Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
Downloaded from YTS.BZ
-Good evening.
Official YIFY movies site: YTS.BZ
Thank you for coming.
There are two mics.
Does that mean they're both mine,
or are we...
One is for the making of 'The Trial, '
or just a few stories about it, and it would seem to me that
this was the best place to get some questions and try
some answers...
and hope not to bore you.
My cinematographer, Mr. Gary Graver...
All right, reel one, take one.
Okay. Again?
I never did that very well.
Okay.
Any questions?
Yes, sir?
-How did you decide on the variety of different types of
music that you used in the score?
I noticed there were...
-Repeat the question, please.
-I noticed there were classical elements of the music in the
score and also jazz, and I was wondering how you decided on the
different elements and where each type of music would go in
the film.
-Well, you know, that's...
There are two ways of answering that kind of question.
One is pompously to pretend that I had a master plan...
and the other is to admit that I put it in where I thought it
would sound good, you know?
Which sounds like begging the question,
but it's the truth.
The basis, of course, is the Gesualdo,
which is the basic music of it, which became a hit as a result
of that.
Nobody had ever heard it, and there was one very limited
record of it, and after that in Europe it was played all over
like a hit tune.
In fact, a lot more people heard that music
than saw the movie anywhere.
It's an extraordinary piece of music because...
it's got musical ideas in it that didn't turn up again for
200 years.
And it's curiously romantic for baroque music,
and full of doom, and beauty, and I liked it for the picture.
I don't know if I would now.
As you notice, I came in afterwards.
I never like to see my movies because I like to remember them
as being so much better than they really were.
And that's true.
Sir.
-What inspired you to make 'The Trial?'
-Well, that's a story.
I take you to the mountains of Austria where,
with my family, I was
enjoying the winter sports,
hoping I would be able to pay the hotel bill at the end of it,
and had just completed being interviewed by Oriana Fallaci
who had stated in the Italian press that I was undoubtedly the
next American president.
My constituency at the time consisted of my wife and
daughter, so I didn't see much future in it... for me in the
White House... and I was waiting for the phone to ring,
which is what all of you will be doing if all of you are rash
enough to go into the film business.
And a family of people called the Salkinds came into my life.
They are a dynasty of filmmakers.
Old Man Salkind, who was an adorable little old gentleman
who hadn't paid a bill in about 32 years...
but loved movies,
genuinely loved movies,
and his son Alexander came to see me.
Now, the Old Man Salkind has gone to dwell beyond the morning
stars, and Alexander is a sort of dean of the Salkind tribe
because it's his son who has made the 'Supermans' and the
millions, and millions, and so on that the Salkinds have made.
The old man, the adorable old man,
had made a famous movie... at least in my youth in the
textbooks on movies it was considered a great movie...
which was the 'Don Quixote' of Chaliapin;
and he had made the first Garbo movie;
and he had a distinguished career.
They had then escaped from Europe and become Mexican film
producers where they'd made about 40 Mexican pictures,
the quality of which I'm not prepared to speak about.
They arrived in this little, tiny Austrian Alpine village in
a taxi cab which they had taken from Innsbruck...
and for which they did not have the money to pay.
This is really true.
And that didn't come out 'til later,
and they said, "We want you to make 'Taras Bulba...'"
and, well, 'Taras Bulba' is a wonderful story... Gogol is my
favorite Russian writer... and I thought,
"That's absolutely wonderful!
These people have come all the way up into the Alps,
and they're all ready to make 'Taras Bulba.'
Splendid!"
And I started to write a script of it,
and then...
I must stop and say that they had to borrow the money to
get in the cab back to Innsbruck, but that was supposed
to be because of problems with the exchange... they hadn't been
able to get Austrian shillings or something.
Later, I was to discover that they didn't have any money at
all, which I think is admirable.
You know, here they were making a trip across Europe,
coming to ask me to make a movie for which they didn't
have a cent.
They didn't even have to eat.
And they came back again in another taxi,
and they said, "We've just read that Yul Brynner is making
'Taras Bulba' in the Argentine," which,
indeed, he did.
I saw a little piece of it for the first time the other night
on television.
It was pretty bad, but there it was...
'Taras Bulba.'
And they said, "We can't have two of them,"
and I said, "That's true."
And they said, "We have here a list of movies
we are ready to finance.
You pick out the one you like."
They didn't say, "What do you want to make?"
They said, "Here is our list," and I said,
"I couldn't add to this list any?"
"No," they said, "here they are."
And there were about 82 titles, most of which were impossible,
and the most likely of which was 'The Trial.'
So I said, "We'll do 'The Trial.'"
So we made 'The Trial.'
And I know that kind of answer is very disappointing because
you want to think of a filmmaker
as having studied in his library
the work which sings the most perfect song to him,
and that I had spent my life wanting to realize Kafka on the
screen... I had never given a thought to it.
But it was a book I admired, a writer I admired,
and it was a challenge I was very happy to accept.
And challenge, indeed, it was
because we went to Yugoslavia to
shoot it, and I had designed all the scenery which was going to
be physically a very different movie.
The scenery begins coming slightly apart all the time so
that it was sort of flying away into the darkness.
So it was a very elaborate and, I think,
interesting, maybe pretentious visual idea for it.
And all of this was to have been built by the Yugoslavs.
And we did those Yugoslav scenes which did not require sets.
We needed an enormous building where we could do that office
scene, where all the people are typing, you know?
And they did, indeed, get from all of any 10,000 typewriters,
and 10,000 desks,
and all that, and we shot that.
And then the Yugoslavs did a trick which they sometimes do.
I don't mean the Yugoslavs as a race;
I mean the Yugoslavs as producers,
because like all people who have lived under occupation for a
long time... the Irish, for instance and particularly...
The Yugoslavs had lived for 400 years under the Turks,
and we must understand that all people who are occupied for a
long time learn as an act of
honor to steal from strangers.
Quite seriously.
In other words they won't steal from each other,
but if a stranger comes with a lot of money from Hollywood or
whatever it is, steal if you can.
And in the case of 'The Trial, ' they did what they do to
hundreds of Italian co-producers.
They got us right up to the day where we were going to be in the
studio... which we never got to see for some mysterious reason.
There was always a breakdown of a car or... so we never got to
look at it.
Finally, they came to that day and they said,
"We made a miscalculation in the money
and we need another $300,000."
Well, the Salkinds didn't have the money to pay our hotel bill
in Zagreb, much less for these sets which had not even begun to
be built.
And the Yugoslavs believed that they had us by the well-known...
situation...
As, indeed, they had done with many co-productions and so on.
And I said to Old Man Salkind,
"Get tickets on the night train.
Don't say anything.
We're all leaving town."
So we all left town to the astonishment of the Yugoslavs
who had expected that they'd be able to get the other half of
the picture and own it in order to provide the sets.
So we arrived back in Paris.
There were no sets, there was no money.
I should explain that, in my reading of the book... and of
course everybody reads the book as a different book,
and my reading is probably more wrong than a lot of people's...
I see the monstrous bureaucracy, which is the villain of the
piece, as not only Kafka's
clairvoyant view of the future,
but his racial and cultural
background of being occupied by
the Austro-Hungarian empire.
And I see a curious combination of the book,
of an unthinkably sterile future combined with an unthinkably
dusty accumulation of those
traditions which bureaucrats set
up in order to perpetuate their monstrous lives.
If I sound like our president I profoundly apologize.
So I have made a parentheses here about that style to explain
how it was that we came to do it.
We came to do it because I picked it out of a list,
and we shot most of it in Paris
because I wanted a 19th century
look to a great deal of what would be,
in fact, expressionistic.
And on the first night in Paris, I was in a hotel near the Seine,
and I am very, very... I hate to use the word superstitious
because I take it more seriously...
I'm awfully serious about the moon.
I think that Robert Graves was right when he said that the most
blasphemous thing that has happened since Alexander cut the
Gordian knot was when
we landed on the moon.
And having let loose with a piece of eccentricity of that
kind you'll see who you're dealing with.
A point there is that the only name on the moon is Nixon and
that they played golf.
Anyway, we are in Paris, and
I am looking out of the window
at three in the morning wondering how we can shoot,
and I see two moons.
Two full moons.
And I go out on the balcony of my hotel room,
and I see that they are the two clocks on the Gare d'Orsay.
I went downstairs, got in a cab, went to the Gare d'Orsay,
which was empty... it only had two trains that came
in a day... and I wandered around and I saw that that was
where the picture could be made.
So that is how it happened to be picked and why it happened to be
made that way.
I'll try to give you a fast answer to the next one.
Yes, ma'am?
-This might give you a chance for a short answer.
In this film, Josef K. runs down that hallway with those
runs down that hallway with those alternating arched
mirrors, and in 'Citizen Kane, ' that famous sequence down...
-There are no mirrors.
-In that archway where she appears in between...
-Oh, yes.
-And we get the mirrors in 'Lady from Shanghai'
and in 'Citizen Kane.'
I wonder if you would comment maybe on the frequency of
multiple mirrors that you use in a number of your films,
and which a man usually a man,
but a character in distress... sees himself over,
and over, and over in these mirrors...
-I can give you an impressive answer which will embarrass me,
and I can also remind you that
I'm a magician and that people say that everything a
magician does is done with mirrors, you know?
Which is a frivolous answer.
And then I can try to give a serious answer which is that the
camera is a peculiar kind of mirror and that
turning the mirror on it seems to me a kind of a magical thing
to do.
I can't tell you why.
Way in the back.
-I was wondering whether you thought there was enough
sympathy for the main character in this film.
-I didn't hear that.
Enough difference between...?
-Do you think that there was enough sympathy for the main
character in this film?
Were you satisfied?
-Now, that's an interesting question,
and I'm glad you asked me that.
A strange thing happened with that movie.
It got wonderful press all over the world,
even in America... even in Time, and Newsweek,
and everything... wonderful press;
and Perkins got very bad press all over the world,
and the entire blame for that is mine because he is a superlative
actor, and he played the character that I saw as K.
And paid the price because nobody else sees it my way.
I find in the book repeated indications that K.
Is a pusher on his way up the bureaucracy;
not Mister Zero in the adding machine,
not Little Mister Nobody, not the poor,
little, faceless accountant, but a young man very anxious to get
ahead in this awful world and doing his best to do that,
and therefore in a state of real neuroses because he is both
terrified of and anxious to conquer the same thing.
I recognize that I did Tony...
who is one of the best actors we have...
a great disservice because he deserved to have made
a tremendous success, and if he didn't with the critics,
the blame is 100 percent with me.
Yes, sir?
-In the filming of 'Othello, ' you said you believed in the
existence of evil, and in this film the evil seems to come from
within man... from his people, from his buildings,
from his laws.
They seem to control this man of society's life and destiny.
Are you saying then that evil comes from within man and not
from outside from nature?
-Wow!
Wow.
I do, indeed, believe in the existence of evil,
and to that extent I'm at odds with most of the people
especially of my generation.
I think evil is a force so great
that it is beyond me to decide
whether it is generated entirely within man,
or whether it is a condition a contagion... as well as
something that we generate within ourselves.
The power of it is so great that it tumbles me.
The metaphysics are beyond me on that.
I'd like to sit at a coffee table and argue it,
but I wouldn't like to be on a distinguished dais of this kind
in a great university...
saying something for quotation on such a majestic theme.
-You made a new order of chapters than the way they were
originally published.
Did you do this for any particular reason?
-You have to repeat...
-Did I make a new order with the story?
-Yes, from the way it was originally published...
-Can you pick this kid up and bring him around the
corner, please?
-I'm so sorry.
You know, I'm a little deaf, and I have a mic and you don't.
-My English is very bad.
-Your English is very good.
It's nothing to do with that.
It's... I really am a little deaf.
-Did you reorder the chapters in the story for any
particular reason?
-Reorder the what of the story?
-The chapters.
-The packet.
-The chapters!
-Everybody knows what's happening.
Did I reorder the chapters?
In other words did I change the plotline,
the narrative line?
Of course!
Of course.
Every film is an original work.
A film should never be an llustration of a book
or of a play.
It should be itself, and it cannot be itself unless its
creator... a word for which I apologize because I hear the
word creator and creativity much to much nowadays... but the
maker, the picture-maker, is
after all engaged in an artform
which is entirely different from literature and the theater,
and he has not only the perfect right,
but the obligation...
to turn the work into something a little different than the
author intended, not to perfectly realize it.
If he perfectly realizes it, we might just as well have lantern
slides and somebody with a lovely voice reading the book.
-One of the things that I find most interesting about the film
is, again, your use of architecture and how all the
buildings seem to be connected except,
I guess, for K.'s apartment.
He seems to go through hallways and get to the different rooms
even though the architecture's quite different,
and I wonder if you could comment more on this.
-It's part of the...
I say in the picture that it's a dream,
that I made a picture like a dream.
I attempted to make a picture which is like some of the dreams
I have had.
I think it's pompous and silly to say what a dream is like
because we're all dreamers, and we all dream different ways.
And I move from one kind of architecture to another in my
dreams without any difficulty whatsoever.
And it's a little harder to do with a camera and make you
believe you're in the same movie,
but that comes from years of hanky panky
and sidearm snookery.
-Do you think Kafka intended it as a dream?
-No.
No, I don't.
But I had to say something to a mass audience.
I had to find a way to make this accessible to an
audience of many millions of people, and the way to do that
was to say it's a dream.
So I've slightly evaded both questions.
-One of the changes you made in the story was at the
very end when Josef K. is killed, he's killed in a very
alarmingly different way than in the book, and I was really
curious as to why you changed both the way he was
killed and the way he was acting when he died.
-Because the book was written before the Holocaust...
and I couldn't bear the defeat of K. in
the book after the Holocaust.
I'm not Jewish, but we are all Jewish since the Holocaust.
And I couldn't bear for him to submit to death as he does in
Kafka, masochistically submit to death.
It stank of the old Prague ghetto,
to me, and I had to let him shout out
defiance until he was blown up.
There's also an embarrassing thing in the picture which is
the mushroom-shaped cloud.
Well, it turns out that any big explosion you can make ends up
in the shape of a mushroom.
So we spent an afternoon trying to get a cloud that wouldn't end
up looking like a mushroom because I hate symbolism,
but there it was.
So I said, "All right, there's gonna be symbolism whether we
like it or not," you know?
Yes, sir?
-In this film, the computer is portrayed as sort of a dumb
adding machine.
The people manipulating it are the ones evil.
Is that your belief about the computer,
that it's merely a big adding machine and that it's not
intrinsically evil itself?
-Well, the question is interesting because there's an
enormous scene in the picture
which was cut out by me two
hours before the opening night in Paris,
which was a scene about the computer which would've more
fully explained my attitude at that time about computers.
My attitude has changed slightly,
but only slightly since then, and I believe that the...
What that scene did, which had...
played at almost nine minutes and as I said I cut it out in
the afternoon of the opening...
what that scene did was to show
man's slavish relationship to something which is really only
his tool.
That was a splendid thing to say but it turned out to be rather a
drag in the picture, so I took it out.
-Why is the condemned man attractive?
After 19 years, do you have anything to add to that?
-Why is the...?
-Condemned man attractive, or...
-Attractive?
-You comment in the film about, you know,
the women find him attractive, and then your character says
that people seem drawn to him and he's fascinating.
-Yeah, well, you know my character,
you don't believe a word I say, do you,
in the movie; you're not supposed to.
That's the real...
masochistic... that's the...
Kafka the masochist at his most...
narcissistic, you know?
Look at my beautiful blood, you know,
as it streams down.
But of course nothing the Advocate says is meant
to be true.
-What is the reason that you like to dub the voices of minor
characters in your films, and which characters did you
dub in 'The Trial'?
-I don't like to dub the minor characters, but...
by the time we get to dubbing, there usually isn't any more
money, particularly if you're working with the Salkinds at
that period.
And as in the case of 'Othello, ' where I did play practically my
supporting cast...
It was economic...
because you don't get a good
actor for free to go into a dark room and
spend all day trying to...
lip sync, you know?
It's a thankless job.
There.
-Why did you choose for yourself the role of the Advocate and not
one of the accused?
-Well, I thought that... I didn't want to play the Advocate.
I didn't want to be in it.
And you would be astonished at the different people I offered
it to, including Gleeson.
I did.
I played the Advocate because there was no other actor of my
caliber that I could afford.
But I enjoyed doing it.
Once I saw Romy in that white nurse's uniform,
I enjoyed every minute of it.
Yes?
-How did you cast the actors in 'The Trial'?
-How did you cast the actors in 'The Trial'?
-How did I cast the actors in 'The Trial'?
The same as I cast any movie, by...
I don't want my answer to sound condescending.
By picking the people that
seemed to be best adapted for it.
In the case of 'The Trial, ' of course,
I had a co-production, and a co-production means that you
have different nations involved.
So I had to have some Germans, and some French,
and some English.
And therefore there are some German actors who might not have
been German otherwise, but I think all the Germans are very
good in it.
I had to get Tamiroff in who was an American,
so we had to have plenty of French actors.
So I had a very good actor, Maurice Teynac,
who played the manager.
I was very happy to have him.
I was limited by the nationalities,
but that's not such a terrible limitation.
The world is full of wonderful actors who
luckily speak our language.
Although, they are getting fewer and fewer because after the war,
every young actor quickly learned English thinking that
was the only way to get ahead.
And nowadays, actors of your age do not
speak English in all the countries in the world.
Very few bother to.
And you're left with those same old faces because pictures have
ceased to be international.
Think how few international pictures play here,
or in London, or in Berlin.
I'm not speaking of festivals; I mean in theaters.
So when everybody thought, "They're gonna make English
speaking pictures forever," everybody learned English.
So it was much easier 20 years ago to cast
across the European continent
as well as you could and not be
disappointed with the result.
I miscast, of course.
Every director does that.
Every director makes terrible mistakes and there's nothing you
can do about it.
But I don't remember that...
except for the...
my controversial reading of K.
That there's anything that could possibly be called bad casting
in it.
But I don't know.
Would somebody say if they think somebody else was badly cast?
It'd be interesting to hear.
It won't hurt my feelings a bit.
-I think K. was very well-cast.
- You do?
- Yes!
-Hooray for you!
-How much obligation do you feel to a mass audience?
-How much
obligation do I feel?
-How much must you modify your vision so that people will...
-There's a missing word here between what I feel and to a
mass audience.
- Obligation.
- Obligation?
I would love to have a mass audience.
You're looking at a man who's been searching for
a mass audience...
And if I had one, I'd be obliged.
That's all I can say.
Here comes a man who looks like he's about to shoot me.
-Talking about money, do you think if you'd had a great deal
of it it would've made your films better,
or did your poverty help your creativity in any way?
-Did my poverty help my creativity?
Uh, no.
No.
I think, however, that it is possible to spoil a
young director...
by giving him too much money
so that he does not learn
one of the main arts of directing which is the ability
to walk away from something
when it is not perfect.
No fine movie was ever made by a director who wants
everything to be perfect.
Because every bad painting has every leaf in the
tree, and every great painting makes you see a tree.
And there are great lessons to be learned by not using money,
by not using the studio largesse unquestioningly;
but there is no advantage in having to reach in your pocket
and pay Madeleine Robinson her salary at the end of every week
otherwise she'd leave the picture...
which is what happened in 'The Trial.'
-A number of your films, obviously this one,
but a number of other ones generate a sort of a palpable
feel of oppression.
Are you as pessimistic as that seems to indicate,
or is that just what you like to do...
-Am I as what?
-As pessimistic as would seem to be indicated by the feeling of
oppression in 'The Trial' and the sort of visual oppression
that comes over in a number of your other pictures.
-Yes, I am a profound pessimist...
with a sentimental inclination
to hope that Pangloss was right
and that I am wrong.
I have a sentimental inclination toward hope.
I believe in bravery, and...
worship it.
To me, it's one of the greatest virtues there are.
And the fact that I am a pessimist is part of what gives
bravery such an importance to me.
Don't call me a macho.
That's not what I'm talking about.
Yes?
-Everytime I see this film, I'm so struck by the brilliant use
of space in so many of the environments,
and yet in the Kafka story, all the spaces seem very cramped.
I wondered if you would talk about what led you to change the
conception of space.
Was it the different medium, or your own vision,
or anything else, I mean, in terms of moving it away from the
kind of space that was in the novel and the kind of space that
you have in the film?
-That's a better question than I have an answer for.
Honestly, it is.
I don't know.
I would want to think about it.
I think my answer would be frivolous,
and I'd like to think about it.
It's a worrisome question.
I don't know.
I thought that I was being faithful to my reading of the
book, and I know that nobody agrees with me,
including those people who like the picture as well as those who
dislike it.
But I did not consciously...
change what I thought was its essential meaning.
But that's as far as I can go, as big a boast as I dare
to make.
Yes?
-What do you see as the role of seduction in bureaucracy?
There seem to be lots of sexual symbols,
or sexuality is almost the antagonist...
along with the bureaucratic oppression.
-That's Kafka.
That really is Kafka.
It's part of the fascination of the book...
is that insistent and
almost onanistic eroticism.
I find that in the book.
It's not an obsession or a specialty of mine.
I'm not...
I would be happy to make a movie in which...
I would be happy to have 40 years of movie making ahead of
me in which it would never be necessary for me to ask the
leading man to take his pants off, you know?
But the eroticism in Kafka is inevitable.
It's there, and it's very strong I think.
Yes?
-You have been quoted in an interview that was taken before
'The Trial' was filmed that you did not think that you would be
the man to film 'The Trial.'
Tonight you have said that you took 'The Trial' on practically
because it was the least intolerable prospect offered
to you...
- Not least tolerable.
- Least intolerable.
-Not least intolerable, no.
I didn't find... No, if I said that,
I was making a bad joke, and I've expressed myself badly.
-It was the best of the 80, or the most likely,
you said, of the 80 that you were offered...
-It was the title I liked.
-Anyways, I would say that the main character is somewhat less
passive than the characters I've read in Kafka.
Taking all that together, do you think that your world vision is
close to Kafka's?
And do you think that's something to take
into consideration for you to make a movie out of his work?
-You know, I didn't
follow that, help me out...
-I'm sorry, the...
-What?
-It's...
-Your world vision, is it close to Kafka's?
-My world vision close to Kafka?
Of course not.
Not at all.
He was a creature born entirely of the Austro-Hungarian Empire,
of his own people, his own religion,
between the two world wars, and there's every possible
difference between us.
We could not possibly have the same vision even if our genes
were the same.
There's no way we could see the world the same at this different
moment in the turning of the globe.
And therefore you'll say I shouldn't have made the picture,
and there's no answer to that either.
Yes, sir?
-Could you tell us about your work with the cinematographer in
planning the look of the this film?
-My work as a cinematographer?
-Your work with the cinematographer in planning the
look of this film.
-I never sit down and
plan with a cinematographer.
-No storyboards...?
-No, no, no.
I had storyboards in 'Kane' only because I was made to.
-Did you go to the set each day not knowing what you were going
to... where you were gonna plop
the camera down or in rehearsal...?
-I believe I'm the only director that I know of
who does this particular thing
which is probably the worst way to go about it.
I didn't begin this way, but I have developed this way.
I light a set before I decide where anybody will
go with the cameramen.
And then when the set looks right to me,
I put the actors where I think they ought to be.
I don't put the actors and then light the set.
It's the exact opposite...
because the set is all we have besides the actors and it ought
to have a chance.
And the only way to give it a chance is to begin with it.
That's my theory anyway.
-How much did 'The Trial' cost to make?
-How much did 'The Trial... '
Well, that will never be known.
It cost me about $80,000.
I never made any money.
It cost me about $80,000.
In fact, it's cost me a lot more money to be a film director than
I've ever made.
That's literally true.
So let that be an encouragement to you all.
-In the program notes, it mentions that the film was not
as great a critical success in Britain and in America as it was
on the continent in Europe.
-That's wrong!
We got wonderful reviews except for the character of K.
-Then my question's tossed out.
-No...
-But what I was going to comment on was that while I was watching
the film, I had a feeling of a very, what
I would consider something that comes from American
traditions of law and British traditions of law,
of this can't happen...
-It's European.
-Exactly, this can't happen, and I thought that maybe that was a
very American thing and a very British thing...
- Lay a count.
- And not a European thing.
-Yes, well it is a very European film.
It was made by me...
really as a European director.
It was made with an essentially European cast.
There was no attempt to stick into it things which would make
it seem as though it's also American because I don't think
there's anything in Kafka which will support that.
To me, he is middle Europe, middle Europe,
middle Europe, and no escape from it.
It's part of his prison; it's part of his enchantment.
-You will use the same actor today,
or what actor you will choose today to make 'The Trial?'
- To make K.?
- Yeah.
-If I were going to do it again?
You mean given the difference of age?
I think...
Pacino...
but then I think Pacino in almost anything I can think up.
Such a fan of his.
But I think he'd be marvelous, yes,
but that's accounting for the difference of age,
of course, Tony's too old now.
We're not running him down.
We've got somebody... there.
The easiest one to reach, isn't it unfair?
All right...
-With all the escapist movies that have come out in the last
few years, is there some topic that you would like to make into
a movie to retaliate against all of this BS?
-To retaliate against escapist movies?
I love escapist movies.
I love them.
I see no obligation on the part of a...
a filmmaker to be serious...
or even to be adult.
I think it's very nice to make movies for children and to make
movies for the child which is in every grown person.
My difficulty with science fiction movies...
I used to write it for my living when there was a thing called
the pulps, which only the most elderly of you will even
recognize as a word, but I was a pulp writer, and I
used to write 'Lobster Men from Mars' and all that.
And I have a certain notoriety in the science fiction field,
but it's never been anything I like very much
'cause I don't believe in the future.
That doesn't mean I think everything's going to end at
this moment, but I think the future is a total hypothesis.
I believe in the present insofar as we can grab it and the past,
and anything about the future I don't believe.
All I've got to do is put on one of those bike helmets,
you know, and silver things and start off into the world of
optical printing, and I'm up the aisle, you see?
And not because they're bad movies,
but because I don't respond.
I didn't like westerns until I was about 50 years old and I
began to see them rerun on television.
I never went to them as a child, and now I adore them.
And I might learn to like, you know,
zing zing and up in outer space, but for the moment it doesn't
say anything to me.
But I'm in favor of them.
I think it's fine.
As long as they are not violent for the
sake of violence or in any way fascistic in their tone,
as long as they partake of a myth or of the mythic quality
which a film can...
can call upon, I think it's a marvelous exercise in
virtuosity, and I immensely admire the people who make them.
-Are there any childlike aspects to 'The Trial, '
and if you made it again would you insert any?
-Do you think so?
-I have a great difficulty finding them.
-Yes, I don't think there are, but there must be because nobody
is completely grown up,
and no work of art...
God, what a terrible thing have I said.
No movie...
No movie is made by a complete adult, you know?
First of all, I don't know any complete
adults in civilian life, so how could they have
infiltrated movies, you know?
It's unthinkable, seems to me.
Yes, sir?
-In regard to that gentleman's last comment,
I did find a lot of childlike aspects in it,
especially in relation to certain kinds of fairy stories...
-In 'The Trial?'
-In 'The Trial.'
Especially 'Alice in Wonderland' and 'The Wizard of Oz' in your
big scene when you're booming to Akim Tamiroff.
I was wondering if you were thinking of that to
some degree...
-Yes, they are... perhaps they're childlike.
Perhaps that's the right word for them.
I thought of them as...
simple-minded and...
I thought of them as being related to the...
to Grimm, you know?
And that, of course, takes us to childhood.
But, you know, the great fairy tales, which
were invented by people living in forests before the
electric light, still live on.
And our reactions to certain
kinds of horror, and delight, and even to cruelty,
which is in this picture you've seen,
is, I suppose, childlike, yes.
But I hadn't thought of it.
You're teaching me things I didn't know.
Yes?
-Having seen 'Citizen Kane' and 'The Trial, '
it seems that both films seem to adopt a sort of Brechtian view
of man and society or man versus man,
and I was very curious, have you ever thought of doing a Brecht
piece, or did that ever come into your work...
-Well...
Dick Wilson here... who was my partner for a long time who's
sitting in the front here... and I were going to do the first
production of 'Galileo, '
and I worked with Brecht and Laughton
on it, and that's as far as I'm prepared to go on the subject of
what is Brechtian and not because I admired him enormously
and thought that he was two people.
One, a Jesuit trained...
literateur, a man who wanted all of his works published in...
the best leather and kept forever,
and a dogmatist.
And all of that was very superficial.
He was essentially a very astute theater man,
and his theory was mostly self-defense.
Sex, sex, sex.
All right.
-I was wondering what you did to affect
really the dizziness of K.
In that movie because I felt very closed in when he was
getting dizzy inside that courtroom,
when he was trying to escape.
-You felt very closed in when I was...
-When K. was dizzy and trying to get out of
the courtroom.
-Yes, that was the idea...
-I'm just wondering how you did that...
-I would've been awfully sorry if you hadn't.
-No, what did you do?
-Oh, how I did it?
The mastery of the cinema.
I'll tell you how we did it.
We put entirely too many people in the room
that there was, you see?
We made claustrophobia by overcrowding.
-Could you tell us a little bit more about the ending,
how you arrived at it?
You told us a little bit why, but how did you come upon the
ending as you did?
-Well, I don't know how I came upon it.
I wanted K. to make a final gesture
even if it was fruitless...
If we want to be... If we want to pin a label on it,
it's existentialist.
I couldn't bear for him to have his throat slit like a pig,
and he throws the grenade back...
which is a way of saying no.
And it seemed to me that putting a man in a hole
with a bomb and letting him try to throw the bomb out expressed
that as well as I could think.
It was as simple a way of stating it as I could think of,
and I haven't since then tried to think of a better one.
Maybe I would've and having done it I...
Yes?
-I have a question about your coverage of scenes.
You've been noted for many rather exceptional long takes
such as the boarding house sequence in 'Kane' or the first
sequence in the room in this film.
Do you customarily cover everything in a master shot...
-I cover nothing.
- Okay.
- I cover nothing.
Never cover.
-So you mean when we see on the screen a long take,
does that mean that that's all you've shot...
-That's all there is.
I was taught that by Jack Ford.
Because when Ford finished a movie,
he never cut it, you know?
He had nothing to do with the editing,
he never went into the moviola,
he never saw a rough cut.
He usually went on a big drunk.
And the way he had of protecting himself was to give them nothing
to go to.
So if he wanted the girl to say...
"Yes, Duke," that was all she got to say.
She didn't get to listen to all the rest of the scene or say the
dialogue that he expected her not to say...
that's all he shot.
And he told me to do it, and I followed his instructions.
-With respect to the opening long take,
how did you determine exactly when you chose to cut
away from it?
-When to cut away?
-It's midway through the scene where you begin to break it up
into individual shots.
What determined the change in the handling of the scene?
-I can't remember.
I just... all I have is a dumb answer.
I really can't remember.
-Because I believe it occurs right in the middle
of a section.
There's no special reason why the long take necessarily ends
at that point...
-Maybe there's a mistake there of some kind.
You know, I don't know.
It seemed to me that we cut only when we went into the other room
with a...
with a woman.
That was the intention...
No, I don't know. I really don't know when we cut.
-Short ends of film, maybe.
-May have been that, short end of the film.
Yes?
-As long as we're still talking about the long takes,
I was wondering if that tendency in the films is more out of your
roots in the theater and presenting something in real
time, or was it more for an expressionist reason?
-No, a long take, for me, depends on two things...
a very good technical crew,
and there are less of them everyday in the world,
all over the world, because of television,
and very good actors.
I did the first reel length takes that were ever made,
and they ended up not that because they cut
into them, but they were reel length,
and in 'Macbeth' they are reel length,
full reel in length.
I believe that it is an enormous help to a cast,
if they are good enough, to play the rhythm of an entire sequence
rather than leaving it to the director entirely
'cause the director has, I always suspect, a little bit too
much power in moviemaking.
In film studies, the actor is underrated.
The story and the director gets a little more
credit than is deserved...
'cause actors keep showing us things we never suspected.
Any good director is constantly astonished by something that his
cast is giving him, you know?
Yes?
-Maybe I'm an incurable optimist,
but I got a lot of hope out of the picture,
partly out of the character's integrity, and
that he was kind of a hero in his integrity and things,
and that he wouldn't stand for things.
Did you mean for a lot of hope to come out of that...
-I am a kind of optimist that believes in integrity and
in all these virtues which
illuminate Western Civilization,
and which are only, I hope, temporarily out of fashion.
I don't believe that the...
physical outlook of mankind
changes virtue.
It only obliges us to behave better.
Oh, that's awfully solemn...
-Could we do this first here and then go back?
-Look at her, she's way down there.
Maybe we could pass the mic...
How about trying to shout it and I'll repeat it.
-As I was noticing the continuity between 'The Trial'
and a lot of your films dating back to 'Citizen Kane, '
as your view seems to be opposed to some of the best interests of
the corporate elite, of which you speak directly about
in 'The Trial, ' and I was wondering if you thought your
personal financial position as a film director is directly
related to the fact that a lot of your views in your films
throughout these ages have not exactly expressed
their interests.
-Would anybody like to answer that question?
-Well, my personal opinion...
-Good, stand up! Let's hear it.
-My personal opinion is that it's true, and
that from what I've read from your career,
although I wasn't alive at the time you first were making
films, that...
That you've had a tremendous problem with the oppression of
corporate bureaucracy dating back since the earliest portions
of your career, and that this is continuing today,
and that's one of the reasons why you've been unable to finish
some of your more recent projects.
-Wow, the only...
-there are only two main projects
which are unfinished.
One is 'The Other Side of the Wind, '
and when I tell you that my partner in that project is the
brother-in-law of the late Shah of Iran you will understand why
we were having a little legal difficulty.
The other unfinished film is 'Don Quixote' which was a
private exercise of mine, and it will be finished as an author
will finish it: in my own good time,
when I feel like it.
It is not unfinished because of financial reasons,
and when it is released its title is going to be
'When Are You Going to Finish "Don Quixote.'
-I appreciate so very much your use of depth of field especially
in this film.
My question is why do you think that it's being dropped in
filmmaking today?
-You never get the same depth of field in color as you do in
black and white, and...
secondly, a lot of the depth of field in 'Kane' was fake.
It was split-screen.
We made up... we said we'd invented a new lens,
and that was just publicity.
Not truth in it at all. What was it called, Dick?
We had some great word for it.
I've forgotten. And it was a fake.
Whenever the shot became impossible we did
the old split-screen.
-Are you using that process...
-That's it, that's it. That's the one.
-Are you using that process in the films
that you're working on now?
-I expect to use it in... I'm about to make two movies.
And one will have no depth of field whatever...
'cause it's a very romantic story, and depth of field is the
enemy of romance.
It is.
And the other is a modern story about an
American political candidate, and it will have as much depth
of field as we can get.
Somebody that hasn't...
Who's nearest the mic, or...
Doesn't seem a fair way to go about it, but...
Anybody looks for justice in this world...
Yes, got somebody? Yes?
-Your statement, that this film is a dream as you express it
seems to say that the conflict within the film is within the
main character's mind.
Would you care to define the conflict within his mind?
-You know, you're all above my head.
Do you mean...
-Well, if this film's a dream,
obviously it'd be the main character's dream if you say...
-No, it's my dream.
-Okay, well, if it's your dream then the
conflict is within your mind.
What is the mental conflict in the film?
It's not just this one man against society...?
-Yes, I dreamt about him.
-Okay.
-I dreamt about him.
And it's not a conflict with society;
it's a failure to flourish...
and...
flower in society.
He's not really in conflict with society.
The man is basically a conformist.
He's not in conflict with society,
but you see that society is killing him even though he's
not fighting it.
He doesn't put up much of a fight.
Yes, in the back, way in the back.
Blue shirt.
Wait for the mic.
He fights as each issue comes along,
but you don't see a man in a real...
aggressive position against society...
-On that response,
I'm wondering then if you say that he's not
really in conflict with his society whether that makes him...
If you say that he's not in conflict with his society...
-Society's in conflict with him.
-Okay, would that make him an autobiographical character
for you?
-No, I never got societies in conflict with me...
-At least in terms of your filmmaking career?
-No, no.
-I mean, you...
-Anybody who goes into films has to be a little crazy,
and has to be ready for every kind of...
disappointment and defeat, and must be grateful for any kind of
evening such as this that he can get out of it.
It's mathematically almost an impossible medium to succeed in
on any sort of important level.
And to have achieved...
enough interest for you to have come into this room is...
the answer to conflict with society.
I'm in no conflicts with society.
I'm in conflict with the Reagan administration.
And that sure as hell isn't society.
Yes, ma'am?
Or sir, or what?
Who's got a microphone near him?
Who's near a microphone?
There.
Yeah.
-I was wondering why in the prologue to the film...
-Repeat, please.
-I was wondering why in the prologue to the film you chose
to use the pinscreen technique when there really wasn't that
much actual animation...
instead of just using charcoal paintings or something.
-Oh, this is the attempt...
this is the attempt to destroy him,
to destroy his faith, to destroy his character.
That fairy story is part of the plot against him.
We are all told fairy stories.
Some of those fairy stories are in TV commercials,
some of them are in presidential addresses,
some of them are in editorials, some of them are in sky writing,
and that prologue... which, by the way,
was made by a couple of wonderful mad Russians living in
Paris, and they make their pictures by putting pins into
blocks of wood...
little needles, and the needles are at different degrees of
depth so that when a light falls on it you get the
light and shadow from the pins, or the needles.
That's what those extraordinary pictures come from,
and I thought they gave a...
In other words, that was the marriage to the Brothers Grimm.
And we repeat the story when I attempt again to corrupt him.
I'm his chief corruptor, I'm the Devil.
-If the fable is a lie, and what Hastler says are also lies,
why do you tell the story at the beginning of the movie in
character as yourself?
-Because...
the film is contaained...
The life of this man is contained within a lie.
We do not have the kind of novel in which a character
leaves a real or benign world
and enters a world of nightmare.
He was born into it, conceived in the womb of horror.
That's why I begin with it.
In other words he can't escape because that's where
he was born anymore than a baby in Bangladesh can escape
dying of starvation.
-I don't know if this is a meaningful point,
but when you are speaking at the beginning of the picture,
you are not in character as Hastler.
You are playing the voice of Orson Welles as you are playing
at the end of the pic...
-Now, that's the magician.
I'm tricking the audience into believing that that's a point of
view so that in a certain atmosphere... because that kind
of trickery is legitimate, I think... I want the audience to
feel the doom
into which K. is born
and to believe that it is there.
It's the voice of the Devil...
but it's not my voice.
It's not my dream.
Yes?
-You've made continuous references to Spain when you
talked about bravery, when you talked about 'Don Quixote, '
when you talked about your project as talking of Spain.
I think I once read that you wanted to become a bull fighter.
-I didn't want to, I was one.
Hard to believe.
I did it by buying the bulls.
-What I want to know is what does Spain culturally represent
for you?
-A great deal.
Anybody of my generation, Spain means enormous things
you cannot possibly appreciate because...
the Spanish Civil War was the central...
tragedy of anybody's life who is my age.
And it's hard to explain to anybody who's younger,
but there it is.
And it's part of the subject of the political movie I'm...
contemporary political movie... I want to make which is called
'The Big Brass Ring.'
Sir?
-Are you just as politically engaged and politically minded
now as you were in the '30s and '40s?
'Cause at the time you wrote a lot about politics.
-Yes.
I'm not as politically engaged for two reasons.
I'm as politically-minded.
I'm more interested in politics than in anything in the world...
much more interested in politics than I am in movies,
or art, or anything.
The truth is that every work of art is a political statement.
When you deliberately make it, you...
This audience is gonna get dizzy.
When you deliberately make it you usually fall into
the trap of rhetoric, and...
the trap of speaking to a convinced audience rather than
convincing an audience.
I don't believe... I think some movies,
and some books and, God, some paintings...
have changed the face of the world.
But I don't think it is the duty of every artist to change the
face of the world.
He is doing it by being an artist.
That just automatically goes with it.
And he may be doing harm when he doesn't mean to.
But oh, God, deliver us from the people who tell us what is right
and what is wrong, what is moral and what is immoral from a
political point of view.
It's just as inexcusable as from a sexual point of view,
seems to me.
Of course we hate the real vices of the world.
Of course we hate racism, and we hate oppression,
all of that kind of... that goes without saying.
If...
you didn't agree with that you wouldn't be here,
you wouldn't have sat through 'The Trial, '
we wouldn't be getting along well together.
I'm talking about that majority of people who
can read a book and talk about something, who are
in general agreement about...
what you have to call the basics...
rather than dogmas.
Yeah?
-I was wondering what scene in 'The Trial' that you felt...
- Repeat, please.
- What did you say?
-Repeat.
-That's so cruel.
It's just like a scene in 'The Trial.'
-"Repeat!" you know?
-Again?
In reviewing your prints now years later,
I wondered if you could give us some hint as to what you thought
you would change in 'The Trial.'
What scene do you feel the worst about,
that makes you cringe the most, and how you would change that to
make it a better scene?
-I would be able to answer that question
if I had ever seen 'The Trial' since I made it.
But I never see my movies after I make them.
-You don't have any regrets about
'The Trial' at all, as if...?
-That's why I don't go to see it.
Be one long regret, you know?
There it is in a can forever.
I can't see where our microphone is,
so I don't know who has the best fighting chance.
- Over here!
- Over there.
-Climb out the chair.
-I remember your eulogy to Jean Renoir a couple years ago in the
Los Angeles Times, and I was wondering if you'd share with us
your feelings on the passing of Abel Gance a couple days ago.
-I'm so sorry, I can't...
-Your eulogy of Jean Renoir,
and would you comment on the passing of Abel Gance.
- Of Abel Gance?
- Yes.
-It's a very painful, very painful question for me because
I have enormous respect for his inventiveness and his
originality, but he is not
in my top list of directors,
and the fact that he died does not change that.
Sorry.
I made his last picture with him,
and my opinion is not from that picture,
it's based on 'Napoleon.'
He was a man obsessed, he had a magnificent obsession,
he had an enormous visual sense,
he contributed incredibly to our
vocabulary in the cinema.
But I am much more interested in...
movies about people.
And I don't think he made one.
Napoleon is a big subject, and it can be dealt with with a cast
of 20 people.
Sir?
-'Scuse me.
Where is this person?
-Cast appalled in waiting, I know.
-Thought there was someone up here.
-An actor friend of mine once told me that he thought one of
the great moments of film was in 'The Third Man' when the
light falls on you and you're revealed looking at...
-Oh, it is one of the great moments!
But remember, I didn't direct it.
Carol Reed directed it.
And do you know that we went... do you know that every... we had
that set built on another stage.
And every afternoon for five days, at the end of the
day's shooting we went and shot
it again until Carol had it exactly the way he wanted it
because he knew it was the key moment of the movie.
-My question to you is, when you are casting,
what do you look for in actors?
What do you all sort of expect actors to bring to you on set?
-I think that, you see...
What do I look for in actors?
And I think acting...
is like sculpture.
Not modeling; the kind where you carve it out of marble.
I think that a performance,
when it deserves to be considered great or important
is always entirely made up of the actor himself
and entirely achieved by
what he has left in the dressing room
before he came out in front of the camera.
In other words it's what you take away from yourself
to reveal the truth of what you're doing
that makes a performance.
And if an actor doesn't have an ability to do that,
I use him only if he has a good face for a few lines.
I think I can tell those actors from others.
I've made disastrous mistakes,
but I think, essentially...
there is no such thing as becoming another
character by putting on a lot of makeup.
You may need to put the makeup, but what you're really doing is
undressing yourself, and even tearing yourself apart,
and presenting to the public that part of you which
corresponds to what you are playing.
And there is a villain in each of us,
a murderer in each of us, a fascist in each of us,
a saint in each of us.
And the actor is the man or woman who can
eliminate from himself those things which will interfere with
that truth.
So I look for those kind of people,
and I look for the right face because,
after all, the camera...
makes pictures, and it likes people and dislikes
people, and you have to try to guess which ones
it will like and which it won't.
Yes, sir?
-Did you have any particular reason for updating 'The Trial'
into the 1960s?
When you made the movie, you made it as a present...
-Yes, I tried to do a
rather tricky thing.
I tried to make a picture which really existed in its own time
but which didn't abuse the eye of the audience and...
not abuse, alienate the audience by becoming a costume picture.
But I made it as though it were happening in its time, and
the people were accidentally dressed in our own time.
That was the intention.
Whether it was successful or not is for you to tell me.
Sir?
-When working on a project like 'The Trial' and some of your
other films where you have written and directed,
does Orson Welles the director ever get in the way of
Orson Welles the writer, or how closely does one follow
the other?
-I think of it as a happy marriage.
No, seriously, no, I don't think so.
I rewrite when I have an original script, and
in Shakespeare somebody didn't write it.
I am rewriting all the time on the set,
and the director never gives me any trouble at all.
I think because I feel a sense of obligation to the script...
which is rather more acute because it's my own.
-Do you find one more difficult than the
other to do? Writing or directing?
-Well, everybody finds writing the hardest thing in the world
to do, you know?
Hemingway used to describe to me how marvelous it was to have
spent a morning when it was all true,
and it was all coming right, and it was all like the greatest
lovemaking in the world.
It was like a true moment in the arena, and all of this.
And about a week later, we were forced by our wives to go to the
ballet, and I shared with Ernest...
and I was his friend so long ago
that I called him Ernest.
He wasn't even Papa when I first knew him.
I shared with him an intense dislike of the ballet.
I only like great ballet dancers at great moments.
The rest of the time, nod, you see?
And we were sitting there,
and I felt him moving around like this, you know?
And he suddenly said to me, "Christ, I'd rather be writing."
That's it.
Goodnight, and thank you very much everybody.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.