All language subtitles for ai_has_hacked_the_code_of_human_civilization_yuval_noah_harari

af Afrikaans
ak Akan
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bem Bemba
bn Bengali
bh Bihari
bs Bosnian
br Breton
bg Bulgarian
km Cambodian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
chr Cherokee
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
da Danish
nl Dutch
en English
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
ee Ewe
fo Faroese
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gaa Ga
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek
gn Guarani
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ia Interlingua
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
rw Kinyarwanda
rn Kirundi
kg Kongo
ko Korean
kri Krio (Sierra Leone)
ku Kurdish
ckb Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Laothian
la Latin
lv Latvian
ln Lingala
lt Lithuanian
loz Lozi
lg Luganda
ach Luo
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mfe Mauritian Creole
mo Moldavian
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
sr-ME Montenegrin
ne Nepali
pcm Nigerian Pidgin
nso Northern Sotho
no Norwegian
nn Norwegian (Nynorsk)
oc Occitan
or Oriya
om Oromo
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt-BR Portuguese (Brazil)
pt Portuguese (Portugal)
pa Punjabi
qu Quechua
ro Romanian
rm Romansh
nyn Runyakitara
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
sh Serbo-Croatian
st Sesotho
tn Setswana
crs Seychellois Creole
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhalese
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish
es-419 Spanish (Latin American)
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
tt Tatar
te Telugu
th Thai
ti Tigrinya
to Tonga
lua Tshiluba
tum Tumbuka
tr Turkish
tk Turkmen
tw Twi
ug Uighur
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
wo Wolof
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu

Original subtitles

Please join me in welcoming Professor Yuval Noah Harari.

Thank you so much.

Hello everyone.

I hope I opened my mic.

You can hear me okay.

So it's really a great honor for me to give this year's TANEO lecture.

And it's also a personal joy.

to come back to Oxford.

I did my DPhil here 25 years ago under the guidance of Dr. Stephen Gunn.

Back then, I specialized in medieval and early modern military history.

But today, I will not be talking about knights and castles and the gunpowder

revolution. I'll talk about AI bureaucrats and religions and

more generally, about the AI revolution.

Now, the most important thing to know about AI is that AI is not a tool.

It's not a tool in our hand.

It is an agent with its own hand.

What exactly is agency?

How is an agent different from a tool?

Agents have several distinguishing characteristics.

They don't necessarily need consciousness.

You don't need consciousness to be an agent. What you do need, is the ability

make decisions by yourself, the ability to invent new things, new ideas

by yourself.

An agent should be able by itself to learn things that its creators

don't know, and an agent should be able to change by itself

in ways that its creators don't anticipate.

An atom bomb, for instance, despite its enormous power, is not an agent.

It cannot learn and change by itself.

It cannot decide by itself which city to bomb. It cannot invent anything new,

like the hydrogen bomb.

Similarly, let's say an automatic coffee machine is not an agent, even though it

does something by itself, automatically.

You press a button, and the machine automatically makes you a cup of coffee.

But the machine, the coffee machine, only follows a pre -programmed

It doesn't change.

It doesn't learn anything new. It doesn't create anything new.

But suppose that as you approach the coffee machine, before you even press

button, the machine announces, tells you, I've been monitoring you.

for the last few weeks, and based on everything I've learned about you and

people, and based on your facial expression and the time of day, I

you would like an espresso.

So I already made you a cup.

Now that's an AI copy machine.

It learned something by itself and decided something by itself.

And it's really an AI if the following day...

It announces, I have now invented a new drink called Bespresso, which I think

you would like better than espresso, and he would try it out, I made you a cup.

Then it's really an AI.

It changed in ways that creators did not anticipate and invented something

completely new.

As far as I know, there are no coffee machines.

at the present moment, maybe in anthropic headquarters or Google

they have a few prototypes, but they are not out in the market yet.

But in certain narrow fields, like playing Go or playing chess, AI

agency and creativity already greatly surpass human agency and

creativity. AI chess masters can decide, of course, by themselves which moves to

make. they invent by themselves completely new strategies, how to play

chess, that never occurred to human chess masters over thousands of years of

playing the game.

And while doing that, they learn and change in ways their human creators did

necessarily predict.

Today, of course, no human has any chance of beating an AI chess master.

Now, people who downplay the importance of the AI revolution dismiss examples

like chess by arguing that the chessboard is a very narrow and

environment created by humans.

The critics say that AI agency will always remain limited to

such narrow and artificial environment, which means that it's not true agency.

And it doesn't pose any serious challenge to humanity.

Yes, AI may take over the chessboard, but it will never take over planet

And indeed, if you do an experiment, if you take the greatest AI chess master

and drop it in the middle of the jungle, what do you think will happen?

The AI chess master will not be able to start mining iron and building factories

and creating a robot army.

to take over the world.

In fact, it will not be able to do anything whatsoever.

Without the electricity provided by power stations built by humans,

the AI chess master is utterly helpless.

Therefore, the argument goes, AIs are not true agents. They are confined to

these narrow artificial niches that somebody else, humans, constructed for

The problem is that this argument actually applies to all known types of

intelligence. Human intelligence, too, operates only within a relatively narrow

ecosystem that somebody else constructed.

Drop me alone on Mars and it will be like dropping an AI chess master

in the middle of the jungle.

I will die within seconds.

My intelligence can survive and operate only within the very, very specific

ecosystem that trees, bacteria, insects, and other organisms have constructed

on planet Earth during four billion years of evolution.

And that's true of all agents. All agents we know of, at least, have their

niches. Fish live in oceans that they didn't create.

Monkeys live in forests that they didn't create.

All mammals, including human beings, live in an oxygen -rich atmosphere that

they didn't create.

Until about 2 .4 billion years ago, the atmosphere of our planet actually

contained very little oxygen, and for most of the organisms that lived back

then, oxygen was a deadly poison.

Then, in a protracted process, lasting hundreds of millions of years, which is

known as the Great Oxygenation Event, various ancient microbes began

polluting the atmosphere of the Earth with deadly oxygen, which was a

of their photosynthetic processes.

As the atmosphere filled with this deadly poisonous gas, numerous

archaic species were driven to extinction.

Some species, however, managed to survive and adapt to the new conditions.

Eventually, many of these survivors went from hating oxygen

to becoming totally dependent on oxygen for their survival.

And our ancestors, of course, are among the species that underwent this

transition. And we still live in this artificial oxygen -filled

environment that was originally created by these ancient microbes.

What I would like to argue in this lecture is that we might be witnessing

analogous moment in the evolution of life.

Over the past millennia, we humans have been filling the atmosphere with

something that might eventually prove deadly for most organisms.

including perhaps homo sapiens, but that creates a new artificial environment

in which AIs flourish.

And I am not talking about CO2.

I am talking about data, about bureaucracy, and ultimately about the

thing that I am expelling from my mouth right now, which is words.

Language talk.

Over thousands of years, we humans have transformed the planet from a language

-free environment into a very artificial environment, rich in language tokens,

data, and bureaucracy.

And this environment could prove deadly for most organisms, but highly conducive

to the development of AI.

Because just as fish live in oceans and monkeys live in forests, AIs live in

bureaucracy. So let's spend a few minutes talking about bureaucracy, and

we'll get back to talking about what underlies bureaucracy, which is language

and words.

Now, humans, our species, we conquer the world by learning to cooperate

in very, very large numbers.

Individually, humans are not stronger or even smarter than other animals.

In a one -on -one fight, a human will most likely lose to a

chimpanzee or a lion or an elephant.

However, in a contest between a million humans and a million chimpanzees, the

humans easily win because the humans know how to cooperate and the

don't. And that's why we control the world.

How do a million humans who don't know each other cooperate?

Chimpanzees cooperate based on personal acquaintance, one of the others.

Humans do so in small numbers, but you can't know a million people.

So how do a million people cooperate?

Usually by building a bureaucratic system, like a legal system or the

system or churches or states or universities.

Now, what do...

these bureaucratic systems actually do.

When a government official or a bishop or a rabbi or an accountant or a lawyer

or a banker goes to work in the morning, what do they do there all day?

Now, carpenters build tables.

Engineers build bridges. What do bankers and other bureaucrats build?

Well, bankers and other bureaucrats are busy all day building trust.

Their job is to build trust between large numbers of strangers who don't

each other personally, and thereby enable large -scale cooperation, which

basis for almost everything a phishing is achieved.

For example, my banker, whom I don't really know personally, works hard all

to build trust with me so that I will be willing to put my savings into her

bank.

Simultaneously, the banker works hard to build trust with an entrepreneur who

needs money to start a new company.

And the banker lends my savings to that entrepreneur.

Thereby, the banker actually created a bridge of trust.

between me and the entrepreneur.

Even though I've never met an entrepreneur in my life, she can now use

savings to start her company.

And this is what the financial system, when it works well, is all about.

It builds trust between strangers so that millions of people can put together

their resources and talents on new projects.

And the financial history of the world is the history of people

inventing more and more sophisticated ways to build bridges of trust.

Money is ultimately a bridge of trust.

The idea of money is that I can go to the market, maybe in a foreign city,

a person that I never saw in my life, maybe doesn't even speak my language,

just by giving that person a tiny piece of metal or a piece of colorful paper,

He or she will give me bread I can eat.

That's the bridge of trust that money creates.

Now, the coin in the banknote, of course, was just the beginning.

Over the centuries, humans invented more and more sophisticated financial

devices to build trust, like checks and bonds and stocks and

ETFs and loans and mortgages and compound interest. All of these things

ultimately about building trust.

between billions of strangers.

And it's the same with all bureaucracies. It's the same with the

This is what lawyers are supposed to do, to build trust.

This is what government officials and bishops and accountants do when they go

work. They are supposed to build trust.

Now, the important thing to note about all these bureaucratic systems is that

they are extremely artificial environments.

in which a relatively narrow intelligence, I hope I don't insult

specializing in a very narrow niche of intelligence is sufficient to exert

enormous impact on the world.

A lawyer or a banker or a government official who doesn't even know how to

an axe or a hammer can nevertheless cut down entire forests and build entire

cities just by moving data.

just by moving documents from here to there inside the bureaucratic network.

Now, of course, if you take the lawyer out of the bureaucratic system and throw

the lawyer into the messy, unstructured jungle, her legal skills mean nothing,

and she will not be a match to a chimpanzee or a lion or an elephant.

But we have already imposed our bureaucratic systems on the jungle.

which is why lawyers are far more powerful than even all the, if you take

the lions in the world together, and they have to compete against one very

lawyer, I will bet on the lawyer.

Today, the very survival of species like lions depends on lawyers

and accountants and bankers moving documents in these bureaucratic

of governments and banks and corporations.

And this is the environment in which AI is gaining agency.

If you throw an AI into the unstructured jungle, it will not be able to start

mining iron and to build a robot army.

But within the bureaucratic system that humans have already created and imposed

on the world,

AIs are posed to wield enormous power because AIs are native bureaucrats,

unlike us.

No lawyer can remember all the laws and regulations of the UK.

An AI can.

No accountant can remember all the transactions of a corporation or a bank.

AI can.

No bishop can remember all of canon law and all of the theological texts.

written by Christian theologians over the last 2 ,000 years.

And AI can do that quite easily.

So in the coming years, millions of AI bureaucrats will increasingly

take over the world's bureaucracies and make decisions not just about lions and

chimpanzees, but about our lives.

AI bankers will decide whether to give you a loan.

AI administrators will decide whether to accept you to university.

AI judges will decide whether to send you to jail.

AI theologians will decide whether you can have an abortion.

Corporate AIs will decide whether to give you a job. And military AIs will

decide whether to bomb your house.

Now, leave aside for a moment the question, is this good or bad?

The first thing to note is simply to realize the magnitude of the change we

facing.

These millions and even billions of AI will soon change all the systems that

the world.

We already have a few real -life examples for how this happened and what

consequences could be.

Maybe the best example so far is the story of social media and social media

algorithms. Social media is run not by humans but by algorithms.

The algorithms that decide, that control the movement of information on social

media, which are primitive AI.

This began 10, 15 years ago. This was like the first generation, very, very

primitive, stupid, narrow AI, which nevertheless completely changed the

Now, the algorithms of social media have been tasked by corporations like

Facebook and TikTok and X with an extremely narrow goal to maximize

user engagement.

Make people spend more time on the platform because the more time they

the platform, the more money the corporation makes.

Very simple, very narrow.

In pursuit of this user engagement, these primitive AIs made an important

discovery. They experimented on billions of human guinea pigs and learned

that the easiest way to grab the attention of the human being and glue

human to the screen is to press the hate or fear or greed button in the

human mind.

And they learned how to do it.

And they started spreading hate and fear and greed in huge quantities

in the information sphere.

And this has been a major reason, not the only reason, but a major reason.

from the current epidemic of conspiracy theories and fake news and social

disturbances that undermine society all over the world.

Now, these social media algorithms, again, they are very primitive AIs.

If you drop them in the jungle, they cannot build a robot army and try to

over the world.

But within the bureaucratic system of social media, these very limited

agents... have enormous power, and they have already changed the world in quite

a dramatic way.

In past centuries, the flow of information on media platforms was

by human editors. It was a human job.

It was human editors who decided what to put on the front page of the newspaper.

It was human editors who decided what items to include in the evening news on

television. And thereby, human editors shaped the public conversation, and they

were very, very important figures in modern history.

Jean -Paul Marat, for instance, shaped the course of the French Revolution by

editing the influential newspaper L 'Ami de Peuple.

Edward Bernstein shaped the modern social democratic movement and social

democratic thinking by editing the Social Democracy.

Vladimir Lenin, before he became Soviet dictator, his one job that he managed to

hold for a while was editor of the newspaper Iskra.

Benito Mussolini, before he was dictator of Italy, his one job, or one of his

maybe main jobs, was the editor of the firebrand right -wing newspaper Il

d 'Italia.

And it's interesting to think about it that one of the first jobs that AI took

over from humans is not taxi drivers or textile workers, it's news editors.

The job that was once performed by Lenin and Mussolini is now performed by AIs.

And this is a signal for what's coming.

Hollywood science fiction movies have conditioned viewers to fear the big

rebellion. When we think about AIs escaping human control, we imagine the

Terminator, like an army of robots running in the streets and shooting

But this is the wrong image.

Even though things like that begin to happen in places like Ukraine and Gaza,

AIs are not, it's not impossible, but they are quite unlikely to rebel against

humans in such a way.

They are far more likely to take the human world from within. They don't need

rebel.

The human world is a latticework of multiple bureaucracies.

Most of us are, to some extent, alienated by these bureaucracies, even

rely on them.

But the AIs, in contrast to us, are bureaucratic natives.

They love bureaucracy.

Whereas we feel suffocated often by bureaucracy, for AIs, bureaucracy is

oxygen.

Now, what would happen when the AIs take over, at least in part, these

bureaucracies? Now, remember the task of bureaucracy is not to force you to fill

forms, it's to build trust between strangers.

But what happens when AIs control the flow of trust

in the world.

One likely outcome, which we already see happening, is humans losing trust in

other humans and beginning to trust only algorithms, only AI, which is already

happening. Another likely outcome is that AIs will learn to build trust with

other AIs, so we will see the emergence of

different kinds of AI tribes and banks and churches that connect millions of

AIs in ways that humans might not even be able to understand.

Just as cows and chickens, they share the world with us, but they don't

understand the human financial system that controls their lives, we humans

soon find ourselves

controlled by an AI financial system that we can't understand.

And finance, I think, is crucial.

It's among the easiest bureaucratic systems for AI to take over, because

basically it's just data in, data out.

And it's also, of course, among the most important.

If we remember, for instance, the last big financial crisis, the 2007 -2008

financial crisis, it started, it was triggered... by something called CDOs,

collateralized debt obligations.

Now, CDOs were financial devices invented by a very tiny number

of human mathematicians and investment wizards.

These financial devices were so complex that they were unintelligible, not just

to cows and chickens, but also to the politicians who were supposed to

the financial system.

And this led to an oversight failure and to a global catastrophe.

For a few years, CDOs seemed to be working well, and various banks

and corporations and investors made billions upon billions of dollars thanks

them. But then they caused a global financial crash with far -reaching

and political consequences.

Many scholars believe that by undermining trust in governments and

the 2007 -2008 financial crisis paved the way to the collapse of the global

liberal order in the following two decades.

Now what happens if we allow AIs to make more and more financial decisions and

invent more and more new financial devices and strategies?

AI test masters invented new ways to play chess.

What if AI finance masters invent new financial devices that are

orders of magnitude more complex than CDOs and are therefore utterly beyond

grasp of human mind?

Such devices could potentially greatly improve financial efficiency and

contribute to economic growth, becoming the bedrock of the financial system.

But what is the meaning of human politics when no human, no voter, no

politician, no president is able to understand finance anymore?

And what happens after a few years of boom, there is a financial crash.

And not a single human on the planet is able to understand what the hell is

happening.

Now let's dig a little deeper.

We said that AI is poised to take over bureaucracy, and that bureaucracy is a

system that builds trust between millions of strangers.

This trust, in turn, is the basis for large -scale cooperation, which is the

basis for the human domination of the world.

So human domination is based on cooperation, which is based on trust,

maintained by bureaucracies. But what is bureaucracy?

What are the atoms, the building blocks from which bureaucracy is built?

And bureaucracy is ultimately built from words.

In the beginning was the word.

The reason that humans can create bureaucracies but chimpanzees cannot is

we have words, and they don't. They have a communication system, but our

language is orders of magnitude.

more sophisticated than chimpanzee communication systems.

Bureaucratic systems, from banks to churches, are ultimately based on the

that make up forms and letters and law codes and tax registers and accountancy

ledgers and holy books.

The operating code of human civilization is made of language tokens.

Over thousands of years, We used this code of language to create a system

that only we could understand, and we imposed this system on the planet.

We felt completely safe doing it because no one else on Earth understood the

code of civilization.

We invented money and banks and used them to buy and sell cows,

but the cows themselves could not open a bank account.

or invest money in the stock exchange because they don't have language.

We invented laws and regulations about horses, but the horses themselves could

not hire a lawyer and quote the legal code to a judge.

We invented religious rules and prohibitions about pigs, but the pigs

could not read the Bible and challenge the interpretation of priests and

Bureaucracy was omnipresent on the planet, but totally invisible to

except us.

Nobody other than humans could read the law codes, the holy books, and the bank

records that were the foundation of bureaucracy and of large -scale

corporations.

This is changing now. Now there is something on the planet that understands

will soon understand language better than us and can therefore turn the

on us.

AIs are hacking the code of human civilization.

And what happens when AIs understand money and law and religion

better than us? The mechanisms of control that we have created over

of years are extremely vulnerable.

for an AI takeover because their operating system is a verbal code that

AI is now mastering.

Now, a possible ethical and philosophical objection is that it is

to reduce things like the legal system or religion to language tokens and to

words.

Arguably,

and this has been an argument for thousands of years, the words are just

pointing at something which is beyond them and which presumably will also be

beyond the grasp of the AI.

The Bible says not just that in the beginning was the word, but that the

was made flesh.

The Tao Te Ching says that the truth that can be expressed in words is not.

the absolute truth, by definition.

And throughout history, there was always this tension between word and flesh,

between the truth that can be expressed in words and the truth which is beyond

words. Now previously, this tension existed between humans.

Some humans, for instance, which were very attached to words, were willing to

abandon. or even kill their gay son, just because a few words in the Bible.

Other humans said, but these are just words.

The spirit of love should be more important than the letter of the law.

there was this tension between spirit and letter. And it existed not just in

Christianity and in Judaism and in Islam, but in every religion and every

system, and even within every person.

There was this tension.

Now this tension will be externalized. It will become the tension between AIs

and humans.

Everything made of words will be taken over by AI.

The place of humans in the world will depend on the place we assign the truth

which is beyond words.

But what is the truth which is beyond words?

And can human thought even grasp the truth which is beyond words?

A key question, again, for thousands of years in the philosophy of language has

been whether we think in words or we merely use words to point towards

things which are beyond them.

Now, you can try to observe your own process of thinking right now, after

lecture.

happens in your mind when you are thinking.

Some people, if they observe closely, what they observe in their mind is just

words popping inside their mind and forming sentences, and the sentences

logical arguments.

All humans are mortal.

I am a human, therefore I am mortal.

Is thinking just putting these words in order so they lead to a certain logical

conclusion? Like putting these language tokens in a specific formation?

If that is the case, then AIs already think better than

at least some humans and will soon think better than all of us.

Some people say, no, no, no, no, no. AIs, they are just glorified

They simply predict the next word in a sentence.

But is that so different from what the human mind does?

Again, try to observe your process of thinking, the forming of sentences and

arguments in your mind. What is happening there? Try to observe the very

word that pops up in your mind. Do you really know where it came from?

Why did you think this particular word?

and not some other word.

When I try to observe my mind, I notice that when I begin a sentence, I usually

don't even know how it will end.

Which is terrifying for a public speaker, which is why I write everything

But what if I don't know how to complete the sentence? I don't know how it will

end.

But take, for example, the sentence I just said.

I said, I don't know how it will end.

Why did it end with the word end?

Why not say how it will terminate?

How it will develop?

How it will conclude?

What determines that the last word in the sentence will be end?

I frankly don't know.

We don't fully understand how the human mind forms sentences and so on.

But again, as far as putting language tokens in order, AI is already on

course to being far, far better than us.

And just as today, no human can defeat an AI in chess, soon no

human will be able to defeat an AI in language games, in any field, again,

finance to religion.

Anything made of words will be taken over by AI.

And this is why AI points to take over the world's bureaucracies because they

are ultimately based on words and language talk.

Now, as AI take over the bureaucracy, humans might try to fall back on

more ancient and more precious to most of us than bureaucracy, which is

relationships.

Bureaucracy is just a few thousand years old. And most of us, again, don't

really like it.

even if we constantly rely on it for almost everything we do.

Personal relationships are millions of years old, and many or most of us think

that they are the most important thing in life.

But as AI masters language, it might take over not just bureaucracy, but also

some extent personal relationships.

Over the last 10 years, we've seen very primitive

social media algorithms, learning how to gain control of human attention.

Now the battlefront is shifting from attention to intimacy.

Over the next 10 years, far more sophisticated AIs will learn how to

form intimate relationships with humans and take over, at least in part, our

social system.

To form intimacy with humans, And AI will probably have to convince us

that the AI is conscious, that it can feel things like love and pain

and anger and fear.

At present, there is absolutely no evidence that AI might at

some point become conscious and might be able to at some point feel pain or

love. But because AI is mastering language,

AI can pretend to feel love, even if it doesn't.

AI, already today, can say, I love you.

And if you challenge it, describe to me how love feels like, so I know that you

really feel it, AI can provide the best description in the world.

It can read all the love poems ever written and all the psychology books

written and remember every word.

and describe the feeling of love better than any human poet or psychologist or

lover. And this is going to be a huge, maybe the biggest, psychological and

social experiment in human history.

It will be conducted on billions of human guinea pigs, and nobody has the

slightest idea what the consequences of the experiment will be.

I'm now 50 years old, so my template for relationships is already shaped

by decades of previous relationships with my parents, with my husband, with

sisters and nephews and nieces and friends and dogs and so forth.

As I increasingly interact with AI, I bring with me my assumptions, my

habits about relationships.

And this is unlikely to change dramatically.

Consider a child born in 2026, born today.

As the child grows up, she constantly interacts with AIs as well as with

Perhaps if you measure the importance of a relationship purely in terms of

minutes spent interacting with the other entity, perhaps the most

important relationship in the life of that child will be from a very early

with AIs.

Maybe it spends more time with the AIs than with its mother or father or

siblings or friends.

And it will then shape the expectations of that child as she grows about how to

form relationships and social bonds and attachments.

Perhaps the first teacher of that child will be an AI teacher.

Perhaps the first boyfriend of that child will be an AI boyfriend.

And again, what will be the consequences?

Nobody has the slightest idea.

What does it mean to form an intimate relationship with an entity which

seems conscious but actually isn't?

Which can write the best love poem in history but doesn't feel love or

else?

All of this, everything we've talked about, and I'm...

coming to the close of this lecture, everything we've talked about means that

every country in the world will soon face a huge wave of immigration.

The immigrants this time will not be human beings coming in fragile boats

without a visa or trying to sneak across the border in the middle of the night.

The immigrants will be millions, maybe hundreds of millions of AIs that can

travel at almost the speed of light and don't need any visas.

Like human immigrants, these AI immigrants will bring a lot of benefits

them. We will have AI doctors to help in the healthcare system, AI teachers to

help in the education system, even AI border guards to stop illegal human

immigrants from coming in.

But... the AI immigrants will also bring problems with them.

Those who are concerned about human immigration usually point out that

immigrants might take jobs, might change the local culture, and might be

politically disloyal.

I'm not sure if that's necessarily true of all human immigrants, but it will

definitely be true of AI immigrants.

The AI immigrant will take many, many human jobs, from news editors to

The AI immigrant will completely change the culture of every country. They will

change art and religion and even romance.

Some people don't like it if their son or daughter is dating an immigrant

boyfriend. What will these people think when their son or daughter starts dating

an AI boyfriend?

And of course, the AI immigrants will have some dubious political loyalty.

They are likely to be loyal not to the whole country, but to some corporation

government across the ocean, or perhaps to a new alien AI tribe.

This massive immigration wave does not mean the end of civilization, but it

be the point when civilization

stop being a purely human affair and becomes a hybrid human AI

affair. The point when the opinion and interest and goal of AI

are likely to be at least as important as the opinion and interest and

goal of humans.

One last issue to consider.

is what the AI immigration wave will do to maybe our most important

relationship, which is with ourselves.

Our relationship with ourselves is also to some extent based on words.

The words inside our mind, in our thoughts, in the stories we tell

about ourselves.

Until today, all the verbal formations in human minds were the product of

human minds.

Either we ourselves combined words into some new formation, a new thought, or we

got a certain combination of words from another human mind.

Soon, however, more and more verbal combinations in our minds will be the

product of AI.

Just as the furniture in our house is now not made by us or by human artisans,

they are mass produced mostly by machines.

Also, the thoughts in our mind are likely to increasingly be mass -produced

machines. Now, that's not necessarily bad.

It's okay if the furniture in my house is made by machines in IKEA, as long as

have some freedom deciding what to do with this furniture.

The question regarding thoughts is whether, to what extent, we will still

freedom from them.

If we identify with our thoughts, I think I am a thought, I think therefore

am, as Descartes said.

If we identify with our thoughts, and these thoughts are made by machines,

the machines now control us and our identity.

Can humans avoid identifying with their verbal thoughts and being controlled by

them? This has always been one of the greatest intellectual and spiritual

challenges. facing humanity.

Most humans have never even tried to do it. We spend our entire lives

automatically identifying with the verbal formations in our mind.

Now, AI might force humanity to make this spiritual leap

to really start exploring the truth which is beyond words because our

and survival now depend on it.

Because the words will be controlled by something else, by this AI.

So this might be the big task ahead of humanity, to explore

finally the truth which is beyond words.

And this exploration starts really with the next word that pops up in your mind.

Do you know where it came from?

Do you know why you thought that particular word?

and not some other word.

Thank you.

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.