All language subtitles for Endgame.2050.2020.720p.AMZN.WEBRip.800MB.x264-GalaxyRG_track3_[eng]

af Afrikaans
ak Akan
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bem Bemba
bn Bengali
bh Bihari
bs Bosnian
br Breton
bg Bulgarian
km Cambodian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
chr Cherokee
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian Download
cs Czech
da Danish
nl Dutch
en English
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
ee Ewe
fo Faroese
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gaa Ga
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek
gn Guarani
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ia Interlingua
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
rw Kinyarwanda
rn Kirundi
kg Kongo
ko Korean
kri Krio (Sierra Leone)
ku Kurdish
ckb Kurdish (Soranî)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Laothian
la Latin
lv Latvian
ln Lingala
lt Lithuanian
loz Lozi
lg Luganda
ach Luo
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mfe Mauritian Creole
mo Moldavian
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
sr-ME Montenegrin
ne Nepali
pcm Nigerian Pidgin
nso Northern Sotho
no Norwegian
nn Norwegian (Nynorsk)
oc Occitan
or Oriya
om Oromo
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt-BR Portuguese (Brazil)
pt Portuguese (Portugal)
pa Punjabi
qu Quechua
ro Romanian
rm Romansh
nyn Runyakitara
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
sh Serbo-Croatian
st Sesotho
tn Setswana
crs Seychellois Creole
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhalese
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish
es-419 Spanish (Latin American)
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
tt Tatar
te Telugu
th Thai
ti Tigrinya
to Tonga
lua Tshiluba
tum Tumbuka
tr Turkish
tk Turkmen
tw Twi
ug Uighur
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
wo Wolof
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu
Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated: 1 00:00:00,043 --> 00:00:01,961 (train passing on tracks) 2 00:00:02,011 --> 00:00:04,241 - When people look at the environment, 3 00:00:04,291 --> 00:00:07,411 look at the world and say, oh everything's fine, 4 00:00:07,461 --> 00:00:10,361 it makes me think of a friend of mine. 5 00:00:10,411 --> 00:00:14,461 And he was a heroin addict and an alcoholic. 6 00:00:14,511 --> 00:00:17,871 And he was a pretty happy heroin addict and alcoholic. 7 00:00:17,921 --> 00:00:19,591 And one day he got into his car, 8 00:00:19,641 --> 00:00:21,241 he'd been shooting up and he'd been drinking. 9 00:00:21,291 --> 00:00:24,091 He got into his car and had some friends in the car 10 00:00:24,141 --> 00:00:25,381 and he was driving, 11 00:00:25,431 --> 00:00:27,161 no one was wearing their seatbelt, 12 00:00:27,211 --> 00:00:28,781 I think you see where this is going. 13 00:00:28,831 --> 00:00:30,861 And if you had asked him and his friends, 14 00:00:30,911 --> 00:00:33,181 as they're in their car, listening to music, 15 00:00:33,231 --> 00:00:35,701 going 100 miles an hour on the freeway, 16 00:00:35,751 --> 00:00:37,021 how they felt, they'd be like, 17 00:00:37,071 --> 00:00:39,631 we feel great, everything's fine! 18 00:00:39,681 --> 00:00:41,571 Ask them three seconds later 19 00:00:41,621 --> 00:00:42,981 when they were in a huge accident, 20 00:00:43,031 --> 00:00:45,791 he lost his legs and two of his friends died. 21 00:00:45,841 --> 00:00:49,221 And how do I convince you that you are that 22 00:00:49,271 --> 00:00:51,401 heroin addict alcoholic in the car 23 00:00:51,451 --> 00:00:53,231 driving without a seatbelt? 24 00:00:53,281 --> 00:00:55,631 'Cause right now, you think things are fine. 25 00:00:55,681 --> 00:00:57,311 I think things are fine. 26 00:00:57,361 --> 00:00:59,991 And I can guarantee you, they are not. 27 00:01:00,041 --> 00:01:05,041 (train passing on tracks) (solemn music) 28 00:02:00,511 --> 00:02:02,101 - Whether we know it or not, 29 00:02:02,151 --> 00:02:04,101 whether we like it or not, 30 00:02:04,151 --> 00:02:08,341 humanity is currently facing existential challenges. 31 00:02:08,391 --> 00:02:11,441 Experts warn that life on Earth is likely to change 32 00:02:11,491 --> 00:02:14,601 drastically in just our generation's lifetime 33 00:02:14,651 --> 00:02:17,436 if we continue business as usual. 34 00:02:17,486 --> 00:02:20,201 So, what does our future have in store for us 35 00:02:20,251 --> 00:02:22,621 just in the next few decades? 36 00:02:22,671 --> 00:02:25,061 To explore this compelling question, 37 00:02:25,111 --> 00:02:28,081 we're first going to watch a short 15 minute story 38 00:02:28,131 --> 00:02:32,721 we created that takes place in the year 2050. 39 00:02:32,771 --> 00:02:35,851 After that, we'll come back and hear what scientists 40 00:02:35,901 --> 00:02:40,439 have to say today about the challenges humanity is facing. 41 00:02:40,489 --> 00:02:43,239 (dramatic music) 42 00:02:45,341 --> 00:02:47,981 - A dramatic day in northern Alaska, 43 00:02:48,031 --> 00:02:51,051 as a 300 foot section of the Dalton Highway 44 00:02:51,101 --> 00:02:55,711 near Sagwan was obliterated by a methane gas explosion. 45 00:02:55,761 --> 00:02:58,411 Leaving behind a large crater. 46 00:02:58,461 --> 00:03:00,331 You are seeing live footage from our 47 00:03:00,381 --> 00:03:03,131 Consolidated News Service Worldeye Drone, 48 00:03:03,181 --> 00:03:08,181 operating 431 miles north of Fairbanks Alaska. 49 00:03:08,301 --> 00:03:10,391 No casualties have been reported, 50 00:03:10,441 --> 00:03:12,711 but the loss of this critical roadway 51 00:03:12,761 --> 00:03:15,671 is expected to cause serious disruptions 52 00:03:15,721 --> 00:03:17,834 for communities throughout the region. 53 00:03:20,891 --> 00:03:23,601 The volatile nature of methane events in this 54 00:03:23,651 --> 00:03:27,921 and other regions if of utmost concern for scientists 55 00:03:27,971 --> 00:03:29,291 monitoring the problem. 56 00:03:29,341 --> 00:03:32,451 For more, we're joined by Dr Marcus Cohen, 57 00:03:32,501 --> 00:03:35,011 who's an advisor to the National Weather Service's 58 00:03:35,061 --> 00:03:37,671 Event Mitigation Unit. 59 00:03:37,721 --> 00:03:39,021 Hello, Dr Cohen. 60 00:03:39,071 --> 00:03:41,041 - Good morning, Megan, glad to be here. 61 00:03:41,091 --> 00:03:43,151 - Dr Cohen, you were telling me over the break 62 00:03:43,201 --> 00:03:46,541 that these methane explosions are nothing new 63 00:03:46,591 --> 00:03:49,391 and you didn't seem to be entirely surprised 64 00:03:49,441 --> 00:03:51,051 by this event either. 65 00:03:51,101 --> 00:03:53,321 - Well, we've been monitoring this phenomenon for decades 66 00:03:53,371 --> 00:03:54,611 and while it's nothing new, 67 00:03:54,661 --> 00:03:57,481 we have seen an increase in the frequency 68 00:03:57,531 --> 00:04:00,331 of these methane bubbles, which is very concerning. 69 00:04:00,381 --> 00:04:03,591 Basically, as the ice melts, underground methane bubbles 70 00:04:03,641 --> 00:04:06,911 rise and eventually leak into the atmosphere. 71 00:04:06,961 --> 00:04:09,241 And sometimes it does so in the form of these 72 00:04:09,291 --> 00:04:11,361 dramatic explosions like we saw today. 73 00:04:11,411 --> 00:04:13,841 - So why is this happening now? 74 00:04:13,891 --> 00:04:16,431 - Well, in short, because the planet is warming, 75 00:04:16,481 --> 00:04:18,341 which is melting the ice and permafrost 76 00:04:18,391 --> 00:04:20,481 that covers the methane. 77 00:04:20,531 --> 00:04:23,171 Methane in the atmosphere heats the planet 78 00:04:23,221 --> 00:04:26,021 and when more of it leaks out from under the ice, 79 00:04:26,071 --> 00:04:28,171 it causes even more warming, 80 00:04:28,221 --> 00:04:30,121 which in turn causes the ice to melt, 81 00:04:30,171 --> 00:04:33,181 which then allows even more methane to reach the surface 82 00:04:33,231 --> 00:04:34,431 and so on and so on. 83 00:04:34,481 --> 00:04:38,391 And this vicious cycle is what we refer to as a 84 00:04:38,441 --> 00:04:40,781 positive feedback loop. 85 00:04:40,831 --> 00:04:44,121 Which, once it gets going, it sustains itself. 86 00:04:44,171 --> 00:04:47,051 - Now that the new International Carbon Mandates 87 00:04:47,101 --> 00:04:49,421 are in place, do you think there's any chance 88 00:04:49,471 --> 00:04:52,643 we can lessen or reverse the situation? 89 00:04:52,693 --> 00:04:54,021 - Well, we started very late, 90 00:04:54,071 --> 00:04:56,301 on meaningful greenhouse gas reforms. 91 00:04:56,351 --> 00:04:59,311 The problem is manmade emissions aren't the only 92 00:04:59,361 --> 00:05:01,151 problem we're facing now. 93 00:05:01,201 --> 00:05:03,131 Even if we completely stop all industrial, 94 00:05:03,181 --> 00:05:05,471 agricultural, and transportation emissions, 95 00:05:05,521 --> 00:05:07,591 bring them down to zero immediately, 96 00:05:07,641 --> 00:05:08,901 the methane and other gasses 97 00:05:08,951 --> 00:05:11,211 that are now being released from under the permafrost 98 00:05:11,261 --> 00:05:13,961 may still push recovery out of reach. 99 00:05:14,011 --> 00:05:16,401 - That is sobering but we have to leave it there 100 00:05:16,451 --> 00:05:18,191 Dr Cohen, on that note, 101 00:05:18,241 --> 00:05:20,181 thank you for being with us today 102 00:05:20,231 --> 00:05:22,656 and helping us understand the situation. 103 00:05:22,706 --> 00:05:24,271 - Thank you, Megan. 104 00:05:24,321 --> 00:05:27,701 - In other news, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric 105 00:05:27,751 --> 00:05:31,111 Authority, or NOAA, issued new warnings. 106 00:05:31,161 --> 00:05:35,321 They are reporting that the ocean's pH is still decreasing, 107 00:05:35,371 --> 00:05:37,911 meaning it's further acidifying. 108 00:05:37,961 --> 00:05:40,961 This, despite concerted attempts to regulate carbon 109 00:05:41,011 --> 00:05:44,961 emissions and industrial and agricultural runoff. 110 00:05:45,011 --> 00:05:47,141 NOAA reports that as a result, 111 00:05:47,191 --> 00:05:49,681 phytoplankton populations in the ocean 112 00:05:49,731 --> 00:05:51,911 are still on the decline. 113 00:05:51,961 --> 00:05:54,521 And last night in an emergency session, 114 00:05:54,571 --> 00:05:58,611 the United Nations extended the ICM Operational Window 115 00:05:58,661 --> 00:06:01,421 through June of 2052. 116 00:06:01,471 --> 00:06:04,241 Prolonging what were intended to be short term 117 00:06:04,291 --> 00:06:06,871 food and water rationing measures. 118 00:06:06,921 --> 00:06:10,431 We are just receiving some breaking news. 119 00:06:10,481 --> 00:06:13,141 An anti-government group in Seattle 120 00:06:13,191 --> 00:06:16,921 has reportedly taken hostages and barricaded themselves 121 00:06:16,971 --> 00:06:19,671 in Pike Place Market. 122 00:06:19,721 --> 00:06:22,821 We're going to try to Consolidated News reporter 123 00:06:22,871 --> 00:06:25,803 Jasmine Patel, live in Seattle. 124 00:06:25,853 --> 00:06:29,241 Hello, Jasmine, are you there. 125 00:06:29,291 --> 00:06:30,731 - Yes, thank you Megan. 126 00:06:30,781 --> 00:06:33,291 We're outside the old Pike Place Fish Market, 127 00:06:33,341 --> 00:06:35,971 once a Mecca for tourists and shoppers looking 128 00:06:36,021 --> 00:06:38,201 to buy fresh Pacific seafood. 129 00:06:38,251 --> 00:06:40,351 It is here that a group calling themselves 130 00:06:40,401 --> 00:06:44,861 Free American Patriots have staged their symbolic stand. 131 00:06:44,911 --> 00:06:47,431 Last night, 30 members of the group took an estimated 132 00:06:47,481 --> 00:06:50,801 25 people hostage from a nearby rail station. 133 00:06:50,851 --> 00:06:53,041 They are armed and barricaded themselves 134 00:06:53,091 --> 00:06:55,021 inside the old fish market. 135 00:06:55,071 --> 00:06:58,415 - What do we know about the group? 136 00:06:58,465 --> 00:07:01,131 - They are another group of what is being referred to 137 00:07:01,181 --> 00:07:03,221 as the Fish Truth Movement. 138 00:07:03,271 --> 00:07:05,881 They believe fishless oceans are a fabrication 139 00:07:05,931 --> 00:07:08,471 of a government conspiracy trying to force 140 00:07:08,521 --> 00:07:12,111 a vegan agenda on an unknowing American public. 141 00:07:12,161 --> 00:07:14,344 - Have they made any demands? 142 00:07:15,431 --> 00:07:17,351 - They say they will release the hostages 143 00:07:17,401 --> 00:07:20,421 once the government reopens and restocks the fish market. 144 00:07:20,471 --> 00:07:22,411 Something that experts have reiterated 145 00:07:22,461 --> 00:07:24,801 is literally impossible. 146 00:07:24,851 --> 00:07:26,874 - Nurse, nurse! 147 00:07:27,951 --> 00:07:30,351 - [News Anchor] Thank you, Jasmine, for that report. 148 00:07:30,401 --> 00:07:31,184 - Nurse! 149 00:07:31,234 --> 00:07:33,951 - What is it Mr. Baker? - It's time for my water. 150 00:07:34,001 --> 00:07:35,641 - [News Anchor] I'm looking at a recent US poll-- 151 00:07:35,691 --> 00:07:38,213 - Okay, yeah, I'll go get it. 152 00:07:38,263 --> 00:07:40,481 - [News Anchor] That shows at least 23% of viewers actually 153 00:07:40,531 --> 00:07:44,891 agree with these groups and believe that fishless oceans 154 00:07:44,941 --> 00:07:46,084 are not real. 155 00:07:47,141 --> 00:07:49,901 I don't think any serious person doubts the UN 156 00:07:49,951 --> 00:07:53,021 when they say fisheries are empty, but 157 00:07:53,071 --> 00:07:54,814 who wouldn't wish it weren't so. 158 00:07:56,213 --> 00:07:58,786 For historical context, fishless oceans 159 00:07:58,836 --> 00:08:03,191 were actually predicted at least 40 years ago. 160 00:08:03,241 --> 00:08:06,501 At a time when about a third of all seafood species 161 00:08:06,551 --> 00:08:08,561 had already crashed. 162 00:08:08,611 --> 00:08:11,201 Some experts predicted back then that we would 163 00:08:11,251 --> 00:08:14,161 have fishless oceans by 2048. 164 00:08:14,211 --> 00:08:15,541 - Here you go. - [News Anchor] As we now 165 00:08:15,591 --> 00:08:18,343 know, that was very close to the mark. 166 00:08:18,393 --> 00:08:21,135 - The ICM mandate specifically allows each 167 00:08:21,185 --> 00:08:24,571 citizen eight eight ounce glasses of water a day. 168 00:08:24,621 --> 00:08:26,651 Eight times eight, remember? 169 00:08:26,701 --> 00:08:28,831 My right, as a human being, 170 00:08:28,881 --> 00:08:31,521 even if I am locked up in this nuthouse. 171 00:08:31,571 --> 00:08:34,091 - Yes, Mr Baker, you do have rights. 172 00:08:34,141 --> 00:08:37,391 And I just gave you exactly eight ounces of water. 173 00:08:37,441 --> 00:08:41,221 The dispenser measures it exactly every time. 174 00:08:41,271 --> 00:08:42,701 (laughs) 175 00:08:42,751 --> 00:08:44,701 - That's what they want you to believe. 176 00:08:46,111 --> 00:08:48,788 - Mr Baker, come back here, Mr Baker! 177 00:08:51,912 --> 00:08:52,695 Mr Baker. 178 00:08:52,745 --> 00:08:53,714 - Hey, hey, hey! 179 00:08:53,764 --> 00:08:56,403 - Hey, calm down, back back. 180 00:08:56,453 --> 00:08:58,117 - No, I need water! 181 00:08:58,167 --> 00:08:59,375 - [Karen] Get him in the bed. 182 00:08:59,425 --> 00:09:03,811 - No, no, I need water! - Okay, okay. 183 00:09:03,861 --> 00:09:05,982 - No, not fair! - You'll get water, 184 00:09:06,032 --> 00:09:07,411 - I need water. - Calm down. 185 00:09:07,461 --> 00:09:09,391 Mr Baker, calm down. - Water. 186 00:09:09,441 --> 00:09:11,244 - [Karen] It's gonna be okay. - I need water. 187 00:09:11,294 --> 00:09:14,221 Need water. - Shh, okay, okay. 188 00:09:14,271 --> 00:09:15,744 We'll get you some water. 189 00:09:18,196 --> 00:09:20,946 (dramatic music) 190 00:09:29,641 --> 00:09:30,981 - What's goin' on, who called the page? 191 00:09:31,031 --> 00:09:34,391 - I did, a patient was acting very aggressively, 192 00:09:34,441 --> 00:09:35,581 but he's calmed down now. 193 00:09:35,631 --> 00:09:37,164 - So, what happened? 194 00:09:38,121 --> 00:09:40,214 Oh, Mr Baker again. 195 00:09:41,861 --> 00:09:43,811 - He was complaining I didn't give him his ration 196 00:09:43,861 --> 00:09:45,991 of water and it blew up from there. 197 00:09:46,041 --> 00:09:47,651 - Well, did ya? 198 00:09:47,701 --> 00:09:49,331 - [Karen] Did I what? 199 00:09:49,381 --> 00:09:50,600 - Give him the right amount. 200 00:09:50,650 --> 00:09:52,231 - What? 201 00:09:52,281 --> 00:09:53,301 What do you think? 202 00:09:53,351 --> 00:09:56,501 I've been hoarding the patients' water for myself? 203 00:09:56,551 --> 00:09:58,791 Of course, I gave it to him and everyone else. 204 00:09:58,841 --> 00:10:00,611 A full eight ounce glass. 205 00:10:00,661 --> 00:10:02,091 What are implying? 206 00:10:02,141 --> 00:10:04,441 - Nothing, sorry, it's just that some of the facilities 207 00:10:04,491 --> 00:10:06,351 had to reduce their rations, so I just wanted 208 00:10:06,401 --> 00:10:08,361 to be sure of our supply and make sure you were 209 00:10:08,411 --> 00:10:10,491 distributing the right amount. 210 00:10:10,541 --> 00:10:12,109 Come on, let's go take a look. 211 00:10:12,159 --> 00:10:14,909 (dramatic music) 212 00:10:18,181 --> 00:10:21,581 - I'm telling you, she did not give me eight ounces. 213 00:10:21,631 --> 00:10:22,661 - Did you get a glass, sir? 214 00:10:22,711 --> 00:10:25,361 - Yeah, with like maybe five ounces, 215 00:10:25,411 --> 00:10:26,801 but not the full eight. 216 00:10:26,851 --> 00:10:30,491 See, they think you can't tell, but I can, 217 00:10:30,541 --> 00:10:33,021 so I said something, it's my right. 218 00:10:33,071 --> 00:10:35,581 And the orderlies went crazy! 219 00:10:35,631 --> 00:10:37,261 They went crazy, but not me. 220 00:10:37,311 --> 00:10:38,221 I was calm. 221 00:10:38,271 --> 00:10:40,964 - It says here you tried to break the water machine. 222 00:10:42,691 --> 00:10:46,081 I thought you said this morning you were ready to go home. 223 00:10:46,131 --> 00:10:49,681 Really, Mr Baker, I want to discharge you, 224 00:10:49,731 --> 00:10:51,631 but you're making it very difficult to do so. 225 00:10:51,681 --> 00:10:54,271 - Oh come on, I'm ready to go. 226 00:10:54,321 --> 00:10:56,331 Look how calm I am. 227 00:10:56,381 --> 00:11:00,371 And I'm not, I'm not suicidal either, 228 00:11:00,421 --> 00:11:02,021 and you know that. 229 00:11:02,071 --> 00:11:03,261 I just wanna go home. 230 00:11:03,311 --> 00:11:05,341 I can have more water there anyway. 231 00:11:05,391 --> 00:11:06,174 - Mr Baker-- 232 00:11:06,224 --> 00:11:08,871 - Oh, you think a hospital, of all places, 233 00:11:08,921 --> 00:11:10,671 wouldn't hold water from its patients. 234 00:11:10,721 --> 00:11:13,681 - Mr Baker, we're just following the ICM mandates. 235 00:11:13,731 --> 00:11:16,401 You're not seriously suggesting that we don't. 236 00:11:16,451 --> 00:11:19,641 And besides, we all need to ration water 237 00:11:19,691 --> 00:11:21,266 while there's a shortage, 238 00:11:21,316 --> 00:11:22,831 and once you're discharged, 239 00:11:22,881 --> 00:11:24,821 you should be doing the exact same thing at home. 240 00:11:24,871 --> 00:11:26,274 - Okay, whatever. 241 00:11:27,951 --> 00:11:30,091 - What's this I hear about fish? 242 00:11:30,141 --> 00:11:32,761 The staff say you're asking for fish at every meal. 243 00:11:32,811 --> 00:11:33,786 You know we don't have any 244 00:11:33,836 --> 00:11:35,073 and you don't have any at home either. 245 00:11:35,123 --> 00:11:36,687 (laughs) 246 00:11:36,737 --> 00:11:39,131 - So, I'm not gonna get a fish sandwich 247 00:11:39,181 --> 00:11:40,745 at my going away party? 248 00:11:40,795 --> 00:11:42,878 (laughs) 249 00:11:43,869 --> 00:11:46,076 ♪ Where have all the fishies gone? ♪ 250 00:11:46,126 --> 00:11:48,341 (laughs) 251 00:11:48,391 --> 00:11:52,650 It's fishy, I mean, who's hiding all those fish? 252 00:11:52,700 --> 00:11:56,291 You, the government, the Japanese? 253 00:11:56,341 --> 00:11:58,731 - Mr Baker, I need to know whether or not 254 00:11:58,781 --> 00:12:00,751 you think there are any fish to eat. 255 00:12:00,801 --> 00:12:02,561 It's for cognitive purposes, 256 00:12:02,611 --> 00:12:04,131 it's very important that I know this. 257 00:12:04,181 --> 00:12:05,560 Please answer the question. 258 00:12:05,610 --> 00:12:06,393 (laughs) 259 00:12:06,443 --> 00:12:08,661 - A smart doctor like you doesn't know? 260 00:12:08,711 --> 00:12:10,011 - I'd like you to tell me. 261 00:12:11,351 --> 00:12:14,051 - If this was a game show, I could win a bunch of money. 262 00:12:14,101 --> 00:12:15,290 - You don't know, do you? 263 00:12:15,340 --> 00:12:17,991 (laughs) 264 00:12:18,041 --> 00:12:20,951 - Oh no, sorry to report to the world, 265 00:12:21,001 --> 00:12:24,401 but as predicted by many fishy scientists, 266 00:12:24,451 --> 00:12:26,521 we have fished all the fishies. 267 00:12:26,571 --> 00:12:27,861 Well, almost all the fishies. 268 00:12:27,911 --> 00:12:30,001 Any that are left are kinda hard to find, 269 00:12:30,051 --> 00:12:31,731 unless you have enough money. 270 00:12:31,781 --> 00:12:32,821 Then you can treat yourself 271 00:12:32,871 --> 00:12:34,654 to some of the old frozen stocks. 272 00:12:36,401 --> 00:12:39,826 And great news folks, we still have plenty of jellyfishies. 273 00:12:39,876 --> 00:12:43,811 Oh, get ready, 'cause we're about to learn to cook 274 00:12:43,861 --> 00:12:47,901 and eat jellyfish, and in other related news, 275 00:12:47,951 --> 00:12:51,801 those tiny little ocean phytoplankton thingies, 276 00:12:51,851 --> 00:12:53,751 well they're dyin' off too, 277 00:12:53,801 --> 00:12:55,820 but no big deal, I mean, 278 00:12:55,870 --> 00:12:58,471 they just make half of our oxygen. 279 00:12:58,521 --> 00:13:00,421 We still have the other half, right? 280 00:13:00,471 --> 00:13:03,801 No problemo, just skip every other breath, folks. 281 00:13:03,851 --> 00:13:05,399 You'll be sound as a pound. 282 00:13:05,449 --> 00:13:07,741 (cries) 283 00:13:07,791 --> 00:13:09,401 - Thank you, thank you, Mr Baker, 284 00:13:09,451 --> 00:13:11,151 that was an excellent explanation. 285 00:13:14,331 --> 00:13:15,981 I remember when I was just a kid, 286 00:13:16,911 --> 00:13:18,411 they warned us about the fish. 287 00:13:20,501 --> 00:13:22,201 Really screwed that up, didn't we? 288 00:13:23,254 --> 00:13:24,747 Couldn't be bothered, I guess. 289 00:13:24,797 --> 00:13:26,841 - It wasn't just the fish. 290 00:13:26,891 --> 00:13:29,221 They warned us about everything, really. 291 00:13:29,271 --> 00:13:31,701 I mean, you're the psychiatrist, you tell me. 292 00:13:31,751 --> 00:13:34,059 Why did we ignore it all? 293 00:13:34,109 --> 00:13:37,151 Really, indulge me, no BS. 294 00:13:37,201 --> 00:13:39,904 - Okay, think about it like this. 295 00:13:40,905 --> 00:13:45,241 What do you get when you mix a lot of shortsightedness 296 00:13:45,291 --> 00:13:48,591 with a little selfishness and just a dash of apathy, 297 00:13:48,641 --> 00:13:52,571 and oh, no shortage of scientific illiteracy, 298 00:13:52,621 --> 00:13:56,181 and don't forget, a whole lot of power and technology, too. 299 00:13:56,231 --> 00:14:01,231 In my opinion, we're two hairs short of being chimpanzees. 300 00:14:01,251 --> 00:14:04,281 We're extremely emotional, with powerful, primitive, 301 00:14:04,331 --> 00:14:06,861 shortsighted survival drives, 302 00:14:06,911 --> 00:14:08,671 and in the blink of an evolutionary eye, 303 00:14:08,721 --> 00:14:10,591 we developed this powerful technology 304 00:14:10,641 --> 00:14:13,284 that completely changed the shape of the planet. 305 00:14:16,181 --> 00:14:19,321 Anyway, let's get back to business. 306 00:14:19,371 --> 00:14:22,821 Probably do need to discharge Mr Baker 307 00:14:22,871 --> 00:14:25,371 and some of the other patients, too. 308 00:14:25,421 --> 00:14:28,451 Beds are full and the waiting list 309 00:14:28,501 --> 00:14:29,971 isn't getting any shorter. 310 00:14:30,021 --> 00:14:34,181 We have what, 21 patients now? 311 00:14:34,231 --> 00:14:35,881 Yeah, 21 patients. 312 00:14:35,931 --> 00:14:37,311 - All suicide attempts? 313 00:14:37,361 --> 00:14:38,144 - Looks like it. 314 00:14:38,194 --> 00:14:41,381 Suicide attempts, suicidal ideation, suicidal gestures. 315 00:14:41,431 --> 00:14:42,481 - I don't blame them. 316 00:14:43,621 --> 00:14:45,631 - Are you all right, why would you say that? 317 00:14:45,681 --> 00:14:47,911 - No, actually, I'm not all right. 318 00:14:47,961 --> 00:14:49,431 Why would I be? 319 00:14:49,481 --> 00:14:53,561 One meal a day, just one measly meal? 320 00:14:53,611 --> 00:14:56,334 Rationing food and water doesn't get you down, too? 321 00:14:57,281 --> 00:15:00,271 And I can't remember the last time we could eat three meals, 322 00:15:00,321 --> 00:15:01,201 just like normal-- 323 00:15:01,251 --> 00:15:04,811 - Look, I know it's hard, but it's just temporary. 324 00:15:04,861 --> 00:15:06,914 - Yeah, that's what they said a year ago. 325 00:15:09,571 --> 00:15:12,201 I feel hungry and weak all the time, 326 00:15:12,251 --> 00:15:14,771 and then the methane bubbles that keep resurfacing. 327 00:15:14,821 --> 00:15:16,411 That doesn't worry you too? 328 00:15:16,461 --> 00:15:17,981 And the plankton thing, 329 00:15:18,031 --> 00:15:20,481 everything just seems to be crashing down all around us-- 330 00:15:20,531 --> 00:15:21,691 - Look, Karen. 331 00:15:21,741 --> 00:15:24,594 The plankton thing's going okay for now, right? 332 00:15:25,521 --> 00:15:27,731 Yes, some types have died off, 333 00:15:27,781 --> 00:15:29,704 but others are supposedly doing okay. 334 00:15:30,601 --> 00:15:33,217 Everything's going to be fine. 335 00:15:33,267 --> 00:15:35,217 (laughs) - Everything's gonna be fine. 336 00:15:36,701 --> 00:15:39,214 Really, just like us? 337 00:15:49,141 --> 00:15:51,801 - Really, Karen, this is about us now? 338 00:15:51,851 --> 00:15:55,041 - No, actually, this is not about us, 339 00:15:55,091 --> 00:15:58,341 but the Department of Agriculture doesn't exactly 340 00:15:58,391 --> 00:16:00,641 share your optimistic views. 341 00:16:00,691 --> 00:16:04,711 I think you're trying to tell me what I wanna hear, again. 342 00:16:04,761 --> 00:16:06,811 Do you really think they can figure out how to farm 343 00:16:06,861 --> 00:16:08,504 so much food with so little water? 344 00:16:08,554 --> 00:16:10,071 - Why are you so mad at me? 345 00:16:10,121 --> 00:16:11,461 I didn't cause this. 346 00:16:11,511 --> 00:16:13,271 - You just take what you want, when you want it, 347 00:16:13,321 --> 00:16:14,971 and you don't care who you hurt? 348 00:16:15,021 --> 00:16:18,251 - Are you talkin' about us or the Earth? 349 00:16:18,301 --> 00:16:19,971 - Both. 350 00:16:20,021 --> 00:16:21,251 We've been down this road before. 351 00:16:21,301 --> 00:16:23,001 You make all kinds of promises-- 352 00:16:23,051 --> 00:16:24,448 - Hey, Karen. 353 00:16:24,498 --> 00:16:27,121 Let's not rehash this again, okay? 354 00:16:27,171 --> 00:16:30,901 It happened, it was good for a time, 355 00:16:30,951 --> 00:16:33,461 but we both knew it wasn't gonna last. 356 00:16:33,511 --> 00:16:35,731 - Sort of like our food and water? 357 00:16:35,781 --> 00:16:37,301 - That's not fair. 358 00:16:37,351 --> 00:16:38,651 I never meant to hurt you. 359 00:16:40,721 --> 00:16:42,681 We've got more important things to focus on, 360 00:16:42,731 --> 00:16:44,271 don't you think? 361 00:16:44,321 --> 00:16:48,674 - I know, I'm sorry, I'm just frustrated. 362 00:16:49,561 --> 00:16:52,284 I don't understand how we let everything get so bad. 363 00:16:53,634 --> 00:16:56,211 - You're back to talking about the Earth again, right? 364 00:16:56,261 --> 00:16:58,654 - Yes, yes, the Earth. 365 00:17:00,031 --> 00:17:03,341 You know, my parents were educated people, 366 00:17:03,391 --> 00:17:06,271 just totally oblivious. 367 00:17:06,321 --> 00:17:08,091 We grew up with so much water and food 368 00:17:08,141 --> 00:17:09,251 we didn't know what to do, 369 00:17:09,301 --> 00:17:13,981 and all the while this whole little mess was brewing. 370 00:17:14,031 --> 00:17:16,311 We ended up turning our one little planet 371 00:17:16,361 --> 00:17:18,801 completely upside down. 372 00:17:18,851 --> 00:17:20,531 - When I was growing up, my folks used to tell me 373 00:17:20,581 --> 00:17:22,201 oh, these are problems in third world countries, 374 00:17:22,251 --> 00:17:23,451 it'll never happen here. 375 00:17:26,051 --> 00:17:28,831 It's the elephant in the room and we all just ignored it. 376 00:17:28,881 --> 00:17:31,344 - Jesus, elephants. 377 00:17:32,621 --> 00:17:35,671 I mean I think there's one left in a zoo somewhere. 378 00:17:35,721 --> 00:17:36,651 Call it what you want, 379 00:17:36,701 --> 00:17:38,701 but we created this mess on our own, 380 00:17:38,751 --> 00:17:40,721 with a mass extinction to boot. 381 00:17:40,771 --> 00:17:43,671 You know, my folks had eight frickin' kids, eight! 382 00:17:43,721 --> 00:17:45,911 Don't get me wrong, I love my parents 383 00:17:45,961 --> 00:17:47,581 and my brothers and my sisters, 384 00:17:47,631 --> 00:17:48,431 but what the hell, right? 385 00:17:48,481 --> 00:17:49,621 It's like we're a plague! 386 00:17:49,671 --> 00:17:52,100 - Karen, calm down, right now. 387 00:17:52,150 --> 00:17:53,664 This isn't helping anything. 388 00:17:56,221 --> 00:17:58,564 The experts, they're getting on top of this. 389 00:17:59,811 --> 00:18:01,528 Let's stick to the facts, 390 00:18:01,578 --> 00:18:04,569 you know, take it a day at a time. 391 00:18:04,619 --> 00:18:09,261 You know what, why don't you take tomorrow off and relax? 392 00:18:09,311 --> 00:18:10,524 - I was planning on it. 393 00:18:16,321 --> 00:18:18,531 - You've got a lot of frozen food. 394 00:18:18,581 --> 00:18:19,881 Why don't you sit down to a big meal 395 00:18:19,931 --> 00:18:22,561 and forget any of this is even happening? 396 00:18:22,611 --> 00:18:24,751 We'll get you back in shape, okay? 397 00:18:24,801 --> 00:18:26,441 - Yeah, sure. 398 00:18:26,491 --> 00:18:30,121 - Karen, I still care about you, I always have-- 399 00:18:30,171 --> 00:18:32,094 - Don't, please don't. 400 00:18:33,031 --> 00:18:34,894 I'm sorry I even brought it up. 401 00:18:37,091 --> 00:18:37,924 - Karen-- 402 00:18:39,631 --> 00:18:41,854 - Thank you for everything, really. 403 00:18:44,171 --> 00:18:45,164 Goodbye, Jerry. 404 00:18:52,262 --> 00:18:55,012 (dramatic music) 405 00:19:05,521 --> 00:19:07,071 - Morning Susan, what's on my plate today? 406 00:19:07,121 --> 00:19:10,841 - Well, we are understaffed and completely full. 407 00:19:10,891 --> 00:19:14,654 It's gonna be a crazy day today, no pun intended. 408 00:19:15,921 --> 00:19:17,451 - Well, when it rains, it pours. 409 00:19:17,501 --> 00:19:20,131 When you see Karen, just send her to my office? 410 00:19:20,181 --> 00:19:21,754 - Jerry, Karen's not, 411 00:19:23,481 --> 00:19:24,384 didn't you hear? 412 00:19:27,551 --> 00:19:28,931 - Hear what? 413 00:19:28,981 --> 00:19:31,361 - Her sister found her yesterday morning. 414 00:19:31,411 --> 00:19:33,584 She's, she's dead. 415 00:19:38,941 --> 00:19:40,844 She was a good kid, sorry. 416 00:19:46,705 --> 00:19:47,538 - Yeah. 417 00:19:49,462 --> 00:19:52,212 (dramatic music) 418 00:19:54,511 --> 00:19:57,451 - Well, that was very shocking and sad. 419 00:19:57,501 --> 00:20:00,061 But in fact, scientists today are warning 420 00:20:00,111 --> 00:20:02,721 that many of the problems in our future scene 421 00:20:02,771 --> 00:20:06,232 could be upon us, and surprisingly soon. 422 00:20:06,282 --> 00:20:09,032 (dramatic music) 423 00:20:10,471 --> 00:20:14,191 Our characters from the future mentioned a mass extinction. 424 00:20:14,241 --> 00:20:16,791 - It's the elephant in the room and we all just ignored it. 425 00:20:16,841 --> 00:20:17,761 - Call it what you want, 426 00:20:17,811 --> 00:20:19,801 but we created this mess on our own, 427 00:20:19,851 --> 00:20:21,971 with a mass extinction to boot. 428 00:20:22,021 --> 00:20:24,641 - [Sofia] Unfortunately, a rapid and widespread 429 00:20:24,691 --> 00:20:26,901 loss of species is something that's 430 00:20:26,951 --> 00:20:29,631 already happening right now. 431 00:20:29,681 --> 00:20:32,421 In fact, biologists have classified our time 432 00:20:32,471 --> 00:20:36,291 as the sixth mass extinction in Earth's history. 433 00:20:36,341 --> 00:20:38,527 - First, let me start by saying that 434 00:20:38,577 --> 00:20:42,331 we have millions of species on the planet 435 00:20:42,381 --> 00:20:46,281 and they have evolved over hundreds of millions 436 00:20:46,331 --> 00:20:49,541 of years into a fantastic array of different 437 00:20:49,591 --> 00:20:52,631 types of plants and animals and microbes. 438 00:20:52,681 --> 00:20:54,551 And it's really fascinating. 439 00:20:54,601 --> 00:20:57,821 At the same time, right now we're undergoing 440 00:20:57,871 --> 00:21:00,011 what's called a mass extinction. 441 00:21:00,061 --> 00:21:03,301 And that means that the rates of extinction 442 00:21:03,351 --> 00:21:07,621 are much faster, much higher than they normally would be. 443 00:21:07,671 --> 00:21:10,401 - In the past, there have been five episodes 444 00:21:10,451 --> 00:21:14,111 of mass extinctions in which the majority of the 445 00:21:14,161 --> 00:21:17,651 plants and animals of the planet were wiped out. 446 00:21:17,701 --> 00:21:21,101 The last one was 65 million years ago 447 00:21:21,151 --> 00:21:24,011 when we lost the dinosaurs and a lot of other things. 448 00:21:24,061 --> 00:21:27,941 Since then we've built up a huge amount of biodiversity, 449 00:21:27,991 --> 00:21:29,671 and then in the last 200 years, 450 00:21:29,721 --> 00:21:31,961 we've started destroying it. 451 00:21:32,011 --> 00:21:34,721 - To recap, the Earth has been around for about 452 00:21:34,771 --> 00:21:37,181 4.5 billion years, 453 00:21:37,231 --> 00:21:39,801 and in those years, there have been a total of 454 00:21:39,851 --> 00:21:42,611 five mass extinctions so far. 455 00:21:42,661 --> 00:21:46,091 The Permian mass extinction was the third and largest one 456 00:21:46,141 --> 00:21:48,591 around 252 million years ago. 457 00:21:48,641 --> 00:21:51,581 The the fifth, and most recent one, 458 00:21:51,631 --> 00:21:53,701 was when the dinosaurs went extinct 459 00:21:53,751 --> 00:21:56,711 about 65 million years ago. 460 00:21:56,761 --> 00:22:00,361 But now we're in the sixth mass extinction. 461 00:22:00,411 --> 00:22:02,641 And unlike the previous five, 462 00:22:02,691 --> 00:22:05,781 this one is the first one that is not caused 463 00:22:05,831 --> 00:22:07,401 by natural phenomena, 464 00:22:07,451 --> 00:22:09,551 like meteors hitting the Earth, 465 00:22:09,601 --> 00:22:11,971 or major volcanic eruptions. 466 00:22:12,021 --> 00:22:13,601 This one is different. 467 00:22:13,651 --> 00:22:17,491 It's being caused by humans and our activities. 468 00:22:17,541 --> 00:22:20,701 It's the first time a single species 469 00:22:20,751 --> 00:22:23,581 is causing a mass extinction. 470 00:22:23,631 --> 00:22:27,581 So, we're truly navigating through uncharted waters. 471 00:22:27,631 --> 00:22:29,681 - We have a catastrophic situation 472 00:22:29,731 --> 00:22:32,881 that's basically unrecognized. 473 00:22:32,931 --> 00:22:34,881 In about the last 40 years, 474 00:22:34,931 --> 00:22:38,314 we've lost more than half the wildlife on the planet. 475 00:22:39,275 --> 00:22:41,121 - That bears repeating. 476 00:22:41,171 --> 00:22:44,541 Over one half of all wild animals on our planet 477 00:22:44,591 --> 00:22:48,331 have disappeared in just the last 40 years. 478 00:22:48,381 --> 00:22:50,641 - I'm sure many people think 479 00:22:50,691 --> 00:22:52,711 what has biodiversity ever done for me 480 00:22:52,761 --> 00:22:54,491 and why should I worry about it? 481 00:22:54,541 --> 00:22:59,301 Well, if you don't have a functioning 482 00:22:59,351 --> 00:23:01,841 ecological system that produces oxygen, 483 00:23:01,891 --> 00:23:03,615 that produces food, 484 00:23:03,665 --> 00:23:06,101 people will not survive. 485 00:23:06,151 --> 00:23:08,531 - Many of our crops, many of the ones that are 486 00:23:08,581 --> 00:23:11,681 the most important really for our own health, 487 00:23:11,731 --> 00:23:14,381 are dependent on an animal pollinator, 488 00:23:14,431 --> 00:23:16,501 like a bee, to pollinate it. 489 00:23:16,551 --> 00:23:18,671 And so, without these pollinators, 490 00:23:18,721 --> 00:23:22,351 we wouldn't have important components of our food supply. 491 00:23:22,401 --> 00:23:25,581 Pollinators help to produce 75% 492 00:23:25,631 --> 00:23:27,841 of our different crop species. 493 00:23:27,891 --> 00:23:30,361 That's how important they are to our diet. 494 00:23:30,411 --> 00:23:32,881 As well as things we really like, like chocolate. 495 00:23:32,931 --> 00:23:35,271 Many people don't know that cacao, 496 00:23:35,321 --> 00:23:36,831 which chocolate comes from, 497 00:23:36,881 --> 00:23:38,791 is pollinated by a tiny fly. 498 00:23:38,841 --> 00:23:42,021 Without that tiny fly, we wouldn't have chocolate. 499 00:23:42,071 --> 00:23:44,735 Personally, I think that would be a catastrophe. 500 00:23:44,785 --> 00:23:47,271 (dramatic music) 501 00:23:47,321 --> 00:23:50,551 - Even if we were to take a more selfish view 502 00:23:50,601 --> 00:23:54,431 of not caring about other species or the natural world, 503 00:23:54,481 --> 00:23:57,511 we should still literally be doing everything 504 00:23:57,561 --> 00:24:00,891 in our power to protect and preserve biodiversity 505 00:24:00,941 --> 00:24:03,501 for our own survival. 506 00:24:03,551 --> 00:24:06,891 - If you had visited the planet three billion years ago, 507 00:24:06,941 --> 00:24:08,661 you would not have survived a minute 508 00:24:08,711 --> 00:24:11,571 because there was no oxygen to breathe, 509 00:24:11,621 --> 00:24:12,941 the water was toxic, 510 00:24:12,991 --> 00:24:15,361 there was no food to eat, 511 00:24:15,411 --> 00:24:17,401 so you wouldn't have survived. 512 00:24:17,451 --> 00:24:20,431 And three billions years of evolution, 513 00:24:20,481 --> 00:24:23,981 of the web of life that makes the planet habitable 514 00:24:24,031 --> 00:24:27,981 is what we are rapidly destroying. 515 00:24:28,031 --> 00:24:33,031 - So why is this tragic loss of biodiversity happening? 516 00:24:33,061 --> 00:24:38,061 - The biggest cause of extinctions is habitat destruction. 517 00:24:38,891 --> 00:24:43,381 We know that all organisms need appropriate habitats 518 00:24:43,431 --> 00:24:45,451 and when you destroy the habitats, 519 00:24:45,501 --> 00:24:48,501 you are wiping out populations. 520 00:24:48,551 --> 00:24:51,871 The basic cause of the extinction episode 521 00:24:51,921 --> 00:24:55,691 of the sixth mass extinction is the much too large 522 00:24:55,741 --> 00:24:58,461 a size of the human enterprise. 523 00:24:58,511 --> 00:25:00,311 - Habitat loss is the number one driver 524 00:25:00,361 --> 00:25:02,611 of biodiversity loss. 525 00:25:02,661 --> 00:25:07,151 And what's behind that is really our population growth, 526 00:25:07,201 --> 00:25:10,604 and also how we consume resources. 527 00:25:11,611 --> 00:25:14,291 - [Sofia] There are several causes for the dramatic loss 528 00:25:14,341 --> 00:25:16,881 of biodiversity we are experiencing. 529 00:25:16,931 --> 00:25:21,571 For example, poaching is a serious threat to many species. 530 00:25:21,621 --> 00:25:25,331 However the biggest driver of species extinctions 531 00:25:25,381 --> 00:25:30,261 is actually the destruction of natural habitats by humans. 532 00:25:30,311 --> 00:25:33,601 According to the United Nations, the livestock sector 533 00:25:33,651 --> 00:25:37,881 is by far the single largest user of land on the planet. 534 00:25:37,931 --> 00:25:41,341 And it is the major driver of deforestation. 535 00:25:41,391 --> 00:25:45,621 Livestock systems occupy a staggering 45% 536 00:25:45,671 --> 00:25:47,594 of the global surface area. 537 00:25:48,911 --> 00:25:51,471 I don't think annual agriculture comes to mind 538 00:25:51,521 --> 00:25:54,291 immediately for most people as the largest 539 00:25:54,341 --> 00:25:56,221 land user on the planet. 540 00:25:56,271 --> 00:25:57,811 But it is. 541 00:25:57,861 --> 00:26:00,011 - [Dr Kremen] So then, as we're eating more meats, 542 00:26:00,061 --> 00:26:02,121 we're eating more of a product that really 543 00:26:02,171 --> 00:26:03,781 just takes a lot to produce. 544 00:26:03,831 --> 00:26:05,221 It takes a lot of land, 545 00:26:05,271 --> 00:26:06,381 it takes a lot of energy, 546 00:26:06,431 --> 00:26:08,211 it takes a lot of water. 547 00:26:08,261 --> 00:26:12,501 And as we use these more expensive products, 548 00:26:12,551 --> 00:26:14,741 as we consume more expensive products, 549 00:26:14,791 --> 00:26:17,981 it means that we basically are co-opting 550 00:26:18,031 --> 00:26:21,201 more of the Earth's resources for ourselves, 551 00:26:21,251 --> 00:26:23,681 and that's competing with biodiversity. 552 00:26:23,731 --> 00:26:26,251 It's meaning that we need to take up 553 00:26:26,301 --> 00:26:27,901 a lot of their habitats. 554 00:26:27,951 --> 00:26:30,701 (dramatic music) 555 00:26:34,941 --> 00:26:39,941 - The fact that we, you know, this weird primate species, 556 00:26:40,731 --> 00:26:45,731 of like relatively hairless, defenseless apes, 557 00:26:45,911 --> 00:26:50,841 are destroying the only home that we know of in the universe 558 00:26:50,891 --> 00:26:52,124 that will support life. 559 00:26:53,612 --> 00:26:58,612 It's horrifying on a scale that we can't even conceive of. 560 00:27:00,771 --> 00:27:03,451 Which is why, like, I feel badly for humans, 561 00:27:03,501 --> 00:27:06,071 but there is a part of me that just thinks, that like, 562 00:27:06,121 --> 00:27:08,641 if we can't change ourselves, 563 00:27:08,691 --> 00:27:12,081 if we can't learn how to live in sort of 564 00:27:12,131 --> 00:27:15,301 sustainable harmony with the only world 565 00:27:15,351 --> 00:27:17,121 that will support us, 566 00:27:17,171 --> 00:27:18,214 we need to go away. 567 00:27:19,221 --> 00:27:21,334 And the other thing is, we will go away. 568 00:27:22,301 --> 00:27:25,701 - In other news, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric 569 00:27:25,751 --> 00:27:29,161 Authority, or NOAA, issued new warnings. 570 00:27:29,211 --> 00:27:33,421 They are reporting that the oceans' pH is still decreasing, 571 00:27:33,471 --> 00:27:36,021 meaning it's further acidifying. 572 00:27:36,071 --> 00:27:39,041 This despite concerted attempts to regulate carbon 573 00:27:39,091 --> 00:27:42,518 emissions and industrial and agricultural runoff. 574 00:27:42,568 --> 00:27:45,318 (dramatic music) 575 00:27:48,271 --> 00:27:50,041 - [Sofia] The newscast in the future reported 576 00:27:50,091 --> 00:27:52,671 that the ocean was acidifying. 577 00:27:52,721 --> 00:27:56,091 Yet again, this is another problem that we don't really 578 00:27:56,141 --> 00:27:58,521 need to go to the future to see, 579 00:27:58,571 --> 00:28:01,601 because it's already happening today. 580 00:28:01,651 --> 00:28:04,431 So, what does ocean acidification mean? 581 00:28:04,481 --> 00:28:07,911 It means the pH of the oceans' water is decreasing. 582 00:28:07,961 --> 00:28:10,931 pH simply measures how acidic or alkaline 583 00:28:10,981 --> 00:28:12,761 a given substance is. 584 00:28:12,811 --> 00:28:16,011 But why is the ocean acidifying? 585 00:28:16,061 --> 00:28:20,631 Well, because a third of all the carbon dioxide, or CO2, 586 00:28:20,681 --> 00:28:23,371 that we are releasing into the atmosphere, 587 00:28:23,421 --> 00:28:25,601 gets absorbed by the ocean, 588 00:28:25,651 --> 00:28:28,231 where it turns into carbonic acid. 589 00:28:28,281 --> 00:28:30,271 And it happens to be the case 590 00:28:30,321 --> 00:28:34,701 that we've put huge amounts of CO2 in the atmosphere 591 00:28:34,751 --> 00:28:37,434 in a very short period of time. 592 00:28:38,281 --> 00:28:41,881 - As we are emitting CO2, a constant fraction of it 593 00:28:41,931 --> 00:28:44,661 goes into the ocean and turns it into an acid. 594 00:28:44,711 --> 00:28:47,601 For every pound of CO2 we emit into the atmosphere, 595 00:28:47,651 --> 00:28:50,621 about 30% of it ends up in the ocean. 596 00:28:50,671 --> 00:28:53,071 So, acidification is a very linear, 597 00:28:53,121 --> 00:28:55,541 very predictable affair. 598 00:28:55,591 --> 00:28:58,751 - The oceans' average pH already dropped from 599 00:28:58,801 --> 00:29:00,831 8.2 to 8.1 600 00:29:00,881 --> 00:29:03,021 since pre-industrial times. 601 00:29:03,071 --> 00:29:05,431 And scientists estimate that it will drop further 602 00:29:05,481 --> 00:29:07,241 by the end of this century, 603 00:29:07,291 --> 00:29:10,791 to an average pH of 7.8 604 00:29:10,841 --> 00:29:15,191 So after being relatively stable for thousands of years, 605 00:29:15,241 --> 00:29:17,831 now we're looking at a total pH drop 606 00:29:17,881 --> 00:29:20,171 of zero point four units 607 00:29:20,221 --> 00:29:22,801 in only about 300 years. 608 00:29:22,851 --> 00:29:27,851 And while point four pH units may not sound like a lot, 609 00:29:27,881 --> 00:29:31,031 for the plants and animals who live in the ocean, 610 00:29:31,081 --> 00:29:33,211 it's a huge change. 611 00:29:33,261 --> 00:29:36,411 - Life, as we know it, has evolved to depend on those 612 00:29:36,461 --> 00:29:40,141 very constant, very well buffered conditions in the ocean. 613 00:29:40,191 --> 00:29:41,941 If the ocean turns more acidic, 614 00:29:41,991 --> 00:29:45,721 it's a chemical environment that a lot of species 615 00:29:45,771 --> 00:29:48,121 are not accustomed to because they've never seen this 616 00:29:48,171 --> 00:29:49,821 in their species lifetime, 617 00:29:49,871 --> 00:29:51,326 millions of years. 618 00:29:51,376 --> 00:29:53,176 And, as such, this can really present 619 00:29:53,226 --> 00:29:55,871 a large challenge to ocean life. 620 00:29:55,921 --> 00:29:58,481 For example, the western United States, 621 00:29:58,531 --> 00:30:00,861 there's a big oyster industry, 622 00:30:00,911 --> 00:30:02,621 and some of the oyster hatcheries, 623 00:30:02,671 --> 00:30:05,581 where the very fragile larvae of the oysters form, 624 00:30:05,631 --> 00:30:08,401 had to be moved to Hawaii because the water 625 00:30:08,451 --> 00:30:10,951 was turning too acidic for them to survive. 626 00:30:11,001 --> 00:30:13,331 And what a lot of people don't realize is that 627 00:30:13,381 --> 00:30:16,371 ocean acidification is already outside the bounds 628 00:30:16,421 --> 00:30:17,624 of natural variability. 629 00:30:20,707 --> 00:30:23,107 - [Sofia] Another creature that has attracted a lot of 630 00:30:23,157 --> 00:30:26,221 concern for its sensitivity to ocean acidification 631 00:30:26,271 --> 00:30:29,181 and warming is phytoplankton. 632 00:30:29,231 --> 00:30:30,481 Why is that? 633 00:30:30,531 --> 00:30:32,181 Well, for a number of reasons. 634 00:30:32,231 --> 00:30:35,021 One of which is that ocean phytoplankton 635 00:30:35,071 --> 00:30:37,331 are responsible for one half 636 00:30:37,381 --> 00:30:40,781 of the world's oxygen production. 637 00:30:40,831 --> 00:30:41,921 Half of it. 638 00:30:41,971 --> 00:30:44,731 - So, half of all plant production happens in the ocean, 639 00:30:44,781 --> 00:30:47,341 and that also means half of our oxygen that is produced 640 00:30:47,391 --> 00:30:49,821 annually on the globe, happens in the ocean. 641 00:30:49,871 --> 00:30:52,431 It's produced by tiny algae called phytoplankton, 642 00:30:52,481 --> 00:30:54,641 which produce the same amount of oxygen 643 00:30:54,691 --> 00:30:56,841 as all other plants in the world combined. 644 00:30:56,891 --> 00:30:58,711 In some sense, every second breath we take 645 00:30:58,761 --> 00:31:00,261 comes from the ocean. 646 00:31:00,311 --> 00:31:03,671 - The further changes in phytoplankton that are projected 647 00:31:03,721 --> 00:31:07,361 if ocean acidification and warming continue, 648 00:31:07,411 --> 00:31:09,881 are completely unprecedented. 649 00:31:09,931 --> 00:31:11,461 So we really don't know how 650 00:31:11,511 --> 00:31:13,504 exactly it's all going to play out. 651 00:31:14,451 --> 00:31:18,671 - In 2018 my one wish for Christmas 652 00:31:18,721 --> 00:31:20,911 was some device that will suck CO2 653 00:31:20,961 --> 00:31:22,991 out of the atmosphere. 654 00:31:23,041 --> 00:31:25,284 But in a way, 655 00:31:27,251 --> 00:31:30,241 I wonder if that would actually be the best thing, 656 00:31:30,291 --> 00:31:33,221 'cause of course, we're on a sorta like, 657 00:31:33,271 --> 00:31:37,511 collision course with disaster and tragedy. 658 00:31:37,561 --> 00:31:40,651 I hate to say this, but we kind of deserve it. 659 00:31:40,701 --> 00:31:43,571 Like, we're the cause of the problem. 660 00:31:43,621 --> 00:31:44,771 You're the cause of the problem. 661 00:31:44,821 --> 00:31:46,351 I'm the cause of the problem. 662 00:31:46,401 --> 00:31:49,691 And sure, it would be nice to magically push a button 663 00:31:49,741 --> 00:31:51,401 and suck all, well, not all of it, 664 00:31:51,451 --> 00:31:54,301 a lot of the CO2 out of the atmosphere, 665 00:31:54,351 --> 00:31:56,711 but what would we have learned? 666 00:31:56,761 --> 00:32:01,041 I don't want a magic fix that will reduce CO2, 667 00:32:01,091 --> 00:32:03,661 I want us to stop treating this planet 668 00:32:03,711 --> 00:32:04,771 like a garbage dump, 669 00:32:04,821 --> 00:32:07,111 and I want us to stop pretending that there 670 00:32:07,161 --> 00:32:10,641 is some, like, plan B, some other planet we can move to. 671 00:32:10,691 --> 00:32:14,331 Like, I'm sorry Elon Musk, Mars is not a viable solution. 672 00:32:14,381 --> 00:32:17,981 You can't move eight billion people to Mars, 673 00:32:18,031 --> 00:32:19,461 which does not support life. 674 00:32:19,511 --> 00:32:22,231 - Sorry to report to the world, but 675 00:32:22,281 --> 00:32:24,831 as predicted by many fishy scientists, 676 00:32:24,881 --> 00:32:26,931 we have fished all the fishies, 677 00:32:26,981 --> 00:32:28,281 well almost all the fishies. 678 00:32:28,331 --> 00:32:30,431 Any that are left are kinda hard to find. 679 00:32:30,481 --> 00:32:32,171 Unless you have enough money. 680 00:32:32,221 --> 00:32:33,261 Then you can treat yourself 681 00:32:33,311 --> 00:32:34,920 to some of the old frozen stocks. 682 00:32:34,970 --> 00:32:37,720 (dramatic music) 683 00:32:39,481 --> 00:32:41,411 - We saw in our future world, 684 00:32:41,461 --> 00:32:43,981 that fish were very hard to come by. 685 00:32:44,031 --> 00:32:46,331 This is based on a simple reality. 686 00:32:46,381 --> 00:32:49,331 We're taking too much life out of the ocean, 687 00:32:49,381 --> 00:32:53,131 while dumping too many harmful things into it. 688 00:32:53,181 --> 00:32:56,141 The World Economic Forum recently issued 689 00:32:56,191 --> 00:32:57,924 a sobering prediction. 690 00:32:57,974 --> 00:33:00,374 With a business as usual scenario, 691 00:33:00,424 --> 00:33:05,401 by 2050 there will be more plastic in the ocean than fish. 692 00:33:06,421 --> 00:33:09,111 The pervasiveness of plastic seems to have really 693 00:33:09,161 --> 00:33:10,721 snuck up on us. 694 00:33:10,771 --> 00:33:14,401 It's a manmade substance, first created in 1907, 695 00:33:14,451 --> 00:33:16,631 but now, barely a century later, 696 00:33:16,681 --> 00:33:19,191 it's literally everywhere. 697 00:33:19,241 --> 00:33:22,671 Most plastic is never recycled either. 698 00:33:22,721 --> 00:33:25,061 In fact, a lot of it can't be recycled, 699 00:33:25,111 --> 00:33:26,691 even if we wanted to, 700 00:33:26,741 --> 00:33:30,441 because of certain components that are used in its making. 701 00:33:30,491 --> 00:33:34,061 According to the United Nations, more than eight million 702 00:33:34,111 --> 00:33:37,081 metric tons of plastic find their way 703 00:33:37,131 --> 00:33:39,901 to the ocean every year. 704 00:33:39,951 --> 00:33:41,967 That's the equivalent of dumping 705 00:33:42,017 --> 00:33:46,698 1,440 garbage trucks of plastic 706 00:33:46,748 --> 00:33:51,748 into the sea every single day. 707 00:33:53,251 --> 00:33:54,201 - Plastic doesn't break down. 708 00:33:54,251 --> 00:33:56,821 It stays in the environment and accumulates. 709 00:33:56,871 --> 00:33:58,791 The more we dump in, the more there is. 710 00:33:58,841 --> 00:33:59,931 It doesn't go away. 711 00:33:59,981 --> 00:34:01,811 It breaks into smaller and smaller pieces, 712 00:34:01,861 --> 00:34:05,901 but those micro-plastics remain and they have toxic effects 713 00:34:05,951 --> 00:34:07,601 that we don't even really understand, 714 00:34:07,651 --> 00:34:09,691 we are only beginning to study now. 715 00:34:09,741 --> 00:34:11,661 Including their effects on humans. 716 00:34:11,711 --> 00:34:15,091 For example, if you eat a muscle, or any shellfish 717 00:34:15,141 --> 00:34:18,001 or any product from the sea is almost guaranteed now 718 00:34:18,051 --> 00:34:20,601 to have little plastic filaments in them. 719 00:34:20,651 --> 00:34:22,911 Because the plastic is everywhere 720 00:34:22,961 --> 00:34:25,431 and is being fed upon by these animals. 721 00:34:25,481 --> 00:34:28,301 - Scientists have even measured the proportion of plastic 722 00:34:28,351 --> 00:34:32,141 mass to the proportion of plankton mass in the ocean 723 00:34:32,191 --> 00:34:35,971 and in some places, like the North Pacific Gyre, 724 00:34:36,021 --> 00:34:40,144 they found there was six times more plastic than plankton. 725 00:34:41,071 --> 00:34:45,001 So we're really turning the oceans into a plastic soup. 726 00:34:45,051 --> 00:34:48,151 - You find plastic in almost all seafood now. 727 00:34:48,201 --> 00:34:51,411 So, when you take a muscle from Halifax Harbor, 728 00:34:51,461 --> 00:34:54,441 it has about 100 plastic filaments in it. 729 00:34:54,491 --> 00:34:56,871 When you take a muscle from an aquaculture farm, 730 00:34:56,921 --> 00:34:58,691 it has about 200 plastic filaments, 731 00:34:58,741 --> 00:35:00,311 because they grow it on plastic ropes 732 00:35:00,361 --> 00:35:02,421 that shed the micro-fibers that then 733 00:35:02,471 --> 00:35:04,011 are eaten up by the muscle. 734 00:35:04,061 --> 00:35:07,401 - So, if you're eating seafood, you're probably also 735 00:35:07,451 --> 00:35:10,001 eating quite a bit of plastic, too. 736 00:35:10,051 --> 00:35:12,151 Embedded in the animal's tissue, 737 00:35:12,201 --> 00:35:15,551 even if you don't see the plastic or taste it. 738 00:35:15,601 --> 00:35:18,201 A recent study from the University of Belgium 739 00:35:18,251 --> 00:35:22,851 actually examined how much plastic seafood-loving 740 00:35:22,901 --> 00:35:26,411 Europeans were eating and estimated it could be 741 00:35:26,461 --> 00:35:31,461 around 11,000 tiny pieces of plastic per person, per year. 742 00:35:31,731 --> 00:35:34,261 We don't know how eating all this plastic 743 00:35:34,311 --> 00:35:36,321 will affect human health. 744 00:35:36,371 --> 00:35:39,031 We've only just started to study this, 745 00:35:39,081 --> 00:35:41,551 so it's still largely an unknown, 746 00:35:41,601 --> 00:35:43,761 which is not reassuring at all. 747 00:35:43,811 --> 00:35:47,521 On top of that, we've also seen that the nano-plastics 748 00:35:47,571 --> 00:35:50,891 which are the very small plastic particles, 749 00:35:50,941 --> 00:35:55,271 can actually cross cell membranes in some fish. 750 00:35:55,321 --> 00:35:58,711 We've seen that they can accumulate in organs, 751 00:35:58,761 --> 00:36:01,961 like the brain, testicles, and liver 752 00:36:02,011 --> 00:36:04,640 and cause problems with the reproduction, 753 00:36:04,690 --> 00:36:06,851 immune system, and behavior. 754 00:36:06,901 --> 00:36:11,001 And this ability of plastic to cross cell membranes 755 00:36:11,051 --> 00:36:14,641 is, in my opinion, one of the most concerning. 756 00:36:14,691 --> 00:36:16,881 Because, if it's affecting wildlife, 757 00:36:16,931 --> 00:36:18,731 I don't know how we can be certain that 758 00:36:18,781 --> 00:36:21,186 it's somehow not going to affect us, too. 759 00:36:21,236 --> 00:36:26,236 (dramatic music) (ocean waves crashing) 760 00:36:29,110 --> 00:36:31,693 (solemn music) 761 00:36:41,631 --> 00:36:44,271 We've known about the problem of fatal encounters 762 00:36:44,321 --> 00:36:46,581 between marine wildlife and debris 763 00:36:46,631 --> 00:36:48,001 for a long time. 764 00:36:48,051 --> 00:36:51,031 Since at least the 1960s. 765 00:36:51,081 --> 00:36:54,661 But today, of course, the magnitude is many times 766 00:36:54,711 --> 00:36:56,631 greater than it was then. 767 00:36:56,681 --> 00:36:58,931 And now we also have more technology, 768 00:36:58,981 --> 00:37:02,041 like cellphones with cameras and YouTube, 769 00:37:02,091 --> 00:37:05,591 so it's easier to witness the plight of these poor animals. 770 00:37:05,641 --> 00:37:07,611 With just a quick Google search, 771 00:37:07,661 --> 00:37:09,941 you'll see clips and pictures uploaded 772 00:37:09,991 --> 00:37:14,544 from all over the world of animals tangled in plastic, 773 00:37:18,391 --> 00:37:19,704 eating plastic, 774 00:37:23,311 --> 00:37:26,024 with plastic forks in their nostrils, 775 00:37:28,521 --> 00:37:31,614 with plastic straws stuck in their noses, 776 00:37:37,231 --> 00:37:40,544 birds dying with plastic-filled stomachs, 777 00:37:43,921 --> 00:37:47,201 baby birds being fed plastics by their mothers, 778 00:37:47,251 --> 00:37:49,501 who mistake it for food, 779 00:37:49,551 --> 00:37:51,711 and even whales, stranded ashore, 780 00:37:51,761 --> 00:37:54,991 starving and dying, unable to eat anything 781 00:37:55,041 --> 00:37:58,211 because their stomachs are filled with plastic, 782 00:37:58,261 --> 00:38:00,051 like this one in severe distress 783 00:38:00,101 --> 00:38:01,701 in the last moments of her life. 784 00:38:04,971 --> 00:38:09,071 I just can't imagine the level of despair and helplessness 785 00:38:09,121 --> 00:38:11,751 whales and all the other animals must feel 786 00:38:11,801 --> 00:38:15,141 as their stomachs fill with plastic to the point 787 00:38:15,191 --> 00:38:18,424 that they cannot eat food anymore and die. 788 00:38:23,791 --> 00:38:26,891 Remember this problem is all because of us. 789 00:38:26,941 --> 00:38:31,091 100 years ago, there was virtually no plastic anywhere, 790 00:38:31,141 --> 00:38:33,362 so it's a tragedy of our own making. 791 00:38:33,412 --> 00:38:36,162 (dramatic music) 792 00:39:44,644 --> 00:39:47,394 (dramatic music) 793 00:39:49,232 --> 00:39:52,371 With a human population of 7.5 billion 794 00:39:52,421 --> 00:39:55,541 and growing, if we all want to eat fish, 795 00:39:55,591 --> 00:39:58,111 then over-fishing seems to be the result. 796 00:39:58,161 --> 00:40:01,431 - Most fishing, prior to 1950, was coastal. 797 00:40:01,481 --> 00:40:05,391 Few fisheries happened way outside in the open oceans. 798 00:40:05,441 --> 00:40:07,491 That changed after World War II because of new 799 00:40:07,541 --> 00:40:10,001 technology, more power diesel engines. 800 00:40:10,051 --> 00:40:12,031 New materials for nets, and so on, 801 00:40:12,081 --> 00:40:14,481 that made it feasible to fish way offshore 802 00:40:14,531 --> 00:40:17,241 in fish populations that had never been fished before. 803 00:40:17,291 --> 00:40:20,241 And what we documented is that within 20 to 30 years, 804 00:40:20,291 --> 00:40:22,361 a lot of those populations became depleted, 805 00:40:22,411 --> 00:40:24,921 particularly for the very large fish. 806 00:40:24,971 --> 00:40:28,381 So the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization 807 00:40:28,431 --> 00:40:30,311 comes out with a report every two years 808 00:40:30,361 --> 00:40:32,011 and what they've shown is that the larger 809 00:40:32,061 --> 00:40:34,701 and larger fraction of those fish populations 810 00:40:34,751 --> 00:40:36,661 is being depleted and right now, 811 00:40:36,711 --> 00:40:40,412 about 80% or more are fully fished, 812 00:40:40,462 --> 00:40:42,321 meaning their fished to capacity 813 00:40:42,371 --> 00:40:44,771 or they're over-fished and being depleted. 814 00:40:44,821 --> 00:40:48,127 - Using data from the UNFAO, scientists from 815 00:40:48,177 --> 00:40:52,401 Dalhousie University projected that by the year 2048 816 00:40:52,451 --> 00:40:55,871 all fisheries would be practically empty. 817 00:40:55,921 --> 00:40:59,501 In other words, if we continue business as usual, 818 00:40:59,551 --> 00:41:03,441 they're warning we could have virtually fishless oceans 819 00:41:03,491 --> 00:41:05,694 in just a few short decades. 820 00:41:06,921 --> 00:41:09,131 - Many studies have concluded that if we keep 821 00:41:09,181 --> 00:41:11,281 fishing the way we've been fishing in the past 822 00:41:11,331 --> 00:41:13,301 we will collapse many or most 823 00:41:13,351 --> 00:41:15,961 fish populations by the middle of the century. 824 00:41:16,011 --> 00:41:18,911 There was just a new paper last year that showed this again 825 00:41:18,961 --> 00:41:22,971 using new data for fisheries management worldwide. 826 00:41:23,021 --> 00:41:25,771 - When people are confronted with this reality 827 00:41:25,821 --> 00:41:27,571 they sometimes think, well, 828 00:41:27,621 --> 00:41:30,281 we can just have farmed fish instead, right? 829 00:41:30,331 --> 00:41:33,191 Although farm fish, or aquaculture, is sometimes 830 00:41:33,241 --> 00:41:36,391 touted as an alternative approach to commercial fishing, 831 00:41:36,441 --> 00:41:40,271 in reality, it has its own set of very serious problems 832 00:41:40,321 --> 00:41:42,291 and can still be detrimental to both 833 00:41:42,341 --> 00:41:44,391 wild fish and ecosystems. 834 00:41:44,441 --> 00:41:48,261 From destruction and contamination of natural habitats, 835 00:41:48,311 --> 00:41:52,164 to genetic problems from the inbreeding of farm fish 836 00:41:52,214 --> 00:41:55,801 that sometimes escape and pass on their problems 837 00:41:55,851 --> 00:41:57,631 to the wild populations, 838 00:41:57,681 --> 00:42:00,371 making them less likely to survive. 839 00:42:00,421 --> 00:42:03,241 In addition, the crowded farming conditions 840 00:42:03,291 --> 00:42:06,971 are a breeding ground for diseases and parasites. 841 00:42:07,021 --> 00:42:10,041 One good example is parasitic sea lice, 842 00:42:10,091 --> 00:42:13,391 which feed on the skin and blood of salmon 843 00:42:13,441 --> 00:42:16,271 and can ultimately kill the fish. 844 00:42:16,321 --> 00:42:19,461 Wild salmon populations have been severely affected 845 00:42:19,511 --> 00:42:22,151 by lice spread from fish farms. 846 00:42:22,201 --> 00:42:26,051 On top of all that, many farmed fish are also carnivorous. 847 00:42:26,101 --> 00:42:29,074 Meaning they need to be fed wild caught fish. 848 00:42:32,731 --> 00:42:35,121 I don't think farming fish is the most effective 849 00:42:35,171 --> 00:42:37,501 or realistic solution to the problem. 850 00:42:37,551 --> 00:42:39,461 A more elegant and simple approach 851 00:42:39,511 --> 00:42:42,751 for all of us who have access to basic food options, 852 00:42:42,801 --> 00:42:44,744 is to simply stop eating fish. 853 00:42:44,794 --> 00:42:47,544 (dramatic music) 854 00:42:59,055 --> 00:43:01,482 - I have some friends who think that like 855 00:43:01,532 --> 00:43:03,561 by being environmentally responsible, 856 00:43:03,611 --> 00:43:05,921 they're going to stop eating land animals and only eat 857 00:43:05,971 --> 00:43:10,424 sea animals, fish and crustaceans and things. 858 00:43:10,474 --> 00:43:11,651 Like, if you care about the ocean, 859 00:43:11,701 --> 00:43:15,301 you have to stop eating animals that live in the ocean. 860 00:43:15,351 --> 00:43:17,261 It's so self-evident, 861 00:43:17,311 --> 00:43:21,281 I don't know how destroying fish 862 00:43:21,331 --> 00:43:23,861 and destroying the ecosystem of the ocean 863 00:43:23,911 --> 00:43:27,291 is somehow environmentally responsible, 864 00:43:27,341 --> 00:43:30,071 but we're a messed up species, 865 00:43:30,121 --> 00:43:31,461 so I'm not surprise that like, 866 00:43:31,511 --> 00:43:33,901 someone came up with that terrible idea. 867 00:43:33,951 --> 00:43:38,171 - My parents were educated people, just totally oblivious. 868 00:43:38,221 --> 00:43:42,881 And all the while, this whole little mess was brewing. 869 00:43:42,931 --> 00:43:45,201 We ended up turning our one little planet 870 00:43:45,251 --> 00:43:46,958 completely upside down. 871 00:43:47,008 --> 00:43:49,758 (dramatic music) 872 00:43:52,441 --> 00:43:55,913 - Our rapidly growing population is a multiplier that 873 00:43:55,963 --> 00:44:00,001 affects every global environmental issue we face. 874 00:44:00,051 --> 00:44:03,601 The fact is, we've had an unprecedented spike 875 00:44:03,651 --> 00:44:07,201 in our population over the last two centuries. 876 00:44:07,251 --> 00:44:10,131 That, coupled with our consumption patterns, 877 00:44:10,181 --> 00:44:13,501 is placing serious strain on our planet's finite 878 00:44:13,551 --> 00:44:16,281 natural resources and ecosystems 879 00:44:17,121 --> 00:44:19,971 - The number of people on the planet would not matter 880 00:44:20,021 --> 00:44:22,541 if we were ethereal beings. 881 00:44:22,591 --> 00:44:25,811 What matters is the combination of the number of people 882 00:44:25,861 --> 00:44:28,941 and their economic activity, namely consumption 883 00:44:28,991 --> 00:44:30,471 and waste products. 884 00:44:30,521 --> 00:44:33,771 - Our species, modern humans, has been around 885 00:44:33,821 --> 00:44:36,438 for about 200,000 years. 886 00:44:36,488 --> 00:44:40,695 And it took us all that time to reach a population of 887 00:44:40,745 --> 00:44:45,661 one billion, which we finally did relatively recently, 888 00:44:45,711 --> 00:44:47,921 in the early 1800s. 889 00:44:47,971 --> 00:44:52,471 But today, only about 200 years after that, 890 00:44:52,521 --> 00:44:55,961 we've multiplied seven times over. 891 00:44:56,011 --> 00:44:59,521 We're not more than 7.5 billion humans 892 00:44:59,571 --> 00:45:04,571 and on track to hit close to ten billion by the year 2050. 893 00:45:04,711 --> 00:45:05,991 - I'm concerned about population, 894 00:45:06,041 --> 00:45:08,691 because if you look over all of human history, 895 00:45:08,741 --> 00:45:11,071 it took up until the 1800s to reach 896 00:45:11,121 --> 00:45:13,161 the first one billion people on Earth. 897 00:45:13,211 --> 00:45:15,501 And the last one billion people, 898 00:45:15,551 --> 00:45:17,611 to go from six to seven billion people on Earth, 899 00:45:17,661 --> 00:45:19,504 took only about 12 years. 900 00:45:21,171 --> 00:45:24,301 - Why did our population grow so quickly in just 901 00:45:24,351 --> 00:45:25,874 the last two centuries? 902 00:45:26,731 --> 00:45:30,081 Well, simply put, we've had the very good fortune 903 00:45:30,131 --> 00:45:33,071 of being able to decrease child mortality 904 00:45:33,121 --> 00:45:35,831 and increase our life expectancies 905 00:45:35,881 --> 00:45:38,549 as a result of the agricultural revolution 906 00:45:38,599 --> 00:45:42,191 and technological advances in modern medicine. 907 00:45:42,241 --> 00:45:45,181 So more children now grow up, 908 00:45:45,231 --> 00:45:48,433 live longer and have children of their own. 909 00:45:48,483 --> 00:45:51,731 And this in the aggregate dramatically increased 910 00:45:51,781 --> 00:45:54,921 the world population in a short period of time. 911 00:45:54,971 --> 00:45:57,771 - Every year we're adding about 80 million 912 00:45:57,821 --> 00:45:58,971 extra people to the planet, 913 00:45:59,021 --> 00:46:01,271 and that is about the population of Germany. 914 00:46:01,321 --> 00:46:04,231 So, if you think about the need to find a good 915 00:46:04,281 --> 00:46:05,651 home for those people, 916 00:46:05,701 --> 00:46:07,551 to ensure that they have access to food, 917 00:46:07,601 --> 00:46:09,651 that they have access to clean water, 918 00:46:09,701 --> 00:46:12,231 that they have healthcare and education. 919 00:46:12,281 --> 00:46:14,331 It really puts things into perspective. 920 00:46:14,381 --> 00:46:18,431 - When I was born, in 1932, 921 00:46:18,481 --> 00:46:20,941 there were two billion people on the planet, 922 00:46:20,991 --> 00:46:24,651 now there are 7.5 billion people. 923 00:46:24,701 --> 00:46:28,601 The size of the human population has more than tripled 924 00:46:28,651 --> 00:46:30,394 in my one lifetime. 925 00:46:32,891 --> 00:46:34,691 One of the really critical things, 926 00:46:34,741 --> 00:46:39,301 the resource that we'll never run out of, is morons. 927 00:46:39,351 --> 00:46:41,261 Morons, for instance, say, 928 00:46:41,311 --> 00:46:43,181 it's only consumption, it's not the 929 00:46:43,231 --> 00:46:45,331 number of people that counts. 930 00:46:45,381 --> 00:46:48,331 That's like saying the area of a rectangle 931 00:46:48,381 --> 00:46:51,741 is determined only by its width, not by its length. 932 00:46:51,791 --> 00:46:54,731 Certainly, consumption is a big problem, 933 00:46:54,781 --> 00:46:56,861 so is population size. 934 00:46:56,911 --> 00:47:00,206 The two multiply together to give you your impact 935 00:47:00,256 --> 00:47:02,268 on your life support systems. 936 00:47:02,318 --> 00:47:03,391 (dramatic music) 937 00:47:03,441 --> 00:47:07,241 - Never in human history, have we asked so much 938 00:47:07,291 --> 00:47:11,671 of our environment, our infrastructure, and our society 939 00:47:11,721 --> 00:47:15,201 to accommodate such large increases in our population 940 00:47:15,251 --> 00:47:18,011 over such a short period of time. 941 00:47:18,061 --> 00:47:21,121 Just as one example, at the pace we are currently 942 00:47:21,171 --> 00:47:23,971 growing our population, we need to be building 943 00:47:24,021 --> 00:47:28,051 63 thousand new classrooms every single week, 944 00:47:28,101 --> 00:47:30,441 repeatedly, week after week, 945 00:47:30,491 --> 00:47:34,091 if we want every child to have access to education. 946 00:47:34,141 --> 00:47:38,121 Funding, building, and staffing 63 thousand new 947 00:47:38,171 --> 00:47:41,791 classrooms every single week, over and over. 948 00:47:41,841 --> 00:47:43,551 So are we building them? 949 00:47:43,601 --> 00:47:46,011 And are we prepared to keep building at that pace 950 00:47:46,061 --> 00:47:47,721 every single week? 951 00:47:47,771 --> 00:47:51,641 The answer is no, unfortunately we are not building them. 952 00:47:51,691 --> 00:47:53,601 And I don't think it's realistic 953 00:47:53,651 --> 00:47:56,561 to think that we could at that pace. 954 00:47:56,611 --> 00:47:59,829 - The impact of human beings on the planet 955 00:47:59,879 --> 00:48:01,819 doubles every 17 years. 956 00:48:01,869 --> 00:48:04,609 That is, if you take the rate of population growth, 957 00:48:04,659 --> 00:48:06,441 and add to it the rate of economic growth, 958 00:48:06,491 --> 00:48:08,281 and put those two things together, 959 00:48:08,331 --> 00:48:11,871 we make twice the impact on the planet every 17 years 960 00:48:11,921 --> 00:48:13,968 and you can't do that for many doublings before 961 00:48:14,018 --> 00:48:15,364 you destroy the planet. 962 00:48:17,371 --> 00:48:19,731 - A lot of people think the population problem 963 00:48:19,781 --> 00:48:23,441 is too many Indians, or too many people in Africa and so on. 964 00:48:23,491 --> 00:48:25,891 Actually, it's too many people in the United States 965 00:48:25,941 --> 00:48:27,201 to start out with. 966 00:48:27,251 --> 00:48:30,661 You and I consume much more than the average person 967 00:48:30,711 --> 00:48:33,371 in Africa or the average person in India. 968 00:48:33,421 --> 00:48:35,201 And that's part of the problem. 969 00:48:35,251 --> 00:48:38,271 To support the people we have today, 970 00:48:38,321 --> 00:48:39,981 the current estimate is you'd need 971 00:48:40,031 --> 00:48:41,971 one and a half Earths to do it. 972 00:48:42,021 --> 00:48:44,101 To support the people we have today 973 00:48:44,151 --> 00:48:46,531 at the style of the average American, 974 00:48:46,581 --> 00:48:49,391 you would need four or five more Earths. 975 00:48:49,441 --> 00:48:53,101 We're living on our capital, not on our interest. 976 00:48:53,151 --> 00:48:56,091 It's as if we were an idiot child that inherited 977 00:48:56,141 --> 00:48:59,671 a million dollars and kept writing bigger checks 978 00:48:59,721 --> 00:49:01,771 on the bank account every year, 979 00:49:01,821 --> 00:49:03,951 and never looking at the balance. 980 00:49:04,001 --> 00:49:06,171 We're using up our precious soils, 981 00:49:06,221 --> 00:49:09,211 we're using up our easily accessible resources. 982 00:49:09,261 --> 00:49:11,911 Basically, we're behaving like idiots, 983 00:49:11,961 --> 00:49:15,291 because we're the only species we know of 984 00:49:15,341 --> 00:49:17,964 that is determinedly set out to destroy itself. 985 00:49:23,971 --> 00:49:27,301 - Supposing the moon had water and an atmosphere, 986 00:49:27,351 --> 00:49:29,381 and we had a cheap way of getting there. 987 00:49:29,431 --> 00:49:31,061 At the present rate of population growth, 988 00:49:31,111 --> 00:49:32,411 we'd fill it up in 10 years. 989 00:49:32,461 --> 00:49:34,291 It wouldn't help us. 990 00:49:34,341 --> 00:49:37,391 - Given the fundamental importance that our population 991 00:49:37,441 --> 00:49:41,111 plays in so many converging environmental issues, 992 00:49:41,161 --> 00:49:43,321 you would think that environmental organizations 993 00:49:43,371 --> 00:49:46,491 would be having a robust conversation about it, 994 00:49:46,541 --> 00:49:50,001 yet most don't talk about population growth that much, 995 00:49:50,051 --> 00:49:51,261 if at all. 996 00:49:51,311 --> 00:49:54,551 - If you think about any controversial topic, 997 00:49:54,601 --> 00:49:59,601 people are always aware of difficult subjects 998 00:49:59,692 --> 00:50:02,751 and if they bring those difficult subjects up, 999 00:50:02,801 --> 00:50:04,011 it may get them into trouble. 1000 00:50:04,061 --> 00:50:07,091 So, if you go to a dinner party and you bring up 1001 00:50:07,141 --> 00:50:09,601 population and people jump all over you, 1002 00:50:09,651 --> 00:50:11,381 you'll say, okay I won't touch that again. 1003 00:50:11,431 --> 00:50:13,071 - There are a few reasons why people are afraid 1004 00:50:13,121 --> 00:50:16,391 to talk about population, but I thing at the heart of it 1005 00:50:16,441 --> 00:50:21,021 because there have been some coercive population programs 1006 00:50:21,071 --> 00:50:24,005 and policies, people are afraid that if they 1007 00:50:24,055 --> 00:50:27,431 make these links between population and the environment, 1008 00:50:27,481 --> 00:50:31,041 that it's suggesting that we have to control the population, 1009 00:50:31,091 --> 00:50:33,421 that there has to be some external force. 1010 00:50:33,471 --> 00:50:36,711 But, good population policies and programs respect what 1011 00:50:36,761 --> 00:50:40,921 couples want and they're about giving women and men 1012 00:50:40,971 --> 00:50:43,631 what they want and not telling people what to do. 1013 00:50:43,681 --> 00:50:46,211 - In talking about the very real problem of 1014 00:50:46,261 --> 00:50:49,251 unsustainable population growth, I believe 1015 00:50:49,301 --> 00:50:53,250 the focus needs to be on raising the awareness of the issue, 1016 00:50:53,300 --> 00:50:56,511 promoting gender equality and women's rights 1017 00:50:56,561 --> 00:51:00,421 around the world, supporting things like family planning, 1018 00:51:00,471 --> 00:51:03,381 so that all women have the means to determine 1019 00:51:03,431 --> 00:51:06,261 the number and spacing of their children, 1020 00:51:06,311 --> 00:51:11,121 encouraging small family norms, supporting adoption efforts, 1021 00:51:11,171 --> 00:51:15,291 increasing education, eradicating poverty, 1022 00:51:15,341 --> 00:51:19,554 and abolishing horrid practices like child marriages. 1023 00:51:20,601 --> 00:51:23,691 These human rights efforts are critically important 1024 00:51:23,741 --> 00:51:26,781 in their own right, but they also happen to be 1025 00:51:26,831 --> 00:51:29,611 some of the most effective actions we can take 1026 00:51:29,661 --> 00:51:32,664 to help slow our population growth rate. 1027 00:51:33,561 --> 00:51:36,861 Also, in our culture, there are still sometimes 1028 00:51:36,911 --> 00:51:39,861 some religious or social pressures that can make 1029 00:51:39,911 --> 00:51:43,051 people feel like they have to have children, 1030 00:51:43,101 --> 00:51:45,991 or they have to have a certain number of children, 1031 00:51:46,041 --> 00:51:48,311 even if they don't really want to. 1032 00:51:48,361 --> 00:51:51,021 Even if you are capable of having and supporting 1033 00:51:51,071 --> 00:51:54,581 children, no one should feel like they must have children 1034 00:51:54,631 --> 00:51:56,831 if that's not what they want to do. 1035 00:51:56,881 --> 00:52:00,881 As a personal example, I actually underwent tubal ligation, 1036 00:52:00,931 --> 00:52:04,681 or permanent sterilization surgery, several years ago 1037 00:52:04,731 --> 00:52:06,841 while single and childless. 1038 00:52:06,891 --> 00:52:10,381 Even though I love kids, I just don't have the inclination 1039 00:52:10,431 --> 00:52:14,121 to have any children of my own, and that's okay. 1040 00:52:14,171 --> 00:52:17,918 But no woman or man should feel like they have to have 1041 00:52:17,968 --> 00:52:21,601 children simply in response to social pressures. 1042 00:52:21,651 --> 00:52:23,803 And for the benefit of all humans, 1043 00:52:23,853 --> 00:52:27,761 including today's children and future generations to come, 1044 00:52:27,811 --> 00:52:31,141 I think we have a moral obligation to raise awareness 1045 00:52:31,191 --> 00:52:35,061 about the unsubstantiality of our current population growth 1046 00:52:35,111 --> 00:52:39,441 rate and the importance of slowing that rate down, 1047 00:52:39,491 --> 00:52:42,441 as well as changing our consumption patterns 1048 00:52:42,491 --> 00:52:46,091 so that we avoid irreparably depleting and destroying 1049 00:52:46,141 --> 00:52:49,801 the very environmental systems on which we humans 1050 00:52:49,851 --> 00:52:52,191 and all other species depend. 1051 00:52:52,241 --> 00:52:55,841 - So, I think that the silence around population 1052 00:52:55,891 --> 00:52:59,731 has to be broken, and people have to speak out 1053 00:52:59,781 --> 00:53:02,881 about the relationship between population and environment, 1054 00:53:02,931 --> 00:53:05,621 that there is something we can do to slow population growth 1055 00:53:05,671 --> 00:53:09,741 and it will have drastic benefits for access to resources, 1056 00:53:09,791 --> 00:53:13,591 access to land, access to water, food security, 1057 00:53:13,641 --> 00:53:17,341 and clean air, stable climate. 1058 00:53:17,391 --> 00:53:19,211 All of that's affected by population. 1059 00:53:19,261 --> 00:53:22,281 It will be much easier to manage these challenges 1060 00:53:22,331 --> 00:53:25,271 if we can slow and stabilize population growth. 1061 00:53:25,321 --> 00:53:28,251 Than if we continue on a business as usual path. 1062 00:53:28,301 --> 00:53:31,914 - A lot of us, myself included, everyone watching, 1063 00:53:31,964 --> 00:53:36,061 most of us self-identify as good people. 1064 00:53:36,111 --> 00:53:38,791 Of the 7.7 billion people on the planet, 1065 00:53:38,841 --> 00:53:40,628 I guarantee you almost all of them think 1066 00:53:40,678 --> 00:53:43,239 they're a good person, and they're leading a good life, 1067 00:53:43,289 --> 00:53:45,611 they're like, lookin' after their family. 1068 00:53:45,661 --> 00:53:49,778 But we are not judged 1069 00:53:49,828 --> 00:53:52,294 on how we self-identify. 1070 00:53:52,344 --> 00:53:55,441 We're judged on our actions, you know, 1071 00:53:55,491 --> 00:53:59,131 and if our actions cause misery and destruction 1072 00:53:59,181 --> 00:54:01,998 and suffering, we're not good people. 1073 00:54:02,048 --> 00:54:05,281 And you know, I'm not God, it's not my place to judge, 1074 00:54:05,331 --> 00:54:07,901 but like, where do we get the idea that we're living good, 1075 00:54:07,951 --> 00:54:10,321 benign lives if the product of our lives 1076 00:54:10,371 --> 00:54:12,861 is nothing but suffering and destruction? 1077 00:54:12,911 --> 00:54:15,661 (dramatic music) 1078 00:54:26,261 --> 00:54:28,341 - Dr Cohen, you were telling me over the break 1079 00:54:28,391 --> 00:54:31,781 that these methane explosions are nothing new, 1080 00:54:31,831 --> 00:54:34,561 and you didn't seem to be entirely surprised 1081 00:54:34,611 --> 00:54:36,241 by this event either. 1082 00:54:36,291 --> 00:54:38,461 - Well, we've been monitoring this phenomenon for decades 1083 00:54:38,511 --> 00:54:41,821 and while it's nothing new, we have seen an increase 1084 00:54:41,871 --> 00:54:43,631 in the frequency of these methane bubbles 1085 00:54:43,681 --> 00:54:45,309 which is very concerning. 1086 00:54:45,359 --> 00:54:48,109 (dramatic music) 1087 00:54:50,111 --> 00:54:52,851 - Our fictional characters in the future were worried 1088 00:54:52,901 --> 00:54:56,531 about methane bubbles escaping from under the Arctic. 1089 00:54:56,581 --> 00:54:59,841 But we actually don't have to go to the future to see this, 1090 00:54:59,891 --> 00:55:03,531 because it's something that's already happening today. 1091 00:55:03,581 --> 00:55:07,111 In fact, the image we used for the fictional newscast 1092 00:55:07,161 --> 00:55:11,211 is from a real life crater in Siberia, thought to have been 1093 00:55:11,261 --> 00:55:15,521 formed by a recent methane pocket explosion in an area 1094 00:55:15,571 --> 00:55:18,611 that used to be covered by frozen permafrost. 1095 00:55:18,661 --> 00:55:21,361 Some places in the Arctic are starting to look like 1096 00:55:21,411 --> 00:55:24,794 bubbling jacuzzis, not because the water is boiling, 1097 00:55:24,844 --> 00:55:28,761 but because methane that was previously trapped in ice 1098 00:55:28,811 --> 00:55:31,274 is now bubbling up to the surface. 1099 00:55:32,231 --> 00:55:34,351 Some daring scientists, like this one from the 1100 00:55:34,401 --> 00:55:37,791 University of Alaska, can even dig just a little bit 1101 00:55:37,841 --> 00:55:42,231 into the ice and light escaping methane right on fire. 1102 00:55:42,281 --> 00:55:44,471 But why does it matter if frozen methane 1103 00:55:44,521 --> 00:55:47,201 is now being released into the atmosphere? 1104 00:55:47,251 --> 00:55:50,351 Well, it's a concern for two main reasons. 1105 00:55:50,401 --> 00:55:53,366 First, because the total amount of methane trapped in frozen 1106 00:55:53,416 --> 00:55:57,371 parts of our planet is truly enormous. 1107 00:55:57,421 --> 00:56:00,961 There's several tons more methane trapped by ice 1108 00:56:01,011 --> 00:56:04,041 than there is in the entire atmosphere. 1109 00:56:04,091 --> 00:56:06,261 The second reason why methane matters, 1110 00:56:06,311 --> 00:56:10,221 is it happens to be an extremely powerful greenhouse gas. 1111 00:56:10,271 --> 00:56:14,631 It's at least 20 times more powerful than carbon dioxide 1112 00:56:14,681 --> 00:56:17,511 in trapping heat from the sun. 1113 00:56:17,561 --> 00:56:21,370 If this enormous store of frozen methane or a big 1114 00:56:21,420 --> 00:56:25,591 part of it is released into our atmosphere, 1115 00:56:25,641 --> 00:56:30,401 it could amplify the degree and speed of climate change. 1116 00:56:30,451 --> 00:56:31,991 - It's a very unusual kind of ice 1117 00:56:32,041 --> 00:56:33,401 that you can actually burn. 1118 00:56:33,451 --> 00:56:36,901 Also, of course, like regular ice, it can melt. 1119 00:56:36,951 --> 00:56:39,281 - It's actually methane trapped in water molecules, 1120 00:56:39,331 --> 00:56:41,761 but frozen and it's under pressure and at cold 1121 00:56:41,811 --> 00:56:43,981 temperatures under the oceans. 1122 00:56:44,031 --> 00:56:45,891 There's a lot of it, but it's deep in the ocean, 1123 00:56:45,941 --> 00:56:47,671 it's hard to get at, it's very unstable, 1124 00:56:47,721 --> 00:56:49,771 so people just generally leave it alone, 1125 00:56:49,821 --> 00:56:51,221 and that's a good thing. 1126 00:56:51,271 --> 00:56:54,041 But in the Arctic Ocean, it's more shallow, 1127 00:56:54,091 --> 00:56:55,671 and so we're already starting to see, 1128 00:56:55,721 --> 00:56:57,298 due to warming, the melting of ice, 1129 00:56:57,348 --> 00:56:58,651 the warming of the Arctic Sea, 1130 00:56:58,701 --> 00:57:00,511 we're starting to see methane bubbles 1131 00:57:00,561 --> 00:57:02,551 coming out of the Arctic Ocean. 1132 00:57:02,601 --> 00:57:06,541 And it's hard to say how much that is so far, 1133 00:57:06,591 --> 00:57:08,961 but we know that with further warming, 1134 00:57:09,011 --> 00:57:10,894 it's going to get worse. 1135 00:57:15,391 --> 00:57:18,681 - The good news is, when methane is locked under 1136 00:57:18,731 --> 00:57:20,421 or within a frozen surface, 1137 00:57:20,471 --> 00:57:24,131 it's harmless because it doesn't enter the atmosphere. 1138 00:57:24,181 --> 00:57:27,381 The bad news is, over the past century, 1139 00:57:27,431 --> 00:57:30,171 we've been putting a lot of carbon dioxide into our 1140 00:57:30,221 --> 00:57:33,371 atmosphere, which traps heat from the sun 1141 00:57:33,421 --> 00:57:36,751 and has been causing the average global temperature 1142 00:57:36,801 --> 00:57:39,471 to warm up, and as a result, 1143 00:57:39,521 --> 00:57:42,471 places that were once permanently frozen, 1144 00:57:42,521 --> 00:57:46,531 are now thawing, or thawing for part of the year. 1145 00:57:46,581 --> 00:57:48,666 - I think the danger of the methane is even though 1146 00:57:48,716 --> 00:57:51,651 we're starting to see the melting of the permafrost, 1147 00:57:51,701 --> 00:57:54,021 we're starting to see bubbling out of the Arctic, 1148 00:57:54,071 --> 00:57:55,881 it's not that it's a lot now, 1149 00:57:55,931 --> 00:57:59,249 but it's a sign of something that could happen in much 1150 00:57:59,299 --> 00:58:00,711 greater amounts in the future, 1151 00:58:00,761 --> 00:58:02,411 and therefore we want to stop it 1152 00:58:02,461 --> 00:58:04,631 before it gets out of control. 1153 00:58:04,681 --> 00:58:08,931 Right now, the biggest contributor to climate change 1154 00:58:08,981 --> 00:58:10,414 and global warming is CO2. 1155 00:58:11,887 --> 00:58:14,356 - So we refer to these gasses, like CO2 1156 00:58:14,406 --> 00:58:18,431 as greenhouse gasses because of this metaphor 1157 00:58:18,481 --> 00:58:20,131 with an actual greenhouse. 1158 00:58:20,181 --> 00:58:23,111 A greenhouse is a glass building that lets sunlight 1159 00:58:23,161 --> 00:58:26,631 come in and then it traps some of the heat in there 1160 00:58:26,681 --> 00:58:29,491 so it's warmer inside the greenhouse 1161 00:58:29,541 --> 00:58:31,441 than outside the greenhouse. 1162 00:58:31,491 --> 00:58:33,561 And I have firsthand experience with a greenhouse, 1163 00:58:33,611 --> 00:58:37,381 having had my wedding reception in a greenhouse, 1164 00:58:37,431 --> 00:58:40,821 in July, in Massachusetts, with no air conditioning. 1165 00:58:40,871 --> 00:58:42,281 So, they work. 1166 00:58:42,331 --> 00:58:46,731 In fact, on our planet, if we didn't have CO2 and those 1167 00:58:46,781 --> 00:58:50,871 greenhouse gasses, the planet would freeze over. 1168 00:58:50,921 --> 00:58:53,941 It would freeze over, from the pole down to the equator. 1169 00:58:53,991 --> 00:58:57,721 - The problem is that in a very short period of time 1170 00:58:57,771 --> 00:59:01,301 we have rapidly increased the amount of these 1171 00:59:01,351 --> 00:59:03,941 heat-trapping substances in our atmosphere, 1172 00:59:03,991 --> 00:59:07,101 not over thousand or millions of years 1173 00:59:07,151 --> 00:59:09,541 like has happened naturally in the past, 1174 00:59:09,591 --> 00:59:14,021 we're literally doing it in the blink of a geological eye. 1175 00:59:14,071 --> 00:59:17,361 The amount of CO2 in the atmosphere used to be around 1176 00:59:17,411 --> 00:59:21,481 280 parts per million for thousands of years, 1177 00:59:21,531 --> 00:59:24,351 until we had the Industrial Revolution. 1178 00:59:24,401 --> 00:59:27,271 And then, in a very short period of time, 1179 00:59:27,321 --> 00:59:32,321 less than 300 years, we increased the concentration 1180 00:59:32,371 --> 00:59:36,504 to over 400 parts per million today. 1181 00:59:37,531 --> 00:59:39,361 Ending our use of fossil fuels, 1182 00:59:39,411 --> 00:59:42,431 by transitioning to clean renewable energy 1183 00:59:42,481 --> 00:59:45,980 is urgently needed to stop this dangerous increase 1184 00:59:46,030 --> 00:59:50,351 in the amount of heat-trapping CO2 in our atmosphere. 1185 00:59:50,401 --> 00:59:53,581 And while we need to absolutely remain diligent 1186 00:59:53,631 --> 00:59:56,721 in the crucial task of transitioning to clean, 1187 00:59:56,771 --> 01:00:00,601 renewable energy, there is also another critical action 1188 01:00:00,651 --> 01:00:03,181 that is available to us as individuals 1189 01:00:03,231 --> 01:00:05,131 that we can all take right now, 1190 01:00:05,181 --> 01:00:08,821 that would have a significant and almost immediate impact, 1191 01:00:08,871 --> 01:00:13,061 and that does not require any new laws or technology. 1192 01:00:13,111 --> 01:00:15,321 According to the United Nations, 1193 01:00:15,371 --> 01:00:19,341 animal agriculture is responsible for more human-caused 1194 01:00:19,391 --> 01:00:22,931 greenhouse gas emissions than the entire global 1195 01:00:22,981 --> 01:00:26,261 transportation sector combined. 1196 01:00:26,311 --> 01:00:28,631 This means that livestock sector, 1197 01:00:28,681 --> 01:00:30,451 the sector that raises animals, 1198 01:00:30,501 --> 01:00:33,091 like cows, pigs, chickens, and goats, 1199 01:00:33,141 --> 01:00:37,484 produces more heat-trapping greenhouse gas emissions 1200 01:00:37,534 --> 01:00:40,641 than all of the cars, buses, trains, 1201 01:00:40,691 --> 01:00:43,231 ships, and airplanes combined. 1202 01:00:43,281 --> 01:00:45,552 In addition, the United Nations reports 1203 01:00:45,602 --> 01:00:50,341 the livestock sector is also the major driver 1204 01:00:50,391 --> 01:00:53,548 of deforestation in the world. 1205 01:00:53,598 --> 01:00:57,511 And trees are an important carbon dioxide sink, 1206 01:00:57,561 --> 01:01:01,704 meaning they absorb and sequester it out of our atmosphere. 1207 01:01:03,751 --> 01:01:07,291 In addition to continued development and implementation 1208 01:01:07,341 --> 01:01:11,231 of clean energy technologies, a mass global shift 1209 01:01:11,281 --> 01:01:15,151 away from animal foods is urgently needed 1210 01:01:15,201 --> 01:01:17,941 and would have significant and almost immediate 1211 01:01:17,991 --> 01:01:21,001 impact in addressing our climate crisis. 1212 01:01:21,051 --> 01:01:23,391 - It's funny, when I became a vegan in 1987, 1213 01:01:23,441 --> 01:01:24,581 my reason was simple. 1214 01:01:24,631 --> 01:01:26,921 I loved animals and I didn't want to do anything 1215 01:01:26,971 --> 01:01:29,591 that contributed or caused animal suffering. 1216 01:01:29,641 --> 01:01:31,871 But as time passed, I began to find out more about 1217 01:01:31,921 --> 01:01:34,461 the role of animal agriculture in human health 1218 01:01:34,511 --> 01:01:36,771 and in the environment, but especially 1219 01:01:36,821 --> 01:01:38,541 what has reinforced my veganism, 1220 01:01:38,591 --> 01:01:42,211 is the role that animal agriculture in climate change. 1221 01:01:42,261 --> 01:01:43,631 - Why are you a vegetarian? 1222 01:01:43,681 --> 01:01:45,801 I asked him and it wasn't even because meat's bad for you, 1223 01:01:45,851 --> 01:01:48,521 he said that raising cattle was bad for the planet 1224 01:01:48,571 --> 01:01:51,921 with cow flatulence in the ozone and the clearing 1225 01:01:51,971 --> 01:01:54,181 of land for the raising of cattle. 1226 01:01:54,231 --> 01:01:56,764 What are you doing to help the environment? 1227 01:01:57,781 --> 01:01:59,223 I'm eatin' the cow. 1228 01:01:59,273 --> 01:02:00,821 (audience laughs) 1229 01:02:00,871 --> 01:02:01,951 - It's your choice, 1230 01:02:02,001 --> 01:02:05,061 comedians and everyone else, you can continue to make jokes 1231 01:02:05,111 --> 01:02:08,511 about cow farts, or you can address the fact 1232 01:02:08,561 --> 01:02:10,701 that animal agriculture and the way it contributes 1233 01:02:10,751 --> 01:02:13,311 to climate change is going to make this planet 1234 01:02:13,361 --> 01:02:15,491 uninhabitable for us. 1235 01:02:15,541 --> 01:02:17,201 - One meal a day? 1236 01:02:17,251 --> 01:02:18,824 Just one measly meal? 1237 01:02:19,671 --> 01:02:22,852 Rationing food and water doesn't get you down, too? 1238 01:02:22,902 --> 01:02:25,791 And I can't remember the last time we could eat 1239 01:02:25,841 --> 01:02:27,291 three meals just like normal. 1240 01:02:28,891 --> 01:02:31,301 - Civilization has only flourished 1241 01:02:31,351 --> 01:02:34,261 when there is food availability. 1242 01:02:34,311 --> 01:02:38,051 Well, unfortunately, severe food and water shortages 1243 01:02:38,101 --> 01:02:41,371 are anticipated in the not-so-distant future 1244 01:02:41,421 --> 01:02:44,191 if we continue business as usual. 1245 01:02:44,241 --> 01:02:48,041 Global resource depletion, our own consumption patterns, 1246 01:02:48,091 --> 01:02:51,008 and population growth all play a part. 1247 01:02:51,058 --> 01:02:53,808 (dramatic music) 1248 01:02:56,551 --> 01:02:59,831 - There are three projections for the year 2050 1249 01:02:59,881 --> 01:03:01,831 made by the UN Population Division. 1250 01:03:01,881 --> 01:03:03,901 High, medium, and low. 1251 01:03:03,951 --> 01:03:07,386 If we're at the high or even the medium projection, 1252 01:03:07,436 --> 01:03:12,436 so somewhere between 9.5 and 10.5 billion people by 2050, 1253 01:03:12,631 --> 01:03:16,221 we will clearly face a food crisis. 1254 01:03:16,271 --> 01:03:19,101 - Right now enough calories certainly are produced 1255 01:03:19,151 --> 01:03:22,031 to feed everyone, so right now enough food is produced, 1256 01:03:22,081 --> 01:03:24,761 but there are these issues that lead to food insecurity 1257 01:03:24,811 --> 01:03:26,691 due to distribution. 1258 01:03:26,741 --> 01:03:28,801 Projecting forward into the future, 1259 01:03:28,851 --> 01:03:31,021 it's easy to imagine that it's less of a distribution 1260 01:03:31,071 --> 01:03:34,131 issue and becomes more of a issue that it's very very 1261 01:03:34,181 --> 01:03:36,871 difficult to actually produce all the calories 1262 01:03:36,921 --> 01:03:38,571 that will be demanded. 1263 01:03:38,621 --> 01:03:40,501 - According to the United Nations, 1264 01:03:40,551 --> 01:03:42,841 with our current population growth 1265 01:03:42,891 --> 01:03:45,611 and the current trends of a growing middle class 1266 01:03:45,661 --> 01:03:47,781 who are consuming more animal foods, 1267 01:03:47,831 --> 01:03:50,631 we'll need to double our crop production 1268 01:03:50,681 --> 01:03:54,711 by the year 2050, just to keep up. 1269 01:03:54,761 --> 01:03:57,301 The problem is our planet doesn't really 1270 01:03:57,351 --> 01:03:59,661 have the land to do this. 1271 01:03:59,711 --> 01:04:02,621 - We're currently using pretty much all of the good 1272 01:04:02,671 --> 01:04:05,536 arable land for agriculture. 1273 01:04:05,586 --> 01:04:07,121 If it's good land for growing crops, 1274 01:04:07,171 --> 01:04:09,321 we're probably already growing crops there. 1275 01:04:09,371 --> 01:04:11,821 There is some other land that could be turned into 1276 01:04:11,871 --> 01:04:14,771 cropland, but generally that's a bad idea, 1277 01:04:14,821 --> 01:04:17,981 because other lands are either sensitive forests, 1278 01:04:18,031 --> 01:04:20,741 or simply not suitable for agriculture. 1279 01:04:20,791 --> 01:04:23,381 - It turns out that feeding the human population 1280 01:04:23,431 --> 01:04:26,871 with animal foods is tremendously inefficient. 1281 01:04:26,921 --> 01:04:29,151 Animal foods require a lot more land, 1282 01:04:29,201 --> 01:04:31,771 a lot more water, and a lot more energy, 1283 01:04:31,821 --> 01:04:34,291 as compared to producing plant foods. 1284 01:04:34,341 --> 01:04:36,381 Keep in mind that we're not just talking about the 1285 01:04:36,431 --> 01:04:39,911 animals themselves, we're also talking about all the food 1286 01:04:39,961 --> 01:04:42,821 that has to be grown to feed all those animals. 1287 01:04:42,871 --> 01:04:45,601 And all the land and water that goes into growing 1288 01:04:45,651 --> 01:04:47,171 all those feed crops. 1289 01:04:47,221 --> 01:04:50,771 Animals are extremely inefficient converters of food, 1290 01:04:50,821 --> 01:04:54,311 meaning they eat much more food than they produce. 1291 01:04:54,361 --> 01:04:57,711 - Globally, about 36% of 1292 01:04:57,761 --> 01:04:59,977 plant-based crop production 1293 01:05:00,027 --> 01:05:01,641 goes to feed animals. 1294 01:05:01,691 --> 01:05:05,181 But only about four percent of that is actually 1295 01:05:05,231 --> 01:05:08,541 returned to our food system in meat that we eat. 1296 01:05:08,591 --> 01:05:12,911 In other words, there's this huge conversion inefficiency. 1297 01:05:12,961 --> 01:05:16,411 We're losing about 90% of the calories 1298 01:05:16,461 --> 01:05:18,751 as we go from grains to meat. 1299 01:05:18,801 --> 01:05:22,091 - You have to feed about 30 calories to a cow to get 1300 01:05:22,141 --> 01:05:26,021 one calorie of edible meat out. 1301 01:05:26,071 --> 01:05:28,271 So it takes-- the cow uses a lot 1302 01:05:28,321 --> 01:05:30,571 of that energy just to live. 1303 01:05:30,621 --> 01:05:34,141 So eating meat is a very inefficient use, 1304 01:05:34,191 --> 01:05:37,821 in energetic terms, of calories. 1305 01:05:37,871 --> 01:05:40,691 - According to scientists from the University of Minnesota 1306 01:05:40,741 --> 01:05:42,571 Institute on the Environment, 1307 01:05:42,621 --> 01:05:45,751 of all the calories we invest in raising animals 1308 01:05:45,801 --> 01:05:48,571 for food, we only recover a fraction, 1309 01:05:48,621 --> 01:05:51,961 on average about 12% in the form of meat, 1310 01:05:52,011 --> 01:05:53,771 dairy, and other animal products. 1311 01:05:53,821 --> 01:05:56,601 - To state the obvious, it takes a lot of energy 1312 01:05:56,651 --> 01:05:59,601 and a lot of resources, to produce food. 1313 01:05:59,651 --> 01:06:03,191 There's seven and a half billion of us on this planet. 1314 01:06:03,241 --> 01:06:08,111 But what doesn't make sense is to produce all this food 1315 01:06:08,161 --> 01:06:10,691 and then feed it to animals. 1316 01:06:10,741 --> 01:06:13,223 You know, I mean, the only analogy I can think of 1317 01:06:13,273 --> 01:06:15,497 is like, imagine taking 1318 01:06:15,547 --> 01:06:19,158 1,000 pounds of corn 1319 01:06:19,208 --> 01:06:20,661 that you could eat yourself, 1320 01:06:20,711 --> 01:06:22,861 and instead turning it into tequila 1321 01:06:22,911 --> 01:06:25,611 and trying to feed yourself off of that. 1322 01:06:25,661 --> 01:06:27,211 Like we see how dumb that would be, 1323 01:06:27,261 --> 01:06:29,101 it's the exact same thing we're doing with grain 1324 01:06:29,151 --> 01:06:30,771 that we feed to animals. 1325 01:06:30,821 --> 01:06:34,101 - So it turns out we can dramatically increase the 1326 01:06:34,151 --> 01:06:36,541 availability of food in the world, 1327 01:06:36,591 --> 01:06:39,893 by feeding ourselves with the plants directly. 1328 01:06:39,943 --> 01:06:44,413 And this is an important humanitarian issue to consider. 1329 01:06:44,463 --> 01:06:47,451 (dramatic music) 1330 01:06:47,501 --> 01:06:49,843 - As I travel around the world, I see poor countries 1331 01:06:49,893 --> 01:06:53,091 who sell their grain to the West, 1332 01:06:53,141 --> 01:06:56,091 while their own children starve in their arms, 1333 01:06:56,141 --> 01:06:58,961 and the West feeds it to livestock 1334 01:06:59,011 --> 01:07:01,891 ...so we can eat a steak? 1335 01:07:01,941 --> 01:07:05,044 Am I the only one who sees this as a crime? 1336 01:07:06,991 --> 01:07:10,011 Believe me, every morsel of meat we eat 1337 01:07:10,061 --> 01:07:13,834 is slapping the tear-stained face of a hungry child. 1338 01:07:15,225 --> 01:07:17,811 - And of course, eating animal foods also affects 1339 01:07:17,861 --> 01:07:20,614 farm animals, too, in a very direct way. 1340 01:07:23,171 --> 01:07:25,721 A couple of years ago, a slaughterhouse gave me 1341 01:07:25,771 --> 01:07:28,471 permission to film inside their facility, 1342 01:07:28,521 --> 01:07:31,101 with some conditions, but I was essentially allowed to 1343 01:07:31,151 --> 01:07:33,531 go in and film whatever I wanted. 1344 01:07:33,581 --> 01:07:37,501 So I grabbed a very easy to use camera and I flew there. 1345 01:07:37,551 --> 01:07:40,071 The first day, I filmed around the holding areas 1346 01:07:40,121 --> 01:07:41,968 next to the slaughter facility. 1347 01:07:42,018 --> 01:07:45,351 And the second day I filmed inside the actual building 1348 01:07:45,401 --> 01:07:47,731 where the slaughtering occurred. 1349 01:07:47,781 --> 01:07:50,451 And one thing in particular that shocked me 1350 01:07:50,501 --> 01:07:52,971 although it probably shouldn't have shocked me 1351 01:07:53,021 --> 01:07:55,341 because this seems so obvious now, 1352 01:07:55,391 --> 01:07:58,151 was how all the animals fight for their lives 1353 01:07:58,201 --> 01:08:00,091 until the very end. 1354 01:08:00,141 --> 01:08:03,021 Somehow they all seem to know they are in danger, 1355 01:08:03,071 --> 01:08:04,851 even in the holding areas. 1356 01:08:04,901 --> 01:08:08,611 One particular cow I saw the first day in the holding areas 1357 01:08:08,661 --> 01:08:13,561 was a beautiful, huge completely white cow. 1358 01:08:13,611 --> 01:08:16,621 And somehow, I think she knew that something 1359 01:08:16,671 --> 01:08:18,941 really bad was going to happen to her. 1360 01:08:18,991 --> 01:08:20,721 Because she was really frightened. 1361 01:08:20,771 --> 01:08:23,061 I don't know if she was able to smell the blood 1362 01:08:23,111 --> 01:08:26,081 of the animals who went before her, or what. 1363 01:08:26,131 --> 01:08:30,571 But she was really anxious and upset and moving around, 1364 01:08:30,621 --> 01:08:33,011 so since I happened to be there, 1365 01:08:33,061 --> 01:08:37,151 my reaction was to try to console this poor cow, 1366 01:08:37,201 --> 01:08:39,441 so I started talking to her 1367 01:08:39,491 --> 01:08:41,381 trying to soothe her, 1368 01:08:41,431 --> 01:08:43,941 and I spent some time with her, 1369 01:08:43,991 --> 01:08:46,941 and after a few minutes, she was a lot calmer, 1370 01:08:46,991 --> 01:08:50,091 and even her eyes looked more relaxed and 1371 01:08:50,141 --> 01:08:51,474 she was in better shape. 1372 01:08:53,361 --> 01:08:55,801 But then the next morning, when I returned 1373 01:08:55,851 --> 01:08:58,471 to film the actual slaughter facility, 1374 01:08:58,521 --> 01:09:02,091 in addition to all the other cows they were slaughtering 1375 01:09:02,141 --> 01:09:06,031 it came the turn of that beautiful and sweet 1376 01:09:06,081 --> 01:09:08,764 and completely white cow to go through slaughter. 1377 01:09:10,351 --> 01:09:12,701 And unlike the other cows before her, 1378 01:09:12,751 --> 01:09:15,311 who were desperately trying to escape, 1379 01:09:15,361 --> 01:09:16,681 trying to crawl up the wall 1380 01:09:16,731 --> 01:09:19,874 and getting up on the hind legs to avoid getting killed, 1381 01:09:20,981 --> 01:09:24,251 this white cow didn't fight at all. 1382 01:09:24,301 --> 01:09:27,271 Most of the other cows had to be shoved in so they could 1383 01:09:27,321 --> 01:09:29,461 close the metal door behind them, 1384 01:09:29,511 --> 01:09:32,591 but this one, they didn't have to shove her in too much, 1385 01:09:32,641 --> 01:09:35,852 because she just came right in and she kept perfectly 1386 01:09:35,902 --> 01:09:39,951 still and did nothing but stare at me 1387 01:09:40,001 --> 01:09:41,891 because I was right there with my camera 1388 01:09:41,941 --> 01:09:45,361 no more than like a meter away from where her head was. 1389 01:09:45,411 --> 01:09:50,411 So this poor cow, I think recognized me from the day before, 1390 01:09:50,631 --> 01:09:52,224 that I had been nice to her, 1391 01:09:53,581 --> 01:09:56,384 and I think she thought I was going to be able to help her. 1392 01:09:57,301 --> 01:10:00,221 Because she was just keeping perfectly still, 1393 01:10:00,271 --> 01:10:02,821 and she just had her eyes wide open, 1394 01:10:02,871 --> 01:10:05,511 locked on my eyes, like she was imploring 1395 01:10:05,561 --> 01:10:06,694 for me to save her. 1396 01:10:09,681 --> 01:10:12,194 But there was absolutely nothing that I could do. 1397 01:10:17,371 --> 01:10:19,954 (door creaks) 1398 01:10:42,302 --> 01:10:45,431 I remember when I left the slaughterhouse that morning, 1399 01:10:45,481 --> 01:10:48,881 it was still pretty early, and as I stepped outside 1400 01:10:48,931 --> 01:10:52,371 there were lots of trees and the birds were singing, 1401 01:10:52,421 --> 01:10:55,271 and everything seemed so peaceful outside. 1402 01:10:55,321 --> 01:10:58,331 And I thought to myself, how unbelievable 1403 01:10:58,381 --> 01:11:00,171 that this world in which we live, 1404 01:11:00,221 --> 01:11:02,701 seems so peaceful and beautiful 1405 01:11:02,751 --> 01:11:06,741 and at the same time, this very world is also 1406 01:11:06,791 --> 01:11:08,411 an unrelenting hell on Earth 1407 01:11:08,461 --> 01:11:11,071 for the animals we use for food. 1408 01:11:11,121 --> 01:11:13,791 Every single piece of animal food we eat 1409 01:11:13,841 --> 01:11:16,471 comes from an animal who desperately wanted 1410 01:11:16,521 --> 01:11:17,682 to not be killed. 1411 01:11:17,732 --> 01:11:21,162 (dramatic music) 1412 01:11:21,212 --> 01:11:23,970 (chickens vocalizing) 1413 01:11:24,020 --> 01:11:26,281 (thrashing desparately) 1414 01:11:26,331 --> 01:11:29,351 Because no matter how local, humane, organic, 1415 01:11:29,401 --> 01:11:32,841 cage free, grass fed, it may be labeled, 1416 01:11:32,891 --> 01:11:37,891 for the animals, this world is a real life horror story, 1417 01:11:38,021 --> 01:11:41,801 one in which they fight for their lives with futility. 1418 01:11:41,851 --> 01:11:44,984 And then ultimately get killed against their will. 1419 01:11:47,101 --> 01:11:50,471 - So you're slaughtering these remarkable animals 1420 01:11:50,521 --> 01:11:52,321 and it's cruel and it's stupid. 1421 01:11:52,371 --> 01:11:55,271 I mean, maybe that's basically, like when humanity 1422 01:11:55,321 --> 01:11:58,071 disappears and we have to write the epitaph for humanity, 1423 01:11:58,121 --> 01:11:59,731 like we'll have a tombstone, it'll just say 1424 01:11:59,781 --> 01:12:02,831 here lies humanity, we had some good ideas, 1425 01:12:02,881 --> 01:12:06,341 but basically we're just so cruel and stupid. 1426 01:12:06,391 --> 01:12:07,944 - Why did we ignore it all? 1427 01:12:09,291 --> 01:12:11,761 Really, indulge me, no BS. 1428 01:12:11,811 --> 01:12:14,574 - Okay, think about it like this. 1429 01:12:15,491 --> 01:12:19,631 What do you get when you mix a lot of shortsightedness, 1430 01:12:19,681 --> 01:12:23,231 with a little selfishness, and just a dash of apathy, 1431 01:12:23,281 --> 01:12:26,961 and oh, no shortage of scientific illiteracy, 1432 01:12:27,011 --> 01:12:30,024 and don't forget a whole lot of power and technology too. 1433 01:12:30,861 --> 01:12:35,861 In my opinion, we're two hairs short of being chimpanzees, 1434 01:12:35,891 --> 01:12:38,911 we're extremely emotional, powerful, primitive, 1435 01:12:38,961 --> 01:12:41,261 shortsighted, survival drives. 1436 01:12:41,311 --> 01:12:44,401 - The reasons why I wrote those lines for Dr Jerry's 1437 01:12:44,451 --> 01:12:48,541 character is because that is my genuine opinion. 1438 01:12:48,591 --> 01:12:51,551 Dr Potts said he thoughts the name for humans 1439 01:12:51,601 --> 01:12:55,391 should be "Homo horribilus" instead of Homo sapiens, 1440 01:12:55,441 --> 01:12:58,941 because humans have been so violent throughout history. 1441 01:12:58,991 --> 01:13:02,291 Dr Ehrlich said he thought a more appropriate name 1442 01:13:02,341 --> 01:13:05,701 was "Homo moronicus" because we're destroying 1443 01:13:05,751 --> 01:13:08,431 the very ecosystems that support us. 1444 01:13:08,481 --> 01:13:12,461 But I think "Homo oblivious" is my preferred name. 1445 01:13:12,511 --> 01:13:15,371 Because we're all just happily going along 1446 01:13:15,421 --> 01:13:19,171 in our busy lives, day-by-day, year-by-year, 1447 01:13:19,221 --> 01:13:21,871 consuming more and more resources, 1448 01:13:21,921 --> 01:13:25,171 running towards a very real precipice, 1449 01:13:25,221 --> 01:13:27,501 but totally oblivious. 1450 01:13:27,551 --> 01:13:29,671 - If we look at the course of humanity, 1451 01:13:29,721 --> 01:13:32,821 I see that humanity, we do a lot of terrible things, 1452 01:13:32,871 --> 01:13:35,141 but we're capable of doing a lot of great things. 1453 01:13:35,191 --> 01:13:38,601 And we're also capable, over time, of identifying 1454 01:13:38,651 --> 01:13:41,351 the things that we should no longer be doing. 1455 01:13:41,401 --> 01:13:44,581 You know, we ended slavery largely. 1456 01:13:44,631 --> 01:13:47,071 You know, 100 years ago in the United States, 1457 01:13:47,121 --> 01:13:50,811 women couldn't vote and children still worked in factories. 1458 01:13:50,861 --> 01:13:53,041 We all know what the right thing to do, 1459 01:13:53,091 --> 01:13:55,001 or the right things to do are. 1460 01:13:55,051 --> 01:13:57,028 We know what to do and we know how to do it. 1461 01:13:57,078 --> 01:13:59,711 The problem is, we're not doing it. 1462 01:13:59,761 --> 01:14:02,021 And until we do, 1463 01:14:02,071 --> 01:14:03,911 we're just going to hasten our own destruction, 1464 01:14:03,961 --> 01:14:05,101 and the destruction of all the other 1465 01:14:05,151 --> 01:14:06,496 creatures on this planet. 1466 01:14:06,546 --> 01:14:09,296 (upbeat music) 1467 01:14:13,831 --> 01:14:16,661 - So what can you and I actually do as individuals 1468 01:14:16,711 --> 01:14:18,161 that would make a difference? 1469 01:14:18,211 --> 01:14:20,227 Probably more than you think. 1470 01:14:20,277 --> 01:14:23,561 In our personal lives, we can educate ourselves 1471 01:14:23,611 --> 01:14:26,041 and others on the science and the urgency 1472 01:14:26,091 --> 01:14:28,371 of these pressing issues. 1473 01:14:28,421 --> 01:14:33,421 We can procure and advocate for clean, renewable energy. 1474 01:14:33,431 --> 01:14:35,791 We can minimize our plastic use, 1475 01:14:35,841 --> 01:14:38,261 especially single use plastic, 1476 01:14:38,311 --> 01:14:40,011 recycle whatever we can, 1477 01:14:40,061 --> 01:14:42,941 and put pressure on companies and our governments, 1478 01:14:42,991 --> 01:14:46,151 to promote the use of biodegradable materials 1479 01:14:46,201 --> 01:14:47,791 instead of plastic. 1480 01:14:47,841 --> 01:14:52,241 They already exist and many look and feel just like plastic. 1481 01:14:52,291 --> 01:14:55,721 When it comes to helping stabilize our population growth, 1482 01:14:55,771 --> 01:14:58,821 we can all support, in whatever way we can, 1483 01:14:58,871 --> 01:15:01,381 gender equality across the world, 1484 01:15:01,431 --> 01:15:05,371 as well as access to education and family planning. 1485 01:15:05,421 --> 01:15:08,103 Also, consider the planetary benefits of having small 1486 01:15:08,153 --> 01:15:10,961 families instead of large ones, 1487 01:15:11,011 --> 01:15:13,901 and please consider adoption as well. 1488 01:15:13,951 --> 01:15:16,521 Last, but definitely not least, 1489 01:15:16,571 --> 01:15:18,881 when it comes to the impact of our diets, 1490 01:15:18,931 --> 01:15:22,701 we can eat plant foods instead of animal foods. 1491 01:15:22,751 --> 01:15:25,721 Changing our diets is absolutely one of the most 1492 01:15:25,771 --> 01:15:28,051 impactful actions we can take, 1493 01:15:28,101 --> 01:15:30,111 and unlike many other issues, 1494 01:15:30,161 --> 01:15:34,071 this one is completely within our control. 1495 01:15:34,121 --> 01:15:37,751 And we can start immediately with our very next meal. 1496 01:15:37,801 --> 01:15:39,731 - So, I've been vegan for 31 years, 1497 01:15:39,781 --> 01:15:41,451 and when I first went vegan, 1498 01:15:41,501 --> 01:15:43,601 I was making $2,000 a year, 1499 01:15:43,651 --> 01:15:45,851 and I was living in an abandoned factory 1500 01:15:45,901 --> 01:15:47,601 in a crack neighborhood. 1501 01:15:47,651 --> 01:15:49,811 And I ate really well. 1502 01:15:49,861 --> 01:15:54,861 Grains, you know, like rice, oats, beans, vegetables, 1503 01:15:55,501 --> 01:15:58,117 fruits, nuts, seeds. 1504 01:15:58,167 --> 01:16:00,201 - Do you really think they can figure out how to farm 1505 01:16:00,251 --> 01:16:01,894 so much food with so little water? 1506 01:16:01,944 --> 01:16:04,861 - Why are you so mad me, I didn't cause this? 1507 01:16:04,911 --> 01:16:06,641 - You just take what you want, when you want it, 1508 01:16:06,691 --> 01:16:08,312 and you don't care who you hurt. 1509 01:16:08,362 --> 01:16:11,112 (dramatic music) 1510 01:16:16,971 --> 01:16:19,811 - As a physician, I can tell you that a sensible 1511 01:16:19,861 --> 01:16:23,411 balanced vegan diet also happens to be very healthy. 1512 01:16:23,461 --> 01:16:27,021 We can easily get all the protein we need from plants. 1513 01:16:27,071 --> 01:16:30,251 And when we eat plant foods, we also get fiber, 1514 01:16:30,301 --> 01:16:34,771 antioxidants and phytonutrients, which promote health. 1515 01:16:34,821 --> 01:16:37,881 And this is just one of the reasons why so many health 1516 01:16:37,931 --> 01:16:40,081 authorities are promoting vegan diets. 1517 01:16:40,131 --> 01:16:43,031 For example, Harvard's Healthy Eating Pyramid 1518 01:16:43,081 --> 01:16:44,581 says, "go with plants" 1519 01:16:44,631 --> 01:16:47,231 "Eating a plant-based diet is healthiest." 1520 01:16:47,281 --> 01:16:50,491 Kaiser Permanente, one of the largest health organizations 1521 01:16:50,541 --> 01:16:53,484 in the country, is looking for ways to make plant-based 1522 01:16:53,534 --> 01:16:57,193 diets the "new normal" for their patients and employees. 1523 01:16:57,243 --> 01:17:00,151 The recent chair of Harvard's Department of Nutrition, 1524 01:17:00,201 --> 01:17:03,391 Dr Walter Willett, recommends you "Pick the best 1525 01:17:03,441 --> 01:17:07,318 "protein packages by emphasizing plant sources of protein" 1526 01:17:07,368 --> 01:17:09,671 rather than animal sources." 1527 01:17:09,721 --> 01:17:12,551 Dr Kim Williams, recent president of the American 1528 01:17:12,601 --> 01:17:15,238 College of Cardiology, vigorously recommends 1529 01:17:15,288 --> 01:17:18,781 a plant-based vegan diet to both his patients 1530 01:17:18,831 --> 01:17:21,531 and to physicians over all other diets 1531 01:17:21,581 --> 01:17:23,741 for optimum nutrition and health. 1532 01:17:23,791 --> 01:17:25,988 - There probably are some really good 1533 01:17:26,038 --> 01:17:27,331 things about the vegetables and fruits. 1534 01:17:27,381 --> 01:17:29,801 You know, it's antioxidants and 1535 01:17:29,851 --> 01:17:34,401 it's vitamins and it's nutrients and fiber. 1536 01:17:34,451 --> 01:17:35,771 That may be all well and good, 1537 01:17:35,821 --> 01:17:37,801 but it might just be that animals are so bad for you 1538 01:17:37,851 --> 01:17:40,571 that in eating anything else that could nutrify you 1539 01:17:40,621 --> 01:17:41,916 without eating an animal, 1540 01:17:41,966 --> 01:17:43,941 is probably going to show up better. 1541 01:17:43,991 --> 01:17:46,571 - Even the largest organization of food and nutrition 1542 01:17:46,621 --> 01:17:50,121 professionals in the US, the Academy of Nutrition and 1543 01:17:50,171 --> 01:17:53,401 Dietetics, has long held their official position 1544 01:17:53,451 --> 01:17:55,891 that balanced vegan diets are healthy, 1545 01:17:55,941 --> 01:17:59,161 nutritionally adequate and appropriate for individuals 1546 01:17:59,211 --> 01:18:02,261 during all stages of life, including pregnancy, 1547 01:18:02,311 --> 01:18:07,311 lactation, infancy, older adulthood, and for athletes. 1548 01:18:07,491 --> 01:18:10,621 - And only thing you know I always want to emphasize, 1549 01:18:10,671 --> 01:18:14,051 that people just don't survive on a plant-based diet, 1550 01:18:14,101 --> 01:18:15,371 they thrive. 1551 01:18:15,421 --> 01:18:18,891 Actually, the recent Olympics that happened in Rio 1552 01:18:18,941 --> 01:18:23,431 the only US male athlete who qualified for 1553 01:18:23,481 --> 01:18:27,311 weightlifting from the US was vegan. 1554 01:18:27,361 --> 01:18:30,911 Scott Jurek, the runner who broke the record for the 1555 01:18:30,961 --> 01:18:33,094 Appalachian Trail is vegan. 1556 01:18:35,361 --> 01:18:37,601 - My name is Josh LaJuanie. 1557 01:18:37,651 --> 01:18:41,671 I am from south Louisiana, a small town call Thibodaux, 1558 01:18:41,721 --> 01:18:45,161 which is about 50 miles southwest of New Orleans. 1559 01:18:45,211 --> 01:18:47,341 That's where I grew up, huntin' and fishin' 1560 01:18:47,391 --> 01:18:49,854 and doin' all the normal country folk stuff. 1561 01:18:51,241 --> 01:18:54,721 Found myself weighing 420ish pounds 1562 01:18:54,771 --> 01:18:57,131 by the time I was 32 year old. 1563 01:18:57,181 --> 01:19:00,935 Never though veganism would ever be a thing in my life 1564 01:19:00,985 --> 01:19:03,331 as hunter, as a fisherman, as a football player, 1565 01:19:03,381 --> 01:19:08,041 as a stereotypical macho country boy, 1566 01:19:08,091 --> 01:19:11,821 with a four wheel drive pickup truck and a shotgun. 1567 01:19:11,871 --> 01:19:14,353 I would have never imagined being vegan at all-- 1568 01:19:14,403 --> 01:19:16,163 - [Megyn] No meat, whatsoever, you don't eat anything-- 1569 01:19:16,213 --> 01:19:16,996 - No, no, no. - [Megyn] Do any of you guys 1570 01:19:17,046 --> 01:19:17,829 still eat meat? 1571 01:19:17,879 --> 01:19:19,821 - [Megyn] Nothing? - No, zero, or dairy. 1572 01:19:19,871 --> 01:19:22,111 - It has changed my life, 1573 01:19:22,161 --> 01:19:24,261 I've learned a lot in the process, 1574 01:19:24,311 --> 01:19:26,761 and ultimately what wound up happening is, 1575 01:19:26,811 --> 01:19:30,371 I lost 230 pounds and I have become an 1576 01:19:30,421 --> 01:19:32,841 ultra-marathoner myself. 1577 01:19:32,891 --> 01:19:35,901 - So Josh LaJaunie is a tremendous athlete. 1578 01:19:35,951 --> 01:19:39,501 I mean, he doesn't run marathons, which is 26.2 miles, 1579 01:19:39,551 --> 01:19:43,431 he runs races that are 50 miles, 100 miles. 1580 01:19:43,481 --> 01:19:45,716 And all powered by plants. 1581 01:19:45,766 --> 01:19:50,766 - When people ask me where I get my protein, 1582 01:19:53,541 --> 01:19:56,841 my very simple answer is food. 1583 01:19:56,891 --> 01:19:59,141 - We get all the protein we need from plants. 1584 01:19:59,191 --> 01:20:01,891 In fact, plants can actually provide us really 1585 01:20:01,941 --> 01:20:03,771 excessive amounts of protein, 1586 01:20:03,821 --> 01:20:05,781 and this is something a lot of people don't realize. 1587 01:20:05,831 --> 01:20:07,991 They think protein is only from animals. 1588 01:20:08,041 --> 01:20:10,581 Plant-foods is where all the health is. 1589 01:20:10,631 --> 01:20:12,781 - Plants have an abundant protein. 1590 01:20:12,831 --> 01:20:15,501 And not just that, getting protein from plants 1591 01:20:15,551 --> 01:20:17,151 is healthier for us. 1592 01:20:17,201 --> 01:20:18,845 It doesn't come with the saturated fat, 1593 01:20:18,895 --> 01:20:22,251 or cholesterol and oxidants 1594 01:20:22,301 --> 01:20:25,181 and things that give us more inflammation, 1595 01:20:25,231 --> 01:20:28,341 or are otherwise detrimental to the health. 1596 01:20:28,391 --> 01:20:30,871 - [Sofia] I think it's also worth mentioning that physicians 1597 01:20:30,921 --> 01:20:33,641 have also been able to reverse cardiovascular disease 1598 01:20:33,691 --> 01:20:35,231 with a plant-based diet. 1599 01:20:35,281 --> 01:20:38,581 The formation of cholesterol plaques inside our vessels 1600 01:20:38,631 --> 01:20:43,261 is ubiquitous on a western diet, and cardiovascular disease 1601 01:20:43,311 --> 01:20:45,860 is the leading cause of death. 1602 01:20:45,910 --> 01:20:47,934 So, it is the most common reason 1603 01:20:47,984 --> 01:20:50,433 for adult men and women to die. 1604 01:20:50,483 --> 01:20:52,741 And these cholesterol plaques start 1605 01:20:52,791 --> 01:20:55,651 forming very early in our lives, 1606 01:20:55,701 --> 01:20:58,501 even though the actual heart attacks and strokes usually 1607 01:20:58,551 --> 01:21:01,331 don't start happening until we hit middle age. 1608 01:21:01,381 --> 01:21:04,539 - We know, from autopsies 1609 01:21:04,589 --> 01:21:08,306 that kids as young as 10, 11 years old, 1610 01:21:08,356 --> 01:21:10,231 who die of other causes, 1611 01:21:10,281 --> 01:21:13,601 when autopsies are done, they already have plaque 1612 01:21:13,651 --> 01:21:15,851 buildup in their arteries. 1613 01:21:15,901 --> 01:21:17,621 - It's obscenely common. 1614 01:21:17,671 --> 01:21:21,311 There are pathology studies of 12 to 14 1615 01:21:21,361 --> 01:21:25,188 year old kids in the US who died for reasons 1616 01:21:25,238 --> 01:21:27,161 unrelated to heart disease, 1617 01:21:27,211 --> 01:21:31,781 but about 65% of those 12 to 14 1618 01:21:31,831 --> 01:21:34,761 year olds have early signs of cholesterol disease 1619 01:21:34,811 --> 01:21:38,171 in the blood vessels that feed their hearts with blood. 1620 01:21:38,221 --> 01:21:40,301 - [Sofia] This military study, for example, 1621 01:21:40,351 --> 01:21:42,851 looked at the autopsies of American soldiers 1622 01:21:42,901 --> 01:21:45,501 who died in combat in the Korean War 1623 01:21:45,551 --> 01:21:49,991 with an average age of 22, and it found that 77% 1624 01:21:50,041 --> 01:21:52,791 of the soldiers already had plaques 1625 01:21:52,841 --> 01:21:55,111 of cholesterol in their arteries. 1626 01:21:55,161 --> 01:21:58,941 So even if you look amazing and very fit on the outside, 1627 01:21:58,991 --> 01:22:00,941 if you're eating a western diet, 1628 01:22:00,991 --> 01:22:04,271 your vessels still probably have cholesterol plaques 1629 01:22:04,321 --> 01:22:07,241 that will keep accumulating and getting bigger 1630 01:22:07,291 --> 01:22:11,301 and could ultimately result in a heart attack or a stroke. 1631 01:22:11,351 --> 01:22:13,451 - If you're eating a western diet, 1632 01:22:13,501 --> 01:22:15,364 you're going to have heart disease. 1633 01:22:16,431 --> 01:22:19,560 - When you look at randomized controlled trials, 1634 01:22:19,610 --> 01:22:22,351 really the only pattern of eating that's been shown 1635 01:22:22,401 --> 01:22:24,131 to reverse heart disease, for example, 1636 01:22:24,181 --> 01:22:25,481 is a plant-based diet, 1637 01:22:25,531 --> 01:22:27,451 one that doesn't have animal products. 1638 01:22:27,501 --> 01:22:30,071 - [Sofia] That's right, this ubiquitous disease, 1639 01:22:30,121 --> 01:22:34,077 that is our number one killer, has actually been reversed 1640 01:22:34,127 --> 01:22:36,141 with a plant-based diet. 1641 01:22:36,191 --> 01:22:38,951 As an example, here's a published case study from the 1642 01:22:39,001 --> 01:22:41,561 Cleveland Clinic Foundation of a patient 1643 01:22:41,611 --> 01:22:45,205 who had a heart attack and was treated with nothing but 1644 01:22:45,255 --> 01:22:48,551 a plant-based vegan diet, with no stints 1645 01:22:48,601 --> 01:22:50,731 or cholesterol lowering medication, 1646 01:22:50,781 --> 01:22:55,641 and he was able to completely reverse the disease, 1647 01:22:55,691 --> 01:22:59,524 to open up the clogged arteries going to his heart. 1648 01:23:00,821 --> 01:23:04,111 There is also a lot of compelling data in the published 1649 01:23:04,161 --> 01:23:07,161 literature that points to plant-based diets being 1650 01:23:07,211 --> 01:23:09,701 helpful in the prevention of cancer. 1651 01:23:09,751 --> 01:23:13,091 For example, scientists with Memorial Sloan-Kettering 1652 01:23:13,141 --> 01:23:16,711 Cancer Center and others literally took petri dishes 1653 01:23:16,761 --> 01:23:19,931 filled with cancer cells and poured blood from people 1654 01:23:19,981 --> 01:23:23,151 following a plant-based diet into one petri dish 1655 01:23:23,201 --> 01:23:26,271 and blood from people following a regular western diet 1656 01:23:26,321 --> 01:23:29,731 into another petri dish to see who's blood could fight 1657 01:23:29,781 --> 01:23:32,251 off the cancer cells better. 1658 01:23:32,301 --> 01:23:36,111 They found that blood from those eating a plant-based diet 1659 01:23:36,161 --> 01:23:40,111 inhibited cancer cell growth by 70%. 1660 01:23:40,161 --> 01:23:43,561 But the blood of those eating a regular western diet 1661 01:23:43,611 --> 01:23:48,411 only inhibited cancer cell grown by a mere 9%. 1662 01:23:48,461 --> 01:23:51,611 So the blood of those following a plant-based diet 1663 01:23:51,661 --> 01:23:54,501 was almost eight times more powerful 1664 01:23:54,551 --> 01:23:56,777 at inhibiting the growth of cancer cells. 1665 01:23:56,827 --> 01:24:00,261 (knife taps on cutting board) 1666 01:24:00,311 --> 01:24:02,791 - The animal protein itself has been closely linked 1667 01:24:02,841 --> 01:24:06,171 to increased production of IGF-1, 1668 01:24:06,221 --> 01:24:08,111 insulin-like growth factor. 1669 01:24:08,161 --> 01:24:10,941 Which is very closely tied to cancer. 1670 01:24:10,991 --> 01:24:12,831 - [Sofia] Yes, among other things, 1671 01:24:12,881 --> 01:24:14,371 one of the mechanisms by which 1672 01:24:14,421 --> 01:24:17,371 animal protein is thought to increase cancer risk 1673 01:24:17,421 --> 01:24:20,391 is something called IGF-1, 1674 01:24:20,441 --> 01:24:24,314 - IGF-1 is insulin-like growth factor one. 1675 01:24:25,641 --> 01:24:28,741 It's a growth factor, it causes things to grow, 1676 01:24:28,791 --> 01:24:31,892 good and bad, including cancer cells. 1677 01:24:31,942 --> 01:24:35,801 It is something that we do not want too much of, 1678 01:24:35,851 --> 01:24:39,631 in our body. However, animal foods 1679 01:24:39,681 --> 01:24:43,501 increase our levels of IGF-1 by two mechanism. 1680 01:24:43,551 --> 01:24:47,331 One, animal foods have IGF-1 in them, 1681 01:24:47,381 --> 01:24:51,631 so when we ingest animal foods, we ingest IGF-1. 1682 01:24:51,681 --> 01:24:56,591 And two, animals foods cause us to produce 1683 01:24:56,641 --> 01:24:58,841 more IGF-1 though our own liver. 1684 01:24:58,891 --> 01:25:02,111 - Eating these animal foods or animal protein, 1685 01:25:02,161 --> 01:25:05,501 actually revs up the enzymes in our liver, 1686 01:25:05,551 --> 01:25:08,244 that your body produces additional IGF-1. 1687 01:25:09,263 --> 01:25:11,871 So if you have a cancer, and we all have cancers 1688 01:25:11,921 --> 01:25:13,701 floating in our blood stream, 1689 01:25:13,751 --> 01:25:16,891 our immune system is constantly recognizing these 1690 01:25:16,941 --> 01:25:19,771 cancer cells and taking them out. 1691 01:25:19,821 --> 01:25:24,821 What IGF-1 does, it makes these cancer cells grow faster. 1692 01:25:25,321 --> 01:25:27,331 It makes them proliferate. 1693 01:25:27,381 --> 01:25:30,161 It makes them easier to metastasize. 1694 01:25:30,211 --> 01:25:33,041 So it helps in the inception of cancer, 1695 01:25:33,091 --> 01:25:36,691 in the growth of cancer, and in the spread of cancer. 1696 01:25:36,741 --> 01:25:39,451 - [Sofia] There's also a direct relationship between some 1697 01:25:39,501 --> 01:25:42,701 cancers and the problematic hormonal content that is 1698 01:25:42,751 --> 01:25:45,201 found in meat and in dairy. 1699 01:25:45,251 --> 01:25:48,921 - Dairy naturally has hormones. So even if the 1700 01:25:48,971 --> 01:25:51,811 packages say no added hormones, 1701 01:25:51,861 --> 01:25:53,281 they can't say no hormones, 1702 01:25:53,331 --> 01:25:55,791 they can only say no added hormones. 1703 01:25:55,841 --> 01:25:59,474 Milk is produced when a cow has just given birth to a baby. 1704 01:26:00,521 --> 01:26:02,931 A cow is no different than any other mammal. 1705 01:26:02,981 --> 01:26:06,351 There are a lot of hormones when a cow has just given birth. 1706 01:26:06,401 --> 01:26:08,461 - [Sofia] Dairy contains large amounts of 1707 01:26:08,511 --> 01:26:12,291 female sex hormones, like estrogens and progesterone. 1708 01:26:12,341 --> 01:26:15,391 And that includes milk labeled as organic 1709 01:26:15,441 --> 01:26:17,471 or no hormones added. 1710 01:26:17,521 --> 01:26:21,751 Remember, those labels only mean no hormones were added, 1711 01:26:21,801 --> 01:26:24,051 which is kind of misleading because, 1712 01:26:24,101 --> 01:26:27,021 regardless of whether hormones were added or not, 1713 01:26:27,071 --> 01:26:31,391 milk still contains all the hormones that are naturally 1714 01:26:31,441 --> 01:26:33,021 produced by the cows. 1715 01:26:33,071 --> 01:26:36,281 Even pediatricians have expressed concerns 1716 01:26:36,331 --> 01:26:39,281 that "Sexual maturation of prepubertal children" 1717 01:26:39,331 --> 01:26:43,541 "could be affected by the ordinary intake of cow milk." 1718 01:26:43,591 --> 01:26:47,241 This study examined the rate of female hormone related 1719 01:26:47,291 --> 01:26:50,648 cancers in 40 countries and found that 1720 01:26:50,698 --> 01:26:53,631 "milk plus cheese make the greatest contribution to the" 1721 01:26:53,681 --> 01:26:56,481 "incidence of ovarian cancer" and that 1722 01:26:56,531 --> 01:26:59,801 "milk plus cheese make the most significant contribution" 1723 01:26:59,851 --> 01:27:02,641 to the incidence of uterine cancers. 1724 01:27:02,691 --> 01:27:05,731 They said among dietary risk factors, 1725 01:27:05,781 --> 01:27:09,491 "we are most concerned with milk and dairy products" 1726 01:27:09,541 --> 01:27:13,831 because their estrogen and progesterone levels are so high. 1727 01:27:13,881 --> 01:27:16,991 As noted in this review published by Johns Hopkins 1728 01:27:17,041 --> 01:27:19,790 School of Public Health, dairy is actually 1729 01:27:19,840 --> 01:27:24,331 "one of the most consistent dietary predictors" 1730 01:27:24,381 --> 01:27:26,164 "for prostate cancer" 1731 01:27:26,214 --> 01:27:29,663 that exists in the published literature. 1732 01:27:32,941 --> 01:27:36,871 - I do not recommend my patients to eat fish. 1733 01:27:36,921 --> 01:27:40,991 Fish is an animal food, just like eggs and dairy and meat, 1734 01:27:41,041 --> 01:27:43,461 and hence it's high in saturated fat, 1735 01:27:43,511 --> 01:27:45,181 it's high in cholesterol, 1736 01:27:45,231 --> 01:27:48,271 and it also raises our IGF-1 levels. 1737 01:27:48,321 --> 01:27:51,531 - When you're eating fish, you're getting mercury, 1738 01:27:51,581 --> 01:27:54,281 you're getting plastics, you're getting dioxins, 1739 01:27:54,331 --> 01:27:56,331 you're getting so many heavy metals. 1740 01:27:56,381 --> 01:27:58,351 - There are plenty plant-based sources of 1741 01:27:58,401 --> 01:27:59,861 Omega-3 fatty acids. 1742 01:27:59,911 --> 01:28:04,251 Without having to deal with the unhealthy aspects of fish. 1743 01:28:04,301 --> 01:28:07,694 - So there you get the Omega-3s, the healthy fats, 1744 01:28:07,744 --> 01:28:09,711 but you don't get the mercury, 1745 01:28:09,761 --> 01:28:11,201 you don't get the heavy metal, 1746 01:28:11,251 --> 01:28:13,291 you don't get the dioxins. 1747 01:28:13,341 --> 01:28:16,251 And this way, you know you're being healthy, 1748 01:28:16,301 --> 01:28:18,081 you're being kind to the environment, 1749 01:28:18,131 --> 01:28:20,631 kind to the oceans, kind to the fish. 1750 01:28:20,681 --> 01:28:23,291 And you're being also kind to your own body. 1751 01:28:23,341 --> 01:28:27,401 - The bottom line is, for those of us with access to food, 1752 01:28:27,451 --> 01:28:30,091 other than our adopted habits and convenience, 1753 01:28:30,141 --> 01:28:33,261 there's no good reason for consuming animal foods. 1754 01:28:33,311 --> 01:28:36,991 Collectively, we're not only imposing unnecessary suffering 1755 01:28:37,041 --> 01:28:39,301 and death on billions of animals, 1756 01:28:39,351 --> 01:28:41,681 we're also devastating the environment that 1757 01:28:41,731 --> 01:28:43,199 supports us all. 1758 01:28:43,249 --> 01:28:45,999 (dramatic music) 1759 01:28:48,461 --> 01:28:51,811 Our planet is special and it is quite literally 1760 01:28:51,861 --> 01:28:54,551 the only home we have. 1761 01:28:54,601 --> 01:28:57,081 This may sound obvious, but really, 1762 01:28:57,131 --> 01:28:58,694 shouldn't we take care of it? 1763 01:28:59,881 --> 01:29:03,291 Let's do whatever we can to preserve and protect 1764 01:29:03,341 --> 01:29:06,711 the only home and the only other companions 1765 01:29:06,761 --> 01:29:10,054 in the universe we have ever know. 1766 01:29:10,104 --> 01:29:12,854 (dramatic music) 1767 01:29:44,382 --> 01:29:49,382 ♪ Now that you're gone ♪ 1768 01:29:49,639 --> 01:29:54,264 ♪ The dawn comes ♪ 1769 01:29:54,314 --> 01:29:58,185 ♪ Now that you're gone ♪ 1770 01:29:58,235 --> 01:30:01,216 ♪ The sun ♪ 1771 01:30:01,266 --> 01:30:04,035 ♪ Will be ♪ 1772 01:30:04,085 --> 01:30:07,951 ♪ No more ♪ 1773 01:30:08,001 --> 01:30:11,258 ♪ The sun ♪ 1774 01:30:11,308 --> 01:30:14,111 ♪ Will be ♪ 1775 01:30:14,161 --> 01:30:19,161 ♪ No more ♪ 1776 01:30:21,559 --> 01:30:24,175 ♪ Will be ♪ 1777 01:30:24,225 --> 01:30:26,392 ♪ No more ♪ 1778 01:30:55,009 --> 01:31:00,009 ♪ Now that you're gone ♪ 1779 01:31:00,352 --> 01:31:05,092 ♪ The dawn comes ♪ 1780 01:31:05,142 --> 01:31:08,778 ♪ Now that you're gone ♪ 1781 01:31:08,828 --> 01:31:12,114 ♪ The sun ♪ 1782 01:31:12,164 --> 01:31:14,861 ♪ Will be ♪ 1783 01:31:14,911 --> 01:31:19,911 ♪ No more ♪ 1784 01:31:21,272 --> 01:31:24,020 ♪ The sun ♪ 1785 01:31:24,070 --> 01:31:26,829 ♪ Will be ♪ 1786 01:31:26,879 --> 01:31:30,714 ♪ No more ♪ 1787 01:31:30,764 --> 01:31:34,148 ♪ The sun ♪ 1788 01:31:34,198 --> 01:31:36,942 ♪ Will be ♪ 1789 01:31:36,992 --> 01:31:41,992 ♪ No more ♪ 1790 01:31:44,381 --> 01:31:46,701 ♪ Will be ♪ 1791 01:31:46,751 --> 01:31:51,751 ♪ No more ♪ 1792 01:31:54,487 --> 01:31:56,768 ♪ Will be ♪ 1793 01:31:56,818 --> 01:32:01,818 ♪ No more ♪ 1794 01:32:03,865 --> 01:32:08,538 ♪ No more ♪ 1795 01:32:08,588 --> 01:32:10,755 ♪ No more ♪ 1796 01:32:18,634 --> 01:32:23,634 ♪ The sun ♪ 1797 01:32:24,771 --> 01:32:28,381 ♪ Will be ♪ 1798 01:32:28,431 --> 01:32:33,431 ♪ No more ♪ 1799 01:32:33,790 --> 01:32:37,227 ♪ Will be ♪ 1800 01:32:37,277 --> 01:32:39,444 ♪ No more ♪ 143731

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.