Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
The perfect murder, the unsolvable crime, does it really exist?
In a TV first, we reveal the cutting -edge technology now used by British
to join the dots and reveal new evidence in all homicide investigations.
I'm Tim Tate. I've been an investigative journalist for almost 50 years.
I'm Sam Robbins, and I'm a criminal intelligence analyst. For over 20 years,
I've worked alongside detectives on major murder investigations.
Together in this new series, we are going to discover the fatal mistakes
prevented the perfect murder from ever being committed.
Cases of medical murder are thankfully very rare. Doctors and nurses
are dedicated to caring for, to saving the sick.
And that's what makes the appalling crimes committed by
state -enrolled nurse Beverly Allitt so shocking.
On the 30th of April of 1991, there was some confusion at the hospital following
the deaths and collapses of a number of children there, and some of it may well
have been criminal.
We had four deaths and 13 children and 23 attacks, and there's no doubt
about it at all, they were all down to Beverley.
Nobody had got a bad word to say about Beverley Allitt initially.
They all thought she would potentially be a good nurse.
She was kind, caring, chatty, friendly.
One of the parents actually asked Beverly Elliot to be a godparent for
children.
You do not expect the caring professions to harm children or harm patients.
Bev Allitt is that little minority group that have taken advantage of the
situation they're in for their own advantage.
At some stage in Beverly Allitt's mind, she thought that she had committed the
perfect murder.
Beverly Allitt, killer nurse.
What my trade, journalists, always refer to these cases as killer angels.
The reality is far more sinister than that, though, isn't it?
Yes, very much so.
Anyone looking to murder within that environment is a serial killer and will
carry on until they are stopped.
So spotting a pattern early is absolutely critical when intervening in
cases. Because when you look at this...
is a relatively short period of time.
59 days in which she killed four children, attempted to kill three
more, and badly injured a further six.
That's an extraordinarily short time period.
It's a prolific series of offending. I was so shocked to realise it was 59 days
and she'd managed to inflict that much damage and death in that time.
Let's start...
At the beginning, what do we know about Alec's childhood and her behaviour
during it?
She'd had a lot of illnesses as a child and there were incidents where you could
describe her as a tension seeker.
There was incidents at school where she fell off the bike or she fell off a wall
and she was the one who always craved attention, always wanted a plaster on
knee.
When she went to hospital with an infection, she'd taken boiling water
mouth so that the temperature was succeeded.
She used to catheterise herself and cause all sorts of problems.
She was constantly needing attention, which saw her hospitalised at one point
and had her appendix taken out.
Not because she had appendicitis, her appendix were perfectly healthy, but
was her ability to manipulate and an act and fame being sick that the doctors
took her appendix out and there was actually nothing wrong with them. So
how adept she was at that age, at a very young age, in order to manipulate
adults and within a medical setting.
And she's doing this why?
Essentially to bring attention onto herself.
We now sort of would call this fictitious disorder, otherwise known as
Munchausen syndrome, where she would create various situations where she
have to see doctors and medical professionals to get help for various
types of illnesses and injuries.
It's certainly the attention that she craved which led her to later crimes.
So as a child and a teenager, she's suffering from Munchausen. Yeah.
She gets a nursing qualification.
She does.
But even during that, she displays behaviour which should have raised a red
flag. Really disturbing stuff that could have made the people that were
supervising her or running the course think maybe something is not well
here.
During the course of training at Grantham Hospital, there had been
bizarre... Incidents, faeces put in a fridge, curtains set on fire, that type
of thing within the nursing home.
And whilst the hospital authorities couldn't say that Beverly Allitt was
responsible, there were suggestions that she was always present when these
events took place.
Beverly Allitt should have never been in nursing in the first place. She was
woefully underqualified.
It's an environment that she should have never entered and most certainly never
been left unsupervised because she wasn't qualified to be a paediatric
But the issue at the time was that the hospital was chronically short -staffed
and Allitt was parachuted in as an emergency contract help.
For an individual who has these quite sadistic or manipulative
and they find themselves working in these environments, they will often come
across situations of life and death almost on a daily basis, and we can see
fragile something is. If somebody didn't intervene at a certain point, then
somebody may have died.
And they will start to see if they actually did a certain act or withheld a
certain medication, that they would have an influence over those people.
And sometimes those kind of lines blur themselves between life and death,
and harm. And sometimes it becomes almost a bit of a game in some respects
people to hold that power over whether they live or die.
So within two days, she's left alone at night, which is...
Shocking enough, but that does give you an indication as to how critical those
staffing levels were.
And that first case, February 1991, she displays
such manipulative behaviour that she persuades the child's parents to
go home and get some rest and to leave Liam Taylor in her care.
Seven -week -old Liam Taylor was brought in with a routine chest infection, and
Alec saw her opportunity.
That night, under Alec's sole care, Liam's condition
deteriorated. He turned blue and developed mysterious blotches
on his skin. Even more strange...
When his body went into spasm, the ward's alarms didn't go off.
By the time a crash team arrived, Liam had suffered
irreversible brain damage.
Ultimately, and on medical advice, his parents agreed to switch off his life
support system.
Little Liam Taylor became Beverly Allards.
First victim.
I don't think at that time that she considered that she was committing the
perfect murder.
I think at that time she was only inflicting the abuse
on the children to draw attention to herself.
Once the first child died, I think there is a possibility that she then thought
that she could get away.
with additional murders.
Within two weeks, she's at it again.
Timothy Hardwick, an 11 -year -old who suffered from cerebral palsy, was
into Ward 4 after suffering an epileptic seizure.
Those fits were quickly controlled by drugs.
Beverly Allitt was seen at his bedside, and...
She called a doctor because the boy was coughing.
The doctors found that there was absolutely nothing wrong with this boy,
the treatment was working.
But within two or three minutes, this boy had stopped breathing.
The resource team were called, but unfortunately they couldn't save him. He
at the hospital.
She's moved on from harming herself or appearing to harm herself, Munchausen
syndrome,
Others, but still to get attention for herself.
Yes, and psychologically that's a big step.
It's one thing to think, well, I can sustain sickness and I've got awful
and pains and poor me.
To then project that onto children to the point where you make them so
unwell that their hearts are stopping. The level that that syndrome then has to
move on is shocking.
And she doesn't stop?
No. And she never would have stopped.
She never would have stopped.
Never? No.
Her third victim, one -year -old Kayleigh Desmond, was admitted to Ward 4
routine chest infection.
Initially, she seemed to be progressing well, to be coming out of it.
But after a period when Allitt was again left in sole charge...
Little Kayleigh took her turn for the worse.
She was rushed away from the hospital to another hospital in Nottingham, and
that ultimately saved her life.
When the doctors at Nottingham Hospital examined Kayleigh, they were puzzled,
because underneath her armpit there was a puncture mark, and beside it a little
air bubble, like a little air blister.
They assume that it's an accident, so no investigation is undertaken.
The question is, when those children arrive and are admitted to the
Hospital, how is someone looking at that saying, we've got another one from Ward
4? It's not just that they're coming from that particular hospital, they're
coming from the same ward.
I'd like to think today that that would have set alarm bells off at that point,
possibly earlier.
There was little doubt that Beverly Allitt abused her position as a nurse.
She used the opportunity to draw attention to herself, to make herself
special and to make herself look very competent.
And that is why she did these things.
There had been a succession of medical crises on Ward 4, and the
common factor in all of this was Beverly Allitt. It should have raised
enormous red flags.
Over the period between the 21st of February and the 22nd of
April, there were...
numerous collapses of children involving 13 children.
The next tipping point if you want is a week after the third attack
when a five -month -old boy comes in, Paul Crampton, with a bronchial
Paul Crampton had been in hospital, and in the first three days, nothing had
occurred. At the end of those three days, he'd had his first collapse.
Eventually, they decided he was hypoglycemic, put him on a glucose drip,
recovered. The next day, Beverly Allitt went to take the drip down, and he again
suffered a second hypoglycemic attack.
Blood was taken at that time.
An analysis of that blood showed that there was an insulin level in the blood
500 milliunits per litre. Now that is extortionately high when you consider
any child should have somewhere between 10 and 15 milliunits per litre of
insulin in the blood.
Once again, the child was treated with glucose and recovered, and there
another three days where nothing occurred with this child, so much so...
that on the fourth day he was expected to go home.
On that day, father arrived at the hospital and found his child blue in a
collapsed state.
He was resuscitated and was taken to the Queen's Medical Centre at Nottingham.
The sheer scale of Alex's attacks is huge. If we went through each of the
that you've identified and laid out, we'd be here.
Next week? Yes.
But the case of the Phillips twins in April 1991 sticks out.
Yes. Becky and Casey were twins who'd been born prematurely. Becky arrives in
Ward 4 on the 1st of April suffering with gastroenteritis. She goes into Alex
Care.
By the 3rd of April, she's found unresponsive. Her sugar levels are too
she's cold to the touch.
Very, very sadly, Becky dies.
She dies in her parents' arms. She does, which is utterly heartbreaking.
Blood was taken at that time, and that again was analysed, and that showed that
this little girl had got 9 ,660 milliunits of insulin in the blood. So
here are two children that over that period of time had been poisoned with
insulin.
Of course, in a medical environment, then...
The chemical such as insulin would have been readily available and they would
have been known to be used therapeutically.
Beverly Allitt would have access to those individuals.
and access to the materials necessary to administer these types of overdoses or
materials that would elicit other reactions such as heart attack, heart
And of course the detection of those overdoses, those injections, would only
really come to light some days later once those individuals had been
to forensic testing.
The twin of Becky Phillips, Katie Phillips, was taken in purely as a
Beverly Allitt was allocated her care and was seen at one point to have turned
the cot through 90 degrees. This had the effect of making it very difficult for
anybody passing down a corridor to see what was going on.
The little girl was heard squealing and stopped breathing.
Her chest was pumped so hard that it broke ribs.
Sadly, this little girl suffered extensive brain damage during this. She
into convulsions after the initial attack on her.
Once again, that's a step forward in behaviour, isn't it? It's like glory
chasing, that I tried, I tried to save this child.
All about getting attention.
All about getting attention.
We know that Alec caused all of that.
By this point, obviously, the parents of the Phillips twins have spent a lot of
time in hospital and have been so used to dealing with Beverly,
who's been on the scene of both of their daughters' extreme medical emergencies.
And at some point...
I'm fairly sure that Elliot has convinced Katie's mother and father that
actually she is the one that saved Katie despite the fact that she has caused
that damage.
But such is her manipulation and her ability to read people and talk to
that Katie and Becky's mother asked her to be God's mother to Katie.
That's early April.
Yes. For the next...
Three full weeks, Alec continues, and more children are attacked and died.
The last child to tragically die under Alec's care was Claire Peck, who was a
-month -old baby who suffered from asthma.
The little girl was taken into the treatment room where Alec was left on
own. Very shortly after, Alec raises the alarm that the child has stopped
breathing.
The child is resuscitated and the doctor decides to give a drug called
aminophiline. And the little girl begins to recover. So much so that the doctor
is so happy, he goes out to speak to the parents, saying, I don't think you'll
have any more problems now.
Within two minutes, up goes the shout that she's collapsed.
And on this occasion, they were unable to resuscitate her.
And that's what raises, finally, the alarm, isn't it? It is, yes. Finally,
Detective Superintendent Stuart Clifton is given the case.
I visited the hospital and I got a brief outline that there were a number of
children over a two -month period who had suffered unexplained collapses.
They'd had 23 incidents over a 59 -day period.
which they couldn't account for.
When I looked at the initial report from Sir David Hull, I began to question
whether there was anything that was worthy of police investigation.
But a gut feeling said that there was.
Clifton's suspicions weren't shared by his bosses, were they? They weren't. He
had to fight really hard to get this case looked at properly.
At the time of the Beverly Allick case, I was a detective constable working in
the child protection unit at Grantham Police Station.
I'd previously been at the forensic science laboratory at Nottingham.
Superintendent Clifton thought I'd be useful on that sort of inquiry.
At the same time, he spoke to my brother, who's also a detective
the police force.
Actually, there was 24 on the team.
There were seven sergeants, seven DCs were investigated, and we had the Holmes
office, which is the computer system for dealing with murders.
The inquiry started in May of 1991, and I first came into contact with Beverly
Allitt on the 7th of May. And at that stage, she was part of the inquiry, as
every other nurse and doctor on the ward. It was merely a fact -finding
I decided that I would concentrate the inquiry teams on one little boy, a
boy called Paul Crampton.
Blood was taken on this occasion.
I tasked one of my detective inspectors with finding a sample of that blood, and
he eventually found one at another hospital at Boston in Lincolnshire.
And it was found to contain not 500 milliunits per litre, but 43
,167 milliunits per litre of insulin in the blood.
Forensic science is such an enormous subject that all of the things that we
mentioned, such as toxicology, pathology, continuity of evidence,
psychiatry, they all fall under the umbrella of forensic science. And so, in
this case, we're able to stitch together a narrative which closed the net around
Beverly Allitt.
When we went to the hospital initially, they couldn't identify the fact that
Insulin had been injected into the child rather than be produced naturally.
When we did research, I found that C -peptide, which is just an enzyme, was
released when people developed insulin in the body.
In Paul Crampton, there was no proportionate quantity of C -peptide,
that this was insulin that had been administered to this child.
So here for the first time we've got some clear evidence that somebody has
attacked children on the ward.
We begin to look at the collapses of all of the children in minute
detail.
As soon as it became obvious that there was more than one child involved and we
had evidence to that effect.
and obviously it became a very different inquiry.
It was probably the most intensive and largest hospital inquiry at the time.
I tasked the members of my team with producing a chart that showed
who was on duty.
when each of these collapses occurred.
That sounds like an easy project, but the duty rotor does not necessarily
reflect what happens on the day, and so we had to gather information.
I actually went and spoke to a professor of mathematics who did an
analytical survey of it. If you put in the 23 incidents
over 59 days...
there was at least 42 people involved, which were nurses, cleaners, visitors to
the hospital.
And it came up that there was one person who would be the person responsible.
That chart quite clearly showed that Beverly Allitt was the only
nurse that was on duty for every one of the collapses.
Nurse Alla had various MOs in committing these crimes, which included injecting
insulin, injecting potassium. In the case of Katie Phillips, she squeezed the
child and broke its ribs.
She injected air into the axilla, so air went up to the heart, caused a heart
attack. And there was 23 of these incidents over 13 children
over a short period of time.
Three weeks into the inquiry, I decided that I would have Beverly Allitt
arrested. It was a girl that was about 21, 22 years of age that had never been
in trouble with the police. And in my naivety, I suppose I thought that
when she came into police custody that she would begin to tell us the truth.
I couldn't have been more wrong.
The arrest at Beverley Island led her home and she was brought to the police
station for interview.
I went with other officers to her house where she was initially arrested on
suspicion of theft of a key and that key was on a key ring that gave access to
the insulin fridge.
Having been arrested, my job was to accompany her to Grantham Police Station
with being female.
She gave no signs whatsoever to me that she was guilty.
She was quite normal to talk to.
She didn't panic or anything like that.
The house was searched.
Amongst other things found was a ward allocations book.
The ward allocation book became important because somebody had taken it.
obviously Beverly Allitt from the ward, and it showed that Beverly Allitt had
been allocated the care of quite a number of the children that had
died.
I interviewed her on the first evening after her arrest.
The best way to describe her is she was like two different people.
Outside of the formal interview, she was friendly, chatty.
trying to make you a friend in some respect.
But there was a distinct change when the button on the recording interview was
switched on.
At no time did she show any emotion.
At no time did she expect to be charged with these
offences. She thought at that stage she'd got away with it.
If you were someone who cared and you went into a profession that was all
caring and saving people's lives, if you were presented with multiple deaths,
you'd be absolutely bereft. You'd be, you know, sobbing and... Wouldn't you
an explanation?
If you were Beverly Allitt, all these children had died or suffered
injuries while you were there, wouldn't you be saying, how did that happen?
Is it the medicine? Is there something wrong with the medical equipment?
Is there someone else on that ward that is a danger to children? I can just
imagine you'd be so distressed if you were questioned about that.
And there were no signs of that at all in the interview. Nothing.
I remember going to her cell one morning to get her out for an interview, and
she'd lost a lot of weight, and as soon as she saw me, she lifted up her top and
said, Oh, look, you know, I've lost a lot of weight. Can you notice? As if we
were the best of friends.
Then you would take her to an interview room, switch the tape on, and she'd get
this antsy attitude.
You know, I didn't do anything.
When she was on bail, she went to live with another nurse.
She attacked.
The grandson gave him drugs from the grandmother and he ended up in hospital.
They found that he'd had a hyperglycemic attack.
Even this 13 -year -old boy said, well, that's strange, isn't it? It's the same
thing that's happened to these babies at Grantham Hospital. What would the press
say if they got hold of that?
We thought that she would be afraid and that she would begin to talk to us. She
would talk about anything.
other than the matter in hand.
She completely and utterly denied anything and distanced herself from
suggestions that she was there at the bedside.
When we were upsetting her, if we were getting close to the truth, she became
antsy and tried to deflect it back to us.
Some tapes of the interview were released.
We're going to listen to some of Beverly Allitt's interview tapes.
I think they're revealing.
What do you think?
Could you give me a full name, please?
Beverly Gail Allitt.
Are you smiling?
Is it funny?
Is it, you know, light -hearted?
Can't you take the interview serious?
You look like one of those.
You tell me what I'm doing to my children.
I'm sticking to my story. I did not do it.
On all them times I was on duty and thinking I'm going to be so stupid to
doing it. I don't know how stupid you are one way or another. See, I've been
there for a lot of occasions when these babies have gone off.
A lot of them.
Probably apart from about three of them.
Which I haven't been there for.
I can't get it through to nobody. And I tell you what, no matter what you say,
I'm sticking to my story. I did not do it.
What's your instant reaction to that?
Disbelief, to be honest with you. The youth...
of language the way that she's referring to deceased children it's really quite
quite shocking it speaks to defensiveness of me but that she's also
any responsibility at all for her actions and to refer to them in that
is disgusting moving on down through her interview let's listen to this one if i
what i suspect are the line of question i'm taking
It's in your interests not to tell the truth, isn't it?
Not to tell the truth? I'm telling the truth. If what I suspect is the truth, i
.e. you administered something unlawfully to Paul Crampton or caused
illness for these other children, it's in your interests not to tell the truth,
isn't it?
No. Isn't it? No.
I'd tell the truth. I'm not going to lie to you. You can't understand the
question. Do you know what causes hyperglycemia?
Diabetes.
Well, apart from that.
No. I don't... I'm very...
I'm not very well upon the diabetic stuff anyway.
No.
I know that if it was given insulin, that would make his shovel go down.
I accept that you're in custody, amongst other things, for the suspected event
murder. You accept that now, which is a very serious allegation.
So if it takes you a long time to think about it, then fair enough. It doesn't
matter how long you make me think about it, I won't be able to tell you the
exact time.
I could go away for a year, come back and say, still no wider.
They can fed up of being in it.
It's very contradictory, isn't it? And in that first clip, there's smiling and
not taking it quite seriously.
And there's the, I'm the nurse in this situation.
And, you know, I've looked after plenty of children.
And then all of a sudden, in the second clip, there's the, I'm just a nurse in
this situation.
Yeah, with the removal of...
She's flip -flopped between, I'm the nurse I looked after and plenty of
lived, but also, I'm the nurse, how would I know? And really, you'd expect a
qualified nurse to know what causes sugar to rise and fall.
You'd hope.
Yes.
Shall we listen to the next clip? Yes.
What's the motive?
What's the motive for doing that? You are trying to establish yourself as a
competent nurse.
I'm not competent. Far from it.
No, I'm one of the brunt -crackiest nurse out.
But I'd rather tell you, I'd rather just say I've already done it, even if I
didn't just to get away.
With all these facts we've put to you, we've spoken to you individually about
each of the two of you.
Surely you've got something to say about those children.
No reply.
Do you happen that you didn't intend to harm, or cause them serious injury, or
indeed kill?
The only person with real answers is yourself, isn't it?
No, Clive.
One key word screams out of that interview to me, motive.
She's asking the police what he thinks her motive might be.
That's calculating.
I very much hear somebody who has got total disdain for authority and when
challenged to bring her credentials to the table.
She dilutes it, dilutes it down and takes the responsibility away.
Total disdain for the fact that she's been caught out.
And challenging them.
And challenging them, yeah.
You don't see that sort of response very often in interviews.
So that people are willing to speak, but they're almost incriminating themselves
in the manner in which they're doing so.
Really interesting audio and language and attitude speaks volumes to me.
It's basically saying you do your worst. Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
How often do you get access to tapes like that? It's really unusual.
when you work on an inquiry and it's a live inquiry, you can choose to watch
tapes because you're part of that investigation team.
But to be able to...
helicopter above and look at all the patterns of offending and to get the
and actually get to listen to the audio is really rare.
I can't lie, it's been disturbing listening to her and her attitude
really, really serious and tragic situation.
Press officers from various newspapers embedded and living at Grantham because
of the number of children that had been attacked and the number of children that
had died in a very short period of time.
This obviously caused great concern to people who were visiting Grantham
Hospital and I'm sure there were people who would not attend Grantham Hospital
purely as a result of this case.
We supported...
The findings of the investigation team that put Allitt at bedside with forensic
evidence that added to a case that was in the main circumstantial.
And as a result, we had sufficient evidence to charge her.
Allitt's trial at Nottingham Crown Court in 1993 captivated Britain. It
horrified.
up and down the country.
It was the sort of trial where the parents of the collapsed and
dead children were present, so there were obviously tears when the evidence
heard by these people.
On the day that I accompanied her to court, we were in the van together, and
was... Looking out like this at the crowds that had gathered outside the
courthouse, it was obvious that she was really enjoying the fact that there were
so many people there. Even though they were all sort of threatening her and
shouting at her and raising fists, she, it's fair to say, was not alarmed. She
was more excited about it.
She wasn't committed to the trial.
One period of time she decided not to attend.
And I think the judge allowed her not to attend.
She was a known manipulator and she would spend time in the prison
hospital wing rather than turning up to court.
Despite all the theatrics, despite all her protestations of innocence, in the
end, Allitt was convicted.
When the jury returned with their verdicts... I think it's fair to say
there wasn't a dry eye in the house, and that included the police officers.
So she's convicted of the 13 offences, four murder, nine grievous bodily harm
with intent, and I think it's fair to say that there was absolutely no
from her at all on conviction.
Justice was achieved for these families.
And for the relatives, she received 13 life sentences.
And in my mind, she should never be released, ever.
When Alec is convicted, and she's convicted and sentenced to multiple life
terms, what would you expect to have happened?
I would have expected her to go to prison.
and to have stayed there for the rest of her life.
But?
As the manipulation continues, Beverly Allitt did go to prison for a short
amount of time, and then she was transferred to a secure hospital.
When you say a secure hospital, people think Broadmoor, but there's Rampton as
well, and that's where she went. Yes.
Conditions? Much more pleasant than prison.
a lot more um liberty in terms of your movement and the treatment that you get
and also you have doctors and mental health workers looking after you she's
getting exactly what she wanted yes yeah she's getting attention yeah
i'm sure that was manipulation on her part and i don't think that that's
justice for the parents
About three or four months later, I went to see her at Rampton Hospital, where
she was currently held.
On this visit, I asked her if she would like to tell me what she'd done.
At that particular time, she admitted nine of the 13 offences.
She offered no explanation and refused to offer any explanation about why she'd
done it.
through her solicitor, wrote to the Home Office and admitted the other four.
So, in the end, she admitted responsibility
for all 13 cases that she was convicted of.
I would think by the time she comes out of prison, she will be way past
committing any other offences.
because of her age and she won't have the opportunity and I'm satisfied that
Bavia committed these offences because she was given the opportunity.
Had this case happened today
I think intervention would have come a lot earlier for multiple reasons. I
that metrics at hospitals are better understood and looked at on a regular
basis. You've got teams looking at data to ensure things like this don't happen
and looking at how many deaths there are and statistics, which I think would
have played very heavily into it should this have happened now.
If there are any failings identified in any profession, certainly in forensic
science, then we have to learn from those lessons. And I have no doubt that
medical profession have studied exhaustively this case and perhaps
and ensure that safeguards are in place.
I've dealt with a lot of murder inquiries over the years and I think
probably tops them in the sense that it's a serial killer within a
hospital environment.
You don't expect nursing staff to be killing people that they're employed to
protect.
I had 33 years of police service.
It's the one inquiry that sticks with me the most.
It was hard work dealing with the parents, particularly the parents that
lost the children, because obviously there's a sensitive side to that as
but we had to get all the information and that from them.
It was touching.
In her own mind, did she think she would get away with perfect murders?
I would suggest yes, because she had...
everything that she needed in order to commit the perfect murders. The victims
were brought to her. She had a plausible reason as to why they would have died
in each case. So, yes, absolutely.
She certainly felt that she had hidden the facts from the authorities.
She made a comment to one of the nurses.
They will never be able to prove anything because they cannot find the
And I think in her own mind, she thought she couldn't be caught.
It's very, very difficult, I believe, for anybody to commit a
perfect murder. I think that if police look at things in minute detail, as we
did in the Alec case, then there will always be something that...
jumps out and identifies.
It's not always easy to get to that point and it's particularly difficult, I
think, where you're working in an environment like a hospital where there
any number of people that could be responsible.
Certainly in this situation, she thought she'd got away with the perfect murder
because nobody really suspected her and the evidence wasn't there.
to point towards her. And it was only upon the investigation, there was some
circumstantial evidence, really, that linked her to all of these crimes that
her eventual undoing.
What is so devastating about what you've laid out is that the patterns are so
clear. Yes.
And when I was doing it, I was really just like, how did this not get spotted
sooner?
Anyone looking at this...
would say anyone who does that is mad yes
you think so wouldn't you you would most certainly think so but she's not
legally mad is she she is not no and the old the old phrase Bad, not mad.
It could be used for Beverly Allitt because legally she is not... I mean,
clearly there are mental health issues there. How could you possibly act in
manner and not have some form of mental health issues?
However, legally... Legally, she's sane.
Yes.
I don't think she was born evil, but...
Maybe something happened to her in her life, maybe it didn't. There was no
evidence of that, but then there was no evidence of her actually committing any
of these crimes.
It was all circumstantial evidence that we had to put together, which made it
obviously difficult and a complex inquiry.
But she was a very, very strange woman.
In the end, it was her own behaviour, her own aberrant behaviour.
which are clear symptoms of Munchausen and Munchausen's by proxy. It was that,
rather than anything else, which attracted the suspicion, which
led to the police investigation, which caused her to be charged and ultimately
convicted. That, in the end, was the difference
between perfect murders and almost perfect ones. Thank you.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.