All language subtitles for Fatal.Fraud.S01E02.1080p.WEB.h264-CODSWALLOP_track3_[eng]

af Afrikaans
ak Akan
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bem Bemba
bn Bengali
bh Bihari
bs Bosnian
br Breton
bg Bulgarian
km Cambodian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
chr Cherokee
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
da Danish
nl Dutch
en English
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
ee Ewe
fo Faroese
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gaa Ga
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek
gn Guarani
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ia Interlingua
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
rw Kinyarwanda
rn Kirundi
kg Kongo
ko Korean
kri Krio (Sierra Leone)
ku Kurdish
ckb Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Laothian
la Latin
lv Latvian
ln Lingala
lt Lithuanian
loz Lozi
lg Luganda
ach Luo
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mfe Mauritian Creole
mo Moldavian
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
sr-ME Montenegrin
ne Nepali
pcm Nigerian Pidgin
nso Northern Sotho
no Norwegian
nn Norwegian (Nynorsk)
oc Occitan
or Oriya
om Oromo
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt-BR Portuguese (Brazil) Download
pt Portuguese (Portugal)
pa Punjabi
qu Quechua
ro Romanian
rm Romansh
nyn Runyakitara
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
sh Serbo-Croatian
st Sesotho
tn Setswana
crs Seychellois Creole
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhalese
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish
es-419 Spanish (Latin American)
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
tt Tatar
te Telugu
th Thai
ti Tigrinya
to Tonga
lua Tshiluba
tum Tumbuka
tr Turkish
tk Turkmen
tw Twi
ug Uighur
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
wo Wolof
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu

Original subtitles

(Narrator) Every fraud begins with a promise,

but most don't end in a murder.

(Tom Truman) They were selling the idea

that you could make a lot of money

if you could secure government contracts.

(Narrator) A quick fortune, easy money, or a life torn apart.

(Ashley Acord) We have this really cool idea for a company,

and we think it could make you a lot of money.

If you put in $10,000, you'll get back $60,000.

(Narrator) But behind these illusions

lie calculated deceptions, carefully hidden in plain sight.

(Keri Nixon) In fraud, trust is a weapon.

Without it, you wouldn't get anywhere.

(Narrator) Sometimes these criminals are backed into a corner

and feel their only way out is to kill.

(Tim Bledsoe) After the initial interview

was when I really knew in my gut that this was a murder.

(dramatic music)

(Tom) Prosecutors love to have the stuff you see on TV...

DNA, fingerprints, videos, confessions.

We had none of them.

(suspenseful music)

(Tim) My name is Tim Bledsoe.

I'm a retired lieutenant with the West Virginia State Police.

It's a small community.

Like most communities in West Virginia,

the majority of the people either know each other

or know of each other.

It's a fairly quiet community, low crime rate.

Somewhere, you know, that you would imagine

would be a good place to raise a family.

(Narrator) In 2017, Michael and Natalie Cochran and their children

were well-known in the local community.

(Micah Leith) My name is Micah Leith,

and I'm the news director at WOAY-TV.

The Cochrans lived in the same community that they grew up in.

Michael and Natalie were high school sweethearts.

They dated throughout college, and they were married.

And most of the people that they became friends with

in the community at least knew of them their entire lives.

(Tom) I'm Tom Truman.

I'm the prosecuting attorney for Raleigh County, West Virginia.

The Daniels community is very tight-knit,

and the Cochrans were heavily involved, especially youth sports.

(Micah) Michael was seen as this...very involved

in his kids' lives. He was really into sports.

He was always body-building and powerlifting with friends.

(Ashley) My name is Ashley Acord.

I'm an assistant prosecuting attorney

for Raleigh County, West Virginia.

Michael Cochran was very enamoured with his wife, Natalie.

He loved his children.

He was very involved in their lives

and in all of their activities.

He would coach sports, hold fundraisers,

do really anything he could to be involved.

(Micah) Natalie was kind of seen as the typical mum.

She worked a good job.

She took care of her kids.

In the community, they had a pretty high profile.

They were involved in a lot of community events

at church, in youth athletics, which, in Southern West Virginia,

youth athletics are probably the biggest thing

that pulls its community together.

(Tom) Natalie went to West Virginia University,

graduated from pharmacy school.

She was such an accomplished pharmacist that CVS

paid for her to get an MBA.

She developed a specialty with diabetes.

(Micah) I can't overemphasise it enough how trusted Natalie was.

Her neighbour more or less trusted her

to provide medical guidance to their child

who was diagnosed with diabetes.

I mean, these are people that grew up with Natalie.

They knew Natalie their whole life.

(Ashley) Michael was definitely

a more domineering figure.

He was a man's man, very prototypical in that way.

And Natalie was always his rock, like the person that

supported him and was behind him.

(Narrator) In June 2017, the couple started a new business venture.

(Tim) Natalie Cochran left the profession of pharmacy in 2017

to form a business with her husband called

Tactical Solutions Group, or TSG.

(Tom) They were selling the idea

that you could make a lot of money

if you could secure government contracts.

And she would get people to invest saying, oh,

there's all sorts of money to be made here.

The government would put out a solicitation for something

that they needed, whether that was medical supplies

or weapons or anything like that.

And then these companies would bid on those contracts and would say,

we can fill them for this price.

So Natalie actually got the idea for TSG

from watching the movie "War Dogs."

And in that movie, they had a company that operated the same way

that TSG was purported to work.

She would tell her friends and family,

hey, you know, Michael and I just watched this really great movie,

and we have this really cool idea for a company,

and we think it could make you a lot of money.

And so she would promise them, you know, if you put in $10,000,

you'll get back $60,000.

And people were, you know, more than willing

to buy into that because they trusted her.

They would get the contract, make the purchases,

and provide them to the government.

The government would pay them for it.

That's how it was supposed to work,

but in reality, it didn't work like that.

(Narrator) The couple operated under two company names:

Technology Management Solutions, TMS,

and Tactical Solutions Group, TSG.

They had an office nearby in Beckley.

(Ashley) Michael Cochran was purported to be the one

that was actually looking for contracts.

And Natalie specifically targeted people that she knew trusted her.

She went to Michael's family.

She went to her own family.

She specifically would go to people that she knew

had money to spare, like businessmen, lawyers, dentists.

(Keri) In fraud, trust is a weapon.

Trust is crucial.

If a family member or a friend that you trusted

and you thought were capable...

they were a professional person,

and they were known in the community...

that would mean that you would trust them.

(Tim) The Cochrans gave the appearance

they did a tremendous volume of firearms sales

and provided a tremendous amount of firearms contracts

to the federal government.

Natalie was offering for these weapons

with sometimes 75% less than what you would pay for retail.

(suspenseful music)

She claimed that the investment opportunities

into the Tactical Solutions Group were very lucrative,

and they would be very lucrative for the potential investor,

but in reality, there was no investment.

It was just... it was a Ponzi scheme.

(Fiona Hotston Moore) My name is Fiona Hotston Moore,

and I'm a forensic accountant and expert witness.

Ponzi schemes are named after one of the very early cases,

a very large case which was perpetrated by Mr Ponzi.

Typically, the way that it works is that the fraudster will

approach friends and family,

they will take small amounts of investments.

They will promise high returns, and they will make high returns

to those initial investors.

But those returns are actually coming from other investors.

It is artificial. There is no business.

It grows very quickly and then tends

to collapse very quickly with, typically, no money

being available to repay the victims.

(Narrator) As the scheme grew, Natalie persuaded

more investors to buy in.

One person in North Carolina invested over $500,000.

A later investor would bring their money in.

Natalie would take a chunk of it and give it to an earlier investor

and say, hey, here's part of your return on your investment.

But we have this other big contract coming up,

and I think you should reinvest it

because it will really double the return

that you're going to get, or triple or quadruple it.

So that was one way that she kind of kept the scheme going.

But over time, it's not... a Ponzi scheme is not sustainable

because the investments dry up.

And that was exactly what was happening here.

(Narrator) In late 2018, Michael and Natalie Cochran

had gotten investments of almost $2.5 million

for contracts to the US government.

(Ashley) When that money from the investments,

from friends and family, was in Natalie's pocket,

she and Michael were really living large.

They were buying new properties.

They bought a boat. They bought a motorcycle.

They bought new cars.

They went on lavish vacations.

(Micah) They were making extravagant purchases,

going on trips, bringing friends and family with them,

and paying for all of it,

living a lifestyle that was pretty foreign

to a lot of people that are in this town.

It certainly seemed that their business was thriving.

There was no indication that

there was anything bad under the surface.

It just seemed like they had built a business

that was performing extremely well.

My name is Dr Keri Nixon,

and I'm a consultant forensic psychologist.

Their spending habits, their presentation,

their standing in the community... all of these things

are part of the same motivator to generate trust,

generate confidence.

(Ashley) Natalie was spending a lot of the money

from investors on personal items.

She would buy luxury handbags.

She bought a pair of bulldog puppies.

She was really just willing to show off all of the money

that she had suddenly come into.

(Tim) The Cochrans made some very large purchases,

you know, but also, in that, demonstrates a lot about who

Michael Cochran was as well.

He not only spent money for himself or for his family,

but he spent money for others.

He did acts of philanthropy for the local school,

for the local youth sports.

There was a local widow. Her husband had passed.

He purchased her a home.

(Narrator) Natalie was spending enormous amounts of money

on personal and luxury purchases.

On loan applications, they inflated the value of their business

as having assets of over $500 million.

Some of the people that Natalie got to invest

were able to come up with a couple thousand dollars

to put into the company.

But there were some who were very wealthy individuals

in high-paying jobs or maybe, you know,

had family money or something.

And those people would invest hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Over time, convincing those same people to reinvest in the company,

she was able to come up with at least

a good couple million dollars.

(Fiona) I think the Cochran Ponzi scheme started

with the intention to defraud.

There appeared to be no evidence that it ever was

a proper trading business, that it had any contracts

with the governments that it said it was going to do.

(Tim) I think there were approximately 12 known

victim investors of the Ponzi scheme.

With the exception of maybe one investor who made one lump sum

of about $500,000 at one time, most of the investors

came in in smaller increments.

(Fiona) Red flags that might indicate a Ponzi scheme

is the very rapid growth of a business,

the lack of financial reports,

the lack of evidence that there is, actually, external customers,

and perhaps the observation

that those that are running the business

actually appear to be making quite a lot of money themselves.

(Tim) It was becoming unsustainable because the money was running out,

and there were no new investors coming in.

So I think, at some point, you know,

it was going to come to a head.

(suspenseful music)

(Narrator) By early 2019, investors were becoming anxious

about receiving returns on their investment.

(Tim) Natalie gave a number of different excuses.

A fictitious government audit was one.

At one point, the US government

had a legitimate government shutdown.

You know, so that provided her some time.

That one, she just got lucky.

Some of the excuses were the government

not being able to pay on time or not being able to complete

a wire transfer or something.

There was a problem at the bank.

There was always some kind of an excuse.

(Tom) One of Natalie's many excuses for not making payments was,

she's been diagnosed with cancer.

Well, then she claimed

she had been sick all night, spiked temperature,

and she needed to be taking insulin

to counteract her chemotherapy.

There is a connection between some chemotherapy and taking insulin,

so that was a plausible explanation.

(Narrator) In early 2019, Natalie, a qualified pharmacist,

asked her neighbour, Jennifer, if she could borrow

some of her supply of the medicine.

(Tom) Natalie tells Jennifer that she was so sick from her chemo

and needed to take insulin, but if she could just borrow a bottle,

she would pay it back later.

So Jennifer, being the good neighbour and loyal friend

that she is, sends her husband to the Cochran house

with a bottle of insulin and some other things in a bag.

(Narrator) Other people in the community

also rallied to support Natalie.

Natalie was the treasurer of a local Little League.

And when she was telling people that she had cancer,

a friend of theirs stepped in and was helping with those accounts.

And as he's looking at those accounts,

he sees there's thousands of dollars missing.

And there are also purchases on there for clothing boutiques,

for fancy dinners, for things that are not

related to Little League, that are not purchases

the League should be making.

(Micah) A lot of money went missing from the Little League.

When they went and looked at the account,

they had hardly any money in there,

and there was supposed to be several thousands of dollars

and all kinds of transactions made,

likely by Natalie Cochran, for dinners and shopping trips

and all kinds of things.

(Narrator) In early February, Michael became concerned

about investors' feedback on the business.

So he and Natalie arranged a meeting at their bank,

hoping to resolve the payment delays.

(Micah) The Cochrans were supposed to fly to Virginia

to meet with a representative of the bank to discuss an issue

they were having with their account that was supposed to be

getting the money from the federal government.

(Tim) Natalie took the kids to school that morning.

Michael had also been out and about that morning.

He had gone to get coffee and returned home.

(Micah) The morning they were supposed to fly,

Natalie cancelled the flight.

(Tim) Michael was very upset because they were not able

to go to the Bank of America.

She had had to cancel the flight.

And that he was so upset that she had given him

two of her blood pressure pills, and he had taken those

and had been sleeping ever since.

(Ashley) Around 12:30 in the afternoon,

Natalie sends a text message to a pair of contractors

that worked for her and Michael,

and she tells them that Michael is unconscious

in the floor of their kitchen, and she needs them

to help her get him to the couch.

Around that same time, she has taken a photograph

of Michael laying in the foetal position

in the floor of their kitchen.

(Tim) Natalie also texted a...

another friend of the family, who was also in law enforcement

and asked him to come to the house as well to help with Michael.

They moved Michael to the couch in the home.

And these contractors described seeing Natalie

checking Michael's vital signs

and, too, including his blood glucose.

(sirens wailing)

(Narrator) Later that day, Michael was transported to the hospital.

(Tim) When Michael arrived at the hospital, initially,

they found that his blood glucose level was critically low,

and there was no way to know how long it had been that low,

other than to see that he was in great distress.

The decision was made to immediately intubate him.

He was deteriorating rapidly.

And the facility he was at did not have

the trauma capabilities necessary to treat him

to the level that he needed.

And the decision was made to transfer him

to Charleston Area Medical Centre.

(Narrator) Natalie reported to medical staff

that Michael had taken 25 times his usual amount

of a body-building supplement purchased from Mexico.

(Tim) She told them that he had overdosed

on this Mexican supplement.

Michael was treated for a few days there,

and Natalie made the decision to have care removed.

And he passed within just a few hours of his arrival.

(Tom) The death of Michael Cochran made no sense.

He was a perfectly healthy, 38-year-old, fit man.

And then all of a sudden, he was unconscious,

and days later, he was dead.

(pensive music)

(Narrator) On February 11, 2019,

Michael Cochran was pronounced dead.

News of his death spread quickly through the community.

(Ashley) Michael died in hospice after he fell unconscious at home.

This, to everyone, was very jarring, I think,

and very shocking because

Michael was a very healthy 38-year-old man.

(Tom) The death of Michael Cochran made no sense.

That made no sense to a lot of people,

including the investigators that took this case.

(Ashley) I think, following Michael's death,

people started to get a little suspicious about the Ponzi scheme.

I know that there was one particular investor who

was owed several thousand dollars.

He had told Natalie, you know, get me my money,

or I'm going to the police.

And he did.

(Narrator) It was at this point the state police

began to look into the Cochrans' business,

suspecting some sort of fraud.

(Tim) We were made aware of this potential financial crime.

The gentleman, who was a business owner in the Beckley area,

had approached one of our state troopers

who he was acquainted with

and informed him that he had invested money

into Natalie's company,

and he had been unable to get any satisfaction on his investment.

And as time had moved forward,

she had become increasingly disengaged with him,

trying to provide different excuses

as to why she was unable to fulfil the agreement they had reached.

(Fiona) You can hide a Ponzi scheme,

I think, short-term.

So you can be giving verbal reports back

to your family and the investors.

I think it becomes more and more difficult the longer things go on.

Because as time goes on, people will be expecting

to see financial accounts.

They will be expecting to see audit reports and so on.

And those will not exist.

(Tim) I saw the text messages between them.

You know, originally, she was very sweet and very kind

with this gentleman.

And as he pressed her more to try to get some satisfaction

over this deal, she became increasingly belligerent

in her texts.

In that conversation, he had also informed the trooper

that Michael Cochran had recently died

and that the circumstances surrounding his death

were somewhat suspicious.

There was no investigation into his death.

There was no autopsy.

At that point, we decided pretty early on

that we wanted to just offer Natalie

an opportunity to speak with us.

I contacted her by phone.

We had no reason, really, to believe

that Natalie had done anything intentional

to Michael to cause his death.

But it certainly needed to be answered, one way or the other.

Her position was that Michael had taken

an overdose of a body-building supplement

that he was using as part of his body-building workout.

Natalie had told us that she had given

this Mexican supplement to the doctors

at Charleston Area Medical Centre.

But when we investigated that, that was not true.

She said that the clomiphene citrate was a supplement

that Michael ordered from Mexico, when, in fact,

her emails showed that she was the one ordering it

and that it came from Florida.

The second interview I had with her, she goes full in on,

Michael was using insulin, injecting himself with insulin.

And she had introduced insulin into the conversation.

That was the turning point right there

in the death investigation, for sure.

(Ashley) There was no evidence that Michael

had ever injected insulin.

In fact, we knew Michael was afraid of needles.

(Narrator) Insulin is used by diabetics to regulate blood sugar,

but if used by someone who doesn't have diabetes,

it can be very dangerous.

I think it's fascinating that Natalie,

who was a pharmacist by trade, in the police interviews,

almost points the finger on herself, inadvertently,

by bringing up the factor of insulin.

She's thinking she's being clever when, actually,

by giving too much information,

she led the police directly back to her.

(Tim) After a month, I think, after the initial interview

was when... when I really knew in my gut

that this was a murder.

Because she had called to complain to our state police headquarters

about what she described as an investigation of her

and wanting it stopped.

No spouse is going to ask that an investigation

into another human being's death be stopped

unless you have something to hide.

So that's the way we presented it to her,

was like, look, ma'am, we're just trying to find out

why your husband's dead. We're not investigating you.

I don't know... and that's what we told her.

I said, we don't know why you're describing this

as an investigation of you.

We're not investigating you.

In reality, we were investigating the Ponzi scheme.

We just didn't want her to know that.

(suspenseful music)

(Narrator) West Virginia State Police

had been investigating Natalie and Michael Cochran's business,

looking for proof of fraud.

Now they suspected she may have also killed her husband.

Late March 2019 and June of 2019, we were accumulating

a massive amount of financial records, bank statements,

bank transactions, anything that we could get

to further the Ponzi scheme investigation, to, hopefully,

arrive at enough probable cause to obtain a search warrant.

(tense music)

(Tom) Investigators had developed a case sufficient

where they got a search warrant,

and they searched the Cochran home that day.

(Tim) We were able to seize her cell phone, and then,

through that search warrant, obtaining,

obviously, digital evidence from her phone,

we were able to pull out just the text messages

between Michael and Natalie.

And there were thousands of pages

that was extremely revealing, to say the least.

(Fiona) If I was looking to give evidence

as to whether Michael knew that Natalie's business

or their business was legitimate,

I would be looking at the communications

that Michael was involved in to see whether he actually

was looking at the bank statements.

Was he seeing the flow of funds?

Is there an email suggesting that

he actually knew what was going on?

Or was his involvement fairly peripheral?

It presented the dynamic of the relationship pretty fast,

you know, especially when it related to how

the TSG business was being operated.

Michael was, I guess, more of the mouthpiece.

He believed that when he sent her these contracts,

that she was doing exactly what he said, and then she was not.

You could see, just from the financial documents that we were

reviewing early on, that the problems with

the Little League account were just a drop in the bucket,

compared to what was really going on with this TSG company.

(Ashley) She had these doctored headings

for financial institutions, banks,

lending agencies, things like that.

She made up Federal Reserve employees and email addresses

and would give those fake email addresses to Michael

so that he thought he was communicating with someone,

only for his emails to bounce back because they weren't real.

(Tom) They seized a number of electronic devices.

And they also found a bottle of insulin,

which was consistent with a bottle of insulin

that had been loaned to Natalie

by a neighbour whose son had diabetes.

(Ashley) That was significant for a couple of reasons...

one, because, at that point,

we did not know what had killed Michael.

Two, no one in the house was diabetic

or had any need for insulin.

And three, the day that Michael fell unconscious,

February 6th, Natalie had specifically requested

a bottle of insulin be brought to her.

(Tim) The bottle of insulin was concealed

inside the refrigerator in the kitchen behind some other items

on one of the shelves inside the door.

(Narrator) Natalie had claimed Michael was using insulin

for body-building, but the police couldn't

prove a link to his death.

In September of 2019, an exhumation was conducted

so that an autopsy could be performed

on Michael Cochran's remains.

(Narrator) The autopsy results were inconclusive.

Unaware she was suspected of murdering Michael,

Natalie continued running the business.

(Ashley) And she's continuing to solicit money from investors.

And at one point, she actually tries to sell the company

to a local businessman.

She entered into a contract with him.

He puts a down payment on the contract.

And luckily, that's about the time that the police stepped in.

(Narrator) On July 24, 2019,

Natalie Cochran filed for bankruptcy.

Two weeks later, she talked with the media,

stating the money laundering and spending

were primarily done by Michael.

(Ashley) She repeatedly claimed

that Michael knew about the Ponzi scheme

because he would sign cheques.

She repeatedly said that he was up to his eyeballs in this.

(Narrator) On September 24, 2019,

Natalie was indicted by a federal grand jury

for the $2.5 million fraud related to the Ponzi scheme.

(Micah) She was arrested on the federal wire fraud

and money laundering charges, and she ultimately pled guilty.

It didn't ever go to trial.

They reached an agreement.

And she was sentenced to, I believe,

11 years in federal prison.

(Narrator) No charges were brought against Natalie Cochran

for the Little League theft.

But now, police and public prosecutors

were building a case against her

for the murder of her husband, Michael.

(Tom) The Natalie Cochran case

arose out of the federal prosecution of a Ponzi scheme.

Our theory of the case was that she killed her husband

because she was about to be uncovered,

and she couldn't have that happen.

In our very first meeting, Ashley and me

and the Ponzi scheme investigator, he said something that

really turned out to be prophetic.

He said, the one thing you can always count on with people

that run a Ponzi scheme, they will do anything

to keep the Ponzi scheme going.

That didn't really sink in at the time,

but boy, later on, that proved to be absolutely spot-on.

(tense music)

(Narrator) In January 2024, Natalie Cochran, already imprisoned

for the $2.5 million fraud, pled not guilty

for the murder of her husband, Michael.

(Tom) I think a murder case that is 100% circumstantial

is going to be a little bit tougher case

because you don't have anything to point to.

You don't have the fingerprints.

You don't have the DNA.

You don't have the video.

You don't have the confession.

None of those things that would go with many murder cases.

I think that that made the case more of a challenge.

(Ashley) We tapered our witness list down

from around 80 witnesses to about 17.

We also really treated this like a circumstantial case that it is.

We knew that we weren't working with eyewitnesses

or DNA evidence or anything like that.

So we really had to build a story, and that's how we tried the case.

(Narrator) The prosecution claimed that Natalie's motive

to murder her husband was to stop the Ponzi scheme being uncovered.

The role of the Ponzi scheme in the murder

was to prove that Natalie had a motive to kill Michael.

And the reason that that's important is because,

according to all the evidence that we have,

Michael had no idea that TSG was not a legitimate company.

If he were to find out that that was happening,

the Ponzi scheme would be over,

and Natalie couldn't let that happen.

(Narrator) Natalie's defence was that

Michael knew about the Ponzi scheme,

so why would she kill him to hide it?

They repeatedly claimed that

Michael knew about the Ponzi scheme

because he would sign cheques,

which doesn't indicate to me in any way

that he was aware of fraud going on.

He was trying to pay out investors.

(Tom) Michael Cochran was not involved in the fraud.

And I base that primarily on about 1,900 pages of text messages

between Michael and Natalie, where he clearly

had no idea what was going on.

And when you compare those 1,900 pages of communications

between the two Cochrans with what Natalie was telling

the other investors in the company, the lies were identical.

And so there is zero evidence to show

that Michael Cochran was involved in any fraudulent activity.

(Narrator) In February 2019, everything changed

when Michael challenged Natalie

about the delays in payments from the government contracts.

(Tom) Michael Cochran, who was fed up with all the delays

Natalie was telling Michael were caused

by banks, by government issues.

He was saying, I'm not putting up with this any more.

So they chartered a flight to fly down and talk to Bank of America

to see why this money that he believed was in the,

really, hundreds of millions of dollars,

was not being paid out to the investors.

We have a situation here where a husband is being controlled.

He's being lied to.

He's being manipulated.

She is involving him in criminal activity without his knowledge.

That is abusive behaviour.

(Narrator) It was on the day of the flight, February 6,

that Michael fell ill.

(Ashley) The morning of February 6,

Natalie reports that she believes she has the flu.

She's texting a couple of different people about that.

She actually goes to the doctor that morning

and gets a steroid prescription.

She texts Michael and says that

she is getting meds for both of them.

Michael was out that morning getting coffee for Natalie

because she wasn't feeling well and was returning home.

But it was odd because Natalie texted the pilot

and said, you know, I can't go.

I'm not feeling well.

And Michael said, well, don't worry about it.

We'll still go. This needs to happen.

And then, ultimately, the flight is cancelled.

And then, of course, we know from that point on,

Michael's not able to make the flight again.

(Tom) When Michael collapsed on the floor,

instead of calling 911, Natalie takes his picture of him

on the floor and sends it to roughly 17 people.

She then proceeds to...

summons people at different times during the day

that would provide a great cover story.

She brought in a physician's assistant,

who has clear medical knowledge.

And that person also suggested,

we need to take him to the hospital.

He needs to go now.

Natalie said, no, I'm going to...

I'm going to let him sleep it off.

Well, there was nothing to sleep off.

He was clearly incapacitated,

and he never recovered from that at all.

(Narrator) On January 15, 2025,

almost six years after Michael's death,

Natalie Cochran faced murder charges.

The prosecution needed to prove it was an insulin overdose

that had killed Michael.

Michael was exhumed for a second time by court order in 2023

by a doctor from Texas.

And he had actually worked on a set of insulin murder cases

that had taken place in West Virginia several years ago.

So he had Michael's medical records.

He was able to create a timetable that showed

all of Michael's blood glucose levels

throughout his stay in the hospital.

He was able to determine that Michael was suffering

from what he called refractory hypoglycaemia,

which meant he had low blood sugar.

He would receive treatment for it, and then it would drop back down.

It wouldn't stabilise as you would expect it to in a healthy person.

The reason that was significant was because that indicated

that Michael had been given insulin.

And that's how we knew that we had our murder weapon.

At that point, he ruled the death a homicide

via exogenous insulin administration.

We used Michael and Natalie's best friends and neighbours.

There were some very key pieces of testimony,

I think, between the two of them.

Chris was very emotional and very raw on the stand and very upfront

about how he felt about the whole thing.

He was actually the one who made the decision

to get Michael to the hospital and get him medical treatment.

Natalie had refused to get Michael treatment all day.

And Chris came in, and he testified on the stand

that the words he said were, "He is going to the hospital,

and I am going to take him."

(suspenseful music)

His wife, Jennifer, she was actually the one

that Natalie had tricked into bringing

the insulin over to the home,

which is ultimately what killed Michael.

And I know that was very hard for Jennifer

because that was never her intention.

She never would have wanted something like that to happen.

(Keri) Something that I've seen in many murder cases

is when people have inadvertently

either not stopped something happening

or provided something or, in some way, been involved

with no knowledge of what was about to happen,

the guilt that they experience is huge.

(Ashley) Jennifer had another very powerful piece of testimony,

I think, because she was actually with Natalie

when Michael was in hospice for those couple of hours

before he passed away.

And I remember one of the last things Jennifer said on the stand

was that she asked Natalie if there was anything

that she could do for her while, you know,

Michael was laying on his deathbed.

And she says, help me hold this pillow over his face.

And I think the whole courtroom was just kind of floored.

Natalie Cochran was extremely difficult to get a read on.

And her demeanour is really interesting to me

because she never really showed a lot of negative emotion.

And certain members of the community

maybe held that against her.

And for me...because I saw every... everything that happened,

basically, in the courtroom during that trial.

And a lot of it seemed to me she was really happy to see her kids.

Because remember, she's been serving

a federal prison sentence all this time.

Like, she has not been free.

This was her first chance to see her family

every single day, in person, all day, in a very long time.

(Ashley) In court, Natalie took an approach

that a lot of women who are on trial for murder tend to take,

and that was that she adopted a much more

conservative look than she had before she was incarcerated.

So she cut all her hair off.

She wore glasses every day.

She did not wear bright colours.

She really toned herself down quite a lot.

It doesn't surprise me at all that Natalie significantly

changed her appearance for court.

Often, people going into court will make themselves

look more vulnerable, not as rich,

hoping to gain sympathy from the jury.

(Ashley) As far as her behaviour,

she constantly had a smirk on her face.

She was very smug, did not seem to believe that anyone

would ever convict her of murder.

(Micah) The overall atmosphere in the courtroom was tense.

Michael's family was there on one side,

and her family was there on the other.

Her family continues to stand by her.

They don't feel she did anything wrong,

even though court documents show that she stole

an insane amount of money from her parents.

So it was a really interesting and heartbreaking dynamic

in the courtroom.

(Tim) It was really hard to sit there and stomach at trial,

you know, as the defence stood there time and time again,

trying to come up with this fairy tale

that Michael Cochran was somehow involved in this Ponzi scheme.

Because that was not the case whatsoever.

You know, Michael Cochran was a victim.

I can't imagine how hard it was for Michael's family

to sit there and listen to that crap.

(Narrator) After almost three weeks in court,

the jury were ready to consider their verdict.

(Micah) The prosecution's case was,

I would imagine, quite difficult to put together

because they had no smoking gun.

They had to take the evidence they had

and kind of bring the narrative together for the jury.

Well, we had a number of challenges.

You know, prosecutors love to have the stuff you see on TV...

DNA, fingerprints, videos, confessions.

All of those things make for a good life for a prosecutor.

We had none of them.

(Narrator) On January 29, 2025,

Natalie Cochran was found guilty of first-degree murder.

Michael's parents, who have been fighting for justice

for their son for so long, finally getting some semblance of closure,

that they know that Michael's death wasn't for nothing

and that his murderer has been held accountable.

It was the most heartbreaking part of the entire proceedings

when her kids were up in the stand,

basically begging the jury for mercy, so that

they could get a chance to see their mum again in 20 years

and maybe rebuild a relationship.

And ultimately, the jury decided that she didn't deserve mercy.

As a forensic psychologist, not many things shock me,

but occasionally, I come across cases where

there is an element of shock.

And in this case, we've got a woman who was a professional,

who seemed to have it all.

She has a lovely husband, a family.

She had the ability to make a great income

and live a great life.

But she wanted more.

(Narrator) Natalie Cochran was sentenced to life in prison

without the possibility of parole.

(Micah) They know they'll probably never

get to hug their daughter again.

Their kids, they don't really have a mother in their life

any more because of this.

It was a very tragic outcome.

(Ashley) On a personal level, it was...

sort of the rush of a lifetime to hear the judge come back

and say that the jury had found Natalie Cochran

guilty of first-degree murder.

And that's not only, you know, for me,

because this is a huge trial win, but really, it was more

for Michael and for his mum and for his friends.

When the guilty verdict was read in the court,

it almost seemed like Natalie didn't believe it.

She shed a single tear.

No visceral reaction, you know, like you would maybe expect.

(Tom) We have what's called our 20/80 list.

And this goes back decades ago to an FBI presentation

that 20% of the people commit 80% of the crime.

Natalie Cochran's kind of odd because

she'd never been in trouble before.

In her case, she made a series of bad decisions

and got a life sentence out of it in a short period of time.

(Keri) They were childhood sweethearts.

According to everybody in the community,

they were deeply in love.

They'd been together since they were 16.

And she was willing to take his life in order for her Ponzi scheme

to remain ongoing.

(Ashley) Natalie and her family

continue to deny that she is a murderer.

I understand that this is your family member.

But look at what she's done to people.

(Tim) In my opinion, when you see people

who are willing to go to those lengths to protect their lie,

there's only one word that comes to mind, dangerous.

They don't come at you with a mask and a gun or a knife.

You don't see these kind of criminals coming.

And that's why they're so dangerous.

(dramatic music)

Subtitles by accessibility@itv.com

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.