Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
When a serious crime is committed and the police need all the help they can
get, there's one group of people they turn to time after time.
The expert witnesses.
Knowing when someone's done something is one thing, but proving it's completely
different. We need that last piece of the jigsaw.
An extraordinary army of men and women with the expertise to reveal the hidden
clues criminals have left behind.
It might be a fingerprint, footwear mark, cell site analysis that can come
up with that golden ticket to put that investigation on a different path.
Using the very latest techniques.
Several months or even years later, evidence can remain and still be
recovered.
This is the inside story of how science helps solve some of the UK's most
complex cases.
The forensics in this case.
showed us what did happen. Not what could have happened, what did happen.
If you've been in a scene, it's virtually impossible to clean everything
up. Something is going to be there. If we're looking in the right place, we'll
find it.
Without the unseen hero painstakingly going through forensic, I might not have
got justice for my daughter.
This is the story of the expert witness.
In this programme, an expert witness examines a muddy crime scene to
determine how a body got there.
He was standing up, straight up, and he was just bent at the waist.
That in itself is interesting.
And when police investigate a number of complaints against the young man... My
gut instinct did say that there was something up with him, something wrong,
but unfortunately I ignored my gut instinct and led to regret.
A virologist is brought in to reveal if the suspect was guilty.
Where you have a transmission, you can see a resemblance between the strains
infecting the two parties.
And it was really that type of linkage that would substantiate the allegations
that were made.
Expert witnesses helped investigations by seeing the clues the rest of us
can't. When the body of an elderly farmer was found in a river, it wasn't
clear to detectives whether it was a case of suicide or murder. But a
bioarchaeologist was able to detect and decipher evidence left at the crime
scene.
Forensic bioarchaeology can help criminal investigation by interpreting
the crime scene. Sometimes the environment can give as much evidence as
the body itself, sometimes more.
June 2018, Gosmore in Hertfordshire.
69-year-old farmer Bill Taylor is reported missing from his home by his
family.
Reporting on the case for the national newspapers at the time was Thomas
Hornell. Gosmore is a small hamlet and most of the farmland there was actually
owned by the Taylors. There was hundreds of acres.
Dozens of police ended up showing up and combing through every blade of grass on
Bill's farmland, searching for him. This was a really big police presence for a
normally sleepy town.
Due to the sheer scale and complexity of the search, the Hertfordshire Police
Major Crime Unit were called in to organise the hunt for Bill. This was
certainly the largest search that I've ever been involved in and coordinated.
While search teams scoured the countryside, Detective Chief Inspector
Carl Foster turned to Bill's family and friends.
They revealed his personal life was complicated.
Estranged from his second wife, Angela...
and with his family at war.
Whilst Bill and Angela were separated, they weren't yet divorced.
Angela wanted to get divorced. Bill was effectively digging his heels in and
saying, no, I don't want to do that.
Both Bill and Angela had children from previous marriages and they had three
children together and in particular Bill's son from his first marriage did
not get on with Angela and her side of the family at all. In fact, they
completely loathed each other.
Bill was kind of stuck in the middle because Bill obviously loved both sides
of the family. He had children and grandchildren in both sides of the
family and he was stuck between a rock and a hard place.
Although police had no body with which to reveal a definitive cause of death,
they began to suspect foul play from within the feuding family.
The police were suspicious of Angela because she didn't seem that moved or
distressed by Bill's disappearance and detectives also overheard her talking
about him in the past tense.
However, detectives could not identify an obvious motive for why Angela would
have wanted her husband dead.
There was already a post-nuptial agreement in place between Bill and
Angela where they'd already agreed on the allocation of property and land
worth anything from £150 to £200 million.
The title deeds had already been moved over to Angela as part of that
agreement, so that effectively, for me, said...
Well, it can't be a financial motive here, then.
But one discovery left detectives convinced someone in Bill's circle held
a serious grudge against him.
One of the issues that concerned us was the fact that his vehicle had been
subject to an arson attack the week prior to him going missing. It had been
attended by officers, Anderson's crime officer. The towel, the shirt and the
fuel can that were found in the Land Rover didn't belong to Bill. We sent all
of those off.
for forensic examination to establish whether there was any forensic evidence
that would assist us.
Detectives continued their investigations, this time into Angela's
personal life, and identified someone who raised their suspicions.
The police began to look at a man named Paul Cannon, who was a digger driver who
had done some work on Bill's farm and was around a lot at Angela's place. So
they really began to look at those two, suspecting a relationship.
Angela admitted she was having an affair with Paul Cannon.
And when lab results returned from the items in the burnt-out Land Rover, they
showed traces of Cannon's DNA.
Significant, but not enough to prove he was responsible for Bill's
disappearance. What the forensic evidence against Paul Cannon did was
obviously elevate our concerns around what was going on between him and Bill,
potentially Angela, and that whole family dynamic.
But on its own, does it explain what has then happened to Bill a week later?
No, it doesn't.
Nonetheless, Hertfordshire Police declared the case a murder inquiry.
Without the body, they didn't have enough evidence to charge either Angela
Taylor or Paul Cannon of any wrongdoing.
But their investigation was far from over.
We became aware that Paul Cannon had been employed at two quarry sites, both
within the county of Hertfordshire.
Whilst the two sites had been shut down...
If Bill has been murdered, could his body have been secreted in either one of
those quarries?
Any disused quarry is a hazardous environment.
These two were huge.
Concerned about the risk to police search teams, Carl turned to
bioarchaeologist Jennifer Miller for advice.
I have a lot of experience of searching landfills for a missing person and
recovery of bodies buried within landfills. So I was asked to advise what
the logistics would be for recovery of anything from this sort of environment.
We walked over the quarries and they're both over an acre. They're between 20
and 30 metres high mounds of industrial waste and it's very, very unstable.
Very, very dangerous. Potential for collapse and it would have taken months,
if not years, to search it all. And without substantiated evidence to say
that he was in there, then it's not worth doing.
DCI Carl Foster took Jenny's advice and decided against excavating the quarry.
Searching for more concrete evidence that Bill was murdered, he examined
mobile phones belonging to Paul Cannon and Angela Taylor.
They contained 28,000 text messages sent between the pair in the four months
before Bill's disappearance.
The contents were shocking.
So this is just a small extract from the thousands of messages between Paul
Cannon and Angela Taylor.
It starts with Paul Cannon, got to get him out of the picture very soon,
darling. And she replies, I don't know how to sort it, someone else maybe.
And Paul Cannon replies to the effect, I only know one man for that and I haven't
spoken to him in a long time, but I'll try.
The following day, the 17th of February, you phone that bloke, can't keep going
on like this. And Cannon replies, I'm good, darling, just spoke to a man going
to be about 20.
To which he replies, I'll go hard with you.
Messages closer to the time of Bill's disappearance were even more chilling.
26th May was the night Bill's Land Rover was subject to the arson attack.
And you've got a conversation here where Paul says, have to go to Dog Kennel, get
something. Dog Kennel is the name of one of the farms that Angela owned.
Angela replies, what you got to get? And then Paul Cannon replies, darling, you
light my fire.
But both Paul Cannon and Angela Taylor refused to make any comments on the
significance of these text messages.
Why did you make the comment, light my fire? Or did he say it to you?
Because neither of you have said it to each other ever before.
It can't be a coincidence that night the Land Rover gets set on fire, can it?
No comment.
Bill was last seen alive around 9.30 by his grandson and then some two hours
later, Paul Cannon sends a message to Angela Taylor saying, just watching Kill
Bill 2, laugh out loud, which is pretty sinister when you know the timeline and
the sequence of events and then you read that message.
The messages also contained violent sexual fantasies centred around
punishing Bill.
But tellingly, they all stopped the day Bill disappeared.
There's no more talk of, you know, getting rid of Bill, killing Bill,
making love while the blood's running down the drain.
None of that.
Why is that?
Why has it stopped on the 4th of June?
The recovery of these messages...
was a huge leap forward in the investigation.
I would describe those messages as a black and white transcript of a
conspiracy to murder Bill.
Angela Taylor and Paul Cannon were both charged with murder.
But Bill's body was yet to be found. The case against the pair was far from
watertight. We were preparing for the no-body trial.
The defence would exploit that and suggest that he's potentially taken
himself off, he might have a girlfriend somewhere, he's had enough and he's
walked out of his life.
Then, in February 2019, eight months after Bill Taylor disappeared, a chance
discovery gave detectives a massive breakthrough.
Bill's remains were found by a fisherman who wanted to get the perfect spot, so
he'd actually gone onto private land owned by Angela.
and discovered the remains of Bill Taylor by the riverbank.
The body offered detectives an entirely new set of clues which could reveal for
the first time how Bill Taylor died.
We knew we were going to need to demonstrate that Bill hadn't gone there
to take his own life and he hadn't gone there and been victim of some form of
medical episode or accident.
DCI Carl Foster needed a thorough forensic analysis of the body and the
riverbank where it was found.
So he turned again to expert witness Jennifer Miller.
My remit was primarily to recover the body and interpret events at the scene,
so how the body had got into the river as best as possible.
The mud was just short of a metre deep. All you could see was the head just at
the banking and the back, which was covered in algae, and there was nothing
else visible. So it was face down in the mud.
The first thing to do is try to understand how the body is lying, so the
disposition of the remains, as it's called.
We're able to identify quite quickly that although he was lying face down, he
was actually standing up and he was just bent at the waist.
So that in itself is interesting.
It's an unusual way to be in.
This unusual position made Jennifer doubt that Bill had become stuck in the
deep mud on his own.
The positioning of the body was such that both feet were facing the bank.
It would be very difficult to walk in backwards through that thick mud without
losing your balance and falling backwards rather than forwards, and
perhaps that's the key point. As you lift your leg to go forwards, you're
more likely to overbalance backwards than you are forwards.
It's more suggestive of being laid there, being put over somebody's
shoulder and with the feet facing forwards and deposited.
What's more, Jennifer concluded Bill may well have already been dead by the time
he was placed in the river.
I think it's unlikely that he was put in there alive and effectively kicking
because he didn't kick. The feet were together, the knees were together, his
thighs were together. He was bolt upright and it's very unlikely, in my
opinion, that he was conscious when this happened.
Under Jennifer's supervision, Bill's body was carefully recovered from the
mud and sent for post-mortem.
That revealed injuries to his neck, consistent with strangulation.
The case against Angela Taylor and Paul Cannon was now as strong as it could be.
Their trial began in September 2019, and Jennifer's evidence was crucial.
At the trial, the defence were quite robust in their questioning. They
insisted that he had potentially walked in and asked me to say if this was
possible. And I did explain to them that having never taken a body into the mire,
I don't know. But I'm quite convinced, in my own opinion, that had he walked
into the mire, then the disposition of the remains would have been very
different.
Jen was really important around the interpretation of that deposition site.
Her evidence was absolutely solid and, yeah, couldn't ask for more, really.
They talked of torturing him in text messages, discussed the cost of hiring a
hitman, and today they were found guilty of his murder. A jury has decided that
wealthy farmer Bill Taylor was killed by his wife and her lover for refusing her
a divorce.
duplicitous and calculating and plainly besotted.
That was the judge's assessment today of lovers Angela Taylor and Paul Cannon as
they were each sentenced to 21 years in prison for the murder of William Taylor.
What a pointless, pointless exercise.
The old fashion, like just removing a love rival, but it just seems so
unnecessary, you know, to murder an old man
However unusual the crime, there's a science that can help solve it. In this
next case, dozens of victims and a national manhunt led police to the
suspect in a one-of-a-kind criminal investigation.
But in order to secure a conviction, police needed the expertise of a
virologist, an expert in viruses.
My main interest has been in the field of the evolution of viruses, how they
change over time. And I think that's obviously something that we're all very
aware of with the COVID pandemic.
Edinburgh 2015, where a shocking crime is unfolding, one that will span the UK,
affect dozens of gay men and end in a dramatic national manhunt.
It started with one man, 26-year-old Daryl Rowe, and one of his victims,
Stuart Roger.
I came across Daryl Rowe through an app called Grindr.
which is a sort of dating hook-up app, a bit akin to Tinder.
I agreed to meet up with Daryl, and during that encounter, he appeared to
tamper or sabotage the condom, which I had insisted on being used.
And at the time, I just wrote off as me over-worrying about something.
I kind of felt quite grossy after the encounter with Daryl, and, you know, the
truth was there was a very dark atmosphere around him, which was
unmistakable.
My gut instinct did say that there was something up with him and that there was
something wrong, but unfortunately I ignored my gut instinct and lived to
regret that.
Stuart seemed to think that something was wrong, but confirmed within days
when he received a string of sinister text messages from Roe.
About eight days later, after the encounter, he sent me a series of
abusive messages, revealing to me that he had indeed sabotaged the condom,
along with a series of other insults and taunts.
I felt an enormous sense of alarm and disturbance when I got those messages.
And I knew that because he had subdued the condom, I was at risk of contracting
something. So I arranged a HIV test as soon as I possibly could.
A couple of weeks after that, I sadly got the phone call from the clinic
asking me to come in that day and telling me that I was HIV positive. And
I knew that it was definitely him.
I did contact the police, I think, within about a week of my diagnosis.
You know, I was determined to get justice and I gave a full statement
about what had happened and told them that this man had violated my consent
and showed them the screen grabs of the messages that he had sent me.
Police Scotland moved to arrest Abel Rowe, but he had fled.
Detectives searched for him and were astonished when he turned up 500 miles
away in Brighton.
Here he was deliberately infecting more men with HIV.
BBC journalist Carol Erskine reported on the case.
In Brighton, another one of his victims had found out he had tested positive for
HIV. He had gone to a clinic to be tested and while he was there he had
shown text messages that Daryl Rowe had sent him, these terrible, horrible
messages that he had sent him to staff at the clinic.
And they then realised that they had seen other men in the clinic who'd had
similar messages.
Police now suspected they were dealing with a serial offender who had left
behind 14 victims in Edinburgh and now eight new victims in Brighton.
Sussex police caught up with Daryl Rowe and he was arrested on a charge of GBH.
But Rowe denied all the charges and under questioning, he claimed he was not
even HIV positive.
Do you have HIV?
No.
Have you had a HIV test recently?
Not recently.
I had a relationship when I first got here and it was unprotected.
So I've not been tested after that.
Okay. So you're saying a couple of months ago you had a relationship, had
unprotected sex?
When I first got here.
I was dating somebody pretty quickly and got quite intense.
Darryl Rowe was bailed in Brighton to return to his foster parents in
Scotland. It was after three weeks of living with them that he went on the run
and was missing.
Detectives were convinced Rowe would offend again.
They shared his image with the media and a national manhunt swung into action.
Police found his tent in the Pentland Hills and they were able to identify it
as being his because it had his medication inside.
But for months there was no sign of Roe until one man saw Roe's image and had a
chilling realisation.
He was living in Newcastle with a man who believed he was in a relationship
with him and had no idea of his previous history.
Roe had changed his name and bank details but continued with his prolific
crime spree infecting even more victims with HIV.
The nationwide manhunt to find him uncovered further victims and he was
actually discovered on a dating website when police were able to compare
pictures of his genitalia and discover that this is the man that they were
looking for.
After a joint operation by Northumbria, Scotland and Sussex Police Forces, Roe
was finally arrested in North Tyneside.
But he claimed that his accusers could have caught HIV from anyone.
Detectives needed to prove that the infection could only have come from Roe.
So they turned to an expert witness, Peter Simmons, Professor of Virology at
the University of Oxford.
We were provided with blood samples from Roe and several alleged victims of him.
We separated white cells from those.
Within white cells, there'll be copies of HIV, often very low numbers, but we
will then amplify those up to an extent, which means we can then directly
determine their genetic sequence and analyze them for linkage.
evolves very quickly so it's not just one strain there are literally hundreds
of thousands of different strains where you have a transmission of hiv then you
can see a resemblance between the strains infecting the two parties and it
was really that type of linkage that we're looking for to substantiate the
allegations that were made we conduct what we call phylogenetic analysis that
will show whether these strains cluster together
or whether they're unrelated to each other.
Well, if we find a strong clustering of strains, and in fact in this case we
did, what this shows effectively is they share a similar or common strain of HIV,
and that would generally be acquired through transmission between them.
Having concluded a strain of HIV was common among Rowe and his victims,
Professor Simmons now had to recheck his results and run the analysis a second
time. We were provided with a second set of samples.
And the idea of that was to show that we reproducibly got the same strains from
the individuals in a different set of samples. That was actually what the
defence expert would demand that we provide as evidence.
In 2018, Dabble Rowe was tried at courts in both England and Scotland.
He was charged with causing grievous bodily harm with intent to infect HIV.
He became the first man in the country to be found guilty of intentionally
trying to spread the virus.
When we were in court, I saw him in the flesh for the first time since the
incident, and that was very nerve-wracking.
It was kind of a vindication to see him cut down to size, and he was a much more
belittled and humble figure sitting there in the dock.
I went to court and had to testify to the judge and jury.
Finding such a strong cluster in such a large number of people was actually key
to the certainty that Roe was involved in this. And I think the genetic
evidence was very well understood by the jury and probably influenced their
decision that he was guilty.
Roe was sentenced to 12 years in England.
And in Scotland, he was given eight years and placed on the Sex Offenders
Register.
I felt a huge amount of relief, most of all.
Sadly, a lot of victims of sexual violence don't get justice, and I was
very lucky in that respect. And actually, that's a credit to the
professionalism of everybody involved on the case.
Peter Simmons' work was crucial in convicting Daryl because it helped us
get to the point where it could be proved beyond reasonable doubt that it
had been transmitted from him to me.
Without a virology finding, the prosecution would rely on the fact that
there was a consistent contact history between Roe and the individuals
concerned.
So having the genetic evidence was certainly very important in showing the
linkage between HIV strains.
within the various parties involved.
Two very different cases there, but both needing the extraordinary skills of
expert witnesses to dig beneath the surface and help detectives uncover the
truth and bring those responsible to justice.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.