Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
IN THERAPY
ESTHER – FRIDAY, DECEMBER 4, 2015, 7 P.M.
Philippe.
Come in.
How are you?
Okay. Well, I’m in a bit of a state.
Still?
You still haven’t shifted that cold?
Can I use your toilet?
Of course. It’s on the landing, remember?
No, it’s okay. Thanks, I think I’ll be fine.
It’s just in case.
I think I’ve got a urinary problem, probably just an infection,
but I keep wanting to go,
and then I can’t. It’s a pain.
I see.
Have you seen a doctor?
I intend to.
But I can’t find the time.
I can’t believe that at my age I’m still chasing the clock.
I feel we’re living in an era
where everything’s blighted by a fantasy of efficiency.
Is it stress or anxiety?
You think my urinary infection is a symptom?
I don’t know.
What do you think?
Something’s wrong, I know that.
There’s something that won’t come out.
I’m confronted with a form of impotence.
I can’t control it.
Sorry, I have to go to the toilet.
The toilet on the landing isn’t very inviting.
It feels like a public bathroom.
Had the soap run out?
No, it’s just that...
You’re upset.
I’m annoyed with myself
for heeding your advice
and being influenced like a novice,
while deep down I knew it was neither coherent nor appropriate.
What are you talking about?
Following your advice, I suggested that Ariane find another shrink.
I even suggested some addresses where she could continue her analysis.
It was a total failure.
The exact opposite of what you predicted. A disaster!
It was a huge setback.
How so?
She thinks it’s because I’m in love with her.
How did you suggest it?
Now you’ll tell me how I did it wrong!
I want to know the context.
- You didn’t just throw it at her? - Of course not. I led into it.
She arrived late, so I tried to explain the meaning of her being late,
that she was no longer at ease in our relationship.
Know what she said?
That a patient in love with her analyst wasn’t a reason to stop.
“You have to deal with that.”
And she’s right.
What do you say?
You went looking for a stick to beat yourself with.
You tried to make her bear the responsibility,
and she turned the argument against you.
Of course she’s right.
It’s you who wants to stop, not her.
What nerve!
You wanted me to stop!
You nagged me all through the last session.
I told you it was a bad idea.
Philippe, please.
If you don’t like a suggestion I make, nothing’s forcing you to follow it.
And I did not order you to get rid of your patient.
You said quite clearly that it was the best solution.
And now I’m picking up the pieces.
I suggested that it might be the best solution for her.
Get some perspective here.
It definitely looks like it’s you who wants rid of her,
and without any responsibility,
since it was my idea.
Philippe,
why?
You’re attributing strategies...
Why are you trying to push her away as quick as you can?
Will this be another session all about Ariane?
Okay, I desire her, a lot.
What can I do about it?
I’m a man and she’s a woman I like.
Nothing new there.
It’s been the same for thousands of years.
Shouldn’t we be able to deal with it?
I can deal with it.
That’s my job,
not to get rid of my desires, but to choose what I do with them.
Everyone has desires.
Teachers and priests get the hots for their pupils.
Even gynecologists get turned on by their patients’ genitals.
What are you saying?
Even if the social consensus
is to ignore the ferocity of our impulses,
you and I know very well what the reality is.
So why are you acting all outraged?
You know I’m right.
Women need to believe
that their gynecologist doesn’t want to lick their pussy,
yet they hope he wants to
and try to provoke him.
Look,
I don’t know if I’m looking outraged, as you say,
but I feel you’re trying very hard to get such a reaction.
You’re shocked?
Not really.
I’m wondering about your odd ideas on gynecologists.
Know what bothers me about this infection?
Having to show my dick to a doctor in a cold, sterile hospital.
With the fear of what he might tell me.
And the humiliation of him seeing it all shriveled up,
when I’d like to show him how strong and powerful it is.
I’d like to know
where this sudden obsession with genitals has come from
when discussing psychoanalytic relationships.
Okay.
I went a bit over the top.
I apologize.
We psychoanalysts have to delve into dark places,
including inside ourselves.
The dark places of human beings.
We have to deal with them without looking away.
Sorry, but your reaction also illustrates
what I have to handle with Ariane.
It’s easy to provoke a reaction
if you know what angers someone,
what touches their heart.
You mean you know what buttons to push to move Ariane?
You’d know exactly what to do if you chose to,
to get her exactly where you wanted her?
And where would that be?
You know very well.
And I’m not the only one with that power.
And those who use it, even analysts, aren’t all men.
I’m not worried about how you might use this power over her,
but that you seem totally unaware
that she may have the same power over you.
A power she doesn’t even need to be conscious of.
Something which plays directly on your fantasy.
The button which has to be pushed to trigger you.
I told you I can handle it, I know what I’m doing,
I’m in control of the process.
I know how far I can let it go.
And if I extend my finger,
I know how to avoid rubbing that button.
Can you hear yourself?
Can you hear your metaphors?
Why is it all about genitals?
In fact, it’s not provocation.
You’re making a desperate appeal for me to put you on the right path.
Are you that lost?
Absolutely.
I came here for your guidance.
To lay down my problem before you,
so you could pick it apart with your usual rigor
and show me where it was stuck.
But instead you told me to let it drop and give the job to someone else.
Imagine my disappointment when it fails and all you say is,
“Damn, it didn’t work! What a shame!”
Thanks a lot!
I was simply questioning how you were handling that therapy.
Everything that followed merely increased my concern.
Not to mention how you’ve been behaving during this session.
You have seemed extremely defensive
and quite puerile, to tell the truth.
I clearly understand where you’re calling from.
You keep bringing the subject back to a place you mentioned at the start,
a place of fear,
worry, and pain.
When I get close you become threatening.
It makes my job harder.
Yeah, well, that’s just how it is.
Deal with it.
You know who Adel Chibane is?
My cop patient who was at the Bataclan...
Philippe, you’re wriggling out of it again.
That’s typical!
You make your mind up without letting me finish.
This is totally relevant to what we’re talking about.
Just listen.
They met, that’s why it’s relevant.
How?
At the end of our session,
Ariane asked – no, she insisted – that we keep going.
It was clearly an act of rebellion, precisely because I’d upset her
with my suggestion of stopping the therapy.
She was rebelling against the framework of the therapy.
I told you it was a setback.
And?
I didn’t give in.
The time is the time, I’m in charge,
it’s disagreeable, but I had no choice.
I was saved by the next patient ringing the bell.
She left in a regrettably angry mood,
and bumped into Adel Chibane.
The one who’d saved you, your next patient?
But he wasn’t.
Chibane had gotten the day wrong.
Which is very significant in itself,
because he’s as regular as clockwork.
But I didn’t get the chance to discuss it with him.
It would have been useful to draw attention to it,
and to the possible meaning of his mistake.
But no, it was Ariane,
in the state in which she left, who jumped on him.
Vexing.
She dragged him off and set her sights on him.
And now he’s after her too.
They’re having dinner. I know how that’ll end.
That’s funny?
It makes you laugh?
It’s not funny.
I’m sorry.
Do you realize how serious the situation is?
I’ll be left to pick up the pieces.
And not just me. Both of them too.
She did it to spite me.
She’s using him to get at me.
I think you could see it differently.
You could consider that it’s not aimed at you.
She’s getting married, isn’t she?
It’s aimed at her fiancé. What’s his name?
Cédric.
Why persist in feeling betrayed?
Excuse me. I have to...
The toilet, again? Twice in one session.
Stop it!
Sometimes needing to piss is just that: needing to go for a piss!
You know the way?
What would you prefer?
For her to stay angry, in pain,
in this setback, as you call it,
but in any case totally obsessed with you?
Or, by waving a magic wand,
you become just her analyst again,
and she unloads her problems to you
to improve her relationship with the world?
One can get addicted to it,
feeling that one means something more to one’s patients.
It’s because we help them get better.
It’s natural that we get something out of that.
Except that we can forget why, and just keep the feeling it gives us.
You know we must always be extremely careful about that.
Esther, listen to me.
I keep telling you about my responsibility to them.
It’s not my fault if things fall apart,
but I can’t shy away if it does
just because it disturbs the peace
in which we’re all cradled.
Look at all the broken promises.
There must be a place where they hold,
where someone says, “I’m here. I’ll be here,
“I won’t give up on you.”
Okay.
Can I try something?
Tell me how she sees you.
What she thinks of you.
She sees me as a mature man,
the holder of a form of knowledge and power.
Which is why she’s trying to place herself in my protection.
That means seducing me.
She considers sexual submission
or rather erotic availability to be a sort of currency.
Don’t analyze her.
Just tell me how you think she sees you.
Yet she’s anticipating that she’ll be disappointed.
She thinks I’m a coward, stuck in a conventional life,
that I’m basically bored in my marriage
and with my other patients.
And that my love for her, because she’s convinced I’m in love,
is blowing the wind of freedom into my life,
that I’ll never have the courage to break out of my prison
and escape with her.
She’s expecting me to get rid of her.
That might be exactly why she’s attracted to me.
That answers your earlier question. She has a subconscious plan for me,
in which I’m both the bait and the executioner.
Why shouldn’t I use that,
if I know I can teach her to channel that energy
and use it not to hurt herself
but, on the contrary, to be more spiritually alive?
Now tell me how you see her.
Esther, this is like one of your behaviorist protocols.
It is one, a bit tweaked, I’ll admit that.
But I’m keeping my eyes open to everything.
Then you’ll hypnotize me so I’ll forget my trauma?
Play along with me.
What comes to mind when you think of her?
She’s a young woman without self-confidence,
with a demand for protection like a baby...
or at least a child.
A sort of hysterization.
Don’t analyze her, describe her.
She’s thirty-three.
She’s extremely beautiful.
Brave, determined,
wounded, but proud.
That makes you want to hold her even more, so she can rest a little.
She’s quick-witted,
with a great capacity for letting go, which is clear from the way she laughs.
She doesn’t fight it, it’s like a cascade around her body.
I think her rashness and physical curiosity push her to experiment,
to experiment in a poetic way in which her body is at stake.
When she was 14,
at the time of her mother’s death,
she had a life-changing experience.
She stayed for a while with friends of her parents,
and fell in love with the husband.
An older man.
It was an escape, of course.
Her father was severely depressed after her mother died.
He was in pieces and clinging to her.
Such an experience leaves an indelible mark
on a child,
having to take care of an adult
who’s just given up.
It’s going against nature.
It’s like death.
Like you during your mother’s depression.
But you were younger, I think.
Here we go again.
Just after your father left you.
My dad doesn’t come into it.
I’m talking about Ariane’s symptoms, not mine.
Whenever something is possible,
she runs away and seeks protection elsewhere.
I should have had more trust in myself
and found a way to point out that deep down that’s all I am:
a new distraction for escaping disappointment and the pain of failure.
But that’s my take on it. I don’t suppose you agree.
But I’ll carry on.
I think it goes back even further than that.
It’s embedded, powerful and deadly.
She has to escape.
You’re the one who wants to escape.
To escape your family life, Charlotte,
the routine of your practice, even your patients...
Stop making it all about me, it’s intolerable.
You identify with Ariane, that’s what I think.
Her wound is your own.
So what you see in her is what’s deep inside you.
She’s your mirror.
I hadn’t said, but Charlotte told me she’s going to Rome next week
with her accountant from the European Parliament.
She’s the one escaping, not me.
How did you react?
I told her to go away.
We’re not living together, anyway.
What?
I’ve been sleeping on my couch since last week.
It doesn’t change much.
For a while now we’ve just been sharing the same space.
What do the children say?
We’re not saying anything yet.
We’ll keep up appearances for a while.
They don’t say anything, but they know, as always.
I think Emmanuel is fine the other side of the Channel.
The less he knows about us, the better he is.
Liza... Christ!
She keeps her distance too.
She prepares class presentations with friends, sleeps at their houses...
If I know her, she’ll be tackling us about it sooner or later.
As for Adam...
Charlotte suddenly went out yesterday, I was left with Adam.
His mother and sister don’t need us in their lives!
I tried to put on a brave face.
We ordered pizzas, we talked about school...
He’s struggling to fit in,
but he’s found a very clever way
of maintaining his uniqueness among all those dimwitted oafs.
It was great.
We even watched
an episode of Malcolm in the Middle. Do you know it?
It’s something his big brother introduced him to.
It’s a series,
a ferocious satire of American society,
of traditional, family values.
It’s refreshing, it really picks you up.
And it’s very educational.
A crash course for children on the childishness of adults.
It was a moment of bonding.
Until he said goodnight and went to bed.
Then I found myself... paralyzed.
I didn’t know what to do.
His mother wasn’t there, I didn’t dare retire to my office...
Remind me how old he is.
Actually,
this is what occurred to me.
That was the moment I realized what really scared me,
that he would find out the truth and think that I had absconded.
Sure enough, I ended up skulking off
to my lair.
I couldn’t go and lie down in our bedroom.
And I’d only just turned off the light when Adam knocked on the door.
“Dad, what are you doing?
“I need something signed for school.”
I don’t believe that.
He was just checking.
Anyway...
Anyway...
We’ll sort things out. Charlotte has to leave for good.
Things will be clearer and it’ll be better like that.
Plus it’ll leave the field clear.
The field clear?
For Ariane?
Are you suggesting I’m pushing my wife onto another man
so I can have an affair with Ariane?
It would at least be a side benefit.
There’s no side benefit!
My wife’s fucking an international bureaucrat, I feel unwelcome at home,
Adam pretends he’s okay at school so as not to add to my concerns...
My life is shit!
I’d be a fucking idiot to create this situation!
Philippe.
What do you want me to do?
Lock Charlotte up in a prison of the mind?
Like my patient Damien,
who goes so far as to get his wife knocked up
to keep his hold on her.
Or dump her at the first hint of uneasiness, like my cop patient?
We’d be sure we weren’t wasting energy trying to save our marriage.
Why come back to those two patients?
I’m following your lead.
My wife has another man,
that’s my fault, so I’m checking what’s going on around me.
Apparently I’m copying my father and looking for the side benefit:
adultery!
What exactly are you looking for here?
I’m serious.
From the start I’ve been wondering why you’ve come specifically to me.
Listen, then.
I’ve wondered that myself.
It’s suddenly struck me today.
I’m your alternative.
What sort of alternative?
In our first session you listed all your patients,
saying how you felt at risk with them.
Remember what you said?
That if they knew what you were thinking, they’d flee.
When I suggested you transfer Ariane,
you immediately thought I would take her.
Your subconscious wish
is to transfer them all to me.
To unload your problems onto me.
That’s the best yet! So I could do what?
Take Ariane on an around-the-world trip?
Grill octopus on a Greek island?
You don’t half talk some bullshit!
I’m laying it down before you,
and asking you to examine it.
No, it makes no sense.
Maybe you subconsciously seized any suggestion to stop being an analyst
with Ariane.
I give up.
Thanks, I’ll manage by myself.
And, despite what you think, I’m not going around to jump on Ariane.
I’m not sure that your true subconscious motivation is Ariane.
Really? That’s new!
I’m serious.
Of course you’re attracted to her.
You even play with the fantasy
of an erotic or romantic affair.
You say it enables you to carry on with her therapy.
But hearing you talk about her today,
about her deep childhood wound which is impossible to cure,
I’m wondering if you don’t have a much more radical impulse
than a simple desire for adultery.
Something that really worries you.
An ancient wound that’s flared up,
so painful it threatens to carry you away.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.