Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:00,714 --> 00:00:04,154
A devastating fire nearly
destroys an iconic cathedral in
2
00:00:04,234 --> 00:00:05,794
the heart of Paris.
3
00:00:06,434 --> 00:00:10,794
But then, beneath the damaged
floor, archaeologists make a
4
00:00:10,874 --> 00:00:12,154
startling discovery.
5
00:00:12,434 --> 00:00:14,594
It's exceptional, the
life of an archaeologist.
6
00:00:15,354 --> 00:00:20,514
Human-shaped sarcophagi,
made of lead, centuries old.
7
00:00:22,194 --> 00:00:25,394
I never, ever thought I
would excavate in Notre Dame.
8
00:00:26,354 --> 00:00:30,554
And, among the bodies, a
thousand shattered fragments of a
9
00:00:30,634 --> 00:00:32,954
once immense stone sculpture
10
00:00:33,514 --> 00:00:35,074
dating from the Middle Ages.
11
00:00:35,594 --> 00:00:38,274
It's like finding the
Mona Lisa in several pieces.
12
00:00:38,954 --> 00:00:42,394
A cloud of questions
surrounds these subterranean secrets.
13
00:00:43,754 --> 00:00:45,234
Whose bodies are these?
14
00:00:46,754 --> 00:00:49,114
He is between 30 and 40 years old.
15
00:00:49,554 --> 00:00:53,074
And what was the massive
sculpture that was destroyed, and
16
00:00:53,154 --> 00:00:55,074
then hidden, buried inside
17
00:00:55,154 --> 00:00:58,434
the most famous cathedral on earth.
18
00:00:58,714 --> 00:01:00,754
Wow, it's really impressive.
19
00:01:01,314 --> 00:01:03,954
Can science and
history solve the puzzle
20
00:01:04,994 --> 00:01:09,434
and rediscover a lost age in
the life of the iconic cathedral?
21
00:01:11,354 --> 00:01:13,754
Lost Tombs of Notre Dame.
22
00:01:18,594 --> 00:01:21,834
Paris, April 15, 2019.
23
00:01:22,194 --> 00:01:24,634
a fire breaks out in
Notre-Dame Cathedral.
24
00:01:25,394 --> 00:01:26,754
It engulfs the roof,
25
00:01:27,154 --> 00:01:30,314
bringing the iconic spire
crashing to the ground.
26
00:01:33,394 --> 00:01:35,154
Witnesses are in shock.
27
00:01:35,514 --> 00:01:37,234
For over 800 years,
28
00:01:37,314 --> 00:01:39,554
the cathedral has stood
in the heart of Paris,
29
00:01:40,314 --> 00:01:44,234
a sacred place, a witness
to centuries of history.
30
00:01:46,354 --> 00:01:49,314
Luckily, firefighters
quenched the blaze in time
31
00:01:49,394 --> 00:01:51,714
to save Notre-Dame
from total collapse.
32
00:01:54,234 --> 00:01:57,274
Yet, the extent of the
damage is staggering.
33
00:01:59,314 --> 00:02:02,074
When the spire collapsed, it
crashed through the center of the
34
00:02:02,154 --> 00:02:04,194
roof, landing at the intersection
35
00:02:04,274 --> 00:02:08,674
of the nave and the
transept, the very center of the
36
00:02:08,754 --> 00:02:11,474
architectural cross that defines the
37
00:02:11,594 --> 00:02:12,394
cathedral's layout.
38
00:02:14,794 --> 00:02:19,194
Nobody wished for this fire, for
this tragedy, but today we must
39
00:02:19,274 --> 00:02:20,354
find the good side of it.
40
00:02:20,434 --> 00:02:22,714
We have access to data
that was inaccessible before.
41
00:02:25,234 --> 00:02:29,194
The collapse leaves a huge hole
in the heart of the building.
42
00:02:30,274 --> 00:02:34,274
But it also sets the stage
for surprising discoveries that
43
00:02:34,354 --> 00:02:36,554
might shed new light on the
44
00:02:36,634 --> 00:02:37,834
history of Notre Dame.
45
00:02:44,474 --> 00:02:48,474
After the initial shock of the
fire has passed, and structural
46
00:02:48,554 --> 00:02:50,194
engineers have inspected and
47
00:02:50,274 --> 00:02:51,674
unstabilized what remains.
48
00:02:52,554 --> 00:02:55,634
Work on the monumental task
of restoring the cathedral
49
00:02:55,714 --> 00:02:59,034
begins, beginning with a massive
50
00:02:59,194 --> 00:03:01,794
network of
interlocking scaffolding on the
51
00:03:01,874 --> 00:03:02,914
inside of the building.
52
00:03:05,274 --> 00:03:09,394
But before they build on top
of the transept crossing, they
53
00:03:09,474 --> 00:03:11,034
need to see what's under
54
00:03:11,114 --> 00:03:13,714
the floor to make sure
it can take the weight.
55
00:03:17,514 --> 00:03:21,314
The investigation is led by
archaeologist Christophe Besnier.
56
00:03:23,314 --> 00:03:25,874
It's exceptional in the life of
an archaeologist, in the life
57
00:03:25,954 --> 00:03:27,274
of a team of archaeologists.
58
00:03:27,754 --> 00:03:29,674
There have been very
few archaeological
59
00:03:29,754 --> 00:03:31,634
interventions in Notre-Dame.
60
00:03:32,114 --> 00:03:35,634
We're going to do some major
work here, so we take great
61
00:03:35,714 --> 00:03:37,394
responsibility for our discoveries,
62
00:03:37,474 --> 00:03:39,674
their understanding and preservation.
63
00:03:41,514 --> 00:03:44,394
It's going to be huge and
exciting work for the team.
64
00:03:45,554 --> 00:03:49,874
This excavation is expected
to be brief, but a trove of
65
00:03:49,954 --> 00:03:52,314
surprising discoveries will mean
66
00:03:52,554 --> 00:03:53,154
otherwise.
67
00:03:57,034 --> 00:04:01,194
As they clear away the floor,
first they uncover a network of
68
00:04:01,274 --> 00:04:02,874
brick tunnels dating back to
69
00:04:02,954 --> 00:04:03,954
the 19th century.
70
00:04:10,114 --> 00:04:13,674
In fact, it was the first
underfloor heating system installed
71
00:04:13,754 --> 00:04:15,154
in Notre-Dame in the 19th
72
00:04:15,234 --> 00:04:15,834
century.
73
00:04:15,914 --> 00:04:18,634
It was made of large brick
ducts, sometimes on one level,
74
00:04:18,714 --> 00:04:20,234
sometimes on two, which were
75
00:04:20,314 --> 00:04:24,114
connected to a boiler located
behind the apse of Notre-Dame.
76
00:04:27,834 --> 00:04:31,034
The ductwork had been installed during
an earlier renovation
77
00:04:31,114 --> 00:04:33,474
in the 19th century, and
78
00:04:33,554 --> 00:04:35,154
it doesn't require special handling.
79
00:04:36,114 --> 00:04:38,994
But what archaeologists see next does.
80
00:04:39,874 --> 00:04:47,034
Human remains, a sealed lead
sarcophagus of unknown age.
81
00:04:48,714 --> 00:04:51,274
Finding bodies is not
completely unexpected.
82
00:04:52,274 --> 00:04:54,354
Burials in and around the cathedral
83
00:04:54,434 --> 00:04:59,594
are part of its history, but
a sarcophagus like this one
84
00:04:59,674 --> 00:05:03,394
is very rare and
immediately begs the questions,
85
00:05:04,114 --> 00:05:07,314
Whose remains are these,
and why are they here?
86
00:05:09,394 --> 00:05:13,314
Archaeologically, we can see
that it's surrounded by fill
87
00:05:13,394 --> 00:05:15,634
containing 14th-century ceramics,
88
00:05:15,834 --> 00:05:18,994
so this could mean it was
buried in the 14th century.
89
00:05:19,634 --> 00:05:22,314
But he is buried in a lead coffin.
90
00:05:22,394 --> 00:05:24,594
This was extremely
rare in the 14th century,
91
00:05:24,674 --> 00:05:28,274
but it's much more common from the
late 15th, 16th century onwards.
92
00:05:29,874 --> 00:05:31,714
And there's another surprise.
93
00:05:31,994 --> 00:05:34,394
The coffin looks out of place.
94
00:05:37,034 --> 00:05:38,914
Christophe has a possible explanation.
95
00:05:42,754 --> 00:05:46,234
- The main hypothesis is
that the coffin was moved.
96
00:05:46,714 --> 00:05:49,074
They moved this coffin and buried it.
97
00:05:49,514 --> 00:05:51,914
They put him in a
vault that was not his.
98
00:05:55,074 --> 00:05:57,474
- Not knowing where it
was originally buried
99
00:05:58,114 --> 00:06:00,994
may make it harder to
determine the person's identity.
100
00:06:04,154 --> 00:06:07,594
Multiple burials and renovations over
the centuries make the
101
00:06:07,674 --> 00:06:09,714
archaeologist's job much
102
00:06:09,794 --> 00:06:10,434
more challenging.
103
00:06:14,114 --> 00:06:18,994
But before they can solve
that mystery, they spot another
104
00:06:19,074 --> 00:06:22,714
coffin, amazingly intact and
105
00:06:22,794 --> 00:06:24,874
protected in a
hollow among the debris.
106
00:06:26,314 --> 00:06:28,914
After clearing a path, they
can see that this one has a
107
00:06:28,994 --> 00:06:30,754
plaque and an epitaph.
108
00:06:33,154 --> 00:06:38,274
Here lies the body of Monsieur
Antoine de la Porte, canon of
109
00:06:38,354 --> 00:06:40,434
the Church of Paris, died
110
00:06:40,514 --> 00:06:44,474
December 24th, 1710, in his 83rd year.
111
00:06:46,474 --> 00:06:50,954
According to the inscription, he
is a canon, meaning he was part
112
00:06:51,034 --> 00:06:52,714
of an elite group of priests
113
00:06:52,794 --> 00:06:56,234
that helped manage the religious and
administrative life of the cathedral.
114
00:06:59,794 --> 00:07:02,394
They were often intellectuals.
115
00:07:02,474 --> 00:07:05,034
They came from noble or
military backgrounds.
116
00:07:05,714 --> 00:07:08,954
Such was the case of Canon
de la Porte, the canons.
117
00:07:09,034 --> 00:07:13,074
When all gathered together, they
formed the chapter of the cathedral.
118
00:07:15,594 --> 00:07:18,434
The assembled canons
took the big decisions.
119
00:07:19,834 --> 00:07:22,834
Canons were a fixture in
Catholic churches until the
120
00:07:22,914 --> 00:07:24,394
end of the 18th century.
121
00:07:26,674 --> 00:07:30,154
Antoine de la Porte is actually
a well-known historical figure,
122
00:07:30,954 --> 00:07:33,834
one of the most famous
canons of Notre-Dame de Paris.
123
00:07:35,834 --> 00:07:40,234
During the 17th century, he served
for over 50 years in the cathedral.
124
00:07:42,634 --> 00:07:46,634
At the Louvre Museum, a large
painting even depicts him in action.
125
00:07:49,154 --> 00:07:51,954
So, here is Canon de La
Porte in all his splendor,
126
00:07:52,034 --> 00:07:53,994
celebrating Mass at Notre Dame.
127
00:07:54,234 --> 00:07:59,874
It was his coffin which was found
during the recent archaeological digs.
128
00:08:01,474 --> 00:08:05,594
Antoine de la Porte's coffin
seems newer than the unmarked coffin.
129
00:08:06,634 --> 00:08:08,154
Yet they are similar.
130
00:08:08,754 --> 00:08:10,754
Could there be a link between them?
131
00:08:13,914 --> 00:08:18,634
For now, it seems their best hope
for more clues are sealed inside.
132
00:08:22,914 --> 00:08:26,234
To avoid their destruction
during renovation, it is decided
133
00:08:26,314 --> 00:08:28,914
to temporarily exhume both.
134
00:08:35,034 --> 00:08:39,994
For me, one of the most
emotional moments of my life was
135
00:08:40,074 --> 00:08:41,714
when the coffins were removed
136
00:08:41,794 --> 00:08:45,354
from the site because these
maneuvers were very complex from a
137
00:08:45,434 --> 00:08:46,554
logistical point of view.
138
00:08:47,234 --> 00:08:51,634
We were really afraid of damaging
them, dropping them, or breaking them.
139
00:08:51,714 --> 00:08:55,114
You have to carry something
that weighs 660 pounds, leaving
140
00:08:55,194 --> 00:08:56,874
it flat, so as not to move
141
00:08:56,954 --> 00:08:57,594
what's inside.
142
00:08:57,914 --> 00:08:59,114
It was a bit stressful.
143
00:09:02,994 --> 00:09:07,234
They hope to open the
coffins and study the remains, to
144
00:09:07,314 --> 00:09:09,514
preserve what they can, and try
145
00:09:09,594 --> 00:09:14,554
to discover the identity of
the mystery body, all to gain a
146
00:09:14,634 --> 00:09:16,074
better understanding of the
147
00:09:16,154 --> 00:09:18,274
people and the history of this place.
148
00:09:27,274 --> 00:09:32,154
Here at Rangueil Hospital in
Toulouse, a team of anthropologists,
149
00:09:32,234 --> 00:09:33,714
forensic doctors, and
150
00:09:33,794 --> 00:09:37,114
radiologists will analyze
the contents of the coffins.
151
00:09:42,674 --> 00:09:43,274
Hello.
152
00:09:44,954 --> 00:09:49,074
Canon Antoine de la Porte's
sarcophagus, as well as that of the
153
00:09:49,154 --> 00:09:51,354
John Doe, are first carefully
154
00:09:51,434 --> 00:09:52,034
cleaned.
155
00:09:54,034 --> 00:09:56,594
Professor Eric Crubezy,
an anthropologist at the
156
00:09:56,674 --> 00:10:00,274
University of Toulouse, examines the
157
00:10:00,354 --> 00:10:03,074
two sarcophagi with
archaeologist Christophe Besnier
158
00:10:03,154 --> 00:10:04,354
before opening them.
159
00:10:05,394 --> 00:10:06,714
A few teeth remain.
160
00:10:07,234 --> 00:10:08,714
The canines are in place.
161
00:10:10,234 --> 00:10:14,154
He's looking for any clue or
detail on the surface of the coffins.
162
00:10:16,554 --> 00:10:18,514
The enlargement for the buttocks here.
163
00:10:18,714 --> 00:10:20,794
Have you ever seen this before or not?
164
00:10:21,514 --> 00:10:22,474
I don't recall.
165
00:10:24,834 --> 00:10:28,314
Unlike Antoine de la Porte's
sarcophagus, this unknown
166
00:10:28,394 --> 00:10:31,954
coffin has a unique hourglass shape.
167
00:10:33,714 --> 00:10:37,914
These lead coffins were
usually custom -made, lead being a
168
00:10:37,994 --> 00:10:40,074
particularly soft and malleable metal.
169
00:10:40,674 --> 00:10:44,834
It was the perfect material to make
an airtight, human-shaped capsule.
170
00:10:46,594 --> 00:10:50,034
It also explains why the top
of the sarcophagus sagged.
171
00:10:50,994 --> 00:10:54,714
Lead weakens and deforms more
quickly than more sturdy metals.
172
00:10:57,674 --> 00:11:01,194
Before opening the coffins,
they put on respirator masks.
173
00:11:01,354 --> 00:11:04,874
The excavation protocol
they follow is very strict,
174
00:11:05,234 --> 00:11:08,954
to safeguard them from lead
poisoning as well as to avoid any
175
00:11:09,034 --> 00:11:10,554
contamination of the remains.
176
00:11:16,794 --> 00:11:19,594
Armed with an angle
grinder, they start with Antoine
177
00:11:19,674 --> 00:11:21,274
de la Porte's sarcophagus.
178
00:11:24,554 --> 00:11:27,514
The bottom of the
coffin is very badly eroded.
179
00:11:28,634 --> 00:11:31,794
What will this mean for the
condition of the remains inside?
180
00:11:33,674 --> 00:11:35,874
- Everyone's got it, yes.
- Okay, let's do this.
181
00:11:35,954 --> 00:11:37,474
All right Camille?
- Yeah, I have.
182
00:11:37,554 --> 00:11:39,074
You can give
it to me. It's okay.
183
00:11:39,994 --> 00:11:43,954
It's okay, I've got it. All
right, let go. Let go, boys.
184
00:11:48,834 --> 00:11:51,674
If the coffin had
remained completely sealed,
185
00:11:52,714 --> 00:11:55,794
de la Porte's body would likely
have been better preserved.
186
00:12:03,474 --> 00:12:05,714
Next, the mystery sarcophagus.
187
00:12:07,274 --> 00:12:09,874
It is a bit harder to
open because its lead
188
00:12:09,954 --> 00:12:11,554
walls are much thicker.
189
00:12:15,474 --> 00:12:18,914
It is also less
damaged, with fewer holes.
190
00:12:19,954 --> 00:12:23,834
So archaeologists hope the body
inside will be better preserved
191
00:12:23,914 --> 00:12:25,594
than Antoine de la Porte.
192
00:12:34,314 --> 00:12:37,474
The lid is also much
heavier to lift up.
193
00:12:38,034 --> 00:12:38,634
OK.
194
00:12:39,034 --> 00:12:39,714
OK.
195
00:12:39,794 --> 00:12:40,394
Hold on.
196
00:12:40,834 --> 00:12:41,914
You can let it go now.
197
00:12:42,314 --> 00:12:43,714
You can let it go now.
198
00:12:44,434 --> 00:12:45,034
It's good.
199
00:12:48,634 --> 00:12:49,594
It's sawed off.
200
00:12:49,674 --> 00:12:51,914
- An immediate surprise
for the archeologists.
201
00:12:52,314 --> 00:12:55,274
John Doe's skull is sawed open.
202
00:12:55,354 --> 00:12:56,394
- Oh, beautiful.
203
00:12:57,114 --> 00:12:58,274
There's a leaf.
204
00:12:58,354 --> 00:12:59,074
There's lots of them.
205
00:12:59,154 --> 00:13:00,034
There's lots of leaves.
206
00:13:00,114 --> 00:13:01,434
Oh wow, that's beautiful.
207
00:13:01,834 --> 00:13:03,594
There are spikes of plants.
208
00:13:03,834 --> 00:13:04,674
That's beautiful.
209
00:13:04,834 --> 00:13:05,754
It's great.
210
00:13:08,754 --> 00:13:12,274
This coffin is full of
unexpected discoveries.
211
00:13:13,274 --> 00:13:15,874
The body has been buried with plants.
212
00:13:16,194 --> 00:13:17,274
But what kind?
213
00:13:17,754 --> 00:13:18,554
And why?
214
00:13:19,074 --> 00:13:21,474
And what possible
reason had there been
215
00:13:21,554 --> 00:13:23,154
to saw open the skull?
216
00:13:23,794 --> 00:13:24,954
So many questions.
217
00:13:28,194 --> 00:13:30,074
Over the next three days,
218
00:13:30,154 --> 00:13:32,714
a dozen specialists
take turns attending
219
00:13:32,794 --> 00:13:34,434
to these two sets of remains.
220
00:13:38,794 --> 00:13:42,714
Patiently, they collect hundreds
of samples of plants and textiles
221
00:13:42,794 --> 00:13:45,234
to be analyzed and interpreted.
222
00:13:52,114 --> 00:13:55,674
Next, the anthropologists make
their first observations of the two
223
00:13:55,754 --> 00:13:57,874
bodies, starting with the cannon.
224
00:13:59,354 --> 00:14:02,634
The skeleton clearly shows
the signs of advanced age.
225
00:14:04,314 --> 00:14:06,874
Antoine de la Porte died at age 83.
226
00:14:09,074 --> 00:14:12,634
Normally a spinal disc is smooth and
flat, but here you see lots of little
227
00:14:12,714 --> 00:14:16,554
spikes, little bony spikes
everywhere, so that's arthritis.
228
00:14:22,834 --> 00:14:27,314
After a first round of sampling, the
skeleton is methodically taken apart.
229
00:14:31,714 --> 00:14:35,794
The scientists are amazed by the
cannon's healthy dental condition.
230
00:14:36,674 --> 00:14:40,714
Surprising for such an elderly
person who lived at a time when
231
00:14:40,794 --> 00:14:42,714
toothpaste didn't exist.
232
00:14:42,994 --> 00:14:47,554
Look at this first molar, which is in
place. It's very well preserved.
233
00:14:47,634 --> 00:14:51,074
See it is polished. That's why I
think he was cleaning his teeth.
234
00:14:56,634 --> 00:15:01,474
Antoine de la Porte lived a long
life and took care of his health as
235
00:15:01,554 --> 00:15:05,354
a member of a prestigious elite
which ran the affairs of Notre Dame
236
00:15:06,074 --> 00:15:10,274
He had the right to be buried in the
Cathedral, like many of his peers.
237
00:15:10,994 --> 00:15:14,954
But how many people were
buried in this special way, and why
238
00:15:15,034 --> 00:15:17,874
did they choose this as
a last resting place?
239
00:15:19,234 --> 00:15:22,914
Almost 400 burials were documented in
Notre Dame, not to mention
240
00:15:22,994 --> 00:15:24,034
all those for which there
241
00:15:24,114 --> 00:15:25,434
is no record in the archives.
242
00:15:26,114 --> 00:15:30,434
At Notre Dame, we knew we were
treading on a huge graveyard.
243
00:15:31,634 --> 00:15:34,354
In cathedrals, it's
mainly the clergy buried here,
244
00:15:34,434 --> 00:15:36,034
along with bishops.
245
00:15:37,754 --> 00:15:40,794
In Catholic faith, there's
the idea that the living can
246
00:15:40,874 --> 00:15:42,474
pray for the dead to reduce
247
00:15:42,554 --> 00:15:46,474
time spent in purgatory, the
time spent atoning, after death,
248
00:15:46,554 --> 00:15:48,274
the harm caused during one's
249
00:15:48,354 --> 00:15:48,954
life.
250
00:15:49,394 --> 00:15:53,194
So it was very important to be
close to this place of celebration.
251
00:15:56,754 --> 00:16:00,634
From the Middle Ages to the
end of the 18th century, bishops
252
00:16:00,714 --> 00:16:02,474
and archbishops were buried
253
00:16:02,554 --> 00:16:05,794
under the choir, the most
sacred place in the cathedral.
254
00:16:07,954 --> 00:16:11,354
Depending on their status,
canons could find a last resting
255
00:16:11,434 --> 00:16:15,994
place under the nave, in the
256
00:16:16,074 --> 00:16:19,674
chapels around the choir,
or the transept crossing.
257
00:16:21,274 --> 00:16:24,634
This central location was
especially prized by canons because
258
00:16:24,714 --> 00:16:25,954
it is just in front of the choir.
259
00:16:28,274 --> 00:16:31,154
The unknown body must have
been someone important to
260
00:16:31,234 --> 00:16:32,514
have been buried there.
261
00:16:33,514 --> 00:16:35,034
Is he a canon also?
262
00:16:35,554 --> 00:16:39,194
His remains will be the subject
of a much more detailed analysis.
263
00:16:40,474 --> 00:16:43,794
Anthropologists and forensic
doctors will try to make this
264
00:16:43,874 --> 00:16:46,794
skeleton speak, to find clues
265
00:16:46,874 --> 00:16:51,314
that might help identify
him, or at least get close.
266
00:16:53,754 --> 00:16:57,834
The age indicator is this
surface here, as well as this surface.
267
00:16:57,914 --> 00:17:01,554
And here, look, they look
almost immature, so the subject
268
00:17:01,634 --> 00:17:03,194
at first estimate might be
269
00:17:03,274 --> 00:17:06,074
between 30 and 40 years old,
perhaps closer to the first
270
00:17:06,154 --> 00:17:07,154
value than the second.
271
00:17:09,434 --> 00:17:11,154
This age is surprising.
272
00:17:11,874 --> 00:17:15,754
Most of the cannons buried inside
the cathedral died in an old age.
273
00:17:18,994 --> 00:17:20,914
After removing the
entire skeleton, a new
274
00:17:20,994 --> 00:17:23,274
round of sampling begins.
275
00:17:24,954 --> 00:17:28,314
John Doe's sarcophagus has
more plants and textiles than
276
00:17:28,394 --> 00:17:29,594
Antoine de la Porte's.
277
00:17:33,074 --> 00:17:34,834
It's all sage.
278
00:17:35,634 --> 00:17:37,314
There are tiny twigs.
279
00:17:38,954 --> 00:17:41,154
It's probably a lamiaceae.
280
00:17:46,514 --> 00:17:49,154
At first look, at this
stage of the investigations,
281
00:17:49,314 --> 00:17:51,954
the body appears to have
been wrapped in a shroud,
282
00:17:53,034 --> 00:17:56,434
since this fabric can be found
in several places on the body,
283
00:17:56,674 --> 00:17:57,674
almost everywhere.
284
00:17:59,234 --> 00:18:01,874
Tomorrow, the two
skeletons will be scanned.
285
00:18:03,194 --> 00:18:05,794
Can the forensic
investigation discover
286
00:18:05,874 --> 00:18:09,554
who this mysterious
character is and why
287
00:18:09,634 --> 00:18:11,354
his skull was sawed open?
288
00:18:20,754 --> 00:18:23,994
Meanwhile, in Notre Dame,
at the transept crossing,
289
00:18:24,074 --> 00:18:27,154
archaeologists make another major
290
00:18:27,354 --> 00:18:30,834
discovery in and around
Antoine de la Porte's tomb.
291
00:18:36,194 --> 00:18:40,954
Bit by bit, they uncover a
few sculpted stone fragments,
292
00:18:41,034 --> 00:18:45,114
followed by dozens more, then hundreds
293
00:18:45,194 --> 00:18:48,274
of pieces, many
extremely well-preserved.
294
00:18:52,914 --> 00:18:56,514
Some still bear traces of
their original painted colors,
295
00:18:58,594 --> 00:19:01,274
buried faces unexpectedly looking
296
00:19:01,354 --> 00:19:08,794
up at the sky, hands and
feet emerging from the ground.
297
00:19:12,074 --> 00:19:16,834
Astounded, the archaeologists
uncover over a thousand fragments.
298
00:19:17,834 --> 00:19:23,314
Some weigh only an ounce,
others up to half a ton.
299
00:19:26,154 --> 00:19:28,954
But why were these
magnificent medieval statues
300
00:19:29,034 --> 00:19:30,834
destroyed and buried here?
301
00:19:33,314 --> 00:19:37,194
Were they fragments from some
kind of renovation, buried here
302
00:19:37,274 --> 00:19:38,394
simply for convenience?
303
00:19:39,674 --> 00:19:43,234
Or is this location evidence
that they were prized relics?
304
00:19:45,754 --> 00:19:48,914
On closer inspection, many
of the pieces seem to be
305
00:19:48,994 --> 00:19:50,234
thematically related.
306
00:19:55,274 --> 00:19:58,794
We didn't expect to find so
many sculpted elements, so
307
00:19:58,874 --> 00:20:00,354
here is a real discovery that
308
00:20:00,434 --> 00:20:01,954
was totally unexpected for us.
309
00:20:02,194 --> 00:20:06,194
Now we're guessing that this is the
medieval choir screen of Notre Dame.
310
00:20:06,434 --> 00:20:10,034
The choir screen was a partition
separating the nave and the choir.
311
00:20:10,514 --> 00:20:14,474
In the Middle Ages, cathedrals
were built using this partition wall.
312
00:20:15,394 --> 00:20:17,754
These choir screens
were richly decorated.
313
00:20:17,914 --> 00:20:19,834
These are real works of art.
314
00:20:20,474 --> 00:20:23,074
We were lucky to
discover it like a puzzle.
315
00:20:23,154 --> 00:20:26,234
It's like finding the
Mona Lisa in several pieces.
316
00:20:28,474 --> 00:20:31,994
Most of the medieval choir
screens were totally destroyed by
317
00:20:32,074 --> 00:20:33,434
the end of the 18th century.
318
00:20:34,434 --> 00:20:38,154
There is no illustration, no
image of the medieval choir screen
319
00:20:38,234 --> 00:20:40,394
that once stood in Notre-Dame.
320
00:20:42,954 --> 00:20:47,034
But in the south of France, at
the Cathedral of St. Cecilia
321
00:20:47,114 --> 00:20:49,874
in Albi, a rare example has
322
00:20:49,954 --> 00:20:54,594
been preserved, giving a sense
of how intricate and impressive
323
00:20:54,674 --> 00:20:56,514
Notre-Dame's sculpted screen
324
00:20:56,594 --> 00:20:57,194
might have been.
325
00:21:00,634 --> 00:21:04,794
In the Middle Ages, the choir,
its stone enclosure, and the
326
00:21:04,874 --> 00:21:07,794
choir's screen marked the geography
327
00:21:07,874 --> 00:21:10,194
of a sacred heart
inside the cathedral.
328
00:21:16,794 --> 00:21:24,354
It was an area reserved for
canons and bishops, the exclusive
329
00:21:24,434 --> 00:21:27,274
space of a religious elite under
330
00:21:27,354 --> 00:21:31,354
a soaring vaulted ceiling,
covered in gold and blue lapis
331
00:21:31,434 --> 00:21:34,634
lazuli, extremely opulent for
332
00:21:34,714 --> 00:21:35,314
the time.
333
00:21:37,554 --> 00:21:42,194
Axelle Janiak is an art historian
studying the history of choir screens.
334
00:21:44,354 --> 00:21:48,474
Today, she's meeting Ariane
Dore, the heritage conservator of
335
00:21:48,554 --> 00:21:50,474
Albi Cathedral, for a special
336
00:21:50,554 --> 00:21:51,154
tour.
337
00:21:53,874 --> 00:21:58,154
At Notre-Dame, too, there was once
a staircase in a similar location.
338
00:22:01,674 --> 00:22:03,594
Welcome to the choir screen platform.
339
00:22:03,674 --> 00:22:04,274
Thank you.
340
00:22:05,194 --> 00:22:06,914
It's so impressive.
341
00:22:09,394 --> 00:22:11,754
I'm happy to let you
discover it since it's now off
342
00:22:11,834 --> 00:22:12,674
-limits to the public.
343
00:22:13,674 --> 00:22:16,794
You know, for me who works
on fragments, it's quite
344
00:22:16,874 --> 00:22:18,594
exceptional to be on a choir screen.
345
00:22:19,634 --> 00:22:22,034
It's quite nice, yes, it's
good to have things well
346
00:22:22,114 --> 00:22:23,314
-preserved from time to time.
347
00:22:25,474 --> 00:22:30,114
From here, Axelle can see clearly how
the stone sculpture forms a screen
348
00:22:30,194 --> 00:22:32,794
between the nave and the choir area.
349
00:22:34,354 --> 00:22:37,994
Each choir screen was known to
have its own unique characteristics.
350
00:22:39,034 --> 00:22:42,114
The screen at Notre Dame was
built two centuries earlier.
351
00:22:43,314 --> 00:22:45,114
So what might that have looked like?
352
00:22:45,794 --> 00:22:48,474
Wow, it's really impressive.
353
00:22:48,554 --> 00:22:52,394
In the 19th century, while he was
renovating Notre Dame de Paris,
354
00:22:53,714 --> 00:22:56,274
Architect
Euge?ne-Violette Leduc dreamt o
-f
355
00:22:56,354 --> 00:22:58,234
-reconstructing the choir screen.
356
00:22:59,434 --> 00:23:03,114
Based on his study of other French
Gothic monuments from the same period,
357
00:23:05,074 --> 00:23:07,754
he made a drawing of what
it might have looked like.
358
00:23:08,914 --> 00:23:11,914
He imagined the sculptures
depicting the Passion of Christ,
359
00:23:12,114 --> 00:23:15,954
His Trial, Flogging,
Crucifixion, and Burial.
360
00:23:19,434 --> 00:23:22,114
The fragments discovered at
Notre -Dame could be part
361
00:23:22,194 --> 00:23:23,714
of scenes like these.
362
00:23:25,354 --> 00:23:28,474
This immense puzzle is
an exceptional discovery.
363
00:23:30,794 --> 00:23:34,634
But at the same time, the
archaeological team thinks they may
364
00:23:34,714 --> 00:23:38,034
have found a surprising
link between the fragments and
365
00:23:38,114 --> 00:23:40,394
Canon Antoine de la Porte.
366
00:23:42,154 --> 00:23:45,874
Archaeologist Helene
Civalleri shows Axelle the clues sh e
367
00:23:45,954 --> 00:23:47,114
has gathered so far.
368
00:23:49,914 --> 00:23:53,314
In this plaster tomb, there
were painted fragments that could
369
00:23:53,394 --> 00:23:55,314
also belong to the choir screen.
370
00:23:56,274 --> 00:24:00,594
And inside that masonry tomb,
we found a well-known figure,
371
00:24:00,674 --> 00:24:02,994
Canon Antoine de la Porte.
372
00:24:03,754 --> 00:24:07,714
So, Antoine de la Porte was buried
with fragments of the choir screen.
373
00:24:09,114 --> 00:24:11,674
Since he died in December 1710,
374
00:24:12,474 --> 00:24:16,794
That means the choir screen was
probably destroyed not long before.
375
00:24:19,074 --> 00:24:21,994
But why destroy
something of such beauty?
376
00:24:22,434 --> 00:24:26,234
To answer this question, it
is important to understand the
377
00:24:26,314 --> 00:24:27,914
function of choir screens.
378
00:24:29,074 --> 00:24:33,554
In the Middle Ages, when canons
gathered for the High Mass, the
379
00:24:33,634 --> 00:24:35,714
doors of the choir screen closed.
380
00:24:42,354 --> 00:24:46,394
Inside the choir, isolated from
the public, the priests and the
381
00:24:46,474 --> 00:24:48,514
canons celebrated High Mass,
382
00:24:49,314 --> 00:24:53,074
including the sacred
rite of the Eucharist.
383
00:24:54,314 --> 00:24:58,554
All this is strictly invisible to the
laity in the nave. This part of the
384
00:24:58,634 --> 00:25:03,754
Mass, it really is the most
important mystery in Catholicism.
385
00:25:04,434 --> 00:25:08,114
That is, the fact that Jesus makes
himself present in the bread and wine,
386
00:25:08,194 --> 00:25:11,434
not only spiritually
but also physically.
387
00:25:15,514 --> 00:25:18,754
But during the 16th
century, leaders of the Protestant
388
00:25:18,834 --> 00:25:21,354
Reformation rose up and criticized
389
00:25:21,434 --> 00:25:23,114
Catholic practices and rituals.
390
00:25:28,754 --> 00:25:32,634
First, they consider
Catholics to be idolaters, and if the
391
00:25:32,714 --> 00:25:34,594
Eucharist is the true body and
392
00:25:34,674 --> 00:25:39,154
blood of Christ, Protestants even
described Catholics as cannibals.
393
00:25:39,434 --> 00:25:41,994
And so there really is this
idea that it's theophagy, it's
394
00:25:42,074 --> 00:25:44,914
eating God, and therefore
395
00:25:44,994 --> 00:25:46,954
that it's something
that's not at all, they say,
396
00:25:47,034 --> 00:25:48,314
enshrined in the Gospel.
397
00:25:49,154 --> 00:25:53,634
The Vatican responded by organizing a
great council for Catholic
398
00:25:53,714 --> 00:25:55,994
bishops to plan a counter-reformation.
399
00:25:57,074 --> 00:25:59,674
They decided to make a
number of rituals, like the
400
00:25:59,754 --> 00:26:01,834
Eucharistic liturgy, more visible
401
00:26:01,914 --> 00:26:02,594
to the faithful.
402
00:26:04,594 --> 00:26:07,594
This marks the beginning of
the gradual dismantling of the
403
00:26:07,674 --> 00:26:09,954
monumental stone choir screens.
404
00:26:11,074 --> 00:26:13,834
From now on, we'll have an open choir.
405
00:26:14,114 --> 00:26:17,554
Very often, the choir screen
is completely demolished, but
406
00:26:17,634 --> 00:26:19,074
sometimes, and this is what
407
00:26:19,154 --> 00:26:22,474
happened at Notre Dame, they
built a new choir screen with a
408
00:26:22,554 --> 00:26:24,074
central section with a large
409
00:26:24,154 --> 00:26:26,714
grid that lets you see
what's happening at the altar.
410
00:26:27,034 --> 00:26:29,594
But the faithful must
remain at a distance.
411
00:26:29,674 --> 00:26:30,834
They can't enter the choir.
412
00:26:30,994 --> 00:26:33,634
You can see, but you can't approach.
413
00:26:34,754 --> 00:26:38,354
Historical records suggest that at
the beginning of the 18th century,
414
00:26:38,434 --> 00:26:40,714
this architectural compromise
415
00:26:40,794 --> 00:26:44,194
was partly paid for by
Antoine de la Porte.
416
00:26:45,634 --> 00:26:49,874
In his religious fervor, he
invested his own money and lent
417
00:26:49,954 --> 00:26:52,594
King Louis XIV the enormous
418
00:26:52,674 --> 00:26:57,394
sum of 10,000 French livres
to fully renovate the choir of
419
00:26:57,474 --> 00:26:58,514
Notre-Dame de Paris.
420
00:27:00,594 --> 00:27:03,674
The destruction of the
medieval choir screen started a few
421
00:27:03,754 --> 00:27:07,554
years before he died, and some
422
00:27:07,714 --> 00:27:10,634
fragments were even used to
build the enclosure where his
423
00:27:10,714 --> 00:27:12,314
sarcophagus was placed.
424
00:27:27,474 --> 00:27:30,834
In Toulouse, the bones of
the mystery man are scanned, x
425
00:27:30,914 --> 00:27:33,434
-rayed, and then analyzed by
426
00:27:33,514 --> 00:27:37,234
radiologist Fabrice Dedouit,
anthropologist Eric Crubezy,
427
00:27:37,314 --> 00:27:40,634
and forensic pathologist
Norbert Telmon.
428
00:27:41,794 --> 00:27:45,034
They present their conclusions
to the archaeologists, starting
429
00:27:45,114 --> 00:27:46,914
with analysis of the skull.
430
00:27:48,794 --> 00:27:53,274
The person who cut it
probably tried several times.
431
00:27:53,594 --> 00:27:58,634
It may raise the question of the kind
of instrument they used for the skull.
432
00:27:59,394 --> 00:28:03,794
You might have a kind of hook
that allows the skullcap to
433
00:28:03,874 --> 00:28:05,394
be separated from the rest
434
00:28:05,474 --> 00:28:09,114
of the skull, which could
perhaps explain why we have this
435
00:28:09,194 --> 00:28:10,834
flaw here, where the person
436
00:28:10,914 --> 00:28:13,114
may have pulled a little too
hard and so part of the bone
437
00:28:13,194 --> 00:28:13,994
has been broken away.
438
00:28:17,474 --> 00:28:20,554
Opening the skull in this way
would have allowed the entire
439
00:28:20,634 --> 00:28:23,514
brain to be removed intact, as
440
00:28:23,594 --> 00:28:26,834
in an autopsy. But why
would such a thing be done?
441
00:28:27,954 --> 00:28:30,874
When you look at the bones,
you see the base of the skull.
442
00:28:30,954 --> 00:28:33,154
That is something you only see
443
00:28:33,234 --> 00:28:36,114
when the brain has been removed. We
have what specialists
444
00:28:36,194 --> 00:28:38,034
call a periosteal reaction.
445
00:28:39,674 --> 00:28:42,954
They see evidence in the bone
that the outer part of John Doe's
446
00:28:43,034 --> 00:28:44,874
brain, called the meninges,
447
00:28:45,354 --> 00:28:49,714
had been inflamed when he was still
alive, leaving a mark on the skull.
448
00:28:52,354 --> 00:28:55,274
So there was what we
call chronic meningitis.
449
00:28:55,554 --> 00:28:59,714
This means it's a subject who had
violent headaches for several months.
450
00:29:00,714 --> 00:29:03,954
This is probably one of the
reasons which contributed to or
451
00:29:04,034 --> 00:29:05,434
even caused his death.
452
00:29:06,354 --> 00:29:09,314
Eric Crubezy thinks these
symptoms were the reason why
453
00:29:09,394 --> 00:29:10,954
the body was autopsied.
454
00:29:12,794 --> 00:29:15,674
Doctors of the time wanted to
understand what caused this
455
00:29:15,754 --> 00:29:17,434
terrible suffering inside his
456
00:29:17,514 --> 00:29:18,114
head.
457
00:29:19,834 --> 00:29:22,194
Meningitis would have weakened
John Doe's immune system, which
458
00:29:22,274 --> 00:29:25,274
could have also caused him to
459
00:29:25,354 --> 00:29:26,834
lose almost all of his teeth.
460
00:29:28,674 --> 00:29:31,674
In fact, only four remain in his jaw.
461
00:29:32,674 --> 00:29:36,234
They also find a specific
pattern of wear inside the hip joint
462
00:29:36,314 --> 00:29:38,114
that could point to John
463
00:29:38,194 --> 00:29:38,954
Doe's identity.
464
00:29:40,874 --> 00:29:42,754
Apparently, he was a horse rider.
465
00:29:44,754 --> 00:29:49,514
When someone rides and does it
for a long time and regularly,
466
00:29:49,594 --> 00:29:53,234
in fact, the femurs that
467
00:29:53,314 --> 00:29:58,434
enter the hip joint, in the
pelvis, they push upward.
468
00:30:00,114 --> 00:30:04,114
We can imagine him as a
cavalier, as a nobleman.
469
00:30:05,194 --> 00:30:08,714
Based on the skeleton, the
scientists believe that John Doe
470
00:30:08,794 --> 00:30:11,274
probably died young, around
471
00:30:11,354 --> 00:30:12,434
the age of 30.
472
00:30:13,674 --> 00:30:16,914
Because he was a horseman, the
experts think it is more likely
473
00:30:16,994 --> 00:30:18,714
that he was a layman and
474
00:30:18,794 --> 00:30:19,754
not part of the clergy.
475
00:30:24,354 --> 00:30:27,474
Back in Paris, the archaeologists
review the data they've
476
00:30:27,554 --> 00:30:29,154
collected to try to identify
477
00:30:29,234 --> 00:30:30,474
this mysterious man.
478
00:30:33,914 --> 00:30:38,194
Camille Colonna has the
results of carbon-14 dating, a
479
00:30:38,274 --> 00:30:39,554
technique that can pinpoint the
480
00:30:39,634 --> 00:30:43,074
amount of time that has passed
since a once-living organism died.
481
00:30:46,434 --> 00:30:49,914
For the unknown, we did C14 tests.
482
00:30:50,114 --> 00:30:53,394
To be safe, we took three samples
and sent them to three different labs.
483
00:30:53,594 --> 00:30:55,314
They all gave us the same answer.
484
00:30:55,394 --> 00:30:56,874
It's definitely 16th century.
485
00:30:58,314 --> 00:31:02,274
In France, the 16th century
began with a period of renewal.
486
00:31:03,914 --> 00:31:06,954
It was the end of the Middle
Ages and the beginning of the
487
00:31:07,034 --> 00:31:09,514
Renaissance, a time of our
488
00:31:09,714 --> 00:31:13,074
and scientific
flourishing, the beginning of modern
489
00:31:13,154 --> 00:31:15,834
surgery which could explain
490
00:31:15,914 --> 00:31:19,594
why John Doe's skull was
sawed open as part of an autopsy.
491
00:31:22,434 --> 00:31:25,674
With the carbon-14
dating, archaeologists can
492
00:31:25,754 --> 00:31:26,994
focus their search through
493
00:31:27,074 --> 00:31:31,034
Notre Dame's record books
particularly. The lists of
494
00:31:31,114 --> 00:31:32,594
tomb inscriptions that were
495
00:31:32,674 --> 00:31:34,874
once visible on the
floor of the cathedral.
496
00:31:40,074 --> 00:31:42,394
There are 400 people
listed in this book.
497
00:31:44,274 --> 00:31:47,154
Can they identify some
suspects that match the forensic
498
00:31:47,234 --> 00:31:48,514
data they gathered so far?
499
00:31:53,674 --> 00:31:54,394
Super.
500
00:31:54,474 --> 00:31:56,114
It's really a beautiful book.
501
00:31:56,434 --> 00:32:00,274
Jean de Saint-Veran,
Pierre Cardonelle, Jean De landes,
502
00:32:00,354 --> 00:32:02,274
oh, Antoine de la Porte!
503
00:32:02,354 --> 00:32:05,154
Black marble tomb at the bottom
of the small gate as you leave
504
00:32:05,234 --> 00:32:06,394
the choir through the main
505
00:32:06,474 --> 00:32:07,394
door into the nave.
506
00:32:08,634 --> 00:32:10,874
Antoine de la Porte is
indeed referenced in the
507
00:32:10,954 --> 00:32:12,314
Book of Inscriptions.
508
00:32:13,954 --> 00:32:16,434
Could there also be a
lead for the mystery man?
509
00:32:18,154 --> 00:32:21,194
Go ahead, turn, and
then take your time.
510
00:32:21,594 --> 00:32:24,314
Edouard de la Madeleine, tomb
at the entrance on the right
511
00:32:24,394 --> 00:32:25,554
in the transept crossing.
512
00:32:25,834 --> 00:32:29,074
Here lies Edouard de la
Madeleine, squire, lord of Saint
513
00:32:29,154 --> 00:32:31,314
-Denis, Saint-Didier, Vauldemont,
514
00:32:31,394 --> 00:32:35,554
Massilly, and Sauges, who died
on April 15 after Vespers in the
515
00:32:35,634 --> 00:32:37,474
year of our Lord, 1587.
516
00:32:37,994 --> 00:32:38,754
Pray god for him.
517
00:32:39,794 --> 00:32:43,554
This Edouard de la Madeleine
matches the suspected profile
518
00:32:43,634 --> 00:32:45,074
on three major points.
519
00:32:45,874 --> 00:32:49,394
He lived in the 16th century,
he's buried at the transept
520
00:32:49,474 --> 00:32:51,954
crossing, and he was a squire,
521
00:32:52,474 --> 00:32:56,114
meaning he was a nobleman in
the service of the king or an
522
00:32:56,194 --> 00:32:57,954
influential lord, spending
523
00:32:58,034 --> 00:32:59,474
a lot of time riding horses.
524
00:33:00,354 --> 00:33:04,794
But Edouard de la Madeleine is
not a well-known nobleman, which
525
00:33:04,874 --> 00:33:07,954
only adds to the mystery of
of his high-status burial.
526
00:33:14,754 --> 00:33:18,114
Christophe Besnier heads to
the National Archives of Paris.
527
00:33:21,154 --> 00:33:24,674
It houses a great part of the
Medieval and Royal Archives,
528
00:33:24,754 --> 00:33:27,194
which were assembled here
after the French Revolution.
529
00:33:30,154 --> 00:33:33,714
Curator Sebastian
Nadiras welcomes Christophe
530
00:33:33,794 --> 00:33:34,994
to this unique place.
531
00:33:38,114 --> 00:33:41,554
On the upper level, there is a
special collection that includes
532
00:33:41,634 --> 00:33:44,754
hundreds of volumes, including
533
00:33:44,834 --> 00:33:48,754
all the records of meetings the canons
of Notre Dame held over the centuries.
534
00:33:52,754 --> 00:33:54,554
This is the chapter register.
535
00:33:55,794 --> 00:33:59,034
This is the register in which
decisions are recorded by the
536
00:33:59,114 --> 00:34:00,794
canons at their three weekly
537
00:34:00,874 --> 00:34:04,034
meetings on Monday,
Wednesday and Friday.
538
00:34:04,314 --> 00:34:06,954
What we can already find
out is whether his death was
539
00:34:07,034 --> 00:34:08,634
announced to the canons.
540
00:34:10,034 --> 00:34:14,474
Each meeting report begins with the
date and the list of canons present.
541
00:34:15,554 --> 00:34:20,354
To go faster, we look in the
margins of the registers for keywords.
542
00:34:23,034 --> 00:34:24,274
I can't read at all.
543
00:34:24,354 --> 00:34:25,514
My Latin is not good enough.
544
00:34:26,314 --> 00:34:29,114
Saint-Fergeau and Epone,
these are our states and forms
545
00:34:29,194 --> 00:34:30,554
belonging to the chapter.
546
00:34:30,834 --> 00:34:31,554
All right.
547
00:34:32,874 --> 00:34:33,834
So this date.
548
00:34:34,074 --> 00:34:36,434
So, at first look, I
don't see anything.
549
00:34:36,514 --> 00:34:37,634
And then we move on to?
550
00:34:38,274 --> 00:34:42,754
Then it's April 17th,
I can't see a thing.
551
00:34:42,874 --> 00:34:46,954
Chatnay, Chapter Estate,
nothing on Edouard de la Madeleine.
552
00:34:47,434 --> 00:34:50,194
So, at first glance,
I don't see anything.
553
00:34:52,434 --> 00:34:55,074
They search up to a
month after Edouard de la
554
00:34:55,154 --> 00:34:56,594
Madeleine's presumed death,
555
00:34:57,674 --> 00:34:59,394
without seeing any mention of him.
556
00:35:00,994 --> 00:35:03,914
Finding information on Edouard
de la Madeleine turns out to
557
00:35:03,994 --> 00:35:05,674
be harder than expected.
558
00:35:08,914 --> 00:35:11,954
He lived in the second
part of the 16th century
559
00:35:12,034 --> 00:35:15,834
when religious wars were raging
between Catholics and Protestants.
560
00:35:20,434 --> 00:35:22,514
Was this squire close to the king?
561
00:35:23,714 --> 00:35:28,034
That might explain his funeral
at Notre Dame and also why his
562
00:35:28,114 --> 00:35:29,674
name is not in the registry.
563
00:35:31,994 --> 00:35:35,474
King Henry III, caught in the
middle of religious wars, was
564
00:35:35,554 --> 00:35:38,594
assassinated by a fanatic monk in
565
00:35:38,674 --> 00:35:43,474
1589, barely two years after the
death of Edouard de la Madeleine.
566
00:35:50,474 --> 00:35:53,994
Given the violence of the
times, if Edouard had been a
567
00:35:54,074 --> 00:35:55,914
particularly loyal servant of the
King,
568
00:35:56,474 --> 00:35:59,714
there's a chance his story
could have been expunged from the
569
00:35:59,794 --> 00:36:01,154
records after his death.
570
00:36:03,874 --> 00:36:07,954
Meanwhile, in the suburbs of
Paris, in a secret location,
571
00:36:08,754 --> 00:36:12,554
fragments of the choir
screen are cleaned inch by inch.
572
00:36:16,234 --> 00:36:19,354
Systematically
digitizing each stone fragment
573
00:36:19,434 --> 00:36:23,834
will eventually allow for a virtual
reconstruction of this immense puzzle.
574
00:36:27,194 --> 00:36:30,634
The findings here are so
numerous and the puzzles so complex
575
00:36:30,714 --> 00:36:33,314
that this process will
576
00:36:33,394 --> 00:36:36,274
likely keep the
archaeologist busy for years.
577
00:36:39,914 --> 00:36:43,714
For art specialists like
chemical engineer Stephanie Duchene,
578
00:36:43,794 --> 00:36:45,994
this discovery is an amazing
579
00:36:46,074 --> 00:36:46,794
treasure trove.
580
00:36:51,434 --> 00:36:54,594
In her quest to decipher the
secrets of this choir screen,
581
00:36:54,674 --> 00:36:57,914
Stephanie teamed up with art
582
00:36:57,994 --> 00:36:59,274
historian Jennifer Feltman.
583
00:37:08,514 --> 00:37:10,714
Jennifer is
particularly interested in the
584
00:37:10,794 --> 00:37:12,234
sculpted busts and heads.
585
00:37:13,594 --> 00:37:16,674
She's eager to work on the
huge challenge of reassembling
586
00:37:16,754 --> 00:37:18,234
the fragments of this unique
587
00:37:18,314 --> 00:37:23,794
choir screen. Known in French as a
jube, she spotted these
588
00:37:23,874 --> 00:37:25,994
two elements and had an idea.
589
00:37:36,074 --> 00:37:39,394
It works very well and the
mortar barely prevents them
590
00:37:39,474 --> 00:37:40,474
from sticking together.
591
00:37:40,554 --> 00:37:41,714
It's perfect. That's perfect.
592
00:37:46,754 --> 00:37:50,434
It's just wonderful to see
the head and body together.
593
00:37:50,914 --> 00:37:55,474
When we have them together already,
the Jube is coming more alive for us.
594
00:37:55,714 --> 00:38:00,074
This is probably an apostle who
would have been a part of the
595
00:38:00,154 --> 00:38:01,834
scenes of the Passion of Christ.
596
00:38:02,594 --> 00:38:06,674
It is the beginning of the
reconstruction of this immense puzzle.
597
00:38:07,594 --> 00:38:09,354
But there is another challenge.
598
00:38:10,154 --> 00:38:11,714
The puzzle is incomplete.
599
00:38:12,674 --> 00:38:15,274
An unknown number of
fragments are missing,
600
00:38:15,834 --> 00:38:17,594
lost during the 19th century,
601
00:38:18,074 --> 00:38:20,954
when architect Violett
Le Duc renovated the cathedral.
602
00:38:21,914 --> 00:38:24,554
A few of these fragments
are now in the Louvre Museum,
603
00:38:25,514 --> 00:38:27,754
but others were sold
to antique dealers
604
00:38:27,834 --> 00:38:29,314
around the turn of the 20th century.
605
00:38:30,514 --> 00:38:32,074
- I would be very curious to see
606
00:38:32,154 --> 00:38:33,914
what the ear looks
like here once this is.
607
00:38:34,434 --> 00:38:37,074
- Now, Jennifer thinks
she may have located
608
00:38:37,154 --> 00:38:38,954
a missing head in the United States.
609
00:38:41,714 --> 00:38:43,754
To confirm, she
asked Stephanie to join
610
00:38:43,834 --> 00:38:45,274
her in North Carolina
611
00:38:45,554 --> 00:38:47,634
on the campus of Duke University.
612
00:38:49,194 --> 00:38:52,474
There, at the National
Museum, a severed head,
613
00:38:52,954 --> 00:38:56,674
purchased in Paris in 1930 by
a wealthy American collector,
614
00:38:57,154 --> 00:38:59,114
is made available for inspection.
615
00:39:03,314 --> 00:39:08,354
This figure really is
striking because its style
616
00:39:08,634 --> 00:39:11,634
is very consonant with
around the year 1230.
617
00:39:12,754 --> 00:39:16,194
And what's fascinating
about it is also the same size
618
00:39:16,274 --> 00:39:17,674
as the other heads
that have been found
619
00:39:17,754 --> 00:39:19,554
in the recent
excavations at Notre Dame.
620
00:39:20,274 --> 00:39:23,314
- The way the eyes and
hairstyle are sculpted
621
00:39:24,714 --> 00:39:27,354
suggests that this head was
carved around the same time
622
00:39:27,434 --> 00:39:30,034
as the statues of the
choir screen of Notre Dame.
623
00:39:34,394 --> 00:39:37,194
To be sure, Jennifer asked Stephanie
624
00:39:37,274 --> 00:39:40,274
to take a tiny sample to
compare its chemical composition
625
00:39:40,594 --> 00:39:42,554
with the fragments from
the French cathedral.
626
00:39:44,914 --> 00:39:46,314
- Is that a white thing?
627
00:39:46,394 --> 00:39:48,954
- Yeah, it's a tiny,
light white thing.
628
00:39:49,034 --> 00:39:49,994
- Wow.
-Yeah.
629
00:39:50,674 --> 00:39:53,394
- Could this be a lost
piece of the medieval screen?
630
00:39:57,554 --> 00:39:59,434
In the archaeologists' laboratories,
631
00:39:59,674 --> 00:40:01,794
the search for John Doe continues.
632
00:40:02,994 --> 00:40:06,274
Plant samples taken from
this human-shaped sarcophagus
633
00:40:06,354 --> 00:40:08,514
have been analyzed
by Frederique Durand.
634
00:40:09,514 --> 00:40:12,274
Her specialty is
archaeobotany, the
635
00:40:12,354 --> 00:40:13,514
study of plant remains,
636
00:40:13,874 --> 00:40:17,634
including pollen,
leaves, flowers, buds,
637
00:40:17,794 --> 00:40:19,234
and micro-plant remains.
638
00:40:20,754 --> 00:40:23,274
She's found a lot of sage and hyssop,
639
00:40:23,874 --> 00:40:26,514
two plants with well
-known medicinal properties.
640
00:40:29,314 --> 00:40:33,394
Both have medicinal
values that are quite similar,
641
00:40:34,474 --> 00:40:37,354
like to fight
chronic infections, asthma,
642
00:40:37,434 --> 00:40:40,714
and chronic bronchitis.
643
00:40:41,994 --> 00:40:44,954
When I started seeing all this,
I wondered whether we weren't
644
00:40:45,034 --> 00:40:47,114
dealing with a tuberculosis patient.
645
00:40:48,994 --> 00:40:52,954
Tuberculosis is known in some
cases to lead to meningitis.
646
00:40:53,914 --> 00:40:56,954
So this diagnosis would be
consistent with the evidence of
647
00:40:57,034 --> 00:40:59,234
inflammation found
in John Doe's skull.
648
00:41:02,914 --> 00:41:05,914
Then, there are the textile
fragments from his coffin.
649
00:41:07,594 --> 00:41:11,474
Fabienne Medard, archaeologist and
specialist in ancient textile,
650
00:41:12,114 --> 00:41:15,394
analyzed and cataloged these
extremely fragile samples.
651
00:41:22,354 --> 00:41:25,794
She shared some samples with
chemical engineer Mohamed Dallal
652
00:41:26,034 --> 00:41:28,234
to examine the
substance of these fibers.
653
00:41:32,794 --> 00:41:36,114
This image shows the
weaving structure.
654
00:41:37,354 --> 00:41:40,074
You can clearly see
the constituent threads.
655
00:41:40,394 --> 00:41:44,914
But if you take a closer look,
and we get into the material,
656
00:41:45,514 --> 00:41:47,674
we'll realize what
we're seeing on the screen.
657
00:41:48,154 --> 00:41:52,714
They're not the fibers, but
rather traces, imprints of the fibers.
658
00:41:53,834 --> 00:41:56,634
As soon as we start to
touch or handle these fibers,
659
00:41:57,074 --> 00:41:59,714
We realized that we only
have sediments, and that it
660
00:41:59,794 --> 00:42:01,394
is only dust, in fact.
661
00:42:02,114 --> 00:42:05,314
But I still managed to
find some intact fibers
662
00:42:05,394 --> 00:42:07,074
that have preserved the
morphological
663
00:42:07,154 --> 00:42:08,754
properties of the textile fibers
664
00:42:09,074 --> 00:42:12,754
that will help us
determine their nature.
665
00:42:13,514 --> 00:42:18,234
So, under the skull and on the
face, it seems to be the same tissue,
666
00:42:18,994 --> 00:42:23,874
which leads us to think that
there was a shroud covering the head,
667
00:42:24,034 --> 00:42:26,234
The entire face.
668
00:42:28,474 --> 00:42:33,074
We are in the presence
of fibers, flax or hemp,
669
00:42:33,154 --> 00:42:35,914
but I think flax given the
geometry of the sections that you
670
00:42:35,994 --> 00:42:37,074
were able to observe.
671
00:42:38,194 --> 00:42:42,634
It is possible to imagine the
preparations that preceded the burial.
672
00:42:43,874 --> 00:42:46,514
The corpse was
wrapped in a linen shroud.
673
00:42:47,914 --> 00:42:50,874
Someone placed a wreath and
a bunch of leaves on him.
674
00:42:53,634 --> 00:42:57,474
Then, a mixture of tin and
lead was applied to the edges of
675
00:42:57,554 --> 00:43:00,754
the sarcophagus, making this
676
00:43:00,834 --> 00:43:02,514
coffin completely airtight.
677
00:43:04,794 --> 00:43:08,114
But these clues still don't
shed light on his identity.
678
00:43:09,274 --> 00:43:12,514
To support the case that this
is indeed the nobleman Edouard
679
00:43:12,594 --> 00:43:15,034
de la Madeleine, they want
680
00:43:15,114 --> 00:43:18,674
to know Edouard's birth year
and confirm that he died young.
681
00:43:22,074 --> 00:43:25,594
Meanwhile, Edouard is not
the only potential candidate.
682
00:43:26,434 --> 00:43:31,034
Anthropologist Eric Crubezy
thinks the unknown mystery man is a
683
00:43:31,114 --> 00:43:33,194
famous French poet who suffered
684
00:43:33,274 --> 00:43:36,394
from tuberculosis, Joachim du Bellay.
685
00:43:39,994 --> 00:43:45,314
He also lived in the 16th
century, was a nobleman, and was an
686
00:43:45,394 --> 00:43:46,634
experienced horse rider.
687
00:43:47,834 --> 00:43:51,474
Joachim died in 1560,
when he was in his 30s,
688
00:43:52,234 --> 00:43:54,754
and some of his poems
describe sufferings
689
00:43:54,834 --> 00:43:56,834
that match the symptoms of meningitis.
690
00:44:01,194 --> 00:44:03,394
He is not in the Book of Epitaphs,
691
00:44:04,154 --> 00:44:07,114
but there are records of
his burial in Notre Dame,
692
00:44:07,754 --> 00:44:09,594
in a chapel behind the choir.
693
00:44:10,794 --> 00:44:12,434
But in the 18th century,
694
00:44:12,514 --> 00:44:14,634
during some renovation
works in this chapel,
695
00:44:15,194 --> 00:44:17,114
his coffin could not be found.
696
00:44:18,954 --> 00:44:22,274
Could he have been moved and
reburied at the transept crossing?
697
00:44:23,434 --> 00:44:25,954
There are no written
records to confirm this.
698
00:44:30,314 --> 00:44:33,954
In-depth historical research
into the candidates and Notre Dame
699
00:44:34,034 --> 00:44:35,994
burials could take years.
700
00:44:41,074 --> 00:44:46,354
In the meantime, what else can science
tell us about the mystery man's bones?
701
00:44:48,034 --> 00:44:51,474
By collecting enamel from the
teeth and a few grams of bone
702
00:44:51,554 --> 00:44:54,194
from a fingertip, it is
703
00:44:54,274 --> 00:44:56,474
possible to find clues
to where he grew up.
704
00:45:00,154 --> 00:45:02,194
It's called isotopic analysis.
705
00:45:03,474 --> 00:45:06,634
Our bodies are made from the
carbon and other chemical elements
706
00:45:06,714 --> 00:45:09,474
we take in when we eat and breathe.
707
00:45:10,754 --> 00:45:15,154
Among the atoms of those elements,
there are variations called isotopes.
708
00:45:17,834 --> 00:45:21,954
The isotopes of strontium,
oxygen, and sulfur can point to the
709
00:45:22,034 --> 00:45:23,514
geographical location where
710
00:45:23,594 --> 00:45:29,394
someone grew up, and nitrogen
and carbon can help determine
711
00:45:29,474 --> 00:45:31,714
if he ate mostly fish or meat
712
00:45:31,794 --> 00:45:32,474
throughout his life.
713
00:45:37,794 --> 00:45:41,474
Anthropologist Rosen Colleter
and geochemistry researcher
714
00:45:41,554 --> 00:45:44,794
Klervia Jaouen process the
samples of enamel and bone
715
00:45:45,114 --> 00:45:46,434
collected from the remains.
716
00:45:50,914 --> 00:45:53,514
In order to extract
the chemical isotopes
717
00:45:53,594 --> 00:45:55,514
that will tell the
story of where he lived,
718
00:45:56,154 --> 00:45:58,954
they first soak the
samples in an acid bath
719
00:45:59,314 --> 00:46:00,714
to break down the material.
720
00:46:06,074 --> 00:46:09,434
The acid causes the bone
samples to become soft,
721
00:46:10,034 --> 00:46:13,594
allowing researchers to
extract a protein, collagen.
722
00:46:19,834 --> 00:46:22,434
Once concentrated,
these collagen molecules
723
00:46:22,514 --> 00:46:24,314
are placed in small tin capsules
724
00:46:24,394 --> 00:46:26,434
to be analyzed by a mass spectrometer.
725
00:46:31,594 --> 00:46:34,874
A few months later, they
receive the first results.
726
00:46:37,074 --> 00:46:40,514
So this is a map showing
the probabilities for oxygen.
727
00:46:40,594 --> 00:46:41,434
Ah, it's much more pronounced.
728
00:46:41,714 --> 00:46:43,474
Once again, Paris, here.
729
00:46:43,714 --> 00:46:47,114
And in terms of probability, we
can see that the higher values
730
00:46:47,194 --> 00:46:49,234
are further east in France.
731
00:46:50,034 --> 00:46:54,434
This discovery seems to point
away from the poet Joachim de Bellay.
732
00:46:55,394 --> 00:46:58,834
He grew up in the west of
France, and this is well
733
00:46:58,914 --> 00:47:01,434
documented, especially in his own
734
00:47:01,514 --> 00:47:02,114
writings.
735
00:47:05,034 --> 00:47:09,394
The analysis says the mystery
man grew up in the east of France.
736
00:47:11,074 --> 00:47:14,514
This result matches with the
little information the archaeologists
737
00:47:14,594 --> 00:47:16,874
gathered so far about Edouard
738
00:47:16,954 --> 00:47:20,754
de la Madeleine, who belonged to
a noble family based in Burgundy.
739
00:47:23,234 --> 00:47:26,754
But the two genealogical
sources they dug up from the archives
740
00:47:26,834 --> 00:47:28,314
are a bit contradictory.
741
00:47:31,354 --> 00:47:34,674
One source, dating from
1711, says that Edouard de la
742
00:47:34,754 --> 00:47:38,434
Madeleine died young and
was a page of King Henry II.
743
00:47:41,274 --> 00:47:44,874
Another genealogical tree, made
later on in the 18th century,
744
00:47:44,954 --> 00:47:46,514
mentions a date of birth.
745
00:47:47,434 --> 00:47:52,234
Based on family memories,
the 3rd of February 1536.
746
00:47:53,794 --> 00:47:57,154
This would mean that he
died at 51 years old.
747
00:47:58,634 --> 00:48:02,834
For the time being, I think he's too
old, because everything we've observed
748
00:48:02,914 --> 00:48:08,914
on the skeleton is a younger
skeleton, he's more like 35, 40.
749
00:48:10,834 --> 00:48:14,794
Both records were written more
than 100 years after Edouard's death.
750
00:48:16,274 --> 00:48:20,194
So, it is certainly possible that
one or more details are inaccurate,
751
00:48:20,274 --> 00:48:22,874
including the dates of
his birth and death.
752
00:48:26,274 --> 00:48:29,234
That could explain why no
mention of him was found in
753
00:48:29,314 --> 00:48:30,434
the canon's registers.
754
00:48:32,154 --> 00:48:35,594
And there are even examples of
errors in the Book of Epitaphs itself.
755
00:48:40,314 --> 00:48:44,314
Even if Edouard de la Madeleine is
not the occupant of this sarcophagus,
756
00:48:45,674 --> 00:48:49,834
his presence as a squire at
the transept crossing, a canon's
757
00:48:49,914 --> 00:48:51,554
territory, remains mysterious.
758
00:48:52,994 --> 00:48:56,514
To understand why he ended up
here will require a more thorough
759
00:48:56,594 --> 00:48:58,154
investigation in the archives.
760
00:49:01,434 --> 00:49:02,914
Despite the contradictions,
761
00:49:03,074 --> 00:49:08,194
they cannot rule out Edouard de la
Madeleine, and he is, in the opinion
762
00:49:08,274 --> 00:49:10,514
of Christophe Besnier
and Camille Colonna,
763
00:49:10,794 --> 00:49:13,754
the most likely
occupant of the mystery tomb.
764
00:49:16,434 --> 00:49:19,434
In the meantime, the
archaeologists have continued their
765
00:49:19,514 --> 00:49:20,434
work at the cathedral.
766
00:49:21,554 --> 00:49:24,234
And since the discovery
of the two sarcophagi,
767
00:49:24,314 --> 00:49:27,034
they have found more than a
hundred other simpler burials
768
00:49:27,114 --> 00:49:28,434
in the sides of the nave,
769
00:49:28,874 --> 00:49:30,474
a less prestigious location.
770
00:49:32,954 --> 00:49:36,834
They are placed in a wooden
coffin or in plaster tombs.
771
00:49:37,354 --> 00:49:40,674
But in the hundred burials found
inside, there are no lead coffins.
772
00:49:40,754 --> 00:49:42,634
This means it is still extremely rare.
773
00:49:42,834 --> 00:49:44,914
Only two out of a
hundred, it's not a lot.
774
00:49:47,354 --> 00:49:49,314
The study of all these skeletons
775
00:49:49,394 --> 00:49:52,154
will help build a large
anthropological and isotopic
776
00:49:52,234 --> 00:49:55,714
database, a tool for
analyzing discoveries
777
00:49:55,794 --> 00:49:56,394
to come.
778
00:49:57,394 --> 00:50:00,994
And once this research is
complete, the human remains will be
779
00:50:01,074 --> 00:50:02,394
reburied at the direction
780
00:50:02,474 --> 00:50:03,954
of the clergy of Notre Dame.
781
00:50:11,114 --> 00:50:14,474
At the cathedral site,
work has progressed rapidly.
782
00:50:15,274 --> 00:50:18,314
a new spire has now been
successfully installed.
783
00:50:21,434 --> 00:50:22,674
But Philippe Jost,
784
00:50:22,754 --> 00:50:25,034
the manager of the
reconstruction of Notre Dame,
785
00:50:25,194 --> 00:50:27,554
is especially
grateful for the incredible
786
00:50:27,634 --> 00:50:30,234
archeological
discoveries made after the fire
787
00:50:30,314 --> 00:50:31,554
caused so much destruction.
788
00:50:33,514 --> 00:50:36,274
- When the fragments
of the choir screen,
789
00:50:36,394 --> 00:50:39,074
the remains emerged at
the transept crossing,
790
00:50:39,154 --> 00:50:40,874
there were extraordinary moments,
791
00:50:41,314 --> 00:50:42,914
unique moments of emotion,
792
00:50:42,994 --> 00:50:45,314
which reminded me of
stories told by the great
793
00:50:45,394 --> 00:50:48,514
archaeologists of the 19th century
794
00:50:48,594 --> 00:50:51,834
who were digging in
Egypt or Mesopotamia.
795
00:50:55,114 --> 00:50:58,314
We really felt this
emotion when the faces appeared,
796
00:50:58,754 --> 00:51:00,794
fragments of
architecture with their color,
797
00:51:01,314 --> 00:51:04,474
and along with the
emotion we saw and understood
798
00:51:04,554 --> 00:51:07,394
the exceptional artistic
quality of these remains.
799
00:51:10,234 --> 00:51:13,674
So from every point of view,
it was one of the highlights of
800
00:51:13,754 --> 00:51:15,354
this five-year adventure
801
00:51:15,434 --> 00:51:17,154
of the restoration of the cathedral.
802
00:51:19,034 --> 00:51:23,434
For researchers and archaeologists,
Notre-Dame-de-Paris has been a
803
00:51:23,514 --> 00:51:25,354
fabulous open-air laboratory.
804
00:51:26,594 --> 00:51:31,074
This great monument of French
history surely holds more secrets
805
00:51:31,154 --> 00:51:32,634
waiting to be discovered.
806
00:51:34,434 --> 00:51:38,474
And with the cathedral now
restored, the world can look forward
807
00:51:38,554 --> 00:51:40,314
to the next chapter in the
808
00:51:40,394 --> 00:51:43,394
incredible story of
Notre-Dame-de-Paris.
67185
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.