Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
In the rural village of Brockham, Surrey, 14 -year -old Roy Tuttle
his way home from school.
One evening, though, when he's aged 14, in April 1968, he doesn't come home.
It was so unusual for somebody to go missing, especially a child who was
hitchhiking home, and they just assumed he would return home. And then three
days later, on the 26th of April, the unthinkable happened.
A forestry worker found Roy's body.
There was an absolute shockwave through the community. People were looking at
each other in the street thinking, how could this happen here?
Despite the tireless efforts of Surrey Police, the investigation stalls and the
case eventually goes cold.
You've looked at all of the leads that you've got. They've all come to a dead
end. You have to start shutting things down.
Abilities in DNA and forensics had moved on. They were able to deliver a DNA
profile and a breakthrough.
in this historic and unsolved case.
Brockham is a village and civil parish in the Mole Valley district of Surrey in
England.
It's a very picturesque village. It has the River Mole running through it and it
is a very idyllic place to live with about 2 ,500 people living there.
It's a village which has its own identity and a great history of a church
dates back to the 13th century. One of the most photographed and picturesque
cricket grounds in the country. It's right on the North Downs.
very close to Box Hill, which is made famous by a scene in Jane Austen's novel
Emma.
In terms of crime, this is a very low crime area. You're looking at
a bike theft, occasional fight outside a pub, that kind of thing. This is an
area to raise children happily and safely.
This is an area that you'd probably retire from if you'd lived in London for
many years. This is an area that's quite close to the big city, but it's
definitely far enough away that it's quiet, peaceful and safe.
In 1968, 14 -year -old Roy Tuttle lives in Brockham with his family.
Raising a family in that area are Hilary and Dennis Tuttle. They already have
one older son, Colin, and in 1954 they have a younger son, Roy Tuttle.
Roy Tuttle, a 14 -year -old boy known as Putts to his friends, he was the son of
Dennis and Hilary Tuttle. He also had a brother, Colin, and they were a very
close, very happy family.
The Tuttles were a very close family of four.
Roy was a little bit shy, a bit reserved. He didn't really go to the
anything, any clubs or activities. But to those who did know him, he was your
run -of -the -mill teenage lad. He was good to be around, happy -go -lucky,
mischievous, as all teenage boys are.
I've been going to Kingston Grammar School, which is a famous old school
famous old school uniform. It's a bright red blazer with grey stripes.
This is very unusual for a British school and it's very, very distinctive
area. The children go from many miles away.
The totals lift around 15 miles from this particular school and anyone in the
area immediately recognise children wearing this red and grey blazer as
Grammar Boys.
So Roy and Colin both attended Kingston Grammar School. In order to get there,
they would take a bus part of the route, but then they would hitch the rest of
the way. And this was because Roy was saving for a bicycle and him and his
brother Colin were saving for a train set as well. So they'd use the money for
their bus fare in order to save for these things that they wanted.
For some context, back in the late 60s, hitchhiking wasn't as taboo as it
perhaps is viewed now.
Their parents at first weren't keen on the idea, but they did resign themselves
to the fact that their boys would hitchhike home.
Nothing had ever happened, so why wouldn't they trust it?
The late 1960s was considered to be relatively safe. I remember doing it
in the early 70s, and you wouldn't have given it a second thought. Now it's a
different thing entirely.
Tuesday 23rd April 1968.
Roy leaves school as normal at 3 .30, and he gets the bus. He gets the bus for
the first part of his journey, but determined to save up for this much
-after bike, he decides to pocket the rest of the cash for himself, and is
on a lay -by near Chessington trying to thumb a lift.
However, that evening, Roy doesn't return home.
As the hours ticked by, Dennis and Hilary started becoming worried about
their youngest boy was.
Perhaps he was out playing with his friends for the first few hours, that's
they thought. But as the evening grew later, they decided to phone the police
and report Roy as missing.
So having called the police, they came round to take a missing person report
from Roy's parents, but they did nothing further that evening, assuming that he
was staying with friends and he would turn up the following morning. Back
this was probably the sort of thing that police would have done, because it was
so unusual for somebody to go missing, especially a child who was hitchhiking
home, and they just assumed he would return home when he'd woken up in the
morning at his friend's house.
When Roy still hasn't come home by the next day, police are now very active in
their search. They're taking descriptions of him to the local
where a young boy might have gone or families who might have seen a young boy
might have information.
They take his description and his information to the local area of Toll,
anyone has seen him there. They speak to local bus drivers, but they don't get
any critical information.
Police would have asked everything about him, what he looked like, what his
interests were, particularly what he was wearing at that time, his route home,
where the likelihood he might be.
They put up posters and started to talk to people about if they'd seen Roy at
any point. They also checked the military pillboxes to see if by any
had fallen asleep in one or was hiding in one, but there was no sign of Roy.
Police threw a whole net around that area of Surrey, stopping cars from the
street, just questioning everybody, producing pictures to try and get some
of lead or some sort of effort.
Media obviously was an important outlet for it, local newspapers, even local TV
news. Anything that could put the picture of Roy in front of the public to
if that produced any sort of response.
But as the days went on, the pressure was on, a missing schoolboy. Every day
that goes by, people start fearing the worst.
Once you start to publicise this, then people help join in, try to provide
information wherever possible.
It was Brockham, Dorking, all around that area was very much a community and
police at that time could rely on that community to help them whatever way they
could.
With every passing hour, the Fowleys must have just thought, their minds must
have raced, the imagination gone wild, the worst.
Obviously, scenarios were playing over themselves.
It just got worse and worse and worse, the pressure higher and higher and
higher. What has happened to their lad? It's a horrible situation for anybody to
be in.
Three days later, everyone's worst fears are confirmed.
So the search continues for the next three days. People are getting more and
more concerned about where Roy may be. And then three days later, on the 26th
April... The unthinkable happened.
A forestry worker working on Lord Breverbrook State found Roy's body.
The boy's body is found in a wooded copse near Mickleham. Forestry workers
the red jacket of the school uniform in the dense undergrowth and move towards
it. They horribly discover this young boy found murdered underneath it.
So interestingly, the forest worker...
had been working in that area in the morning. He'd gone off to take a break
had come back later on in the day, and that's when he had found Roy, leading to
the suggestion that Roy had been put there very recently.
Police sealed off the area where the body had been discovered.
Now a missing person inquiry has suddenly escalated into a murder hunt.
Examination of the body, the pathologist told them that not only had Roy been
strangled, possibly with a ligature, the police believed it was in fact...
quite possibly his own school type, but that he had been brutally sexually
abused, in fact raped.
The police have a tough job, and any policeman will tell you one of the worst
aspects of his job is having to go to a family, particularly parents of someone
who has died in tragic circumstances, and break the news.
It is a very, very difficult job, and you can just imagine not only the
of the police who are having to sit down with the parents, but the parents
themselves. Finally, they have the news they'd been dreading for so many days.
Child murders were almost unheard of. When a child goes missing, Leglo's found
dead, there's an absolute shockwave through the community, through the wider
community, even across the country. The ultimate murder of Roy Tuttle was real
front -page news, and people were looking at each other in the street
how could this happen here?
Surrey police are under intense pressure to locate a child rapist and murderer
and deliver justice for Roy's family.
But will they succeed?
On 23 April 1968, 14 -year -old Roy Tuttle disappears in the quiet village
of Brockham in Surrey.
Three days later his body is found outside Cherkley Court in Mickleham.
He has been sexually assaulted and strangled.
Just three days after Roy first disappeared, his family get the most
most awful news that you can imagine.
A young boy's body has been found.
The parents of this murdered schoolboy, utterly distraught, their lives
completely ruined.
Roy's father, Dennis, was to die within a year or two, no doubt of a broken
heart. I'm sure whatever reason he died would have... been exasperated by what
had happened. Hillary was to die 20, 30 years later.
There's no comeback here. There's no way you can make this up. It's always part
of your life.
Officers secure the scene to preserve crucial evidence.
This isn't an area where something like this has ever happened before. This is a
forest close to the estate of Lord Beaverbrook, the Canadian press baron
part of Winston Churchill's war cabinet.
So police at that time in the late 1960s don't have the DNA and forensic
capabilities that we have today.
But police work in terms of boots on the ground is very much the same. They
cordon off the area, they seal the scene, they speak to anyone that's been
through the area and they're busy knocking on doors asking, did you see
anything? Have you seen this missing boy?
It was a country lane, for want of a better term. There was metal railings,
metal fence either side, and the body was actually about a couple of yards
over the fence.
Slightly concealed, but not overly concealed, so there was no great effort.
houses nearby, no witnesses nearby, and it looked as though it was a sort of
hurry dump, if that made sense.
You know, no great effort was taken to conceal the body.
The police were working on the theory that this had to be someone who had a
previous MO for picking up boys and sexually abusing them and then disposing
them. They didn't think this was a single one -off opportunist crime, that
was someone who had a pathway and knew how to do this.
Fear, of course, that the community was a child killer on the loose.
All the pressure that they were under didn't change the fact that they had so
little to go on. It was not impossible for someone to have picked up this boy,
sexually abused him, killed him, left the county, left the area, could have
to any other part of Britain and just disappeared way out beyond the reach of
Surrey Police.
Investigators begin their inquiries within the local community.
Surrey Police brought in officers from over the county who were engaged in
-to -house inquiries trying to identify Roy's last movements, etc.
The SIO at that time, Paddy Doyle, I know that this was very personal to
because Paddy had a son of the same age and it really was a case of trying to
trace witnesses, identify Roy's potential last movements and appeal for
to come forward.
Police have now got 150 officers on the scene and they are now interviewing
people at mass.
They complete 10 ,300 interviews in a very short amount of time.
These interviews, they could be anything from 20, 30 minutes to several hours.
They interview pretty much anybody that might have seen anything in that area.
So police had very little to go on at this point. So they put up posters in
area to ask if anybody had seen anything suspicious.
And a bus driver came forward to say there had been an Austin Westminster
in the lay -by where he should have been able to pull his bus into at the
relevant time that Roy disappeared.
A boy matching Roy's description was seen leaning into that window. The
was leaning across, speaking back to him. This man was described as being
stocky, with white greyish hair. The same car had been reported seen near
the body was dumped.
One of the most significant details about this car not only is it a grey
Austin Westminster which is quite a distinctive vehicle but it has also got
registration plates on it. In the late 60s the British government decided to
have yellow registration plates on the back of a car and white registration
plates on the front of a car. This car has those white and yellow registration
plates.
So following the posters being put up for information, a lady came forward to
say that at about half past four on the relevant day, she had seen a boy
matching Roy's description, hitchhiking. And she had said to him, being
concerned, she had said, there are plenty of buses passing here, you don't
to hitchhike. But Roy, being unconcerned, said, oh, I'll be
she left and she went to do some grocery shopping. And when she came back about
20 minutes later, Roy was gone, suggesting that in that time span, he
into a vehicle.
So police carry out an exhaustive search of anybody that owns an office in
Westminster and in those days this is a manual search in every sense of the
word. You've got to get the phone book out, you've got to have paper records,
you've got to go through, find somebody's phone number, phone them,
them, go around to their address, record it all on separate bits of paper and
then it all goes back into case files. This is an exhaustive search and in the
end it proved a fruitless one.
With the car search yielding no results, police turned to a newly emerging field
of investigation.
Forensic science was still in its infancy, really, when it came to helping
police detectives in the late 60s. And all the forensic examination of the
and the body was able to show was a blood stain on Roy's trousers.
The problem was that the blood stain could only narrow it down to either
group A or blood group O.
Now, unfortunately, those are the two most common blood groups in the world,
the police were not given any help, really, certainly when you judge it by
modern times, by what they found at the scene.
They would have spoken to anyone who they considered as a potential suspect
eliminated them. Did they have any firm idea as to who was responsible?
Absolutely not.
You know, they had no fingerprints or anything else like that that could have
identified the suspect from. So even if they had a suspect... trying to tie that
suspect down to the scene and to the murder, unless there's witnesses, may
been an uphill struggle.
Fibres at that time wasn't a science.
You know, you're talking about 1968, you're talking about fingerprints and
fact that he had a blood type. They were the most important aspects of forensic
recovery that they had. Fibres wasn't one of the considerations.
In 1968, nobody ever thought of a sex offenders register.
This wasn't to come in for many decades.
So there was no actual list of known sexual deviants. If the police were to
to trace around the country those who had committed sexual offences, they
have to make individual inquiries to each individual police force, which of
course would take forever, and of course many police forces couldn't be bothered
to cooperate with over a crime that wasn't committed in their area.
It was a very haphazard approach to dealing with sex crimes, partially
these sort of sex crimes wouldn't say unheard of, but they were rare, and
were more concerned with more routine crimes which kept on recurring.
TV reconstructions of high -profile cases are a familiar thing for TV
today and a familiar thing on social media and TV news. However, at that
they hadn't been done. And desperate to get a breakthrough in this case, Philip
Doyle, the lead inspector on this case, creates the first TV reconstruction of
this boy's final moment.
He recruits his own son to walk up and down...
similar to Roy Tuttle, in the same uniform, along the same road, in a bid
and jog the memory of anybody who might watch that broadcast and anybody who
might have seen something on that fateful day.
If the police were now under serious pressure, they'd never lost a child in
these sort of circumstances, but they had no leads.
The bloodstains wouldn't have helped them a great deal. The sightings that
come up had really amounted to nothing between the possible connection with the
driver of an Austin Westminster Mark II, which was looking like a needle in a
haystack across the country, and the fact that he was hitchhiking home.
They had nothing else to go on.
Detectives pursue other lines of inquiry, learning of a potential suspect
profile bears similarities to this case.
They then start to look at similar crimes and similar offenders. They know
this individual has a predilection for young boys and has a sexual interest in
schoolboys. And so they head to the north of Scotland, Aberdeen, where
have apprehended a man who has been sexually assaulting a young boy there.
custody that day is Brian Longfield.
Field himself said he had nothing to do with the Surrey incident, nothing to do
with Tuttle's disappearance.
Despite the obvious similarities of the two attacks, there was nothing that a
Surrey police could take from this connection at all.
With no evidence linking him to the murder of Roy Tuttle, Brian Field is
as a suspect.
So the investigation went on for years with very little leads.
Scotland Yard were called in to assist.
They couldn't find anything to further the investigation.
Every now and then they would put out an appeal for information and somebody
would come forward with something fresh, but it never led anywhere.
Although it remained high profile, they never got anywhere with finding out who
had killed Roy.
There does come a period in time where you've exhausted all of your inquiries
that you can conduct, you've looked at all of the leaks that you've got,
all come to a dead end, and you still have to start shutting things down.
Because you start shutting things down doesn't mean to say it comes to an end.
And of course, over the years, if they had other pieces of information coming
in, they would take the files off the shelves and they would pursue these
of information to see if they could identify who was responsible.
Sadly, they were unlucky, unfortunate.
and just couldn't identify a suspect.
By 1996, almost 30 years after schoolboy Roy Tuttle's unsolved murder, his
parents had now passed on without knowing who was responsible for their
death. His brother had moved to America to start a new life, and police were
still working away, trying to catch this killer. Abilities in DNA and forensics
had moved on. Studying again the trousers Roy wore on the day he was
they were able to deliver a DNA profile and a breakthrough in this historic and
unsolved case.
Finally, police have a genetic profile of the killer, but will this
lead to an arrest?
30 years after the murder of 14 -year -old Roy Tuttle, police have finally
a breakthrough with the use of forensic science.
However, their work is still far from over.
By 1996, both of Roy's parents had passed away.
Colin had moved to America.
His, at that point, was the longest unsolved child murder case in Britain.
That wouldn't be the case for much longer though. In that year cold case
were being looked at again.
This was after the introduction of the DNA database a year earlier in 1995.
Forensic technology had advanced in the three decades since Roy's murder.
The cold case review came at the perfect time. In December of 1996 a sample was
recovered from Roy's trousers.
It was semen. So now police had a DNA profile of Roy's killer. They just
a name and a face to match.
In the late 90s, suddenly DNA sourcing exploded. The science suddenly took huge
leaps forward, particularly it helped in forensic police work. Suddenly police
didn't just have a blood group to go on, they had all the integral patterns of
blood and semen to work on, which produced like a passport. It really
narrow down to just single people.
Despite this progress, investigators are unable to match the DNA to a suspect.
Then in 2000, a cold case unit re -examines the case.
I first heard about Roy Tootle and the murder of Roy Tootle in August of 2000.
I was basically the head of CID for Surrey. We were going through a quiet
and one of the DCIs popped his head into the office and said, do you mind if we
start looking at the cold case? And the cold case was...
the one of Roy Tootle. We had time on our hands so we gave the authority for
to pull out all the case files and start seeing what we could find, if there's
anything further we could do.
It's a small team because it was a cold case and in fairness I don't solve
crimes, the team solved the crime.
I'm just the head of the team. There was the DCI who was like a dog with a bone
and they collected all the paperwork.
And what they actually did was, there was a thing called the National Crime
Faculty at that time, in 2000.
This was down at Brams Hill.
And they had started a section called the Seated Crimes Analysis Section. And
they had started doing the analysis of all sex crimes and suspects throughout
the country, bringing all the information together.
They put the files that we had, we put the information that we had in respect
Roy Tootill.
Brian Field re -emerges as a lead suspect.
Detectives look into his past to get a better understanding of the man.
Brian Lunfield is born in 1936 in Market Raisin, a market town with its own
racecourse in a largely rural area.
He doesn't live with his parents, they put him into foster care and he is put
into a home called Lynn Wode House.
So Paul and Ruby Field were actually very well known. He had used all his
to buy a home that he could then adopt children into.
So Brian had 14 siblings. There were 15 of them all together living in this
house. And it was like a bit of an experiment, really, but seemed to the
world to be absolutely perfect.
Paul Field was such a familiar name in the media at that time. Not only was he
awarded an OBE for his services to young children, but he was singled out to
appear on This Is Your Life, which was an enormous programme in the 60s,
presented by Eamon Andrews, primetime, ITV, anything between 13, 15 million
people would tune in to watch the story of this man's life.
He was a familiar figure in the media and on television.
Brian Field was doing national service, but he was given leave to attend the
filming of this programme, along with his... 13, 14 other siblings to support
his foster father and was there on television in his military uniform.
On the outside, in the press, the home has a glowing reputation.
On the inside, for many of the boys there, this is not the case. Other boys
the home accused Brian of abusing them and say in later years Brian had an
obsession, a predilection for sexual abuse.
Aged 15, Brian leaves the foster home, and after a brief spell in the military,
he goes to work for the Milk Marketing Board.
Faithfully, this is a job that allows him to move easily around different
of the country. He sells milk machinery around the West Country, and for a spell
in the late 60s, he also lives in Surrey.
criminal record it started in 1969 when he was in his 30s with a gross indecency
charge in 1972 that case in aberdeen where he'd abducted a young 14 year old
sexually abused him boy managed to escape but he was jailed for that in
he was jailed for four years after abducting two boys aged 13 and 16 though
thankfully they did manage to flee
He put them in the back of his car and as he's driving along he took a tyre
out and said, right you two, take your clothes off.
The boy, scared witless, managed to fight and struggle and get out the car
was driving along the road.
And then Fields was later identified as the driver, arrested and convicted for
that. Had these boys not managed to get out of the car, they would have been
dead. Here's a man who lacked complete empathy and was bordering on the fact of
being a psychopath.
So with all these convictions, it meant that Brian was well -known to police by
this point. He was described as a bit of a Jekyll and Hyde, a hard -working man
when he was sober.
but give him a drink, and he turned into somebody completely different.
So this made him prime suspect, really, for the disappearance of Roy in 1968.
Now in his 60s, Brian Field lived in the small town of Solihull, near
Birmingham, where he's a respected member of the community.
Brian Fields was like many paedophiles in so much that he was intensely devious
and had two sides to his character.
Outwardly, he was charming to people, to his family and friends, was seen as a
hard worker. But his more sinister side would come out, particularly when he was
drunk, and that was he had a vicious and violent temper.
From the 80s and 90s, he was working as a gardener and outdoors as a labourer,
and he built up quite a physique.
So this was an extremely dangerous character in that he had a violent
was very fit and strong, and he had paedophilic tendencies.
This was a horrendous cocktail and put every schoolboy in danger.
With the evidence aligning, the cold case unit is determined to link Brian to
the murder of Roy Tuttle.
Having identified him as a potential suspect was one thing. Being able to
it was a different thing entirely.
So we started...
Making inquiries at Bryanfield, we found out that he was living up in Solihull,
near Birmingham.
And then at the same time, we started to chase up if there was any forensic. We
found that Roy's clothing had been put away at the forensic science laboratory
up in Huntingdon, in Fraser.
They dug the clothes out. We asked for an analysis to be made of the clothing.
And much to our joy, much to our surprise, there was a DNA hit.
And the DNA hit came back to Brian Lund Field.
In September 1999, Brian Field was arrested in Birmingham for drink
After the introduction of the database, it was mandatory to give a DNA sample
after being arrested.
In the year 2000, the DNA sample recovered from Roy's trousers matched
DNA sample taken when he was arrested.
So we had this sort of parallel.
Intelligence suggested it could have been. DNA said it was.
And it's a case of then of a sharp intake of breath because you're now
at 30 years has passed and you're now on the track of a killer. So we set up
surveillance up in Birmingham. We started to watch, identify where Phil
living and we were watching him. I think he was a 64 -year -old man who was very
fit. and agile so it was then a case of getting all of our eggs in one basket
getting all the evidence together and then deciding right we're going to go
arrest them police immediately elated by this sudden explosive new breakthrough
and they placed a field immediately under surveillance just to try and get a
feel of who he is and then amass all the evidence that they have in order to
finally go and arrest him
We lost sight of him for a brief period in time, and I remember jumping in one
of the cars and we hot -footed it up to Birmingham.
And as we got to Solihull, we had identified that it was in his flat and
arrested there.
Members of the community are stunned at his arrest for such a horrific crime.
After he's been released from prison in the 80s, he settled into the Birmingham
area. His marriage broke up, three children no longer live with him,
pursued his life as a gardener, as a labourer, often for cash in hand, which
meant that he didn't have to pay tax or he virtually disappeared.
But those who knew him, who lived around him, thought, what a great guy. He was
down the pub by a drink, amiable, outgoing, a perfect neighbour. Nobody
lived in his area, in his street, or knew him, had any idea whatsoever about
this man's past.
He exploited trust and normalcy as a way to mask his deviance and avoided
detection for decades.
His arrest created genuine shock among those who believed they knew him.
He was taken to Solihull Police Station, where he was booked in, and then he was
driven south down to Surrey. And we had each stage planned out. There was going
to be no conversations in the car.
Everything was going to be done exactly by the book.
So we got him down to Surrey and we had prepared an interview strategy with him.
Obviously you've been arrested for the murder of a boy called Roy Lindsay
Tuttle. Now that boy was a Kingston grammar school boy and he went missing
his way home from school in April of 1968.
Did you ever give any schoolboys a lift in your car at all? No. In 1960?
No, no.
Are you quite sure about that? Yeah, positive.
Did you ever stop and talk to any schoolboys?
Engage them in any kind of conflict? No, no.
Did you murder Roy Tuttle? No, I did not. I don't even know, I've never seen
him. I'm going to show you a photograph of this boy, OK?
OK, and that's a copy of Roy when...
You won't miss him?
No, no, never.
I mean, he looks like a latter lad, really.
No, I've never seen him before.
You're 100 % sure you've never seen this boy before?
Yeah.
He sat down and faced with all the evidence the police had accrued, a
-to -one DNA evidence, his past record of identical attacks.
I think the police immediately expected that Field would crumble. He was now in
his mid -60s and could see that surely there was no way out. In fact, Field
accepted his past behaviour but said that that was all gone, nothing like
now. And what's more, he had...
No knowledge of who this Roy Tuttle was. Had never been in that area at that
particular time all the way back in 1968.
Forget it, I've nothing to do with it.
Police have his DNA, but they want a confession.
Will Brian Field admit to the sexual assault and murder of Roy Tuttle back in
1968?
More than 30 years after the murder of Roy Tuttle, police finally have DNA
evidence linking Brian Field to the crime.
But when questioned, he denies all accountability.
Police now have Field in custody and they put to him that they have a match,
DNA profile that links him to the murder of Roy Tuttle in 1968.
Field announces yes.
I did have an interest in young boys. Yes, I've been convicted of multiple
assaults on young boys and the kidnap of young boys. I don't know anything about
this case. This was not me.
The lack of response from Field may have taken police by surprise, but they
immediately went off to magistrates to apply for an extension to the custody
time limits, i .e. to keep him under arrest for longer before they had to
the decision whether to charge him or to release him. At the end of the second
day of questioning, they told Field that tomorrow we're going to have to take
fresh DNA evidence from you and match that up.
The last thing we were going to do that night was get a DNA sample from him.
So we requested a DNA sample from him, which he supplied, and then we let him
stew overnight.
And he obviously started to put two and two together. So therefore the following
day when he was brought out for interview, he sat down, I've got to tell
something.
He confessed in detail to the abduction, rape and murder of Roy Tuttle.
I'm sorry, I've misled you all the time.
I didn't do that. I've been to prison.
I'm sorry.
I'm sorry.
All right.
All right.
Look at me.
Give me a minute.
It's important now, for everyone concerned, that we finish this.
Yeah, it's gone on a long, long time.
Yeah, yeah.
OK.
I was driving around it.
to the road.
And I told him, you know, come, get off the bus.
And the son -in -law, I'm sure he's son -in -law, he stood there.
And I stopped and he got in.
And I asked him where he was going.
Do you mean the car?
Yeah. What do you do?
Right, I tried to go in.
Okay, how did you just do that?
You went over the front seat.
And I tried to do it on the front of the crosswalk on the seat.
I thought you'd get thrust again.
But no, I've only come out the other way.
Okay, how did you stay in?
You haven't yet.
Put the tie down, isn't that?
Tighten it.
Can you demonstrate?
Re -age it.
And put it around it now.
Tighten it right now.
You've got to put it through the box a bit.
Put it, cast them for a while and have them carry down. And then suddenly you
won't like them anymore.
Tighten it. You've got to help.
Thank yourself for it.
He proceeded to tell us exactly how he picked up Roy Tootle, how he got him in
the car, how he tried to force him to perform oral sex.
and how he strangled them it's actually quite chilling to watch
how Brian Field describes how he strangled Roy Tootle and then of course
him in the boot of the car and he kept him in the car for a few days We've got
the DNA, we've got his admissions, etc.
But was it possible for him to put him in the boot of a mini? So we got a mini.
We got someone about the size of Roy Tuttle. We tried to get him in the mini
make sure it was physically possible.
So we started to follow up on the results of his interview to try and find
physical corroboration as much as we had the DNA and his admissions, etc.
So an awful part about this is that Brian admits that after dumping Roy's
He then drives to the hospital to visit his wife who has just given birth to
their child.
The fact that he's going to see his wife at the hospital who's just given birth
and he picks a young boy up and kills him tends to suggest that lack of
the lack of feeling, the fact that he's, you know, psychopathic tendencies.
No emotions.
Complete lack of emotion just highlighted the fact that here was a
killer, completely no interest whatsoever in the knock -on effect of
activity, and that a family had been completely destroyed, utterly destroyed.
In contrast to the grief that he had caused, Field's life just went on as
normal.
After compiling the full body of evidence, authorities moved to prosecute
Field for the murder of Roy Cuttle.
A case file which was substantial because of all the information that had
gathered over the years and of course in the year 2000 -2001 there was a
different way of presenting a case at court.
You had a thing called disclosure whereas we had to disclose any material
could potentially undermine a prosecution case and of course within
there was massive potential and it had not been for the DNA and the admission
but nevertheless you still got to go through this disclosure process.
So we bought this scanner that did something like about a thousand pages a
minute and we scanned every single document into this scanner so therefore
had a composite file from the paperwork we put it made it electronic and that
meant we were then able to disclose everything to the defence solicitor who
representing Brian Field.
So eventually the trial date arrives and Brian is taken to the Old Bailey where
his case is heard. Brian pleads guilty to the murder of Roy Tuttle but denies
the sexual assault. And the reason for this is that he will know that he could
be given extra time if he admitted to the sexual assault on top of the murder
charge. So he only admits to the murder and is found guilty of the murder of Roy
Tuttle.
He didn't plead guilty to the sexual assault.
Had he pleaded guilty to the sexual assault and he'd gone to prison,
a sex offender like that, then of course the regime within prison would have
treated him differently.
So being a murderer is one thing, being a murderer with serious sex assault on a
young boy would have been something else.
In November 2001, Brian Field is sentenced to life imprisonment for the
of 14 -year -old Roy Tuttle. He would serve 22 years.
The judge's open court remarks emphasised the importance of DNA
how it was essential for bringing justice for Roy's family.
Field's confession was the first time that the police realised that what Field
was driving was a white Mini, not an Austin Westminster Mark II. All that
of time searching for Austin Westminster Mark II had been completely wasted.
Police at the time obviously weren't to know that. That was the only lead they
had. But it's come as a blow to the pride of the police that they had been
chasing a complete red herring for so long.
There was a lot of relief, the fact that Field was convicted.
There was a lot of relief within the team that he was convicted.
But there was also a lot of relief is that Field was a predator from the day
that he lived in the foster home to the day that he died was a danger to
society.
so there was a great relief the fact that after the conviction failed
harm anyone else this was a huge story for the media not only was it the
-running cold case success and that it was finally a killer court after 33
but the Throwback to those of us who were there in the 60s. The newspapers,
black and white pictures of Roy looking at this schoolboy. Pictures of what
happened in Chessington in 1968.
Remarkable how evocative those pictures can be.
Field was a persistent, aggressive paedophile who'd proven that he was
of taking schoolboys off the streets and abusing them. This was somebody that
kidnapped two young boys after Roy Tuttle's death. Thankfully, they escaped
had abused another 14 -year -old boy on another occasion.
Police looked at his profile and were linking him to any number of assaults
any other number of missing children.
for cases that they hadn't found, but as yet they don't currently have the DNA
breakthrough to convict him on any other charges.
Phil is a practised psychopathic offender. He is able to behave without
empathy, without any humanity.
Even though he's able to keep up a veneer of respectability as a working
family man, he is somebody that was an ever -present danger to children.
and somebody under drink or without drink was able to act on these inhuman,
beastly impulses in the middle of the day. This is somebody that snatched a
child off the road at the end of the school day. This is somebody that acted
broad daylight, that acted in public and acted even though he had multiple
sentences for this kind of behaviour.
This is somebody that was not going to be stopped.
Field ultimately died behind bars at the age of 87 in 2024 at HMP Full Sutton
from natural causes.
Of serenity, he denied his victims.
You meet with the brother and you meet with Paddy Doyle and you saw what it
meant to them and you then get this stark realisation that after 30 years,
this was solvable, then potentially any cold case is solvable. All you really
have to do...
is look hard enough and look for the opportunities and look for the clues.
And it gave me confidence in going forward that cold cases are actually
investigating. Because had we not arrested Brian Field, then he would have
continued to offend and potentially kill other people.
Despite finally closing the case on his murder, there weren't many left alive
who knew Roy to witness justice being served.
So tragically, the parents of Roy never got to see justice done. They never got
to learn who had killed their child.
But the reaction to Brian being found guilty or even being accused of this
was incredible.
He had built a whole new life in Birmingham and people there thought he
wonderful. He was a regular at the pub. They had a whip round for his 60th
birthday, something which was unheard of. He was a really popular man. And
people heard of his arrest... They absolutely said the police had got the
person. I could not believe that he could be responsible for anything quite
heinous as this murder of a young boy.
The Roy Tuttle story has stayed with me for countless years.
When he was killed, he was 14 and I was 12. I had a bike, I had a train set, the
two things he'd set his heart on as well, and I went to school in 1968 on a
And I look back... On all those years, how lucky I was to lead a life that I
have, and how lucky I've been to live as many years as I have. And if only Roy
had even a slice of the luck that I had, he would never have ended in such a
gruesome, degrading, humiliating, terrifying murder that he had to
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.