Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
Hello. Come in.
Charlotte, how nice to see you.
- Thanks for seeing us, Esther. - No problem.
- This is where you see your patients? - Used to.
I no longer see patients, except in exceptional cases.
You must be nice and comfy here.
What are you doing now?
Getting my thoughts in order.
Well, my notes.
Writing a book?
No, not really. I’m...
I’m trying to make notes about what I’ve learned,
and also about new theories. I’m finding stuff out.
Since Gaëtan died, I have almost no passion or desire for anything.
I write.
Well, can we get started?
IN THERAPY
ESTHER – FRIDAY, DECEMBER 18, 2015, 3 P.M.
First I think it’s important to establish the framework.
It’s a very unusual situation for me.
Gaëtan and I often voiced our reservations about couples therapy.
I told you, the idea just popped up. Charlotte suggested it.
I didn’t specifically ask to come here.
That’s how I understood it, which is why I asked you.
- But I’d understand if... - No, I’m fine with the contradiction.
Because it’s you two and it’s me.
There’s theory and there’s the reality of bonds.
We’ve been friends a long time.
I’ll do my best to help you through this difficult time.
Thanks, Esther. I’m touched.
We’ll talk today,
and perhaps meet another two or three times, if necessary.
Then you’ll decide if you want to see someone whose profession it really is,
or keep coming here.
You alone have the solution to keeping your relationship going.
Whatever it might be.
I have no trick, all I can do is facilitate dialogue between you.
So I suggest we get started.
Who wants to jump in?
What I can say is that I’m struggling.
I’m struggling to see how we can carry on after what’s happened.
You know, Charlotte’s little escapade.
I realize that that word
may sound a little condescending, but...
I heard what Charlotte told me when she got home.
Feeling that she’d made a mistake on her first night in Rome.
I know she’s honest about that, and I think it’s brave of her...
to have suggested speaking to a third person.
I can also appreciate my share of the responsibility,
but I know that the only solution
is for us to forgive each other for past negligence.
Otherwise we can’t move on.
But, to be honest,
there’s something in me that refuses to forgive her.
I’m angry with her.
Have you talked?
The day I got back I needed to talk to him,
because I think that leaving it just makes it harder.
But I could see that he didn’t want to,
so I suggested getting help, and he thought I meant you.
He asked if it was a good idea, I said I didn’t know,
and he said, “I’m not sure Esther will agree.”
There’s meaning in misunderstandings.
So I decided to ask for this favor,
which I thought Charlotte had asked me to ask of you.
And, since you agreed...
Well, even in a misunderstanding, you arranged it together.
What’s stopping you re-initiating dialogue?
I don’t know. The wounded pride of the average male.
The laughable void of the white, educated fifty-something,
who feels deep down that he’s starting to lose his grip.
Who thought he still meant something
to the wife with whom he’s shared so much,
maybe the only person who remembers him when he was passionate,
combative, attractive, desirable...
Now, however, I find that in her eyes I’m disappearing.
Maybe that’s hard to forgive.
For me it’s the last betrayal and abandonment.
Maybe the most serious.
Sorry, but aren’t you getting the violins out?
- Didn’t that move you? - Were you trying to move us?
If you’re asking if I’m sincere, I don’t know. What is sincerity?
One tries to say something,
and one discovers what it is , as it comes out.
That is why I ask.
All I know is that I can feel there’s something broken in me,
and I need to find it by talking about it.
Is that what you couldn’t say to Charlotte?
What you needed me for?
I want to pack it all in.
That’s what I’m trying to say.
I felt a sort of warning in a reaction I had to my cop patient.
He provoked me and I was that close to punching him.
Instead of that I crumpled up in a miserable heap.
It may be time for me to reconsider my profession.
You’re not saying you want to quit because of me?
Not because of you. It’s me.
I’m saying that what matters most to me is finding a way
for our marriage, our family, to exist.
Then, like Esther, I’m struggling to follow your great self-questioning.
Your marriage, your family? Are you sure they’re your priorities?
That hasn’t been obvious just lately.
That’s what I’m trying to tell you. That’s what’s wrong in my life.
That’s what I want to change.
Despite what’s happened, I’m trying to accept my share of responsibility.
Maybe it’s...
my pride, my wounded vanity, that’s in the way.
That’s why I need to formulate it with a witness.
I’m using her to make sure that my words
aren’t just a persuasive performance,
but are sincere.
I think we have to listen to what you’re saying.
But maybe it’d be good to get things between you on a clearer basis.
On an equal basis.
I don’t understand. What do you mean?
You don’t need me to witness something else?
Esther, are you trying to break the record
for the pregnant innuendo?
What are the two of you talking about?
I warned you that this wasn’t very orthodox.
Is there something I should know?
Esther seems to think I should mention
conversations we’ve had about a female patient.
A fragile patient who was also affected
by recent events.
But I think that’s problematic from an ethical viewpoint.
You’re stepping outside your role.
What have you talked about and how does it concern me?
You know about the concept of transference.
Yes, I think so.
Transference is the mechanism whereby the patient develops
extreme feelings of attachment to her analyst,
projecting onto him the attributes of ideal love,
quite divorced from reality, of course.
Transference can be seen as an obstacle to analysis
because, while the patient relives, with her analyst,
her earliest attachment problems,
the process of the treatment is hampered.
But, in fact,
if it’s well handled,
transference is a crucial stage of the treatment.
Between the analyst and patient
there’s a purified, paradigmatic replaying
of the original..
Have you fucked her?
I don’t fucking believe it!
If not for you, he wouldn’t have coughed that up.
When I think of how you’ve let me stew in my guilt,
playing the outraged victim, when you’ve been fucking a patient!
But... Charlotte, of course I haven’t.
You have! He’s lying, right?
Charlotte, calm down.
- You don’t understand. - Yes, I do!
Something’s been going on, look at your face!
You haven’t had sex, okay. But you’re in love?
I want to know.
Now he’ll confuse me with his contorted reasoning, until I’m totally lost.
Who is this woman?
Is he mad about her? Does he reassure her?
Does he enlighten her about the basic concepts of psychoanalysis?
Transference, desire, and God knows what else.
She must be pretty. Fragile, huh?
Lost her father at the age of 12 or 13. That’s the sort he likes.
Okay, I admit I tried to use your guilt to win your sympathy,
so you’d feel pity and rediscover some interest in me.
And to sweep your lust for a patient under the carpet.
I made this appointment happen!
Probably so I’d be able to talk about this.
You weren’t very keen to.
Because I’m divided.
Of course it’s not clear, of course I have contradictory feelings.
Look at yourself.
Last week you dumped everything – your husband and family –
and now you’re here, consumed with jealousy
about a patient with whom nothing has happened.
If you accept your own complexity,
you won’t find it so hard to accept mine.
There are hidden reasons why you do things.
This is how he is!
He can always explain what you’re doing, always to his advantage.
It’s my experience as an analyst.
I try to maintain a distance. I’d like to help you do so.
I’m sorry, but in expressing how you feel
you are both equal and legitimate.
No experience is worth more than another.
Thanks. He always finds an underlying reason.
I used to love it, but now I can’t take it any more.
That’s why I went to Rome with Stéphane.
Why?
To stop being trapped in this thing with him.
Where I have to watch every word I say, every gesture...
I feel I’m trapped in my skin, in a sort of computer program,
determined in advance, yet I always end up feeling guilty that I got it wrong.
“Try again!” But I don’t understand.
The machine isn’t working right, but it’s still going...
With Stéphane, all I had to do was let myself be wanted
and feel myself existing.
I could breathe, or at least I thought so, because...
that didn’t lead anywhere either.
It just evaporated, like that.
After Charlotte’s efforts,
it would be good if you tried to explain what’s happened with your patient.
I don’t think it’s a fair parallel.
What?
Sorry. I find your sincerity very brave, I really do,
but I don’t agree there’s a parallel.
I’m not trying to deny that I felt a powerful attraction to her,
but nothing happened. That’s an important nuance.
But you really want to!
Yes, okay, I was tempted, it was flattering.
I even imagined things. That’s only human.
But I kept my distance. I didn’t act on my thoughts.
Plato said something like,
“The wise man does in dreams what the madman does in reality.”
Here he goes, with his Plato lecture!
And I didn’t say, but she’s quitting analysis.
She had her last session on Monday.
So you’re free to see her outside now.
I’ve taken steps to try to save our marriage. What’s left of it.
What kills me is that I feel I know her, his pretty Monday patient.
Like I have a photo of her before my eyes.
- How long has she been coming? - For... I don’t know, maybe a year.
A year of fantasizing, and my fling didn’t even last six months.
I told you, it’s not the same thing.
Maybe that was when you started humping me again, now and then.
I bet it was Monday nights.
- Now you’re raving. - Yeah, right, I’m raving!
She’s young, pretty, sexually liberated,
yet lost and in need of reassurance, so you give her life meaning,
because she’s very intelligent and needs only a mentor.
- Stop it. - It seems I know her, because I do!
- What do you mean? - I know her because she’s me.
Me, when I met you.
Stop it, that’s nonsense.
Why do you say that, Charlotte?
What’s the link between her and you?
I don’t know, sorry.
No, it’s important.
You’re describing how you saw yourself when you met Philippe.
Is that how you felt?
Yes, that was me.
I was lost.
I needed to be reassured, to feel worthy.
I needed to be appealing.
Philippe gave me all that.
In exchange, I conformed to what he expected of me.
Being a companion, a mother, an admirer.
And something has changed?
Me.
I think I’ve changed, yes.
I grew and I accomplished things.
I feel...
In fact..
Philippe’s right, it all comes from me.
I’m no longer the woman he fell in love with.
Charlotte, you’re wrong.
I loved you for your wounds and your fragility, yes,
but also for your strength.
We helped each other to grow.
I needed that strength, I still do.
Philippe,
Charlotte no longer feels in agreement with the subconscious pact you had.
In a way, she’s challenging the rules of the game.
Wouldn’t you be doing the same thing,
to have the same pact with another?
I think you’re being dishonest, Esther,
fitting her words to your concepts, making her say what she didn’t say.
It’s manipulation.
Stop interpreting and answer her question.
Okay, I’ll tell you what I think, but you won’t like it.
I think the two of you have leagued up against me.
Don’t worry, I haven’t gone paranoid.
That’s very reassuring!
I don’t think we’ve fully evaluated what happened with the terrorist attacks.
Philippe, please!
Let me explain, please, it’s important.
At the moment of that shock I think a word occurred to us all,
and that word is “war”.
We’re at war.
I’m not saying we really are, that’s a geopolitical debate.
I’m saying that in our minds we’ve all been living, since that night, in a war.
I don’t see how this is related.
What we call reality is different for each person.
Everything that was well oiled before is now creaking.
All parts of the whole are affected by a multiplying factor of antagonism.
Everything that was distinct or different
has become conflictual.
We’ve put war everywhere.
You mean that’s why
you feel attacked? Esther and I are waging war on you?
All relationships have become tense. It’s just the start.
If we’re not careful, soon it’ll be war everywhere.
Between the rich and the poor, the workers and the bosses,
blacks and whites, parents and children, men and women...
Charlotte, what do you think of what he’s just said?
You’re also largely concerned.
Sorry, but I’m not sure I understand.
If I’m angry with you now,
it’s because I’m caught up in a rancor
which is exacerbated by the current climate,
and which I can only deal with through conflict
because at the moment we’re making everything antagonistic?
- Okay, can I ask you a question? - Of course. We’re talking.
Are you basically saying that you don’t feel concerned by our conflict,
not personally concerned?
Not personally,
but of course it concerns me structurally.
Help me, I give up!
What would it mean to be personally concerned?
Could it mean you’d find yourself in the position of the bad guy?
The bad guy?
If we examine the facts, the bad guy would be a fifty-something
who’s tried to go with a younger woman,
and refuses to question himself in his marriage
because he can’t respond to what his wife is asking of him.
Yes, that would be a bad-guy position.
And it doesn’t remind you of anyone? Outside of yourself, of course.
I know you always want to come back to my father.
Yes, you described my father, but I’m fighting other problems.
Can you share them?
Is it within my understanding to know what you’re experiencing?
Or is it a waste of time to even try?
We inherit different inner worlds. That makes things complicated.
As well as being a man and a woman,
we clearly don’t have links
to the same historical and cultural environments.
You see, for me,
there’s all the history I’ve inherited.
Centuries of being a minority, of marginalization, of persecution...
The fact that members of my mother’s family
died in the atrocities of the 20th century,
that my mother sank into a melancholy
partly due to her childhood during the occupation...
All of that plays a part.
And it’s something we don’t share.
You’re not saying we don’t understand each other because you’re Jewish?
No. But with our subconscious inheritance,
with what we’ve carried inside since childhood,
and in a troubled period like now, yes, it can make a difference.
It brings me closer to my cop patient, for example.
The worst war-related thing to happen to your family,
was how your dad escaped conscription in ’62.
Esther, do something. He’s talking absolute nonsense.
You’re trying anything to provoke us.
I had to work so hard to convince you
that Adam was upset by anti-Semitic stuff he heard at school,
but you weren’t very bothered at all.
When did you become so dishonest?
The problem deep down is incompetence.
Couples therapy needs special guidance.
If you bring up subconscious pacts in the first session,
it can only aggravate the conflict.
What if we look, instead, at denial?
Aggressiveness?
Systematic obstruction?
Is that enough to explain the anger? Is that the effect you’re after?
You can settle your little theoretical quarrel.
I’m going home to work out what to think
about this demoralizing time I’ve just had.
This keeps happening, people leaving your sessions in anger.
If I were you, I’d ask myself some questions.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.