Original subtitles

>> SHE'S IN THE BEDROOM.

WATCH YOUR STEP.

I'D INTRODUCE YOU TWO, BUT I

BELIEVE YOU'VE ALREADY MET.

THE CARVINGS ON THE FACE ARE

ALMOST IDENTICAL TO THE FIRST

ATTACK.

>> IDENTICAL EXCEPT FOR 2

THINGS. HE'S NEVER COME BACK FOR

ONE OF HIS VICTIMS, AND HE'S

NEVER KILLED. RAPING AND CARVING

ISN'T ENOUGH FOR HIM ANYMORE.

HE'S CROSSED THE LINE. LOST

CONTROL. THAT'S WHEN YOU START

TO MAKE MISTAKES, ISN'T IT?

AND THERE IT IS.

>> TELL ME WHAT YOU DON'T LIKE

ABOUT YOURSELF, MR. MONTEJO.

>> MONTEJO? MY NAME IS TRAPP.

GRANVILLE TRAPP?

>> I'M SORRY. I MUST HAVE

GRABBED THE WRONG FILE THIS

MORNING.

>> IT'S OK. PEOPLE ARE ALWAYS

MISTAKING ME FOR SOMEONE ELSE

THESE DAYS. MY OWN MOTHER SAYS

SHE BARELY RECOGNIZES ME

ANYMORE. LOOK AT THIS MUG, HUH?

IT'S A HALLOWEEN MASK.

>> YOU'RE REFERRING TO THE

HOLLOWNESS AROUND YOUR CHEEKS?

>> I'M REFERRING TO MY AIDS

FACE. I'M HIV-POSITIVE. THE

COCKTAIL I'M ON RIGHT NOW IS

WHAT'S DOING THIS. NOT THAT I'M

COMPLAINING THAT MUCH. I'M STILL

ALIVE, WHICH IS MORE THAN I CAN

SAY FOR JOHN. HE WAS MY PARTNER

FOR 5 YEARS.

>> AND WAS HE ON A TREATMENT

PLAN AS WELL?

>> HA. MR. HOMOPATHIC? HE

WOULDN'T TAKE IBUPROFEN. WE

TRIED LICORICE, CAT'S CLAW--

ANYTHING TO BOOST HIS IMMUNE

SYSTEM. I CASHED IN MY 401K FOR

THESE MEDS AND, WELL...HE DIDN'T

LAST A YEAR AFTER HE WAS

DIAGNOSED.

>> I'M VERY SORRY.

>> I'M NOT. ASSHOLE WAS SCREWING

AROUND ON ME ALMOST FROM THE

BEGINNING. HE USED TO MEET MEN

ONLINE AND SET UP

ANONYMOUS MEETINGS FOR SEX THE

WHOLE TIME WE WERE TOGETHER. I

NEVER KNEW.

IT'S SCARY. TO GET THAT CLOSE TO

SOMEONE, TO KNOW EVERY DETAIL OF

THEIR LIFE, TO DRESS THEM...

I NEVER IMAGINED I WOULD BE

DECEIVED LIKE THAT.

>> TECHNICALLY, THE TERM FOR

YOUR CONDITION IS FACIAL

LIPOATROPHY. I'M GUESSING YOU'RE

ON A HIGH DOSAGE OF ZERIT OR

RETROVIR?

OVER TIME, THE REACTION FROM

THOSE CHEMICALS IS THAT IT

WILL EAT AWAY THE FAT CELLS IN

THE FACE, ARMS,

LEGS, MID-SECTION.

>> WHATEVER YOU CALL IT, IT IS

MY SCARLET LETTER THAT SCREAMS,

"SICK GAY MAN. STAY AWAY."

I JUST WANT TO START DATING

AGAIN.

>> DATING?

>> I'M NOT DEAD. I'M JUST

LONELY. I WANT MY OLD FACE BACK.

>> WHEN DID YOU GET TO BE SUCH

AN EXPERT ON AIDS MEDICATION?

>> I BUY GINA'S SUPPLY EVERY

MONTH.

>> I NEVER KNEW THAT.

>> THERE'S A LOT OF THINGS YOU

DON'T KNOW ABOUT ME, SEAN.

MISS McGRAW. TO WHAT DO WE OWE

THIS DISPLEASURE?

>> STEP AWAY FROM THE COUNTER,

CHRISTIAN.

>> OH, WE DON'T PLAY THOSE KINDS

OF GAMES ANYMORE, SWEETHEART.

WHAT ARE YOU DOING HERE?

>> STEP AWAY FROM THE COUNTER

AND PUT YOUR HANDS BEHIND YOUR

HEAD. NOW!

>> WAIT. HOLD ON A SECOND.

>> WHAT THE HELL'S GOING ON?

>> CHRISTIAN TROY, YOU ARE UNDER

ARREST OR THE MURDER OF RHEA

REYNOLDS. YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO

REMAIN SILENT.

>> THE MOST IMPORTANT THING IS

TO NOT LET WORD OF THIS GET OUT.

TO ANYONE. THE PRESS GETS WIND

OF HIS ARREST, BUSINESS WILL

SUFFER. AGREED?

>> SURE. FINE. EVERYTHING'S BACK

TO NORMAL THEN. HOW CAN YOU BE

SO BLITHE, SEAN? LOOK, THE COPS

CAN'T ARREST ANYONE FOR A CRIME

LIKE THIS UNLESS THEY HAVE

SERIOUS EVIDENCE, RIGHT?

>> I'D BE WILLING TO BET KIT HAD

CHRISTIAN ARRESTED JUST TO GET

BACK AT HIM.

>> DO YOU THINK SHE'D ACTUALLY

GO THAT FAR JUST BECAUSE SHE WAS

DUMPED?

>> THAT BITCH? HELL YEAH.

>> LIZ, YOU DON'T REALLY THINK

CHRISTIAN IS THE CARVER, DO YOU?

>> PEOPLE WHO KNEW TED BUNDY

THOUGHT HE WAS A HELL OF A GUY.

HE WAS COLLEGE EDUCATED, VERY

CHARMING, GOOD WITH THE LADIES.

AND THEN YOU FIND OUT HE

STRANGLED THEM AFTER BITING

THEIR NIPPLES OFF.

>> BEING CHARMING AND SCREWING A

LOT OF WOMEN DOES NOT MAKE YOU A

SERIAL KILLER.

>> I KNOW, SEAN. I AM JUST

PLAYING DEVIL'S ADVOCATE.

>> I'VE KNOWN CHRISTIAN FOR 20

YEARS. FOR THE BETTER PART OF

THAT TIME WE'VE SPENT 14 HOURS A

DAY TOGETHER. I COULD TELL YOU

ALMOST EVERY DETAIL OF HIS LIFE,

FROM HOW MANY CAVITIES HE HAS TO

WHAT HE KEEPS IN HIS SOCK

DRAWER. I KNOW HIM LIKE HE'S A

PART OF ME. AND I KNOW THERE'S

NO WAY IN HELL HE DID WHAT HE'S

BEING ACCUSED OF.

>> YOU KNEW HIM FOR 20 YEARS,

AND YOU NEVER WOULD HAVE

IMAGINED HE WAS MATT'S FATHER,

EITHER.

>> YOU KNOW WHAT WE CALL THE

ONES WHO FALL ASLEEP IN HERE?

GUILTY.

YOU SEE, AN INNOCENT MAN, HE'S

TERRIFIED AT THIS POINT. HE'S

THINKING THAT MAYBE HE'LL NEVER

SEE HIS FAMILY AND FRIENDS

AGAIN. HE'S THINKING THAT MAYBE

HE'LL GET RAPED IN PRISON. AN

INNOCENT MAN WON'T SLEEP BECAUSE

HE'S TOO ANXIOUS. A GUILTY MAN,

HE FIGURES HE'S BEEN CAUGHT.

HE CAN FINALLY STOP RUNNING AND

GET SOME SLEEP.

>> 14 HOUR IN THIS PLACE WITHOUT

EVEN A CUP OF COFFEE, AND

GANDHI WOULD BECOME A

NARCOLEPTIC.

>> CAN I OFFER YOU SOMETHING TO

DRINK, THEN? WE MIGHT BE HERE A

WHILE.

>> I DON'T THINK SO. YOU PROVED

YOUR POINT. YOU'RE PISSED YOU

GOT DUMPED. I GET IT. BUT I'M

DONE PLAYING. IF I'M NOT HOME BY

10:00 AND DEEP INTO A BEER AND

SOME CHINESE FOOD, I'LL HAVE MY

LAWYER SUE YOU FOR DEFAMATION OF

CHARACTER, FALSE ARREST AND, IF

POSSIBLE, BEING A ROYAL BITCH.

>> YOU'RE UNDER ARREST FOR

MURDER, CHRISTIAN. THIS ISN'T A

GAME.

>> IF YOU'RE SO SURE THAT I'M

THE CARVER, WHAT'S THERE TO TALK

ABOUT? HMM? YOU JUST WANT TO

TORTURE ME.

>> ACTUALLY, I'M HERE TO HELP

YOU.

>> HELP ME?

>> WITH YOUR CONFESSION.

>> OH.

>> GIVE IT TO ME, AND I'LL WORK

WITH THE D.A. TO WAIVE THE DEATH

PENALTY. YOU'VE HURT ENOUGH

PEOPLE, CHRISTIAN. SPARE THE

ONES YOU LOVE AND CONFESS YOUR

CRIMES.

>> WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU TALKING

ABOUT?

>> KIMBER AND I HAD A NICE CHAT

SEVERAL HOURS AGO.

Kimber: YOU'RE WASTING MY TIME.

I'M NOT ANSWERING YOUR

QUESTIONS, KIT.

Kit: AFTER ALL THE INTIMACY

WE'VE SHARED? WHAT DO YOU HAVE

TO HIDE FROM ME NOW, KIMBER?

OF COURSE, I SHOULD REMIND YOU

THAT ANYTHING YOU SAY IN HERE IS

ON THE RECORD. LYING WOULD ONLY

IMPLICATE YOU IN CHRISTIAN'S

CRIMES.

>> CHRISTIAN ISN'T A MURDERER.

YOU KNOW THAT. THIS IS ALL

ENTRAPMENT.

>> YOU MEAN BECAUSE WE SLEPT

TOGETHER? SWEETHEART, I HATE TO

BREAK IT TO YOU, BUT I WAS

UNDERCOVER.

>> WE'RE SOME SORT OF ASSIGNMENT

TO YOU? YOU REALLY ARE A SICK,

TWISTED PERSON.

>> THE TRUTH IS, IF YOU WANT TO

CATCH A DEVIANT KILLER, YOU HAVE

TO GET CLOSE ENOUGH TO WATCH HIM

WORK.

>> AS I RECALL, YOU'RE THE

DEVIANT ONE.

>> INTERESTING JUDGMENT, COMING

FROM SOMEONE WHO MAKES HER

LIVING AS A WHORE. ALL THAT SEX

DESENSITIZES YOU AFTER A WHILE,

DOESN'T IT? YOU START NEEDING

MORE AND MORE KINKINESS TO GET

OFF. BONDAGE, ROLE PLAYING,

MASOCHISTIC BEHAVIOR. ANYTHING

TO KEEP UPPING THE ANTE. IN

FACT, MAYBE YOU AND CHRISTIAN

ARE ANOTHER PAUL AND KARLA

BERNARDO.

>> WHO?

>> MARRIED COUPLE FROM CANADA,

BACK IN THE NINETIES. LIKED TO

KIDNAP AND DRUG WOMEN, BRING

THEM BACK TO THEIR HOME. BEFORE

THEY KILLED THEM, KARLA WOULD

VIDEOTAPE HER HUSBAND RAPING THE

UNCONSCIOUS BODIES. YOU CAN'T

DISPUTE THE FACT THAT AS A

DIRECTOR, YOU KNOW YOUR WAY

AROUND A CAMERA.

>> YOU THINK I'M A KILLER?

WHY DON'T YOU ADMIT WHY YOU

REALLY BROUGHT ME DOWN HERE,

KIT? YOU'RE JEALOUS OF ME. YOU

FELL IN LOVE WITH CHRISTIAN, AND

NOW THAT IT'S JUST ME AND HIM,

YOU'RE TRYING TO GET YOUR

REVENGE.

>> ONCE YOU SCREW A GIRL'S LOVER

IN FRONT OF HER, THERE'S NO NEED

TO GET REVENGE, IS THERE?

THEN AGAIN, ASSAULTING AN

OFFICER IS GROUNDS FOR ARREST.

>> OH, YOU'RE KIDDING. YOU'RE

ARRESTING ME? YOU'RE NOT

ARRESTING ME!

>> YOU HAVE NO RIGHT TO TREAT

HER LIKE THAT. SHE DIDN'T HURT

YOU.

>> THAT'S SWEET. YOU'RE ACTING

LIKE A REAL PERSON WHO'S CAPABLE

OF LOVING SOMEONE.

>> I DO...LOVE HER.

>> LOOK WHAT YOU'VE DONE TO HER

SINCE YOU'VE MET HER. COCAINE

ADDICT, PORN STAR. NOW ARRESTED

FOR ASSAULTING AN OFFICER. HAS

THERE EVER BEEN ANYTHING YOU'VE

TOUCHED THAT YOU DIDN'T DESTROY?

YOU BETTER WISE UP AND START

COOPERATING WITH ME, CHRISTIAN,

OR KIMBER IS ONLY THE BEGINNING.

ONCE WORD OF YOUR ARREST GETS

OUT, AND PEOPLE REALIZE WHO YOU

REALLY ARE, I MIGHT BE THE ONLY

FRIEND YOU HAVE LEFT.

>> DID THEY SET ANY KIND OF

BAIL?

THIS IS GONNA COST CHRISTIAN

EVERYTHING HE HAS IF IT GOES TO

TRIAL, ISN'T IT?

>> IT WON'T GO TO TRIAL. HE

DIDN'T DO ANYTHING.

>> I KNOW HE DIDN'T. BUT PEOPLE

GET RAILROADED BY THE JUSTICE

SYSTEM ALL THE TIME. I MEAN,

EVEN IF HE'S FOUND INNOCENT, THE

DAMAGE IT COULD DO TO HIS

CAREER, JUST TO BE ACCUSED.

WOULD YOU STILL STAY IN BUSINESS

WITH HIM?

>> ARE YOU SERIOUS? OF COURSE I

WOULD. ABSOLUTELY.

>> EVEN IF IT COST YOU THE

PRACTICE? EVERYTHING YOU'VE

WORKED FOR YOU WHOLE LIFE?

>> HE'S INNOCENT, JULIA. IF I

HAVE TO, I'LL HELP PAY HIS LEGAL

FEES MYSELF.

>> HOW COULD I BE THE CARVER IF

I WAS CARVED MYSELF?

Kit: YOU HAD ALL THE RIGHT TOOLS

TO BEGIN WITH. FIRST YOU GAVE

YOURSELF A TRACE AMOUNT OF THE

TRANQUILIZER--JUST ENOUGH TO

PASS SCRUTINY AND INVESTIGATION.

AS A SURGEON, YOU'D KNOW EXACTLY

WHERE TO CARVE YOURSELF, SO

YOU'D NEVER BE IN ANY REAL

DANGER. THEN YOU HID ALL YOUR

TOOLS AND JUMPED INTO BED.

AFTER YOU LET YOURSELF BLEED A

WHILE, YOU CALLED THE POLICE.

A BRILLIANT MISDIRECTION, I MUST

ADMIT.

>> WHAT ABOUT THE FACT THAT I

WAS RAPED? HOW COULD I FAKE

THAT?

>> YOU REFUSED A POLICE

EXAMINATION. THERE'S NO PROOF OF

ANY ASSAULT OR PENETRATION.

>> YOU DON'T HAVE A SINGLE HARD

FACT. YOU WANT ME OR ANYONE ELSE

TO BELIEVE THAT YOU HAVE A CASE?

I THINK YOU NEED SOMETHING A

LITTLE MORE SOLID THAN A

BREAKDOWN FROM MY GIRLFRIEND AND

SOME FAR-FLUNG THEORY ABOUT HOW

I FAKED MY OWN CARVING.

>> MAYBE THIS WILL HELP.

YOUR SIZE, I BELIEVE. FOUND IN

RHEA'S APARTMENT AFTER THE

MURDER. BLOOD ON THE OUTSIDE OF

THE CONDOM MATCHES RHEA'S. SEMEN

ON THE INSIDE MATCHES YOURS.

THAT SOLID ENOUGH FOR YOU?

>> I CAN EXPLAIN THE CONDOM. YOU

PLANTED IT.

>> THAT'S YOUR DEFENSE?

>> GIVEN ALL THE USED MAGNUMS

I'VE USED WITH YOU OVER THE LAST

3 MONTHS, IT WOULD BE EASY FOR

YOU TO STEAL ONE AND LEAVE IT IN

RHEA'S BED.

>> LET'S SEE. I SNUCK INTO

RHEA'S APARTMENT AFTER SHE WAS

MURDERED, BUT BEFORE THE POLICE

SHOWED UP, AND HID ONE OF YOUR

USED CONDOMS THAT I STOLE FROM

YOUR TRASH CAN A WEEK AGO?

I'M NEVER ADVERSE TO A GOOD

CONSPIRACY THEORY, CHRISTIAN,

BUT EVEN THAT ONE'S A LITTLE

THIN.

>> IF YOU DIDN'T PLANT IT,

SOMEBODY DID.

>> WHO WOULD DO THAT?

>> THROW A STONE DOWN SOUTH

BEACH. YOU'LL HIT SOME MODEL I

SCREWED AND NEVER CALLED BACK.

WHY DON'T YOU START THERE?

>> I'D RATHER LOOK AT SOMETHING

NO ONE KNOWS ABOUT. YOU WERE IN

REFORM SCHOOL AS A CHILD. IS

THAT RIGHT?

>> WHEN I WAS 12. WHAT'S THAT

GOT TO DO WITH ANYTHING?

>> QUITE A LOT, ACTUALLY, WHEN

YOU CONSIDER WHAT LANDED YOU

THERE IN THE FIRST PLACE. I

FOUND A LOT OF FASCINATING

NEWSPAPER ARTICLES FROM BACK

THEN.

SEEMS THAT YOU WERE QUITE THE

CARVER, EVEN AT AN EARLY AGE.

Kit: ANIMAL KILLING IN CHILDREN

IS ONE OF THE EARLIEST SIGNS OF

SOCIOPATHIC BEHAVIOR. ALMOST ALL

SERIAL KILLERS START OUT THAT

WAY.

>> I DIDN'T KILL THESE ANIMALS.

I FOUND THEM THAT WAY. THEY WERE

ALREADY DEAD.

>> YOU JUST CUT OFF THEIR HEAD

AS AN EXPERIMENT.

>> WHAT CAN I SAY? I'VE ALWAYS

WANTED TO BE A SURGEON.

>> YOU MEAN YOU WERE EXERCISING

THAT GOD COMPLEX OF YOURS.

>> IT'S NOT A GOD COMPLEX.

I WAS A KID. I WAS BORED.

CURIOUS.

>> THAT'S FUNNY. THAT'S WHAT

MATT SAID THE OTHER DAY ABOUT

WHY HE PICKED UP A TRANSSEXUAL.

HE WAS CURIOUS.

>> DON'T START COMPARING MY

CHILDHOOD TO WHAT'S GOING ON

WITH MATT. WE GREW UP UNDER VERY

DIFFERENT CIRCUMSTANCES.

>> YES, BUT THAT'S WHAT MAKES IT

SO FASCINATING. THAT DESPITE THE

DIFFERENT UPBRINGINGS, YOUR

GENES HAVE PRODUCED A CHILD

THAT'S PROVEN TO BE AS VIOLENT

AS YOURSELF. NATURE BEATS

NURTURE EVERY TIME.

>> YOUR PROSECUTORIAL ARGUMENTS

WILL NOT STAND UP IN COURT.

>> OH, I THINK THEY WILL ONCE I

PROVE BEYOND REASONABLE DOUBT

THAT YOUR VIOLENCE IS INNATE.

LET'S TAKE A WALK.

YOU HAVE VISITORS.

>> OH, MY GOD. CHRISTIAN.

>> I'M OK.

>> HOW HAVE THEY BEEN TREATING

YOU?

>> LIKE A CRIMINAL. BEING LOCKED

ALONE IN A ROOM WITH THAT BITCH

FOR 2 HOURS, NOW I AM READY TO

KILL SOMEBODY.

>> SHE'S GOT A SERIOUS CASE FROM

WHAT I HEAR.

>> WHAT DO YOU MEAN, FROM WHAT

YOU HEAR?

>> THEY FOUND ONE OF YOUR

CONDOMS AT THE SITE, RIGHT?

>> IS THAT TRUE?

>> YOU DON'T ACTUALLY BELIEVE I

COULD...

SHE PLANTED IT, SEAN. HOW ELSE

DO YOU THINK IT GOT THERE?

>> SHE ALSO TOLD US THAT YOU

HAVEN'T ASKED FOR A LAWYER.

>> I HAVEN'T DONE ANYTHING.

I DON'T NEED ONE.

ASKING FOR REPRESENTATION IS

TANTAMOUNT TO SAYING THAT I'VE

GOT SOMETHING TO HIDE. I DON'T.

>> [SIGHS]

>> I CAN'T BELIEVE THIS IS

HAPPENING TO ME.

>> WE'VE HIRED A LAWYER FOR YOU.

CUNNINGHAM'S THE BEST IN THE

CITY. HE'S ON HIS WAY.

>> THANK YOU.

>> IT'S NOT BECAUSE WE DOUBT

YOU, CHRISTIAN. IT'S JUST

BECAUSE WE WANT TO MAKE SURE

YOU'RE PROTECTED, THAT'S ALL.

>> YOU WANT TO PROTECT ME?

THEN GO TO MY CONDO. KIT'S

GETTING A SEARCH WARRANT AND

TEARING THE PLACE APART

TOMORROW.

>> WHAT DO YOU WANT US TO DO?

>> [SIGHS] I NEED SOMEBODY I

TRUST TO BE THERE SO SHE DOESN'T

PLANT ANY MORE EVIDENCE. SHE

KNOWS SHE'S NOT GONNA GET A

CONFESSION, SO SHE'S TRYING TO

TURN EVERYBODY I KNOW AGAINST

ME.

>> YEAH. MAYBE A LITTLE MORE ON

THE RIGHT CHEEK. ANOTHER 3ccs

UNDER THERE, HE'LL LOOK EXACTLY

LIKE HIS OLD, HEALTHY SELF.

>> THIS ISN'T RIGHT.

>> OK, THEN WE START WITH A

SMALLER DOSE. WE'LL WAIT TO SEE

HOW IT SETTLES--

>> THIS MAN IS SICK. WHY ARE WE

HIDING HIS DISEASE? IF WE MAKE

HIM LOOK LIKE A NORMAL, HEALTHY

GUY, HE COULD SLEEP WITH ANYONE

HE WANTS AND SPREAD THE VIRUS

UNDETECTED NOW. THAT'S DANGEROUS

AND IRRESPONSIBLE.

>> ARE YOU ASSUMING HE'S GONNA

JUST RUN OUT OF HERE WHEN WE'RE

DONE AND BANG EVERYONE HE SEES

JUST TO INFECT THEM?

>> I ONLY SPENT 10 MINUTES IN A

CONSULTATION WITH HIM. I DON'T

KNOW HIM AT ALL.

>> I THINK CHRISTIAN'S ARREST

HAS GOTTEN YOU A LITTLE

PARANOID, MY FRIEND.

>> YOU KNOW THEY FOUND A CONDOM

AT THE CRIME SCENE THAT MATCHES

CHRISTIAN'S DNA.

>> SO WHAT? THE POLICE PLANTED

IT. IT HAPPENS ALL THE TIME.

>> DNA DOESN'T LIE.

>> ASK OJ. HE'LL TELL YOU

OTHERWISE.

YOU THINK CHRISTIAN DID IT.

>> I DIDN'T SAY THAT. IT'S NOT

WHAT I THINK.

YOU'VE ONLY KNOWN HIM A FEW

MONTHS. I'D SAY YOU'D BE MORE

SUSCEPTIBLE TO BELIEVING HE'S

GUILTY.

>> I THINK IT'S THE OPPOSITE,

REALLY. I THINK YOU KNOW MORE

ABOUT SOMEONE IN THE FIRST 5

MINUTES THAN YOU DO IN AN ENTIRE

20-YEAR RELATIONSHIP. THINK

ABOUT IT. THOSE FIRST GUT

INSTINCTS, THEY'RE ALWAYS RIGHT.

IT'S TIME AND SENTIMENTALITY

THAT CLOUD THE MIND'S ABILITY

TO JUDGE.

>> I'VE TAKEN THE LIBERTY OF

FILLING IN A LOT OF DETAILS

ALREADY ON THIS CRIME REPORT,

DATES OF THE ATTACKS, VICTIM'S

NAMES, ET CETERA. ALL YOU NEED

TO DO IS SIGN HERE FOR NOW,

AND WE CAN WORK ON THE LANGUAGE

OF YOUR CONFESSION AFTER YOU GET

SOME REST. I'M SURE YOU'LL AGREE

THAT GIVEN ALL THE EVIDENCE,

THIS IS YOUR BEST WAY OUT.

>> SCREW YOU. I WANT MY LAWYER.

>> YOU BRING A LAWYER INTO THIS,

AND I WON'T BE ABLE TO HELP YOU

ANYMORE, CHRISTIAN. MY DEAL IS

OFF THE TABLE.

>> YOU WANNA PLAY HARDBALL,

SWEETHEART? YOU HAVE NO IDEA WHO

YOU'RE DEALING WITH.

>> I'M SORRY TO HEAR THAT.

I'LL GET YOUR LAWYER, THEN.

HE'S BEEN WAITING.

OH! IF YOU DON'T MIND, LET ME

GIVE YOU SOME ADVICE. TELL HIM

YOU WANT TO PLEAD INSANITY.

>> WHAT, FOR SLEEPING WITH YOU

IN THE FIRST PLACE?

>> GIVEN YOUR FAMILY LINEAGE,

I THINK YOU HAVE A GOOD CHANCE

TO AT LEAST AVOID THE DEATH

PENALTY. A JURY MIGHT EVEN HAVE

SYMPATHY FOR YOU.

>> WHAT DO YOU KNOW ABOUT MY

LINEAGE?

>> YOU HAVE A GENETIC

PREDISPOSITION TO VIOLENCE,

CHRISTIAN. IT'S IN YOUR BLOOD.

>> WHAT ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT?

>> I FOUND YOUR BIRTH MOTHER,

CHRISTIAN. SHE'S STILL ALIVE.

>> YOUR ADOPTION RECORDS HAD

BEEN SEALED BY THE COURT BECAUSE

SHE WAS ONLY 15 WHEN YOU WERE

BORN. I HAD THEM SUBPOENAED AS

PART OF YOUR INVESTIGATION, THEN

TRACKED HER DOWN FROM THERE.

IT TURNS OUT YOUR MOTHER LIVED

ONLY A HUNDRED MILES FROM MIAMI.

>> ALL THIS TIME?

>> WHEN I CONTACTED HER, SHE

INSISTED ON COMING DOWN

PERSONALLY. NORMALLY, I'D NEVER

LET A SUSPECT DO THIS, BUT I

HAVE A SOFT HEART WHEN IT COMES

TO FAMILY REUNIONS.

YOU HAVE 5 MINUTES.

>> HELLO, CHRISTIAN.

>> THEY ALWAYS TOLD ME YOU WERE

DEAD.

>> I'M SORRY. THIS MUST BE QUITE

A SHOCK FOR YOU, THEN.

>> UM, DETECTIVE McGRAW HAS

FILLED ME IN ON MOST OF THE

DETAILS OF WHAT'S HAPPENING

FOR YOU--

>> DETECTIVE McGRAW HAS THE

WRONG MAN IN CUSTODY. SHE KNOWS

THAT.

>> WELL, I SUPPOSE THERE'S ONE

THING YOU CAN'T DENY, AND THAT

IS THAT YOU LOOK A LOT LIKE YOUR

FATHER.

>> IS HE STILL ALIVE, MY FATHER?

>> I DON'T KNOW, BUT I'M PRETTY

SURE HE NEVER EVEN KNEW YOU

EXISTED.

>> YOU NEVER TOLD HIM ABOUT ME?

>> I WAS ONLY 14 AT THE TIME...

WHEN HE RAPED ME.

HE ATTACKED 10 OTHER GIRLS

BEFORE ME. BROKE INTO THEIR

HOMES, RAPED THEM, CUT OFF A

PIECE OF THEM TO TAKE WITH HIM

AS SOME SORT OF TROPHY.

I SUPPOSE THAT'S WHAT WAS

GOING TO HAPPEN TO ME

IF MY FATHER HADN'T COME HOME

EARLY FROM WORK THAT NIGHT.

THEY NEVER CAUGHT HIM.

>> WHY DIDN'T YOU GET AN

ABORTION?

>> I PROBABLY SHOULD HAVE.

BUT THAT ISN'T WHAT MY FAMILY

BELIEVED IN AT THE TIME.

REGARDLESS OF HOW YOU WERE

CONCEIVED, YOU WERE THE INNOCENT

ONE. YOU DESERVED TO BE SAVED.

>> SAVED? DO YOU HAVE ANY IDEA

WHO MY FOSTER PARENTS WERE,

WHAT THEY DID TO ME?

>> NO, AND I'M SORRY--

>> I'M SORRY. THIS IS A

LITTLE...

[SIGHS] LITTLE MUCH FOR ME TO

DEAL WITH RIGHT NOW.

>> THE FACT IS I KNEW THAT

LOOKING INTO YOUR FACE EVERYDAY

WOULD ONLY REMIND ME OF THE

RAPE. I THOUGHT I WAS BEING

RESPONSIBLE GIVING YOU UP.

BUT I WASN'T. THAT'S WHY I'M

HERE NOW.

YOU NEVER HAD A CHANCE TO BE A

GOOD MAN, CHRISTIAN. WHEN YOU

REALIZE WHO YOUR FATHER WAS,

WHAT HE PASSED ON, AND I...

I OWED IT TO YOU AFTER ALL THIS

TIME TO TELL YOU MYSELF...

AND I OWE IT TO ALL THOSE OTHER

POOR GIRLS TO TRY TO CONVINCE

YOU TO STOP.

>> YOU HAVEN'T SEEN ME SINCE I

WAS BORN, AND YET...

YOU THINK I'M A KILLER.

I EARN $750,000 A YEAR...

AT LEAST. I'M A GODDAMN SURGEON.

JUST BECAUSE MY FATHER RAPED YOU

DOESN'T MEAN THAT I'VE TURNED

INTO THE SAME MAN.

>> CHRISTIAN, PLEASE--

>> PLEASE DON'T TELL ME YOU'VE

COME DOWN HERE ALL THIS WAY

AFTER ALL THIS TIME TO CONVINCE

ME THAT I'M A MURDERER.

>> THIS WASN'T EASY FOR ME,

EITHER, YOU KNOW, TO DIG UP THE

PAST! WHAT DO YOU THINK IT'S

LIKE?! TO REALIZE THAT MY SON,

WHOM I NEVER SHOULD HAVE HAD,

TURNED OUT TO BE MY WORST FEAR.

>> I USED TO FANTASIZE WHEN I

WAS BEING BEATEN AND MOLESTED

BY MY FOSTER FATHER THAT...

NONE OF THAT PAIN COULD HURT ME

BECAUSE MY MOTHER WAS AN ANGEL

LOOKING DOWN ON ME FROM HEAVEN.

THAT'S WHAT GAVE ME THE STRENGTH

TO GO ON, MAKE SOMETHING OF MY

LIFE.

NOW I JUST WISH YOU WERE DEAD.

HOW'S THAT FOR A CONFESSION?

I'M DONE IN HERE.

[DOOR OPENS AND CLOSES]

>> IS THAT REALLY NECESSARY?

THOSE ARE ALL $200 SHIRTS.

>> THEY'RE EVIDENCE NOW.

EACH ONE WILL BE SENT TO THE LAB

FOR DNA TESTING TO MATCH FOR

TRACES OF BLOOD AND SEMEN.

BAG AND TAG ALL OF THESE,

PLEASE.

>> IT JUST SEEMS EXCESSIVE.

WHAT EXACTLY ARE YOU LOOKING

FOR?

>> ANYTHING THAT LINKS DR. TROY

TO OTHER CRIME SCENES OR FITS

WITH THE PROFILE.

>> AND WHAT PROFILE IS THAT?

>> SEXUALLY DEVIANT MASOCHIST

OBSESSED WITH APPEARANCES.

WELL, WHAT DO WE HAVE HERE?

HIS CLOSET PORN COLLECTION.

OF HUMAN BONDAGE AND SUFFERING.

WHIP SMART. THE GANG-BANG GANG.

>> KIMBER DIRECTS ADULT VIDEOS.

I'M SURE THOSE ARE HERS.

>> THE ONES KIMBER DIRECTS

AREN'T NEARLY AS HARDCORE AS

THESE. HERS HAVE THEMES OF

FEMALE EMPOWERMENT, NOT

DEGRADATION.

>> FOUND THESE IN THE KITCHEN

DRAWER.

>> CAN'T SAY THIS SURPRISES ME.

VERY COMMON FOR CRIMINALS TO BE

OBSESSED WITH THEIR OWN CRIMES

AND THE PRESS ATTENTION THEY

GET. IT'S A WAY TO RELIVE THE

RUSH OF THE ATTACK.

>> McNAMARA/TROY IS PROBABLY

MENTIONED IN HALF THOSE

ARTICLES. WE DO THE PRO BONO

WORK ON THE VICTIMS.

>> MOST PEOPLE WHO ARE VICTIMS

OF VIOLENT CRIMES TEND TO SHUN

REMINDERS OF THEIR OWN ABUSE.

>> THAT'S JUST A THEORY.

IT DOESN'T PROVE ANYTHING.

>> I DON'T EVEN KNOW WHY I'M

INDULGING YOUR PRESENCE.

>> WHY ARE YOU?

>> BECAUSE IT'S TIME YOU SEE

CHRISTIAN FOR WHO HE REALLY IS,

A TERRIFYING SOCIOPATH.

>> [SIGHS]

>> CASE IN POINT.

>> WHAT'S YOUR EARTH-SHATTERING

CONCLUSION, THAT HE'S A NEAT

FREAK?

>> THERE'S WHERE THE-MAID-DOES-

NEAT AND THEN THERE'S SCARY,

OBSESSIVE, COMPULSIVE NEAT,

WHICH IS ALWAYS ABOUT TRYING TO

HIDE SOMETHING.

>> TRANQUILIZER. THE EXACT SAME

TYPE THE CARVER USES TO PARALYZE

HIS VICTIMS.

>> I DON'T UNDERSTAND. WHY WOULD

KIT BRING YOUR MOTHER IN TO SEE

YOU?

>> WELL, I'M BUSY. YOU'RE GONNA

HAVE TO TAKE CARE OF THIS, ALL

RIGHT? I'M SORRY. WHERE WERE WE?

>> MY BAIL. WHEN CAN I GO HOME

AND TAKE A SHOWER?

>> WELL, THE POLICE CAN HOLD YOU

FOR ANOTHER 24 HOURS BEFORE THE

D.A. HAS TO SET UP A HEARING, SO

YOU MIGHT BE HERE FOR THE

WEEKEND.

>> ARE YOU KIDDING? I HAVE TO

SPEND 2 MORE DAYS IN THIS SHIT

HOLE?

>> TRUST ME, THAT'S THE GOOD

NEWS. THAT MEANS THEY'RE TRYING

TO BUY SOME MORE TIME TO BUILD A

STRONGER CASE.

>> HOW CAN THEY NOT HAVE A CASE?

THEY'VE ALREADY ARRESTED HIM,

SEARCHED HIS APARTMENT, FOUND

THE CONDOM...

>> BOTTOM LINE, IF THEY THOUGHT

THEY HAD THEIR MAN, THEY

WOULD'VE RELEASED HIS IDENTITY

TO THE MEDIA BY NOW. WHICH

BRINGS ME TO YOUR DEFENSE. NOW,

OUR STRATEGY FROM THIS POINT ON

IS TO EXPOSE POLICE ABUSES, AND

DISCREDIT THEIR INVESTIGATION.

NOW, THE WAY WE DO THAT IS

CONDUCT OUR OWN INQUIRY, AND

SPIN IT IN OUR FAVOR. THAT'S

GONNA TAKE A LOT OF RESOURCES.

>> WHAT DOES THAT MEAN IN

REGARDS TO YOUR FEE?

>> WELL, IT'S TOUGH TO GIVE YOU

A HARD AND FAST NUMBER, BUT

GIVEN THE SCOPE AND NATURE OF

THIS CASE, I'D SAY ANYWHERE

BETWEEN 3 AND 5 MILLION.

>> COULD YOU EXCUSE US FOR A

MOMENT?

>> CERTAINLY.

>> I CAN TAKE OUT A LOAN AGAINST

THE BUSINESS. WILL YOU HELP ME

DO THAT? LOOK, THIS GUY'S THE

BEST IN MIAMI. IT'S GONNA COST,

BUT I CAN'T TAKE ANY MORE

CHANCES IF I WANT MY FREEDOM.

>> THEY FOUND THE TRANQUILIZER

IN YOUR APARTMENT, CHRISTIAN.

SO YOU'RE NOT GONNA TRY TO DENY

IT WAS YOURS?

>> I ORDERED IT A MONTH AGO

THROUGH THE OFFICE. IT'S NOT

WHAT YOU THINK.

>> IT'S NOT? 'CAUSE AT THIS

POINT, I'M NOT SO SURE ANYMORE.

>> LOOK, I BOUGHT IT BECAUSE I

WAS HAVING DOUBTS. I DIDN'T KNOW

IF I WAS ACTUALLY PARALYZED THAT

NIGHT, OR IF...I WAS JUST

WILLING TO LET HIM HURT ME.

>> I DON'T UNDERSTAND.

>> COME ON, SEAN. I'M A STRONG

GUY. 5 CCs OF THAT STUFF ISN'T

ENOUGH TO PARALYZE ME TO THE

POINT WHERE I CAN'T MOVE.

>> I HAD THE SAME THING HAPPEN

TO ME, AND I COULDN'T MOVE FOR

AN HOUR. I DON'T KNOW WHY YOU

WOULD THINK--

>> BECAUSE I DID MOVE. I MOVED

MY FINGERS WHEN IT WAS HAPPENING

TO ME. I DON'T KNOW IF IT WAS A

REFLEX OR A NERVE TWITCH OR

SOMETHING, BUT...I LIE AWAKE

EVERY NIGHT WONDERING IF I

COULD'VE DONE SOMETHING. IF I

DIDN'T FIGHT BACK BECAUSE IN

SOME KIND OF WAY, I...I FEEL

LIKE I DESERVE IT.

>> FOR WHAT?

>> FOR WHAT?! FOR SCREWING JULIA

WHEN YOU WERE ENGAGED. FOR

CHEATING ON EVERY GIRLFRIEND

I'VE EVER HAD. FOR CHARGING 10

GRAND TO RAISE A PAIR OF SAGGING

TITS ON SOME SOCIALITE BITCH.

FOR GENERALLY BEING A SOULLESS

MAN. TAKE YOUR PICK. YOU NEED TO

BELIEVE ME, SEAN. IF I'M THEIR

GUY, THAT MEANS I CUT YOU. THAT

MEANS I TOOK A KNIFE, AND I CUT

YOUR FACE. DO YOU REALLY THINK I

COULD DO THAT?

>> I'M GONNA GO BACK TO MY CELL.

IT'S GETTING A LITTLE

UNCOMFORTABLE IN HERE.

>> GOOD EVENING, THIS IS ANDREA

HALL AT MIAMI DADE POLICE

PROCESSING CENTER, WITH A WCNU

EXCLUSIVE. A LOCAL PLASTIC

SURGEON, DR. CHRISTIAN TROY, HAS

BEEN ARRESTED ON SUSPICION OF

BEING THE CARVER. JUST 36 HOURS

AFTER THE MURDER OF RHEA

REYNOLDS, POLICE SAID THEY

FINALLY CAUGHT A BREAK IN THE

CASE THAT HAS KEPT MIAMI IN THE

GRIP OF FEAR FOR THE LAST 6

MONTHS. A POLICE SPOKESMAN WOULD

NOT REVEAL ANY DETAILS OF THE

EVIDENCE THAT LED TO DR. TROY'S

ARREST, BUT DID TELL ME A

SPECIAL INVESTIGATOR HAD BEEN

TARGETING THE DOCTOR FOR SOME

TIME. AN IRONIC TWIST IN THIS

ARREST IS THAT IT WAS DR. TROY,

PART OF THE SURGERY TEAM OF

McNAMARA/TROY, WHO HAD

VOLUNTEERED TO REPAIR THE FACES

OF THE VICTIMS HE ALLEGEDLY

CARVED. A FEW OF THOSE WOMEN WHO

WERE CONTACTED FOR REACTION TO

THE NEWS REFUSED TO COMMENT AT

THIS TIME. WITHOUT A DOUBT,

LOCAL REACTION IN THE MIAMI AREA

IS ONE OF RELIEF AND CAUTIOUS

OPTIMISM.

>> HONEY, ARE YOU AWAKE? YOU

WERE TOSSING AND TURNING SO

MUCH. WHAT, YOU HAVING A BAD

DREAM?

>> IT WAS HORRIBLE. I WAS IN

PRISON.

>> WELL, I MADE YOU YOUR

FAVORITE BREAKFAST. MAYBE THAT

WILL HELP MAKE YOU FEEL BETTER.

AND IF YOU HURRY UP AND FINISH,

I'LL LET YOU SHAVE MY LEGS. AND

WHO KNOWS WHAT ELSE.

>> BOY, IS THIS YOUR LUCKY DAY.

LET'S GO.

>> ISN'T THERE SOME KIND OF RULE

WHERE I'M ALLOWED TIME TO REST

BETWEEN INTERROGATIONS?

>> YOU'RE FREE TO GO.

>> WHAT?

>> DETECTIVE McGRAW MET WITH THE

D.A. THIS MORNING, CONVINCED HIM

TO DROP ALL CHARGES.

>> WHY?

>> I GUESS THE REAL CARVER

STRUCK AGAIN LAST NIGHT.

EVIDENCE AT THE CRIME SCENE WAS

ENOUGH TO CONVINCE HER THAT YOU

WERE INNOCENT.

>> MR. TRAPP.

>> OH, MY GOD. IT'S YOU.

>> I DIDN'T MEAN TO STARTLE YOU.

I'LL GO SEE IF I CAN FIND DR.

McNAMARA.

>> NO. NO. NO. I'M GLAD YOU'RE

HERE. UH, I NEED SOMEONE TO GIVE

ME THE FINAL ONCE OVER. CAN YOU

DO IT SO I CAN BE DISCHARGED?

>> THE FILLER HAS SET, AND I

DON'T SEE ANY SIGN OF INFECTION.

YOU'LL NEED TO TAKE SOME

ANTIBIOTICS FOR A FEW WEEKS, BUT

OTHERWISE, YOU LOOK--

>> LIKE MY OLD SELF AGAIN. IT'S

FUNNY. LAST WEEK WHEN PEOPLE

LOOKED AT ME, ALL THEY SAW WAS A

DYING MAN. TODAY I LOOK READY TO

TAKE ON THE WORLD. IT'S LIKE MY

WHOLE IDENTITY CHANGED

OVERNIGHT.

>> AT LEAST YOURS WAS FOR THE

BETTER.

>> ON THE OUTSIDE, YEAH. BUT ON

THE INSIDE, I'M STILL THE SAME

PERSON. I GUESS, UH...PEOPLE

ONLY SEE WHAT THEY WANT TO.

>> OH, THERE YOU ARE.

GOD, I WAS SO RELIEVED WHEN I

HEARD YOU GOT OUT.

I NEVER SHOULD HAVE DOUBTED YOU,

CHRISTIAN. I KNEW IT WAS ALL A

CASE OF MISTAKEN IDENTITY.

CAN YOU BELIEVE THAT ANDREA

HALL JUMPED THE GUN LIKE THAT?

HALF OUR APPOINTMENTS CANCELLED

THIS WEEK. THE OTHER HALF, I'M

SURE, AREN'T EVEN BOTHERING TO

CALL TO SAY THEY'RE NOT COMING

IN. WITH EVERYTHING YOU WENT

THROUGH, I HAVE HALF A MIND TO

CALL THE STATION AND--

>> IT'S NOT A PROBLEM, SEAN.

>> ARE YOU KIDDING? THIS MIGHT

TAKE MONTHS FOR US TO RECOVER

FROM. RIGHT NOW, WE HAVE NO

SURGERIES ON THE BOOKS.

>> SHE REPORTED THE STORY

BECAUSE I CALLED HER AND TOLD

HER WHAT HAPPENED. THEY STILL

GIVE YOU ONE CALL IN PRISON, YOU

KNOW.

>> YOU LEAKED THE STORY? WHY?

>> BECAUSE I KNEW THE REAL

CARVER WOULD HATE NOT GETTING

CREDIT FOR HIS OWN WORK.

>> SO YOU KNEW HE WOULD STRIKE

OUT AGAIN.

>> I HOPED HE WOULD. THEN THEY'D

HAVE TO RELEASE ME.

>> YOU PLANNED TO GET OUT OF

PRISON BY SACRIFICING ANOTHER

INNOCENT PERSON? HOW COULD YOU

EVEN THINK LIKE THAT?

>> I HAD NO CHOICE, SEAN.

EVERYONE IN MY LIFE, EVERYBODY

THAT I TRUSTED ABANDONED ME,

INCLUDING YOU! JESUS CHRIST.

WE'VE KNOWN EACH OTHER FOR 20

YEARS. I THOUGHT YOU KNEW ME.

>> I THOUGHT I DID, TOO.

>> YOU'RE BACK.

THE LATEST CARVER VICTIM IS IN

YOUR OFFICE, CHRISTIAN.

>> TELL ME WHAT YOU DON'T LIKE

ABOUT YOURSELF.

[CAPTIONED BY THE NATIONAL

CAPTIONING INSTITUTE

--www.ncicap.org--]