Original subtitles

[♪ "Nobody But U" by Hollow Disco, Jonny Royall, The Home Of Happy playing]

♪ I'm glad we waited ♪

♪ I, I think we made it ♪

[Andrew] Holy shit!

♪ I'm just waiting for you to, you to, you to ♪

♪♪

-Is that my man? -What?!

-Is that my man?! -[group screaming and cheering]

[♪ upbeat music playing]

[cheering continues]

♪♪

I'm back.

Toss me to the wolves, baby. I'm ready to get back in there.

-Oh, my God, wait. -[Noah] Michael!

-I missed you so much! -Hi.

♪ My heart is waiting ♪

♪ For you to, you to... ♪

[Rachael] I cannot believe that Michael is back.

Ah!

Like, I-- It's a dream come true at this point.

Like, obviously I had hope, but I had hope every day,

and every day he didn't show up.

So, that was kinda dwindling.

[laughter, overlapping chatter]

Everyone's so dolled up.

[Katya] Are you okay?

I'm good-- I had a baby.

[laughter]

-[Madi] Congrats! -Okay.

So, I had a death in my family, so I had to go home

and just, uh, be with the fam for a little bit.

But the person who died told me,

"I want you to go on a reality show,

and I want you to be famous for never busting a nut."

So, I wanted to come back here and just honor his truth.

[crew laughing]

Why do you guys all look so lovely?

[Madi] We have a sacrifice tonight.

-[♪ dramatic sting] -Is it elimination right now?

[contestants] Yeah!

Hoo-hoo-hoo! Hot damn.

-Don't eliminate me. -[laughter]

[Kaitlyn Bristowe] Don't count on it, Michael.

They're brutal.

Because in just one hour,

some virgins will be sacrificed to...

[echoing] Chastitor,

the volcano God of not getting any.

[person screaming]

Some still desperately need a connection to save them.

Not Noah.

Because just as the sacrifice got real,

he suddenly realized Katya is the love of his life

and a great life raft.

I mean, "friend."

It is actually now or never.

[Kaitlyn] Oh Michael, I forgot.

We've got some beautiful new people

who also haven't ever bumped uglies.

Just ask for an update,

but be sure to clap each... word... you... say.

What happened when I was gone?

Rachael will fill you in on everything.

Yeah, that would be nice. It's good to see you again.

-Yeah-- -Don't say it so formally.

What?

Right before Michael left,

I felt so secure, so safe.

I could actually see myself losing my virginity to him

and, and then he's just gone.

The day you left, like, I was--

literally sat here, cried for like two hours straight.

You cried?

Oh, my God, it's so embarrassing how much I cried.

Over this? Are you sure?

-Yeah. -Alright.

It's kind of wild to hear, but thank you.

Why are you surprised?

You don't think you're amazing?

[♪ gentle music playing]

I think I'm okay.

It's really nice that Rachael waited for me.

It makes me feel wanted, which is always a good feeling.

'Cause, like, when it comes to dating,

I'm not necessarily the most confident person.

I think there's always that little voice in the back of your head

that's just like, "You suck."

We got so close in, like, only, like, a few days

and then, like, all these days keep going by

and I'm like, everybody's like building on relationships.

-Yeah. -And I was like,

I wish you were here so we could build.

Yeah, well, well now I'm back.

♪♪

-We'll get back to where we were. -I can't-- I'm so happy.

My heart is happy.

I'm so excited to pick up where we left off.

That was something I was really nervous about.

But I feel like there was, like, a little bit of hesitancy on his end

that I'm not sure about.

I hope it's just in my head.

I'm happy to be here.

♪ Ooh ♪

♪ If you want me like this ♪

♪ You got me like this ♪

Just holding a singular nail.

And then, like, my vagina's tingling.

[chuckles] Oh.

-[Rachael laughs] -That's all it takes?

-[♪ sparkling flourish] -[ocean waves crashing]

[Kaitlyn] As Michael gets used to Rachael looking at him

the way I look at a donut,

Jake and Sara are still negotiating

each other's romantic dietary restrictions.

Yeah, I wanted to kinda like, chat with you a little bit.

-Mm-hm. -I think one thing I've realized...

Mm-hm.

Kissing in front of everybody

-and things like that. -Okay.

♪♪

It's just, you know, physical touch is something that I like, you know?

-Mm-hm. -Um,

but I value, like, having good communication.

[Kaitlyn] As Jake and Sara try to align before the sacrifice,

time's almost up for others.

So far, Noah's considered more virgins

than a chess club recruitment drive

and made his final Hail Mary pass at Katya.

He can only pray she has safe hands,

and he won't see any more fumbling of his balls.

I'm gonna step forward for Katya.

You guys are done.

-Yeah. -Now it's like, guilt-free.

I was like, yeah, like, I feel this way.

Tonight, I wanna step forward for Katya

because our friendship is built

on such a wholesome foundation.

He basically said that he realized way too late

that what our relationship is

is exactly what he's looking for.

Huh?

I don't know any of the thought process.

I mean, I don't know if Katya was floored,

but I would be on the fuckin' floor like, "Huh?"

[Katya] Noah and I have a very, very, very special bond.

-Yeah. -[Katya] I love him.

-[Madi] Yeah. -[Katya] To his core.

The timing is genuinely insane.

But I believe him.

I know that what he was saying was true.

Okay, so who hasn't he been into?

If I get a V-card, I know who it's going to.

-Brooklyn, will you go on a date with me? -Yeah.

Virgin sacrifice is here,

and now, all of a sudden, Noah's interested in Katya.

What the fuck?

I'm calling it right now, that is not genuine.

Not in the slightest.

[Madi] I see a guy who is very confused,

and it's like, almost, like, he's scrambling a little bit.

♪♪

[Katya] Well, of course, I understand why Rachael and Madi

are suspicious of Noah's intentions

and, in general, the timing could not be worse.

Had this happened a day before,

we would be in a completely different place right now.

I think she needs time to process

and search within herself if it's actually rec-- like, reciprocable.

-[Ty] Right. -Reciprocated? Reciprocated.

-Yeah. -...with the whole Brooklyn thing.

'Cause I told you guys Brooklyn or bust.

I'm completely indifferent to Noah having a connection with Katya

now that things are done with me and her.

Brooklyn coming here was a big answer to all of that for me.

And I really do appreciate Noah stepping back

'cause I do want to explore that with all my energy and heart.

[Brooklyn] I'm just annoyed about this whole situation.

Like, seriously, like, have you ever,

like, even heard Katya say that she likes him?

[Farha] I don't think so.

He definitely, I still think likes you.

I think he's just playing a strategy game

to try to force you to be with his roommate, which sucks.

Bros before hoes, I guess.

[Brooklyn] I am feeling very conflicted

going into tonight's virgin sacrifice.

Andrew is nice and sweet,

but I definitely am not wanting to get hurt

by any type of bro code or anything.

So, I just have my guard up a little bit.

[Andrew] It's time.

-[Madi] Alright. Ready? -[Katya] I don't wanna get up.

You got this, chica. We're good.

[♪ "Back of My Mind" by Extreme Music playing]

♪ Singing to lovers ♪

♪ I used to call mine ♪

[Katya] I genuinely do not know what to do.

I really love Noah,

but Rachael and Madi are also in my ear

and making me question

whether or not his feelings are truly genuine.

[♪ tense music playing]

Welcome, everyone, to your second virgin sacrifice.

[Colton Underwood] Tonight is all about making sure

you are all on the path to finding love.

Tonight, we will call on the men

one at a time,

and you're gonna declare which one woman

you can see a romantic future with.

Now, ladies, when your name is called,

let him know if you feel the same way.

And if it is not mutual,

you both may be in jeopardy of going home.

[♪ dramatic music playing]

Michael, step on up here.

[Kaitlyn chuckles]

♪♪

-The person-- -Alright, Mich--

-Oh. -Oh.

You can get right into it, too, it's fine.

[Michael] Let me do what I need to do. Uh...

You wanna say something?

-No, no, go for it. It's all you. -Okay.

The person who I feel a romantic connection with

-is Rachael. -Ooh! Okay.

[giggles]

Rachael, you are very fun and entertaining,

but you make me feel really good about myself.

Michael, I'm excited to see where we continue to grow,

and I'm glad you're back.

Happy to be back.

[group clapping]

[Rachael] You wanna kiss on the lips?

[group] Aw!

[Colton] That's great to see.

[Michael] Kissing Rachael, sparks are flying, magic is in the air.

It just feels good.

[in gruff voice] It's been a while.

Alright, next up is Jake.

♪♪

Going into the virgin sacrifice tonight,

my strongest connection is Jake,

but he set a boundary that he doesn't want PDA.

So, I am worried where his head is at.

The person I feel a romantic connection with would be...

Sara.

You're patient, kind, and we agree on boundaries,

and you're so patient with me. Thank you.

[Sara] Jake, thank you so much for that.

I'm very grateful for you, and always being there for me.

You're so kind and sweet,

-not spicy... -[Jake chuckles]

...and, um, of course, I would want to continue a connection with you.

Awesome, thank you.

-Aw. -[group clapping]

[laughter]

Oh. He snuck one in there.

Yeah, it's gettin' PG-13 in here now.

Next up, Godwin.

[♪ tense music playing]

So, the woman that I feel a romantic connection with is...

♪♪

...Deya.

[♪ dramatic sting]

[♪ tense music playing]

Deya, I couldn't see myself in this journey to find love

without you.

I look at Godwin and Deya

and they seem like so locked in,

but I still have feelings for him.

Well, Godwin, I'm so glad that you chose me

'cause I choose you back.

-Love it, love it. -[Deya squeals and laughs]

I'm excited to keep building this relationship.

Godwin's my guy,

and that's the one I wanna go all the way with.

[group clapping]

[♪ gentle music playing]

Up next, Ty.

Sweet.

[♪ upbeat music playing]

Um, the person I see a romantic connection with is Jade.

♪♪

Jade, the person you are really fascinates me.

-[chuckles] -It pulls me in

to want to know more about you.

[♪ upbeat music playing]

Ty, I've really enjoyed getting to know you,

and I wanna continue this emotional connection.

-Thanks, Jade. -[group clapping]

Aw! My cheeks hurt.

[Colton] We love it.

Alright, Noah, you're next.

'Kay.

[♪ tense music playing]

♪♪

The girl that I mostly have a romantic connection with

is Katya.

[Katya] Mm.

You are so confident and beautiful and loving,

and our friendship has shown me a real side of you

that I've grown to appreciate,

and those feelings have grown inside of me.

Uh, they've taken me by surprise.

I'm really grateful for the opportunity to say

what's been happening in my heart.

Noah. [chuckles]

[Noah] I feel like I'm leading with my heart,

but I don't even know that Katya is open

to taking our friendship and turning it into something romantic.

[♪ tense music playing]

You know that I care about you so deeply.

♪♪

Thank you for that.

[♪ music intensifies]

I'm filled with absolute dread over what's about to happen.

♪♪

-[birds chirping] -[ocean waves crashing]

[♪ dramatic music playing]

Noah. [chuckles]

You know that I care about you so deeply.

So thank you for that.

But, that being said,

I have to stay true to who I am and what I believe,

and... I refuse to be

less than anyone's first choice,

let alone anyone's last resort.

But that is my truth, and

I will not be stepping forward.

[♪ dramatic music playing]

[Noah] I 'm worried that this may mean the end of my journey.

I feel like I'm putting my heart on the line

as best as I can,

and, uh...

and there's just some heavy consequences that come when you do that.

[♪ tense music playing]

I didn't step up for Noah because I have self-respect.

I was not his first option, I wasn't his second option,

I wasn't his third option.

I don't think I was his fourth option.

The way things ended between Andrew and I,

I couldn't trust Noah.

I'm not trying to force a connection to stay.

That's not who I am.

Alright, so next up is Andrew.

[Andrew clears throat]

The person I feel a romantic connection with is Brooklyn.

[♪ tense, curious music playing]

From our initial conversation to the catamaran

to our walk on the beach

and sharing cookies right here,

I've felt nothing but radiating peace and love from you,

and it's something I need and want in my life.

♪♪

I wanna thank you for saying all that.

That's really sweet.

[crickets chirping]

But I just don't feel the same way. I'm really sorry.

[♪ gentle music playing]

-[softly] I'm sorry. -[softly] It's okay.

♪♪

Andrew, how are you doing?

I've been better.

Feelings need to be mutual for something to progress,

so I get it.

Just sucks.

[♪ gentle music playing]

Alright, and finally, Mike.

[Mike] I felt like there was a connection here for me with Carissa

and I think this is what's been a little challenging to navigate,

is that, for me, can I get there again?

There are a lot of women over here

hoping that you will be their first.

I have tried so deeply to find a romantic connection.

I couldn't get there,

and you guys deserve better than that, so...

[♪ tense music playing]

With that being said, I think it's best for me to remove myself.

♪♪

That's... that's where I'm at.

Um...

[♪ dramatic music playing]

But I do have a request.

I have had conversations with Madi...

[♪ gentle music playing]

...and I know you are looking for something real,

and I want you to have that opportunity.

And if that's alright with you guys,

even if I'm leaving,

I want her to stay and figure that out.

We love that, Mike.

Aw.

Thank you. You're just the best.

-[group clapping] -Thank you. Thank you so much.

Mike saving me,

it's probably one of the nicest things that a guy has ever done for me,

which is sad. [laughs]

That's the nicest thing a guy's ever done for me.

But, like, it kind of like healed a little part of me,

of like, "Oh, I do deserve love."

[♪ upbeat music playing]

-Okay? -Okay.

Tonight's been so dramatic

and so surprising,

that we have another announcement.

Farha and Brooklyn,

you haven't had enough time here to answer the question,

Are You My First?

Tonight, you both are safe as well.

You deserve a second chance of finding love.

-Thank you. -[Brooklyn] Thank you.

I am so relieved

that Kaitlyn and Colton are letting me stay.

Woo! [laughs]

-Thank you, Colton and Kaitlyn. -[heart chimes]

[Brooklyn laughs]

Alright, well, now that that's settled,

we do have to wrap this up.

Andrew, Noah, Katya, and Mike,

you have been sacrificed.

Please say goodbye to the friends that you've made on the island.

♪ I wish there was another way to say this ♪

♪ Don't wanna break your heart, but I can't fake it ♪

I didn't expect to have this experience at all,

but I'm just so grateful for it.

-Love you guys. -[Jade] Bye.

-You're a queen! -Thank you.

I deserve to be someone's priority.

I deserve love, I deserve care,

I deserve the world.

Remember, the goal is to fall in love,

get married, so we don't die virgins, right?

-[laughter] -See you guys.

The joke when I was younger was like,

"Oh, it's gonna be the 40-year-old virgin,"

then it's like, yeah, six years away.

Take care, everyone.

♪♪

I just want someone to see me and, like, love me for me.

A girl who traditionally never goes for me in the past

didn't go for me today,

and it's been happening for, like, my whole dating life.

-Bye, love you guys, see ya. -[group] Bye, Noah!

♪ If it makes you happy, it's not me ♪

The spark I've been waiting to find this entire time I finally have it,

and I get to appreciate it for like an hour.

[voice breaking] Yeah, I just am, like, pretty embarrassed. [crying]

♪ I wish there was another way to say this ♪

It's time to go home

and give my mom and dad a big hug. [chuckles, sniffles]

[Colton] So, I know that was very emotional.

Hopefully, tonight has been a huge step for all of you.

And for Madi, Brooklyn, and Farha,

this will be your last chance to find love.

♪♪

Do not waste this opportunity.

Now, go on to the beach club, you little lovebirds.

I am so happy to have just survived the virgin sacrifice

and to have a second chance.

But I don't really have a strategy at this point

because there's no guys here that I'm currently interested in.

And so, I am really, really hoping for some new men,

because I genuinely do wanna find a connection.

♪♪

-[birds chirping] -[ocean waves crashing]

[♪ "Everybody Wake up!" by Lisa Loeb playing]

[Colton] Ten-hut! Rise and shine, purity platoon.

If you've still got your virginity handy,

you must be ready to lose it at any time.

For peak readiness, you must be in peak physical condition.

[birds chirping]

[Ty exhales]

Go.

[♪ electropop music playing]

Finish strong.

♪♪

Alright, you can take a breather.

-That's my coach. -Good shit.

Yeah.

[Colton] While some guys might be working on

cracking open their six-packs,

today is all about strong couples

and giving them the perfect conditions to move forward

or crash and burn.

You know, whatever works.

[Godwin] If dudes come

and they wanna pull your girl for chats,

I think, like, you should allow it.

Don't be like, "No, don't talk to her." You know what I'm saying?

-Because at the end of day... -[laughing]

...at the end of the day, what's meant to be will be.

I really, really have great feelings for you.

-[Deya] Yeah. -But then also, like...

-[Deya] Oh, dang. -You know what I'm saying?

There's still interest.

Like, are you gonna, like, try to talk to her more?

Like, what's the plan?

I mean, again, like, you're still the priority,

but I also want to, like, figure things out.

I can't really do anything.

What do you mean you can't do anything?

Well, I-- Like, you could still say something to Jade.

-Yeah. Don't cry. -But like, I can't-- [laughs]

I guess I'm disappointed that Godwin's still open

to getting to know Jade,

but Godwin reassured me that I was his priority.

I'm going all in on this relationship,

and hopefully my heart doesn't steer me wrong.

-[♪ gentle music playing] -[ocean waves lapping]

[voice breaking] I'm grateful for you.

I am as well.

[Colton] Godwin consoles Deya like someone else was to blame.

Meanwhile, Sara's confused about Jake breaking his own boundaries

when it comes to PDA with last night's kiss.

And despite knowing he's entirely to blame, she says this.

I'm not trying to like, um... blame you in any way,

but I just feel like it's just been

-a little off for me a little bit. -[Jake] Okay, yeah.

[Sara] After the virgin sacrifice, I was kind of bothered by Jake

because he had just had a conversation with me

about not wanting to do PDA in front of a bunch of people.

It makes me worry about us moving forward

and us being intimate in any other way if he can't follow his own boundary,

which is something as simple as kissing.

It has nothing to do with me

not wanting to kiss you or wanting to kiss you.

I want to kiss you.

-But it's me being-- -But it just can't be like that.

-Yeah, yeah. -Especially when you tell me...

-Uh-huh. -...that you, you don't want to.

[Jake] I can see why she's confused.

My last kiss was six years ago

with my ex-girlfriend.

Usually, when I kiss somebody, it's in a commitment.

Technically, me and Sara are,

are not boyfriend and girlfriend,

so I kind of broke my rules.

I love being able to just hold your hand.

I think anything more than that

I think would probably jumble our emotions.

-Mm-hm. -This could be a healthy way

-to dive deeper into, "What is this?" -[Sara] Mm-hm.

-Yeah? -Yes.

I love that. I love that. Aw.

-I love that. Yeah. -[Sara chuckles]

[Colton] Well, nothing an awkward hug won't fix.

Lucky thing Jake was with Sara

because if he'd seen single ladies Madi, Brooklyn, and Farha holding hands,

no amount of awkward hugs could revive him.

[Madi] I feel like we need to walk in a circle

-and like chant or something. -Yeah. [laughing]

-And be like, "Please give us cute boys." -Should we draw, like, a pentagram?

Oh, my gosh.

What the fuck are they doing?

I think we should, like, put out our manifestations.

[Madi] Okay.

I feel like I'm looking for a goofball

-who could be a short king, dark hair... -[Brooklyn] Mm-hm.

-...um, kind, kind, kind, kind, kind. -Yeah.

What about you?

I'm looking for basically my prince.

I'm looking for a hung,

non-religious, accepting Greek god.

That would be nice to see.

[Kaitlyn] Now that was a powerful manifestation

because it wasn't long before they were dealing with a powerful man infestation.

♪ 'Cause I'm the chosen one ♪

♪ Whoa ♪

[gasps] Yo!

Holy shit.

Oh shoot, there's three.

There's three!

-The one in the blue. Okay? -[Madi] They got "muskles."

[Layne] My name is Layne, I'm 24.

I'm a virgin because I just

haven't found the right girl yet.

[Rachael] Oh, my God, there's one for each of you!

[Spencer] I'm Spencer.

I am 25 years old.

I'm a virgin because I've never been in love.

I'm not afraid to fall in love.

Um, I just haven't met the right person.

If I have a good connection with someone,

I'm okay to step on toes.

-[Deya] Hey. -[Rachael] Hi!

[Vivek] I'm Vivek. I'm 23.

On a scale of one to 10,

I'm probably like an 11 on the confidence scale.

-I'm Madi. -Vivek.

-Nice to meet you. -Nice to meet you.

Thank you, virgin gods,

for giving us the three new men.

I'm not saying what we did worked,

but maybe it, you know, shifted some things around. I don't know.

-Alright. -[card chiming]

-[Deya] Oh, my God. -[Ty] Okay.

"Are you ready to sweep some ladies off their feet?

"When you're ready, each of you will ask one woman

to join you on a sexy group date tonight."

-[contestants] Oh! -Wow.

-[Spencer] Can I grab you? -Okay.

[♪ upbeat music playing]

-How tall are you, like 6'5"? -[Spencer chuckles]

-Yeah, I'm 6'5". -[Deya] Oh!

-How do you feel? Yeah. -I'm... I'm confident.

I feel like we're in a great space,

and if another dude come in and want to pull her for a chat,

you know, that's something that I think should be respected

because we're all here to find the love of our life.

Yeah.

I know Godwin says that he's okay with Deya

talking to these new guys,

but how can he not be a little concerned with her

formulating this connection with Spencer?

This just means more competition.

Tell me about your story.

-Yeah. Um-- [chuckles] -Why you're still a virgin.

-I'm waiting for my wife so, um... -[Deya] Good for you.

-Yeah. -Me too, I'm waiting

-for my husband to do that. -Nice.

What's like something you would do to, like,

make a guy, like, know you might be interested?

-Maybe just like a little wave, you know? -[Vivek chuckles]

So, why did you decide to come here?

Like, where else am I gonna find a, a group of virgins?

Like, I don't see a virgin on the street.

-I mean... -Yeah.

-They don't hold up signs or anything. -I mean, that'd really make things

-a lot easier, huh? Yeah. -Really, I know.

It would be great for me to start a new chapter,

move forward, hopefully find love again.

Not again.

Hopefully find love.

I did not love him. If you put that in, I will seriously be really mad.

What do you, like, normally look for when you're dating?

Shorter girls, which I mean, everyone here is.

I mean, you're like so tall

-everyone's shorter than you. -Yeah.

Do we live up to your expectations of,

-of hot virgins? -I think, I think so. [laughs]

Hot virgins, yeah.

So, what's, like, prompted your virginity?

I think when I'm ready to take that step with a girl,

it's gonna be someone I know, and I really care about, I really trust.

[Farha] Vivek's really attractive.

He's kind of hard to read because he is so mellow.

But it could just be nerves in the presence

of my intimidating sex appeal.

I like your eyes. They're so blue.

Thank you, you too.

-Are yours, like, green on the inside? -Yep.

-They, like, look the same as mine. -[chuckles]

You're very, you're very beautiful.

Oh, thank you so much.

I think you're, like, handsome too.

Layne definitely has a unique vibe to him

because I think he seems very, very sweet

and almost, like, gentle.

And he called me beautiful, which is sweet.

[Kaitlyn] Like most guys,

the tank top trio were glad to get the foreplay out of the way

and come clean about who they'd take on a date.

First up to choose, Layne.

[♪ suspenseful music playing]

Brooklyn, would you like to go on a date with me tonight?

-I'd love to. [giggles] -[Layne] Alright.

[cheering and applause]

[Kaitlyn] And now, Vivek.

Farha, would you like to go on a date with me tonight?

-Let's get it. Yeah. -[cheering and applause]

[Kaitlyn] Last but not least, Spencer.

[♪ curious music playing]

Deya, would you, uh, like to go on a date with me tonight?

Yes.

[laughter and applause]

[Godwin] Spencer picked Deya for the date.

It doesn't feel good,

but it would be terrible for me

to tell her to close herself off,

while I'm also trying to explore my options with Jade.

[Brooklyn] Alright.

-[Michael] Go get ready! -[Madi] Bye!

Are you maybe upset?

-It's okay to be. Or how are you-- -Yeah.

How are you feeling

-that you didn't get asked? -I feel so many different things.

-Uh-huh. -I kind of think it might be for the best.

-'Cause then there's no pressure. -[group] Mm.

And I can get to know them when they're

-a little bit more comfortable. -[group agreeing]

[Madi] I'm definitely bummed I don't get picked for the date

and I'm trying not to go back into the mindset of like,

"Oh, well, duh, that's just my life."

I mean, I get why Deya gets picked for a date

'cause she's so much fun.

But she has Godwin.

Like, let me have someone.

[♪ "We Could Be Lovers" by Stuart Winters, Beatrice Blobb & Alex Nova playing]

♪ We could be lovers ♪

♪ If you didn't have one already ♪

♪ If you didn't have one already ♪

-[birds chirping] -[ocean waves crashing]

[♪ upbeat music playing]

[Kaitlyn] It's date night and the virgins will connect

as they learn how to dance.

Love is unpredictable, but one thing is guaranteed.

This montage is the last time you'll see any actual dancing tonight.

[Deya laughs]

[Deya] It's not a secret that I had feelings for Godwin,

but then again,

I'm so excited to be on this date with Spencer.

I just think love comes to those who are open.

-Hi, guys. Surprise! -Hi!

[Brooklyn] I'm so excited to learn Salsa,

especially with Layne.

He's very handsome,

and it feels super romantic touching Layne's arms

and him grabbing my waist.

Ooh-la-la, fabulosa.

[chuckles]

[♪ percussion music playing]

-Oh, I love this music. -[Spencer laughs]

I love Salsa dancing,

but Spencer started off hopping a lot.

So, I was like, "Hey, calm it down with the hopping."

It's in the hips

and, you know, in the confidence.

[♪ Salsa music playing]

Brooklyn and Deya are having the time of their lives

because they're both adept dancers.

Hopefully, Vivek's the type of guy who's not just turned off

by my lack of skill.

Wait, am I supposed to mirror your feet?

And, hopefully, we'll fuck after.

♪♪

[Kaitlyn] Back at the chastity compound,

Rachael and Michael are creating their own date night

by crashing the never-before-seen

love shack.

[Rachael] Do you want me to tell you where we're going?

-No, no, no, s-- I like surprises -[Rachael] Okay.

This is really exciting to have Michael back.

I feel like having that time away,

the feelings grew,

but our relationship hasn't grown.

So, I feel like we really need one-on-one time.

No distractions, just the two of us.

[Rachael squeals]

[Kaitlyn] Alert, alert, they're heading into the love shack.

This is not a drill.

Does this mean what I think it means?

-[Michael] Champagne. -[Rachael] Candles.

[Michael] Meatballs.

-Oh, this is nice. -[Rachael] This is, like, way romantic.

-[Michael] I know. -[Rachael] [gasps] Oh!

[Kaitlyn] Does that mean that Michael is gonna be Rachael's first?

Did anyone have that on their bingo card?

[Rachael] Oh!

[laughing] Just shove, shove them in your pockets.

-[Michael laughs] -Oh, my gosh.

I see the condoms, dry heave, and, uh, it's like,

whoa, [chuckles] this is happening.

Uh, I like to take my sweet time.

Typically, take probably too much time.

But also, losing my virginity with Rachael,

that's a real possibility.

[laughs] I'm getting flustered just thinking about it.

Oh, we're definitely spending time in here, for sure.

Oh, what the heck's that?

-Oh, whoa! -[both laughing]

Crack it open.

♪ Company ♪

[♪ "Company" by Bigger Story Music playing]

♪ Baby, keep me company ♪

♪ Turn the lights down low and stay ♪

[Rachael] Are you a cuddler?

Sure.

-[Rachael] What do you mean "sure"? -I'm not anti-cuddle. It's fine.

-Are you? -Mm-hm.

Being in bed with a guy,

it's definitely out of my comfort zone,

but, also, this is kind of what I came here for.

I came here to be with somebody

who makes me want to explore physical intimacy with

and a deep relationship with.

And I think that Michael's that right person.

Oh, you go underneath?

-Yeah. -That can't be right.

-Why? -You think?

[♪ tense music playing]

[Michael blows air]

Is it my hair?

-[Michael blows air] -Oh, my God, I'm so sorry.

Cuddling with Michael in the love shack

is not how I imagined it.

[Rachael] Okay.

I feel like my body is having like a visceral reaction.

It feels uncomfortable to me and awkward,

which is so not us.

Okay, I'm ready for bed.

Yay, me too. I'm hot.

[Rachael] I'm feeling just disappointed

that my issues when it comes to physical intimacy

are starting to, like, creep up,

and I didn't think they would do that with Michael.

It's like everything's just shutting down inside me.

♪ Where do we go from here? ♪

Bye, love shack.

See you again another time.

[Michael] What started off fun and bubbly

and maybe even a little bit sexual

has sort of morphed into, like, a little bit, like, awkward and tight.

So, I'm not sure what went wrong.

Maybe we're just not as ready

to dive into, like, the physical aspects

of a relationship as we thought we were.

♪ Where do we go from, go from here now? ♪

[♪ "Rise Awake" by Peter Higher playing]

♪ Stare out 'til locking eyes with you ♪

[Farha] I feel like you could do, like, Bollywood.

-Have you gotten that before? -[Vivek] Yeah, a little bit.

[Farha] Well, you have blue eyes, have a more unique feature.

So, I feel like they would cast you in a lot of stuff.

Yeah, these are contacts.

-[♪ music stops] -So, I don't wanna deceive you.

I like how it looks and, like,

-I just made it part of my thing. -I wear, I wear fake glasses,

-so I'm just as vain. -Okay. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

-I think-- -We both, we both do eye things.

[laughs] Yeah, these are my fake tits right here.

-[laughing] -Yeah, exactly, exactly.

[Vivek] Farha and I kind of just get along really well.

It's like, really, like, refreshing to, like, date a girl

who is, like, unapologetic and open,

upfront about, like, how she stands.

What are, like, some things you're, like, looking for?

Guys who are chill.

Like, I don't like when guys, like, put on, like, a performance.

Like, you seem very mellow and laid back, which is cool, which I like.

And, like, genuine.

So, that's preferable.

I appreciate that. [chuckles]

[Farha] I think out of all the guys that have been here,

I think Vivek is the one that shows the most potential.

Like, he seems mature for his age.

He's intelligent, and he's attractive.

And I try not to objectify men, but I did notice a bulge.

So, happy ending.

So, you like, grew up, like, on a farm?

Yeah, I'd say yeah.

-No way. -[Layne] Yeah.

My hometown is like, a total, like, farm town, too.

-Yeah? -Yeah, like cows and horses...

-Like, cowboys and stuff? -...and, like, everything.

-Yeah. Yeah. -Like the cowboy hats and stuff.

Wait, so how long ago were you in the Army?

Um, so I joined a year and a half ago,

and I got my pilot's license while I was doing that too,

-and going to college. -Your pilot's license?

-Yeah. Well... -That's really cool.

Yeah, it's a lot of fun.

I feel really special that you picked me for the date tonight.

'Cause it's like, right when I saw you I thought you were, like, super cute.

-Oh. -So, when you said my name,

I was like, so happy.

Oh, and I feel really good, yeah.

-Yeah? -Yeah.

I already think I found a great girl.

[giggles] Thank you.

I like your personality too, so...

-Okay, thank you. -...yeah.

I'm glad I haven't screwed that up.

Oh. [laughs]

-Um, yeah. -Yeah. No, you haven't.

[♪ "Moonlit Floor (Kiss Me)" by Lisa playing]

♪ Ooh la, la, la ♪

♪ I'ma need to hear you say it out loud ♪

♪ 'Cause I love it when my name slips out your mouth ♪

With Layne, I am definitely feeling an energy.

How could I not?

Like, he's super, like, handsome.

We're just, like, having a good time together.

Like, so far he, like, is checking my boxes.

[clicking tongue]

[softly] I think we're supposed to go down to like--

♪ Kiss me under the Paris twilight ♪

Kissing Brooklyn feels great.

[laughs] It feels amazing.

Yeah, I don't wanna have any regret.

I went for it, and it worked out perfect.

I'm glad. [laughs] I don't regret that.

Mission accomplished.

♪ Kiss me out on the moonlit floor ♪

♪ Kiss me under the Paris twilight ♪

♪♪

♪ So kiss me ♪

-[birds chirping] -[ocean waves crashing]

[Kaitlyn] Hot on the heels of their sexy Salsa class,

things are heating up between Deya and Spencer.

Or, is the dance floor the closest they'll ever get

to using the rhythm method?

-That was so much fun! -That was fun.

Wow.

I'm actually surprised that you ended up getting it.

[both laughing]

-Uh, I don't-- -'Cause at first,

there was, like, a lot of bouncing involved.

-There was a lot of bouncing. -[Deya laughs]

[Spencer chuckles]

I feel like the main reason why I asked you tonight

is because we probably had more of the same beliefs, religiously.

I have dated people with different views

and usually-- it's not that it doesn't go well,

but usually there's always someone that kind of like, catches up, you know?

They see it as more of a challenge like, "Oh--"

Oh, like trying to take it. Lose your--

[Spencer] Yeah, trying to, like, get in my pants or whatever.

[both laughing]

Thanks for explaining your, like, train of thought

on how you went about it.

I'm definitely looking for something serious.

[Kaitlyn] Deya's seriously trying to give Spencer a shot,

but back at Club Celibacy,

Godwin's getting even more serious with his other flame, Jade.

How serious?

Putting-a-towel-down serious.

[Jade] I feel like me and Ty are great.

We're in a great space.

The emotional connection is strong.

But then, with Godwin,

I want to see if there is something there,

and we haven't had the time

because of our other connections.

And obviously, this would be a prime opportunity.

What's been up?

[chuckling] Um...

just, uh...

I mean, I feel like I want to live in the moment,

letting you know how I feel,

and really be as intentional as possible.

[Deya] I do feel pretty strongly

-about what I have with Godwin. -[Spencer] Sure.

-[Deya] And-- -[Spencer] He's a cool dude.

-[Spencer] He's a great guy. -[Deya] Yeah, he is.

And I like where it's at right now.

So, we're gonna-- I'm gonna keep exploring it...

-Sure, I hear ya. -...and see where it, where it goes.

Spencer seems like a really nice guy,

but at the same time, I think it would be so hard for me

to try to build as deep of a connection

as I've already built with Godwin.

And I want to further that connection.

I'm all the way in.

I am, like,

pretty, um--

Trying to get wife'd up

-by, by Godwin. -[laughing] Yeah.

-I hear ya. -[laughing] By Godwin.

[♪ "I Just Love You" by LA Space Program playing]

One of my biggest regret if I was to leave tonight,

is that I wasn't able to push through

in getting to know you as much as possible.

♪♪

[Ty] To see the person that you're building a connection with

talking to someone else,

of course you're gonna have thoughts and feelings of, like,

you know, "I hope we're good."

I've been a part of different love triangles

where I was just a placeholder,

you know, while she was waiting for that other guy to gain interest.

And it always ends the same way.

I feel like I'm stuck in between, like, a rock and a hard place.

-[Godwin] Yeah. -With, like, you and Ty

and I'm trying to keep it, like, respectable.

Yeah.

I want to continue to get to know you.

[Godwin] I feel like you are amazing. Like...

-[chuckles] -Like, truthfully.

♪♪

I'm excited to hear that Jade is still interested in me.

I like almost everything about Jade.

Like, her smile, just her energy, vibe,

and her beauty.

The more I'm around Jade,

that makes me want to pursue things further with her.

Of course, I have feelings for you.

I would be lying, you know,

if I said I didn't.

[♪ "The Heart Wants What It Wants" by Kelson playing]

♪ Oh, oh, oh ♪

With Godwin, what I appreciate about him

is that he's very persistent

and steadfast in getting to know me.

And I love that.

I love persistency in a man. I think it's a great quality.

And those emotional pieces

that I feel like I've been missing,

I am starting to see.

And I want to continue to see them.

So, with Godwin,

I'm feeling it,

you know? [laughs]

♪ But it's my heart ♪

♪ It wants what it wants ♪

♪ Oh, hey ♪

[Colton] Next time, on Are You My First?...

[♪ dramatic music playing]

Wait, Kaitlyn. Kaitlyn.

[Colton] ...Rachael needs advice...

Think like something's wrong with me.

Nothing is wrong with you.

[Colton] ...Madi makes a pass...

"Layne, will we be knocking boots anytime soon or what?"

[group exclaims]

[Colton] ...and...

"Jade's so good at geometry,

she turned a love triangle into a love rectangle."

[contestants] Oh!

[Colton] ...a roast burns some feelings.

[Deya] I'm done waiting.

Making it easier for you

by removing myself.

[♪ dramatic sting]

[♪ "This Déjà Vu" by Nick Kingsley and Malory playing]

♪ Just 'cause I like you ♪

♪ Doesn't mean I wanna be with you ♪

♪ It drives me crazy ♪

♪ Going through this back and forth ♪

♪ This déjà vu ♪

♪ One, like Dolce ♪

♪ Two, Gabbana ♪

♪ Bey, Jay-Z, without the drama ♪

♪ But I'm still stuck here in a loop ♪

♪ The same old thing, this déjà vu ♪

♪ ♪

[♪ upbeat music playing]