Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:04,330 --> 00:00:05,629
.
2
00:00:05,630 --> 00:00:07,380
- In the criminal justice
system,
3
00:00:07,632 --> 00:00:09,092
the people are represented
4
00:00:09,093 --> 00:00:11,552
by two separate,
yet equally important groups:
5
00:00:11,553 --> 00:00:13,423
the police,
who investigate crime,
6
00:00:13,424 --> 00:00:16,181
and the district attorneys,
who prosecute the offenders.
7
00:00:16,182 --> 00:00:17,809
These are their stories.
8
00:00:22,022 --> 00:00:26,067
[suspenseful music]
9
00:00:26,192 --> 00:00:28,361
- We find the defendant,
10
00:00:28,486 --> 00:00:30,113
Carter Mills,
11
00:00:30,196 --> 00:00:32,657
not guilty of murder
in the second degree.
12
00:00:32,741 --> 00:00:38,621
* *
13
00:00:38,663 --> 00:00:41,750
[siren wailing]
14
00:00:43,418 --> 00:00:46,379
- He killed my sister, Nolan.
15
00:00:49,591 --> 00:00:54,846
[banging on door]
16
00:00:54,929 --> 00:00:58,475
- Please tell me you had
nothing to do with this.
17
00:00:58,558 --> 00:01:04,814
* *
18
00:01:04,898 --> 00:01:05,948
- Nolan.
19
00:01:08,352 --> 00:01:10,736
What the hell's going on?
20
00:01:10,737 --> 00:01:13,156
- Carter Mills is dead.
21
00:01:13,281 --> 00:01:15,511
Someone gunned him down
about two hours ago.
22
00:01:16,868 --> 00:01:17,994
- Any suspects?
23
00:01:18,036 --> 00:01:19,788
- Not at the moment.
24
00:01:22,332 --> 00:01:24,442
- Have you connected
with Sam about this?
25
00:01:25,251 --> 00:01:26,503
- Yes.
26
00:01:26,670 --> 00:01:28,963
She is having a hard time.
27
00:01:29,089 --> 00:01:30,507
She didn't say too much.
28
00:01:30,548 --> 00:01:31,966
- What do you mean?
29
00:01:32,092 --> 00:01:35,345
- She didn't want to engage.
Uh...
30
00:01:35,428 --> 00:01:39,265
she's obviously very upset
with the verdict,
31
00:01:39,391 --> 00:01:40,767
and with me.
32
00:01:46,189 --> 00:01:48,233
- I get it.
33
00:01:48,234 --> 00:01:50,192
That's a hell of a thing,
to watch the man
34
00:01:50,193 --> 00:01:51,777
who killed your sister
and another young woman
35
00:01:51,778 --> 00:01:53,154
walk out of court a free man.
36
00:01:53,238 --> 00:01:54,823
- It sure is. Yeah.
37
00:01:55,870 --> 00:02:00,119
- There's no reason
to think Sam had anything
38
00:02:00,120 --> 00:02:02,372
to do with this, right?
39
00:02:02,455 --> 00:02:03,998
- [sighs]
40
00:02:08,086 --> 00:02:10,005
- I'm not sure.
41
00:02:12,674 --> 00:02:15,552
[dramatic music]
42
00:02:15,635 --> 00:02:22,600
* *
43
00:02:58,970 --> 00:03:01,890
- [panting]
44
00:03:05,602 --> 00:03:07,520
[shouts]
45
00:03:11,316 --> 00:03:14,235
[breathing heavily]
46
00:03:23,286 --> 00:03:24,336
- Hey.
47
00:03:24,412 --> 00:03:26,039
How are you doing?
48
00:03:26,122 --> 00:03:27,374
- Thank you.
49
00:03:27,457 --> 00:03:30,627
- I'm sorry if I-
50
00:03:30,628 --> 00:03:32,044
Sam, come on, for God's sake.
51
00:03:32,045 --> 00:03:35,507
I-I just wanna say
I was worried.
52
00:03:35,548 --> 00:03:37,592
- Worried that I shot him?
53
00:03:37,676 --> 00:03:39,719
- It was an emotional case.
54
00:03:39,844 --> 00:03:41,805
- Yes, it was.
55
00:03:41,888 --> 00:03:45,767
But it all turned out
for the best, I suppose.
56
00:03:45,892 --> 00:03:48,436
We had our chance, Nolan.
57
00:03:48,561 --> 00:03:49,896
It just didn't work out.
58
00:03:50,021 --> 00:03:52,649
- I-I did what was
required by the law.
59
00:03:52,650 --> 00:03:53,857
- That's one way to look at it.
60
00:03:53,858 --> 00:03:55,235
- And the other?
61
00:03:55,318 --> 00:03:57,188
- You did what you
wanted to do, Nolan.
62
00:03:57,237 --> 00:03:59,447
You did what made you
feel good and noble.
63
00:03:59,572 --> 00:04:01,442
And it's obviously
important to you.
64
00:04:02,826 --> 00:04:07,414
- No, what is important
is following the law.
65
00:04:07,455 --> 00:04:10,792
In case you forgot,
that's our job.
66
00:04:12,312 --> 00:04:15,963
- I know it's our job
to hunt down killers,
67
00:04:15,964 --> 00:04:18,173
but I kind of feel like
throwing this one a parade.
68
00:04:18,174 --> 00:04:20,802
- At least send him
some sort of fruit basket.
69
00:04:20,885 --> 00:04:23,138
So a street camera
picked up Carter Mills
70
00:04:23,263 --> 00:04:25,932
being killed at 9:38 p.m.
71
00:04:26,057 --> 00:04:28,059
And check this out.
72
00:04:28,060 --> 00:04:30,436
This dude was sweeping up right
across from the crime scene
73
00:04:30,437 --> 00:04:32,105
at the time of the murder.
74
00:04:33,732 --> 00:04:36,484
- Play that back real quick.
75
00:04:36,485 --> 00:04:38,986
Sweeping up out front,
minding his own business,
76
00:04:38,987 --> 00:04:42,574
and he sees or hears the
gunshot and runs back inside.
77
00:04:42,615 --> 00:04:44,159
Let's track this guy down.
78
00:04:44,284 --> 00:04:46,745
- I just spoke to Shaw.
79
00:04:46,828 --> 00:04:49,789
Something opened up over at
the 88, and he's gonna take it.
80
00:04:51,291 --> 00:04:54,210
- I knew he wanted to get back
to Brooklyn,
81
00:04:54,294 --> 00:04:56,963
so good for him.
82
00:04:57,005 --> 00:04:58,673
I'm gonna miss
that guy, though.
83
00:05:08,058 --> 00:05:09,768
- Yeah, that's me.
84
00:05:09,851 --> 00:05:12,854
Sweeping the sidewalk
against the law or something?
85
00:05:12,896 --> 00:05:14,481
- No.
86
00:05:14,564 --> 00:05:16,816
Murder is.
87
00:05:16,858 --> 00:05:18,368
- I got nothing
to do with that.
88
00:05:18,443 --> 00:05:21,696
I was just sweeping
the sidewalk.
89
00:05:21,780 --> 00:05:23,100
- But you saw the shooting?
90
00:05:24,282 --> 00:05:25,700
- Okay, fine.
91
00:05:25,784 --> 00:05:29,079
I-I heard the gunshots,
looked over,
92
00:05:29,162 --> 00:05:32,290
and I saw some guy
on the ground bleeding.
93
00:05:32,415 --> 00:05:34,793
- What about the shooter?
You see him too?
94
00:05:34,834 --> 00:05:37,170
- No, but it wasn't a him.
95
00:05:37,295 --> 00:05:38,345
It was a her.
96
00:05:39,881 --> 00:05:41,216
- How do you know?
97
00:05:41,217 --> 00:05:43,342
- She yelled something
right before the gunshots.
98
00:05:43,343 --> 00:05:44,760
- You remember her exact words?
99
00:05:44,761 --> 00:05:46,262
- Yep.
100
00:05:46,304 --> 00:05:48,181
"You deserve this."
101
00:05:50,684 --> 00:05:53,353
- I appreciate you
keeping us in the loop.
102
00:05:53,395 --> 00:05:55,772
But what's all this
concern based on,
103
00:05:55,897 --> 00:06:00,151
just because the shooter
appears to be female?
104
00:06:00,276 --> 00:06:03,071
- She also appears to be
thin and medium height.
105
00:06:03,154 --> 00:06:04,823
- Oh, well,
that narrows it down
106
00:06:04,864 --> 00:06:06,700
to, what, to 3 million people?
107
00:06:06,783 --> 00:06:08,743
- Well, we all know
how upset Sam was.
108
00:06:08,827 --> 00:06:10,078
- We all were upset.
109
00:06:10,079 --> 00:06:11,537
That doesn't mean anything.
110
00:06:11,538 --> 00:06:14,249
- He killed her sister, Nolan,
111
00:06:14,332 --> 00:06:17,210
and she owns
a .38-caliber handgun,
112
00:06:17,252 --> 00:06:20,714
same weapon used
to kill Carter Mills.
113
00:06:20,797 --> 00:06:22,340
So if you know anything...
114
00:06:22,382 --> 00:06:25,176
[suspenseful music]
115
00:06:25,260 --> 00:06:26,845
* *
116
00:06:26,970 --> 00:06:29,848
- When I found out that
Carter had been shot,
117
00:06:29,973 --> 00:06:31,975
my first instinct
was to check in on Sam.
118
00:06:32,100 --> 00:06:34,894
So I went to her
apartment, and-
119
00:06:37,564 --> 00:06:39,315
- She was there?
- Yes.
120
00:06:39,357 --> 00:06:41,443
- What did she say?
121
00:06:41,484 --> 00:06:44,362
- She was angry
with-with me, mostly,
122
00:06:44,363 --> 00:06:46,613
because we had a disagreement
about the case.
123
00:06:46,614 --> 00:06:50,493
And, um, yeah,
anyway, she was angry.
124
00:06:50,494 --> 00:06:52,327
- Have you checked
the surveillance footage?
125
00:06:52,328 --> 00:06:54,371
Was Sam even out and about
at the time of the shooting?
126
00:06:54,372 --> 00:06:57,249
- We have video of her arriving
at her apartment building
127
00:06:57,250 --> 00:07:00,962
28 minutes after the 911 call.
128
00:07:01,087 --> 00:07:03,840
So I have to talk to her.
129
00:07:03,882 --> 00:07:06,176
- I understand.
130
00:07:06,259 --> 00:07:11,264
* *
131
00:07:11,306 --> 00:07:15,518
- Do you own a gun,
a .38 revolver?
132
00:07:15,602 --> 00:07:17,312
- I do.
133
00:07:17,395 --> 00:07:19,481
Bought one three years ago.
134
00:07:19,522 --> 00:07:21,816
Someone was stalking me.
I didn't feel safe.
135
00:07:21,817 --> 00:07:23,067
- Are you still
in possession-
136
00:07:23,068 --> 00:07:25,653
- Let's just cut
to the chase, okay?
137
00:07:25,737 --> 00:07:28,239
- We have reason
to believe a woman
138
00:07:28,281 --> 00:07:31,576
of your height and body type
shot and killed Carter Mills.
139
00:07:31,618 --> 00:07:34,621
- You're saying I'm a suspect.
140
00:07:34,746 --> 00:07:39,000
- So I'm asking your permission
to check your gun
141
00:07:39,001 --> 00:07:41,168
to prove that it wasn't
involved in the shooting
142
00:07:41,169 --> 00:07:42,337
so that we can clear you.
143
00:07:46,299 --> 00:07:48,760
- If you wanna test my gun,
get a warrant.
144
00:07:51,012 --> 00:07:53,348
* *
145
00:07:58,555 --> 00:07:59,853
.
146
00:07:59,854 --> 00:08:00,904
- Wow.
147
00:08:00,905 --> 00:08:02,773
You're really doing this, huh?
148
00:08:02,774 --> 00:08:04,526
- I asked your permission,
but...
149
00:08:04,527 --> 00:08:06,151
- You guys wanna start
in the back?
150
00:08:06,152 --> 00:08:07,529
I'll take the bedroom.
151
00:08:21,292 --> 00:08:23,003
- Hey, check it out,
dark hoodie.
152
00:08:23,128 --> 00:08:25,380
- Okay, bag it.
Get it over to the lab.
153
00:08:28,216 --> 00:08:30,844
- I need you to open this safe.
154
00:08:30,845 --> 00:08:32,511
It's all spelled out
in the warrant, Sam.
155
00:08:32,512 --> 00:08:34,931
You know how this works.
156
00:08:34,973 --> 00:08:37,225
[safe beeps]
157
00:08:38,727 --> 00:08:39,777
No gun.
158
00:08:41,980 --> 00:08:43,606
- Come on, Sam.
Where is the gun?
159
00:08:43,648 --> 00:08:45,984
- No more questions.
160
00:08:46,109 --> 00:08:48,939
When you're done searching
my apartment, please leave.
161
00:08:52,198 --> 00:08:55,410
- Brady said your gun
was missing?
162
00:08:55,493 --> 00:08:57,370
Is there a reason for that?
163
00:08:59,164 --> 00:09:01,207
- Nolan, I'm not doing this.
164
00:09:01,291 --> 00:09:02,417
- Why not?
165
00:09:02,418 --> 00:09:03,542
- I'm not gonna do
or say anything
166
00:09:03,543 --> 00:09:05,462
that may incriminate me.
167
00:09:05,545 --> 00:09:07,297
- If you are involved-
168
00:09:07,422 --> 00:09:09,924
- I'm not.
169
00:09:10,050 --> 00:09:13,219
Nolan, I swear
I didn't shoot him.
170
00:09:13,220 --> 00:09:14,803
- So then why not just
hand over the damn gun?
171
00:09:14,804 --> 00:09:16,014
- Because I don't have it.
172
00:09:16,015 --> 00:09:17,514
- What do you mean
you don't have it?
173
00:09:17,515 --> 00:09:18,932
- I threw it in the river.
I don't have it.
174
00:09:18,933 --> 00:09:21,811
[uneasy music]
175
00:09:21,936 --> 00:09:23,646
* *
176
00:09:23,688 --> 00:09:26,149
I was just so angry.
177
00:09:26,274 --> 00:09:29,611
I didn't know how to process
what had happened.
178
00:09:29,612 --> 00:09:31,487
The only thing that made sense
to me in that moment
179
00:09:31,488 --> 00:09:32,868
was to confront the bastard.
180
00:09:32,989 --> 00:09:34,866
I wanted to see him.
181
00:09:34,908 --> 00:09:37,118
I wanted to scare him.
182
00:09:37,243 --> 00:09:39,662
So I grabbed my gun,
and I started
183
00:09:39,663 --> 00:09:41,747
walking towards his apartment,
which is insane.
184
00:09:41,748 --> 00:09:44,084
It's crazy. I know that.
185
00:09:44,085 --> 00:09:46,251
But after a few blocks,
I realized it was
186
00:09:46,252 --> 00:09:48,797
a bad idea,
a terrible idea.
187
00:09:48,880 --> 00:09:50,757
So I went on a walk instead.
188
00:09:50,840 --> 00:09:52,801
I ended up on the promenade,
189
00:09:52,926 --> 00:09:57,013
and I threw my damn gun
in the East River.
190
00:09:57,097 --> 00:09:58,147
- Why?
191
00:10:01,226 --> 00:10:04,229
- Because I was afraid
of what I might do with it.
192
00:10:04,312 --> 00:10:09,401
* *
193
00:10:09,442 --> 00:10:10,819
[elevator bell dings]
194
00:10:10,902 --> 00:10:14,072
- So our .38 is at the bottom
of the East River,
195
00:10:14,073 --> 00:10:16,990
and you think this somehow
suggests that she's innocent?
196
00:10:16,991 --> 00:10:18,993
- I do.
197
00:10:19,077 --> 00:10:20,995
- As a person,
I hope you're right.
198
00:10:21,079 --> 00:10:23,665
As a cop, I'm-
I'm not buying it.
199
00:10:23,790 --> 00:10:26,292
I mean, from that
one conversation with you,
200
00:10:26,293 --> 00:10:28,293
she admitted to
practically everything
201
00:10:28,294 --> 00:10:29,494
but the actual shooting.
202
00:10:29,504 --> 00:10:30,880
- I understand.
203
00:10:30,881 --> 00:10:32,965
- I mean, she admitted
to leaving her apartment
204
00:10:32,966 --> 00:10:34,717
with the intent
of confronting the victim.
205
00:10:34,718 --> 00:10:36,761
She admitted to
carrying a .38 caliber
206
00:10:36,845 --> 00:10:39,014
and throwing that weapon
into the river.
207
00:10:39,015 --> 00:10:40,723
- I know it looks suspicious,
I do,
208
00:10:40,724 --> 00:10:43,143
but I've known Sam
for-for six years,
209
00:10:43,226 --> 00:10:45,353
and she has never
lied to me, not once.
210
00:10:45,437 --> 00:10:47,230
- That's very sweet,
211
00:10:47,313 --> 00:10:50,442
but it doesn't mean anything.
212
00:10:50,525 --> 00:10:52,110
[knock at door]
213
00:10:52,111 --> 00:10:55,487
- Hey. I just got off the phone
with a potential witness.
214
00:10:55,488 --> 00:10:57,157
- Nolan, would you mind?
215
00:11:01,786 --> 00:11:03,166
- Damn, it's like that, huh?
216
00:11:04,956 --> 00:11:06,875
- What's up?
217
00:11:06,876 --> 00:11:09,084
- The guy I just spoke with
says that he literally
218
00:11:09,085 --> 00:11:11,588
bumped into a young woman
wearing a dark hoodie
219
00:11:11,589 --> 00:11:13,964
just after the shooting,
about a block from the scene.
220
00:11:13,965 --> 00:11:15,342
- Did he get a look at her?
221
00:11:15,383 --> 00:11:20,347
- Said she was about 30 to 35,
brunette, and pretty.
222
00:11:20,430 --> 00:11:22,307
- [sighs]
Okay.
223
00:11:22,432 --> 00:11:24,559
Uh, bring him in
and see if he can
224
00:11:24,642 --> 00:11:26,332
pick Maroun out of
a photo lineup.
225
00:11:27,880 --> 00:11:31,357
- Do you really think
it's possible
226
00:11:31,358 --> 00:11:32,901
that Sam shot this guy?
227
00:11:32,902 --> 00:11:34,360
- He raped
and killed her sister.
228
00:11:34,361 --> 00:11:35,411
- Yeah, I know, but-
229
00:11:35,528 --> 00:11:37,947
- If someone did that
to my sister
230
00:11:38,073 --> 00:11:41,242
and then walked out of court
a free man, I don't know.
231
00:11:47,165 --> 00:11:53,088
- It's hard to tell, but, ah,
232
00:11:53,171 --> 00:11:55,581
I'm not sure I see the woman
from the other night.
233
00:11:55,590 --> 00:11:58,802
- Well, you said she was about
30, 35 and pretty, right?
234
00:11:58,927 --> 00:12:00,303
- Yeah.
235
00:12:00,387 --> 00:12:03,056
- None of those faces
ring a bell?
236
00:12:03,181 --> 00:12:05,308
- I mean,
they're all attractive,
237
00:12:05,392 --> 00:12:08,728
but I don't recognize
any of them.
238
00:12:08,729 --> 00:12:11,105
- Well, do you remember
anything else about her,
239
00:12:11,106 --> 00:12:13,483
besides being young and pretty?
240
00:12:13,608 --> 00:12:17,070
- I mean, she was tall,
for a woman anyway.
241
00:12:17,195 --> 00:12:20,323
- Is that a guess, or...?
- No, she bumped into me.
242
00:12:20,365 --> 00:12:22,826
It was a minute or so
after I heard the gunshots.
243
00:12:22,867 --> 00:12:24,285
- What do you mean?
244
00:12:24,411 --> 00:12:27,122
- She ran into me,
almost knocked me over,
245
00:12:27,123 --> 00:12:28,956
and we were standing
face-to-face.
246
00:12:28,957 --> 00:12:30,827
I was looking right at her,
you know,
247
00:12:30,834 --> 00:12:33,044
and we were pretty much
the same height.
248
00:12:33,169 --> 00:12:35,505
I don't see her
in these photos.
249
00:12:35,630 --> 00:12:36,710
- And how tall are you?
250
00:12:36,798 --> 00:12:37,966
- 5'9".
251
00:12:40,510 --> 00:12:42,762
- Okay.
Thank you for your time.
252
00:12:42,763 --> 00:12:44,596
- I'm sorry I couldn't
be more helpful.
253
00:12:44,597 --> 00:12:46,725
- No, it's great.
Thank you.
254
00:12:46,808 --> 00:12:48,226
- Maroun is 5'3".
255
00:12:48,268 --> 00:12:49,561
If this woman is 5'9"...
256
00:12:49,602 --> 00:12:51,479
- Then Maroun is not our gal.
257
00:12:51,604 --> 00:12:54,024
- Which is good news.
258
00:12:54,065 --> 00:12:55,115
I like Sam.
259
00:12:56,526 --> 00:12:57,861
- So do I.
260
00:12:57,986 --> 00:13:00,238
[footsteps approaching]
261
00:13:02,782 --> 00:13:05,535
- I was just talking to Brady.
262
00:13:05,660 --> 00:13:08,913
They have found new evidence
that seems to exclude you
263
00:13:08,955 --> 00:13:10,582
as a suspect for now.
264
00:13:10,623 --> 00:13:12,542
They're still waiting
to hear back
265
00:13:12,543 --> 00:13:14,752
from the lab about the hoodie
they found in your apartment.
266
00:13:14,753 --> 00:13:17,881
- Oh, well,
they're wasting their time.
267
00:13:18,006 --> 00:13:20,342
- I know.
268
00:13:20,467 --> 00:13:22,427
- Nolan,
269
00:13:22,552 --> 00:13:25,764
if I actually had the ability
to take someone's life,
270
00:13:25,805 --> 00:13:28,725
I'd be in handcuffs right now
271
00:13:28,808 --> 00:13:32,937
because I really, really wanted
to kill that son of a bitch.
272
00:13:33,063 --> 00:13:35,899
[soft tense music]
273
00:13:36,024 --> 00:13:38,234
But I couldn't.
274
00:13:38,360 --> 00:13:42,614
* *
275
00:13:42,655 --> 00:13:45,241
- That's good to know,
276
00:13:45,325 --> 00:13:49,871
given that we spend
so much time together.
277
00:13:49,913 --> 00:13:51,623
- [scoffs]
278
00:13:51,706 --> 00:13:57,879
* *
279
00:14:02,836 --> 00:14:04,176
.
280
00:14:04,177 --> 00:14:06,512
- Well, there's definitely
no shortage of people
281
00:14:06,513 --> 00:14:08,263
who hated this guy,
that's for sure.
282
00:14:08,264 --> 00:14:10,015
- And a few who seem to be
in love with him.
283
00:14:10,016 --> 00:14:12,226
"Carter, you're far
too handsome to be evil.
284
00:14:12,227 --> 00:14:13,644
"If I'm being honest,
you're so hot,
285
00:14:13,645 --> 00:14:15,230
I don't even care
if you did it."
286
00:14:15,271 --> 00:14:17,982
- Who could possibly love
such a disgusting man?
287
00:14:17,983 --> 00:14:20,651
- I guess good looks and a
toothy smile will get you far.
288
00:14:20,652 --> 00:14:23,028
- I spoke to a doorman at
Carter's building who claims
289
00:14:23,029 --> 00:14:24,405
to have known him pretty well.
290
00:14:24,406 --> 00:14:26,324
Also said
what a great guy he was.
291
00:14:26,325 --> 00:14:28,450
Said the only woman he saw him
with in the last few months
292
00:14:28,451 --> 00:14:30,494
was his girlfriend.
- What do we know about her?
293
00:14:30,495 --> 00:14:32,485
- Not much, except that
she's a lawyer,
294
00:14:32,486 --> 00:14:34,248
and that she stuck with him
throughout the trial,
295
00:14:34,249 --> 00:14:35,541
even gave a few emotional
interviews about what
296
00:14:35,542 --> 00:14:36,835
a wonderful man he was.
297
00:14:36,960 --> 00:14:38,920
- So she's an idiot.
298
00:14:39,045 --> 00:14:40,095
- You said it.
299
00:14:40,171 --> 00:14:41,548
- Well, talk to her anyway.
300
00:14:41,589 --> 00:14:43,219
Maybe she can
tell us something.
301
00:14:45,760 --> 00:14:48,722
- There was definitely
a lot of online hate.
302
00:14:48,763 --> 00:14:52,600
But we weren't really
out in public too often.
303
00:14:52,767 --> 00:14:56,187
We'd go to court,
back to his apartment,
304
00:14:56,271 --> 00:14:58,314
order in.
305
00:14:58,440 --> 00:15:04,320
We just wanted to get through
this horrible ordeal,
306
00:15:04,362 --> 00:15:06,781
and we did.
307
00:15:06,906 --> 00:15:08,074
But...
308
00:15:11,119 --> 00:15:14,414
Everyone forgets
that he was acquitted.
309
00:15:14,456 --> 00:15:16,386
- So just to be clear,
you aren't aware
310
00:15:16,387 --> 00:15:18,417
of any recent arguments
or confrontations?
311
00:15:18,418 --> 00:15:21,755
- No, the only person he argued
with lately was his sister.
312
00:15:21,921 --> 00:15:23,882
- You know what
they fought about?
313
00:15:24,049 --> 00:15:28,011
- Carter wanted her to come
to court, show some support.
314
00:15:28,136 --> 00:15:30,138
But she wasn't into it.
315
00:15:30,305 --> 00:15:32,682
Said she didn't believe
he was innocent,
316
00:15:32,724 --> 00:15:35,310
that she hoped the jury
was going to convict him.
317
00:15:35,393 --> 00:15:38,521
It was awful
318
00:15:38,646 --> 00:15:39,814
and hypocritical.
319
00:15:39,939 --> 00:15:41,608
- Why is that?
320
00:15:41,609 --> 00:15:43,192
- Carter was
really good to her.
321
00:15:43,193 --> 00:15:46,654
Paid her rent,
invested in her art gallery,
322
00:15:46,780 --> 00:15:48,990
and she's the sole beneficiary
of his will.
323
00:15:54,662 --> 00:15:57,665
- I wanted to support him,
but...
324
00:15:57,707 --> 00:16:00,627
in my bones, I knew
he was guilty, and I-
325
00:16:02,712 --> 00:16:06,091
I didn't wanna help him
get away with it.
326
00:16:06,092 --> 00:16:08,467
- So after he was acquitted,
how did that make you feel?
327
00:16:08,468 --> 00:16:10,136
- I was upset
328
00:16:10,220 --> 00:16:12,180
but not surprised.
329
00:16:12,263 --> 00:16:13,523
- What do you mean by that?
330
00:16:13,640 --> 00:16:16,351
- Carter always
gets away with everything.
331
00:16:16,434 --> 00:16:18,019
Since he was five years old,
332
00:16:18,020 --> 00:16:19,228
no one ever
held him accountable,
333
00:16:19,229 --> 00:16:21,106
truly accountable.
334
00:16:21,147 --> 00:16:22,524
- Is that what you did?
335
00:16:22,607 --> 00:16:25,527
Hold him accountable for
what he did to that model?
336
00:16:25,694 --> 00:16:27,112
- No, I-
337
00:16:27,278 --> 00:16:29,197
no, I didn't kill him.
338
00:16:29,239 --> 00:16:34,577
I was in Brooklyn
with my girlfriend that night.
339
00:16:34,661 --> 00:16:36,830
This is us at dinner.
340
00:16:36,831 --> 00:16:41,291
- Do you know anyone else
who felt the same as you,
341
00:16:41,292 --> 00:16:43,168
might have wanted
to see Carter punished?
342
00:16:43,169 --> 00:16:47,173
- No, no one specific anyway,
but I'm sure the list is long.
343
00:16:47,215 --> 00:16:49,092
The pattern was
always the same.
344
00:16:49,175 --> 00:16:50,315
People would meet him,
345
00:16:50,343 --> 00:16:53,054
fall in love with him,
346
00:16:53,096 --> 00:16:55,140
and then eventually
end up hating him.
347
00:16:56,683 --> 00:16:58,935
- Except his girlfriend, right?
348
00:16:59,019 --> 00:17:01,189
Poor thing stuck with him
to the bitter end.
349
00:17:02,188 --> 00:17:04,941
- I'm not so sure about that.
350
00:17:05,066 --> 00:17:07,902
- Thanks for coming by.
351
00:17:07,903 --> 00:17:09,778
Uh, we're just trying
to understand
352
00:17:09,779 --> 00:17:14,159
why you failed to mention
that you broke up with Carter
353
00:17:14,242 --> 00:17:16,119
three days prior
to the verdict.
354
00:17:16,202 --> 00:17:18,121
- Excuse me?
- His sister told us.
355
00:17:18,204 --> 00:17:19,956
- Oh.
356
00:17:19,957 --> 00:17:21,623
- You broke up with him three
days before the trial ended.
357
00:17:21,624 --> 00:17:22,876
- That's not true.
358
00:17:22,917 --> 00:17:24,627
- So, what?
She's making it up?
359
00:17:24,669 --> 00:17:26,087
- I don't know.
360
00:17:26,129 --> 00:17:28,256
She and Carter
don't really talk too much.
361
00:17:28,340 --> 00:17:29,924
- Well, that might be true,
362
00:17:29,925 --> 00:17:31,717
but he reached out to her
after the breakup,
363
00:17:31,718 --> 00:17:33,636
and he told her
he was very upset.
364
00:17:33,720 --> 00:17:35,100
- I find that hard to believe.
365
00:17:35,180 --> 00:17:36,806
- Well, it happened.
366
00:17:36,848 --> 00:17:38,433
- What's your point?
367
00:17:38,516 --> 00:17:41,353
- My point is, did you break up
with Carter, yes or no?
368
00:17:41,436 --> 00:17:43,313
- What difference does it make?
369
00:17:43,314 --> 00:17:45,230
- Well, it means next to
nothing if you didn't lie
370
00:17:45,231 --> 00:17:47,192
about it and then
double-down on it.
371
00:17:47,193 --> 00:17:50,277
I mean, why would you lie about
something so insignificant?
372
00:17:50,278 --> 00:17:51,446
- I didn't lie.
373
00:17:51,571 --> 00:17:53,698
I just-
374
00:17:53,865 --> 00:17:55,325
I didn't mention it.
375
00:17:55,408 --> 00:17:57,577
[suspenseful music]
376
00:17:57,619 --> 00:18:00,080
- So you did break up with him?
377
00:18:01,915 --> 00:18:04,292
- Yes.
- How come?
378
00:18:04,417 --> 00:18:07,629
- I was tired of all
the negative attention
379
00:18:07,712 --> 00:18:08,963
and publicity.
380
00:18:09,089 --> 00:18:12,884
I just couldn't
handle it anymore.
381
00:18:12,926 --> 00:18:14,736
- But you believed
in his innocence.
382
00:18:14,761 --> 00:18:15,929
- I did.
383
00:18:15,970 --> 00:18:18,056
- Until the bitter end?
- Yes.
384
00:18:18,139 --> 00:18:21,810
- And how did you feel when
you found out he was acquitted?
385
00:18:21,851 --> 00:18:23,395
- I was...
386
00:18:23,561 --> 00:18:26,648
happy and relieved.
387
00:18:29,526 --> 00:18:32,112
Everyone thought I was crazy,
that I was blind.
388
00:18:32,153 --> 00:18:35,073
So when the jury voted
to acquit,
389
00:18:35,198 --> 00:18:36,908
I felt vindicated.
390
00:18:40,495 --> 00:18:42,914
- Okay.
391
00:18:42,997 --> 00:18:47,210
This is a recent ATM withdrawal
from a bank
392
00:18:47,252 --> 00:18:51,172
in Pennsylvania three hours
after the verdict for $600.
393
00:18:53,466 --> 00:18:55,176
- So?
394
00:18:55,177 --> 00:18:57,344
- It turns out that bank
was located in the same mall
395
00:18:57,345 --> 00:18:59,514
as a store called
Ike's Gun Shop.
396
00:19:03,059 --> 00:19:06,938
And it turns out Ike's Gun Shop
has a lot of cameras.
397
00:19:07,022 --> 00:19:14,029
* *
398
00:19:14,112 --> 00:19:16,948
That's you
buying a .38 revolver
399
00:19:16,990 --> 00:19:20,285
the day your ex-boyfriend
400
00:19:20,326 --> 00:19:22,037
was acquitted of murder.
401
00:19:22,203 --> 00:19:29,169
* *
402
00:19:29,252 --> 00:19:31,004
- I want a lawyer.
403
00:19:35,300 --> 00:19:38,053
- I hope you get a good one.
404
00:19:38,136 --> 00:19:39,888
I really do.
405
00:19:47,848 --> 00:19:49,188
.
406
00:19:49,189 --> 00:19:52,067
- Police just arrested
Carter's ex-girlfriend,
407
00:19:52,776 --> 00:19:54,486
Julia Keaton.
- What?
408
00:19:54,611 --> 00:19:57,238
She was his biggest supporter.
- I know.
409
00:19:57,239 --> 00:19:59,198
- Do we know what happened,
what provoked the shooting?
410
00:19:59,199 --> 00:20:00,533
- No, not yet.
411
00:20:01,534 --> 00:20:02,584
- Hm.
412
00:20:04,537 --> 00:20:06,247
- How are you feeling?
413
00:20:06,248 --> 00:20:07,331
- About what?
414
00:20:07,332 --> 00:20:09,125
- This case.
415
00:20:09,250 --> 00:20:11,920
Do you wanna be involved?
416
00:20:12,045 --> 00:20:13,797
- Yes.
417
00:20:13,838 --> 00:20:15,965
- Are you sure?
- I'm positive.
418
00:20:15,966 --> 00:20:18,884
- All right, as long as you can
separate your personal feelings
419
00:20:18,885 --> 00:20:19,843
from the case.
420
00:20:19,844 --> 00:20:20,894
- Oh, I think I can.
421
00:20:20,929 --> 00:20:22,722
- Okay.
422
00:20:22,847 --> 00:20:25,100
Sam,
423
00:20:25,183 --> 00:20:28,311
you need to be honest
424
00:20:28,436 --> 00:20:30,146
with me, with yourself.
425
00:20:30,230 --> 00:20:34,567
Are you capable of thinking
like a prosecutor on this case?
426
00:20:34,651 --> 00:20:36,069
Because you said it already.
427
00:20:36,070 --> 00:20:37,528
Part of you wishes
that you had the guts
428
00:20:37,529 --> 00:20:39,030
to kill this bastard yourself.
429
00:20:39,114 --> 00:20:40,240
- I'm good, Nolan.
430
00:20:40,323 --> 00:20:42,784
I can do it.
431
00:20:42,867 --> 00:20:44,744
I need to do it.
432
00:20:48,164 --> 00:20:50,959
- I hope the evidence
is pretty damn compelling
433
00:20:50,960 --> 00:20:52,793
because there's not a person
in this city
434
00:20:52,794 --> 00:20:54,545
shedding a tear
over this guy's death.
435
00:20:54,546 --> 00:20:56,548
- Nor should they,
but here we are.
436
00:20:56,631 --> 00:21:00,301
- We don't get to pick
our victims or our defendants.
437
00:21:02,512 --> 00:21:05,015
We're just here
to present the evidence.
438
00:21:05,098 --> 00:21:07,350
- So...
439
00:21:07,392 --> 00:21:08,685
what do we know?
440
00:21:08,768 --> 00:21:11,688
- We know she bought a gun,
a .38 revolver,
441
00:21:11,771 --> 00:21:14,399
in Pennsylvania
six hours before the murder.
442
00:21:14,441 --> 00:21:16,234
- That's a good start.
443
00:21:16,359 --> 00:21:17,527
Police recover it?
444
00:21:17,652 --> 00:21:19,279
- No, but there's more.
445
00:21:19,362 --> 00:21:23,116
We also have two pieces
of video footage.
446
00:21:23,158 --> 00:21:25,201
The first is the actual murder.
447
00:21:25,202 --> 00:21:28,287
The only helpful thing here is
that you can see the shooter's
448
00:21:28,288 --> 00:21:29,831
wearing a dark hoodie.
449
00:21:29,914 --> 00:21:33,043
The second video shows
Julia entering her apartment
450
00:21:33,126 --> 00:21:35,462
12 minutes after the 911 call,
451
00:21:35,463 --> 00:21:37,129
wearing the same hoodie
as the shooter,
452
00:21:37,130 --> 00:21:38,673
and it's definitely her.
453
00:21:38,798 --> 00:21:40,175
- Okay, good.
454
00:21:40,258 --> 00:21:42,302
So what about motive?
- Unclear.
455
00:21:42,385 --> 00:21:45,221
I mean, we know Julia
and Carter were dating,
456
00:21:45,305 --> 00:21:47,057
that Julia supported him.
457
00:21:47,098 --> 00:21:48,725
- And that
she broke up with him
458
00:21:48,850 --> 00:21:51,436
three days prior
to the conclusion of the trial.
459
00:21:51,478 --> 00:21:53,563
- Okay, but you're comfortable
460
00:21:53,564 --> 00:21:55,189
moving forward
with what we have?
461
00:21:55,190 --> 00:21:57,776
- I am.
462
00:21:57,901 --> 00:21:59,027
- Charge murder 2.
463
00:22:04,407 --> 00:22:06,517
- Three days after
the defendant broke up
464
00:22:06,534 --> 00:22:10,413
with Carter Mills and six hours
after she purchased
465
00:22:10,497 --> 00:22:13,208
the .38 revolver
from Ike's Gun Shop,
466
00:22:13,333 --> 00:22:15,126
she shot and killed him.
467
00:22:15,251 --> 00:22:20,674
Why she committed
this crime is unclear.
468
00:22:20,799 --> 00:22:22,759
But as you will see,
the evidence
469
00:22:22,884 --> 00:22:24,886
will show that she did.
470
00:22:24,969 --> 00:22:28,098
We will present video of the
shooting in which you will see
471
00:22:28,139 --> 00:22:31,810
a person with a thin build
in a dark-colored hoodie
472
00:22:31,851 --> 00:22:33,603
shooting Carter Mills.
473
00:22:33,728 --> 00:22:35,958
We will also present
a second piece of video
474
00:22:35,959 --> 00:22:38,315
from outside the defendant's
apartment building
475
00:22:38,316 --> 00:22:39,901
on the night of the murder.
476
00:22:40,026 --> 00:22:43,113
It will show the defendant,
clear as day,
477
00:22:43,196 --> 00:22:47,617
wearing the same hoodie as the
person who shot Carter Mills.
478
00:22:47,701 --> 00:22:50,620
And, finally, we will
present two witnesses,
479
00:22:50,745 --> 00:22:53,289
one who heard her yell,
480
00:22:53,331 --> 00:22:55,250
"You deserve this,"
481
00:22:55,375 --> 00:22:58,211
prior to opening fire,
and another who will testify
482
00:22:58,253 --> 00:23:00,463
that he not only
saw the defendant
483
00:23:00,588 --> 00:23:03,591
near the crime scene
moments after the murder,
484
00:23:03,717 --> 00:23:05,802
but that she
literally ran into him
485
00:23:05,885 --> 00:23:08,138
in her haste to escape.
486
00:23:08,179 --> 00:23:10,223
Like I said,
487
00:23:10,265 --> 00:23:12,767
we may not know
what provoked the defendant
488
00:23:12,892 --> 00:23:14,477
to kill Carter Mills,
489
00:23:14,602 --> 00:23:18,356
but we know that she did.
490
00:23:31,119 --> 00:23:35,040
- We agree with everything
Mr. Price just said,
491
00:23:35,081 --> 00:23:38,418
including the fact
that Julia Keaton
492
00:23:38,543 --> 00:23:42,797
shot and killed Carter Mills.
493
00:23:42,922 --> 00:23:47,677
But there's a reason,
a good reason.
494
00:23:47,761 --> 00:23:53,600
Carter Mills was going to kill
her that night in that moment.
495
00:23:53,641 --> 00:23:57,145
So Julia did
what she had to do
496
00:23:57,270 --> 00:24:00,648
and killed him first.
497
00:24:00,732 --> 00:24:04,194
Julia Keaton acted
in self-defense.
498
00:24:04,319 --> 00:24:08,573
She shot Carter Mills
because it was necessary
499
00:24:08,615 --> 00:24:10,450
to prevent her own death.
500
00:24:10,492 --> 00:24:14,371
And that, ladies and gentlemen,
501
00:24:14,496 --> 00:24:16,706
is not against the law.
502
00:24:16,831 --> 00:24:20,835
[tense music]
503
00:24:20,960 --> 00:24:24,798
- Credible or not, arguing
self-defense is the right move.
504
00:24:24,923 --> 00:24:27,217
The video evidence
is too strong.
505
00:24:27,342 --> 00:24:29,386
Question is, can they prove it?
506
00:24:29,511 --> 00:24:31,096
- I'm not sure.
507
00:24:31,097 --> 00:24:33,013
- What about the video
of the shooting?
508
00:24:33,014 --> 00:24:35,140
Does that sync up
with the self-defense claim?
509
00:24:35,141 --> 00:24:37,267
Does Carter appear to
threaten her in any way?
510
00:24:37,268 --> 00:24:39,187
- It's hard to say.
511
00:24:39,270 --> 00:24:42,100
He takes a few steps towards
her, and then she shoots him.
512
00:24:42,107 --> 00:24:45,110
But there is
no physical contact.
513
00:24:45,235 --> 00:24:48,446
She is at least
15 feet away from him
514
00:24:48,571 --> 00:24:50,448
when she starts shooting,
but it-
515
00:24:50,532 --> 00:24:52,367
it doesn't matter.
516
00:24:52,492 --> 00:24:54,619
- What do you mean?
- She's lying.
517
00:24:54,620 --> 00:24:56,995
She didn't just happen to cross
paths with Carter that night.
518
00:24:56,996 --> 00:24:59,874
She was waiting for him,
and she was carrying a gun,
519
00:24:59,916 --> 00:25:02,794
a gun that she bought six hours
prior to the shooting.
520
00:25:02,919 --> 00:25:04,713
No, this was an execution.
521
00:25:04,796 --> 00:25:06,589
- Can you prove it?
522
00:25:06,715 --> 00:25:07,924
- [sighs]
523
00:25:08,049 --> 00:25:10,135
Yeah, I think so.
524
00:25:10,136 --> 00:25:12,094
The evidence is
mostly circumstantial.
525
00:25:12,095 --> 00:25:14,723
But when you add it all up,
I think it's clear
526
00:25:14,724 --> 00:25:16,432
this was not
a random encounter.
527
00:25:16,433 --> 00:25:19,144
Julia set out to kill
Carter Mills that evening,
528
00:25:19,269 --> 00:25:20,729
and she succeeded.
529
00:25:20,854 --> 00:25:23,144
- The defense will obviously
portray Carter
530
00:25:23,189 --> 00:25:25,233
as a violent predator,
531
00:25:25,234 --> 00:25:27,735
someone who had been charged
with rape and murder,
532
00:25:27,736 --> 00:25:29,570
someone capable
of killing an ex-girlfriend
533
00:25:29,571 --> 00:25:31,489
in the blink of an eye.
534
00:25:31,490 --> 00:25:33,991
If they're successful, they'll
win, regardless of the facts.
535
00:25:33,992 --> 00:25:36,368
- The problem is,
it's not easy to hide the truth
536
00:25:36,369 --> 00:25:37,662
about who Carter was.
537
00:25:37,704 --> 00:25:39,204
Him being on trial for murder,
538
00:25:39,205 --> 00:25:40,622
that's public information.
539
00:25:40,623 --> 00:25:43,543
- It doesn't mean
it's admissible.
540
00:25:43,626 --> 00:25:46,296
File a motion trying
to limit the scope
541
00:25:46,421 --> 00:25:48,840
and detail surrounding
the prior murder trial.
542
00:25:49,883 --> 00:25:51,926
- Already did.
543
00:25:52,052 --> 00:25:53,887
- You want to preclude
the defense
544
00:25:53,928 --> 00:25:56,806
from discussing the defendant's
prior murder trial?
545
00:25:56,807 --> 00:25:59,266
- Evidence of a murder
victim's prior bad acts
546
00:25:59,267 --> 00:26:02,354
is not admissible as proof
of the victim's propensity
547
00:26:02,355 --> 00:26:04,396
to act in a certain manner,
such as being
548
00:26:04,397 --> 00:26:06,315
the initial aggressor
in a confrontation.
549
00:26:06,316 --> 00:26:09,235
- But there are exceptions
in self-defense cases
550
00:26:09,319 --> 00:26:12,155
if the defendant was aware
of the prior bad acts.
551
00:26:12,238 --> 00:26:15,158
And in this case,
the defendant clearly was.
552
00:26:15,159 --> 00:26:17,409
She sat through
Carter Miller's murder trial.
553
00:26:17,410 --> 00:26:19,580
She heard all
of the horrific allegations.
554
00:26:19,704 --> 00:26:22,040
She was even aware
he was the prime suspect
555
00:26:22,082 --> 00:26:23,541
in a second murder case.
556
00:26:23,542 --> 00:26:25,250
- That may be true,
but Your Honor,
557
00:26:25,251 --> 00:26:27,212
the mere mention
of this prior trial
558
00:26:27,253 --> 00:26:29,089
is, on its face, prejudicial.
559
00:26:29,172 --> 00:26:31,716
- Carter Mill's reputation
and prior acts
560
00:26:31,800 --> 00:26:34,886
are essential to establishing
my client's state of mind
561
00:26:34,928 --> 00:26:36,513
on the night of the shooting.
562
00:26:36,514 --> 00:26:38,389
She had heard all of
the disturbing evidence
563
00:26:38,390 --> 00:26:41,434
that Mr. Price
himself presented.
564
00:26:41,559 --> 00:26:43,728
She didn't suddenly unhear it
565
00:26:43,770 --> 00:26:46,231
just because Carter
was acquitted.
566
00:26:46,356 --> 00:26:47,732
- I agree with Ms. Paymor.
567
00:26:47,857 --> 00:26:49,984
The defense can discuss
the prior trial,
568
00:26:50,110 --> 00:26:53,405
the allegations, his general
reputation for violence.
569
00:26:53,530 --> 00:26:56,825
- I'm sorry, general reputation
for vi-
570
00:26:56,950 --> 00:27:00,203
With all due respect,
that is ridiculous.
571
00:27:00,245 --> 00:27:02,247
- One, it's not.
572
00:27:02,330 --> 00:27:05,333
Two, never preface a statement
with "all due respect,"
573
00:27:05,334 --> 00:27:07,167
then say something
disrespectful.
574
00:27:07,168 --> 00:27:11,089
You tried and lost
that murder case, Mr. Price.
575
00:27:11,090 --> 00:27:13,048
And the mere fact
you brought that case
576
00:27:13,049 --> 00:27:16,511
meant you believed Carter Mills
was guilty of murder.
577
00:27:16,636 --> 00:27:18,179
And now what?
578
00:27:18,263 --> 00:27:20,348
You wanna pretend he wasn't?
579
00:27:20,473 --> 00:27:22,642
That the prior trial
didn't happen?
580
00:27:22,726 --> 00:27:25,979
No, the defense has a right
to let the jury know
581
00:27:26,104 --> 00:27:28,106
who Carter Mills really was.
582
00:27:28,189 --> 00:27:31,109
[tense music]
583
00:27:31,192 --> 00:27:33,987
* *
584
00:27:34,070 --> 00:27:37,866
- I don't really know why,
but I believed him.
585
00:27:37,991 --> 00:27:43,455
The idea of Carter raping
someone or killing someone
586
00:27:43,496 --> 00:27:45,623
didn't seem possible.
587
00:27:45,707 --> 00:27:48,209
I'd never seen
Carter act violently.
588
00:27:49,836 --> 00:27:51,629
So...
589
00:27:51,755 --> 00:27:53,048
I stayed with him.
590
00:27:53,173 --> 00:27:55,800
- Did you and Carter remain
romantically involved
591
00:27:55,842 --> 00:27:57,385
for the duration of the trial?
592
00:27:57,510 --> 00:28:01,056
- No, I broke it off
toward the end.
593
00:28:01,139 --> 00:28:02,515
- Can you explain why?
594
00:28:02,599 --> 00:28:05,727
- I knew that even
if he were acquitted,
595
00:28:05,852 --> 00:28:08,146
the stigma would remain.
596
00:28:08,271 --> 00:28:12,067
Plus, I thought that the jury
was going to convict him,
597
00:28:12,150 --> 00:28:15,737
that he was going to spend
the rest of his life in prison.
598
00:28:15,820 --> 00:28:18,490
And I couldn't
handle that either.
599
00:28:18,573 --> 00:28:22,285
So I broke it off.
600
00:28:22,410 --> 00:28:26,498
- What happened when you told
Carter you wanted to move on?
601
00:28:26,581 --> 00:28:29,793
- He got angry,
602
00:28:29,918 --> 00:28:33,004
started calling me
all kinds of horrible names.
603
00:28:34,297 --> 00:28:36,257
- Can you please
be more specific?
604
00:28:39,844 --> 00:28:44,349
- He called me a liar,
605
00:28:44,391 --> 00:28:47,769
a bitch,
606
00:28:47,894 --> 00:28:49,604
a whore.
607
00:28:51,856 --> 00:28:53,525
- And then what?
608
00:28:53,608 --> 00:28:58,905
* *
609
00:28:58,947 --> 00:29:02,534
- Then he pushed me
against the wall.
610
00:29:05,161 --> 00:29:06,579
And he started choking me.
611
00:29:10,583 --> 00:29:14,713
And then he threw me
onto the floor, and...
612
00:29:20,051 --> 00:29:22,721
He raped me.
613
00:29:22,762 --> 00:29:25,390
- Objection,
this is unfair surprise.
614
00:29:25,432 --> 00:29:27,684
- Statement against
self-interest.
615
00:29:27,767 --> 00:29:29,728
- Overruled.
- Your Honor-
616
00:29:29,769 --> 00:29:30,979
- Sit down, Mr. Price.
617
00:29:33,940 --> 00:29:34,990
Please continue.
618
00:29:38,069 --> 00:29:42,198
- He threatened to kill me
if I told the police.
619
00:29:42,282 --> 00:29:44,451
- And how'd that
make you feel?
620
00:29:46,619 --> 00:29:47,996
- Awful.
621
00:29:51,082 --> 00:29:53,460
I was terrified.
622
00:29:57,130 --> 00:29:59,966
I was a threat to his freedom.
623
00:30:01,509 --> 00:30:03,595
- Can you tell the jury
what happened
624
00:30:03,636 --> 00:30:06,514
on the night of the shooting?
625
00:30:06,598 --> 00:30:10,018
- I took a walk
to clear my head,
626
00:30:10,101 --> 00:30:12,437
trying to figure out
what to do,
627
00:30:12,562 --> 00:30:15,190
whether to call the police
628
00:30:15,273 --> 00:30:18,026
or move to a different city.
629
00:30:20,362 --> 00:30:22,947
Then...
630
00:30:23,073 --> 00:30:27,035
I saw him, and I-
631
00:30:28,828 --> 00:30:30,288
I froze.
632
00:30:32,499 --> 00:30:34,709
And we just sort of
looked at each other.
633
00:30:37,170 --> 00:30:40,298
Then he said,
634
00:30:40,423 --> 00:30:42,884
"I told you
they wouldn't convict me."
635
00:30:47,180 --> 00:30:49,933
And he started laughing.
636
00:30:50,058 --> 00:30:52,769
And he walked toward me
637
00:30:52,852 --> 00:30:56,356
and said, "You're done."
638
00:30:56,481 --> 00:30:59,984
- And how did you
interpret that statement?
639
00:31:00,110 --> 00:31:03,530
- I interpreted it to mean
that he was going to kill me.
640
00:31:03,655 --> 00:31:07,117
- In that moment,
were you in fear for your life?
641
00:31:07,200 --> 00:31:08,827
- Yes.
642
00:31:08,952 --> 00:31:11,079
I was convinced
he was going to kill me.
643
00:31:11,204 --> 00:31:12,914
So...
644
00:31:16,292 --> 00:31:17,836
I shot him.
645
00:31:19,004 --> 00:31:20,588
He was evil.
646
00:31:20,714 --> 00:31:23,842
I don't know why it took me
so long to realize it,
647
00:31:23,883 --> 00:31:26,428
but he was going
to kill me,
648
00:31:26,553 --> 00:31:28,763
I swear.
649
00:31:28,805 --> 00:31:30,140
I know it!
650
00:31:30,265 --> 00:31:33,852
[sobbing]
651
00:31:37,022 --> 00:31:38,712
- I think that's enough
for today.
652
00:31:38,732 --> 00:31:42,277
We're adjourned until
tomorrow, 9:00 a.m.
653
00:31:42,360 --> 00:31:43,862
Ms. Keaton, you're excused.
654
00:31:43,945 --> 00:31:50,744
* *
655
00:32:02,666 --> 00:32:03,964
.
656
00:32:03,965 --> 00:32:05,015
- Hey.
657
00:32:05,967 --> 00:32:08,345
Paymor just sent over
an amended witness list.
658
00:32:08,428 --> 00:32:10,930
One of Julia's friends is
gonna testify that
659
00:32:10,931 --> 00:32:13,223
Julia called her the night
of the alleged rape
660
00:32:13,224 --> 00:32:15,268
and told her what happened.
661
00:32:15,352 --> 00:32:16,922
- We should try
to exclude her-
662
00:32:16,936 --> 00:32:19,856
- No, it's admissible
as a prompt outcry.
663
00:32:19,981 --> 00:32:22,984
Goes to her subjective state
of mind and whether or not
664
00:32:23,068 --> 00:32:25,070
she was in reasonable fear
for her life.
665
00:32:25,153 --> 00:32:26,946
- So trying to shift the focus.
666
00:32:27,030 --> 00:32:28,406
- Mm.
667
00:32:28,407 --> 00:32:30,407
- They wanna barrage
the jury with all
668
00:32:30,408 --> 00:32:33,620
the horrific details of Julia's
sexual assault allegation.
669
00:32:33,703 --> 00:32:36,053
But they don't need to hear
even more evidence
670
00:32:36,054 --> 00:32:38,832
about what a monster he was,
especially because it has
671
00:32:38,833 --> 00:32:40,751
no bearing on what
happened immediately
672
00:32:40,752 --> 00:32:42,170
prior to the shooting.
673
00:32:42,253 --> 00:32:44,923
Did Carter threaten
to kill her in that moment?
674
00:32:44,964 --> 00:32:47,467
If so, was his threat credible?
675
00:32:47,550 --> 00:32:49,969
Did it justify lethal force?
676
00:32:54,599 --> 00:32:56,101
- [exhales]
677
00:32:56,184 --> 00:32:59,896
What are we really trying
to accomplish here?
678
00:33:00,021 --> 00:33:01,731
- Um...
679
00:33:01,815 --> 00:33:05,068
we're trying to get justice
for the victim.
680
00:33:05,151 --> 00:33:08,154
- Who happens to be
a really, really horrible man.
681
00:33:08,279 --> 00:33:09,698
- We are past all that, Sam.
682
00:33:09,781 --> 00:33:12,492
- Oh, trust me, Nolan,
I am really trying my best
683
00:33:12,617 --> 00:33:14,452
to think like a prosecutor,
684
00:33:14,536 --> 00:33:18,081
to ignore my personal feelings,
I swear.
685
00:33:18,164 --> 00:33:20,583
But this isn't a murder case.
686
00:33:20,709 --> 00:33:23,503
- She left her apartment
with a gun in her purse,
687
00:33:23,628 --> 00:33:26,381
a gun she had just bought
with the intent
688
00:33:26,464 --> 00:33:27,924
of killing Carter Mills.
689
00:33:27,925 --> 00:33:29,633
That's practically
the definition of murder.
690
00:33:29,634 --> 00:33:31,428
- Yeah, but why?
Why did she do it?
691
00:33:31,511 --> 00:33:33,430
Because he had just raped her
692
00:33:33,431 --> 00:33:35,597
and threatened to kill her
if she told anyone.
693
00:33:35,598 --> 00:33:38,518
And the guy gets acquitted
and is a free man-
694
00:33:38,643 --> 00:33:40,687
free to rape, free to kill.
695
00:33:40,770 --> 00:33:42,313
- So she assassinated him.
696
00:33:42,355 --> 00:33:45,191
She yelled, "You deserve this,"
697
00:33:45,316 --> 00:33:46,943
just before she opened fire.
698
00:33:46,944 --> 00:33:48,569
- She was acting
under the influence
699
00:33:48,570 --> 00:33:50,195
of extreme
emotional disturbance.
700
00:33:50,196 --> 00:33:52,156
That's manslaughter, Nolan,
all day long.
701
00:33:52,157 --> 00:33:55,785
- Sam-Sam,
we talked about this,
702
00:33:55,869 --> 00:33:57,662
about staying focused
on the law.
703
00:33:57,704 --> 00:34:00,040
- I am making a legal argument.
704
00:34:02,667 --> 00:34:04,586
You want the emotional one?
705
00:34:06,421 --> 00:34:09,758
Julia should have never been
in that position to begin with.
706
00:34:09,841 --> 00:34:11,676
If we had won the damn case,
707
00:34:11,718 --> 00:34:14,512
if we actually convicted
Carter Mills,
708
00:34:14,596 --> 00:34:16,264
this would have never happened.
709
00:34:16,348 --> 00:34:18,558
[soft tense music]
710
00:34:18,683 --> 00:34:20,727
We let a monster walk free.
711
00:34:23,688 --> 00:34:27,942
You let a monster walk free.
712
00:34:27,943 --> 00:34:29,860
If you ask me,
we practically forced
713
00:34:29,861 --> 00:34:31,237
Julia to shoot the bastard.
714
00:34:31,238 --> 00:34:32,863
- That is not fair.
You and I both-
715
00:34:32,864 --> 00:34:34,282
- What's not fair
716
00:34:34,283 --> 00:34:36,867
is watching the man
who killed your little sister
717
00:34:36,868 --> 00:34:39,871
and another young,
innocent woman walk free
718
00:34:39,872 --> 00:34:41,330
because the guy trying the case
719
00:34:41,331 --> 00:34:43,374
didn't have the guts
to do what was necessary
720
00:34:43,375 --> 00:34:45,293
to get a conviction.
721
00:34:45,418 --> 00:34:50,840
* *
722
00:34:50,924 --> 00:34:53,134
That's what's not fair.
723
00:34:53,259 --> 00:35:00,141
* *
724
00:35:02,727 --> 00:35:04,688
- You wanna offer man 1?
725
00:35:04,813 --> 00:35:08,233
- If we take Julia at her word
on the rape allegation,
726
00:35:08,234 --> 00:35:10,109
I think it is reasonable
to conclude that
727
00:35:10,110 --> 00:35:11,402
she was acting under
the influence
728
00:35:11,403 --> 00:35:14,114
of extreme emotional
disturbance.
729
00:35:14,155 --> 00:35:16,533
Not to mention,
there's a really good chance
730
00:35:16,534 --> 00:35:18,909
the jury's gonna buy
her self-defense story,
731
00:35:18,910 --> 00:35:20,954
and she walks.
732
00:35:21,027 --> 00:35:24,373
- Are you doing this
because you think
733
00:35:24,374 --> 00:35:27,752
it's the right legal move?
734
00:35:27,877 --> 00:35:29,295
Or to placate Sam,
735
00:35:29,379 --> 00:35:31,798
to make amends
for the Carter Mills trial?
736
00:35:33,758 --> 00:35:36,428
- It's the right move, Nick.
737
00:35:36,511 --> 00:35:38,471
- You didn't
answer my question.
738
00:35:41,933 --> 00:35:45,854
- It is the right legal move.
739
00:35:50,150 --> 00:35:51,693
- If you say so.
740
00:36:03,163 --> 00:36:05,707
- We appreciate the offer,
741
00:36:05,790 --> 00:36:07,042
but let's be honest.
742
00:36:07,043 --> 00:36:08,876
There isn't a juror alive
that wants to punish
743
00:36:08,877 --> 00:36:10,420
Julia for what she did.
744
00:36:10,421 --> 00:36:12,338
- We're not here to debate
whether Carter Mills
745
00:36:12,339 --> 00:36:14,507
was a good man.
We know he wasn't.
746
00:36:14,632 --> 00:36:18,720
But murder is still murder.
747
00:36:18,845 --> 00:36:22,182
Having said that, in light
of the highly emotional
748
00:36:22,265 --> 00:36:24,601
circumstances
surrounding this event,
749
00:36:24,726 --> 00:36:27,729
we are willing to accept
a guilty plea to man 1.
750
00:36:28,983 --> 00:36:32,066
- We'll discuss
and get back to you.
751
00:36:32,067 --> 00:36:33,401
- You have 24 hours.
- Okay.
752
00:36:33,485 --> 00:36:35,153
[phone buzzes]
753
00:36:35,236 --> 00:36:36,738
I need to take this real quick.
754
00:36:36,780 --> 00:36:38,073
I'll be right back.
755
00:36:41,826 --> 00:36:43,244
[door shuts]
756
00:36:43,328 --> 00:36:48,541
- I just wanna say, I feel
terrible about everything.
757
00:36:50,669 --> 00:36:54,673
He should have never walked
out of that damn courtroom.
758
00:36:54,756 --> 00:36:59,844
- I know what Carter did
to your sister.
759
00:37:01,388 --> 00:37:02,972
And I-
760
00:37:03,098 --> 00:37:04,974
[somber music]
761
00:37:05,058 --> 00:37:07,227
I'm so sorry.
762
00:37:09,854 --> 00:37:13,108
I can't believe
how stupid I was.
763
00:37:13,191 --> 00:37:15,777
I feel like such a fool.
764
00:37:15,819 --> 00:37:17,929
He thought he could do
whatever he wanted.
765
00:37:17,987 --> 00:37:20,240
He thought that
he was above the law.
766
00:37:20,365 --> 00:37:22,075
That's why I did what I did.
767
00:37:22,158 --> 00:37:25,620
That's why I waited outside his
damn condo so that I-
768
00:37:29,541 --> 00:37:30,959
I-I didn't mean to say that.
769
00:37:31,042 --> 00:37:33,294
- Shh, shh.
770
00:37:33,378 --> 00:37:34,838
Stop talking.
771
00:37:34,963 --> 00:37:41,928
* *
772
00:38:10,915 --> 00:38:11,965
Hey.
773
00:38:13,126 --> 00:38:15,128
Um...
774
00:38:15,253 --> 00:38:17,422
just got a text from Paymor.
775
00:38:17,505 --> 00:38:19,299
Julia wants to accept the plea.
776
00:38:23,345 --> 00:38:25,638
But there is something
you should know.
777
00:38:25,680 --> 00:38:28,099
After the meeting this
afternoon, Julia and I
778
00:38:28,224 --> 00:38:30,685
talked for a minute.
779
00:38:30,769 --> 00:38:34,606
I told her I felt awful
about what had happened to her.
780
00:38:34,689 --> 00:38:37,108
She got very emotional.
781
00:38:37,192 --> 00:38:40,445
She said, uh...
782
00:38:40,487 --> 00:38:43,281
she said that
she felt like a fool
783
00:38:43,365 --> 00:38:45,950
for believing in his innocence.
784
00:38:46,034 --> 00:38:49,412
And, uh,
then she said something
785
00:38:49,537 --> 00:38:52,874
she didn't mean to say.
786
00:38:52,999 --> 00:38:58,088
And she was just so
emotional that, uh...
787
00:38:58,129 --> 00:38:59,939
well,
she accidentally confessed
788
00:39:00,006 --> 00:39:03,218
to waiting outside Carter's
building prior to killing him.
789
00:39:04,597 --> 00:39:07,846
- Which means
she lied on the stand.
790
00:39:07,847 --> 00:39:09,224
- Yeah.
791
00:39:09,349 --> 00:39:11,726
- And she and Carter
didn't just, um,
792
00:39:11,727 --> 00:39:14,061
didn't just happen
to cross paths that night.
793
00:39:14,062 --> 00:39:15,939
- Well, you were right.
794
00:39:15,980 --> 00:39:17,524
This was premeditated.
795
00:39:17,607 --> 00:39:20,485
This was an assassination.
796
00:39:20,568 --> 00:39:22,987
On paper, anyway.
- On paper?
797
00:39:23,071 --> 00:39:25,156
- Based on
the letter of the law.
798
00:39:32,497 --> 00:39:33,707
- All right.
799
00:39:33,832 --> 00:39:37,002
So how do you wanna proceed?
800
00:39:39,212 --> 00:39:41,464
- Uh, are you asking
what I would do
801
00:39:41,506 --> 00:39:43,508
or what I think you wanna do?
802
00:39:43,591 --> 00:39:46,469
- No, I'm asking
for your opinion.
803
00:39:46,594 --> 00:39:47,644
- Okay.
804
00:39:47,679 --> 00:39:52,350
Um, well, we have two choices.
805
00:39:52,434 --> 00:39:55,603
I mean, I can testify
as a rebuttal witness
806
00:39:55,687 --> 00:39:58,023
and tell the jury
what Julia blurted out.
807
00:39:58,148 --> 00:40:02,360
Or, uh, we can
both pretend that
808
00:40:02,444 --> 00:40:04,654
I didn't hear
what Julia just said,
809
00:40:04,738 --> 00:40:08,408
accept the damn plea,
and move on.
810
00:40:08,409 --> 00:40:10,034
- I didn't ask
for choices, Sam.
811
00:40:10,035 --> 00:40:12,829
I asked for an opinion,
for your opinion.
812
00:40:12,954 --> 00:40:14,622
- Yeah.
813
00:40:14,748 --> 00:40:17,709
Well, my opinion is
we accept the damn plea.
814
00:40:17,792 --> 00:40:20,253
[pensive music]
815
00:40:20,378 --> 00:40:22,008
Just because
we can win the case
816
00:40:22,130 --> 00:40:25,633
based on the letter of the law
doesn't mean we need to.
817
00:40:25,759 --> 00:40:32,599
* *
818
00:40:32,682 --> 00:40:35,268
- I agree.
819
00:40:42,484 --> 00:40:43,735
Hey, Sam.
820
00:40:43,818 --> 00:40:44,868
- Yeah?
821
00:40:51,076 --> 00:40:53,536
- Thanks for being so honest.
822
00:40:53,620 --> 00:41:00,585
* *
823
00:41:11,632 --> 00:41:12,971
.
824
00:41:12,972 --> 00:41:15,642
[dramatic music]
825
00:41:15,975 --> 00:41:22,941
* *
826
00:41:42,460 --> 00:41:45,380
[wolf howls]
827
00:41:45,430 --> 00:41:49,980
Repair and Synchronization by
Easy Subtitles Synchronizer 1.0.0.0
58979
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.