Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
Music Sticks
and stones will break my bone
Our ways will be true
And when your mom's dead and
gone I'll sing this lullaby just for
you Word becomes
of all the little words
Who never come there
They lined up all around the
block On the nickel over
there You better
bring a bucket
They throw in the pail
If you don't get my letter
Then you'll know that I'm in jail
Word becomes of all the little boys
Who never save their breath
Sleeping like a baby On
the nickel over
there Music
On June 28, 1979, Dr.
Nathan Sack of Columbus, Ohio, a well-known surgeon and his wife, had
come to Atlanta for the annual convention of the Association of Nuclear Medicine.
They were to be part of Atlanta's 131st homicide of 1979.
Give me your hand back.
Hurry up.
Music Dr. Sack's murder was
on the front page of the Atlanta Daily Newspapers and prominent in newspapers all
over the country.
But a short time later, a crime happened that barely was mentioned in one of
Atlanta's newspapers.
In all likelihood, the boy was already dead when he was brought to this spot.
He was 14 years old.
The second boy was last seen on his way to a skating rink.
He too was 14 years old.
This was the beginning of a case that was to be one of the most baffling
and the crime annals of the United States.
And before the ordeal had ended, a city would go crazy.
And no one who touched the case in any way would ever be the same again.
The Atlanta Child Murders had begun.
Do you realize the increase in homicides this year?
No, I'm afraid I don't, but I'm quite sure you do.
We have had 231 homicides, a 61% increase over 1978.
I hope you realize that when you print stories like that, how much you hurt
Atlanta. One of our main sources of revenue is the convention trade.
The city is 66% black and we are going to have a proportionate number of
black officers, whether you like it or not.
Somebody got it!
Somebody come out!
Would you like to play?
Well, I don't have any money.
Well, I'll take this.
Gee, thanks, sir.
Another boy was found.
His name was Leroy Millard James.
He was 14.
How long has he been gone?
He left you about four or thirty.
All right, I'll go look for him.
Don't worry.
He just went to do an errand and he disappeared.
And somebody must know something.
A young boy just doesn't drop off the face of the earth.
How are you?
Is he turning out of the field?
You have a great deal of Atlanta out there.
They want to know your feelings.
Thank you. I can't help wondering if they're working as hard as they
would if it were a white child from a middle class background.
Would there have been a better chance of saving him if he'd done something right
away? I don't know.
This is a place where black babies are hunted down and killed.
Like animals.
There are kids being murdered all over the streets of Atlanta.
But they don't matter because the department doesn't make any points if it
solves their murders, does it?
One more word like that, Mike, and I'm going to ask you for your badge.
Go ask him back.
Rather turn him on, badge.
Jake, somebody's got to stop these crimes against children.
Oh, there's no telling where we'll end.
And what are you saying to the police force?
I am advising them.
I am pleading with them to concentrate their efforts on this geographic pattern
and to put stakeouts here, here, here, and here in order to help prevent the next
murder. It was the morning of Latonya Wilson's seventh birthday.
As unbelievable as it may seem, somebody actually removed the window pane closest to
the lock, reached through, opened the lock, then opened the
door and stepped in.
That person picked her out of her bed where she was sleeping next to her sister,
then walked past her brother who was sleeping in the next bed and took
her out of the house.
You want us to make a statement that there's a jacked-the-ripper killing the
poor black children of Atlanta, but I don't believe that.
We got ourselves a black mayor.
We got ourselves a black commissioner of public safety.
Black councilmen. We got everything black from top to bottom.
We got everything but protection for our black children.
If you want to kill off of Reese, the first thing you must do is kill
the sea. Now, the whole thing here in Atlanta is the first step in a plan
toward genocide. No, my baby.
My baby. My baby.
My baby has disappeared.
It's a green carpet fiber.
It's very unusual because the cross-section of the fiber shows a trilobular design with
one short leg.
Trilobular design.
That's right. Come on, Mark.
Come over here.
Well, I'll still settle for a fingerprints motive.
Old-fashioned things like that.
What do you want to bet when we find the murder?
He's got a green carpet in his house.
The eight-year-old boy has been identified by dental records as Christopher
Richardson, son of Selena Cobb, who lives in 2624.
I'm so sorry, Miss Cobb.
Could you tell us how you feel?
Get out.
Get out. You don't have no more heart than the captain you brought in here.
What should I do?
Now what I'm like in my heart is I'm just trying to find out what's happening.
Get out! Get out of my house!
Come on, get out of here!
Get out of here!
Help! Help!
Help! By mid
-March, the pattern of deaths changed again.
The bodies were being dumped into the river.
The body was clad in red, bathing type shorts.
Could have been drowning.
But I think we have to mark this mechanism unknown.
What am I charged with, man?
You're a suspect in the case of the missing and murdered children, chair.
You guys are so desperate for a suspect that it's affecting your faculties.
And if I wasn't a veteran of 18 years on the police force, I'd be scared
as hell right now.
Because I know how easily a case can be made to work if there's a need
for it. Look, I'm just warning you, chair.
You just stay out of our way.
Get on out the case.
We have staked our bridges into Cald, Fulton and Cobb counties.
I heard a splash.
A loud splash.
Is that a car on the bridge?
I can't see it from where I'm at.
That splash was to change the course of the Atlanta murders and perhaps
American jurisprudence forever.
Let's see your identification.
Wayne Williams. That's right.
Did you throw a body into the river?
Are you crazy?
Would you get out of the car, please?
Come on. Get up.
What is it?
Come on. Step back here, will you, please?
Would you move back there?
Had we come to the end of what we were looking for for two years, was
this the man who choked the life out of, shot, bludgeoned and drowned 28
human beings? Or was it someone caught in the net of hysteria and
the need to bring an end to Atlanta's nightmare?
You heard a splash.
I could have been a beaver.
There are a lot of beavers around here.
They splash their tails in the water.
It could sound like a body.
I know the difference between a beaver splashing its tail and the sound of a body.
You do. How?
Like it's to be a lifeguard.
This little incident on the bridge here is going to be the talk of the town.
The talk of the country.
I just hope we're not starting an avalanche of something we can't stop based on a
splash. Somebody throwing a body off a bridge that nobody has seen and the
murderer getting back into a station wagon that nobody saw stopped.
Come on, Johnny!
You got that after a minute, man.
I don't know anything about it.
That's nothing, buddy.
I don't know anything about it.
I'm going to be back before you get to work.
I'm sorry.
Wayne! I
have a warrant for your arrest.
Mr. Slayton,
just eight days ago, you said you had insufficient evidence to arrest Wayne
Woodson. I did.
What made you change your mind?
I finally found out I couldn't corroborate William's story that he
had crossed the bridge at three in the morning to visit a woman who he was
going to interview for a musical audition.
But now in your own words, you said you might have a good case for lying,
but not for murder.
Yes, sir. What about me?
Now, I've gone over the fiber evidence with the Georgia Bureau of Investigation
and Larry Peterson and I found it's much more substantial than I
had believed. And that's something else.
There's a great possibility if we don't move on this, Williams may leave the
country. Mr. Slayton, I hate to ask this question.
I think you're one of the finest officials this state's ever had.
But there are persistent reports of that pressure to prosecute Wayne Williams was
brought on you at a meeting at the Capitol.
Yes, sir. You got me on out there, sir.
I've been in office for eight years.
If I had visited the governor's mansion there would not have been any such pressure
that I would have recognized.
There were no threats.
There were no ultimatums.
No deadlines. All right, sir.
Al Binder joined the defense for Wayne Williams.
He was one of the best criminal lawyers in the South.
In the courtroom, he sometimes affected the talk and dress of a hick.
But Al Binder is no hick.
I want you to join a defense team in an advisory capacity.
I understand you know more about the Atlanta murder than anybody else.
What are you paying?
Nothing. That's an attractive offer.
Well, what the hell do you think I'm getting?
I can imagine.
The one thing that makes it almost irresistible is what the expression on the
faces of the Atlanta police force might be if they discover that Dettinger is part of
the Wayne Williams defense team.
Thank you. I have a problem though.
I'm not so sure Wayne Williams is innocent.
I could be a dangerous man to have around.
And while I'm investigating the case, I could come up with evidence that says he's
killed it.
Chance I'll take.
May I ask why you're taking the case?
Well, I'm a strange specimen.
Not only am I a missus of a Jew, but I've become accepted by the good
old boys as one of their own.
Things are going too smoothly for me at the moment.
I'm accepted. I'm making money.
I miss the good old days when the Clucke clan was burning my house and shooting
at my car.
Now you know what Wayne Williams is up against?
Federal Bureau of Investigation, Georgia Bureau of Investigation, Atlanta police
force, newspapers. And who has he got to protect?
Me. That isn't enough to make the old adrenaline go and feel alive again.
Nothing is.
They were indicting him for Jimi Ray Payne too.
That's what it says.
But you and I were at the on-toxic.
We were there when the medical examiner said death was caused by an undetermined
mechanism. The medical examiner changed their mind.
It's been known to happen before.
Take, take.
I have gone over this child's background almost from the day he was born.
I've talked to the kids in his class.
I've talked to his friends.
I have checked his record.
There's no evidence of violence there.
What does somebody do?
Wake up one morning with no previous record and go out and kill all these people?
Ben, you know Slayton.
He's one of the few men of the previous administration we can trust.
You think he would have allowed this boy to be arrested if he knew he could
be innocent? Do you think there's a conspiracy?
No, I don't.
But this town needs to put these murders behind it if he wants to survive.
So it desperately wants to believe that Wayne is guilty.
Ben. I mean, even some very nice people are saying that maybe he's not guilty.
But we ought to convict him anyway.
Ben, it's not our business to decide whether or not he's guilty.
It's Slayton's and it's that jury's and it's the state court and the supreme court.
Here you go.
Keep change. The prosecution and defense teams in the Wayne Williams case
interviewed nearly 900 prospective jurors.
On January 5th, 1982, they finally agreed on the 12th people that
would be acceptable.
And the jury were nine women and three men, eight black and four white.
The jury foreman was signed by the court.
Vicki Lamber, a county clerk from Georgia Power.
Lonnie Brown, long haul truck driver.
Ruby Hidd, seamstress.
Dorothy Rucker, a worker at Grady Hospital.
Walter Brown Jr., research technician for state transportation department.
Clarice Jones, manager for Southern Bell.
JoLynn Willingham, state public health auditor.
Julia M. Wing, a retired bank clerk.
Gail Thomas Jones, manager for Southern Bell.
Will everyone please rise?
Court is now in session.
The Honorable Clarence Cooper, Judge Preside.
Sitting on the bench was 40-year-old Judge Clarence Cooper.
Please be seated.
Slayton. Ladies and gentlemen, I'm Lewis Slayton,
district attorney for Fulton County.
This case is going to be to you like a jigsaw puzzle, with
a whole lot of pieces fitted in.
At the conclusion, there'll be enough pieces so you'll be able to see the big
picture. The witnesses which will be presented to you are not
willing witnesses.
They're reluctant.
They're nervous.
They know that Mr.
Byron is a good man.
The judge here has a reputation for being an expert in cross-examination.
And they know that whatever they testify to might be twisted around where
it may seem like they're not too small.
I want you to sit back and enjoy yourselves the best you can.
We'll try to make it interesting enough for you so that we'll keep you keenly alert
throughout the whole trial.
And at the conclusion, I believe you'll be satisfied with the result.
Thank you.
May it please the court?
Your Honor?
Ladies and gentlemen, I was born in Mississippi.
I've been in this town for nine days.
And all the folks I met have been very kind and courteous
to me.
I was in awe last night about this trial.
Before I went to sleep, I asked God's blessing on His court.
I asked God's orders on you and myself
to see that justice is done.
I want to introduce you to the defendant.
Wayne, I want you to stand up and look at the jury.
It's Wayne Williams, the defendant.
Sit down, son.
Wayne was born late in life to Fay and Homer, who
were school teachers in this community for years.
They owned a modest home,
and they lavished all their love, money, and attention on their young
son, their only child ahead.
At approximately 3 a.m.
on May 26, 1981,
a recruits named Mr.
Campbell heard his play.
Officers saw the headlights of Wayne Williams' station wagon.
They stopped him, asked him to be thrown off the bridge.
He denied it.
Now, the authorities did not detain him.
They searched his car and let him go.
Two days later, the body of an adult black male by the name of Nathaniel
Cater, 28 years old, was found in the river.
Nathaniel Cater was what was known as a streetwise person.
He sold his blood for money.
And he sold his body for money.
Wayne is also accused of another murder, of a 21-year-old
man, Jimmy Ray Payne.
Life wasn't too kind for Mr.
Payne, either. Payne spent most of his juvenile and adult days in institutions.
On two occasions, he attempted suicide.
For one month,
law enforcement personnel haunted Wayne up
and down the streets of Atlanta like a dog.
Now, the only thing that Wayne Williams said regarding that indictment, outside of
the fact that he wasn't guilty,
was that the only thing I've killed is a roach in
myself. I'm
going to ask you, if you sit in judgment of this man,
that you search for the truth.
We're going to ask you to apply to the accused the same treatment that you want
for yourself.
And I thank you, Your Honor.
Well, knowing my heart whether or not he's guilty.
Well, it's not so easy to tell always.
We may never know.
Don't say that.
There ain't nothing they can do to save him, even if they got that smart Jewish
lord of Mississippi.
Oh, we'll be the judge and jury.
He won't serve a life sentence in no jade.
It'll be six feet under in a box.
Same as the kids he killed.
What is your name, sir?
My name is Salah Zaki.
Dr. Zaki, what is your position?
I'm the associate medical examiner for Fulton County.
Dr. Zaki, did you perform an autopsy on Jimmy Ray Payne?
Yes, I did.
What was your conclusion, doctor, as to the cause of death?
The cause of death was asphyxia.
Thank you. Your way, please.
Mr. Binder.
I want to talk to you about your death certificate.
You signed this first was June 16, 1981, didn't you?
Yes. It's got Jimmy Ray Payne, death undetermined.
That's correct. Now, would you go along with me in the medical profession that this
is a solemn instrument, is it not?
Yes. Now you've got another report.
Instead of undetermined, it's now homicide.
That is correct.
That was after the defendant Wayne Williams was indicted for the murder of Jimmy Ray
Payne. I mean, you knew that, didn't you?
Yes. Did you not tell Inspector Will Shorted, Atlanta police that
if it had not been for other killings, that in all probability you would have ruled
Payne's death an accidental drowning?
No. No, I don't believe I said that.
Well, did you not tell an officer of the FBI that the death of Jimmy Ray
Payne could well be that of drowning?
Well, I didn't exclude drowning.
Would you please answer yes or no?
I can't just answer yes or no on a statement.
State yes or no?
Well, it could be yes, as I said.
Did you not tell Inspector Robbie Hamrick that in your opinion the
death of Jimmy Ray Payne could well be that of drowning?
And that you based your opinion on the fact that the body was clad in what
seemed to be red, bathe-type shorts, and the signs of asphyxiation
were not present?
Again, it can't be within this context.
Well, just answer yes or no, whether you did or not.
I don't remember.
Did you ever say to officers of the law that the height and weight of the
victim was underestimated by someone and that you thought it was done diabolically?
Yes. It was a suspicion I had.
I told them Jimmy Payne was 5' 6 or 7.
They put down 5' 2.
I feel that they put that down so he would seem smaller, smaller and more like
the other victims.
How did you come to your attention that Jimmy Ray Payne sold blood in this
community rather frequently?
No. No one told me he sold blood.
Well, would you tell the jury if a person sells blood frequently that it reduces
his blood level?
It can cause anemia.
And if he sells it frequently, would you go along with me to say that it
would reduce his platelets and that he could hemorrhage easily?
That's a difficult question to answer.
Yeah, but it happens, don't it?
Yes, it sometimes does.
Dr. Zackie, do you know how Jimmy Ray Payne died?
How he died?
Yes. I
have not been able to establish an exact mechanism for it.
Thank you, Dr.
Zackie. My
name is David Rufus Stingel.
Howdy. Hi, Chair Delage.
Hi. He's employed by the National Weather Service.
He's a service hydrologist.
Would you tell Mr.
Bindo why you're here?
I was called on to perform research specifically in relation to Jimmy Ray
Payne. My way.
I made a study about the path of the body in the river and where it
was found. Would you tell Mr.
Bindo what happened to your study?
They changed it.
Changed it? Jimmy Ray Payne was supposed to have been dropped off the right bank of
the river and found on the left side.
It was my job to find out how that could happen.
And how could it have happened?
There are only two ways that an object can move from one side of the river
to the other.
If it's carried by the currents or if there's some other external force moving
it. Go on.
I looked at the wind and the water currents and in neither case was there any
evidence of any mechanism that would move an object from one side of the river to
the other. What did you find?
I found that there was nothing in the wind or the currents that indicated that.
That's what they wanted me to change.
How do you feel about all this, Mr.
Dangle? I don't feel that things are being dealt with squarely.
Would you tell Mr.
Bindo what you asked permission to do?
I wanted to construct a floating dummy of the approximate size and weight of Jimmy
Ray Payne. So that we could monitor how an actual human body would move in the
river along the river bottom.
What did they tell you?
They said they didn't need me to do the research at this time and wouldn't give
me any expenses for it.
Supposing we paid your expenses to make these tests?
I don't know how it will come out.
There's always the possibility that my research may end up being damaging to your
case. Go ahead and make your experiments, Mr.
Dangle. Now
you're sure this approximates Payne's body?
Uh-huh. We're using the water for weight.
I was very careful to make sure the specific gravities were the same.
I call them Ferdinand.
Where'd you get it?
From the Fiz Ed Department, the local college.
They use them for first aid.
Should we lower them in there?
Yeah. They roll them over on the face down.
Alright, now push them out.
The floating dummy was released at the same point below the bridge on the right-hand
side where Wayne Williams was supposed to have thrown Jimmy Ray Payne's body.
Dangle tracked it as it moved downstream with the current.
The first five times, the dummy only traveled a short distance before it hit a
bend in the Chateau G.
on the right bank, and was snagged and held by branches and debris underneath the
surface. But Dangle released Ferdinand anyway and followed its path
down to the point where Payne's body was found.
Dangle would later testify that not only was it a good idea to have a good
idea of the potential for the next experiment, but not once in the dozen times
that Ferdinand was sent on his voyage.
Did he ever end up on the left side of the bank where Payne's body was
found? You want to take that detail when Wayne Williams
was arrested? Yes, sir.
You were the first one that heard his pledge?
Yes, sir. Are you familiar?
Was the body sitting in the water?
Yes, sir, I am.
Would you tell us how?
I was a swimmer on my high school team for three years, and I've life-gotted
for three years.
Would you tell us the sound you heard was that similar to anything that you've heard
before? Very similar to a body hitting the water.
Thank you.
Now, would you agree with me that along about three o'clock in the morning, it
gets pretty dark outside?
Yes, sir. I remember I had a Boy Scout troop once.
Do you have a Boy Scout?
Yes, sir. We used to camp out a lot.
You camp out a lot?
Yes, sir. When you wake up in the middle of the night, the slightest noise sounds
loud, doesn't it?
Yes, sir, when you wake up at night.
Sure it does.
Was it difficult for you to stay awake all the time?
Frankly, I was totally uncomfortable down there with all the animals and the noises.
I wasn't going to let any of them animals get to me.
The first night I was there, a beaver got very close to me.
Did it scare you?
Yes, sir, at the time, I didn't know it was a beaver.
You just don't like meeting them in the dark, do you?
I didn't like meeting anything in the dark under that bridge.
How many did you see?
30 to 50.
Well, the beavers always stay on the land, or they jump in the water now, then.
Both. Now, you were up there on the bank, and you heard a splash.
Would you tell the court majority whether or not the moon was shining, do you
remember? At the time, I don't believe it was.
Where was your flashlight?
Next to me.
Did you shine it on the water after you heard the splash?
Yes. See anything?
No. Now, when you joined the police force, didn't they tell you there were times
when policemen risked their lives for citizens?
I guess so.
You were a life guy.
You have to take some tests.
Did you qualify for that?
Yes, sir. And they teach you how to save people from drowning, don't they?
Yes, sir. And there are times when a man has got to take his life and
expose it to danger, doesn't he?
Yes, sir. Now, tell his court nurse, jury, did you dive in the water and try
to save the body?
You heard fall in the water that night.
No, sir. You didn't use the training you had to go
in there and try to save that which you thought was a body in the river?
No, sir.
You just failed the Boy Scout test.
They didn't in the trial.
The defense introduced another recruit who had been on the bridge detail.
Now, what if anything unusual?
Did you ever hear Mr.
Jacobson on the radio?
The most unusual thing we heard probably from anyone on all the bridges was
the ghost stories.
Well, what did he say in that regard?
He said he saw someone standing by the river's edge and he thought that maybe they
might be throwing a body into the river.
And a SWAT team was called in to investigate down into the woods and they
came back on the radio and said that he had only seen a ghost.
What sorts of noises do people make at night, if you know?
Well, if light is shined on them or they're scared, they make us splash
the noise with their tail on the water.
I wouldn't give anything that Mr.
Campbell ever tell you concerning Mr.
Jacobs' fear of the dark.
Well, he said he was afraid to even go out into the woods to urinate by
himself. Well,
you ever told, along with other recruits, that your status as a civilian employee
rather than as a regular police officer might result in any kind of
enrichment for you?
Lieutenant Dick Weber told him, you guys know you'll be able to collect a reward,
don't you?
Campbell turned around and said, that's okay, I'm going to split it with everybody.
Under what circumstances was that information given to all the recruits?
Because of the fact that the public was getting mad at the police department
because they couldn't find the child murderer.
Did you ever get assigned the job of going and collecting any type of animal here?
Well, yes, sir.
We were taken from the task force to go over to the Humane Society to check
records for owners of specific types of dogs.
What kind of dog here did they tell you to collect, Mr.
Lawson? Siberian Husky, Afghan Hound,
Russian Wolf Hound, and Malamute.
Did they ask you to get in a German Shepherd Head?
No. Do you know the type of person with regards to size
and physical prowess the task force was looking for?
We were told numerous times, you know, we were looking for an extremely large, strong
person. Did they have any suspects that you knew of at the time?
We had composite drawings of about 12 or 15.
They were hanging on the wall there at the task force.
Did any of them look like Wayne Williams?
No, sir, I don't recall any of them even looking close to Wayne Williams.
Do you know the defendant Wayne Williams on trial here today?
Yes. Would you point him out?
That's him.
I'd like to, if you will, refresh your memory and go back to the first time
you had an occasion to see him.
Would you tell us about that?
Well, I was in this record store downtown and I picked up this flyer.
A young lady at work down there, she gave it to me.
I said this guy was in the music business.
So I said, yeah, I'll give him a call because I'm trying to sell some of
my own music productions.
As a result, did you meet Mr.
Williams? Yes, I did.
Now, did you have occasion to see Wayne Williams at the Atlanta studios?
Yes, I did.
Now, did you ever have any conversation with Mr.
Williams? That seems strange to you?
Well, I talked to him about the murders once.
I said, what a shame it was that those children were getting killed now.
Well, how did the conversation go?
Well, I asked him what did he think about it.
You know, he just kind of said point blank.
I think they ought to keep the damn asses at home.
Now, anything else occur with regard to a note?
He was sitting down in the studio once and he gave me this note.
I think Carla Bailey snatched it out of my hand and threw it away or whatever.
Tyllis, as best you recall, what that note said and
your reaction to it.
Please, Jack, your honor, unless you can produce it.
His memory, your honor, he can testify as to what he recalls.
He's subject to cross-examination.
Okay. I'm going to let it in.
Thank you, your honor.
Now, what did that note say so far as you recall?
It could be a mayor.
It could be a president.
Or it could even be a killer.
And what was Wayne Williams' reaction to your reading that note?
I asked him, I said, who would do something like this?
And he just started laughing.
He started laughing?
Thank you, Mr.
Heisman. Did you know Nathaniel, Kater?
I did. When was the last time you saw him?
It was the Friday before he disappeared, May 15th.
Now, would you tell us about that?
I was headed for another neighbor's house, and I saw Nat sitting on a bench in
the park with another fellow.
What was Nathaniel doing in that neighborhood?
He lived with his mother and father, and they lived a few blocks away from the
park. Was there anybody with Nathaniel that day?
Yes, there was.
I remember quite well.
Why do you remember him?
The reason I noticed him was that he was a well-dressed man, and I had
never seen Nat sitting with a man that was dressed like that.
What did you have on?
Grey trousers and a grey long-sleeve shirt.
Did you notice any animals around?
That was a dog, a German shepherd.
Do you see the man in court that you saw on the park bench with Nathaniel,
Kater? Yes. Would you point him out?
He's sitting between the lady and the man, right there in the blue.
She's with you.
You know Wayne Williams before he saw him on TV?
I didn't. Do you remember saying on a newscast, you saw Wayne Williams
with Nathaniel Kater on Memorial Day?
Three days after Wayne Williams was supposed to have thrown Nathaniel Kater
off the bridge?
No, I do not.
Did you ever tell him about the death of a man?
You saw Miss Epstein, you saw Miss Twain in the shirt with two hands printed on
the material? Two hands hugging the woman's body.
But you said it was a well-dressed man wearing grey trousers and a grey long
-sleeve shirt. Well, it's still the grey shirt that got the palm of the woman's hand
hugging the body.
You said that Mr.
Kater lived with his mother and father when he last saw
her. Yes. Now, little lady, didn't you know that Mrs.
Kater died in 1973?
Well, I had no idea of that.
But you said you knew him very well.
Well, yes, I knew him well.
Now, tell me about that dog.
Do you like dogs?
Yes, I have a dog.
Oh, what kind do you got?
I have a German Shepherd.
You like that dog?
I love him.
Was that other dog pretty frisky?
Yeah, frisky. He was a real playing dog.
Playing dog?
Later in the trial, Binder introduced a most unusual witness.
Your Honor, there's been a great deal of speculation about my next witness.
There have been rumors that they've had to build an electric fence around the Williams
home to protect people from it.
He's been characterized by newspapers and by witnesses being ferocious, frisky,
and a dangerous ally, Mr.
Williams. Ladies and gentlemen, including
members of the jury,
I want everybody to be absolutely quiet during this demonstration.
The dog in question is going to be brought in the court, and we don't want
to unnecessarily excite the dog.
Proceed, Mr. Binder.
Let the record reflect that the dog in question was brought into the courtroom.
The jury has had an opportunity to observe the dog, to
determine whether or not the dog is frisky.
I'm going to go to the court.
Mr. Slayton, how do you think the trial is going?
How do you think it's going?
We tend to think that your apprehension is about Mr.
Binder, that he might make the witness not too smart.
Is this happening?
Well, I enjoy watching Mr.
Binder work. He's a brilliant attorney.
But still, earlier in the trial, some of the fiber evidence, for instance, I believe
the jury will find overwhelming.
But there's some feeling that fiber evidence, without further corroboration, is
not sufficient to convict a man.
If you excuse me, I better get back to my law books, as you can see.
I have to do my homework to keep up with Mr.
Binder. Whoops. Sorry.
Come on in, Chuck.
I'm a diabetic.
If you want to have to give me a shot, I'll have all sorts of strange
things happen to me.
I just want to tell you, I think you're doing a terrific job.
Thank you. The most important place coming up tomorrow, though, the fibers.
Yeah, I know.
More travesty of justice than true justice.
It's perpetrated by trace evidence in the courtroom.
Jury's like it when a district attorney parades a lot of scientific paraphernalia
in front of them.
It gives a mental image of a white smock stainless steel gloves, a glass of
porcelain. And they put gray credence in scientific showmanship, yup.
He had a heart attack last year, too.
I'm not an invalid yet.
Keep looking at the mothers in the courtroom and wondering what they're
thinking. Do they think I'm trying to get the murderer of their sons off?
They keep looking at Wayne.
Wonder what they're thinking about.
These fibers are taken from the green carpet found in Wayne Williams' bedroom.
And ones that were taken from the bodies of Jimmy Payne and Nathaniel Cater.
Can you explain the shape of the green carpet fiber found in Williams'
home? The appearance of this fiber shows a tri
-lobal-like carpet fiber.
It is uncommon because of the unusual design used by the Wellman Company.
Miss Payson, could you look over here, exhibit 638?
These represent two fibers which I recovered from the shorts of Jimmy Payne.
The bedspread that was found in the Williams' house seemed to be darker in
appearance than the fibers which I recovered from the shorts of Jimmy Payne.
I subjected the bedspread to a three-day period in water obtained
from the Chattahoochee River and allowed it to sit on a window sill.
To see if that might change the physical appearance of the fibers.
There was a bleaching effect.
What are these other fibers over here, sir?
637. Now these are eight other fibers that were found from Wayne Williams' environment
on the bodies of the victim.
Thank you, Miss Payson.
Would you take the stand again, please?
Did you have occasion to make comparisons of the animal hair
you recovered from Mr.
Payne with the animal hair that you recovered from the Williams doll?
Yes, I did.
What is your conclusion?
I found that they were consistent.
Based on your examination of the fibers and hairs found upon
Jimmy Payne and Nathaniel Cater and the comparison of the
fibers and hairs found in the home of defendant Wayne Williams, do
you have an opinion as to the significance of these comparisons?
In my opinion, the combination of these fibers found on one or more of
the victims make it almost impossible for them to have come from any environment
other than Wayne Williams'.
Thank you, Mr.
Payson. You may as well.
Do you have a list of the policemen that handled the bodies of Payne Cater before
you abandoned them?
I have no knowledge of them.
Yes or no?
No, I have no such list.
Have you determined whether any of these people left fibers on the bodies
of Payne Cater?
In my opinion, there would have been a direct physical contact with the victim.
Any question that provides for a yes or no answer, would you please answer?
Now, have you determined that none of the people that handled the bodies contributed
to the transfer of the fibers to the body of Payne or Cater, yes or
no? No.
Did you ascertain whether some of the fibers could have come from the debris of
the river?
I did examine a sample of water obtained from the Cater which had a later date.
I determined that there were none.
Had a later date?
Would you tell the jury what that date was?
September 14th. You know, I pretended to tell the jury that on September the 14th,
the composition of the water was exactly the same as the day that the deceased body
was found four months earlier, are you?
I don't know what the difference may have been in the composition of the water.
What was the total number of fibers you removed from Mr.
Payne? I don't know the exact number.
Hundreds? Yes, hundreds.
You looked at those fibers and as you didn't find none of them would match in
a Williams home, you didn't look no further, did you?
I compared the fibers.
Answer, yes or no?
I don't believe I could answer that with a yes or no answer.
What I am asking you is a scientist and an expert.
Just tell the jury.
Honestly, did you or did you not go any further?
Yes, I did, consider them further.
Oh, we're down to the homes of Payne and Cater and
see if any of those fibers were the same types that could be associated with
living environment?
No. You go to the place where Payne stayed a hundred years?
I have no personal knowledge of where Mr.
Payne and Mr.
Kate Frick were.
So the answer is no.
That's correct.
You're down to the Falcon Hotel and go in the room and do a search for
Dog Hair yourself?
I did that myself, no.
Can you specifically state that Dog Hair was necessarily from the breed of a German
Shepherd? Not specifically, no.
Well, prior to Wayne Williams coming to your knowledge, you all were looking
for Malamute or Husky Dog Hair, weren't you?
I had made the subjective evaluation to determine that a Husky
or a Malamute may be involved.
Yes or no?
Yes. Now, isn't it true, when you found that dog down
there at the William's home, Malamute and Husky went out the window and the fibers on
the body became that of a German Shepherd?
The hairs, which I examined, were consistent with that type breed, not to the
exclusion of others.
You can't tell, Mike, by a dog hair, can you?
Now, those fibers from the shorts and those
you found from the bedspread as a scientist, chemist
or expert, those light fibers, they bothered you, didn't they?
Couldn't get them at you, looking for, could you?
When the comparison was first made against the
American Shepherd, fibers pulled directly from the bedspread as against the question
fibers, the difference was significant in the mind.
Yes. And you started with spare men and you never could get it the right color,
could you?
Well, I managed to get them very close,
but not exactly the same.
The answer is
no. Would
you tell the jury whether or not you made this observation?
And as a scientist, forensics,
a relatively new kid on the block and you never know what a jury is going
to do, but I'm optimistic about our case.
Did you make that statement?
Yes, sir. Now, when you make a statement like that about this case, aren't
you departing from that detached house where the scientist lives and
becoming a member of the prosecution team?
No, sir. I don't think so.
Al, I'm afraid that what we feared all along
is going to happen.
I have heard that they're going to try to introduce ten other cases with a
justification of pattern.
Other cases now?
Yes, ma'am.
I guess they can see their case against Williams as an entirely substantial.
So they want to introduce other murders to the trial with a justification that there
was similar pattern in those cases.
What is that?
Well, if you can say the kids were bludgeoned, strangled, suffocated, stabbed,
left on land in the water in the front of buildings and in the woods as
a pattern, there's pattern.
Your Honor, may I approach the bench to that?
Yes, you may.
Thank you.
The state is prepared to present at this time an evidence of the
murders which will tend to prove planned scheme pattern bent
to mind and identity.
Your Honor, the introduction of other murders
would be so inflammatory that my client would not possibly receive
a fair trial.
Either they indict him for the murders they want to bring in or they let it
go. Under the authority of state versus Johnson and Vass, others,
it is the obligation and responsibility to introduce Adam.
I will hear arguments.
Thank you.
The jury may be excused.
Slave. Thank
you. The first case where
there is a pattern is the case of Alfred Evans.
We are dealing with a victim, black, male, comes from a
situation of poverty, a broken home, a street, hustler.
Vulnerable to be in picked up.
There's no evidence of forced abduction.
There is a method of body disposal which is
quite unique. People apparently are killed and dumped.
There are fibers from the bedspread of the defendant, carpet fibers, dog
hairs, various other fibers.
Next case,
Eric Middlebrooks,
street hustler.
The gear disappears and then he's found, dumped, laid out
on his back.
Pat Baltazar, gear in the street hustler.
May it please the court, Johnna.
I don't think he should refer to these deceased as street hustlers.
The only thing these poor children had in common was that they were poor.
But if that is justification for pattern in America, the
courts would be filled with requests like this.
Overruled. Proceed.
Lupigida, young,
black, poor family,
street hustler,
strangled. And you can say the same thing in these five
other cases.
That's Charles Stevens, Jojo Bell,
Lear Rogers, John Porter, William Barrett.
All murdered in the same way.
All vulnerable to be in picked up.
No forced abduction.
Unusual method of disposal in the body.
Killed and dumped.
As in many cases,
they are fibers in which there is a match.
Thank you.
Mr. Binder.
Your Honor, Your Honor, there is no pattern here.
Pattern would lead you to believe they all died the same way, but they didn't.
Asphyxiation. Strangulation by an object.
You heard the doctor.
Plunt trauma to the head, stab wounds.
Where is the pattern?
If there is a pattern, it is in the minds of those who indicted
the defendant. Nowhere else.
Slate. Connections run through these cases unmistakably.
The pattern is obvious that it has caught the attention of the entire western world.
The western world is obsessed with child murders.
But the fact is my client is charged with killing one man of
21 and another of 28.
Your Honor, the public confidence depends on facts
in a courtroom being developed within the rules of evidence.
It is imperative that evidence be excluded, which may
unduly prejudice the defendant based on uncharged crimes.
The court will take this matter under submission.
Mr. Hatch, your Honor, there is no question.
Where the hell have you been?
I'm looking all over the place for you.
You all right?
Chet, whoops.
They're gonna introduce pattern.
I just heard.
I really didn't believe they would.
It wasn't enough.
I had two murders against Wayne.
I have so many documents and witnesses to interview that I haven't had time for.
Now they want me to defend them against 10 more murders.
Now look, my friend, you already had one heart attack six months ago.
Let's put this out and get you upstairs.
Yeah. You good for this?
Yeah. Okay, let's go.
Shit, I'm trying to say something nice to me.
If you want to hear something right here, I'll go see you.
Parents are here again.
Tell them I'm busy.
Look, why won't you see us, ma'am?
Did you hear them in the courtroom?
Did you hear what they're saying?
They're calling our kids street hustlers.
But Yusuf was nine years old when he died.
What kind of street hustler comes from a nine-year-old child who was an honor
student of his class?
Who was only out after dark if he was doing some errand for some old person
who couldn't get out of the store?
When a white kid go out and earn a dollar washing cars or running errands, that's
just enterprise. But when one of our kids do the same thing, he ain't nothing but
a low-down dirty street hustler.
Why do they have to lie about him?
Look, people, you've come to the wrong place.
Go to Slayton, go to Mayor Jackson, go to Lee Brown.
I'm nothing here.
I'm just an errand boy.
They're the ones who run the city.
If you've got a complaint, go to them.
They won't talk to us.
You know that.
Every night I see my baby in my dreams.
I had hoped that I would see some kind of meaning to their death, but there
isn't going to be, is there?
Look, I'm not God.
I don't have a pipeline into Wayne Williams' mind.
Do you care that much about that damn badge?
How much do you need that money?
How much do you need that money?
They're right.
They're no better than the others.
You're not the prosecutor, you're not the judge.
So what do they want from you?
You know something?
Walker said those same words to me.
Murders never would have reached these proportions if people had stopped worrying
about trying to protect their own positions.
Well, what can you do?
I can tell them about the witnesses that are coming up.
Come in. You listen to me.
I've seen you leave this house, what with fear, to go out into the street into
some scene where you could get the life blown out of you.
I've seen you get up and answer a call when you were so tired that every
inch of you ate.
You can't lose everything you have?
For what?
What if he isn't guilty of the murders?
You know and I know they're going to find Wayne Williams guilty no matter what you
do or no matter what anybody does.
They talk about pain in Cade and that courtroom.
You could be out and trying to sell blood tomorrow to pay for the grocery bills.
That's how close we are to the edge.
What are you doing?
This is Ben.
Meet me at the Three Dooses.
Never mind what for, just meet me there.
Who is that?
That is Demetra.
What are you going to do?
You're not going to tell them anything you shouldn't are you?
You're not going to put yourself in jeopardy.
You're not going to put all of us in jeopardy are you?
Why this cloaking diagram meeting you afraid it may ensay in my company?
I'm going to give you some information.
Why? There are some things I think the defense should know.
It's the case like that.
Listen Ben, if I were not disturbed, we'd rather not tell everything I knew to the
press than resign.
You can do that though, would you?
I'm not that big a fool.
Why would I be being a fool?
What impact would it have?
Another cops opinion?
You resigned, how much good did it do?
I resigned because I felt I had to.
Right, now you're on the outside.
This way I at least have access to information.
I can use the labs.
I have some influence.
Outside I'm just another loner like you.
Scouting around, finding whatever, without resources that might have been available to
me. Yeah, well I've been saying the same thing all over again, so save the lecture.
Just tell me why I'm here.
I want to tell you about a witness named Darrell Davis.
Another one who calls himself Cool Breeze.
I'm listening.
I'm listening.
I'm listening.
I'm listening.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.