All language subtitles for L.A. Law S05E15 The Beverly Hills Hangers

Previously on L .A. Law.

News on Victor.

It looks like the brother will have
permanent brain damage.

Oh, God.

Guy who hit him registered .16.

Drunk driver.

Okay, I'm hereby granting your petition.

The life support equipment shall be
disconnected.

Well, if you were having an affair with
Rosalind Shays, would you tell anybody?

You're sleeping with her.

Please leave, Anne. I don't trust that
woman. For those of you who have been

skipping page one for the last few
months, Miss Davis and her lover is

with murdering her 72 -year -old
husband.

The Beverly Hills Hangers. The very one.

My last lawyer suggested I plead out.
That means either he thinks I'm guilty

he doesn't think he can win.

John Fryer's a pretty sharp defense
attorney.

If he's telling me to admit to a crime I
didn't commit, Mr. Mullaney, he's not

sharp enough.

How would you describe her spirits?

Her husband's dead. The police are
blaming her. You people are calling her

hanging bitch every day in the papers.

She is unhappy.

I went in on this case, Michael, as much
as possible. Don't worry, Tommy. I got

big plans for you. Good, because this
thing... Yeah, this is serious juice.

Maybe you got the flu.

It ain't the flu.

It's just nerve.

Big trials make me nauseous.

No,

no, Mike, I'm okay.

I'm feeling better by the second.

This is a good thing, you know? It means
that I'm ready.

Yeah, but you look white.

Gwen Hall.

Best goalie in the history of hockey.
Used to puke before every game.

Means you're ready. That's all. I'm
pumped.

Okay. We're going to leave here at 10
.15. Oh, the judge said the cameras are

okay in the courtroom. Great.

You coming to the staff meeting?

In a second. I just want to go over this
a couple more times.

Okay, people, settle in.

First up, happy birthday, Leland
McKenzie. Happy birthday.

How old today?

102. You look good.

Thank you. First item, the big day is
finally upon us. Yes. People versus

David. All right. We open in an hour.
We're ready to go. Excellent.

We'll have a command post set up here in
the conference room. Any surprises come

up at trial, we'll have lawyers ready to
jump. Great. We gonna win? We got a

shot. I like our jury draw. I like Judge
Gates. Cook's one of the best DAs, but

his case has holes. Keep him off guard
wherever you can.

Disrupt his rhythm, he's less effective.

And we held back a couple of motions in
limine just so we could spring the

objections at the trial, put him back on
his heels a little. With all the

publicity, we want that acquittal.

Moving on. Leland, you're handling the
Cheever's prospectus. Ann and I go over

the final draft tomorrow. It'll go out
to the client by Friday. Very good.

Victor, any other cases you want
reassigned?

Uh, no. I'm back.

Fine. Again, let me reiterate everyone's
sympathy.

If there's anything you need from us,
please don't hesitate.

I just want to say that the support that
you've all been giving me is

overwhelming, and I'll always be
grateful to all of you for that.

Thanks.

Miss Davis has no comment. No comment.

Miss Davis is also not wearing her hair
back,

contrary to previous reports.

It was the perfect crime.

The victim was despondent over cancer,
so he just strung himself up.

Grieving, shocked widow discovers the
body, calls the police, everybody cries,

the will gets probated, and Ricky
Davis...

inherits $26 million.

Now, I'm sure the original plan when she
married this 70 -year -old man with

cancer was to just patiently wait out
his death. She had her lover on the

It wasn't as if she was making much of a
sacrifice.

But when Harold Davis suddenly decided
to divorce her, the game plan was

She'd lose everything by virtue of a
prenuptial agreement, and she wasn't

to let that happen. Oh, no. So she and
her lover, David Schaefer, motivated

solely by greed, staged an apparent
suicide and hanged Harold Davis to his

death.

That's what the evidence will show,
ladies and gentlemen.

Ricky Davis murdered her husband for his
money.

It's as simple as that.

Quiet, please.

Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, my
name is Tommy Mullaney.

My partner is Michael Cusack, and
together we represent that woman sitting

there. Her name is Ricky Davis.

Now, I'm sure you have read a lot about
this lady, and if you're reading the

same papers as me, You gotta be
thinking, she's guilty.

I know, I thought that. That day she
walked into our office for the first

But then we began piecing together the
facts.

Then, when she passed our lie detector
test... Objection!

That's out of line. You know better than
that. The jury is to disregard that

last remark.

A polygraph test is not deemed reliable.

You're to give that statement no weight
whatsoever.

Mr. Mullaney, don't test me. I
apologize.

You see, hanging is a very tricky thing.
It's easy for it to go wrong.

Now, Ricky had access to his medication.

She could have drugged him to death.

She knew where he kept his gun. She had
easier ways to stage a suicide if that's

what she wanted to do.

But hanging him?

That's tough.

Why would she choose that? And why would
she discover the body with her lover

and draw attention to her infidelity?

Does that make sense to you? No, it's
too easy.

I mean, sure, we got a dead guy. There's
no doubt about that.

And we have got a defendant with a
motive. No argument there either. But

isn't any case.

Forget about what you've been reading.

You pay attention here.

We're going to pull the curtain off the
prosecution's dog and pony show.

You just watch us. My only request here
is that you all pay attention.

And if you do, we won't have to ask you
for anything else.

I promise.

Oh, now, you didn't have to get me
anything.

Well, at your age, birthdays are at a
premium.

Demand and supply, you know.

That's very touching.

Oh, my.

This is beautiful.

You like it?

Well, superb, but it's too much. I mean,
it's way, way too much.

There's an inscription on the back.

Just say yes.

Yes to what?

Leland.

Will you marry me?

Yes to what?

I'm serious, Leland.

I don't want to shock you.

I mean, usually I am the master of
subtlety, but I just don't know how to

into something like this.

I've just been so happy the last four
months, and I'm not a young gal, and I

know what I want.

You want me?

I want to be your wife.

What about me? When do I testify?

I'm not sure I'm putting you up there.

Why not?

Well, the truth is, Ricky, you come off
unlikable.

I think the jury will read you as cold.

I also think that Cook will tear you
apart on the adultery and no one will

two cents about you after that.

But if I don't take the stand, it'll
look like I'm hiding something.

Well, maybe, but I still think that...
Do you really think that it's better to

hide what I am than to let them actually
see it?

Listen to me, both of you. I don't want
to be buried away in this, to be

shielded from the jury like I'm the...

selfish bitch that the press keeps
calling me. I'm not that person.

I don't want to be treated like that
person. Not by them and not by you. You

understand me?

Look, this is a murder trial.

Tomorrow morning I am facing off against
a seasoned homicide detective. The man

is a pro.

I got a lot of work to do here.

So let us do what we do.

Who the hell do you think you are
talking to me like that?

We know you're scared, Ricky.

Everybody is a little scared.

But you got to trust us. You just got
to.

Detective, when you arrived at the
scene, what did the defendant tell you?

and Mr. Schaefer returned to the house
and found the deceased suspended from

ceiling. She stated it was her belief
that Mr. Davis had taken his own life.

Did the evidence support her belief?

No, it did not.

Why not, detective?

Well, first of all, you can see by the
scrape marks around the victim's neck

that he tried to free himself.

And second, we dusted the beam and cord
and found one clean print.

It belonged to the defendant.

We also found a partial print which
matched David Schaefer. They said these

prints got there when they attempted to
cut the victim down after discovering

it. Well, if that were true, there would
have been prints all over the beam and

cord. The fact that we found just the
two suggests that somebody tried to wipe

the surfaces clean and just wasn't
careful enough. What other evidence

you to the defendant?

Well, the will and also the fact the
defendant never had an alibi except to

that she went for a drive with Mr.
Schaefer following the brunch.

Did you confront her with your
suspicions? Yes, I did. She said she

speak with her attorney.

Thank you, detective.

Nothing further.

Was there any sign of a struggle in the
bedroom? No. Wasn't that strange?

Do you think that they put the noose
around his neck and then politely asked

to stand up on a chair while they tied
the other end around the beam? Well, we

believe that he was rendered unconscious
first.

Right.

According to your initial report, you
say you believe the victim was struck in

the forehead with a blunt object which
knocked him unconscious, after which he

was hanged. We now believe he was
suffocated into a state of

Oh, really?

Well, why do you believe that,
Detective?

Because the symptoms of suffocation and
hanging are the same, so there'd be no

evidence of it. So, in other words,
there is no evidence of it. Now,

if, in fact, he was suffocated into
unconsciousness before he was hanged,

how do you explain the scratch marks on
his face and neck that he got while he

was supposedly trying to free himself?

He probably regained consciousness right
before the hanging.

Ah.

Well, is there any evidence of that?
Yeah, the scratch marks. They clearly

this wasn't something that he wanted to
do. Well, maybe he changed his mind. I

mean, hanging is a very brutal, horrible
way to go, isn't it? Yeah. Yeah. In

fact, you yourself investigated another
hanging suicide three years ago in which

the victim also tried to claw himself
free. Isn't that right, detective?

There was one such incident, yes.

Thank you.

Okay, on to the fingerprints. Now, there
were a lot of smudged, unusable prints

all over the cord and the beam, right?
Yeah. Now, isn't it possible that in

their panic, in their frantic attempts
to free Mr. Davis from the noose, that

they smudged a lot of their own prints
and left only a few clean ones?

It's not impossible. Thank you,
detective.

And in fact, from all the physical
evidence, Harold Davis could have

suicide, right?

Yes, but I don't think so.

Thank you, detective.

That's all.

I still think we have a problem with the
profit definition.

It's ambiguous at best, and that's going
to be construed against us if anything

goes wrong.

Are you listening to me?

Oh, yes.

What's the matter, Leland? Come on, this
stuff is tough enough without you

drifting off into outer space.

I'm sorry.

Okay, so, um... Ann, last night,
Rosalind Chase proposed

to me.

Proposed what?

Marriage. She gave me a beautiful
Cartier watch and asked me to be her

How exciting.

You think... Well, what do you think
about the two of us as a couple?

You seem very cute.

Could you see yourself standing at our
wedding ceremony?

I'm sure it would be lovely.

The truth, Anne.

I would sooner dive headfirst into my
own vomit.

Anne. Dating her is one thing. Sleeping
with her is another. But to exchange

wedding vows with a person who can shed
her skin and swallow large rats whole is

something... I don't need that much
truth. Leland, how can you even think of

marrying that woman? I'm lonely, Anne.

Rosalind and I, we laugh together.

We have a wonderful intellectual
relationship and, uh...

See, I'm 62 years old, and loneliness,
it's everything they say it is.

Do you love her?

I'm very fond of her.

You're very fond of her?

Mm -hmm.

I'm sorry, Leland.

Hey, I am certainly no authority on
marriage.

My first one ended in divorce, and
Stuart and I... Well...

We still have our problems, but at the
core of it all, I love him and trust him

more than anybody I've ever known or
ever will know.

Can you say that about Rosalind?

Well, I'm not asking myself those kinds
of questions.

It's a much simpler test.

I know my life without her.

I've seen my life with her.

I'm happier with her.

Your Honor, people call Marion Davis to
the stand.

Your Honor, the defense objects to this
witness being called.

No relevance, Your Honor. She's the
victim's daughter, Judge. Mr. Davis made

certain statements to her regarding the
defendant.

That's your say and admissible. Dead man
statute.

It does not apply. Quiet.

We're not going to discuss this in here.
Let's go.

All for a proof.

The victim told her that the defendant
had been acting strangely, that she

seemed up to something. Now, this was
one week before the murder. That is

prejudicial, you're saying.

We can give an instruction. Oh, come on.
The daughter hates Ricky Davis. The

father knew it. He could be saying this
crap to appease her. We got no means of

assuring reliability here. He's right.
I'm not going to put her up there and

that stuff. It'd be a reversible error.
Next witness.

Your Honor. Next witness.

Mark Shalios, the victim's lawyer.

Objection. We object to him, too. It's
also hearsay. Plus attorney -client.

Privilege doesn't extend beyond the
client's life. That is a still hearsay.

Honor, I need this witness to establish
motive. He is the only person who can

testify as to the victim's intent to
divorce the defendant. That's why they

to shut him down. It is an out -of
-court declaration being admitted for

truth. It's black -letter hearsay. I'm
going to allow it. What? Your Honor. You

can't. Yes, I can.

Then I want Mr. Shalios' files for
discovery.

Work product privilege.

No, no, no, no, no.

You can't have it both ways, Mr. Cook.
If you want the lawyer to testify, fine.

But first, you give all his files to the
defense by 3 o 'clock this afternoon.

Not 3 .30, not 3 .15. 3 o 'clock. You'll
be on the stand tomorrow.

All right. Here we go.

Attorney Michael Kuzak staggered the
prosecution badly with his cross

-examination of Detective Foley.

Good.

Listen to this.

Ricky's lawyers blocked the victim's
daughter, Marion Davis, from even taking

the stand.

The daughter was also considered to be a
key prosecution witness.

And right now, John, the district
attorney's office is reportedly

We still got serious work to do here.

Tommy,

hit it.

Tomorrow's witness, attorney Mark
Shellios, victim's lawyer.

He's produced six boxes of files on
Harold Davis. I've been through four

already. They're very well organized,
nothing unusual.

Yeah, he'll testify about the will and
who takes what, and no surprises there.

Stewart, you checked off on that?

Yeah, it's very simple. No codicils. He
left everything to the American Cancer

Society, unless survived by Ricky, in
which case he takes everything.

There's nothing ambiguous about it. Only
thing is, he...

He may not have been witnessed properly.

Meaning what? Probably nothing. If he
dies in test day, she gets everything

anyway. CJ, you got any dirt on this
guy?

Not yet.

Single man.

Dates various women. Clean living.

Basically pretty dull.

A Rick Stevens, the PI, has signed.

So if there's anything under this guy's
nails, we will know.

Okay. Jonathan, give Abby a hand with
the rest of those files.

Now, the prosecution should rest
tomorrow with strong motive and shaky

evidence. I'll move for the directed
verdict, but it probably won't go.

That means we start off with our
forensic expert and move on to the

Now, are you going to put Ricky on the
stand?

We don't know yet. Oh, do it. They'll
suspect if you don't. Hey, hey, we don't

know yet, all right?

Jonathan, Abby, get to work on those
files.

Tommy, you and I should get some sleep.

Who can sleep?

You had been Mr. Davis's lawyer for how
long, sir? Since 1978.

And under the terms of his most recent
will, how much money did the defendant,

Ricky Davis, stand to inherit?

As the lone beneficiary, she stood to
inherit the entire estate.

Valued at about $26 million.

And, sir, if they were divorced?

Prenuptial agreement limited her to $500
,000.

Mr. Shalios, when was the last time you
spoke with the deceased, Harold Davis?

Five days before his death.

Could you tell us what was said?

Objection here, sir.

Overruled.

Mr. Chalios, what did Mr. Davis tell
you? He told me he wanted to file for

divorce from his wife, Ricky.

She was being unfaithful, and he wanted
to terminate the marital relationship.

And five days later, he was found hanged
to death?

Yes.

And, sir, who besides the defendant
stood to gain from Mr. Davis's death?

Nobody. At least no individual.

If she survived him, she took all.

If she didn't?

He went to the American Cancer Society.

And, sir, do you have any reason to
believe Harold Davis was suicidal?

Objection. Overruled. Answer the
question.

He was not suicidal.

He was upbeat. You've got to be kidding.

Shut down, Mr. Kuzak, or I'll hold you
in contempt.

Continue, Mr. Shalios. His spirits were
up.

In fact, on the day he called me about
the divorce, he asked me to establish

contact with the oncology departments at
both the Sloan Kettering Hospital and

the Johns Hopkins Hospital.

What for? To determine whether they had
any experimental treatments for liver

cancer.

This man wanted to live. Both of you.
Both of you.

Don't make me warn you again. The
testimony is allowed.

I have nothing further.

Do you have any psychiatric training,
Mr. Shellius? No, I do not.

You got any clinical or educational
training which would allow you to

whether or not a person is suicidal?

I knew Mr. Davis... Answer my question,
sir.

I have no formal training.

One second, please.

I have nothing further, Your Honor.

Thank you, Mr. Shellius.

Mr. Cook?

People call as its last witness, Mr.
David Schaefer.

Objection. Your Honor, this is a
surprise.

He's on our witness list. Well, they put
more than 100 people on their witness

list, Your Honor. The chances of this
man being called were almost nil. He's

on the same chart. But he's on their
list, Mr. Cusack. He can call the

I'll give you an hour of recess.

Son of a bitch.

What's going on? He cut a deal with his
testifying. He had to cut something.

Ricky, if you've been holding anything
back, now's the time to come clean. What

can Schaefer say?

Nothing. He's innocent. We're both
innocent.

What about when you broke up? The
Schaefer guy got an axe to grind?

He was hurt, yes, but so what? He can't
testify to anything except to the fact

that I was an unfaithful wife.

Listen, if we are not prepped for him,
we could get killed out there.

Think hard.

Does he have any information that could
be of use to them? There isn't any

information for him to have, Michael.

Knock, knock.

Rosalind, what a surprise. I just
dropped Leland off from lunch.

Do you have a second?

Um, sure.

Can we sit?

Of course.

How have you been?

Fine, fine.

You?

I know we're not very close, so what I'm
about to say may hit you like a depth

charge.

Two nights ago, I asked Leland to marry
me.

Wow. Yeah, wow.

He said he needed some time to think
about it, and it's my feeling that he

probably come to you. Why me?

Because nobody else here is married
except Stuart.

And you, no doubt, will have the
strongest opinions.

Knowing Leland, he will want to confront
the thickest part of the wall.

What do you want from me, Rosalind? An
open mind.

I love him very much.

I didn't think I'd ever fall in love
again, but I did.

He's on the fence, Anne.

I'd just like for you not to impulsively
push him to the other side.

The truth is, Rosalind, Leland did come
to me on this.

I might have nudged him a little.

Nudged?

Actually, I was kicking him with both
feet.

I don't think he should marry you.

I'm sorry.

Okay.

Rosalind, nobody has done a bigger about
-faith on you than I have.

A year ago, I probably considered you to
be the most unredeemable person I had

ever had the displeasure of meeting.

Now, I not only admire you, I actually
like you.

But with you and Leland, I just don't
see it.

Well, as always, you're honest.

Thank you for that.

I really do love him.

Rosalind?

I didn't change his mind.

Could you state your name for the
record, please? David Alan Schaefer. Mr.

Schaefer, could you state your
relationship with the defendant, Miss

Davis? Between the period of September
of 1989 and October of 1990, we were

lovers. Sir, I call your attention to
the date August 19, 1990.

Were you with the defendant on that day?

Yes, I was.

We had brunch at Mirabella Restaurant on
Sunset.

And then we went to her Beverly Hills
home.

That's where we discovered the body.

Mr. Davis's body?

Yes, sir. He was hanging from the
ceiling in his bedroom.

What did you do?

Well, we tried briefly to get him down.
He was clearly dead.

So... We called the police. They came.
Three days later, Ricky and I were

arrested and charged with the crime.

Did you have anything to do with this
man's death, Mr. Schaefer? No, I did

To your knowledge, did Ricky Davis have
anything to do with his death?

Well, I certainly didn't think so at the
time, but now I think she did.

Order.

I want you to tell us why.

Objection. This man's opinion is...
Overruled. Every time we get to the good

parts, you start objecting.

I object to that.

Go ahead, sir. Well, first off, Ricky
had been acting strangely all week. The

second thing is, she would never take me
back to her house in Beverly Hills.

Never. But on this day, it seemed very
important that I go with her.

I think it was to establish an alibi.

Objection. Objection. Again, sir, just
tell us what you know. Keep your

to yourself.

Anything else, Mr. Schaefer?

Yes.

About a week before that day, I was
riding with her in her car. That's when

noticed the book in the back seat with a
bookmark in it. Did you open this book?

Yes, I did. It was a book on knots.

Excuse me? All kinds of rope knots.

And the page that was marked was a
chapter on bunt line knots.

Bunt line knots?

Which meant nothing to me at the time.
But about three weeks ago, my lawyer

asked me to go through all the reports
on my arrest.

And that's where I saw it, that the knot
on the cord that was used to hang Mr.

Davis was a bundline knot.

Mr.

Schaefer, you're giving this testimony
in exchange for charges against you

dropped. Isn't that right?

But I'm telling the truth.

I didn't want to believe this.

I loved her very much.

But I can't ignore the facts.

Thank you, Mr. Schaefer.

That's all.

Let me see now, Mr.

Schaefer. According to your testimony
here, you had all the pieces to this

puzzle three weeks ago.

Why didn't you speak up then? I did. The
district attorney didn't want to make a

deal until yesterday.

Let's cut to the bone, Mr. Schaefer.

Yesterday, you're up on murder charges.
And today, you're a free man in exchange

for this ridiculous story.

I am telling the truth.

Of course you are. Why would you lie?

Just to avoid ending up in the gas
chamber?

No. Move to strike that. Withdrawn. No
further use for this witness.

I have a couple more questions.

Mr. Schaefer, was this Ricky Davis's car
or was this the family car?

It was the one she used to drive most of
the time. To your knowledge, did Mr.

Davis ever drive this car?

Yes. Mr. Schaefer, did you ever have
occasion to go sailing with Harold

Yes. Now, the book that you found in the
back seat of the car, the title of that

book was Nautical Knot. Isn't that
right?

Yes. It's possible that that book
belonged to Mr.

Davis, isn't it, sir?

It was the car that she used to drive
most of the time. Yeah, but it's

that the book belonged to him, right?

Yes, I suppose it's possible.

I don't know.

I don't think he really nailed us. I
mean, the jury saw him for what he was,

don't you think?

I don't know.

I mean, at this point, it's hard to know
nothing.

Okay, our witnesses.

Witnesses.

Chris Harris, forensics, going first.
He's yours.

Psychiatrist, Dr. John Busick, second.

Also yours.

I'm taking all the character witnesses.

Wake up, cool gentleman.

One of the women.

Attorney Mark Chelios has been dating is
Marion Davis, daughter of the victim.

What? Mm -hmm.

This was taken two nights ago, even
though you can't make her out.

This was taken last night. That's
definitely her. And note the shoes.

The same.

Also, Rick showed her picture around the
various eating establishments

frequented by Mr. Chelios.

And people there remember seeing her as
far back as six months ago.

Tommy, get Stuart on the phone. Get him
in here.

Yeah, it's quarter to 12. I don't care.
Wake him up. C .J., Mark Shalios' office

building. Videotape records everybody
who goes in and comes out. You told me

that, right? Yeah, Paltek security.

I got a buddy who works there. They're
supposed to keep the tapes for 30 days

before they erase.

All right.

Take Ann, Abby, Jonathan, even Douglas
and Leland if you have to, but go

those tapes.

Tommy, call your friend at Paltek. Have
him clear the brush for C .J. Then call

Stewart. Tomorrow.

We are going to put Mark Shelleyos back
on the stand.

Let me take him, Michael. I'll pop the
pus right out of him. Uh -uh. This one's

mine.

I'm going to get him.

Mr. Shelleyos, you previously stated
that you drafted Harold Davis' most

will. That's correct.

I show you this, sir, and ask you if you
recognize it. It's a memo dictated by

me after we executed the will. Would you
please read paragraph three for the

record, sir?

Mr. Davis, indicating his accord with
provisions contained therein, executed

signature as testator. I then affixed my
signature as witness to the foregoing.

Mr. Davis then confirmed to Julia
Delaney that the testator's signature

fact, his, and Ms. Delaney then affixed
her signature as a second witness. You

say that Mr. Davis then confirmed to
Julia Delaney that the signature was, in

fact, his.

Didn't she see him sign the will? Well,
I'm sure she did. Well, then why did he

have to tell her what she already saw?

Well, I'm not really sure. I mean, this
took place many months ago. Mr.

Shellios, I have here a signed
declaration of Ms. Delaney obtained from

morning, which I offer the court.

She states that she was not in the room
when he signed.

That's why he had to tell her that the
signature was his.

There's no question he signed the will.
Are you trying to say... The actual

signing of this will was not witnessed
by two people, was it, Mr. Shellios?

I guess maybe it wasn't. And what did
that fact do to the validity of this

Technically, it makes it invalid.

In other words, Mr.

Davis died with no will at all. It
doesn't matter.

If a spouse dies in testate, California
law states that the bulk of the estate

goes to the surviving spouse.

Ricky Davis would still be the main
beneficiary. If Ricky Davis is convicted

murder, she would be disqualified.

And with no valid will, the Cancer
Society is out. Who then gets all the

under California law, Mr. Shalyos?

Surviving children.

And who would that be in this case? His
only child is a daughter, Marion Davis.

So Marion Davis, that woman right there,
stands to inherit everything if

my client is convicted. Isn't that
right, Mr. Shalyos? I doubt very much

she would be well -versed in the
validity of wills. Well, she would be if

had a clever lawyer with lots of inside
information advising her.

Do you have a personal relationship with
Marion Davis?

Objection. Getting to the good part,
Judge.

Overruled. Do you have a personal
relationship with Marion Davis?

We've had dinner together.

Mr. Shalios, I show you a photograph
taken two nights ago.

Mr. Shalios, would that be you and
Marion?

Yes.

Would you please describe for the court
what it is you're doing in the picture?

We're kissing.

How long have

you been seeing Mary? Your Honor, a
brief recess, please. Sit down.

How long?

About eight months. And Mr. Shelley
Oates, she knew that will would be

invalid, didn't she?

All she had to do was challenge it.
Marion Davis could never have killed her

father. You purposely saw to it that
that will would be invalid so that he

die intestate, didn't you, Mr. Chelios?
I'm asserting my Fifth Amendment rights.

I refuse to answer any more questions.

That's okay.

I don't have any more.

Mr. Cook?

Nothing, Your Honor.

You may step down, sir.

Let's stop right here.

The defense will call us next week.
Michael, I don't care who we put up

will never have more momentum than we've
got right now. Mr. Cusack.

One second, Your Honor.

You're serious, Michael. You just
dropped a bomb here. Let's get the jury

in here delivering while the room's
still shaking.

Are you ready to close?

Are you kidding?

Your Honor, the defense rests.

Closing argument's two o 'clock. We're
adjourned.

We're not going out to lunch?

Well, I thought we'd talk here first.

Rosalind, I'm very happy being with you.

You... You don't have to preface
anything, Leland.

Your answer is no.

I realize I may never meet anyone again
whom I'll come to love, but

it would be wrong to marry you out of
the port.

Do you think in time you might love me?

Did you ever think I could be so
ridiculous?

Oh, you're not ridiculous.

You have no idea how scared I was in
that restaurant.

You don't know how close I was to saying
yes.

So what do we do now?

I don't want to stop seeing you.

Well, I guess it would be stupid for us
not to. I mean, at our age, we

enjoy each other's company.

Love is for the young, right?

Listen.

Let's skip lunch, huh?

I've got some errands and we're still on
for dinner, right?

Oh, sure, sure.

Good. Maybe Italian tonight.

I feel like pasta.

All right.

This is the right thing.

See you later on.

I don't know about you people, but I am
more confused now than when we first

started. Let's just start with what we
do know for sure. First, all the

evidence, all of it could be consistent
with suicide.

Their star homicide detective told you
that under oath.

So, the main thing against Ricky Davis
was motive. She was supposedly the only

one with motive.

Now, the witness who was selling that
was the attorney Mark Shellios.

Then suddenly, turns out that's wrong.

The will was invalid.

The daughter stands to get everything
if... if she can get Ricky

disqualified with a murder conviction.

And she... knew this. She knew because
she was sleeping with, guess who? Mr.

Chelios, the attorney, who carefully
arranged for the will to be invalid.

What a scheme, huh?

Wow.

Well, people, right now, I don't know,
maybe Marion Davis killed her father for

the money.

Maybe the guy did really commit suicide.
I can't know.

The prosecution, they definitely do not
know.

They're over there suddenly dropping
charges against the boyfriend, David

Schaefer. One day he's up on first
degree, next day he's not.

They don't have a clue what's going on.

What a mess.

Reasonable doubt all over. What a
terrible mess.

The defendant's a wealthy woman who
hired the best lawyer's money could buy.

And they've done everything possible to
confuse you.

And they're good.

These lawyers are very good.

But let's reduce this thing to the basic
facts.

Ricky Davis had a $26 million motive.
Ricky Davis' fingerprints were found on

the cord that was used to hang the
victim. Ricky Davis doesn't have an

Her own lover concluded she had to have
done it.

There was a book describing how to make
the knot that was found tied around the

victim's head.

That book was found in her car.

Common sense, ladies and gentlemen.

Ricky Davis killed her husband.

Mr. Mullaney may be confused, but I'm
not, nor should you be.

What's going on? The jury's in. It's on
TV. What? They're covering it live.

Joyce?

Deliberating less than an hour. What's
happened? A very short deliberation. We

expect it to at least go overnight.
They're just filing it. They're here

Joyce. They don't look happy.

There's Mike and Tommy. They're
acquitting. If they come back this fast,

are definitely acquitting. Shh. That
doesn't mean anything. Now listen.

Has the jury reached a verdict?

Yes, Your Honor.

And how do you find?

We, the jury, in the matter of the
people versus Ricky Davis on the charge

first -degree murder, find the defendant
not guilty.

He's in the back. We have a press room.
We'll answer all questions.

You've got a press room set up. I need a
few minutes.

You start with him, Tommy. We'll be in
in a minute.

I'm absolutely numb.

Yeah, well, you should be.

You pulled it off.

What do you mean I pulled it off?

It was too easy, Ricky.

The whole thing just fell together too
neatly.

What are you talking about?

I'm talking about you and Mark Chelios.

We got a hold of the videotaped security
recordings from his office building.

You've been in there twice in the last
month.

So? So you two killed your husband, not
you and David Schaefer. You and Mark

Chelios either did it or had it done.

That's absurd.

Oh, I don't think so.

Mark Chelios is a brilliant attorney.

That screw -up on the wheel is a mistake
even a rookie wouldn't make. He did it

to give the daughter a motive.

He romanced Marion Davis to set her up
and to set himself up to be impeached on

the witness stand.

I've completely lost you now.

You follow me exactly.

You both knew there was no way Harold
Davis could possibly be murdered without

suspicion falling directly on you.

You could try to stage a suicide, sure,
but that would be 50 -50 at best.

The only way to guarantee you're getting
away with it was double jeopardy.

To be tried and acquitted.

So, Mark Shellio sets himself up as the
big witness against you. The guy who's

going to provide motive.

He puts his memo into his files and he
gives the files to us.

He kisses Marion Davis when he's got to
know we're having her followed.

You insisted that we tail the daughter.

You insisted that we tail Mark
Shellio's.

Why would he take the stand and make
himself a suspect?

Probably because he has an airtight
alibi.

Maybe because he knows that since you
made all the arrangements, there'd be no

way for anybody to trace anything to
him, even if he was investigated.

It's a nice story, Counselor. Too bad
you can't repeat it.

Well, sometimes I forget my ethical
obligations.

You'd risk disbarment.

And like you said, double jeopardy
applies. I'm free no matter what you do.

Well, I can sure as hell screw up your
inheritance.

I doubt it. I was found not guilty.

And anything you say at probate will be
inadmissible because I'll assert

attorney -client privilege.

Not to mention the fact that I could
stick your firm with a $26 million

You want to expose your partners?

You got two choices here.

There's a big press conference going on.

You can walk in there with a long face
and claim you were completely duped by

your client, or you can say nothing and
just be the brilliant star defense

attorney the whole country now knows you
to be.

A winner or a loser.

It's up to you, Michael.

I believe I'm free to go.

Well, I knew they were dead the second
that they made the deal with Schaefer.

That showed the jury right then the
prosecutor had no rudder on his boat.

Cusack, did you... Where's Ricky?
Where's your client?

Miss Davis is a little too emotionally
spent to join us right now.

Obviously, she's delighted with the
verdict, as we all are. Well, Mr.

how does it feel to win the biggest case
in the country?

Feels great.

Great. Can we get a picture of the two
of you?

Yeah.

Did you feel like you had to pay
tomorrow?