Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
Are you going out?
You too?
Are you going to Strasbourg?
On a Tuesday?
We have to talk to the kids.
They know.
But we’re saying nothing so they’re in an impossible position.
Emmanuel didn’t even call at Christmas.
Liza is scowling all the time.
She didn’t smile all week at my parents’.
As for Adam...
- Did your parents say anything? - Who cares?
No, they didn’t, but that’s not what I’m talking about.
I’m talking about your children.
About Adam, who’s bottling it up every day.
He wakes in the night, screaming. He’s 11!
We have to fix it.
What’s the matter?
Has something happened? Talk to me!
Is it us?
I haven’t closed the door, you know?
Just because I don’t want to see Esther again.
I need some time, do you understand?
We have to talk honestly to the children about our problems.
You’re right.
We’ll do it.
When I get back we’ll think about it together.
See you tomorrow?
IN THERAPY
ESTHER - TUESDAY, JANUARY 5, 2016, 9 A.M.
Thanks for seeing me.
No problem. What happened is horrible.
It’s a heavy sky today.
There’s not much light here.
Sit down.
Charlotte phoned to tell me she doesn’t want to continue.
I’m sorry about that but I respect her decision.
She thinks we’re getting lost in a labyrinth.
I think she wants to make her decisions by herself.
That’s what I understood.
She has her head screwed on right.
I wish I were a novelist or playwright.
What do you mean?
A little puppet theater.
Where the artist maps out the characters’ destinies,
makes them do the right thing at the right moment,
decides who sleeps with whom, who lives, who dies,
when the big revelation has the most impact,
and when a cooling off is most appropriate.
But no, we’re not demiurges.
Or even a bad novelist.
Disappointing his readers, who want blood and woe,
by choosing the outcome that makes his character happy.
There!
I’d like to create mediocre and boring works,
in which all the characters find the happiness and calm they deserve.
I’m sorry, Philippe,
sincerely sorry about what happened to your patient.
Those who helped him go are sorry.
His brothers-in-arms in the police are distraught.
His hierarchy, all the way up to the ministry.
His father is totally devastated.
He didn’t deserve that end.
Yes, everyone is sorry.
Institutions have no feelings.
Nor do hierarchies.
And the individuals caught up in those structures...
I don’t like them salving their conscience
by expressing their sorrow.
Do you mean you consider me like an institution?
A hierarchy?
What do you think?
Do you really feel anything?
Philippe, I share your grief.
It’s tragic.
You don’t think I’m sincere,
you think I’m holding you responsible for his death.
Do you feel guilty?
Adel’s death is an absolute tragedy
towards which every event ineluctably drove him.
He tried, with amazing courage,
to escape the death wish inherited from his family history,
and his father’s guilt.
Adel deployed so much energy building the path of his life.
Under his armor, patiently constructed to hold up a shaky edifice,
was such sensitivity, such finesse, such fragility.
He’d lost before he started. Nothing he could do.
It was all determined
by what his beginnings had inscribed in him.
Everything he did helped to bring about a destiny that wasn’t his own.
All that energy, just to, in the end...
You haven’t talked about him like that before.
Am I idealizing him?
It’s possible.
Or the tragedy is letting me see in him what I refused to see before.
So why do you feel responsible?
You just said he was doomed.
I should have worked out how to protect him,
how to stop him following his tragic logic to the end.
If I can see that someone can’t ensure his own safety,
if I’m aware of that,
if I have a strong suspicion...
isn’t it my duty to stop him hurting himself?
I should have stopped him going.
I didn’t.
I didn’t because I had a doubt.
I wasn’t sure any more.
That moment of doubt makes me responsible.
On the contrary.
Taking up a position like that is very risky.
After his death, I got to see a report from the intelligence services.
Fabien, Adel’s friend, gave it to me.
He’d got it from Vincent, his colleague in the police.
It’s touching, how they’ve passed it around.
Chibane is the only thing we all have in common.
I wonder if we form a sort of chain of guilt.
The second day he was out there in the field,
I think,
Adel was with a small group doing reconnaissance.
They were going through a village
when they were attacked.
Apparently he didn’t fall back with the others.
He joined the poorly armed villagers who were taking on the jihadis.
He fell among those peasants,
who were trying to drive off a bunch of killers.
In a way he was a hero.
It’s awful and heroic at the same time.
But it wouldn’t have happened
if I hadn’t revealed that destiny to him.
If I hadn’t connected him to that end
which he’d managed to keep out of his line of sight.
His father’s quite right.
My responsibility is overwhelming.
I should never have disturbed his subconscious defenses.
You’ve seen his father?
At the funeral.
Then he came to my place yesterday.
I called you after he’d gone.
I was really upset.
The man is a monster of guilt, both allotting it and feeling it.
He’s doing what he can.
He brought his son up in ignorance for a reason.
He pushed him towards the future.
He kept him from turning to his roots,
his culture, and all that bullshit.
He knew he wasn’t tough enough to face it.
The past is toxic. His logic holds water.
You’re saying the best way to live is in ignorance?
Where’s freedom of choice if we don’t know what’s shaped us?
You mean I was right to awaken the demons of his past,
for the sake of his right to know? Okay.
But why couldn’t I set him straight?
What happened, at that moment, is insane when I think back on it.
Believe it or not, but for just a moment I thought that he was right.
That maybe I did need guys like him,
to sacrifice themselves and ensure my safety.
Because if that war comes here,
I’m not prepared.
Maybe I am ready to pay to be protected.
Maybe there are people like Chibane whose problems suit them to that job.
Warriors, tragic heroes.
As opposed to us neurotics.
After all, there isn’t just Madame Bovary or Proust.
There’s also The Iliad, Antigone...
and Die Hard.
You said it yourself. Adel Chibane was not a puppet.
Even less was he your puppet.
None of your patients is.
And your relationship is only a tiny part of their lives,
of what guides their actions.
You don’t have control over your patients’ fates.
Yes, it was his fate, his freedom, a succession of circumstances...
Heaven forbid it was anyone’s responsibility!
But in all those factors there was me and him.
And you and me too.
Why are you trying to fudge the question of my responsibility?
I’m not denying the effects of analysis.
Our collective irresponsibility makes me angry.
Our splendid intellectual superiority,
which lifts us high above the mire of material causality.
We shrinks!
I’m angry with Freud,
that bourgeois, conservative Viennese Jew.
I’m angry with Lacan,
that bourgeois Parisian Catholic, and just as conservative.
And with us, theorizing our detachment from worldly affairs,
staying out of the game, neutral, uninvolved, apolitical...
No, worse. Politically pessimistic!
Put the theoretical debate to one side for a moment.
Do you think analysis is a way of escaping from reality?
I’m in a bad way, Esther.
I’m barely sleeping.
I wake in the middle of the night, crippled with anxiety.
I lie there wide awake till dawn.
I can’t talk to my wife.
When I face her,
it’s like a veil falls over my brain, paralyzing me.
I couldn’t even talk to her about Chibane’s death.
So, as for our relationship and our children’s wellbeing...
The oldest has gone for good.
And my daughter is trying to forge her identity
in a violent – even criminal – gang.
As for the little one...
he cries out at night in his sleep.
Are you okay?
Yeah, I’m okay.
I’ll get you a glass of water.
Philippe! I’ll call for an ambulance!
It’s all right. I’m okay like this.
You scared me.
Here, drink some water.
How do you feel?
Okay.
I’ll just rest here a couple of seconds.
I think I’ll go home.
I heard what you said earlier.
- The sky is overcast. - So?
We can’t see the stars or the constellations.
We have no points of reference.
I do know you, despite our disagreements.
Do you know what sailors say in such cases?
I know because, before Gaëtan,
I had a lover who was a navy doctor.
He had a beautiful and very sexy blue uniform.
He taught me this, among other things.
I’m listening.
I think I know where you’re going with this.
About sailing.
When our senses are blind, we must trust our instruments.
Only our instruments.
They’re less infallible than us.
Our instruments.
Sextants, compasses, screens, radars...
That’s you all over.
Theory, the mechanism...
There you are, behind your theoretical dashboard.
With so many instruments you can’t see the sky.
Maybe the mistake is to stop trusting your instinct.
With all your tools you’ve forgotten how to look at the sky.
You no longer know how to sniff the wind,
how to use your body as a measuring instrument.
What do I care that your objective truth
aligns itself with microphysics or the brain’s chemistry?
Shall I tell you what I think, deep down?
The little good I’ve done my patients...
Take the swimmer.
I think I’ve helped her a bit because I got involved,
I gave some of myself.
But that couple...
I executed the correct academic flight plan,
but I’m really not sure I did them any good.
Especially her,
with her mental core that’s so fragile and unreachable.
To hell with instruments!
To hell with masters!
We should chuck them into the current, as Zhuang Zhou said.
Our bodies in the current, that’s the measure of everything.
As Zhuang Zhou said.
Down with Zhuang Zhou!
I know exactly what you’re thinking.
You think all this is because of Ariane,
that I’m questioning all this so I can sleep with my patient.
Another hypothesis. What if I let Chibane go, to get rid of a rival?
That works, huh?
Is that what you think?
Stop evading it, answer me!
Are we back on Ariane, yes or no?
Sorry, Philippe, but it was you who brought her up. Right?
Was it like this when you still had patients?
Like what?
I don’t know.
The decor, the atmosphere.
Pretty much, yes.
- I’ve redecorated a few times, but... - It feels old.
It’s not at all reassuring.
It’s like you, in fact.
Something about it induces stress.
A feeling of being locked up, restrained...
You feel that to break free you’d need lots of courage, faith and energy.
The structure, rules and norms all weigh down!
There are different schools.
And you know that every patient projects their own concerns.
What’s your office like?
It’s snug,
with lots of old engravings, globes, sextants...
proclaiming that I’m striving for reference points
of good taste and beauty.
It tells you what a snob I am,
and how eager I am to be liked.
Isn’t that what you think of me?
I’d never allow myself such violence.
What you call violence,
my violence,
comes from the power of the emotions troubling me.
I’m no longer holding them back, I want to stay mentally alive,
and not betray my desire.
And in such moments, well, sorry,
but one mustn’t give up.
Otherwise something in us dies.
It all dries up,
bit by bit, year after year.
And in the end we get this.
Which proclaims how you’ve given up on your life,
given up on desire, given up on love...
I’ve never understood how you could give up so totally.
While Gaëtan was openly cheating on you,
why didn’t you take the opportunity to escape?
What were you afraid of?
Do you know what Franck said, two weeks before his cancer finished him off?
“Esther is my biggest regret.
“A loss about which I’m inconsolable.”
What do you say to that?
That this is another strategy of mine to justify sleeping with Ariane?
Why do you need my blessing to do that?
That’s a typically shitty shrink’s answer!
Maybe I’ve just lost my faith.
I see all we’ve built up,
and I realize it makes no sense,
like a religion, like an empty rhetorical exercise,
a marketing campaign
that has no more punch than the proverbs of the Dalai Lama,
or...
a sect,
which is constantly becoming more radical and isolated.
Shrinks can neither take up arms nor do themselves in.
All they can do is insult each other.
It doesn’t make them very likeable.
And there you are, the devotee of an abandoned religion,
still hanging on to its rituals,
with your nice little decor,
your utensils, your ceremonial objects,
your incomprehensible prayers...
And like all the devout, you’re obsessive about it.
You’re afraid the world will end
if you change one line of your liturgy.
That’s why you let the most important thing in life get away...
Love.
Shut up! You’re talking nonsense.
It’s mind-boggling how wrong you are about me.
How can you accuse me of being cold and insensitive,
when all my life I’ve struggled with the violence of my emotions?
You’re the one who needs a prison guard!
Can’t you see how fragile I am?
How I need distance?
How my emotions are a horrible boiling magma
ready to explode and destroy everything in its path?
You projected what suits you onto me!
I’m not the cold monster you describe,
a crouching spider.
I’m finding my peace, bit by bit, step by step.
Of course I wanted Franck.
Of course his desire aroused me.
But it wasn’t hard to resist.
And it wasn’t because of rules, ethics or God knows what else.
It was because the man I loved, loved madly,
was Gaëtan, even if he did cheat on me.
Even if he’d lost all sense of proportion.
I could never bring myself to really hold it against him.
From the first day to the last I loved him.
Dumping my pride.
Even when he was fucking his little disciples, and everyone knew.
That’s who I really am.
I met Gaëtan in a period of my life
when I had no limits.
He let me be myself.
That’s not very “girl power”, I don’t care.
I’m a feminist, fuck the contradictions!
After he died, I stood there by his grave,
and I knew that if I were to do it all again...
I’d do it just the same.
He made me understand who I was without him.
Do you think I’m writing a novel in my office?
It obsesses you. Do you think I’m writing your life story
or preparing the prosecution’s closing speech against you?
I’m just trying to be alone.
By myself.
With the help of words. They’re what I’m hanging on to.
You’ll never understand what we had.
Maybe some people are incapable of love.
Can I tell you love doesn’t exist?
That we can’t sacrifice everything for it?
That in your office, like at all times all over the world,
the most absolute, crazy and improbable love can arise?
I can’t tell you that.
But don’t use my life!
Stop talking to me about Franck! It wasn’t Franck I loved, it was Gaëtan!
Don’t mention him to me again, okay?
Give me a break.
Stop dragging me and everyone else into your orbit.
If it’s what you want, I’ll say it.
Go to her.
Pay the price.
It’s exorbitant, but pay it without haggling or complaining.
Do it!
Now go.
Go!
I’m sorry.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.