Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
[Music]
can i help you sir
yes i'd like to see something in a 38
for home protection lots of break-ins
around our neighborhood the past few
months
and don't i know only last week right on
our street
how's this yeah
a woman could manage that all right it's
mainly for my wife
sorry she being home alone most of the
time i'm at work
um a 22 is a little lighter but a 38
really do the job well that's what i
want something that'll really do the job
yeah i guess my wife can handle it
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
charlie johnson yeah
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
yeah well i understand lady well that is
not exactly a police matter
i know ma'am
[Music]
i just killed a man on lenox avenue
117th street
let go of me i don't want to escape okay
nobody say a word not even you mister
just relax
my name is dennis reardon i live alone
that and my wife having died one month
ago
my daughter having been raped and
murdered ten months before that
neda and me we had three children
dennis jr priest serving in south
america now
frank was killed in vietnam
and my daughter agnes my
she was
one night she was on her way home
you see she works for this law firm down
on wall street
legal secretary so bright
the firm was sending her to school at
night to become a lawyer
which is what she was doing when it
happened
there was this one night
oh
just take your time mr reardon you can
take as much time as you need
well
night classes don't get out until after
nine
so it was dark when she was crossing
city hall park on a way to get the
subway
and he grabbed her and he dragged her
off under a tree
after he robbed her
he ripped off her clothes and
he did things rape
and more
but why did he have to kill her why
he took all her money and jewelry that
she had
and he threw her purse away with some
cards in it
which is how come they called me the
next morning to i'd
identified the body
that day i promised netted
i'd keep after the police until they
caught that animal
and it turns out i didn't have to they'd
already caught him that same night
and he made a complete confession well
we felt thank god
now that murderer will pay for what he
did to our aggie
especially since i identified aggie's
jewelry which they found on him
so we just wait for the trial
and then months later
the detective on the case called and
told us to come down to the courthouse
but there isn't any trial it's just a
hearing
and the district attorney says judge
lingle
in view of your honors rulings the
people find it impossible to make a
prime
a prima facie case a prime of facey case
therefore we consent
to this indictment being dismissed i
took neda home
but from that day on she started failing
she just lost the will to live
another grave i made a vow
if the law wouldn't do anything about a
man guilty of murder
then i would do something about it so
three days ago
i went out of state where it's legal and
i bought a gun that gun that you have
there
and just about an hour ago i found
charlie johnson
and i killed him and now i want to be
tried
is there anything else you'd like to say
mr ridden
i'd like to see my priests
what's he doing this time just listen
to me on principles you don't have to
run for office i
do sir you don't know the details your
uncle harriet principles he also used
his head
he would never have done an idiot pool
thing like this
you know what that is that's another
call from another tv report
asking why it's not possible to ever get
a murder indictment against the cop
in this city
no no no no no calls from any reporters
none and the election's only a few
months away
sir if it'd make your life any easier
i'll resign
you can tell them you fired me because i
disobeyed orders
yeah that would do it
gordon i accept your resignation
why would you do a damn cool thing like
that brad wait
would you just listen to me now maybe i
can straighten it out
i'd be better off for private practice
anyway yeah yeah we're getting started
in criminal law may not be as easy as
you think buddy
well i'll manage that
i don't forget you and arlene is
supposed to have dinner with us
unless it's ours hold on gloria be right
back morning mr gordon any messages your
client called
uh-huh very delicately put cynthia now
what did my only client say
555-2040 yes yes one minute please
it's for you
brad gordon mr gordon where are you
in my office what i left a message this
morning instructing you to be in judge
klein's chambers at one o'clock today
are you sure you got the right brad
gordon i don't have any matter before
judge klein mr gordon get over here
and fast sure okay
come
bradley franklin gordon yes shawna
sit down thank you sir
harry gordon your uncle yes yes he was
sir
are you as good a lawyer as he was
uh there were very few lawyers as good
as my uncle harry said yeah he was
very good and he was very kind
he was a big help to me when i first
started and practice a big help and
that's why
when i saw your name there i noticed
your name on the list of lawyers who
volunteered their time
or energy if i'm here because you're
paying back a debt to my uncle harry sir
uh forget it i'm uh i'm on my own now
yeah i heard all about what happened in
the da's office
principal huh
yeah now i also know
how hard it is for a young lawyer to get
started around here
on his own how many uh
how many clients you got three or four
oh well maybe seven or eight
yeah that doesn't make a lot of practice
does it
oh still you got time you're young
you know
what you need is a good case to pay the
rent you know and to get you some
walking around money and it so happens
that i have a very
unusual case right here
on the calendar he's refused any defense
then why not just let him plead guilty
sir because i have principles of my own
i will never accept that a guilty plea
when the charge is murdered too murder
too
who's the man sir brandon dennis
redden
oh isn't he that father who uh
yeah i see now you know what i like
i'd like you to take on his defense
sure i mean uh
yes your honor uh now this new kind of
yours
he must plead to the indictment of
murder
at ten o'clock on tuesday morning yes
sir
so you better get your tail over to
rikers island
see him thank you sir hi
[Applause]
mr reardon brad gordon i've been
appointed to be your new attorney sir
won't you sit down please i'd prefer to
stand this may take some time sir i hope
not
now mr reardon in order for me to defend
you i need to know exactly what happened
so
it's all in my confession they showed it
to the other attorneys didn't they show
it to you
yes sir but i want to know your
innermost thoughts or your your feelings
before you bought the gun while you were
buying it while you were tracking
charlie johnson especially
at the moment you shot it please i get
it
okay if that's what you want start
making notes
from the time our agnes got raped and
murdered i kept thinking that animal has
got to pay
that's all you thought about right and
then when johnson got off scot-free
without even a trial
and never wasted away then i had a
double reason
that's when i began planning i couldn't
sleep
couldn't eat for thinking about it it
became an obsession with you
obsession that's it an obsession
one thing in this world for me was to
kill that killer
right i got it
tell me mr reardon exactly how did you
feel while you were shooting him
well that's the strangest thing while i
was shooting him i didn't feel anything
at all
my mind was a total blank total black
good and after that
after that i heard a voice
you heard a voice dennis reardon my
beloved son
well done the voice of god praised you
for killing charlie johnson
have you got that all of it i sure do
good now tear it up
i said tear it up mr reardon
this has the makings of a very credible
defense
i figured that's what you came for an
insanity plea
well it's very important for the people
to know that i was sane when
i did it very sane and i'm still saying
so tear it up
mr reardon listen tear it up
now look kid don't waste your time
i don't want to be defended well sir for
the moment i am your lawyer
and i'm certainly going to do my best to
defend you sir will you put me on the
stand
that depends will you agree to cooperate
or cooperate hell
i just want everyone to know why i did
it sir that's the one reason not to put
you on the stand
in murder two there are two key things
the prosecution must prove one that you
did it
and two that you had the intent to kill
if i put you on the stand and you admit
intent
that's the ball game i insist upon
testifying
mr reardon you don't understand what is
staring you in the face
conviction i mean that means minimum 15
years that's longer than you have to
live sir
it's worth it to let the people know
[Music]
sweetheart yep
hi
any luck yeah all bad let's have a drink
yeah dinner's ready and this new recipe
says to serve piping hot
veal parisian and chinese rock salt lady
you are too much
beautiful successful an excellent cook
cordon bleu wonderful lover
better than cordon bleu
and ever since i left the da's office
you've practically been supporting me
you know it's only temporary
but i must admit there is one thing
wrong with you
do you know the very idea of making love
to a stock market analyst could make a
man impotent
yeah so that's your excuse the last few
days
it's weird in case
still no defense defense i can't even
get cooperation from my own client
oh your mother called the office again
today what'd she say this time
and did you tell her it's not me but you
who doesn't want to get married i didn't
think it necessary to discuss all that
with her
or me either please tell me what
go on eat your dinner
um if rudin won't cooperate what will
you do
well uncle harry used to say and you
know that uncle harry was the best damn
best criminal lawyer in new york until
the day he died
well he was who knows that better than i
meaning
meaning the first four times you went
out you spent the whole evening telling
me about how wonderful your uncle harry
was
the first four times no way no
no all right if your uncle harry was so
brilliant
tell me what he would do with the
weirding case no no wait
don't tell me i'll tell you my uncle
harry would say
no matter how bad the case appears to be
the odds are always with the defendant
all you have to do is find one loophole
establish one reasonable doubt in the
minds of the jury
yes but in this case if the prosecutor
puts on enough witnesses and if you stay
alert
you'll find that loophole so pick away
at every witness
the gospel according to uncle harry
okay brilliant nephew pick away
pick away dixieland honey what uncle
harry meant
was go harry the prosecutor has to
stretch the truth to make his case
an impeachable witness a faulty
confession
so there are things to pick away at but
not in this case
it's airtight
bye now i brought you boys here because
every once in a while i like to see some
justice done around here justice based
on humanity and not just
laws so what i'd like you to do is to go
back to your boss
and talk to him about a plea a plea
of manslaughter in the first instead of
murder too
and you you talk to your client about
taking
a plea he's a strange man sir very
stubborn
convince him for everyone's sake mostly
his own
plead guilty to manslaughter absolutely
not
because i did intend to kill johnson so
i should be charged with murder
tried for murder and punished for murder
i want everyone to know that dennis
reardon did what he had to because the
law wouldn't
and for that you're willing to spend the
rest of your life in prison son
with netagon with aggie gone
what life uh
mr rudin do something for me sure kid
anything but plead guilty to
manslaughter
uh in the courtroom don't call me son
or kid uh doesn't look good counselor
how's that that's better
those are my huskies got them from the
property clerk so i can go to your house
get you a proper suit some
white shirts tie to make a good
impression on the juror during the trial
you knew all along i wouldn't settle for
a deal didn't you
i had to try so long as you knew
[Music]
who are you what are you doing here
i'm mr riordan's lawyer i'm here to pick
up some decent clothes for his trial
oh in that case that's all right then
i'm mary delahanty his neighbor how do
you do
come on upstairs and i'll see if i can
help you thanks
off the poor man as soon as it was in
the papers about him
surrendering but the dirty hooligans
broke in here and stripped the place
bare
i didn't leave anything unturned today
what a mess
there's nothing left nothing like
heaven's ned isn't here to see this
[Music]
that was his agnes such a lovely girl
real refined
[Music]
[Music]
brad
[Music]
reached out to put my arm around you
how long have you been out here since
midnight
have you thought of your opening to the
jury tomorrow no
well you think of something brilliant
not sure
our only hope is to make that jury
experience the agony that agnes reardon
suffered in those last
terrible moments of her life there's not
a single legal precedent that makes it
possible for me to turn this into the
trial of charlie johnson
can i come to court
not even for moral support i don't know
if you give me financial support oh brad
i don't want you to come to the trial
[Music]
please
is it true your client tried to hang
himself in his cell and they had to cut
him down
oh god man will you make weird and
available for interviews during the
trial
no comments our producer did a minute
survey and it's according to him next to
the president
this case is the most exciting news on
her at six o'clock news uh
so you owe our audience more than a no
comment do you know my dear that the
courts were established to achieve
justice not to supply items
for the tv news so we can boost your
ratings excuse me
i don't know and so ladies and gentlemen
of the jury
we will prove that on the 21st day of
june
dennis rearton bought a pistol in
another state
and then drove back to new york with a
specific
intent to kill the one charlie johnson
and that on the 24th day of june he did
indeed track down
johnson fired five shots hitting him
four times
and killing him instantly now we will
prove all that
not only by witnesses but most important
by a detailed and
uncontested confession by mr reardon
thank you i'd mr gordon
your opening statement
conor the defense chooses not to make an
opening statement
constant is that your considered
decision
your honor nothing in the code says i'm
forced to make an opening statement
hi mr crew your first witness thank you
your honor
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
sorry sir full up
[Music]
yes sir
mr ward you've been sworn in and you
understand that you are under oath
i want you to relax and to think very
carefully
and to tell this jury in your own words
mr ward exactly what happened
yes sir
me and charlie just finished having
lunch at the avalon restaurant up on
linux avenue
we come out and we hear someone call
charlie johnson so we turn to see
and as we turn we see this white man
this stranger who just starts shooting
at charlie
charlie sit back falls to the ground
and this white man just gets
in his car and drives off
just drives off now then mr ward the man
who fired those shots at charlie johnson
do you see him in this courtroom yes sir
that's him are you absolutely sure
yes sir never forget his face
thank you mr ward
mr reardon have you got your rosary yes
of course what
use it this is crucial
[Applause]
mr ward did you testify that you and
charlie johnson had lunch at the avon
restaurant that day
yes sir but mr johnson was killed around
three or four in the afternoon
lunch mr ward well
it was it was kind of a
late lunch
uh and by any chance did you
also have a drink
well i uh i guess
we had a drink or two no sir not two i
remember that
you're sure about that now well
maybe just two just two
mr ward what did you do
when you claimed that mr reardon started
shooting at charlie johnson well when i
hear gunfire i duck
i learned that in the army so you ducked
when soon as the shooting started
so the only time that you could look at
the man that you claim shot your friend
was in that fraction of a second between
turning to see who called
charlie johnson and ducking for cover
but i did get a good look at him
are you asking this jury of intelligent
men and women to believe
that with three or four drinks in you
you get a flash look at a total stranger
and you can come in this courtroom and
truthfully testify that that is the man
that killed your dear friend charlie
johnson
come now mr ward
mr ward when charlie johnson felt badly
wounded
exactly what did you do i rushed to
charlie
to see what i could do for him but just
moments ago you testified
that you watched his assailant get to
his car get in and just drive off
now which did you do i guess i did both
and i guess that while your dear friend
was bleeding to death
you stood there watching his assailant
make his getaway
maybe charlie johnson wasn't such a good
friend of yours as you would have this
jury believe
we was close very close
close enough to talk man-to-man
close enough to talk about your women
well
sometimes maybe exchange a few names a
few phone numbers as
close friends do from time to time well
i reckon so
were you such a close friend that he
told you exactly how he raped and
murdered agnes reardon
objection the question is irrelevant and
immaterial your honor we are not here to
try the case of people versus johnson as
much as mr gord would like
we are here to decide the case of people
versus rear
anything else is irrelevant your honor
in his opening the prosecutor made it
very clear that intent
is crucial in this crime therefore i
feel i have every right
to explore the question of intent in all
its aspects and that includes
the rape and murder of agnes riordan
i will sustain the prosecution's
objection your honor the jury has
arrested gordon
the court has ruled now if you have any
questions from this witness
that are relevant to this case do you
no more questions sir
so the council may regain his composure
we will stand in recess until
1 30.
well mr gordon how crucial was that
question that judge klein ruled out
would it affect the rest of your case no
comments for the benefit of the tv
audience would you come on camera and
explain the legal consequences no
comment please come on let's go find
crew come on let's go
thank you i ask you not to come i know
i'm sorry i just couldn't stay away what
about the office
my presence there doesn't make the
market go up and down i was hoping my
presence here might help
so are you gonna get another chance to
put charlie johnson on trial
one last shot that's all
and at that time did you make a record
of the defendant's confession
yes i did i have here now a videotaped
recording of the defendant's confession
which the people now offer into evidence
your honor may the technicians bring in
the equipment yes constant
thank you
one night she's on her way home you see
she works for this law firm
not on wall street it's a legal
secretary
so bright
the firm was sending her to school at
night to become a lawyer
which is what she was doing when it
happened
there was this night
oh just take your time mr reardon you
can take as much time as you need
well night classes don't get out until
after nine
so it was dark when she was crossing
city hall park on her way to get the
subway
and he grabbed her
months later we get a call from the
detective on the case
come down to the courthouse but there
isn't any trial it's just a hearing
and there's a lot of argument back and
forth between a young district attorney
and this
is judge i can identify aggies
judge lancel just bangs his gavel and he
says clear the courtroom
and just like that
is dismissed it's all over and this
murderer
is walking out of the courtroom a free
man
and he's laughing i took neda home
but from that day on she started failing
lost the will to live
and just about an hour ago i found
charlie johnson
and i killed him and now i want to be
tried
now it's more important than ever that
you put me on that stand why
because there's certain things i wanted
to say in that confession and i never
got to say them
you admitted intent that's all that was
missing from their case and you just
gave them that
i can't let your confession be the last
thing that jury remembers
got to figure out some way to counteract
it lights
now gentlemen since it's almost four
o'clock i think we should adjourn
for the day your honor before we adjourn
i would like to ask mr crew to resume
the stand
well mr gordon i don't like to impose on
the jury
beside that it takes time to remove this
equipment
and to put this uh courtroom back in
order i can wait
all right mr gordon but unless you can
finish
by four o'clock don't even start
four o'clock your honor mr gordon
yeah victor cult
i said victor cole dr cole
oh the literary mush picture agent yeah
i read about you in the columns all the
time
well if you don't mind brad you don't
mind my calling you brad do you
brad you're sitting on a gold mine am i
well that uh that confession alone is
going to give my client 15 years to life
no no no the rights
the rights you must get them the
literary rights to written story
for a book or a movie or a mini series
let's see this is big brad very big
yeah how big figure i'd say about 400
thousand dollars
and what happens to that 400 000 when i
lose this case
i would raise the price to 500 000 after
all
if you lose the case what's the first
thing you'll do
appeal in a murder case that's automatic
exactly which of course keeps the
interest alive until the book comes up
you don't miss anything dear sorry brad
don't say no so quickly think of the
personal publicity that goes with the
book the radio and tv guest show
think what that could do for the career
of a bright young lawyer i can't think
about anything right now
got to uh read trust me i have done
these deals before
lots of them
all rise
please set
mr
mr gordon i'd like to remind you yes i
know your honor
i must be finished by four o'clock sir
mr crew was mr reardon's the first
confession that you've ever taken
mr gordon since you and i worked
together in the district attorney's
office you know that i've taken many
confessions
then tell us during all those
confessions have you ever encountered a
man
who was more insistent on confessing
than this defendant
i've never encountered a man so lucid so
calm and so insistent on making a
confession and it never occurred to you
that this man didn't know what he was
doing
that he has a compulsion to confess the
compulsion of a religious zealot
mr gordon in the miranda case the
supreme court of the united states laid
down precisely what my job was and i
performed that job precisely
did the supreme court ever hand down a
decision exempting a prosecutor from
having a little humanity a little
compassion for a man who suffered such a
grievous wrong
i please are no flights of fancy now if
you have proper questions
you ask them sorry ron
mr crew at the time of the defendant's
confession
were you aware of his religion mr gordon
i don't understand the relevancy of the
question
mr crew you are aware aren't you the
confession is a holy sacrament of the
catholic church
of course and that a catholic is brought
up from early his childhood to believe
that if you sin
you confess and if you confess you're
granted absolution not put on trial for
murder now wait just
i suggest mr carew that you took
advantage of this devout
god-fearing man by letting him confess
you took advantage of his religious
convictions
and i suggest mr gordon that you are
trying to divert the attention of this
jury away from that confession by
playing on the emotion of the catholics
and the jury
gentlemen please i want you sir
no flights of fancy besides
it's four o'clock i have just two more
questions your honor
proceed the counselor mr crew
at the time that you were taking mr
riordan's confession
did you know the identity of the victim
i was informed when i arrived at the
11th precinct
and tell us would you have
felt the same acted the same toward mr
reardon
if his victim had not been a black man
[Music]
in the end it always comes down to this
doesn't it
a man can be your co-worker
colleague even a friend
until the heat is on but then
then he's just a black man after all
isn't he
[Music]
mr gordon i would have acted in the same
manner if the defendant's victim had
been black or white
catholic protestant or jew
and you know that
no further question john
the quarters adjourn until 9 00 am
tomorrow morning
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
i had to get their minds off your
confession
[Music]
[Applause]
diverting the jury's attention away from
that confession to the race issue
never been very clever
[Music]
now that what did reardon say you did
talk to didn't you about the rights
the book of picture writes the brand did
you talk to him
no i didn't talk to him you didn't talk
to him why not
i'm here this will make it easier what
the hell is that it's the usual release
i have defendant signed
get written to sign it
[Music]
go on say it it was a lousy thing for me
to do since you're already aware of that
fact there's no reason for me to say it
or anything else to you
from now on arlene
i swear i didn't plan it i mean i
couldn't let the jury go home with
reardon's confession the last thing they
remembered it was almost four o'clock i
was testing
desperate is one thing this was
despicable
[Music]
across the bridge
in supreme court today what was a murder
trial
suddenly erupted into a racial war and
alongside it
even dennis reardon's confession faded
into relative insignificance
the prosecution has rested its case so
tomorrow the defense
will have its turn
at least i got him to play down the
confession
[Applause]
under the adversary system it was my
duty as the defense attorney
[Applause]
uh
can i speak to lester please yeah sure
i'll hold on
yeah oh
i see
he wouldn't come to the farm can you
blame him
i guess not
[Music]
wow
[Music]
thanks i'm doing this to save the wall
[Music]
i tried to apologize
that man calls keeps showing up at trial
what does he want
[Music]
i'm gonna ask reardon to sign this
thanks brad for what oh
every time i think i found a good reason
to leave you you uh
you do something that makes me think
you're not such a louse after all
you can't leave me why not
because this is your apartment silly
gonna sleep yeah what i have staring me
in the face tomorrow
you do have those character witnesses
an old lady has been rearden's neighbor
for 26 years his
boss at the warehouse and his parish
priest
who will all testify that reardon was a
fine upstanding citizen
until he committed a murder terrific
uncle harry would know what to do
[Music]
he'd probably hold it
before you got home tonight i had time
to do a lot of thinking
about the trial about us
mainly about you
yeah when your uncle harry was alive
who did he quote meanie
meaning what made uncle harry a great
lawyer
was what he thought was what he did
one thing he did not do is go around
quoting his uncle
that's for a hero worshiping little boy
not a grown man
[Music]
and while we're at it the next time your
mother asks why we're not yet married
you can tell her the little boys don't
get married men
do i'm sorry brad
you got to start living your life as if
there never was an uncle harry there is
just brad gordon
and his client dennis reardon
the question now is what is brad gordon
going to do not uncle harry
but brad gordon who has struck out on
every
legal showdown in this case
you know what the the real trouble is
that rare never wanted a defense
all he wanted was for people to share
his outrage so maybe they'd do something
about the justice system
judge klein will never let you defend
reardon by putting johnson on trial you
know that
exactly but what if i can get the jury
to share
reardon's outrage by putting the system
of justice on trial
[Music]
brad can you do that i don't know
but i'm damn well gonna find out
and you're gonna help me help you how
by doing exactly what i tell you to do
tomorrow morning
[Music]
your witness will appear monday morning
or your client's case will be thrown out
of the court
yes ah this is for judge langley
i was told he once had handed him
personally
what do you mean intruding on my
courtroom and there's a hearing in
progress
attendant stop that woman hold it right
there mister
you take your hands off me or i'll see
you for false arrest
this is illegal absolutely illegal
all right
come to the bench yes your honor
do i understand that you just had this
subpoena served
unjudged lengle is there something wrong
sir is it defectively drawn
no no it's not effectively drawn but you
take it back
and we'll go on on the premise that it
was never served
well i don't see how i can do that sir
you see that attractive blonde woman in
the front row
she served the subpoena on judge lingle
now i can put her on the stand to
testify to that if you like
what i'd like i'd like you to withdraw
this and to forget it
there
now what in hell are you trying to accom
don't you come to my chambers your honor
if there's any question that judge
lengle will honor this valid subpoena i
want it argued out in the presence of
this court stenographer
and the press i think the public has a
right to know
and if you don't think so sir i'm going
out on the courthouse steps and tell
them how i've been muzzled during this
trial
you realize that i can hold you in
contempt for
any derogatory statement that you may
make even outside of this quarter
i know that sir so don't threaten me
uh clerk would you remove the jury
thank you mr crew
come to the bench thank you
crew do you know what the scheister has
just done
he's had the unmitigated call to
subpoena judge lingle as a whip
no uh please strike that strike that
please and make it read
uh mr crew i'm afraid that i'm afraid
that i
must inform you that your opponent in
this case
has taken a most regrettable step
he has had this subpoena served on judge
l'engle as a witness in this case your
honor the people very strongly oppose
such an outlandish tactic your honor
once the prosecutor introduced the
subject of judge l'engle into this case
we introduce brad you name me one
witness one who even mentioned judge
lingle mrs harrison do you have your
notes of yesterday
produce them mrs harrison find the place
where the prosecutor introduced the
confession of dennis reardon and
follow me while i read some excerpts if
i make a mistake
leaving a single word correctly
and i quote
there's a lot of arguing back and forth
between this young district attorney and
this judge
lingle until he takes both attorneys
into a side room when they come out
judge
lingo climbs back on the bench and says
does the prosecutor have a statement to
make and this young district attorney
says judge alengo in view of your honors
ruling that people find it impossible to
make a prima facie case but judge
langle wraps his gavel and says clear
the courtroom i grabbed the young
district attorney and say how can a
judge do a thing like that
and he says mr reardon judge lengle
threw out his confession because when
johnson murdered your daughter he was
out on bail
for another crime five times your honor
five times judge lengle's mention i
maintain
that when the prosecutor introduced that
confession
into evidence he also introduced the
subject of judge l'engle and under
the rules of evidence i have every right
to pursue it and i insist
that judge lengle honor this valid
subpoena or be held in contempt accord
like any other citizen
this request is unprecedented now the
people insist that this subpoena be
vacated the people
mr crew which people
judges and lawyers the bureaucracy that
you call people
or the people out there the average
citizens who really are the people
if it's those people that you represent
mr crew then why this conspiracy between
you and judge klein
to keep them from knowing what's on the
minds of our judges is that what brought
us
to where we are now when the people that
you claim to represent
live in constant fear for their safety
and their lives
if it's the people you represent mr
carew
an answer to them
your honor the defense awaits your
decision the trial will stand in recess
till after lunch
do you solemnly swear to tell the truth
the whole truth and nothing but the
truth in the matter of so i do
your name lango michael lingle
now then mr lingle mr gordon
as you well know the witness is a judge
on this court
and he is entitled to be addressed with
respect equal to his position
and from now on you will not call him mr
lango
but judge rangel may i address him as
your honor
your honor
[Laughter]
proceed now then tell us uh your honor
are there times when the opinion of one
judge does not agree with the opinion of
another judge
yes so that if one wanted to discover uh
why a particular decision was made in a
particular way one would have to ask
the judge who made it judge klein if it
is council's intent
to force me to justify my decision in a
past case
i will not submit to it i absolutely
will not is that your intention
mister no sir but the jury has seen
a confession in which judge langell's
decisions played a crucial part
in the crime for which my client is now
on trial i ask
simply that he explained to this jury
what happened and why
because i'm sure they're just as
confused as dennis reardon was
when all when all charges of rape and
murder against charlie johnson were
dropped without even a trial
sir as long as your questions are
confined to eliciting information for
the benefit of the jury
i will allow them but if you ask judge
langle to justify
his decisions i will rule them out is
that clear
yes your honor now
uh your honor
in his confession my client referred to
being in court
when you just threw out all the evidence
against charlie johnson young man
i did not just throw out evidence
i was conducting a proper hearing to
suppress evidence
oh thank you for that correction sir a
hearing
to suppress evidence now would you
explain to this jury exactly what that
means sir
some of the most crucial decisions in a
criminal case
concern what evidence may legally be
presented to a jury
and what may not well if jurors are
charged with reaching a fair decision
sir
couldn't all the evidence be presented
to them i'm sure this jury would like to
know
your honor i really don't see why i
should have to instruct this jury as if
they were a first year class in law
school
will you stop wasting the time of this
court and get to the pertinent questions
yes sir sir in the case against charlie
johnson for the rape and murder of agnes
reardon
exactly what evidence were you asked to
suppress
certain physical evidence what kind of
physical evidence
agnes weirdness jewelry which was found
on johnson's person at the time of his
arrest
yes
was there any other evidence sir yes
such as there were scratches
on charlie johnson's face inflicted
during agnes reardon's struggle to keep
from being
killed and raped most
now likely would you please tell
this jury explain to them exactly
on what grounds did you exclude all that
evidence
whenever evidence is seized by the
police without a warrant
or without proper provocation such
evidence is considered illegal under the
fourth amendment to our constitution
which prohibits
illegal search and seizure
therefore it must be thrown out it's the
only way to force the police to obey the
law
since charlie johnson was apprehended
within an hour
after the murder could there have been
time to secure a warrant
of course not but there was no
provocation
to arrest him in the first place for the
benefit of the jury sir
why not
[Music]
four out of ten in all units in the
vicinity the possible rape and homicide
just occurred in city
hall park
[Music]
so you see the officer arrested johnson
without cause
simply because mulberry street is a
predominantly white
italian neighborhood and a black man
walking along that street
late at night appeared suspicious to him
sir by that time had the policeman heard
a radio report that the body of a young
woman had been found in city hall park
yes but at the time of the arrest no one
knew that a black man might be involved
therefore the officer had no right to
stop and search johnson
merely because he was black you know the
law mr gordon
provocation legal provocation is needed
before an arrest and a search can be
made provocation
such as
sir i demand an answer to my question
what constitutes legal provocation
well if the man have been acting
suspiciously or if you were committing
some other offense oh so say that
instead of
of merely walking down the street
charlie johnson
had say uh swiped an apple
from a fruit stand would that have been
grounds on which to stop him
we are waiting yes it would and then all
the evidence the
stolen jewelry scratches semen stains
would have been admitted
yes what a fortunate thing for
charlie johnson that he didn't feel an
urge to swipe an apple
that was only walking away from the
robbery
rape and murder of agnes reardon object
your honor
now i insist that council be ordered to
confine himself to asking questions and
not making comments
i saw her and i warn you sir that if you
go any further
i will rule that you are stalling and i
will excuse this witness
your honor you had just explained why
you threw out all the evidence
against charlotte johnson council is
being repetitious
and wasting the time of this court sorry
sir
the prosecutor also produced this
confession by charlie johnson
in which he described in full detail how
he raped and murdered agnes reardon
which i would like to read to this jury
object your honor all such evidence has
been ruled irrelevant in this case
sustain then i would like to offer this
document for the sole purpose of
informing the jury as to its disposition
by judge lengle
your honor
what happened to this confession i ruled
it out
a confession of guilt to such heinous
crimes and you just ruled it out
counselor i warned you not to try to
force this witness
to justify his decisions your honor i've
already reconciled myself to the fact
that too many times the decisions of
judges are unjustifiable
gordon i declare you in contempt of this
court
and we will hold the hearings for
punishment at the end of this trial
now you follow me sir you too mister
okay wise guys so you finally succeeded
succeeded you know very well what i mean
you
jockeyed me into declaring you in
contempt
in front of the jury which constitutes
reversible error
okay so now you win your appeal let's
get it over with
sir i want judge lingle on that stand
i'm sorry i'm not through with it but
you have a new trial what more do you
want
i want to give my client the kind of
defense that he's entitled to sir now
may i continue
or do you want me to go out and explain
to the jury why i was not allowed to sir
your honor the confession of charlie
johnson you felt compelled to rule it
out
why the fifth amendment to our
constitution
i'm sure the jury is familiar with the
expression he took the fifth meaning he
refused to testify because it might
incriminate him
i show you now a transcript of the
interrogation of charlie johnson before
he confessed
was he apprised of his legal right to
remain silent
before making any statement you have a
right to consult an attorney you cannot
afford one
we will provide the wishing attorney
[Music]
but now right now
you understand that anything you say may
be held against you
yeah okay
then in your own words tell us what
happened
then before johnson's confession he was
given all his rights under the fifth
amendment
and under the miranda rule as well yes
and yet you still ruled out his
confession why
for very valid legal reasons
oh by this time i'm sure this jury would
be mighty curious to know those reasons
sir
ladies and gentlemen despite the false
impression the council is trying to
create
the johnson confession did not meet the
standards set down by the highest court
of new york state
which standards council you know the
legal answer that question is extremely
complicated and i don't think this jury
would be able to follow it
i'm willing to take that risk it would
require discussing the rogers case
well i'm sure these ladies and gentlemen
will survive it and if it would be of
any help to you sir
i have with me a copy of the decision
in the rogers case sir
defendant rogers while out on bail for
one crime
was arrested for a second crime during
his arrest
he admitted his guilt to the second
crime and so he was convicted
but on appeal his admission of guilt
was thrown out and his conviction was
reversed
had rogers been read all his miranda
rights yes
then on what possible ground could the
court throw out his confession
as i said he was out on bail for a
previous crime
are you telling this jury that his
previous crime served as a defense in
his second crime
in this state once a suspect
has an attorney in one criminal case
he's considered represented by that same
attorney in all subsequent criminal
cases
therefore any confession he might make
not in the presence of that attorney
is not admissible into evidence you mean
sir even though rogers had not asked for
that attorney to be present
he should still have been there so our
high court held
now let me get this straight the absence
of an attorney that rogers did not ask
for
who he did not retain and who had no
connection
with the second case was the reason that
the court threw out
roger's confession i can see now why you
assumed that this jury
would have trouble understanding a
ridiculous ruling like that
mr gordon you listen to me ordinarily i
forego
punishment in contempt until after the
trial is over
but because you continue to attack our
courts
i hereby declare you in contempt
a second time and i find you
the maximum amount allowed under the law
for each offence now sir are you sure
that you still wish to continue with
that witness
more sure than ever sir
[Music]
[Music]
sir would you explain to this jury the
connection between the rogers case and
this confession by charlie johnson
at the time charlie johnson was
apprehended for raping
and killing agnes reardon he was out on
bail
since his first attorney was not present
confession in the written case had to be
ruled out
sir are you telling this jury that if
johnson had not been out on bail
did not have an attorney for his
previous crime that this confession
would have been admitted
sir the jury is waiting for your answer
yes that confession would have been
admissible
and sir by any chance do you know the
charge on which charlie johnson was out
on bail when he murdered agnes reardon
yes that charge rape
of a 15 year old black girl
you'll both approach the bench
now gordon you are deliberately
holding the law up to ridicule to trick
me into another outburst in front of
that
jury but there is not a chance and you
remember this that we judges have long
long memories now get on with it
i have just one last question to ask the
witness sir all right as long as it's
one last question
i promise you answer oh before i ask the
question sir
i would like to offer into evidence
three documents
the interrogation of charlie johnson at
the time of his arrest
his confession and a copy of the
decision in the rogers case
your honor quite frankly i don't see the
purpose in all of this but the people
have no objections
and now your honor just one last
question
with all the evidence that you had
before you in the johnson case
did you in your own mind have any doubt
that he was guilty of the rape and
murder of agnes reardon
it's irrelevant charlie johnson is not
on trial here
your honor objection has been sustained
your honor i refuse to be silenced i
have every right mr gordon
you have been warned damn it
i know how you all feel about judges
judges are too lenient
judges are bleeding heart liberals but
how do you think i felt in this johnson
case
the district attorney came in with solid
proof
face scratches semen match stolen
jewelry
and i had to rule all that out because
the officer had made a mistake
by stopping johnson on the street they
presented his confession
i had to rule that out too under the
rogers case
did i want to no but i had to it was my
duty under the law so yes counselor
i'll answer your question
did i think charlie johnson was guilty
there was never any doubt in my mind
he was guilty as hell that's what i had
to hear
in some courtroom from some judge i owed
it to neda
i ordered to aggie
all right your seats
thank you your honor no further
questions sir
the defense rest council will sum up
first thing in the morning
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
[Music]
counsel your client wants to talk to you
before i bring him in what's wrong he's
an idealist
i don't know
[Music]
mr reardon what's wrong i've been
thinking all night
couldn't sleep i hope it isn't too late
too late wait a minute you haven't
finally decided to cooperate yet
i mean with the proper coaching i could
have put you on the stand you might have
done us some good but but now no no no
no kids nothing like that
it's just that today
when you make your summation
say a few nice words about aggie about
neda
it's the last time anyone will ever hear
about it
[Music]
okay sure thank you
and look kid don't make any big plea for
me
just tell them why i did it warn the
people
and don't blame yourself you're a good
lawyer
in time you'll forget all about this
case and win some big ones
they're waiting for sir
ladies and gentlemen when dennis
reardon's daughter was murdered
did he rush out buy a gun and hunt down
the man who killed his daughter
he did not because the police caught the
man
and dennis reardon would get up on the
witness stand
identify his daughter's stolen jewelry
and seal the fate of her killer
that's the way the system works isn't it
but then
dennis and neda reardon made a shocking
discovery that is not the way the system
works there was no trial
no chance to testify there was only a
hearing and for what purpose
are hearing to suppress evidence why not
call it by its rightful name
a hearing to suppress the truth
counselor
i think you are straying from your
proper summation
and i think i am not sir and if you're
going to hold me in contempt again get
it over with because i have a lot more
to say before i'm through
aware of the strain you're under i will
instruct the stenographer to strike that
outburst
now you proceed but you can find
yourself to commenting
on the evidence only yesterday
you heard judge langle say that he was
forced
to let charlie johnson go free because
the officer stopped johnson
without good cause now bear in mind that
if johnson had swiped a 10 cent apple
all that evidence would have been
admissible but judge lingle threw it out
why because to force the police
to obey the law judges punish them by
throwing out the evidence
think about that i mean do you think was
judge langell really punishing that
officer no he was punishing you
he was punishing me
and he turned loose on us the innocent
public a rapist
a murderer and somehow that was supposed
to teach that officer a lesson
and that ladies and gentlemen is the law
as laid down by our judges
the law that is supposed to protect you
counselor
sorry ronnie now
you're you're saying to yourselves
didn't johnson confess
to the raping and killing of agnes
reardon why wouldn't that be enough
proof
but then you must recall that judge
lingle threw out that confession too
why because johnson was out on bail for
another rape
and since his attorney from a previous
crime was not present
they had to throw out that confession
what have we come to when a man's best
defense
is his criminal record counselor
now there were some things that judge
lingle did not tell you yesterday that
rogers case
which forced him to throw out the
johnson confession not all the judges in
the rogers case agreed
there were two judges that objected very
strongly one judge said that to
throw out such a confession and and i
quote would stretch the comprehension of
the average citizen to the breaking
point
your honor the people object the people
mr crew
the objection is sustained and without
any sarcastic remarks mr gordon
your honor i've placed the rogers
decision into evidence so i'm merely
commenting on the evidence that you
charged me to do sir
continue counselor
and this judge went on uh and he was
warning his fellow judges
and again i quote judges decisions
must appear to be rational and fair as
well as practical
if the courts are to retain the respect
of the people
unquote you know i wonder if
if that judge were to say that in this
courtroom today would he be held guilty
of contempt
now counselor do not presume too much
on the patience of this court sorry ron
and now we come to the case of people
versus dennis reardon a man who lived a
decent respectable life
until he discovered that justice had
been turned
into a dangerous game that set a guilty
murderer loose on a defenseless public
because no longer do our judges ask us
is a man guilty now they ask us can you
prove him guilty
by our arbitrary rules guilt and
innocence go out the window
only the rules are sacred not the lives
of innocent people the rules protect the
rules
to hell with the people
so you see ladies and gentlemen what is
really
on trial in this courtroom is our system
of justice object your honor sustain
counsel is straying from proper
summation your honor i was merely
commenting on the evidence
you will not put the legal system on
trial
in my courtroom
never in all my years on the bench have
i ever had to interrupt an attorney
during his summation to declare him in
contempt
but with you i make an exception and
because
money fines seem to have no effect on
you whatsoever
i hereby sends you to
five days in the county jail beginning
after this trial now
your honor is it really necessary i
warned him
now you finish your summation quickly
and in proper fashion
do you understand
sit down
ladies and gentlemen something happened
in this courtroom yesterday
to you i saw it in your eyes when judge
lengle
rose up on the platform and protested i
knew charlie johnson was guilty as hell
but i had to let him go
outrage that's what you felt
but now it is in your hands
to send the word out to all the judges
in this land that if you would retain
our respect then give us some measure of
fairness
in our course how do you do that
well last night when i was preparing my
summation a very interesting thought
became clear to me not a single
prosecution witness was able to testify
that dennis reardon had the intent to
kill
charlie johnson there was only one place
where intent could be inferred
defendant's confession and i couldn't
help but think to myself
my goodness what if after they're
secluded in that room
this jury decides to hold a little
suppression hearing of their own
what if they say it isn't fair that
because charlie johnson
had a criminal record his confession
should be thrown out
but because dennis reardon does not have
a criminal record
his confession should be held against
him let us
restore some measure of a fairness of
sanity into our courts
let us throw out dennis reardon's
confession
forgive me your honor a flight of fancy
late at night in the mind of an
overworked defense counsel
i'm sure that uh this jury will not be
swayed by it
outrage or not you cannot say to dennis
rieden
you have our permission to go out and
kill another man
if you do that you will have turned our
system of justice back a hundred years
to the law of the frontier
the day of the vigilante
there are those who would have you
believe that the fourth and fifth
amendments
to our constitution were written to
protect the rights
of criminals like charlie johnson
not so they are for your protection
and for mine to protect us
from the knock on the door by secret
police in the middle of the night to
protect
us from being arrested without cause
held without charges or as is the case
in some countries
from being sentenced to prison camps or
insane asylums
not for what we do but for what we think
crime in the streets no matter how
rampant public outrage no matter how
strong
can never justify abandoning the laws of
this nation
you see if our freedom is to survive
then our system of justice must survive
and this jury by its verdict must play
its part in making sure that it does
survive
ladies and gentlemen you must return a
verdict of guilty
of murder
thank you
and now that i have explained the
applicable law
you the jury take the case into your own
hands
file out and commence your deliberations
thank you
fred up until now you haven't taken me
very seriously
well to prove my good faith you know
what i just did cause it wouldn't matter
i took a little liberty i booked you on
the today show
yes i've made you a celebrity before the
book is written because
it's not my story to sell why not other
lawyers do it
not this lawyer listen to me young man
for the rest of your life people are
going to be divided into two classes
those who are on tv and those who only
watch it
now unless you're on it you may as well
not exist
this is your chance it's a once in a
lifetime chat
but first you've got to get rid to sign
this release it could mean a million
dollars
maybe more
okay come with me
mr reardon sorry to interrupt you sir
this is mr coles
mr coles thinks there's big money in a
book about you sir you could
make a fortune brad that isn't exactly
how this
release reads it will oh you're an
important man now
mr reardon by any chance if you're found
innocent you could capitalize on that a
million dollars maybe more
because i killed a man you want to pay
me a million dollars
that's the way the publishing business
is these days mr reed
[Applause]
you want the world to know about what
happened to aggie don't you
well this would be the only authorized
version of her story
look if we don't write the book somebody
else will good let him
but not me mr reardon i'll tell you what
i do
when we make the movie i'll get
catherine hepburn to play your wife
and jane fonda to play aggie how about
that damn it man don't you understand
for me it would be like robbing a grave
mr carlson
i think you're making a great mistake
sorry pop the only way was for you to
tell him yourself
what kind of world are we living in kid
is the almighty dollar so important that
people will buy and sell anything
there's a verdict find gordon and crew
yes sir
hey gordon what do you think we heard
any comments
what do you think the verdict will be
excuse me
[Music]
all rise
be seated
bring in the defendant
well i guess this is it kid i mean
consulate
right pop this is it and don't blame
yourself you did your best
bring in the jury
be saved
i have been informed that the jury has
reached a verdict
the defendant will rise and face the
jury
ladies and gentlemen of the jury what is
your verdict
we the jury find a verdict of guilty
[Music]
this is not a football stadium this is a
corner law
clerk will you get that slip from the
foreman
[Applause]
is this the jury's verdict yes sir
i mean your honor
we the jury find a verdict of
guilty insofar as the justice system
is concerned
as for the defendant dennis reardon
we find him not guilty
[Music]
this is against the evidence it's
clearly against the evidence
it's bound to happen one day well
without the usual thanks
the jury is excused
and the defendant is free to go
[Music]
you did good kid i mean
kid you did real good
[Music]
what i said that day
it's unforgivable i'm sorry i'm truly
sorry
i know brett it's the adversary system
right
you say anything you do anything in
defense of your client
hey but brad don't you ever wonder is it
this system which corrupts lawyers or
lawyers who corrupt this system
at dinner still on
yeah brad it's still on
it's still on
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
[Music]
you
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.