All language subtitles for ice-on-fire-2019-720p-amzn-web-dl-x264-mkvcage-ws

af Afrikaans
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bn Bengali
bs Bosnian
bg Bulgarian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
da Danish
nl Dutch
en English
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek Download
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
km Khmer
ko Korean
ku Kurdish (Kurmanji)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Lao
la Latin
lv Latvian
lt Lithuanian
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
ne Nepali
no Norwegian
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt Portuguese
pa Punjabi
ro Romanian
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
st Sesotho
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhala
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
te Telugu
th Thai
tr Turkish
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu
or Odia (Oriya)
rw Kinyarwanda
tk Turkmen
tt Tatar
ug Uyghur
Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated: 1 00:00:34,690 --> 00:00:39,107 Over the last 250 years we have, in effect, 2 00:00:39,191 --> 00:00:44,899 conducted the largest science experiment in history. 3 00:00:44,982 --> 00:00:48,107 Since the advent of the Industrial Revolution, 4 00:00:48,191 --> 00:00:52,899 we have burned over 1.4 trillion tons of carbon 5 00:00:52,982 --> 00:00:55,149 into the atmosphere. 6 00:00:55,232 --> 00:00:58,441 It has changed life on earth as we know it, 7 00:00:58,524 --> 00:01:02,232 especially in the Arctic. 8 00:01:02,316 --> 00:01:04,731 The melting of the world's snow and ice 9 00:01:04,814 --> 00:01:07,940 has now triggered multiple climate tipping points, 10 00:01:08,024 --> 00:01:12,191 threatening the very existence of life on earth. 11 00:01:12,274 --> 00:01:17,024 Yet this disturbing future need not be set in stone. 12 00:01:17,107 --> 00:01:21,024 We have long had alternatives to fossil fuels. 13 00:01:21,106 --> 00:01:24,274 But more recently, we have actually discovered 14 00:01:24,358 --> 00:01:27,608 how to pull carbon out of the atmosphere, 15 00:01:27,690 --> 00:01:32,274 giving us a chance at reversing climate disruption. 16 00:01:32,358 --> 00:01:35,732 If we are able to reverse climate change in time, 17 00:01:35,815 --> 00:01:40,899 it would be an unprecedented achievement in human history. 18 00:01:40,982 --> 00:01:43,274 But the clock is ticking. 19 00:01:43,358 --> 00:01:47,731 Scientists say we must implement these solutions immediately. 20 00:01:47,814 --> 00:01:50,940 At this critical turning point, we must give a voice 21 00:01:51,024 --> 00:01:54,358 to the impartial experts who have presented us 22 00:01:54,441 --> 00:01:58,899 with the facts they have spent a lifetime to uncover. 23 00:01:58,982 --> 00:02:01,399 It is their time to be heard. 24 00:02:01,483 --> 00:02:05,523 They are the scientists, researchers and innovators 25 00:02:05,607 --> 00:02:07,649 who have found the solutions 26 00:02:07,732 --> 00:02:12,357 to preserve the very life of our shared world. 27 00:02:29,231 --> 00:02:31,148 There is a couple different projects 28 00:02:31,231 --> 00:02:33,940 that require manual sampling. 29 00:02:37,523 --> 00:02:41,065 So one of them is the long-term CO2 record. 30 00:02:43,690 --> 00:02:45,814 And the way it's set up, you still need a person 31 00:02:45,898 --> 00:02:49,773 to come physically take the sample every Tuesday. 32 00:02:51,857 --> 00:02:54,565 I'm the person that gets to go in the Sno-Cat 33 00:02:54,648 --> 00:02:57,106 to take the measurements. 34 00:02:59,191 --> 00:03:01,066 We want to keep that long-term record going 35 00:03:01,149 --> 00:03:02,939 the way it's always been taken. 36 00:03:05,065 --> 00:03:08,024 Monitoring and tracking what we're doing to our atmosphere 37 00:03:08,107 --> 00:03:10,939 is a serious and difficult endeavor. 38 00:03:11,023 --> 00:03:12,773 For the last 50 years, 39 00:03:12,856 --> 00:03:15,482 dedicated researchers from around the world 40 00:03:15,565 --> 00:03:18,316 travel weekly to the same locations, 41 00:03:18,399 --> 00:03:21,190 taking samples of greenhouse gases 42 00:03:21,273 --> 00:03:23,939 that cause climate disruption. 43 00:03:24,023 --> 00:03:28,190 So we're at about 11 and a half thousand feet at Niwot Ridge 44 00:03:28,273 --> 00:03:31,648 in the front range of the Rocky Mountains in Colorado. 45 00:03:31,731 --> 00:03:37,648 And this is NOAA's long-term CO2 sampling site here. 46 00:03:37,731 --> 00:03:39,482 It's the third longest in the world. 47 00:03:41,398 --> 00:03:43,316 So, these are the flasks that we're gonna use 48 00:03:43,399 --> 00:03:45,856 to collect our sample, made out of glass. 49 00:03:45,939 --> 00:03:50,939 And after we're done today filling them with air, we'll ski 'em down to our office, 50 00:03:51,023 --> 00:03:54,190 and then we'll take them down to NOAA's office in Boulder where they get analyzed 51 00:03:54,273 --> 00:03:57,065 along with similar flasks from all over the world. 52 00:03:57,148 --> 00:03:59,523 The reason we do it up here 53 00:03:59,607 --> 00:04:02,065 and a lot of the sampling sites are high up in the atmosphere 54 00:04:02,148 --> 00:04:03,898 is the air up here is well mixed 55 00:04:03,981 --> 00:04:07,565 so you're getting a good sample of the whole atmosphere. 56 00:04:07,648 --> 00:04:09,648 There's the little inlet on the roof. 57 00:04:09,731 --> 00:04:11,231 When I turn on the pump, 58 00:04:11,315 --> 00:04:15,357 it's gonna suck the air into these flasks. 59 00:04:15,440 --> 00:04:17,523 This is actually the whole... 60 00:04:17,607 --> 00:04:20,106 carbon cycle and greenhouse gases, 61 00:04:20,190 --> 00:04:23,190 and CO2 and methane are the big ones. 62 00:04:25,273 --> 00:04:27,231 When they took the first sample in 1968, 63 00:04:27,315 --> 00:04:30,231 it measured 322 parts per million. 64 00:04:32,440 --> 00:04:35,648 And now we don't know what this sample's gonna measure yet, 65 00:04:35,731 --> 00:04:38,648 but it's probably gonna be around 408. 66 00:04:38,731 --> 00:04:41,773 So, it's a little bit of an increase. 67 00:04:44,565 --> 00:04:47,440 And now I'm just putting everything away 68 00:04:47,523 --> 00:04:49,689 and getting it ready for next week's sample. 69 00:05:05,565 --> 00:05:09,189 One of NOAA's missions since its inception 70 00:05:09,272 --> 00:05:12,440 was to measure carbon dioxide in the atmosphere 71 00:05:12,523 --> 00:05:15,856 and other gases that affect the carbon cycle. 72 00:05:15,939 --> 00:05:18,397 Two samples are collected every week 73 00:05:18,481 --> 00:05:20,398 from around the globe. 74 00:05:20,482 --> 00:05:23,731 So we're looking to see how these gases change with time. 75 00:05:23,814 --> 00:05:27,356 And the way to do that is to continuously collect samples. 76 00:05:28,773 --> 00:05:31,648 Currently, we have about 60 locations. 77 00:05:31,731 --> 00:05:34,772 Most of the samples are collected in remote areas 78 00:05:34,855 --> 00:05:38,023 away from population centers. 79 00:05:38,106 --> 00:05:40,023 And we measure them on this set of instruments 80 00:05:40,106 --> 00:05:43,439 for six gases that affect the carbon cycle. 81 00:05:43,522 --> 00:05:48,689 Those gases are carbon dioxide, methane, carbon monoxide, 82 00:05:48,773 --> 00:05:51,647 molecular hydrogen, nitrous oxide 83 00:05:51,730 --> 00:05:53,230 and sulfur hexafluoride. 84 00:05:53,314 --> 00:05:56,856 This system runs five days and five nights a week, 85 00:05:56,939 --> 00:05:57,981 24 hours a day. 86 00:05:58,065 --> 00:05:59,481 So what I'm doing right now 87 00:05:59,564 --> 00:06:01,397 is putting the air samples on the manifold 88 00:06:01,481 --> 00:06:03,231 and start the measurements. 89 00:06:03,315 --> 00:06:04,981 And then I can walk away. 90 00:06:30,065 --> 00:06:34,397 I lead NOAA's Global Greenhouse Gas Reference Network. 91 00:06:34,481 --> 00:06:37,647 The aim of the Global Greenhouse Gas Reference Network 92 00:06:37,730 --> 00:06:42,064 is to provide data that are fully calibrated, 93 00:06:42,147 --> 00:06:45,230 carefully quality controlled and documented. 94 00:06:45,314 --> 00:06:47,231 Data that will still be fully credible 95 00:06:47,315 --> 00:06:49,607 a hundred years from now and longer, 96 00:06:49,688 --> 00:06:54,272 so that as climate change is happening now 97 00:06:54,356 --> 00:06:56,648 and in the future over the earth, 98 00:06:56,731 --> 00:06:59,564 there will be information for scientists 99 00:06:59,688 --> 00:07:01,980 that they can really trust 100 00:07:02,064 --> 00:07:04,898 so that they can diagnose what actually happened 101 00:07:04,981 --> 00:07:09,147 and how climate change actually happens, how it works. 102 00:07:10,314 --> 00:07:12,855 So modern CO2 measurements 103 00:07:12,938 --> 00:07:15,772 were initiated by Dave Keeling, 104 00:07:15,855 --> 00:07:18,564 a description situation of oceanography. 105 00:07:18,647 --> 00:07:23,439 Around 1956, he started measuring along the west coast. 106 00:07:23,522 --> 00:07:28,647 He saw that during mid-afternoon wherever he was, 107 00:07:28,730 --> 00:07:32,481 he found pretty much the same concentration everywhere. 108 00:07:32,564 --> 00:07:36,147 And so it got into his head the idea that maybe 109 00:07:36,230 --> 00:07:37,481 there's something that we can call 110 00:07:37,564 --> 00:07:38,980 a background concentration. 111 00:07:39,064 --> 00:07:40,938 He started continuous measurements then 112 00:07:41,022 --> 00:07:43,439 at Mauna Loa Island of Hawaii 113 00:07:43,522 --> 00:07:45,897 and on the coast of Antarctica. 114 00:07:47,439 --> 00:07:50,439 The last ice age at the end of that glaciation 115 00:07:50,522 --> 00:07:53,189 from 20,000 to 11,000 years ago, 116 00:07:53,272 --> 00:07:56,522 CO2 increased by about 80 ppm 117 00:07:56,606 --> 00:07:59,481 from 200 to 280, roughly. 118 00:07:59,564 --> 00:08:01,147 It was very slow. 119 00:08:01,230 --> 00:08:05,688 It took 6,000 years for CO2 to climb the 80 ppm. 120 00:08:05,772 --> 00:08:07,064 Six thousand years! 121 00:08:09,356 --> 00:08:10,730 In pre-industrial times, 122 00:08:10,813 --> 00:08:12,230 so before 1850, 123 00:08:12,314 --> 00:08:14,938 CO2 was close to 280 ppm. 124 00:08:15,022 --> 00:08:19,105 And now of course we see 2 ppm per year. 125 00:08:19,189 --> 00:08:24,439 That increase was due 100% to human activities. 126 00:08:26,189 --> 00:08:28,481 The spike that we now see, 127 00:08:28,564 --> 00:08:32,772 compared to most geologic history, 128 00:08:32,855 --> 00:08:34,897 I call it an explosion. 129 00:08:36,606 --> 00:08:38,522 It's... 130 00:08:38,606 --> 00:08:43,397 It's like instantaneous in geologic time scale. 131 00:08:47,064 --> 00:08:49,021 Carbon has increased dramatically 132 00:08:49,104 --> 00:08:51,189 since the Industrial Revolution. 133 00:08:51,272 --> 00:08:53,980 But what does that actually mean for all of us? 134 00:08:55,481 --> 00:08:57,355 What we have learned is that excess carbon 135 00:08:57,438 --> 00:08:59,730 creates climate disruption. 136 00:08:59,813 --> 00:09:03,439 It changes the weather patterns and life support systems 137 00:09:03,522 --> 00:09:07,897 upon which society depends to survive. 138 00:09:07,980 --> 00:09:09,730 We have always known 139 00:09:09,813 --> 00:09:12,606 that there's a toxicity associated with fossil fuels, 140 00:09:12,688 --> 00:09:15,229 but we'd always thought that it was basically a toxicity 141 00:09:15,313 --> 00:09:16,730 that would affect humans, 142 00:09:16,813 --> 00:09:20,147 you know, or other individual life forms. 143 00:09:20,230 --> 00:09:22,355 It's really only in the-- 144 00:09:22,438 --> 00:09:24,481 within my lifetime certainly 145 00:09:24,564 --> 00:09:27,064 that it has become frighteningly apparent 146 00:09:27,147 --> 00:09:29,606 that the accumulation of carbon in the atmosphere 147 00:09:29,688 --> 00:09:31,854 has caused it to warm up. 148 00:09:31,937 --> 00:09:34,564 This greenhouse effect, this toxicity, 149 00:09:34,647 --> 00:09:39,104 impacts the life systems of the planet as a whole. 150 00:09:39,188 --> 00:09:42,813 And, you know, once I got that back in the mid-90s, 151 00:09:42,897 --> 00:09:44,397 I had to start talking about it 152 00:09:44,481 --> 00:09:46,481 and we've been talking about it ever since. 153 00:09:51,230 --> 00:09:54,813 When we talk about dangerous planetary warming, 154 00:09:54,897 --> 00:09:59,481 we're referring to something akin to a two degree Celsius, 155 00:09:59,564 --> 00:10:02,230 that's about three and a half degree Fahrenheit 156 00:10:02,314 --> 00:10:05,271 warming of the planet relative to pre-industrial times. 157 00:10:05,355 --> 00:10:08,272 That is where we start to see some of the worst 158 00:10:08,356 --> 00:10:12,104 and potentially irreversible impacts of climate change: 159 00:10:12,188 --> 00:10:13,771 substantial melting of the ice sheets 160 00:10:13,854 --> 00:10:17,439 and associated substantial rise in sea level, 161 00:10:17,522 --> 00:10:19,938 permanent droughts in mid-latitudes, 162 00:10:20,022 --> 00:10:23,438 and the list goes on. 163 00:10:23,521 --> 00:10:27,439 Well, catastrophic would be we melt the major ice sheets, 164 00:10:27,522 --> 00:10:30,313 the Greenland ice sheet and the West Antarctic ice sheet 165 00:10:30,396 --> 00:10:35,314 as all the major coastal cities of the world are flooded. 166 00:10:35,397 --> 00:10:37,146 You've got less land. 167 00:10:37,229 --> 00:10:39,104 You've got environmental refugees, 168 00:10:39,188 --> 00:10:41,646 some people leaving those regions. 169 00:10:41,729 --> 00:10:44,189 People leaving the tropics because it's getting too hot 170 00:10:44,272 --> 00:10:46,146 for human habitation. 171 00:10:46,229 --> 00:10:49,104 It's getting too hot for agriculture. 172 00:10:49,188 --> 00:10:52,730 Crops in the tropics will decrease dramatically 173 00:10:52,813 --> 00:10:54,480 in their productivity. 174 00:10:54,563 --> 00:10:58,313 In short, you're looking at a world with less land, 175 00:10:58,396 --> 00:11:02,147 less food, less water and more people. 176 00:11:02,230 --> 00:11:06,563 And that's a recipe for a national security disaster. 177 00:11:20,063 --> 00:11:21,521 I work on the carbon cycle, 178 00:11:21,605 --> 00:11:25,480 tasks that I've taken on for more than 30 years 179 00:11:25,563 --> 00:11:27,356 and truth be told, I figured 180 00:11:27,439 --> 00:11:30,521 we would have done something about this 20 years ago 181 00:11:30,605 --> 00:11:31,979 and I could be off doing something else, 182 00:11:32,063 --> 00:11:33,812 but I'm still doing what I'm doing. 183 00:11:36,771 --> 00:11:38,438 If you think about the relationship 184 00:11:38,521 --> 00:11:40,355 between carbon dioxide and sea level, 185 00:11:40,438 --> 00:11:43,355 there's a couple of interesting points in that relationship. 186 00:11:43,438 --> 00:11:48,271 One of them is when CO2 goes up to roughly 400 parts per million. 187 00:11:48,355 --> 00:11:53,020 That is warm enough that we melt off chunks of Antarctica, 188 00:11:53,103 --> 00:11:54,771 chunks of Greenland. 189 00:11:54,854 --> 00:11:56,854 And those chunks are the chunks that are 190 00:11:56,937 --> 00:11:58,438 what we call marine base. 191 00:11:58,521 --> 00:12:00,812 So the base of the ice sheet in West Antarctica 192 00:12:00,896 --> 00:12:04,104 is below sea level because it's pinned to the sediments. 193 00:12:04,188 --> 00:12:05,521 And once it starts to melt, 194 00:12:05,605 --> 00:12:07,188 it's one of these freight trains. 195 00:12:07,271 --> 00:12:09,438 We don't know how this thing is gonna stop. 196 00:12:11,063 --> 00:12:14,854 And we're dangerously at that point right now. 197 00:12:18,063 --> 00:12:19,646 The other threshold is somewhere around 198 00:12:19,729 --> 00:12:22,812 six to seven hundred parts per million CO2. 199 00:12:22,896 --> 00:12:26,521 That's warm enough that there is no more ice, 200 00:12:26,605 --> 00:12:28,103 land ice on the planet. 201 00:12:28,187 --> 00:12:31,812 And you have about 80 meters higher sea level. 202 00:12:33,937 --> 00:12:35,936 We are on our way 203 00:12:36,020 --> 00:12:38,812 to six, seven hundred parts per million. 204 00:12:41,771 --> 00:12:45,187 But I think that's one of those interesting threshold moments 205 00:12:45,270 --> 00:12:48,729 in our relationship with the planet where, 206 00:12:48,812 --> 00:12:52,770 are we gonna push the climate system 207 00:12:52,853 --> 00:12:55,188 so far out of balance 208 00:12:55,271 --> 00:12:59,146 that we threaten the melting of all land ice? 209 00:13:10,312 --> 00:13:11,936 Guomundur Ingi Guobrandsson: Yeah, it has changed. 210 00:13:12,020 --> 00:13:14,854 Icelandic nature is experiencing change 211 00:13:14,937 --> 00:13:16,646 because of climate change. 212 00:13:16,729 --> 00:13:20,312 This is quite visible in the south coast, for example. 213 00:13:20,395 --> 00:13:23,438 Our largest glacier, Glacier Vatnajokull 214 00:13:23,521 --> 00:13:26,645 or Water Glacier if you translate it directly, 215 00:13:26,728 --> 00:13:29,145 has also retreated quite a lot. 216 00:13:29,228 --> 00:13:32,229 There is one very interesting observation 217 00:13:32,313 --> 00:13:36,645 that everybody noticed when they drive the south coast now 218 00:13:36,728 --> 00:13:40,146 and that is that they drive over the longest bridge in Iceland, 219 00:13:40,229 --> 00:13:42,271 almost one kilometer in length, 220 00:13:42,355 --> 00:13:45,479 and there is almost no water under it. 221 00:13:45,562 --> 00:13:50,605 So you think, OK, why building such a big bridge 222 00:13:50,687 --> 00:13:52,395 for almost no water? 223 00:13:54,604 --> 00:13:58,563 Well, this is just climate change. 224 00:13:58,646 --> 00:14:01,145 The river changed its course 225 00:14:01,228 --> 00:14:04,395 is because of the retreat of the glacier. 226 00:14:07,271 --> 00:14:11,936 So now we have this sort of monument, 227 00:14:12,020 --> 00:14:15,729 a symbolic thing of the past. 228 00:14:30,103 --> 00:14:35,354 The Arctic is a profoundly different place right now. 229 00:14:35,437 --> 00:14:39,062 In the Arctic, the impacts of climate change 230 00:14:39,145 --> 00:14:41,562 are the most extreme. 231 00:14:41,645 --> 00:14:45,479 What scientists are finding is that what happens in the Arctic 232 00:14:45,562 --> 00:14:49,729 has major impacts for the rest of the planet. 233 00:14:49,812 --> 00:14:52,479 I am working with measuring greenhouse gases 234 00:14:52,562 --> 00:14:54,062 at the Arctic location 235 00:14:54,145 --> 00:14:56,395 and understanding how the greenhouse gases 236 00:14:56,479 --> 00:14:58,686 are changing over time. 237 00:14:58,770 --> 00:15:02,103 I am concerned about the increase of temperature in the Arctic 238 00:15:02,187 --> 00:15:06,605 and the impact this might have on all the Arctic systems. 239 00:15:06,687 --> 00:15:09,645 But what I think is extremely important to be aware of 240 00:15:09,728 --> 00:15:14,228 is that with the sea ice reduction we have now 241 00:15:14,312 --> 00:15:15,936 and all the other changes, 242 00:15:16,020 --> 00:15:18,604 you might change the whole weather system, 243 00:15:18,686 --> 00:15:20,520 and this has global impact. 244 00:15:22,270 --> 00:15:24,853 We know that the changes that we see in Arctic 245 00:15:24,936 --> 00:15:27,853 does not only stay in the Arctic. 246 00:15:31,437 --> 00:15:33,270 Yeah, I've been working on sea ice 247 00:15:33,354 --> 00:15:35,062 the last 50 years pretty much. 248 00:15:35,145 --> 00:15:39,686 And the whole Arctic has changed so much in that time. 249 00:15:39,770 --> 00:15:44,103 Loss of ice, loss of not only a loss of area of ice, 250 00:15:44,187 --> 00:15:45,728 but the loss of the appearance 251 00:15:45,811 --> 00:15:48,604 of the great ice fields of the past 252 00:15:48,686 --> 00:15:52,062 with huge pressure ridges and very, very thick ice. 253 00:15:52,145 --> 00:15:56,479 Really dramatic ice scenery has all gone. 254 00:15:58,853 --> 00:16:01,728 Last month I was up in the Barents Sea 255 00:16:01,811 --> 00:16:04,062 on a research cruise in a region where 256 00:16:04,145 --> 00:16:07,019 normally you would have quite a lot of multiyear ice. 257 00:16:07,102 --> 00:16:08,895 We couldn't find any multiyear ice. 258 00:16:15,894 --> 00:16:20,145 So the ice was all very thin, 30 centimeters thick. 259 00:16:20,228 --> 00:16:23,478 The Arctic Ocean is no longer a continent of ice 260 00:16:23,561 --> 00:16:26,312 but something that becomes just water in summer. 261 00:16:26,395 --> 00:16:31,727 There is a real, a huge loss as far as beauty is concerned, 262 00:16:31,810 --> 00:16:36,770 but also as far as the physics of how the planet operates. 263 00:16:36,853 --> 00:16:39,644 The ice is disappearing because the climate's warming, 264 00:16:39,727 --> 00:16:41,977 that's pretty obvious that will happen, 265 00:16:42,061 --> 00:16:44,354 but there's much more to it than that, 266 00:16:44,437 --> 00:16:46,270 because in fact you have 267 00:16:46,354 --> 00:16:48,685 many other feedback mechanisms going on 268 00:16:48,769 --> 00:16:50,810 which cause the effects on the planet 269 00:16:50,894 --> 00:16:54,270 to be far worse than just the retreat of the ice. 270 00:16:57,061 --> 00:16:58,561 So the Arctic's warming up 271 00:16:58,644 --> 00:17:00,604 three times faster than the rest of the world 272 00:17:00,686 --> 00:17:02,103 and the temperature difference 273 00:17:02,187 --> 00:17:04,562 between the Arctic and lower latitudes 274 00:17:04,645 --> 00:17:06,894 is getting less, and that means 275 00:17:06,977 --> 00:17:10,020 that the jet stream is getting to be weaker. 276 00:17:10,103 --> 00:17:11,562 And as it gets weaker, 277 00:17:11,645 --> 00:17:14,019 it goes from being almost a straight line 278 00:17:14,102 --> 00:17:19,770 to becoming big lobes reaching up north and south. 279 00:17:19,853 --> 00:17:21,603 And with it, when you have a lobe like that, 280 00:17:21,685 --> 00:17:23,935 it means that polar air can come down 281 00:17:24,019 --> 00:17:28,228 to lower latitudes than it normally reaches in one sector, 282 00:17:28,312 --> 00:17:30,769 and then in the sector to the east or west of it, 283 00:17:30,852 --> 00:17:33,353 you've got warm air going up north 284 00:17:33,436 --> 00:17:34,978 further than it should do. 285 00:17:35,062 --> 00:17:37,395 So you're getting bizarre weather extremes 286 00:17:37,479 --> 00:17:39,727 which of course everybody's been commenting on. 287 00:17:39,810 --> 00:17:41,519 The trouble is where these air masses 288 00:17:41,603 --> 00:17:44,562 are causing such extreme changes 289 00:17:44,645 --> 00:17:46,354 happens to be the latitudes 290 00:17:46,437 --> 00:17:49,519 at which you have the maximum food production. 291 00:17:49,603 --> 00:17:51,603 Suddenly our ability to feed everyone 292 00:17:51,685 --> 00:17:55,519 is being affected by these polar changes. 293 00:17:57,394 --> 00:17:59,394 You can't take that amount of ice away 294 00:17:59,478 --> 00:18:02,145 without affecting so many other things. 295 00:18:13,769 --> 00:18:17,810 The impact of our actions are starting to hit home. 296 00:18:17,894 --> 00:18:20,603 Scientists' predictions are now coming true 297 00:18:20,685 --> 00:18:22,353 sooner than expected. 298 00:18:22,436 --> 00:18:25,935 We are tragically suffering through severe storms, 299 00:18:26,019 --> 00:18:28,686 droughts, floods and fires 300 00:18:28,770 --> 00:18:31,727 that are progressively becoming more intense 301 00:18:31,810 --> 00:18:33,186 and more unpredictable. 302 00:19:17,311 --> 00:19:20,436 Fires started almost simultaneously 303 00:19:20,519 --> 00:19:22,353 in multiple places. 304 00:19:24,186 --> 00:19:27,852 Over 7,000 structures were destroyed 305 00:19:27,935 --> 00:19:29,977 and about 3,000 homes. 306 00:19:30,061 --> 00:19:33,102 I think at the height in the early days of the fire, 307 00:19:33,186 --> 00:19:38,603 maybe about 100,000 people were evacuated. 308 00:19:38,685 --> 00:19:42,102 It's a collective trauma. 309 00:19:44,311 --> 00:19:47,269 Sounded like a war zone, looked like a war zone. 310 00:19:47,353 --> 00:19:50,144 They talk about the Hanley Fire, it took a day to get here. 311 00:19:50,227 --> 00:19:53,019 It burned about the same footprint, but it took about a day. 312 00:19:53,102 --> 00:19:55,478 It burned less than 200 structures. 313 00:19:55,561 --> 00:19:57,144 This fire started at night, 314 00:19:57,227 --> 00:19:59,935 made it to Santa Rosa in four, four and a half hours, 315 00:20:00,019 --> 00:20:02,809 and there's no comparison other than the footprint. 316 00:20:02,893 --> 00:20:04,269 Cal Fire Incident Management Team 317 00:20:04,353 --> 00:20:06,935 came here to help run this incident 318 00:20:07,019 --> 00:20:08,644 and he just shook his head and said, 319 00:20:08,727 --> 00:20:10,310 "Man, I've never seen anything like this. 320 00:20:10,393 --> 00:20:12,519 I've been doing this a long time." 321 00:20:12,644 --> 00:20:15,603 So that's not terribly comforting, 322 00:20:15,685 --> 00:20:19,560 but that's where we're at right now. 323 00:20:19,643 --> 00:20:21,143 If we keep having these wind events, 324 00:20:21,227 --> 00:20:22,644 how do we protect our citizens? 325 00:20:22,727 --> 00:20:24,561 How do we protect our infrastructure? 326 00:20:24,644 --> 00:20:26,311 What are the things that we can do 327 00:20:26,394 --> 00:20:29,226 to make it as good as possible? 328 00:20:29,310 --> 00:20:32,561 We've been through four, five years of drought. 329 00:20:32,644 --> 00:20:35,684 That drought stresses all the brush, all the trees. 330 00:20:35,768 --> 00:20:40,061 And the winds at Geyser Peak on one of the weather station 331 00:20:40,144 --> 00:20:43,394 was clocked at 108 miles an hour. 332 00:20:43,478 --> 00:20:45,226 And I don't know what you do with those kinds of winds. 333 00:20:45,310 --> 00:20:47,727 When something catches on fire, 334 00:20:47,810 --> 00:20:50,727 it's all you can do to try to figure out where it's going 335 00:20:50,810 --> 00:20:52,435 and how fast it's gonna get there. 336 00:20:55,851 --> 00:20:57,519 I never would have thought a fire 337 00:20:57,603 --> 00:21:00,768 would come out of the hills and run the flats in Santa Rosa. 338 00:21:00,851 --> 00:21:01,851 I really didn't. 339 00:21:03,851 --> 00:21:05,394 Cars were being flipped over. 340 00:21:05,478 --> 00:21:10,060 There were shoebox chunks of, you know, embers 341 00:21:10,143 --> 00:21:13,477 that were being carried well ahead of the fire. 342 00:21:13,560 --> 00:21:15,311 You'll see there's some trees 343 00:21:15,394 --> 00:21:17,353 where all the limbs are just, they're snapped off. 344 00:21:17,436 --> 00:21:19,643 They're not burned off, they're snapped off. 345 00:21:22,185 --> 00:21:25,478 These natural disasters are so common now 346 00:21:25,561 --> 00:21:28,934 that people know it's gonna happen to their community. 347 00:21:29,018 --> 00:21:33,436 It's not like a matter of if, but when. 348 00:21:33,519 --> 00:21:36,726 It is a wake-up call to everyone 349 00:21:36,809 --> 00:21:39,310 that climate change is here 350 00:21:39,393 --> 00:21:42,102 and that you need to plan for it. 351 00:21:47,934 --> 00:21:53,101 Climate disruption is causing a rise in extinctions today, 352 00:21:53,185 --> 00:21:56,393 but this isn't the first time. 353 00:21:56,477 --> 00:22:00,226 Scientists studying geological records have shown 354 00:22:00,310 --> 00:22:03,851 there is a connection between spikes in carbon 355 00:22:03,934 --> 00:22:07,019 and the past five mass extinctions. 356 00:22:09,018 --> 00:22:10,934 There is a natural law 357 00:22:11,018 --> 00:22:15,810 that the carbon cycle affects the fabric of life. 358 00:22:15,894 --> 00:22:19,435 Every time there has been a massive increase in carbon, 359 00:22:19,518 --> 00:22:24,934 the web of life weakens and sometimes collapses. 360 00:22:30,684 --> 00:22:35,435 I've been working on the way in which the carbon cycle 361 00:22:35,518 --> 00:22:38,851 is associated with the occurrence of mass extinctions 362 00:22:38,934 --> 00:22:43,602 and whether the carbon cycle can undergo instabilities associated with them. 363 00:22:45,268 --> 00:22:48,185 So the carbon cycle is where life 364 00:22:48,268 --> 00:22:50,393 and the environment interact. 365 00:22:50,477 --> 00:22:54,018 You can think of it as one grand loop between photosynthesis, 366 00:22:54,101 --> 00:22:58,018 which is a process that takes carbon dioxide out of the atmosphere 367 00:22:58,101 --> 00:23:03,393 and converts it to oxygen and plant matter or organic carbon. 368 00:23:03,477 --> 00:23:06,435 And then the back reaction of the loop we call respiration 369 00:23:06,518 --> 00:23:11,809 which is the process via which we convert that plant matter to carbon dioxide. 370 00:23:13,809 --> 00:23:16,560 The grand loop of the carbon cycle takes about 371 00:23:16,643 --> 00:23:20,643 a hundred gigaton of carbon out of the atmosphere and oceans every year 372 00:23:20,726 --> 00:23:22,560 and it returns it each year. 373 00:23:22,643 --> 00:23:24,392 So this is a hundred gigatons out 374 00:23:24,476 --> 00:23:26,893 and a hundred gigatons back in. 375 00:23:26,976 --> 00:23:31,518 But what we're contributing is on the order of about 8% from fossil fuel burning. 376 00:23:31,602 --> 00:23:36,768 It's an 8% increase compared to what is normally going back and forth in a year. 377 00:23:36,851 --> 00:23:41,184 It turns out to be more than what volcanoes are putting into the system. 378 00:23:53,435 --> 00:23:57,435 The planet is constantly in the process 379 00:23:57,518 --> 00:24:00,893 of rebalancing its cycles, like its water cycle 380 00:24:00,976 --> 00:24:03,101 and its nitrogen cycle and its carbon cycle. 381 00:24:03,185 --> 00:24:06,683 You've gotta think of it as it's in constant flow. 382 00:24:06,767 --> 00:24:09,851 And part of the planet's doing that, you know, 383 00:24:09,934 --> 00:24:15,392 was to take all the carbon that was in the dinosaurs and land plants 384 00:24:15,476 --> 00:24:21,268 and press that into eventually oil and fossil fuels. 385 00:24:21,352 --> 00:24:24,267 Over long periods of time it was sequestered 386 00:24:24,351 --> 00:24:27,477 and we're a young species. 387 00:24:27,560 --> 00:24:31,808 And we were curious and we dug up the carbon 388 00:24:31,892 --> 00:24:35,393 that had been sequestered by the earth. 389 00:24:35,477 --> 00:24:39,143 And we burned it, not knowing it was like 390 00:24:39,226 --> 00:24:43,683 burning furniture in a house with its windows closed. 391 00:24:44,893 --> 00:24:46,310 So what's happened 392 00:24:46,393 --> 00:24:49,225 is that the planet is reeling from that. 393 00:24:49,309 --> 00:24:53,643 There's an excess of carbon up in the atmosphere. 394 00:24:53,726 --> 00:24:58,725 What it's doing is causing the living conditions 395 00:24:58,808 --> 00:25:02,518 here on earth to go out of balance. 396 00:25:02,602 --> 00:25:06,559 So as a biologist, when I look at climate change, 397 00:25:06,642 --> 00:25:11,893 yes, I look at rising seas and melting polar caps. 398 00:25:11,976 --> 00:25:14,017 Those are evidence for me. 399 00:25:14,100 --> 00:25:19,435 But when we begin to look at what's happening 400 00:25:19,518 --> 00:25:24,850 to the biological organisms in response to the warming trends, 401 00:25:24,933 --> 00:25:27,142 they are already on the move. 402 00:25:27,225 --> 00:25:31,683 They're moving towards the poles to get cooler. 403 00:25:31,767 --> 00:25:35,850 They're moving from the lower mountains up in elevation, 404 00:25:35,933 --> 00:25:39,517 meaning their ranges are moving. 405 00:25:39,601 --> 00:25:43,683 They also sometimes move without their helpers. 406 00:25:43,767 --> 00:25:46,809 A plant will move north and its pollinator won't make it. 407 00:25:46,893 --> 00:25:49,892 This is called in our bloodless language of science, 408 00:25:49,975 --> 00:25:53,517 it's called ecological disruptions. 409 00:25:55,642 --> 00:25:58,808 So for me, if we change the very conditions 410 00:25:58,892 --> 00:26:01,892 that gave rise to all of this, 411 00:26:01,975 --> 00:26:06,476 and to us, we-- 412 00:26:07,517 --> 00:26:09,142 It's gonna get crazy. 413 00:26:12,310 --> 00:26:14,392 When the carbon cycle is unstable, 414 00:26:14,476 --> 00:26:18,975 it moves into a realm that we don't understand. 415 00:26:19,059 --> 00:26:21,892 Going back to geologic time is that occasionally 416 00:26:21,975 --> 00:26:25,725 there are these essentially bursts within the carbon cycle 417 00:26:25,808 --> 00:26:27,642 in which things change. 418 00:26:30,601 --> 00:26:32,100 One of them which is widely known 419 00:26:32,184 --> 00:26:34,933 as the Paleocene Eocene Thermal Maxima 420 00:26:35,017 --> 00:26:36,850 55 million years ago. 421 00:26:38,975 --> 00:26:42,017 And others which are decidedly worse. 422 00:26:42,100 --> 00:26:43,767 They're destructive or catastrophic events. 423 00:26:43,850 --> 00:26:45,392 They're mass extinctions. 424 00:26:45,476 --> 00:26:48,059 The worst of them known as the Permian Extinction. 425 00:26:51,476 --> 00:26:52,975 So that's the historical record 426 00:26:53,059 --> 00:26:54,891 but what we're doing to the carbon cycle now 427 00:26:54,974 --> 00:26:56,601 is another kind of problem 428 00:26:56,683 --> 00:26:58,850 because now we know what's going on. 429 00:26:58,933 --> 00:27:03,224 We know that we have been adding carbon dioxide 430 00:27:03,308 --> 00:27:05,100 as a consequence of fossil fuels. 431 00:27:05,184 --> 00:27:07,434 And then the question is, does that risk 432 00:27:07,517 --> 00:27:10,476 engendering the kind of bursts that we've seen in the past 433 00:27:10,559 --> 00:27:11,974 that could create what I would call 434 00:27:12,058 --> 00:27:14,767 an instability in the carbon cycle? 435 00:27:14,850 --> 00:27:17,559 That is one in which small changes 436 00:27:17,642 --> 00:27:19,476 become bigger changes. 437 00:27:19,559 --> 00:27:23,225 That's a precise scientists' definition of catastrophe. 438 00:27:24,725 --> 00:27:26,975 When you get down to the individual level, 439 00:27:27,059 --> 00:27:29,766 losing one's home to a flood is a catastrophe. 440 00:28:50,975 --> 00:28:52,849 We can still avoid 441 00:28:52,932 --> 00:28:55,391 breaching that dangerous limit of two degrees, 442 00:28:55,475 --> 00:28:56,891 but if you do the math, 443 00:28:56,974 --> 00:28:59,601 with each passing year of relative inaction, 444 00:28:59,683 --> 00:29:01,682 it's getting more and more difficult 445 00:29:01,766 --> 00:29:03,807 to limit our carbon emissions 446 00:29:03,891 --> 00:29:07,434 and remain under two degrees Celsius warming. 447 00:30:17,433 --> 00:30:21,183 We know we have put too much carbon into the atmosphere. 448 00:30:21,266 --> 00:30:23,891 But how much is too much? 449 00:30:23,974 --> 00:30:26,974 Scientists have figured out what that amount is 450 00:30:27,058 --> 00:30:29,141 and have created a carbon budget 451 00:30:29,224 --> 00:30:32,974 that will create a margin for life. 452 00:30:33,058 --> 00:30:35,807 This budget tells us where we are now, 453 00:30:35,891 --> 00:30:38,058 how much more carbon we can burn 454 00:30:38,141 --> 00:30:40,350 and how much needs to be removed 455 00:30:40,433 --> 00:30:44,766 in order to sustain life on earth as we know it. 456 00:30:48,433 --> 00:30:50,141 I would say the major challenge 457 00:30:50,224 --> 00:30:53,224 is indeed dangerous climate change. 458 00:30:53,308 --> 00:30:57,433 And if we want to avoid dangerous climate change, 459 00:30:57,516 --> 00:31:00,682 well, then we have to accept that the atmosphere 460 00:31:00,766 --> 00:31:03,974 is for humankind a limiting disposal space. 461 00:31:04,058 --> 00:31:09,015 So roughly we can emit 800 gigatons CO2 462 00:31:09,098 --> 00:31:12,391 into the atmosphere in this limiting disposal space. 463 00:31:12,475 --> 00:31:16,182 And if you take into account that over the last five years 464 00:31:16,265 --> 00:31:19,058 we have already used 200 gigatons, 465 00:31:19,141 --> 00:31:23,016 so this basically means that over the next two decades 466 00:31:23,099 --> 00:31:27,224 we have exhausted the limiting disposal space. 467 00:31:27,308 --> 00:31:30,224 So in Paris it was very important 468 00:31:30,308 --> 00:31:33,057 that the whole world and the whole world leaders 469 00:31:33,140 --> 00:31:36,724 agreed on limiting temperature increase 470 00:31:36,807 --> 00:31:38,558 to well below two degrees. 471 00:31:38,641 --> 00:31:40,891 So that's the kind of safeguard line 472 00:31:40,974 --> 00:31:42,349 and it's very important that 473 00:31:42,432 --> 00:31:45,141 more than a hundred nations stand behind it. 474 00:31:45,224 --> 00:31:47,932 So imagine the volume that is in this ball. 475 00:31:48,016 --> 00:31:50,640 That's a kind of symbol for the CO2 476 00:31:50,723 --> 00:31:54,932 that is still in the ground in terms of coal 477 00:31:55,016 --> 00:31:57,558 or in the form of oil and gas. 478 00:31:57,641 --> 00:32:00,515 So this is the amount of carbon. 479 00:32:00,599 --> 00:32:03,807 And if we want to limit the temperature 480 00:32:03,891 --> 00:32:07,015 to two degrees globally, we may only emit 481 00:32:07,098 --> 00:32:10,974 this little amount of carbon into the atmosphere. 482 00:32:11,058 --> 00:32:14,308 And to see that we have a lot more of carbon 483 00:32:14,391 --> 00:32:18,182 still stored in the ground that we can emit in the atmosphere 484 00:32:18,265 --> 00:32:21,266 when we want to limit the temperature to two degrees. 485 00:32:21,350 --> 00:32:24,057 So therefore the question is, how does it fit together? 486 00:32:24,140 --> 00:32:26,806 So, now for the next 20 years, 487 00:32:26,890 --> 00:32:29,266 this is an enormous important time span 488 00:32:29,350 --> 00:32:31,308 to transform our economies, 489 00:32:31,391 --> 00:32:34,848 to decouple economic growth from emission growth. 490 00:32:34,931 --> 00:32:39,058 And by middle of the century, we need zero emissions, 491 00:32:39,141 --> 00:32:44,140 and after 2050 you need even negative emissions. 492 00:32:44,223 --> 00:32:47,641 The carbon clock is just informing people where we are now. 493 00:32:47,724 --> 00:32:50,931 What is the pathway how we exhaust 494 00:32:51,015 --> 00:32:54,475 the limiting disposal space of the atmosphere. 495 00:32:54,558 --> 00:32:57,265 And this is a huge challenge for humankind. 496 00:33:08,681 --> 00:33:11,974 Science tells us that our current climate crisis 497 00:33:12,058 --> 00:33:14,681 is a problem we've created. 498 00:33:14,765 --> 00:33:17,765 But it is also a problem we can fix. 499 00:33:17,848 --> 00:33:21,641 Not only do we need to stop emitting carbon at the current levels 500 00:33:21,724 --> 00:33:24,057 by switching to renewable energy, 501 00:33:24,140 --> 00:33:29,308 but it is also critical to pull carbon out of the atmosphere. 502 00:33:29,391 --> 00:33:34,848 Climate change can be reversed if we act now. 503 00:33:34,931 --> 00:33:38,016 Recently researchers have figured out what solutions 504 00:33:38,099 --> 00:33:43,140 can draw carbon down, getting us back to pre-industrial levels. 505 00:33:46,265 --> 00:33:49,390 There's only two things you can do about the atmosphere. 506 00:33:49,474 --> 00:33:52,223 You can either stop putting greenhouse gases up there 507 00:33:52,307 --> 00:33:55,223 or you can bring CO2 back down. That's it. 508 00:33:55,307 --> 00:33:57,515 And you can do the first one by conservation, 509 00:33:57,599 --> 00:34:00,140 energy efficiency and clean energy. 510 00:34:00,223 --> 00:34:02,765 And the second one through photosynthesis, 511 00:34:02,848 --> 00:34:07,599 whether it's on land, on farms, on forests, phytoplankton, 512 00:34:07,681 --> 00:34:10,390 kelp in the oceans; there's only two things you can do. 513 00:34:10,474 --> 00:34:13,432 So that actually sorts it pretty simply. 514 00:34:13,515 --> 00:34:17,723 And in the past what has been done in terms of solutions 515 00:34:17,806 --> 00:34:20,057 is that it's focused on energy. 516 00:34:20,140 --> 00:34:22,015 Energy, energy, energy. 517 00:34:22,098 --> 00:34:24,057 And the reason for that is understandable. 518 00:34:24,140 --> 00:34:25,848 So it makes perfect sense to say, 519 00:34:25,931 --> 00:34:29,140 "Well, let's stop putting that CO2 up there," 520 00:34:29,223 --> 00:34:32,723 excepting that in the process of emphasizing clean energy, 521 00:34:32,806 --> 00:34:35,349 renewable energy, solar, wind, et cetera, 522 00:34:35,432 --> 00:34:39,973 it's sort of occluded the rest of the solutions. 523 00:34:49,015 --> 00:34:51,015 The purpose of Drawdown is to see 524 00:34:51,098 --> 00:34:54,765 if the 80 solutions that we had modeled 525 00:34:54,847 --> 00:34:58,723 would scale to the point where we could reverse global warming 526 00:34:58,806 --> 00:35:00,557 within 30 years, 527 00:35:00,640 --> 00:35:03,348 going from reduce to reverse. 528 00:35:03,431 --> 00:35:05,014 The bend the carbon curve, 529 00:35:05,097 --> 00:35:08,057 what Drawdown shows, is that we have choices. 530 00:35:08,140 --> 00:35:13,348 And that if we increase the rate that we're scaling some of the solutions, 531 00:35:13,431 --> 00:35:16,474 then we could achieve Drawdown at 2050. 532 00:35:18,265 --> 00:35:21,264 And if you say the odds are long, 533 00:35:21,348 --> 00:35:23,640 I agree, they're long odds. 534 00:35:23,723 --> 00:35:25,640 I'll take 'em. 535 00:35:54,181 --> 00:35:55,972 My name is Linwood Gill. 536 00:35:56,056 --> 00:35:59,557 I'm the Chief Forester for the Usal Redwood Forest Company. 537 00:36:00,890 --> 00:36:04,306 Usal Redwood Forest is a community forest, 538 00:36:04,389 --> 00:36:07,890 it's owned by a non-profit, the Redwood Forest Foundation. 539 00:36:07,973 --> 00:36:10,098 It's a 50,000 acre forest 540 00:36:10,182 --> 00:36:14,139 which is dedicated to managing the forest 541 00:36:14,222 --> 00:36:15,723 on a long-term basis 542 00:36:15,806 --> 00:36:18,182 for the economic stability of the community, 543 00:36:18,265 --> 00:36:21,431 as well as restoring the forest habitat, 544 00:36:21,514 --> 00:36:24,014 restoring the fish habitat, 545 00:36:24,097 --> 00:36:26,349 and also for sequestering carbon. 546 00:36:26,432 --> 00:36:32,348 And carbon sequestration is a main part of our operations right now. 547 00:36:32,431 --> 00:36:35,015 Carbon sequestration is an important part 548 00:36:35,098 --> 00:36:37,680 of combatting climate change. 549 00:36:37,764 --> 00:36:41,848 The Usal Redwood Forest is a very young redwood forest. 550 00:36:41,931 --> 00:36:45,598 and redwoods can absorb more carbon 551 00:36:45,680 --> 00:36:47,930 than any other forest type on the planet. 552 00:36:49,639 --> 00:36:51,140 Redwoods store carbon 553 00:36:51,223 --> 00:36:54,930 by absorbing carbon from carbon dioxide 554 00:36:55,014 --> 00:36:57,181 out of the air into its needles 555 00:36:57,264 --> 00:36:59,474 and stores it into the bowl of the tree, 556 00:36:59,557 --> 00:37:02,805 the trunk or the roots, the branches. 557 00:37:02,889 --> 00:37:04,639 To my knowledge, 558 00:37:04,722 --> 00:37:06,639 this is one of the largest carbon projects 559 00:37:06,722 --> 00:37:08,681 in the country, yes. 560 00:37:16,139 --> 00:37:19,056 I am the Biochar Project Manager 561 00:37:19,139 --> 00:37:21,431 for the Redwood Forest Foundation. 562 00:37:21,514 --> 00:37:25,139 We're sort of at a perfect storm right now in California 563 00:37:25,222 --> 00:37:29,431 where we have over a hundred million dead trees in the Sierra. 564 00:37:29,514 --> 00:37:32,306 And we need to do something with that. 565 00:37:34,222 --> 00:37:36,889 We have what is called the western pine bark beetle, 566 00:37:36,972 --> 00:37:41,972 which makes its living by feeding on ponderosa pine, and other trees as well. 567 00:37:43,722 --> 00:37:46,473 And these beetles have been around for thousands of years 568 00:37:46,556 --> 00:37:50,139 and have lived in harmony and balance with the trees. 569 00:37:50,222 --> 00:37:52,556 But unfortunately, because of climate change 570 00:37:52,639 --> 00:37:54,556 and because of the long drought, 571 00:37:54,639 --> 00:37:56,680 millions of trees are very weak 572 00:37:56,764 --> 00:38:00,930 and have difficulty defending themselves against the beetles. 573 00:38:01,014 --> 00:38:05,805 Biochar can definitely be one of the ways that we address the beetle damage 574 00:38:05,889 --> 00:38:08,431 in the dead and dying trees of the Sierras. 575 00:38:08,514 --> 00:38:13,514 Biochar is essentially the form of charcoal that is suitable 576 00:38:13,598 --> 00:38:15,139 for use in agriculture 577 00:38:15,222 --> 00:38:18,680 and in helping to build more healthy soil. 578 00:38:21,722 --> 00:38:24,805 When you pyrolize woody biomass particularly, 579 00:38:24,889 --> 00:38:28,972 about half of the carbon that is in that woody biomass 580 00:38:29,056 --> 00:38:32,764 can be saved, is a residual charcoal. 581 00:38:32,847 --> 00:38:36,514 And biochar is very much like coral for the soil 582 00:38:36,598 --> 00:38:39,556 in that it can hold nutrients, it can hold water. 583 00:38:39,639 --> 00:38:41,722 It's more of an architecture. 584 00:38:41,805 --> 00:38:43,638 It incubates life. 585 00:38:43,721 --> 00:38:46,972 You're saving about half of the carbon that's in that plant 586 00:38:47,056 --> 00:38:50,431 and then can put it to better use and sequestering it in soil 587 00:38:50,514 --> 00:38:53,389 for great benefit to agriculture. 588 00:38:53,473 --> 00:38:56,764 We have all this biomass that we have to do something with. 589 00:38:56,847 --> 00:38:59,472 They are a fire hazard and, as you know, 590 00:38:59,555 --> 00:39:03,264 right now we have something like ten fires in California. 591 00:39:03,348 --> 00:39:08,180 And by producing biochar we can return some of that material back into the forest 592 00:39:08,263 --> 00:39:11,847 in a safe manner, or we can take some of that biochar 593 00:39:11,930 --> 00:39:13,972 and take it down into the Central Valley, 594 00:39:14,056 --> 00:39:16,971 which desperately needs water savings. 595 00:39:17,055 --> 00:39:19,680 And one of the prime benefits of biochar 596 00:39:19,764 --> 00:39:23,514 is that it can help to retain water in soils. 597 00:39:23,598 --> 00:39:28,556 If we put biochar in just 10% of the world's soil, 598 00:39:28,639 --> 00:39:33,513 we'll actually sequester 29 billion tons of CO2. 599 00:39:33,597 --> 00:39:36,472 29 billion tons. That's on 10%. 600 00:39:36,555 --> 00:39:39,514 And that's using only-- quote-unquote-- 601 00:39:39,598 --> 00:39:43,513 "surplus waste material," so that's significant. 602 00:39:45,472 --> 00:39:49,014 And then we have the carbon offset credits. 603 00:39:49,097 --> 00:39:50,888 And to keep those carbon credits coming, 604 00:39:50,971 --> 00:39:54,055 we have to employ workers to do our forest inventories, 605 00:39:54,138 --> 00:39:56,389 to work with the carbon verifiers 606 00:39:56,473 --> 00:39:59,180 to make sure the carbon that we say is on the property 607 00:39:59,263 --> 00:40:00,721 is on the property, 608 00:40:00,804 --> 00:40:03,138 and then is maintained into the future. 609 00:40:03,221 --> 00:40:06,264 I'd like to think that we're a model that others can join in 610 00:40:06,348 --> 00:40:09,055 and do the same thing that we're doing out here. 611 00:40:09,138 --> 00:40:10,721 This isn't rocket science. 612 00:40:10,804 --> 00:40:15,305 The carbon storage, as we move into the future, is huge. 613 00:40:15,388 --> 00:40:18,597 And we need more larger, 614 00:40:18,679 --> 00:40:20,930 older forests, intact forests, 615 00:40:21,014 --> 00:40:23,222 that we know will never be developed 616 00:40:23,306 --> 00:40:25,888 and can continue into perpetuity. 617 00:40:42,513 --> 00:40:44,513 I'm Kate Scow, and I'm a professor 618 00:40:44,597 --> 00:40:46,347 in Land, Air and Water Resources 619 00:40:46,430 --> 00:40:48,431 at University of California, Davis. 620 00:40:48,514 --> 00:40:51,472 And I'm a soil microbial ecologist. 621 00:40:51,555 --> 00:40:54,929 So the carbon cycle on a global scale 622 00:40:55,013 --> 00:40:58,763 involves aquatic systems and terrestrial systems. 623 00:40:58,846 --> 00:41:02,971 So soil is a very important part of the terrestrial systems. 624 00:41:05,264 --> 00:41:08,388 Soil actually contains two to three times 625 00:41:08,472 --> 00:41:10,679 the amount of carbon that is in the atmosphere. 626 00:41:10,763 --> 00:41:15,513 Soil is the place where primary productivity is supported. 627 00:41:15,597 --> 00:41:18,679 That means all the vegetation that grows, 628 00:41:18,763 --> 00:41:22,679 that fixes CO2 through photosynthesis 629 00:41:22,763 --> 00:41:24,138 from the atmosphere, 630 00:41:24,221 --> 00:41:25,555 what miraculous, like, 631 00:41:25,638 --> 00:41:27,347 creating mass here on the ground 632 00:41:27,430 --> 00:41:28,971 out of what? Air? 633 00:41:29,055 --> 00:41:31,347 It's, like, still amazing to me. 634 00:41:31,430 --> 00:41:34,472 That productivity brings all this carbon in. 635 00:41:34,555 --> 00:41:37,430 The plant fixes the CO2, it dies, 636 00:41:37,513 --> 00:41:39,721 it falls onto the ground, 637 00:41:39,804 --> 00:41:41,138 and all that plant residue 638 00:41:41,221 --> 00:41:43,804 now enters into the soil carbon cycle. 639 00:41:43,888 --> 00:41:46,180 It's way bigger than the atmosphere, 640 00:41:46,263 --> 00:41:49,096 what is residing in soil. 641 00:41:50,513 --> 00:41:54,472 So organic farms obtain their nutrients 642 00:41:54,555 --> 00:41:56,970 not from synthetic fertilizers. 643 00:41:57,054 --> 00:42:01,597 The fertilizer is in the form of organic material. 644 00:42:01,679 --> 00:42:04,596 That could be cover crops, or it could be compost 645 00:42:04,678 --> 00:42:08,888 that's made of food wastes or yard wastes or animal waste 646 00:42:08,971 --> 00:42:10,638 that you put in the soil. 647 00:42:10,721 --> 00:42:12,970 So in organic systems, you may be putting 648 00:42:13,054 --> 00:42:17,013 up to eight times as much carbon into the soil 649 00:42:17,096 --> 00:42:19,846 compared to a conventional system. 650 00:42:19,929 --> 00:42:23,430 So it's like part of it is really basic. 651 00:42:26,430 --> 00:42:30,554 Climate change gives us an opportunity 652 00:42:30,637 --> 00:42:35,013 to really behave differently on this planet. 653 00:42:35,096 --> 00:42:38,055 We see what we can do at our worst, 654 00:42:38,138 --> 00:42:40,304 and now the question is, 655 00:42:40,387 --> 00:42:46,221 if we were to consciously... 656 00:42:46,305 --> 00:42:50,013 be a part of the healing... 657 00:42:50,096 --> 00:42:53,929 it'll unleash, I think, our creativity. 658 00:42:56,012 --> 00:42:59,138 You realize, "Oh my gosh, I have a back yard. 659 00:42:59,221 --> 00:43:03,180 Oh my gosh, I have a park near me." 660 00:43:05,095 --> 00:43:08,347 If we were to see ourselves as helpers 661 00:43:08,430 --> 00:43:11,138 who could help the helpers heal this planet... 662 00:43:13,762 --> 00:43:16,096 that is so much better than seeing ourselves 663 00:43:16,180 --> 00:43:18,597 as disruptive toddlers with matches. 664 00:43:18,679 --> 00:43:24,012 You begin to realize that all of us are somehow connected 665 00:43:24,095 --> 00:43:26,597 to little bits of the solution. 666 00:43:26,679 --> 00:43:30,387 Right now we live and direct at my mentor's house, 667 00:43:30,471 --> 00:43:33,763 the OG, the organic gardener, Ron Finley. 668 00:43:33,846 --> 00:43:35,846 I'm more inspired to always come here 669 00:43:35,929 --> 00:43:37,678 and learn and figure out different ways 670 00:43:37,762 --> 00:43:40,429 to how I can actually utilize a small plot of land 671 00:43:40,512 --> 00:43:43,096 to grow the most that I can. 672 00:43:43,180 --> 00:43:46,262 Culinary climate action is basically what I like to see, 673 00:43:46,346 --> 00:43:50,971 when I'm growing the food and it's basically taking all that carbon out the atmosphere, 674 00:43:51,055 --> 00:43:52,472 it's pulling it in. 675 00:43:52,555 --> 00:43:54,013 And we also can see the fact 676 00:43:54,095 --> 00:43:56,554 that we can put it back into the soil. 677 00:43:58,887 --> 00:44:01,888 Now only at the same time it's creating green jobs, 678 00:44:01,971 --> 00:44:05,512 you know, and also addressing things like diabetes and obesity 679 00:44:05,596 --> 00:44:07,179 in my community, where I come from. 680 00:44:07,262 --> 00:44:09,138 You know, there's a lot of plots, 681 00:44:09,221 --> 00:44:10,888 there's a lot of city access, 682 00:44:10,970 --> 00:44:12,803 there's a lot of water that's available. 683 00:44:12,887 --> 00:44:15,596 This is really just a beautiful cause and effect. 684 00:44:15,678 --> 00:44:20,596 We're literally pulling out all the harmful poisons 685 00:44:20,678 --> 00:44:23,471 that we, like, literally just emit into our atmosphere. 686 00:44:23,554 --> 00:44:27,513 And the best way that you want to transform that is by growing some food. 687 00:44:27,597 --> 00:44:29,928 Put it on the roof. Put it in your window sill. 688 00:44:31,387 --> 00:44:33,512 But we feel the heat rising. 689 00:44:33,596 --> 00:44:35,929 You know, being a farmer is being futuristic. 690 00:44:36,013 --> 00:44:37,554 There is no doomsday mentality. 691 00:44:37,637 --> 00:44:39,346 You have to actually plant water 692 00:44:39,429 --> 00:44:41,596 and think that you're going to reap what you sow. 693 00:44:41,678 --> 00:44:43,888 So that's the conversation that I'd like to see 694 00:44:43,971 --> 00:44:46,512 when we're talking about transforming the climate. 695 00:44:46,596 --> 00:44:48,012 It's not gonna happen overnight. 696 00:44:48,095 --> 00:44:51,554 But you do have to start now. Now is the time. 697 00:45:13,179 --> 00:45:14,928 My name is Bren Smith. 698 00:45:15,012 --> 00:45:17,262 I'm the owner of Thimble Island Ocean Farm. 699 00:45:17,346 --> 00:45:21,928 And we're here in the Thimble Islands in Long Island Sound. 700 00:45:22,012 --> 00:45:25,054 And I was, I'm born and raised in Newfoundland, Canada, 701 00:45:25,137 --> 00:45:27,887 high school dropout, and have fished all over the globe. 702 00:45:27,970 --> 00:45:30,387 I fished in Gloucester up in Newfoundland, 703 00:45:30,471 --> 00:45:32,887 and then I was in the Bering Sea for a bunch of years. 704 00:45:32,970 --> 00:45:36,304 And, you know, that was the height of industrialized fishing. 705 00:45:36,387 --> 00:45:39,220 We were tearing up entire eco-systems with our trawls, 706 00:45:39,304 --> 00:45:42,220 chasing fewer and fewer fish further and further out to sea. 707 00:45:42,304 --> 00:45:44,178 So it was completely unsustainable. 708 00:45:44,261 --> 00:45:45,928 In fact, a lot of the fish I was catching 709 00:45:46,012 --> 00:45:49,262 was going to McDonald's for their Fishwich sandwich. 710 00:45:51,471 --> 00:45:53,386 It really caused a wake-up call 711 00:45:53,470 --> 00:45:55,554 for a lot of folks in my generation. 712 00:45:55,678 --> 00:45:57,637 I was actually out in the Bering Sea, 713 00:45:57,720 --> 00:45:59,346 and the cod stocks crashed. 714 00:45:59,429 --> 00:46:02,094 And, you know, thousands of people thrown out of work, 715 00:46:02,178 --> 00:46:04,429 canneries shuttered, and it really taught me 716 00:46:04,512 --> 00:46:08,179 that you can build up an economy and a culture over hundreds of years 717 00:46:08,262 --> 00:46:10,178 and if you don't protect the resources, 718 00:46:10,261 --> 00:46:13,387 eco-system collapse can wipe it out in a matter of years. 719 00:46:15,887 --> 00:46:18,386 And that's when we really begin to realize 720 00:46:18,470 --> 00:46:22,262 that issues like overfishing, like climate change, 721 00:46:22,346 --> 00:46:24,012 that they're not environmental issues 722 00:46:24,095 --> 00:46:25,927 for a lot of us that work on the ocean, 723 00:46:26,011 --> 00:46:27,595 they're economic issues. I mean, 724 00:46:27,677 --> 00:46:30,179 there's gonna be no food, no jobs, on a dead planet. 725 00:46:32,596 --> 00:46:34,470 When I realized this wasn't sustainable, 726 00:46:34,553 --> 00:46:37,471 I went on this search for sustainability. 727 00:46:37,554 --> 00:46:40,179 I remade myself as an oysterman. 728 00:46:40,262 --> 00:46:43,136 And what oysters taught me was that Mother Nature 729 00:46:43,219 --> 00:46:45,844 created these technologies millions of years ago 730 00:46:45,927 --> 00:46:47,554 designed to mitigate our harm. 731 00:46:47,637 --> 00:46:49,637 We don't need advanced technologies. 732 00:46:49,720 --> 00:46:52,470 Mother Nature has seaweeds and shellfish 733 00:46:52,553 --> 00:46:55,762 which sequester five times more carbon than land-based plants, 734 00:46:55,845 --> 00:46:59,137 filter 50 gallons of water a day per oyster 735 00:46:59,220 --> 00:47:00,802 pulling nitrogen out of our system. 736 00:47:00,886 --> 00:47:03,303 I mean, my job as a steward of the ocean 737 00:47:03,386 --> 00:47:06,803 is to take Mother Nature's technologies and grow them. 738 00:47:06,887 --> 00:47:08,886 And it's pretty simple. 739 00:47:08,969 --> 00:47:13,637 So the beautiful thing about if you grow just restorative species, 740 00:47:13,720 --> 00:47:15,512 is there's zero inputs. 741 00:47:15,596 --> 00:47:18,011 We don't need fresh water, we don't need animal feed, 742 00:47:18,094 --> 00:47:20,511 we don't need fertilizer and we don't need land, 743 00:47:20,595 --> 00:47:23,845 making it hands down the most sustainable form of food production 744 00:47:23,928 --> 00:47:26,053 on the planet. 745 00:47:26,136 --> 00:47:29,470 So kelp is this beautiful seaweed. 746 00:47:29,553 --> 00:47:32,471 It's like the gateway drug to a new cuisine. 747 00:47:32,554 --> 00:47:34,719 It's one of the fastest-growing plants on earth. 748 00:47:34,802 --> 00:47:38,053 It soaks up five times more carbon than land-based plants. 749 00:47:38,136 --> 00:47:39,887 It's called the Sequoia of the Sea. 750 00:47:39,970 --> 00:47:41,677 But it's just the beginning. 751 00:47:41,761 --> 00:47:43,345 I mean, we're starting with kelp, 752 00:47:43,428 --> 00:47:47,178 but there are 10,000 edible plants in the ocean. 753 00:47:47,261 --> 00:47:50,261 Part of the plant we can turn into kelp noodles, 754 00:47:50,345 --> 00:47:54,844 but then this is just biofuel we turn into fertilizer 755 00:47:54,927 --> 00:47:56,970 and we can turn into animal feed. 756 00:47:57,054 --> 00:48:00,053 If you provide a seaweed diet to cows, 757 00:48:00,136 --> 00:48:03,303 you get a 90% reduction in methane output. 758 00:48:03,386 --> 00:48:05,387 It's stunning. And cows have been eating-- 759 00:48:05,471 --> 00:48:08,677 cows, sheep, goats, have been eating kelp for hundreds of years. 760 00:48:08,761 --> 00:48:11,053 Hebrides Islands, Maine, all sorts of places. 761 00:48:11,136 --> 00:48:12,553 You know, the volume's stunning. 762 00:48:12,636 --> 00:48:16,053 We can do 10 to 20 tons of kelp per acre, 763 00:48:16,136 --> 00:48:18,011 150,000 shellfish. 764 00:48:18,094 --> 00:48:19,470 And you scale this up, 765 00:48:19,553 --> 00:48:21,219 if you were to take a network of our farms 766 00:48:21,303 --> 00:48:23,054 totaling the size of Washington State, 767 00:48:23,137 --> 00:48:25,094 technically you could feed the world. 768 00:48:25,178 --> 00:48:28,094 If you took five percent of U.S. territorial waters 769 00:48:28,178 --> 00:48:30,011 and farmed in our style, 770 00:48:30,094 --> 00:48:31,887 you could create 50 million direct jobs 771 00:48:31,970 --> 00:48:36,303 and sequester the equivalent carbon of 20 million cars. 772 00:48:38,553 --> 00:48:41,677 Our farms also help mitigate acidification. 773 00:48:41,761 --> 00:48:44,802 The kelp creates something called a Halo Effect 774 00:48:44,886 --> 00:48:48,428 which reduces the acidity in the oceans, 775 00:48:48,511 --> 00:48:51,053 which then allow our oysters and other shellfish 776 00:48:51,136 --> 00:48:53,094 to grow thicker shells 777 00:48:53,178 --> 00:48:57,761 and not be as susceptible to acidification. 778 00:48:57,844 --> 00:49:00,553 So, I mean, climate change was supposed to be 779 00:49:00,636 --> 00:49:04,094 this 100-year sort of slow lobster boil. 780 00:49:04,178 --> 00:49:05,719 And instead it's here and now. 781 00:49:05,801 --> 00:49:07,428 Luckily, as fishermen, 782 00:49:07,511 --> 00:49:09,802 we can transition to something that keeps that 783 00:49:09,886 --> 00:49:12,011 and have the pride of helping feed my country, 784 00:49:12,094 --> 00:49:13,261 and that's just so exciting. 785 00:49:13,345 --> 00:49:15,136 I can be part of, you know, 786 00:49:15,219 --> 00:49:16,595 the army that's going to help, 787 00:49:16,677 --> 00:49:18,636 hopefully, save the planet. 788 00:49:30,969 --> 00:49:34,136 If we put 10 units of CO2 in the atmosphere, 789 00:49:34,219 --> 00:49:36,636 ten very large units of CO2 in the atmosphere, 790 00:49:36,719 --> 00:49:38,844 about five stay in the atmosphere 791 00:49:38,927 --> 00:49:40,843 and about two and a half go into plants 792 00:49:40,926 --> 00:49:43,636 and about two and a half goes into the ocean. 793 00:49:43,719 --> 00:49:47,219 So you've got an acidic ocean. So how do you deal with that? 794 00:49:47,303 --> 00:49:50,886 Nature handles this problem by making more shells, 795 00:49:50,969 --> 00:49:54,677 which is the marine snow idea, 796 00:49:54,761 --> 00:49:56,843 that little beasties grow in the water, 797 00:49:56,926 --> 00:50:00,219 they make calcium carbonate shells, so shells fall. 798 00:50:00,303 --> 00:50:03,511 The problem with that is, the planet loves to operate 799 00:50:03,595 --> 00:50:06,177 on time scales of millions of years. 800 00:50:06,260 --> 00:50:08,677 And we don't. 801 00:50:08,761 --> 00:50:13,094 So, question becomes, can you speed that process up? 802 00:50:17,802 --> 00:50:21,303 We have to investigate all our options. 803 00:50:21,386 --> 00:50:23,635 There are more experimental hypotheses 804 00:50:23,718 --> 00:50:25,886 that still need to be tested. 805 00:50:25,969 --> 00:50:32,218 One solution may lie in a microscopic community of life called marine snow. 806 00:50:34,636 --> 00:50:37,719 So, fundamentally, what do we need? 807 00:50:37,802 --> 00:50:41,344 Well, we need this planet as it was, 808 00:50:41,427 --> 00:50:45,677 we have to bring it in the state that it was 200 years ago. 809 00:50:45,761 --> 00:50:49,010 Higher concentrations of carbon dioxide, 810 00:50:49,093 --> 00:50:51,761 they increase acidity of the ocean. 811 00:50:51,844 --> 00:50:54,553 The oceans are losing their ability 812 00:50:54,636 --> 00:50:57,385 to capture carbon from the atmosphere. 813 00:50:57,469 --> 00:51:00,219 And we have to do something about it. 814 00:51:00,303 --> 00:51:03,345 We have to help these systems 815 00:51:03,428 --> 00:51:07,594 which cycle carbon between the atmosphere, 816 00:51:07,676 --> 00:51:10,511 between the plants on the land, 817 00:51:10,595 --> 00:51:13,260 and between the oceans. 818 00:51:13,344 --> 00:51:15,635 And with marine snow, 819 00:51:15,718 --> 00:51:19,719 it just needs a little help from us. 820 00:51:19,802 --> 00:51:23,718 The main products will be removal of carbon dioxide 821 00:51:23,801 --> 00:51:26,761 and the production of oxygen. 822 00:51:26,844 --> 00:51:28,470 What we can do is 823 00:51:28,553 --> 00:51:31,676 insert into the ocean very small, 824 00:51:31,760 --> 00:51:35,636 minute amounts of iron, 825 00:51:35,719 --> 00:51:37,428 but very, very little, 826 00:51:37,510 --> 00:51:39,260 so it doesn't have anything to do 827 00:51:39,344 --> 00:51:41,926 with that term "fertilization." 828 00:51:42,010 --> 00:51:44,927 To give you a measure, we need altogether 829 00:51:45,011 --> 00:51:48,635 about 6 kilograms of iron for initiating this process 830 00:51:48,718 --> 00:51:52,886 on 100,000 square kilometers of the southern oceans. 831 00:51:52,969 --> 00:51:56,510 The cells form organic matrix, 832 00:51:56,594 --> 00:51:58,469 which is the foundation 833 00:51:58,552 --> 00:52:01,844 for the formation of the marine snow. 834 00:52:01,927 --> 00:52:05,676 It is then, when the matrix appears, 835 00:52:05,760 --> 00:52:09,010 it becomes very attractive for cyanobacteria 836 00:52:09,093 --> 00:52:11,302 and heterotrophic bacteria, 837 00:52:11,385 --> 00:52:15,510 which colonize these particles, and then actively grow. 838 00:52:15,594 --> 00:52:18,927 And then we just let them do their job, 839 00:52:19,011 --> 00:52:22,344 because they can stay suspended 840 00:52:22,427 --> 00:52:25,177 for a very long period of time. 841 00:52:25,260 --> 00:52:28,135 We tracked these marine snow particles 842 00:52:28,218 --> 00:52:30,635 for more than four months... 843 00:52:30,718 --> 00:52:35,260 so they can float around and sequester organic matter, 844 00:52:35,344 --> 00:52:36,968 and when they become heavy, 845 00:52:37,052 --> 00:52:40,510 they simply sink down to the sea floor. 846 00:52:43,135 --> 00:52:45,926 The speed of this change, 847 00:52:46,010 --> 00:52:49,135 and increase in the concentrations and temperature-- 848 00:52:49,218 --> 00:52:51,093 we must act. 849 00:52:51,177 --> 00:52:52,427 And we can. 850 00:52:52,510 --> 00:52:56,594 I'm 100% positive that we can achieve 851 00:52:56,676 --> 00:53:01,469 um...reorganization of human activities 852 00:53:01,552 --> 00:53:05,427 to work together with nature, and not against it. 853 00:53:14,718 --> 00:53:18,675 Science has long proven we have existing technologies 854 00:53:18,759 --> 00:53:22,469 that work, and they are already being implemented. 855 00:53:22,552 --> 00:53:26,385 It's just become a matter of political will and scale. 856 00:53:26,469 --> 00:53:31,260 We need a multitude of solutions moving forward simultaneously. 857 00:53:31,344 --> 00:53:34,010 In order to solve this crisis, 858 00:53:34,093 --> 00:53:39,302 it is critical we move to 100% renewable energy now. 859 00:53:39,385 --> 00:53:41,385 So, the top five solutions, 860 00:53:41,469 --> 00:53:45,634 number two was onshore wind, and that wasn't a surprise. 861 00:53:53,301 --> 00:53:57,260 Onshore wind, though, being much greater than solar, 862 00:53:57,344 --> 00:53:59,760 was a surprise to us. 863 00:54:03,968 --> 00:54:07,510 Solar was number eight in ten, actually. 864 00:54:11,967 --> 00:54:15,218 The sun is the largest resource we have. 865 00:54:15,302 --> 00:54:17,925 All the other resources pale compared to the sun. 866 00:54:18,009 --> 00:54:19,759 We have known that for a long time, 867 00:54:19,842 --> 00:54:23,093 we just never understood how to harvest it in an economic way. 868 00:54:23,177 --> 00:54:25,302 That's what's different now. 869 00:54:25,385 --> 00:54:28,675 Solar PV is in a stage where we're already lower than fossil fuel. 870 00:54:28,759 --> 00:54:30,968 Well, solar has come a long way. 871 00:54:31,052 --> 00:54:34,260 Carter in the '80s already installed solar in the White House. 872 00:54:34,344 --> 00:54:36,426 Reagan tore it down later on. 873 00:54:36,509 --> 00:54:39,135 And only in 2001, 874 00:54:39,218 --> 00:54:42,760 when Germany started to deploy solar on a large scale, 875 00:54:42,842 --> 00:54:46,426 we have been getting the benefit of economy of scale. 876 00:54:46,509 --> 00:54:49,469 Eventually we will be able to power 877 00:54:49,552 --> 00:54:53,259 the entire electrical grids with solar and wind, 878 00:54:53,343 --> 00:54:57,135 and all we need is wind and storage, and solar and storage. 879 00:54:59,635 --> 00:55:03,593 So, if you want to power the entire United States with photovoltaic, 880 00:55:03,675 --> 00:55:07,052 we would need about 30,000 square miles in area. 881 00:55:07,135 --> 00:55:09,134 That would give us enough to power 882 00:55:09,217 --> 00:55:12,717 all the power grids in every state of the United States. 883 00:55:15,885 --> 00:55:20,800 Mount Signal is a project that powers about 70,000 homes in San Diego. 884 00:55:20,884 --> 00:55:25,426 The second phase, the power is going to be wheeled to Southern California. 885 00:55:27,551 --> 00:55:31,217 The price of electricity that we produce at Mount Signal 886 00:55:31,301 --> 00:55:33,800 is already lower than fossil fuels. 887 00:55:33,884 --> 00:55:38,051 It's also a price that delivers fuel price certainty to the utility. 888 00:55:39,925 --> 00:55:43,176 The price is flat over the next 25 years, 889 00:55:43,259 --> 00:55:49,052 not something that you get from any other fossil fuel energies. 890 00:55:49,135 --> 00:55:52,634 We have integrated so much solar in California already. 891 00:55:52,717 --> 00:55:55,675 Ten years ago, people would've said, "No, that's not really possible." 892 00:55:55,759 --> 00:55:58,925 Well, here we are, solar is covering already 893 00:55:59,009 --> 00:56:01,301 up to 25% of California. 894 00:56:01,384 --> 00:56:04,551 The rate payer had no material increase in pricing, 895 00:56:04,634 --> 00:56:07,010 and we're still alive, it all works. 896 00:56:07,092 --> 00:56:10,759 And we have been able to reduce carbon on the way there. 897 00:56:15,717 --> 00:56:18,176 Over the last years we saw now 898 00:56:18,259 --> 00:56:21,092 utilities volunteering to buy solar. 899 00:56:21,176 --> 00:56:24,051 We see this mindset shifting. 900 00:56:24,134 --> 00:56:27,551 We still under-appreciate the value that PV brings. 901 00:56:27,634 --> 00:56:31,259 People do not comprehend that in five years, 902 00:56:31,343 --> 00:56:33,468 we will have PV at much lower price. 903 00:56:33,551 --> 00:56:36,009 We will be able to dispatch it at night, 904 00:56:36,092 --> 00:56:38,634 and you combine that with wind, you get this paradigm 905 00:56:38,717 --> 00:56:42,217 where we are truly living in a hundred percent renewable environment. 906 00:56:42,301 --> 00:56:44,384 And this is feasible. 907 00:56:44,468 --> 00:56:47,426 We don't need any new invention for that, 908 00:56:47,509 --> 00:56:49,092 we know all the technology. 909 00:56:49,176 --> 00:56:53,384 We just need to make sure that the people responsible 910 00:56:53,468 --> 00:56:57,674 for the planning of resources, for the infrastructure planning, 911 00:56:57,758 --> 00:57:01,343 understand that this is a different technology, 912 00:57:01,426 --> 00:57:04,384 and it will get cheaper over time. 913 00:57:08,675 --> 00:57:10,301 Coal is coming back. 914 00:57:10,384 --> 00:57:11,884 - Clean coal is coming back. 915 00:57:11,967 --> 00:57:13,967 A hundred percent. 916 00:57:14,051 --> 00:57:18,675 My administration is putting an end to the war on coal. 917 00:57:18,759 --> 00:57:22,468 Gonna have clean coal, really clean coal. 918 00:57:51,551 --> 00:57:53,468 It's difficult enough, sometimes, 919 00:57:53,551 --> 00:57:55,259 to communicate science to the public. 920 00:57:55,343 --> 00:57:58,133 Now, you take that challenge, 921 00:57:58,216 --> 00:58:00,551 and you add to it 922 00:58:00,634 --> 00:58:05,592 a concerted effort by fossil fuel interests 923 00:58:05,674 --> 00:58:07,467 and the front groups that they fund 924 00:58:07,550 --> 00:58:10,343 to pollute the discourse over climate change, 925 00:58:10,426 --> 00:58:13,799 to confuse the public, to confuse policymakers. 926 00:58:13,883 --> 00:58:16,258 We need to transform our energy sector, 927 00:58:16,342 --> 00:58:18,217 move away from fossil fuel energy, 928 00:58:18,301 --> 00:58:19,717 towards renewable energy. 929 00:58:19,800 --> 00:58:21,800 Well, that's rather inconvenient 930 00:58:21,884 --> 00:58:23,924 for the powerful fossil fuel interests 931 00:58:24,008 --> 00:58:27,176 who have many millions of dollars invested 932 00:58:27,259 --> 00:58:29,925 in our continued addiction to fossil fuels. 933 00:58:30,009 --> 00:58:31,674 And they've fought tooth and nail 934 00:58:31,758 --> 00:58:33,383 to maintain that addiction, 935 00:58:33,467 --> 00:58:35,301 in part by attacking the science 936 00:58:35,384 --> 00:58:39,425 linking climate change to that behavior, 937 00:58:39,508 --> 00:58:41,924 the burning of fossil fuels. 938 00:58:45,925 --> 00:58:47,799 A question that we get asked a lot is, 939 00:58:47,883 --> 00:58:51,091 how do we know that the CO2 rise in the atmosphere 940 00:58:51,175 --> 00:58:52,758 is because of human activity. 941 00:58:52,842 --> 00:58:55,716 And the answer is that we leave fingerprints 942 00:58:55,799 --> 00:58:58,592 all over the atmosphere. 943 00:58:58,674 --> 00:59:02,384 And one of the fingerprints that we leave in the atmosphere 944 00:59:02,468 --> 00:59:06,674 is via what we call Carbon-14, or radioactive carbon. 945 00:59:06,758 --> 00:59:09,133 So when we burn coal, oil, and natural gas, 946 00:59:09,216 --> 00:59:11,593 we leave an imprint on the atmosphere 947 00:59:11,675 --> 00:59:16,175 of what we call negative Carbon-14, or less Carbon-14. 948 00:59:16,258 --> 00:59:18,383 Because fossil fuels are so old, 949 00:59:18,467 --> 00:59:20,966 there's no Carbon-14 left, it's all decayed away. 950 00:59:21,050 --> 00:59:23,716 We can actually measure, very accurately, 951 00:59:23,799 --> 00:59:26,008 how much fossil fuels we burn 952 00:59:26,091 --> 00:59:28,509 by measuring C-14 in the atmosphere. 953 00:59:28,593 --> 00:59:33,758 It is nature's verification system that we have. 954 00:59:36,967 --> 00:59:39,008 They've persuaded enough people 955 00:59:39,091 --> 00:59:41,258 and sowed enough doubt 956 00:59:41,342 --> 00:59:45,258 that it's making it more difficult than in the past 957 00:59:45,343 --> 00:59:47,841 to actually get anything done about climate change, 958 00:59:47,924 --> 00:59:49,799 and that's really depressing. 959 00:59:49,883 --> 00:59:51,841 And the fact is that the agenda 960 00:59:51,924 --> 00:59:54,176 that many of these fossil fuel corporations, 961 00:59:54,259 --> 00:59:57,883 and those who are running them are engaged in, is malicious 962 00:59:57,966 --> 00:59:59,467 in the danger it's creating 963 00:59:59,550 --> 01:00:01,550 and the havoc that it is wreaking on our planet. 964 01:00:01,633 --> 01:00:03,425 So we've got a bunch of people 965 01:00:03,508 --> 01:00:08,091 who are literally profiting off the death of life on Earth. 966 01:00:08,175 --> 01:00:11,133 I think that some climate denial, 967 01:00:11,216 --> 01:00:13,342 particularly the well-funded climate denial, 968 01:00:13,425 --> 01:00:16,133 that is being done by people who know better, 969 01:00:16,216 --> 01:00:18,550 rises to the level of a crime against humanity 970 01:00:18,633 --> 01:00:21,175 that probably should be prosecuted in the Hague. 971 01:00:29,342 --> 01:00:33,425 While climate deniers have succeeded in delaying action, 972 01:00:33,508 --> 01:00:36,840 a much more ominous problem has emerged. 973 01:00:36,923 --> 01:00:39,633 Very recently, scientists have recorded 974 01:00:39,716 --> 01:00:43,758 increasing levels of methane gas in the atmosphere. 975 01:00:43,841 --> 01:00:47,175 Methane, a powerful greenhouse gas, 976 01:00:47,258 --> 01:00:51,508 has the potential to increase temperatures even further. 977 01:00:51,592 --> 01:00:53,508 Increased methane is a sign 978 01:00:53,591 --> 01:00:56,674 that we are reaching a critical tipping point. 979 01:00:56,758 --> 01:00:58,674 But where is it coming from? 980 01:00:58,758 --> 01:01:03,007 And how much will it accelerate climate disruption? 981 01:01:03,090 --> 01:01:05,758 Scientists are racing to find out. 982 01:01:11,757 --> 01:01:13,966 So, we are in front of 983 01:01:14,050 --> 01:01:16,300 the University of Wyoming Mobile Laboratory. 984 01:01:16,383 --> 01:01:18,923 We have different instruments inside 985 01:01:19,007 --> 01:01:22,425 that measure what's in the air that we are breathing right now. 986 01:01:22,508 --> 01:01:24,342 It's doing that in real time. 987 01:01:24,425 --> 01:01:25,924 And we are able, like that, 988 01:01:26,008 --> 01:01:28,382 to chase emission sources and plumes, 989 01:01:28,466 --> 01:01:32,175 and understand where sources of pollutions are located, 990 01:01:32,258 --> 01:01:36,090 what activities are going on that lead to enhanced methane. 991 01:01:38,673 --> 01:01:40,924 Inside of our lab, we have a couple instruments. 992 01:01:41,008 --> 01:01:44,840 We have a proton-transfer-reaction time-of-flight mass spec 993 01:01:44,923 --> 01:01:48,758 to measure volatile organics like benzene, toluene. 994 01:01:48,841 --> 01:01:51,841 And then we also have a Picarro cavity ring-down 995 01:01:51,924 --> 01:01:54,174 to measure methane concentrations. 996 01:01:54,257 --> 01:01:57,883 We can see data from these instruments in real time 997 01:01:57,966 --> 01:02:01,382 due to an inlet we have up on our mast above the van, 998 01:02:01,466 --> 01:02:04,715 which pulls air in and feeds into our instruments. 999 01:02:04,798 --> 01:02:08,924 So, we found with aerial and road mapping 1000 01:02:09,008 --> 01:02:12,215 that we have more sources of methane in areas 1001 01:02:12,299 --> 01:02:14,924 where we extract the gas than we expected. 1002 01:02:15,008 --> 01:02:18,466 And to really pinpoint where there are leaks of methane, 1003 01:02:18,549 --> 01:02:20,715 you need to be very close to the sources. 1004 01:02:20,798 --> 01:02:23,758 And the mobile lab gives us the flexibility 1005 01:02:23,841 --> 01:02:27,882 to pinpoint where we see the largest leaks. 1006 01:02:27,965 --> 01:02:31,632 The company has drilled brand-new megapad, 1007 01:02:31,716 --> 01:02:36,049 22 wells in the middle of renewed urban development 1008 01:02:36,132 --> 01:02:37,757 in western Greeley. 1009 01:02:37,840 --> 01:02:40,049 This is a site that had a lot of contention, 1010 01:02:40,132 --> 01:02:42,883 given its size and its location. 1011 01:02:46,549 --> 01:02:49,090 So the local community, from what I've heard, 1012 01:02:49,174 --> 01:02:51,591 is not really kept up to breadth 1013 01:02:51,673 --> 01:02:53,382 on what's going on at the site. 1014 01:02:53,466 --> 01:02:55,840 There's a huge sound wall around the operation, 1015 01:02:55,923 --> 01:02:59,592 and the state is not really maybe doing its best 1016 01:02:59,674 --> 01:03:01,965 at facilitating the communication. 1017 01:03:02,049 --> 01:03:04,591 We saw operations going on with a lot of flaring. 1018 01:03:04,673 --> 01:03:06,507 It seems very large volume of gas. 1019 01:03:06,591 --> 01:03:08,965 The yellow color of the flame 1020 01:03:09,049 --> 01:03:11,923 tells you it's not complete combustion. 1021 01:03:12,007 --> 01:03:13,673 So, we are going to continue 1022 01:03:13,757 --> 01:03:15,883 doing those drives to understand those sources, 1023 01:03:15,966 --> 01:03:20,549 but also to track what the local population may be exposed to. 1024 01:03:20,632 --> 01:03:23,090 So some oil- and gas-producing regions 1025 01:03:23,174 --> 01:03:25,965 have such a large concentration of methane 1026 01:03:26,049 --> 01:03:29,299 in the atmosphere above them that you can see it from space, 1027 01:03:29,382 --> 01:03:32,798 and that's something that was described a few years back 1028 01:03:32,882 --> 01:03:34,715 for the Four Corners region, 1029 01:03:34,798 --> 01:03:37,965 and that's really the key for us to be like detectives 1030 01:03:38,049 --> 01:03:42,050 and map where we see the largest sources of emissions. 1031 01:03:53,965 --> 01:03:56,965 So in 2014, 1032 01:03:57,049 --> 01:04:00,507 NASA scientists in cooperation with NOAA, 1033 01:04:00,591 --> 01:04:03,757 University of Michigan, and other scientists, 1034 01:04:03,840 --> 01:04:06,965 identified a methane hotspot the size of Delaware 1035 01:04:07,049 --> 01:04:08,757 in the Four Corners region. 1036 01:04:08,840 --> 01:04:10,257 That methane hotspot 1037 01:04:10,341 --> 01:04:12,673 is the largest accumulation of methane gases 1038 01:04:12,757 --> 01:04:14,840 in the United States. 1039 01:04:14,923 --> 01:04:18,549 This ranch, this spot that we're on, 1040 01:04:18,632 --> 01:04:20,882 is approximately ground zero. 1041 01:04:20,965 --> 01:04:23,507 If you were able to identify a middle 1042 01:04:23,591 --> 01:04:26,049 for that Delaware-shaped cloud, 1043 01:04:26,132 --> 01:04:29,007 it might very well be right here where we're standing. 1044 01:04:29,090 --> 01:04:31,174 And it's closely identified 1045 01:04:31,257 --> 01:04:33,548 the cause of that methane hotspot 1046 01:04:33,631 --> 01:04:38,049 to be predominantly the emissions from drilling, 1047 01:04:38,132 --> 01:04:39,507 such as this site, 1048 01:04:39,591 --> 01:04:43,132 as well as coal and other fossil fuels. 1049 01:04:45,965 --> 01:04:48,549 So the methane hotspot is identified 1050 01:04:48,632 --> 01:04:50,756 basically because of the technology 1051 01:04:50,839 --> 01:04:52,632 that NOAA and NASA had 1052 01:04:52,715 --> 01:04:55,424 following the advent of the FLIR cameras, 1053 01:04:55,507 --> 01:04:57,257 which are the infrared cameras 1054 01:04:57,341 --> 01:05:00,882 that let us identify the leaks and vents and flares 1055 01:05:00,965 --> 01:05:04,424 that cause the methane hotspot to accumulate. 1056 01:05:04,507 --> 01:05:07,631 You have to think of it in its full sense, 1057 01:05:07,714 --> 01:05:10,632 and that is 60 years and more 1058 01:05:10,715 --> 01:05:14,341 of leaking, venting, flaring, 1059 01:05:14,424 --> 01:05:17,298 and careless practices here in the San Juan basin, 1060 01:05:17,381 --> 01:05:21,215 over a million acres, in total 30,000 wells, 1061 01:05:21,299 --> 01:05:23,797 that have caused that methane hotspot 1062 01:05:23,881 --> 01:05:25,881 to finally accumulate 1063 01:05:25,964 --> 01:05:28,382 and stand as evidence 1064 01:05:28,466 --> 01:05:31,341 of what natural gas drilling 1065 01:05:31,424 --> 01:05:33,590 ultimately results in. 1066 01:05:33,672 --> 01:05:35,423 People lose sight of the fact 1067 01:05:35,506 --> 01:05:38,757 that the conventional wells created the methane hotspot, 1068 01:05:38,840 --> 01:05:42,465 and that they are a daily culprit. 1069 01:05:47,007 --> 01:05:50,590 So, this is a conventional natural gas well. 1070 01:05:50,672 --> 01:05:53,798 This is very typical equipment throughout the San Juan basin 1071 01:05:53,882 --> 01:05:55,923 and many gas fields across America. 1072 01:05:56,007 --> 01:05:58,298 This one is leaking pretty badly 1073 01:05:58,381 --> 01:06:00,922 from some of the standard equipment that's on it. 1074 01:06:01,006 --> 01:06:03,174 This just requires, honestly, 1075 01:06:03,257 --> 01:06:07,256 a crescent wrench, a little bit of Teflon tape-- 1076 01:06:07,340 --> 01:06:10,048 some attention will fix this leak. 1077 01:06:10,131 --> 01:06:11,798 If I had a single wish, 1078 01:06:11,882 --> 01:06:17,298 my wish would be to pull an investor in oil and gas here 1079 01:06:17,381 --> 01:06:20,840 and stand them where I'm standing, let them see that leak. 1080 01:06:20,923 --> 01:06:24,672 Let them see that times 18,000 in the San Juan basin, 1081 01:06:24,756 --> 01:06:28,048 and get them to stop obstructing a federal rule 1082 01:06:28,132 --> 01:06:30,507 that stays in place to protect my family, 1083 01:06:30,590 --> 01:06:33,006 to protect taxpayers across New Mexico, 1084 01:06:33,089 --> 01:06:36,672 and provide federal fair and equal protection 1085 01:06:36,756 --> 01:06:38,632 across the western states. 1086 01:06:38,715 --> 01:06:40,881 Let's get those guys out of the boardroom, 1087 01:06:40,964 --> 01:06:42,672 right here on this well location, 1088 01:06:42,756 --> 01:06:45,715 let 'em look at that leak that can be easily fixed. 1089 01:06:45,798 --> 01:06:50,797 And when I found out that the EPA administrator, Scott Pruitt, 1090 01:06:50,881 --> 01:06:54,131 knew that the data had come in 1091 01:06:54,214 --> 01:06:58,256 that methane leaks and the chemicals that come with them 1092 01:06:58,340 --> 01:07:02,381 harm children to a greater degree than they did to me, 1093 01:07:02,465 --> 01:07:06,214 I was just outraged that he would try again 1094 01:07:06,298 --> 01:07:08,922 to roll back the federal protections for us. 1095 01:07:09,006 --> 01:07:12,007 You know, if someone came onto my ranch 1096 01:07:12,090 --> 01:07:15,631 with the stated objective of harming my children, 1097 01:07:15,714 --> 01:07:18,256 it would be over my dead body. 1098 01:07:31,881 --> 01:07:34,340 250 million years ago, 1099 01:07:34,423 --> 01:07:36,256 sudden releases of methane 1100 01:07:36,340 --> 01:07:38,756 produced kind of a secondary effect 1101 01:07:38,839 --> 01:07:42,672 that finished off large chunks of life on Earth. 1102 01:07:42,756 --> 01:07:44,672 And one of the debates right now 1103 01:07:44,756 --> 01:07:46,922 is whether the methane that is buried in the Arctic, 1104 01:07:47,006 --> 01:07:49,214 whether the methane that is, you know, in the permafrost, 1105 01:07:49,298 --> 01:07:50,881 in the seas all over the world, 1106 01:07:50,964 --> 01:07:54,548 how rapidly that will be mobilized, 1107 01:07:54,631 --> 01:07:57,298 and how destructive that mobilization will be. 1108 01:07:59,089 --> 01:08:01,381 The release of this ancient methane 1109 01:08:01,465 --> 01:08:05,173 may lead to exponentially more warming. 1110 01:08:05,256 --> 01:08:08,839 Will this methane create an apocalyptic scenario? 1111 01:08:08,922 --> 01:08:13,465 This is a question scientists are desperately trying to answer. 1112 01:08:13,548 --> 01:08:15,631 I'm the director of the Center 1113 01:08:15,714 --> 01:08:18,922 for Gas Hydrate, Environment, and Climate. 1114 01:08:19,006 --> 01:08:22,298 Here we have a team of 50 to 60 scientists 1115 01:08:22,381 --> 01:08:25,131 working on understanding the impact of methane 1116 01:08:25,214 --> 01:08:27,173 on the global climate system. 1117 01:08:27,256 --> 01:08:31,672 This methane is stored beneath the Arctic Ocean floor 1118 01:08:31,756 --> 01:08:34,465 in huge reservoirs, 1119 01:08:34,548 --> 01:08:36,839 at locations we sometimes know, 1120 01:08:36,922 --> 01:08:39,255 but we often do not know very much about it. 1121 01:08:39,339 --> 01:08:42,672 So, we are applying here geophysical methods 1122 01:08:42,756 --> 01:08:46,589 to quantify the methane hydrate reservoirs, 1123 01:08:46,671 --> 01:08:48,590 and also to see how stable 1124 01:08:48,672 --> 01:08:52,256 those methane hydrates are today, but also in the future. 1125 01:08:54,297 --> 01:08:58,423 Methane is one of the most aggressive greenhouse gases. 1126 01:08:58,506 --> 01:09:01,881 Methane has, fortunately, a shorter lifetime. 1127 01:09:01,964 --> 01:09:07,756 The Earth has a natural system for regulating input of methane 1128 01:09:07,839 --> 01:09:10,921 from the ocean into the atmosphere. 1129 01:09:11,005 --> 01:09:13,464 And this system is working quite efficiently. 1130 01:09:13,547 --> 01:09:18,006 But this system is also changing, because the ocean current system is changing, 1131 01:09:18,089 --> 01:09:20,130 the ocean temperature is changing, 1132 01:09:20,213 --> 01:09:23,172 the ocean chemistry is changing. 1133 01:09:23,256 --> 01:09:27,214 So, methane was in a kind of equilibrium for some time, 1134 01:09:27,298 --> 01:09:32,631 and during the last couple of years, we see quite a distinct increase in methane. 1135 01:09:32,714 --> 01:09:35,797 Do not know where this signal is coming from, 1136 01:09:35,881 --> 01:09:38,505 and at the present time, that, of course, 1137 01:09:38,589 --> 01:09:41,173 is putting a pressure on the scientific community 1138 01:09:41,256 --> 01:09:43,548 to give an answer to the politicians: 1139 01:09:43,631 --> 01:09:46,464 what is going on with the methane in the atmosphere? 1140 01:09:46,547 --> 01:09:48,422 Where is the methane coming from? 1141 01:09:48,505 --> 01:09:52,298 What is presently becoming more unstable? 1142 01:09:52,381 --> 01:09:54,838 We have done some very comprehensive 1143 01:09:54,921 --> 01:09:56,963 measurement campaigns where we have measured 1144 01:09:57,047 --> 01:09:59,881 at the sea floor, in the ocean, 1145 01:09:59,964 --> 01:10:03,130 at the sea surface, and in the air at the same time 1146 01:10:03,213 --> 01:10:08,839 to understand how methane is regulated in this whole system. 1147 01:10:08,922 --> 01:10:11,838 There is a lot of methane stored at the sea floor, 1148 01:10:11,921 --> 01:10:15,213 and this is so much that only a small change 1149 01:10:15,297 --> 01:10:19,630 might impact the ocean, or the atmosphere. 1150 01:10:23,047 --> 01:10:26,006 The balance here needs a lot more focus, 1151 01:10:26,089 --> 01:10:29,422 a lot more observations, and combining atmosphere, 1152 01:10:29,505 --> 01:10:32,963 ocean, climate, different kind of components together. 1153 01:10:35,422 --> 01:10:37,213 In my profession, 1154 01:10:37,297 --> 01:10:41,339 I'm interested in studying methane cold seeps in the ocean, 1155 01:10:41,422 --> 01:10:44,422 in the Russian Arctic, and also in the Barents Sea. 1156 01:10:44,505 --> 01:10:46,005 It's, well, basically, 1157 01:10:46,088 --> 01:10:48,213 streams of gas bubbles rising from the sea floor, 1158 01:10:48,297 --> 01:10:52,713 and those gas bubbles are mostly composed of methane gas. 1159 01:10:52,796 --> 01:10:55,505 First, it's gas hydrates, that's solid form. 1160 01:10:55,589 --> 01:10:58,380 It's basically ice-like structures. 1161 01:11:00,380 --> 01:11:04,589 Also, the gas can be present as free gas, which is gas bubbles. 1162 01:11:04,671 --> 01:11:08,172 Plumes of methane bubbles can vary. 1163 01:11:08,255 --> 01:11:09,838 In some areas in the Arctic, 1164 01:11:09,921 --> 01:11:13,963 we find gas seeps as tall as 800, 900 meters. 1165 01:11:16,005 --> 01:11:17,464 And the water depth in these areas, 1166 01:11:17,547 --> 01:11:20,088 a little more than 1,200 meters. 1167 01:11:20,172 --> 01:11:22,963 In shallower areas, we often find gas seeps 1168 01:11:23,047 --> 01:11:25,380 that are almost reaching the sea surface. 1169 01:11:25,464 --> 01:11:29,880 East Siberian Sea is definitely an area of concern for guys studying methane, 1170 01:11:29,963 --> 01:11:32,255 in particular because it's so shallow there. 1171 01:11:32,339 --> 01:11:37,630 So, those methane bubbles have really high potential to get to the sea surface. 1172 01:11:37,713 --> 01:11:39,796 Some areas, Spitzbergen, 1173 01:11:39,880 --> 01:11:43,921 we find the methane flares that are almost reaching the sea surface. 1174 01:11:51,087 --> 01:11:54,464 We have warmed the atmosphere to such a degree 1175 01:11:54,547 --> 01:11:57,796 that we have hit the tipping point of a melting Arctic. 1176 01:11:57,880 --> 01:12:00,754 We now face the potential 1177 01:12:00,837 --> 01:12:03,630 for an abrupt climate change scenario. 1178 01:12:03,713 --> 01:12:08,004 Current models predict we will shoot way past the Paris Agreement, 1179 01:12:08,087 --> 01:12:11,047 to five degrees and more, 1180 01:12:11,130 --> 01:12:16,712 causing even more catastrophic tipping points to be activated. 1181 01:12:16,795 --> 01:12:18,630 Warming might lead 1182 01:12:18,713 --> 01:12:22,130 to large injections of methane into the atmosphere. 1183 01:12:22,213 --> 01:12:24,837 It's something we need to be concerned about. 1184 01:12:24,920 --> 01:12:29,838 I would only add that it's one of many possible stressors. 1185 01:12:29,921 --> 01:12:32,505 We move into a high-risk situation 1186 01:12:32,589 --> 01:12:35,754 where we don't really have any experience 1187 01:12:35,837 --> 01:12:39,547 and we don't know how to deal with it. 1188 01:13:00,421 --> 01:13:03,339 The permafrost, and methane in general, 1189 01:13:03,422 --> 01:13:05,380 is of a great concern. 1190 01:13:05,464 --> 01:13:09,379 And I think that this is something 1191 01:13:09,463 --> 01:13:13,796 perhaps we need to pay more attention to methane in general, 1192 01:13:13,880 --> 01:13:16,670 in relation to the climate issue. 1193 01:13:16,754 --> 01:13:19,463 My concerns are that 1194 01:13:19,546 --> 01:13:23,754 there are great reservoirs of methane in the world, 1195 01:13:23,837 --> 01:13:25,546 in particular in the Arctic. 1196 01:13:25,629 --> 01:13:28,589 It is the risk of going beyond the tipping point 1197 01:13:28,671 --> 01:13:30,963 where it will be difficult to go back 1198 01:13:31,047 --> 01:13:33,837 and reverse the problem. 1199 01:13:42,920 --> 01:13:48,213 It's a very plausible feedback mechanism that in Arctic soils, 1200 01:13:48,297 --> 01:13:49,962 permafrost soils, 1201 01:13:50,046 --> 01:13:53,004 there's an enormous amount of organic material frozen. 1202 01:13:53,087 --> 01:13:56,464 And the amount that is available there, potentially, 1203 01:13:56,547 --> 01:14:00,920 to turn into CO2 and methane is maybe three times, four times 1204 01:14:01,004 --> 01:14:04,671 all of the fossil fuels that we have burned. 1205 01:14:11,588 --> 01:14:16,588 If we take all this material out of the deep freeze... 1206 01:14:16,670 --> 01:14:20,963 you very likely get large CO2 and methane emissions 1207 01:14:21,047 --> 01:14:23,463 on a huge scale, 1208 01:14:23,546 --> 01:14:26,254 over which we have no control. 1209 01:14:29,921 --> 01:14:33,463 I study methane emissions from lakes. 1210 01:14:33,546 --> 01:14:35,712 We are in interior Alaska, 1211 01:14:35,795 --> 01:14:39,172 and we are in discontinuous permafrost. 1212 01:14:40,712 --> 01:14:42,087 The thing that we're looking at 1213 01:14:42,171 --> 01:14:43,795 is microbial methane. 1214 01:14:43,879 --> 01:14:46,171 This methane bubbling here behind me, 1215 01:14:46,254 --> 01:14:48,754 it's dead plant and animal remains 1216 01:14:48,837 --> 01:14:50,504 that were locked up in permafrost 1217 01:14:50,588 --> 01:14:52,463 for tens of thousands of years. 1218 01:14:52,546 --> 01:14:54,463 And as that permafrost is thawing, 1219 01:14:54,546 --> 01:14:57,962 the microbes eat that soil carbon, 1220 01:14:58,046 --> 01:15:00,004 and they turn it into methane. 1221 01:15:01,546 --> 01:15:04,129 This process of permafrost thawing, 1222 01:15:04,212 --> 01:15:08,171 and that thawing permafrost fueling methane production, 1223 01:15:08,254 --> 01:15:11,129 and then methane escapes into the atmosphere, 1224 01:15:11,212 --> 01:15:13,295 causes climate warming, 1225 01:15:13,378 --> 01:15:15,379 which causes more permafrost to thaw, 1226 01:15:15,463 --> 01:15:17,546 we call that a permafrost carbon feedback. 1227 01:15:17,629 --> 01:15:19,171 It is a natural process. 1228 01:15:19,254 --> 01:15:21,004 Our concern, though, 1229 01:15:21,087 --> 01:15:23,421 is that as climate warms 1230 01:15:23,504 --> 01:15:27,296 at a faster rate than it has in the last 10,000 years, 1231 01:15:27,379 --> 01:15:29,712 that permafrost is going to respond 1232 01:15:29,795 --> 01:15:31,504 by thawing a lot more quickly 1233 01:15:31,588 --> 01:15:34,254 and releasing, at a faster rate, methane gas. 1234 01:15:34,338 --> 01:15:37,004 Now every time I go to a new lake, 1235 01:15:37,087 --> 01:15:39,253 I attempt to light these gas pockets. 1236 01:15:39,337 --> 01:15:41,171 Because it's a very high concentration of methane, 1237 01:15:41,254 --> 01:15:42,837 it's highly flammable, 1238 01:15:42,920 --> 01:15:45,504 we see a positive flame test when they contain methane. 1239 01:15:45,588 --> 01:15:48,003 So it's a quick gas chromatograph on the lake 1240 01:15:48,086 --> 01:15:49,712 to tell us do we have a methane lake, 1241 01:15:49,795 --> 01:15:52,879 or are we dealing with a different kind of lake? 1242 01:15:52,962 --> 01:15:55,836 There are many new lakes forming that were not here 1243 01:15:55,919 --> 01:15:58,546 30 or 60 years ago... 1244 01:15:58,629 --> 01:16:04,003 and those lakes have 10 to 100 to 1,000 times more methane than the rest of the lakes. 1245 01:16:06,254 --> 01:16:09,087 They are a picture of the type of methane emissions 1246 01:16:09,171 --> 01:16:13,669 we expect to see in the next 10 to 50 years 1247 01:16:13,753 --> 01:16:17,087 as permafrost warms and thaws, 1248 01:16:17,171 --> 01:16:19,546 and that permafrost feedback cycle kicks in 1249 01:16:19,629 --> 01:16:21,170 and really accelerates. 1250 01:16:24,129 --> 01:16:27,212 Now, is it methane, is it permafrost, 1251 01:16:27,296 --> 01:16:32,296 is it the dissolved organic carbon in the ocean which is suddenly remobilized? 1252 01:16:32,379 --> 01:16:36,087 These things are all intertwined with each other. 1253 01:16:36,171 --> 01:16:39,711 So, really what one needs to ask is: 1254 01:16:39,794 --> 01:16:42,546 are there positive feedbacks within the system? 1255 01:16:42,629 --> 01:16:44,254 The answer is yes. 1256 01:16:44,338 --> 01:16:47,919 So, it just stands to reason, purely by common sense, 1257 01:16:48,003 --> 01:16:52,171 the less you disturb it, the better off things will be. 1258 01:17:04,170 --> 01:17:09,754 We have the solutions at hand, but the question still remains. 1259 01:17:09,837 --> 01:17:15,628 Can we mobilize and take collective action before it's too late? 1260 01:17:15,711 --> 01:17:18,795 There isn't the oomph in the world to do this. 1261 01:17:18,879 --> 01:17:22,253 They talk about, with the Paris Agreement, 1262 01:17:22,337 --> 01:17:25,546 how we must reduce our carbon emissions 1263 01:17:25,629 --> 01:17:29,128 and to keep temperature rise at some low level, 1264 01:17:29,211 --> 01:17:32,545 but in fact, of course, we won't be able to do that. 1265 01:17:34,463 --> 01:17:36,545 The technology that can save us is something 1266 01:17:36,628 --> 01:17:39,878 that would take carbon dioxide out of the atmosphere. 1267 01:17:42,086 --> 01:17:43,962 So it ought to be obvious 1268 01:17:44,046 --> 01:17:47,378 that the biggest research effort that man is involved in 1269 01:17:47,462 --> 01:17:51,546 should be to develop direct air capture methods that work. 1270 01:17:53,628 --> 01:17:56,003 If we do that, then we can save the world, 1271 01:17:56,086 --> 01:17:58,462 and so why don't we do it? 1272 01:18:09,629 --> 01:18:12,128 Direct air capture is machines 1273 01:18:12,211 --> 01:18:15,836 which take in ambient air and extract the CO2 from this air. 1274 01:18:15,919 --> 01:18:19,337 For the last ten years, we have been working on direct air capture, 1275 01:18:19,420 --> 01:18:23,462 with the goal of making it with the least possible energy impact, 1276 01:18:23,545 --> 01:18:25,628 and ultimately with the best economics. 1277 01:18:25,711 --> 01:18:29,503 This machine consists of four 40-foot shipping containers, 1278 01:18:29,587 --> 01:18:32,211 and can be any size, there is no limit to it. 1279 01:18:32,295 --> 01:18:34,211 So we take in the ambient air here. 1280 01:18:34,295 --> 01:18:37,794 And inside, we have our filter structure. 1281 01:18:40,003 --> 01:18:42,628 We get the waste heat of the waste incinerated 1282 01:18:42,711 --> 01:18:43,961 to drive this plant. 1283 01:18:45,003 --> 01:18:46,711 Once the CO2 is captured, 1284 01:18:46,794 --> 01:18:49,378 this gas is then going to a greenhouse, 1285 01:18:49,462 --> 01:18:51,711 and this greenhouse is using the CO2 1286 01:18:51,794 --> 01:18:53,753 to increase the CO2 concentration 1287 01:18:53,836 --> 01:18:56,086 in the atmosphere of the greenhouse. 1288 01:18:56,170 --> 01:18:59,211 Which is done already nowadays, but with fossil CO2, 1289 01:18:59,295 --> 01:19:02,628 and from tomorrow on, they're going to use atmospheric CO2. 1290 01:19:06,587 --> 01:19:09,377 This plant will allow to close a carbon cycle. 1291 01:19:09,461 --> 01:19:12,378 So, of course, the CO2 goes into the greenhouse, 1292 01:19:12,462 --> 01:19:15,128 and goes to the tomatoes and cucumbers, 1293 01:19:15,211 --> 01:19:18,169 and once we eat them, the CO2 goes back to the atmosphere. 1294 01:19:18,252 --> 01:19:21,086 But since we recapture the CO2 from the atmosphere, 1295 01:19:21,170 --> 01:19:22,545 it's a closed cycle. 1296 01:19:22,628 --> 01:19:26,085 So, this can be a missing piece of the pie 1297 01:19:26,169 --> 01:19:29,587 in order to close a global carbon cycle 1298 01:19:29,669 --> 01:19:32,170 in the energy or transportation sector. 1299 01:19:35,294 --> 01:19:38,462 So, besides using CO2 in a greenhouse like this, 1300 01:19:38,545 --> 01:19:41,587 we can take CO2, we can take water, 1301 01:19:41,669 --> 01:19:43,294 and we can take renewable energy. 1302 01:19:43,377 --> 01:19:47,503 We can again produce fuels-- for example, jet fuel. 1303 01:19:47,587 --> 01:19:52,294 In order to capture 1% of global CO2 emissions, 1304 01:19:52,377 --> 01:19:56,211 we would need roughly 300,000 of the plants behind me, 1305 01:19:56,295 --> 01:19:58,253 which is of course a very high number. 1306 01:19:58,337 --> 01:20:01,294 But if you compare this to existing infrastructures, 1307 01:20:01,377 --> 01:20:03,794 it's a scale which humanity can handle. 1308 01:20:03,878 --> 01:20:07,669 So, it's definitely an achievable goal. 1309 01:20:12,753 --> 01:20:16,502 The next project is to bring a plant to Iceland 1310 01:20:16,586 --> 01:20:18,710 to capture CO2 from the air 1311 01:20:18,793 --> 01:20:23,086 and sequester the CO2 underground. 1312 01:20:23,170 --> 01:20:27,127 And in two hours, you literally turn CO2 into a stone, 1313 01:20:27,210 --> 01:20:30,753 which stores it in a permanent and safe manner. 1314 01:20:33,502 --> 01:20:37,377 In order to run the plant, we would use geothermal heat. 1315 01:20:39,170 --> 01:20:41,337 There's an abundance of it on Iceland, 1316 01:20:41,420 --> 01:20:44,419 therefore we would have low carbon footprint energy 1317 01:20:44,502 --> 01:20:46,836 available to drive the machine. 1318 01:20:46,919 --> 01:20:48,753 So, today is a very special day. 1319 01:20:48,836 --> 01:20:52,835 We have brought CO2 capture plant up here to Iceland. 1320 01:20:52,918 --> 01:20:55,337 And we are taking CO2 out of the air, 1321 01:20:55,420 --> 01:20:57,628 and then pumping it underground, 1322 01:20:57,711 --> 01:21:00,419 storing it in the basalt rock formation 1323 01:21:00,502 --> 01:21:01,960 within the CarbFix project. 1324 01:21:02,044 --> 01:21:03,710 So, we extract CO2 from the air 1325 01:21:03,794 --> 01:21:07,044 and permanently remove it by turning it into rock. 1326 01:21:07,127 --> 01:21:09,336 And yesterday night was the first time 1327 01:21:09,419 --> 01:21:13,045 that atmospheric CO2 was injected into the ground. 1328 01:21:13,128 --> 01:21:15,502 We can go up to thousands, ten thousands, 1329 01:21:15,586 --> 01:21:18,960 hundred thousands, and even up to millions of tons of CO2 1330 01:21:19,044 --> 01:21:22,253 per year that can be extracted from the atmosphere. 1331 01:21:22,337 --> 01:21:23,877 That is actually, to our knowledge, 1332 01:21:23,960 --> 01:21:25,668 the first time ever in the world 1333 01:21:25,752 --> 01:21:27,502 that direct air capture of CO2 1334 01:21:27,586 --> 01:21:30,587 has been combined with underground safe 1335 01:21:30,669 --> 01:21:32,752 and permanent storage of CO2. 1336 01:21:36,002 --> 01:21:39,378 Yeah, it's a new relationship with carbon. 1337 01:21:39,462 --> 01:21:40,877 Why can't we find a way 1338 01:21:40,960 --> 01:21:42,668 to make it an ingredient for something? 1339 01:21:42,752 --> 01:21:44,544 Why can't we put it in our plastics 1340 01:21:44,627 --> 01:21:46,085 or in our building materials? 1341 01:21:46,169 --> 01:21:48,711 Or through the help of carbon dioxide chemistry, 1342 01:21:48,794 --> 01:21:52,169 turning carbon dioxide into the things that we need every day? 1343 01:22:07,835 --> 01:22:13,085 I'm Daniel Nocera, the Patterson-Rockwood professor of energy at Harvard University. 1344 01:22:13,169 --> 01:22:17,085 These are my labs, the labs where we invented 1345 01:22:17,169 --> 01:22:19,502 the artificial leaf and the bionic leaf. 1346 01:22:19,586 --> 01:22:24,502 And what they do is a complete photosynthesis. 1347 01:22:24,586 --> 01:22:29,502 Sunlight, air and water, to fuels and food. 1348 01:22:31,002 --> 01:22:33,044 Think about photosynthesis. 1349 01:22:33,127 --> 01:22:36,252 If you think about what it really does, 1350 01:22:36,336 --> 01:22:38,668 it's the building block of life, 1351 01:22:38,752 --> 01:22:40,752 and its building blocks, literally, 1352 01:22:40,835 --> 01:22:45,294 are CO2, water, and sunlight. 1353 01:22:45,377 --> 01:22:48,543 And we build all of this, like this, 1354 01:22:48,626 --> 01:22:53,877 wood and food, and starch, and biomass. 1355 01:22:53,960 --> 01:22:57,001 That's a remarkable transformation. 1356 01:22:57,084 --> 01:23:01,169 This photosynthetic process, it's very complex, 1357 01:23:01,252 --> 01:23:03,461 but we really listen to nature. 1358 01:23:03,544 --> 01:23:06,293 And that, we finally ended up doing in 30 years. 1359 01:23:06,377 --> 01:23:09,002 And something that makes us really happy, 1360 01:23:09,085 --> 01:23:12,502 not only can I say yes, we can do it artificially, 1361 01:23:12,586 --> 01:23:16,461 I can do it ten times better than photosynthesis. 1362 01:23:16,544 --> 01:23:20,586 We made special catalysts that coated the artificial leaf, 1363 01:23:20,668 --> 01:23:24,419 and then they would split water to hydrogen and oxygen. 1364 01:23:24,502 --> 01:23:28,169 The second part of the invention is the bionic leaf. 1365 01:23:28,252 --> 01:23:31,501 It takes the hydrogen from the bacteria 1366 01:23:31,585 --> 01:23:33,336 and then it makes fuels. 1367 01:23:33,419 --> 01:23:36,877 And so, depending on what genes I put into the bacteria, 1368 01:23:36,960 --> 01:23:40,251 I could have the bacteria make materials, 1369 01:23:40,335 --> 01:23:42,002 they could make drugs. 1370 01:23:42,085 --> 01:23:45,127 We've shown they can make fertilizer. 1371 01:23:45,210 --> 01:23:48,335 We can work out of any water source, 1372 01:23:48,418 --> 01:23:52,127 including natural waters, sea water. 1373 01:23:52,210 --> 01:23:54,127 As long as you have my artificial leaf, 1374 01:23:54,210 --> 01:23:56,501 you can do it in your backyard. 1375 01:23:56,585 --> 01:24:01,586 We don't need to dig what's been down there and release more CO2. 1376 01:24:01,668 --> 01:24:04,626 The artificial leaf, working with the bionic leaf, 1377 01:24:04,709 --> 01:24:07,084 takes the CO2 out of the atmosphere, 1378 01:24:07,168 --> 01:24:09,544 uses sunlight and water, and we make fuel. 1379 01:24:09,668 --> 01:24:14,959 So, we don't add any more to the atmosphere, any more CO2. 1380 01:24:15,043 --> 01:24:19,210 And it's another issue, because the cost I'm up against, 1381 01:24:19,294 --> 01:24:23,585 the developed world has spent tens of trillions of dollars 1382 01:24:23,667 --> 01:24:25,084 to build what they now use. 1383 01:24:25,169 --> 01:24:26,835 It's kind of hard to walk away from 1384 01:24:26,918 --> 01:24:29,293 a multi-trillion dollar investment 1385 01:24:29,376 --> 01:24:30,543 that you've paid off. 1386 01:24:30,626 --> 01:24:32,418 So, that's what it's all about. 1387 01:24:32,501 --> 01:24:37,667 Therefore, you need policy and you need good partnership. 1388 01:24:37,751 --> 01:24:43,127 And the public informing them that they have options, 1389 01:24:43,210 --> 01:24:46,959 and that there can be this different world. 1390 01:24:51,001 --> 01:24:53,710 This new world can be sustainable, 1391 01:24:53,793 --> 01:24:56,001 innovative, and profitable. 1392 01:24:56,084 --> 01:24:59,543 The green economy is creating millions of jobs, 1393 01:24:59,626 --> 01:25:01,752 and will create millions more. 1394 01:25:01,835 --> 01:25:03,876 It matches and will surpass 1395 01:25:03,959 --> 01:25:07,126 the economy of the fossil fuel industry. 1396 01:25:07,209 --> 01:25:10,085 The challenge to reverse climate disruption 1397 01:25:10,169 --> 01:25:13,251 opens up opportunity for everyone. 1398 01:25:13,335 --> 01:25:17,960 It is now more profitable than ever to be green. 1399 01:25:21,959 --> 01:25:23,585 Up until recently, 1400 01:25:23,667 --> 01:25:27,918 the profit you could make from creating the problem 1401 01:25:28,002 --> 01:25:30,876 was greater than the profit 1402 01:25:30,959 --> 01:25:32,501 you could make from the solutions. 1403 01:25:32,626 --> 01:25:35,043 So, the solutions had to be done with subsidies, 1404 01:25:35,126 --> 01:25:37,418 which were rare and non-existent, 1405 01:25:37,501 --> 01:25:40,751 or altruism, or faith. 1406 01:25:40,834 --> 01:25:43,293 But people who are making the problems were raking it in, 1407 01:25:43,376 --> 01:25:44,959 raking it in, raking it in. 1408 01:25:45,043 --> 01:25:47,084 And I think we're at a crossover 1409 01:25:47,168 --> 01:25:50,376 where actually the profit you can make from the solutions 1410 01:25:50,460 --> 01:25:52,877 is greater than the profit from the problems. 1411 01:25:52,960 --> 01:25:55,209 And that is not well understood. 1412 01:25:55,293 --> 01:25:57,751 So it's not that altruism need not apply, 1413 01:25:57,834 --> 01:25:59,126 it's a great thing. 1414 01:25:59,209 --> 01:26:01,917 But actually, altruism will not be needed 1415 01:26:02,001 --> 01:26:05,501 in order to move towards a world where we reverse global warming, 1416 01:26:05,585 --> 01:26:08,543 because in fact, it's less expensive. 1417 01:26:08,626 --> 01:26:12,834 It's more profitable, more beneficial, more jobs. 1418 01:26:12,917 --> 01:26:15,460 It's the most amazing thing that's happened 1419 01:26:15,543 --> 01:26:17,126 in the last few years, 1420 01:26:17,209 --> 01:26:19,667 and it's going to do nothing but increase 1421 01:26:19,751 --> 01:26:21,001 as the years go by, 1422 01:26:21,084 --> 01:26:23,376 because engineers and designers, 1423 01:26:23,460 --> 01:26:25,709 and basically who are unknown and unnamed, 1424 01:26:25,792 --> 01:26:28,834 have been working diligently, and are working diligently 1425 01:26:28,917 --> 01:26:32,834 to reinvent a new way of being a human being 1426 01:26:32,917 --> 01:26:34,751 relating to this planet. 1427 01:26:53,791 --> 01:26:57,460 In Orkney, we have a really strong maritime tradition. 1428 01:26:57,543 --> 01:27:01,708 And since the '70s, the oil and gas industry in Aberdeen 1429 01:27:01,791 --> 01:27:04,043 has been a major contributor to the local economy, 1430 01:27:04,126 --> 01:27:06,293 providing tens and thousands of jobs. 1431 01:27:06,376 --> 01:27:07,959 But really, in the last few years, 1432 01:27:08,043 --> 01:27:09,292 we've seen quite a big downturn 1433 01:27:09,375 --> 01:27:11,208 in terms of the oil and gas industry 1434 01:27:11,292 --> 01:27:12,751 and the price of oil. 1435 01:27:12,834 --> 01:27:15,418 But we've got lots of really experienced people 1436 01:27:15,501 --> 01:27:17,875 in offshore operations on our doorstep, 1437 01:27:17,958 --> 01:27:20,792 and they're finding new jobs in offshore renewables 1438 01:27:20,876 --> 01:27:22,667 and companies such as ourselves. 1439 01:27:25,959 --> 01:27:29,709 Tidal energy is almost an entirely untapped resource. 1440 01:27:29,792 --> 01:27:31,709 We think we have the potential around the world 1441 01:27:31,792 --> 01:27:35,334 for about 100 gigawatts of capacity, perhaps more. 1442 01:27:35,417 --> 01:27:38,501 And what that equates to is a low-carbon energy 1443 01:27:38,585 --> 01:27:41,335 for millions and millions of homes. 1444 01:27:43,666 --> 01:27:46,125 What we've got here is the world's most powerful 1445 01:27:46,208 --> 01:27:48,751 floating tidal energy generator. 1446 01:27:48,834 --> 01:27:50,585 We've got a floating platform 1447 01:27:50,667 --> 01:27:52,833 to which two rotors are mounted. 1448 01:27:57,709 --> 01:27:59,750 We start with the rotors turning, 1449 01:27:59,833 --> 01:28:01,334 which produces electricity, 1450 01:28:01,417 --> 01:28:03,042 which comes back up into the machine 1451 01:28:03,125 --> 01:28:04,418 where it's conditioned, 1452 01:28:04,501 --> 01:28:09,000 and then it gets transformed, and stepped up, 1453 01:28:09,083 --> 01:28:11,666 and fed back into the grid. 1454 01:28:11,750 --> 01:28:13,667 It's like a wind turbine on its side 1455 01:28:13,751 --> 01:28:16,084 with two rotors instead of one. 1456 01:28:16,168 --> 01:28:20,083 Two weeks ago, we had great success. 1457 01:28:20,167 --> 01:28:24,084 First period of 24-hour continuous generation from the device. 1458 01:28:24,168 --> 01:28:27,791 It actually operated beyond expectations. 1459 01:28:27,875 --> 01:28:31,460 The device itself generated over 18 megawatt-hours of power 1460 01:28:31,543 --> 01:28:33,750 in that 24-hour period. 1461 01:28:33,833 --> 01:28:37,125 We're converging on more traditional methods 1462 01:28:37,208 --> 01:28:38,625 of renewable generation, 1463 01:28:38,708 --> 01:28:41,460 and really putting tidal out there 1464 01:28:41,543 --> 01:28:44,125 as a real competitive technology across the world 1465 01:28:44,208 --> 01:28:46,000 and the world's generation needs. 1466 01:28:48,043 --> 01:28:51,584 The tidal turbine is, it's 63 meters long in total. 1467 01:28:51,666 --> 01:28:54,292 We do all the power conversion within the device itself, 1468 01:28:54,375 --> 01:28:56,292 and it's ready, then, for export 1469 01:28:56,375 --> 01:28:58,460 right into the UK electricity grid. 1470 01:28:58,543 --> 01:29:02,500 So, you know, we're aiming for tens of thousands 1471 01:29:02,584 --> 01:29:04,584 of these tidal turbines, 1472 01:29:04,666 --> 01:29:06,335 but this, you know, fully integrated system 1473 01:29:06,418 --> 01:29:09,417 for producing low carbon energy, so we're very excited about it. 1474 01:29:12,584 --> 01:29:15,293 So, EMEC was set up as a testing laboratory, 1475 01:29:15,376 --> 01:29:17,833 because we know that there's a huge amount of energy 1476 01:29:17,916 --> 01:29:20,708 in the oceans all around the world, 1477 01:29:20,791 --> 01:29:23,335 and we're trying to find a way to harvest it. 1478 01:29:23,418 --> 01:29:26,500 And so, we realized that one of the most important things 1479 01:29:26,584 --> 01:29:28,916 was to have a test center which would allow us 1480 01:29:29,000 --> 01:29:31,000 to find out how to do this properly. 1481 01:29:31,083 --> 01:29:33,417 So, what we've got is a site here 1482 01:29:33,500 --> 01:29:35,500 where we've got cables that are out in the sea 1483 01:29:35,584 --> 01:29:38,334 that allow developers of these machines 1484 01:29:38,417 --> 01:29:40,543 to put these machines on to our cables, 1485 01:29:40,626 --> 01:29:44,042 and the electricity is then brought on to shore. 1486 01:29:44,125 --> 01:29:46,250 And that then feeds into our national grid. 1487 01:29:46,334 --> 01:29:47,750 So, this is real. 1488 01:29:47,833 --> 01:29:50,459 This is making electricity out of seawater. 1489 01:29:52,375 --> 01:29:54,791 So, at the moment, we've got a device called the Penguin, 1490 01:29:54,875 --> 01:29:57,000 and that's by a company called Wello Oy, 1491 01:29:57,083 --> 01:29:58,625 and their machine is effectively 1492 01:29:58,708 --> 01:30:01,958 a large pendulum inside a ship. 1493 01:30:02,042 --> 01:30:03,375 And as the ship moves, 1494 01:30:03,459 --> 01:30:05,208 this pendulum turns horizontally, 1495 01:30:05,292 --> 01:30:07,375 and that then generates electricity. 1496 01:30:07,459 --> 01:30:08,875 The sea is unrelenting, 1497 01:30:08,958 --> 01:30:11,042 and it will really try and damage equipment. 1498 01:30:11,125 --> 01:30:13,708 So, making the equipment as reliable, robust, 1499 01:30:13,791 --> 01:30:16,417 efficient, cost-effective, all these things 1500 01:30:16,500 --> 01:30:18,167 are the things that people are grappling with. 1501 01:30:18,250 --> 01:30:19,708 But the really clever thing is, 1502 01:30:19,791 --> 01:30:21,375 we have done that piece of alchemy. 1503 01:30:21,459 --> 01:30:23,624 We've actually turned seawater into electricity. 1504 01:30:23,707 --> 01:30:27,125 And that really is huge, because people are worried about 1505 01:30:27,208 --> 01:30:28,791 whether you can do this or not for years, 1506 01:30:28,875 --> 01:30:30,083 and we've just shown you can. 1507 01:30:30,167 --> 01:30:32,207 And that's a big step forward. 1508 01:30:56,250 --> 01:30:59,124 No one can say that the scientist has not warned, 1509 01:30:59,208 --> 01:31:03,750 has not told that we have to reduce the emissions of greenhouse gases. 1510 01:31:03,833 --> 01:31:05,499 That should be clear to many. 1511 01:31:05,583 --> 01:31:06,874 How much farther can we go? 1512 01:31:06,957 --> 01:31:08,417 How many more tipping points can we go 1513 01:31:08,500 --> 01:31:10,000 before we hit a tipping point 1514 01:31:10,083 --> 01:31:13,417 from which our civilization cannot recover, 1515 01:31:13,500 --> 01:31:16,082 or from which the life of this planet, 1516 01:31:16,166 --> 01:31:19,000 or a large portion of the life on this planet cannot recover? 1517 01:31:19,083 --> 01:31:22,124 We cannot allow ourselves to reach those points. 1518 01:31:22,207 --> 01:31:23,707 And we're so damn close to it. 1519 01:31:23,790 --> 01:31:25,625 We're at a turning point. 1520 01:31:25,708 --> 01:31:29,125 Either we can stay the course and drown, burn, 1521 01:31:29,208 --> 01:31:30,957 and starve ourselves to death 1522 01:31:31,041 --> 01:31:32,957 in the face of the climate crisis, 1523 01:31:33,041 --> 01:31:36,208 or we can come together, we can innovate. 1524 01:31:37,666 --> 01:31:38,915 Where do we stand? 1525 01:31:38,999 --> 01:31:41,458 Is it possible? Is it game over? 1526 01:31:41,541 --> 01:31:43,083 Or is it, in fact, game on, 1527 01:31:43,167 --> 01:31:45,292 which is that we have at hand 1528 01:31:45,375 --> 01:31:48,291 the ability, capacity, and solutions 1529 01:31:48,374 --> 01:31:50,082 that can reverse global warming, 1530 01:31:50,166 --> 01:31:52,958 not mitigate, not reduce, not stabilize, 1531 01:31:53,042 --> 01:31:54,833 but reverse? 1532 01:31:54,916 --> 01:31:56,499 When you make your goals bigger, 1533 01:31:56,583 --> 01:31:57,999 it opens up possibility. 1534 01:31:58,082 --> 01:32:00,041 It opens up imagination. 1535 01:32:00,124 --> 01:32:03,167 It opens up innovation. It doesn't foreclose. 1536 01:32:03,250 --> 01:32:05,166 It actually does the opposite. 1537 01:32:05,249 --> 01:32:08,458 And so, it's not that there's one solution, 1538 01:32:08,541 --> 01:32:12,375 but together, you can achieve drawdown 1539 01:32:12,459 --> 01:32:15,249 by doing 80% of the solutions. 1540 01:32:15,333 --> 01:32:19,167 Every one of them has so many cascading benefits, 1541 01:32:19,250 --> 01:32:21,166 makes a better world for everybody. 1542 01:32:21,249 --> 01:32:25,749 So, we don't lose by understanding 1543 01:32:25,832 --> 01:32:27,500 that climate change is happening 1544 01:32:27,584 --> 01:32:30,915 and responding to it, so what's the problem? 1545 01:32:38,124 --> 01:32:39,874 We are the first generation 1546 01:32:39,957 --> 01:32:42,624 to see the advance of climate disruption, 1547 01:32:42,707 --> 01:32:46,125 and the last with a chance to fix it. 1548 01:32:46,207 --> 01:32:48,249 In spite of all this evidence, 1549 01:32:48,333 --> 01:32:50,790 we are currently burning fossil fuels 1550 01:32:50,874 --> 01:32:53,375 at an ever-increasing rate. 1551 01:32:53,459 --> 01:32:55,207 We have heard from the scientists 1552 01:32:55,291 --> 01:32:59,874 who have told us the truth based on actual research. 1553 01:32:59,957 --> 01:33:03,583 It is time to end the delay, to listen, 1554 01:33:03,665 --> 01:33:07,041 and to implement the solutions at hand. 1555 01:33:07,124 --> 01:33:11,707 Time is running out. The ice is melting. 1556 01:33:11,790 --> 01:33:15,583 Decisive action must be taken now. 1557 01:33:15,665 --> 01:33:18,124 There is no other option. 1558 01:33:18,207 --> 01:33:21,665 This moment is within our reach. 1559 01:33:21,749 --> 01:33:23,790 Let us grasp it. 1560 01:33:23,874 --> 01:33:27,291 It is up to us, each one of us, 1561 01:33:27,374 --> 01:33:32,624 to save this unique blue planet for generations to come. 1562 01:34:03,041 --> 01:34:07,707 ♪ Lord, if you're not listening ♪ 1563 01:34:07,790 --> 01:34:09,874 ♪ I'll stop praying ♪ 1564 01:34:12,041 --> 01:34:14,082 ♪ If you're not watching ♪ 1565 01:34:14,166 --> 01:34:18,499 ♪ Will you see me fall to my knees? ♪ 1566 01:34:20,749 --> 01:34:24,041 ♪ Lose it all ♪ 1567 01:34:27,498 --> 01:34:32,166 ♪ Lord, if I can't see it ♪ 1568 01:34:32,249 --> 01:34:34,749 ♪ I can't feel it ♪ 1569 01:34:36,582 --> 01:34:38,374 ♪ If I can't feel it ♪ 1570 01:34:38,458 --> 01:34:41,082 ♪ It's not happening ♪ 1571 01:34:43,082 --> 01:34:46,915 ♪ Love is light but ice keeps burning ♪ 1572 01:34:49,082 --> 01:34:53,457 ♪ Love and hope are just a fall ♪ 1573 01:34:53,540 --> 01:34:56,333 ♪ From your hill ♪ 1574 01:34:56,416 --> 01:35:01,248 ♪ Can you hear us calling again? ♪ 1575 01:35:04,458 --> 01:35:08,957 ♪ Lord, we're all lost ♪ 1576 01:35:09,041 --> 01:35:11,540 ♪ Is life worth living? ♪ 1577 01:35:13,707 --> 01:35:17,956 ♪ If you're not watching I'm not doing wrong ♪ 1578 01:35:19,748 --> 01:35:23,790 ♪ Hope and rain and ice is burning ♪ 1579 01:35:27,290 --> 01:35:31,957 ♪ Then you see us turn on a friend ♪ 1580 01:35:33,583 --> 01:35:38,290 ♪ Will you hear them calling again? ♪ 1581 01:35:41,874 --> 01:35:45,873 ♪ Lord, the world went dark ♪ 1582 01:35:45,956 --> 01:35:48,333 ♪ The wave came crashing ♪ 1583 01:35:50,249 --> 01:35:54,748 ♪ If we're all gone will you still carry on? ♪ 1584 01:35:56,540 --> 01:36:00,873 ♪ Love is light but ice keeps burning ♪ 1585 01:36:04,540 --> 01:36:09,540 ♪ Will you see us ride to the edge? ♪ 1586 01:36:11,415 --> 01:36:14,999 ♪ One last fall from the hill ♪ 1587 01:36:18,248 --> 01:36:21,081 ♪ Dear Lord ♪ 1588 01:36:21,165 --> 01:36:25,498 ♪ If you don't want me I'm not staying ♪ 1589 01:36:27,332 --> 01:36:31,332 ♪ Love is light light keeps burning ♪ 1590 01:36:33,748 --> 01:36:37,831 ♪ Let me know if I'm worth saving ♪ 1591 01:36:39,623 --> 01:36:42,041 ♪ We're almost gone ♪ 1592 01:36:42,124 --> 01:36:46,165 ♪ So if we fall again ♪ 1593 01:36:48,914 --> 01:36:51,748 ♪ Will you carry on? ♪ 1594 01:36:54,081 --> 01:36:59,040 ♪ If we're falling in ♪ 1595 01:36:59,123 --> 01:37:05,165 ♪ Will you catch us all? ♪ 1596 01:37:20,040 --> 01:37:26,248 ♪ Lord, just let me know if I'm worth saving ♪ 130457

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.