Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:05,000 --> 00:00:10,000
- Original file by zfeet -
- Resynced by Ornlu Wolfjarl -
2
00:00:23,400 --> 00:00:26,066
TIM O'BRIEN: They shared
the weight of memory.
3
00:00:27,566 --> 00:00:31,431
They took up what others
could no longer bear.
4
00:00:33,732 --> 00:00:39,030
Often, they carried each
other, the wounded or weak.
5
00:00:39,031 --> 00:00:40,696
They carried infections.
6
00:00:40,697 --> 00:00:42,897
They carried chess sets, basketballs,
7
00:00:42,898 --> 00:00:45,130
Vietnamese-English dictionaries,
8
00:00:45,131 --> 00:00:48,796
insignia of rank, Bronze
Stars, and Purple Hearts,
9
00:00:48,797 --> 00:00:52,928
plastic cards imprinted
with the Code of Conduct.
10
00:00:52,929 --> 00:00:55,660
(thunder rumbles)
11
00:00:55,661 --> 00:00:59,462
They carried diseases, among
them malaria and dysentery.
12
00:01:03,296 --> 00:01:07,926
They carried lice and ringworm
and leeches and paddy algae
13
00:01:07,927 --> 00:01:10,228
and various rots and molds.
14
00:01:12,094 --> 00:01:13,394
(rain pouring)
15
00:01:14,560 --> 00:01:18,226
They carried the land itself...
16
00:01:18,227 --> 00:01:20,060
Vietnam.
17
00:01:34,625 --> 00:01:38,124
("My Country 'Tis of Thee" playing)
18
00:01:38,125 --> 00:01:41,024
(mouths): Thank you.
19
00:01:44,457 --> 00:01:47,490
(indistinct chatter)
20
00:01:47,491 --> 00:01:50,956
(applause)
21
00:01:56,523 --> 00:02:02,121
I can tell you, as I look back
over those months and years,
22
00:02:02,122 --> 00:02:05,521
that we have met with the
wives and the mothers
23
00:02:05,522 --> 00:02:10,053
of those of you who were prisoners of war,
24
00:02:10,054 --> 00:02:15,886
they were and are the bravest,
most magnificent women
25
00:02:15,887 --> 00:02:17,352
I have ever met in my life.
26
00:02:18,953 --> 00:02:21,185
And now, if they will give me
my official toasting glass,
27
00:02:21,186 --> 00:02:22,519
I will propose the toast.
28
00:02:24,018 --> 00:02:25,118
Tonight...
29
00:02:25,119 --> 00:02:28,451
NARRATOR: On May 24, 1973,
30
00:02:28,452 --> 00:02:30,350
President Nixon invited
31
00:02:30,351 --> 00:02:33,649
all the returned prisoners
of war and their families
32
00:02:33,650 --> 00:02:35,517
to Washington.
33
00:02:35,518 --> 00:02:38,584
Among them was Everett Alvarez,
34
00:02:38,585 --> 00:02:43,016
the first pilot shot
down over North Vietnam.
35
00:02:43,017 --> 00:02:45,182
EVERETT ALVAREZ: Sometimes,
I feel too much attention
36
00:02:45,183 --> 00:02:48,249
was being paid to us, the P.O.W.s.
37
00:02:48,250 --> 00:02:51,048
And what about the poor guys
that fought the war, those kids?
38
00:02:51,049 --> 00:02:56,282
You know, that came home,
um, you know, amputees...
39
00:02:56,283 --> 00:03:02,313
Uh, wounded with the injuries of war.
40
00:03:02,314 --> 00:03:04,481
What about them?
41
00:03:04,482 --> 00:03:07,113
We had our own challenges,
42
00:03:07,114 --> 00:03:09,679
and the key was to, to face these
43
00:03:09,680 --> 00:03:12,513
and yet maintain our, our honor.
44
00:03:12,514 --> 00:03:14,314
That's what it was.
45
00:03:16,214 --> 00:03:18,844
NARRATOR: Dr. Hal Kushner,
46
00:03:18,845 --> 00:03:21,678
who had been a prisoner
for more than five years,
47
00:03:21,679 --> 00:03:24,212
was unable to attend.
48
00:03:24,213 --> 00:03:28,343
He was reunited with his
family at Valley Forge.
49
00:03:28,344 --> 00:03:32,444
HAL KUSHNER: We flew to
Valley Forge, Pennsylvania.
50
00:03:32,445 --> 00:03:36,444
And I came off the helicopter
and I saw my wife...
51
00:03:39,444 --> 00:03:42,243
...and my daughter,
52
00:03:42,244 --> 00:03:44,041
who I hadn't seen since she was 2 1/2
53
00:03:44,042 --> 00:03:46,010
And she was born in 1963.
54
00:03:52,477 --> 00:03:57,275
So she was ten years old.
55
00:03:57,276 --> 00:03:59,075
And my son, who I had never seen,
56
00:03:59,076 --> 00:04:01,374
a week before his fifth birthday.
57
00:04:01,375 --> 00:04:05,041
And he had on a little
tie and a little coat.
58
00:04:08,575 --> 00:04:10,373
And my mom and dad.
59
00:04:10,374 --> 00:04:15,240
And my mother was just
overcome with emotion.
60
00:04:18,474 --> 00:04:22,238
And I just...
61
00:04:22,239 --> 00:04:25,972
It was just an incomprehensible moment.
62
00:04:25,973 --> 00:04:28,305
And we hugged everybody.
63
00:04:28,306 --> 00:04:31,104
And my little boy had a
flag, American flag.
64
00:04:34,205 --> 00:04:37,570
NARRATOR: Like many P.O.W. marriages,
65
00:04:37,571 --> 00:04:41,737
Hal Kushner's would not survive.
66
00:05:01,868 --> 00:05:05,899
On March 29, 1973,
67
00:05:05,900 --> 00:05:10,000
the last American troops
left South Vietnam.
68
00:05:10,001 --> 00:05:13,732
Fewer than 200 Marines would remain,
69
00:05:13,733 --> 00:05:16,432
assigned to guard consular offices
70
00:05:16,433 --> 00:05:18,098
and the American Embassy
71
00:05:18,099 --> 00:05:21,398
and other installations in Saigon.
72
00:05:21,399 --> 00:05:27,231
Thousands of other Americans,
including C.I.A. agents,
73
00:05:27,232 --> 00:05:29,364
diplomats, and contractors,
74
00:05:29,365 --> 00:05:31,265
stayed behind, as well.
75
00:05:33,731 --> 00:05:35,730
Over the next two years,
76
00:05:35,731 --> 00:05:38,129
the forces of North and South Vietnam
77
00:05:38,130 --> 00:05:42,263
would continue to savage one another.
78
00:05:42,264 --> 00:05:46,763
And the Vietnamese people
would find themselves
79
00:05:46,764 --> 00:05:48,862
back where they were at the beginning,
80
00:05:48,863 --> 00:05:53,495
engulfed in an apparently endless civil war
81
00:05:53,496 --> 00:05:58,094
and struggling over what kind
of future they would have.
82
00:06:01,794 --> 00:06:06,360
For the United States, combat did end,
83
00:06:06,361 --> 00:06:11,592
but controversy over the war did not.
84
00:06:11,593 --> 00:06:14,392
TIM O'BRIEN: The best you
could say about Vietnam
85
00:06:14,393 --> 00:06:17,891
was that certain blood was being shed
86
00:06:17,892 --> 00:06:20,292
for uncertain reasons.
87
00:06:20,293 --> 00:06:22,192
The blood was for sure...
88
00:06:22,193 --> 00:06:23,824
the bodies, the widows, the orphans...
89
00:06:23,825 --> 00:06:25,323
they were certain.
90
00:06:25,324 --> 00:06:30,090
Nobody disputed it, the
dead people were dead.
91
00:06:30,091 --> 00:06:34,757
But the rectitude of the
war was in great dispute.
92
00:06:34,758 --> 00:06:36,389
Smart people in pinstripes
93
00:06:36,390 --> 00:06:38,323
couldn't make their minds up about the war.
94
00:06:47,057 --> 00:06:49,622
And I remember asking myself...
95
00:06:54,656 --> 00:06:57,988
"Was it worth it?"
96
00:06:57,989 --> 00:07:03,353
Maybe it was all a big
mistake, and, you know,
97
00:07:03,354 --> 00:07:06,087
what, what was it all about?
98
00:07:06,088 --> 00:07:09,119
We answered the call,
99
00:07:09,120 --> 00:07:12,086
me and probably 2 1/2 million
other young Americans
100
00:07:12,087 --> 00:07:14,352
who went over there.
101
00:07:14,353 --> 00:07:20,217
It was a cause worth the effort.
102
00:07:20,218 --> 00:07:23,817
And sometimes, things just don't turn out
103
00:07:23,818 --> 00:07:26,184
and the guys in the white hats don't win.
104
00:07:26,185 --> 00:07:28,651
But that doesn't make it, uh,
105
00:07:28,652 --> 00:07:32,051
or doesn't basically take away
106
00:07:32,052 --> 00:07:34,952
from the rectitude of the cause.
107
00:07:59,281 --> 00:08:01,914
Subcommittee will come to order.
108
00:08:01,915 --> 00:08:04,212
NARRATOR: Night after night
during the spring, summer,
109
00:08:04,213 --> 00:08:06,746
and fall of 1973,
110
00:08:06,747 --> 00:08:09,647
Americans watched the Nixon administration
111
00:08:09,648 --> 00:08:12,046
slowly come apart.
112
00:08:12,047 --> 00:08:13,678
Blackmail,
113
00:08:13,679 --> 00:08:15,612
enemies lists,
114
00:08:15,613 --> 00:08:17,678
dirty tricks,
115
00:08:17,679 --> 00:08:20,877
a vice president forced to resign,
116
00:08:20,878 --> 00:08:23,911
perjury, cover-up,
117
00:08:23,912 --> 00:08:27,310
abuse of presidential power,
118
00:08:27,311 --> 00:08:30,610
secret White House tapes.
119
00:08:30,611 --> 00:08:32,010
FRED THOMPSON: Mr.
Butterfield, are you aware
120
00:08:32,011 --> 00:08:34,144
of the installation of
any listening devices
121
00:08:34,145 --> 00:08:36,011
in the Oval Office of the president?
122
00:08:39,776 --> 00:08:43,943
I was aware of listening devices.
123
00:08:43,944 --> 00:08:45,675
Yes, sir.
124
00:08:45,676 --> 00:08:47,208
Good evening.
125
00:08:47,209 --> 00:08:49,874
The country tonight is in
the midst of what may be
126
00:08:49,875 --> 00:08:52,442
the most serious constitutional crisis
127
00:08:52,443 --> 00:08:54,042
in its history.
128
00:08:54,043 --> 00:08:55,975
I told the president about the fact
129
00:08:55,976 --> 00:08:58,340
that there were money demands being made
130
00:08:58,341 --> 00:09:00,373
by the seven convicted defendants.
131
00:09:00,374 --> 00:09:02,574
He asked me how much it would cost.
132
00:09:02,575 --> 00:09:04,873
I told him I could only make an estimate
133
00:09:04,874 --> 00:09:08,440
that it might be as high as
a million dollars or more.
134
00:09:08,441 --> 00:09:11,440
He told me that that was no problem.
135
00:09:11,441 --> 00:09:15,472
I had no prior knowledge
of the Watergate break-in.
136
00:09:15,473 --> 00:09:18,804
I neither took part in nor knew about
137
00:09:18,805 --> 00:09:21,640
any of the subsequent cover-up activities.
138
00:09:23,671 --> 00:09:25,071
The one frustrating thing about...
139
00:09:25,072 --> 00:09:26,471
about going to Canada was,
140
00:09:26,472 --> 00:09:29,170
it left me outside the debate here.
141
00:09:29,171 --> 00:09:31,970
I felt about... frustrated
with that till this day.
142
00:09:31,971 --> 00:09:36,269
NARRATOR: As the Watergate
scandal unfolded, Jack Todd,
143
00:09:36,270 --> 00:09:38,570
who had deserted the United States Army
144
00:09:38,571 --> 00:09:39,702
and fled to Canada,
145
00:09:39,703 --> 00:09:42,136
had never felt so bitter,
146
00:09:42,137 --> 00:09:44,668
so disenchanted, so out of touch
147
00:09:44,669 --> 00:09:47,668
with what the United States
seemed to have become.
148
00:09:47,669 --> 00:09:53,501
He asked himself, "How did we
let this gang take charge?"
149
00:09:53,502 --> 00:09:59,000
Then he made a decision
he would always regret:
150
00:09:59,001 --> 00:10:03,199
he renounced his American citizenship.
151
00:10:03,200 --> 00:10:05,266
JACK TODD: I thought it
was a political act,
152
00:10:05,267 --> 00:10:08,265
renouncing my American citizenship.
153
00:10:08,266 --> 00:10:12,865
And it was the stupidest thing
I have ever done in my life.
154
00:10:12,866 --> 00:10:15,298
I'm a Canadian citizen and I'm proud of it.
155
00:10:15,299 --> 00:10:19,033
It's a wonderful country, but
in here, I'm an American.
156
00:10:26,831 --> 00:10:28,263
JOHN NEGROPONTE: Well,
the agreement was called
157
00:10:28,264 --> 00:10:30,330
"The Agreement to End the War
158
00:10:30,331 --> 00:10:33,031
and Restore Peace in Vietnam."
159
00:10:33,032 --> 00:10:36,862
And, of course, that was a huge euphemism.
160
00:10:36,863 --> 00:10:40,162
It neither ended the war
nor did it restore peace.
161
00:10:40,163 --> 00:10:42,695
And if you look at the substance of it,
162
00:10:42,696 --> 00:10:44,129
it really was a withdrawal agreement.
163
00:10:44,130 --> 00:10:46,062
We were withdrawing our forces
164
00:10:46,063 --> 00:10:49,062
in exchange for prisoners of war.
165
00:10:49,063 --> 00:10:53,928
Those are the two matters that
were definitively settled
166
00:10:53,929 --> 00:10:55,528
by the peace agreement.
167
00:10:55,529 --> 00:11:00,660
We got our troops out and
we got our prisoners back.
168
00:11:00,661 --> 00:11:07,226
The rest is just all a model
of nebulosity and vagueness
169
00:11:07,227 --> 00:11:09,593
and didn't resolve a darn thing.
170
00:11:41,656 --> 00:11:43,822
NARRATOR: Neither North nor South Vietnam
171
00:11:43,823 --> 00:11:47,187
had had any intention of
observing the cease-fire
172
00:11:47,188 --> 00:11:49,754
called for in the peace
treaty signed in Paris
173
00:11:49,755 --> 00:11:54,154
on January 27, 1973.
174
00:11:54,155 --> 00:11:56,554
Even before the ink was dry,
175
00:11:56,555 --> 00:12:01,021
each side had sought to claim
as much territory as it could
176
00:12:01,022 --> 00:12:05,352
in what became known as
"the War of the Flags."
177
00:12:05,353 --> 00:12:07,886
Within three weeks of the ceasefire,
178
00:12:07,887 --> 00:12:13,318
there were already some 3,000
violations by both sides.
179
00:12:13,319 --> 00:12:16,784
South Vietnamese President
Nguyen Van Thieu,
180
00:12:16,785 --> 00:12:20,385
who now commanded the
fifth-largest army on Earth,
181
00:12:20,386 --> 00:12:25,918
insisted the ARVN take and hold
every inch of South Vietnam,
182
00:12:25,919 --> 00:12:27,984
something they had been unable to do
183
00:12:27,985 --> 00:12:33,450
even with the help of nearly
600,000 American troops.
184
00:12:33,451 --> 00:12:35,282
(explosion)
185
00:12:35,283 --> 00:12:38,483
Meanwhile, the North Vietnamese
had attacked Tay Ninh,
186
00:12:38,484 --> 00:12:40,748
near the Cambodian border,
187
00:12:40,749 --> 00:12:43,681
hoping to establish a rival
capital of their own
188
00:12:43,682 --> 00:12:45,715
in the South.
189
00:12:45,716 --> 00:12:50,314
Hanoi installed surface-to-air
missiles near Khe Sanh,
190
00:12:50,315 --> 00:12:53,548
just below the DMZ.
191
00:12:53,549 --> 00:12:57,079
At the same time, ARVN
troops attacked enclaves
192
00:12:57,080 --> 00:12:59,646
seized by the North Vietnamese.
193
00:12:59,647 --> 00:13:03,880
The fighting went on for months.
194
00:13:03,881 --> 00:13:07,178
Hanoi built a new paved highway
195
00:13:07,179 --> 00:13:09,613
within South Vietnam itself,
196
00:13:09,614 --> 00:13:13,913
down which convoys of 200 to 300 vehicles
197
00:13:13,914 --> 00:13:15,777
soon began streaming:
198
00:13:15,778 --> 00:13:21,711
trucks, tanks, and heavy guns
moving in broad daylight.
199
00:13:21,712 --> 00:13:25,643
And they began laying
down a giant oil pipeline
200
00:13:25,644 --> 00:13:30,111
to fuel their vehicles in the South.
201
00:13:30,112 --> 00:13:33,543
Nixon had privately
promised President Thieu
202
00:13:33,544 --> 00:13:36,709
that he would retaliate
with American airpower
203
00:13:36,710 --> 00:13:41,043
if Saigon ever seemed seriously threatened.
204
00:13:41,044 --> 00:13:42,674
(gavel banging)
205
00:13:42,675 --> 00:13:45,141
But in Washington, week by week,
206
00:13:45,142 --> 00:13:48,274
as the secrets of Watergate
kept tumbling out,
207
00:13:48,275 --> 00:13:54,573
Nixon's influence on Capitol
Hill steadily weakened.
208
00:13:54,574 --> 00:13:59,273
In June of 1973, an energized Congress,
209
00:13:59,274 --> 00:14:02,540
reflecting the views of a
majority of Americans,
210
00:14:02,541 --> 00:14:05,839
voted to stop all military operations
211
00:14:05,840 --> 00:14:10,738
in or over Vietnam, Laos, or Cambodia
212
00:14:10,739 --> 00:14:12,571
by August 15,
213
00:14:12,572 --> 00:14:15,006
and insisted that they not be resumed
214
00:14:15,007 --> 00:14:17,938
without congressional approval.
215
00:14:17,939 --> 00:14:20,137
"America wants peace,"
216
00:14:20,138 --> 00:14:23,737
Senator Edward Kennedy of
Massachusetts declared.
217
00:14:23,738 --> 00:14:29,504
"Congress is strong in its
resolve to end the killing."
218
00:14:29,505 --> 00:14:32,769
LEWIS SORLEY: To abandon
the South Vietnamese,
219
00:14:32,770 --> 00:14:36,603
when all we were providing
them at the end was money,
220
00:14:36,604 --> 00:14:38,603
was reprehensible,
221
00:14:38,604 --> 00:14:42,369
and disrespected the
sacrifices of all soldiers,
222
00:14:42,370 --> 00:14:45,002
ours and the South Vietnamese.
223
00:14:45,003 --> 00:14:46,701
I think the moral obligation,
224
00:14:46,702 --> 00:14:49,868
that doesn't stem from a
philosophical commitment
225
00:14:49,869 --> 00:14:51,201
to stopping communism.
226
00:14:51,202 --> 00:14:54,266
Now it stems from our keeping our promises
227
00:14:54,267 --> 00:14:58,333
to this erstwhile, unfortunate ally.
228
00:14:58,334 --> 00:15:00,200
That they had us as the ally
229
00:15:00,201 --> 00:15:02,533
where the other guys had the Soviet Union
230
00:15:02,534 --> 00:15:05,100
and communist China.
231
00:15:05,101 --> 00:15:06,866
Most Americans, I think,
232
00:15:06,867 --> 00:15:08,799
would not like to hear it
said that the communists
233
00:15:08,800 --> 00:15:11,099
were more faithful allies
than the United States.
234
00:15:11,100 --> 00:15:14,365
But that is, in fact, what the case was.
235
00:15:14,366 --> 00:15:17,864
ROBERT GARD: While one regrets
that we pulled the rug out,
236
00:15:17,865 --> 00:15:19,731
in some respects,
237
00:15:19,732 --> 00:15:23,863
I think the ultimate outcome
would've been the same.
238
00:15:23,864 --> 00:15:28,629
Had we continued, it would have cost
239
00:15:28,630 --> 00:15:31,530
probably more lives in the long term
240
00:15:31,531 --> 00:15:34,196
with no change in the outcome.
241
00:15:34,197 --> 00:15:36,495
NARRATOR: In the 18 bloody months
242
00:15:36,496 --> 00:15:38,962
that followed the signing
of the peace accords,
243
00:15:38,963 --> 00:15:44,096
South Vietnam's position became
more and more precarious.
244
00:15:44,097 --> 00:15:47,528
But by the summer of 1974,
245
00:15:47,529 --> 00:15:50,395
few Americans were paying attention.
246
00:15:50,396 --> 00:15:55,060
They were riveted by what was
happening to their own country.
247
00:15:55,061 --> 00:15:57,693
...to investigate fully and completely
248
00:15:57,694 --> 00:16:00,493
whether sufficient grounds exist
249
00:16:00,494 --> 00:16:02,794
for the House of Representatives
250
00:16:02,795 --> 00:16:05,992
to exercise its constitutional power
251
00:16:05,993 --> 00:16:08,425
to impeach Richard M. Nixon,
252
00:16:08,426 --> 00:16:11,758
president of the United States of America.
253
00:16:11,759 --> 00:16:14,491
SPEAKER: Mr. Danielson? -Aye.
254
00:16:14,492 --> 00:16:18,624
SPEAKER: Mr. Drinan? -Aye.
255
00:16:18,625 --> 00:16:21,557
SPEAKER: Mr. Rangel? -Aye.
256
00:16:21,558 --> 00:16:23,556
SPEAKER: Ms. Jordan? -Aye.
257
00:16:23,557 --> 00:16:26,190
SPEAKER: Mr. Lott? -No.
258
00:16:26,191 --> 00:16:30,056
NARRATOR: On July 27, 1974,
259
00:16:30,057 --> 00:16:32,890
the House Judiciary Committee recommended
260
00:16:32,891 --> 00:16:37,790
that the president be impeached
for abusing his office.
261
00:16:37,791 --> 00:16:41,554
On August 9, rather than face impeachment,
262
00:16:41,555 --> 00:16:45,488
Richard Nixon became the first
president in American history
263
00:16:45,489 --> 00:16:47,421
to resign.
264
00:16:47,422 --> 00:16:49,353
NIXON: Always remember,
265
00:16:49,354 --> 00:16:51,620
others may hate you,
266
00:16:51,621 --> 00:16:55,388
but those who hate you don't win
267
00:16:55,389 --> 00:16:58,352
unless you hate them,
268
00:16:58,353 --> 00:17:01,287
and then you destroy yourself.
269
00:17:01,288 --> 00:17:04,552
NARRATOR: At the presidential
palace in Saigon,
270
00:17:04,553 --> 00:17:07,351
President Thieu closed his office door
271
00:17:07,352 --> 00:17:09,751
and refused to see anyone.
272
00:17:09,752 --> 00:17:12,519
He had staked South Vietnam's survival
273
00:17:12,520 --> 00:17:14,786
on Nixon's personal pledge
274
00:17:14,787 --> 00:17:17,050
that North Vietnamese
aggression would be met
275
00:17:17,051 --> 00:17:20,317
by renewed American airpower.
276
00:17:20,318 --> 00:17:24,983
Just a few days after the
new president, Gerald Ford,
277
00:17:24,984 --> 00:17:26,616
moved into the White House,
278
00:17:26,617 --> 00:17:28,683
Congress cut in half the funds
279
00:17:28,684 --> 00:17:31,650
for military and economic assistance
280
00:17:31,651 --> 00:17:35,150
Nixon had promised to deliver to Saigon.
281
00:17:36,650 --> 00:17:40,815
Conditions in South Vietnam
continued to deteriorate.
282
00:17:40,816 --> 00:17:43,414
With the American military presence gone,
283
00:17:43,415 --> 00:17:48,047
one out of every five
civilian workers was jobless.
284
00:17:48,048 --> 00:17:50,748
Prices soared.
285
00:17:54,614 --> 00:17:57,613
DUONG VAN MAI ELLIOTT: There were
many mistakes made by the Americans,
286
00:17:57,614 --> 00:17:59,680
but the biggest mistake
287
00:17:59,681 --> 00:18:04,013
was in creating the sense of dependency.
288
00:18:04,014 --> 00:18:07,580
Another mistake was in creating
an army in their own image,
289
00:18:07,581 --> 00:18:13,978
an army that was used to
fighting a rich man's war.
290
00:18:13,979 --> 00:18:15,544
And South Vietnam was too poor
291
00:18:15,545 --> 00:18:18,378
to be able to sustain that kind of war.
292
00:18:18,379 --> 00:18:22,578
NARRATOR: Thieu had steadily
grown more authoritarian,
293
00:18:22,579 --> 00:18:26,677
closing newspapers, restricting
opposition parties,
294
00:18:26,678 --> 00:18:31,542
selling political and
military appointments.
295
00:18:31,543 --> 00:18:35,643
A coalition of Catholics
and Buddhists charged him
296
00:18:35,644 --> 00:18:39,142
with corrupting every aspect
of South Vietnamese life,
297
00:18:39,143 --> 00:18:42,308
and demanded his resignation.
298
00:18:42,309 --> 00:18:44,241
Thousands of demonstrators
299
00:18:44,242 --> 00:18:47,209
poured into the streets of Saigon.
300
00:18:50,076 --> 00:18:54,306
Meanwhile, the chronically
underpaid South Vietnamese Army
301
00:18:54,307 --> 00:18:57,640
had its pay cut further.
302
00:18:57,641 --> 00:19:00,874
It began to disintegrate.
303
00:19:00,875 --> 00:19:04,905
As many as 20,000 men were
deserting each month,
304
00:19:04,906 --> 00:19:08,439
most heading home to try to
help their families survive
305
00:19:08,440 --> 00:19:11,373
in such hard times.
306
00:19:11,374 --> 00:19:14,572
Those ARVN who stood and fought
307
00:19:14,573 --> 00:19:17,971
often had to do so without
the sophisticated weaponry
308
00:19:17,972 --> 00:19:21,803
they'd been trained by
the Americans to use.
309
00:19:21,804 --> 00:19:24,670
Much of the equipment Nixon had provided
310
00:19:24,671 --> 00:19:28,803
was ill-suited to the war
the South was now waging,
311
00:19:28,804 --> 00:19:31,770
aircraft for which there
were no trained pilots
312
00:19:31,771 --> 00:19:33,602
or ground crews,
313
00:19:33,603 --> 00:19:35,936
artillery and military vehicles
314
00:19:35,937 --> 00:19:38,834
for which there were no spare parts.
315
00:19:38,835 --> 00:19:43,935
And the U.S. Congress was
in no mood to provide more.
316
00:19:43,936 --> 00:19:46,369
Fuel ran low.
317
00:19:46,370 --> 00:19:49,400
So did ammunition.
318
00:19:49,401 --> 00:19:53,233
Before long, artillerymen
in the Central Highlands
319
00:19:53,234 --> 00:19:56,532
could fire just four shells a day,
320
00:19:56,533 --> 00:20:02,134
and infantrymen were limited
to 85 bullets a month.
321
00:20:20,566 --> 00:20:22,765
NARRATOR: In November of 1974,
322
00:20:22,766 --> 00:20:27,197
the Politburo and the Central
Military Committee met in Hanoi
323
00:20:27,198 --> 00:20:29,564
to discuss strategy.
324
00:20:29,565 --> 00:20:32,263
Some members urged caution.
325
00:20:32,264 --> 00:20:34,363
They worried that if they tried
326
00:20:34,364 --> 00:20:37,263
to push Saigon to the point
of collapse too quickly,
327
00:20:37,264 --> 00:20:40,063
the Americans would return.
328
00:20:40,064 --> 00:20:45,862
Final victory, they calculated,
would come in 1976.
329
00:20:45,863 --> 00:20:50,526
Party First Secretary Le Duan didn't agree.
330
00:20:50,527 --> 00:20:53,561
"Now that the United States
has pulled out," he said,
331
00:20:53,562 --> 00:20:57,361
"it will be hard for them to jump back in."
332
00:20:57,362 --> 00:20:59,725
He ordered a test attack
333
00:20:59,726 --> 00:21:03,225
to see if the Americans would
intervene with airpower
334
00:21:03,226 --> 00:21:05,325
as they had during the Easter Offensive
335
00:21:05,326 --> 00:21:08,125
2 1/2 years earlier.
336
00:21:08,126 --> 00:21:09,658
(artillery fire)
337
00:21:09,659 --> 00:21:12,091
In December 1974,
338
00:21:12,092 --> 00:21:14,458
North Vietnamese forces
attacked Phuoc Long,
339
00:21:14,459 --> 00:21:16,391
northeast of Saigon.
340
00:21:20,425 --> 00:21:24,491
Within three weeks, they had
overrun the entire province
341
00:21:24,492 --> 00:21:29,789
and had killed or captured
thousands of ARVN defenders.
342
00:21:29,790 --> 00:21:34,856
The United States did nothing in response.
343
00:21:34,857 --> 00:21:40,221
President Ford, preoccupied
with other problems...
344
00:21:40,222 --> 00:21:44,320
inflation, unemployment,
tensions in the Middle East...
345
00:21:44,321 --> 00:21:46,020
held a press conference
346
00:21:46,021 --> 00:21:50,154
that offered the South
Vietnamese no comfort.
347
00:21:50,155 --> 00:21:51,621
REPORTER: Are you considering
348
00:21:51,622 --> 00:21:53,453
any additional measures,
beyond a supplemental,
349
00:21:53,454 --> 00:21:56,519
of assistance to the South
Vietnamese government?
350
00:21:56,520 --> 00:22:00,153
I am not anticipating
351
00:22:00,154 --> 00:22:03,152
any further action beyond that supplemental
352
00:22:03,153 --> 00:22:04,553
at this time.
353
00:22:04,554 --> 00:22:07,253
NARRATOR: Washington
seemed to have no interest
354
00:22:07,254 --> 00:22:09,318
in fulfilling the secret pledges
355
00:22:09,319 --> 00:22:12,651
Nixon had repeatedly made to Thieu.
356
00:22:12,652 --> 00:22:15,685
He was stunned.
357
00:22:15,686 --> 00:22:17,752
STUART HERRINGTON: With the communist flag
358
00:22:17,753 --> 00:22:22,083
planted in a provincial capital
just to the north of Saigon,
359
00:22:22,084 --> 00:22:24,816
to me, the handwriting was on the wall.
360
00:22:24,817 --> 00:22:28,282
I then communicated with
my family, and told them
361
00:22:28,283 --> 00:22:31,582
that even though my tour was
supposed to take me till August,
362
00:22:31,583 --> 00:22:33,582
that I would be home sooner.
363
00:22:33,583 --> 00:22:38,314
And then I began to quietly,
one little box at a time,
364
00:22:38,315 --> 00:22:41,814
mail my possessions out of Vietnam.
365
00:22:41,815 --> 00:22:46,313
("Kashmir" by Led Zeppelin playing)
366
00:22:46,314 --> 00:22:48,548
NARRATOR: The North
Vietnamese now undertook
367
00:22:48,549 --> 00:22:51,713
a new assault on cities
in the Central Highlands,
368
00:22:51,714 --> 00:22:54,114
including Ban Me Thuot,
369
00:22:54,115 --> 00:22:57,413
where their forces outnumbered
the over-extended ARVN
370
00:22:57,414 --> 00:22:59,579
nearly six to one.
371
00:22:59,580 --> 00:23:03,181
("Kashmir" continues)
372
00:23:05,579 --> 00:23:10,046
Ban Me Thuot fell in two days.
373
00:23:10,047 --> 00:23:13,845
JAMES WILLBANKS: And here is
the second province to fall,
374
00:23:13,846 --> 00:23:17,510
and it falls fairly quickly.
375
00:23:17,511 --> 00:23:19,077
At that point, they realize,
376
00:23:19,078 --> 00:23:20,577
"Well, we don't have to wait till 1976,
377
00:23:20,578 --> 00:23:21,910
we can go for it now."
378
00:23:21,911 --> 00:23:23,943
NARRATOR: Hanoi was delighted
379
00:23:23,944 --> 00:23:27,110
by the Americans' lack of response.
380
00:23:27,111 --> 00:23:32,343
But all the previous offensives
Le Duan had set in motion...
381
00:23:32,344 --> 00:23:34,343
in 1964,
382
00:23:34,344 --> 00:23:37,142
in 1968,
383
00:23:37,143 --> 00:23:39,374
in 1972...
384
00:23:39,375 --> 00:23:43,274
had ended in failure.
385
00:23:43,275 --> 00:23:46,975
This time, he turned to
General Vo Nguyen Giap,
386
00:23:46,976 --> 00:23:49,940
the architect of the great
victory over the French
387
00:23:49,941 --> 00:23:51,506
at Dien Bien Phu,
388
00:23:51,507 --> 00:23:56,675
who had been sidelined
during the Tet Offensive.
389
00:24:18,771 --> 00:24:20,570
NARRATOR: For weeks, the ARVN top command
390
00:24:20,571 --> 00:24:23,737
had warned Thieu that his
already weakened forces
391
00:24:23,738 --> 00:24:25,636
were spread too thinly;
392
00:24:25,637 --> 00:24:29,802
that it was no longer possible
to defend the entire country.
393
00:24:29,803 --> 00:24:32,568
He had angrily resisted.
394
00:24:32,569 --> 00:24:37,036
But now, suddenly, he changed his mind.
395
00:24:37,037 --> 00:24:40,768
Thieu ordered his troops
to abandon the highlands,
396
00:24:40,769 --> 00:24:42,634
to withdraw under fire
397
00:24:42,635 --> 00:24:46,468
and then regroup in order
to retake Ban Me Thuot.
398
00:24:46,469 --> 00:24:49,067
It would have been a near-impossible task
399
00:24:49,068 --> 00:24:51,799
with a carefully worked-out plan.
400
00:24:51,800 --> 00:24:53,933
Thieu had none.
401
00:24:53,934 --> 00:24:55,535
(gunfire)
402
00:24:57,835 --> 00:24:59,632
(explosion)
403
00:24:59,633 --> 00:25:02,034
The result would be disaster.
404
00:25:20,098 --> 00:25:21,664
NARRATOR: Within a week,
405
00:25:21,665 --> 00:25:25,264
Pleiku and Kon Tum were in enemy hands.
406
00:25:26,630 --> 00:25:31,496
BAO NINH:
407
00:25:42,495 --> 00:25:45,161
According to Western
diplomats here in Saigon,
408
00:25:45,162 --> 00:25:47,828
the South Vietnamese are
quitting the Central Highlands
409
00:25:47,829 --> 00:25:50,728
because they hope to avoid a complete rout.
410
00:25:50,729 --> 00:25:52,360
The withdrawal is said to be an attempt
411
00:25:52,361 --> 00:25:55,393
to save men and equipment
that may become sorely needed
412
00:25:55,394 --> 00:25:58,293
in other, more heavily populated
parts of the country.
413
00:26:25,257 --> 00:26:28,389
NARRATOR: As the ARVN fled south,
414
00:26:28,390 --> 00:26:31,689
400,000 civilians fled with them.
415
00:26:38,355 --> 00:26:41,054
The enemy blocked the main roads
416
00:26:41,055 --> 00:26:44,421
so that they had to take
a disused back road.
417
00:26:44,422 --> 00:26:46,553
Thousands died,
418
00:26:46,554 --> 00:26:49,120
killed by North Vietnamese shells
419
00:26:49,121 --> 00:26:50,887
and machine gun fire,
420
00:26:50,888 --> 00:26:53,486
trampled by fellow refugees,
421
00:26:53,487 --> 00:26:56,119
run over by retreating tanks,
422
00:26:56,120 --> 00:26:59,453
blown apart by South Vietnamese bombs
423
00:26:59,454 --> 00:27:04,118
dropped by pilots who
mistook them for the enemy.
424
00:27:04,119 --> 00:27:08,119
Reporters called it the "Convoy of Tears."
425
00:27:10,220 --> 00:27:13,984
Then, Hue fell.
426
00:27:28,151 --> 00:27:32,048
NARRATOR: On March 29, 1975,
427
00:27:32,049 --> 00:27:35,149
the North Vietnamese entered Danang,
428
00:27:35,150 --> 00:27:37,416
South Vietnam's second-largest city.
429
00:27:39,650 --> 00:27:43,082
Civilians and soldiers alike tried to flee.
430
00:27:49,448 --> 00:27:52,314
(crowd clamoring)
431
00:27:52,315 --> 00:27:56,613
"Danang was not captured," an
American reporter remembered.
432
00:27:56,614 --> 00:28:00,845
"It disintegrated in its own terror."
433
00:28:00,846 --> 00:28:02,613
(plane engine starting)
434
00:29:17,538 --> 00:29:20,504
NARRATOR: On the same beach
where the U.S. Marines
435
00:29:20,505 --> 00:29:23,137
had landed nearly ten years earlier,
436
00:29:23,138 --> 00:29:26,803
beginning America's combat
involvement in Vietnam,
437
00:29:26,804 --> 00:29:30,968
16,000 ARVN soldiers fought for space
438
00:29:30,969 --> 00:29:34,402
with 75,000 terrified civilians
439
00:29:34,403 --> 00:29:38,334
aboard an improvised fleet of
freighters and fishing boats
440
00:29:38,335 --> 00:29:43,267
headed south for Cam Ranh
Bay, Vung Tau, and Saigon;
441
00:29:43,268 --> 00:29:48,435
anywhere they thought Northern
troops might not follow.
442
00:29:54,333 --> 00:29:58,366
Thousands drowned struggling
to reach the boats.
443
00:29:58,367 --> 00:30:01,732
Thousands more were killed by enemy shells
444
00:30:01,733 --> 00:30:04,399
raining down on the beach.
445
00:30:20,730 --> 00:30:23,329
NARRATOR: Danang, Tam Ky,
446
00:30:23,330 --> 00:30:25,697
Quang Ngai, Qui Nhon,
447
00:30:25,698 --> 00:30:29,761
Nha Trang, Cam Ranh Bay.
448
00:30:29,762 --> 00:30:33,129
The North Vietnamese kept
moving closer and closer
449
00:30:33,130 --> 00:30:34,929
to Saigon.
450
00:30:34,930 --> 00:30:40,160
It was stunning to sit there in Saigon,
451
00:30:40,161 --> 00:30:42,861
writing the daily ledes
452
00:30:42,862 --> 00:30:46,660
on the fall of all these places.
453
00:30:46,661 --> 00:30:49,759
You just were overwhelmed
454
00:30:49,760 --> 00:30:52,627
with ten years' worth of history
455
00:30:52,628 --> 00:30:56,825
and seeing all of it come unglued.
456
00:30:56,826 --> 00:30:58,126
(explosion)
457
00:30:58,127 --> 00:30:59,793
FRANK SNEPP: At the end of March,
458
00:30:59,794 --> 00:31:03,693
18 North Vietnamese divisions,
459
00:31:03,694 --> 00:31:06,125
with five in reserve,
460
00:31:06,126 --> 00:31:07,391
were now arrayed
461
00:31:07,392 --> 00:31:12,391
against, basically, six
South Vietnamese divisions.
462
00:31:12,392 --> 00:31:15,323
The manpower imbalance
463
00:31:15,324 --> 00:31:19,124
was about three or four to one,
in favor of the communists.
464
00:31:19,125 --> 00:31:21,256
This was breathtaking.
465
00:31:21,257 --> 00:31:24,089
NARRATOR: The North Vietnamese now decided
466
00:31:24,090 --> 00:31:25,990
to move against Saigon
467
00:31:25,991 --> 00:31:30,856
and take it before Ho Chi
Minh's birthday on May 19.
468
00:31:30,857 --> 00:31:33,622
It became clear to Thomas Polgar,
469
00:31:33,623 --> 00:31:36,689
the C.I.A. station chief in Saigon,
470
00:31:36,690 --> 00:31:40,454
that the time had come to begin
preparing for an evacuation.
471
00:31:40,455 --> 00:31:44,320
There were still some 5,000
Americans in Saigon,
472
00:31:44,321 --> 00:31:46,153
and there were also as many
473
00:31:46,154 --> 00:31:49,752
as 200,000 South Vietnamese
and their families
474
00:31:49,753 --> 00:31:53,519
who had cooperated with the United States.
475
00:31:53,520 --> 00:31:57,452
But Ambassador Graham Martin disagreed.
476
00:31:57,453 --> 00:31:59,852
He was a resolute Cold Warrior,
477
00:31:59,853 --> 00:32:02,151
who had been appointed to reassure Thieu
478
00:32:02,152 --> 00:32:04,885
of continuing American backing,
479
00:32:04,886 --> 00:32:07,584
and his feelings had only been intensified
480
00:32:07,585 --> 00:32:10,384
by the death of his son in Vietnam.
481
00:32:10,385 --> 00:32:12,650
He had not been appointed ambassador,
482
00:32:12,651 --> 00:32:14,384
he had told an aide,
483
00:32:14,385 --> 00:32:18,016
to "give Vietnam away to the communists."
484
00:32:18,017 --> 00:32:21,617
The C.I.A. was being alarmist, he said.
485
00:32:21,618 --> 00:32:23,883
There would be no attack on Saigon,
486
00:32:23,884 --> 00:32:27,215
and, therefore, no evacuation.
487
00:32:27,216 --> 00:32:32,449
President Thieu also continued
to insist all was not lost.
488
00:32:32,450 --> 00:32:35,615
The ARVN were ready to
"fight on to the last bullet
489
00:32:35,616 --> 00:32:38,415
and the last grain of rice," he said.
490
00:32:40,315 --> 00:32:43,246
Just 40 miles east of Saigon,
491
00:32:43,247 --> 00:32:45,480
North Vietnamese forces attacked
492
00:32:45,481 --> 00:32:48,746
the town of Xuan Loc on Highway One,
493
00:32:48,747 --> 00:32:52,979
the last obstacle on their way to Saigon.
494
00:32:52,980 --> 00:32:55,780
Although they were
outnumbered and outgunned,
495
00:32:55,781 --> 00:33:00,013
the South Vietnamese commander
refused to retreat.
496
00:33:00,014 --> 00:33:04,779
He was determined to keep
the enemy from his capital.
497
00:33:04,780 --> 00:33:07,579
REPORTER: You're certain
that you can hold Xuan Loc?
498
00:33:07,580 --> 00:33:09,112
Surely, surely.
499
00:33:09,113 --> 00:33:10,843
I am certain to you.
500
00:33:10,844 --> 00:33:13,643
I am sure with you I can hold Xuan Loc.
501
00:33:13,644 --> 00:33:16,778
Even the enemies uses, you
know, the double forces
502
00:33:16,779 --> 00:33:19,709
or maybe three time more than my forces.
503
00:33:19,710 --> 00:33:21,043
But no problem, sir.
504
00:33:21,044 --> 00:33:22,477
No problem.
505
00:33:23,843 --> 00:33:26,543
FORD: A vast human tragedy
506
00:33:26,544 --> 00:33:31,341
has befallen our friends
in Vietnam and Cambodia.
507
00:33:31,342 --> 00:33:33,042
NARRATOR: On April 10,
508
00:33:33,043 --> 00:33:36,707
President Ford appealed to a
joint session of Congress
509
00:33:36,708 --> 00:33:39,508
for emergency aid to Saigon.
510
00:33:39,509 --> 00:33:42,108
If they refused and Saigon fell,
511
00:33:42,109 --> 00:33:45,739
Congress, not the White
House, should take the blame.
512
00:33:45,740 --> 00:33:48,507
Under five presidents and 12 Congresses,
513
00:33:48,508 --> 00:33:52,839
the United States was engaged in Indochina.
514
00:33:52,840 --> 00:33:56,405
Millions of Americans served,
515
00:33:56,406 --> 00:33:58,506
thousands died,
516
00:33:58,507 --> 00:34:03,337
and many more were wounded,
imprisoned, or lost.
517
00:34:03,338 --> 00:34:07,837
NARRATOR: The president asked
Congress for $722 million
518
00:34:07,838 --> 00:34:09,637
in military aid.
519
00:34:09,638 --> 00:34:11,505
There was no applause.
520
00:34:11,506 --> 00:34:14,937
Most legislators, and their constituents,
521
00:34:14,938 --> 00:34:18,104
thought it was too late
to make any difference.
522
00:34:18,105 --> 00:34:23,235
In the end, Congress voted
against any military aid.
523
00:34:23,236 --> 00:34:25,869
BUI DIEM: I didn't think that it is good
524
00:34:25,870 --> 00:34:30,169
for a big nation like the U.S.
to behave like that.
525
00:34:30,170 --> 00:34:31,868
Because by that time,
526
00:34:31,869 --> 00:34:35,734
we didn't ask for the blood
of American soldiers.
527
00:34:35,735 --> 00:34:40,168
I mean, the last minute, they
washed their hands like that.
528
00:34:40,169 --> 00:34:43,200
It is not up to a diplomat
to use strong words
529
00:34:43,201 --> 00:34:44,668
against the American,
530
00:34:44,669 --> 00:34:47,934
but I felt deeply sorry about it.
531
00:34:50,534 --> 00:34:53,466
SNEPP: We broke every rule in
the book to get people out,
532
00:34:53,467 --> 00:34:56,533
the young officers did,
533
00:34:56,534 --> 00:35:01,865
while the ambassador continued to stonewall
534
00:35:01,866 --> 00:35:04,099
both the embassy and Washington.
535
00:35:04,100 --> 00:35:08,065
NARRATOR: Evacuation plans
were finally drawn up.
536
00:35:08,066 --> 00:35:11,330
There were four options:
537
00:35:11,331 --> 00:35:16,829
sealift by cargo ships anchored
in the port of Saigon,
538
00:35:16,830 --> 00:35:20,196
airlift by commercial airliner,
539
00:35:20,197 --> 00:35:23,030
a military airlift,
540
00:35:23,031 --> 00:35:25,395
and, as a last resort,
541
00:35:25,396 --> 00:35:27,929
evacuation by flights of helicopters
542
00:35:27,930 --> 00:35:31,128
to a flotilla of U.S. Navy ships
543
00:35:31,129 --> 00:35:33,995
in the South China Sea.
544
00:35:33,996 --> 00:35:38,361
Ambassador Martin continued
to show little interest.
545
00:35:38,362 --> 00:35:40,327
The slightest sign that the United States
546
00:35:40,328 --> 00:35:43,261
would abandon South Vietnam, he said,
547
00:35:43,262 --> 00:35:47,094
would produce panic in the streets.
548
00:35:47,095 --> 00:35:48,261
(gunfire and explosions)
549
00:35:48,262 --> 00:35:50,061
On April 21,
550
00:35:50,062 --> 00:35:53,625
Xuan Loc finally fell to
the North Vietnamese.
551
00:35:53,626 --> 00:35:58,825
The ARVN had valiantly held
on for 12 bloody days.
552
00:35:58,826 --> 00:36:04,691
Highway One was now open
all the way to Saigon.
553
00:36:04,692 --> 00:36:09,957
That evening, President Thieu resigned.
554
00:36:09,958 --> 00:36:15,091
Four days later, the C.I.A.
would spirit Thieu to Taiwan,
555
00:36:15,092 --> 00:36:17,122
where an American emissary brought him
556
00:36:17,123 --> 00:36:19,923
a private message from President Ford.
557
00:36:19,924 --> 00:36:23,822
It was not a good time for
him to visit America.
558
00:36:23,823 --> 00:36:27,621
Antiwar feelings were too strong.
559
00:36:27,622 --> 00:36:31,056
"It is so easy to be an enemy
of the United States,"
560
00:36:31,057 --> 00:36:32,556
Thieu said,
561
00:36:32,557 --> 00:36:36,255
"but so difficult to be a friend."
562
00:36:36,256 --> 00:36:39,220
News of Thieu's resignation
563
00:36:39,221 --> 00:36:42,187
had sent thousands of panicked Vietnamese
564
00:36:42,188 --> 00:36:44,420
rushing to Tan Son Nhut Airport,
565
00:36:44,421 --> 00:36:47,119
hoping to get out of their country.
566
00:36:47,120 --> 00:36:52,653
Some had exit visas; many did not.
567
00:36:52,654 --> 00:36:57,318
Marines did what they
could to establish order.
568
00:36:57,319 --> 00:37:01,851
Master Sergeant Juan Valdez was
the noncommissioned officer
569
00:37:01,852 --> 00:37:06,351
in charge of Marine Corps
Security Guards in Saigon.
570
00:37:06,352 --> 00:37:08,485
He had been one of the first Marines
571
00:37:08,486 --> 00:37:12,551
to land in Vietnam in 1965.
572
00:37:12,552 --> 00:37:15,683
VALDEZ: People were trying
to bribe the Marines.
573
00:37:15,684 --> 00:37:19,183
You know, they were bringing
money out there, jewelry,
574
00:37:19,184 --> 00:37:21,382
to get them out of the country.
575
00:37:21,383 --> 00:37:23,250
I think just about every
Marine that was at the gate
576
00:37:23,251 --> 00:37:25,315
encountered this type of bribes.
577
00:37:25,316 --> 00:37:27,750
But they had to refuse them, yeah, yeah.
578
00:37:27,751 --> 00:37:31,114
NARRATOR: Duong Van Mai Elliott's family
579
00:37:31,115 --> 00:37:33,915
had fled Hanoi in 1954,
580
00:37:33,916 --> 00:37:37,015
leaving behind her older sister, Thang,
581
00:37:37,016 --> 00:37:39,947
who had joined Ho Chi Minh's forces.
582
00:37:39,948 --> 00:37:42,347
Now, 20 years later,
583
00:37:42,348 --> 00:37:45,380
with the North Vietnamese
closing in on Saigon,
584
00:37:45,381 --> 00:37:47,247
they were faced with the prospect
585
00:37:47,248 --> 00:37:50,413
of fleeing once again.
586
00:37:50,414 --> 00:37:53,779
DUONG VAN MAI ELLIOTT: My
mother didn't want to leave.
587
00:37:53,780 --> 00:37:56,611
She said she didn't want
to be a refugee again.
588
00:37:56,612 --> 00:37:59,345
She had been a refugee too many times.
589
00:37:59,346 --> 00:38:02,246
Plus, my sister Thang was about to arrive
590
00:38:02,247 --> 00:38:05,777
and meet us after all these years.
591
00:38:05,778 --> 00:38:10,810
She said she wanted to stay and see Thang.
592
00:38:10,811 --> 00:38:14,276
My father was determined to leave,
593
00:38:14,277 --> 00:38:18,376
because he was afraid that if
we stayed, we'd be killed.
594
00:38:18,377 --> 00:38:23,009
He got mad at my mother, and they argued,
595
00:38:23,010 --> 00:38:25,308
but in the end, my mother yielded
596
00:38:25,309 --> 00:38:28,843
to his, uh, insistence that we should...
they should leave.
597
00:38:30,477 --> 00:38:33,008
PHAN QUANG TUE: I knew that
the end was approaching.
598
00:38:33,009 --> 00:38:36,207
When you are at the center of the storm,
599
00:38:36,208 --> 00:38:38,374
you have to get out.
600
00:38:38,375 --> 00:38:43,606
When I myself and my immediate family,
601
00:38:43,607 --> 00:38:45,606
and my father and his immediate family,
602
00:38:45,607 --> 00:38:48,241
went to the Tan Son Nhut Airport,
603
00:38:48,242 --> 00:38:52,205
through the whole thing I said,
"This is crazy, you know.
604
00:38:52,206 --> 00:38:55,772
Why, why do we have to leave
under these conditions?"
605
00:38:55,773 --> 00:38:57,339
It was so humiliating.
606
00:38:57,340 --> 00:39:02,671
And I carry that humiliation
with me to the United States.
607
00:39:02,672 --> 00:39:05,472
When I get in line to sign up for a job,
608
00:39:05,473 --> 00:39:07,471
you know, I was a...
609
00:39:07,472 --> 00:39:10,937
I remind them of the war in Vietnam,
610
00:39:10,938 --> 00:39:13,603
which the Americans hate.
611
00:39:13,604 --> 00:39:16,637
You have to lose a nation and a dream
612
00:39:16,638 --> 00:39:20,138
to feel... to feel that humiliation.
613
00:40:40,495 --> 00:40:43,827
JEAN-MARIE CROCKER: We
have always sent a wreath
614
00:40:43,828 --> 00:40:47,993
to his grave at Arlington.
615
00:40:47,994 --> 00:40:51,060
Partly in remembrance, of course, of him,
616
00:40:51,061 --> 00:40:55,059
but also thinking, if other
grieving people are there,
617
00:40:55,060 --> 00:40:59,226
or just people that are
visiting to pay their respects,
618
00:40:59,227 --> 00:41:03,558
that it's good for them
to know that people are,
619
00:41:03,559 --> 00:41:05,858
that the soldiers are remembered.
620
00:41:20,256 --> 00:41:22,755
FORD: Today...
621
00:41:22,756 --> 00:41:26,822
America can regain the sense of pride
622
00:41:26,823 --> 00:41:29,687
that existed before Vietnam.
623
00:41:29,688 --> 00:41:34,555
But it cannot be achieved
by refighting a war
624
00:41:34,556 --> 00:41:38,653
that is finished as far
as America is concerned.
625
00:41:38,654 --> 00:41:41,555
(applause)
626
00:41:43,388 --> 00:41:44,487
(explosion)
627
00:41:44,488 --> 00:41:47,785
NARRATOR: On April 27, 1975,
628
00:41:47,786 --> 00:41:51,053
rockets landed in the heart of Saigon.
629
00:41:51,054 --> 00:41:54,252
It was the signal for the
North Vietnamese to begin
630
00:41:54,253 --> 00:41:56,651
their main assault on the city.
631
00:41:56,652 --> 00:42:00,119
They attacked from five sides,
632
00:42:00,120 --> 00:42:03,219
"like a hurricane," their commander said.
633
00:42:03,220 --> 00:42:06,884
The White House ordered
all American cargo ships
634
00:42:06,885 --> 00:42:09,350
to sail out to sea without waiting
635
00:42:09,351 --> 00:42:11,683
to take on any passengers.
636
00:42:11,684 --> 00:42:15,483
There now could be no organized sealift.
637
00:42:15,484 --> 00:42:19,750
(Jimi Hendrix Experience's "All
Along the Watchtower" playing)
638
00:42:27,082 --> 00:42:29,648
NARRATOR: When the
communists began shelling
639
00:42:29,649 --> 00:42:33,814
the seaside town of Vung Tau,
just southeast of Saigon,
640
00:42:33,815 --> 00:42:35,780
thousands of terrified people
641
00:42:35,781 --> 00:42:38,280
clambered into any vessel they could find
642
00:42:38,281 --> 00:42:41,214
in hope of rescue by the Americans.
643
00:42:41,215 --> 00:42:43,813
Before the exodus ended,
644
00:42:43,814 --> 00:42:46,947
more than 60,000 refugees from Vung Tau
645
00:42:46,948 --> 00:42:48,679
would be picked up.
646
00:42:48,680 --> 00:42:51,979
But thousands more were left behind,
647
00:42:51,980 --> 00:42:55,745
floating helplessly at sea.
648
00:42:55,746 --> 00:42:57,778
At the American Embassy,
649
00:42:57,779 --> 00:43:00,844
Ambassador Martin cabled Henry Kissinger,
650
00:43:00,845 --> 00:43:02,512
now secretary of state,
651
00:43:02,513 --> 00:43:04,811
that "It is the unanimous opinion
652
00:43:04,812 --> 00:43:06,777
"of the senior personnel here
653
00:43:06,778 --> 00:43:11,877
that there will be no direct
or serious attack on Saigon."
654
00:43:11,878 --> 00:43:14,143
SNEPP: A lot of us began to wonder
655
00:43:14,144 --> 00:43:17,309
whether he had lost grip on reality.
656
00:43:17,310 --> 00:43:22,210
He had come down with
pneumonia in the final days.
657
00:43:22,211 --> 00:43:24,675
He was terribly enfeebled.
658
00:43:24,676 --> 00:43:27,741
And it's possible this
affected his judgment.
659
00:43:27,742 --> 00:43:31,808
NARRATOR: Evacuation planners
had quietly designated
660
00:43:31,809 --> 00:43:33,674
two spots within the embassy
661
00:43:33,675 --> 00:43:36,340
as potential helicopter landing zones...
662
00:43:36,341 --> 00:43:39,640
a courtyard that could
accommodate large choppers,
663
00:43:39,641 --> 00:43:42,041
and the helipad on the embassy roof,
664
00:43:42,042 --> 00:43:44,607
meant for smaller ones.
665
00:43:44,608 --> 00:43:48,973
An old tamarind tree stood in
the center of the courtyard.
666
00:43:48,974 --> 00:43:52,539
Again and again, the Marines
asked Ambassador Martin
667
00:43:52,540 --> 00:43:54,606
for permission to cut it down
668
00:43:54,607 --> 00:43:57,872
so as not to interfere with
the lift-offs and landings
669
00:43:57,873 --> 00:44:00,938
they were certain would soon have to begin.
670
00:44:00,939 --> 00:44:03,770
He always refused.
671
00:44:03,771 --> 00:44:07,438
That tree was a symbol of
American resolve, he said.
672
00:44:07,439 --> 00:44:11,470
Cutting it down would
send the wrong message.
673
00:44:11,471 --> 00:44:14,437
Meanwhile, General Duong Van Minh,
674
00:44:14,438 --> 00:44:16,104
who had been part of the coup
675
00:44:16,105 --> 00:44:19,802
that overthrew President
Diem 12 years earlier,
676
00:44:19,803 --> 00:44:23,603
was sworn in as the new
president of South Vietnam.
677
00:44:23,604 --> 00:44:26,503
He called for an immediate cease-fire
678
00:44:26,504 --> 00:44:32,567
and asked that Americans
leave within 24 hours.
679
00:44:32,568 --> 00:44:33,868
(explosion)
680
00:44:33,869 --> 00:44:36,967
NARRATOR: On April 29,
at 3:58 in the morning,
681
00:44:36,968 --> 00:44:39,800
North Vietnamese rockets began falling
682
00:44:39,801 --> 00:44:42,101
on Tan Son Nhut Airport.
683
00:44:42,102 --> 00:44:44,434
The North Vietnamese were just...
684
00:44:44,435 --> 00:44:46,100
walking these shells...
685
00:44:46,101 --> 00:44:48,366
these big 130-millimeter artillery shells
686
00:44:48,367 --> 00:44:49,933
all over the airfield,
687
00:44:49,934 --> 00:44:51,799
destroying the runway, basically.
688
00:44:51,800 --> 00:44:53,165
It was close enough
689
00:44:53,166 --> 00:44:54,798
that you could hear the
incoming go overhead.
690
00:44:54,799 --> 00:44:55,965
(whistling, explosion)
691
00:44:55,966 --> 00:44:58,264
NARRATOR: Two Marine guards,
692
00:44:58,265 --> 00:45:02,164
Lance Corporal Darwin Judge,
of Marshalltown, Iowa,
693
00:45:02,165 --> 00:45:06,464
and Corporal Charles McMahon,
Jr., of Woburn, Massachusetts,
694
00:45:06,465 --> 00:45:08,698
were killed in the barrage...
695
00:45:08,699 --> 00:45:13,097
the last American servicemen
to die in Vietnam.
696
00:45:13,098 --> 00:45:16,197
♪ All along the watchtower...
697
00:45:16,198 --> 00:45:18,396
VALDEZ: I still blame the ambassador.
698
00:45:18,397 --> 00:45:19,729
This shouldn't have happened.
699
00:45:19,730 --> 00:45:21,895
You know, if the ambassador
had taken action
700
00:45:21,896 --> 00:45:25,161
and gotten people out of there,
which he was supposed to,
701
00:45:25,162 --> 00:45:28,228
this would have never happened.
702
00:45:28,229 --> 00:45:30,727
NARRATOR: The runways were cratered
703
00:45:30,728 --> 00:45:32,528
and blocked by wrecked planes,
704
00:45:32,529 --> 00:45:36,760
littered with jettisoned
bombs and fuel tanks.
705
00:45:36,761 --> 00:45:41,427
The Americans had run out
of evacuation options.
706
00:45:41,428 --> 00:45:44,460
It was time to call in the helicopters
707
00:45:44,461 --> 00:45:46,860
from the offshore fleet.
708
00:45:46,861 --> 00:45:48,225
There was no way
709
00:45:48,226 --> 00:45:50,325
all of the remaining South Vietnamese
710
00:45:50,326 --> 00:45:52,527
could be evacuated.
711
00:45:54,326 --> 00:45:56,526
(chain saws buzzing)
712
00:45:56,527 --> 00:45:59,291
The tamarind tree in the embassy compound
713
00:45:59,292 --> 00:46:01,257
was finally hacked down
714
00:46:01,258 --> 00:46:04,257
so helicopters could begin landing.
715
00:46:04,258 --> 00:46:07,491
VALDEZ: So they had to chop
this big tamarind tree down,
716
00:46:07,492 --> 00:46:09,991
cut it in pieces, tow it away.
717
00:46:09,992 --> 00:46:11,991
And then they had to get
the fire department
718
00:46:11,992 --> 00:46:14,755
to wash all the debris and everything
719
00:46:14,756 --> 00:46:16,155
so when the choppers land,
720
00:46:16,156 --> 00:46:17,856
they wouldn't suck up all those debris
721
00:46:17,857 --> 00:46:20,389
into the, uh, into the engines.
722
00:46:20,390 --> 00:46:23,288
NARRATOR: Just after 11:00 a.m.,
723
00:46:23,289 --> 00:46:26,022
a prearranged signal to
evacuate was broadcast
724
00:46:26,023 --> 00:46:30,022
over a special radio
frequency in the capital:
725
00:46:30,023 --> 00:46:34,753
"The temperature in Saigon
is 105 degrees and rising."
726
00:46:34,754 --> 00:46:36,387
("White Christmas" by
Tennessee Ernie Ford playing)
727
00:46:36,388 --> 00:46:38,220
♪ I'm dreaming...
728
00:46:38,221 --> 00:46:40,720
NARRATOR: It was supposed to
be followed by Bing Crosby
729
00:46:40,721 --> 00:46:42,953
singing "White Christmas."
730
00:46:42,954 --> 00:46:45,619
But the disc jockey
couldn't find the record
731
00:46:45,620 --> 00:46:50,852
and played Tennessee Ernie
Ford's version instead.
732
00:46:50,853 --> 00:46:54,818
Americans and Vietnamese with proper papers
733
00:46:54,819 --> 00:46:57,651
gathered at pre-arranged collection points
734
00:46:57,652 --> 00:47:00,250
and boarded convoys of buses.
735
00:47:00,251 --> 00:47:04,185
Angry South Vietnamese beat
on the sides of the vehicles
736
00:47:04,186 --> 00:47:06,650
as they moved through the crowded streets
737
00:47:06,651 --> 00:47:08,783
to the airport.
738
00:47:08,784 --> 00:47:13,316
Philip Caputo, now covering
the fall of Saigon,
739
00:47:13,317 --> 00:47:16,149
was among the evacuees.
740
00:47:16,150 --> 00:47:19,315
PHILIP CAPUTO: We were evacuated
from Tan Son Nhut Air Base.
741
00:47:19,316 --> 00:47:23,382
But we drove past the embassy,
and you just saw this scrum,
742
00:47:23,383 --> 00:47:28,247
this horde of people pressing
up against the walls,
743
00:47:28,248 --> 00:47:31,182
and Marines standing on the wall
744
00:47:31,183 --> 00:47:36,546
and gun-butting people
to, uh, to keep them...
745
00:47:36,547 --> 00:47:38,981
to keep them from pouring over the walls.
746
00:47:38,982 --> 00:47:41,947
NARRATOR: The evacuees at
the airport were divided
747
00:47:41,948 --> 00:47:44,879
into helicopter teams of 50 each,
748
00:47:44,880 --> 00:47:48,112
and led down a long hallway to the tarmac.
749
00:47:48,113 --> 00:47:50,612
Someone in Caputo's group joked
750
00:47:50,613 --> 00:47:55,778
about finally seeing "light
at the end of the tunnel."
751
00:47:55,779 --> 00:47:57,845
The choppers take off.
752
00:47:57,846 --> 00:48:01,411
And they're flying, uh...
flying toward the coast.
753
00:48:01,412 --> 00:48:05,043
And you could look down
and all you could see,
754
00:48:05,044 --> 00:48:07,310
all around Saigon, all around the airfield,
755
00:48:07,311 --> 00:48:10,876
were just these plumes of
smoke from burning buildings,
756
00:48:10,877 --> 00:48:13,309
from exploding artillery shells.
757
00:48:13,310 --> 00:48:16,209
And I'll never forget going
over that coastline,
758
00:48:16,210 --> 00:48:20,241
seeing the entire 7th
Fleet... dozens and dozens...
759
00:48:20,242 --> 00:48:23,342
and this enormous fleet
out there like that.
760
00:48:23,343 --> 00:48:28,307
And I just remember this sense
of, of disbelief, completely.
761
00:48:28,308 --> 00:48:31,375
Disbelief and relief at the same time.
762
00:48:34,476 --> 00:48:36,740
VALDEZ: There were anywhere
from 10,000 to 12,000 people
763
00:48:36,741 --> 00:48:39,074
surrounding the embassy.
764
00:48:39,075 --> 00:48:42,474
We're supposed to get
Americans out of there.
765
00:48:42,475 --> 00:48:44,806
And we were supposed to
get South Vietnamese
766
00:48:44,807 --> 00:48:47,673
that worked for us in the embassy.
767
00:48:47,674 --> 00:48:50,006
The C.I.A. was behind us,
768
00:48:50,007 --> 00:48:51,305
and they were pointing at the people
769
00:48:51,306 --> 00:48:53,238
who were supposed to get out.
770
00:48:53,239 --> 00:48:56,037
But every time you reached out
to grab a specific individual,
771
00:48:56,038 --> 00:48:57,905
other people were grabbing your hands
772
00:48:57,906 --> 00:48:59,972
and trying to pull you
down with them, you know,
773
00:48:59,973 --> 00:49:01,472
so that you could help them out.
774
00:49:01,473 --> 00:49:05,136
SNEPP: Some Americans had left so rapidly,
775
00:49:05,137 --> 00:49:07,803
they'd left the radios behind.
776
00:49:07,804 --> 00:49:11,937
So their Vietnamese friends
were on the radios
777
00:49:11,938 --> 00:49:13,802
begging to be rescued.
778
00:49:13,803 --> 00:49:16,170
"I'm Han, the driver."
779
00:49:16,171 --> 00:49:19,403
"I'm Mr. Ngoc, your translator."
780
00:49:19,404 --> 00:49:24,234
I realized what the Americans
had often done in Vietnam.
781
00:49:24,235 --> 00:49:29,170
They had forgotten that
these were human beings.
782
00:49:31,301 --> 00:49:33,700
My experience in Vietnam
783
00:49:33,701 --> 00:49:39,933
had often been like a
B-52 strike from on high.
784
00:49:39,934 --> 00:49:43,866
I never had to confront the
consequences of my action.
785
00:49:43,867 --> 00:49:47,099
I could just let the bomb doors open
786
00:49:47,100 --> 00:49:51,432
and still remain detached.
787
00:49:51,433 --> 00:49:53,765
NARRATOR: Elsewhere in the embassy,
788
00:49:53,766 --> 00:49:57,931
Marines frantically destroyed
classified documents.
789
00:49:57,932 --> 00:50:01,030
VALDEZ: The top of the roof
had two big incinerators
790
00:50:01,031 --> 00:50:03,565
right underneath the helicopter pad.
791
00:50:03,566 --> 00:50:06,130
And the Marines burned classified material
792
00:50:06,131 --> 00:50:08,196
around the clock.
793
00:50:08,197 --> 00:50:10,363
But to my understanding, even when we left,
794
00:50:10,364 --> 00:50:14,096
there was still classified
material left behind.
795
00:50:14,097 --> 00:50:17,762
SNEPP: Well, when the choppers
finally began coming in,
796
00:50:17,763 --> 00:50:20,595
the downdraft ripped open those bags
797
00:50:20,596 --> 00:50:22,996
and there was classified material
798
00:50:22,997 --> 00:50:26,361
all over the parking lot.
799
00:50:26,362 --> 00:50:28,294
When the North Vietnamese arrived,
800
00:50:28,295 --> 00:50:34,093
they apparently Scotch-taped
that material back together
801
00:50:34,094 --> 00:50:36,360
and it became a blood
list that they could use
802
00:50:36,361 --> 00:50:39,693
to track down people, Vietnamese,
who'd worked for us.
803
00:50:39,694 --> 00:50:43,560
NARRATOR: Embassy officials
dumped bags of currency
804
00:50:43,561 --> 00:50:45,025
into an oil drum
805
00:50:45,026 --> 00:50:46,792
and set it afire.
806
00:50:46,793 --> 00:50:49,560
Millions of dollars in contingency funds
807
00:50:49,561 --> 00:50:51,758
went up in smoke.
808
00:50:51,759 --> 00:50:55,492
"This will be the final
message from Saigon station,"
809
00:50:55,493 --> 00:50:59,659
the C.I.A. chief Thomas
Polgar wired to Washington.
810
00:50:59,660 --> 00:51:04,590
"It has been a long fight and we have lost.
811
00:51:04,591 --> 00:51:07,523
"Those who fail to learn from history
812
00:51:07,524 --> 00:51:09,589
"are forced to repeat it.
813
00:51:09,590 --> 00:51:13,923
"Let us hope that we will not
have another Vietnam experience
814
00:51:13,924 --> 00:51:16,689
"and that we have learned our lesson.
815
00:51:16,690 --> 00:51:20,022
Saigon signing off."
816
00:51:23,589 --> 00:51:26,389
More than 50 U.S. helicopters
817
00:51:26,390 --> 00:51:29,555
now crisscrossed the sky over Saigon,
818
00:51:29,556 --> 00:51:33,087
picking up evacuees from
designated rooftops,
819
00:51:33,088 --> 00:51:35,420
as well as the embassy,
820
00:51:35,421 --> 00:51:38,753
ferrying them to the fleet far out at sea,
821
00:51:38,754 --> 00:51:40,555
then returning for more.
822
00:51:42,287 --> 00:51:45,118
Some desperate South Vietnamese officers
823
00:51:45,119 --> 00:51:47,053
also commandeered helicopters
824
00:51:47,054 --> 00:51:49,419
for themselves and their families,
825
00:51:49,420 --> 00:51:51,453
dangerously crowding the decks
826
00:51:51,454 --> 00:51:54,052
of the American aircraft carriers.
827
00:51:54,053 --> 00:51:56,985
There was no room for them.
828
00:51:56,986 --> 00:51:59,684
WILLBANKS: The image
that remains in my mind
829
00:51:59,685 --> 00:52:01,717
is the picture of the helicopter
830
00:52:01,718 --> 00:52:04,551
being pushed over the side of the carrier.
831
00:52:04,552 --> 00:52:07,783
The helicopter was everything in Vietnam.
832
00:52:07,784 --> 00:52:10,683
I mean, it was dust-off, it was resupply,
833
00:52:10,684 --> 00:52:13,115
it was fire support, it was everything.
834
00:52:13,116 --> 00:52:18,249
All I could think of was:
what a waste, what a waste.
835
00:52:18,250 --> 00:52:20,781
As I watched that all unfold,
836
00:52:20,782 --> 00:52:24,882
I, I felt responsible.
837
00:52:24,883 --> 00:52:26,114
I was ashamed.
838
00:52:26,115 --> 00:52:28,181
We had told these people
839
00:52:28,182 --> 00:52:30,448
that we would be there to support them
840
00:52:30,449 --> 00:52:31,949
and we were not.
841
00:52:37,049 --> 00:52:40,913
SNEPP: About 9:15 on the last night,
842
00:52:40,914 --> 00:52:44,147
Polgar came and he said,
"We've got to all leave.
843
00:52:44,148 --> 00:52:45,779
"We've been ordered by
headquarters to leave.
844
00:52:45,780 --> 00:52:47,479
Let's go."
845
00:52:47,480 --> 00:52:51,678
NARRATOR: Ambassador Martin had
wanted to be the last man to leave.
846
00:52:51,679 --> 00:52:55,479
But at about 4:00 in the
morning of April 30,
847
00:52:55,480 --> 00:52:59,844
a CH-46 touched down on the embassy roof.
848
00:52:59,845 --> 00:53:03,878
Its pilot carried orders
from the president himself.
849
00:53:03,879 --> 00:53:07,776
Martin was to leave, now.
850
00:53:07,777 --> 00:53:10,276
"I guess this is it," he said.
851
00:53:10,277 --> 00:53:12,444
As Martin was helped aboard,
852
00:53:12,445 --> 00:53:15,108
he was handed the furled American flag
853
00:53:15,109 --> 00:53:19,376
that had flown from the
flagstaff the previous day.
854
00:53:19,377 --> 00:53:25,375
He lifted off at 4:58 a.m.
and headed out to sea.
855
00:53:25,376 --> 00:53:29,442
President Ford had also
ordered that from then on,
856
00:53:29,443 --> 00:53:33,840
only Americans would be evacuated.
857
00:53:33,841 --> 00:53:37,740
Tens of thousands of South Vietnamese
858
00:53:37,741 --> 00:53:39,706
would be left behind,
859
00:53:39,707 --> 00:53:42,440
and more than 400 were still waiting
860
00:53:42,441 --> 00:53:44,140
in the embassy courtyard.
861
00:53:44,141 --> 00:53:46,873
Time and again, they had been assured
862
00:53:46,874 --> 00:53:50,838
helicopters were on the
way to pick them up.
863
00:53:50,839 --> 00:53:53,504
HERRINGTON: I was directed
864
00:53:53,505 --> 00:53:56,805
to stay with the Vietnamese
and keep them warm,
865
00:53:56,806 --> 00:53:59,503
meaning, "Don't give any hint
866
00:53:59,504 --> 00:54:05,170
that all these promises we
made to them are for naught."
867
00:54:05,171 --> 00:54:07,370
I felt sick at heart, I had a hard time.
868
00:54:07,371 --> 00:54:09,336
It was dark out, so I didn't have to worry
869
00:54:09,337 --> 00:54:12,470
about looking these folks in the eye.
870
00:54:12,471 --> 00:54:15,602
But I made my excuse and,
um, (speaks Vietnamese)...
871
00:54:15,603 --> 00:54:17,568
"I have to go to the bathroom."
872
00:54:17,569 --> 00:54:20,936
And left into the landscaping,
873
00:54:20,937 --> 00:54:23,835
circuitous route to the
back door of the embassy,
874
00:54:23,836 --> 00:54:25,567
to the chancery building,
875
00:54:25,568 --> 00:54:27,968
and made my way to the roof.
876
00:54:27,969 --> 00:54:32,834
NARRATOR: Some 129 Marines
remained in the compound.
877
00:54:32,835 --> 00:54:34,134
They did their best
878
00:54:34,135 --> 00:54:37,566
to pull back into the embassy
and up onto the roof
879
00:54:37,567 --> 00:54:39,134
without alerting the Vietnamese
880
00:54:39,135 --> 00:54:42,300
that they were about to be left behind.
881
00:54:42,301 --> 00:54:45,433
VALDEZ: We locked ourselves
inside the embassy
882
00:54:45,434 --> 00:54:48,832
and found ourselves up on the roof.
883
00:54:48,833 --> 00:54:51,299
It was actually after we
got up on top of the roof
884
00:54:51,300 --> 00:54:53,264
that we started seeing all
these masses of people.
885
00:54:53,265 --> 00:54:55,731
Some of them had already come
on the embassy compound.
886
00:54:55,732 --> 00:54:57,331
And they broke those doors.
887
00:54:57,332 --> 00:55:00,231
And that's how those, uh, South Vietnamese
888
00:55:00,232 --> 00:55:03,664
were able to get inside the embassy.
889
00:55:05,997 --> 00:55:10,695
RON NESSEN: This action closes a
chapter in the American experience.
890
00:55:10,696 --> 00:55:15,262
The president asks all
Americans to close ranks,
891
00:55:15,263 --> 00:55:19,561
to avoid recriminations about the past,
892
00:55:19,562 --> 00:55:22,494
and to work together on the great tasks
893
00:55:22,495 --> 00:55:25,594
that remain to be accomplished.
894
00:55:25,595 --> 00:55:30,093
Now, to, uh, give you details of
the events of the past few days
895
00:55:30,094 --> 00:55:31,961
and to answer your questions,
896
00:55:31,962 --> 00:55:33,428
Secretary of State Kissinger.
897
00:55:33,429 --> 00:55:34,760
REPORTER: Mr. Secretary, are you confident
898
00:55:34,761 --> 00:55:37,059
that all the Americans
that wanted to come out
899
00:55:37,060 --> 00:55:38,860
are out of Saigon,
900
00:55:38,861 --> 00:55:40,460
and do you have any idea
901
00:55:40,461 --> 00:55:42,259
of the number of Americans
who remain behind?
902
00:55:42,260 --> 00:55:44,992
I have no idea of the number of Americans
903
00:55:44,993 --> 00:55:46,658
that remain behind.
904
00:55:46,659 --> 00:55:50,191
Uh, I am confident that every American
905
00:55:50,192 --> 00:55:51,558
who wanted to come out,
906
00:55:51,559 --> 00:55:54,757
uh, is, is out.
907
00:55:54,758 --> 00:55:57,757
What we need now in this country
908
00:55:57,758 --> 00:56:01,758
is to heal the wounds and
to put Vietnam behind us.
909
00:56:03,458 --> 00:56:06,624
NARRATOR: An aide handed Kissinger a note.
910
00:56:06,625 --> 00:56:09,656
It said that the 129 Marines
911
00:56:09,657 --> 00:56:13,923
had somehow been left
behind on the embassy roof.
912
00:56:13,924 --> 00:56:17,389
Helicopters were dispatched
to pick them up.
913
00:56:17,390 --> 00:56:20,389
Eventually, only Sergeant Valdez
914
00:56:20,390 --> 00:56:25,187
and his ten-man embassy
security unit remained.
915
00:56:25,188 --> 00:56:27,754
But then, an hour went by
916
00:56:27,755 --> 00:56:30,354
with no sign of any more helicopters.
917
00:56:30,355 --> 00:56:32,921
Their radio was dead.
918
00:56:32,922 --> 00:56:36,121
The Marines had no way to contact the fleet
919
00:56:36,122 --> 00:56:39,552
to see if anyone was on the way.
920
00:56:39,553 --> 00:56:41,353
VALDEZ: Everything stopped.
921
00:56:41,354 --> 00:56:43,152
We're being left behind.
922
00:56:43,153 --> 00:56:46,052
People are sitting around in
their own little thoughts,
923
00:56:46,053 --> 00:56:48,852
uh, not doing too much talking.
924
00:56:48,853 --> 00:56:51,952
We pretty much decided that we
were going to fight it out,
925
00:56:51,953 --> 00:56:53,385
use these small arms that we had
926
00:56:53,386 --> 00:56:55,818
and just fight it to the end.
927
00:56:55,819 --> 00:57:00,683
We started seeing two puffs of
smoke coming from out at sea.
928
00:57:00,684 --> 00:57:03,918
As they got closer, then
we were able to determine
929
00:57:03,919 --> 00:57:05,649
that they were helicopters.
930
00:57:05,650 --> 00:57:07,917
It was a relief.
931
00:57:07,918 --> 00:57:10,316
One of the Marines, I believe
it was Staff Sergeant Sullivan,
932
00:57:10,317 --> 00:57:11,482
my assistant,
933
00:57:11,483 --> 00:57:13,182
grabbed me and started pulling me in
934
00:57:13,183 --> 00:57:14,748
as the ramp's going up.
935
00:57:14,749 --> 00:57:21,315
NARRATOR: At 7:53 a.m., April 30, 1975,
936
00:57:21,316 --> 00:57:25,714
the last helicopter lifted
off the embassy roof.
937
00:57:25,715 --> 00:57:28,348
Master Sergeant Juan Valdez
938
00:57:28,349 --> 00:57:33,079
was the last American to climb aboard.
939
00:57:33,080 --> 00:57:35,579
(sirens wailing)
940
00:57:35,580 --> 00:57:37,979
The government of South Vietnam
941
00:57:37,980 --> 00:57:40,515
had less than five hours to live.
942
00:57:44,780 --> 00:57:49,779
President Minh spoke from
the palace at mid-morning.
943
00:57:49,780 --> 00:57:53,577
He urged what was left of
the South Vietnamese Army
944
00:57:53,578 --> 00:57:55,412
to stop fighting.
945
00:57:55,413 --> 00:58:00,076
"We are here waiting," he said,
"to hand over the authority
946
00:58:00,077 --> 00:58:04,244
in order to stop useless bloodshed."
947
00:59:25,603 --> 00:59:27,534
NARRATOR: At noon,
948
00:59:27,535 --> 00:59:31,466
North Vietnamese tanks
flying Viet Cong flags
949
00:59:31,467 --> 00:59:33,367
smashed their way through the gates
950
00:59:33,368 --> 00:59:35,301
of the presidential palace.
951
00:59:37,566 --> 00:59:40,732
Within hours, victorious soldiers
952
00:59:40,733 --> 00:59:44,533
were calling Saigon "Ho Chi Minh City."
953
00:59:47,433 --> 00:59:51,964
All over town, ARVN soldiers
tore off their uniforms
954
00:59:51,965 --> 00:59:55,730
and did their best to melt into the crowds.
955
00:59:55,731 --> 00:59:57,998
Families burned their photo albums
956
00:59:57,999 --> 00:59:59,864
so there would be no evidence
957
00:59:59,865 --> 01:00:04,764
that their sons or husbands had
ever fought for South Vietnam.
958
01:00:07,063 --> 01:00:11,296
Colonel Tran Ngoc Toan had
been fighting the communists
959
01:00:11,297 --> 01:00:13,396
for more than 12 years,
960
01:00:13,397 --> 01:00:15,362
and had survived terrible wounds
961
01:00:15,363 --> 01:00:18,128
suffered at the Battle of Binh Gia.
962
01:00:18,129 --> 01:00:20,528
He was leading what was left
963
01:00:20,529 --> 01:00:23,794
of the 4th South Vietnamese
Marine Battalion
964
01:00:23,795 --> 01:00:28,895
near Bien Hoa, 20 miles east of Saigon.
965
01:00:28,896 --> 01:00:31,693
His commanding general had long since
966
01:00:31,694 --> 01:00:36,059
bribed his way aboard a
ship and fled the country.
967
01:00:36,060 --> 01:00:40,859
An American friend had urged
Toan to get out, too.
968
01:00:40,860 --> 01:00:42,760
He refused.
969
01:01:25,489 --> 01:01:28,553
NARRATOR: A South Vietnamese police officer
970
01:01:28,554 --> 01:01:30,754
walked to a memorial built to honor
971
01:01:30,755 --> 01:01:34,286
those who had fallen
defending South Vietnam.
972
01:01:34,287 --> 01:01:37,420
He saluted it, stood there for a time,
973
01:01:37,421 --> 01:01:41,019
and then shot himself in the head.
974
01:01:41,020 --> 01:01:44,386
DUONG VAN MAI ELLIOTT: It
was a very messy ending
975
01:01:44,387 --> 01:01:47,319
to a very messy war.
976
01:01:47,320 --> 01:01:49,752
I felt a sense of relief,
977
01:01:49,753 --> 01:01:53,650
but also a sense of sadness when it ended.
978
01:01:53,651 --> 01:01:58,617
I felt relief that the
killing, destruction,
979
01:01:58,618 --> 01:02:00,884
finally came to an end,
980
01:02:00,885 --> 01:02:03,084
and I didn't care which side won.
981
01:02:03,085 --> 01:02:05,549
To me, Vietnam won.
982
01:02:05,550 --> 01:02:07,516
Vietnamese people won
983
01:02:07,517 --> 01:02:10,849
because they finally could live normally.
984
01:02:10,850 --> 01:02:16,483
And sad because I saw that
my family was again fleeing,
985
01:02:16,484 --> 01:02:18,547
and this time from their homeland,
986
01:02:18,548 --> 01:02:22,014
and their future was very uncertain.
987
01:02:22,015 --> 01:02:25,147
And I knew that with the
communists taking over,
988
01:02:25,148 --> 01:02:29,646
Vietnamese society would
be changed drastically.
989
01:02:29,647 --> 01:02:32,247
NARRATOR: Lo Khac Tam had been fighting
990
01:02:32,248 --> 01:02:35,980
in the North Vietnamese Army
for nearly ten years now,
991
01:02:35,981 --> 01:02:39,380
beginning with the bloody
clash in the la Drang Valley,
992
01:02:39,381 --> 01:02:43,580
the first full-scale battle
of the American war.
993
01:02:43,581 --> 01:02:48,012
Now he was watching that war's end.
994
01:03:21,641 --> 01:03:25,241
In Vietnam, we finally have
reached the end of the tunnel,
995
01:03:25,242 --> 01:03:27,575
and there is no light there.
996
01:03:27,576 --> 01:03:31,173
What is there, perhaps, was
best said by President Ford,
997
01:03:31,174 --> 01:03:33,606
"a war that is finished."
998
01:03:33,607 --> 01:03:37,240
LEWIS SORLEY: I happened
to be at a conference
999
01:03:37,241 --> 01:03:38,705
at Tufts University,
1000
01:03:38,706 --> 01:03:41,406
and the dean there was a former ambassador
1001
01:03:41,407 --> 01:03:43,373
who spoke to us late on that day,
1002
01:03:43,374 --> 01:03:45,772
as it turned out, the fateful day.
1003
01:03:45,773 --> 01:03:49,104
And he said he had just
come back from Washington,
1004
01:03:49,105 --> 01:03:52,838
where the spring weather was beautiful
1005
01:03:52,839 --> 01:03:55,536
and the daffodils were in bloom,
1006
01:03:55,537 --> 01:04:01,838
to Boston, where it was gloomy
and gray as it was in his heart.
1007
01:04:03,738 --> 01:04:06,970
And people hissed him and booed him.
1008
01:04:06,971 --> 01:04:10,370
I was there in uniform.
1009
01:04:10,371 --> 01:04:12,736
One of my great regrets
was that I did not get up
1010
01:04:12,737 --> 01:04:14,768
and start laying waste to those people
1011
01:04:14,769 --> 01:04:16,168
who disrespected the ambassador
1012
01:04:16,169 --> 01:04:19,235
and his sorrow at the
fall of South Vietnam.
1013
01:04:19,236 --> 01:04:21,735
I got a call from the V.V.A.W.
national office
1014
01:04:21,736 --> 01:04:24,401
from some friends of
mine from the old days.
1015
01:04:24,402 --> 01:04:26,500
They were having a big celebration,
1016
01:04:26,501 --> 01:04:29,633
drinking booze and, "Ah, well,
it's a great day, isn't it?"
1017
01:04:29,634 --> 01:04:32,666
And I said, "Are you nuts?"
1018
01:04:32,667 --> 01:04:35,666
I said, "No, it's not a great day."
1019
01:04:35,667 --> 01:04:38,666
To see America leaving like that,
1020
01:04:38,667 --> 01:04:43,431
after we'd given almost 60,000
of our sons and daughters,
1021
01:04:43,432 --> 01:04:47,031
that wasn't something to celebrate.
1022
01:04:47,032 --> 01:04:48,998
I knew we were abandoning
1023
01:04:48,999 --> 01:04:52,565
millions of South Vietnamese
that had trusted us,
1024
01:04:52,566 --> 01:04:55,465
thrown in their lot with us.
1025
01:04:55,466 --> 01:04:58,696
That wasn't anything to celebrate.
1026
01:04:58,697 --> 01:05:01,163
I thought it was just one
of the saddest moments
1027
01:05:01,164 --> 01:05:04,897
I'd ever seen in American history.
1028
01:05:04,898 --> 01:05:07,028
So when some future
politician, for some reason,
1029
01:05:07,029 --> 01:05:11,128
feels the need to drag
this country into a war,
1030
01:05:11,129 --> 01:05:13,028
he might come out here to Arlington,
1031
01:05:13,029 --> 01:05:15,229
and stand maybe right over there somewhere,
1032
01:05:15,230 --> 01:05:19,095
to make his announcement and
to tell what he has in mind.
1033
01:06:48,818 --> 01:06:51,617
(cheering)
1034
01:06:51,618 --> 01:06:55,084
TOM VALLELY: In Vietnam, the
Communist Party is triumphant.
1035
01:06:55,085 --> 01:06:57,851
And they have exceptionalism, too.
1036
01:06:57,852 --> 01:07:01,717
And their exceptionalism gets in their way
1037
01:07:01,718 --> 01:07:05,482
just like our exceptionalism
got in our way.
1038
01:07:05,483 --> 01:07:09,382
So they unify the country
in a military sense,
1039
01:07:09,383 --> 01:07:13,849
and then they, they don't really
unify the country after that.
1040
01:07:13,850 --> 01:07:18,448
They, they try, but they fail.
1041
01:07:18,449 --> 01:07:21,313
NARRATOR: In the end,
there was no bloodbath
1042
01:07:21,314 --> 01:07:24,380
on the scale many had feared,
1043
01:07:24,381 --> 01:07:28,947
but hundreds, perhaps thousands,
of people in the countryside
1044
01:07:28,948 --> 01:07:30,647
are thought to have been killed
1045
01:07:30,648 --> 01:07:35,979
in individual acts of revenge
or political retaliation.
1046
01:07:35,980 --> 01:07:39,146
Those who had served the Thieu regime,
1047
01:07:39,147 --> 01:07:41,811
from generals to ordinary clerks,
1048
01:07:41,812 --> 01:07:45,546
were required to undergo re-education.
1049
01:07:45,547 --> 01:07:47,477
Enlisted men were assured
1050
01:07:47,478 --> 01:07:51,145
they would only have to submit
to three days of "study."
1051
01:07:51,146 --> 01:07:55,678
Officers needn't attend
for more than a month.
1052
01:08:27,607 --> 01:08:29,841
NARRATOR: A million and a half people
1053
01:08:29,842 --> 01:08:34,640
are believed to have undergone
some form of indoctrination.
1054
01:08:34,641 --> 01:08:39,206
ARVN cemeteries were
bulldozed or padlocked,
1055
01:08:39,207 --> 01:08:42,205
as if the memory of an
independent South Vietnam,
1056
01:08:42,206 --> 01:08:45,104
and those who had died for that cause,
1057
01:08:45,105 --> 01:08:48,339
could both be obliterated.
1058
01:08:48,340 --> 01:08:49,937
DUONG VAN MAI ELLIOTT: The communists,
1059
01:08:49,938 --> 01:08:53,370
in their effort to erase vestiges
1060
01:08:53,371 --> 01:08:55,071
of the former regime,
1061
01:08:55,072 --> 01:08:59,169
have not allowed the South Vietnamese
1062
01:08:59,170 --> 01:09:02,669
who lost their sons in the war
1063
01:09:02,670 --> 01:09:08,235
to mourn, to have their graves
and to honor their memory.
1064
01:09:08,236 --> 01:09:11,901
It caused a division
that lasts to this day,
1065
01:09:11,902 --> 01:09:16,900
that the winners would not
accommodate the losers
1066
01:09:16,901 --> 01:09:18,836
in some way.
1067
01:09:31,967 --> 01:09:37,398
NARRATOR: After 30 years of war,
much of Vietnam lay in ruins.
1068
01:09:37,399 --> 01:09:40,133
Three million people are
thought to have died,
1069
01:09:40,134 --> 01:09:42,432
North and South.
1070
01:09:42,433 --> 01:09:46,198
Still more had been wounded.
1071
01:09:46,199 --> 01:09:50,532
Thousands of children fathered
by American servicemen
1072
01:09:50,533 --> 01:09:53,463
had been left behind.
1073
01:09:53,464 --> 01:09:59,896
Villages needed to be rebuilt,
land had to be reclaimed.
1074
01:09:59,897 --> 01:10:03,362
Cities were choked with refugees.
1075
01:10:03,363 --> 01:10:06,263
Millions were without work.
1076
01:10:06,264 --> 01:10:10,629
President Ford imposed an economic embargo.
1077
01:10:10,630 --> 01:10:16,594
Washington refused to recognize
the new government of Vietnam.
1078
01:10:16,595 --> 01:10:19,427
But Le Duan and his allies on the Politburo
1079
01:10:19,428 --> 01:10:21,860
remained optimistic.
1080
01:10:21,861 --> 01:10:25,194
"Nothing more can happen,"
one committee member said.
1081
01:10:25,195 --> 01:10:27,892
"The problems we face now are trifles
1082
01:10:27,893 --> 01:10:31,260
compared to those in the past."
1083
01:10:31,261 --> 01:10:34,127
Le Duan resolved, with Soviet help,
1084
01:10:34,128 --> 01:10:37,192
to turn all of Vietnam into what he called
1085
01:10:37,193 --> 01:10:42,091
an "impregnable outpost
of the socialist system."
1086
01:10:42,092 --> 01:10:46,390
Hanoi forcibly collectivized
agriculture in the South,
1087
01:10:46,391 --> 01:10:48,857
virtually abolished capitalism,
1088
01:10:48,858 --> 01:10:51,457
nationalized industries,
1089
01:10:51,458 --> 01:10:53,991
and appointed planners to run it all
1090
01:10:53,992 --> 01:10:57,524
along strict communist lines.
1091
01:10:57,525 --> 01:11:01,656
The result would be economic disaster.
1092
01:11:01,657 --> 01:11:06,623
Inflation rose as high as 700% a year.
1093
01:11:06,624 --> 01:11:09,289
People starved.
1094
01:11:38,286 --> 01:11:41,252
NARRATOR: To compound its problems,
1095
01:11:41,253 --> 01:11:44,918
Vietnam found itself, once again, at war,
1096
01:11:44,919 --> 01:11:48,551
caught between the interests
of the two communist powers
1097
01:11:48,552 --> 01:11:51,551
that had once been its staunchest allies,
1098
01:11:51,552 --> 01:11:54,184
China and the Soviet Union.
1099
01:11:54,185 --> 01:11:55,518
(gunshot, man yells)
1100
01:11:55,519 --> 01:11:58,683
After the brutal Maoist regime in Cambodia
1101
01:11:58,684 --> 01:12:00,282
raided border areas,
1102
01:12:00,283 --> 01:12:04,449
Vietnamese troops, with Soviet
arms and encouragement,
1103
01:12:04,450 --> 01:12:09,148
crossed the frontier in
1978 and overthrew it.
1104
01:12:09,149 --> 01:12:11,381
A frustrating ten-year
1105
01:12:11,382 --> 01:12:13,982
counterinsurgency campaign followed
1106
01:12:13,983 --> 01:12:18,714
that some called "Vietnam's Vietnam."
1107
01:12:18,715 --> 01:12:20,647
Before it was over,
1108
01:12:20,648 --> 01:12:24,547
the Vietnamese would lose
some 50,000 more men,
1109
01:12:24,548 --> 01:12:29,713
almost as many as the Americans
had lost in their war.
1110
01:12:29,714 --> 01:12:31,114
(explosions and gunfire)
1111
01:12:31,115 --> 01:12:33,078
Meanwhile, communist China,
1112
01:12:33,079 --> 01:12:37,046
determined to punish Vietnam
for invading Cambodia,
1113
01:12:37,047 --> 01:12:39,746
and to show Moscow it would
not have a free hand
1114
01:12:39,747 --> 01:12:41,546
in Southeast Asia,
1115
01:12:41,547 --> 01:12:46,144
sent 85,000 troops storming
into northern Vietnam.
1116
01:12:46,145 --> 01:12:49,512
They devastated areas along the border
1117
01:12:49,513 --> 01:12:53,312
before the Vietnamese pushed them back.
1118
01:12:55,312 --> 01:12:58,977
ED BRADLEY: The South China Sea, 1978.
1119
01:12:58,978 --> 01:13:02,709
They come ashore at the
rate of 10,000 a month,
1120
01:13:02,710 --> 01:13:05,275
much faster than the United
States or any other nation
1121
01:13:05,276 --> 01:13:07,176
is willing to accept them.
1122
01:13:07,177 --> 01:13:11,274
They come chasing an elusive memory:
1123
01:13:11,275 --> 01:13:13,475
the promise of America.
1124
01:13:13,476 --> 01:13:18,873
NARRATOR: A million and a half people
would eventually flee Vietnam:
1125
01:13:18,874 --> 01:13:21,974
supporters of the old Saigon regime,
1126
01:13:21,975 --> 01:13:24,008
refugees from the renewed fighting
1127
01:13:24,009 --> 01:13:26,073
along the Cambodian border,
1128
01:13:26,074 --> 01:13:28,939
and ethnic Chinese residents of Vietnam,
1129
01:13:28,940 --> 01:13:33,439
whom the new government had
treated especially harshly.
1130
01:13:33,440 --> 01:13:37,705
Hundreds of thousands of
the boat people died.
1131
01:13:37,706 --> 01:13:40,039
Others suffered in refugee camps
1132
01:13:40,040 --> 01:13:42,339
throughout Southeast Asia.
1133
01:13:46,606 --> 01:13:51,738
Some 400,000 eventually made it to America,
1134
01:13:51,739 --> 01:13:54,569
where they settled in nearly every state,
1135
01:13:54,570 --> 01:13:57,470
industrious, entrepreneurial,
1136
01:13:57,471 --> 01:14:01,304
more eager to take part in
American political life
1137
01:14:01,305 --> 01:14:04,902
and more likely to become American citizens
1138
01:14:04,903 --> 01:14:08,402
than other immigrant groups from Asia.
1139
01:14:08,403 --> 01:14:12,468
But for that first generation
of Vietnamese Americans,
1140
01:14:12,469 --> 01:14:17,503
memories of their homeland
could never be erased.
1141
01:15:04,629 --> 01:15:06,462
KARL MARLANTES: I remember I was
1142
01:15:06,463 --> 01:15:08,596
with one of my daughters, uh... (chuckles)
1143
01:15:08,597 --> 01:15:10,928
at an intersection and
some guy came up behind me
1144
01:15:10,929 --> 01:15:14,060
and blasted the horn.
1145
01:15:14,061 --> 01:15:16,260
When I came to my senses,
1146
01:15:16,261 --> 01:15:18,295
I was on the hood of his car,
1147
01:15:18,296 --> 01:15:21,360
about to, trying to kick his windshield in.
1148
01:15:21,361 --> 01:15:23,626
And I went... and there's
people all over looking at me.
1149
01:15:23,627 --> 01:15:25,393
I mean, this is crazy. This is crazy.
1150
01:15:25,394 --> 01:15:27,259
And then I started going,
"Well, this is weird."
1151
01:15:27,260 --> 01:15:29,660
I sort of slinked back
to my car and, you know,
1152
01:15:29,661 --> 01:15:31,358
my daughter, she's about
four, looking at me,
1153
01:15:31,359 --> 01:15:32,493
"Wow, what's that all about?"
1154
01:15:32,494 --> 01:15:33,925
And I go, "What is that all about?"
1155
01:15:33,926 --> 01:15:35,159
I had no idea.
1156
01:15:35,160 --> 01:15:37,527
I had no idea that it was
even related to the war.
1157
01:15:39,626 --> 01:15:43,525
NARRATOR: It is as old as war itself.
1158
01:15:43,526 --> 01:15:46,493
The ancient Greeks called
it "divine madness."
1159
01:15:49,292 --> 01:15:54,457
It was "soldier's heart" in the Civil War,
1160
01:15:54,458 --> 01:15:59,156
"shell shock" during the First World War
1161
01:15:59,157 --> 01:16:01,491
and "combat fatigue" in the Second.
1162
01:16:05,457 --> 01:16:08,621
Following Vietnam, it was given a new name,
1163
01:16:08,622 --> 01:16:12,054
Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder...
1164
01:16:12,055 --> 01:16:14,789
PTSD.
1165
01:16:14,790 --> 01:16:19,521
MARLANTES: And what you learn
is that PTSD doesn't go away.
1166
01:16:19,522 --> 01:16:22,887
But now if someone honks the horn,
1167
01:16:22,888 --> 01:16:24,387
and it startles me, I'm still...
1168
01:16:24,388 --> 01:16:26,087
My heart rate's still going to go up,
1169
01:16:26,088 --> 01:16:28,119
and it'll be there for five
minutes and I'm like this.
1170
01:16:28,120 --> 01:16:30,852
But, "Ten, nine, it's just some asshole,
1171
01:16:30,853 --> 01:16:33,052
"he's had a bad day at
work, eight, seven, six,
1172
01:16:33,053 --> 01:16:34,918
"it's not... no one's
shooting at you, you're safe,
1173
01:16:34,919 --> 01:16:36,551
it's seven, six, five,
four, three, two, one."
1174
01:16:36,552 --> 01:16:38,185
And I can control it,
1175
01:16:38,186 --> 01:16:39,551
whereas I couldn't do it before
1176
01:16:39,552 --> 01:16:41,619
because I didn't understand
what was going on.
1177
01:16:43,219 --> 01:16:45,750
NARRATOR: Adding to the
pain many veterans felt
1178
01:16:45,751 --> 01:16:50,018
was their country's eagerness
to forget the war.
1179
01:16:50,019 --> 01:16:52,550
There were few parades.
1180
01:16:54,050 --> 01:16:59,651
In many ways, everyone came
home from Vietnam alone.
1181
01:17:01,450 --> 01:17:03,149
When I got home,
1182
01:17:03,150 --> 01:17:04,615
and my mom and dad were there,
1183
01:17:04,616 --> 01:17:07,182
my brothers and sisters, my wife.
1184
01:17:07,183 --> 01:17:08,883
And we're embracing and...
1185
01:17:11,583 --> 01:17:16,282
I couldn't relate to my wife
or my mother what I had seen,
1186
01:17:16,283 --> 01:17:19,680
what I had done in Vietnam.
1187
01:17:19,681 --> 01:17:22,014
I could've talked to my brothers about it,
1188
01:17:22,015 --> 01:17:25,281
but they, they knew I didn't want to.
1189
01:17:25,282 --> 01:17:28,213
And so it just, uh,
something unsaid, you know.
1190
01:17:28,214 --> 01:17:30,280
"Welcome back, Vince.
1191
01:17:30,281 --> 01:17:33,246
You've been through the, the
wringer, but welcome back."
1192
01:17:36,179 --> 01:17:38,544
NARRATOR: In April 1981,
1193
01:17:38,545 --> 01:17:41,212
a panel of eight architects and sculptors
1194
01:17:41,213 --> 01:17:43,279
gathered in an airplane hangar
1195
01:17:43,280 --> 01:17:46,944
at Andrews Air Force
Base outside Washington.
1196
01:17:46,945 --> 01:17:49,877
They were there to choose
the winning design
1197
01:17:49,878 --> 01:17:53,043
for a Vietnam memorial
for the nation's capital
1198
01:17:53,044 --> 01:17:55,778
from more than 1,400 submissions.
1199
01:17:59,578 --> 01:18:03,709
The memorial was the brainchild
of a single stubborn veteran,
1200
01:18:03,710 --> 01:18:06,741
a former rifleman named Jan Scruggs,
1201
01:18:06,742 --> 01:18:10,241
who, after suffering a
frightening flashback,
1202
01:18:10,242 --> 01:18:13,107
told his wife he wanted
to "build a memorial
1203
01:18:13,108 --> 01:18:16,441
"to all the guys who served in Vietnam.
1204
01:18:16,442 --> 01:18:19,575
It'll have the name of everyone killed."
1205
01:18:19,576 --> 01:18:21,173
With other veterans,
1206
01:18:21,174 --> 01:18:24,106
he established a nonprofit organization,
1207
01:18:24,107 --> 01:18:26,806
the Vietnam Veterans Memorial Fund,
1208
01:18:26,807 --> 01:18:30,973
and went to work collecting
money and making plans.
1209
01:18:30,974 --> 01:18:35,639
In the end, some 650,000 Americans
1210
01:18:35,640 --> 01:18:39,205
would contribute more than $8 million.
1211
01:18:39,206 --> 01:18:43,972
The judges chose submission number 1026.
1212
01:18:43,973 --> 01:18:45,205
(applause)
1213
01:18:45,206 --> 01:18:47,205
SUSAN PETERSON: 21-year-old Maya Ying Lin,
1214
01:18:47,206 --> 01:18:49,370
an architect student at Yale University,
1215
01:18:49,371 --> 01:18:51,637
got the $20,000 prize.
1216
01:18:51,638 --> 01:18:53,571
Her winning design is comprised
1217
01:18:53,572 --> 01:18:56,137
of two elongated triangles
of black granite,
1218
01:18:56,138 --> 01:18:58,703
inset into a hill and
inscribed with the names
1219
01:18:58,704 --> 01:19:03,570
of the 57,692 men and women
who died in the war.
1220
01:19:03,571 --> 01:19:07,969
Lin, whose parents emigrated
from China in the 1940s to Ohio,
1221
01:19:07,970 --> 01:19:09,534
thought she wouldn't win
1222
01:19:09,535 --> 01:19:12,069
because her design was too
strange and too strong.
1223
01:19:12,070 --> 01:19:15,300
I had a general idea that I
wanted to describe a journey,
1224
01:19:15,301 --> 01:19:18,568
a journey that would make
you experience death
1225
01:19:18,569 --> 01:19:21,134
and where you'd have to be an observer,
1226
01:19:21,135 --> 01:19:23,899
where you could never really
fully be with the dead.
1227
01:19:23,900 --> 01:19:25,967
It wasn't going to be something
that was going to say,
1228
01:19:25,968 --> 01:19:27,832
"It's all right, it's all over,"
1229
01:19:27,833 --> 01:19:29,000
because it's not.
1230
01:19:29,001 --> 01:19:31,898
NARRATOR: Differences about the war
1231
01:19:31,899 --> 01:19:36,066
colored people's feelings
about the proposed design.
1232
01:19:36,067 --> 01:19:39,566
Some who believed that the war
had been unjust and immoral
1233
01:19:39,567 --> 01:19:43,132
feared the monument was
somehow meant to glorify it.
1234
01:19:44,598 --> 01:19:48,164
Others feared its stark
design failed to do justice
1235
01:19:48,165 --> 01:19:52,130
to the cause for which
Americans had fought.
1236
01:19:52,131 --> 01:19:54,829
The writer Tom Wolfe dismissed it
1237
01:19:54,830 --> 01:19:57,930
as "a tribute to Jane Fonda."
1238
01:19:57,931 --> 01:19:59,929
TOM CARHART: I don't care
about artistic perceptions.
1239
01:19:59,930 --> 01:20:02,063
One needs no artistic education
1240
01:20:02,064 --> 01:20:04,629
to see this memorial design for what it is:
1241
01:20:04,630 --> 01:20:07,228
a black scar.
1242
01:20:07,229 --> 01:20:09,161
Black, the universal color
1243
01:20:09,162 --> 01:20:11,661
of sorrow and shame and degradation
1244
01:20:11,662 --> 01:20:14,495
in all races and all societies worldwide.
1245
01:20:14,496 --> 01:20:17,593
In a hole, hidden as if out of shame.
1246
01:20:17,594 --> 01:20:20,360
JANICE CONNALLY: Mr. Chairman,
members of the commission,
1247
01:20:20,361 --> 01:20:22,061
I speak as an individual,
1248
01:20:22,062 --> 01:20:24,660
a member from the general public.
1249
01:20:24,661 --> 01:20:29,292
What are the memorable images
from the war in Vietnam?
1250
01:20:29,293 --> 01:20:30,892
A guerrilla,
1251
01:20:30,893 --> 01:20:33,493
shot at point-blank range.
1252
01:20:33,494 --> 01:20:36,125
A naked girl, afire, running,
1253
01:20:36,126 --> 01:20:38,260
screaming down a dusty road.
1254
01:20:39,792 --> 01:20:41,925
I think Maya Lin was right
1255
01:20:41,926 --> 01:20:45,323
in going beyond these kinds of images.
1256
01:20:45,324 --> 01:20:50,191
She resolved all the pain and
conflict of that unhappy time
1257
01:20:50,192 --> 01:20:54,957
in a simple message of
sacrifice and quiet heroism.
1258
01:20:54,958 --> 01:20:59,856
NARRATOR: In an official vote of
support for Maya Lin's design,
1259
01:20:59,857 --> 01:21:03,588
the American Gold Star
Mothers spoke for many.
1260
01:21:03,589 --> 01:21:05,489
"Nowadays," they said,
1261
01:21:05,490 --> 01:21:08,456
"patriotism is a complicated matter.
1262
01:21:08,457 --> 01:21:10,587
"But perhaps that is why
1263
01:21:10,588 --> 01:21:12,587
"the V-shaped, black granite lines
1264
01:21:12,588 --> 01:21:16,055
"merging gently with the sloping earth
1265
01:21:16,056 --> 01:21:18,587
"convey the only point about the war
1266
01:21:18,588 --> 01:21:20,754
"on which people may agree:
1267
01:21:20,755 --> 01:21:24,086
that those who died should be remembered."
1268
01:21:24,087 --> 01:21:27,421
("Bridge Over Troubled Water"
by Simon and Garfunkel playing)
1269
01:21:46,185 --> 01:21:50,017
♪ When you're weary
1270
01:21:52,618 --> 01:21:54,917
♪ Feeling small
1271
01:21:57,551 --> 01:22:04,982
♪ When tears are in your eyes
1272
01:22:04,983 --> 01:22:13,147
♪ I'll dry them all.
1273
01:22:13,148 --> 01:22:17,813
RION CAUSEY: As you got out of the
car and you approached the wall,
1274
01:22:17,814 --> 01:22:22,380
the intensity of which, it grabs you...
1275
01:22:23,647 --> 01:22:25,048
You go up...
1276
01:22:28,347 --> 01:22:29,879
You see the names,
1277
01:22:29,880 --> 01:22:31,180
you touch the names...
1278
01:22:33,846 --> 01:22:35,912
(crying): It's intense.
1279
01:22:35,913 --> 01:22:42,945
♪ Bridge over troubled water
1280
01:22:42,946 --> 01:22:46,479
♪ I will lay me down.
1281
01:22:55,577 --> 01:22:56,843
SORLEY: I did not like
1282
01:22:56,844 --> 01:22:58,676
the Vietnam wall.
1283
01:22:58,677 --> 01:23:02,543
I considered it an ugly, black ditch
1284
01:23:02,544 --> 01:23:06,307
and that it said the only people that, uh...
1285
01:23:06,308 --> 01:23:08,542
to be commemorated are the dead,
1286
01:23:08,543 --> 01:23:13,008
not because they're heroes,
but because they're victims.
1287
01:23:14,508 --> 01:23:17,541
I didn't go.
1288
01:23:17,542 --> 01:23:20,806
Until...
1289
01:23:20,807 --> 01:23:23,006
one year...
1290
01:23:23,007 --> 01:23:26,139
they were going to put the
wreath in front of...
1291
01:23:26,140 --> 01:23:28,272
the name of my roommate.
1292
01:23:28,273 --> 01:23:31,005
(voice breaking): I had, I had to go.
1293
01:23:31,006 --> 01:23:34,439
So I've gone every year since then
1294
01:23:34,440 --> 01:23:38,338
to remember those we, we lost.
1295
01:23:38,339 --> 01:23:40,338
And, um...
1296
01:23:40,339 --> 01:23:41,971
I walk down to the far left
1297
01:23:41,972 --> 01:23:46,771
and I run my fingers over that name.
1298
01:23:53,503 --> 01:23:55,769
You go to that wall,
1299
01:23:55,770 --> 01:23:58,970
and even my son, who was nine
years old when I first took him,
1300
01:23:58,971 --> 01:24:02,102
and you see over 58,000 names,
1301
01:24:02,103 --> 01:24:07,469
and you know that unwritten
behind or beside each name,
1302
01:24:07,470 --> 01:24:11,668
there's a mother or a father
or a wife or a daughter
1303
01:24:11,669 --> 01:24:15,867
whose lives were forever shattered
1304
01:24:15,868 --> 01:24:18,535
by that damn war.
1305
01:24:22,935 --> 01:24:27,565
NANCY BIBERMAN: I've been to
the wall, more than once.
1306
01:24:27,566 --> 01:24:29,533
When I look back at the war and, you know,
1307
01:24:29,534 --> 01:24:31,632
think of the horrible things, you know,
1308
01:24:31,633 --> 01:24:35,131
we said to, you know,
vets who were returning,
1309
01:24:35,132 --> 01:24:38,997
you know, calling them
"baby killers" and worse,
1310
01:24:38,998 --> 01:24:44,931
I, you know... I feel very sad about that.
1311
01:24:44,932 --> 01:24:48,597
I can only say that, you
know, we were kids, too,
1312
01:24:48,598 --> 01:24:51,031
you know, just like they were.
1313
01:24:51,032 --> 01:24:53,862
It grieves me, it grieves me today.
1314
01:24:53,863 --> 01:24:57,495
It pains me to think of
the things that I said
1315
01:24:57,496 --> 01:24:59,062
and that we said.
1316
01:24:59,063 --> 01:25:02,562
And I'm sorry.
1317
01:25:04,896 --> 01:25:06,963
I'm sorry.
1318
01:25:14,029 --> 01:25:15,229
(bird calling)
1319
01:25:18,095 --> 01:25:19,827
CAROL CROCKER: I didn't want to go.
1320
01:25:21,161 --> 01:25:27,893
And it was a beautiful summer morning.
1321
01:25:27,894 --> 01:25:33,291
Went to the Lincoln Memorial first.
1322
01:25:33,292 --> 01:25:37,624
A comforting place to be.
1323
01:25:37,625 --> 01:25:39,757
And...
1324
01:25:39,758 --> 01:25:44,790
And then crossed the street and
walked in towards the entrance.
1325
01:25:44,791 --> 01:25:48,189
And, as you know, at first, you
can't really see the wall,
1326
01:25:48,190 --> 01:25:51,890
and you're coming down
into the grassy hill.
1327
01:25:51,891 --> 01:25:56,788
And when I caught sight of it,
1328
01:25:56,789 --> 01:25:59,924
I literally lost my breath.
1329
01:26:01,056 --> 01:26:03,724
Of course, I wept.
1330
01:26:05,822 --> 01:26:10,287
I had help getting lifted
up so I could touch it.
1331
01:26:10,288 --> 01:26:12,988
I found my brother's name.
1332
01:26:17,155 --> 01:26:19,253
I looked at my brother's name
1333
01:26:19,254 --> 01:26:23,454
in the company of all those other people.
1334
01:26:25,553 --> 01:26:28,252
There was sadness.
1335
01:26:28,253 --> 01:26:32,818
But now he wasn't alone, either.
1336
01:26:32,819 --> 01:26:36,419
He was in the company of people.
1337
01:26:36,420 --> 01:26:39,118
And he was there
1338
01:26:39,119 --> 01:26:43,584
for people to know and to think about.
1339
01:26:43,585 --> 01:26:45,350
And he wasn't forgotten.
1340
01:26:45,351 --> 01:26:47,151
And he wasn't lost.
1341
01:26:47,152 --> 01:26:51,451
It was incredibly healing
and freeing for me.
1342
01:26:59,316 --> 01:27:01,548
As I was walking towards it
from the reflecting pool,
1343
01:27:01,549 --> 01:27:04,449
there were so many names on those walls.
1344
01:27:04,450 --> 01:27:08,480
And all of a sudden, my throat swole up,
1345
01:27:08,481 --> 01:27:10,415
and I thought, "I can't do this.
1346
01:27:10,416 --> 01:27:12,614
I can't do this right now."
1347
01:27:12,615 --> 01:27:15,847
And I collapsed.
1348
01:27:19,215 --> 01:27:23,314
And all the tears I'd been holding back...
1349
01:27:25,380 --> 01:27:27,446
I didn't cry, I sobbed.
1350
01:27:27,447 --> 01:27:31,446
I was on my knees, sobbing.
1351
01:27:31,447 --> 01:27:34,913
I couldn't stop, I couldn't get my breath.
1352
01:27:37,678 --> 01:27:42,776
And I was so grateful to
God that it was there.
1353
01:27:42,777 --> 01:27:45,711
I thought,
1354
01:27:45,712 --> 01:27:48,444
"This is going to save lives.
1355
01:27:48,445 --> 01:27:51,343
This is going to save lives."
1356
01:28:35,472 --> 01:28:37,905
VALLELY: I was struck by its beauty
1357
01:28:37,906 --> 01:28:40,871
and how at peace Vietnam
looked from the air.
1358
01:28:40,872 --> 01:28:43,571
I had a sense of anticipation in my body.
1359
01:28:43,572 --> 01:28:45,904
I had worked hard for
many months with others
1360
01:28:45,905 --> 01:28:50,437
to organize this trip and
to negotiate our arrival
1361
01:28:50,438 --> 01:28:51,570
with the Vietnamese government.
1362
01:28:51,571 --> 01:28:52,704
How do you do?
1363
01:28:52,705 --> 01:28:53,936
Toi ten Tom Vallely.
1364
01:28:53,937 --> 01:28:56,768
VALLELY: I came back to
Vietnam as a veteran
1365
01:28:56,769 --> 01:28:59,003
to learn from history,
1366
01:28:59,004 --> 01:29:02,069
and to see how the place had changed.
1367
01:29:02,070 --> 01:29:04,068
(laughter)
1368
01:29:04,069 --> 01:29:06,234
There had only been 200 Americans
1369
01:29:06,235 --> 01:29:07,902
that had been to Vietnam since 1975,
1370
01:29:07,903 --> 01:29:09,534
and most of them had been correspondents
1371
01:29:09,535 --> 01:29:11,202
and had been in the South.
1372
01:29:11,203 --> 01:29:13,800
(clamoring, horn honking)
1373
01:29:13,801 --> 01:29:16,766
Many of the kids, you'd
walk down the street,
1374
01:29:16,767 --> 01:29:18,567
and they'd go, "Lien Xo, lien Xo,"
1375
01:29:18,568 --> 01:29:20,067
which means "Russian."
1376
01:29:20,068 --> 01:29:21,532
And you'd go, "Nolien Xo,
1377
01:29:21,533 --> 01:29:24,099
toi la nguoi My"... "I'm an American."
1378
01:29:24,100 --> 01:29:26,765
And their face would light up,
and they'd go, "American!"
1379
01:29:26,766 --> 01:29:28,765
And it would spread like wildfire
1380
01:29:28,766 --> 01:29:30,798
through the schoolyard, or the street
1381
01:29:30,799 --> 01:29:32,764
that Americans were here.
1382
01:29:32,765 --> 01:29:35,264
And they'd come out and they'd
be very, very friendly.
1383
01:29:35,265 --> 01:29:38,931
(laughter)
1384
01:29:38,932 --> 01:29:40,131
Goodbye.
1385
01:29:40,132 --> 01:29:42,730
Goodbye! Goodbye!
1386
01:29:42,731 --> 01:29:44,199
(laughter)
1387
01:29:47,631 --> 01:29:52,596
NARRATOR: Tom Vallely had served
with the Marines in Vietnam.
1388
01:29:52,597 --> 01:29:58,295
16 years later, the country drew him back.
1389
01:29:58,296 --> 01:30:00,862
He founded the Vietnam Program
1390
01:30:00,863 --> 01:30:03,261
of the Kennedy School at Harvard,
1391
01:30:03,262 --> 01:30:09,561
and helped educate some of the
country's future leaders.
1392
01:30:09,562 --> 01:30:12,727
I got very, very involved
in the reconnecting
1393
01:30:12,728 --> 01:30:15,093
between the United States and Vietnam,
1394
01:30:15,094 --> 01:30:17,860
and how that reconnection takes place,
1395
01:30:17,861 --> 01:30:22,926
I spent a decade of my life
putting those pieces together.
1396
01:30:22,927 --> 01:30:25,225
NARRATOR: Although the United States
1397
01:30:25,226 --> 01:30:28,493
did not have diplomatic
relations with Vietnam,
1398
01:30:28,494 --> 01:30:32,457
veterans had begun coming
back on their own,
1399
01:30:32,458 --> 01:30:37,525
revisiting places where they had fought...
1400
01:30:38,658 --> 01:30:41,724
...meeting old foes...
1401
01:30:43,824 --> 01:30:47,656
...planting trees and building schools,
1402
01:30:47,657 --> 01:30:51,624
trying to put the war behind them.
1403
01:30:53,156 --> 01:30:56,190
Vallely worked closely with other veterans,
1404
01:30:56,191 --> 01:30:59,821
including three United States senators,
1405
01:30:59,822 --> 01:31:03,654
who became among the most
influential American advocates
1406
01:31:03,655 --> 01:31:06,422
for normalizing relations:
1407
01:31:06,423 --> 01:31:09,220
John McCain from Arizona,
1408
01:31:09,221 --> 01:31:14,188
who had endured six years
as a prisoner of war;
1409
01:31:14,189 --> 01:31:17,319
John Kerry from Massachusetts,
1410
01:31:17,320 --> 01:31:20,819
the ex-commander of a Swift Boat;
1411
01:31:20,820 --> 01:31:24,019
and Bob Kerrey of Nebraska,
1412
01:31:24,020 --> 01:31:27,552
a former Navy SEAL.
1413
01:31:27,553 --> 01:31:30,818
Their task would not be easy.
1414
01:31:30,819 --> 01:31:34,185
Hanoi insisted the United States make good
1415
01:31:34,186 --> 01:31:38,817
on a promise to provide
funds for reconstruction.
1416
01:31:38,818 --> 01:31:41,885
For its part, the United States demanded
1417
01:31:41,886 --> 01:31:43,649
a complete accounting
1418
01:31:43,650 --> 01:31:46,884
of the 2,500 Americans whose remains
1419
01:31:46,885 --> 01:31:49,484
had never been recovered.
1420
01:31:49,485 --> 01:31:54,983
Hanoi, which had more than
300,000 missing of its own,
1421
01:31:54,984 --> 01:31:59,648
refused to cooperate.
1422
01:31:59,649 --> 01:32:04,581
But events both within Vietnam
and far beyond its borders
1423
01:32:04,582 --> 01:32:08,883
slowly moved things along.
1424
01:32:36,546 --> 01:32:41,978
NARRATOR: Le Duan died in 1986.
1425
01:32:41,979 --> 01:32:46,377
His successors adopted
what they calleddoi moi,
1426
01:32:46,378 --> 01:32:49,943
a more pragmatic reformist economic policy.
1427
01:32:52,478 --> 01:32:56,708
As the Cold War ended,
Soviet aid disappeared,
1428
01:32:56,709 --> 01:33:01,909
and Hanoi finally began to help U.S.
military teams
1429
01:33:01,910 --> 01:33:05,740
search for American remains.
1430
01:33:05,741 --> 01:33:10,375
VALLELY: The architects of normalization
1431
01:33:10,376 --> 01:33:12,674
are the Vietnamese.
1432
01:33:12,675 --> 01:33:15,806
It's not the Americans.
1433
01:33:15,807 --> 01:33:18,139
And the normalization of Vietnam
1434
01:33:18,140 --> 01:33:23,272
is a strategy of the
Vietnamese Communist Party
1435
01:33:23,273 --> 01:33:25,638
to join the world.
1436
01:33:25,639 --> 01:33:27,238
They want to join the world.
1437
01:33:27,239 --> 01:33:30,504
And the United States makes it
hard for them to join the world.
1438
01:33:30,505 --> 01:33:33,472
So John McCain insists,
1439
01:33:33,473 --> 01:33:35,437
"Yeah, you want to have normalization?
1440
01:33:35,438 --> 01:33:38,804
All your prisoners need to be
out of re-education camp."
1441
01:33:38,805 --> 01:33:41,270
"You want normalization?"
1442
01:33:41,271 --> 01:33:44,338
John Kerry... "I need all the
information about the missing."
1443
01:33:46,338 --> 01:33:48,935
NARRATOR: In 1994,
1444
01:33:48,936 --> 01:33:51,870
after the Vietnamese met
the Americans' demands,
1445
01:33:51,871 --> 01:33:56,202
the United States lifted its trade embargo.
1446
01:33:56,203 --> 01:34:00,934
Full normalization came the following year.
1447
01:34:00,935 --> 01:34:04,369
The new American ambassador
was Pete Peterson,
1448
01:34:04,370 --> 01:34:09,501
who had spent six years
in Hanoi as a P.O.W.
1449
01:34:11,969 --> 01:34:14,233
In November of 2000,
1450
01:34:14,234 --> 01:34:17,499
President Bill Clinton traveled to Vietnam,
1451
01:34:17,500 --> 01:34:21,499
the first American president
to visit that country
1452
01:34:21,500 --> 01:34:25,166
since Richard Nixon reviewed U.S.
troops there
1453
01:34:25,167 --> 01:34:28,066
31 years earlier.
1454
01:34:29,999 --> 01:34:31,966
BARACK OBAMA: Now we can say something
1455
01:34:31,967 --> 01:34:33,764
that was once unimaginable:
1456
01:34:33,765 --> 01:34:37,930
Today, Vietnam and the
United States are partners.
1457
01:34:37,931 --> 01:34:42,664
We have shown that hearts can change,
1458
01:34:42,665 --> 01:34:44,429
and that a different future is possible
1459
01:34:44,430 --> 01:34:48,264
when we refuse to be prisoners of the past.
1460
01:35:53,323 --> 01:35:56,188
MIKE HEANEY: I went back to Vietnam.
1461
01:35:56,189 --> 01:35:59,989
I got in touch with a
provincial vets organization.
1462
01:36:04,288 --> 01:36:06,720
This is a huge organization
of Vietnamese vets,
1463
01:36:06,721 --> 01:36:10,220
all former enemies.
1464
01:36:10,221 --> 01:36:11,786
All former enemies.
1465
01:36:11,787 --> 01:36:14,686
But now, mellowed quite a bit, like me.
1466
01:36:14,687 --> 01:36:17,253
You know, they're guys my age, grandpas.
1467
01:36:17,254 --> 01:36:23,252
And after we got past the initial
checking each other out,
1468
01:36:23,253 --> 01:36:26,785
and is this a political thing or not,
1469
01:36:26,786 --> 01:36:34,585
they could not have been more
gracious and more loving.
1470
01:36:34,586 --> 01:36:39,651
They took me under their
wing like a brother soldier.
1471
01:36:39,652 --> 01:36:45,251
We exchanged painful memories, stories.
1472
01:36:48,283 --> 01:36:52,482
And I did a little ceremony
honoring the guys I'd lost,
1473
01:36:52,483 --> 01:36:56,015
honoring the Vietnamese
enemies that we'd killed.
1474
01:36:56,016 --> 01:36:59,982
And just telling them, you know,
they could be at peace now.
1475
01:37:05,414 --> 01:37:09,315
It was a wonderful, wonderful trip.
1476
01:37:11,382 --> 01:37:13,212
You know, you don't...
1477
01:37:13,213 --> 01:37:16,013
You don't get closure,
but you get some peace.
1478
01:37:16,014 --> 01:37:18,381
You get some peace... I got some peace.
1479
01:37:28,479 --> 01:37:33,378
NARRATOR: In Vietnam, the
land has largely healed.
1480
01:37:33,379 --> 01:37:37,111
Old animosities have mostly been buried.
1481
01:37:39,178 --> 01:37:41,878
But ghosts remain.
1482
01:37:44,511 --> 01:37:46,043
Americans and Vietnamese
1483
01:37:46,044 --> 01:37:48,209
work together to clean up places
1484
01:37:48,210 --> 01:37:51,643
where Agent Orange has poisoned the earth.
1485
01:37:51,644 --> 01:37:56,009
Unexploded ordnance,
half-hidden in the ground,
1486
01:37:56,010 --> 01:38:00,308
still takes lives each year.
1487
01:38:00,309 --> 01:38:04,274
Aged mothers and fathers
from northern Vietnam
1488
01:38:04,275 --> 01:38:06,641
still roam the south,
1489
01:38:06,642 --> 01:38:07,906
seeking to discover
1490
01:38:07,907 --> 01:38:10,442
what happened to their sons and daughters.
1491
01:40:07,362 --> 01:40:11,727
SAM WILSON: As we finally came
lurching out of Vietnam...
1492
01:40:13,093 --> 01:40:18,459
We were beginning to doubt ourselves.
1493
01:40:18,460 --> 01:40:23,126
And, uh, that's a foreign
feeling for an American.
1494
01:40:23,127 --> 01:40:27,191
We, we seldom doubt ourselves.
1495
01:40:27,192 --> 01:40:32,291
This turned out to be the most
bitter, the most divisive...
1496
01:40:32,292 --> 01:40:35,125
or second-most bitter and
second-most divisive...
1497
01:40:35,126 --> 01:40:37,791
war in our entire history.
1498
01:40:37,792 --> 01:40:42,291
And we still hurt because of it.
1499
01:40:44,524 --> 01:40:48,290
We have feelings of guilt about Vietnam.
1500
01:40:50,389 --> 01:40:53,923
NARRATOR: More than four
decades after the war ended,
1501
01:40:53,924 --> 01:40:57,254
the divisions it created between Americans
1502
01:40:57,255 --> 01:41:00,822
have not yet wholly healed.
1503
01:41:00,823 --> 01:41:05,121
Lessons were learned and then forgotten;
1504
01:41:05,122 --> 01:41:10,121
divides were bridged and then widened;
1505
01:41:10,122 --> 01:41:16,452
old secrets were revealed and
new secrets were locked away.
1506
01:41:16,453 --> 01:41:20,685
The Vietnam War was a tragedy,
1507
01:41:20,686 --> 01:41:24,585
immeasurable and irredeemable.
1508
01:41:27,620 --> 01:41:31,052
But meaning can be found
in the individual stories
1509
01:41:31,053 --> 01:41:33,517
of those who lived through it,
1510
01:41:33,518 --> 01:41:36,750
stories of courage and comradeship
1511
01:41:36,751 --> 01:41:38,818
and perseverance,
1512
01:41:38,819 --> 01:41:42,317
of understanding and forgiveness
1513
01:41:42,318 --> 01:41:47,183
and, ultimately, reconciliation.
1514
01:41:52,550 --> 01:41:56,081
O'BRIEN: "They shared the weight of memory.
1515
01:41:56,082 --> 01:41:59,447
"They took up what others
could no longer bear.
1516
01:41:59,448 --> 01:42:03,247
"Often, they carried each
other, the wounded or weak.
1517
01:42:03,248 --> 01:42:07,147
"They carried infections.
1518
01:42:07,148 --> 01:42:09,379
"They carried chess sets,
1519
01:42:09,380 --> 01:42:11,914
"basketballs,
1520
01:42:11,915 --> 01:42:15,547
"Vietnamese-English dictionaries,
1521
01:42:15,548 --> 01:42:22,245
"insignia of rank, Bronze
Stars and Purple Hearts,
1522
01:42:22,246 --> 01:42:29,011
"plastic cards imprinted
with the Code of Conduct.
1523
01:42:29,012 --> 01:42:32,077
"They carried diseases,
1524
01:42:32,078 --> 01:42:35,510
"among them malaria and dysentery.
1525
01:42:35,511 --> 01:42:41,943
"They carried lice and
ringworm and leeches,
1526
01:42:41,944 --> 01:42:48,075
"paddy algae and various rots and molds.
1527
01:42:48,076 --> 01:42:54,542
"They carried the land itself... Vietnam,
1528
01:42:54,543 --> 01:42:58,475
"the place, the soil...
1529
01:42:58,476 --> 01:43:00,974
"a powdery orange-red dust
1530
01:43:00,975 --> 01:43:07,640
"that covered their boots
and fatigues and faces.
1531
01:43:07,641 --> 01:43:11,006
"They carried the sky.
1532
01:43:11,007 --> 01:43:14,072
"The whole atmosphere,
1533
01:43:14,073 --> 01:43:16,872
"they carried it...
1534
01:43:16,873 --> 01:43:20,772
"the humidity, the monsoons,
1535
01:43:20,773 --> 01:43:25,005
"the stink of fungus and decay, all of it.
1536
01:43:25,006 --> 01:43:27,238
"They carried gravity.
1537
01:43:27,239 --> 01:43:30,105
"They moved like mules.
1538
01:43:30,106 --> 01:43:32,805
"By daylight, they took sniper fire;
1539
01:43:32,806 --> 01:43:34,704
"at night, they were mortared.
1540
01:43:34,705 --> 01:43:38,304
"They crawled into tunnels and walked point
1541
01:43:38,305 --> 01:43:40,736
"and advanced under fire.
1542
01:43:40,737 --> 01:43:43,669
"But it was not battle,
1543
01:43:43,670 --> 01:43:46,702
"it was just the endless march,
1544
01:43:46,703 --> 01:43:49,702
"village to village.
1545
01:43:49,703 --> 01:43:54,202
"They marched for the sake of the march.
1546
01:43:54,203 --> 01:43:58,035
"They plodded along slowly, dumbly,
1547
01:43:58,036 --> 01:44:02,302
"leaning forward against
the heat, unthinking,
1548
01:44:02,303 --> 01:44:06,000
"all blood and bone, simple grunts,
1549
01:44:06,001 --> 01:44:08,534
"soldiering with their legs,
1550
01:44:08,535 --> 01:44:11,101
"toiling up the hills and
down into the paddies
1551
01:44:11,102 --> 01:44:16,033
"and across the rivers and up
again and down, just humping,
1552
01:44:16,034 --> 01:44:21,799
"one step and then the
next and then another.
1553
01:44:21,800 --> 01:44:23,365
"They made their legs move.
1554
01:44:25,466 --> 01:44:27,333
They endured."
1555
01:44:29,565 --> 01:44:31,332
("Let It Be" by The Beatles playing)
1556
01:44:41,363 --> 01:44:44,763
♪ When I find myself
in times of trouble ♪
1557
01:44:44,764 --> 01:44:47,995
♪ Mother Mary comes to me
1558
01:44:47,996 --> 01:44:50,396
♪ Speaking words of wisdom
1559
01:44:50,397 --> 01:44:53,728
♪ Let it be
1560
01:44:53,729 --> 01:44:56,628
♪ And in my hour of darkness
1561
01:44:56,629 --> 01:45:00,494
♪ She is standing right
in front of me ♪
1562
01:45:00,495 --> 01:45:03,127
♪ Speaking words of wisdom
1563
01:45:03,128 --> 01:45:06,226
♪ Let it be
1564
01:45:06,227 --> 01:45:09,527
♪ Let it be, let it be
1565
01:45:09,528 --> 01:45:12,859
♪ Let it be, let it be ♪
1566
01:45:12,860 --> 01:45:16,393
♪ Whisper words of wisdom
1567
01:45:16,394 --> 01:45:19,826
♪ Let it be
1568
01:45:19,827 --> 01:45:22,793
♪ And when the brokenhearted people ♪
1569
01:45:22,794 --> 01:45:26,657
♪ Living in the world agree
1570
01:45:26,658 --> 01:45:29,491
♪ There will be an answer
1571
01:45:29,492 --> 01:45:32,824
♪ Let it be
1572
01:45:32,825 --> 01:45:36,024
♪ For though they may be parted ♪
1573
01:45:36,025 --> 01:45:40,257
♪ There is still a chance
that they will see ♪
1574
01:45:40,258 --> 01:45:42,622
♪ There will be an answer
1575
01:45:42,623 --> 01:45:45,855
♪ Let it be
1576
01:45:45,856 --> 01:45:49,290
♪ Let it be, let it be
1577
01:45:49,291 --> 01:45:53,289
♪ Let it be, let it be ♪
1578
01:45:53,290 --> 01:45:56,089
♪ Yeah, there will be an answer ♪
1579
01:45:56,090 --> 01:45:59,220
♪ Let it be
1580
01:45:59,221 --> 01:46:02,620
♪ Let it be, let it be
1581
01:46:02,621 --> 01:46:07,021
♪ Let it be, yeah, let it be ♪
1582
01:46:07,022 --> 01:46:09,953
♪ Whisper words of wisdom
1583
01:46:09,954 --> 01:46:14,320
♪ Let it be
1584
01:46:14,321 --> 01:46:16,852
♪ And when the night is cloudy
1585
01:46:16,853 --> 01:46:21,319
♪ There is still a light
that shines on me ♪
1586
01:46:21,320 --> 01:46:24,286
♪ Shine until tomorrow
1587
01:46:24,287 --> 01:46:27,984
♪ Let it be
1588
01:46:27,985 --> 01:46:31,550
♪ I wake up to the sound of music ♪
1589
01:46:31,551 --> 01:46:34,983
♪ Mother Mary comes to me
1590
01:46:34,984 --> 01:46:38,084
♪ Speaking words of wisdom
1591
01:46:38,085 --> 01:46:41,183
♪ Let it be
1592
01:46:41,184 --> 01:46:44,249
♪ Yeah, let it be, let it be
1593
01:46:44,250 --> 01:46:49,148
♪ Let it be, yeah, let it be
1594
01:46:49,149 --> 01:46:51,816
♪ There will be an answer
1595
01:46:51,817 --> 01:46:55,282
♪ Let it be
1596
01:46:55,283 --> 01:46:58,481
♪ Let it be, let it be
1597
01:46:58,482 --> 01:47:02,980
♪ Let it be, yeah, let it be
1598
01:47:02,981 --> 01:47:06,046
♪ There will be an answer
1599
01:47:06,047 --> 01:47:09,146
♪ Let it be
1600
01:47:09,147 --> 01:47:12,380
♪ Let it be, let it be
1601
01:47:12,381 --> 01:47:17,145
♪ Let it be, yeah, let it be
1602
01:47:17,146 --> 01:47:19,812
♪ Whisper words of wisdom
1603
01:47:19,813 --> 01:47:27,813
♪ Let it be.123983
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.