths before, 396 00:25:52,821 --> 00:25:55,861 these are some of the most, difficult cases to work. 397 00:25:56,861 --> 00:25:59,861 Particularly if you have kids of your own at the house, 398 00:26:00,021 --> 00:26:03,101 because this is an absolutely innocent person 399 00:26:03,261 --> 00:26:05,701 who cannot possibly defend themselves. 400 00:26:05,861 --> 00:26:07,741 So you really have to take a deep breath, 401 00:26:07,901 --> 00:26:10,381 because you can't allow all these emotions that you're feeling 402 00:26:10,541 --> 00:26:13,261 to interfere with your investigation. 403 00:26:16,941 --> 00:26:19,421 Whenever you investigate the murder of a child, 404 00:26:19,581 --> 00:26:21,181 and I've investigated several, 405 00:26:21,341 --> 00:26:23,821 it's a very different kind of case 406 00:26:23,981 --> 00:26:27,741 to investigating the murder of an adult in quite a number of ways. 407 00:26:27,901 --> 00:26:31,021 Firstly, on a personal level, we're all humans. 408 00:26:31,181 --> 00:26:33,261 We all have emotions and so do my team. 409 00:26:33,421 --> 00:26:35,461 It's quite a harrowing thing to investigate 410 00:26:35,621 --> 00:26:39,341 when you're uncovering detail of most unimaginable cruelty 411 00:26:39,501 --> 00:26:42,661 and unspeakable acts that you don't think any human being could 412 00:26:42,821 --> 00:26:45,261 ever, ever perpetrate, but these two did. 413 00:26:46,061 --> 00:26:47,221 So there's that element. 414 00:26:47,381 --> 00:26:49,821 But you put aside any personal feelings, 415 00:26:49,981 --> 00:26:52,301 and then you look at how you investigate it. 416 00:26:52,461 --> 00:26:56,061 Well, in a homicide of an adult, they've got a background. 417 00:26:56,221 --> 00:26:58,781 And normally you're looking for the motive 418 00:26:58,941 --> 00:27:01,061 as to why that murder has taking place. 419 00:27:01,221 --> 00:27:06,101 In a case of a 16 week old baby, that baby has had very little life. 420 00:27:06,261 --> 00:27:08,021 And half the life that she had 421 00:27:08,181 --> 00:27:10,741 was obviously in a high dependency unit in hospital. 422 00:27:10,901 --> 00:27:14,301 So there's no background in terms of that baby 423 00:27:14,461 --> 00:27:16,021 in any contact with anybody else. 424 00:27:21,741 --> 00:27:23,701 As soon as the trial started 425 00:27:23,861 --> 00:27:26,901 and as soon as the prosecution delivered their opening statements, 426 00:27:27,061 --> 00:27:30,061 it was just immediately clear that there was so much more to this case 427 00:27:30,221 --> 00:27:31,701 than was initially thought. 428 00:27:34,461 --> 00:27:36,941 The trial, I thought, was a very interesting trial 429 00:27:37,101 --> 00:27:39,101 because bearing in mind the engagement we'd had 430 00:27:39,261 --> 00:27:40,661 with Baker and Wiltshire, 431 00:27:40,821 --> 00:27:44,621 what we'd seen from them was that they were very cold, 432 00:27:44,781 --> 00:27:49,301 very much in denial of any wrongdoing. 433 00:27:50,101 --> 00:27:53,061 And so it's going to be interesting to see, firstly, 434 00:27:53,221 --> 00:27:55,141 what they gave evidence in their defence, 435 00:27:55,301 --> 00:27:57,181 and if so, how would they come across. 436 00:27:57,341 --> 00:27:58,901 What were they going to say? 437 00:28:01,221 --> 00:28:03,221 They don't have to prove anything. 438 00:28:03,381 --> 00:28:05,461 It's for the prosecution to prove their guilt 439 00:28:05,621 --> 00:28:07,021 beyond a reasonable doubt. 440 00:28:07,181 --> 00:28:08,981 So they, as defendants, 441 00:28:09,141 --> 00:28:11,701 they could have sat in the defence box, 442 00:28:11,861 --> 00:28:13,341 deciding not to give evidence 443 00:28:13,501 --> 00:28:17,541 and to let the prosecution prove or try to prove their guilt. 444 00:28:19,981 --> 00:28:23,141 Interestingly enough, what both of them decided to do 445 00:28:23,301 --> 00:28:25,701 because they were charged with the same crime, 446 00:28:25,861 --> 00:28:27,861 sitting in the dock together, 447 00:28:28,021 --> 00:28:29,821 they decided to engage in 448 00:28:29,981 --> 00:28:32,141 what is known in English law as a cut throat defence. 449 00:28:32,301 --> 00:28:34,061 So they both blamed each other. 450 00:28:37,021 --> 00:28:40,661 I think that's a calculated gamble as far as they were concerned. 451 00:28:40,821 --> 00:28:45,461 And thought the evidence is clear that Amani has been murdered 452 00:28:45,621 --> 00:28:49,541 and we were her parents and we were together with the baby. 453 00:28:53,021 --> 00:28:55,941 Baker decided to go to the witness box. 454 00:28:56,101 --> 00:29:01,061 Her evidence essentially was that she had woken up 455 00:29:01,221 --> 00:29:03,221 on the 28th of September 456 00:29:03,381 --> 00:29:07,421 and Jeffrey Wiltshire had said to her I've killed the baby. 457 00:29:08,341 --> 00:29:10,421 Now, this is what you're going to do. 458 00:29:10,581 --> 00:29:14,101 And she painted Wiltshire as a coercive domestic offender 459 00:29:14,261 --> 00:29:16,301 that had abused her over period of time. 460 00:29:17,781 --> 00:29:21,661 And she said that she went along with it because she was in fear. 461 00:29:23,301 --> 00:29:26,661 Wiltshire, apparently, according to her, had dressed Imani 462 00:29:26,821 --> 00:29:30,181 and then Baker then put Imani in the harness 463 00:29:30,341 --> 00:29:33,101 and put Imani around herself, 464 00:29:33,261 --> 00:29:34,781 knowing her own daughter was dead, 465 00:29:34,941 --> 00:29:37,861 and then went along with this facade, this charade, 466 00:29:38,021 --> 00:29:39,581 in the street. 467 00:29:39,741 --> 00:29:41,101 But here's the thing. 468 00:29:41,261 --> 00:29:43,421 If that were actually true, 469 00:29:43,581 --> 00:29:46,981 and it was imminent fear of danger or harm to herself 470 00:29:47,141 --> 00:29:48,501 that she really feared, 471 00:29:48,661 --> 00:29:52,781 the moment she got on that bus, knowing that she could give evidence 472 00:29:52,941 --> 00:29:55,021 against Wiltshire and involve the police, 473 00:29:55,181 --> 00:29:56,501 why didn't she do that? 474 00:29:59,741 --> 00:30:03,621 We then heard a different side to Rosalin's story, 475 00:30:03,781 --> 00:30:05,941 because at first when she gave a police statement, 476 00:30:06,101 --> 00:30:07,301 she said, oh no, no, 477 00:30:07,461 --> 00:30:10,141 my partner wouldn't do anything like that to her. 478 00:30:10,301 --> 00:30:14,101 She didn't notice any injuries, just a small mark above her eye. 479 00:30:14,261 --> 00:30:16,821 And then we start to hear of details that Wiltshire was abusive 480 00:30:16,981 --> 00:30:19,861 and controlling or taking drugs every day. 481 00:30:20,021 --> 00:30:24,221 So it's a much bigger kind of picture of neglect and depravity. 482 00:30:26,981 --> 00:30:29,981 The interesting part for me, again with this, 483 00:30:30,141 --> 00:30:32,621 was her demeanour this time around 484 00:30:32,781 --> 00:30:36,061 where she'd been cold before and even on the bus CCTV, 485 00:30:36,221 --> 00:30:39,981 you could see that she had no concern at any point. 486 00:30:40,141 --> 00:30:43,301 And now she's presenting herself as is terrified victim 487 00:30:43,461 --> 00:30:44,741 that's been coerced. 488 00:30:44,901 --> 00:30:47,181 That was totally innocent. I had no choice. 489 00:30:48,101 --> 00:30:49,501 All of a sudden, 490 00:30:49,661 --> 00:30:53,701 Baker became confrontational, became a different person. 491 00:30:53,861 --> 00:30:55,541 And so really, 492 00:30:55,701 --> 00:30:59,821 once her bogus account was properly probed in the witness box, 493 00:30:59,981 --> 00:31:01,421 it fell apart, 494 00:31:01,581 --> 00:31:04,621 as did Baker, and her real character came out. 495 00:31:05,661 --> 00:31:08,101 That was seen by all, including the jury. 496 00:31:13,021 --> 00:31:14,581 Wiltshire's account, 497 00:31:14,741 --> 00:31:16,741 was, again, a very, very interesting one, 498 00:31:16,901 --> 00:31:19,861 the way that he decided to go about defending himself. 499 00:31:20,021 --> 00:31:23,101 And he basically said it was nothing to do with me. 500 00:31:24,741 --> 00:31:28,781 When he asked by his defence counsel, did you murder Imani, 501 00:31:28,941 --> 00:31:32,181 he said, I'm a baby maker, not a life taker. 502 00:31:33,221 --> 00:31:35,061 And the reason he said that, 503 00:31:35,221 --> 00:31:37,341 apart from the obvious attempt to defend himself, 504 00:31:37,501 --> 00:31:41,221 was that he claimed to be the father of 23 children by 18 women. 505 00:31:42,781 --> 00:31:47,981 So he was basically just refusing any part, any knowledge in it, 506 00:31:48,141 --> 00:31:49,901 says it's nothing to do with me. 507 00:31:53,461 --> 00:31:55,421 Looking at the two defendants themselves, 508 00:31:55,581 --> 00:31:56,781 there was lots of lying, 509 00:31:56,941 --> 00:31:58,661 lots of going back on original statements, 510 00:31:58,821 --> 00:32:01,181 lots of trying to put the blame on somebody else. 511 00:32:01,341 --> 00:32:05,421 I feel that Rosalin's statements were the ones that 512 00:32:05,581 --> 00:32:07,821 was kind of- She was tripping herself up the most. 513 00:32:07,981 --> 00:32:10,621 And it was clear that they weren't in this together anymore. 514 00:32:10,781 --> 00:32:14,141 They definitely, you know, diverged and were trying to blame each other. 515 00:32:20,501 --> 00:32:23,461 With both co-defendants blaming the other, 516 00:32:23,621 --> 00:32:25,221 it can cause so much confusion 517 00:32:25,381 --> 00:32:30,901 that the jury is not able to decide definitively who did what. 518 00:32:31,621 --> 00:32:35,701 And in that situation, they can't convict either one. 519 00:32:38,141 --> 00:32:42,581 As more details of the abuse emerged and the kind of the deceit 520 00:32:42,741 --> 00:32:44,261 around trying to cover i tup, 521 00:32:44,421 --> 00:32:47,581 there was a real sense of disgust and a real hope that, you know, 522 00:32:47,741 --> 00:32:50,581 justice was going to be served for this poor child. 523 00:32:52,501 --> 00:32:53,941 We looked at everything, 524 00:32:54,101 --> 00:32:57,461 but we were unable to definitively say which one inflicted 525 00:32:57,621 --> 00:32:58,901 the fatal injury. 526 00:32:59,061 --> 00:33:01,021 But what we could say, without a doubt, 527 00:33:01,181 --> 00:33:04,101 was that all of those injuries, including the fatal injury 528 00:33:04,261 --> 00:33:06,541 had occurred within that period of time 529 00:33:06,701 --> 00:33:10,501 when that baby was in the care of Rosalin Baker, 530 00:33:10,661 --> 00:33:14,421 Jeffrey Wiltshire, in Wiltshire's bedsit in east London. 531 00:33:18,221 --> 00:33:21,221 The public perception would be 532 00:33:21,381 --> 00:33:24,421 that it doesn't matter who inflicted the death. 533 00:33:24,581 --> 00:33:28,661 Both of these people are responsible, and it's murder. 534 00:33:28,821 --> 00:33:31,461 However, legally speaking, 535 00:33:31,621 --> 00:33:35,181 without being able to prove an intent to kill the child 536 00:33:35,341 --> 00:33:39,261 or a cause of death, you cannot prove murder. 537 00:33:39,421 --> 00:33:42,821 And that fact in itself means the difference between 538 00:33:42,981 --> 00:33:44,661 ten years in jail 539 00:33:44,821 --> 00:33:47,461 or spending the rest of your life in jail. 540 00:33:49,741 --> 00:33:51,301 And in this particular case, 541 00:33:51,461 --> 00:33:55,701 knowing that the jury may struggle to reach a verdict on homicide, 542 00:33:55,861 --> 00:33:59,621 because we just couldn't prove which person inflicted the fatal injury, 543 00:33:59,781 --> 00:34:03,341 the judge decided that it was better to direct 544 00:34:03,501 --> 00:34:05,621 about an alternative charge. 545 00:34:18,301 --> 00:34:20,741 Some of the other passengers on the bus actually gave 546 00:34:20,901 --> 00:34:22,821 really, really compelling evidence at the trial, 547 00:34:22,981 --> 00:34:25,701 and they spoke of how they were trying really hard 548 00:34:25,861 --> 00:34:29,021 to revive this little body, this little girl, 549 00:34:29,181 --> 00:34:31,101 thinking that there might be a chance 550 00:34:31,261 --> 00:34:32,621 that they could save her life. 551 00:34:32,781 --> 00:34:34,621 And then when she went off the bus, 552 00:34:34,781 --> 00:34:36,341 they thought that they'd failed 553 00:34:36,501 --> 00:34:39,141 and that maybe, perhaps there was something else they could have done. 554 00:34:39,301 --> 00:34:42,341 And so to learn that, actually, this baby had been dead the whole while 555 00:34:42,501 --> 00:34:45,021 and that her mother was sitting there knowing this was happening, 556 00:34:45,181 --> 00:34:47,101 that must have just been horrifying. 557 00:34:48,101 --> 00:34:51,341 Some of them said that they actually had kind of effects of trauma, 558 00:34:51,501 --> 00:34:54,461 were unable to sleep, had to take medication because of it. 559 00:34:54,621 --> 00:34:57,141 It must have just been so distressing for everybody 560 00:34:57,301 --> 00:34:58,501 on that bus. 561 00:35:13,381 --> 00:35:15,661 The prosecutor told jurors 562 00:35:15,821 --> 00:35:18,621 that Rosalin Baker enacted what's been described 563 00:35:18,781 --> 00:35:20,461 as a nightmare charade, 564 00:35:20,621 --> 00:35:22,261 claiming her baby had fallen ill. 565 00:35:23,261 --> 00:35:24,701 Passengers tried to help. 566 00:35:24,861 --> 00:35:28,421 They were panicking and distressed, compared to Baker, 567 00:35:28,581 --> 00:35:31,701 who was noted to be calm and cold. 568 00:35:35,621 --> 00:35:38,381 Many homicide cases I dealt with, 569 00:35:38,541 --> 00:35:41,941 when a jury goes out, I was always nervous. 570 00:35:42,101 --> 00:35:45,981 I was always confident in the evidence we presented, 571 00:35:46,141 --> 00:35:50,181 but always nervous only because there's so much riding 572 00:35:50,341 --> 00:35:52,061 on that particular case. 573 00:35:52,221 --> 00:35:54,181 You know, you've got a victim murdered, 574 00:35:54,341 --> 00:35:56,101 you've got a family wants justice. 575 00:35:56,261 --> 00:35:58,101 Justice for the victim themselves. 576 00:35:58,901 --> 00:36:01,221 And when you've worked hard to get all of the evidence 577 00:36:01,381 --> 00:36:02,541 that you possibly can, 578 00:36:02,701 --> 00:36:05,741 and it's sufficient to present that case to a jury, 579 00:36:05,901 --> 00:36:07,861 you obviously want to get the right verdict. 580 00:36:11,221 --> 00:36:13,381 So I was nervous but confident. 581 00:36:20,861 --> 00:36:23,061 Very tense moments when a jury return. 582 00:36:24,141 --> 00:36:27,581 And on this occasion, we got back and were told there was a verdict. 583 00:36:27,741 --> 00:36:30,941 And then they're asked, do you find the defendant guilty or not guilty? 584 00:36:32,821 --> 00:36:36,861 And in this case, it was guilty of causing or allowing the death 585 00:36:37,021 --> 00:36:38,461 of Imani Baker. 586 00:36:41,421 --> 00:36:43,901 The jury deliberated for 14 or so hours, 587 00:36:44,061 --> 00:36:46,261 but they couldn't agree that the evidence was kind of 588 00:36:46,421 --> 00:36:47,781 beyond reasonable doubt, 589 00:36:47,941 --> 00:36:50,221 that they were both guilty of murder or one of them. 590 00:36:50,381 --> 00:36:52,661 So they those charges couldn't be upheld. 591 00:36:55,221 --> 00:36:58,421 Ultimately, they're not able to prove murder. 592 00:36:58,581 --> 00:37:00,741 And that has to be incredibly frustrating, 593 00:37:00,901 --> 00:37:05,501 because they have committed such a heinous crime, multiple times. 594 00:37:05,661 --> 00:37:08,301 Inflicted terrible abuse on this child, 595 00:37:08,461 --> 00:37:11,541 yet, because they're not able to prove murder, 596 00:37:11,701 --> 00:37:14,061 it doesn't seem like justice was served. 597 00:37:17,541 --> 00:37:19,861 Because it was difficult to pinpoint 598 00:37:20,021 --> 00:37:22,061 who actually had delivered the fatal blow, 599 00:37:22,221 --> 00:37:26,421 they ended up with lesser charges and a lesser sentence of 11 years, 600 00:37:26,581 --> 00:37:28,061 which is reduced to ten. 601 00:37:28,981 --> 00:37:32,901 And that's not an adequate sentence for what happened to this child. 602 00:37:34,141 --> 00:37:35,661 Their hands were tied. 603 00:37:37,341 --> 00:37:39,461 Had they been convicted of the homicide, 604 00:37:39,621 --> 00:37:41,661 the actual substantive murder, 605 00:37:41,821 --> 00:37:44,501 they'd have probably gone to prison for 30 years. 606 00:37:44,661 --> 00:37:48,461 The sentence they got was 11, later reduced to ten on appeal. 607 00:37:50,101 --> 00:37:52,181 On the one hand, justice has been done, 608 00:37:52,341 --> 00:37:55,421 that it's been proven Imani was unlawfully killed 609 00:37:55,581 --> 00:37:57,141 at the hands of her parents. 610 00:37:58,421 --> 00:38:01,981 But it was just a shame we couldn't have proved 611 00:38:02,141 --> 00:38:05,301 which one had administered that fatal injury. 612 00:38:08,301 --> 00:38:09,581 When we got the sentencing, 613 00:38:09,741 --> 00:38:12,341 I definitely felt that this was miscarriage of justice 614 00:38:12,501 --> 00:38:15,861 and it did not properly represent the horror 615 00:38:16,021 --> 00:38:18,421 that this poor, innocent child had to endure. 616 00:38:21,861 --> 00:38:25,141 They got 11 years, I think sentence was then reduced by a year. 617 00:38:26,061 --> 00:38:28,941 And I don't think that is a adequate punishment. 618 00:38:32,381 --> 00:38:36,581 This had to be a very difficult case for not just the investigators, 619 00:38:36,741 --> 00:38:38,781 but also for the jury. 620 00:38:42,501 --> 00:38:44,661 Because this is an emotional case. 621 00:38:46,541 --> 00:38:48,581 No one's going to make it out of this trial 622 00:38:48,741 --> 00:38:50,421 without an emotional scar. 623 00:38:52,621 --> 00:38:54,461 Because this is a baby. 624 00:38:54,621 --> 00:38:57,941 16 weeks old, vulnerable, small. 625 00:38:58,101 --> 00:39:01,941 Completely helpless against the hands of her parents. 626 00:39:06,301 --> 00:39:08,181 It can be very frustrating, 627 00:39:08,341 --> 00:39:12,261 when you know that this particular person did that crime, 628 00:39:12,421 --> 00:39:13,501 you know it. 629 00:39:14,381 --> 00:39:17,741 But they're let off with a lesser offense than what they should have. 630 00:39:18,621 --> 00:39:21,181 Sometimes what you have to do is you just got to suck it up 631 00:39:21,341 --> 00:39:22,901 because there's nothing you can do about it. 632 00:39:23,061 --> 00:39:24,621 That is the justice system. 633 00:39:27,581 --> 00:39:30,621 Looking at the whole, staged plot itself, 634 00:39:30,781 --> 00:39:34,421 it seemed that the reason they did it in such a busy, public bus was 635 00:39:34,581 --> 00:39:36,621 because they wanted to bring as many people as possible 636 00:39:36,781 --> 00:39:37,981 into their deceit. 637 00:39:39,821 --> 00:39:42,821 But in doing so, they've actually affected so many people 638 00:39:42,981 --> 00:39:44,581 and traumatised so many people. 639 00:39:46,861 --> 00:39:48,901 Some of the people who are on the bus say they can now 640 00:39:49,061 --> 00:39:51,901 no longer take buses because they feel so scared 641 00:39:52,061 --> 00:39:53,861 about what happened that day. 642 00:39:55,181 --> 00:39:58,301 And also, this was an incident where people of the community 643 00:39:58,461 --> 00:40:02,541 really did step in to help, and it was all in vain. 644 00:40:02,701 --> 00:40:04,981 And there's a sense that they might not do that again, 645 00:40:05,141 --> 00:40:08,661 because they don't want to be used in someone else's horrible plot. 646 00:40:13,541 --> 00:40:17,261 The person who I think it affected the most on that bus 647 00:40:17,421 --> 00:40:19,901 was the lady that administered CPR. 648 00:40:20,061 --> 00:40:24,181 And I spoke to that lady at length after she gave evidence 649 00:40:24,341 --> 00:40:27,501 and she gave evidence and she was from Italy. 650 00:40:27,661 --> 00:40:32,261 A lovely lady who was just on her way to work that day. 651 00:40:32,421 --> 00:40:35,941 And that lady was totally innocent, minding her own business 652 00:40:36,101 --> 00:40:37,621 wanted to do the best she could. 653 00:40:37,781 --> 00:40:42,941 And when she discovered that this baby was cold as ice 654 00:40:43,101 --> 00:40:44,621 as she described it, 655 00:40:44,781 --> 00:40:47,341 and then saw the bruise under the eye, 656 00:40:47,501 --> 00:40:51,341 you know, and still administered CPR, 657 00:40:51,501 --> 00:40:54,221 even though she might well have known that she was dead. 658 00:40:54,381 --> 00:40:56,061 But it was a terrific thing for her 659 00:40:56,221 --> 00:40:58,901 and her everlasting thoughts after was that she could not get 660 00:40:59,061 --> 00:41:00,341 on a bus again. 661 00:41:00,501 --> 00:41:02,741 She did want to travel on public transport again. 662 00:41:02,901 --> 00:41:05,861 If she saw a baby, you know, she'd be upset 663 00:41:06,021 --> 00:41:08,221 because she was worried the same thing would happen again. 664 00:41:08,381 --> 00:41:09,861 And that's the level of trauma 665 00:41:10,021 --> 00:41:12,901 that Rosalin Baker subjected this lady to. 666 00:41:20,301 --> 00:41:23,301 Despite the fact that they thought this was a means 667 00:41:23,461 --> 00:41:25,421 by which they could cover up the crime... 668 00:41:26,381 --> 00:41:30,541 ...they had no understanding of how the pathology examination would work 669 00:41:30,701 --> 00:41:34,421 and the fact that it would reveal overwhelming evidence 670 00:41:34,581 --> 00:41:37,301 that this child had died due to abuse. 671 00:41:40,661 --> 00:41:43,861 This case stands out to me for a number of reasons. 672 00:41:44,021 --> 00:41:46,181 Firstly, the callous nature, 673 00:41:46,341 --> 00:41:51,861 and the cruelty that somebody can hurt a child. 674 00:41:52,741 --> 00:41:55,901 But let alone hurt a child, murder a child, 675 00:41:56,061 --> 00:41:58,621 let alone a 16 week old child. 676 00:42:01,301 --> 00:42:03,381 We can identify the warning signs. 677 00:42:03,541 --> 00:42:05,501 And the warning signs were there in this case. 678 00:42:05,661 --> 00:42:08,741 But unfortunately, many of these systems are overloaded 679 00:42:08,901 --> 00:42:13,101 and they can't follow up on every single difficult case. 680 00:42:13,261 --> 00:42:15,181 So lots of cases, you know, 681 00:42:15,341 --> 00:42:17,421 just don't get the attention that they need. 682 00:42:17,581 --> 00:42:19,741 I think had there been enough resources, 683 00:42:19,901 --> 00:42:22,581 this baby probably would have been saved. 684 00:42:27,301 --> 00:42:29,381 I see death all the time. 685 00:42:29,541 --> 00:42:32,141 I don't like it, but I see it. 686 00:42:32,781 --> 00:42:36,301 But here's someone going on a ride on a double decker bus. 687 00:42:36,461 --> 00:42:38,981 All of a sudden they're confronted with a dead baby. 688 00:42:39,141 --> 00:42:42,061 What's the worst thing in the world if you're a family person? 689 00:42:42,221 --> 00:42:44,181 Is what a dead, innocent baby? 690 00:42:44,941 --> 00:42:47,861 They're the ones that were really, traumatised by all this. 691 00:42:48,021 --> 00:42:49,821 And I feel mostly for them. 692 00:42:56,861 --> 00:42:58,661 Looking back at this case, 693 00:42:58,821 --> 00:43:01,381 there's so many parts of it that kind of ignites 694 00:43:01,541 --> 00:43:03,141 different emotions: anger, frustration, 695 00:43:03,301 --> 00:43:06,261 but the overwhelming sense of this just pure sadness 696 00:43:06,421 --> 00:43:09,061 and pain you feel for this little girl. 697 00:43:10,221 --> 00:43:12,821 You know, she didn't have the love and support of her parents. 698 00:43:12,981 --> 00:43:14,261 Definitely. 699 00:43:14,421 --> 00:43:18,181 She didn't have wider protection from social services. 700 00:43:18,341 --> 00:43:21,341 Probably the safest she had been was when she was in an incubator. 701 00:43:21,501 --> 00:43:25,221 And that's just a really, really tragic start to any life. 702 00:43:53,981 --> 00:43:56,981 Subtitles by Sky Access Services 55785

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.