Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
Pick up a box of factory 10 millimeter
off the shelf. The most powerful
production auto pistol round most men
will ever own and there's a real chance
the rounds inside it are doing exactly
what a 40 Smith and Wesson does. Same
speed, same energy, same hole. You paid
more for the box. You'll feel more
recoil at the range and downrange the
target can't tell the difference. The
word on the side of that box is doing a
lot of work. The powder inside it isn't.
That's the Ali. And it's not a small one
because of where the 40 came from in the
first place. Most men think the 10 mm
and the 40 are rivals. Two different
cartridges that compete on the shelf.
They're not rivals. One is the other one
with the power turned down. And the
company that turned it down did it on
purpose with the government's blessing
almost 40 years ago.
Once you know that story, you can't
unsee it and you'll never read a 10 mm
box the same way again. So, let's settle
it. 10 mm versus 40 Smith and Wesson.
What you were sold, what you actually
got, and which one of these two was the
honest deal the whole time. Stick around
because the thing that decides this
isn't on the gun. It's in the load. And
it's something the company that sold you
the ammo is counting on you never lining
up side byside. To see the lie clearly,
you have to go back to where the 40 came
from. Because the history is the whole
case.
In the 1980s, Colonel Jeff Cooper wanted
a cartridge with more reach than a 45
and more authority than a 9 mm.
The result was the 10 mm auto and it was
ferocious. A genuine full power load
pushed a 180 grain bullet somewhere
around 1,250 ft per second for over 600
ft-lb of energy. That is revolver magnum
territory out of a semi-auto.
The FBI fell in love with it after the
Miami shootout in 1986 exposed how
little their service rounds were doing.
And then the 10 mm ran into the wall
every owner eventually meets. The full
power round kicks hard. Hard enough that
a lot of agents struggled to shoot it
well or fast. The bureau did not drop
the cartridge though. They specified a
reduced load instead. A 180 grain bullet
at around 980 ft pers, roughly 400
ft-lb. Soft enough for everyone to
qualify with. The shooting world has a
name for that load to this day. They
call it the FBI light. This is the part
that turns a footnote into the biggest
lie in the gun industry.
Smith and Wesson and Winchester looked
at that downloaded FBI spec and realized
something. If the 10 mm was only going
to be loaded that soft anyway, you
didn't need the big long case to do it.
You could chop the case down, fit it
into a smaller 9 mm sized pistol, and
hit the exact same numbers. In 1990,
they did precisely that, and they called
it the 40 Smith and Wesson. The 40 was
never designed to compete with the 10
mm. It was designed to be the 10 mm
downloaded FBI spec in a shorter case, a
10 mm with the power turned down by
birth. The community even nicknamed it
the 40 short and weak. And they weren't
entirely joking. If you've ever wondered
why these two rounds look like brothers,
that's why. They fire the exact same
diameter bullet, 4/10 of an inch. The 40
is just the short one. And the clearest
proof of how close they are sits right
in your own pistol. Most 10 mm guns will
run 40 Smith and Wesson without
complaint. A lot of folks shoot the
cheaper 40 through their 10 mm at the
range the same way a man runs 38 special
through his 357.
The case is shorter, so it isn't the
ideal long-term diet and the careful
guys fit a dedicated 40 barrel for it,
but the fact that the bigger gun happily
eats the smaller round tells you what
you're dealing with. These aren't rivals
from different families. One is the
other with the case chopped down. Just
know it only works one direction. A 10
mm is too long to chamber in a 40. So
don't ever try that. If you've owned one
of these for years and you're only
hearing the real story now, this is the
channel that gives it to you straight.
Subscribe and you won't miss the next
one. Now the part that decides
everything. So where's the lie exactly?
It isn't the marketing department
velocity printed on the box. Yes, that
number comes from a longer test barrel
than the one on your pistol. So,
everybody's ammo clocks a little slower
than the label in the real world. That's
true of every cartridge, and it's not
the scandal. The scandal is what the 10
mm is loaded to in the first place. The
big ammo makers spent decades loading
their everyday 10 mm down to that same
FBI light level. And you don't have to
take my word for it. You can read it off
their own cataloges. Look up a major
maker's 180 grain 40 and their 180 grain
10 mm side by side and you'll find the
10 listed at maybe 20 or 30 ft per
second faster than the 40. Same bullet,
same speed, two different prices. Part
of the reason is that most hollow points
made in this caliber were actually
designed to open at slow 40 speeds and
they tear themselves apart if you push
them to real 10 mm velocity. So the
factory simply doesn't push them. The
result is that a whole lot of the 10 mm
on the shelf is doing 40 Smith and
Wesson work. You are paying 10 mm money
and burning 10 mm recoil for 40
performance. And the only place the
difference shows up is your wallet and
your wrist.
The actual numbers tell the story and
this audience checks them. Honest full
power 10 mm. The buffalo boores and
underwoods of the world. A 180 grain
bullet runs around 1,250 to,300 ft per
second. 600 ft-lb and up. A 40 Smith and
Wesson with the same weight bullet runs
around 1,000 ft per second. right at 400
foot-p pound. That's a real gap. Close
to 50% more energy. And it's exactly why
a true 10 mm is a legitimate woods and
hog and black bear cartridge, while the
40 is not.
But now look at the soft factory 10 mm.
The FBI light stuff filling most of the
shelf. It comes out of the barrel at 980
1,000 ft pers right at 400 ft-lb same as
the 40. You did not buy more power. You
bought a longer case and a bigger gun to
launch the identical performance and
you're paying for it every time you
reload at the register. So, the whole
thing comes down to which 10 mm you
actually bought. Full power 10 mm
genuinely beats the 40 by a wide margin.
downloaded 10 millimeter, which is most
of what's sold, ties the 40 exactly
while costing more and kicking harder
for the privilege.
So, what does the 40 actually give up?
Honestly, less than its nickname
suggests. A 40 pushing a 180 grain
bullet at 1,000 ft pers is doing real
work. In gelatin, against a two-legged
threat, an honest 40 and an honest full
power 10 mm using similar hollow points
land closer together than the spec sheet
implies because past a certain point,
both are punching deep and expanding,
and the extra 10 mm energy is going into
the back stop. The 10 mm real undeniable
edge is on the things with thick hide
and heavy bone, bear, hogs, deer, where
that extra velocity and a heavy hardcast
bullet matter, and where the 40 simply
isn't enough gun. Fair warning, even
there, the 10 mm isn't the last word.
Plenty of serious bare country guys
still reach for a 44 Magnum or a hot
Hardcast 45, and that's a debate for
another day. For a paper target or a
man-sized threat, the Honest 40 gives up
very little. For a charging boar, the
Honest 10 mm is in a different class.
Both of those sentences only hold up as
long as that 10 mm is the real thing and
not the downloaded version. If this is
the kind of straight answer you came
looking for, hit subscribe before we go
on. Two more things everyone gets wrong
and they decide which gun you should
actually buy.
Start with capacity because half the
internet believes the 40 wins here and
it doesn't. Not the way they think. The
bullet is the same width. So the
magazines run almost identical. A Glock
20 and 10 mm holds 15. A Glock 22 and 40
holds 15. Same count. What the 40
actually buys you is a smaller, lighter
gun for that same 15 rounds because the
case is shorter. So the 40 fits frames
the 10 mm never will. That's a real
advantage for carry. It is not a
capacity advantage and the man who tells
you otherwise at the gun counter has it
backwards. The other thing people get
backwards is recoil and cost where the
40 quietly wins the dayto-day. The 10
mm, when it's loaded to its real
potential, kicks hard. Noticeably harder
than the 40. Hard enough to slow your
follow-up shots and wear on you over a
long range session. And it costs more
per round, often quite a bit more. The
40 is cheaper, softer, fits a smaller
gun, and holds the same number. For a
man whose job is defending himself
against other men, not bears, the 40
does the work for less money and less
punishment.
The round the internet spent 30 years
calling short and weak has been the
smart everyday buy the whole time.
There's a bitter footnote to all this
that makes the betrayal worse. The FBI,
the agency that started the whole 10 mm
craze, couldn't live with the recoil
even after they downloaded it, which is
the entire reason the 40 got built. And
then years later, the bureau walked away
from the 42 and went right back to the
9mm because modern 9mm hollow points
finally did the job with less recoil and
more rounds in the gun. So the cartridge
the whole industry chased, downloaded,
chopped down, and sold you as the
powerful choice was abandoned at the top
by the very people who created the
demand for it. The power race the 10 mm
was supposed to win quietly ended with
everyone going back to the smallest
round in the argument.
The verdict is what you came for. So
take one second and subscribe first.
This channel puts out a new one of these
every single day, and the next matchup
is already in the works. So, here's the
verdict, and it's going to land
differently depending on which gun is in
your safe right now. The 10 mm is the
more powerful cartridge. That part is
true, and it always was, but it is only
the more powerful cartridge when you
feed it honest, full power ammunition,
and most of what's sold isn't. Buy a 10
mm, fill it with ordinary factory loads,
and you've very likely bought a 40 Smith
and Wesson that costs more, kicks
harder, and rides in a bigger gun. For
performance, you could have had cheaper
and softer. The only way the 10 mm
delivers the power you paid for is if
you take control of the ammunition, buy
the named hot loads, the Underwoods, and
the Buffalo Bores, or learn to load your
own. If you're not willing to do that,
the honest answer is brutal. You bought
the badge, not the performance. And the
40 Smith and Wesson, the round the
internet spent 30 years mocking, turns
out to be the honest one in this fight.
It never pretended to be more than it
is. It does exactly what the box says,
in a smaller gun for less money at the
same capacity.
The Lie was never that the 40 is weak.
The liie is that the 10 mm on the shelf
is strong.
One of these cartridges tells you the
truth about itself every time you pull
the trigger. The other one depends
entirely on whether the man who loaded
it was honest. And most of the time he
wasn't.
So tell me in the comments if you own a
10 mm. Have you ever actually put your
factory carry load over a chronograph?
And what did it really do? And the one I
want most for the men who carry the 40
and have taken the short and weak jokes
for years. Did this change how you feel
about the round in your holster or did
you know the truth the whole time?
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.