All language subtitles for Slay.the.Dragon.2019.1080p.WEB.h264-OPUS

af Afrikaans
ak Akan
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bem Bemba
bn Bengali
bh Bihari
bs Bosnian
br Breton
bg Bulgarian
km Cambodian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
chr Cherokee
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
da Danish
nl Dutch
en English
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
ee Ewe
fo Faroese
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gaa Ga
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek
gn Guarani
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ia Interlingua
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese Download
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
rw Kinyarwanda
rn Kirundi
kg Kongo
ko Korean
kri Krio (Sierra Leone)
ku Kurdish
ckb Kurdish (Soranî)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Laothian
la Latin
lv Latvian
ln Lingala
lt Lithuanian
loz Lozi
lg Luganda
ach Luo
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mfe Mauritian Creole
mo Moldavian
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
sr-ME Montenegrin
ne Nepali
pcm Nigerian Pidgin
nso Northern Sotho
no Norwegian
nn Norwegian (Nynorsk)
oc Occitan
or Oriya
om Oromo
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt-BR Portuguese (Brazil)
pt Portuguese (Portugal)
pa Punjabi
qu Quechua
ro Romanian
rm Romansh
nyn Runyakitara
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
sh Serbo-Croatian
st Sesotho
tn Setswana
crs Seychellois Creole
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhalese
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish
es-419 Spanish (Latin American)
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
tt Tatar
te Telugu
th Thai
ti Tigrinya
to Tonga
lua Tshiluba
tum Tumbuka
tr Turkish
tk Turkmen
tw Twi
ug Uighur
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
wo Wolof
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu

Original subtitles

This is the one great voice we have

in a democracy, the voice of our vote.

I don't want everybody to vote.

Elections are not won by a majority of people,

they never have been, and they are not now.

This idea that government is beholden

to the people is still the most unique idea

in all the long history of man.

Make sure that we get people in office

who are going to be responsive to the needs of the individuals

that they represent.

They are changing the rules.

That's not right, that's not fair,

and that is not just.

The National Guard has been called in

to aid in the water crisis in Flint, Michigan,

a city with a water supply contaminated with lead.

Thousands of residents exposed

to toxic levels of rust,

iron, and lead want to know who is to blame.

Volunteers from across the state and country

have trucked in water on U‐Haul trucks

because of the city's contaminated drinking water.

The entire population,

roughly 100,000 was potentially exposed to lead.

The Flint water crisis really starts

with the 2010 elections.

In those elections, Republicans gained

total control of the state government

in Michigan.

One of the things that they did was they passed

what they called an emergency manager law.

This law allowed the state government

to effectively override local government

and install their own executive

to do practically whatever they wanted

in terms of public policy.

Governor Snyder signed a new law

giving financial managers broader powers

to fix the finances

of communities and school districts.

Seven emergency financial managers

are in place including in cities like Detroit,

Flint, and Pontiac.

These emergency managers were described

as virtual dictators over their communities.

They could impose spending cuts,

they could re‐bargain contracts.

They took control to keep control.

If that meant taking democracy away,

they decided that that would be the route they would take.

We have to send the message

that we will not tolerate emergency dictators in the land.

There was widespread grassroots opposition

because it was so extreme.

We fought it, we fought it in protest,

we fought it using our bodies.

Shame, shame, shame, shame.

We fought it at the ballot box.

In November 2012, by a pretty significant margin,

voters rejected this extreme, emergency manager law.

We were excited because grassroots won,

everyday people won, and said,

"We don't want emergency management."

And then in the midnight hour, in a lame duck session,

the legislature found this loophole,

changed some words,

changed some commas, and created a new law,

and then after they changed it,

made sure that it could never be repealed again.

One of the first things that Republicans did

when they took over the legislature

was they drew these aggressive legislative districts

that locked in Republican majorities.

The legislature never would have passed

the Emergency Manager Act in Michigan if it had not been

for gerrymandering.

The people did not want this, they went to the ballot box

and they made that clear in a referendum.

But the legislature knew

they were no longer accountable to the people.

They knew that these district lines

completely insulated them.

Three, two, one.

Yeah!

Here's to Flint!

‐ Here's to Flint! ‐ Here, here!

My office started getting phone calls.

"This water is horrible, it comes out of the tap brown."

I'll never forget, one lady came up to me in a meeting

and said, "Reverend, my dog won't drink this water."

This crisis began over a year ago, silently,

when the city switched from a Detroit water system,

to the Flint River.

The Flint River has a high salt content,

so it corroded the pipes that it flowed through,

and lead from those pipes leached into the system.

It happened because elected officials

had the ability to do whatever they wanted to do.

"If I don't ever have to worry about being unelected,

I don't care about your water.

Why? Because I don't have to be accountable to you."

Faith in government began to wane, faith in democracy,

faith in the whole process began to wane.

I think Flint woke people up.

Just sitting and watching, like, these politicians

just so blatantly disregard the will of the people.

You have these officials who feel untouchable,

who feel like they can't get unelected

because they've designed

and rigged a system to make it that way.

I just reached a point where it was like, why aren't we‐‐

how can we do something about this, like, how?

I wanted to have some way to come together

and start fixing this.

And stop accepting that things are corrupt.

In this age of the internet, you're so connected to, like,

these great examples of people who start off on something,

and it does work sometimes.

And so I think I thought, you know,

I'm going to throw it out into the world.

From the moment I posted it, I saw so many people

who were just upset with the current way politics

had been happening.

I saw that there was a pent‐up energy.

I was like, "I'm not alone."

So I just thought I would, yeah, try.

Where you draw the lines

makes all the difference.

A mapmaker knows as they draw a line

how it's going to influence an election precisely.

The reason that you gerrymander

is to make it harder

for your opponents' vote to count.

And there are a few different ways you do that.

You can pack your opponent,

so you can put your opponent's supporters

into as few districts as possible,

so they'll win some seats, but you'll win

all the other seats.

Then there is also cracking, that's the other way

gerrymandering works,

where you spread your opponents out.

So, fine, you'll give your opponents 20 percent

of the vote in a bunch of districts,

but they're never going to win those districts.

The effects of packing and cracking

are to create seats that are safe.

The winner is pre‐decided,

just by the way that the districts are drawn.

It really represents legislators picking voters,

rather than voters picking legislators,

and I think most people find that offensive.

The system is no longer working,

the political system no longer works

for the average person,

and in Michigan, it no longer works for Michiganders.

So for today, we're going to do a campaign highlight,

kind of give everybody an update of what's happened

over the last month.

We wanted to do something about this issue,

but to pretend that we knew at all what we were doing

would be a complete lie.

I'm John Hanieski, I'm heading up

the finance committee.

I got pulled out a few weeks ago,

I know Katie from college, we sat next to each other

in public policy class.

And then I'm also the state field director,

so I have that group also which consists of...

There had been some news pieces saying

that there was not interest from our elected officials

in changing this.

The proposal at a glance is it's going

to be a citizen's commission.

And so it just felt like an independent

citizen‐driven commission that would draw the lines

in a fair and transparent way was the way to go.

You prescribe for fixing this, this citizens' commission.

Four would be Democrats, four would be Republicans,

five would be Independents.

Yeah, so right now the process happens completely

behind closed doors and is the most partisan thing

that could happen.

You have one party

with lobbyists locking themselves behind,

you know, that door.

Our process takes all of that and throws it out

into the open.

Thank you guys so much for coming out on a Saturday.

Because I don't do politics for a job,

it's not a huge part of my life.

When we started talking to other groups, you know,

they were like well, nobody in your group has, you know,

directly ran a ballot initiative, so...

I mean are you going out

and talking to groups, trying to get

some big organizations who might have some

financial resources behind them?

We're looking to coalition build.

It... Redistricting is an issue that affects

so many different things.

So who do you have on board?

No organizations formally yet,

but we're working with plenty.

You're trying to coalition build,

who is in your coalition?

I think they didn't know what to do with us.

So this is part of the 14th Congressional District,

so why was it created this way?

But we started doing these town halls.

Farmington has

a good number of Republicans in it,

so you pull Pontiac out

and you put it in the next district over

because there it contributes to majorities

for the other side.

And we saw, you know, a renewed sense of urgency

from the people of Michigan.

We started from a Facebook post in social media,

and quickly turned into a thousand different strangers

from across the state that have come together

to go through the process, learning as we go.

Seeing that all those in favor of the motion

‐ signify by saying aye. ‐ Aye.

All those opposed? The motion carries.

Yes, we have something very important for you to do.

I'm going to cry.

I am shaking, thank you.

Our whole campaign has been about the people,

about representing accurately the voices of the people

and making sure that what we actually want as change,

doesn't get manipulated from anybody,

and I feel so confident that we have done that

and will continue to do that.

So thanks and let's go gather petitions.

Yeah!

Thanks, Joe.

Gerrymandering takes its name

from a man named Elbridge Gerry,

the Governor of Massachusetts in 1812

who agrees to maps that draw up wild districts.

A political cartoonist takes one look at this

and thinks it looks like a salamander,

so it becomes known

as gerrymandering.

Quick sidenote, you are not wrong to notice

that the "gerry" in gerrymander

refers to a guy whose name was actually pronounced Gary

because literally everything

about gerrymandering is stupid and wrong.

All the way through the mid to latter part

of the 20th Century,

gerrymandering, though it was pervasive...

State legislatures all over America are at it again.

It was never used to consolidate

and make permanent

the power of any one political party.

Gerrymandering continues to be

an effective weapon to maintain the status quo.

It was often about incumbent protection

and both sides would do it.

Democrats did a terrific job of gerrymandering

California in the 1980s.

There was a congressman named Phillip Burton who used to say

that the district lines that he drew there

were his contribution to modern art.

The fact is gerrymandering

has become a national scandal.

The Democratic controlled state legislatures

have so rigged the electoral process

that the will of the people cannot be heard.

Ladies and gentlemen,

the next first family of the United States of America.

November 2008, we have the historic election

of our first African American president.

You see a Democratic super majority

in the U. S. Senate,

and it returns a Democratic majority

to the U. S. House.

The defeat is total, Republican leaders

just can't spin it any longer.

Barack Obama promised to change

the red states blue and he did.

It is remarkable.

If you watch the news coverage of that night,

folks were talking as if the Republican party was dead

for a generation, not simply because of this election,

but because of the way American demographics

are changing.

I think Republicans saw the writing on the wall which is

there are fewer and fewer Republicans born every day,

and more and more Democrats every day.

They're running out of room.

There's no question now Republicans have got

a lot of work to do.

Something is wrong with the Republican party.

The damage is very severe.

Our party is eroding by the day.

There is always that moment, right?

Whenever there is a big loss for a party,

there's this moment of panic.

I think those of us who have been around a little bit

kind of can see past the panic, but still have the fundamental

What are we going to do?

How do we get back?

And I think that, you know, part of that

turned out to be our REDMAP project.

Chris Jankowski is one of the smartest minds

in the Republican party.

He understands that as important as 2008 was,

2010 had the opportunity to be a much more

important election.

2010 is a zero year, elections ending in zero

are more consequential

because it's a census year and we redistrict

every state legislative seat and congressional seat

following the census.

The census provides an estimate of how many people

are in every state, and every county,

and every block.

As per the constitution, in order to keep up

with population shifts, they build new state

and congressional districts.

In 80 percent of all states,

it's the state legislatures that play the key role

in redistricting.

If you win state legislatures in 2010,

you get to draw the new maps that control all the elections

over the next decade, and they knew that.

Jankowski goes to Republican donors

and says I can deliver two things for you.

I can deliver conservative control of congress,

perhaps for a decade,

but I can also promise Republican control

the state legislatures

and we can move a conservative agenda

through the states as well.

It was a very easy sell to those

who were involved in state elections.

What we did was we took the cost

of swing congressional seats over 10 years, five elections,

and we pegged that at over 100 million per election.

We said okay for this price we can get control

of those state legislatures and re‐draw the maps.

We projected it would be quite a cost‐efficient endeavor.

25, 30 million dollars rather than

almost half a billion.

If you look at the donors to this project you see

the big money interests that help fund the Republican party

and conservative politics in the country.

Walmart.

Altria which is big tobacco.

The Chamber of Commerce.

Establishment corporate interests,

like the Koch brothers.

2010 already was setting up to be a big year

for the Republicans, but what they wanted to do

was win the right seats.

The key seats that would allow them to have an influence

on the redistricting process.

It was Wisconsin, Ohio, Pennsylvania,

North Carolina, Colorado.

You know Michigan, I had looked at their map,

looked at their research, and their plan,

and I said, "Okay, we're in for a million,"

and they said, "Really?"

And I said, "Yep, so I want you to spread this map.

Act like you've got another million."

They spent tons and tons of money in races

where people had never even seen TV ads before.

Senator Reynolds supports

Obama's health care takeover.

A billion‐dollar tax increase to fund

more government spending.

Unemployment has almost doubled.

We looked and said okay,

looks like crime is an issue here.

This incumbent has bad crime votes,

so we're going to educate them on that.

You know this is a bad budget vote,

this is a bad school vote.

We went wherever the data suggested we should go.

We had no idea what was about to hit us.

Nobody had ever seen anything like it.

In the last weeks of that campaign,

mailers from my opponent were arriving every day.

Incumbent senator Margaret Dickson,

who does she really care about?

Right at the end there was a campaign ad

against me that portrayed me apparently as a prostitute.

What does Margaret Dickson

really care about?

I didn't really sense it in North Carolina

until the very end, and I saw it in my race,

and I saw it when I talked to colleagues,

they were having the same experience.

We all had kind of this "ah‐ha" moment.

And it was true, it wasn't just North Carolina,

it was true across the country.

It's shaping up as a big Republican night.

It is being called a GOP sweep

and a Tea Party tidal wave.

We knew it was going to be a good night.

The Friday before that, I went out on a limb and predicted

we would pick up at least 10 legislative chambers

and possibly higher.

And right after I got off the phone with that reporter

I thought, "Ooph, that seems, yeah, I believe it,

I see it in the data, but it just seems really amazing."

But then as the night unfolded we took everything

we intended to take.

North Carolina House and Senate flip

to the Republicans for the first time since 1870.

The Indiana House has flipped,

the Pennsylvania House has flipped,

Michigan House has flipped,

the Ohio House has flipped, the Iowa House has flipped.

A tsunami just hit the heartland.

This was actually something that wasn't covered

a whole lot at the time.

A dozen or so states would turn into Republican hands

and would now have control over drawing all

of the district boundaries.

They did this for 30 million dollars.

It's the biggest bargain and perhaps the biggest heist

in modern American political history.

For us, it was mission accomplished.

And then the second part of the plan was what happened

with redrawing the lines.

We sent out a letter to all of the new leaders

and said, "If you need resources,

we would be happy to provide those for you."

They say, "If you need mapping help,

if you need legal help, you let us know,

we've got the money for you.

We have the experts, we have the money, let us help."

Tom Hofeller is kind of a superstar

in gerrymandering.

It's my job to advise Republican stakeholders

in the redistricting question on how they can maneuver

through these thickets.

He goes around and works

for Republican legislators in multiple states

and will draw their maps.

There is something almost like

an old country doctor about Hofeller.

He would pack his old kit bag, you know, with his laptop,

kiss his wife in Alexandria, Virginia goodbye,

and pet his dog.

And then set off into a country

that was about to be redrawn by him.

Redistricting used to be done by legislators

or their legislative staff,

so it was always a partisan project,

but at least people lived in the state,

and they knew the people, and they knew the politics.

These people out of Washington,

all they know is where the airport is

when they come down and deliver the plans.

And they also know how to use sophisticated software

to maximize political results.

Hofeller has got a piece of software

and he downloads a bunch of political data into that

and he spits out the most partisan map

that he thinks the courts will allow.

Gerrymandering from 1788 through 2000

is in its minor leagues.

In 2010, gerrymandering jumps straight

into its steroids era.

Big data and big technology emerge in such a way

that you can carve

more precise gerrymanders than ever.

They used census data, educational levels,

income levels.

Voters' partisan history,

their race and their gender, and their age,

those factors tell you so much about a voter

that you can predict how they're going to vote

in a few years with a strong degree of confidence.

They could go down the street and, "These people

are Republicans, we're going to put them in this district,

these people are Democrats,

we're going to put them over here."

There was no transparency at all

because they were using private computers,

they were being drawn off site

by hired Republican consultants.

Picture a black box.

Whatever happens inside that black box, you can't see.

They just come out and they say here is the map.

It was a flawlessly functioning map.

Every single district hit what you might call

the sweet spot, safe enough for Republicans

to consistently win it,

but it didn't waste excess votes,

they could have spread around to other districts.

On the other hand,

the few Democratic districts they drew

were designed to quarantine as many Democratic voters

as possible.

So, here is what they do.

They get data on where all the African Americans live

and then they just draw lines around it

so the really crazy looking maps,

the really squiggly looking ones,

the reason they're squiggly is because they're picking up

all the African American communities

all throughout the state.

Take a look at North Carolina's congressional map.

Look at District 12, it's so weirdly shaped

they can't even fit the 12 in it.

Looks like a Rorschach test, what do you see in this shape?

I don't know, it's either a dragon or 300 years

of institutional racism.

Republicans have cynically

put more and more minorities into what's called

the majority minority district.

So the district goes 50 percent minority,

to 60 percent minority, to 70 percent minority,

and the reason they're doing this is so that minorities

will have less impact in all of the other districts.

And that was exactly the strategy that Tom Hofeller

used in North Carolina.

Funneling as many black voters as possible

into the 1st and 12th Congressional Districts,

while bleaching the surrounding areas.

The truth is

the Republicans targeted African Americans,

but the motivation wasn't,

"We want to hurt African‐Americans,"

it was "We want to hurt Democrats."

One of Hofeller's crowning achievements

is what he did in the western part

of North Carolina,

in particular, the district that was occupied at the time

by a moderate Democrat, Heath Shuler.

Heath Shuler was a former

University of Tennessee quarterback.

He was kind of a moderate to conservative Democrat.

You didn't send me up there

to blindly follow any one party,

you sent me up there to do what's right

for our mountain families.

Loved guns, is anti‐abortion,

he was the very picture of a good old boy.

And so you can't really run against this guy

like he's a San Francisco Democrat.

So they had to change the guy's district.

The most Democratic area of his district was Asheville,

which is this little Haight‐Ashbury

in the middle of the mountains.

Hofeller just essentially carved Asheville

out of that map and moved it to another area,

an area that was so Republican that it could absorb Asheville.

Suddenly that part of Buncombe County

where Asheville was a part

was suddenly quite a conservative district.

Heath Shuler, recognizing the writing on the wall,

retires from politics altogether.

Suddenly now it's there for the taking by Republicans

and the guy who wins it is a guy named Mark Meadows.

2012 is the time

that we're going to send Mr. Obama home

to Kenya or wherever it is, we're going to do it.

Meadows is now

the chairman of the Freedom Caucus

which is the hardline group in the House of Representatives

that opposes anything that is not orthodox,

you know, conservatism.

Replacement of people like Shuler

with people like Meadows

is actually one of the reasons why

the country, as a whole, has become so hyper‐partisan.

Candidates in the middle, both moderate Republicans

and conservative Democrats, they've been the key targets.

It moves our political system towards polarization.

When a member of congress need only fear

a primary challenge,

when they are so safe in their seat

that they cannot actually lose an election,

all they care about is guarding their base.

So working across the aisle, compromise,

trying to find common ground, all of the things

we used to think of as being central

to the art of politics

actually become the only things that can cost them their seat.

These are all shrink‐wrapped in packages of a hundred

and so are the petitions,

so I'm just going to make sure that you have 19.

‐ These look great. ‐ Yeah, they do.

Then it's only for people who signed,

people who don't sign don't get anything.

Yeah, they don't.

So, that's where we're headed.

Are you guys registered to vote in Michigan?

Excuse me, ma'am, are you a registered voter

here in Michigan?

Have you had a chance to sign the petition

to end gerrymandering in Michigan?

To end what?

Would you be interested in signing

a petition against gerrymandering?

Against what's that?

Gerrymandering.

In Michigan it is almost impossible

for a petition drive to gather enough signatures

without using paid professional petition circulators.

You're not paying for names.

‐ Correct. ‐ And you don't intend to?

Correct, yeah.

Right now, we're at two weeks in officially today,

we have 50,000 signatures

that have been gathered a hundred percent

by volunteers from across the state.

We're working with Voters Not Politicians

for the anti‐gerrymandering drive.

Because right now politicians are manipulating

the system, so then they don't listen to voters.

Hi, this is Katie, I'm doing a super,

super late weekly update.

I just wanted to say thank you to every single person

who decided to start gathering signatures.

So I would start with today's date.

The anti‐fracking movement had a lot of energy

and they failed to get the signatures needed

to get on the ballot.

‐ Do you know about the topic? ‐ Oh, yeah.

You're all set, okay, wonderful.

I mean, the only group ever

to manage getting a petition on the ballot

using only volunteers was Right to Life.

If anyone else is interested in signing.

I'm not sure if anyone has been paying attention

at all to our ticker,

but we are at 196,000 signatures,

which is absolutely amazing.

They're not only on pace to get the 400,000

that they want, but they, it looks like they're going

to do it before their deadline which is really amazing.

I tell you these folks are everywhere.

I mean I can't go to a public event

without seeing them.

Oh my gosh, remember right after we got approval

where they called all our people old ladies

who aren't going to get anything done?

They're like, their minds are blown, it's awesome.

Aww, goodbye, hair.

Ah, I wish I was better at this.

It's pretty bad.

Not as much as I do.

Today we turn in our signatures

to the Secretary of State.

Who would have known that a little over a year ago

we would be here today turning them in two months early

with all volunteers?

In under 40 days

we got all 83 counties represented

and that is only possible

because all of you guys decided to say,

"Heck yeah I'm going to join onto this thing."

Here is where we're loading up the petitions.

I'm not sure if everybody can see this,

but there are literally rows and rows of boxes.

I remember the first time I saw this group get together

and talk about it and, you know,

I'm a veteran political reporter,

I'll have you know.

And I looked at these people and I was like, "No way."

No way.

I know what a winning operation looks like

and this isn't it.

They have turned every political operative's

predictions on their head.

They have really blown the box up

and there is no more box, they have reinvented everything.

Our proposal will take redistricting out of the hands

of politicians and lobbyists

who do their work behind closed doors

and give it to citizens who will do it in the public.

What we've seen in other states who have done

redistricting efforts similar to ours

is you see higher voter turnout.

There's about 13 different states

that have independent commissions.

Our U‐Haul.

Yeah, yeah, yeah. There it is, a really full truck.

Thousands of people worked on this campaign.

If we can get this passed in 2018,

there will be thousands of people who affected law

that will affect every election in Michigan.

It was for and by the people and I know that's like

kind of hokey, and kind of like, you know,

really Founding Fathers‐y, but like the fact

that we would actually be able to do that

and prove that democracy is still out there,

that's amazing.

No matter what you do for this campaign,

entering the check numbers, like it all is only possible

because of each of you.

And I know at least on my end, that's the best part

about this campaign is seeing that really the political power

is inherent in the people, so yeah!

The one thing that we are sure of

is that legislators will fight like crazy

to retain this power they have.

I think there will be a vicious fight by the people

who are in power to preserve that power.

They're going to want to try to find some way

to litigate us, to keep us off from the ballot.

We are not going to outspend our opposition.

We might get lucky and get outspent four to one.

We're probably going to get outspent 10 to 20 to one.

The opposition is going to try to bleed us dry financially.

And then they're going to go for the PR.

They're going to be saying that we are complex,

that we are complicated, and that we're confusing.

We cannot make our policy sound even a little bit...

complex, confusing at all.

Like, we have to make sure

it's a very simple and direct approach,

and that the language that we use

to describe the policy reflects that.

They're absolutely worried about us.

They know and we know

that once this gets on the ballot,

it almost always passes.

The election of 2010 had been the Tea Party wave

and the redistricting that followed

the election of 2010

would keep those legislators in their seats.

In a normal political cycle, we would expect a wave

to come in and a wave to recede,

and a wave to come in and a wave to recede.

We see this over and over again.

The election of 2010 was a giant wave

and the Republican Party

put up an enormous sea wall in order to stop

that wave from receding.

And when that happened, we have seen extreme policy

as a result.

Wisconsin is basically an evenly divided state.

Half of the state is Republican

and half the state is Democratic.

In 2010, Project REDMAP and the Republicans

invested a large amount

of very strategically targeted money.

They took the State Assembly and the State Senate

and they won the governorship.

No matter where you live,

no matter what your background,

no matter who you voted for,

we all live in Wisconsin together,

and we're going to move this state forward together.

Scott Walker just swept in

with the rest of the Republicans.

I mean the slate went from everything Democratic,

to everything Republican, everything.

REDMAP, for us, was only the beginning.

State governments, like Wisconsin,

were little laboratories of democracy.

Now that we got control of them,

we wanted to do something with it.

‐ Good morning. ‐ Good morning.

I see everyone's here to see my prediction for

the Ohio State/Wisconsin game on Saturday.

In this bill will be a change in terms of state employees

not being required to be a part of their union.

Act 10 would essentially do away

with collective bargaining for public sector employees.

That was something that had been a long tradition

in Wisconsin, had been a cherished part of the state.

That was a total surprise.

This is a significant change,

this is obviously a very bold and aggressive change.

The Republicans, they understood,

Scott Walker understood that public sector unions,

the teachers, the municipal workers,

the folks that pick up your garbage,

they tend to vote Democratic and they use their unions

as a means of promoting their political views.

Thanks very much for your time.

So he wanted to destroy that.

I knew what this would mean.

It came up in caucus and I think my exact words were,

"Are you crazy?"

People kill each other's dogs over this kind of stuff.

When Act 10 was introduced, the entire state

just rose up in anger.

We are proud to stand with you,

Wisconsin backers.

First there was 10,000, then there was 20,000,

then there were 30,000, and this thing just sparked.

Hey, hey, ho, ho, Scott Walker has got to go.

Tens of thousands of people in the capitol.

Solidarity forever.

As many as 100,00 on the capitol ground some days

and this thing is sustained for days, and days,

and weeks, and weeks.

It's just hard to express how angry people were.

You know this is a place like Minnesota,

people are basically nice, and suddenly we had

this incredible, polarized atmosphere.

‐ We are the union! ‐ We are the union!

The mighty, mighty union.

We were a state that had a strong tradition

of trade unions.

People thought, "What in the world is he trying to do?"

Hi, this is Scott Walker.

Scott, David Koch, how are you?

Hey, David, I'm good, and yourself?

I'm very well.

Little disheartened by the situation there,

but what's the latest?

We're actually hanging pretty tough.

You know amazingly there is a much smaller group

of protesters, almost all of whom

are in from other states today.

5,000 to 6,000 state workers

will get at‐risk notices for layoffs.

We might ratchet that up a little bit, you know.

Beautiful, beautiful,

got to crush that union.

Just as there were all these protesters begging

this governor to listen to them,

the person who he was willing to listen to

and so eager to please

was an out‐of‐state billionaire.

He talked about coordinating with other governors,

which made it very clear that this is a national plan.

I talk to Kasich every day,

you know, John has got to stand firm in Ohio.

I think we can do the same thing with Rick Scott in Florida.

I think Snyder if he got a little more support,

probably could do that in Michigan.

This was a test run to see if they could

run over public employee unions nationwide.

There's a lot of us new governors who got elected

to do something big.

You're the first domino.

Yep, this is our moment.

Republicans had no fear of losing power

because they could draw districts

to insulate themselves from public opinion.

The leadership of the Republican Party

in both the House and the Senate in Wisconsin

are able to tell their members, "It's okay to vote for this.

It might not be popular, stay strong,

we are drawing you a seat you cannot lose."

While the streets were full of people demonstrating,

hundreds of thousands of people,

what we didn't know was that Scott Walker

and the legislature took the computers

that they were going to use to redistrict

out of the capitol building, and they moved them

across the street to a Republican law firm

by the name of Michael Best and Friedrich.

And in the very back of that law firm they set up

a secret mapping room.

It's an incredibly powerful and jarring juxtaposition.

You have these two things playing out,

there's all these people protesting

the anti‐union legislation.

Right across the street, key aides to the legislature

are writing, in secret,

the redistricting maps that will determine

Republicans' power for the next decade.

Knowing that they had both houses

of the legislature,

they did everything they could to hide

their map drawing process not only from the public,

but even from most Republicans.

Nobody could even come into the room

unless you signed a secrecy agreement.

And if you'd signed that secrecy agreement

and you managed to get into the room,

which you could only do if you were a Republican,

you were only allowed to see your own map.

So you have before you the various maps

and we have some other members of the legislation here

and we're open for questions.

When we first see the maps,

it's obvious that there's some significant bias in them.

Some individual legislators had been drawn

competing districts

that were going to be much tougher for them to win in.

There were these districts that were drawn

to pull Democratic voters into suburban districts

so there would be fewer Democratic districts.

And there were clearly some districts that were going

to be less competitive.

It was very well calculated.

They knew exactly what they were doing.

We're closing in

on the first results in the battle for the White House.

When the results were known on election night

and we had been killed in the election,

somebody said, "Well, don't worry, all is not lost,

the Republicans won 60 seats in the Assembly."

I said to myself

and I said audibly to the people I was with,

"Well, that can't be right,

there's a mistake here somewhere."

And it was at that point I began to realize

that things had changed.

You have several states in 2012

where Democratic candidates

actually won more votes statewide

than Republicans did, but Republicans would win

lopsided majorities.

You had Pennsylvania where Democrats won more votes

and Republicans walked away

with a thirteen to five advantage.

Michigan where Democrats won more votes

and Republicans had a nine to five advantage.

North Carolina.

Wisconsin.

All of these states at either the congressional

or legislative level saw Democratic candidates

win more votes statewide but Republicans

win a majority of seats.

Republicans could not be beaten

and they were not beaten.

Even when their side got many fewer votes.

And what you immediately see

in all of these gerrymandered states

is the rapid movement of a very conservative agenda

through state legislatures.

A new bill being considered in Wisconsin

would allow local school districts

to make sex education

and teaching contraception optional.

Republicans here called a special session

to pass House Bill 2, more commonly known

as the "Bathroom Bill".

A recent move by the legislature removes one route

to recourse in wage disputes.

It started the moment the General Assembly

went into session.

We're on the 10th order of business,

second reading of amendments and senate bill.

A legislative blitzkrieg would be

the way I would describe it.

There was anti‐regulation,

anti‐environment.

The clerk will close the role,

Assembly Amendment 3 is adopted.

Defund public schools.

Destabling and going after Planned Parenthood.

Concealed carry was another issue

that they fought for a long time.

Democratic governor would veto it,

they were able to put that through.

Another gun rights bill

is on the table to protect drivers

who carry their firearms inside their vehicles

and go to work.

If you wonder,

"Why do we see representatives that are doing things

that their constituents don't want?"

"Why are laws being passed that don't seem to reflect

the wishes of the public?"

Gerrymandering is a big part of the explanation.

One legislator stood on the floor and said,

"We are now in power,

and we're going to exercise that power,

and you all can sit back and forget about it."

Bring back, bring back,

oh, bring back Wisconsin to me.

People began wondering,

"Where are all of these laws coming from?"

The fact that Wisconsin, Michigan, North Carolina,

Florida, Texas, Pennsylvania, they're all passing

virtually identical pieces of legislation,

that's not a coincidence, someone is behind this.

ALEC stands for

the American Legislative Exchange Council

and the goal of ALEC is to push out policies

to maximize corporate profits at the state level.

This has been a goal of the right for decades.

This is a shadow arm of the Republican party.

You have corporations literally writing bills

in conjunction with state legislators

and then state legislators

introducing those bills to become law.

How many of our Christians have what I call

the goo‐goo syndrome?

Good government, they want everybody to vote.

I don't want everybody to vote.

Elections are not won by a majority of people,

they never have been

from the beginning of our country,

and they are not now.

As a matter of fact, our leverage in the elections

quite candidly goes up

as the voting populace goes down.

A developing story, a voter ID bill in Wisconsin

is moving on to the full assembly.

The measure would require voters to show

their ID's at the polls.

I first became aware of ALEC after the 2010 election

when we began to see all of these new voter ID laws.

And it was clear that these voter ID laws

had been written by ALEC after the 2008 election,

because we saw the model bill, we saw the bill

that had ALEC's name on it.

Republicans say their intent

is to eliminate voter fraud

by requiring a photo ID from anyone

who votes in Wisconsin.

They have advanced these model bills

on voter identification

by creating this lie that somehow

people are impersonating people at the polls.

Republicans say this will cut down

on documented election fraud in the state.

It's only when you begin to understand

that in fact voter fraud is an incredibly small problem

in American elections.

Then you begin to realize that all of these laws

were passed for an entirely different reason.

It had nothing to do with voter fraud,

it was all about trying to prevent

Democratic‐leaning voters

from being able to cast a ballot.

Instead of trying to reach out to minority voters,

they said, "No, now that we've gerrymandered the districts,

we're going to go after

and suppress those voting rights."

Those bills would have never been passed

but for the gerrymandering that took place.

In the '90s, North Carolina was actually

really progressive when it came to voting rights.

I'm a North Carolinian and lots of my family

were the people that gained the ability to vote.

They liked being able to register at license offices,

they liked early voting.

They loved what's known as Souls to the Polls,

which is early voting on Sunday.

I've talked to people who had that sense of joy,

who've had, for the first time in their lives,

a sense of belongingness.

The process opened up, more people were voting,

and percentagewise,

African American registration levels

became more at parity with whites.

And we turn to a strict new voter ID law

in North Carolina,

which is putting a spotlight on the broader national fight

over when and where people can cast ballots.

What the new North Carolina voting law did

was it rolled back almost every single one

of those new provisions that had been created

to add more black people to the electorate.

It didn't just include strict voter ID,

but it cut early voting,

it eliminated same‐day voter registration,

it eliminated out‐of‐precinct voting,

it even eliminated Citizens Awareness Month

which the state of North Carolina

ran to encourage people to register to vote.

It was all about

suppressing African American vote

in order to give Republicans an extra one to three percent

which is the margin of victory

in all of our competitive races.

So even though gerrymandering has reduced

the number of competitive races to only about 10 percent,

they wanted to reduce it even more.

Ain't going to let no extremists turn me around,

turn me around, turn me around.

I've interviewed people who say now

they have lost their pride,

they've lost that sense of belonging.

And that's a lot deeper than just the nuts and bolts

of a partisan advantage.

There was a client that I represented,

she was born at home with a midwife,

didn't have a birth certificate, couldn't get an ID.

She went to vote in person and she was turned away.

It's humiliating when you go and say, "I'm a citizen,

I have the right to vote, I would like to vote,"

and everyone else around you is voting,

and they turn you away and say, "No you can't vote."

It is humiliating.

Republicans see their time running out

when it comes to the demographics.

They see that the country is getting less white,

more educated, and overall just more diverse.

What they have come up with

is a plan to try and stem that tide.

It starts with gerrymandering, it starts with drawing lines

that give them the ability to win all of these districts.

The second part of this process is voter suppression tactics

designed to make it harder for Democrats

and minorities to exercise the right to vote.

It's not a bunch of disparate parts,

it's not like one voter suppression law here,

one gerrymandering law here, this is part of a concerted

this is part of a concerted national strategy

by the Republican party

that's being undertaken all across the country

including in so many important swing states.

We battled to get voter ID on the ballot

for the November '16 election.

How many of your listeners really honestly are sure

that President Trump was going to win Wisconsin

if we didn't have voter ID

to keep Wisconsin's elections clean and honest?

I absolutely think you can draw a line

line between he voter suppression efforts

and the gerrymandering efforts and election results.

We are seeing efforts

to undermine the very core values

of American democracy.

Nothing is more fundamental in America

than having the right to vote,

and having the right to representation,

and those two core values have been undermined

by this new assault on democracy.

‐ Hello. ‐ Hello, great to see you.

You too, how are you?

It looks good, right?

Hi, Bill.

Good to see you, how are you?

‐ Hello. ‐ Hi!

Congratulations,

I've been watching your campaign.

‐ Thank you. ‐ That's very exciting.

Hey, Mary Lynne, good to see you.

I just want to be sure

that everybody gets to know Don Winter,

who hasn't been to one of these meetings before.

These are all your fellow planners, Don.

Emily Bunting, Janet Mitchell, that's a lawyer.

Well one question I had, too, about this election,

about the Supreme Court election‐‐

I've never met an epidemiologist that didn't get nailed!

Hello.

Hey, how are you? Good to see you.

That's Ruth, that's Nick, Annabelle,

you know the names, I'm sure. Peter Earle.

We did meet through our involvement in this field.

Our relationship has sort of fueled the lawsuit,

but then at the same time, the lawsuit,

it's sort of a mutually reinforcing circle.

Maybe coming from abroad, I have less

of a sense of the status quo.

So when I see something, like the fact that legislators

are allowed to draw their own district lines,

I'm more easily able to say, "Well why?"

Like that doesn't make any sense.

Can we sit out there so we can look at maps?

I brought all the maps on the wall.

I thought it might be useful to hear from all of you

about your districts

to understand what's wrong with your districts as they are.

So, maybe would all of you feel comfortable,

we have the map at the moment, you're welcome to come up

point and tell me what you like,

and what you don't like, and what you would prefer.

We were taken out of our district

and attached to a strongly Republican district.

I really feel that our vote is a wash.

No matter what I do or what we do as Democrats,

we can't get a representative elected.

We're sort of in exile down in Grant County

and I have these two secure Republicans

who do not bother with me.

This is the district now, and you can look,

like it goes up here a little bit.

You can look at how crazy it is with all these different lines,

but what's interesting, you'll notice,

here's the city of Portage, it goes around the city lines,

the city of Portage.

That's a Democratic‐‐ Excludes it.

It goes right around the city limits.

Here is the city of Compass, this is a Democratic city,

it goes right around the city lines

and keeps it out.

So they took the four largest municipalities

and went right around the city lines.

It's a very good example of gerrymandering.

The Whitford plaintiffs realized

there was no legislative fix to gerrymandering.

Democrats were never going to be able to win enough seats

under the gerrymandered maps to have any sort of impact,

so they had to attack this in the courts,

and they had to attack it in an innovative way.

If you are on the side that you say

gerrymandering isn't unconstitutional...

But no federal court had ever outlawed

partisan gerrymandering before.

And to succeed,

the Whitford plaintiffs had to show

that Republicans deliberately intended

to deprive Democrats of representation.

We're trying to figure out,

how are we going to get a case before the court

that could once and for all resolve this problem?

And we saw an avenue here.

We immediately demanded that Republicans

in The Wisconsin state legislature

give us all of the documents from the secret mapping room

related to the redistricting process.

All the emails, all the iterations of the maps,

and they responded to us that, "No, you don't get

this information. This information is privileged."

The court said, "No, you have to give them these documents.

You're required to produce this information,

this is not something you can hide from the public."

We knew that they weren't being

completely forthcoming in all of the information

they were providing to us.

There were some spreadsheets that were created

by the mapmakers,

but we noticed that for some reason,

we didn't have any spreadsheets in April, or in May,

or I think June, also, of 2011.

And so we hired a computer forensic expert

to look through the hard drives to see

if he could come up with any spreadsheets

from that time frame where they were missing.

The first thing that struck me

is one of the external hard drives

had screws on the bottom that had a number of scratches.

This lead me to believe

that someone had disassembled this external hard drive.

I also determined that a piece of commercial wiping software

had been downloaded and executed.

And in one hard drive we identified

almost one million deleted files.

Someone did not want us to see what had been

on those hard drives.

Mark was able to recover dozens of spreadsheets.

And these spreadsheets turned out to be

what we would see as smoking gun evidence

in the case.

The spreadsheets told a story

about how these maps were being drawn,

and how these were different scenarios

that were being played out.

It was as though they were testing.

You look at each successive spreadsheet

and you can see the maps getting more and more biased.

They started at 49 seats at their basic map,

then go up to 52 seats, and 55 seats, then 57 seats,

and 58 seats, and 59 seats.

What they were doing was they're reducing

the number of competitive seats.

They got pretty quickly to 59 seats for themselves.

I think there were four or five iterations

of the map at 59.

Then they take the 59‐seat map and they continue

and they continue to tweak it

subjecting it to this analysis to say,

well what if the Democrats do really well?

What if our candidates lose the argument with the voters?

On that final map,

even under the scenario of the Democrats winning

the vote by the biggest margin they've ever won

in modern Wisconsin history,

the Republicans would still get 59 seats minimum

in the state assembly.

That's an astonishing manipulation of democracy.

I mean think about it for a second.

I mean, people elect their representative

and representatives are accountable to the people

who elect them.

And, um... But if you do this,

if you were able to gerrymander effectively,

and egregiously, and durably for an entire 10‐year period,

there's no accountability.

They can do whatever the hell they want

and that is what they have been doing in Wisconsin.

Good morning.

I'm Peter Earle and I'm the lead trial lawyer

in this lawsuit which we filed today.

When one party gains control

of all the levers of government and then stacks the deck

in their favor to keep control

regardless of the will of the people,

the very heart and soul of our democracy is weakened.

There had never been a successful opinion of any sort

in this kind of a case.

I'm always a pessimist when it comes to litigation.

I thought that our odds of winning a trial

were less than 50 percent.

Federal Court rules today

that Wisconsin state voting districts

drawn up by Republicans are unconstitutional.

I remember when it came out, immediately, I called Nick.

She just yelled out, you know, "We won, we won."

I was like, "You have to come right now,

I'm going to buy champagne."

We were absolutely delighted to actually see

a verdict in your favor,

you know, for the first time in 30 years.

It was awesome.

This is the single biggest case for the future

of our democracy since Citizens United.

This may be the last time we have an opportunity

to do something about partisan gerrymandering.

If they lose, it's no holds barred.

We'd like to thank you all for joining us

from near and far, crossing the country,

and crossing partisan lines to focus on solutions.

We're here at the Unrig the System Summit

and we are mostly just building connections.

That guy you were talking to said he would

introduce us to that funder.

We're all volunteers

and we've never done this before,

so we have a lot to learn from people.

‐ Hey, Anna. ‐ Nice to meet you.

What organization are you with?

What's been really fun about it

is that everybody knows about us already.

We're kind of famous.

I'm trying to be modest about that.

‐ Congratulations. ‐ Thank you.

Thank you.

‐ On the app or... ‐ I'm a fan.

Oh, great.

I'm the director in Wisconsin.

Oh, awesome. Can we connect?

Can we first take a selfie?

Yes, please, please, that would be great.

Such amazing stuff just in being all volunteer,

and engaging people, it's really been amazing.

He is my lawyer.

I wish.

So, you got my text?

What was your text?

It's before you speak, Heather and I want to talk

to you about how to find a way to get a money pitch in.

If you talk about where we're at.

‐ Just, I mean... ‐ Mm‐hmm.

That's how we're starting is "Where are you at?"

Where we're at, quite honestly where we're at

is we're waiting for the Board of Canvassers,

but frankly we're raising money.

I'm Katie Fahey,

I'm with an organization called Voters Not Politicians.

One of the things that they're now having to figure out

is how do we go from being

a citizen signature gathering effort

to a campaign?

And how do we start to talk to

a much broader universe of people,

some of whom will be told by the opposition

that this is a power grab

and you should never vote for it.

Yeah.

Fight, oh my god, we know.

What about

the Voters Not Politicians ballot proposal?

If that gets on the ballot, do you think it's going to pass,

and does that cause a big problem for Republicans

going forward?

I don't think it will pass,

but also when you talked in your intro

about, this is some 27‐year‐old miraculously came up

and organization came together, I don't believe it.

I believe when you peel behind it,

you are going to see that this has all been

constructed by Democrats.

‐ But you think it will fail? ‐ I do.

The opposition is being led by Robert LaBrant.

LaBrant gets his start in politics working

for the Chamber of Commerce

and he is the maestro of redistricting in Michigan.

As far as ballot questions are concerned,

I've spent most of my summer trying to work out

a legal strategy to get one of the ballot question proposals

off the ballot.

LaBrant understood before anybody else

just how crucial these redistricting fights could be.

Every 10 years we do redistricting in Michigan

and I've kind of made that a kind of specialization.

Democrats tend to cluster in urban cities

and Republicans are kind of more evenly spread out.

In drawing district lines based upon

traditional redistricting criteria,

Democrats have a lot of wasted votes.

I don't think that's a direct result

of Republican gerrymandering, it's just a fact of life.

The real intent of LaBrant

and the other Republicans in Michigan

was revealed in a series of emails

exchanged between them during the redistricting process

in 2011.

The emails show that they gerrymandered

the state intentionally.

So, for everyone who doesn't know,

we've gotten sued officially.

Um, they have filed a suit with the court of appeals

saying that our petition touches too many parts

of the constitution,

and so it's a wholesale revision and not something

that's appropriate for a ballot initiative.

Any time you want to change something in Michigan,

any time you want to have a citizen‐led effort

to take back control over what's happening

in state government,

you better come with a lot of money

because there's going to be a lot of money on the opposition

funding their lawyers to challenge everything.

This move is another one of those fundamental things

that's wrong with our democracy.

It's one of those things where, like, it's not really right.

Like, we have the right to petition our government,

and gather signatures, and get it on the ballot,

and then they're trying to do, like say that we can't.

Although we knew we were going to get sued,

it's not right that we are.

Hey, everybody, I wanted to do an update.

Normally I do this either on a Facebook Live,

or with an interview group, or a number of things.

You know, like an hour ago I was feeling so good.

Point of pride that I've always had

is that we've done things the way that, like,

you hope that they're done. Um...

I think that with this court case

it's made it feel really real that...

there's a lot of power out there that controls a lot

of things that you don't get to be in control over,

that you can try and work as hard as you can,

but, you know,

a misplaced comma or a word can throw things out.

And it feels really real right now,

the pressure feels on, um, because...

what if something does happen?

What if it's not possible for a group of people

to band together and...

try as hard as they can and...

what if it still doesn't matter?

I don't want to disappoint anybody.

The U. S. Supreme Court will now decide

whether the maps that determine who you vote for

are constitutional.

The case on partisan gerrymandering

has the potential to reshape American politics

as we know it.

Hey, Peter.

Hello.

‐ Welcome. ‐ Good to see you guys.

Hey, welcome.

Okay, we'll get the lawyers in now.

All right, lawyers.

With you, with you.

Stay, stay, stay.

One more, look serious,

like you're trying to save democracy.

This is what democracy looks like.

It's a little weird to have so much

of the world focusing on this.

I got woken up at 6:30 with my dad calling me

saying that he saw Nick, my co‐counsel and husband,

on Australian TV talking about the case.

We've had a countdown on our whiteboard in Chicago.

Somebody rang me and was like, "Oh, don't you have

a case in the next, you know, few months?"

I was like, "It's in five days, now it's four days."

Yeah, we're nearly there.

Um, so how about this?

As this case illustrated,

it's now possible to draw a district map

that is so extremely and durably biased

that democracy itself is gravely compromised?

Paul is the best possible person

in America to do this.

He is one of the country's

best respected Supreme Court specialists

who also has a particular expertise

in election law and redistricting.

You look at the first election,

you do sensitivity testing,

what does the sensitivity testing

have to show?

For the Plaintiff to win?

‐ Yes. ‐ Uh...

That over a plausible range of outcomes...

I think everybody gets nervous before they argue

in the Supreme Court.

The most important thing is to be extremely well prepared

and know what you're going to say first.

Because once you start talking, it's usually okay.

What you want to do is get to the green light point,

which is basically, "This court therefore has a choice,

either use the standards we've given you

to limit this abusive practice, or give a green light

to the gerrymanderers to have at it."

‐ I like have at it. ‐ I do too.

We got very close to winning the Vieth case,

as it became known.

We got four votes to say that the map was unconstitutional.

There were four votes to say

that the issue is a political question

that shouldn't be in the courts at all.

That was the opinion written by Justice Scalia.

The basic problem

is that some degree

of political motivation and affect in districting

is not unconstitutional.

And then there was Justice Kennedy,

who was in the middle.

Kennedy is telling the legal community

and the social science community,

you know, "I'm interested.

I'm willing to tackle this undemocratic practice,

but I need some assurance that there's a reliable,

workable test."

And so at the moment

fighting partisan gerrymandering in the courts

means coming up with a standard

that would be persuasive to Justice Kennedy.

We could not have done more to answer

that call for a standard.

To say, "This is the case, if there's any case

in which you have to draw the line

and say it's unconstitutional and wrong."

There are few times in your life

when you get to particularly be my age,

you look back and you say,

you know, "There were times when I could have made

a difference and did I step up to the plate

and do what I really needed to do

and have the courage to do it?"

And the plaintiffs in this case

stood up for what they believed in.

We are at a real crossroads and I think the window

is going to close on whether or not we can really bring about

this reform

if we don't get it done in this case.

All eyes will be on the U. S. Supreme Court

as it hears a Wisconsin case challenging the way

the state's legislative districts are drawn.

The legal question is,

can we even measure this? Should we get into it?

Is this a political question that we should stay out of?

And can we define what's extreme gerrymandering?

‐ Rise up! ‐ Fight back!

‐ Rise up! ‐ Fight back!

It's a fixed system.

It's a fixed system, that's what gerrymandering

is all about.

Congress will never, ever fix this problem

because they have one interest and one interest only

and this is to stay in power.

Mr. Chief Justice and may it please the court,

what the state is asking for here is a free pass

to continue using an assembly map

that is so extreme

that it effectively nullifies democracy.

Hi, everyone, I'm Paul Smith,

I argued the case this morning for the plaintiffs

from Wisconsin.

We hope that the court will see its way clear to say

this is not only a constitutional violation,

it's a constitutional violation for which there is

a meaningful judicial remedy.

One thing I don't do is come out in front

of a bunch of cameras and predict Justice's votes,

but I do think he understood our position

and that he seems quite concerned

about where the country is right now.

Thank you, everybody.

There were some great lines,

did you think of them yesterday?

Just real zingers.

Like the festival of gerrymandering

the likes of which we have never seen.

Well you heard Justice Sotomayor's comments,

you know, I mean you did this, and then you did this,

and then you did this to really ratchet up

the representation.

That was all based on the spreadsheets

that you had recovered for us on the hard drives.

I'm glad it worked out, fingers crossed, we'll see.

I do want to say that you get to be a star

of the day one day if you're a Supreme Court guy.

But the case is made in the trenches

and this case was really made with all of you,

the plaintiffs, the lawyers.

If we didn't have that foundation,

we wouldn't have been in the Supreme Court.

So hope springs, we're going to do it.

Thank you, everybody.

We have brought together some of the best minds

in the legal community...

and we have studied, so carefully,

the Supreme Court's jurisprudence on this question

and built an evidentiary record

that is so complete that I'm confident

we're going to win,

I'm confident we're going to win.

I'll tell you, the future of our democracy depends on it.

Here we go, somebody says,

"Is there any chance of the gerrymandering cases

being decided today?"

Of course there is.

I mean, so I think we're mentally prepared

for a win, obviously it's fantastic, right?

But we've talked over the loss like so many times

that I think we're prepared if that happens.

9:00 o'clock sharp.

Okay, come on.

Last decision, Washington v. United Sates?

What's Washington v. United States?

I don't know, but that means it's not us.

All right.

We can relax.

Okay, I bet it's next Monday.

I don't know why I'm so calm now that I think about it,

it's going to be very stressful if it comes.

I just think it's not.

I just had a very detailed dream that like,

Roberts announced the opinion, just like, you know,

went after us on standing.

Like ruled against us on every single possible issue.

I think it's called a nightmare, Nick.

Second Minnesota Voters Alliance.

Oh, Mansky is reversed and remanded.

Is that it?

Second and final opinion, oh yeah, we're done.

Woo‐hoo!

‐ Not today. ‐ That's a wrap.

Need more coffee.

I bet this is happening.

Ah! Don't freak me out.

But I'm excited, but I'm scared, but I'm excited.

Is Annabelle coming here if there's a decision, just now?

‐ Mm‐hmm. ‐ All right.

Oh my God, it's our case, oh my God,

it's Gill from the Chief Justice.

Holy shit, oh my God, look.

Look.

Quiet.

Holy shit, it's ours.

Oh my God, I'm going to be sick.

It is Gill, it is Roberts.

‐ F‐‐‐, why is it Roberts? ‐ What is it? What is it?

Okay, it's here, it's here.

You know the decision is long and complex,

but a quick read of it tells me that essentially

what the court has said is that these plaintiffs

did not prove that they had standing

and individualized harm to bring the case.

This morning, the Supreme Court not ruling

on partisan gerrymandering, not putting forth a test

as to when to determine

there has been partisan gerrymandering,

and really sort of punting this issue for another day.

‐ No! ‐ F‐‐‐ you.

F‐‐‐ you.

"Failed to demonstrate Article 3 standing."

F‐‐‐, damn them.

Really, like that's your f‐‐‐ing decision ground?

Now the Supreme Court did say

that the challengers can try again

to see if they can overcome

the legal obstacle of getting through

the courthouse door achieving standing,

showing that they have a particular injury

and this case does go back to the lower courts.

Oh, wait, so it is vacated and remanded.

Oh, it is vacated and remanded?

Yeah, to go back, let's see.

Oh, wait.

We might be still alive, it might be that like,

"Okay, you have to go back and technically like get

some more plaintiffs with some more allegations."

So, did you win or lose?

So, the court says that in order to pursue a claim

like ours, you need to identify specific people,

specific voters who live in cracked or packed districts.

It's not enough to just assert exclusively

a statewide harm or a statewide injury.

We have some plaintiffs ready to go,

we are ready to amend our complaint,

and move forward.

So it's not, I mean, it's not a disaster,

it's just frustrating timewise.

I can't tell, are you disappointed,

are you not disappointed?

This is far from the worst scenario.

Yes, I mean, it's frustrating because we want

to just win, right?

Obviously, we want to just freaking win.

But it's not a loss, right?

I mean we haven't lost, we're still going,

we still have things to say, and it suggests we're going

to eventually win, which is a good sign.

Yeah, I would say, too, that like, you know,

before today, my estimate of our odds

of ultimately winning was below 50 percent.

Now I think it's above 50 percent

our odds of ultimately winning.

We continue to follow

that bombshell announcement out of Washington.

Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy is retiring.

The 81‐year‐old was nominated by President Reagan

and served on the country's highest court

for more than 30 years.

There is really no way to sugar coat it.

The retirement of Anthony Kennedy

was terrible news for those people

that wanted to see the court do something positive

on gerrymandering.

He was the only conservative justice

that was at least open minded

about finding a solution on this issue

and now he is gone.

It is now obvious that the Supreme Court

is not going to be our savior on partisan gerrymandering.

We may have to be our own saviors.

People are trying to take back these district lines

that have been rigged against them.

They want a fair playing field.

The hope lies now at the state level.

We are seeing around the country, Michigan, Utah,

Colorado, Ohio, Missouri, there are citizen pathways

moving forward.

These are red states, these are blue states,

these are purple states.

These are states that went for Trump,

these are states that went for Clinton.

This is going to be the battlefield moving forward.

The Michigan Supreme Court

is about to have a political hot mess

dumped on its lap.

The Michigan Court of Appeals

said the ballot question meets the legal requirements

and the voters should decide in November.

But the challengers now plan

to go to the state Supreme Court.

‐ Hey. ‐ How are you doing?

Good, how are you?

Good, do you mind if I chat with you

‐ for a few minutes? ‐ No, not at all.

Great, so how do you feel about today?

We feel good.

You know, it's exciting to be here

at the Hall of Justice.

We had a really strong Court of Appeals opinion,

3‐0 decision saying our opposition's case

is without merit and we have every confidence

that we'll remain on the ballot on November 6th.

I remember distinctly when we were doing our town halls

that one of the top questions I received was,

isn't it impossible to do this?

Like, isn't it‐‐ Aren't you going to get challenged

by the Supreme Court anyways?

So, we don't even have language yet,

we haven't like whatever,

and like the people of Michigan

were already really worried about that

because we consistently have seen

opposition wanting to undermine this process.

Good morning.

This is a special session of the Michigan Supreme Court

to address an emergency election matter.

The scary part is that the Michigan Supreme Court

is a political body.

Our judges get nominated from political parties.

Five of them were nominated from the Republicans

and two of them came from the Democrat side.

We know that the Michigan GOP is applying a lot of pressure

to let them know how they would like them to rule.

The constitution is very clear

that the people are the source of all governmental power

and they have the ability to define how the government

is going to be set up.

At the expense of the people having their right

to elect representatives as they've done

for two generations.

I don't believe this infringes that

whatsoever, Your Honor.

It substitutes 13 citizens chosen at random

across this state in place of a process in which

10 million people have a direct participation

in the process by electing their representatives

and senators.

Is that not somewhat consequential?

I suppose the question is whether they decide

that they want the legislature to have this power,

or a commission,

or to do it in some other fashion?

All power in our state and in our nation

is derived from the people, right?

Are there any further questions?

We stand adjourned.

Yeah, sounds great.

How are you doing?

Logged a big day, eh?

Yeah.

Let's go here with the people...

Okay, sounds good.

So this is really a fight against

status quo and change?

I believe it is.

Actually, I think it's a fight about whether the people

of Michigan can be trusted

to amend own constitution or not.

I feel like we were fairly heard,

and that we left it on the table,

and I think that what I heard was that our constitution

is enshrined in letting the people of our state

decide these issues.

Thanks, guys.

Sit down, sit down.

Oh my God, Jenny, calm down.

We have an election to win.

We know that our opposition now knows that we are an army

and that we can apply pressure in ways that they can't.

It is time to make it so that we get

way over two million votes for voting yes

and so that people know what

an Independent Citizens Redistricting Commission

can mean for Michigan.

It is time to knock some doors.

Good morning, I'm a volunteer

from Voters Not Politicians.

Hi, we're volunteers with Voters Not Politicians.

I want to congratulate the people of Michigan

for the great choice and the great vote

of the Supreme Court.

So that the people move forward with the initiative

and to have redistricting happening in Michigan

because it's the voters versus the politicians,

that's what this is all about.

We've got to go and vote for the voters,

not the politicians.

That's awesome. What?

Proposal 2 is on the ballot,

Katie Fahey is supporting the proposal

and of course conservative Republican Jamie Roe

doesn't like it at all.

Democrats lose races in this state

because they have bad candidates,

not because we have bad lines.

This is an unnecessary solution to a problem that doesn't exist.

The people who draw the lines now are accountable to each

and every one of us at the ballot box,

the 13‐member star chamber

is going to be accountable to nobody.

Proposal 2, deal breaker number one.

Proposal 2 gives 13 new redistricting commissioners

absolute authority in your constitution.

Proposal 2 lets 13 new redistricting commissioners

vote themselves unlimited pay and unlimited perks.

Convicted felons can be picked as commissioners.

It's 3,200 words.

Vote no on 2 or the joke's on you.

Something that is super bothering me right now

is that robo‐call they did from "Katie" urging them

to vote no on Prop 2 and 3.

Like there is no way you just chose Katie out of a hat.

Jerks.

I'm tired.

You are looking live at democracy in action.

We're seeing huge numbers of voters showing up today

at the polls.

Are there door hangers for today, we got asked.

They're here.

Aren't those the same door hangers

we have been using?

No, it says, "vote today".

Oh, it does? Cute.

So much more

than just candidates on the ballot today,

we're taking a look at three proposals

that could drastically change

what it means to be a Michigan voter.

Proposal 2 would create

an independent commission

to draw new legislative and congressional districts

after each census.

Got some info on Prop 2 ending gerrymandering

in our state.

Thank you for voting.

Yeah.

It's coming down to the wire.

About an hour left to go before the polls close

across the state of Michigan in these crucial

midterm elections.

Thank you.

‐ 8:01. ‐ 8:01.

Okay.

That's it, there's nothing else we can do.

We've done everything we can do.

It's almost 10:00 p. m. and you guys are,

it's only 11‐ish percent reporting but you're up by...

Nine, only nine.

That doesn't make me feel good.

I think, I wish we were winning by more.

Just so I feel a little better, but you know what?

That's okay.

I wish they would just be done.

Are you also preparing the we lost?

Is there a good gift for that too?

We lost, oh...

Just taking a look now at some

of the election results still coming in right now.

Proposal 2 would change the way

Michigan draws its state house,

state senate, and congressional districts.

And right now the yes votes are well ahead.

Do they call the proposals

later than they call candidates?

Who calls it?

Who are we waiting for?

Now that some of the results are coming in,

I'm like, "Yeah, okay.

Okay, maybe, maybe, maybe, maybe."

Who said it?

A bunch of news articles.

No, Elizabeth, you believed in us

before like almost anybody did.

I just got told we called it.

Way to fucking change the Michigan constitution.

How am I not crying?

How are you guys, I cry all the time, you never cry.

Come here. Come here.

Aww. Okay, okay, we should say something.

I feel like we should say something.

Hey, guys, we won!

We f‐‐‐ing amended the state constitution.

Okay, okay, okay, okay, okay, okay.

I can't breathe, Kelly.

All political power is inherent in the people!

There were three other states across our country

who were trying to end gerrymandering too.

We had Utah, Missouri, and Colorado.

Missouri has been called,

they have also officially ended gerrymandering,

heck yes!

Utah is almost called, 57 percent reporting

for changing lines.

In Colorado it was at 71.4 percent, 71!

This is not a moment, but a movement.

The people of our country are sick of this

and if we don't come and say that enough is enough,

then nothing is going to change.

But we have proven that you can keep your integrity,

you can make it so that you can invite anyone

to the table, you can operate a campaign

in a transparent way

where we actually trust the people of our state

to make decisions,

and it ends up in a beautiful result

that unites thousands of people and is about to unite

millions of people.

It mattered that you showed up,

it mattered that you knocked doors,

it mattered that you gathered signatures,

and stood in the rain, in the cold, in the heat.

All of that mattered for generations of people.

Your sacrifices have changed our constitution.

The Michigan state constitution opens with,

"All political power is inherent in the people."

We are those people, this is our power,

let's go have

an Independent Citizens Redistricting Commission

that restores faith in democracy.

Cheers.

And I think we're ready to party.

Respect our vote,

respect our vote,

respect our vote, respect our vote.

All votes matters.

Voting rights are human rights,

voting rights are human rights.

Show me what democracy looks like.

This is what democracy looks like.

Show me what democracy looks like.

This is what democracy looks like.

I believe that we will win, I believe that we will win.

I believe that we will win, I believe that we will win.

I believe that we will win, I believe that we will win.

I believe that we will win, I believe that we will win.

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.