Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
Previously on Pig Advances.
I've retrieved what appears to be a right middle or ring finger severed at
second joint.
Maybe we should turn you loose and let the mob outside deal with you. You can't
do this. We can do whatever we want.
We're the cops.
The discovery of the body would be fruits of a poisonous
tree. I may have no choice.
but to dismiss the charges.
When I come back, the three of you are going to tell me the brilliant plan
you've devised to keep that bastard in jail. You've got to figure it out!
Mr. Latham, you are going to trial.
If the Supreme Court has a problem with that, they can come and get me.
We've got two choices.
The right to the appellate court, try to overturn Judge Bone, get your statement
and the evidence suppressed, Or try this case right now, which I think we should
do. Why?
Because our chances of a conviction are better the sooner we go.
We've got all our evidence except for the weapon, and if we haven't found that
by now... What about DNA?
Well, all the blood we found was hers.
Hair and fiber go to her, him, and in the car, her family.
It's not airtight.
Exactly. It's circumstantial.
That's why I'd like to try it while it's still fresh in the jury's head. Time
can only help the defense.
Then why does Wombo want to go now?
Because I could take advantage of the short investigation.
I can argue that they didn't take the time to look for anybody else.
It'll play into reasonable doubt.
Plus, this trial is a free shot for us.
See, if they lose, they can still get it overturned on constitutional grounds.
If they win, the state can't appeal an acquittal. The man walks.
It's a free bite for him. Wambaugh knows what he's doing.
Do we?
Appellate courts are less likely to overturn a trial than they are a
If we can get a conviction now, we make his chance on appeal much tougher.
I say we go.
I say we go.
Do I have a chance?
Yes.
No. Our case is circumstantial, but it's very strong.
He can't win.
I cannot lose this guy.
We won't.
Okay.
Okay.
Okay.
You like murder trials, Kimberly?
This is going to be a good one.
Sheriff Department is a joke.
It frustrates me.
If they knew how to collect evidence, they'd have caught the real killer. Mr.
Wambaugh likes to try these cases in the media where he's free to make up the
fact. He says this because I'm Jewish.
He comes in here today with nothing but public pressure to get a conviction.
Yeah, well, you'll see what we've got. I'm getting goosebumps.
I'd appreciate it if you didn't attack my father in the press.
Kimberly, the media has taken away the presumption of innocence.
I have to use the spotlight to get it back.
You ready?
I think so.
Remember, they'll probably introduce the pictures early. Look horrified to see
them. The jury has to see that they shock you like anybody else.
Now, it's not imperative that you look, but I want you in the room.
I want the jury to be reminded of your tragedy.
Do we have to be here for the whole trial?
I prefer it.
Emotion cuts in our favor.
I've got your parents, a sister, your grandmother, and an uncle you've never
met.
My family is coming? And for the purpose of this trial, you're close -knit.
The jury cannot see it otherwise.
Well, how'd you get them to show up?
You're their only son.
Will they testify?
Not a chance.
If he puts up any character witness, then we are free to impeach with our
witnesses, and I've got about 20.
I even have a teenage girl that was threatened by him at knife point two
ago. What?
But I can't use it.
The law says we can't talk about previous bad acts to convince the jury
this one.
Wait a second. Now, this guy attacked another girl with a knife, and we can't
tell the jury about it? That's right.
But if they try to argue that he's a good guy... We can roll out our
witnesses, this girl included.
See, Wanbao knows that.
He won't put this guy's parents up or anybody to even hint about his
Then what's our case?
The state has the burden to make the case.
I just have to shoot holes in it, and I will.
The worst thing is those pictures.
They're some of the most graphic images I've ever seen.
I apologize for having to show them to you.
They'll be difficult to look at, but you must look at them.
The testimonial evidence will show that Susan Ingrams was stabbed 11 times, but
you cannot know the violent savagery unless you look.
The prosecution will show beyond all reasonable doubt that the person
responsible for this repulsive carnage is Brian Latham, the man sitting right
over there.
That concludes my opening statement.
I would ask first...
When you go home tonight, let us all say a prayer for Susan
Ingram's and her family.
Nobody here can feel their pain.
This judicial proceeding can never make them whole.
The prosecution has laid a setting of a horrible tragedy.
Savagery.
The defense does not dispute this, but we do take issue with their conclusion
to who is responsible.
It wasn't Brian Latham.
When the prosecution searched for a witness, they drew a blank.
They looked for a motive.
Blank.
They search for a weapon?
Nothing.
They comb my client's person and property for bloodstains and forensic
Any evidence at all that would connect Brian Latham to violence?
Nothing.
As to their efforts to find the person who really was responsible for this
murder...
Mr.
Littleton has shown you the victim.
I've shown you their case.
Time of death, cause of death, absence of other hair or fibers on the body, In
the car or at the scene?
Check. And Carter, make sure your voice works, okay? We're not going to get a
conviction if you sound like a damn chipmunk again.
Why are you so nervous?
Because Wambaugh opened great, that's why.
Then you go up.
You're going to cover all the prints, the tire tracks, the footprints, and
corroborate the store owner's statement.
Then I put you up, Kenny. You are critical.
Me, me, me.
Carter.
His pointing you to where the body was is the linchpin.
His demeanor, his look of contrition, guilt, his sense of wanting redemption
a crime he knew he committed, his feeling of remorse for taking a human
These are the things you saw in that cell, and these are the things you must
make that jury see.
I've been over it.
Okay.
There's one other thing we've got to talk about.
Now,
I don't mean to be critical, but this is a reality that we're dealing with.
The Sheriff's Department is perceived to be terrible and largely that perception
is accurate.
Your investigational habits are shoddy. There is a shocking lack of professional
credibility in the personnel.
Kenny, your intelligence doesn't translate.
Juries tend to think of you as simple.
Officer Stewart, you were thought of as intelligent and thorough, but also
erratic.
And Carter, where do I begin with you?
What's your point?
My point is, every case I prosecute is hampered by the credibility of this
branch.
Now, there are some pluses.
The people know and trust you.
And one of the reasons I didn't try to kick venue is because in another town,
potential jurors might not extend the same personal trust that comes from
knowing you. They'd only focus on the professional incompetence. We're not
incompetent. Look, I don't mean to attack you, but I have to make you aware
this reality so that you're prepared to beat it.
When you get up on that stand, I want to see authority.
Carter, you are a great medical examiner. Make that jury know that.
Kenny, you're clear -headed. Be precise and decisive when you're in that witness
chair.
A district attorney can only play his hand, and you people are my hand.
Now, I want that jury to know this son of a bitch is guilty because you know
You three know it.
So, if you think he did it, then why are you helping him?
You have to understand, Zach, even guilty defendants are entitled to a
and a fair trial.
Why?
Well, you see, um, the state has to prove guilt before they can lock
up.
The defense attorneys have to make sure that the burden of proof is met in every
case.
It's all about protecting our system of justice.
So when defense attorneys represent guilty people, they're nevertheless
protecting the system.
And by doing that, the innocent are served.
Do you understand?
No.
You will when you're old enough.
He killed somebody, and you're helping him.
How old do I have to get?
Wambaugh is using you.
The jury knows the sheriff's daughter is sitting at the defense table.
They probably know you were friends with Susan Ingrams.
You're being used.
Time of death can't be fixed positive since the decomposition process is
affected by the body being in water, the temperature of which was 54 degrees
Fahrenheit. But through forensics, entomology, rigor mortis, and post
changes, I can fix death between 1 and 4 a .m. Now, I should like to explain...
Objection!
Too boring.
We'll agree that she died between 1 and 4 a .m. So stipulated.
Were you able to determine the cause of death, Dr. Pike?
Yes, I was.
Excuse me.
It was death by stabbing. The victim received multiple wounds from a seven
serrated blade. The fatal blow being a stab wound to the heart itself.
I'd like to show you a picture of the victim... I will stipulate that the girl
was killed with a big knife.
I would like to be able to offer my evidence... You just want to show the
pictures off to shock the jury.
I agree.
Move on, Mr. Littleton.
What about the severing of the finger, Dr. Pike?
Oh, yes.
This appeared to be a premortem incision.
Judging from the cuts on the dorsal side of the arms and the palms, it appeared
the victim tried to defend herself inside the car. It was during the
that I think the middle left finger was in fact severed.
And is there anything else that these wounds told you, Dr. Pike, aside from
cause of death?
Yes, that this was an extremely primal and brutal killing.
This woman was butchered.
It was the most gruesome autopsy ever in my professional experience.
Thank you, Dr. Pike.
Nothing further.
Dr. Pike, do any of your medical findings connect this crime to
Brian Latham?
My medical findings?
No.
Thank you.
That's the man, all right. He bought the beer and then he got right into her
car. And what time was that, sir?
Just after 11.
And when I closed up at 12 .30, his truck was still parked in my lot.
And are you sure it was this man and the victim Susan Ingrams?
Positive.
You said to the police my client looked normal, even friendly.
Yes, I did.
And after observing my client's behavior... You had no reason to think
Susan Agrams was in danger, did you?
Well, no.
In fact, you never called the police.
Nothing seemed wrong. Is that correct?
Yes, I guess that's so. Thank you, sir.
Nothing further?
You may step down.
The people call it laying the fever.
Objection!
Sidebar.
We've been through this.
She's excluded.
Just open the door on character testimony, Your Honor. What?
He got Mr. Emanuel to testify that the defendant was normal and friendly. He
character on issue. He cross -examined on what Mr. Emanuel saw.
The witness is excluded. It also goes to pattern, Your Honor. This man attacked
this girl at knife point. The witness is excluded.
Damn it, Your Honor.
I don't think you meant to do that.
I'm trying to put on a case here.
Fine. Do it. But you can't put witnesses up to establish that the defendant is a
bad person.
Now, get back.
Does it bother you?
We're trying to free a man who committed murder.
He never told me he's guilty.
You never asked him.
I know this may be difficult to understand, but it would have been wrong
to ask.
I did what a good defense attorney is supposed to do.
And that's what's hard to understand, that it's proper procedure for lawyers
navigate around the truth.
The system of justice, Kimberly, doesn't always mean that the player should act
justly. Take the Lefevre girl.
When John Littleton called her as a witness, he knew Judge Bone would deny
But by calling her, the jury got to see that there was somebody else who had
something to say for the prosecution.
They get the impression there's more to tell than they're being told.
It's cheating.
Not much, just a little sleight of hand.
We all do it because we know the other guys are going to do it, and we don't
want them to have the edge.
Judge Bone was right. It's all about winning and losing.
Well, the truth is supposed to be a product of the adversary process.
So, yes, that means both sides try to win at all costs.
Even when it means we're trying to free a guilty killer.
I try not to ask myself such tricky questions.
All hair and fibers found in the car belonged either to the victim, the
family members who also drove the car, or the defendant.
The defendant?
Yes. Several strands of hair found on the victim or in her car matched the
samples taken from Brian Latham.
We also found slight skin fragments under her fingernails that were an
genetic match with the defendant.
You have an established foundation for this witness to give DNA evidence.
In the spirit of cooperation, we'll stipulate that the hair, skin, and
fibers probably came from my client.
Well, this all happened during a brief wrestling match where my client
unsuccessfully tried for sex.
Move to strike.
Sustained. The jury will disregard defense counsel's last statement.
Move on.
What other evidence did you find, deputy?
The only tire tracks leading to the pond were those of the victim's car, meaning
whoever committed the murder probably drove in the victim's car to the swamp,
dumped the body, then drove the car back to where it was discovered the
following morning on Prospect Road.
And did you find any footprints at the pond site?
We did.
And they matched the shoes being worn by the defendant at the time we arrested
him. And were there any other prints to suggest that someone else had been
around? No, there were not.
And were there any hairs or fibers found on the person of the victim that did
not come from either the victim or the defendant?
No, there were not.
Thank you, Deputy.
I have nothing further.
When you arrested my client, you checked his person, his truck, and motel room
for physical evidence, didn't you?
Yes. Did you find any?
No.
Nothing? Not even a spattering of blood?
Not anything?
No. You never found a murder weapon?
No, we did not.
Eyewitnesses? No.
What a thing.
Before Susan Ingrins left the house on the night of question, do you know what
happened?
She was involved in an argument with her parents. An angry argument, according
to the statement that they made to the police.
And you say you found their hair and fibers in her car.
Maybe they found her and killed her. Objection. Counsel.
It's just a theory, I know.
Did you explore this possibility, Deputy Stewart?
No, we did not.
Why not?
There was no evidence indicating any involvement by the parents.
You didn't even consider that it could be anybody else, did you, Deputy?
All the evidence pointed to him. All the evidence you bothered to collect.
Under oath, Deputy Stewart, there's been a lot of public pressure for you to
solve this crime, hasn't there?
Public hysteria does not compromise our investigation.
I again remind you that you are under oath.
When you interrogated Brian Latham, did you say to him, you won't get a fair
trial. Somebody's going to pay for what happened to this girl.
If you're the only suspect we offer up, then it'll be you, whether you're
innocent or not.
Did you say that, Deputy?
That was in the context of an interrogation. He told you he was
And you responded, it doesn't matter.
Somebody has to be blamed. And then you said, we're the cops.
We can do anything we want.
We were doing a good cop, bad cop thing. You said it, didn't you?
Yes.
But you don't understand.
Thank you.
But I think I do.
I can't take this. I just cannot take this anymore.
First, you violate the Constitution.
Now, the case should have been kicked on that screw -up. And now this?
I cannot take... You tell the defendant that he will not get a fair trial. It
doesn't matter if he's innocent or not. The jury's going to convict him anyway?
It was a tactic.
A tactic?
It was a tact... Oh, it was a tactic.
We dispense... with the Constitution as a tactic. We threaten unfair trials as a
tactic. These are the tactics of the Rome, Wisconsin Sheriff's Department. I
have had it. John. No, a killer's going to walk, Sheriff.
Don't defend them.
Take responsibility.
Their behavior is a reflection on you, and right now your whole damn
department's a joke.
I'm a joke.
We are the team responsible for letting a murderer walk.
Turn on the newscast tomorrow night and just listen to what all the commentators
are saying about all of us. And if that doesn't sink in, try.
Just try making eye contact with Susan Ingram's parents.
Their daughter was chopped into pieces, and the man who's responsible is going
to go free because of our incompetence. This isn't over yet.
There's still Kenny's testimony.
Imagine the confidence I get from that.
Nothing is helped by this.
Deputy Locos, tomorrow.
Tomorrow, I put the whole prosecution in your hands.
Unexpected surprises are the best.
Not to me.
Get out.
You're a character.
I'm also the judge in the case you're trying.
Don't you know what ex parte is? Of course I do. It's Latin.
But when I saw you eating, I thought you might want company.
Social. Wrong again.
Get out.
You know, Henry, not to discuss the facts, because I know I cannot do that,
what a cross I had today.
With Max on the stand, any lawyer could only hope to have one cross like that in
a career. I could actually get this guy off.
You must be very proud.
Back when I started practice, I would actually get aroused by success in the
courtroom.
Sexually stimulated.
Not a lot, but a little.
I'm so happy you're sharing this. This all happened when I was in my 20s.
I won a lot of cases since then. It's become routine.
But today, when I crossed Max, and when she admitted to those things that she
said in the interrogation, What a rush.
I felt a little tingle.
Not much, just a little.
I had a moment, Henry.
You must admit that the practice of law can be a very gratifying thing.
I need a housekeeper.
Boy's gone?
Yeah, they left early. They wanted to walk.
Shouldn't you be going to school?
I'm in court. The teachers know.
Shouldn't miss a whole week.
What's the problem, Daddy?
You don't want me sitting at Wambaugh's table.
I get it. But don't come at me sideways with the school thing.
Don't. Talk to me with that tone.
My tone is honest. All right.
You want me out of that courtroom so the jury might think that I abandoned the
defense. So how about this, Daddy? How about I go to court, announce Brian
Latham is guilty, and then I'll go to school?
I told you to drop that tone. What about me? I haven't even looked at you in my
class. Talk to you. I'm an adult now.
You're a little sensitive because you are ashamed of what you are doing.
You should be ashamed of trying to take advantage of... I am ashamed. I'm
ashamed of my daughter. You go to hell!
I knew he believed in God.
And I asked him, as a believer in God, as a believer that every Christian
deserves a proper burial, I asked him to tell me where that body lay.
And his response?
At first, he just looked down.
So I asked him to think about her parents.
I asked him to make things right.
I asked him again, make things right.
That's when he told me.
Told you where to look.
Exactly.
We then proceeded to the destination and retrieved the corpse.
And did Brian Latham admit to killing Susan Ingram? He didn't say it in words,
but he made it clear.
He put that girl in the swamp.
Thank you, Deputy.
I have nothing further.
Are you a mind reader, Kenny?
No, sir, I'm not.
Yet you say that my client made something clear without words.
What'd you do, play charades?
All I can say, counsel, is the communication isn't limited to words.
Perhaps... May I finish my response, please? No.
Yes.
Go ahead.
He was careful not to say it exactly.
But I was in that room.
I to I, we looked at each other.
Catholic to Catholic.
We knew we had to face the truth.
And he told me where the body was.
He was admitting to me that he killed her.
Did he say it with words?
No. Did he say it?
Yes, he did.
So, we have to assume the body language skills of Kenny Lockers. I was the only
person in the room with him. You can't contradict me because you weren't there.
And I'm telling you and everybody in this room, that man killed Susan
Objection. Sustained.
That remark is stricken.
Any more questions, Mr. Wambaugh?
No, Your Honor.
Nothing further.
The witness may step down.
We just got hurt.
Penny was good.
So what happens now? I think we got to testify.
Now, you listen to me very carefully, Mr. Latham. Your life depends on it.
Follow this.
If you don't testify, we will lose.
Now, that's simple.
Here's where it's complicated.
As your lawyer, I have an obligation to say that you must tell the truth.
If I know you're going to lie, I have a duty to either not put you up there or
to let you testify in the narrative only, in which case the jury will figure
things out.
The best thing would be, of course, for me to believe that you didn't kill Susan
Agrams. Then I would have no ethical problem putting you on the stand.
You with me?
I think so.
So I'm now going to ask you for the first time.
Did you kill Susan Ingrams?
No, I did not.
Excellent. Now, here are the problem areas you must explore. Kimberly.
Fragments of your skin found under her fingernails. You said you briefly
wrestled with her. A little sexual foreplay.
Perhaps it got rough and she scratched you.
I don't know.
It's for you to think about.
Kimberly.
Your footprints at the scene, you're knowing where the body was.
That's their whole case.
If you can satisfy these questions, we still have a chance.
Remember, you have an obligation to tell the truth at all times, of course.
Of course.
Very important.
If Mr. Littleton traps you on cross, if he catches you in any misstatement, it's
probably because this whole thing is so upsetting that you get confused.
Imagine being accused of such a horrible crime.
Whose mind wouldn't be affected?
I got you.
Good.
So tell me, what happened after the two of you left the store?
At first, we just drove around drinking the beer.
We actually drove down to the pond for a little bit. I got out and looked
around. You went to the pond?
Just for a few minutes. She said it was her favorite place.
Then we went driving around some more.
and pulled over on a dirt road.
And what happened there?
Well, we finished the beer, and we started to kiss a little bit.
Then things kind of heated up.
How?
Well, the kissing got a little more passionate, and I, you know,
touched her breasts and buttocks.
And this was all consensual?
Completely. Then I kind of tried to take her pants off, and we wrestled a
little.
She kind of scratched me.
She scratched you?
Yes.
She said she didn't want to go any further, so we stopped.
And then what?
Then she drove me back down to the store, probably around 2.
I got out, got in my truck, and drove home.
That was the last I saw her.
Well, Brian, how did you know where the body was?
I didn't know.
Deputy Locos kept pressing me for places to look.
She had said that the pond was one of her favorite places, and I kind of
directed him to look there.
I didn't know.
I was just trying to help.
You were just trying to help.
Tell me something, Mr. Latham. Why didn't you tell the police you'd been to
pond?
As they brought me in, my lawyer instructed me to tell them nothing.
But you went on to say a lot.
Whoa.
Once they said I was a suspect, I certainly told them all that I thought
relevant, that I'd been kissing her and that we were together.
I didn't think the pond was really relevant at that point. But at some
you changed your mind about that.
Well, when she didn't turn up, I remembered her telling me that the pond
favorite place.
So I thought maybe she went back there and maybe something happened to her
there, but I didn't do it. Yeah, you keep saying that.
Is there anybody...
who can verify the time that you got back to your motel that night. I don't
know. It's your job to collect evidence, not mine, sir.
Thank you.
And isn't it funny how all the evidence we did collect points right at you?
And isn't it strange that you knew exactly where that body could be found?
But you say you didn't do it, so I guess it's our evidence versus your
credibility.
Have you ever been convicted of a crime?
I asked you a question, sir.
Breaking and entering. How many times?
Twice.
You're a convicted felon.
So can we both agree that when this jury goes back to deliberate, that it should
turn on your credibility?
Objection sustained.
One last thing.
You said when it became clear that the girl couldn't be found, you directed
Kenny to the pond.
But when the police first brought you in, they made it clear that Susan Ingram
was missing.
Why didn't you tell them about the pond then?
I, uh... I forgot.
You forgot?
I was being accused of a horrible crime.
I was upset.
Can you imagine being told you're a murder suspect?
I was in shock.
Yeah, I bet you were.
I'm done with this witness.
The witness may step down.
There must be something in the water in Rome, Wisconsin, because things just
seem to keep happening there, and they happen fast.
Today, the Brian Latham murder trial is expected to go to the jury, just two
weeks after the defendant allegedly killed Susan Engrams. You'll remember
is the same town where the mayor was convicted of murder last year, only to
succeeded by another mayor who was murdered by his own son.
Maybe we should move. Just eat your cereal, Zach.
I'm off to court. Anybody got a problem with that?
No.
Not at all?
Good.
We all want to believe he's the guy.
We're desperate to believe it.
Of course, then we can fix things.
You'd find him guilty, get him off the street.
Go back to feeling safe and sitting on our front porches.
The facts, they're pretty good.
He was last seen with her.
His footprints were at the pond and he knew where the body was.
Now you could take the circumstantial evidence, combine it with your fear and
desperation and fudge a conviction.
The town will probably be grateful to you.
But I bet that there are a few of you...
who are afraid of condemning an innocent man.
Maybe some of you take seriously the obligation to find guilt beyond a
reasonable doubt.
Then you've got trouble.
He drove to the pond with her, then to a roadside where they kissed a little and
wrestled some. That explains all the physical evidence, the hairs, the
the footprints.
His knowledge that she liked the pond, that explains it all.
No weapon.
No witnesses.
No blood of my client or his possessions.
Nothing even microscopic.
How is that possible?
There would have to be a small spattering of blood somewhere.
Simple answer.
He didn't do it.
Brian Latham.
is innocent.
And even if you hate the thought of it, you at least have to admit the
possibility. It's at least possible somebody came after Brian left and
Susan Engrams.
Deputy Stewart testified that they didn't even look for anybody else. They
didn't even investigate it.
They were confident that you would convict whoever they would throw up for
sacrifice.
So what do you do?
I could ask you to go back to that room and do right by Brian Latham.
I could ask you to do right by the system.
Instead, I'll only ask you to do right by yourselves.
You all know there's reasonable doubt.
You can't not know it.
So all I ask is that when you come back out of that jury room, come out with
your integrity intact.
Come out with a verdict of not guilty.
He's right. Not guilty.
Come on.
Mr.
Littleton.
You better be good.
Well, for one, I agree with him.
This thing comes down to your integrity.
The last thing I do is ask you to safeguard the system. The system today
perverted.
Attorneys jockey for positioning.
We manipulate the press for jury bias.
We hire publicists to remake criminals into victims.
The truth?
The truth is only relevant if it supports our case.
But this process still has one redeeming exception that continues to make it the
best in the world. It's called the jury.
It's made up of people who, for the most part, still cling to the ideal that it
must be about truth.
It may be diminishing, but many Americans are still raised with a public
conscience, an ingrained sense of morality.
And if we get enough of those people in this box, the system still works.
I don't know what we've got in this box today.
I do know you could go back to that room, dissect all the semantics, play
the pieces of evidence, consider all the magical possibilities.
You could stay back in that room for a week, because anything is possible.
Anything can be doubted.
But reasonable doubt?
Drifter with a criminal record.
Last seen with her.
Knows exactly where the body was. His skin is under her fingernails. Come on.
He killed that girl.
He lied up on that chair. Every one of us knows that.
Now, is it possible the things that he said? Of course.
Is it conceivable that he forgot to mention the pond to the police, but then
remembered on the stand with the help from his lawyer?
Anything is conceivable.
But that's not what happened.
You look each other in the eye when you go back to that room. You know what
happened.
That man brutally stabbed this girl to her death.
Their daughter, Susan Ingle.
She's gone.
She's gone forever.
Do you people have a conscience?
A barometer of good and evil.
Show me.
Show this community.
Show these parents.
Show them that the truth, in fact, does count more than the contest.
Like he said, come out of that room with your integrity intact.
When I said I was ashamed of you, I didn't mean it.
I know.
I think the law can be a very noble profession.
Especially if you're part of it.
You're an extraordinary young woman, Kimberly.
I'm just afraid that...
You'll set your standards by one ball.
That would be a shame.
The
court
will come to order.
Will the defendant please rise?
Madam Foreman, has the jury reached the verdict?
We have, Your Honor.
What say you?
In the matter of people versus Brian Latham on the charge of murder in the
degree, we find the defendant guilty as charged.
Yes! Get it! Yes!
Members of the jury, thank you for your time.
Your service is concluded.
This matter is adjourned.
Bailiff, take the defendant into custody.
Will appeal.
I've already written the brief.
Van's waiting out back. Let's get him down. Deputy, one second.
Come on. One second, please.
Alone.
Hold on.
Make it quick.
It's all over.
Done.
I got no motive to say anything to you. Say it fast.
Truth time.
Catholic to Catholic.
Me to you.
I didn't do it.
I'm going to jail forever.
I know it.
I'm convicted.
But I'm innocent.
We gotta go. Come on.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.