Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
[applause]
[music]
[music]
[music]
[applause]
>> Passengers of the Titanic
actually didn't want to leave the ship
for almost 2 hours
after it hit the iceberg.
People thought that Titanic was
unsinkable.
Lifeboats left half empty.
Only the last half an hour people
started to panic.
But by that time it was already too
late.
Not enough lifeboats.
Nowhere to hide.
Nowhere to run.
I came here today to tell you that we
find ourselves in a similar predicament,
in a similar situation.
Our ship has already hit the iceberg.
We have already started
to sink
without even realizing it.
And I'm talking about the ship of our
personal freedoms.
Personal freedoms have been eroded
everywhere in the world almost without
exception.
I know this from personal experience.
I've been running large social media
platforms for almost 20 years. Actually,
exactly 20 years.
And I witnessed firsthand
which methods governments use to
suppress our freedoms and to take away
our basic rights.
I've seen all the tricks.
The PR tricks, the legal tricks, the
political tricks.
The manipulations, the official excuses.
I've became an expert at this.
And the thing that bothers me most today
is that some of the same tricks that
have been employed
by authoritarian regimes in places like
Russia or China and Iran
are now being also used
in some Western countries.
But maybe I'm exaggerating things,
right? Let's look at the facts.
Thousands of people are getting arrested
every year in the United Kingdom
for social media posts.
You say something politically incorrect
online, you may end up being fined or
spend some time in prison. In Germany,
large the largest country in the
European Union,
people get arrested and persecuted for
insulting politicians online, thousands
of people every year. You call a
politician a bigot or a thief online and
you can serve up to 3 years in prison.
So, now people are afraid to use their
real identities. People stop using their
real names
when they make comments online.
And the European Commission is pushing
for a new measure.
A measure to require that all social
media users
present their IDs
before they can access social media
sites.
Their official justification is child
protection.
They want to ban social media services
for everybody under 16. And for that,
they need people to verify their age
by presenting their ID.
But what will happen if social media
sites are banned for teenagers?
Will it bring harm or good?
Actually, we know the answer to this
question.
Why? Because it has already been tried.
This experiment has already been
conducted. It's It's has been carried
on.
In Russia.
So, Russia banned Telegram, the largest
social media platform at the time,
for all of its citizens
because we refused to comply with their
demands for mass surveillance and
censorship.
However, 95% of Russian teenagers still
use Telegram every month.
How? They use VPNs. They bypass the
entire thing.
And there's very little you can do with
VPNs. Russia is trying very hard. They
have invested billions in trying to
fight VPNs. They're banning hundreds of
VPNs every month
using
IP addresses and traffic patterns. They
even installed surveillance hardware
into every data center of every internet
provider in the country
trying to monitor all the traffic and
trying to prevent people from using
VPNs. And they failed. Despite all this
effort, they failed.
The majority of the population of Russia
still uses Telegram. The majority of the
population of Iran still uses Telegram
as well. Despite the fact that Iran has
been blocking Telegram for all of its
citizens since 2018.
So, we know exactly what happens when
you ban social media for part of your
population. They just switch to VPN.
The problem is once we force teenagers
and children to use VPNs all kind of
nasty, illegal, fringe content
gets unlocked for them.
Certain websites that have been banned
years ago
all of a sudden become available again.
So, the children end up being in a
larger danger
than they're in now.
And you can ask yourself, so if this
policy is destined to fail, you know,
obviously
we see how it played out in other
countries.
Why is the European Commission and the
United Kingdom and Australia and Canada
and some other countries are pushing for
this measure?
Is it incompetence?
Maybe.
But the British government seems to have
given an answer to this question.
Publicly, they promoted the Online
Safety Act as a set of laws to protect
children.
To force
people to verify their age
in order to access social media. They
needed to protect children.
Privately, though, they offered a
different explanation.
In their submission to the High Court of
England published last year, the British
government said that the principal part
of the Online Safety Act had nothing to
do with protecting children. Instead,
they said, and I quote,
the main part of the Online Safety Act
was aimed at capturing large platforms
with significant influence over public
discourse.
Now, let's think about it.
They used protection of children as a
pretext, where in fact in fact, they
wanted
more control over political speech
online.
And this is very sad
because
protecting children is exactly the same
justification that has been used in
countless other cases by authoritarian
regimes
over the course of the last century.
Why? Because once somebody says child
protection, all of a sudden,
it triggers
very ancient, very deep parts of our
brain.
Who would be against protecting
children?
Everybody is scared for the future of
their offspring.
Once somebody says we need to protect
the children, they're in danger,
it completely bypasses logic. It
bypasses debate. It bypasses
rationality.
All of a sudden, are ready to give up
everything.
And authoritarian regimes were able to
smuggle all kinds of repressive
legislation
under the guise of protecting children.
Now, the same justification is being
used by the European Commission
to push for a set of surveillance laws,
the so-called chat control,
the chat control initiative.
For 5 years, the European Commission has
been trying to
force
a new set of laws that would require
every messaging app to implement a
backdoor to their encryption.
So that everything that we share online,
every private message,
every private photo
that we sent
using apps like Telegram or WhatsApp or
any other
would be automatically monitored.
And if the system detects that we are
trying to do something illegal, it
alerts
the authorities.
The justification here, again, is
child protection.
And this has been tried on the European
level and also on the national level.
The French government has been trying to
pass a similar law
that would basically mandate mass
surveillance
on the national level.
The French Senate
has approved this law.
It got stuck on the level of National
Assembly, but the French Senate thought
it was a reasonable
and a good idea to enact
mass surveillance.
So, this shows how dangerous it is and
how close we are
even here
in Europe
to the to
a state where we end up
being monitored.
Now, the French used slightly
different justification. They said, "We
need
to combat crime. We need to do something
about terrorism.
We need to do something about drug
trafficking.
And that's why we need to spy on you.
For your own protection, you have to
give up your essential right to
privacy."
And this again has been tried countless
times
in the history of humanity, where we
or different nations
throughout history have been offered an
exchange.
Give up some of your essential liberty
in exchange for some temporary safety.
And this deal, this offer is always a
scam, and it always turned out to be a
scam.
>> [applause]
>> It was Benjamin Franklin who said,
"Those who are willing to give up
their essential liberty for some
temporary safety deserve neither liberty
nor safety."
>> [applause]
>> And we see that.
We see that in countries faces. Ask
people living in Russia
or living in Iran whether they feel
safer today
than they felt 10-15 years ago.
They definitely lost a lot of their
freedoms in the last decade or two.
Have they gained any safety?
I doubt that.
Once you allow
law enforcement, police have access to
your messages,
you will not prevent crime.
The criminals will be the first to
switch on to other tools,
more secure. They will use VPNs. They
will use private secret apps.
They can even wipe code their own
encrypted messaging app now in the age
of AI.
The criminals will be fine.
It will be the law-abiding citizens who
will be put in danger.
It will be the ordinary people that will
have their privacy taken away from them.
Not the criminals.
Well, how do I know that? Maybe I'm
inventing things.
Again, from my experience in Russia 15
years ago when I was still running VK,
the largest social network in Russia at
the time,
we started to receive weird
data requests from from the Russian
police.
You know, back then VK actually
disclosed in some cases contents of
private messages, unlike Telegram today
which doesn't disclose it ever.
VK back in the day did that, provided
there was an official justification.
And we started to notice something
weird.
Something was off about this data
request coming from the Russian police.
We realized
that the people who were included in
these investigations
had nothing to do with with the crimes
that were described there.
So, we started to investigate the
investigators.
And we came to a conclusion to a
conclusion pretty fast
that the police was corrupt.
They went were trying to access private
messages of innocent people in order
to then blackmail them
and sell their private data to
criminals.
They used it for harassment
and other things.
So, you could say, "Okay,
you had this
um
traumatizing experience in Russia, but
surely nothing of the kind can happen in
the civilized West."
Well, I have bad news for you.
Last year, a French tax official was
caught stealing the financial data
of people
who held large amount of crypto assets
and other wealth.
So, a French tax bureaucrat was selling
personal financial data of French
citizens
to criminals.
Now, as a result of this leak and
countless other leaks from French
government systems,
you have a catastrophic rise in the
number of kidnappings in France.
Just in the first 3 months of 2026, you
have over 40 victims of kidnappings in
France. People getting tortured,
harmed, [snorts]
harassed, humiliated,
all because the government wanted too
much data and failed to protect it.
And now they want more of the data.
The situation is already catastrophic as
it is,
but they don't want to stop there.
They also want to access your personal
messages. They want to access IDs of
everybody who's using social media.
Imagine the damage
it can inflict
if they get what they want.
Now, this is already completely insane
and unbelievable.
But there's a third method, a third
issue,
>> [snorts]
>> a trick that has been used by
authoritarians for decades.
And now it is being increasingly
exported from the East to the West.
I'm talking about selective enforcement
of laws. Now, the way it works is pretty
straightforward.
First,
you need to introduce
a large number of laws.
You need to overburden a certain certain
industry
with
excessive
mutually exclusive contradictory
regulation.
As a result,
you make compliance impossible.
Now you can treat every
entrepreneur, every CEO, every uh
business owner
in this country, in a certain industry,
as a criminal.
But then the government carefully starts
to choose who to persecute.
If the business owner is loyal,
if it complies with immoral,
unlawful demands from the government,
gives certain political favors,
then the law enforcement system and the
judicial system look the other way.
They don't do anything.
But, if the business owner
decides to stand up
for the constitutional rights
of his or her fellow citizens,
if they
refuse to cave in
to political
demands from the authoritarian
government, then
the persecution and the enforcement of
laws comes in full.
And once somebody starts to criticize
the government for doing that,
the
eternal, perennial response is, "We're
just
enforcing the law.
You don't want to live in a country
which is lawless.
We're just enforcing the laws."
I personally experienced that
in my days in Russia.
I had a criminal investigation against
me.
In 2013, I believe I have a criminal
investigation against me in Russia
today.
But, interestingly,
this is something that we see
increasingly in the West as well. And
you can say, "There's no way it can
happen.
It's something from the world of the
barbaric East."
Well, I have bad news.
Elon Musk said that the European
Commission offered him a secret deal
where they demanded that he
conducts
censorship
of certain political narratives on his
platform. And in exchange, the European
Commission promised him not to enforce
certain fines and laws on his company.
Elon Musk said that he refused that
offer.
But, most other platforms accepted it.
Then Elon's company was hit by a
120
million euro fine
from the European Commission
for seemingly unrelated issues,
something that has to deal with
transparency.
Now, we can doubt the words of Elon
Musk. Maybe he was inventing things,
right?
But unfortunately
his words are at least
indirectly confirmed by the results of
the investigation conducted by the US
Congress.
The US Congress published emails between
the European Commission officials and
managers of
large social media platforms during the
pandemic.
These emails included
attempts to pressure
all these networks
to silence political narratives and
accounts
that were inconvenient
for the European Commission at that
time.
So,
you had Facebook, Instagram, TikTok,
YouTube, and others
ban, censor,
down rank,
shadow ban,
demote
accounts and narratives
that spread inconvenient truths or
inconvenient narratives. The official
justification for that
was that the European Commission was
trying to combat misinformation and
conspiracy theories
during the pandemic.
Well, now years after it seems that
many of those so-called conspiracy
theories turned out to be at least
partially true, and in any case were
worthy of a public debate.
Now, everything from the artificial
origins of COVID
to the limited nature of the anti-COVID
measures
to the immense harm done to the young
generation by school closures
all of it once considered
conspiracy theories is now becoming part
of the mainstream
debate and the mainstream view of what
happened during COVID.
So, those narratives were silenced
not because they were untrue.
They were silenced because they were
inconvenient
by those people in power.
And if this is not
political censorship I don't know what
is.
Now, I myself
has been personally
exposed to selective enforcement of laws
also in Europe
not just in Russia.
And I talked about it last year on this
stage
uh
after I was arrested in Paris for
reasons that are still unclear in 2024.
I got offered a secret deal by the head
of the French intelligence
who asked me to silence certain
political voices.
Well, I refused that deal and I'm still
under this investigation and still
facing many years in prison.
But
I don't want to talk about this today.
I want to
conclude
by telling you a related story.
Something that happened during these
days when I
uh
was detained in Paris and I was uh
spending a few days in this uh police
custody, basically a jail cell.
I was interrogated for
almost 3 days
and there was this translator that was
helping us. He was appointed by the
judge.
And after 3 days of translating
during one of this uh
pauses between sessions
the translator was sitting there
seemingly shocked.
Perhaps she was shocked by the selective
and political nature of the charges
brought against me.
But she looked at me, she looked at the
police officers present and she said
"I left the Soviet Union in the '80s
because I wanted to escape an
environment
where my freedoms are limited. I wanted
to escape an environment
where human rights are disrespected.
But now, after witnessing what I've
witnessed
I feel like the Soviet Union
is catching up with me. I feel like I'm
back in the Soviet Union."
In that room in Paris
that woman who escaped
the Soviet Union
felt
she's back in the Soviet Union. And of
course, perhaps she was being over
dramatic. Perhaps she was exaggerating
things. But if we let the current trends
continue
we can end up in a place much worse than
the Soviet Union of the '80s.
You know, when my parents sent each
other letters
or sent telegrams to their relatives in
the Soviet Union of late ages.
Sometimes they expressed hope that the
KGB would not open the letters.
That the KGB would not have enough
resources to read everything that
they have to write.
After all, there was a human limit to
surveillance.
There were only so many KGB officers,
only so many hours in a work day.
Only so many letters they could open.
Now, we don't have this luxury.
In the world of AI, if we give up our
right to privacy,
you can be certain that every message
that you send will be monitored, will be
analyzed.
Every draft, every thought, every idea
will be scored.
Every relationship will be mapped.
The future can become much darker and
more dystopian
than the Soviet Union of the '80s.
So, we don't have this luxury
that the passengers of the Titanic had.
We cannot afford
to have this ship sunk.
See, there is nowhere to escape.
In the past, dissidents from
authoritarian countries
could flee to the West.
But if the current trajectory continues,
in a decade or two from now, they will
have hard time
trying to understand whether they have
already left their repressive homeland
or they're just entering another
open-air prison.
Now,
I hope it will not come to that.
But, we need to realize the gravity of
the situation. We need to start acting.
We don't have a backup plan.
We don't have lifeboats.
There is no second West. There's no
backup civilization.
For decades or centuries, the West has
been
a guiding star for everybody who loved
freedom, and we need to preserve that.
If the ship of Western freedom sinks,
the rest of the world
is likely to follow.
We will lose freedoms everywhere.
So, we cannot let this happen.
We cannot let this ship sink.
The only way forward
is to fix this ship.
Let's do that.
Thank you very much.
>> [applause]
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.