Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:27,695 --> 00:00:30,573
Jefferson is my
hometown. I love it.
2
00:00:33,492 --> 00:00:35,578
You know, we're not the
crime capital of the world.
3
00:00:35,661 --> 00:00:37,538
We don't have many murders.
4
00:00:39,373 --> 00:00:42,085
It's a place where people
still leave their cars open
5
00:00:42,168 --> 00:00:45,088
and their front doors open.
6
00:00:45,171 --> 00:00:47,215
This violent act was
so out of character,
7
00:00:47,298 --> 00:00:50,510
unbelievable to happen in
our nice, small community
8
00:00:50,593 --> 00:00:51,885
where nothing really happens.
9
00:01:04,857 --> 00:01:07,151
The murder scene is
like a jigsaw puzzle.
10
00:01:07,234 --> 00:01:09,695
You're trying to put
all the pieces together.
11
00:01:12,156 --> 00:01:15,785
You have a woman who's been
murdered in the basement.
12
00:01:15,868 --> 00:01:17,620
The victim was
stabbed multiple times
13
00:01:17,703 --> 00:01:19,789
about the upper
torso and the face.
14
00:01:19,872 --> 00:01:21,916
Her head was bashed in,
15
00:01:21,999 --> 00:01:24,119
which caused her eyeball to
explode out of the socket.
16
00:01:25,961 --> 00:01:29,215
And just the saturation
of the blood was evidence
17
00:01:29,298 --> 00:01:32,843
that it was violent,
very violent murder.
18
00:01:36,055 --> 00:01:39,225
And Tom, he's the only
one not in the home.
19
00:01:39,308 --> 00:01:41,769
It was imperative
to try to find him.
20
00:01:41,852 --> 00:01:43,354
It was all hands on deck.
21
00:01:43,437 --> 00:01:46,399
K-9 units, crime scene units,
full detective bureaus.
22
00:01:46,482 --> 00:01:47,984
We got patrol cars
running around
23
00:01:48,067 --> 00:01:49,902
through the
neighborhoods. Nothing.
24
00:01:49,985 --> 00:01:51,863
It was just go where the
dog's trying to lead you
25
00:01:51,946 --> 00:01:53,823
and see if you
can find anything.
26
00:01:53,906 --> 00:01:56,242
And of course we didn't.
27
00:01:56,325 --> 00:01:58,411
We went on down to
the condominiums
28
00:01:58,494 --> 00:02:00,747
that were being built
and cleared those.
29
00:02:00,830 --> 00:02:02,832
And by then, it was
getting close to daylight
30
00:02:02,915 --> 00:02:04,459
and we realized that we
31
00:02:04,542 --> 00:02:06,627
were probably not going
to find him at this point.
32
00:02:06,710 --> 00:02:09,589
The decision was made to
hold off on the search
33
00:02:09,672 --> 00:02:11,882
and wait till the
day shift comes in.
34
00:02:16,387 --> 00:02:19,599
Wake up in the morning,
and that's the first time
35
00:02:19,682 --> 00:02:24,937
where the adults start being
dodgy with what's going on.
36
00:02:25,020 --> 00:02:28,107
"What happened in White Rock?"
"Well, we're not really sure."
37
00:02:28,190 --> 00:02:29,858
"Is everyone okay?"
"Well, we don't know."
38
00:02:31,527 --> 00:02:33,112
Then the phone starts
ringing with my friends,
39
00:02:33,195 --> 00:02:36,532
and they're like, "Mrs.
Sullivan was murdered."
40
00:02:36,615 --> 00:02:39,452
I'm like, "What?
41
00:02:39,535 --> 00:02:41,078
There was a murder?
42
00:02:41,161 --> 00:02:42,455
Like an actual
murder in Jefferson?"
43
00:02:42,538 --> 00:02:44,040
Like, "Who did it?"
44
00:02:44,123 --> 00:02:47,042
And at this point, we still
don't know, but Tommy's missing.
45
00:02:49,920 --> 00:02:53,216
So the first bit of rumor
mill that was going on
46
00:02:53,299 --> 00:02:55,676
was that there's a
murderer loose in town,
47
00:02:55,759 --> 00:02:57,553
and he kidnapped Tommy.
48
00:03:01,015 --> 00:03:03,309
So we're all like, "Holy shit."
49
00:03:03,392 --> 00:03:05,228
There was a murderer
that kidnapped a kid,
50
00:03:05,311 --> 00:03:06,938
and what the hell
is he doing to him?
51
00:03:07,021 --> 00:03:09,522
I'd seen movies where
kids were abducted.
52
00:03:11,817 --> 00:03:15,988
In "America's Most Wanted,"
that was very recent still.
53
00:03:16,071 --> 00:03:18,074
Host John Walsh,
54
00:03:18,157 --> 00:03:19,826
whose six-year-old son
Adam was brutally murdered,
55
00:03:19,909 --> 00:03:21,619
leads this crusade
against crime.
56
00:03:21,702 --> 00:03:23,495
I was... I was terrified.
57
00:03:25,497 --> 00:03:27,041
It was snowing like
hell the night before.
58
00:03:27,124 --> 00:03:28,960
We all wanted to go out on a
sleigh riding, we couldn't.
59
00:03:29,043 --> 00:03:31,462
We wanted snowball
fights, we couldn't.
60
00:03:31,545 --> 00:03:33,421
No one could leave the house.
61
00:03:59,031 --> 00:04:01,617
Panic. It's not just a reaction.
62
00:04:01,700 --> 00:04:05,538
It's a state of
mind, an instinct.
63
00:04:05,621 --> 00:04:09,250
When something horrific happens,
we scramble for answers.
64
00:04:09,333 --> 00:04:12,294
We start looking for someone
or something to blame.
65
00:04:14,505 --> 00:04:16,172
Panic can distort everything.
66
00:04:17,841 --> 00:04:19,635
It spreads faster than facts.
67
00:04:19,718 --> 00:04:22,554
And soon, it's not
about truth anymore.
68
00:04:24,181 --> 00:04:26,766
It's about the fear
that consumes us all.
69
00:04:34,984 --> 00:04:37,736
{\an8}Tommy was known as a
Reverend Brown kid.
70
00:04:39,321 --> 00:04:41,157
Everyone knew him from church.
71
00:04:41,240 --> 00:04:44,118
He was an altar boy, which was
also an elevated position there.
72
00:04:44,201 --> 00:04:47,079
And he was an all-area,
106-pound wrestler.
73
00:04:50,290 --> 00:04:52,084
New Jersey is a wrestling state.
74
00:04:52,167 --> 00:04:55,713
It's like a more popular
sport than football.
75
00:04:55,796 --> 00:04:58,507
So the wrestlers were,
in a way, kind of,
76
00:04:58,590 --> 00:05:00,051
the good ones were
kind of revered
77
00:05:00,134 --> 00:05:02,053
because everyone
knew the discipline
78
00:05:02,136 --> 00:05:03,816
that it took to really
excel at that sport.
79
00:05:07,307 --> 00:05:08,643
I was principal of
80
00:05:08,726 --> 00:05:12,104
Reverend George A.
Brown Memorial School.
81
00:05:12,187 --> 00:05:15,274
Tom Jr. was in the school
from first grade on.
82
00:05:17,067 --> 00:05:20,112
{\an8}He was very handsome.
83
00:05:20,195 --> 00:05:23,449
{\an8}I remember him as being blond,
but I saw a picture of him
84
00:05:23,532 --> 00:05:26,619
{\an8}and he had darker hair
than I remembered,
85
00:05:26,702 --> 00:05:29,789
but he had the most
beautiful blue eyes.
86
00:05:29,872 --> 00:05:32,291
He was a good student.
87
00:05:32,374 --> 00:05:36,669
He basically made no ripples.
88
00:05:42,051 --> 00:05:43,803
It was Sunday morning,
89
00:05:43,886 --> 00:05:46,889
I received a call from
the convent that said
90
00:05:46,972 --> 00:05:50,434
that they could not find Tom.
91
00:05:52,102 --> 00:05:53,729
I felt shock,
92
00:05:55,397 --> 00:05:56,774
basically...
93
00:05:59,777 --> 00:06:01,111
unbelief.
94
00:06:02,821 --> 00:06:05,741
And then, when they
didn't know where Tom was,
95
00:06:05,824 --> 00:06:08,411
I had so many
concerns about that.
96
00:06:08,494 --> 00:06:10,579
Like, where would he be?
97
00:06:18,754 --> 00:06:19,797
Hello?
98
00:06:19,880 --> 00:06:21,632
The following morning,
99
00:06:21,715 --> 00:06:23,718
I had received a call from
the dispatcher saying that
100
00:06:23,801 --> 00:06:25,302
one of our police officers
who lives in White Rock
101
00:06:25,385 --> 00:06:28,848
was speaking on the
phone to a woman.
102
00:06:28,931 --> 00:06:30,683
She just happened
to be talking to her
103
00:06:30,766 --> 00:06:32,351
and asked about
what was going on.
104
00:06:32,434 --> 00:06:34,353
And as she was talking to her,
105
00:06:34,436 --> 00:06:36,647
she looked out her back
window and saw a body.
106
00:06:39,525 --> 00:06:41,068
Oh, my God.
107
00:06:41,151 --> 00:06:42,778
Blood on the ground.
108
00:06:42,861 --> 00:06:45,406
At first, they weren't too
sure if he was still alive.
109
00:06:45,489 --> 00:06:47,783
Then the woman clarified,
"He's dead, he's dead."
110
00:06:49,701 --> 00:06:51,662
It was Tommy Sullivan.
111
00:06:51,745 --> 00:06:54,665
It was a couple houses
across the street
112
00:06:54,748 --> 00:06:57,043
and over from the
Sullivan house.
113
00:06:57,126 --> 00:06:59,170
The backyard was fenced in.
114
00:06:59,253 --> 00:07:01,255
There was a shed to
the left of the body.
115
00:07:03,465 --> 00:07:05,968
The snow was so deep at the time
116
00:07:06,051 --> 00:07:09,930
that the body kind of
sat below the snow.
117
00:07:16,937 --> 00:07:20,149
I got a call, and said
they had found Tommy,
118
00:07:20,232 --> 00:07:22,567
and to come back down.
119
00:07:39,793 --> 00:07:43,798
His wrists were cut
all the way down to...
120
00:07:43,881 --> 00:07:47,468
pretty much through
to the bones.
121
00:07:47,551 --> 00:07:51,930
His throat had been cut from one
side all the way to the other.
122
00:07:55,559 --> 00:07:58,979
You could actually look
down into his windpipe,
123
00:07:59,062 --> 00:08:00,521
cut it all the way across.
124
00:08:04,902 --> 00:08:08,155
The medical examiner was
pointing out the blood splatter
125
00:08:08,238 --> 00:08:10,282
or spurting blood
on a wooden fence.
126
00:08:12,201 --> 00:08:14,453
And there was some
discussion about
127
00:08:14,536 --> 00:08:16,204
how this could have happened.
128
00:08:18,040 --> 00:08:21,669
As brutal as his mother
had been murdered,
129
00:08:21,752 --> 00:08:24,630
this was equally as brutal.
130
00:08:28,425 --> 00:08:30,803
His throat was cut ear to ear
131
00:08:30,886 --> 00:08:33,639
and his head was hanging
back, um, you know.
132
00:08:33,722 --> 00:08:36,684
Esophagus, everything
was visible.
133
00:08:36,767 --> 00:08:38,477
So this was shocking.
134
00:08:40,354 --> 00:08:42,814
The thought was that
this was a suicide.
135
00:08:44,483 --> 00:08:49,488
Just the nature of the violence,
the nature of the wounds,
136
00:08:49,571 --> 00:08:54,993
people have a hard time relating
that to a 14-year-old boy.
137
00:08:58,664 --> 00:09:00,791
White Rock is a pretty
tight-knit community.
138
00:09:04,294 --> 00:09:06,839
You have people who have
been there for a long time,
139
00:09:06,922 --> 00:09:08,548
born there.
140
00:09:10,550 --> 00:09:13,762
Everybody kind of
knew each other.
141
00:09:13,845 --> 00:09:16,223
The police, if we
had found Tommy,
142
00:09:16,306 --> 00:09:18,350
you can kind of keep that
under wraps to some degree
143
00:09:18,433 --> 00:09:20,435
to finish out your
investigation.
144
00:09:22,104 --> 00:09:26,859
But the fact that Tommy
was found by a neighbor,
145
00:09:26,942 --> 00:09:29,652
that's not gonna stay
too secret too long.
146
00:09:30,988 --> 00:09:32,323
Hello?
147
00:09:32,406 --> 00:09:33,866
My brother got the first call.
148
00:09:33,949 --> 00:09:36,827
"They found Tommy, he's dead."
149
00:09:36,910 --> 00:09:39,830
My mom screams, starts crying.
150
00:09:39,913 --> 00:09:42,333
I went, "Where did
they find him?"
151
00:09:42,416 --> 00:09:45,169
Like, the neighbor's backyard.
152
00:09:45,252 --> 00:09:47,713
Like, across the street?
What are you talking about?
153
00:09:47,796 --> 00:09:49,590
We've got to find out more.
154
00:09:49,673 --> 00:09:51,842
So then I start trying to call.
And I think I actually broke
155
00:09:51,925 --> 00:09:53,928
the news to a couple
of my friends, okay?
156
00:09:54,011 --> 00:09:56,096
And then they didn't believe me.
And then they tell their mom.
157
00:09:56,179 --> 00:09:58,339
So everybody's trying to get
confirmation of the story.
158
00:10:00,517 --> 00:10:02,310
We started finding
everything out.
159
00:10:07,482 --> 00:10:10,235
That Betty Ann was dead
and that Tommy was dead.
160
00:10:11,528 --> 00:10:14,448
You're trying to process that
as like a 13-year-old boy.
161
00:10:14,531 --> 00:10:16,951
You know, oh, my God, how
could this happen type thing.
162
00:10:17,034 --> 00:10:18,869
So, it was scary.
163
00:10:18,952 --> 00:10:20,788
And it just leaves you
really, like, unsettled
164
00:10:20,871 --> 00:10:22,164
and really uneasy.
165
00:10:25,792 --> 00:10:28,045
I was there at Tommy's scene
166
00:10:28,128 --> 00:10:31,382
when they located
a Boy Scout knife
167
00:10:31,465 --> 00:10:33,925
that they found with his body.
168
00:10:35,427 --> 00:10:37,263
It was a typical camping knife,
169
00:10:37,346 --> 00:10:40,432
maybe four or five inches long.
170
00:10:41,933 --> 00:10:43,727
It can be super sharp.
171
00:10:43,810 --> 00:10:46,814
If you spend enough time
sharpening it, I guess.
172
00:10:46,897 --> 00:10:49,649
It would have to be pretty sharp
to do the damage that it did.
173
00:10:52,194 --> 00:10:53,737
I don't know how
you could do that
174
00:10:53,820 --> 00:10:55,948
after you've already
sliced your wrists,
175
00:10:56,031 --> 00:10:58,284
how you could stick the
knife in your throat
176
00:10:58,367 --> 00:11:00,119
and slice all the way across.
177
00:11:00,202 --> 00:11:02,162
It certainly didn't make sense.
178
00:11:06,416 --> 00:11:09,003
They still had to do the
medical examiner's report
179
00:11:09,086 --> 00:11:11,547
on Mrs. Sullivan's body,
because at this point,
180
00:11:11,630 --> 00:11:13,299
they didn't know if
that was the same knife
181
00:11:13,382 --> 00:11:16,385
that killed the mother.
182
00:11:16,468 --> 00:11:19,847
When his body was found, the ID
unit, everybody was still there.
183
00:11:19,930 --> 00:11:22,141
So it was easy for them
to photograph everything
184
00:11:22,224 --> 00:11:24,643
and collect the
remaining evidence.
185
00:11:24,726 --> 00:11:26,854
There was only one
set of footprints,
186
00:11:26,937 --> 00:11:29,398
and they were Tommy's that
led to where he was...
187
00:11:29,481 --> 00:11:31,734
where he was found.
188
00:11:31,817 --> 00:11:34,987
It isolated him as
the only person.
189
00:11:35,070 --> 00:11:36,470
It wasn't like there
was a struggle.
190
00:11:37,989 --> 00:11:44,204
It was more a validation
of, this is Tommy.
191
00:11:44,287 --> 00:11:45,747
This is what Tommy did to Tommy.
192
00:11:47,374 --> 00:11:48,625
There were just his prints
193
00:11:48,708 --> 00:11:51,754
that went from the
road up to that yard.
194
00:11:51,837 --> 00:11:54,214
So it appears as if,
after he crashed the car,
195
00:11:54,297 --> 00:11:56,175
got the car stuck,
196
00:11:56,258 --> 00:11:58,259
that he immediately
went to that backyard.
197
00:12:01,972 --> 00:12:07,227
The family car was across
the street from the house.
198
00:12:07,310 --> 00:12:09,188
It had a sloped driveway,
199
00:12:09,271 --> 00:12:12,691
so it appeared that it had
rolled down across the street
200
00:12:12,774 --> 00:12:16,236
into a snowbank, and
it was stuck there.
201
00:12:16,319 --> 00:12:17,780
And that's when they found
202
00:12:17,863 --> 00:12:19,823
some of Tommy's
belongings in the car.
203
00:12:28,039 --> 00:12:31,376
And that's where they
found the contract...
204
00:12:33,295 --> 00:12:36,590
...the contract that
Tommy had written
205
00:12:36,673 --> 00:12:40,093
to the greatest demons of hell.
206
00:12:43,388 --> 00:12:47,726
{\an8}"To the greatest demons
of hell, I, Tom Sullivan",
207
00:12:47,809 --> 00:12:50,270
"would like to make a
solemn exchange with you.
208
00:12:50,353 --> 00:12:54,525
"If you give me the most
extreme of all magical powers,
209
00:12:54,608 --> 00:12:57,820
"I will use them wisely to
tempt as many people as possible
210
00:12:57,903 --> 00:12:59,988
"to do evil and follow you.
211
00:13:00,071 --> 00:13:02,366
"I will kill many
Christian followers
212
00:13:02,449 --> 00:13:04,535
"who are serious
in their beliefs.
213
00:13:04,618 --> 00:13:06,703
"Although I will
not kill my family
214
00:13:06,786 --> 00:13:09,915
"until I live for 10
years from this very day,
215
00:13:09,998 --> 00:13:12,418
"this will be done to
avoid any neighbors
216
00:13:12,501 --> 00:13:15,212
from becoming suspicious,
not out of love for them."
217
00:13:16,671 --> 00:13:18,507
{\an8}"Throughout my new life,
218
00:13:18,590 --> 00:13:20,717
{\an8}"I promise to perform
any Satanistic ritual
219
00:13:20,800 --> 00:13:23,262
"except homosexual acts."
220
00:13:23,345 --> 00:13:26,389
"I will do these to prove my
loyalty to the demons of hell."
221
00:13:28,683 --> 00:13:30,519
"Exactly 20 years from this day,
222
00:13:30,602 --> 00:13:32,271
"I promise to commit suicide.
223
00:13:32,354 --> 00:13:35,065
"At this time, I will
go directly to hell
224
00:13:35,148 --> 00:13:38,068
"to work with you as a demon.
225
00:13:38,151 --> 00:13:41,196
"I will tempt all teenagers
on Earth to have sex,
226
00:13:41,279 --> 00:13:43,615
have incest, do drugs,
and worship you."
227
00:13:46,618 --> 00:13:49,455
{\an8}"I believe that evil
will once again rise
228
00:13:49,538 --> 00:13:52,416
{\an8}"and conquer the love of God.
229
00:13:52,499 --> 00:13:55,335
If this pact is to your
approval, sign below."
230
00:13:59,589 --> 00:14:02,551
The part in the contract
about killing his family
231
00:14:02,634 --> 00:14:04,386
has an X through it, and
then, in parentheses,
232
00:14:04,469 --> 00:14:06,721
he has next to that, "I have
already killed my family."
233
00:14:09,808 --> 00:14:14,104
Now, the contract, well, I was
obviously taken aback by it,
234
00:14:14,187 --> 00:14:16,565
especially when he, you know,
235
00:14:16,648 --> 00:14:18,025
that he'd already killed his
family, because he thought,
236
00:14:18,108 --> 00:14:20,611
once he torched the place,
once he lit those papers,
237
00:14:20,694 --> 00:14:22,279
that the house was
going to burn down,
238
00:14:22,362 --> 00:14:24,082
he was going to kill
his father and brother.
239
00:14:29,077 --> 00:14:31,079
The contract.
240
00:14:31,162 --> 00:14:32,915
For a lot of people,
241
00:14:32,998 --> 00:14:37,294
that was a pretty
telling piece of evidence
242
00:14:37,377 --> 00:14:41,882
that kind of linked
this behavior,
243
00:14:41,965 --> 00:14:46,594
this murder-suicide, into
the realm of the occult.
244
00:14:49,889 --> 00:14:51,808
Once the word got out
245
00:14:51,891 --> 00:14:54,937
that this could have had
its roots in some type
246
00:14:55,020 --> 00:14:58,815
of Satanic belief system,
there was media on scene.
247
00:14:58,898 --> 00:15:00,984
A mother and son from New Jersey
248
00:15:01,067 --> 00:15:03,403
are dead tonight following a
devastating murder and suicide
249
00:15:03,486 --> 00:15:05,405
with shades of the occult.
250
00:15:05,488 --> 00:15:07,366
He reportedly went into a rage,
251
00:15:07,449 --> 00:15:09,952
stabbed his mother to death,
then ran into the living room,
252
00:15:10,035 --> 00:15:11,787
where he set a pile
of papers on fire.
253
00:15:11,870 --> 00:15:13,705
Then ran to a neighbor's yard
254
00:15:13,788 --> 00:15:15,541
where he slit his own throat.
255
00:15:15,624 --> 00:15:17,543
Books on Satanism
were found in the fire
256
00:15:17,626 --> 00:15:19,670
that was burning in the living
room of the Sullivan home.
257
00:15:19,753 --> 00:15:22,339
A major crime happens
in your community
258
00:15:22,422 --> 00:15:24,716
and of course the media
comes out and they go around
259
00:15:24,799 --> 00:15:26,593
and start speaking
to all the neighbors.
260
00:15:26,676 --> 00:15:29,930
{\an8}All we've heard is that
Tommy killed his mother
261
00:15:30,013 --> 00:15:31,890
{\an8}and then tried to kill
himself and died in the woods.
262
00:15:31,973 --> 00:15:33,892
You don't think that
something like that
263
00:15:33,975 --> 00:15:36,353
can happen right next
door or across the street.
264
00:15:40,190 --> 00:15:44,278
In the late '80s, I was
a freelance journalist,
265
00:15:44,361 --> 00:15:48,740
and I wrote primarily for
the women's magazines.
266
00:15:48,823 --> 00:15:51,034
I was assigned the article
267
00:15:51,117 --> 00:15:55,414
because I lived in New
Jersey at the time.
268
00:15:55,497 --> 00:15:59,668
I was told there's a story
out of this suburban town
269
00:15:59,751 --> 00:16:03,505
in New Jersey of this
young teenage boy
270
00:16:03,588 --> 00:16:06,173
who brutally killed his mom.
271
00:16:07,509 --> 00:16:09,386
And we want you to find out
272
00:16:09,469 --> 00:16:11,471
what happened here.
273
00:16:11,554 --> 00:16:15,100
How did this
typical American boy
274
00:16:15,183 --> 00:16:19,813
take a dumbbell and
smash his mom in the head
275
00:16:21,439 --> 00:16:25,360
and literally try
to cut her face off?
276
00:16:29,197 --> 00:16:31,408
It's horrifying. It's
scary. It's fascinating.
277
00:16:31,491 --> 00:16:33,076
It's mysterious.
278
00:16:33,159 --> 00:16:35,328
It's... insane.
279
00:16:37,247 --> 00:16:41,292
So I was going to dig
as deeply as I could.
280
00:16:43,002 --> 00:16:45,088
{\an8}If you asked me anything
about this yesterday morning,
281
00:16:45,171 --> 00:16:47,132
{\an8}I would have said,
great kid, wrestler,
282
00:16:47,215 --> 00:16:50,135
{\an8}baseball player, good student.
283
00:16:50,218 --> 00:16:52,346
He wasn't some horrible kid
284
00:16:52,429 --> 00:16:54,640
who had tons of trouble,
285
00:16:54,723 --> 00:16:56,350
that the schools kept
coming to the parents
286
00:16:56,433 --> 00:16:58,352
and saying, "You have to do
something with this child,"
287
00:16:58,435 --> 00:17:00,270
or the parents
kept punishing him.
288
00:17:00,353 --> 00:17:03,607
That wasn't what
this kid was about.
289
00:17:03,690 --> 00:17:06,526
And that's why it
was so fascinating,
290
00:17:06,609 --> 00:17:09,195
because there was
no easy answer here.
291
00:17:10,655 --> 00:17:11,823
And we want answers.
292
00:17:14,159 --> 00:17:15,911
{\an8}14-year-old Tommy
was an eighth grader
293
00:17:15,994 --> 00:17:19,414
{\an8}at Reverend George A. Brown
Memorial School in Sparta.
294
00:17:19,497 --> 00:17:22,334
{\an8}There's deep concern
for the Sullivan family,
295
00:17:22,417 --> 00:17:24,336
but there's also concern for
the children in the school
296
00:17:24,419 --> 00:17:26,380
and how they will
deal with the tragedy.
297
00:17:26,463 --> 00:17:29,508
The media was
everywhere in the town,
298
00:17:29,591 --> 00:17:32,427
and we wanted to protect
our children, number one.
299
00:17:32,510 --> 00:17:37,265
We had psychologists,
psychiatrists, um...
300
00:17:37,348 --> 00:17:38,516
counselors.
301
00:17:40,643 --> 00:17:43,313
{\an8}The children were doing
a lot of processing,
302
00:17:43,396 --> 00:17:47,401
{\an8}and they did not need to
be assaulted by the media.
303
00:17:47,484 --> 00:17:51,321
So we said to them, "There
will be people around.
304
00:17:51,404 --> 00:17:57,077
Get on your bus and do
not speak to the media."
305
00:17:57,160 --> 00:17:59,204
The students at Thomas
Sullivan's parochial school
306
00:17:59,287 --> 00:18:01,164
in Morris County, New Jersey,
got some counseling today.
307
00:18:01,247 --> 00:18:03,291
And then, when I was
looking at the news...
308
00:18:03,374 --> 00:18:05,127
No cult group here
at the school.
309
00:18:05,210 --> 00:18:07,212
...and I saw this
eighth grader...
310
00:18:07,295 --> 00:18:08,964
{\an8}He changed.
311
00:18:09,047 --> 00:18:10,549
{\an8}He was more quiet and he
kept things to himself.
312
00:18:10,632 --> 00:18:12,884
{\an8}...I was like, "No!"
313
00:18:12,967 --> 00:18:16,096
Did you know anything about
his Satanic obsessions?
314
00:18:16,179 --> 00:18:17,723
Um...
315
00:18:17,806 --> 00:18:19,307
It was quiet. He kept
it basically to himself.
316
00:18:19,390 --> 00:18:22,060
The past week, maybe
the last couple of days,
317
00:18:22,143 --> 00:18:24,383
he said something about it,
but no one would believe him.
318
00:18:28,566 --> 00:18:31,194
Some people suspected that,
319
00:18:31,277 --> 00:18:34,906
because he was
toying with Satanism,
320
00:18:34,989 --> 00:18:39,411
this is what led him to do this.
321
00:18:39,494 --> 00:18:41,413
I understand there may have been
322
00:18:41,496 --> 00:18:43,290
some Satanic indications
in that letter, as well.
323
00:18:43,373 --> 00:18:45,250
That's correct.
324
00:18:45,333 --> 00:18:48,419
Murder stories are fascinating
in and of themselves, right?
325
00:18:50,129 --> 00:18:54,509
And now it's this young
boy murdering his mother,
326
00:18:54,592 --> 00:18:57,554
supposedly in the name of Satan.
327
00:18:57,637 --> 00:19:00,265
Well, now you've got
yourself a home run.
328
00:19:00,348 --> 00:19:03,727
There are unanswered questions
about Satanism in America.
329
00:19:03,810 --> 00:19:06,313
Unsolved incidents of
torture and murder.
330
00:19:06,396 --> 00:19:08,190
In every state in the nation,
331
00:19:08,273 --> 00:19:09,983
authorities are
investigating some form
332
00:19:10,066 --> 00:19:12,819
of what they call
Satanic activity.
333
00:19:12,902 --> 00:19:16,782
The Tommy Sullivan story played
perfectly into a cultural phobia
334
00:19:16,865 --> 00:19:20,202
that was running rampant in
suburban America at the time.
335
00:19:20,285 --> 00:19:23,330
Fears that young adults were
being seduced by darker,
336
00:19:23,413 --> 00:19:25,123
more violent things.
337
00:19:25,206 --> 00:19:27,125
We know it as Satanic panic.
338
00:19:28,751 --> 00:19:30,837
Fantastical games like
Dungeons & Dragons
339
00:19:30,920 --> 00:19:33,965
with their demonic covers
and blood magic conjuring.
340
00:19:34,048 --> 00:19:37,344
Dr. Thomas Radecki says
there are 28 deaths related
341
00:19:37,427 --> 00:19:40,263
to Dungeons & Dragons
in the last five years.
342
00:19:42,307 --> 00:19:45,602
Hyper-violent movies
dripping with gore and death.
343
00:19:45,685 --> 00:19:48,563
And angry, thrashing
heavy metal music.
344
00:19:48,646 --> 00:19:50,440
Heavy metal.
345
00:19:50,523 --> 00:19:52,526
Some would say it's the
selling of Satanism.
346
00:19:52,609 --> 00:19:54,277
Parents feared
347
00:19:54,360 --> 00:19:56,279
that their innocent
children were running away
348
00:19:56,362 --> 00:19:58,615
from their idyllic
lives towards a darkness
349
00:19:58,698 --> 00:20:01,159
that they couldn't understand.
350
00:20:01,242 --> 00:20:02,744
You can see the
pentagram on the walls,
351
00:20:02,827 --> 00:20:04,996
the inverted cross, the 666.
352
00:20:05,079 --> 00:20:06,915
Representing Satan
with the horns.
353
00:20:06,998 --> 00:20:08,917
We don't want people to think
that we're being overreactive,
354
00:20:09,000 --> 00:20:11,670
but truly, is
Satanic involvement,
355
00:20:11,753 --> 00:20:13,296
is Satanic criminal behavior,
356
00:20:13,379 --> 00:20:16,049
is it happening,
and to what degree?
357
00:20:16,132 --> 00:20:18,134
Tommy Sullivan Jr,
358
00:20:18,217 --> 00:20:20,929
he was the perfect
example of it all.
359
00:20:21,012 --> 00:20:23,056
In a statement to police,
360
00:20:23,139 --> 00:20:26,184
Tommy's younger
brother, Brian, stated,
361
00:20:26,267 --> 00:20:29,479
"Tom had been acting strange
for the last two to three weeks,
362
00:20:29,562 --> 00:20:31,940
"had been interested
in witchcraft,
363
00:20:32,023 --> 00:20:34,818
"and had several books
about it in his room,
364
00:20:34,901 --> 00:20:37,028
"listened to heavy metal music,
365
00:20:37,111 --> 00:20:39,781
believed there was
messages from the devil."
366
00:20:43,326 --> 00:20:46,329
Officer Hart believes
heavy metal encouraged
367
00:20:46,412 --> 00:20:49,249
Tommy Sullivan to butcher
himself and his mother.
368
00:20:49,332 --> 00:20:53,211
Within literally weeks of his
death and his mother's death,
369
00:20:53,294 --> 00:20:55,297
Tommy had been
listening to music
370
00:20:55,380 --> 00:20:56,798
by some heavy metal artists.
371
00:20:56,881 --> 00:20:58,425
Sullivan's father says
372
00:20:58,508 --> 00:21:00,802
heavy metal music was to blame.
373
00:21:00,885 --> 00:21:02,804
There was one by Ozzy Osbourne.
374
00:21:02,887 --> 00:21:05,098
It was "Suicide" or
something to do with suicide.
375
00:21:05,181 --> 00:21:08,560
โช Suicide is the only way out โช
376
00:21:08,643 --> 00:21:10,478
Another one he was actually
singing to one time
377
00:21:10,561 --> 00:21:12,772
about killing his mother.
378
00:21:14,565 --> 00:21:17,986
It's no big secret that
our interests label us.
379
00:21:18,069 --> 00:21:20,155
I mean, look at me.
380
00:21:20,238 --> 00:21:22,866
When I was a kid, I loved
horror movies and the macabre.
381
00:21:22,949 --> 00:21:25,410
I was into Iron
Maiden and weird shit
382
00:21:25,493 --> 00:21:27,829
that you could buy
from Spencer Gifts.
383
00:21:27,912 --> 00:21:30,373
My bar mitzvah had a
bloody cake and a magician
384
00:21:30,456 --> 00:21:31,750
that sawed me in half.
385
00:21:31,833 --> 00:21:34,252
It was over-the-top
and innocent fun,
386
00:21:34,335 --> 00:21:38,256
{\an8}a rebellious escape from the
humdrum of school and life.
387
00:21:38,339 --> 00:21:41,843
{\an8}But back then, it wasn't
so cute to everyone else.
388
00:21:41,926 --> 00:21:45,055
Once Satanic panic
washed over my town,
389
00:21:45,138 --> 00:21:47,098
my parents got calls
from the school saying
390
00:21:47,181 --> 00:21:50,143
that no one would let their
kids sleep over in my house.
391
00:21:50,226 --> 00:21:52,646
{\an8}Perhaps the most dangerous
kind of devil worship.
392
00:21:52,729 --> 00:21:54,731
They were afraid I was
going to infect them
393
00:21:54,814 --> 00:21:57,484
with darker interests.
394
00:21:57,567 --> 00:22:02,280
I turned out fine, but for kids
like Tommy, it didn't end well.
395
00:22:02,363 --> 00:22:05,283
{\an8}There may have been something
about all that dark imagery
396
00:22:05,366 --> 00:22:08,286
{\an8}that awakened something
that festered inside him,
397
00:22:08,369 --> 00:22:11,204
{\an8}and it became a real nightmare
that needed to come out.
398
00:22:15,752 --> 00:22:18,213
{\an8}The Sullivan case not just
got national attention,
399
00:22:18,296 --> 00:22:21,007
{\an8}it got international attention.
400
00:22:21,090 --> 00:22:22,300
We had them all here.
401
00:22:22,383 --> 00:22:23,885
I mean, this was...
402
00:22:23,968 --> 00:22:26,429
this went on for a
good couple of weeks.
403
00:22:26,512 --> 00:22:29,182
And Geraldo at the time
came to White Rock.
404
00:22:29,265 --> 00:22:32,227
{\an8}Whether a Satan exists
is a matter of belief,
405
00:22:32,310 --> 00:22:34,521
{\an8}but we are certain
that Satanism exists.
406
00:22:34,604 --> 00:22:37,774
I remember Detective
Hart doing interviews.
407
00:22:37,857 --> 00:22:41,152
Detective Paul Hart thought
he had seen everything.
408
00:22:41,235 --> 00:22:43,071
He wanted to go to the house.
409
00:22:43,154 --> 00:22:45,490
I was like, "Well,
I don't know."
410
00:22:45,573 --> 00:22:49,619
He just bounded up onto the
porch, knocked on the door,
411
00:22:49,702 --> 00:22:53,123
and said, "Hi, I'm
Geraldo. Can we come in?"
412
00:22:53,206 --> 00:22:54,833
And the doors opened up,
413
00:22:54,916 --> 00:22:58,294
and we went down and
filmed in the basement.
414
00:22:58,377 --> 00:23:00,130
As we came down here,
415
00:23:00,213 --> 00:23:02,090
We found Mrs. Sullivan
laying on the floor
416
00:23:02,173 --> 00:23:03,550
just about in this area here.
417
00:23:03,633 --> 00:23:05,301
I mean, he was doing the show,
418
00:23:05,384 --> 00:23:09,097
and it was to
identify the problem.
419
00:23:09,180 --> 00:23:11,307
It was actually one of, I think,
420
00:23:11,390 --> 00:23:14,853
the first case that he
profiled in any depth.
421
00:23:14,936 --> 00:23:17,272
Do you think... you're
not a theologian,
422
00:23:17,355 --> 00:23:19,190
a theologian, you're a cop.
423
00:23:19,273 --> 00:23:21,192
Do you think that
Tommy was possessed?
424
00:23:21,275 --> 00:23:24,696
{\an8}I think that possession
is a state of mind.
425
00:23:24,779 --> 00:23:26,531
As far as the media,
426
00:23:26,614 --> 00:23:30,535
I understand their position
is to... to report the news.
427
00:23:30,618 --> 00:23:32,370
And I think it was more
for the sensationalism.
428
00:23:32,453 --> 00:23:34,330
I mean, the case itself
was sensational enough.
429
00:23:34,413 --> 00:23:36,249
I remember some of
the media reports.
430
00:23:36,332 --> 00:23:38,251
Everybody's trying to figure
out, like, what happened?
431
00:23:38,334 --> 00:23:39,961
How did this go so bad?
432
00:23:40,044 --> 00:23:42,464
The town was pretty freaked out.
433
00:23:42,547 --> 00:23:44,549
Obviously, it's a small town.
434
00:23:46,259 --> 00:23:48,720
You want to know, A,
what happened, and B,
435
00:23:48,803 --> 00:23:50,471
is it going to happen to me?
436
00:23:52,557 --> 00:23:54,642
There might've been a little
intentional mythologizing,
437
00:23:54,725 --> 00:23:56,311
a little bit, to be honest,
438
00:23:56,394 --> 00:23:59,147
especially when the
Satanic stuff broke.
439
00:23:59,230 --> 00:24:01,775
Then it's like, all right,
if we're talking about that,
440
00:24:01,858 --> 00:24:04,110
we can say basically whatever
the hell we want, you know?
441
00:24:04,193 --> 00:24:06,361
And so people were adding
their own opinions to it.
442
00:24:08,573 --> 00:24:13,328
One of the rumors was that he
attended a Satanic black mass,
443
00:24:13,411 --> 00:24:15,080
and then everybody panicked.
444
00:24:15,163 --> 00:24:18,249
First of all, does this Satanic
cult in the woods exist?
445
00:24:18,332 --> 00:24:20,043
Is that real?
446
00:24:20,126 --> 00:24:23,338
If it does, how does that happen
447
00:24:23,421 --> 00:24:24,923
under our noses, right?
448
00:24:25,006 --> 00:24:27,717
How does... How...
Who's involved in it?
449
00:24:27,800 --> 00:24:30,011
People thought he was
drinking people's blood.
450
00:24:30,094 --> 00:24:33,556
He would go sneak out
of the house at night.
451
00:24:33,639 --> 00:24:36,475
This little boy apparently goes
into the woods and sets fires.
452
00:24:39,187 --> 00:24:41,189
Someone said that
he took a hatchet,
453
00:24:41,272 --> 00:24:43,441
put it under his
chin, jammed it up,
454
00:24:43,524 --> 00:24:45,610
and then ripped it
out to the side.
455
00:24:45,693 --> 00:24:47,278
That's how everybody
said he did it.
456
00:24:47,361 --> 00:24:48,613
We didn't know about
the Boy Scout knife.
457
00:24:48,696 --> 00:24:49,906
That became fact.
458
00:24:49,989 --> 00:24:51,407
The rumors were pretty strong.
459
00:24:51,490 --> 00:24:53,284
It's kind of like in school
where you'd play the game,
460
00:24:53,367 --> 00:24:54,994
whisper something
in one person's ear.
461
00:24:55,077 --> 00:24:56,788
By the time it gets all
the way around the room,
462
00:24:56,871 --> 00:24:59,833
it's completely different.
It was snowballing,
463
00:24:59,916 --> 00:25:01,876
but we couldn't comment
on it at the time.
464
00:25:01,959 --> 00:25:04,252
It was still considered
an active investigation.
465
00:25:10,676 --> 00:25:13,513
1988, I was pastor
of Grace Church
466
00:25:13,596 --> 00:25:16,349
in Jefferson, New Jersey.
467
00:25:16,432 --> 00:25:18,393
The Sullivan family went
468
00:25:18,476 --> 00:25:20,645
to St. Thomas Roman
Catholic Church,
469
00:25:20,728 --> 00:25:22,355
which was across from my church.
470
00:25:25,191 --> 00:25:26,943
It was the beginning of winter.
471
00:25:27,026 --> 00:25:30,155
It was January, right
after the holidays.
472
00:25:30,238 --> 00:25:34,993
And you could feel not just
the coldness of the snow,
473
00:25:35,076 --> 00:25:39,789
so to speak, but that this
town will be changed forever.
474
00:25:39,872 --> 00:25:41,999
Betty Sullivan had been killed,
475
00:25:43,584 --> 00:25:45,836
and all of a sudden,
we lost our innocence.
476
00:25:47,463 --> 00:25:48,882
We prayed for the family.
477
00:25:48,965 --> 00:25:50,508
We prayed for Tom.
478
00:25:50,591 --> 00:25:53,011
We prayed for Betty Ann.
479
00:25:53,094 --> 00:25:55,221
We prayed for the
family that was left.
480
00:25:58,516 --> 00:26:00,309
We prayed for ourselves.
481
00:26:03,646 --> 00:26:06,065
I remember we went to church
482
00:26:06,148 --> 00:26:09,319
and it was just all everybody
wanted to talk about.
483
00:26:09,402 --> 00:26:13,156
Such a small town with
such a tragic event.
484
00:26:13,239 --> 00:26:17,285
I realized I was...
485
00:26:19,954 --> 00:26:22,040
the last person
to see him alive.
486
00:26:22,123 --> 00:26:23,833
It was just a
little overwhelming
487
00:26:23,916 --> 00:26:25,919
because I knew it
was much bigger,
488
00:26:26,002 --> 00:26:28,755
much bigger than me at that
moment, that's for sure.
489
00:26:28,838 --> 00:26:32,217
And the family was going
through trauma and devastation.
490
00:26:32,300 --> 00:26:34,969
And for some reason,
491
00:26:35,052 --> 00:26:38,139
I was in there with
them at that time.
492
00:26:38,222 --> 00:26:42,977
And hearing how brutal
Mrs. Sullivan passed
493
00:26:43,060 --> 00:26:46,105
made me think something
evil was involved.
494
00:26:49,066 --> 00:26:50,276
At that point,
495
00:26:50,359 --> 00:26:54,572
the goal was to work on just
continuing the ministry,
496
00:26:54,655 --> 00:26:57,825
bringing healing and
bringing understanding.
497
00:26:57,908 --> 00:27:00,411
{\an8}It's Thursday night,
people are tired,
498
00:27:00,494 --> 00:27:03,206
{\an8}but questions about what
happened to Tommy Sullivan,
499
00:27:03,289 --> 00:27:06,626
{\an8}fears that it could happen
to somebody else's child,
500
00:27:06,709 --> 00:27:09,462
brought parents out of
their houses this evening.
501
00:27:09,545 --> 00:27:12,048
This freaked out the community.
502
00:27:12,131 --> 00:27:14,342
We had an assembly
at our high school,
503
00:27:14,425 --> 00:27:15,927
and it was standing room only.
504
00:27:16,010 --> 00:27:17,971
We had to have a second assembly
505
00:27:18,054 --> 00:27:20,056
because people couldn't get in.
506
00:27:20,139 --> 00:27:22,392
{\an8}500 people packed
this auditorium
507
00:27:22,475 --> 00:27:24,227
{\an8}to learn about Satanism.
508
00:27:24,310 --> 00:27:27,772
{\an8}I'm really scared about
the future for the kids.
509
00:27:27,855 --> 00:27:29,399
It makes you wonder, you know,
510
00:27:29,482 --> 00:27:31,317
if it can't happen
to your child.
511
00:27:31,400 --> 00:27:33,861
The town's reaction to it,
512
00:27:33,944 --> 00:27:35,905
they were treating him like he
was infected with something.
513
00:27:35,988 --> 00:27:37,282
You know, did he
infect my children?
514
00:27:37,365 --> 00:27:39,117
What are they going to do?
515
00:27:39,200 --> 00:27:41,828
We parents worry, you
know, it's in our DNA.
516
00:27:41,911 --> 00:27:44,330
I mean, what's more
important than your child?
517
00:27:44,413 --> 00:27:47,250
Is this something that my kid
is going to get into trouble?
518
00:27:47,333 --> 00:27:49,543
Is this something that
I have to worry about?
519
00:27:51,170 --> 00:27:53,381
Something had to
have caused this.
520
00:27:53,464 --> 00:27:57,969
Because to say, "Oh, we
don't know," that's too hard.
521
00:27:58,052 --> 00:28:00,555
So we've got to come
up with a reason.
522
00:28:00,638 --> 00:28:01,972
And the reason here was Satan.
523
00:28:03,641 --> 00:28:07,520
But Satanism, that's
outside of the home,
524
00:28:07,603 --> 00:28:10,231
and that's some other thing
that sort of penetrated here.
525
00:28:10,314 --> 00:28:14,235
And if I don't let
it in, I'm safe.
526
00:28:17,530 --> 00:28:19,115
People wanted to understand,
527
00:28:19,198 --> 00:28:21,159
like parents would
come and talk to me,
528
00:28:21,242 --> 00:28:23,745
how do we protect our kids
from different groups?
529
00:28:23,828 --> 00:28:26,998
And being someone who studies
theology and knowing history,
530
00:28:27,081 --> 00:28:30,126
also having a very
good understanding
531
00:28:30,209 --> 00:28:33,546
of what we would refer
to as spiritual warfare,
532
00:28:33,629 --> 00:28:36,298
I understood how high
the stakes would be.
533
00:28:37,675 --> 00:28:40,803
The ramifications were going
to be great in the community
534
00:28:40,886 --> 00:28:42,680
and in the church
and in my life.
535
00:28:44,265 --> 00:28:46,434
There is a Satan, there is evil.
536
00:28:46,517 --> 00:28:48,728
There are negative forces.
537
00:28:48,811 --> 00:28:52,440
We must be aware
that it is real.
538
00:28:52,523 --> 00:28:53,941
It is absolutely real.
539
00:28:55,693 --> 00:28:58,321
Yes, there's evil.
540
00:28:58,404 --> 00:29:01,949
But your religion helps
you to deal with that.
541
00:29:04,243 --> 00:29:07,246
And it was a challenge for every
single person in that school.
542
00:29:07,329 --> 00:29:11,417
We definitely had to face
543
00:29:11,500 --> 00:29:13,461
the reality
544
00:29:13,544 --> 00:29:18,883
that evil can seem
to many to just be,
545
00:29:18,966 --> 00:29:21,636
eh, you know, it's
nothing really big.
546
00:29:21,719 --> 00:29:23,888
We could no longer say that
547
00:29:23,971 --> 00:29:27,392
because we were
confronted with evil.
548
00:29:27,475 --> 00:29:31,437
We were confronted
with the Satanic world.
549
00:29:33,731 --> 00:29:38,152
I've never really been touched
with evil except for this.
550
00:29:41,238 --> 00:29:43,950
It was a very pious,
very religious town,
551
00:29:44,033 --> 00:29:45,660
where a majority
of the households
552
00:29:45,743 --> 00:29:47,495
were regular churchgoers.
553
00:29:47,578 --> 00:29:50,039
Right? Sunday mass,
like clockwork.
554
00:29:51,582 --> 00:29:53,042
So it was like the
devout Catholics in town
555
00:29:53,125 --> 00:29:54,544
had their answer,
556
00:29:54,627 --> 00:29:57,670
that he was possessed, it
was demonic possession.
557
00:30:00,841 --> 00:30:02,677
They're looking for a boogeyman.
558
00:30:02,760 --> 00:30:04,136
The boogeyman's
always the devil.
559
00:30:06,514 --> 00:30:08,391
It was scary.
560
00:30:08,474 --> 00:30:11,269
And then the parents
were terrified
561
00:30:11,352 --> 00:30:13,146
that it could... their
kids could be next
562
00:30:13,229 --> 00:30:14,814
or that they could be next.
563
00:30:14,897 --> 00:30:16,566
So that's where
the real fear was.
564
00:30:16,649 --> 00:30:21,863
And as a trickle down
kind of circumstance,
565
00:30:21,946 --> 00:30:26,242
it's never comfortable for kids
to see their parents scared.
566
00:30:26,325 --> 00:30:30,455
So there was this kind of low
level feeling of discomfort
567
00:30:30,538 --> 00:30:32,039
among the kids
568
00:30:32,122 --> 00:30:34,959
because we're seeing
569
00:30:35,042 --> 00:30:37,336
that our parents don't
have all the answers.
570
00:30:37,419 --> 00:30:39,255
I bought into the story,
571
00:30:39,338 --> 00:30:41,215
like I felt that this
was a Satanic thing
572
00:30:41,298 --> 00:30:44,802
and the devil was there
and helped create,
573
00:30:44,885 --> 00:30:47,305
you know, this mess.
574
00:30:47,388 --> 00:30:49,307
That was me as a 19-year-old
575
00:30:49,390 --> 00:30:54,020
because of all the
drama surrounding it
576
00:30:54,103 --> 00:30:57,190
and everybody was just
consumed, you know.
577
00:30:57,273 --> 00:30:59,817
So, you know, you start
to believe things.
578
00:31:01,485 --> 00:31:04,030
I just remember
being super-affected
579
00:31:04,113 --> 00:31:08,201
and not really knowing,
like, kind of lost.
580
00:31:08,284 --> 00:31:11,120
The only way that people seemed
to be able to make sense of it
581
00:31:11,203 --> 00:31:13,831
was with this Satanism angle.
582
00:31:13,914 --> 00:31:16,501
And I remember the one detail
that they were pressing was,
583
00:31:16,584 --> 00:31:19,104
"Well, when you're possessed by
the devil, you can do anything."
584
00:31:21,338 --> 00:31:24,759
{\an8}In my 13-year-old head,
585
00:31:24,842 --> 00:31:26,427
I didn't know what was possible,
586
00:31:26,510 --> 00:31:28,262
what wasn't possible.
587
00:31:28,345 --> 00:31:29,764
But God and the devil and...
588
00:31:29,847 --> 00:31:32,058
I mean, all of my fears
were about the fact
589
00:31:32,141 --> 00:31:34,060
that it was possible.
590
00:31:34,143 --> 00:31:36,771
And while I'm doubting
that, at the same time,
591
00:31:36,854 --> 00:31:39,315
I'm like, "Okay, well, what
the hell happened next door?
592
00:31:39,398 --> 00:31:41,441
Because maybe it did happen."
593
00:31:50,534 --> 00:31:51,869
You're trying to process that
594
00:31:51,952 --> 00:31:53,746
and you don't really
want to sleep.
595
00:31:56,707 --> 00:31:58,876
It just felt evil.
596
00:32:01,754 --> 00:32:03,963
I started having nightmares...
597
00:32:15,184 --> 00:32:19,146
...that the devil would go
underneath Tommy's house,
598
00:32:19,229 --> 00:32:22,982
come underground, and
come up into my room...
599
00:32:36,080 --> 00:32:39,040
...and then go in my mouth
and take over my body.
600
00:33:03,399 --> 00:33:04,817
The source of all this
601
00:33:04,900 --> 00:33:07,153
is the apparent
practice of Satanism.
602
00:33:07,236 --> 00:33:08,696
It's easy to look
back at this time
603
00:33:08,779 --> 00:33:10,823
and laugh at the hysteria.
604
00:33:10,906 --> 00:33:13,951
Sensationalistic news
feeding parental fears.
605
00:33:14,034 --> 00:33:17,121
We have young people
captivated in something
606
00:33:17,204 --> 00:33:19,373
that can make
killers out of them.
607
00:33:19,456 --> 00:33:22,335
Religious communities turning
to the only explanation
608
00:33:22,418 --> 00:33:24,587
they can think of... Satan.
609
00:33:24,670 --> 00:33:26,172
{\an8}A small New Jersey
community stunned...
610
00:33:26,255 --> 00:33:27,548
{\an8} But the truth is,
611
00:33:27,631 --> 00:33:29,884
something made this
seemingly normal child
612
00:33:29,967 --> 00:33:32,428
{\an8}murder his mother in cold blood.
613
00:33:32,511 --> 00:33:35,598
And there had to be an
answer hidden somewhere
614
00:33:35,681 --> 00:33:37,558
in his final days.
615
00:33:37,641 --> 00:33:40,186
About three weeks
ago, the father says,
616
00:33:40,269 --> 00:33:43,356
"In addition to an increased
interest in heavy metal music,
617
00:33:43,439 --> 00:33:46,942
the young Sullivan had started
a research project into Satanism
618
00:33:47,025 --> 00:33:48,735
at the Catholic
school he attended.
619
00:33:54,408 --> 00:33:57,662
Tom Jr. was a regular student,
620
00:33:57,745 --> 00:34:02,333
never in my office except
the last three weeks
621
00:34:02,416 --> 00:34:06,295
when we had an incident
622
00:34:06,378 --> 00:34:10,216
that was unlike anything
623
00:34:10,299 --> 00:34:11,884
I had ever experienced before.
624
00:34:14,803 --> 00:34:18,641
There was a teacher
who came to me,
625
00:34:18,724 --> 00:34:21,018
and she said,
626
00:34:21,101 --> 00:34:23,145
"The students would like
627
00:34:23,228 --> 00:34:28,107
to have a comparative
religion opportunity."
628
00:34:30,277 --> 00:34:33,698
She said, "Every group has
to tell about the religion
629
00:34:33,781 --> 00:34:36,325
and then how it relates to
630
00:34:36,408 --> 00:34:39,453
or is different from
the Catholic tradition."
631
00:34:39,536 --> 00:34:41,872
I thought, "Well,
that sounds good."
632
00:34:43,957 --> 00:34:46,627
A couple days later,
she came to me
633
00:34:46,710 --> 00:34:49,380
and she said, "There is a group
634
00:34:49,463 --> 00:34:52,800
that would like to do, um,
635
00:34:52,883 --> 00:34:55,427
Satanic... the Satanic Church."
636
00:34:57,971 --> 00:34:59,932
Well, I felt, first of all,
637
00:35:00,015 --> 00:35:02,143
it wasn't a religion
638
00:35:02,226 --> 00:35:07,981
like Buddhism, Hinduism, Islam.
639
00:35:09,817 --> 00:35:13,779
And they're young
and impressionable.
640
00:35:13,862 --> 00:35:16,323
She came back to me and said,
641
00:35:16,406 --> 00:35:18,659
"Well, if you don't know it,
642
00:35:18,742 --> 00:35:20,285
how can you confront it?"
643
00:35:22,538 --> 00:35:26,167
Hmm. I thought about that.
644
00:35:26,250 --> 00:35:29,878
I prayed over it
and I said, "Yes."
645
00:35:32,256 --> 00:35:35,968
And she... she went with it.
646
00:35:36,051 --> 00:35:39,763
And Tom Jr. was in that group.
647
00:35:43,058 --> 00:35:45,644
If I could do that over again,
648
00:35:47,312 --> 00:35:49,481
I don't know that
I would say, "Yes."
649
00:35:56,822 --> 00:36:01,786
Tom took every single Satanic
book out of the public library.
650
00:36:01,869 --> 00:36:04,830
We had nothing in school.
651
00:36:04,913 --> 00:36:06,791
So he studied it
652
00:36:06,874 --> 00:36:10,001
and then he shared the
information with the other kids.
653
00:36:17,134 --> 00:36:18,177
What did you come up with?
654
00:36:18,260 --> 00:36:19,970
Sacrifices.
655
00:36:20,053 --> 00:36:21,972
Sacrifices. Hmm.
656
00:36:24,182 --> 00:36:26,183
I can't believe they
let us pick this.
657
00:36:32,733 --> 00:36:35,945
I don't think the children
658
00:36:36,028 --> 00:36:38,238
had ever faced
659
00:36:40,741 --> 00:36:43,828
something that is so diabolical,
660
00:36:43,911 --> 00:36:49,375
so different from what they
believe and hold as true,
661
00:36:49,458 --> 00:36:53,003
and how powerful
it seemed to them.
662
00:36:53,086 --> 00:36:55,673
That there was a power in this.
663
00:36:55,756 --> 00:36:57,967
And it wasn't a
comfortable power.
664
00:36:58,050 --> 00:36:59,802
The kids themselves said,
665
00:36:59,885 --> 00:37:02,346
"This was the scariest
thing we've ever done.
666
00:37:02,429 --> 00:37:03,722
And it bothered us."
667
00:37:07,225 --> 00:37:10,437
When he returned
from Christmas...
668
00:37:13,690 --> 00:37:15,442
...the children
told their teachers.
669
00:37:15,525 --> 00:37:17,820
They said, "Tom
is talking crazy."
670
00:37:17,903 --> 00:37:21,949
They came to me and they
didn't give me any specifics.
671
00:37:22,032 --> 00:37:25,786
They just said, "We're
worried about Tom.
672
00:37:25,869 --> 00:37:28,789
He's saying crazy things.
673
00:37:28,872 --> 00:37:30,624
It's just not right."
674
00:37:32,876 --> 00:37:35,004
{\an8}When I heard that
he picked Satanism,
675
00:37:35,087 --> 00:37:37,923
{\an8}I was like, "That's weird,
but that's pretty funny,"
676
00:37:38,006 --> 00:37:40,384
{\an8}because it was also
related to, like,
677
00:37:40,467 --> 00:37:42,136
the music he was
listening to, so, like,
678
00:37:42,219 --> 00:37:44,972
he was making... It
was a bigger joke.
679
00:37:45,055 --> 00:37:46,557
To me, that's what
the project was.
680
00:37:46,640 --> 00:37:50,561
It was... it was, "Screw
you. I like this music."
681
00:37:50,644 --> 00:37:53,480
And I remember some of
the people in our class
682
00:37:53,563 --> 00:37:55,274
that he was hanging out with
683
00:37:55,357 --> 00:37:56,734
were much more into
some of that music.
684
00:37:56,817 --> 00:37:58,652
I know he became
closer with Chucky.
685
00:38:00,153 --> 00:38:01,780
Chucky was cool.
686
00:38:01,863 --> 00:38:03,365
He would do all the same stuff,
play "Manhunt" and whatnot,
687
00:38:03,448 --> 00:38:05,075
but Chuck was super
into the music stuff.
688
00:38:05,158 --> 00:38:07,160
And Tommy and he had
hit it off on the music.
689
00:38:09,413 --> 00:38:12,958
At the time, they were huge into
the Black Sabbath, Ozzy stuff.
690
00:38:13,041 --> 00:38:15,084
So they would hang out
and talk about that stuff.
691
00:38:27,556 --> 00:38:31,310
On Wednesday of that week,
692
00:38:31,393 --> 00:38:34,647
there was an
incident in gym class
693
00:38:34,730 --> 00:38:37,983
where Tom and Chucky...
694
00:38:39,735 --> 00:38:42,404
were cutting class
695
00:38:42,487 --> 00:38:46,116
and they talked
the whole period.
696
00:38:46,199 --> 00:38:49,119
The teacher got back
and found them there.
697
00:38:49,202 --> 00:38:51,664
She reported them to me.
698
00:38:51,747 --> 00:38:56,251
So after school, I put the two
boys into two different classes,
699
00:38:56,334 --> 00:38:59,964
and I went into the
class with Chucky.
700
00:39:00,047 --> 00:39:03,842
And I said, "What were
you talking about?"
701
00:39:05,469 --> 00:39:08,346
And he said, "I'm
not telling you."
702
00:39:10,265 --> 00:39:13,185
I said, "You don't have
to tell me what you said.
703
00:39:13,268 --> 00:39:16,730
But just give me, you know...
What took 40 minutes?"
704
00:39:18,398 --> 00:39:21,527
And what I got back was
the most surprising answer
705
00:39:21,610 --> 00:39:23,779
I've ever received in my life.
706
00:39:23,862 --> 00:39:28,033
"He was trying to
convince me to join him"
707
00:39:29,743 --> 00:39:32,120
"in doing Satanic things."
708
00:39:33,663 --> 00:39:36,958
And I said, "Run
that by me again."
709
00:39:39,669 --> 00:39:42,631
Chuck, remember our history
class, doing that religion unit?
710
00:39:42,714 --> 00:39:44,008
Yeah.
711
00:39:44,091 --> 00:39:45,884
I think you might be
a good fit for it.
712
00:39:45,967 --> 00:39:47,886
It has a lot to offer you.
713
00:39:47,969 --> 00:39:49,430
What does it offer you?
714
00:39:49,513 --> 00:39:51,389
Power, freedom.
715
00:39:53,725 --> 00:39:55,269
What is it?
716
00:39:55,352 --> 00:39:57,021
Satanism.
717
00:39:57,104 --> 00:40:01,900
Chucky said that Tom
Jr. was told by Satan
718
00:40:01,983 --> 00:40:07,573
that he needed to have
disciples, to proselytize...
719
00:40:07,656 --> 00:40:09,783
and he used that word...
720
00:40:09,866 --> 00:40:13,829
proselytize people to
join him in his efforts
721
00:40:13,912 --> 00:40:15,914
to help Satan.
722
00:40:17,541 --> 00:40:18,959
I said, "What did you say?"
723
00:40:21,586 --> 00:40:24,006
And he was shaking,
and he said...
724
00:40:24,089 --> 00:40:26,424
I didn't do anything.
I said, "No."
725
00:40:31,096 --> 00:40:33,681
"I said, 'No.'"
726
00:40:35,392 --> 00:40:38,729
I said, "I'm happy for you."
727
00:40:38,812 --> 00:40:40,981
He said, "But he tried so hard.
728
00:40:41,064 --> 00:40:43,567
He had all these reasons.
729
00:40:43,650 --> 00:40:47,154
He said he really, really
wanted me to join."
730
00:40:49,906 --> 00:40:51,658
Chucky's confrontation
with Tommy
731
00:40:51,741 --> 00:40:54,036
may have started
with this letter.
732
00:40:54,119 --> 00:40:55,996
It was uncovered
by Jefferson police
733
00:40:56,079 --> 00:40:58,582
{\an8}during their investigation.
734
00:40:58,665 --> 00:41:00,542
{\an8}It's written backwards
735
00:41:00,625 --> 00:41:03,087
{\an8}and seems to be addressing
Chuck in the name
736
00:41:03,170 --> 00:41:06,965
{\an8}of the demon of teenage
lust and damnation.
737
00:41:07,048 --> 00:41:10,511
{\an8}When you hold it up to a
mirror, it reads like this...
738
00:41:10,594 --> 00:41:15,724
{\an8}"Chuck, the power of all deadly
sins dwells within my soul.
739
00:41:15,807 --> 00:41:19,228
{\an8}Do you want in? This
is your last chance.
740
00:41:19,311 --> 00:41:20,854
{\an8}Write back now."
741
00:41:24,733 --> 00:41:26,819
So I left there thinking,
742
00:41:26,902 --> 00:41:29,905
"Oh, I have to go talk to Tom."
743
00:41:33,450 --> 00:41:38,872
And as I walked down the
hall, I thought to myself,
744
00:41:38,955 --> 00:41:41,333
"You know little or
nothing about this."
745
00:41:44,878 --> 00:41:47,381
I went into the room,
746
00:41:47,464 --> 00:41:49,800
and I just said,
747
00:41:49,883 --> 00:41:55,430
"Tom, I was talking to
the boy you were with,
748
00:41:55,513 --> 00:41:59,434
and he said that you were trying
749
00:41:59,517 --> 00:42:03,522
to get him to join you
750
00:42:03,605 --> 00:42:06,857
in helping Satan."
751
00:42:14,199 --> 00:42:18,829
And he looked back in
the most steeled way
752
00:42:18,912 --> 00:42:22,582
with these beautiful
blue eyes and said...
753
00:42:24,000 --> 00:42:25,209
It's too late.
754
00:42:26,711 --> 00:42:28,921
..."It's too late."
755
00:42:36,513 --> 00:42:38,431
It's too late.
756
00:42:41,601 --> 00:42:43,520
The room got cold for me.
757
00:42:43,603 --> 00:42:45,939
I was freezing cold in there.
758
00:42:46,022 --> 00:42:49,902
And I thought, "It was so iced.
759
00:42:49,985 --> 00:42:51,904
It was so convinced.
760
00:42:51,987 --> 00:42:54,156
It was so adult."
761
00:42:54,239 --> 00:42:57,242
And the way he said
it was just done.
762
00:42:57,325 --> 00:43:00,161
This is not negotiable.
It's not happening.
763
00:43:02,038 --> 00:43:05,457
It was almost as if I was
talking to someone else.
764
00:43:09,713 --> 00:43:14,425
And I felt it was too late.
765
00:43:20,098 --> 00:43:23,393
The question for me was,
766
00:43:23,476 --> 00:43:27,314
"Was I talking to Satan
767
00:43:27,397 --> 00:43:29,398
or Tom?"
56470
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.