Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:34,265 --> 00:00:37,025
Sebastian junger: When a
society collapses into anarchy
2
00:00:37,035 --> 00:00:40,295
And violence, civilians
inevitably take matters
3
00:00:40,304 --> 00:00:42,704
Into their own hands.
4
00:00:45,307 --> 00:00:47,167
They form armed militias.
5
00:00:47,176 --> 00:00:49,436
They put up
checkpoints and roadblocks.
6
00:00:49,444 --> 00:00:52,244
They kill or expel anyone
in the area who might threaten
7
00:00:52,246 --> 00:00:54,546
Their grip on power.
8
00:00:58,049 --> 00:01:00,219
Sebastian junger: In
that kind of environment,
9
00:01:00,218 --> 00:01:04,118
Radical ideologies are
almost guaranteed to take hold.
10
00:01:04,286 --> 00:01:06,416
Radicalism
depends on desperation.
11
00:01:06,422 --> 00:01:08,762
It depends on grievance.
12
00:01:08,757 --> 00:01:11,157
And it then provides its
own harsh answers to the
13
00:01:11,159 --> 00:01:13,329
Corruption and the
violence that afflict much
14
00:01:13,327 --> 00:01:15,287
Of the world.
15
00:01:20,598 --> 00:01:22,798
Sebastian junger: People will
always turn to radicalism once
16
00:01:22,801 --> 00:01:25,101
They have exhausted
every other option.
17
00:01:25,103 --> 00:01:27,343
Militant: Allahu akbar,
allahu akbar.
18
00:01:27,503 --> 00:01:29,203
Sebastian junger: They have to.
19
00:01:29,205 --> 00:01:31,765
Their very
survival is at stake.
20
00:03:27,452 --> 00:03:30,452
Robin yassin kassab: At first it
wasn't a revolutionary movement.
21
00:03:30,456 --> 00:03:32,756
They weren't calling for
the fall of the regime or
22
00:03:32,758 --> 00:03:34,858
The execution
of the president.
23
00:03:39,797 --> 00:03:41,427
Robin ysssin kassab:
It was very simple.
24
00:03:41,432 --> 00:03:44,972
"we want our
children to be released."
25
00:03:45,667 --> 00:03:47,867
They were
calling for dignity,
26
00:03:47,870 --> 00:03:51,440
Which is important
in a country where people
27
00:03:51,440 --> 00:03:54,310
Were used to being
humiliated and pushed around.
28
00:03:58,780 --> 00:04:01,450
Sarah chayes: It's really
remarkable the degree to which
29
00:04:01,449 --> 00:04:04,949
Corruption has played an
important role in driving a
30
00:04:04,952 --> 00:04:08,452
Variety of security crises
that had been breaking out in
31
00:04:08,455 --> 00:04:11,715
The last five to ten years.
32
00:04:12,490 --> 00:04:16,230
Every single one of the
arab spring revolutions was
33
00:04:16,228 --> 00:04:20,398
Explicitly an
anti-corruption revolution.
34
00:04:20,398 --> 00:04:23,698
These were countries run
by extremely sophisticated
35
00:04:23,701 --> 00:04:27,741
And successful
criminal organizations.
36
00:04:27,738 --> 00:04:31,868
The people who are paid to
uphold the law are the very
37
00:04:31,875 --> 00:04:34,335
Ones violating it.
38
00:04:34,344 --> 00:04:37,414
It's humiliating.
39
00:04:37,612 --> 00:04:40,852
Tunisia catches fire.
40
00:04:43,951 --> 00:04:46,591
Libya catches fire.
41
00:04:48,854 --> 00:04:52,024
Egypt catches fire.
42
00:04:53,657 --> 00:04:55,987
Bashar al-assad looks
at that and says,
43
00:04:55,993 --> 00:04:57,763
"I'll be damned."
44
00:04:57,761 --> 00:05:02,301
So he was willing
to respond to peaceful
45
00:05:02,298 --> 00:05:05,428
Demonstrations with
maximal use of force.
46
00:05:30,856 --> 00:05:33,556
Sarah chayes: The
bet that he made was
47
00:05:33,559 --> 00:05:36,429
"there's, at this
point, no compromising
48
00:05:36,428 --> 00:05:39,298
With this movement so
if I wanna stay in power,
49
00:05:39,297 --> 00:05:42,727
I have to absolutely
take it to the limit."
50
00:05:52,441 --> 00:05:54,611
Robin yassin kassab:
Very quickly we got into this
51
00:05:54,610 --> 00:05:58,850
Cycle of protests that
were met by gunfire which led
52
00:05:58,847 --> 00:06:01,007
To funerals the next day.
53
00:06:03,584 --> 00:06:05,884
The funerals
became bigger protests.
54
00:06:05,886 --> 00:06:09,086
The demands, then,
began to get bigger.
55
00:06:10,089 --> 00:06:14,089
Social justice and freedom,
an end to corruption.
56
00:06:15,593 --> 00:06:19,563
The regime responded again
with more and more violence.
57
00:06:24,901 --> 00:06:27,001
Zaidoun al-zoabi: I
participated in demonstrations
58
00:06:27,004 --> 00:06:29,544
And I was
detained twice afterwards.
59
00:06:29,539 --> 00:06:33,739
In that jail, I
witnessed at least the death
60
00:06:33,743 --> 00:06:38,483
Of 80 people who died
just because of the conditions.
61
00:06:39,580 --> 00:06:43,380
There was no oxygen,
there was no medicine.
62
00:06:44,917 --> 00:06:47,887
There was no space for you.
63
00:06:47,887 --> 00:06:50,947
You can't sleep,
there's no sleep.
64
00:06:54,625 --> 00:06:57,725
Wardens did not
have to beat us.
65
00:06:57,729 --> 00:07:00,599
We used to do it
to each other.
66
00:07:00,598 --> 00:07:03,498
You know, just like a couple
of rats put in a small, small,
67
00:07:03,500 --> 00:07:07,370
Small space, and we were,
we were just biting each other.
68
00:07:07,370 --> 00:07:10,540
It is a factory of terrorism.
69
00:07:10,539 --> 00:07:15,669
You would go inside as
an ordinary person and
70
00:07:15,676 --> 00:07:18,376
Leave as a terrorist.
71
00:07:35,660 --> 00:07:37,760
Linda ibrahim:
I was almost 16, 17
72
00:07:37,763 --> 00:07:41,733
When the
revolution started.
73
00:07:41,965 --> 00:07:43,725
I wanted to do something.
74
00:07:43,734 --> 00:07:45,904
I mean, I wanted to
participate in demonstrations.
75
00:07:45,902 --> 00:07:48,572
I wanted these
things to stop.
76
00:07:50,873 --> 00:07:55,543
Emely issa: That night,
I tried to prevent them.
77
00:07:56,810 --> 00:08:00,580
I told them you are young
and we don't know yet how will
78
00:08:00,581 --> 00:08:02,651
The regime
behave against you.
79
00:08:02,649 --> 00:08:05,679
I was afraid
they will shoot.
80
00:08:05,685 --> 00:08:07,475
They will shoot.
81
00:08:09,788 --> 00:08:12,818
I tried, but they
insisted so I told them
82
00:08:12,824 --> 00:08:15,524
"okay, I will
be in front of you.
83
00:08:15,526 --> 00:08:19,586
I will be the first, but you
have to follow my instructions."
84
00:08:34,573 --> 00:08:38,713
Emely issa: If god gave
me 1,000 years to live,
85
00:08:38,711 --> 00:08:41,881
I will never
forget that sound.
86
00:08:45,883 --> 00:08:48,183
Linda ibrahim: When
you see such sufferings,
87
00:08:48,186 --> 00:08:51,586
There is no childhood.
88
00:08:52,622 --> 00:08:55,662
So many of my
friends were killed.
89
00:08:56,025 --> 00:09:00,455
And this is the
hardest thing, you know.
90
00:09:00,463 --> 00:09:03,933
Before, we wanted many
things, we wanted to change,
91
00:09:03,933 --> 00:09:06,803
But now we just want
peace, you know, for,
92
00:09:06,802 --> 00:09:10,902
Stop killing
children, I mean.
93
00:09:11,905 --> 00:09:15,165
Stop killing
innocent people.
94
00:09:18,911 --> 00:09:21,651
Bbc news: Mr. President,
human rights watch, for example,
95
00:09:21,648 --> 00:09:25,178
30th of January this year,
has said that forces loyal to
96
00:09:25,184 --> 00:09:28,194
Bashar al-assad "have
deliberately and viciously
97
00:09:28,187 --> 00:09:30,947
Attacked civilians in
opposition-held areas using
98
00:09:30,956 --> 00:09:34,486
Bashar al-assad: No, there's
no indiscriminate weapons.
99
00:09:34,492 --> 00:09:37,592
When you, when you shoot,
you aim, and when you shoot,
100
00:09:37,595 --> 00:09:39,755
When you aim you aim
at terrorists in order
101
00:09:39,763 --> 00:09:42,763
To protect civilians.
102
00:09:42,766 --> 00:09:45,226
Again, if you're talking
about casualty, that's war.
103
00:09:45,235 --> 00:09:48,035
You cannot have
war without casualty.
104
00:09:52,773 --> 00:09:54,943
Man: Alahu akbar...
105
00:10:00,279 --> 00:10:03,209
Alahu abkar.
106
00:10:13,625 --> 00:10:19,655
♪
107
00:10:26,737 --> 00:10:29,707
Robin yassin kassab:
The regime wanted a war.
108
00:10:29,707 --> 00:10:31,637
This sounds strange.
109
00:10:31,642 --> 00:10:33,842
Why on earth would any
regime, or government,
110
00:10:33,844 --> 00:10:37,014
Or state provoke a
war against itself?
111
00:10:47,789 --> 00:10:50,119
Robin yassin kassab: The
regime knew very well that it
112
00:10:50,125 --> 00:10:52,825
Couldn't survive a
genuine reform process.
113
00:10:52,827 --> 00:10:54,957
If there was a
real reform process,
114
00:10:54,962 --> 00:10:56,802
One thing would
lead to another.
115
00:10:56,797 --> 00:10:59,297
There would, there would
be more and more transparency,
116
00:10:59,299 --> 00:11:02,729
More and more crimes would
be exposed, and in the end,
117
00:11:02,735 --> 00:11:06,095
At best, the president and
his top officers would have
118
00:11:06,105 --> 00:11:09,765
Ended up in prison
stripped of their stolen wealth.
119
00:11:13,844 --> 00:11:16,884
They thought that in a
military conflict, in a war,
120
00:11:16,881 --> 00:11:20,751
They could win because
they had done it before.
121
00:11:21,884 --> 00:11:27,264
Under hafez al-assad,
the father of bashar in 1982,
122
00:11:27,257 --> 00:11:30,157
They used artillery,
they used aerial bombardment,
123
00:11:30,159 --> 00:11:33,059
They probably used
chemical weapons,
124
00:11:33,061 --> 00:11:36,161
And they killed
somewhere between 10,000 and
125
00:11:36,164 --> 00:11:41,304
40,000 people, and the memory
of that terror kept the syrian
126
00:11:41,301 --> 00:11:44,971
People silent until 2011.
127
00:15:33,994 --> 00:15:36,234
Reporter: Pictures have
emerged today apparently
128
00:15:36,230 --> 00:15:38,400
Showing members of the
syrian army defecting to join
129
00:15:38,398 --> 00:15:40,398
Protesters in
the city of homs.
130
00:15:42,068 --> 00:15:44,638
Robin yassin kassab: You
have a growing number of local
131
00:15:44,637 --> 00:15:48,237
Volunteers and a growing
number of military defectors
132
00:15:48,240 --> 00:15:51,140
Who were joining together
to form into hundreds of
133
00:15:51,142 --> 00:15:54,682
Self-defense militias which
eventually all came together
134
00:15:54,678 --> 00:15:58,108
Under the umbrella titled,
"the free syrian army."
135
00:16:14,228 --> 00:16:17,058
Ahmed: These groups the
fsa had in aleppo at that
136
00:16:17,065 --> 00:16:19,625
Time were really helpful.
137
00:16:20,033 --> 00:16:22,973
Once in salaheddin, I
was demonstrating in there.
138
00:16:30,107 --> 00:16:33,537
People start just
falling on the ground that,
139
00:16:33,544 --> 00:16:35,614
From shooting
from the regime.
140
00:16:35,612 --> 00:16:38,482
They closed the road on us.
141
00:16:57,763 --> 00:17:00,003
Ahmed: And then, like out
of nothing, like angels,
142
00:16:59,999 --> 00:17:02,299
Somebody shoot the
thugs and they fell
143
00:17:02,301 --> 00:17:03,701
And they were
able to escape.
144
00:17:44,139 --> 00:17:45,169
Soldier: Takbir!
145
00:17:45,174 --> 00:17:46,344
Fsa soldiers: Allahu akbar!
146
00:17:46,341 --> 00:17:47,411
Soldier: Takbir!
147
00:17:47,408 --> 00:17:48,438
Fsa soldiers: Allahu akbar!
148
00:17:48,442 --> 00:17:49,442
Soldier: Takbir!
149
00:17:49,443 --> 00:17:53,243
Christoph reuter: The
propaganda of the regime was
150
00:17:53,246 --> 00:17:58,176
"we are not confronted
with a local revolution
151
00:17:58,183 --> 00:17:59,783
Of people who
demand rights.
152
00:17:59,784 --> 00:18:04,154
No, we are confronted with a
foreign-funded jihadi movement."
153
00:18:04,155 --> 00:18:05,615
Peter bouckaert:
Actually, a lot of the
154
00:18:05,623 --> 00:18:09,193
Jihadists were
released by the syrian regime
155
00:18:09,193 --> 00:18:12,663
In the very early
stage of the conflict.
156
00:18:20,302 --> 00:18:23,342
There was an amnesty which
allowed a lot of people with
157
00:18:23,339 --> 00:18:27,269
Very nasty records to be
freed from custody in syria.
158
00:18:27,808 --> 00:18:30,478
It was a strategy of survival.
159
00:18:30,478 --> 00:18:32,638
Robin yassin kassab: The
regime thought enough people
160
00:18:32,646 --> 00:18:35,306
In the outside world would
be scared away from the
161
00:18:35,315 --> 00:18:39,175
Revolution by the size of
these bearded working classmen
162
00:18:39,185 --> 00:18:41,545
With kalashnikovs
and they were right.
163
00:18:43,655 --> 00:18:47,215
And america, in 2011,
2012, they were saying,
164
00:18:47,226 --> 00:18:50,256
"we can't allow
weapons to go into syria.
165
00:18:50,262 --> 00:18:53,732
We can't send the democrats,
the nationalists of the free
166
00:18:53,732 --> 00:18:57,602
Army weapons, because some
of those weapons might get into
167
00:18:57,602 --> 00:19:00,642
The hands of
islamist extremists."
168
00:19:01,204 --> 00:19:05,114
Will mccants: In the absence
of a major international effort
169
00:19:05,108 --> 00:19:10,238
To build a army to
oppose the assad regime,
170
00:19:10,845 --> 00:19:14,205
A lot of private
individuals in the gulf began
171
00:19:14,216 --> 00:19:18,146
To fund armed groups on
the ground inside of syria.
172
00:19:18,886 --> 00:19:22,356
Ghaith abdul-ahad: Fsa was a
fantastic media labeled term,
173
00:19:22,357 --> 00:19:24,417
But there was no
central authority,
174
00:19:24,425 --> 00:19:27,385
No one could command anyone,
no one could have a one unity
175
00:19:27,394 --> 00:19:30,564
On a frontline.
176
00:19:30,728 --> 00:19:35,328
I would go to a village,
it has five, six militias.
177
00:19:35,333 --> 00:19:38,873
I would come few months later,
they have multiplied into 50,
178
00:19:38,869 --> 00:19:44,169
60 because forming a militia
became a way of getting money.
179
00:19:44,740 --> 00:19:47,140
The amount of money,
the amount of ammunition,
180
00:19:47,143 --> 00:19:49,713
The amount of weapons pumped
into that conflict totally
181
00:19:49,712 --> 00:19:51,782
Destroyed the revolution
and turned it into the
182
00:19:51,780 --> 00:19:54,310
Dynamics of civil war.
183
00:20:29,582 --> 00:20:32,682
Peter bouckaert: Early in
the war, isis wasn't present.
184
00:20:32,686 --> 00:20:35,286
There was a very
diverse landscape.
185
00:20:35,288 --> 00:20:37,548
So a lot of the
bosnians, and the tunisians,
186
00:20:37,556 --> 00:20:40,756
And the libyans, the more
extreme kind of elements of
187
00:20:40,759 --> 00:20:43,859
Those groups came
on there "el muhadrim."
188
00:20:44,761 --> 00:20:46,731
El muhadrim
means the immigrants,
189
00:20:46,730 --> 00:20:48,430
The foreign fighters.
190
00:20:48,431 --> 00:20:51,731
These groups fought alongside
each other around aleppo.
191
00:21:10,484 --> 00:21:12,954
Ahmed: Fighters came
3:00 in the morning,
192
00:21:12,954 --> 00:21:14,454
Sneaked inside aleppo.
193
00:21:14,455 --> 00:21:16,315
Nobody knew
they were coming.
194
00:21:16,323 --> 00:21:18,223
There were just,
like, in every corner,
195
00:21:18,224 --> 00:21:20,594
You could see one fighter.
196
00:21:23,862 --> 00:21:25,432
And then in the morning,
197
00:21:25,430 --> 00:21:28,400
Two tanks started
shooting this neighborhood.
198
00:21:29,499 --> 00:21:32,329
The fsa started shooting it.
199
00:21:32,336 --> 00:21:36,266
They had only this rpg and
it was not enough for that tank.
200
00:21:37,005 --> 00:21:40,265
The second day,
three tanks came.
201
00:21:43,777 --> 00:21:46,377
They destroyed the
first one and then they
202
00:21:46,380 --> 00:21:49,010
Destroyed the last one.
203
00:21:49,547 --> 00:21:51,377
So the one in the
middle, just, like,
204
00:21:51,383 --> 00:21:52,723
Surrendered himself.
205
00:21:52,717 --> 00:21:54,377
Man: Allahu akbar!
206
00:21:58,354 --> 00:21:59,794
Allahu akbar!
207
00:21:59,789 --> 00:22:02,419
Man: Allahu akbar!
208
00:22:03,824 --> 00:22:06,364
Ahmed: In the same day,
when all this happened,
209
00:22:06,360 --> 00:22:08,260
Most of the
people left aleppo and
210
00:22:08,261 --> 00:22:10,461
They went to
the countryside.
211
00:23:36,076 --> 00:23:38,076
Mahmoud al-basha: Hanano
military base was the biggest
212
00:23:38,078 --> 00:23:41,548
Military base for
assad regime in aleppo city.
213
00:23:41,548 --> 00:23:44,378
So when the fsa
took half of the city,
214
00:23:44,384 --> 00:23:47,454
They decided to
attack this military base.
215
00:24:15,610 --> 00:24:19,080
Ahmed: In this military base,
there were thousands of weapons,
216
00:24:19,647 --> 00:24:22,377
Warehouses
full of weapons.
217
00:24:23,784 --> 00:24:26,624
So many groups,
people I know, friends,
218
00:24:26,621 --> 00:24:29,021
Were going to hanano
military base and they were
219
00:24:29,023 --> 00:24:31,623
Just taking weapons.
220
00:24:57,516 --> 00:24:59,616
Man: Then the
bombardments started.
221
00:25:04,188 --> 00:25:06,958
Day and night, non-stop.
222
00:27:31,831 --> 00:27:33,701
Sebastian junger: One of
the problems with letting a
223
00:27:33,700 --> 00:27:35,870
Civil war go on
too long is that more
224
00:27:35,868 --> 00:27:38,768
And more people
get involved.
225
00:27:44,340 --> 00:27:46,640
It's a little bit like a
bar fight where all of a sudden,
226
00:27:46,643 --> 00:27:50,753
Everyone's jumped in and is
throwing chairs at each other.
227
00:27:53,014 --> 00:27:56,224
Syria became a civil war
in response to the violence
228
00:27:56,218 --> 00:27:59,088
Of the government.
229
00:27:59,087 --> 00:28:01,587
Eventually, iran got
involved through hezbollah
230
00:28:01,589 --> 00:28:04,859
To support
the assad regime.
231
00:28:04,858 --> 00:28:06,988
The kurds got involved.
232
00:28:06,993 --> 00:28:09,163
Turkey got involved.
233
00:28:09,161 --> 00:28:12,201
The arab gulf
states got involved.
234
00:28:13,964 --> 00:28:16,734
Eventually, all the world
powers and all the regional
235
00:28:16,734 --> 00:28:20,344
Powers had some investment
in the war in syria and in many
236
00:28:20,337 --> 00:28:22,867
Cases were actively
involved in the fighting.
237
00:28:26,040 --> 00:28:31,110
Once you get in a proxy fight,
so many people have such huge
238
00:28:31,112 --> 00:28:35,152
Interests in the outcome that
it's almost impossible to stop.
239
00:28:45,757 --> 00:28:48,957
President obama: Obviously,
this is a very tough issue.
240
00:28:48,961 --> 00:28:53,801
I have indicated repeatedly
that president al-assad has
241
00:28:53,799 --> 00:28:57,829
Lost legitimacy that
he needs to step down.
242
00:28:57,836 --> 00:29:00,966
So far, he hasn't gotten
the message and instead has
243
00:29:00,973 --> 00:29:04,373
Doubled down in
violence on his own people.
244
00:29:04,975 --> 00:29:11,105
I have, at this point, not
ordered military engagement in
245
00:29:12,181 --> 00:29:17,121
The situation, but we have
been very clear that a red line
246
00:29:17,120 --> 00:29:21,260
For us is we start
seeing a whole bunch of chemical
247
00:29:21,257 --> 00:29:24,157
Weapons moving
around or being utilized.
248
00:29:24,159 --> 00:29:25,889
That would
change my calculus.
249
00:29:25,894 --> 00:29:27,294
That would change.
250
00:29:27,295 --> 00:29:28,985
Robin yassin kassab:
When he said that,
251
00:29:28,996 --> 00:29:30,996
A lot of syrian
revolutionaries were very
252
00:29:30,998 --> 00:29:32,298
Upset because it
seems to be saying that,
253
00:29:32,299 --> 00:29:35,169
"look, you can
use scud missiles,
254
00:29:35,168 --> 00:29:38,238
You can shoot
them down in the street,
255
00:29:39,337 --> 00:29:41,867
You can use warplanes.
256
00:29:41,873 --> 00:29:44,873
Anything is fine
except chemical weapons."
257
00:30:09,199 --> 00:30:10,969
Robin yassin kassab:
Then, of course,
258
00:30:10,968 --> 00:30:13,268
He did use
chemical weapons.
259
00:30:50,105 --> 00:30:54,065
Robin yassin kassab: He killed
1450 people in five hours,
260
00:30:54,076 --> 00:30:56,106
In the
suburbs of damascus.
261
00:30:56,111 --> 00:30:59,081
Men, women, and
children, choking to death.
262
00:30:59,080 --> 00:31:01,010
Senator mccain: President
of the United States called
263
00:31:01,015 --> 00:31:03,915
Lindsey graham and me
over to the oval office.
264
00:31:03,917 --> 00:31:05,947
Looked us in
the eye and said,
265
00:31:05,952 --> 00:31:08,052
"they've crossed the
line, I'm gonna attack.
266
00:31:08,054 --> 00:31:10,424
I'm gonna degrade
bashar al-assad,
267
00:31:10,423 --> 00:31:12,263
I'm gonna upgrade the
capabilities of the free
268
00:31:12,258 --> 00:31:14,418
Syrian army and I'm
gonna reverse the momentum
269
00:31:14,426 --> 00:31:16,126
On the battlefield."
270
00:31:16,127 --> 00:31:17,927
We emphasized two.
271
00:31:17,928 --> 00:31:21,028
We walked out and there
was the usual cameras and said,
272
00:31:21,031 --> 00:31:22,961
"we're with the
president all the way."
273
00:32:08,176 --> 00:32:10,636
Senator mccain: I'm sitting
in my office and they're on cnn,
274
00:32:10,646 --> 00:32:12,906
The president
has decided not to.
275
00:32:12,914 --> 00:32:14,554
President obama: My
fellow americans.
276
00:32:14,548 --> 00:32:17,118
Tonight I wanna
talk to you about syria.
277
00:32:17,117 --> 00:32:19,017
Senator mccain: That
wasn't just disillusioning
278
00:32:19,018 --> 00:32:21,178
To me and
lindsey graham.
279
00:32:21,186 --> 00:32:24,646
The saudis had planes on
the runway when they found out
280
00:32:24,656 --> 00:32:28,556
President obama: Because we
cannot resolve someone else's
281
00:32:28,559 --> 00:32:30,659
Civil war through force.
282
00:32:30,661 --> 00:32:33,031
Robin yassin kassab: The
red line disappeared.
283
00:32:33,030 --> 00:32:36,230
There were thousands of
defections in that week.
284
00:32:36,233 --> 00:32:38,133
Thousands of soldiers and,
285
00:32:38,134 --> 00:32:41,444
And officers who'd
be loyal to the regime,
286
00:32:41,437 --> 00:32:44,037
Hadn't dared to jump,
they thought now it's going
287
00:32:44,039 --> 00:32:45,569
To change because the
americans are going to get
288
00:32:45,573 --> 00:32:47,973
Involved and they
defected in that week,
289
00:32:47,975 --> 00:32:49,035
But nothing happened.
290
00:32:58,216 --> 00:33:00,346
Robin yassin kassab: Quite
a few fighters in syria,
291
00:33:00,352 --> 00:33:02,352
Quite a few
revolutionary fighters said,
292
00:33:02,354 --> 00:33:05,254
"look, we're never going
to get help from the west.
293
00:33:05,256 --> 00:33:08,486
This guy can do
anything he wants.
294
00:33:09,091 --> 00:33:12,331
He can kill us all with
any weapons that he can find,
295
00:33:12,328 --> 00:33:16,058
In any way he chooses
and the west is never going
296
00:33:16,065 --> 00:33:18,595
To come to our aid."
297
00:33:43,522 --> 00:33:46,222
Zaidoun al-zoabi: Syria
is just a small triangle that
298
00:33:46,225 --> 00:33:49,225
Is hardly
visible on the world map.
299
00:33:49,228 --> 00:33:52,128
You will see that this
triangle is just like the
300
00:33:52,130 --> 00:33:56,330
Heart of the world and
if this crisis is not solved,
301
00:33:56,334 --> 00:34:00,274
Believe me, everyone
in the world will suffer.
302
00:34:03,472 --> 00:34:06,142
Will mccants: In 2011,
the syrian civil war
303
00:34:06,142 --> 00:34:08,012
Begins to take root.
304
00:34:08,010 --> 00:34:11,280
At the same time, the
american military finishes its
305
00:34:11,279 --> 00:34:14,049
Withdrawal from iraq.
306
00:34:14,048 --> 00:34:17,748
So, the islamic state has
more freedom of action in iraq
307
00:34:17,751 --> 00:34:21,121
And they begin to look
to syria as a place to give
308
00:34:21,121 --> 00:34:24,091
Themselves some
strategic depth.
309
00:34:24,090 --> 00:34:27,420
Robin yassin kassab: In syria,
it looks like isis is a creation
310
00:34:27,426 --> 00:34:29,286
Of bashar al-assad.
311
00:34:29,294 --> 00:34:33,234
It's a creation of his
scorched earth policy.
312
00:34:33,231 --> 00:34:36,301
Assad had in effect an
undeclared non-aggression
313
00:34:36,300 --> 00:34:38,130
Pact with isis.
314
00:34:38,135 --> 00:34:42,265
And even today, when isis
and the free army are fighting
315
00:34:42,272 --> 00:34:46,512
Each other, assad will
come and bomb the free army.
316
00:35:21,475 --> 00:35:23,635
General flynn: It's
a cancer that exists.
317
00:35:23,644 --> 00:35:28,084
The islamic
world knows it exists.
318
00:35:28,081 --> 00:35:31,721
The rest of the world
now sees it, feels it,
319
00:35:31,717 --> 00:35:33,817
Is bleeding because of it.
320
00:35:33,819 --> 00:35:36,249
Is terrorized
because of it.
321
00:35:36,254 --> 00:35:38,494
It's not
30,000 guys in syria.
322
00:35:38,489 --> 00:35:42,259
The islamic state
is a global problem.
323
00:35:42,259 --> 00:35:44,189
Christoph reuter: In its
beginning it's an iraqi
324
00:35:44,194 --> 00:35:48,234
Organization, but what they
had for syria was a blueprint,
325
00:35:48,231 --> 00:35:53,271
A very detailed
plan, step a, b, c, d,
326
00:35:53,268 --> 00:35:56,838
How to colonize
a foreign country.
327
00:35:56,838 --> 00:36:01,338
The first phase was training
camps where they form a hybrid
328
00:36:01,342 --> 00:36:05,342
Army from the incoming
people from tunisia, egypt,
329
00:36:05,346 --> 00:36:10,276
Daghestan, germany who didn't
even have one common language.
330
00:36:27,199 --> 00:36:30,529
Christoph reuter: It's an
absolutely loyal army with no
331
00:36:30,536 --> 00:36:33,236
Local affiliations.
332
00:36:33,503 --> 00:36:38,413
And then, locally to
know who is who in the
333
00:36:38,408 --> 00:36:42,678
Respective villages, they
started to open da'wah offices,
334
00:36:43,411 --> 00:36:46,151
Missionary offices.
335
00:36:46,148 --> 00:36:48,208
And they did so in
many, many places.
336
00:36:48,415 --> 00:36:51,145
In tal rifaat, in mar'a,
in al-dana, in mayadin,
337
00:36:51,451 --> 00:36:55,151
In deir ez-zor, in manbij.
338
00:36:55,387 --> 00:36:57,487
And so, slowly,
slowly, slowly,
339
00:36:57,490 --> 00:37:02,460
They knew exactly what is the
composition of this community.
340
00:37:02,461 --> 00:37:07,401
Whom we could buy,
whom we have to kill?
341
00:37:08,264 --> 00:37:11,274
First, they
did this secretly.
342
00:37:11,268 --> 00:37:14,798
Then, only, once they felt
powerful enough, they would,
343
00:37:14,804 --> 00:37:18,374
With lightning stroke,
take over a particular village.
344
00:40:40,603 --> 00:40:42,903
Sarah chayes: What they're
doing is saying this system is
345
00:40:42,906 --> 00:40:46,866
So rotten, it's so
thoroughly rotten that the
346
00:40:46,876 --> 00:40:50,136
Only way to improve
it is by fire and blood.
347
00:40:59,485 --> 00:41:02,645
Robin yassin kassab: The public
display of horrific violence
348
00:41:02,655 --> 00:41:06,485
Against individuals is something
which goes way back in history
349
00:41:06,492 --> 00:41:11,032
And every culture has done it
at some time or, or the other.
350
00:41:12,496 --> 00:41:16,896
In britain, they used to
hang, draw, and quarter.
351
00:41:17,834 --> 00:41:20,604
In china, they were
dragged into the street
352
00:41:20,604 --> 00:41:23,144
And beaten to death.
353
00:41:23,139 --> 00:41:26,769
In France, women who had
slept with german soldiers,
354
00:41:26,775 --> 00:41:29,635
Had their hair cut off and
were beaten in the streets,
355
00:41:29,644 --> 00:41:32,684
Stripped naked and paraded.
356
00:41:33,146 --> 00:41:36,516
In the United States, people
would take their wives and
357
00:41:36,517 --> 00:41:39,547
Their children along to the
lynching of the black man and
358
00:41:39,553 --> 00:41:41,593
Then they'd stand there
and smile and have their
359
00:41:41,588 --> 00:41:45,518
Photograph taken
next to his corpse.
360
00:41:45,525 --> 00:41:48,585
This display of public
violence was seen as a
361
00:41:48,594 --> 00:41:53,064
Necessary part of government
in order to send the message
362
00:41:53,064 --> 00:41:55,064
Out into society.
363
00:41:55,066 --> 00:41:57,596
"we can do anything
we like with you.
364
00:41:57,601 --> 00:42:01,141
Don't resist us because we
have total power to do the most
365
00:42:01,137 --> 00:42:04,807
Horrific things and there's
nothing you can do about it."
366
00:42:12,746 --> 00:42:14,546
Sebastian junger: All
societies are blind to
367
00:42:14,548 --> 00:42:16,748
Their own violence.
368
00:42:17,649 --> 00:42:20,619
From the use of
napalm in vietnam,
369
00:42:20,619 --> 00:42:22,749
To the bombing
of german cities,
370
00:42:22,754 --> 00:42:26,994
To the use of
nuclear weapons in japan,
371
00:42:26,991 --> 00:42:29,491
The United States has
killed far more civilians
372
00:42:29,493 --> 00:42:32,133
Than isis ever could.
373
00:42:32,128 --> 00:42:34,598
In world war ii alone,
allied forces are thought
374
00:42:34,597 --> 00:42:38,097
To have killed around
one million civilians.
375
00:42:39,999 --> 00:42:42,869
We're focused on the
wrongdoing of other groups.
376
00:42:42,869 --> 00:42:45,839
It's an adaptive trait
that's probably hardwired
377
00:42:45,838 --> 00:42:48,568
Into the brain because
it has survival value.
378
00:42:48,873 --> 00:42:51,713
President bush: Either
you're with us or you're
379
00:42:51,710 --> 00:42:54,710
With the terrorists.
380
00:42:55,045 --> 00:42:57,675
Sebastian junger: It allows us
to demonize the enemy who we
381
00:42:57,681 --> 00:43:00,951
May have to fight and
to avoid the moral conflict
382
00:43:00,950 --> 00:43:03,750
That comes with killing.
383
00:43:05,586 --> 00:43:08,116
When the united
states invaded iraq,
384
00:43:08,122 --> 00:43:11,962
They killed tens of
thousands of innocent people.
385
00:43:11,959 --> 00:43:16,529
You can't do that and imagine
there won't be consequences.
386
00:43:22,734 --> 00:43:24,744
Ghaith abdul-ahad:
By early 2003,
387
00:43:24,737 --> 00:43:27,797
The majority of iraqis
were happy to see the back
388
00:43:27,806 --> 00:43:30,536
Of saddam hussein.
389
00:43:31,108 --> 00:43:32,908
There is excitement,
there is hope,
390
00:43:32,910 --> 00:43:36,710
There is a
degree of anxiety.
391
00:43:36,714 --> 00:43:38,884
I remember two days
after the fall of baghdad,
392
00:43:38,882 --> 00:43:40,782
People were talking about,
393
00:43:40,783 --> 00:43:43,283
"why are the
americans aggressive?"
394
00:43:44,885 --> 00:43:46,885
"why are they pointing
their guns at the people
395
00:43:46,888 --> 00:43:49,918
In the street?"
396
00:43:50,223 --> 00:43:54,863
Saddam had committed
massacres within the society,
397
00:43:54,861 --> 00:43:58,831
Enormous levels of violence,
but you couldn't see it.
398
00:43:59,063 --> 00:44:01,103
Within the
american occupation,
399
00:44:01,099 --> 00:44:03,729
Violence is televised.
400
00:44:03,734 --> 00:44:06,204
Pictures of the americans
putting bags on the head of
401
00:44:06,203 --> 00:44:09,103
People and sitting
them behind barbed wire,
402
00:44:09,105 --> 00:44:12,635
Forcing people to be
naked, humiliating people.
403
00:44:19,712 --> 00:44:23,182
The loss of their
credibility was enormous,
404
00:44:23,183 --> 00:44:27,293
They could have paved the
iraqi roads in gold and still
405
00:44:27,287 --> 00:44:31,357
They can do the
humiliation of abu ghraib.
406
00:44:35,293 --> 00:44:38,963
There was a burning
american armored vehicle
407
00:44:38,964 --> 00:44:41,664
In haifa street in baghdad.
408
00:44:44,768 --> 00:44:49,768
As I'm walking I hear,
see two small helicopters.
409
00:44:51,907 --> 00:44:54,737
They fire a rocket into
the crowd that was celebrating
410
00:44:54,744 --> 00:44:57,714
Around the burning vehicle.
411
00:45:00,982 --> 00:45:07,122
I run towards the scene and
I see this circle with a young
412
00:45:08,154 --> 00:45:14,294
Boy stunned, missing leg, a
pool of blood and some liquids.
413
00:45:15,827 --> 00:45:18,857
Other people
scattered in the middle.
414
00:45:26,770 --> 00:45:28,800
They're not screaming,
they're not wailing,
415
00:45:28,806 --> 00:45:33,306
The injured people are
silent, the silence of shock.
416
00:45:37,946 --> 00:45:39,276
The helicopters come again,
417
00:45:39,281 --> 00:45:43,351
They fire another
rocket into the crowd.
418
00:45:43,351 --> 00:45:49,791
I'm trying to be as
thin as the curb, you know,
419
00:45:50,823 --> 00:45:55,193
And then you realize
there is people left in
420
00:45:55,195 --> 00:45:58,795
The middle of the road.
421
00:45:59,197 --> 00:46:02,827
There's this guy who was
injured in the first attack
422
00:46:02,834 --> 00:46:04,834
And then was hit again.
423
00:46:04,836 --> 00:46:10,166
He raises himself, he
looks around, he falls,
424
00:46:10,840 --> 00:46:14,010
Stretches his arm,
and still waits.
425
00:46:14,010 --> 00:46:16,480
No one can help him,
no one can do anything.
426
00:46:16,479 --> 00:46:18,049
The helicopters were gone,
427
00:46:18,047 --> 00:46:22,977
But everyone was
mortified with fear.
428
00:46:24,851 --> 00:46:28,151
Violence by the end
of 2003, early 2004,
429
00:46:28,155 --> 00:46:31,815
Is a normal fact of society.
430
00:46:32,024 --> 00:46:34,934
When you see body
parts in the street,
431
00:46:34,927 --> 00:46:38,227
When you see pieces of
flesh hanging from a tree,
432
00:46:38,230 --> 00:46:43,070
When you see children killed
because they were playing in
433
00:46:43,068 --> 00:46:47,068
The middle of the road,
I don't think there is
434
00:46:47,072 --> 00:46:51,972
Difference in horror between
seeing children just being hit
435
00:46:52,375 --> 00:46:55,405
By an american rocket
with their limbs scattered,
436
00:46:55,412 --> 00:46:58,482
With their, with their legs
oozing these fluids in the
437
00:46:58,481 --> 00:47:01,481
Middle of the street of
baghdad and seeing someone,
438
00:47:01,484 --> 00:47:05,024
You know, executed by isis.
439
00:47:05,020 --> 00:47:07,420
You don't equate
the two parties,
440
00:47:07,422 --> 00:47:09,862
But from the perspective
of someone who lost his leg
441
00:47:09,857 --> 00:47:13,557
There is no good violence
and bad violence.
442
00:47:17,896 --> 00:47:19,926
Peter bouckaert: It is
very important for people to
443
00:47:19,932 --> 00:47:24,972
Understand just how much what
is happening in syria today is
444
00:47:24,970 --> 00:47:28,910
Related to what happened
in iraq over a decade ago.
445
00:47:31,074 --> 00:47:36,114
Iraq under saddam hussein
was a sunni ruled country with
446
00:47:36,113 --> 00:47:40,013
Both the kurdish and the
shia majority that suffered very
447
00:47:40,016 --> 00:47:43,946
Significantly at the
hands of that sunni dominance.
448
00:47:46,086 --> 00:47:50,116
Whether you agree or not
with the military intervention,
449
00:47:50,124 --> 00:47:53,994
The main failures were
not the military intervention.
450
00:47:53,994 --> 00:47:56,564
It's the de-ba'athification
of the country,
451
00:47:56,563 --> 00:47:58,963
Which completely marginalized
the sunni population.
452
00:48:00,131 --> 00:48:02,971
Paul bremer: I am
today establishing an iraqi
453
00:48:02,968 --> 00:48:05,228
De-ba'athification council.
454
00:48:05,236 --> 00:48:07,396
General petraeus: I was an
occupation commander with all
455
00:48:07,404 --> 00:48:09,844
Of the responsibilities
that went along with that,
456
00:48:09,839 --> 00:48:12,969
Which essentially meant
running part of iraq,
457
00:48:14,075 --> 00:48:16,935
Firing the ba'ath party,
casting them on the ash heap
458
00:48:16,945 --> 00:48:21,075
Of history, created
tens of thousands of iraqis,
459
00:48:21,082 --> 00:48:23,582
Including the
most educated and,
460
00:48:23,584 --> 00:48:26,954
And influential in
various sunni-arab communities
461
00:48:26,954 --> 00:48:29,994
Especially, whose
incentive now was to oppose
462
00:48:29,990 --> 00:48:34,060
To new iraq rather
than to support it.
463
00:48:34,060 --> 00:48:35,590
Huge mistake.
464
00:48:35,594 --> 00:48:38,034
Dennis ross: It didn't make
sense to do this kind of
465
00:48:38,029 --> 00:48:41,099
Wide-scaled de-ba'athification
when within iraq itself,
466
00:48:41,098 --> 00:48:44,428
You wanna get a job, you
had to join the ba'ath party.
467
00:48:44,434 --> 00:48:47,034
So, you know, you, it's,
it's a little bit like the
468
00:48:47,036 --> 00:48:48,196
De-nazi-fication.
469
00:48:48,203 --> 00:48:51,503
Not everyone was, you know,
470
00:48:51,506 --> 00:48:56,266
Part of shaping a
repressive regime that
471
00:48:56,276 --> 00:48:59,006
Suppressed everybody else.
472
00:49:15,660 --> 00:49:17,890
Ghaith abdul-ahad: The
sunnis were oppressed by the
473
00:49:17,896 --> 00:49:20,196
Americans, by the
shi'a government of iraq.
474
00:49:20,198 --> 00:49:23,028
Isis comes and
promises liberation,
475
00:49:23,034 --> 00:49:27,544
Promises the end of that,
promises bringing back the
476
00:49:27,538 --> 00:49:31,368
Sunni's pride that they've
lost from 2003 and bringing
477
00:49:31,375 --> 00:49:34,275
Them back into control.
478
00:49:47,988 --> 00:49:49,918
Christoph reuter: If you
called something ba'athi
479
00:49:49,924 --> 00:49:52,164
Nobody would follow,
but once they discovered,
480
00:49:52,159 --> 00:49:56,389
"hey, if you, if we say that
we fight in the name of islam,
481
00:49:57,028 --> 00:50:01,098
In the name of jihad
against the foreign occupiers,
482
00:50:01,099 --> 00:50:04,429
We have something
that resonates."
483
00:50:24,220 --> 00:50:30,630
♪ . ♪
484
00:50:50,243 --> 00:50:52,613
Robin yassin kassab:
Their propaganda owes a lot to
485
00:50:52,613 --> 00:50:56,053
Hollywood action
films and to computer games
486
00:50:56,049 --> 00:50:58,179
That kids grow
up on these days.
487
00:51:00,385 --> 00:51:05,085
Isis knows that if they make
a high production video shot
488
00:51:05,090 --> 00:51:08,290
From various angles,
if they get a white guy,
489
00:51:08,293 --> 00:51:12,403
Put him in a guantanamo
style orange jumpsuit,
490
00:51:12,397 --> 00:51:16,367
They get a child or
an english speaker to cut his
491
00:51:16,367 --> 00:51:21,567
Head off with a knife,
they know that that night,
492
00:51:21,571 --> 00:51:25,171
Maybe the film will not
be shown on mainstream tv,
493
00:51:25,174 --> 00:51:28,544
But they know that the story
of the film will be headline
494
00:51:28,544 --> 00:51:31,014
News everywhere in the world.
495
00:51:31,013 --> 00:51:32,653
Lester holt: There
is breaking news tonight of a
496
00:51:32,647 --> 00:51:34,577
Chilling new
isis propaganda video.
497
00:51:34,582 --> 00:51:36,652
Reporter: The men believed
to be syrian were shackled and
498
00:51:36,650 --> 00:51:41,090
The video shows the egyptian
prisoners being marched onto a
499
00:51:41,087 --> 00:51:43,087
Beach by militants
dressed in black then the
500
00:51:43,089 --> 00:51:46,119
Prisoners are
beheaded brutally.
501
00:51:46,125 --> 00:51:48,755
Robin yassin kassab: Nobody
will be talking about assad on
502
00:51:48,760 --> 00:51:51,660
The same day he may have
incinerated a hundred people
503
00:51:51,662 --> 00:51:54,732
In barrel bombs, but we
don't see those people dying.
504
00:51:54,731 --> 00:51:57,301
We've, nobody has made
a high-production video of it
505
00:51:57,300 --> 00:52:00,200
And followed it up
with a threat to the west.
506
00:52:03,502 --> 00:52:07,142
It's very effective at
striking fear into the hearts
507
00:52:07,139 --> 00:52:11,209
Of their enemies because the
prospect of being captured by
508
00:52:11,209 --> 00:52:14,139
These people is too
horrific to contemplate.
509
00:53:24,881 --> 00:53:27,351
Daniel koehler: The way they
use social media sites like
510
00:53:27,351 --> 00:53:30,821
Facebook, twitter, youtube,
and messenger services is so
511
00:53:30,821 --> 00:53:33,121
Incredibly sophisticated.
512
00:53:33,123 --> 00:53:35,423
They have a type of
member that only engage in
513
00:53:35,425 --> 00:53:37,155
Online jihad.
514
00:53:37,160 --> 00:53:39,830
This is the place where
they spread the ideology,
515
00:53:39,829 --> 00:53:45,229
Peter bergen: You know, 6900
westerns have gone to join.
516
00:53:45,866 --> 00:53:48,226
So, you know, it's not
an insignificant number.
517
00:53:48,236 --> 00:53:51,696
Some of these kids
who are joining, you know,
518
00:53:51,706 --> 00:53:55,736
Fairly living pretty humdrum
lives in belgium, France,
519
00:53:55,908 --> 00:53:59,778
London, United States,
and they're joining isis and
520
00:53:59,779 --> 00:54:01,309
They're part of something
bigger than themselves and
521
00:54:01,313 --> 00:54:02,353
It's exciting.
522
00:55:10,947 --> 00:55:12,877
Will mccants: The men
who run the islamic state
523
00:55:12,883 --> 00:55:19,323
For all of its pretense to
be a religious organization, uh,
524
00:55:19,587 --> 00:55:21,447
And all its
quotation of scripture,
525
00:55:21,456 --> 00:55:24,786
When you look at how they
behave as an organization,
526
00:55:24,792 --> 00:55:28,532
Um, in many ways,
uh, it resembles, uh,
527
00:55:28,529 --> 00:55:32,499
The rough and tumble politics
of a criminal organization.
528
00:55:32,499 --> 00:55:34,869
I mean, they put
hits out on people,
529
00:55:34,868 --> 00:55:36,528
They extort people,
530
00:55:36,536 --> 00:55:39,396
Raising millions of dollars
a year by these activities.
531
00:55:56,320 --> 00:55:58,320
Christoph reuter: They went
into an area and the first
532
00:55:58,323 --> 00:56:01,993
Thing they would do is
the flour mill, the bakery,
533
00:56:01,993 --> 00:56:05,363
The concrete
factory has to be taken
534
00:56:05,363 --> 00:56:07,863
Without damage immediately.
535
00:56:08,564 --> 00:56:13,504
They thought about "what
do we need to maintain the
536
00:56:13,503 --> 00:56:16,873
Infrastructure of this area?"
537
00:56:36,558 --> 00:56:38,658
Christoph reuter:
For example, for the,
538
00:56:38,661 --> 00:56:40,591
From a policeman and
soldiers on the iraqi side,
539
00:56:40,596 --> 00:56:42,656
They told him,
"you're an infidel."
540
00:56:42,664 --> 00:56:44,964
Theoretically, you have
to die, but you can buy
541
00:56:44,966 --> 00:56:47,566
A "forgiveness card."
542
00:56:47,568 --> 00:56:49,868
The forgiveness card and the
money you have paid for shows
543
00:56:49,870 --> 00:56:53,400
That you are repenting and
every checkpoint will know if
544
00:56:53,406 --> 00:56:54,966
You show them the
forgiveness card that
545
00:56:54,974 --> 00:56:56,744
You have been forgiven.
546
00:56:59,543 --> 00:57:02,613
So everybody bought for
$400 a forgiveness card.
547
00:57:02,878 --> 00:57:05,608
A few months later,
the decree came out and,
548
00:57:05,615 --> 00:57:07,675
"oh, the forgiveness
cards have expired."
549
00:57:07,683 --> 00:57:10,053
You can buy a new one,
but it costs a bit more.
550
00:57:10,785 --> 00:57:14,445
So everything,
everything is costly.
551
00:57:14,688 --> 00:57:16,518
Robin yassin kassab: The
vast majority of the syrian
552
00:57:16,524 --> 00:57:20,894
People see, um, isis as
a foreign occupation force.
553
00:57:21,995 --> 00:57:26,595
In January
2014, the free army,
554
00:57:27,165 --> 00:57:30,725
The islamic front
militias, and al-qaeda,
555
00:57:30,736 --> 00:57:33,866
All of them
declared war on isis.
556
00:58:39,866 --> 00:58:42,596
Robin yassin kassab: They
kicked isis out of the whole
557
00:58:42,603 --> 00:58:47,173
Of western syria out of
latakia, idlib, out of aleppo,
558
00:58:48,773 --> 00:58:53,713
But then in iraq, because
the iraqi state had become so
559
00:58:53,712 --> 00:58:57,912
Dysfunctional because the
sunni arabs in iraq had become
560
00:58:57,916 --> 00:59:02,516
So alienated, they
welcomed these people back in,
561
00:59:02,519 --> 00:59:05,619
Or some of them did.
562
00:59:06,121 --> 00:59:09,761
Christoph reuter: They started
their blitzkrieg in iraq,
563
00:59:09,758 --> 00:59:15,588
Taking over mosul,
tikrit, shirgat, hawija.
564
00:59:15,596 --> 00:59:19,796
And they managed to overrun
the weapon depots of about
565
00:59:19,800 --> 00:59:22,730
Four iraqi army divisions.
566
00:59:22,935 --> 00:59:26,265
They were drowning in weapons,
they couldn't even take all
567
00:59:26,272 --> 00:59:29,012
The weapons with them
and burned some of them.
568
00:59:29,008 --> 00:59:31,738
But now, they were a
full-fledged army with
569
00:59:31,744 --> 00:59:33,814
Humvees, with
strikers, with tanks.
570
00:59:36,680 --> 00:59:38,680
Robin yassin kassab: They
captured all the money in the
571
00:59:38,683 --> 00:59:41,753
Banks in the north of
iraq and they used this money
572
00:59:41,752 --> 00:59:45,552
And the weapons to
surge back into syria.
573
00:59:45,555 --> 00:59:49,755
And they took large
parts of the country.
574
00:59:50,825 --> 00:59:54,825
Christoph reuter: It was
the peak of their power.
575
00:59:54,830 --> 00:59:59,030
And they used this moment
to declare the caliphate.
576
01:00:36,003 --> 01:00:38,173
Sebastian junger: Only a few
centuries after the birth of
577
01:00:38,172 --> 01:00:41,912
Christ, the muslim
world started expanding.
578
01:00:41,909 --> 01:00:45,339
They were at the
forefront of the arts,
579
01:00:45,345 --> 01:00:48,375
Of the sciences,
of astronomy.
580
01:00:49,881 --> 01:00:53,251
They really were the center
of knowledge in the world.
581
01:00:56,722 --> 01:00:59,822
There's a real yearning to
return to those days of glory,
582
01:00:59,825 --> 01:01:01,925
Understandably.
583
01:01:01,927 --> 01:01:03,927
They have been enduring
enormous oppression by
584
01:01:03,929 --> 01:01:07,799
Dictators that are often
propped up by the west and
585
01:01:07,799 --> 01:01:10,269
Completely dominated
by western technology
586
01:01:10,268 --> 01:01:13,098
And western culture.
587
01:01:13,104 --> 01:01:16,314
Part of what isis is doing
is trying to regain the former
588
01:01:16,307 --> 01:01:22,307
Glory of the caliphate and
of the worldwide dominance that
589
01:01:22,312 --> 01:01:25,752
Muslim society enjoyed
many, many centuries ago.
590
01:01:33,854 --> 01:01:36,664
Charlie rose: Reports from
iraq today say the isis army
591
01:01:36,657 --> 01:01:40,357
And other sunni muslim forces
captured another major target.
592
01:01:40,360 --> 01:01:43,230
It is the oil refinery
in baiji that produces
593
01:01:43,229 --> 01:01:44,289
One-third of iraq fuel.
594
01:01:44,296 --> 01:01:46,956
Christine romans: Isis
militants have seized a major
595
01:01:46,965 --> 01:01:51,825
Uh, the field produces
75,000 barrels of oil a day.
596
01:01:51,836 --> 01:01:53,266
It's the latest.
597
01:01:56,338 --> 01:01:58,838
Amos hochstein: From the
early days of the conflict,
598
01:01:58,840 --> 01:02:01,310
Gaining territory control
over areas that have energy
599
01:02:01,309 --> 01:02:05,039
Infrastructure were of
primary focus because they
600
01:02:05,046 --> 01:02:08,946
Give revenue, but they
also give semblance of a state
601
01:02:08,949 --> 01:02:11,919
To be able to provide
natural resources, electricity,
602
01:02:11,918 --> 01:02:13,978
Fuel, cooking oil.
603
01:02:13,986 --> 01:02:16,346
All those things is
what a government does.
604
01:02:19,256 --> 01:02:22,886
They had people that were able
to handle the expertise part.
605
01:02:22,893 --> 01:02:25,193
There are enough syrians in
the local areas that have been
606
01:02:25,195 --> 01:02:27,925
Working on these
oil fields for decades.
607
01:02:27,931 --> 01:02:30,031
Amos hochstein: And while
they controlled a relatively
608
01:02:30,033 --> 01:02:32,973
Smaller portion of the
overall syrian territory,
609
01:02:32,969 --> 01:02:35,099
They controlled an
overwhelming percentage
610
01:02:35,104 --> 01:02:38,414
Of the oil and gas
infrastructure and fields.
611
01:02:39,473 --> 01:02:41,273
George kiourktsoglou:
Based on our research,
612
01:02:41,275 --> 01:02:45,405
We came up with a number
of 45,000 barrels a day.
613
01:02:46,111 --> 01:02:49,811
You are looking at a ceiling
of roughly two million dollars
614
01:02:49,815 --> 01:02:52,815
A day income for daesh.
615
01:03:31,355 --> 01:03:33,315
George kiourktsoglou:
Daesh is a different beast.
616
01:03:33,324 --> 01:03:35,964
Daesh has a whole
portfolio of financial resources
617
01:03:35,959 --> 01:03:39,159
And of course, the
smuggling of crude oil is
618
01:03:39,162 --> 01:03:40,962
Just a part
of this portfolio.
619
01:03:40,963 --> 01:03:44,503
This portfolio also
include weapons trafficking, uh,
620
01:03:44,499 --> 01:03:47,529
Human trafficking, smuggling,
and of course, antiquities.
621
01:03:53,539 --> 01:03:56,769
Doctor al-azm: Looting of
antiquities in the region,
622
01:03:56,776 --> 01:03:58,506
Not just in syria,
in the region as a whole,
623
01:03:58,511 --> 01:04:00,981
Is a time-honored tradition.
624
01:04:01,546 --> 01:04:03,946
In times of hardship,
what do people do?
625
01:04:03,949 --> 01:04:06,479
They find alternative
sources of income.
626
01:04:08,184 --> 01:04:11,824
And so now, they just
start to loot at will.
627
01:04:25,530 --> 01:04:30,130
Doctor al-azm: The islamic
state institutionalized the
628
01:04:30,135 --> 01:04:31,965
Process of looting.
629
01:04:31,970 --> 01:04:34,340
They made it
part of the state.
630
01:04:53,356 --> 01:04:55,386
Doctor al-azm: As the looting
process became more and more
631
01:04:55,392 --> 01:04:58,962
Sophisticated, they would
issue permits to allow people
632
01:04:58,962 --> 01:05:01,832
To bring in heavy machinery.
633
01:05:01,996 --> 01:05:04,556
They established
auctions in which to sell
634
01:05:04,566 --> 01:05:07,196
These looted items.
635
01:05:07,400 --> 01:05:11,570
Colonel bogdanos: History be
damned, get me more material,
636
01:05:11,571 --> 01:05:16,471
More canay-formed
tablets, more cylinder seals.
637
01:05:16,475 --> 01:05:18,475
More anything.
638
01:05:18,477 --> 01:05:20,407
More is just more.
639
01:05:20,412 --> 01:05:22,852
More means more money.
640
01:05:22,847 --> 01:05:25,307
From syria alone,
isis was making
641
01:05:25,316 --> 01:05:27,976
Tens of millions of dollars.
642
01:05:30,953 --> 01:05:34,123
While tens of millions of
dollars may not mean much to
643
01:05:34,123 --> 01:05:36,023
You, how much
does an ied cost?
644
01:05:36,024 --> 01:05:39,094
How much is
a 7.62 mm bullets?
645
01:05:39,093 --> 01:05:41,033
How much do 50 of
those bullets go for?
646
01:05:41,028 --> 01:05:42,558
How much does an ak-47 cost?
647
01:05:42,562 --> 01:05:44,132
How much is an rpg?
648
01:05:44,130 --> 01:05:46,430
How many rpgs can you
buy with a million dollars?
649
01:05:46,432 --> 01:05:49,102
Doctor al-azm: Isis
sees cultural heritage as
650
01:05:49,101 --> 01:05:51,271
An exploitable resource.
651
01:05:51,269 --> 01:05:53,999
And so for them, they
will loot what they can sell,
652
01:05:54,005 --> 01:05:56,935
But one of the primary
uses has been propaganda.
653
01:06:08,150 --> 01:06:10,890
Colonel bogdanos: Once you
destroy the cultural heritage
654
01:06:10,887 --> 01:06:13,947
Of a people, you are
in effect attacking and
655
01:06:13,956 --> 01:06:17,116
Destroying their
cultural identity.
656
01:06:17,125 --> 01:06:19,255
Once you destroy
their cultural identity,
657
01:06:19,260 --> 01:06:21,590
It's but a short step
to destroy and eradicate
658
01:06:21,595 --> 01:06:24,395
The people themselves.
659
01:06:47,285 --> 01:06:50,445
♪
660
01:07:36,232 --> 01:07:39,072
Reporter: Tens of thousands
of people from the yazidi
661
01:07:39,069 --> 01:07:42,199
Religious minority fled to
this mountain ridge to escape
662
01:07:42,205 --> 01:07:45,065
Isis militants who
recently captured the
663
01:07:45,074 --> 01:07:46,614
Nearby town of sinjar.
664
01:08:11,464 --> 01:08:15,204
Christoph reuter: The kurdish
regional government made it a
665
01:08:15,202 --> 01:08:20,242
Huge international outcry
that we have tens of thousands
666
01:08:20,240 --> 01:08:25,140
Of yazidis thirsty and starved
to death on this mountain.
667
01:08:26,277 --> 01:08:30,107
It was like you are touched,
the biblical maze of masada.
668
01:08:30,547 --> 01:08:33,117
People on the
mountain, 50 degrees,
669
01:08:33,117 --> 01:08:36,747
In hot summer without water,
and all the jihadists sitting
670
01:08:36,753 --> 01:08:41,023
Around the mountains
waiting to kill everybody.
671
01:08:41,023 --> 01:08:45,193
You had old conflicts, old
hatreds between the yazidis
672
01:08:45,193 --> 01:08:50,663
From sinjar and the sunni's
ultra-loyalists to saddam.
673
01:08:50,665 --> 01:08:54,425
They were keen to make clear
that this area will never be
674
01:08:54,435 --> 01:08:57,165
Inhabited by yazidis again.
675
01:08:58,137 --> 01:09:01,807
♪ . ♪
676
01:09:07,179 --> 01:09:11,449
Sebastian junger: One of their
slogans is "we the jihadists,
677
01:09:11,450 --> 01:09:15,350
We love death more than
you in the west love life."
678
01:09:16,419 --> 01:09:21,219
A lot of people think that that
means that they're psychotic.
679
01:09:21,224 --> 01:09:24,064
Only crazy people
would act like that.
680
01:09:24,060 --> 01:09:27,630
But there is no way to
fight people who frame their
681
01:09:27,631 --> 01:09:32,331
Struggle in those terms
without also taking into
682
01:09:32,335 --> 01:09:35,595
Account some kind of
social and historical justice.
683
01:13:13,487 --> 01:13:19,587
♪
684
01:13:55,528 --> 01:14:01,028
♪
685
01:14:08,874 --> 01:14:10,914
President obama: Our
objective is clear.
686
01:14:10,910 --> 01:14:14,680
We will degrade and ultimately
destroy isil through a
687
01:14:14,680 --> 01:14:19,520
Comprehensive and sustained
counterterrorism strategy.
688
01:14:40,836 --> 01:14:43,696
Christoph reuter: Isis had
not anticipated this reaction
689
01:14:43,706 --> 01:14:47,606
Because when two months
prior, they had overrun mosul.
690
01:14:47,609 --> 01:14:49,639
Obama's reaction was basically,
691
01:14:49,644 --> 01:14:52,114
"oh, we should do
something about it."
692
01:14:52,113 --> 01:14:54,653
But nothing happened.
693
01:14:54,648 --> 01:14:58,778
Once the americans started
to attack the islamic state,
694
01:14:58,785 --> 01:15:02,215
Isis needed to react somehow.
695
01:15:02,221 --> 01:15:04,691
So it was a
message for the u.S.
696
01:15:04,922 --> 01:15:06,662
Isis militant: We are
willing to lay down our blood
697
01:15:06,658 --> 01:15:07,958
On this soil.
698
01:15:07,959 --> 01:15:09,959
So try, try to come.
699
01:15:09,961 --> 01:15:13,631
I will kill every
single soldier, bismillah.
700
01:15:13,896 --> 01:15:15,896
We will chop off the
heads of the americans,
701
01:15:15,899 --> 01:15:18,629
Chop off the heads of the
french, chop off the heads of.
702
01:15:20,736 --> 01:15:22,736
Sebastian junger: Every war
is a form of dialogue between
703
01:15:22,739 --> 01:15:24,809
The warring parties
and all actions are a
704
01:15:24,807 --> 01:15:27,707
Form of communication.
705
01:15:32,646 --> 01:15:36,746
When president obama
decided to bomb isis forces,
706
01:15:36,751 --> 01:15:39,651
He was communicating to isis
that we were not gonna stand
707
01:15:39,653 --> 01:15:42,823
By and let anything happen.
708
01:15:43,621 --> 01:15:46,691
And isis needed to be
communicating to the west that
709
01:15:46,691 --> 01:15:48,821
They could not be messed with.
710
01:15:48,826 --> 01:15:50,926
Isis member: Today,
your military air force is
711
01:15:50,928 --> 01:15:52,788
Attacking us daily in iraq.
712
01:15:52,796 --> 01:15:56,626
So any attempts by you, obama,
to deny the muslims their
713
01:15:56,633 --> 01:15:59,803
Rights of living in safety
under the islamic caliphate
714
01:15:59,802 --> 01:16:02,902
Will result in the
bloodshed of your people.
715
01:16:06,273 --> 01:16:09,813
Sebastian junger: As a result,
isis cut off james foley's head.
716
01:16:10,776 --> 01:16:13,836
That didn't stop the bombing,
so they kept cutting off heads
717
01:16:13,846 --> 01:16:15,676
And we kept bombing.
718
01:16:15,946 --> 01:16:18,646
Isis member: I'm back,
obama, because of your arrogant
719
01:16:18,649 --> 01:16:20,719
Foreign policy
towards the islamic state.
720
01:16:20,717 --> 01:16:24,547
You, obama, have yet
again, for your actions,
721
01:16:24,554 --> 01:16:27,694
Killed yet another
american citizen.
722
01:16:27,955 --> 01:16:29,855
David cameron: We will
stick to the very clear
723
01:16:29,857 --> 01:16:31,557
Strategy that we have.
724
01:16:31,558 --> 01:16:33,788
To help make sure the
kurds get the arms they need
725
01:16:33,793 --> 01:16:37,763
To fight off, uh, these
brutal, uh, extremist militants.
726
01:16:38,629 --> 01:16:41,559
Isis member: This british man
has to pay the price for your
727
01:16:41,566 --> 01:16:43,966
Promise, cameron, to
arm the peshmerga against
728
01:16:43,968 --> 01:16:45,668
The islamic state.
729
01:16:45,669 --> 01:16:48,639
Your evil alliance with
america will only accelerate
730
01:16:48,638 --> 01:16:50,738
Your destruction.
731
01:19:09,106 --> 01:19:11,336
Peter bergen: The long-term
prognosis of isis is not great
732
01:19:11,342 --> 01:19:13,182
Because they made
a world of enemies.
733
01:19:13,177 --> 01:19:16,037
That is not a
winning strategy.
734
01:19:16,046 --> 01:19:19,246
Napoleon was the greatest
general of the modern era but
735
01:19:19,249 --> 01:19:23,719
So everybody, then,
coalesced to get rid of him.
736
01:19:23,720 --> 01:19:25,090
Isis is making
the same mistake.
737
01:19:35,096 --> 01:19:37,096
Peter bergen: They're already
suffering the consequences.
738
01:19:37,099 --> 01:19:39,899
They keep losing territory.
739
01:19:40,300 --> 01:19:43,200
Basically the whole world
is ganged up against them.
740
01:20:22,039 --> 01:20:24,439
Dennis ross: Putin didn't
go into syria to fight isis.
741
01:20:24,442 --> 01:20:26,442
If that was the case,
he would've fought isis.
742
01:20:26,444 --> 01:20:29,014
80% of the bombing
was on non-isis targets.
743
01:20:38,519 --> 01:20:41,349
Senator mccain: I see what
looks like the future now and
744
01:20:41,356 --> 01:20:45,186
That is a very influential
russia with a bashar assad
745
01:20:45,193 --> 01:20:48,963
That is able to at least
control the areas of syria
746
01:20:48,963 --> 01:20:51,803
That are of most
importance to him.
747
01:20:51,799 --> 01:20:54,199
Robin yassin kassab: The assad
regime and lately russia, too,
748
01:20:54,201 --> 01:20:57,001
Have been bombing not just
militia formations on the
749
01:20:57,003 --> 01:21:01,813
Ground, they've been bombing
bakeries, schools, hospitals.
750
01:21:16,921 --> 01:21:19,861
Because the people can't
defend themselves from this
751
01:21:19,858 --> 01:21:23,928
Aerial bombardment,
it's absolute hell on earth.
752
01:21:24,928 --> 01:21:28,558
Assad wants those in the
middle to be eliminated so the
753
01:21:28,565 --> 01:21:31,465
Choice is either him or isis.
754
01:24:26,602 --> 01:24:28,202
Peter bergen: The airstrikes
are killing about a thousand
755
01:24:28,204 --> 01:24:33,474
Isis members every month,
and ratcheting down the oil,
756
01:24:33,475 --> 01:24:35,635
And getting rid of
some of their money.
757
01:24:35,643 --> 01:24:37,683
That is really
going to impact them.
758
01:24:37,678 --> 01:24:39,678
If you control several
million people and you're
759
01:24:39,680 --> 01:24:42,010
Taxing them for pretty
much everything they do.
760
01:24:42,015 --> 01:24:43,305
That's all the money.
761
01:24:43,316 --> 01:24:45,316
So every time
they lose a big city which is
762
01:24:45,318 --> 01:24:49,188
That's several hundred
thousand people they can't tax.
763
01:29:02,502 --> 01:29:05,672
Alex jordanov: This new form
of terrorism was introduced by
764
01:29:05,672 --> 01:29:09,542
Al-qaeda's ideologue
abu musab al-suri.
765
01:29:09,974 --> 01:29:14,744
In his writings where he calls
for a form of low cost terror,
766
01:29:14,746 --> 01:29:18,306
Many terror acts all over the
place conducted by the people
767
01:29:18,316 --> 01:29:19,376
That actually live there.
768
01:29:30,893 --> 01:29:32,533
Reporter: San
bernardino, california
769
01:29:32,528 --> 01:29:33,928
Mass casualty situation.
770
01:29:33,929 --> 01:29:35,599
A terror attack in
the french city of nice.
771
01:29:35,597 --> 01:29:36,797
At least 80 people.
772
01:29:36,798 --> 01:29:39,368
The 17-year-old
used an axe and knife
773
01:29:39,367 --> 01:29:44,437
A lone gunman called 911
to pledge allegiance to isis.
774
01:29:46,038 --> 01:29:47,738
Woman: Oh my god.
775
01:30:11,762 --> 01:30:13,562
General flynn: This
is what terrorists do.
776
01:30:13,564 --> 01:30:15,904
They instill fear
in societies.
777
01:30:15,899 --> 01:30:18,499
If you instill
fear in a society,
778
01:30:18,501 --> 01:30:19,571
It comes at a big cost.
779
01:30:19,568 --> 01:30:25,708
With some of the, you know,
some of the comments that are
780
01:30:25,707 --> 01:30:28,567
Being made about various,
781
01:30:28,576 --> 01:30:31,506
Parts of our society
and what to do about them.
782
01:30:31,512 --> 01:30:34,582
You know, the whole
issue of immigration is a big,
783
01:30:34,581 --> 01:30:37,451
Big deal, uh, and that's,
784
01:30:37,450 --> 01:30:40,650
That's playing out
terribly in europe.
785
01:31:53,690 --> 01:31:55,820
Teun voeten: The
summer of 2015,
786
01:31:55,826 --> 01:31:57,986
Suddenly hundreds of
thousands of people came,
787
01:31:57,994 --> 01:32:01,004
Syrian refugees from turkey.
788
01:32:00,997 --> 01:32:04,567
There are a lot of extremely
decent, sophisticated, uh,
789
01:32:04,567 --> 01:32:07,167
People among the immigrants.
790
01:32:07,169 --> 01:32:09,539
But you have also
small time criminals
791
01:32:09,538 --> 01:32:11,198
And infiltrators from isis.
792
01:32:13,540 --> 01:32:15,940
A lot of people feel
overwhelmed by what they
793
01:32:15,943 --> 01:32:18,443
Perceive as an invasion
of muslims threatening
794
01:32:18,445 --> 01:32:21,205
Our way of life.
795
01:32:21,846 --> 01:32:24,446
The muslim people
in europe it's only around
796
01:32:24,449 --> 01:32:28,449
5% but in certain cities,
for instance in brussels,
797
01:32:28,453 --> 01:32:29,693
One generation from now,
798
01:32:29,687 --> 01:32:33,457
The muslim community
will be the majority.
799
01:32:35,724 --> 01:32:38,864
This has caused an
enormous political backlash
800
01:32:38,861 --> 01:32:42,061
And resurgence of
right-wing movements.
801
01:32:44,198 --> 01:32:46,598
General flynn: The resources
that are gonna be required to
802
01:32:46,601 --> 01:32:49,501
Correct some of these
problems that we have, refugees,
803
01:32:49,503 --> 01:32:51,573
Displaced people
around the world, is,
804
01:32:51,571 --> 01:32:53,771
Just the numbers
are staggering.
805
01:32:53,773 --> 01:32:57,043
We have to get back in there,
stabilize that area to the
806
01:32:57,042 --> 01:32:59,782
Point where you can then
tell all these people who would
807
01:32:59,778 --> 01:33:01,738
Rather live in
their own homes,
808
01:33:01,746 --> 01:33:03,946
You can tell them and
they'll all come back.
809
01:33:03,948 --> 01:33:08,018
Otherwise, the likelihood
of a far greater conflict grows
810
01:33:08,018 --> 01:33:10,688
Higher and higher every day.
811
01:35:22,184 --> 01:35:24,194
Sebastian junger: Any
reasonable person would flee
812
01:35:24,187 --> 01:35:27,917
The kind of fighting
that we've seen in syria.
813
01:35:29,823 --> 01:35:31,963
They'd happily
risk their lives to be
814
01:35:31,960 --> 01:35:33,760
Smuggled across the border.
815
01:35:33,761 --> 01:35:35,191
They'd collect by
the millions in neighboring
816
01:35:35,195 --> 01:35:40,725
Countries even living
in squalid refugee camps.
817
01:35:40,733 --> 01:35:42,903
Eventually, they'd make
their way to the west to look
818
01:35:42,901 --> 01:35:45,501
For a better life
for their children.
819
01:35:46,169 --> 01:35:49,239
People say "look,
it's not our problem."
820
01:35:49,239 --> 01:35:51,939
Okay, it's not your
problem but that doesn't mean
821
01:35:51,941 --> 01:35:54,941
You won't be affected by it.
822
01:36:01,983 --> 01:36:03,853
You can say that you
don't actually care about human
823
01:36:03,852 --> 01:36:07,322
Suffering but the truth is
that all violence and misery
824
01:36:07,322 --> 01:36:10,422
Eventually affect
the entire world.
825
01:36:12,325 --> 01:36:15,385
In that sense, there is no
escaping the fact that we are
826
01:36:15,395 --> 01:36:18,925
All part of the human race.
827
01:36:19,196 --> 01:36:21,856
There is no escaping the
fact that borders become
828
01:36:21,866 --> 01:36:24,896
Irrelevant once people
start dying and societies
829
01:36:24,902 --> 01:36:29,942
Begin to collapse.
830
01:38:15,142 --> 01:38:20,382
♪ ♪
65236
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.