Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
In the criminal justice system In the criminal justice system
the people are represented
by two separate yet equally important groups:
the police, who investigate crime
and the district attorneys, who prosecute the offenders.
These are their stories.
Since when are you such a financial wizard?
Because I have a 401-K.
I have a savings account
I have life insurance
and my brother-in-law just put me in a mutual fund.
I don't want to hear about anything else.
When it comes time to retire
you're going to be crying in your beer.
What the hell is this?
There's one of them.
But where are the rest of them?
Oh, God.
Who is he?
According to his I.D., his name is Ronald Lee.
He's a molecular biologist.
Any idea what he died from?
Not really.
All I can see is
the one bite mark on his hand.
Must have bitten clear through the glove.
Forcible entry?
Not to the doors, not to the cages.
The monkeys were infected with something, right?
They weren't here to learn how
to ride unicycles.
According to what the lab people said
half of them were infected with a recombinant AIDS virus.
Any sign of them?
Only the one.
This the perp?
Yeah, two guys who work here
got him back in the cage.
And what's your story, huh?
They said when one of them gets out
they fight like hell to not get put back in.
So would I.
[Captioning sponsored by STUDIOS USA TELEVISION
and NBC]
17 monkeys were taken.
Eight of them were infected
with a strain of simian immunodeficiency virus
that's been genetically modified
with human AIDS virus.
How likely is it
that they'll infect anybody else?
Suffice it to say that anyone who gets near them
is at risk of being bitten and infected.
We have no idea
where these monkeys are? Not as of yet.
At this point I think
it's inadvisable to go public
with the fact that the Center for Disease Control is involved.
All it's going to do is create unnecessary panic.
Agreed.
If we don't manage
to locate these monkeys in a reasonable period of time
I'm derelict in my responsibilities
if I don't go public.
What's reasonable?
72 hours.
We'll do the best we can.
I'll want updates.
Yes, sir.
Uh, Dr. Tong.
If you could stick around for a minute
we need to ask you a few questions.
Sure.
Thanks.
Have we heard from the M.E.?
Well, they put the preliminary
cause of death as anaphylactic shock
probably brought on by an allergic reaction
to something in the monkey's saliva.
Well, if the guy was allergic to monkeys
what was he doing working in the lab?
According to the M.E., anaphylactic shock
doesn't require a preexisting allergy.
Well, what are you thinking for motive?
The monkeys go for
between 5,000 and 8,000 per
and there were 18 of them.
Robbery would be a possibility.
Another possibility
is if they were making progress
on an HIV vaccine, it could have been a case
of industrial espionage.
Well, has anyone received word
of an animal rights group being involved?
Not so far.
Because there was a fatality
most groups that would do this sort of thing
might not be quick to claim responsibility.
Has this particular research facility
been the target of protest?
We'll let you know.
Soon.
People find out we use primates, we catch heat.
Well, what kind of heat?
Oh, protests, nasty letters, some threats.
Any, uh, threats against specific people?
Oh, yeah.
I had someone call
and say were going to stick a needle in me
like we do to the primates.
Sounds like you don't take it too seriously.
I just lost a close friend
and a gifted biochemist.
I also lost, potentially, years worth of research.
I take that very seriously.
What I won't do is be intimidated by these people.
Can you give us any specifics
on who these people are?
Talk to my head of security.
He knows who they are.
Last demonstration we had was in September.
Like, 20 people walking around
in front of the entrance with signs.
A couple of them got inside
and poured blood on the floor.
My guys detained them until the cops got here.
We pressed charges
for trespassing and criminal mischief.
What kind of a security system do you have in place?
Electronic key access to this wing of the building;
separate access to where the monkeys are kept.
Any history
of electronic keys falling into the wrong hands?
Well, it's been known to happen.
Computer hackers figure out how to replicate the code
they can fabricate something that fools the scanner.
Did it ever happen here?
It happened at a research facility
in Wisconsin.
From what I understand, they had a break-in
some files were destroyed
and they never apprehended who did it.
This last protest
where they broke in and poured the blood--
what was the name of the organization?
They called themselves All Living Creatures United.
We really take no satisfaction in Mr. Lee's death.
Oh, I'm sure that'll be of great comfort to his family.
Unfortunately, his job
put him in the front lines of a struggle.
We're not asking for a sound bite here, Ms. Perlow.
We just want to know who in your organization
was present at the facility.
I wouldn't have that information.
You encourage your members
to break into animal research labs?
We encourage our members to follow their consciences.
So, as long as their conscience tells them to
you'd support an action like this?
I-I'm not saying that.
You refuse to give us a list of your members.
There is no list of members.
There are 17 diseased animals
unaccounted for, Ms. Perlow.
If you think you're going to be able
to protect anybody's identity
you're very much mistaken.
The two detained at the demonstration
one of them is Maxine Walden, 21, dean's list
the other one is Barry Pratt
previously arrested for assault, burglary
and possession of burglary tools.
I'll take care of number two.
So, what's the difference
between Veggan and Vegetarian?
Vegan.
It's no animal products of any kind.
So, what, no milk, no eggs, no cheese... ?
That's right.
It's kind of restrictive
isn't it?
Well, if you're really interested
I can get you some reading material.
I was just making conversation.
Do you know anything
about this research lab that got broken into?
No.
Any idea where monkeys hole up
when they're on the lam?
No, I have no idea.
You were arrested in a demonstration
at this lab a few months ago.
That's right, I was.
You been back there since?
No.
Where were you last night?
I was playing basketball at the Y.
Anybody we can call to verify that?
Well, I have the team roster
on my Palm Pilot.
You want to see?
Yes, we do.
You're here because I have a record, right?
It isn't for the food.
His alibi checks out.
He hasn't been talking
to animal rights groups in Wisconsin?
None that we can identify.
And his e-mails tell us nothing?
The only name that means anything is Maxine Walden.
Who's that?
The other protester who was detained at the demonstration.
Might be worth a visit.
The day of the demonstration
was the last time you were at the lab?
Yes.
So, what, it was just a passing fancy?
I'm involved in various actions
related to animal rights.
That was the last time I was at that
particular location.
So, how come you didn't get arrested that day at the lab?
I was let go.
I think the question is why you were let go.
I think I was late for a doctor's appointment.
A security guard took pity on me.
You expecting intruders?
No.
Then, what are you doing
with a stun gun?
There were some incidents with women being attacked
on their way back to the dorm.
I got it for that.
Where'd you get it from?
A friend of mine got it for me.
I'm not going to tell you who that friend is
'cause I don't want to get him in trouble.
You know, these are illegal in New York City.
We're going to have to take this away from you.
Take it.
We're also going to have to contact
the D.A.'s office.
You could be in a lot of trouble.
You know, the more cooperative you are
the more likely they are to let it go.
I'll take my chances.
What are your security officers armed with?
A night stick and a stun gun.
And who was supposed to stay with the demonstrators?
If I remember correctly, it was
Peavey and Castellano.
And they were supposed to wait
with the demonstrators until the cops showed.
Peavey decided to let one of them go
'cause she had a doctor's appointment.
He came to me with a whole sob story
about how she was just an innocent kid
got caught up in things.
Is Peavey working today?
Day off.
Do you have an address where we can find him?
Mm-hmm.
He lives with his mother.
He likes it here.
He could afford his own place.
Well, with rents in the city
being what they are
time enough when he gets married, huh?
I hope I live that long.
What, no prospects?
None that he tells me about.
Do you have any idea
where we can find him, Mrs. Peavey?
Well, is-is he in some trouble?
No, no, we just need to ask him
a couple of questions.
Oh.
His friend, Alsie, has a boat on City Island.
I think he said he was going there.
Thanks.
N-now you're sure h-he's not in any kind of trouble?
I ain't seen him.
His mother said he was coming over here.
I ain't seen him in over a month.
He's coming over here, it's news to me.
You two have a falling out?
Nah.
His mother gave us the impression
you were best friends.
What can I tell you?
I ain't seen him.
What do you go for on this thing?
Ah, fluke, weakfish.
The blues are running
we go for them.
George go out with you?
Hey, used to.
We used to go out together all the time.
What happened?
I don't know what happened.
He, uh, he lost his interest in fishing.
Said it was the same thing as hunting
which he also don't want to do anymore.
He say why?
Ah, it was taking a life.
I said, I ain't exactly up nights worrying
about the life of a fluke.
What did he say to that?
He got mad at me-- he says, uh, there's
enough other protein sources on the planet
so we don't need to slaughter animals.
And I know he didn't come up with that on his own.
Turns out, he's seeing some girl.
She's into all that no meat, no leather kind of thing.
Anyway, that was the last time he came around here.
Whoever did it
do you actually think they meant to kill anyone?
Letting diseased animals out of their cages?
That could be considered a little risky.
They're diseased because they were injected with a virus.
Where can we find George?
I have no idea.
Do you realize that interfering with a criminal investigation
is a felony?
I'm not interfering with anything.
If you're helping him, you're interfering.
Are you guys trying to intimidate me?
'Cause if you are, it's not working.
When's the last time
you saw George?
I don't know
last week sometime.
Are you two romantically involved?
That's none of your business.
If you'll excuse me, I'm late for class.
Hey, Ms. Walden... if people start getting bit by these animals
your friend's going to go to the top of the FBI's most wanted list.
I don't know what friend you're talking about
but anyone who cared enough about those animals to rescue them
would make sure they're not running around loose.
They'd make sure they were safe.
Well, we'll pass along your assurances
to the people in Washington.
He's not showing up for work
his mother doesn't know where he is
or at least that's what she says.
Well, Maxine's the key.
We sit on her, he'll show up.
I'll talk to the DA about a wire tap.
We're thinking he might've tried to place the monkeys
in a refuge of some kind.
Well, we're going to check the tri-state area
for any complaints involving nondomestic animals.
Great, that might at least tell us
who'd be willing to take them.
Vietnamese pot-bellied pig breeder.
Oh, now doing time for mail fraud.
Faye Ireland.
Who's that?
One of the queens of the tight sweater movies.
She's running an animal refuge in Putnam County.
Had a tiger get out and terrorize the neighborhood.
You want to meet her, Lennie?
I was thinking she might know something about the monkeys.
I had a chimp that got rescued from a circus
but he died last year.
And that was it for the primates.
Well, we thought maybe somebody contacted you
looking to place some spider monkeys.
These were the monkeys that were rescued
from the lab?
That's right.
I'm sorry, I can't help you.
Well, where would somebody who rescued monkeys go?
If they were responsible
they'd find an animal refuge
run by someone who knew what they were doing.
How many places are there like that in this area?
Not enough given how many animals
are out there needing rescuing.
Could you provide us with a list of names?
These people do what they do
because of their love for animals.
Now, w-we're all vulnerable to problems with neighbors.
We don't really like to call attention to ourselves.
You found me.
I'm not going to help you find anyone else.
Ms. Ireland...
unless we find these monkeys by tomorrow morning
there're going to be
men from Washington
standing right where I'm standing now.
They're going to turn your place upside down.
They're going to quarantine your animals
and they're not going to take no for an answer.
You're in a world of trouble here, guys.
I have no idea what you're talking about.
All we were told was the monkeys needed a home.
Where were you told they came from?
From an animal trainer.
Is this the animal trainer that called you?
It was someone who got them away from the animal trainer.
Then they were stolen.
No, no, no
they were rescued.
We didn't delve into where they came from.
We were told they needed at least a temporary home.
We agreed to provide them with a temporary home.
We quarantined them away from the other animals.
We had them examined by a vet.
We were taking
care of them.
We know something about taking care of HIV infections.
Who brought them here?
Oh, he-he didn't give a name.
What did he look like?
Ordinary-looking.
I wouldn't know him again if I fell over him.
You two better
get your things together.
We're going to take a little ride into Manhattan.
Why? Receiving stolen property.
Listen, all we do is take care of sick and abused animals.
You can tell all that to the DA.
Right now you're under arrest.
No, no, we can't leave without providing care
for the animals.
We can't help you with that.
No?
Well, then I hope you're prepared
to subdue me by force
because I'm not leaving my animals.
We can do that.
Uh, damn it.
What is it that you want from us?
We just want to know
who brought you the monkeys.
His name's George.
Where's George, Mrs. Peavey?
Did you ever stop and think
that-that maybe
somebody left those cages open
by accident?
You know, you're not helping your son
by concealing where he is.
He's a grown man.
He don't tell me where he's going.
Mrs. Peavey...
lying comes naturally
to some people.
You're not one of those people.
He's so mixed up.
We're not going to hurt him.
He's at his friend Alsie's.
George Peavey
this is the New York City Police Department.
Please come out with your hands above your head.
If you do not come out
the boat will be boarded
and you'll be taken off by force.
Put your hands behind your back.
It's a lousy day for a boat ride, anyway.
How tough do you think it's going to be
to prove that you were the one that broke into the lab?
I don't know. You ought to consider it, don't you think?
Whoever broke into the lab caused Ronald Lee's death.
Maybe by accident they did.
I don't think the DA's going to
see it that way.
The more cooperative, whoever broke
into the lab is, the better it's going to be for them.
I don't think I
should say anything.
And the better it's going to be
for Maxine.
What does this have to do with Maxine?
Come on, George.
No, uh...
no, she didn't break into the lab.
She didn't plan it with you?
No!
She didn't put the idea into your head
that these monkeys needed to be freed from these cages.
That they needed to be rescued
from the experiments that were being done to them.
Oh, she never said that.
We think she did.
She's a committed animal rights activist.
And we can prove the two of you were romantically involved.
From there it's just connect the dots
until we charge her with conspiracy.
No, I don't want you to charge her with anything.
She didn't do anything.
Are you saying you did this
all on your own?
Yeah.
Yeah, that's what I'm saying.
We'll want a full written statement to that effect.
We have a confession
that he broke into the lab
with the intention of freeing
the monkeys.
What are we charging him with?
Man Two. Isn't that a little steep?
He had knowledge of the health hazard they posed.
He knew one got loose.
He did nothing about it.
I think it's the correct charge.
Can we make it stick?
I think we can.
If you're talking about pleading to, uh, Burglary Three
Trespassing, I'll even throw in Criminal Mischief
we're all ears.
Bring in culpability for the death of that researcher
forget it.
A researcher working on developing an AIDS vaccine
dies as a direct result of your client's actions.
Are you really that confident about taking that to a jury?
Oh, you're a long way from establishing
the result was anything like direct.
Monkey is let out of cage, monkey bites man, man dies.
How much more direct do you want it?
That's not the way the jury will see it.
How will the jury see it?
George Peavey's heart was in the right place.
If his head was a little slow in catching up
that's no reason to send him
to prison.
Criminally negligent homicide-- going once...
going twice...
Pass.
See you in court.
Did you perform the autopsy
on Ronald Lee, Dr. Rodgers?
I did.
What did you determine was the cause of death?
Anaphylactic shock
brought about by a reaction to an antigen
carried in the saliva of a monkey.
Were you able to determine
how Dr. Lee came to be exposed to this saliva?
He was bitten.
Were you able to determine which monkey bit him?
The bite marks matched those of the monkey
found at the scene.
Thank you, Dr. Rodgers.
I have nothing further.
Is a monkey bite always fatal, Doctor?
No.
What made it fatal this time?
Dr. Lee had a reaction
to something in the saliva.
It would seem to be an odd choice of employment
for him to be working with monkeys if he was allergic
to them, would it not?
Objection. Irrelevant.
I will allow it.
He didn't have to have
a preexisting allergy to have the reaction he did.
Were there any signs that the monkey attacked Dr. Lee?
No.
In fact, a single bite on the hand
would suggest
that it was Dr. Lee reaching for the monkey
when he was bitten, isn't that correct?
I don't know enough about primate behavior
to comment on that.
So, had Dr. Lee not been trying
to grab the monkey
and had he not been allergic to the degree that he was
we probably wouldn't be here today, would we, Doctor?
Probably not.
In that case, we're done.
Redirect, Your Honor.
Dr. Rodgers
according to your familiarity with the crime scene
was the monkey in or out of its cage
when Dr. Lee was bitten?
Out.
Nothing further.
You were
Mr. Peavey's supervisor, is that right?
Yes.
Had Mr. Peavey worked in the immediate vicinity
of where the monkeys were kept?
Yes, he had.
Are there signs saying
that the monkeys are biologically hazardous?
Yes, there are.
Had you ever brought it
to Mr. Peavey's attention
that some of the monkeys were infected
with a highly virulent strain
of the AIDS virus?
I brought it to the attention
of every man I had working for me.
I never wanted them to forget it.
Why'd you do it, George?
Well, the monkeys had been given
this experimental AIDS vaccine
and they were starting to inject them
with the AIDS virus.
Now, nobody knew if the vaccine would work
and everybody expected
that probably
most of the monkeys would die
and I didn't think that was right.
Did you make
any kind of arrangements for the monkeys
after you took them out of the lab?
Uh, I arranged
with this animal refuge place to take them.
What did those arrangements entail?
I gave the two guys with the refuge
uh, $15,000 to cover the cost
of caring for them.
Where did you get the money?
I had a '64 Impala that was my dad's.
Uh, one owner, always garaged.
Uh, I sold it.
When, uh, my dad was dying
and it got so my mom couldn't take care of him anymore
uh, we put him in a hospice
and so they could take care of him...
uh, and they made it easier on him.
And I wanted some place that would do the same
for the monkeys.
Did you know Ronald Lee, George?
Yes.
How'd you feel about the fact that he died?
Objection. How the defendant feels
is irrelevant.
Sustained.
Okay, Mr. McCoy, if that's the case
I have no further questions.
What did you do after that monkey escaped, Mr. Peavey?
I tried to catch him.
For how long did you try?
Oh, I don't know.
Um, 15 minutes, 20 minutes.
I imagine you were fearful of being caught
if you stayed too long
were you not?
Yes, sir.
So, after 15 or 20 minutes, you left.
Yes, sir.
Did you call the authorities
and alert them
there was a monkey loose?
No.
You told no one that a monkey infected
with a deadly virus was out of its cage
and that anyone entering that lab
was vulnerable
to being bitten and infected?
Objection.
Asked and answered.
I know I should have.
I... you know, I didn't think the monkey would bite anyone.
I... you know, I-I looked at his face
when he was out and jumping around
and you know, he-he just seemed so happy to be out of that cage.
If he was so happy
what kept you from catching him
and taking him with you to the animal refuge?
Your Honor, there's an objection
before the court.
Was it fear of being bitten?
Move on, Mr. McCoy.
At what point did you inform the authorities, Mr. Peavey?
Never.
I have nothing further.
What's the, uh, sympathy factor for the defendant
going to amount to?
Hopefully less than for a victim
who dedicated his life to AIDS research.
So, we're feeling fairly confident, are we?
Yes, we are.
Oh, thanks.
Peavey's moving for a substitution of counsel.
It's the defendant's desire
to present a defense with which I don't agree
and am not competent to prepare.
As such, I'm asking the court
to relieve me as counsel.
You've been around a long time, Howard.
What's the defense that you're not competent to prepare?
I think Mr. Oyler is in a better position to explain it.
Well, simply put, Your Honor
it's essentially an expansion of self-defense.
Give me that again.
A justification defense is available
when someone uses force
under the reasonable belief
it was necessary to defend themselves
or others.
Other persons.
Mr. Peavey was of the belief the circumstances required him
to take the actions he did.
Tell me, Counselor, that you're not asking me
to be the first judge in history
to rule that monkeys are persons.
Well, much as it's my feeling that such a position
would be entirely well-founded morally
that's not what I'm asking.
Good.
Since a defense of justification
turns on reasonableness of belief
not objective criteria, the only question is
whether or not the defendant
was reasonable in his beliefs that the monkeys
were entitled to be saved.
Your Honor, the law of justification defense
does not pertain to the defense of monkeys.
The reasonableness
of the defendant's belief is irrelevant.
135 years ago
justification defense didn't pertain
to the defense of slaves.
The law, Your Honor... evolves.
I want to go on record as saying that I do not believe
the word "others" in the statutory language
"defense of others"
refers to monkeys.
What I believe, however
does not provide a conclusive basis
for dismissing the argument.
That said, I'm going to leave it to the jury
to decide whether or not the defendant's actions
were reasonable.
You've got your forum, Counselor.
I trust you'll use it to serve your client...
and not your cause.
Who's picking up the tab for this?
A defense committee was established
by a few animal rights organizations.
For them it's a test case.
What do we know about the lawyer?
He clerked for Harry Blackmun.
He made partner at Stroock.
He took a major pay cut
to do animal rights law full-time.
He's going after a lot of legitimate people
with this.
It has to be taken seriously.
Your honor, I renew my objection
to this witness being qualified as an expert.
Mr. Oyler?
He's a full professor of bio-ethics
at a major university.
He's published over 20 books.
His field of expertise is irrelevant to this case.
His field of expertise is central to our case.
Due to the nature of this case
I'm going to allow for a more liberal set of criteria.
The witness can testify.
Are you familiar, Professor
with the experiments being performed on the monkeys
at the lab where Ronald Lee worked?
I am.
What's your view of them?
My view is
that acts of unspeakable cruelty were being committed.
Is it not a well-settled principle
that animals are necessary to scientific research?
It's a well-settled principle that they're available.
Objection. What does any of this have to do
with the defendant's actions in this case?
Your Honor, the witness is here
to challenge the underlying assumption
whereby animals are held captive and made to suffer.
Now, unless we're given a credible basis with which to challenge that
the defendant's actions cannot possibly be justified.
I'll allow it... to a point.
Dr. Serafian
would you change your position
if the research done on the monkeys
produced an AIDS vaccine?
I believe there are other ways of conducting research
that don't require
the torture and slaughter of animals.
If I told you we could cure cancer
by sacrificing ten infants for research
would you approve?
I'll make it easier--
ten convicted murderers.
In either case, as a society
we wouldn't allow it.
The life and liberty of a human being is inviolate.
On what basis are the lives of animals deemed less so?
The underlying belief
that animals are not possessed of a soul has provided it.
How do you view the actions of George Peavey ethically?
I view the death of Mr. Lee as regrettable and tragic.
I view the actions of Mr. Peavey
as courageous and profoundly moral.
No further questions.
I'd like to ask you
a few questions about your writings, Professor.
"One commits a greater offense against nature
by killing a healthy primate than a severely retarded child."
You've taken that out of context.
Put it in any context you like.
What I'm attempting to put across
is that a healthy primate
can experience both pain and the anticipation of pain
more acutely than a severely retarded infant.
Hence the primate suffers more.
And to you, the suffering of the primate
is more offensive than the suffering of the infant.
They're both offensive to me.
I'm not opposed to one and indifferent to the other.
"In an enlightened time
"the liberation of animal experimentation labs
"will be viewed as having the same moral imperative
as the liberation of Buchenwald."
The moral imperative is to end suffering.
In that, they are the same.
And so, there is as much justification
for the killing of an AIDS researcher in a primate lab
as there is for the killing of a guard
in a concentration camp.
I can think of circumstances
where that would be the case, yes.
Thank you, Professor.
I have nothing further.
I started talking to George
about animals being more than just property.
I told him how Gandhi said
you judge a civilization by how it treats animals.
You could tell it was the first time
he ever heard that kind of thing.
Did it seem to have an effect on him?
It's hard to say.
I knew he liked me.
I kind of figured
he was telling me whatever he thought
would do him the most good.
Did there come a time
when you felt that the effect was genuine?
It was when I told him about the pigs.
Would you tell the court what that was.
Experiments were conducted
on how severe burns affect pigs' appetites.
The pigs were tied down fully conscious
and burned with blowtorches.
I showed him a videotape of it.
He hasn't been the same since.
Ask to admit said videotape into evidence.
Objection. May we approach?
Counsel may approach.
This is irrelevant.
It's prejudicial.
It's pandering by the use of shock value
with no possible relation to the case at hand.
We're trying to demonstrate
the defendant's state of mind, Your Honor.
By showing pigs being burned with blowtorches.
It's what he saw. That's what was being done.
It's not what was being done to these monkeys at this lab.
It's collateral evidence, Mr. Oyler.
It doesn't come in.
Step back, please.
No further questions.
You had discussions with the defendant
about the welfare of these monkeys in specific
did you not?
Many of them.
And is it fair to say that the gist of these discussions
was that these monkeys would be better off
pretty much anywhere other than where they were?
I think you could say the same thing
about anyone who's locked in a cage and injected with AIDS.
In the course of these discussions
was mention ever made of the hazards to human beings
if these monkeys were released from their cages?
I'm sure George didn't intend
for any humans to be exposed to them.
Was it ever discussed?
No.
It didn't occur to you
that if these monkeys were released or transported
there was at least a chance
that something would go wrong and someone would be exposed?
No, it didn't. It didn't occur to either one of us.
Do you think maybe it should've?
Sustained. Objection.
Nothing further.
Dr. Tong
take us through what happens to the monkeys in your lab.
Take us through
if you will, how you obtain them
what you do with them
what happens when you're done with them.
We obtain them from large commercial breeding colonies.
We inoculate them with the vaccine.
We then inject half of them with an active AIDS virus
and keep half of them as a control group.
What happens to the monkeys injected with the virus?
Thus far we've had some reasonably promising results.
There was substantial T-cell production
in response to the virus, which would indicate
that the animals were fighting off the infection.
Has it ever happened
that some of these animals
notwithstanding this wonderful vaccine
have succumbed to the infection?
Yes, it has.
What's been your response on those occasions?
Well, once it's clear that the animal has contracted AIDS
it's our policy to put the animal down.
When you say "put the animal down"
you mean kill the animal?
That's right.
How do you do that?
We inject them
with a lethal mixture of ketamine and pentobarbital.
And you do this so they won't suffer.
That is exactly why we do it
and if they don't exhibit symptoms of AIDS
we care for them until they live out their lives.
Now, this may come as a surprise to you, Mr. Oyler
but the people who work with these monkeys
do everything possible to minimize their discomfort.
Everything, that is, short of not giving them AIDS.
Objection. Counsel is arguing with the witness.
Sustained.
Are you aware of the fact
the primates such as the ones used in your lab
are capable of highly advanced communication;
that they organize themselves
into families and communities?
Sustained. Objection. Irrelevant.
When you obtain these animals
from these large breeding colonies
you frequently obtain brothers and sisters and cousins.
Is that not a fact?
It's possible.
And when your experiments
call for uniformity of genetic material, you will, on occasion
obtain a mother and its offspring
is that not correct?
When that's what we're looking for, yes.
Then you're also probably aware
that when one of these monkeys
begins to exhibit symptoms of the AIDS virus
which you injected them with, these mothers, brothers
sisters and cousins are there to see it.
Objection. Speculation.
Sustained.
If it's not also objectionable speculation
I'd like to ask you, Doctor
when you put one of these suffering monkeys down--
when you kill it-- does that ever seem to register
on the mothers or the brothers or the sisters?
Animals are never put down in the same room as other animals.
So they're taken out of the room, never to return.
Yes.
Do you think that registers?
It's possible that it does.
I have no further questions.
Based on the number of jurors ordering hamburgers for lunch
I'd say we have more than a sporting chance.
Unless the meat-eaters start to feel guilty.
Well, we're there on the law
we're there on the facts.
I don't think they'll let him go on guilt.
Excuse me. I'm May Peavey.
I'm here to talk to you about my son.
Come in, Mrs. Peavey.
Thank you.
I don't want to take up too much of your time.
I know you're very busy.
How can we help you?
Well... I'm very worried
that the people my son is listening to...
they maybe don't have his best interests in mind.
Have you talked to your son about this?
No, he... he thinks I'm just overly protective...
or that I got something
against this Maxine, which I don't.
I'm just so worried about him.
I thought maybe... if you made him some kind of offer
he'd-he'd come to his senses.
We made him an offer.
That was before the trial started.
If anything, the attorney he has now
will be less receptive than the one he had before.
I'm asking, won't you just try?
If you're convicted of second-degree manslaughter
you'll be sentenced to five to 15 years.
Eligible for parole in five.
If you plead guilty
to criminally negligent homicide
you'll be sentenced to one to three years.
George?
Oh...
I thought you were the one who was supposed to answer them.
It's a reasonable offer
and I think you should consider taking it.
Could I talk to Maxine?
I'll get her.
George has asked to speak to you.
Where is he?
He's in the conference room.
You can come with me.
Apparently, he looks to you for guidance.
George actually knows his own mind pretty well.
Does he?
If I take their offer
I could be out in as little as a year.
If we go to the jury, we don't know what'll happen.
Isn't that right?
Pretty much.
I think you should take their offer.
Well, that doesn't do much for this being a test case.
There'll be other test cases.
This was supposed to be a perfect one, though.
You've done enough
for the cause of animal rights, George.
No one's going to hold it against you if you want
to take their offer.
She told me about this guy, John Brown
who made this raid at Harpers Ferry
to steal guns
to free slaves.
You ever hear of him?
Apples and oranges.
Pretty brave guy.
Yeah, he was.
What would he do?
You've got to make this decision for yourself.
Thank you for your offer, Mr. McCoy.
I'll stand trial.
There can be no argument
but that what George Peavey did, he did out of conscience.
This was not a crime of vengeance or greed.
His action was motivated solely by the compassion he felt
for the suffering of another living creature.
We're not accustomed to worrying about suffering
when it's other than human suffering.
We think nothing of killing animals
to mount their heads over our mantles
or to test for hair spray
and when objections are raised
the people raising them are mocked as kooks
hopelessly outside the mainstream
because the basic unassailable principle
that allows for us to take animals
and do whatever we want with them
is that they're property.
Much like a lump of coal or a plank of wood
or a truck or a shovel or a hammer or a nail
belongs to its owner
so, too, does an animal.
I'd like to remind you of a time
in the not too distant past
when that same distinction was drawn
based on the color of one's skin
when Africans were packed into ships like cordwood
and brought to this continent as property of their owners
and they had no rights
and their suffering did not matter
and anyone who objected was a kook
and outside the mainstream.
My client is one such person.
He saw suffering
and he sought to end it.
That his efforts brought about the unanticipated tragedy
in the death of Ronald Lee
should not force us to criminalize his intent
because his intent was good and decent.
It was his belief
that to save an animal from suffering and death
would be an action held reasonable
by any enlightened society.
I believe one day our society will be so enlightened.
I hope and pray that day is today.
In the middle of the 14th century
there was a plague in Europe
that killed some 25 million people--
about a third of the population.
It was carried by fleas
who were infected with a bacteria
that was carried by rats.
We call those animals pests or vermin
and we take considerable pains to see to it
that their populations are kept in check.
We do this whether it results in their suffering or not
because to allow their population to go unchecked
risks another bubonic plague.
What does this have to do with a monkey confined in a lab?
The answer is that they both represent
how we as a society
value human life above nonhuman life
and proceed accordingly.
Does that mean
that we have no compassion for nonhuman suffering?
Not at all.
I believe the men and women in this lab
care deeply about these monkeys.
It's just that they care for the men, women and children
who suffer and die from AIDS more.
But, all of that--
all of it-- is beside the point.
How we treat animals, whether or not animals suffer--
that is not the issue.
The nobility of the defendant's motives--
that is not the issue.
The only issue in this case
is whether the defendant is criminally responsible
for the death of Ronald Lee.
There is no question the defendant willfully
knowingly broke into that lab
and took those virally infected monkeys out of their cages.
It was that action that created the potential for harm.
It was that action that caused
the death of Dr. Lee.
And so now...
I ask you to do what the law requires.
Has the jury reached a verdict?
We have, Your Honor.
What say you?
We find the defendant guilty.
Oh...
George...
George, I'm so sorry.
Man's dominion over the animals remains intact.
And a jury decides to follow the law.
And a hero is born.
[Captioning sponsored by STUDIOS USA TELEVISION
and NBC
Captioned by The Caption Center WGBH Educational Foundation]
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.