Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
In this programme, when a married couple are found poisoned to death, a
toxicologist is asked to investigate.
There was no reason why fentanyl should have been present in their bodies.
And a forensic footprint analyst helps nail a double killer.
Foot remarks is one of the only evidence types that you can say for certain that
a mark was made by a specific few.
Welcome to Expert Witness, the series where we reveal how science helps solve
some of the UK's toughest criminal investigations.
Senior crime and court reporter at the Colchester Gazette followed the case
closely.
Stephen Baxter was a successful businessman.
Carol Baxter also then went on to start her own business, completely separate
from her husband.
And they were really, really enjoying life.
But Carol was in poor health.
She was living with a condition called Hashimoto's disease, a chronic
disorder, which she blamed.
for her increasing levels of fatigue and forgetfulness.
Carol's health was failing.
Stephen was having to start looking after his wife and would have to keep
an eye on his wife in case she ended up doing something like leaving the iron on
or forgetting that she had turned the hob on or something like that, something
that could actually lead to quite a serious incident.
On 9th April 2023, the couple's daughter, Eleanor, became concerned when
couldn't make contact with her parents.
All her WhatsApp messages weren't being replied to.
Understandably, she got really quite nervous and wanted to know what was
happening. She'd driven past the house and seen the curtains were drawn.
Eleanor went to their home to check on them.
She knocked on the door.
Doesn't get an answer.
She knocks on the windows at the front of the house and
still no one comes to the front door.
But nothing would prepare her for what she was about to see.
Through the conservatory, slumped in their armchairs, were her parents'
bodies.
Family friend Luke DeWitt, who lived nearby, came rushing to the scene.
In this moment of pure panic, he takes over the call with the police.
The
emergency
services were there in real force. The police, the ambulance, the fire service
were there as well because they had to check if there had been any carbon
monoxide.
Luke DeWitt is there to give Elena a hug, to give her brother a hug.
As one of the first on the scene, DeWitt was questioned by police.
People just talking about work and the business. Carol can't work anymore.
He's perfectly, perfectly calm when he speaks to the officers.
While there was no immediate evidence of foul play, a major crimes investigation
was launched and the bodies were sent for post -mortem examination.
It is a cliche, but there wasn't a smoking gun at the scene. There was no
weapon. There was no evidence of carbon monoxide.
Detectives looked into the couple's background and discovered Carol had been
contact with a Dr. Andrea Bowden.
She claims to be an expert on Hashimoto's disease, the condition Carol
struggling with. A lot of the advice from this Dr.
Andrea Bowden starts to become very strange.
She's told not to let certain people into the house.
She's told to cast contacts with certain people.
She's told to drink smoothies that have turmeric in them.
Carol had been doing exactly as Dr Bowden prescribed.
But when police tried to contact the doctor, there was no trace of her.
Then... When a simple toxicology test was administered at the post -mortem
examination, a sinister turn.
The toxicology shows that there are levels of fentanyl, both in Stephen
system and Carol Baxter's system.
There was no medical explanation for why fentanyl, an opioid painkiller many
times more potent than morphine, was present.
So detectives asked lead toxicologists... An expert witnessed
investigate further.
The main request from the police was to determine the conclusive presence of a
drug. They were particularly interested in the presence of fentanyl.
Fiona was provided with blood, urine and stomach content samples.
She prepared a specimen of each for analysis by high sensitivity equipment
detects the presence of drugs and medications.
This is our LC -MS machine and it's essentially a long specialised tube
with a detector at one end. And drugs travel down the tube at different speeds
so they reach the detector at different times.
And then the detector measures the mass and it breaks the molecule into
fragments.
These fragments are analysed to identify exactly which drugs were present in the
sample. This will collect all the data and then the data is processed on a
computer and then that enables us to produce the results.
And the results were irrefutable.
Fentanyl was detected in both Carol and Stephen's blood samples.
The presence of fentanyl was a concern because neither Mr.
or Mrs. Baxter were known to be prescribed fentanyl, so there was no
fentanyl should have been present in their bodies.
The levels were within the range that could be fatal, particularly in a person
that's unaccustomed to taking the drug.
Meanwhile, when the family home was searched...
A suspicious document was discovered in Stephen's office.
This was the will that had mysteriously and very
coincidentally appeared in Stephen Baxter's office. And it
wasn't in a folder. It was just placed quite meticulously on his desk.
According to the will... Luke DeWitt was a benefactor in the event of the
Baxter's death.
And now he was also a suspect in a murder investigation.
Back at the lab, Fiona Perry's analysis had revealed something else.
In Mrs Baxter's blood sample, as well as fentanyl, we also detected another
medication called promethazine.
This is a common medication found in sleeping
tablets. But under what circumstances were these drugs administered?
We don't normally analyse stomach contents but in this case we were
asked to analyse the stomach contents for fentanyl and promethazine in order
to determine a whether there was a large amount of the drug still present in the
stomach.
and B, whether it was possible to say whether the drug had been taken orally
not.
The concentrations of fentanyl and promesazine were significant, and they
suggest that the drug had been taken orally.
The toxicology blows open the case. There is no way that anyone would have
able to survive the level of fentanyl in their system.
On top of the toxicology results,
Police arrested Luke DeWitt.
When police
investigate Luke DeWitt, it becomes clear just how heavily involved
he had become in their lives, how often he was round at the house, how often he
was helping to care for Carol Baxter, almost round the clock.
The police... go to Luke DeWitt's house in Mersey Island.
They go to his room. They find a huge number of devices.
In total, 80 phones, laptops and hard drives were seized.
Once the police seize Luke DeWitt's devices, the details that they can glean
really quite incredible.
They found evidence Luke DeWitt wrote the will himself.
The day after Carol and Stephen's bodies were found.
That he created false identities, including Dr. Andrea Bowden, and a
of fictitious patients, all supposedly with Hashimoto's disease, just like
Carol. She's found this little community of other people who have been in
exactly the same position as her, and that he was behind all of the personas.
She was so desperate.
to essentially be in good health, that she would listen to anyone
who had any kind of advice.
It's interesting that he was seen as somebody who was fairly quiet and
unassuming by other people, somebody who was a bit of a nerd, in fact.
Forensic psychologist Kerry Danes has researched the case.
Here is the world.
A fantasy where he can operate, where he can create different personas and
he can cause things to happen in the real world.
That's very intoxicating for somebody who is inadequate.
For two years, DeWitt used his fake personas to communicate with Carol and
Stephen. And by posing as a doctor, he convinced both of them to drink detox
smoothies. It meant that he could get her to drink these horrendous
which were absolutely disgusting and she hated.
But he also can give Stephen Baxter that drink and he can convince Stephen
Baxter that what he's going to be drinking is going to be helping.
Detectives now suspected the witch even prepared these smoothies himself.
This is somebody who wants to constantly push the envelope so that they can feel
that they are powerful, that they are in control, they are the puppet master.
The devices were not the only damning evidence the police discovered while
searching his home.
They also found fentanyl.
His story is that his dad has been suffering from cancer, his dad had been
prescribed... Fentanyl patches as part of his treatment.
His dad was sad they died. And it just so happened, DeWitt claims, that he was
sorting through a load of the fentanyl patches that his dad had been prescribed
and he was getting ready to drop them off at the pharmacy. He just hadn't got
round to it just yet.
Detectives also discovered promazazine in DeWitt's house.
The same drug Fiona Perry detected... in Carol's blood sample.
Again, DeWitt had a ready explanation.
The story for the promethazine is that he was using it to help with his eczema
and he would mix it in with skin cream and he would use that to treat his
eczema.
Detectives were not convinced.
They believed DeWitt slowly poisoned Carol by lacing her smoothies with
promethazine before murdering both Carol and Stephen by introducing fentanyl.
He was charged with their murder.
But DeWitt argued that the Baxters had taken the fentanyl themselves.
He admitted to persuading Carroll to drink detox smoothies, but claimed to
done it on Stephen's instruction.
His argument is that, yes, OK, maybe, maybe I did make these accounts, maybe
they are all connected to me, but this was under Stephen Baxter's instruction
because he was desperate for Carroll to get better as well.
DeWitt also claimed Carol's long decline was caused not by promethazine, but by
her Hashimoto's disease.
Detectives needed to prove otherwise, so they turned to a specialist in the
condition, consultant endocrinologist Dr Naveed Younis.
I thought it was unusual for me to comment on Hashimoto. Generally, it's a
condition which is standard treatment, and the condition is just generally well
managed.
The package that the police provided me was all the medical records from Carol
Baxter.
Dr Eunice studied Carol's GP and hospital records.
The treatments she'd been receiving were standard and her condition should have
stabilised. She'd been having regular blood tests.
She'd had a blood test done a month before she'd actually died and
the blood tests were all satisfactory and normal.
Even if she had stopped taking her medication, maybe for a number of weeks
before her death, I don't think this would have been rapid enough to cause
to develop symptoms of confusion and the behaviour that she had.
So I overall felt, based on all the medical evidence that I had in my hands,
based on the symptoms, that there was something else causing the symptoms that
she experienced.
Detectives were now certain Cavill's declining health was due to her
being slowly poisoned with promethazine.
before she and her husband were killed with fatal doses of fentanyl.
And there was further extraordinary evidence. A hidden camera was discovered
the Baxter's home.
It was connected to DeWitt's phone.
He can check up on them. He can check to see if they have actually succumbed to
this fentanyl poisoning.
He watched the Baxter's die on camera.
It was almost as if the case couldn't get any weirder, but it just kept on
getting more and more unbelievable.
DeWitt was tried for double murder. He pleaded not guilty.
But the evidence from Fiona Perry and Dr Naveed Younis made for a watertight
case. On March 20th, 2024, DeWitt was found guilty and sentenced to life with
a minimum term of 37 years.
In all my years of policing, Luke DeWitt is one of the most dangerous men I have
ever come across.
I have absolutely no doubt in my mind, had he not been caught, he would have
gone on to kill further people.
Forensic toxicology is a very satisfying job and it is nice to know that you are
providing some results that are useful as the case goes forward.
Toxicology was absolutely crucial in this case for establishing a cause of
death. And that's when the toxicology starts to link to all of the other
separate pieces of evidence.
It's difficult to imagine a case that has as many layers
as this one when it comes to the extents.
of the manipulation and the length to which Luke DeWitt went to ensure that
victims suffered for a long time before he actually killed them.
The founding premise of forensic science is that every contact leaves a trace.
In our next case detectives believe that two separate murders may be linked to
the same man.
Can a forensic expert match footprint evidence from both scenes and bring the
culprit to justice?
Bewdley, Worcestershire, January 2012.
Police are called to a property on the banks of the River Severn.
Inside, they discover the body of Betty Yates.
Liz Beacon, a senior journalist for BBC Points West, researched the case.
Betty Yates was a 77 -year -old retired schoolteacher who was widowed. She lived
on her own in an isolated cottage. And although she lived alone, she was really
well -loved by the community.
West Mercia Police began investigating what appeared to be the brutal murder of
a vulnerable elderly grandmother.
Investigations revealed that she had been beaten with her own walking stick
she'd then been stabbed four times.
Police at the crime scene also found evidence that suggested Betty's killer
hadn't left the scene in a hurry.
After this attack, it was as if the killer tidied up after themselves.
Betty's walking stick had been put back in its holder and the killer had pulled
the blinds down and locked up before they'd left.
Forensic evidence, including swabs taken from the victim's hands and a yoga mat
lying near her body, was taken from the scene and sent for examination.
Betty's family appealed for help in finding her killer.
To lose your mum is always dreadful.
But to lose your mum like this, when you worry constantly about how frightened
she might have been or what she might have felt during such a vicious attack,
like a nightmare.
Please. If you know anything about this, can you come forward?
A £10 ,000 reward was offered for information.
But as the weeks went by, police were no closer to catching Betty's killer.
With a murderer on the loose, there was a very real fear it could happen again.
Five weeks later and 70 miles away in Thornbury near Bristol, Avon and
Police were called to a suspicious death.
at the vicarage of St Mary's Church.
Police have launched an investigation after a vicar was found dead in his home
near Bristol.
The Reverend John Suddards is understood to have suffered stab wounds.
He was found by workmen yesterday at the locked vicarage.
Reverend John Suddards was the 59 -year -old vicar of St Mary the Virgin Church
in Thornbury and he'd only been the vicar there for six months and he wanted
be the sort of vicar that people could reach out to. He was always happy to
offer people a cup of tea or a bowl of soup.
Reverend Suddards had been stabbed multiple times and the assailant had
apparently staged a scene designed to humiliate his victim.
There was some pornography, a condom wrapper, party poppers, underwear, an
of Jesus Christ and a mirror.
Detectives also found clues that the killer had remained at the scene for a
considerable amount of time.
After the attack, the killer ate some food, drank some beer and watched DVDs
the vicarage before leaving the following morning.
Investigators had no idea who could have committed such a brutal crime, but the
killer had left something behind.
A bloody footprint.
At this point they had no suspect to compare it with.
Then they got their first break.
There were CCTV cameras outside the vicarage which provided the police with
really valuable images.
They shared these images with the public showing a tall man carrying a backpack.
Members of the public recognised the man and four days after the murder police
released the name of their prime suspect.
Stephen Farrow is the man police named yesterday as a murder suspect.
Just hours after releasing this image of the 47 -year -old, he was arrested at
this house in Folkestone in Kent after a tip -off from a member of the public.
Police began looking into Farrow's background.
Stephen Farrow was from Shropshire. He was one of six children and he grew up
a deeply religious family.
He was said to have hated his father, but he did really love his mother. But
had a deep -rooted hatred of Christianity.
It was soon discovered he had a history of violence and had served eight years
for aggravated burglary.
Police began to explore any links to the murder of Betty Yates.
Could Farrow be a double killer?
and could the bloody footprint found at the vicarage provide the evidence they
needed?
They called in Pordrig O'Shea, an expert witness specialising in marks and
traces.
I was given brief circumstances of the incident, what had happened, and the
exhibits that were present at the scene.
Now in custody, police were able to seize Farrow's boots, enabling Pordrig
compare them with the footprints from the crime scene.
We're looking at this for overall size, pattern, any degree of wear and also any
damage features that may be present.
Pordrig instantly noticed damage to the sole of one of the boots and hoped the
flawed feature might make his job easier.
The chance of that damage feature being present on this shoe and on another shoe
in the same position, with the same size, shape, is actually very, very
To get the print of the boot, Known as a test mark, Pordrick first coats the
sole in aluminium powder.
So I've placed the boot now onto the sticky acetate, which will transfer the
aluminium -powdered sole pattern onto the acetate and then peel it off.
And it's left a one -to -one impression of the shoe print.
The test mark and the prints left at the crime scene appear to match.
But Pordrig must also look for corresponding damage marks.
We need to confirm that any features we find on a test mark are actually present
on the shoe itself to be able to confirm that they are damage features.
Pordrig's footprint analysis had given him a clear result.
The marks recovered from Reverend John Sodor's scene were similar in pattern to
the submitted boots from Stephen Farrow.
And detectives recovered more vital evidence linking Farrow to the murder at
Vicarage. After the arrest, police found a knife on Stephen Farrow. They also
found traces of Reverend Sadar's blood on Farrow's jacket and trousers.
Detectives were now convinced Farrow was also guilty of Betty Yates' murder.
Both victims had lived alone and were deeply involved in Christianity,
Farrow despised.
And evidence at both crime scenes suggested the killer had lingered for
time afterwards.
But Farrow denied murdering either victim.
Could Padraig prove that the suspect had been in Betty Yates' home?
He thought the yoga mat found close to her body might hold the answers.
I was asked in relation to the Betty Yates case to examine a yoga mat that
footwear marks on it and compare those with the boots from Stephen Farrow.
But there was a problem. The yoga mat had already been cut into pieces by the
original forensic team.
in a bid to find biological material.
Having a full -length mark enables us to make size comparisons.
If we don't have the entire footwear mark we can't be certain that it's
that right size as the shoe that's been submitted.
Pordrig was supplied with the remainder of the yoga mat.
There was a partial mark present on the piece of cut -out fabric and then a
remaining partial mark already on the yoga mat.
and when that is placed in together, it looks like a full -length footwear mark
is now visible.
The footprints on the yoga mat match Stephen Farrow's boots, and Portrigue's
evidence now links him to both murders.
Conclusive evidence is the highest evidence we can have, and we don't see
very often generally in forensic science.
Footwear marks is one of the only evidence types that you can say for
that a mark was made by a specific shoe.
A full DNA profile of Farrow was also found on a swab taken from Bessie's left
hand which strengthened the case against him.
He was charged with two counts of murder and a burglary he was suspected of
committing at a separate address in Thornbury.
At first, Farrow admitted to the burglary but denied the murders until he
confronted with the forensic evidence.
He admitted to the manslaughter of John Suddards on the grounds of diminished
responsibility due to his mental state at the time. But he continued to deny
murder of Betty Yates.
The case went to trial in October 2012.
The jury found him guilty of both murders and of the burglary after
for eight and a half hours.
A homeless man with a hatred of Christians who murdered a retired
vicar has been jailed for life.
Stephen Farrow, diagnosed as a psychopath, killed Reverend John Suddard
vicarage in South Gloucestershire and 77 -year -old pensioner Betty Yates at her
home in Worcestershire.
Both murder cases were solved by forensics.
through DNA and footprint analysis.
The forensic work of Podrick O'Shea was absolutely crucial in getting a
conviction. Although Farrow had admitted to the manslaughter of John Suddard, he
was still denying that he'd killed Betty Yates, so linking the two crime scenes
was absolutely key.
The work I carried out was very important in relation to the Betty Yates
It was a conclusive link between the suspect and the scene.
and it was a very strong link between the defendant and the scene at Reverend
Suddhurst.
Several of my colleagues have worked on this case as well, and it was all vital
to getting the result that we got.
Two cases there that show how science and expertise cut through lies and
uncertainty to reveal the truth about what really happened, ensuring justice
could finally be served for those who no longer have a voice.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.