Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
In the criminal justice system In the criminal justice system
the people are represented
by two separate yet equally important groups:
the police, who investigate crime
and the district attorneys, who prosecute the offenders.
These are their stories.
Why can't I come up?
No, that's what you said last night.
That's what you said the night before.
Hey, Kendra, man, I blew off the comp list at Justin's
because I thought I was going to see you
and now you're telling me your girlfriend's there...
I need your phone!
That's why I'm standing on the...
Hey, what are you, nuts?
My house is burning and my son's inside.
I need to report a fire.
The building's only 50% involved.
Our guys got here fast.
Not fast enough.
CO asphyxiation.
Never woke up.
What were the suspicious origins?
Some kind of accelerant was definitely used.
Is that the mother?
Yeah, Mrs. Parnell.
Mrs. Parnell, I'm Detective Briscoe.
This is Detective Green.
We're really very sorry about what happened.
Were there any other family members home at the time?
My daughter's at a sleepover.
It's good that she wasn't here.
Hey, hey, wait, hey
where do you think you're going?!
What happened? Who are you?
I'm Richie Zwick.
I have the store.
The store that's going out of business?
There's one store.
I have the store.
Sir, why don't you park your car?
We're going to need to take some information from you.
This is a friggin' disaster.
I got a delivery today of 200 Lladro.
Sir, you're in the middle of the street.
I just got the Leroy Nieman's series
of New York Yankee lithographs.
That's paper! It's burnt!
This woman just lost her son.
Shut your mouth
and move your car.
There's your accelerant.
Paint thinner.
Found it in the back hall.
Better stick close to Mr. Zwick, there.
He's going to be really upset when he finds out
there are people in this world
who'd deliberately cost him his lithographs.
Note the alligator char on the wall.
Wait, what is that?
Heavy char alternating with untouched area.
You get that when the fire's really running.
Are you sure somebody used paint thinner?
We're sending three stairs over to the lab.
I'm guessing we find accelerant on all of them.
Any idea which floor they were going for?
That's your department.
How long has this Jacques Ricard
been "going out of business"?
The neighbors say five years.
Well, maybe he decided it was time.
You had an electric fire a year ago
that you claimed a $275,000 loss from.
You had a flood the year before
to the tune of 400 grand.
No locusts?
Oh, cute.
You think I did it?
Destroy your own merchandise
to collect on the insurance?
No, you'd have to be pretty desperate to do that.
Yeah, you'd have to have
like, the State Sales Tax Authority
padlock your front door for non-payment.
That got straightened out.
Because you came into enough money
to pay off the arrears.
100%, and you know how I came into the money?
My partner went into hock to the shys
and don't ask me for any names
'cause I ain't moving to Montana
in the witness protection program.
Who's your partner?
Jack Anta-- Jacques Ricard.
Jack and Richie.
Why not?
He had a bypass.
He had to move to Florida.
I keep the name out of regard.
When did you get out?
What do you mean, when did I get out?
You didn't get those tattoos at a kid's birthday party.
When did you get out?
A year ago.
What were you in for?
Possession with intent.
Your boss ever ask you to do something
that might get you sent back?
No.
You know we're going to be looking pretty hard
for somebody who starts a fire that a kid dies in.
I don't know anything about that, man.
You know somebody who does?
That old woman sits in front of the building all day.
If she saw anybody around here last night
it wasn't me.
I got to get back.
I don't like telling tales, but, you know
you've got all kinds of characters on this block.
All kinds of sex business, drugs
people coming and going all hours.
Did you see anybody around last night
who might know something about the fire?
I got my theories.
Oh, yeah?
Yeah, like this one, with the store.
You saw somebody from the store around here?
Last night was my program, so I was watching the television
but this is what these people do.
They wait for some unsuspecting person
to come in from out of town so they can cheat them.
They're not nice.
And if they can't make a dollar any other way
they burn the place down.
All this poor woman's
been through until now, and now this.
What has she been through up until now?
Well, the handicapped son, the husband-- all of it.
What is it about the husband?
Well, I don't like to tell tales
but, I mean, there was a lot of problems.
When's the last time
you saw the husband?
Yesterday.
Come on, Katie, let's go get some ice cream.
Let me know if you need anything.
I don't know what I'd do
if I didn't have her as a friend.
Mrs. Parnell, what can you tell us
about your ex-husband?
What do you want to know?
Well, when was the last time you saw him?
I don't know, uh...
a few weeks ago, maybe.
What about last night?
Why do you ask that?
We were told that the two of you
used to quarrel quite a bit.
That's true.
Um, it's probably why we got divorced.
He wouldn't start a fire, though.
That fire probably started by something electrical.
That building had fuses blowing all the time.
What can you tell us about your son?
What do you mean?
What kind of condition did he have, exactly?
What difference does that make now?
Probably none.
It would just help us to understand the situation.
He had... developmental problems.
Um...
I had a difficult, um, pregnancy, and...
he had respiratory problems, and some learning disability.
Nothing that matters now.
Where can we find your ex-husband, Mrs. Parnell?
Colin's off today.
Did he call in sick?
That's what they tell me.
In other words, you haven't spoken to him yourself?
Me personally? No.
Who has heard from him?
Has anybody talked to Colin?
I talked to him.
Did he say where he'd be today?
No.
He just called in to say he wouldn't be in?
He told me what happened to his son
and said he wouldn't be in all week.
He left a phone number if I need to reach him.
Thank you.
Yeah?
Police Department.
We're looking for Colin Parnell.
Can you tell me what this is about?
We just need to ask him a few questions.
He's in the other room.
You Colin Parnell?
Yeah.
I'm Detective Briscoe.
This is Detective Green.
We'd like to speak to you.
About the fire?
Yeah. We'd like to fill in a couple of the blanks.
Not a lot I can help you with there.
Tough break about your son.
What are the blanks you'd like me to fill in?
It'd probably be better
if you came down off the ladder.
Okay?
When was the last time you spoke to your ex-wife?
I don't know.
I don't keep track.
When was the last time
you were over to her apartment?
A month, six weeks-- I don't know.
Not more recently than that?
No. Why--
did somebody see me?
Will that determine whether or not
you're going to tell us the truth?
I've gone to see my kids when they weren't there.
I wasn't counting those times.
Was yesterday one of those times?
Yeah, yesterday was one of them.
Does that make me a suspect?
Is this, uh, oil base or latex?
Oil.
You clean up with paint thinner?
Yeah, so what?
So wipe your hands.
You're going for a ride.
Let me explain something to you, Colin.
Somebody set the fire that killed your son.
That makes it a homicide, and that makes your life
and everybody else's life in that building our business.
You think I'd kill my son?
I don't know yet.
So what did you two used to fight about?
Everything, from the wrong brand of beer
to a towel left on the floor
to whether or not we'd be better off
with Ian living someplace else.
Because of a learning disability?
Is that what Megan called it?
Yeah, a learning disability
with some respiratory problems.
Ian was borderline retarded, epileptic
his digestive system didn't work right
meaning he had to be fed and cleaned up after
and just for laughs, he had bad enough asthma
that he had to have a respirator kept by his bed.
That'd be Megan calling it a learning disability.
Was it your son's condition that led to the breakup?
Megan saw him as God's gift.
I'd look at him and see God's curse.
On my best days, God's joke.
I hated her for how she threw herself into it
how she never asked anything of me, never complained.
She made me feel like
I didn't deserve to breathe the same air as her.
I stood it for as long as I could stand it.
Now you're feeling good enough
to paint another woman's apartment, huh?
I took off from work because my son died.
I don't know you all that long, Colin
but I'm guessing that you're a guy who has a lot of guilt.
The Irish have a long, proud tradition of that.
It got too much to take.
You didn't have to be thinking about the consequences.
You were walking by the building that you used to live
the family that you walked out on.
You had the paint thinner
to take to your girlfriend's apartment
and that Irish guilt kicked in, huh?
I bought the paint thinner this morning.
I have the receipt to prove it.
Where were you last night?
With Lori and her friends
first having dinner at Leshko's, and then back at her apartment.
Can you provide us with proof of that?
Yeah.
Good, you'll need to.
He was with me the entire night.
With you where?
We had dinner at Leshko's
we took a walk through Tomkins Square Park
we went back to my apartment
watched Yojimbo, had sex, went to sleep.
What time was it when you went to sleep?
1:30, quarter to two.
Had you had anything to drink, anything to smoke before that?
You guys are a joke, you know that?
Yeah, well, we're just trying to figure out
if you might be off about the time.
Nobody told you about this kid and fire?
We're cops. Nobody tells us anything.
The kid was obsessed with fire.
You couldn't put lit candles on his birthday cake
'cause he wouldn't stop staring at them.
He started fires a dozen times in the past.
Why would neither his mother or father have mentioned that?
They'd rather not think
about the possibility that he did this to himself.
You talked to Colin?
Yeah, according to him
your son was severely handicapped.
Sure, according to him.
He found the least little thing we had to do for Ian utterly overwhelming.
We were told that Ian was prone to starting fires.
I stopped smoking so there wouldn't be matches around.
I replaced the gas stove in the apartment with an electric.
Was he out of your sight long enough to have set that fire?
Yeah.
Since you stopped smoking
where'd he get the matches?
I don't know. I must've had a pack hidden away somewhere.
Mommy! Mommy, watch me!
Excuse me.
Wherever she hid them, he must've found them.
And the paint thinner?
I kept the supply room locked, always.
Where was the key?
Above the door.
How high is that?
Did Ian know it was up there?
Maybe he did.
As long as I wasn't using anything that made noise
he liked to hang around me.
When I mopped or changed the light bulbs
I made it like he was helping me.
He could've known the key was up there, sure.
He had a history of starting fires.
He could've set this one and then forgotten about it.
Gone to sleep and died of smoke inhalation.
I'm just not sure this kid was capable of setting this fire.
But you said he set them in the past.
Hey, setting a match to a newspaper is one thing.
Here he's dragging something to stand on
over to the closet door, reaching up for the key
unlocking the door
pulling out the can of paint thinner
opening it, pouring it...
Yeah, but did he know the paint thinner would work?
I mean, what is this kid's IQ?
His father and his mother have completely different stories.
Maybe you should talk to someone else.
Ian had a condition
known as childhood disintegrative disorder.
In some ways it resembled severe autism
but then it comes accompanied
with a whole host of other problems as well.
How long was he a student here?
Five years.
At a certain point, his condition worsened.
It became impossible for us to care for him here.
In what way did it worsen?
He'd become increasingly aggressive, violent.
His motor skills deteriorated.
He required constant monitoring of his respiratory
and digestive functions.
When you say his motor skills deteriorated
what does that mean?
Loss of hand-eye coordination
balance, equilibrium.
Could he use a key to unlock a door?
Possibly, if he was familiar with the key and the door
and there were no additional obstacles in his way.
How about finding something to stand on
reaching over the door jamb, and taking the key down?
Not this kid.
Thanks for your time, Doctor.
Ian used to be a sweet, happy boy.
His mother worked so hard
at believing that Ian could improve
that he could be mainstreamed.
What she found out was that Ian would only get worse.
I watched it sink in and I thought it would kill her.
It nearly did.
I'm sorry, Megan's not here.
Do you know where she is?
I think Katie had a play date with a friend.
Excuse me. Could I possibly trouble you for a glass of water?
Oh, it's not trouble at all. Would you like some, too?
Great, yeah.
So how's Megan holding up?
She's hanging in there.
I think spending time with Katie really helps her.
Yeah, I guess if anything would help, that would.
Thanks.
Megan and her daughter sleep out here?
It's not the Carlyle
but we're making do.
Well, you're a good friend.
That's what counts at a time like this.
Is this Megan's nightgown?
Uh-huh.
Didn't they want to run those tests
on her article of clothing?
Oh, yeah, the guy kept calling me leaving me messages.
I keep forgetting to do anything about it.
Thank you.
You think she'd mind if we took this?
What's it for?
The Fire Department.
Whenever there's a loss of life
they run these trans-iridium tests.
I can't imagine she'd mind if you took it.
Well, thanks.
We'll get it back to her as soon as they're done with it.
We're not seeing drugs and alcohol involved.
From all reports, she's a solid citizen.
The ex-husband's alibi checks out?
Yep.
And the mother hasn't taken up
with some skel we should be looking at?
Her whole life's about caring for her son.
She hasn't taken up with anybody.
It's hard for me to imagine
this fits the profile of mothers who kill their own kids.
Lieutenant?
Yeah.
Thanks.
And you were your usual painstaking selves
in obtaining the nightgown?
Absolutely.
Good, there's paint thinner on it.
I went to bed at 10:30, woke up, smelled smoke
and ran out of my room.
Where'd you go?
I told you where I went.
I went to try and save my son.
But you couldn't.
No, I couldn't.
I went to try to open his door
and the doorknob was too hot to touch
plus there was flames and smoke and I couldn't get in.
The problem is, Mrs. Parnell is that your son's door
wasn't closed.
It wasn't closed?
No, these marks on the ceiling
show that it was open.
I remember it being closed.
If I'm wrong
maybe I was in a state of panic or...
You also never went to bed.
What are you talking about?
Your bedroom door was closed.
It slowed down the fire.
Your bed was completely intact, see?
Blankets pulled up
all the way up to the top of the bed.
That bed was never slept in.
It was a warm night.
I slept on top of the blankets.
You're not helping yourself, Megan.
Are you saying I killed my own son?
What we're saying is you were in a desperate situation
and maybe without meaning to, you looked to get out of it.
I never looked to get out of anything.
The fire was set, Megan.
So what? So why is it
you think I'm the only one who could've set it?
We found paint thinner on your nightgown.
I think maybe I should talk to a lawyer.
I think maybe she's right.
Jack. Jack!
Good morning.
Good morning, Mr. Mayor. Mayor Giuliani.
I'm here to accompany Nora on her first day of school.
Jack and I know each other
but Miss Carmichael, I don't believe we've ever met.
No, we haven't. How do you do?
Well, to tell you the truth, I'm a little nervous.
Nora and I worked together
on many organized crime cases.
She was always nervous, but always brilliant.
Well, it is a little daunting coming in behind Adam Schiff.
He called me last night. He said you were
a great interim appointment and he was very impressed.
Gee, I don't think I've ever known Adam to be impressed.
Well, he asked me not to repeat that part.
Ahh.
Well, I've got to get back to City Hall.
You're going to be absolutely terrific.
You've been doing a great job, Jack.
Keep up the good work.
Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
Thank you very much.
Did Adam say where he was calling from?
Vienna.
He's been meeting with Wiesenthal
on the Holocaust reparations.
He seems to be getting
a lot of satisfaction from his work.
That's great, that's great.
Murder in the second degree.
How does the defendant plead?
Barry Peck for the defense, Your Honor.
I know who you are, counselor.
My client pleads not guilty.
People request bail in the amount of $500,000.
What an unconscionable abuse of the judicial process.
Mr. Peck...
Your Honor, forgive me.
This woman has had to endure the untimely death of one child.
She asks that the imposition of bail
in any amount not serve to separate her
from her remaining child
pending resolution of this matter.
This woman is charged with bringing about
the untimely death of her child.
The heinous nature of the crime
requires the imposition of high bail.
Why is she compounding this woman's tragedy?
Your Honor, I hope the Court recognizes
that this prosecution would not
have been undertaken had there not been
substantial evidence of the defendant's guilt.
That is a blatant falsehood.
You know it to be a blatant falsehood, and I'm offended
at having to address you as an officer of the Court.
Can it, counselor.
Bail is set in the amount of $100,000.
Call the next case.
Abbie, sorry about the rhetorical excesses in there.
I'm kind of a take-no-prisoners type of litigator.
That right?
Well, when you get to know me
you'll see I don't take it outside the courtroom.
I don't plan to get to know you.
The heart's an unruly little Chihuahua.
You might get to know me very well.
You want to talk about a deal, talk.
I have that rarest of all birds, my sweet--
an innocent client.
The only deal I'm looking for is one in which she walks away.
Well, then, I'll see you in court.
Do me a favor.
Wear those heels?
What's her lawyer hoping for?
He's hoping a jury will find her too sympathetic to convict.
Is she?
Not as far as I'm concerned.
She kills her son.
She sets fire to a building
endangers who knows how many other people's lives?
Once you get past her being pretty
I don't think she's got a lot else going for her.
She did spend the last 12 years taking care of this kid.
Well, that's what she's supposed to do.
I understand.
We still have to expect them to use her son's condition
to cultivate sympathy for the defendant.
Then you use it
to cultivate sympathy for her son.
Is taking the life of a person with disabilities
any less of a crime
than taking the life of a person without them?
Absolutely not.
Since the underlying crime is arson
why aren't we trying her for felony murder?
There's not a jury in the world
that would convict her of it.
Are we vulnerable to a defense of extreme emotional disturbance
bringing it down to manslaughter?
I don't think it's proximate enough in time.
The extreme emotional disturbance
is one she was living with for 12 years.
We have her deliberately setting the fire?
Yes, and we have a witness
we're hoping will give us her state of mind at the time.
Abbie needs to interview her.
Well, if we have her for the fire
then we have her for murder two.
I saw him at least once a month--
fractured skull, broken wrist, broken ribs.
Was he being physically abused?
Not at all.
The fractured skull came from autistic-type head banging
the broken wrist from an epileptic seizure
the broken ribs from a fall.
The hospital also treated his mother.
For what?
He was having a seizure
and she tried to hold him down to protect him
and he threw her halfway across the room
chipped a bone in her elbow.
I told her he needed to be
in a home.
And what did she say?
He'd be better off dead.
Your Honor
it's our contention--
and I think I'm on very solid legal ground making it--
that this emergency room doctor's testimony falls
squarely under the heading of privileged communication
and should be excluded per force.
Who was the patient at the time she made the statement?
Her son was.
Privilege doesn't come into play; the testimony's in.
What else?
Well, I think it's self-evident
that the nightgown doesn't come in.
Assume it's not self-evident.
No warrant, no consent.
The defendant's friend gave consent.
She didn't have the right to give consent.
Case law says-- and I can stack them as high as you like--
that where there's
a reasonable expectation of privacy
cops can't go in and start grabbing.
Where in the apartment was
the nightgown found?
The living room floor.
Has the defendant's friend affirmed that?
She has, Your Honor. We have a sworn affidavit.
Judge, even if you grant consent to search
they had no right to seize.
"Consent to seize" motion wasn't briefed, Your Honor.
Motion's denied. Nightgown comes in.
Mr. Gee, did you undertake tests on the back steps
leading up to the defendant's apartment?
Yes, we used a methyl silicone gum capillary to extract
volatile hydrocarbons.
What did you find?
Several alkaline peaks that indicated
a class three accelerant.
Can you be specific as to which class three accelerant it was?
In my opinion, it was paint thinner.
This is the chromatograph in question?
Yes.
People's Exhibit 1A.
And... what does this represent?
That's from the nightgown.
People's Exhibit 1B.
These look remarkably similar.
There was paint thinner on the nightgown, too.
Thank you.
Mr. Gee, you maintain that these graphs indicate
a class three accelerant, such as paint thinner?
Correct.
What other class three accelerants are there?
Dry cleaning solvents,
charcoal lighters...
So in other words...
this graph might show paint thinner...
and this graph might show lighter fluid?
It's not possible.
It's not possible that Ms. Parnell was trying
to get a spot out of a dress, or grilled up a hot dog
and that that's what put the accelerant
on her nightgown, that's not possible?
The number of peaks on the graph would be different in this case.
What's on the nightgown
is paint thinner.
So you say.
I'm through with this witness.
Because her bedroom door was closed
and the room itself was far away from the point of origin
the damage to the defendant's bed was relatively minor.
In what position did you find her blanket?
As you can see in the photos
it was still tucked in.
Are you aware of the defendant's statement to the police
that she was asleep in bed when the fire started?
Yes, I am.
Have you ever heard of somebody
waking up with flames all around them
and tucking in their blanket before they run out the door?
Not in my experience.
How about closing the door behind them after they run out?
No sir.
Thank you, no more questions.
Your witness.
Is it possible to fall asleep on top of the blankets?
It's possible.
On a hot night, you could even say, could you not
that it was more than possible
it was common?
The night of the fire, it was 54 degrees.
Well, if someone was reading a book or a magazine
they might fall asleep on top of their blankets
regardless of the temperature, mightn't they?
They might.
No further questions.
But no books or magazines were found
by the defendant's bed.
I saw Ms. Parnell two days before the fire.
What did she say about her son at that time?
She said that his seizures were getting more violent
and more frequent
that the anticonvulsants weren't working.
She said that she was afraid for her son
and she didn't know what to do.
What did you recommend?
I recommended
that she place him in a residential facility.
What was her response?
She said she had looked into it
but that every halfway decent group home that was equipped
to handle her son's medical needs
had at least a five-year waiting list.
She said that if it came
to putting him in an institution
that he'd be better off dead.
Thank you, doctor. I have nothing further.
Dr. Balakrishna, you're from Pakistan, aren't you?
Objection. Irrelevant.
Sustained.
I'm sure that wherever you're from
people exaggerate sometimes
don't they?
Yes.
Doesn't the phrase "he'd be better off dead"
sound to you like an exaggeration?
I thought so at the time.
Mm.
And what did you think "at the time"
of Megan Parnell's feelings toward her son?
I thought that she loved him
that she cared very deeply about him.
Did you think "at the time" that she wanted him dead?
Sustained. Objection. Speculative.
Did she say she wanted him dead?
No.
As a matter of fact, doctor
didn't she ask you about alternative treatments
for her son?
Yes, she did.
Did she ask you about a place
she could take her son
somewhere in the world
where she could take her son
that something might be done for him?
Yes, she did ask me that.
Does that sound to you like someone
who is looking to end her son's life?
No, it doesn't.
Thank you, doctor.
I have nothing further.
I think we might've come in a little high at Murder Two.
What was her intent?
Her intent was to set a fire.
That doesn't mean an emotional disturbance defense won't fly.
The fact is, she went to this emergency room doctor that week
she was confronted with the hopelessness
of her son's condition and she reacted.
Is that a legal opinion or an emotional response?
It's a legal opinion.
Is it your legal opinion that justice is served
by letting her enter a plea to manslaughter?
Yes.
Abbie?
I'll defer to Jack on this one.
Go to it.
Thank you.
Are you expecting us to fall to our knees in gratitude?
I expect you to recognize this is the best deal
you're going to get and advise your client accordingly.
I'd have to go to prison, though.
Any deal is going to entail prison time.
I don't think I could bear to be separated
from my daughter.
If you're found guilty of murder
you'll be separated
for a lot longer.
The long and short of it, guys, is
we'll take our chances with the jury.
You mean she'll take herchances with the jury.
I don't distance myself from my clients.
Okay. We're due in court.
At this time, Your Honor, the defense moves
to dismiss all charges against Megan Parnell
on the grounds that the prosecution has failed
to make out a prima facie case.
Denied. Approach.
Is there a plea to be worked out here?
We've offered Man One, Your Honor
but defense counsel's not interested.
Can you explain your thinking on that one, Mr. Peck?
Your Honor
while I'm aware of the potential cumulative impact
of the evidence
circumstantial though it may be
I don't believe the interests of justice are served
by exposing my client to criminal penalties
a manslaughter plea might entail.
Therefore at this time
after having consulted with my client
I'd like to change our plea to not guilty
by reason of mental disease or defect.
What?
This was always anticipated as a possibility.
Your Honor, this is nothing more
than Mr. Peck's conceit that he can pull
a rabbit out of a hat
and his never-ending love for opportunities to hear himself talk.
I'd stake my life that this doesn't represent
an informed decision by the defendant herself.
I speak for the defendant herself.
You've got a week.
What's this jury going to think
when they hear you change your story
from she didn't do it to she did do it
but she was insane at the time?
Well, they're going to think that Megan Parnell is
a young woman of tragic circumstances
and... I have beautiful eyes.
Short version? She's not insane.
Not now, not the night she set the fire.
And the long version?
For a murderess, she's very appealing.
And when she's released from prison
you can ask her out.
I meant appealing from the standpoint
that she suffered from significant mental problems.
Like what?
Acute anxiety, depression
chronic sleep deprivation.
Her son never allowed her to sleep
for more than two hours at a time.
Well, I don't think the penal code
has been amended to include fatigue
as a defense for murder.
I feel for her.
She was terrified by all kinds of images
she thought her son would have to endure
if he was taken away from her.
She was exhausted beyond all measure.
For one short, horrible instant
she thought the way to solve her problems
was to burn them down.
But she wasn't insane?
No, she wasn't insane.
There's a chemical reaction in the brain
when you're under stress.
We can see the abnormalities in a PET scan.
Can these abnormalities be serious?
Absolutely.
Neurons stop transmitting; glucose stops metabolizing.
Brain function of a severely stressed individual
is indistinguishable from that of a person who is mentally ill.
In your opinion, Doctor
was the defendant severely stressed
at the time of the fire?
Based on my interviews with Megan
there is no question but that her stress level rose
to the clinical designation
of A.C.S.S.
And what is that, Doctor?
Acute Caretaker Stress Syndrome.
A.C.S.S. is characterized by irrational behavior
radical emotional dissonance and cognitive malfunction.
Could she tell the difference
between right and wrong?
In my opinion, no.
Thank you, Doctor.
Where'd you go to medical school, Doctor?
My doctorate
is in applied kinesiology.
I did not go to medical school.
What's your background in psychology?
I both read and lectured extensively
and I have a syndicated radio program
now heard in most major markets.
In other words, you're not a psychologist
but you play one on the radio.
Objection. Counsel is mocking the witness.
Yes, I am.
Sustained.
This disorder you speak of--
this A.C.S.S.--
I've been looking for it
in these very large reference books
and I couldn't find it.
It's a relatively new diagnosis.
Invented by whom?
It was first identified by myself.
Recognized by the American Psychiatric Association? Not yet.
Any other professional organizations?
It will be.
I'm glad we're on the cutting edge.
Objection.
Mr. McCoy continues to mock the witness.
Withdrawn. I have nothing further.
I was Ian Parnell's caseworker
at Children's Services for the past two years.
So you were intimately involved in his situation?
Yes, sir.
It was you who placed Ian
in the Highcrest Home for Disabled Children?
That was the best option at the time.
Was it a viable option?
No.
Why not?
We weren't equipped for someone with those kinds of problems.
Ian was ultra-sensitive to noise.
A place like that got very noisy.
And because he would block it out
by banging his head against the wall
he'd give himself concussions.
So why didn't you put him someplace else?
I couldn't find a suitable place that had room.
And his mother was more understanding
than I had any right to expect her to be.
Unfortunately, she only had two options:
put her son in a large, state-run institution
or take care of him herself.
Your witness.
Have you ever had any other children
who had difficulty adjusting to their new residential situation?
Yes.
Did any of their parents kill their children?
Not to my knowledge.
Thank you.
First time I noticed something was wrong with Ian
he just turned four.
He was singing his favorite song, "Old MacDonald"
and he forgot that pigs say "oink."
Then he started complaining
there was a bad mouse inside his head.
In three months, he stopped talking or using the toilet.
Would you describe yourself as having
a sustained feeling of desperation ever since?
Objection. Leading.
Lay the foundation, counsel.
Since your son's condition made itself known
have you been able to regain anything
approaching normalcy?
Objection.
Leading.
Is Mr. McCoy categorically opposed
to permitting this woman to testify?
She has to testify according to the rules of evidence, Mr. Peck
so let's see if we can get her to do that.
Ms. Parnell, when your son's health
began deteriorating, what did you do?
Um, we tried Lovaas intervention
auditory interpretation
steroids, several different diets
Clonidine...
Every month, there was a new treatment...
a new miracle cure.
We'd have such high hopes...
nothing helped.
What about special ed?
He hated special ed.
It was always too loud
and disturbing.
When my marriage
started falling apart
we tried sending Ian to respite care for the weekend
but they'd call us up usually by Friday night
to take him back.
And then he started having seizures and I...
I was... afraid that he'd...
kill himself, so...
Ian needed me, but he was getting too big
and he stopped letting me change his diaper
or brush his teeth or give him medicine.
I couldn't take care of him anymore.
Why didn't you send him somewhere?
Whether it was an institution or a group home.
Whatever it was
some place would have taken him off your hands.
I couldn't.
To other people, he was... just some weird... kid
who threw his poop around the room.
To me
when he was listening... to "Old MacDonald"
he was my baby.
I loved him so much.
Your witness, Mr. McCoy.
Ms. Parnell...
your plea is not guilty by reason of insanity.
Yes.
That means that at the time you set the fire
you didn't know right from wrong.
I didn't know what I was doing.
You knew enough to lie to the police.
I didn't mean to lie to them.
You knew enough to go downstairs
unlock the janitor's closet
pour paint thinner on the steps
and leave your son to die in a fire.
No, I did not.
Ms. Parnell
is it or is it not true
that you willfully and deliberately
set the fire in which your son died?
My son didn't die in the fire.
He died before the fire.
The coroner's report states
that the cause of death was smoke inhalation.
He was having a seizure
and he went into convulsions
and I had the syringe to give him his injection
to stop the convulsion
just like I've done all those times before...
But this time, I... I didn't do it...
I... watched his body contorting in pain.
That poor, tortured body had never stopped hurting
and I didn't do it.
I let him go
and then I went into the bathroom
and I took his pills-- all of them--
and I swallowed them.
I set the fire, and I lay down next to him to die myself.
But you changed your mind.
The smoke made me cough...
and the pills didn't work.
And I started to think about my daughter
and I got up and I ran outside
and I grabbed a phone out of some guy's hand and I...
I dialed 911
and I never would have set the fire
if I'd known Ian was alive.
I never would have done that to him.
I never would have made him suffer like that.
He suffered so much in his life.
Is she telling the truth?
The M.E. said the kid could have been in a coma
from the seizures.
She thought he was dead.
In fact, he was still breathing
just enough to get some smoke into his lungs.
Why'd she wait this long
to tell us?
It's possible she suppressed her memory of that night.
It's possible she felt too guilty
to fully participate in her own defense.
It's also possible
that her lawyer isn't an idiot we take him for.
He held onto this
until he thought it would do the most good.
No, he's an idiot.
What's the likelihood of getting a conviction on murder two?
Nil.
Unless the jury thinks she's lying.
I don't think she's lying.
Assume she's not; that's manslaughter.
Given her state of mind
and the extenuating circumstances
I don't think what she did
warrants a conviction for manslaughter.
Well, what do you think?
Marshall of the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade?
I don't think we should be sending her to prison.
Her failure to act comes under depraved indifference.
It qualifies as manslaughter under People v. Lyttle.
If that's what the judge charges on
that's what the jury will convict her for.
We have the evidence to support that?
Yes.
In this case, for this defendant
the penalties are too severe.
We can't let our sympathy for a defendant
distort our primary responsibility.
What are you saying?
You've got to do your job, Jack.
Do either of you intend
to bring a motion for lesser-included offenses
to be charged to the jury?
The defense asks for a charge on murder two only.
That's what the prosecution got an indictment for
that's the burden of proof they should be held to.
As usual, Mr. Peck
you've completely misstated the law.
Mr. McCoy, you're entitled to ask that my charge to the jury
include allowing them to return guilty verdicts
on manslaughter one and two, as well as murder.
The prosecution has no objection to a charge
on murder two only.
Your Honor, may I have a moment
to confer with my colleague?
That's not necessary, Abbie.
We'll take our chances on murder two.
Madam Foreperson, has the jury reached a verdict?
We have, Your Honor.
Will the defendant please rise?
What is your verdict?
We, the jury, on the charge of murder in the second degree
find the defendant not guilty
by reason of mental disease or defect.
Thank you for your verdict, ladies and gentlemen.
The defendant is hereby remanded
to Kirby Forensics Center for evaluation.
Tough case, McCoy.
A little tip from the other side of the aisle:
next time you have a shot
at lesser-included offenses, take it.
Thanks.
I heard about the verdict.
Yeah. You win some, you lose some.
Which was this?
I would have gone for a conviction. Me, too.
Which is why I'm glad it was Jack trying the case.
Well, based on what this woman did
she deserves to be punished.
I think she is.
Have a good night.
You, too.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.