Original subtitles

Falmouth Coast Guard calling Angel Cove Lifeboat.

Distress flare sighted one mile west of Seal Island.

Besides, what difference would an early night have made?

We're both on call, day or night. That's the whole point.

Hurry.

Right, what's the shout?

There was a red flare reported over Seal Island.

Someone's in trouble. That's all we know.

- What time do you call this? - The middle of the night.

Jake, hurry up. Come on. Come on.

Okay, stay safe, everyone!

Angel Cove Lifeboat, this is Falmouth Coast Guard.

Can you give me your current position please? Over.

Roger that. We're nearly there. Over.

Phillip, bring them up to port. Erica, to starboard.

- Hold on, Jake!

Nice night for it.

This is hopeless.

Just keep at it.

Angel Cove Lifeboat, this is Falmouth Coast Guard.

Can we have an update on your search, please? Over.

Falmouth Coast Guard, this is Angel Cove Lifeboat.

We have completed a search and found nothing.

I'm confident that it's another hoax call. Over.

Roger that. Happy for you to stand down

and return to station. Over.

Turn her around. I'll get them in.

We're turning back.

Phil! Phillip!

Erica! Erica!

Time-wasting idiots!

Man overboard! Man overboard!

Portside! Portside!

- Erica! Chrissy! - Chrissy!

Falmouth Coast Guard!

Falmouth Coast Guard, this is Angel Cove Lifeboat.

We have two crew members washed overboard. Over.

Angel Cove Lifeboat, this is Falmouth Coast guard.

Copy that and standing by. Do you require assistance?

Repeat. Do you require assistance? Over.

Angel Cove Lifeboat, are you receiving me? Over.

Yeah.

Can you take a photo of that?

- Just the rip, yeah? - Yeah. Thanks.

Chrissy? I'm Jane Kennedy, the coroner.

How are you feeling?

Like someone just died.

Look, we don't have to do this right now

- if you don't want to. - Let's get it over with.

- You sure? - Mmm.

Could you talk me through what happened last night?

The Coast Guard reported

a distress flare just after 2:00 a.m.,

so we went out on the shout but we drew a blank.

There's nothing unusual in that.

Round about half of our call-outs

turn out to be wild goose chases.

So, Erica was operating the front searchlight

and I went to tell her we were turning the boat around.

I had one last look to see

if there was any vessel or bodies in the water.

There were waves coming over the deck

and the next thing I knew, we were both in the water.

And you don't remember how it happened?

No.

- How's your eye? - Eh?

That's quite a bruise you've got there.

Yeah. It's the least of my worries.

Look, I've got a lot to do. I need to be getting on.

Chrissy, I don't think that's a good idea.

Looks like an accident.

Yeah, they were obviously washed overboard.

- Then I found this. - Oh, here we go. What's that?

A small tear in Erica's lifejacket.

Almost invisible to the naked eye,

but large enough to prevent it

from fully inflating when she hit the water.

Well, cases like this are automatically referred

to my friends at the Marine Accident Investigation Branch.

They're very thorough.

The skipper can't remember how she ended up in the sea.

What if one of the other crew members

pushed her and Erica over the side?

Now, what if, and this is just a wild stab in the dark,

they were washed overboard?

Okay. Look, if you want a motive, how about this?

In January, Chrissy Woodward became

the first female lifeboat cox in Devon's history

and the first thing she did

- was promote Erica. - Oh, come on.

- Davey, I'm serious. - I know you are.

But things have moved on, haven't they?

Ever since Emmeline Pankhurst

chained herself to them railings,

we've got female police officers,

female world leaders.

I believe we've even got a female coroner.

Jane, come on, no one cares.

What, so you're not gonna talk to her?

No. I'm not gonna go looking for trouble.

That's more your department.

Thanks.

Shut the door!

Oh, yeah, I've known Chrissy for years.

I was her mentor when she first volunteered.

And what were your impressions?

He does Sean Connery

and a surprisingly good Russell Harty.

Yeah, what that girl don't know about sailing

you could fit on a postage stamp.

She was 17 when she won the Lighthaven Regatta,

and within two weeks of working on the boat crew,

- she was teaching me. - So you weren't surprised

when you heard she was the new skipper?

Nah, Andy was training her up to take over.

His doctor had already told him that he didn't have long,

you know, 'cause of his drinking.

Well, mind you, not everyone was pleased with the promotion.

Old Bob Fountain was spitting nails when he found out.

Why?

Well, Bob's the longest-serving crew member.

You know, he thought his experience

entitled him to the top job.

He wouldn't have been any good at it, though.

I mean, you need people skills to run a boat crew.

Bob may be many things, but a diplomat he ain't.

Oi! Go easy on the ham.

I don't know if I bought enough.

If the mourners want more,

they'll have to buy it off the bar menu.

If you don't mind me asking, why did you quit the boat?

I thought I was pushing my luck, to be honest.

You can only look death in the face so many times.

He failed his medical.

They thought you were too chubby, didn't they?

Ooh, that flippin' car alarm. It is useless.

Oh. Mum, I ought to go, if that's all right.

That's all right, love. Thanks for your help.

Come on.

Mick! Mum!

What's happened?

Did you get a look at 'im?

- No. - Who was he?

- I don't know. - Oh, my God, Mick!

Are you all right? I'm gonna call an ambulance.

Oh, don't fuss, woman. I'm all right.

- Let's get you up.

- Oh! Oh!

Blimey, what happened to you?

Someone clocked him one last night in the pub car park.

Who'd do something like that?

Well, they didn't leave a forwarding address.

Snuck up behind me like a thief in the night.

- Well, they probably were. - Eh?

A thief, if they were in your car park.

See? I told you he wouldn't take it seriously.

It's no wonder the country's in the state it is.

Well, I could take it seriously, couldn't I?

You ask Jane. I could take it very seriously.

I could insist you install some CCTV

outside your premises, record any suspicious activity.

- Well, I mean, it's... - Yeah.

The only problem with that is,

you might not like what we find.

Shall we?

- Thanks, Davey. - Cheers, mate.

strong to save

the restless wave

the mighty ocean deep

limits keep

when we cry to Thee

And now Phillip would like to say a few words.

Anyone who knew Erica Ryland associated her with love.

As her partner for seven unforgettable years,

I was privileged to feel the full force of that love.

Whether we were praying in a Buddhist temple.

Diving to the bottom of the ocean.

Or relaxing in this very church.

We were inseparable.

Togetherness.

That's a precious thing.

After all,

some people in this world

never get close to anyone.

Mr Mitchell, I'm Jane Kennedy, the coroner.

I was just wondering if I could ask you

a few questions about the accident.

I was just wondering if you saw anything.

What were you doing at the time?

I'm the helm.

Right. So, you steer the boat.

- Hmm. - What?

- Sorry. I better take this. - But...

Let me guess. You're fascinated by the macabre.

- What? - Well, I mean, your hair.

Your clothes.

You dress like someone just died.

Someone just did.

Ah, good point.

- You okay? - Oh. No.

But thanks for asking.

- Can I sit down? - Sure.

I tell you it was a catastrophe

just waiting to happen.

Women at sea are unlucky.

Especially if they're at sea with you, eh, Bob?

- And a woman who whistles,

that's even worse. Now that Erica,

she used to whistle in the lifeboat station.

Well, that's just asking for trouble.

"A whistling woman and a crowing hen

"brings the Devil out of his den."

Oh, give it a rest, Fountain.

No one's interested in your ignorant drivel.

Can I get another one, please?

- Of course. - Oh, is that right,

Mr University Educated Car Mechanic?

Yeah, and?

I'll tell you what's ignorant.

That's you pretending you and Erica were inseparable

when the whole town knows she was sick to death of you.

Bob. That's enough.

This is neither the time or place.

We've lost one of our own.

Erica was a loyal friend.

She was a brilliant second cox.

And Phillip loved her.

So show some respect.

That was forensics. Turns out Erica's lifejacket

may have been tampered with after all.

So you do need to speak to the skipper now.

Yeah, looks that way.

Chrissy! Sorry to bother you.

Just a couple of questions.

And I am sorry to have to ask you this,

but could anyone apart from Erica

have got hold of her lifejacket?

- Easily. - Really? Why's that?

Well, we just leave all the kit and the lifejackets

out on an open shelf. For ease of access, really.

Uh, you know, speed is of the essence.

Yeah. And I guess each crew member

is responsible for their own kit, is that right?

Everyone, including the apprentices.

And would you say Erica was the kind of person

that paid attention to detail?

Absolutely.

So, can you think of any reason

why anyone would want to damage Erica's lifejacket?

Is that a serious question?

Yeah. I'm afraid so, yeah.

Absolutely not. Erica was popular with everyone.

- What, even Bob Fountain?

You can't take Bob Fountain at face value.

Look, he's an idiot on land,

but at sea, he's an absolute godsend.

How'd you get the black eye?

Oh, I don't know.

Could have been any number of ways.

Yeah. All right, thanks.

- I'll let you get on. - Yeah.

Cheers.

Well, I have to justify

every new inquiry that I take on.

As it stands, I don't have enough evidence

to launch an initial investigation.

You do, as the coroner, however, have the right to investigate

any death you find suspicious, so, be my guest.

So, it's over to me.

Yeah.

Why didn't you phone me

instead of lying awake all night worrying,

you silly sausage?

It's a bit lame, isn't it?

I mean, what do I say? "I heard someone whistling.

"They tried the door handle and then they went away."

It's probably just some drunk not realising we were closed.

Yeah, maybe. Maybe not.

What if someone's got a grudge against me?

Now you're just being fanciable.

- Think you mean fanciful? - No.

I mean fanciable.

Would you like a nice bacon sandwich?

Would that make things better?

- Do you think it might help? - Mmm-hmm.

It doesn't work.

Oh.

Apologies for the inconvenience.

What was that about?

Oh, I bought a job lot of car alarms, didn't I?

No wonder they were cheap.

Let me guess. You installed one in your own car.

Well, how was I to know that it was gonna go off

every time a fly buzzed past?

Luckily, these stun guns have been selling like hotcakes.

All the rage in Plymouth. That is my last one.

Mick, that's a prohibited firearm.

Oh, is it really illegal to help protect the vulnerable?

This is the sort of thing you need in your line of work.

Fully rechargeable.

Just take off the safety cap and press the red button. Boom.

Peace of mind, just £35.

I'm sorry, but I'm gonna have to confiscate this.

- Eh? - I trained as a lawyer, didn't I?

You can't expect me to look the other way.

No, wait a minute.

I take you into my confidence

and this is how you repay me?

There are vulnerable people out there.

I hope you can sleep at night.

- Hey. - Hey.

So, I've uncovered a couple of interesting snippets

about Erica Ryland.

Apparently, her finances

were separate from her partner's

and she was in trouble.

She had enormous credit card bills

and no way to pay 'em back.

Okay. Well, there's a lot of that around.

- Nothing else? - Yeah.

Last month she went to the GP, complaining of nausea.

Turns out she was pregnant.

But when they carried out the postmortem,

there was no trace of a child.

Thanks for taking the time to talk to me.

Oh, it's my pleasure.

Do you want to come up to the crew room?

It's just a bit quieter up there.

Yeah, sure.

Here.

What's this for?

Show me how to tie a bowline.

- Why? Don't know how? - Of course, I know.

I was tying 'em before you were born.

I'm trying to find out if you know.

You knew Erica was pregnant?

Yeah, and I knew she didn't want to be.

That's why she had the termination.

She booked into a private clinic.

I thought she was broke.

I lent her the money.

Well, she didn't have anyone else to turn to

and she couldn't exactly ask Phillip.

- Why not? - Because Phillip didn't know about the baby.

And before you ask, he was the father.

She wasn't seeing anyone else. She just felt

like the relationship had run its course.

She was only living with him

because she couldn't afford to move out.

So, Bob Fountain was right.

Erica was sick of Phillip and everyone could see it.

Everyone but Phillip.

And what is that supposed to be?

Well, I didn't know how to do a bowline,

so I made you a rabbit instead.

See, there's its ears.

And then this is its fluffy little tail.

You think that's supposed to be funny, do you?

You are putting peoples' lives at risk, your own included!

All right, Bobby. Don't blame me.

Blame the rabbit.

- Oh, go on, get out of it! Go on. Get out of my sight! - Whoa, whoa, whoa.

The boy's only having a bit of fun, Fountain.

You're just too dim to see the joke.

Dim, am I? "Dim"? I'll show you dim!

Let me at him, the stuck-up ponce.

- I'll rip his lungs out!

Young Jakey knows I don't mean anything by it.

Don't you, lad?

Maybe I'm in the wrong job.

Oh, I don't believe that.

Well, this wouldn't have happened on Andy's watch.

No fighting when he was here. No one would have dared.

I bet even Andy had moments of doubt.

We all do.

Even you?

Are you kidding me?

I feel out of my depth at least once a day.

Twice on Mondays.

You seem really confident.

Ah, it's pure bluff. Truly.

See you later, mate.

Were you and Andy close?

What makes you ask that?

Just the way you talk about him.

Hmm.

The skipper was... Was ever such a kind man.

You would've liked him.

You know, the last thing he made me promise

was to give up drinking, and you know what?

When I go home tonight, the first thing

I'm gonna do is pour myself a stiff G&T.

You still call him the "skipper".

Well, yeah.

You're the skipper now. Remember that.

Chrissy! Chrissy!

Try not to move. Are you all right?

Careful, careful, careful, careful.

What just happened?

I think someone tried to kill you.

Stay there.

Davey, it's me.

You need to get to Chrissy's house.

I think someone just tried to take her life.

Okay. Bye.

Count yourself lucky. Had you been going any faster,

it could have taken your head clean off your shoulders.

So you both think it was attempted murder?

Well, at the very least, it was a malicious act

intended to cause actual bodily harm.

One thing we can be sure of

is the culprit knows you and your movements.

I'd advise you to be on your guard.

Keep all your doors and windows locked,

especially after dark, and I'll arrange

for a police unit to swing by, keep an eye on you.

All right. I think we're done.

You've got my number. Call if you need anything.

- Thank you. - Oh!

This, on top of everything else.

Come on, Davey. Surely this is linked

to the death of Erica Ryland.

Oh, really? You can prove that, can you?

- No, but... - Proof, Jane.

I can't do anything without proof.

Mick, are you awake?

No.

Babe, you're shaking like a leaf.

Hello?

Erica?

Oh, it's you. Thank God for that.

You nearly scared the life out of...

Thank you.

Well?

Well, what?

Have you got enough grounds

to launch an initial investigation?

He was killed with a speargun.

The kind that scuba divers use.

Isn't Phillip Spence a scuba diver?

Yeah. I know that.

That's why I've got him down at the station,

along with the rest of the crew,

waiting for me to give them the old Davey Higgins third degree.

- Clint, can you do me a favour? - Yeah.

Can you research the lifeboat crew?

- What, all of them? - No, just the six that were on the boat

when Erica died.

We're missing something. I know we are.

Okay.

So, Gobby... Mind if I call you Gobby?

Where were you last night?

Don't shrug your shoulders, my friend.

I'm gonna need an answer.

Home.

Can you prove you were at home?

My wife can vouch for me.

Right, so your wife was with you?

No. No, she was in Okehampton

- visiting her sister. - Sorry?

- She phoned me, didn't she? - Okay, what time was that then?

This morning.

So, how could she vouch for your movements last night?

'Cause when she phoned this morning,

I told her what I was doing last night.

Let's start again, shall we?

And you were with your mum and dad all night, is that right?

- Yeah, afraid so. - Well, how are they?

- Haven't seen them for ages. - Yeah, they're okay.

Dad's started playing his guitar again.

Ah, that's good. Is he getting any better?

- Well, depends. - Depends? On what?

Whether you like Smoke On The Water.

Honestly, it's all he can play.

Well, that's not a bad thing, I suppose.

Give him my regards, will you? Your mum, too.

- All right, we're done. - Cheers.

Mind how you go.

What?

That's your idea of the third degree, is it?

No, I'm saving that for Phillip Spence,

because if Spence knows that Erica had an abortion

and that Chrissy paid for it,

that puts him right in the frame, doesn't it?

Did you know that Erica was expecting a child?

Your child.

And more to the point, did you know that Erica

decided not to have that child?

Because as a man and a Buddhist, I believe,

that must have been very hard for you.

Look, I can see where this is going,

but I refuse to answer any more questions

until I've seen a solicitor.

Okay.

I researched the lifeboat crew, just as you asked.

- And? - And, I must admit,

I have rarely encountered a less inspiring bunch.

Okay, so, Phillip Spence recently passed an advanced driving test

and is troubled by ingrown toenails.

Wait, it gets better.

In 1987, Gobby Mitchell won a pie-eating contest in Paignton.

And Jake, you already know about.

What's that supposed to mean?

Well, you know, just all the obvious stuff.

You do know that Jake's big sister was Leah Taylor, right?

- Who? - Leah Taylor,

Davey's first murder inquiry.

Sorry, I just assumed it was common knowledge.

Well, I wouldn't have been living here at the time.

So that's why Davey knew Jake's parents.

You think it's important?

Of course I remember the case.

Not the kind of thing you forget, really.

I'd just joined CID and what I wanted,

more than anything else, was to get my teeth stuck

into a real murder inquiry.

Be careful what you wish for, huh?

Did you know Leah's family before?

Yeah, I knew her dad, Colin.

We played rugby together back in the day.

We weren't exactly best mates or anything,

but I liked him. He was a good guy.

He's more of a mate of Mick's actually.

Anyway, when they found Leah,

I had to go 'round there with my ex-governor,

break the news.

That must have been hard.

Yeah. It was terrible.

He came to the door with the little fella.

You mean Jake?

She'd gone shopping.

We didn't have to say anything, really.

He could tell from the look on our faces.

They say coppers don't take their work home with them.

Don't you believe them.

What happened at the trial?

It never went to trial.

- He was deemed unfit to stand. - Oh...

Mentally ill or confused or something.

Thanks.

All right.

Jane?

Yeah?

Do me a favour, will you?

Don't go bothering Jake, not without good reason.

Sure.

One, two, Danny La Rue.

Three, four, Roger Moore.

Mick, I need to talk to you about Leah Taylor.

That's the last thing I wanna talk about.

Because you knew her dad?

Mick, please. This could be important.

Well, if you must know,

I was on the boat that picked up John Barns,

Leah's murderer.

Well, he tried to drown himself, didn't he?

Yeah, we fished him out of the water.

He tried to drown himself after he killed Leah?

No. Two weeks before.

That's what's so hard to take.

Everyone knew Barns was dangerous.

He'd attacked a girl before.

If we hadn't saved his life that night,

Jake's sister would still be alive.

So the night it happened, who...

Who exactly was on the boat?

Me. Andy. Chrissy.

Erica and Bob. Yeah, all of us.

Is there any way Jake or any of his family

could have known this?

Don't reckon so.

All it would say in the log is

"Swimmer in distress rescued off Angel Cove."

That's what they say when it's a suicide attempt.

"In distress." It's a sort of code.

And anyone who would join the lifeboat, they...

They would know this code?

Oh, definitely, yeah.

Thanks, Mick.

Davey, it's me.

Listen, I think I might know what's going on.

Can you call me back?

Hi.

Are you talking to me?

Yeah.

Uh, my mum wants to know

if you'd like to join our quiz team.

Your mum?

All right.

I want you to join our quiz team.

Well, why didn't you say so?

Come on.

Right now, ladies and gentlemen,

if I could just have your attention, please.

Ladies and gentlemen, if I can beg silence, please.

Thank you, thank you, thank you all for turning up.

Right. Now, before we get the quiz underway,

I've just got something to say.

Uh...

As you know tonight was originally organised

as a fundraising to get a memorial

for our beloved Erica Ryland,

but, uh, sadly, as you all know by now,

last night we lost another loyal

and long-serving member of the lifeboat crew,

our old friend Bob Fountain.

So, now I ask you to dig deep tonight

as we help to raise money to put towards

a fitting memorial plaque

honouring both those two lost heroes.

Thank you.

Now, if you'd like to get your brain cells galvanised,

another quick sip on that sherry

and we'll start off with question one of round one.

Who wrote the novel Treasure Island?

Well, I hope you lot know this one.

Who wrote the novel Treasure Island?

I want you...

Gobby?

What is it?

I didn't know about the baby.

Not until it was too late.

Erica had spent the night at her sister's.

At least, that's what she said.

But when she came home, I could see she'd been crying

so I asked her what was wrong and she told me.

I'm sorry.

That must have been very upsetting for you.

I was furious.

Called her every name under the sun.

All my Buddhist training went out of the window.

So when you saw Chrissy and Erica together on the boat,

that's when you saw your opportunity.

Wait, what's Chrissy got to do with it?

- Well, I think you know. - I assure you, I don't.

Chrissy lent Erica the money for the abortion.

Okay.

That does surprise me.

But it doesn't change anything.

Chrissy and me were friends before Erica came along.

We'll remain friends now she's gone.

- Really? - Well, Chrissy must think so.

Why else would she trust me with Bobby?

Sorry, I'm not with you.

Last night, as I was getting ready for bed,

Chrissy brought her dog 'round,

asked me to take care of him

in case something happened to her.

Well that's a bit extreme, isn't it?

Well, that's what I told her, but she was adamant.

Even cried when she said goodbye to him.

I said, "Chrissy, the police are watching your house.

"What could possibly happen?"

Interview suspended at 20:55.

And question ten.

Who played Batman in the 1989 film of the same name?

- Once again, that's who played Batman... - Oh, I know this one.

Keaton. Buster Keaton.

...in the 1989 film of the same name?

What's so funny?

It was Michael Keaton.

Well, yeah, that's what I meant.

Write it down.

Yeah, write it down, Julie.

- You know my name's Judith. - That's what he meant.

You always were mouthy, Jake Taylor,

even when you were little.

All right, Judith.

Right. Well, I hope everyone is happy

'cause we're now having a short intermission.

It's luxury fish-and-chip time. Enjoy.

- Seriously? - Yeah.

- Seriously? - What's wrong with that?

What are you two smirking at?

- Nothing. - Jake's got a crush on Chrissy.

Not any more. Like, when I was a kid.

Oh, yeah? How did you know her?

Come on, Jake. Spill the beans.

"Spill the beans"?

Chrissy used to live next-door-but-one.

She used to, uh, baby-sit for me and my sister.

Mum, what is it?

Have either of you seen Chrissy recently?

No.

Why are you so embarrassing?

It was funny.

- Chrissy! - Nearly there!

Get off him!

Mick. Mick.

Mick.

Say something.

Please say something.

Something.

That was clever.

The way you faked an attempt on your own life

to throw us off the scent.

Well, not clever enough, obviously.

This is about John Barns, isn't it?

The night he tried to kill himself,

I said we should let him drown.

The skipper overruled you, didn't he?

That was Andy all over.

Always doing the right thing, no matter what.

It was only at the end that he admitted,

he admitted he'd been wrong.

He said that rescuing Barns

was the single greatest regret of his life.

But I bet he didn't tell you

to go around murdering your fellow crew members?

He said we were all guilty

and that amounts to the same thing!

- Is he all right? - He's all right.

They went that way.

You waited till the storm was at its worst

and when you saw your opportunity,

you dragged Erica over the side

and tried to drown her, didn't you?

Only she fought back.

That was Erica all over.

Even while I was holding her under, she still kept fighting.

Hit me so hard, I almost blacked out.

Well, now they're gone, it's my turn.

I mean, fair's fair, right?

Chrissy, taking your own life, that's not gonna help anyone.

Chrissy!

No! Get off me! No! No!

No!

No!

So, why were you following her?

I watch people.

And like this lady here,

I may not say much, but I notice things.

She's been down ever since Andy copped it.

I was more scared that she might do herself in.

No. Just everyone else.

Oh, my big man.

I really thought I'd lost you.

No way, my love.

I had her just where I wanted her.

A couple more seconds, I'd have broken both her arms.

7-2-4, please respond.

So, what brought you out here?

I notice things, too.

Yeah?

Have you noticed it's your round?

It's always my round.