Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
(Narrator) Every fraud begins with a promise.
(Vicky Thakordas-Desai) She paid for their weddings.
She paid for various trips.
She wanted to look after them as best as she could.
(Narrator) A quick fortune, easy money,
or a life transformed overnight?
She would have left a reasonable estate behind.
It would have been a sizeable sum of money.
(Narrator) But behind these illusions lie
calculated deceptions, carefully hidden in plain sight.
It's not uncommon for us to see economic abuse
mixed with psychological abuse or coercive control.
It's relatively easy with online banking
for someone to help or coerce someone into transferring
money out of their investments into another bank account.
(Narrator) Sometimes these criminals are backed into a corner
and feel their only way out is to kill.
(Sheila Anderson) I just felt very, very sad
that somebody would want money so desperately that you'd
have to end somebody's life.
(suspenseful music)
(distant siren wailing)
(bright music)
(Emma Wilson) My name is Emma Wilson,
and I'm a fire scientist.
I investigate fires, usually on behalf of the police,
usually the primary investigator.
So I attend a fire scene when I'm invited to
to work out where it started, how it started, and if possible,
to help with who might have started it, if there is a who.
(tense music)
(Narrator) In the early hours of December 15, 2021,
a fire was reported in the suburbs of Newark, Nottinghamshire.
(tense music)
I first got involved in this case when I was contacted
by Nottinghamshire Police.
I was told that it was a domestic fire,
that there had been a fatality.
The victim's name was Elizabeth Vamplew.
(tense music)
I was told that it had been investigated by a team initially,
but their findings were inconclusive,
and that they needed a second opinion in order to be able
to confirm the route that the investigation should go.
(Narrator) Elizabeth Vamplew was a 77-year-old mother and grandmother,
and a familiar face amongst the tight-knit community
of her quiet cul-de-sac.
(Sheila) I'm Sheila Anderson.
I was born and Broadnook, and I came
down here to live in a bungalow because of my disability.
Elizabeth was a very, very lovely woman.
When I opened the paper and I saw that, I was really shocked.
I couldn't believe it.
It was just something that you don't hear of all the time,
not it like that.
(unsettling music)
My name is Poppy Everton.
I work for Hourglass Safer Ageing.
Elizabeth was a really warm and caring person,
somebody that was always going out of her way to support and help
the people around her and her loved ones.
She was a devoted mother and grandmother,
really enjoyed spending time with her grandkids.
That was when she was at her happiest.
She ultimately loved Christmas, and her family
often talk about how that time of year brought her such joy.
Very, very well liked amongst family, friends,
and the community as a whole.
(Narrator) Elizabeth was most happy tending
her small but well-kept garden
and spoiling her three beloved grandchildren.
We also know that Elizabeth would help with money or gifts
for her family, whether that be at birthdays, Christmases,
and just making sure that they felt supported by her.
My name is Dr Vicky Thakordas-Desai
and I am a consultant forensic psychologist.
(tense music)
Elizabeth seemed to be a doting and caring mother.
She clearly loved her children.
She wanted the best for them.
She had supported them financially.
She paid for their weddings,
she paid for various trips for them,
and it just seemed that she wanted to look
after them as best as she could.
(Narrator) Elizabeth suffered from limited mobility
and required visits from nurses twice a day.
My name is Peter Joyce, King's Counsel,
and I was the lead prosecutor in the case.
Elizabeth was very disabled.
Her breathing was poor.
Her mobility was very poor.
She had to go around in a wheelchair.
She was put to bed.
She was got up.
She was basically looked after.
She was all but bedbound, but not quite.
(Narrator) One of Elizabeth's nurses was
her daughter-in-law, Karen Vamplew.
(Sheila) Actually, I've bumped into Karen a time or two,
and I've spoken to her, and we just said hello,
and she just seemed an ordinary person like myself.
(Poppy) Karen was an informal carer for Elizabeth,
so although Elizabeth had paid carers coming in,
Karen was helping her with particular things
that she may have needed support with.
(Vicky) By Karen regularly checking in on Elizabeth
and being present for her, it seems that Elizabeth
would have felt a sense of trust and safety around Karen.
Here was somebody who was looking after her,
who wanted to ensure her well-being.
(Narrator) Karen Vamplew was a 41-year-old
mother of four who was known to have financial difficulties.
Karen Vamplew was married to Elizabeth Vamplew's son.
Karen had trouble making ends meet.
There's no question about that.
(Vicky) Chronic financial stress can be
very debilitating for an individual.
So the level of pressure that she would have been
under to pay off her debts, to support her family
would have been immense.
(Narrator) At 1:25 AM on December 15, 2021,
Karen Vamplew called emergency services
to report a fire at Elizabeth's home.
(siren wailing)
The version of events given by Karen was that she had woken up
in the early hours of the morning,
had become nervous around her mother-in-law,
and wanted to check on her.
She drove to the property, said that when she got there,
she had realised she'd forgotten her keys
and couldn't remember the number for the key safe.
She said she'd gone there to look because she
had not had a call from Elizabeth.
(Emma) So she tried to raise her mother-in-law
by knocking on the door and the windows,
and could not get any attention.
But she also doesn't describe seeing, hearing,
or smelling anything else at that time.
My understanding is that she was initially
present for a significant period of time,
when she couldn't find her keys and couldn't access the key lock,
according to her.
She then says that she goes back home to retrieve her key,
but that she'd only left the area for around 10 minutes,
and then returned.
And when she returns,
she opens the front door to Elizabeth's bungalow
and immediately sees smoke.
She said she'd found the fire light.
She said that she'd gone in and pressed an alarm button.
(Emma) Then Karen immediately contacts the fire service.
(tense music)
(siren wailing)
(Narrator) Fire services took just five minutes to respond,
arriving at Elizabeth's home at 1:30 AM.
When the fire service arrive, Karen has then explained
to the fire crews and the fire investigator that
her mother-in-law was a heavy smoker
and had a habit of smoking in bed.
(Narrator) When firemen entered the blazing property,
they encountered intense heat and smoke two feet from the floor.
They found Elizabeth crouched at the foot of her bed.
Elizabeth had to be rescued by two very brave
firemen who got her out alive, despite the fact
she was grievously injured.
She was saying something about cigarettes
to the nurse at the hospital.
(Narrator) Elizabeth was suffering from burns to 80% of her body
and from the effects of smoke inhalation.
Elizabeth was recovered outside by the firefighters
and actually was later taken to hospital, and died there.
(Sheila) All over the television, Facebook, social media,
and in the "Newark Advertiser."
And it was in the "Newark Advertiser" that
I read all about it properly.
I feel very, very sad that the lady had to die.
(unsettling music)
(Narrator) On December 15, 2021,
77-year-old Elizabeth Vamplew died
after being rescued from her burning home.
And police immediately launched an investigation.
(Emma) When I was first told that there had been a fatality,
I was told that she was an elderly lady who lived
in an address on her own,
that she had carers come to help her
on a daily basis in the morning and in the evening,
and that she was largely bedbound and needed help to move around.
I was also told that she had a son and a daughter-in-law who were
part of her family group, and that her daughter-in-law was
part of her care group at times, as well.
(unsettling music)
(Narrator) In the initial stages of the investigation,
police had little evidence to suggest the fire was
not caused by Elizabeth dropping a cigarette in her bedroom.
The information that Karen Vamplew gave
to the fire investigation team at that initial stage
was that Elizabeth was a very heavy smoker
and tended to smoke in bed.
However, information from the carers was
that she did not smoke in her bed.
She smoked once in the morning and once in the evening.
Elizabeth was quite canny in some ways,
because she pretended she didn't smoke, but did,
and hid the cigarette ends in the kitchen
or smoked outside the door.
But she was also very careful about smoking
because whenever she finished her cigarette,
she would put it out under a tap and hide it away to get rid of it.
(Emma) The information about smoking in her bed
was only ever received from Karen, so that was the route
that the initial investigation team followed,
that she was a heavy smoker.
Their conclusion was that the fire was most likely the cause
of a dropped lit cigarette in the bed.
(tense music)
(Narrator) As part of the initial investigation,
both Elizabeth's son and daughter-in-law Karen
were questioned by police.
He was very angry that that had happened to him.
Quite clearly, being at home on the night of his mother's death,
there was nothing to do with him.
(Narrator) Police were particularly interested in questioning
Karen about her movements on the night Elizabeth died.
She said she'd gone there to look
because she had not had a call from Elizabeth.
Her account was she found the fire
and had gone round by chance that night.
That was the basic story.
There was CCTV evidence of her leaving her home.
There was evidence of her car arriving and being parked
quite near to Elizabeth's home.
There was CCTV evidence of her running away from the first visit
back to her car... not walking, running.
There was CCTV evidence of her getting home
carrying what looked like a towel.
There was more CCTV evidence of her coming out of her house,
again, about two minutes later, having changed,
and going back, purporting then to find the house on fire.
(Narrator) Police also discovered Karen contacted
the home insurance company the very day
that Elizabeth had died in the fire.
Karen contacted the insurers on the same day
her mother-in-law dies, and it really just shows
how insensitive she was to the situation.
But equally, it raised suspicions.
(tense music)
(Narrator) In early 2022, police decided
to take a more detailed look into Karen Vamplew's background.
(Emma) I was given very little detail
about the background of the case.
It helps me to remain unbiased.
Since my initial examination of the information,
my understanding is that there was some fraud aspect
to it involving financial gain of Karen
taking money from Elizabeth.
Karen was hard up, no question.
Karen Vamplew's main interest in life, it seemed to me,
was actually money for Karen.
(tense music)
Karen needed Elizabeth's money to make ends meet,
to maintain her lifestyle with her husband and kids.
(Narrator) Despite having no previous criminal record,
police discovered that Karen had been accused
of financial misdealings in the past.
(Peter Joyce) She'd had a previous relationship, which had ended,
when it was suggested that she'd taken money.
And she then dumped that particular friend
or male friend when that came out.
She wasn't charged with anything about that,
but she was investigated about it.
(Narrator) Police also discovered
that in the weeks leading up to her death,
Karen made a number of cash withdrawals
from Elizabeth's account.
I looked at all the banking evidence.
I looked at the evidence of Elizabeth's expenses,
which we saw down the years.
Some of the material that she'd given to Karen
or money she'd given to Karen were legitimate, but very few.
(tense music)
My name is Fiona Hotston Moore, and I'm a forensic accountant
and expert witness.
Typically, when we're looking at someone like Elizabeth
and they're a bit older
and perhaps spending a lot of time at home,
we expect to see fairly modest expenditure.
We would see small amounts for looking after themselves,
maybe the odd gift to the family members,
and then regular payments to their carers.
So it's a very consistent pattern.
(Poppy) When Karen was interviewed by police
several times, at a certain point,
it was disclosed that some of the bills
for Karen and her husband were actually in Elizabeth's name.
And the reason that was given for this was that,
ultimately, the company was potentially
going to cut Karen and her partner off due to the debts,
potentially, that had accrued already.
And so they had put this in Elizabeth's name.
Karen did mention that Elizabeth was aware of this.
If I was looking at the records and I noticed that someone was
paying someone else's bills,
then that could potentially be a red flag.
Why would they be paying them?
It could be out of the kindness of their heart,
but it could suggest that actually they weren't aware they were
paying someone else's bills,
or there was a level of coercion going on.
(Narrator) When police examined Elizabeth's bank statements,
the number of unusual cash withdrawals led
investigators to suspect that Elizabeth had
been the victim of economic abuse.
I think older people, the most common form of abuse
is economic abuse.
It's often for some form of financial gain.
So it's not uncommon for us to see economic abuse
mixed with psychological abuse or coercive control.
(soft music)
(Peter) Karen was one of Elizabeth's carers.
Karen played on that to have access to Elizabeth's finances.
Often the power dynamic when there are care and support needs
for the victims can be worrying when that person who's delivering
that care and support is ultimately somebody
who has their own gain in mind.
And somebody who needs that level of care and support
is going to be very dependent on that person
to provide that for them.
And unfortunately, that puts them in the perfect position
to exploit that power.
Karen was in a trusted position.
She was supporting Elizabeth,
and it is possible that because she was
helping her in her day-to-day activities,
that she felt entitled to something from Elizabeth
and entitled to that money.
(Poppy) Karen admitted in a police interview
that she felt that Elizabeth was quite well off,
money wise, in her opinion.
And ultimately, Elizabeth was in a position
where she owned the bungalow that she lived in.
She was able to pay independently for carers,
for a cleaner, for a gardener.
And to Karen, who was
in significant financial dire straits, ultimately,
this would have potentially been an area of real resentment.
(unsettling music)
(Narrator) Police discovered around April 2021,
Elizabeth had approximately £27,000 in her bank account.
But the balance began to dwindle soon after Karen
became Elizabeth's nurse.
It's relatively easy with online banking
for someone to help or coerce someone into transferring
money out of their investments into another bank account.
And it's potentially difficult to trace that
happening until it's happened.
(Peter) It shows a gradual denuding of the account
of Elizabeth's money and going down, and down, and down.
And you could see transactions happening
which clearly for Karen's benefit.
Karen was doing much of her shopping and things
on Elizabeth's account.
She had access to the card.
We could see where the money had been spent,
and then you could see how the account had been,
basically, reduced over the months
from the moment Karen became a carer with the card.
(tense music)
(Vicky) It is possible that Karen started
to rationalise in her own mind
that she was entitled to some of this money.
She was caring for Elizabeth.
She was checking in on her.
She was doing her day-to-day errands.
So Karen may have felt a sense
of entitlement to those funds.
(tense music)
(Poppy) Hourglass did a piece of research a few years ago,
and one in four people that were spoken to
did not think that taking money
from an older relative's bank account
or precious items from their home counted as abuse.
And this is, unfortunately, a societal issue as a whole.
This notion of entitlement that if you provide care
and support for somebody, you are entitled to money,
you're entitled to belongings it's just not true.
You provide care and support for somebody in your family
because you want to provide care and support for them.
That doesn't come with strings attached,
or it shouldn't come with strings attached.
But ultimately, people do feel entitled
to some form of gain from that.
And that's where these situations in domestic abuse
can really escalate and the risk can really escalate.
(tense music)
(Fiona) In cases such as Elizabeth's,
we would also look at their wider financial investment.
So we'd be looking at any ISAs
and savings and so on that they've got,
and seeing whether those ISAs and savings were still there.
Or was there evidence that actually those had
been drawn from as well?
(Narrator) Police also discovered that
in the days leading up to her death,
£10,000 was withdrawn
from Elizabeth's individual savings account, known as an ISA.
(tense music)
(Poppy) This essentially goes
to show the access that Karen does have,
not only to Elizabeth's account.
But we have to think about
how she may have coerced that from Elizabeth
and what the conversations may have been to lead to that,
whether it's emotional manipulation,
whether it's coercive control and the level of threat there.
There are lots and lots of ways that people can use
to essentially manipulate and exploit older people
for financial gain.
(unsettling music)
(Vicky) Karen was in a position of trust.
Elizabeth had trusted her with access to her accounts.
And over time, Karen took advantage of that trust
and drained Elizabeth's account of her savings.
This tells me that Karen had really started to see Elizabeth
as a means to an end.
Elizabeth was a financial source for her.
It seems that Karen had stopped seeing Elizabeth as a human being,
and she was reduced to an object that could
satisfy her own needs and desires.
(tense music)
(Narrator) During their investigation
into Elizabeth Vamplew's death, police discovered that
the day before Elizabeth died in the house fire,
Karen Vamplew accompanied her mother-in-law to the bank.
(Peter) The bank was saying, before we authorise funds,
any more payments on the card,
we want to see the older Mrs Vamplew,
in other words, Elizabeth, to see whether or not
she was being taken advantage of by the user of the card.
Elizabeth was bedbound,
and Karen did something with regard to the phone
that stopped the bank getting in touch directly with Elizabeth,
like turning off the answering machine, something like that.
But she prevented the bank getting directly to Elizabeth
while she, Karen, was milking the account.
(Narrator) When the bank were unable to speak with Elizabeth
on the phone, the bank limited Elizabeth's spending
to just £5 per transaction.
And that's when the bank put a stop on the card.
And effectively, that's when the goose stopped
laying the golden egg.
It's also the time, I think, when Elizabeth first
became really aware as to just how extensive
Karen's raiding of her account had been.
(Poppy) On the 14th of December, 2021,
Karen accompanied Elizabeth to the bank.
And this is something that we may see in situations where
that perpetrator will attend appointments,
whether at a bank, a GP surgery,
with social care, with that victim,
because ultimately, what this does is,
if that victim is concerned that something's going on
or something untoward may be happening,
particularly with their finances, because Karen went with Elizabeth,
it leaves very little room for any disclosures
to be made to bank staff, or to any other professionals
that we see in these situations, as well.
(tense music)
(Peter) And it's almost certain
that that was the first time that Elizabeth really understood
just how Karen had been milking Elizabeth's account,
because there was virtually nothing left in it.
It was very, very depleted by her daughter-in-law.
For the first time, Elizabeth knew just what
had been happening to her money.
(tense music)
(Narrator) After examining bank records,
police discovered that in just eight months,
Elizabeth's account balance dropped
from £27,000 to £105.
It's very likely that during that trip to the bank,
Elizabeth realised how much money had been taken out of her account,
the vast differences with what should be in there,
to her knowledge, and what was actually in the account.
And it may be at that point,
she has become aware that she has been exploited
by her daughter-in-law, Karen.
And ultimately, in that moment, you have to consider
the horror, the betrayal, the concerns about money worries.
Because not only has this been done
by somebody in a position of trust and somebody within the family,
so that betrayal is going to be very much overwhelming.
(Narrator) The trip to the bank was less than 24 hours before the fire
that would take Elizabeth's life.
There was not really much time for Elizabeth to react,
and if she was made aware during that trip to the bank,
the financial economic abuse that was happening
from her daughter-in-law, it is quite suspicious
that the incident happened the following day.
And similarly, something that we see as a charity,
when there are grandchildren in a situation,
an older person may not choose to report to the police,
because ultimately, they do not want to criminalise the parents
of their grandchildren.
(Peter) The day after the visit to the bank,
two things happened, I think.
Elizabeth found out what had been happening,
and the day after, the money had ceased for Karen.
Elizabeth had ceased to be of use to Karen.
She was only a burden now in terms of having to care for her,
and so she killed her.
(dramatic music)
(flames crackling)
(Narrator) With police now believing that Elizabeth was
the victim of economic abuse before she died,
fire expert Emma Wilson was brought in to determine exactly where
and how the fire was started.
The damage at the bungalow was relatively limited.
It was primarily restricted to the bedroom that Elizabeth used.
There was some damage that had come out
into the hallway of the bungalow,
and some smoke damage had spread to some of the rooms
where doors had been open.
However, information from the carers was that
she did not smoke in her bed.
(Peter) Elizabeth didn't take cigarettes into her bedroom.
She normally smoked at the kitchen door
so the smell would not invade the house.
She didn't want the smell in the house,
which was another feature why you wouldn't
have her smoking in her bedroom.
And she always took great care to get rid
of the evidence of having smoked.
(Narrator) Emma was also sceptical of Karen Vamplew's account
that she hadn't noticed the fire when she first arrived
at her mother in law's home.
So Karen's story didn't make sense,
because if she had been outside that front door of the bungalow
10 minutes prior to her entering it
and alerting the fire service to a large flaming fire,
I would have expected her to have heard the smoke detector,
smelled smoke or seen smoke as she looked through the letter slot,
and, therefore, to have alerted the fire service at that point
of a fire within the property.
As a fire scientist, my issue with that is,
there is a difference in the way that flaming fires
and smouldering fires burn.
Smouldering fires develop with large amounts
of smoke, but no flames.
They can take a minimum of 10 minutes on the right materials,
but more likely 20, 30 minutes, or several hours
to develop into a flaming fire.
Whereas a flaming fire, or a fire started by a lighter or a match,
that continues as a flaming fire for its entire duration
and only takes minutes to really take hold.
So there is a big difference in the timing factors
of those different types of fires.
(Narrator) Emma Wilson and the forensic team examined
photographic evidence from the fire
to determine if she believed the fire had been started
by Elizabeth smoking in bed.
The only evidence of smoking materials that I saw in the images
was in the kitchen.
(Peter) They went into great detail as to where the fire had started.
I mean, they looked in the kitchen for things
like cigarettes and the ashtray.
I did ask the initial investigation team
if they found anything amongst the debris.
The reason I asked that is because when something like a lighter
is burnt in a fire, it doesn't look like a lighter anymore.
All you have are the metallic parts.
So you have the lighter shroud, you have the flint wheel,
but you don't have the plastic bodies.
I asked the initial investigation team
if they'd found anything like that,
and they said they had not.
(Narrator) The forensic team decided to carry out
a series of tests to replicate the start of the fire
using samples of Elizabeth's bedding.
(Emma) As part of their investigation,
they did carry out some laboratory-based burning tests.
These were small-scale tests based on fragments of the bedding
and the mattress recovered from the scene.
The tests that were done, however, were inconclusive.
This is likely because there had been a fire.
Firefighters had extinguished the fire with quite a lot of water,
so the materials that they used were
no longer in their primary state.
So they were wet, and they'd probably
suffered from being packaged in plastic packaging
for a while afterwards, as well.
(tense music)
The conclusion that they reached was that with those materials,
it did not cause a fire,
but given that they had been altered
by the addition of firefighting water,
that they couldn't be sure that under other conditions,
such as the materials being dry,
that it could not have caused a fire.
(unsettling music)
(Narrator) Emma Wilson decided to carry out
more elaborate tests to determine the cause of the fire.
I made two recommendations.
One recommendation was to carry out a new series of burning tests,
to use dry materials that were the same or as similar
as possible to those that Elizabeth had in her property.
And that meant getting the same type of mattress,
getting bedding of the same type, and also washing it,
and making sure that it had some wear to it
so that it wasn't brand new,
and then setting up a burning test so that we could see
whether or not, on these dry materials that were
as close as possible to the ones Elizabeth had,
whether or not we could start a fire using a cigarette.
(tense music)
They did all sorts of tests.
They did do tests with the fire expert.
They did it in a shipping container with identical mattress,
identical things.
They needed to prove that
Elizabeth hadn't set fire to the bed herself.
(tense music)
(Emma) We set up a mattress with the bedding.
We carry out several tests using cigarettes,
all of the same brand that Elizabeth smoked.
We would light them and we would put them in different positions
within the bedding.
That included partial covering with the duvet.
That included putting it on the pillow
and on the mattress with the sheet on it itself.
So we did several tests, and none of them
initiated even a smouldering fire.
The final test that we carried out involved
applying a flame to the corner of the bed,
and that initiated a fire immediately.
(tense music)
The fire that we lit caused fire damage in a very similar pattern
to what could be seen in Elizabeth's bedroom.
(tense music)
It was my opinion in my review process
that this was not an accidental death at that stage.
So it means that somebody set the fire,
rather than it being a dropped lit cigarette.
(tense music)
I think it was at this point that the investigation team were
confident that they could say that this fire was caused by a person
applying a flame to the bedding.
(tense music)
They completely disproved any idea that a cigarette...
a lit cigarette could have caused the fire to Elizabeth's bed.
And they proved that the only way the fire could have been started
was by a live flame ignition.
(tense music)
(Narrator) On September 27, 2023,
Karen Vamplew is re-arrested and charged with the murder
of her mother-in-law, Elizabeth.
Having spoken to two CPS lawyers, I think,
it was quite apparent, having spoken to them,
that they'd come to the conclusion she should be prosecuted.
I'm bound to say my reaction was exactly the same.
She must be.
And the fact that Elizabeth
was bed bound at the top of the bed
and the fire started at the foot of the bed
clearly meant that someone else had lit it.
The case was with a lighter.
(tense music)
The report proved that it was caused by naked flame.
Now, that would not have been, and could not have been
at the foot of the bed done by Elizabeth.
So there's one obvious person.
Karen.
(tense music)
(suspenseful music)
(Narrator) In April 2024, Karen Vamplew stood trial
at Leicester Crown Court
for the murder of her mother-in-law, Elizabeth Vamplew.
(Peter) It was emotion.
The emotion in the dock was the defendant looking at photographs
of her children throughout.
The emotion in the public gallery was her husband.
(Vicky) Karen would have known that
by killing Elizabeth, that was going to bring
a tremendous amount of grief and loss
to her husband and the family.
Yet, it seems that she justified her actions by convincing herself
that the ends justified the means,
that her husband was going to inherit the money,
that Elizabeth was old and frail,
and that removing that pain for her,
it is possible that she justified all of those things.
(Narrator) Despite pleading not guilty,
Karen Vamplew did not give evidence in court.
(Peter) But she didn't come out at the dock.
She didn't give evidence.
She didn't risk giving evidence and risk being cross-examined
about the overwhelming case that, in the end, we had against her
because there was no satisfactory answer she could give.
She couldn't possibly have answered
the questions I was going to have for her,
so she didn't come out.
(tense music)
(Vicky) Despite the evidence against her,
Karen protested her innocence.
And that can be for a number of reasons.
It's a method of self-protection and self-survival.
Again, Karen may also have had the dawning of realisation
that she's killed a family member,
she's killed a mother-in-law, and the significant impact
that that's going to have on her family.
(tense music)
(Narrator) After a 21-month investigation,
the prosecution argued money was Karen's motive
for killing Elizabeth.
(dramatic music)
(Peter) We could prove that Karen had
been taking money from Elizabeth.
What I was really interested in proving was that she killed her.
If you're prosecuting a case, you don't actually need a motive
so long as you can prove the killing.
I was proving the killing because that's what she was charged with.
She wasn't charged with fraud.
That was the motive for the killing.
(dramatic music)
(Narrator) During the trial, Elizabeth's financial records were
shown to the jury to illustrate the depth
of the financial abuse she suffered in the weeks before her death.
(Fiona Hotston Moore) In cases like Elizabeth's case,
we would be obtaining the banking records of the victim
over a number of years, and we would be analysing them
to see what was their typical areas that they spent money on,
to try and get a feel for how much they typically spent in a year,
and in which areas they spent it.
And then we would be looking for changes
in those trends of expenditure.
So are there now larger amounts, perhaps,
being withdrawn from the bank or cash transactions?
And who is making those withdrawals,
if we can actually tell?
And what might be the reason for those?
So those would be the telltale red flags.
(tense music)
(Narrator) During the trial, the prosecution also
highlighted the number of inconsistencies
in Karen's version of what happened the night Elizabeth died.
She told friends different things.
She told her husband different things.
She told family different things.
She had been lying to all these people about what had happened,
the order of events, who'd gone where,
when she'd found the fire, and so on.
She'd just been lying to her friends and family throughout.
And they basically felt betrayed.
(tense music)
Karen had spun a web of lies.
Her stories were inconsistent, her accounts were discrepant,
and investigators would have picked up on that
and used that to their advantage.
(Narrator) The prosecution argued that once she had drained
Elizabeth's account of all her funds,
Karen set fire to Elizabeth's home because she believed her husband
would inherit half of her mother-in-law's estate,
thought to be worth around £150,000.
I think she probably hoped that her husband would get
a part of his mother's will, and she, Karen,
would benefit from it, because she would have left
a reasonable estate behind, as well.
It would have been a sizable sum of money for Karen's husband
and Karen's sister-in-law, which no doubt Karen would
have hoped to have benefited from.
(sombre music)
(Vicky) Karen had rationalised in her mind
that she needed the money, and that someday,
her husband was going to inherit that money.
She needed the money there and then,
so she... there is evidence of her using identity fraud
and taking money from Elizabeth's account
to fund her own lifestyle.
Her actions became desensitised, and she started to morally justify
in her own mind why taking money from Elizabeth
at this stage in her life was appropriate and valid.
So she justified it.
She'd rationalised it in her own mind,
and therefore very quickly had accepted
a conclusion that ending Elizabeth's life
was one of the options.
I think the real motive was, in fact,
getting rid of the burden of having to care for someone
when you really didn't want to.
(Narrator) A key piece of evidence for the prosecution was
the testimony of fire expert Emma Wilson.
As an expert witness arriving at court,
knowing that your testimony is
going to be a large part of the case,
it's going to be a big part of the jury's considerations,
and it's going to help them make their decision
on innocence and guilt.
For me, knowing that that's
the reason I'm appearing in court, there's a nervousness to it.
(tense music)
(Narrator) Emma's testimony was vital to prove
that the fire could not have been started
by Elizabeth smoking in bed.
(Peter) Elizabeth never, on the evidence, smoked in her room.
Secondly, she always smoked in the kitchen or by the door...
the open door.
She didn't like people to smell the fact she'd been smoking.
She didn't like people to see that she'd been smoking,
which was why she'd put the cigarette out under the tap,
rather than leaving a sort of smelly ember.
Basically, she hid the fact that she'd been smoking
from the carers coming from her sister.
They all knew she smoked, but she was... pretends that she didn't.
But she didn't take cigarettes into her bedroom.
(tense music)
(Emma) Considering the physical evidence that we have,
it's my view that it's more likely
that Karen entered Elizabeth's bungalow,
went to her bedroom, ignited a fire on the bed
whilst Elizabeth was in it, and then left the property,
and closed the door after her.
She then went home, got changed,
and it is likely that she had some sort of injury
or wound or burn on her arm,
and that's why she had a towel covering it when she returned,
that when she returned, she did enter a property that
was filled with smoke and had a fairly sizable fire within it,
and pressed the careline.
(unsettling music)
It is likely that Elizabeth became aware of the fire
because she wasn't found in her bed.
She was found by the firefighters at the base
of the bed on the floor,
so she had made some attempt to escape.
(melancholy music)
(Narrator) The prosecution argued that Karen's movement on the night
of the fire clearly showed this was a crime
of planning and premeditation.
She went around to Elizabeth's house when Elizabeth was in bed,
having been tucked up for the night by the carers
at about 6:00.
And she went round and set fire to the bed
whilst Elizabeth was in it.
Eventually, when she went back for the second time,
pretending to find the fire that she'd lit,
poor Elizabeth had managed,
however disabled, to get out of bed,
and was lying on the floor at the foot of the bed.
And that's where she was rescued by the firemen.
(tense music)
The offence shows a level of planning and premeditation,
although there's clearly evidence of a lack
of sophistication within that.
Karen had access to the home
and started the fire in the home.
So for Karen, she was intent upon doing this.
She'd planned it.
It was now or never.
She had to take the opportunity, and that's what she did,
starting the fire, burning the house down
with Elizabeth in it.
(Narrator) On May 17, 2024,
the jury delivered their verdict.
She was convicted of murder unanimously by the jury.
No question of a majority verdict.
(melancholy music)
Hearing the verdict, it is almost like a sense of completion,
because to me and the evidence that I had,
that is what I would have expected the jury to get from that.
(Peter) She had to be given life in prison,
because that's the only sentence for murder.
And in this case, it was 32 years.
(melancholy music)
(Narrator) Despite the successful conviction,
the verdict provided mixed emotions for Elizabeth's family.
(Peter) I went to see the family and friends.
It was then that it became...
I became aware just how cross the husband was.
Her husband was very angry, not at the verdict.
He was very angry that the initial police investigation had
wrongly arrested him, because he was nothing to do
with the killing of his mother.
He was livid that he had been arrested
in the first investigation, and understandably.
(melancholy music)
(Vicky) There are no winners in this.
The tragedy of losing a mother in the way that she was lost,
a grandmother in the way that she was lost, but equally,
a wife and a mother who would have been detained
and is detained for a very long time,
the psychological shadow and effects of that would...
would be immense.
(melancholy music)
(Poppy) It's very hard to imagine
how Elizabeth's family would have been affected by this situation.
I think it's very difficult to think about them having to pick up
the pieces of not only losing someone that was very dear to them
and a huge part of their family.
But also, who the perpetrator was and what the motivations were
is going to be really, really hard to come
to terms with as a family member.
It is almost a double betrayal.
You've lost somebody, and the person that has taken
them from you is also within your family.
(melancholy music)
(tense music)
Subtitles by accessibility@itv.com
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.