Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
In the criminal justice system In the criminal justice system
the people are represented
by two separate yet equally important groups:
the police, who investigate crime
and the district attorneys, who prosecute the offenders.
These are their stories.
...1-19, 1-19, 119.
Excuse me.
Excuse me.
Officers, there's a homeless woman...
There's a homeless woman at the end of the platform.
She's being eyed by some men
and I'm concerned that she's vulnerable.
What do you mean, "vulnerable"?
I mean, she's asleep on the bench
and she's vulnerable.
All right, lady, calm down.
Show us what you're talking about.
What are you looking at?
Come on, dear, rise and shine.
Hold on, Manny.
Oh, dear God.
How come they call the Squad
for a DOA on a subway platform?
Maybe it's a person of great renown.
Maybe they thought we didn't have anything else to do.
Come on, folks, let's go.
You two the ones found the body? Yeah.
Anybody see how it happened?
Not so far.
Cause of death?
Paramedic's best guess is, uh, cerebral hemorrhage.
There's an abrasion on her scalp--
maybe from a fall, maybe not.
They figure she's been dead about two hours.
Not much blood.
You got an I.D.?
M.E. gave us
a green light to tag and bag.
All I found were house keys, a Metrocard...
some kind of receipt.
No purse?
If she had one, it's gone.
Well-dressed... nails done.
She puts in an honest day's work
then waits for the Downtown Local to go home.
Yeah... and she caught the Express.
"Single blunt force trauma
to the vertex of the skull."
You know, it's hard to fall on the top of your head.
The hemorrhage was at the point of impact.
M.E. have any idea what was used?
Yep.
They found particles
of cement and asphalt in her scalp.
You mean like one of those paving stones?
Hey, they were working on the station.
That's what was laying around.
Looks like a hit-and-run.
All right. Thanks.
No one's filed a report with Missing Persons
fitting her description.
Which could mean she was from out of town.
Oh, that's just what we need:
"Female Tourist Beaten To Death On The Subway."
No, she was dressed more like a business woman than a tourist.
Metrocard ride history.
Thanks.
Let's see.
Repeated evening entries
at the station where the body was found...
corresponding morning entries at Franklin Street.
So, not a tourist.
We'll canvas with the photo
see if somebody can tell us who she is.
Sorry.
Her Metrocard indicates
that she came through here Tuesday morning.
Sorry.
Nothing about her jumps out? Sorry.
Is this
the only entrance?
For uptown service.
Downtown, you have to go across the street.
I know, you're sorry.
Excuse me, sir.
You here every day?
Rain or shine, boss.
Do you recognize this woman?
She don't look so good.
Well, you'll have to forgive her-- she's dead.
Take a look.
If she is the lady I'm thinking
she's a Wall Street Journal, a Times, New Yorker
Advocate.
Advocate?
A gay monthly.
You notice which way she comes from?
Oh, from across the street
and if she's the same lady, she always had a cup of coffee.
Thank you.
Two? Lennie: We're trying to put a name
to this woman's face.
We want to know if she gets her morning coffee here.
Sheila does the take-out.
Sheila, Sheila, come here a sec.
These, uh, police are looking for this broad.
We actually want to know if somebody recognizes her.
Yeah. I know her.
Comes in every morning for coffee.
Haven't seen her
in a few days.
Do you know her name? No.
What happened to her?
Do you know if she lived around here?
You're not going to tell me what happened?
She died.
Yeah, well... I can tell that from the picture.
Another person I know gone, and this one had kids.
How do you know that? Every other week
she's in here with new pictures
that she just picked up from next door.
Thanks. Yeah.
Maybe ours; maybe not ours.
Uh, what if somebody
doesn't pick them up right away?
In here.
It's dated two weeks ago.
The name on it's "Donnatelli."
Is there a first name
or an account number? Only last name.
Oh.
It's her.
There's a number six on the building.
We're going to need these.
$12.41.
I should pay?
Van Buren: How are we making out?
There's 17 Donnatellis listed in the book
none of them with an address in that neighborhood.
Well, I don't care if we have
to try her house keys door-to-door.
When The Post runs that picture on the front page
we're going to have a suspect.
Well, apparently, she takes an interest
in gay periodicals, if that's significant.
Hey, uh, Stephanie Donnatelli.
611 West 18 Street.
Hey, there's a six in the photograph.
DMV faxed us driver's license photos
of every female Donnatelli over 21.
Hmm.
If she lives on West 18 Street
why does she get the subway
at Franklin?
Good question.
Maybe we should see
who else lives at this address.
Yes?
New York City detectives.
Is this the home of Stephanie Donnatelli?
It's the home of her children and her ex-husband.
Why?
Uh, may we come up?
I wondered why I hadn't heard from her.
She was supposed to take the kids to a matinee.
You didn't call?
I figured she forgot...
even though it's not like her to forget
and I was pissed and surprised
I figured... she had a lot going on at work.
I didn't want to make a whole thing of it.
I should have called.
Steph never would have forgotten something involving the kids.
Where did she work?
She was a...
book editor at Arcade Publishing.
They're at 23rd and Broadway.
That's a block away from the subway.
Look, uh...
I know that, uh...
this is lousy time to ask questions like this
but... we have to know
who might have known your ex-wife.
Now, can you tell us anything about her private affairs?
You mean, like, her sex life?
Anything at all.
At the age of 30
Stephanie came to the conclusion
that she was gay.
She still loved me.
I still loved her.
She adored her kids.
We just needed
to stop living together as husband and wife.
Was she involved with anyone?
She hadn't been for a long time.
This last month or so
she's called me up on the phone at night
and we've talked and talked and...
she's told me how... how lonely she is.
We're really sorry for your loss.
Can you think of anything
she might have had with her--
jewelry, a watch, an address book?
Uh... she had a... one of those funny watches
a Swatch watch, I think it is
with Winnie-the-Pooh on it.
She had different pins, different bracelets.
There wasn't one that she wore all the time.
Uh...
There was a-a cross that my mother gave her--
a little gold cross
that she did wear all the time.
Yeah, we showed the photograph
around some bars near where she lived.
No one recognized her
and the ex-husband says that wasn't her scene.
So, if some nut case goes after a woman with a paving stone
its the Konchalavsky woman all over again.
They guy went away, right?
It's a copycat.
Right. Thanks.
Well, apparently, even though she's dead, her credit isn't.
Somebody used her American Express card.
You don't check I.D.s.?
Well, it's the cashier's responsibility
to do that.
I don't know what happened in this instance.
The transaction record says
the credit approval came in at 11:43.
Okay. Fast forwarding.
I take it those persons don't have authorization
to use that credit card.
Ooh, you're good.
I'll make a copy of the tape.
No. We'll make a copy.
We're sure the cashier didn't know them?
We talked to her on the way out.
She said no.
Well, when you do find the girls
I want you to add a charge of felony bad taste.
Wearing white after Labor Day?
Someone just used the card again.
Movie theater-- 107th and Broadway.
I don't even know you.
How was the movie, ladies?
Do I know you?
No, but I know you.
You're both under arrest
for possession of stolen property.
Let's go.
I found that card.
Sure, and it just happened to be in the pocket
of the woman it belonged to.
Please!
Let me break it down for you, sweetheart.
That card belonged to a woman
who is now dead.
She was murdered on her way home from work.
We don't know nothing about that.
Possession of a stolen
credit card's a felony.
If you didn't commit the murder yourselves
you're at least an accessory after the fact.
Book 'em on that, and take 'em up to Central.
Hold up! Wait a minute!
We didn't...
We have no choice.
They're just messing with us.
You think?
What time's the next wagon leave for Central booking?
About 15 minutes.
Add these two to the list.
Wait a minute! Wait! Hold up!
Darlene, don't you say nothing.
I can't be going through this.
I got to graduate junior college.
Who gave you the card?
Don't you say nothing, Darlene.
Trey Wiles gave us that card.
Who's Trey Wiles?
Her boyfriend, and he works
in shipping on 7th Avenue and 39th street.
She's a spiteful bitch!
She know Trey ain't had nothing to do with this.
You still going to put us on that wagon?
Keep it coming.
Trey Wiles? Yeah.
Put your hands behind your back, bro.
Hey, what's up with this?
Some questions came up about your credit rating.
Yeah, we want to find out
if you're eligible for the Gold Card.
Yo, come on, man.
My boss finds out about this
I'm going to lose my job.
Oh, you got bigger troubles than that, kid.
The American Express card you gave Shantay
belonged to a woman who was murdered.
Mm-hmm. For real?
Where'd you get it?
Hey, look, man, I don't know nothing about no murder.
Okay. Here's the deal, Trey.
If I have to put your ass in the back of this car
and drive down to the precinct
you're going upstate
so, you tell us who gave you the card
and you just had a bad day
and you're home by supper.
All right, I'll tell you where I got it.
I bought it. From who?
Street dude.
"Street dude." What's his name?
Raffi something
or something Raffi, man. I don't know.
He's a homeless dude.
Lives in the shelter on 127th.
Comes around here every now and then
sells stuff.
That's all, man.
You better hope he's sleeping in today.
Ah, he's under me.
I'm the chief administrator here.
We're looking for a certain guest
of this establishment, a Raffi something?
Raffi Lorraine?
How many Raffi's you got?
Ten beds back on the left.
Thanks.
Raffi Lorraine?
Come on, man. It ain't time yet.
Early checkout today. Come on.
What did I do?
This your stuff? Yeah.
You want to take it with you?
Where am I going?
For a ride with us.
You want to take it with you or not?
If I don't, it wont be here when I get back.
Do you mind if I take a look?
Go ahead.
There's no weapons or anything
that might hurt me?
No.
This yours?
Yes, sir.
Buttons from the wrong side, chief.
I'm not picky about such matters.
Where'd you find it?
Garbage can.
Why would somebody throw away
a beautiful coat like this, huh?
People with money get tired
of their clothes sometimes.
They get tired of their gold crosses, too?
Token clerk tells us you're a regular, Raffi.
Yeah. And you're a real pain in the ass
to all the passengers.
I don't bother nobody.
The woman that cross belonged to was beaten to death.
Do you understand?
I didn't do that.
Hey, we got you on the subway platform
and we got you with the victim's possessions.
Now, you have something to say
because the train's about to leave the station?
I saw who killed her.
You sure it wasn't you?
He was a black guy.
Maybe 30, 40.
One of them buggy guys, goes off on you.
Yeah? What did you see this buggy guy do?
He was walking around talking to himself.
Walking one end of the platform to the other.
The train comes in, people get on
except for that guy.
And you.
I'm working that platform.
I've got garbage to go through.
Okay. What did you see?
This gal comes through the turnstile.
Stood near where the guy was.
And all of a sudden, he hits her with a rock!
She walks a little ways away from him
she grabs her head, drops down to a bench
and he walks over
and he grabs her eyeglasses off of her
and then he walks right out of the station.
And you robbed whatever you could off the body?
That is what I did.
I'm not proud of myself for doing it
but that is all that I did!
He knew about the paving stone.
Which doesn't guarantee him not being the one who used it.
His rap sheet's petty thefts and drugs.
I think he's telling the truth.
Okay. Well, why don't you run down this buggy black guy story?
There was an E.D.P. in the vicinity.
Maybe there was a complaint.
Officer Carlson?
Yeah.
Detectives Green, Briscoe.
Sarge told me you'd be coming around. What's up?
Uh, a few days ago
you responded to an E.D.P. in the subway.
Yeah. Guy took a leak on the platform.
Female passenger took exception.
No collar?
It would have just been a summons.
Why? What happened?
Uh, you think you could I.D. him?
What did he do?
We're looking at him for a homicide.
I don't believe it.
Did you get a name?
He wouldn't give us a name.
We tried to take him to a shelter, but he refused.
Manager of an SRO
on Eighth Avenue owes me a favor.
Took him over there.
Somebody's in there.
New York City Police Department.
Open up.
Got a key?
It's okay. It's okay.
Take it easy.
All right. Come on.
We're going to get you up now.
Need to take you out of here.
Where you taking me?
To the Police Department.
We need to talk to you.
I need to finish what I'm doing.
Oh, you'll have plenty of time.
Don't worry.
Where is he?
Interrogation Room.
He's refusing to be fingerprinted.
I figure, we didn't want to force the issue
and have him lawyer up.
Okay, thanks.
You're welcome.
Sir, my name is Abby Carmichael.
I'm an Assistant District Attorney.
I understand there's some problem
with you letting us fingerprint you.
Sir?
Oh, oh, hold it! Whoa!
He does that every so often.
I need to go outside.
Okay. Sure.
But before you do, I want to talk to you
for a little while.
Is that all right?
The air in here is bad.
I need to go outside.
Can you tell me where you got your glasses?
I needed them.
I couldn't see who was talking to me.
Did you take them from the woman on the subway?
I couldn't see who was talking to me
so that's why I took 'em.
Now, I need to go outside.
Before I can let you
go outside, I need to know
who you are.
I'm... Regis Philbin.
Is that your final answer?
Okay, how about this?
You let us fingerprint you
and when the prints come back
they'll confirm you're Regis Philbin
and then everyone will know.
How does that sound?
Brian Gallant.
Three misdemeanor convictions
all involving some violence.
He got out of Rikers a week ago.
Tell me he didn't get bail.
The court remanded him at his arraignment
for a 7-30 exam.
Is he competent?
Assuming Regis Philbin
and all the other nutsy stuff isn't an act
I'd say borderline.
This also may not be
the first attack he's responsible for.
Do you remember the attack on that Konchalavsky
woman last year?
Don't tell me.
Confessed.
Matches the composite.
Okay. I don't want to rely on the civil commitment
to keep him of the streets.
Find out who's doing his evaluation.
Make sure we talk to them
before they write their report.
Got it.
Then let's talk to his lawyer.
Okay.
You have no forensics linking him to the crime.
He was in possession of the victim's eyeglasses.
Somebody else had the victim's coat.
Somebody else had the victim's credit card.
We also have a witness.
A homeless drug addict with a criminal record
from here to Bayonne.
Mr. Gallant made admissions
to two separate attacks.
Counselors, we all know he wasn't competent
to waive counsel.
The psychiatrist thinks he is competent.
Sure. They shovel medication into him--
he's competent.
He killed the mother of two children.
Doesn't that enter into this for you?
What are you looking for?
Manslaughter, first degree.
Because that's what you think he's guilty of
or it looks good on your resume?
You're kidding, right?
Tell me he's not insane, Jack.
I'll tell you
you're not getting him off based on that.
He stole property and ran.
And flight's the one indicator
jury's love to rely on
when they reject an insanity defense.
So it doesn't matter whether or not he's insane.
What matters most is
he doesn't get to do this again.
Look at him, guys.
That's the master criminal
you're looking to unleash your prosecutorial zeal on.
There's a ten-year-old and an eight-year-old
who just found out
they don't have a mother anymore.
Maybe you'd like to come
take a look at them.
Anything less than Man One possible?
Man One's it.
Your Honor, I'm handing up the psychiatric report
confirming this defendant's competency to enter
a plea of guilty
to manslaughter in the first degree
in the death of Stephanie Donnatelli
and assault of the first degree arising out of an attack
on Nadine Konchalavsky.
You're satisfied
with this report, Mr. Jordan?
Yes, I am, Your Honor.
Very well.
Mr. Gallant, you understand that by pleading guilty
you'll be sentenced to a period of ten to 20 years.
Yes.
Did you kill Stephanie Donnatelli?
I need you to answer for the stenographer.
Yes.
Did you attack Nadine Konchalavsky?
Yes.
Can you tell us why you committed these crimes?
No reason.
Uh, Mr. McCoy
I assume a motion to vacate
the charges against the individual
currently incarcerated
for the attack on Miss Konchalavsky
has been filed.
It has, Your Honor.
He'll be released as soon as I let
corrections know we're done.
We're done.
We're done?!
Please, Mr. Donnatelli.
You guys declare yourselves done and you're done?
You say the one and only person responsible
for Steph getting killed is this lunatic?
You put a line through it on your list
and then you pat yourselves on the back!
Mr. Donnatelli, I understand you're upset
but this isn't the time
or the place to address these things.
Tell me what is the time and place, and I'll be there!
Tell me when you're going to hold someone accountable
for turning him loose on Steph...
and I'll be there.
He did a year?
Misdemeanor assault.
He was released
the night before he killed Stephanie Donnatelli.
He was dropped off
at the Queensboro Plaza subway station
at midnight with a token and a dollar and a half.
Who made that call?
Standard operating procedure.
We know from his medical chart
that he made 11 visits to the jail's clinic
which... means it's a safe bet someone knew something
about his mental condition.
Yeah. What did they know, and when did they know it?
Still... it's a long way
from civil negligence
to criminal liability.
Yes, it is.
Well, before we go
after the Department of Corrections
or Psychiatric Services
or whoever it is who's responsible for this
I'd like to know we have a chance at winning.
We have some work to do before you make that call.
These are the inmates treated at Rikers clinic
in the first six months of last year.
These are the inmates treated in the last six months.
Quite a disparity.
That's because they stopped
referring prisoners to hospitals.
Why?
Six months ago
the City privatized medical treatment at Rikers.
An HMO for inmates.
They gave a managed-care contract
to a company called SMJ Medical Services.
SMJ gets a monthly bonus
when it holds down costs.
Which it does
by not sending inmates to hospitals.
Which is why Brian Gallant was never referred.
Leon Greg--
thirty-four.
He was awaiting trial for robbery
and his weight dropped 30 pounds
in less than two months.
Your medical treatment consisted
of giving him an aspirin.
Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa.
This is the Chief Executive Officer of the company.
Our understanding is not that you're here
to conduct an open-ended inquiry into inmate diagnosis.
In the past six months
four inmates have died at the Rikers clinic
three without ever seeing the inside of a hospital.
Those six months correspond
to the period SMJ was hired to oversee
the jail's medical services.
That's not fair.
Are the terms of your client's contract such
that he receives a bonus
for denying a prisoner access to a hospital?
Absolutely not.
He receives
a certain amount of incentive pay
for successfully meeting targets
an arrangement recently upheld
by The United States Supreme Court, by the way.
Is it your reading
of Pegram v. Herdrich
that people like Brian Gallant can get released
without warning the authorities
without follow-up care?
Mr. Gallant had served his time.
My client had no choice.
Unless he was aware
of the danger Gallant posed.
I reviewed
the procedures followed in Mr. Gallant's case.
I believe they were, in all respects...
correctly implemented.
Doctor's prescription?
Jessie Dobbs?
Is there someplace we can talk?
What about?
Brian Gallant.
I've got nothing to say.
You were his Case Manager.
You were transferred here the day after he was arrested.
That's a grand jury subpoena, Ms. Dobbs.
Now we can either do this here or there.
What do you want?
I want to know who made the decision
for Brian Gallant to be released.
Miss, I am little person working for a big company.
It's a simple question.
You were at Rikers at the time.
And I'm not at Rikers anymore, am I?
Were you sent here
to keep you away from an investigation?
You'd have to ask them that.
If it was your decision to release him without meds
I can understand how they might want
to make sure you didn't make
the same mistake twice.
It wasn't my decision.
Then, whose decision was it?
According to Jessie Dobbs, you were the doctor responsible
for the treatment of inmates at Rikers.
I oversaw the clinic.
So for over a year, Brian Gallant was your patient?
I had limited contact with him
but, technically, I guess I was his doctor.
"Technically"?
I'm only at Rikers twice a week.
Most of his visits were handled by his Case Manager.
Are you suggesting
a Physician's Assistant's qualified
to diagnose his mental condition?
I-I-I didn't hear the word "qualified" in what he said.
He's describing
his contact with the patient.
It's his lack of contact
that concerns us.
11 visits
over a year's time, doctor?
On three occasions
Ms. Dobbs's notes indicate Gallant was complaining
of hearing voices, having hallucinations?
I-I gave him his medication.
But you never had him evaluated.
Don't respond.
Your lawyer's right.
Save your explanation for a jury.
On what charge?
Manslaughter
if he was aware of the danger Gallant posed
and recklessly ignored it.
Do you know how many inmates I see on any given day?
How many?
Don't respond. They want to try
to get an indictment, let them.
What are you, nuts?
Look... I did the best I could.
I was paying off medical school loans...
a mortgage.
I have two kids.
Doesn't excuse what you did, Doctor.
I wasn't allowed to have him evaluated.
You were told that?
Andrews fired a doctor for making too many referrals.
Same day, he calls me in.
He asks me if I heard about the firing
and if I was familiar with SMJ's policy
limiting referrals.
He told me, he hoped I didn't make the same mistake.
This is a very courageous man
you have sitting here.
I assume we'll be able to work something out.
If he testifies
his job was threatened, there won't be any charges.
I will ask him
to surrender his medical license for a year.
That's not right. That's not right.
He took an oath, and it wasn't to an HMO.
He was doing the best he could
under the circumstances.
S-Stop.
Brian Gallant was kept sedated.
without ever being referred out
for treatment or evaluation.
Was SMJ aware of the danger he posed
to the public?
Dr. Sanders will testify
that Phillip Andrews fired another doctor at Rikers
for excessive hospital referrals
and, then, threatened to fire him
if he did the same thing.
Which, of course, Phillip Andrews will deny doing.
If it comes down to credibility, I think we're in good shape.
No, it comes down to more than that.
If we go in there
and start taking potshots at HMOs, first of all
we're flying in the face of Pegram v. Herdrich
and, then, secondly, what if we prevail?
I mean, what does that do to a healthcare system
that depends on HMOs to provide their treatment?
You're not suggesting
we give them a free pass because of that?
No, I'm suggesting we look
at the fallout that's likely to ensue
and be sure and differentiate
the conduct of this HMO from the conduct
of HMOs in general.
That said, I'd like nothing better
than to hang their heads on our wall.
Phillip Andrews?
Yes?
You're under arrest for manslaughter
in the death of Stephanie Donnatelli.
"Manslaughter"? What is this, a prank?
No prank.
Then, there's been a big fat mistake.
Get your commanding officer on the phone.
I want to hear from him that I should be arrested.
On your feet, pal.
Your coverage doesn't provide
for a second opinion.
Gallant was a patient
at the clinic at Rikers Island?
Yes.
For what complaint?
He originally presented
with periodic auditory-command hallucinations
uh, some delusional behavior.
What was done for him?
He was given varying doses of Halcyon, Ativan and Valium.
Was he ever referred to a psychiatric hospital for evaluation?
No.
Why not?
Mr. Gallant didn't meet the criteria established
by my employer for a psychiatric referral.
Which criteria were those?
Mr. Gallant was
controllable with medication.
If I made the referral, I'd have been fired.
Objection. Introduces facts not in evidence.
Overruled.
Why do you say you would've been fired?
Objection. Calls for speculation. Overruled.
You're annoying me, Mr. Axtell.
Another physician at the clinic
had referred an inmate under a similar situation
and was terminated.
Phillip Andrews warned me
not to make the same mistake.
What was your last contact
with Mr. Gallant prior to his release?
That would've been on September 8.
What, if anything, transpired on that occasion?
I... I gave him his medication.
September 8 was four days before Mr. Gallant's release.
Yes.
Was he examined
on the day of his release?
No.
Was he given any medication
for him to take subsequent to his release?
No.
Why was that?
He wasn't SMJ's problem anymore.
Objection.
That's sustained.
Nothing further.
Dr. Sanders
to the best of your knowledge, Phillip Andrews
is not himself a doctor, isn't that right?
I don't believe he is, no.
So, you understood, did you not
that he relied on the determinations
of doctors, such as yourself
to assess treatment?
Yes.
Did you ever tell him you believed Brian Gallant
to be psychotic?
No, I didn't.
No.
Did you ever tell him
Brian Gallant constituted a threat to himself or others?
No.
Oh. Was that information on his chart?
No.
Was he supposed to sense it from crystals or magical beans?
Objection. Sustained.
Wasn't it your responsibility, Doctor, to tell him?
He wanted me to take care of it
the cheapest way possible, period.
The State Board of Review has revoked your license
to practice medicine, isn't that so, Doctor?
Yes.
I'll bet you got somebody else to blame
for that, too.
Objection.
Withdrawn.
I hear these voices inside my head.
Sometimes, it's worse than other times.
How was it during the time
you were incarcerated on Rikers Island?
Bad.
Did you bring that to the attention
of the prison doctor?
Yes.
What did he do?
Gave me medicine.
Were you ever examined by a psychiatrist?
No.
Did you ever ask
to be examined by a psychiatrist?
I told them I was having trouble with voices.
I told them it was keeping me up nights--
my bad uncle and my good uncle
saying about bringing the car down from Yonkers.
I said, "I ain't bringing no car down from Yonkers."
That's right.
On the day you were released...
were you given any medication?
No.
Thank you.
Nothing further.
What did you do with the token they gave you?
I used it.
Used it to go into Manhattan?
Where you hit a woman over the head
with a paving stone and killed her?
I'm sorry.
I know you say you're sorry, but...
you did know what you were doing, didn't you?
Objection. Irrelevant.
This man's state of mind
is what my client is on trial for, Your Honor.
No, Counselor.
Your client is on trial
for what he allegedly did.
I will allow you some leeway on cross.
On the day you pled guilty
to manslaughter, Mr. Gallant
did you or did you not, in front of this same judge
say that you were the person
responsible for the death of Stephanie Donnatelli?
Yes.
I'm done.
Redirect, Your Honor.
Mr. Gallant, can you tell us why you committed
this horrible crime?
My bad uncle.
Your bad uncle
told you to?
Yes.
Does he talk to you all the time?
No.
When doesn't he talk to you?
When I take my medicine.
Then he stays in Yonkers.
I have nothing further.
Three weeks ago, we said Brian Gallant was responsible.
Now we seem to be saying someone else is responsible.
That's got to hurt us.
He was found competent by a court-appointed psychiatrist.
If that psychiatrist hadn't found him competent
I would have found
another one who did.
It's called prosecuting.
In any event, this one could go either way.
You have a defendant
responsible for sending a dangerous psychotic
out among the citizens of New York.
Whatever excuses he has--
whatever excuses the two of you have
now that you've gone after him, I want you to run him to ground.
SMJ's is a for-profit company.
I'm not ashamed to admit that
but at no time did I ever allow finances
to dictate the course of medical treatment.
To what do you attribute the decline
in hospital referrals?
I attribute it
to improved medical service at the jail.
By focusing on efficiency
we've been able to cut the need for hospitalization.
What about in Brian Gallant's case?
I suspect Mr. Gallant's case
would present a challenge to any clinician.
Given that the severity of it was never communicated
to me, I was in no position to effectively
monitor his treatment regime.
Had it been...
maybe there would have been a different outcome.
Thank you.
Inmates diagnosed with heartburn
who turn out to have coronaries.
HIV patients left untreated.
Psych patients left unevaluated.
Is that your idea of improved medical service
Mr. Andrews?
I'm not satisfied with our diagnostic success rate.
And I think you're going to see
a steady improvement on that score.
What you have to keep in mind
is, we're still in the shake-out cruise
of a new program.
You're responsible for the bottom line
on the shake-out cruise are you not, Mr. Andrews?
Yes, I am.
And there's no question
but that the bottom line is helped
the fewer hospital referrals are made?
Like it or not, medical care is a business today.
No HMO can survive without conducting a realistic
cost-benefit analysis
of its treatment protocols.
Brian Gallant was treated 11 times.
Three violent altercations.
Another five visits
for irrational behavior.
Was your failure
to authorize even one psychiatric referral
part of the cost-benefit analysis?
I was relying
on the clinic physician's observations
to determine a course of treatment.
You had him on tranquilizers nonstop.
I didn't have him on anything.
That was Sander's call.
And by the way, according to his chart
he was responding to the medication.
So you were reviewing his medical chart?
Mr. Andrews?
Periodically, yes.
You were being kept aware
of his progress, or lack thereof
periodically?
Yes.
And you were authorizing his medication?
I was authorizing the expenditure.
I'm not the prescribing physician.
Tell the jury
what Mr. Gallant's complaint was
the last three times he was seen at the clinic.
There's no complaint indicated.
No complaint?
In a company
as cost conscious as yours
isn't it a fact
that the only reason
you would be spending money on medication
where there was no complaint
would be to prevent what was otherwise inevitable?
No.
Because you knew
that it was inevitable that without medication
Brian Gallant would become violent.
That's not true.
When the time came
you were only too happy to see him go
because a hospital stay or a psychiatric evaluation
would have been contrary to your cost-benefit analysis.
Objection. Counsel's making speeches.
Ask a question, Mr. McCoy.
Isn't it a fact, that you knew exactly what kind of danger
Brian Gallant posed upon being released?
I didn't know.
You didn't want to know.
The big bad HMO.
Uncaring, unfeeling.
Placing profits before people
in its savage quest to make money.
A convenient political target
if ever there was one.
Criminally responsible for one man killing another man?
Not on your life.
If there were an outbreak
of tuberculosis
or if prisoners were dying
due to negligent medical care
Phillip Andrews would have to answer for that.
If he took a money-be-damned approach
and dispensed medical care at Rikers Island
as if it were the Mayo Clinic
he would have to answer for that, too
and I might add...
answer to you, the taxpayers, as well.
So he does his job...
professionally
compassionately.
And for doing his job
they want to send him to jail.
A few short weeks ago
Brian Gallant pled guilty
to Manslaughter in the First Degree--
a plea that could only be entered
with the approval of this prosecutor.
And now, this same prosecutor
is back here with bigger fish to fry.
Don't let the political ambitions of a District Attorney
pervert this court of law.
Whatever political capital Mr. McCoy and his boss
can extract from it
don't let it be done to our system of justice.
Don't let it happen
to this innocent man.
No one should be heard to say
that providing medical care at Rikers Island is easy.
Nor is it the position
of this District Attorney's office that there aren't
legitimate financial constraints on the provider.
We've heard that the defendant
operating under those constraints
is just a simple man doing the best he could.
Let's look at that a little bit.
Brian Gallant was at Rikers for a year.
He was medicated on a daily basis
by the defendant's company
with the defendant's knowledge.
On the day he was released
he was hallucinating
and disoriented.
Nonetheless, he was handed over to the Department of Corrections
who dropped him off
at a subway station in the middle of the night.
He was given no medication
no referral for ongoing care.
Not an address to go to.
Not a phone number to call.
This was not done by accident or oversight.
This was the express instruction of the defendant.
Was not the violent behavior of Brian Gallant
a foreseeable event?
Was not the defendant well aware
not only of Mr. Gallant's propensities
but of the risk he constituted
for every person he came in contact with?
The answer is, of course he was aware of it.
Of course, he chose to ignore it.
Of course, it was his recklessness
that brought about
this woman's death.
Find him guilty, ladies and gentlemen.
He deserves it.
Madame Forelady, I understand the jury's reached a verdict?
We have.
On the first count of the indictment
charging Manslaughter in the Second Degree
we find the defendant not guilty.
On the lesser included charge
of Criminally Negligent Homicide
we find the defendant guilty.
Okay, bye-bye.
Dateline wants to interview me
about the verdict.
Jane Pauley or Stone Phillips?
Stone Phillips.
They'll probably try to get you to say
it opens the door to massive malpractice claims.
Well, it's worth it if it changes the way
HMOs do business in this city.
How much time will Andrews serve
with good behavior?
Under a year.
Good, that means jail, not state prison.
He'll serve it at Rikers.
Let's hope he has a good immune system.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.