All language subtitles for Expert Witness - S01E01 - Soil and Insects

af Afrikaans
ak Akan
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bem Bemba
bn Bengali
bh Bihari
bs Bosnian
br Breton
bg Bulgarian
km Cambodian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
chr Cherokee
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
da Danish
nl Dutch
en English
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
ee Ewe
fo Faroese
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gaa Ga
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek
gn Guarani
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ia Interlingua
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
rw Kinyarwanda
rn Kirundi
kg Kongo
ko Korean
kri Krio (Sierra Leone)
ku Kurdish
ckb Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Laothian
la Latin
lv Latvian
ln Lingala
lt Lithuanian
loz Lozi
lg Luganda
ach Luo
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mfe Mauritian Creole
mo Moldavian
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
sr-ME Montenegrin
ne Nepali
pcm Nigerian Pidgin
nso Northern Sotho
no Norwegian
nn Norwegian (Nynorsk)
oc Occitan
or Oriya
om Oromo
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt-BR Portuguese (Brazil)
pt Portuguese (Portugal)
pa Punjabi
qu Quechua
ro Romanian
rm Romansh
nyn Runyakitara
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
sh Serbo-Croatian
st Sesotho
tn Setswana
crs Seychellois Creole
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhalese
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es-419 Spanish (Latin American)
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
tt Tatar
te Telugu
th Thai
ti Tigrinya
to Tonga
lua Tshiluba
tum Tumbuka
tr Turkish
tk Turkmen
tw Twi
ug Uighur
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
wo Wolof
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu

Original subtitles

When a serious crime is committed and the police need all the help they can

there's one group of people they turn to time after time.

The expert witnesses.

Expert witnesses are the golden thread that runs through cases that every

conviction needs.

An extraordinary army of men and women with the expertise to reveal the hidden

clues criminals have left behind.

There are so many.

important pieces of evidence, paint evidence, glass, fibre evidence.

They search harder and look deeper using the very latest techniques.

If I can work out how old those insects are, that's going to give me the minimum

time since death.

This is the inside story of how science helped solve some of the UK's most

complex cases.

It really was becoming the last throw of the dice.

Nothing's going to bring her back, but she'd had the justice that she rightly

deserved.

This is the story of the expert witness.

Today, we travel to Edinburgh to look at the fascinating story behind one of

Scotland's longest -running investigations, the World's End Murders.

They just had the...

Terrible misfortune to cross paths with two evil, dangerous men.

And we go to Scamenden Moor near Huddersfield to look at the science

finding the killer of Christopher Pratt.

I like to think that the forensic entomology is providing one bit of a

evidence and it might often be the missing one that finally solves the

Our first investigation is a rare one, a double murder from 1977.

Back then, forensic science was still in its infancy, and a lack of evidence

meant that for nearly 40 years, the killer went free, until a modern -day

witness unlocked clues hidden in some soil samples and helped convict the

murderer.

Aberdeen, 2013.

Lorna Dawson has been asked to help solve one of the UK's longest -running

cases, the World's End Murders. Lorna remembers the crime only too well.

I got a phone call from Lothian and Borders Police and they said, we've got

cold case here and there's some solid samples that were taken from one of the

victims in the World's End Murders.

Would you be able to look at it?

I said, yes, we'll have a look at them. And I thought, goodness me, that's the

case that was in Edinburgh when I was a student.

Edinburgh, 1977,

a city famous for its nightlife, when suddenly two 17 -year -old friends,

Scott and Christine Eadie, were discovered murdered after a night out at

city's famous World's End pub.

I had just moved to Edinburgh as a student studying geography and geology

shocked us all. There was a real fear, particularly amongst my peers. I noticed

that there's a couple of men joining the company and these are strangers and

they're seen speaking to Helen and Christine.

At 10 o 'clock the pub's closed and everybody leaves.

So they're seen leaving, going down St Mary's Street in the company of these

men.

That was the last witness sighting of the two young women. Helen's brother,

Kevin, was 11 years old. He remembers growing panic at home as the hours

with no word from his sister.

I remember waking up and there was still a light on in the house, so I got up

and my mother was sitting downstairs, wondering why

Helen didn't come home.

Come the next morning, obviously...

There was a lot of concern.

You just knew it wasn't right.

The following day, Helen and Christine's families received the news they were

dreading. Their daughters' bodies had been found.

Firth was Christine's.

A dog walker had been walking along the tide line on the beach and saw what he

thought was a tailor's dummy lying on the coast.

As they approached, they got closer, they realised it wasn't Taylor's dummy,

was actually the body of Christine.

Lying on top of her coat in the middle of a field.

We came from an environment where nobody locked their doors, so we were a

trusting family.

Helen was a trusting girl.

The household was just distraught. I mean, it blows a family apart.

Police quickly secured the crime scene and began an extensive search of the

where Helen's body was found.

We were lucky in that the first response from our crime laboratory, our forensic

laboratory, were scientists who were practised in crime scene management.

That morning on the 16th of October, a young South African scientist called

Lester Nibb, he attended at the scene and so he took possession of the coat,

took possession of the gaggings and the bindings.

But Lester Nibb went even further.

He recovered forensic evidence for which police did not yet have the science to

crack, including soil samples from the body and the crime scene.

He secured these samples in a proper way and made sure that not only were they

preserved properly, but that there was a clear record of everywhere they had

been. And this is absolutely critical.

In 1977, forensic science was still in its infancy. It would be decades before

these samples could be effectively analysed. You know that something very

important is here.

You just don't have the means or the wit or the science to interpret it.

So what you must do is you must retain it carefully and you must monitor the

developments of a forensic science until such times as it gives up its secrets.

One piece of evidence frustrated detectives more than any other.

That's Helen's coat. And this is the lining, which was so absolutely crucial.

There was a large stain.

which we always presumed was the murderer.

But in 1977, there was no way for science to identify who that person was.

It was very difficult for the police to work out in those times what happened.

And, of course, then there was no DNA technology, so it was very difficult,

although they had samples.

There was none of these new methods that are now available that could help the

investigation of that crime.

For nearly 30 years, the investigation made little progress and Helen and

Christine's killer remained on the loose. Then, in 2003, advances in DNA

analysis gave police the breakthrough they had been waiting for.

What they did was they looked at the stain and if you think about that stain

on Helen's coat, it's a bit like DNA soup.

And what they managed to do was they managed to pick the individual elements

of this soup and actually create not one, but two male profiles and

a female profile.

The female profile obviously was Helen Harcourt, the one male profile, and it

was not on any database whatsoever.

But the second male profile, we checked that against the database and that came

up. It's Angus Robertson Sinclair.

Angus Sinclair was a convicted murderer, already in prison for killing another

young woman.

It turned out the second DNA profile belonged to his brother -in -law, Gordon

Hamilton. Hamilton had died in 1996.

But with compelling new DNA evidence, Angus Sinclair could now be prosecuted

the murder of Helen Scott and Christine Eadie.

Nothing was certain, however, and Tom was worried he needed even more to

guarantee a conviction.

Now, we had built up a very compelling circumstantial case surrounding

that strong case of DNA because we always suspected that what Angus

would say was, yes, I may have met them and we had consensual sex, but I didn't

kill them.

Sure enough, in court, Sinclair's defence team did precisely that.

Sinclair claimed the women were alive when he left them and he denied their

murder. Without more supporting evidence, he was acquitted.

I remember speaking to someone and they said, well, that's it.

I remember these words, that's it, there's nothing you can do.

And I remember walking away from that thinking...

Somebody can do something.

It would take another seven years of scientific progress, but that somebody

would prove to be soil expert Lorna Dawson.

In the intervening period between the first trial and 2013, we had been

developing methodology to look at the organic profile in soil.

So soils vary across the landscape, but they also vary with depth.

Because soil can be geo -referenced, the inorganic part can tell us about what

the underlying geology is, and that is mapped, so we know where it has come

from.

Soil helps us answer the where question.

They tried to convict Angus Sinclair in 2007 using DNA evidence alone.

It wasn't enough.

Now the investigation team turns to samples of soil gathered by Lester Nibb

the original investigation.

Think about building this picture. So you've not only got the strong central

feature of the DNA, but you also have the background to the picture.

And the background to the picture is how Helen Scott got to that place.

You know, was she carried? Was she dumped? Did she walk?

In 2007, Angus Sinclair's defence team claimed Helen was still alive when he

left her.

They insisted someone else must have killed her.

Now, brand -new soil analysis techniques could prove otherwise.

So these are the traces.

This is one of the aggregates from Helen Scott's feet, LD4.

So this led...

to the conclusion that she had likely stood or walked not only in the wheat

field but also at the grass verge, leading the prosecutors to conclude that

had indeed been alive at that time and likely walked to her death.

This discovery would prove a major breakthrough, especially when combined

new evidence from the tights used to bind Helen.

Between 2007 and 2013, DNA evidence had come on.

We could tell a lot more from the knots and bindings.

When we undid the bindings, we found low -copy samples of Angus Sinclair's DNA,

and we could show through expert witnesses that these knots had not only

tied by him, but they'd been tied tightly by him.

Lorna's soil evidence proved Helen had walked to where she had been killed.

Meanwhile, the DNA from the bindings put Sinclair with her body.

We needed evidence from experts like Lorna so as to support the DNA case.

It was very important to build up that sequence of events.

We could then show that she had not wandered off, that she had been walked

the field to be...

to be killed, all building up that compelling picture

which Angus Sinclair could not wriggle out of.

The team now had enough to start a brand -new prosecution.

The trial was scheduled for 2014.

As the date drew for the start of the new trial, you're always going to have a

concern that...

you're not going to get the result, the desired result, that's going to bring

justice.

Everything was hanging on the new evidence.

Lona had just one chance to explain to the jury what she had found.

An expert witness must not... People don't realise the amount of work that

into an examination, an analysis, evaluation, and interpreting that

and then presenting it in court.

Lorna's evidence not only helped contradict Sinclair's account of what

for the jury, it also offered a compelling account of Helen Scott's

moments.

You're describing a scene and you're painting a picture for a jury. The jury

have got to get their heads round a whole three -dimensional picture of what

exactly took place here.

So the fact that Lorna Dawson could say this...

Poor girl who was murdered in this field was actually walked in. It was hugely

compelling.

Angus Sinclair was found guilty and sentenced to 37 years, symbolic of the

it had taken to reach a conviction.

We have waited 37 years for justice.

Today, that wait has ended.

We finally have justice for Helen and Christine.

Angus Sinclair was one of the most evil, dangerous

men to walk the face of the UK.

All that's lost.

And that's the bit that you start to think about.

Of all the evidence gathered at the scene of a crime, perhaps one of the

surprising are the tiny creatures who act as silent witnesses to the events

unfolded. Insect life can help prove a timeline right at the beginning of an

investigation when clues are thin on the ground. And our next case shows just

how crucial that evidence can be.

The number one question that police ask me is, How long has this body been dead?

Forensic entomology is providing one bit of a jigsaw evidence and it might often

be the missing one that finally solves the picture.

2009. The body of a 51 -year -old man has been found by a jogger.

Police are called to the scene and journalist Nick Britton is assigned to

the case.

Christopher Pratt's body was found after he went missing, lying naked in

wasteland near Scamondon.

Christopher Pratt was a civil servant and father of two from Grantham in

Lincolnshire. His body had been on the moor for some time.

Why he had been left there was a mystery.

To solve it, forensic investigators needed to act as quickly as possible, as

retired detective Roy Lambert explains.

You only get one chance.

He's now frequently called on as an expert witness to determine time of

numerous murder investigations.

I've been working as an expert witness in the field of forensic entomology for

about 30 years now.

Establishing time of death is really important. It sets the whole timescale

the investigation.

I like to think that the forensic entomology is providing...

One bit of a jigsaw evidence and it might often be the missing one that

solves the picture.

Martin's ability to determine time of death is all down to the life cycle of

blowflies. When a body is left in the open air, they're quickly attracted to

and they egg.

Larvae hatch from these eggs and it's their rate of development that provides

Martin with vital clues.

The life cycles of all blowflies are very similar, so egg to larva to puparia

adult fly, but the rates of development can vary, so it's very important

to get the identification correct if you want to get the timing right.

Martin began an analysis of the insects found on Chris Pratt's body.

Just as important as their species was the temperature around the body. This

affects how quickly the larvae grow.

Blueflies grow almost exponentially, really rapidly, and so even subtle

differences in temperature are important.

The difference between these is 27 degrees and these ones just 21 degrees.

Only 6 degrees, but they're much, much bigger in the jar here. If you don't

into account temperature, then there's no way you can tell how old the insects

are. In a way, unlike us, they don't just...

age in days they age proportional to heat as well so there's no way at all of

telling how old these maggots are by just looking at them what you need to do

take into account the temperature data without that there's no way that you can

provide a accurate estimate of their age

scamond

and moore has a microclimate very different to the surrounding area In

prove how long Christopher Pratt had been lying there, Martin needed to work

the temperatures at the scene where the body was discovered.

Not surprisingly, there wasn't a convenient weather station right by the

and so what we needed to do was try to get estimates of what the actual scene

temperatures were. So a data logger was placed there by the scenes of crime

officers.

So this is a typical data logger. They record temperature.

and relative humidity.

Basically they enable you to put the temperature recording device at the

where the body was found and you can record for ideally something like 10

after the body was removed and then you can relate the temperatures from the

data logger to those at a nearby weather station for the same period.

What this allowed us to do is then actually work out what temperatures the

insects were experiencing and how fast they would develop.

While Martin continued his analysis, the police investigation also made

progress. They discovered that Christopher Pratt had been seen with a

Desmond Lee.

Desmond Lee's a very dangerous man.

And by the time he met Christopher Pratt, he'd already served one life

for murder, having murdered his... The biggest maggots were around about 11mm

long.

From the laboratory studies, although they were somewhat limited, we had a

pretty good idea of how long it would take for those larvae to develop to that

size at the temperatures that we found at the scene.

And so we were able to determine when those eggs were first laid on the body.

Martin's evidence showed Christopher Pratt's body lay on the moor for over

days until it was discovered.

At last, detectives had a likely time of death.

They now looked for CCTV from around this time.

When they found footage of Chris entering Desmond Lee's flat, they

in for questioning.

Once, if you're lucky, you've established a time frame of when a

died, as an investigator, you can then use that when you're going questioning

witnesses and suspects to find out where they were during that period,

to establish either an alibi or they haven't got an alibi.

Desmond Lee had no alibi. Under questioning, he admitted Christopher had

his flat.

but claimed it was an accident.

His neck was broken, his voice box was crushed during an extremely violent act.

Lee claimed he put Chris's remains on the moors out of panic, yet detectives

could show that before he even moved the body, Lee had sufficient nerve to use

Chris Pratt's credit cards for a personal spending spree.

He paid off his mobile phone bill that night.

The next day, bought a load of goods from a supermarket.

He then went back to the flat, bundled Christopher's body into his car and

it to wasteland and just dumped it.

The callousness to do that is truly extraordinary.

April 2010, at Leeds Crown Court, Desmond Lee stood trial for the murder

Christopher Pratt.

During the trial, the weight of evidence stacked up and stacked up against

Desmond Lee.

Of course, we had CCTV footage of Christopher Pratt entering Desmond's

flat. We have the forensic entomologist saying that he had been in the field

for... pretty much the entire time since he was last seen. We have Desmond Lee's

history. He's a convicted killer. And all of these things added up and led to

the jury convicting unanimously Desmond Lee of Christopher Pratt's murder.

The judge sentenced Desmond Lee to life imprisonment.

In this case, like in all cases where we're able to help the police

investigation, I'm just astonished how callous some people can be.

Two very different cases there, but reassuring to see how both were finally

solved by science and the tenacity of an expert witness so that justice can

finally be delivered.

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.