All language subtitles for The.Witness.2015.1080p.BluRay.x264-[YTS.AM]

- Go on through the right.

Here we are.

- If you don't mind,
I'm gonna check out

sort of sight lines here.

- Sure.

-I was 16 when my sister
Kitty was murdered

in New York City.

In an instant she was gone.

No one understood me
like Kitty.

-Two weeks ago today

twenty minutes after 3:00
in the morning

it was a dark night.

Kitty Genovese, 28 years old,
drove her car

into this parking lot
at the Kew Gardens Station

of the Long Island Railroad as
she had been doing for a year.

She stopped, saw a man
against the wall

she didn't quite make it
halfway down the block

before the killer
drove a knife into her.

-I heard the screaming,
and I went to, uh,
the bedroom window

and I saw some girl
on her knees

and she was screaming,
"Help, help."

-Just exactly what was it
you heard?

- "Save me, save me."

-Didn't this frighten you
or shock you?

- No.

- Fifteen years ago, a young
woman was stabbed to death

in front of a Queens,
New York apartment

half a block from her home.

- Tomorrow marks
what many people regard

as one of the most
shameful anniversaries

in New York City history.

-Fifty years ago, her murder

led to the adoption
of the 911 system.

- Police discovered
that more than 30 people

had witnessed her attack

and no one had picked up

the phone to call the police.

-Lights came on
in the apartment building

a window opened, the attacker
got nervous and left

but not a single person
came to the rescue

no one even called
the police at a time

when the average response time
was 2 minutes.

So the man came back
and stabbed her again.

It sent a chilling message
suggesting that we were

each of us,
not simply endangered..

...but fundamentally alone.

-Two weeks after
my sister Kitty's funeral

the "New York Times" published
a front-page story.

It barely mentioned
her killer.

Instead it focused
on Kitty's neighbors

and practically blamed
38 of them for her death.

"The Times" story
was seen as proof

that New York City
was uncaring

that America was
falling apart.

And my sister's been
the symbol

of bystander apathy
for decades.

The girl no one cared about.

But recently "The Times"
published a new article.

It challenged the accuracy

of its original report.

And others now claim
the story of 38 witnesses

is more myth than fact.

What did the witnesses
actually see or hear?

Were there really 38?

Why didn't they try
to help my sister?

For years, I avoided
the details of that night

because they were just
too painful

but it's worse
not knowing the truth.

-Mr. Skoller?

- Bill?
-Yeah.

- Hi.
-How you doing?

- Alright. How are you?
Charlie Skoller.

-Bill Genovese.
- How are you, Bill?

-Nice to meet you.

Going around here

is anxiety provoking.

- Are you sure
you wanna do this?

This has to be
very difficult for you.

- No, I absolutely

I absolutely wanna do it.

It's interesting. When you
drive back here it's --

You know, when you're out
on Queens Boulevard there

it seems so,
for me anyway, city-ish.

Here now you're in this really
nice neighborhood.

-This block is
all residential

one-family homes.

Pull into this parking lot.

Because that's where
your sister pulled her car

into this lane.

And this is where

Winston Moseley caught up to her

and struck the first blows
to her back.

Many of your sister's
neighbors

really heard everything
that was going on,
heard the screams

knew that an attack
was taking place

and knew
that it was a violent attack.

It wasn't that your sister
was just screaming and screaming

she was yelling, "Help, help,
I'm being stabbed."

That was not just screams alone.

And Joseph Fink was seated
in the lobby of the Mowbray.

He was the night
elevator operator

and he saw the entire
first attack take place

from beginning to end..

...and he knew exactly
what was happening.

And instead of doing anything,
he got on the elevator

went downstairs,
went to his apartment

and went to sleep.

Now, as she was being attacked
in this hallway

Karl Ross looked down

and he saw
that second attack take place.

And he went to the telephone

called his girlfriend.

She said, "Don't get involved."

- It just kills me to think
that when he first looked down

he could have ended it
right there by doing something.

He could have yelled down, "I'm
calling the police." And that --

-Yes. Or, "The police
are on their way."

- How much time do you think,
if you can remember

from the first attack
to when he finds her again?

- I would say about a half
an hour, possibly 40 minutes.

Long enough for somebody
to have called the police

and for the police
to have arrived

and probably to save
your sister's life.

-Turns out,
I'm not the first

to look for these witnesses.

-We traced Karl Ross
to this pet store

but we found that he'd sold it.

The new people here kindly
agreed to contact him for us

but Karl Ross remains silent.

Mr. Koshkin, I wanted
to ask you one more time

if you would speak to us?

-20/20 had no luck

interviewing witnesses
in 1979.

If I was going
to have more success

Charlie Skoller suggested

that I start
with the trial transcript.

My family couldn't bear
to go to the trial in 1964

so I never heard the testimony
of the witnesses.

Only 5 of the 38 witnesses
were called to take the stand.

Samuel Koshkin, Robert Mozer

Sophie Farrar, Andree Picq

Irene Frost.

-I heard a shriek.

I got outta bed,
went to the window

and I saw a man and a woman

standing across the street

by the bookstore.
I looked at them for a minute.

Nothin' happened,
so I got back to bed.

The second time she screamed
"Please, help me, God.

Please help me.
I've been stabbed."

I went to the window,
and as I got there

she was kneeling down
on the sidewalk

and he was running
up the street.

-Did you know
Irene Frost at all?

She worked
for your grandfather.

-Oh yeah, oh yeah.
I know the name well.

My grandfather didn't know
much about running
the business

and apparently
I -- Irene stole

several $100,000 from him

so her name
doesn't sit too favorably

in the Hirsch family.

- Now, do you know
if she's alive

or dead at this point?

-Oh, she's long dead.

-I saw this girl
at the bookstore kneeling

and this fellow had her down
bending over her.

And I hollered,
"Hey, get out of there."

And he jumped up and ran.

He ran like a scared rabbit.

I never saw anybody
take off as quick.

-I heard the voice upstairs.

Suddenly, the neighbor's
screaming something

and the man ran away
very fast, near the bus stop.

The poor girl get up slowly..

...and she screamed, "Help!"

And walking slowly
toward the drugstore

and up towards
the back street.

I was still at the window

scared, kind of frozen.

And a few minutes
after that man came back

walking normally
as if nothing happened.

And then he went down
to the train station

and then he came out again

and left in the back

and I could not see anything..

...but I heard
the last 2 screams.

"Help, help."

-Hi, is this
the Michael Farrar
from Kew Gardens?

Michael, I just
recently found out

that your mom was with my sister
when she passed away.

I was wondering if she'd be
willing to talk to me?

- My mom, she really
liked Kitty.

And, you know, she can't get
around no more

but I spoke to her
and she told me stuff

that I couldn't hear when I was
younger, what happened and all.

We'll get into that later.

- This was Kitty's
apartment here.

- On this side?
- Right here, yes.

- And then yours
is straight ahead?

- Yes.

This room here,
this was my room.

Kitty's window is right there.

When I went
to school sometimes

if Kitty would have coffee

and toast with my mom.

Kitty confided in her a lot.

They were friends
and they talked

about whatever women

talked about, you know.

-So that night,
what happened?

I mean, in your house,
what happened?

- A -- a scream,
a loud, loud scream

a horrible,
blood curdling scream

and it woke me up.

- How many people
do you think heard it?

- Just looking at the windows,
about 40, 50

could be 60
because it was so loud.

Uh, the whole neighborhood
had to hear it.

And this neighborhood
back in the 60s

I remember
a lot of the older people

they had numbers on their arms

they were
in concentration camps.

That type of a person
might not wanna get involved

with authorities because
of what happened
with the Nazis

so, you know, you can't blame
people for being afraid.

But that night
when I walked up the hallway

my parents were up, out,
this window was open

and my father was looking out
the window.

Well, he didn't see anything

so my parents went back to bed.

About 20 minutes later or so

somebody called my mom

and that's when my mom
said to my father

"Kitty's in the hall bleeding."

And she just grabbed her jacket
and threw it on.

And she started to run

and my father was putting
his pants on

and he says,
"Wait, wait for me."

And she ran down.

- So she comes in, it's 3:30
in the morning or thereabouts

and it's freezing cold.

- It was cold March..

...and this is actually
the doorway.

When my mom tried to open
the door, it hit Kitty

and she was facing her head
towards the door

her feet towards the stairs

and my mother had to push
the door in to get in.

She held her,
and she could feel

the stab wounds in her back

and her hands kept going,
still fighting

and my mom
finally calmed her down

but she couldn't talk
and she started to gurgle.

That was her, she was just
passing then

she was dying, so --

Hours later I opened the door

and the whole bottom
of this foyer was blood.

But you could actually
smell the blood.

You know, it's like something
you don't forget.

It's like walking
in an old butcher shop

how you could smell that
the -- the human, the meat.

It -- You know, it --

The prints on the wall
were marked in pencil

1, 2, 3, 4, 5.

And it wasn't until
I was talking to my mother

and I said when I looked in,
I saw the handprint.

And she says, "That was
my fingerprints on the wall."

- Your mom?
-Yeah.

'Cause when she went
to get up, she was like

she went and she put her hands
on the wall.

My mom spoke to one woman
from a newspaper back then

and she told her what happened
and the woman says

you know, "Would you do that
again, if you had to? "

And my mother says,
"Certainly, of course."

When the paper come out,
it says my mom said

that she would never get
involved with it

and that's when my mother says,
"lt don't pay to talk

because they twist
what you say."

And that's, she never said
anything since...you know.

- Do you think your mother
would talk to me?

- I -- I'll twist her arm
a little, you know,
but I think she would.

- Not, not too hard, but --

- I think that she would
do that.

- Thank you so much.

- I wish it could have been

different circumstances.

Alright?
- Yeah, really.

- You know, give the best
to your family and --

-Why was Sophia left out
of the original story?

It would have made such
a difference to my family

knowing that Kitty died
in the arms of a friend.

Truth is my family
doesn't know much
about Kitty's murder.

The only time we learned
any details of that night

was in 1995.

That's when the killer
appealed for a retrial.

It briefly brought us
face to face with the man

who murdered and attempted
to rape Kitty.

Hearing those details
for the first time

was unbearable for me
and my siblings.

- Speaking for myself..

...it never goes away.

I never forget the day

that the policemen
in New Canaan

came to our door,
knocked on it..

...and told us what happened.

- It was very early
in the morning

and the doorbell went off

and I think
I was awakened by that

and I heard
the -- the conversations.

And then, then, then

just ex -- extreme

like piercing, screaming.

And then freezing in my bed.

-My mother, my mother
was a basket case.

My father was also.

My father couldn't even
identify my, my, uh

sister's body in the morgue. He
had to send his brother there.

- And the neighbors
are all like

"Oh, my God,
what can we do for you? "

And it's like, uh --

"Why don't you take,
why don't you take Frank? "

I -- I just went off
to the McSweeny's.

I was with them for weeks.

I never even went
to my sister's funeral.

It was all over the news,
everywhere.

So, I got a lot
of my information

just from sneaking maybe,
and turning on a TV and --

-The only thing we could
think about is the tragedy.

We almost erased her
from our lives.

Bill, it's hard to say
how he handled it.

I -- I -- I really, you know,
we really never sat down

and talked about it.

She took a --
a shine to Billy.

She spent a lot of time
with him.

-Kitty and I were separated
when I was 6.

That year my parents decided

the city
was getting too dangerous

so we left
for New Canaan, Connecticut.

Kitty had already
graduated high school

and much to my parent's
frustration

she decided
to stay in the city.

For the next 10 years,
I only saw her on weekends

when she would come to visit.

We'd have a lot of fun driving
around in her red Fiat.

But the best part was talking
late into the night.

Kitty seemed to know
about everything.

And I was a curious kid
and asked a lot of questions.

Kitty always took the time
to answer them.

For decades, the identity
of the so called 38 witnesses

has been a mystery.

If I was going to track
any of them down

first I'd have to find out
who they were.

I requested
all the information
on my sister's murder

from the New York police
department.

They sent me copies
of the original detective

accounts of witness interviews
called DD5's.

-I saw her, she was wearing
a black coat and high heels

and the coat was held
around her body.

She was a, a small girl --
-Terrific scream.

-What I thought at first
was some cat --

-It sounded like a child.

-And I looked out to see
and I couldn't see anything.
-Otherwise I --

-The police want to know
your name and everything
and they get people involved.

These kind of people don't
want to get involved.
-Why didn't we do something?

-I mean, I -- I feel
a terrible guilt.

-Much of the reports
were illegible.

And almost all the names
had been redacted.

I was at a dead end
without the names.

But I thought of someone
who might be able to help.

- 20/20 has gone back
to reexamine

what has become
a classic case

not of crime,
but of social behavior.

-Hello?
-Aram?

-Yes.
-This is Bill Genovese.

My sister was Kitty Genovese.

-Oh, yes.
Oh, my goodness.

- Did you, did you have any
luck in reaching
any of the witnesses?

-I did try
to track them down, yes.

I used to have a file.

Uh, I have some stuff
at Columbia

and, uh, if it were anywhere

it could be there.

-The list Aram had found

contained summarized versions

of the witness accounts.

Most importantly,
it had the names.

These statements
from the neighbors

matched the DD5 reports.

So Aram's list must have come
from the police interviews.

When I added up the number

of entries, there were 38.

Could these be
the 38 witnesses?

Lynne, I presume.
- Yes, Bill, I presume.

-Yes, and you're Tod.
- This is Tod. Bill.

- Uh, Bill.
-How're you doing?

- Good.
Can I help?

- Nah, I'm good.
- Okay.

- Can't we help you?

- Over here, yeah.

So, you lived
in the Mowbray?

What apartment, what floor?

- Second floor. 214.

- Did you feel
like the neighborhood was safe?

- Yes.

- Cause you were 19, 20

around 1964.

Did you feel you could come
and go in the evening?

- Oh, yes,
but I could see people

and they would just pull down
the shades or --

There was a fear.

There was a fear
in that building, I think.

-What was your experience
that night?

- I heard a scream.
It woke me up.

I looked out the window,
I didn't see anything

I didn't hear any more.

And I said, "Oh, well."
I went back to sleep.

- Did it wake your parents up?

- No, as far as I know.

The next morning
the detectives were pounding
on the door

and I told them what I had,
you know, experienced.

- Yeah.

- Do you think you were
1 of the 38

that were reported
to have done nothing?

- I -- I supposed I could be

I could be counted
in with that.

-Hmm.
When the police --

- Because I woke up

I looked out the window...
and I went back to bed.

But I wasn't in that group.
-Yeah.

- I -- I, that was not my
behavior in that, in that.

-Yeah.
- Yeah.

- In my research, your name
and your mom's name

is down there as saying

"I heard, George, he's --"
Eh, let me get it right

"George, he's, he's done it
to me.

George, he's done it to me."
Twice.

And then, "Please help me."

So, you and your mom

you were probably counted
as part of the 38.

And, according
to your remembering

your mom never said anything?

- No, as far as I know, she
never spoke to the police
at all.

-Yeah.

-Wow, I have no idea
who George is

but I, I never heard
of anything like that.

And as far as I know
momma was asleep.

That is shocking.

Wow.

- Come on in.
- Hello.

- How are ya?
- You're Hattie?

- Yes.
- Hi, Bill Genovese.

- Nice to meet you.
- How're you doing?

- Nice strong grip.

-Were you ever interviewed
by the police?

- Yes, I think I was, yeah.

- This is what they recorded
anyway, that you said to them.

"Hattie Grund, saw a woman
screaming, "Help."

"She was standing
in front of cleaners.
No male was present."

- That's true. I heard somebody
saying "Help, help.."

...from what I recall
and then I called the police.

- You called the police?
-Always.

And they said,
"We already got the calls."

- Hmm.
-I didn't even finish
my statement.

And they said,
"We've already gotten the call."

It wasn't that people
didn't call.

There might have been other
people that called..

...because once you got
the police station

before you could finish they
said, "We've gotten the calls."

- When news reporters, uh,
came to talk to you, uh

were they pushing the, you
know, the witness story
and asking --

- Oh yeah, they were persistent
in getting information,
you know.

And that's the thing Kew Gardens
got a little aroused

when they said they were,
we were apathetic.

We were not. There are always
a few people that call.

-After hearing
Hattie Grund claim

she and others
called the police.

I requested the police log
of phone calls
from that night.

The only call they list
is from Karl Ross

well after Moseley was gone.

Did the police fail
to log the calls?

Or did Hattie just create
a story she could live with?

A witness who doesn't know
she's a witness.

So many other missed details
of that night.

Like the fact that Kitty
didn't die alone.

How could anything be believed
about this story?

I never questioned it.

Two years after Kitty's death

I graduated high school.

The Vietnam War
was in full swing.

Many of my peers were looking
for ways not to serve.

Whether the war
was right or wrong

I couldn't help but see them

as apathetic bystanders.

I wasn't going to be like
the 38 witnesses

So I enlisted in the Marines.

And at 18, you're going off
to war and you're thinking

"I'll come home okay."

-I think he's looking
for the ultimate inner peace.

The choices that he made
in his life

um, were all related to the fact

that no one
helped his sister.

And if he knows the truth,
that's a peacefulness.

I mean, I'm hoping for Bill
that there'll be closure.

You know, like he didn't
lose his legs

in Vietnam for nothing.

-The version of the story
that was accepted as fact

for so many years was written

by the late reporter
Martin Gansberg.

His editor at "The Time"

was a man named Abe Rosenthal

who became a major figure
in journalism.

From what I've found,
it's Rosenthal

who's credited with breaking
the story.

And later that year

he wrote a book called
"38 Witnesses."

-This story has never died.

I still get mail about it,
people write theses about it.

There are lectures
and seminars at universities.

They are obsessed
by this story.

It's like a jewel.

You keep looking at it

and different things
occur to you.

It's affected my approach
to life, I think.

-Okay, sir.

-According to his book,
he first heard
my sister's name

when he had lunch
with the city's police chief

10 days after the murder.

- I was, uh, nauseated
at the idea

that people in New York City

in Queens, knew that a girl
was getting killed.

And later they dis,
it was discovered

that 38 people
didn't do anything.

It was the failure
of New York City

or the people
of New York City

to take action, stick out
a hand, do something.

- Right.
- Shout, "Hey, we need help."

And that was what grabbed
the people of the city

and other cities.

- Well, where did
the number 38 come?

I wonder was it synthesized
somehow to make a big impact?
- No.

-So that we could
get a positive.

I mean,
for a positive result --

- You asked the question
and I'm telling you.

I can't swear to God

that there were 38 people.

Some people say
there were more

some people say
there were less

but what was true..

...people all over the world

were affected by it.

Did it do anything?

You bet your eye
it did something.

And I'm glad it did.

-Forty years after
the original article appeared

the "New York Times"
reexamined their account.

They acknowledged
some of the original
article's flaws

and highlighted the questions
surrounding the story.

Most of the revisionist
information

came from Joe DeMay.

A Kew Gardens resident
and amateur historian.

- I sat down and I read
through the article

and when it was all through
I thought to myself

"What the heck this,
this can't make

this doesn't make
any sense at all."

If you read
through the article

the first paragraph
is crystal clear

and absolutely riveting.

For more than half an hour

38 respectable,
law-abiding citizens

in Queens watched
a killer stalk
and stab a woman

in 3 separate attacks
in Kew Gardens.

Well, turns out there weren't
38 eyewitnesses at all.

The witnesses to the case,
with one or two exceptions

were ear witnesses,
not eye witnesses.

What happened is this.

There was an initial attack
on Austin Street

that was broken off,
the killer fled.

Your sister then got up
and she walked around

to the back of the building.

The people in the apartment
building could not

have seen her for more
than a couple of minutes.

When they saw him come back
the few witnesses

that were still at their
windows, Kitty was long gone

as far as they knew
she was some place safe.

So, yeah, the story
was generally correct

but in a lot of the important
details it was grossly

exaggerated and simply
not true.

-When I first came upon
his website

my first reaction
was to sort of brush it off.

But then I came back
and read it very closely

and realized, "Wow, his argument
is incredibly compelling."

If the story had been reported
more accurately

it still would have been
a 2 or 3 day

maybe -- maybe even 4 day story

but it would not have been
a 50 year story.

We would not still be sitting
here talking about it today.

- Did anybody ever challenge
the 38 witness

38 eyewitness story?

- Yeah. Not at the time.

Not in 1964.
In fact to the contrary.

Other newspapers, other
magazines, "Li-Life Magazine"

ran with it and then even
exaggerated it further.

-This is Mike Wallace.

Why did 38 people fail to act?

The answer to that question
concerns every one of us

who fears perhaps that apathy

has become part
of our way of life.

-The question becomes

was it worth
all the attention it got

or was it a media creation?

- Oh, I think to a certain
degree it was a media creation.

No one investigated the 38.

No one followed up on it
or anything of that nature.

- Do you have any feel
for why that would have been

with this case
versus any other case?

- Because it was taken
seriously

by "The New York Times."

The reason I picked up on it..

...was because Abe Rosenthal
is a man I respect.

Good reporter, in a position
of authority

at "The New York Times."

I mean, "The Times" had, still
does, but back then particularly

had that kind of clout.

It's a fascinating...
troubling story.

And undoubtedly,
sold newspapers.

- Hi, is this Mr. Lelyveld?
-Yes, sir.

-When did you start working
at "The Times? "

-I became a reporter
in 1963, I guess.

- Do you think the original
"Times" story is accurate?

-I remember feeling
it was a little skimpy.
- Yeah.

-That it, that it reached
its judgment quickly.

- Have you ever heard
of a woman named Sophia Farrar?

-No.

-Sophia Farrar actually did

go down to be with her

as soon as she found out
about it.

-And did the police list her

as a witness in their reports?

- Yeah, she testified in court.

-And she's not mentioned
in "The Times" story?

- No.

-Well, that's just, uh

that's inexcusable then.

The question would be
why the competition

didn't look into it.

- Hi, Richard Wald?
-Speaking.

-You were the managing editor

at "The New York Herald
Tribune" in '64?

Did "The Tribune"
ever write a story

about how "The Times"
covered the story of 38?

-No, I don't remember
"The Tribune" ever doing that.

Let's assume you were
a reporter on the scene.

If you had a sense
that it didn't happen

that way,
I would have assigned people
to go and check.

- Right.

-But I don't know
any reporter

who felt that way.

- Mr. Pressman.
- Hi, Bill. How are you?

- Good. I'm good.

-In 1964,
I was a reporter at WNBC

and I had no first hand
knowledge of the story

but my friend Danny Meenan
covered the story.

At this point
he was doing radio

I believe for WMCA,
and, uh

among all the police reporters
I've known

and I've known many,
he was one of the best

if not the best.

He said, "The story doesn't make
any sense to me."

And he gave me an account of

uh, what he found.

And it says here,
"There were many witnesses.

"Some 30 odd in the number.

"One conclusion all seemed
to have, it was a drunken brawl

between man and wife."

Martin Gansberg, the author

of the "Page One Story"
in "The Times"

which caused the furor,
was challenged

by this irate reporter.

"Why didn't you include
in your story

"the fact that many
witnesses did not

believe a murder
was taking place? "

Gansberg replied..

"...It would have ruined
the story."

-That to me is incredible.

It's curious to me why,

and I'm not trying
to blame Danny Meenan

or yourself or anybody else
but why --

how come people didn't call
"The Times" out on that?

- Because it was
"The New York Times"

and Danny, you know,

he had to continue
to hold on to his job.

I don't think that he
probably was interested

in taking on Abe Rosenthal
and "The New York Times."

A couple of years passed,

I was teaching a course

and this seemed
to be something

that the class
would want to explore.

A couple of the people
in my class being enterprising

I guess you would say,
called Rosenthal.

And Rosenthal called me.

He was really angry,
he was screaming at me.

"Do you realize," said Rosenthal

"that this story has become

emblematic of a situation
in America? "

"That it's become the subject
of sociology courses

books and articles."

And I think that
that is abhorrent

to anyone
who is interested in truth.

-For me to hear that,
it's just shocking

because I grew up and moved
in certain directions

based on this story
being fact.

But indeed it was
not totally fact.

- Did they say why they just
sat there doing nothing

while that girl
screamed for help?

- They all had
the same answer.

They didn't wanna get involved.

- A young woman
stabbed 14 times

then raped
outside her building.

- While 40 of her neighbors
turned up their TVs

so they couldn't
hear the screams.

- If you're a witness
in one of these things,
you know what you gotta do?

Put on a shirt and tie,
you gotta go down to court --

- So because of a little
inconvenience

you don't wanna get involved?!

- Listen, let me explain
something to you, huh?

Shut up!

-You look at things
that happen in the world

and that's one of the ways
that you decide

what course
you're gonna take.

And if those things
aren't accurate

then you could
chart the wrong course.

If Kitty Genovese

is a name
that immediately summons

something to people's minds

then that thing that gets
summoned should be the truth.

- So, that's everyone who,
who saw --

-These are witnesses.

-Witnessed in some way,
at least heard something.

And A.M. Rosenthal's the guy
who wrote "38 Witnesses."
- Right.

-The truth of the matter is,
38 people didn't see it.

- Okay.

Dr. and Mrs. Rubenstein
heard screams, "Help, help

they're killing me."

-You know, I often wondered

how much detail
Billy would get into.

- "He heard a woman scream
at about 3 o'clock."

-So and so did this,
so and so opened the window,

so and so shouted,
so and so --

For what? She's dead.

She's murdered,
you know.

I don't want --
Why do I wanna hear that?

- "Standing over her
and repeatedly striking her.
The girl then --"

-I personally never heard
a story

from my dad's family members
about Kitty.

I think her death
overshadowed her life

for anybody involved with it.

- In some ways there was this
hush-hush about her life

because they couldn't talk
about her death.

It probably made it
more traumatic

because they weren't able
to celebrate her life.

They were focusing
on her death
by hiding the fact

that she was even alive
to begin with.

-I mean, to me,
she's a picture in a magazine.

I know her from things
I read on Wikipedia

or Googled or read randomly
in a book

when I was in high school
in English class

and didn't realize
it was my aunt

until about half-way through.

I know how she died.
- Yeah.

- That's the story
I could tell you.

-Inside, dad?
- Yeah.

One more.

As you're beating your head up
against the wall

and having to relive
this murder scene

over and over again, it's like,
you know, you stop and say

"Why the hell
am I doing this?

This is, like, nuts.

I don't know, I guess
the message for me

and why I can't stop until
I feel like it's over.

-Yeah, when is it over?

- I -- I'll know
when it's over.

Let me just describe something
really quickly.

My sister Kitty, for you,
would be

a combination of mom and me.

So imagine that.

Mom and I both get murdered
on the street.

- Well, see, I never knew
it was like that for you.

Like, you've never --

I mean, you've never expressed
it in that way.

- Right.

So the obsessive part of me

that's gotta get
to the end of it

the end isn't reached yet.

There's see -- there's more
bases I'd like to touch.

For instance, like, Kitty
was married, did you know that?

- No, I --
No.

-My sister was so much more
than her final 30 minutes.

But in our late-night talks,

her life in the city
barely came up.

All I knew was
she worked in a bar.

Was briefly married
to a man named Rocco.

In the past few years,
journalists have revealed

that her roommate Mary Ann
was actually her lover.

If I didn't know something
as important as that

how well did I really
know my sister?

Even though I haven't seen him
since I was 6

I decided to reach out
to Rocco.

"Dear Rocco, I've been working
with a filmmaker

for several years
on a documentary about Kitty."

"At this point, I have
questions about her life

"in New York
after high school

and I think you hold the key
to the answers."

"William, I respect
the feeling expressed
in your message

"and I ask you do the same
for mine

which are to respect
my desire for privacy."

"My relations with Kitty shall
remain a mystery forever."

-Hi, pops.

What are you doing?

- I'm reading through
Kitty's yearbook.

"May we dance forever
on each others' feet"

Love and Stuff, Elsa."

So this is where you went
to high school?

-This is where
we went to high school.

And when we played hooky,
we were in that park.

which we did a lot.

-Did Kitty have any
aspirations of going
to college?

-No.

And it's interesting
because she was smart.

But I don't remember her
ever striving for the "A."

Probably 'cause
we were all cut-ups.

Everyone loved Kitty.

She was funny, very witty.

She had an, an enormous
following.

She was a very good mimic
of teachers

particularly
our French teacher.

She would do
the Sid Caesar thing

where she made believe
she was talking French.

To be in Kitty's clique
was a big deal.

We played hooky.

We went to the beach

or here in the park

or smoking on the roof.

And she was the head
of the pack.

-So, you first heard
about Kitty's murder --

- I remember reading the obit.

It said that she was a barmaid.
-Yeah.

- Okay?

And, um, I was, I --

I remember thinking,
"What a pity, what a waste"

that she wound up a barmaid.

- I'm Wally Brosnan, Bill.
- Wally, Bill Genovese.

I was a friend
of Kitty's, too.

- Good. Nice to meet you.
- Hiya, Bill.

- Nice to meet you.
- My pleasure.

-Kitty started out
as a bar maid

but eventually she earned
a position as a bar manager.

Her last job was at a tavern
called "Ev's 11th Hour."

Somehow I didn't
imagine this.

The neighborhood's
changed quite a bit.

- Neither did we.
We didn't imagine it either.

- Big difference.

-When did the bar open?

- 8 o'clock in the morning.

- Now, you better
be here at 8:00.

Or else they'll be
knocking down the door.

- Well, what was she like
in there, was she, you know

if there was trouble, did --
did anybody get into fights?

- She cut off what's his name,
Harry Allerman

she cut him off, told him
he couldn't come in anymore.

- Why, what was he doing,
screamin', yellin'?

- Well, you know,
he was just a drunk.

- So would you, would you --

Was she like a tough person
to deal with?

- No!
- She was a pussycat.

-When, uh, when my
last daughter was born

she came to the hospital
with me.

-Oh, really?
- Yeah.

Yeah, she came
to the hospital with me.

-She was just --
she was just good

like, she'd goof with ya.

You know, you'd goof with her
and she -- right back at you

you know, right back at you.

-What was Ev's bar like?

- Uh, it was like,
uh, cheers.

Everybody knows everybody else
and everybody's business.

-Do you think she liked
working there?

- Oh, she loved it. Yeah.
-Yeah?

- Oh, yeah.
That bar was her home.

She was the queen
of the place.

Some of the people at the bar
used to think I was her
boyfriend.

But I don't think
the people at the bar

had any idea she was gay.

- Hmm.

- I don't, in fact,
I'm positive they didn't
know about it.

- Oh, yeah. Everybody
knew that she was gay.

- Oh, really?
-Oh, yeah. Everybody knew.

And let's put it this way,
she was one of the boys.

I mean, guys used to borrow
money off her.

- Borrow money from her?
-Yeah.

Everybody in there gambled
in one way or another.

- Kitty was arrested
for something

or charged with something.

What was that about?

- Not that I knew of.

-What do you guys
know about that?

- No, I don't,
I don't remember that.

-What she would do

people would give her bets
to give to the bookie.

- Hmm.

And she got caught
in the middle.

People were giving
her bets and they said

"You're booking the horses."
That's, that's what happened.

She got locked up or something
for that one time. Yeah.

- I didn't know my sister
was such a racketeer.

-Apparently,
Kitty's arrest is the source

of the most famous
picture of her.

For years, I wondered
where did this image
come from?

It wasn't until I looked
closely that I noticed

a piece of string
hanging around her neck.

A piece of string
that would have held up

her arrest identification.

So this was her mug shot.

It's hard for me
to picture that Kitty

when I think about the one
we saw when she come to visit.

She seemed right at home
in that role.

But she also seems to have
thrived in New York City.

Zipping around
in her little red Fiat.

Coming home alone
late at night.

There's one more person
who can tell me more about

Kitty's life in the city,
her lover Mary Ann.

She used to come to New Canaan
with Kitty on weekends.

I assumed
they were just roommates.

After Kitty died, we never
spoke to her again.

She declined to be
interviewed on camera.

But she did agree to let me
record our conversation.

Mary Ann, I --
I was always curious

how did you and Kitty meet?

-It was either
the Duchess or the Sea Colony

I don't remember the name.

I was sitting at the bar
having a beer

and this woman comes up
to me and said

"Don't I know you
from somewhere? "

I said, "Well, no."

So then I said, "Well, I live
at 74th and Broadway."

I had a room and there's
a payphone across the street.

And so somehow she found it.

So I had a note on the door
when I came back home.

"I'm gonna call you at 7:00
on this payphone."

So she called me.

I fell very much
in love with her. Mmm.

-Do you think Kitty
was in love with you as much?

-I'm not sure.

I think she had conflicts
about being gay.

Because we would have,
we would have arguments
around this.

I think in time,
she would have worked it out.

But she didn't have
the chance.

-On the 13th, did you hear
anything that night?

-This is hard because
I blocked a lot of this out.

The police woke me up.
They knocked on the door.

-Hmm.

-We went down to the morgue,
4 o'clock in the morning.

That's when I identified her.

I remember sitting
outside on the bench

and they said,
"We're gonna take you home."

I said, "No, I'm gonna
wait for her."

-What about Karl Ross,
do you remember him?

-She cried out to him, right?
-Yeah.

-He had the pet shop,
that's how we met him.

-Oh!
-He got the poodle for me.

We had an argument
and she bought it for me.

His name was Andrew.

Somewhere around the funeral,
your father,
he came down there

and he said, "I want the dog
because it's Kitty's."

I said, "No, it's mine."

Thanksgiving afternoon

I woke up, the dog
was just gone.

Just gone.
I never saw him again.

-I remembered,
after Kitty passed

Andrew appears at our house.

And I thought it was my dad's
way of cheering my mother up.

And it did just the opposite.
-Hmm.

-I remember her saying,
"The dog needs to go back."

Then he disappeared.

I can't, I mean,
that's terrible.

I apologize
for my family for that.

That's -- that's awful.

-A trauma can be so bad

that it tears you up,
but somehow you have to heal

but right now,
I haven't healed.

You know, you feel you could
have saved somebody

if you only knew?
That's what I feel.

-I totally understand that.

-I slept with her shirt
for a long time.

-What do you think needs
to happen for you to heal?

-I don't know.
I really don't know.

Have you ever gone
to his parole hearings?

-No.

-Maybe facing him
and seeing this

reprehensible human,
not even human being

would make me say,
"That's it."

-You say that you remember
almost nothing of the murder?

- The details of it, no.

-Uh, it -- it sort of

it -- the length of time

when it was reconstructed
was approximately 32 minutes.

Is a total blank?

- I remember the street.

I remember the act itself..

...but the details, no.

-You remember the act itself?
- Yes.

-And what was it?

- The act was the --
the swinging of a knife.

And that, uh,
really doesn't take a lot

to kill a person, I guess.

-Could anything be gained
from sitting down

with Winston Moseley?

In his 49 years in prison,
I never seriously
considered it.

In his 49 years in prison,
I never seriously
considered it.

After all, Moseley not only
killed my sister

he destroyed my family.

My parents
never really recovered.

My mother had a stroke
the year after Kitty's murder.

My father died of a stroke,
when he was only 59.

My mother's faith got her
through those years

and she said she forgave
Moseley in her heart.

Before I try to meet him
face to face

I need to know more about him.

-Winston Moseley
was arrested 5 days
after my sister's murder

while stealing a television
from a house in Queens.

This time, a neighbor
was good enough to intervene.

-How are you, sir?
- I'm good.

- So, he saw Winston
going into the house?

- Well my father was sitting
on a porch like he usually did.

He saw this gentleman
went into Banister's home

and my father says,
"What are you doing here? "

And he made a break
down the hill

and my father catches him

fell on top of him
and he couldn't move.

So he just called
the police department.

They came right away.

They put him in a patrol car
and took him away.

- His demeanor was what?

- He was just
as calm as can be.

-Really?

- Just as calm as can be.

And nobody came to my father's

to the house when we lived here

to sit down and say thank you.

You're the only one.

-Somebody brought
in this small

meek-looking black guy.

And they brought the prisoner

up to the detective office.

One of the detectives
got an idea.

He said,
"Hey, you know that guy

"he looks like
he could be -- match

the description of the --
the person who killed
Kitty Genovese."

the description of the --
the person who killed
Kitty Genovese."

And we started
to question him.

By the time we got done
talking to him

we knew we had one of the, uh,
most bloodthirsty killers

that I had ever met.

- Okay.

- I was sitting
pretty much where you are.

And Winston Moseley sat in that
table right over there.

The best word to describe

Winston Mosley, is ice.

Nothing fazed him at all.

Nothing fazed him.

- My dad was assigned
to represent

uh, Winston Moseley.

I was like a junior partner
in the office at the time

and Moseley was
a very, very bright

and manipulative individual.

He had an lQ of 135.
He had two children.

He had a good, well-paying job.

He was very soft-spoken.

The confession as
to Kitty's killing

just, sort of,
flowed normally as

as part of...
his conversational tone.

- So it was, like,
"I stole a TV and, by the way

I killed this person? "

- Essentially.

-Moseley also confessed
to the murder of a woman

named Annie Mae Johnson.

He murdered her
outside her house

two weeks
before he killed Kitty.

According to Moseley,
he approached her

as she was getting out
of her car at night.

He shot her four times
in the stomach
with a.22 rifle.

He then rolled
her body into the house

and raped her while her
unwitting family members

were upstairs.

She was still breathing

so he wadded up
some newspaper..

...piled them around her,
and lit the house on fire.

Two weeks after
he killed Annie Mae Johnson..

...Moseley crossed
Kitty's path.

While he was
attacking my sister

he knew people were watching.

He heard Robert Mozer
yell down

from the 7th floor
of the Mowbray.

He ran to his car,
sat for a few minutes

and decided that no one
was going to intervene.

So he changed hats
and headed back

to rape and murder my sister.

When he found her inside
the vestibule, Kitty screamed.

He heard the door open
at the top of the stairs

but quickly realized Karl Ross
was going to do nothing.

As he drove away from
Kew Gardens after the murder

Moseley crossed paths
with a driver

who had fallen asleep
at a red light.

He approached the car..

...held his knife
out of sight..

...gently woke
the driver and sent him
safely on his way.

The jury found Moseley guilty
and sentenced him to death.

But Moseley appealed
and his sentence was reduced

to life in prison.

And that should have been
the last anyone

heard of Winston Moseley.

However, in 1968,
Moseley escaped from prison

and terrorized Buffalo,
New York.

Over the next four days

he broke into houses,
raped a woman at gunpoint..

...and took hostages
when the FBl closed in.

Neil Welch ran the FBl office
in Buffalo at the time

and he was the first
to arrive at the scene.

-And I walked
immediately over

and stood in the front
of the building..

...and he said,
"Come in." you know.

He sat in a chair and
we were about 5 or 6 feet apart

and he's got the gun
pointed at me.

I had a gun in my left pocket.

I had a direct shot
right at him.

- But, but in that direct
confrontation

your take on him was..

- Dangerous.
- Yeah.

- But..

Well, I felt comfortable
in talking to him.

I put my hand out and I said

"Let me have the gun, Winston."

You have my guarantee that
you will be treated fairly.

One thing that l,
I was taken aback with

was how small he was.

You know,
I almost expected a larger

presentation of -- of evil.

-Since his escape, Moseley
seems to have transformed
himself.

- I'm going to continue
to try to do positive

instructive things

to try to make up
for those crimes.

-In 1977, he completed
his sociology degree

from the confines of a cell.

That year, he also wrote
an editorial
in the New York Times

claiming he was reformed.

- This process is, is really,
a -- aimed at helping you.

We know that by helping you,
we're probably going to help

Winston, assuming that
he is in a position

to meet with you voluntarily
and whether or not

you know, he's remorseful
for what he did.

So maybe we could start it off
by talking about

you know, what it is
you're trying to accomplish

by having a meeting, uh,
with, uh, Winston Moseley.

- I'm curious as to
what his life was like

over the last 49 years.

Here, he murdered two people.

How does he think about that?
-Mm-hmm.

- What did he think
about the events?

If, if he wants to offer that.
-Mm-hmm.

- If that opens him up to where
he has things he wants to say

so be it. Let's hear it.

- What about if he says no,
he's not willing to participate?

- Well, I think
it'd be unfortunate..

...on one level.

And then,
on another level I think..

Well, that's a relief.

-Drink ourselves funny.
-Did you open my wine?

-Oh, that one,
you got it.

- Where's the stuff
on the bottom?

- Where is it, I don't know.

- I've got a bowl of pasta

with no clams.
That's -- how'd you do that?

-No there is.

-Uh, some people say
they called the cops

the cops didn't react
because there was a bar

in this quiet neighborhood,
there was a bar

you know, people like,
it's again like a Rorschach

it's like, what do you see
in this senseless pattern

so we're trying
to get with Moseley.

Send him an email.

- You sent him an email?

-Yep.
- Wow.

-Bill.

- What?
- What?

- What's the, um..

What's the question, um..

What's the question..
What do you want answered?

At what point are you
going to be satisfied?

- Well, the thing is,
sadly for me

one question leads
to another question

leads to another question
leads to 5 questions

leads to 10 questions,
and it's, uh

you know,
it's a geometrical thing.

- We're now sitting here

we're still talking about Kitty.

And I'm okay with that..

- Yeah.
- But 50 years..

- If you buried it,
you should have.

You should have
because it's, it's..

It's ea -- it's easily

described as an obsession
on my part.

- I really need to.

-Bury it.
- Yeah.

-Hello?
-Uh, hello, Bill.

Uh, this is Mark Collins,
and Janet is with me as well.

-Hi, Bill!
- Hi, Janet. How're you doing?

-Very good. How are you?
- Good.

-We met
with Winston Moseley.

We are very, uh..

...very, uh,
disappointed, however

as -- as,
as you will be that

he has chosen
not to pursue a dialogue

uh, process with you.

-You know, he was very
clear that he's been contacted

by multiple media sources

and he's just, as he put it,
"Tired of being exploited."

-You know, we know how
important this is for you

and so it was frustrating
for us to..

Obviously not nearly as
frustrating as you must feel.

- So is that
the final w -- word

or can I write a letter to him?

-You're certainly
not barred or prohibited

from writing a letter to him,
I just don't see

him changing his mind.

- Yeah. I really appreciate it.
-Okay.

- Thank you very much.
-Okay, bye-bye, Bill.

- Hi. Steven?

- Bill?
- Bill Genovese.

- Hi, I'm Steven.
- Yes.

- Nice to meet you.

- How do you like
to be addressed?

Reverend?

Reverend Moseley?
Or Steven Moseley? Or..

- However you feel
comfortable calling me.

- Steven, if it's okay.
- That's fine.

- I thought to be perfectly
straight with you

and to show you exactly
where I'm coming from

I spent many, many
hours and days writing this.

And in some places
it's gonna seem harsh

but I think that you probably
will be able to read it

and understand
where I'm coming from.

- Yeah, I, uh..

...I see how you feel about,
uh, what happened.

- Yeah.
- When I was 7 years old.

- Oh. No, I know.

I don't hold the son responsible

for the father's deeds.

Your dad won't talk to me..

...and I'm, uh,
trying to find a way

in my own heart
to forgive him.

- Can -- can I explain to you
what forgiveness does?

When you forgive people,
it's for yourself.

It's for you.
- Yeah.

- Uh..

How would you feel
about him getting paroled?

Because, um...you know

if it had not been
for the, uh, notoriety

of this story..

...he'd have probably been
paroled by now.

- But see my concern is
there's that part of him

that seems to be
a very good person

and there's that part of him

that maybe
he has no control over

that really is...for lack of
a better term, a monster.

- 50 years ago.

- 50 years ago, but my
concern is, where is he now?

- Only thing I know
is from what he's told me.

You know?
He said he just snapped out.

Because there was some racial
tensions going on back then.

And your sister was using a lot
of racial slurs at him and

he just lost it.
That's what he told me.

- Mm-hmm.
- So I, I don't know.

- Do you, do you realize
he killed another woman?

-I.. That's something
that I'm not real

uh, you know, sure of --

- And the other, the other
woman was African-American.

- Okay, well, maybe he did
do that. I don't know, you know?

-Yeah.
- Uh, that's something
we never discuss.

Um, I can only imagine
how you feel.

I don't know,
but I can imagine.

- Right.
- You took a loss,
your family took a loss.

And my family took a loss.
You know, it affected everybody.

My brother and I, we -- we
went through school with

uh, ridicule.

Uh, people, you know, they used
to pick with us and call us

children of a murderer
and all this.

So, what happened to your sister

changed my form
of thinking also....you know.

And I wanted to be
the good guy

and try to fix
the badness in the world.

Now, you know, um,
let me just say this here..

I, I was kind of..

...apprehensive about
talking to you.

From what I've understood

there was a Genovese
crime family.

Are you related to the crime
family of the Genovese?

- No, not at all.

- I've always, uh, been told

that, that it had been
the, the crime family that was

you know, that Kitty was from.

- Steven, between you and me

it's not true.

- Everybody in my family
says to me you know

"You' re crazy, you shouldn't go
there. You may not come back"

- Ha.

- I said, "I'm not,
I'm not afraid to die."

I said, "lf it's my time
to die, I'm ready to go."

- So you're not only
cordial for coming here

but you're courageous
for coming here.

- Yeah, uh...
I know that, uh..

...at some point
in a person's life

they have to move on,
you know, and, and

then you'll have some peace
of mind about it, you know?

And, you know,
hopefully, you know

we can put everything that's
happened behind us and move on.

-About a month after
talking with Steven Moseley

his father Winston
sent a letter.

He described in detail
a bizarre version

of what happened the night
of Kitty's murder.

According to him,
he was nothing more
than the getaway driver

for the true killer.

An ltalian mobster
named Dominic.

"At that point, Dominic ran
at the woman
and I thought

"I was seeing him hitting her

"in her back with his fist.
I didn't know he had a knife.

""Why? " I asked.

""She owed me" was all he said.

"He said to me
in a very menacing way quote

""Not a word about tonight
to anyone.

""If you ever mention my name

""if you talk, you'll be sorry.

Your family will pay.""

And then it's
simply signed Winston Moseley.

Incredible.

-It's so delusional.
-Yeah.

It's kind of like, uh,
the human condition.

One believes their own bullshit
in evolving stories.

- Amazing. 50 years
and he's come up with this.

- Yeah.

It's hard to let go
when you can never know
the whole truth.

I'll never be able
to put myself

in the place of the neighbors.

- Welcome to our home.

- This is the bedroom.

- Hello.
- Hi.

The one in the bedroom
looks directly down

at the parking lot.

-And I can never really know

what it was like
for Kitty that night.

What thoughts
went through her mind.

Only once in 50 years
have I come close

to understanding.

It was July, 1967.

I was on patrol
near an enemy village.

Lying in the middle of that
paddy, I was completely alone.

I thought of Kitty.

What was it like for her
when she realized

no one was going to save her?

But Marines
carried me to safety

and I lived
to tell the story.

- Whatever possessed you to go
running off into the paddy like
that?

- I'm a marine.
-How do you mean?

- I'm a marine.
I'll take care of 'em.

After 50 years, I felt
there was one more thing
I had to do.

- Hi, how are you?
- Good. How are you?

- I'm Shannon.
- Pleased to meet you, Shannon.

- Nice to meet you.
- Beeby?

- Yes.

-Hello.
- Michael?

-Yes.
- It's Bill Genovese.

I'm here with a woman
named Shannon Beeby

and she is going
to act out the

vocalizations here
on the street.

So of course the only person
we really have..

...is yourself,
who can give us a -- an idea

of how loud was it
in your apartment.

-The scream was so loud

that it woke me up
from a dead sleep.

I've never heard anything
in my life that loud.

- Help me!

Help me!

Oh, my God, please help me.

Please, help me!

Help me!

Help me!

Oh, God..

Help!

- Thank you.

- Bill, how you doing?
How's everything?

- Good.
- Good to see you.

- This is unbelievable.

- I know.

She was my friend
and I knew she was hurt.

She was my friend
and I knew she was hurt.

And l..
And she needed help.

That was -- that was my reason

for flying down those stairs.

And then when I came in

I'll never forget the black..

It kills me
when I think about it.

It kills me
when I think about it.

The black leather gloves
and all cuts

all through the gloves
on her both hands.

I only hope

that she knew it was me.

That she wasn't alone.

-This is the youngest, Frank

-This is the youngest, Frank

and this is the oldest, Vin.

So it was Kitty, Vin, Susan

Bill and then Frank.

This is our granddaughter.
-Oh, she's beautiful.

-I've come to realize
that the whole truth

about Kitty's death
will never be known.

But maybe that's why the story
continues to fascinate people.

But maybe that's why the story
continues to fascinate people.

- You really only
had to know one thing

to appreciate how
misleading that lead was.

-And if nothing else,
it got us

to think about
what we owe each other.

- To not only be vigilant
but to get involved

and to help in
any capacity that we can.

-50 years
after Kitty's death,
I still miss her.

I wish she had the chance
to know her nieces
and nephews.

I wish she had the chance
to know her nieces
and nephews.

To meet her grand-niece
who's named after her.

But this journey
has taught me and my family

more about Kitty than
we ever thought we'd know.

-For some reason or other,
she really took

a-a liking to Billy,
more than me.

-Although I remember,
one time

I didn't eat
my spaghetti and she

dumped the spaghetti
on my head.

-Yes! Really?
-Yeah.

Kitty taught me to never
stop asking questions.

Kitty taught me to never
stop asking questions.

But I know
she'd want me to move on.

♪ God is in the roses ♪

♪ The petals and the thorns

♪ Storms out on the oceans

♪ Storms out on the oceans ♪

♪ The souls who will be born ♪

♪ And every drop
of rain that falls ♪

♪ Falls for those who mourn ♪

♪ God is in the roses ♪

♪ And the thorns ♪

♪ The sun is on the cemetery ♪

♪ The sun is on the cemetery ♪

♪ Leaves are on the stones

♪ There never
was a place on Earth ♪

♪ That felt so much like home ♪

♪ We're falling like
the velvet petals ♪

♪ We're bleeding
and we're torn ♪

♪ But God is in the roses ♪

♪ And the thorns ♪♪