Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:02,741
This programme contains distressing
and graphic images and descriptions
2
00:00:02,741 --> 00:00:04,621
of death and injury including
children, and discussions
3
00:00:04,621 --> 00:00:05,980
of torture and abuse.
4
00:00:05,990 --> 00:00:07,999
I hope they are OK.
5
00:00:11,821 --> 00:00:13,861
A group of Palestinian
emergency workers and medics
6
00:00:13,861 --> 00:00:17,021
are on a rescue mission.
7
00:00:17,021 --> 00:00:19,720
Their ambulance is clearly marked,
with lights flashing.
8
00:00:19,730 --> 00:00:22,879
These moments need to be documented.
9
00:00:26,581 --> 00:00:28,621
RAPID GUNSHOTS
10
00:00:28,621 --> 00:00:30,341
Israeli soldiers
open fire, and start
11
00:00:30,341 --> 00:00:35,381
to kill the rescue workers.
12
00:00:36,221 --> 00:00:38,541
GUNSHOTS CONTINUE
13
00:00:38,541 --> 00:00:41,501
They said the convoy was suspicious
because its lights were off.
14
00:00:41,501 --> 00:00:44,381
But when 15 bodies were exhumed
from a mass grave, this video
15
00:00:44,381 --> 00:00:47,501
from the phone of one of the dead
medics exposed the Israeli version
16
00:00:47,501 --> 00:00:52,541
of events as untrue.
17
00:00:52,661 --> 00:00:53,941
SHOUTING, GUNSHOTS
18
00:00:53,941 --> 00:00:55,581
This is just one
attack amongst hundreds
19
00:00:55,581 --> 00:00:58,150
on Palestinian healthcare workers.
20
00:00:58,160 --> 00:00:59,519
Mum, forgive me, mum.
21
00:00:59,520 --> 00:01:03,639
This is the path I chose, to help people.
22
00:01:03,640 --> 00:01:04,959
Forgive me, mum.
23
00:01:04,960 --> 00:01:08,119
I swear I only chose this path to help others.
24
00:01:11,901 --> 00:01:14,061
As Israel has bombed Gaza,
hundreds of Palestinian doctors
25
00:01:14,061 --> 00:01:19,061
and medics have refused
to leave their hospitals.
26
00:01:21,581 --> 00:01:24,861
We are in the theatre,
in the operating room.
27
00:01:24,861 --> 00:01:25,941
Full darkness.
28
00:01:25,941 --> 00:01:27,101
No water, no electricity.
29
00:01:27,101 --> 00:01:32,101
But we have a hero -
surgeons in Gaza.
30
00:01:32,181 --> 00:01:34,741
SIREN WAILS
31
00:01:34,741 --> 00:01:36,181
Homes, schools
and universities have been
32
00:01:36,181 --> 00:01:41,181
destroyed, killing and injuring
tens of thousands.
33
00:01:43,701 --> 00:01:46,861
But from the first day of the war,
Israel attacked the one thing
34
00:01:46,861 --> 00:01:51,750
Palestinians needed most -
its healthcare system.
35
00:01:51,760 --> 00:01:53,719
We're in the orthopaedic ward,
36
00:01:53,920 --> 00:01:55,439
it's full of injured.
37
00:01:56,400 --> 00:01:59,879
Three rooms filled with patients
were blown up, and the ceiling fell on them.
38
00:02:03,621 --> 00:02:06,021
21 months on, and every
one of Gaza's 36 main
39
00:02:06,021 --> 00:02:11,701
hospitals has been attacked,
forced to evacuate or destroyed.
40
00:02:11,701 --> 00:02:16,461
Bam!
41
00:02:16,461 --> 00:02:19,101
And Israel has been killing the very
people trying to keep
42
00:02:19,101 --> 00:02:21,501
the healthcare system alive -
its doctors and medics -
43
00:02:21,501 --> 00:02:23,141
despite hospitals and healthcare
workers being protected
44
00:02:23,141 --> 00:02:28,181
under international law.
45
00:02:28,661 --> 00:02:29,941
He got injured.
46
00:02:29,941 --> 00:02:34,941
They shooted at us
in the operating room.
47
00:02:37,141 --> 00:02:42,141
Israel claims Hamas uses hospitals
as part of its military strategy.
48
00:02:43,301 --> 00:02:46,221
Hundreds of healthcare
workers have been killed.
49
00:02:46,221 --> 00:02:48,861
Hundreds have been detained.
50
00:02:48,861 --> 00:02:53,181
Many of them have been
forcibly disappeared.
51
00:02:53,181 --> 00:02:55,341
This film is a forensic
investigation into Israeli military
52
00:02:55,341 --> 00:02:57,461
attacks on hospitals in Gaza,
and allegations of targeting
53
00:02:57,461 --> 00:03:02,501
and abuse of doctors
and healthcare workers.
54
00:03:04,741 --> 00:03:07,341
Our Palestinian team on the ground
have gathered testimony from health
55
00:03:07,341 --> 00:03:10,430
workers and their families.
56
00:03:10,440 --> 00:03:16,680
They hung me up, everyone was hung up,
57
00:03:16,681 --> 00:03:17,520
blood flowing from everyone.
58
00:03:17,781 --> 00:03:19,701
And Israeli whistle-blowers have
told us they've witnessed
59
00:03:19,701 --> 00:03:21,581
Palestinian prisoners being tortured
and that some Israeli
60
00:03:21,581 --> 00:03:31,581
medics are complicit.
61
00:03:31,941 --> 00:03:34,301
I don't even think that
in the Israeli society, there
62
00:03:34,301 --> 00:03:36,261
is a need for a cover-up these days.
63
00:03:36,261 --> 00:03:41,261
You can do almost whatever you want
when it comes to Gazans.
64
00:04:03,701 --> 00:04:06,141
Sderot is an Israeli
town bordering Gaza.
65
00:04:06,141 --> 00:04:09,261
It was raided by Hamas militants
on October 7th and at least 70
66
00:04:09,261 --> 00:04:14,301
people were killed here.
67
00:04:17,981 --> 00:04:21,581
SHOUTING
68
00:04:21,581 --> 00:04:26,581
DANCE MUSIC
69
00:04:27,621 --> 00:04:29,301
In total,
around 1,200 people were killed
70
00:04:29,301 --> 00:04:31,661
by Hamas and other militant groups,
and 251 were taken
71
00:04:31,661 --> 00:04:36,701
as hostages into Gaza.
72
00:04:37,221 --> 00:04:41,501
MAN SHOUTS: Allahu Akbar!
73
00:04:41,501 --> 00:04:43,821
Israelis have been coming to this
vantage point in Sderot
74
00:04:43,821 --> 00:04:46,981
to pay their respects to the dead...
75
00:04:46,981 --> 00:04:51,941
..and to watch Gaza being attacked.
76
00:04:51,941 --> 00:04:54,581
For over a week, Israeli forces have
been raiding northern Gaza,
77
00:04:54,581 --> 00:04:57,861
especially Jabalia refugee camp,
which you can see from here.
78
00:04:57,861 --> 00:05:02,861
There have been reports of over 300
Palestinians have been killed.
79
00:05:03,421 --> 00:05:07,781
We just heard a massive boom and saw
the smoke rising behind us.
80
00:05:07,781 --> 00:05:12,541
And reports just coming in now,
Israeli Air Force has bombed
81
00:05:12,541 --> 00:05:17,101
the Al-Falah Medical Centre
in Jabalia, northern Gaza.
82
00:05:17,101 --> 00:05:22,101
Another medical centre
that's been attacked.
83
00:05:22,981 --> 00:05:25,381
At the start of the war,
the Israeli Army targeted
84
00:05:25,381 --> 00:05:30,381
Gaza's largest hospital,
Al-Shifa.
85
00:05:40,621 --> 00:05:42,261
The hospital was already
overwhelmed with casualties
86
00:05:42,261 --> 00:05:47,301
from strikes on Gaza City.
87
00:05:47,921 --> 00:05:51,400
Medical teams worked around the clock.
88
00:05:54,301 --> 00:05:58,511
Mohammad Abu Salmiya
was the hospital's director.
89
00:05:58,521 --> 00:05:59,960
The situation was extremely difficult.
90
00:06:00,561 --> 00:06:04,200
We saw injured people with wounds
that began to rot.
91
00:06:04,521 --> 00:06:06,400
We were unable to change their bandages.
92
00:06:12,661 --> 00:06:16,661
In early October, there
were close to 150 specialists
93
00:06:16,661 --> 00:06:19,461
working at Al-Shifa,
among them two orthopaedic surgeons,
94
00:06:19,461 --> 00:06:24,461
Mohammed Obeid and Adnan Al Bursh,
seen here on the left.
95
00:06:28,081 --> 00:06:29,240
Do you go to kindergarten?
96
00:06:30,241 --> 00:06:34,521
I was with Dr Adnan 24/7 in the same department.
97
00:06:35,802 --> 00:06:41,321
The fear was overwhelming,
the medical teams were terrified.
98
00:06:43,762 --> 00:06:53,441
We felt we were being targeted to weaken
the resolve of the people in northern Gaza.
99
00:07:06,781 --> 00:07:08,421
Al-Shifa became a symbolic
target for Israel.
100
00:07:08,421 --> 00:07:12,221
The Israeli military
claimed there was a Hamas
101
00:07:12,221 --> 00:07:14,381
command centre beneath it,
and even released this video
102
00:07:14,381 --> 00:07:19,381
animation of what it
said it looked like.
103
00:07:20,261 --> 00:07:22,701
CCTV footage was later released
by the Israeli Defense Forces,
104
00:07:22,701 --> 00:07:24,581
the IDF, showing two injured
hostages being rushed
105
00:07:24,581 --> 00:07:29,581
into the hospital by Hamas
militants on October the 7th.
106
00:07:36,381 --> 00:07:38,541
The IDF's bombing campaign
was driving tens of thousands
107
00:07:38,541 --> 00:07:43,541
of displaced people to seek refuge
in and around Al-Shifa.
108
00:07:50,661 --> 00:07:53,861
Israel had cut off electricity
and water to the Gaza Strip.
109
00:07:53,861 --> 00:07:58,861
Hospital generators were quickly
running out of fuel.
110
00:07:59,981 --> 00:08:03,221
We are in the theatre,
in the operating room.
111
00:08:03,221 --> 00:08:06,421
Full darkness, no
water, no electricity.
112
00:08:06,421 --> 00:08:10,781
But we have a hero -
surgeons in Gaza.
113
00:08:10,781 --> 00:08:12,901
We are working now in surgery
with chargeable light,
114
00:08:12,901 --> 00:08:17,941
with manual ventilation.
115
00:08:21,941 --> 00:08:24,341
The Israeli Army dropped thousands
of leaflets ordering the population
116
00:08:24,341 --> 00:08:26,741
of northern Gaza to move south,
and issued evacuation orders
117
00:08:26,741 --> 00:08:31,781
for hospitals in the north.
118
00:08:36,362 --> 00:08:40,241
We ignored these messages as we could
not forget that we work at al-Shifa Hospital.
119
00:08:40,482 --> 00:08:44,441
Because it was the backbone
of the entire health system in Gaza.
120
00:08:45,282 --> 00:08:50,521
By stopping al-Shifa from operating,
you have disabled the whole health system in Gaza.
121
00:08:50,922 --> 00:08:56,121
As we did not abide by the messages
they started sending us rockets
122
00:08:57,541 --> 00:08:59,261
SIRENS WAIL
123
00:08:59,261 --> 00:09:04,261
EXPLOSION
124
00:09:06,661 --> 00:09:07,701
On November 3rd,
125
00:09:07,701 --> 00:09:10,341
an Israeli strike hit a convoy
of ambulances exiting the hospital.
126
00:09:10,341 --> 00:09:14,581
The Palestinian Red Crescent said
15 people were killed.
127
00:09:14,581 --> 00:09:18,341
At least 60 were injured.
128
00:09:18,341 --> 00:09:20,261
The Israeli Army claimed
the ambulances were transporting
129
00:09:20,261 --> 00:09:25,301
Hamas militants, but it did not
provide any evidence of this.
130
00:09:30,541 --> 00:09:32,701
Three days later, the hospital's
solar panels were struck,
131
00:09:32,701 --> 00:09:35,061
destroying one of its last sources
of energy and killing
132
00:09:35,061 --> 00:09:40,101
at least one person.
133
00:09:46,581 --> 00:09:50,061
SCREAMING
134
00:09:50,061 --> 00:09:51,941
On November 10th,
a tank shell hit tents
135
00:09:51,941 --> 00:09:55,941
outside the hospital.
136
00:09:55,941 --> 00:09:59,261
It was the first of several strikes
on the hospital complex in 24 hours,
137
00:09:59,261 --> 00:10:04,301
including on a maternity ward.
138
00:10:06,501 --> 00:10:11,501
Within days, Israeli troops had
completely surrounded the hospital.
139
00:10:11,803 --> 00:10:16,442
We were under siege in al-Shifa
Hospital for 12 days.
140
00:10:16,763 --> 00:10:21,522
A huge number of displaced people
and medical staff fled the hospital after that.
141
00:10:22,123 --> 00:10:26,202
But some stayed to treat the injured...
142
00:10:26,683 --> 00:10:32,322
like myself and Dr Adnan Al Bursh.
143
00:10:35,981 --> 00:10:37,621
Hospital administrators said
there wasn't enough fuel
144
00:10:37,621 --> 00:10:42,501
to keep generators running.
145
00:10:42,501 --> 00:10:45,741
As a result, at least 40
patients died, including
146
00:10:45,741 --> 00:10:49,461
four premature babies.
147
00:10:49,461 --> 00:10:54,221
Doctor Adnan Al Bursh joined medical
staff to dig a mass grave.
148
00:10:59,381 --> 00:11:03,021
The IDF finally raided Al-Shifa.
149
00:11:03,021 --> 00:11:05,181
It failed to provide sufficient
evidence showing the existence
150
00:11:05,181 --> 00:11:08,621
of a key Hamas command centre,
and Israel has continually
151
00:11:08,621 --> 00:11:13,621
prevented access for
an independent investigation.
152
00:11:14,781 --> 00:11:18,701
Patients who could began
to leave the hospital.
153
00:11:18,701 --> 00:11:21,421
They were accompanied
by around 60 medical staff,
154
00:11:21,421 --> 00:11:25,873
including surgeons Adnan Al Bursh
and Mohammed Obeid.
155
00:11:25,883 --> 00:11:29,962
Honestly, this is a difficult sight to behold.
156
00:11:30,323 --> 00:11:34,602
This is Dr Adnan, may God protect us.
157
00:11:35,101 --> 00:11:37,941
The route led to the south of Gaza,
but there weren't enough
158
00:11:37,941 --> 00:11:39,221
doctors in the north.
159
00:11:39,443 --> 00:11:45,162
I was scared to walk in the other direction
because snipers might shoot at me.
160
00:11:47,123 --> 00:11:51,882
But I knew the majority of the injured
would need bone surgery,
161
00:11:51,883 --> 00:11:55,722
so orthopaedic surgeons ought to stay
in the north of Gaza.
162
00:11:56,301 --> 00:11:58,941
As soon as they could,
Doctors Al Bursh and Obeid left
163
00:11:58,941 --> 00:12:03,941
the IDF-ordered route and headed
north to the Indonesian Hospital.
164
00:12:12,341 --> 00:12:16,341
The war had separated
Adnan Al Bursh from his wife,
165
00:12:16,341 --> 00:12:19,633
Yasmine, and their children.
166
00:12:19,643 --> 00:12:20,402
Hi Adnan.
167
00:12:20,403 --> 00:12:22,122
Good morning, good morning.
168
00:12:22,523 --> 00:12:23,642
Tell me how you are,
169
00:12:25,203 --> 00:12:26,842
and where are you now, Adnan?
170
00:12:27,643 --> 00:12:29,242
I am now at the Indonesian Hospital.
171
00:12:30,643 --> 00:12:32,162
Are they going to transfer you to the South?
172
00:12:32,483 --> 00:12:34,322
I am not going to the South.
173
00:12:36,003 --> 00:12:39,722
My husband told me I am staying in the hospital,
174
00:12:40,403 --> 00:12:42,882
and I will get you and the children to a safe place
at your uncle's house.
175
00:12:43,203 --> 00:12:47,002
Because if the Occupation commits a crime,
we'd all be gone.
176
00:12:48,203 --> 00:12:51,242
If our fate is to die, it should be just me,
not you or the children.
177
00:12:51,243 --> 00:12:54,562
We do not want to be erased like many
other families have been.
178
00:13:02,661 --> 00:13:04,781
But the Indonesian Hospital
and its vicinity was also
179
00:13:04,781 --> 00:13:09,941
targeted by the IDF.
180
00:13:09,941 --> 00:13:12,581
Again, the IDF said a Hamas tunnel
complex lay beneath it...
181
00:13:12,581 --> 00:13:15,181
..and also that rockets had been
launched from sites close by.
182
00:13:15,181 --> 00:13:21,941
CHILD SCREAMS
183
00:13:23,221 --> 00:13:26,861
Dr Al Bursh's ward
was struck on November 20th.
184
00:13:26,861 --> 00:13:28,741
This footage, broadcast
on Al Jazeera, shows him
185
00:13:28,741 --> 00:13:33,781
injured after the attack.
186
00:13:35,301 --> 00:13:40,301
12 patients on the ward were killed.
187
00:13:41,341 --> 00:13:43,701
Three days later, the Israeli Army
issued evacuation orders, then
188
00:13:43,701 --> 00:13:47,861
raided and shut down the hospital.
189
00:13:47,861 --> 00:13:52,061
Dr Al Bursh was on the move again.
190
00:13:52,061 --> 00:13:53,941
He joined Dr Obeid
at Al Awda Hospital,
191
00:13:53,941 --> 00:13:58,981
their third in short succession.
192
00:14:00,221 --> 00:14:05,261
This hospital had come under Israeli
attack just days before.
193
00:14:05,341 --> 00:14:10,381
SHOUTING
194
00:14:19,701 --> 00:14:21,101
Nine months
later, Al Awda Hospital
195
00:14:21,101 --> 00:14:26,141
was partially functioning.
196
00:14:26,564 --> 00:14:27,683
It's all good.
197
00:14:29,284 --> 00:14:31,911
When was the last time he had it changed?
198
00:14:32,021 --> 00:14:36,021
Dr Mohammed Obeid was
still working there.
199
00:14:37,181 --> 00:14:39,781
During a lull in the fighting,
he told us about the
200
00:14:39,781 --> 00:14:42,724
attacks on the hospital.
201
00:14:42,734 --> 00:14:45,323
This is the third floor.
202
00:14:46,164 --> 00:14:48,003
It's a very painful memory,
203
00:14:48,724 --> 00:14:52,123
this area was full of patients,
204
00:14:52,124 --> 00:14:54,603
and this is where the counter was
for the duty doctors.
205
00:14:54,884 --> 00:14:56,643
And three doctors were killed here,
206
00:14:56,964 --> 00:15:01,763
Dr Mahmoud Abu Nejaila, Dr Ahmed Sahar
and Dr Ziad Tatar.
207
00:15:05,741 --> 00:15:08,141
Two weeks after the ward
was hit, Dr Obeid says
208
00:15:08,141 --> 00:15:13,141
the Israeli Army gave the director
of the hospital an ultimatum.
209
00:15:14,964 --> 00:15:22,483
They told us they have a full record of
every single person in the hospital
210
00:15:23,004 --> 00:15:27,443
and if anyone stayed, they might
either destroy it or kill the women and children.
211
00:15:32,301 --> 00:15:34,541
Dr Al Bursh made a final
call to his family.
212
00:15:35,084 --> 00:15:36,843
Are you good?
Yes.
213
00:15:37,364 --> 00:15:38,243
Happy?
214
00:15:38,364 --> 00:15:39,243
Yes.
215
00:15:39,444 --> 00:15:40,923
Oh, where is Elen?
216
00:15:41,964 --> 00:15:44,683
Here is Elen, come talk to your dad.
217
00:15:45,884 --> 00:15:48,123
Come on, before the Jews [Israelis] come.
218
00:15:49,684 --> 00:15:53,323
Elen, where are you, I've missed you.
219
00:15:53,844 --> 00:15:55,683
Dad, come stay with us.
220
00:15:55,684 --> 00:15:57,523
Yes, I will come to you tomorrow.
221
00:15:59,444 --> 00:16:00,603
Take care of your mum.
222
00:16:02,484 --> 00:16:04,323
At that moment, I felt my heart
beating out of my chest.
223
00:16:05,484 --> 00:16:07,283
The fear overcame me.
224
00:16:07,764 --> 00:16:11,003
He is going out to the army,
I do not know what they'll do to him,
225
00:16:11,684 --> 00:16:13,123
will they beat him or detain him?
226
00:16:13,124 --> 00:16:15,083
I'm not used to being separated from him.
227
00:16:17,581 --> 00:16:19,981
There is no footage
of Adnan Al Bursh being seized,
228
00:16:19,981 --> 00:16:21,901
but Al Jazeera obtained these
pictures showing men
229
00:16:21,901 --> 00:16:25,461
stripped to their underwear
in the vicinity of the hospital.
230
00:16:25,461 --> 00:16:28,941
We don't know if there are any
medics in these pictures.
231
00:16:29,325 --> 00:16:32,404
We all went outside the hospital for interrogation.
232
00:16:33,245 --> 00:16:35,124
Within five minutes,
233
00:16:36,325 --> 00:16:40,084
soldiers came and took Dr Adnan Al Bursh
after calling his name.
234
00:16:40,605 --> 00:16:45,124
Dr Adnan stood up, and showing no fear,
235
00:16:45,125 --> 00:16:46,764
he walked away with them.
236
00:16:46,885 --> 00:16:53,164
But he looked directly at me
as if he was saying goodbye.
237
00:16:54,205 --> 00:16:57,404
That was the last time I saw Dr Adnan Al Bursh.
238
00:17:06,821 --> 00:17:08,501
Like hospitals, medics are given
extensive protections
239
00:17:08,501 --> 00:17:13,501
under international law,
regardless of their political views.
240
00:17:13,981 --> 00:17:16,101
The Israeli Army said
Dr Al Bursh was arrested
241
00:17:16,101 --> 00:17:18,101
on suspicion of terrorism.
242
00:17:18,101 --> 00:17:21,661
They provided no evidence of this.
243
00:17:21,661 --> 00:17:24,501
Dr Al Bursh praised the October 7th
attacks at the time,
244
00:17:24,501 --> 00:17:27,621
and has been supportive of militant
groups in the past, like some other
245
00:17:27,621 --> 00:17:32,661
doctors in this film.
246
00:17:36,421 --> 00:17:39,221
Following three of the hospital
raids that we've investigated,
247
00:17:39,221 --> 00:17:41,861
we found that medics were taken
to locations human rights groups
248
00:17:41,861 --> 00:17:46,861
have described to us as black sites,
where there's no judicial oversight.
249
00:17:47,541 --> 00:17:51,621
HE GIVES ORDERS
250
00:17:51,621 --> 00:17:53,061
Footage of the sites is rare,
251
00:17:53,061 --> 00:17:56,221
but this was filmed by a member
of the IDF in a football
252
00:17:56,221 --> 00:17:58,061
stadium in Gaza City,
and was posted online
253
00:17:58,061 --> 00:17:59,741
in December 2023.
254
00:17:59,741 --> 00:18:01,901
We can't confirm if medics
are in these images,
255
00:18:01,901 --> 00:18:04,021
but thousands of Palestinians have
been taken to these
256
00:18:04,021 --> 00:18:09,061
sites, including medics.
257
00:18:14,101 --> 00:18:16,261
We travelled to Ramallah,
in the occupied West Bank,
258
00:18:16,261 --> 00:18:21,261
to meet Budour Hassan,
an Amnesty International researcher.
259
00:18:24,541 --> 00:18:28,221
Now, you've been investigating
black sites in Gaza.
260
00:18:28,221 --> 00:18:31,141
What are these black
sites being used for?
261
00:18:31,141 --> 00:18:33,301
In these sites, the soldiers have
absolutely complete power
262
00:18:33,301 --> 00:18:35,661
to abuse, to torture,
to hit, to humiliate the detainee,
263
00:18:35,661 --> 00:18:40,701
without any oversight.
264
00:18:45,461 --> 00:18:47,821
What can you tell me
about the detainment of Palestinian
265
00:18:47,821 --> 00:18:51,781
doctors and healthcare workers?
266
00:18:51,781 --> 00:18:54,941
So, if there is one characteristic
for which this war has stood out
267
00:18:54,941 --> 00:18:56,781
it's the systematic targeting
of the Palestinian healthcare
268
00:18:56,781 --> 00:19:05,061
sector in the Gaza Strip.
269
00:19:05,061 --> 00:19:09,701
We're not talking about 10, 20, 30,
40 healthcare workers.
270
00:19:09,701 --> 00:19:13,541
We're talking about
hundreds of detainees.
271
00:19:13,541 --> 00:19:15,941
Israeli authorities would say that
maybe these healthcare workers know
272
00:19:15,941 --> 00:19:18,261
some information about hostages,
or they knew information about Hamas
273
00:19:18,261 --> 00:19:23,301
fighters being treated.
274
00:19:24,781 --> 00:19:26,701
But on many occasions,
these doctors are probably
275
00:19:26,701 --> 00:19:31,301
interrogated just once or twice -
and that's it.
276
00:19:31,301 --> 00:19:35,141
The torture and unlawful treatment
to which healthcare workers
277
00:19:35,141 --> 00:19:37,261
are subjected is evident intent
of the Israeli authorities
278
00:19:37,261 --> 00:19:42,301
to destroy Palestinians.
279
00:19:47,941 --> 00:19:51,101
So there is also an element
of genocidal intent.
280
00:19:51,101 --> 00:19:53,221
And destroying the healthcare
sector, basically taking it out
281
00:19:53,221 --> 00:19:55,341
of service through different means -
not always necessarily
282
00:19:55,341 --> 00:19:57,501
by directly attacking them,
but by also detaining hundreds
283
00:19:57,501 --> 00:20:02,541
of healthcare workers.
284
00:20:07,261 --> 00:20:10,701
Budour says she's identified
at least four black sites so far.
285
00:20:10,701 --> 00:20:13,101
So, do you think there
are other black sites that
286
00:20:13,101 --> 00:20:14,981
you haven't heard about,
that you haven't been
287
00:20:14,981 --> 00:20:18,141
able to identify?
288
00:20:18,141 --> 00:20:20,981
I think what we were able
to identify is just a drop
289
00:20:20,981 --> 00:20:26,021
in an ocean of horror.
290
00:20:37,461 --> 00:20:40,101
This image of a black
site was posted online.
291
00:20:40,101 --> 00:20:42,541
We've been told the four
men in the foreground
292
00:20:42,541 --> 00:20:45,541
are all healthcare workers.
293
00:20:45,541 --> 00:20:47,501
One of them is now in Egypt.
294
00:20:47,501 --> 00:20:50,301
You are one of these men.
295
00:20:50,301 --> 00:20:51,901
Which one are you?
296
00:20:51,901 --> 00:20:53,101
This is who I am.
297
00:20:53,101 --> 00:20:54,421
You're that one?
298
00:20:54,421 --> 00:20:55,621
Yes.
299
00:20:55,621 --> 00:20:57,981
VOICEOVER: Khaled Hamouda
is a specialist surgeon.
300
00:20:57,981 --> 00:20:59,621
It was shocking.
301
00:20:59,621 --> 00:21:02,141
I mean, this is really shocking.
302
00:21:02,141 --> 00:21:03,181
Yes.
303
00:21:03,181 --> 00:21:08,181
It looks apocalyptic.
304
00:21:08,661 --> 00:21:11,301
And later, you said that
you were put into this pit?
305
00:21:11,301 --> 00:21:13,221
It's a huge hole,
you know, very high.
306
00:21:13,221 --> 00:21:15,821
A month before this picture
was taken, Dr Hamouda was working
307
00:21:15,821 --> 00:21:17,781
at the Indonesian Hospital.
308
00:21:17,781 --> 00:21:20,421
After it was attacked and shut down
by the Israeli Army,
309
00:21:20,421 --> 00:21:22,541
he was forced to move
to Kamal Adwan Hospital,
310
00:21:22,541 --> 00:21:24,061
a short walk from his home.
311
00:21:24,061 --> 00:21:26,421
This is your home?
312
00:21:26,421 --> 00:21:28,581
This is where I live.
313
00:21:28,581 --> 00:21:29,581
OK.
314
00:21:29,581 --> 00:21:31,381
Our building, it's three floors.
315
00:21:31,381 --> 00:21:33,021
Yeah.
316
00:21:33,021 --> 00:21:34,901
He shared the building
with his extended family,
317
00:21:34,901 --> 00:21:37,861
three of whom were doctors.
318
00:21:37,861 --> 00:21:42,861
He says they were the only
occupants of the building.
319
00:21:44,301 --> 00:21:47,461
On December 3rd, 2023, his house
was hit by a direct air strike.
320
00:21:47,461 --> 00:21:51,286
Ten of Khaled Hamouda's
family were killed.
321
00:21:51,296 --> 00:21:54,005
Most of my family were killed,
322
00:21:54,966 --> 00:21:59,165
Also my older brother, 38 years old,
323
00:21:59,166 --> 00:22:03,045
And my younger brother, Dr Mohammed,
and my uncle and his wife.
324
00:22:03,766 --> 00:22:07,085
My son, Ahmed, and I were injured.
325
00:22:07,446 --> 00:22:11,645
But my wife and my two daughters
were not injured and we sent them outside.
326
00:22:14,861 --> 00:22:17,221
So, can you tell us what happened
after they attacked
327
00:22:17,221 --> 00:22:18,261
it, where you went?
328
00:22:18,261 --> 00:22:20,181
We moved away about
30m - here, exactly.
329
00:22:20,181 --> 00:22:21,261
Mm-hm.
330
00:22:21,261 --> 00:22:22,461
In front of this building.
331
00:22:22,461 --> 00:22:24,581
So all these buildings
were still standing and only
332
00:22:24,581 --> 00:22:25,661
your building was hit?
333
00:22:25,661 --> 00:22:26,701
Yes.
334
00:22:26,701 --> 00:22:28,141
So you ran up the street?
335
00:22:28,141 --> 00:22:29,181
Yes.
336
00:22:29,181 --> 00:22:30,221
Up to another building?
337
00:22:30,221 --> 00:22:32,821
We thought we were safe now,
because the air strike finished
338
00:22:32,821 --> 00:22:34,061
and the building almost destroyed.
339
00:22:34,061 --> 00:22:35,141
Yes.
340
00:22:35,141 --> 00:22:37,981
And about ten of you sat outside
this building in the road?
341
00:22:37,981 --> 00:22:40,101
Yes.
342
00:22:40,101 --> 00:22:41,781
And that's when a drone strike hit?
343
00:22:41,781 --> 00:22:45,821
Yes.
344
00:22:46,326 --> 00:22:51,166
My family and I, my wife and my children,
345
00:22:51,247 --> 00:22:52,686
we were attacked at that very moment...
346
00:22:53,127 --> 00:22:55,886
I have no doubt it was intentional.
347
00:22:57,741 --> 00:22:58,781
Khaled Hamouda was injured.
348
00:22:58,781 --> 00:23:02,381
He was taken to
Kamal Adwan Hospital.
349
00:23:03,407 --> 00:23:07,086
I was shocked to see one of the nurses who
I worked with carrying my daughter.
350
00:23:17,647 --> 00:23:23,486
She was carrying my daughter, Reem,
she was dead.
351
00:23:26,367 --> 00:23:29,126
That was the moment I knew
she had been killed.
352
00:23:50,847 --> 00:23:53,846
I recognised her from her clothes.
353
00:23:55,687 --> 00:23:59,966
I asked the nurse to come closer
so I could see her face.
354
00:23:59,967 --> 00:24:03,446
She asked if I knew her.
I said, "Yes, she is my daughter."
355
00:24:07,887 --> 00:24:11,246
My daughter...
356
00:24:11,247 --> 00:24:13,046
She said, "She was dead on arrival."
357
00:24:17,047 --> 00:24:20,246
My wife's body was retrieved from the street,
358
00:24:20,247 --> 00:24:24,726
and I was told the following morning
that I lost my wife too.
359
00:24:26,861 --> 00:24:29,221
The two strikes killed 12 members
of Khaled Hamouda's family,
360
00:24:29,221 --> 00:24:31,701
a family of doctors.
361
00:24:32,567 --> 00:24:36,366
I don't know where they were buried,
I never saw them again.
362
00:24:40,541 --> 00:24:45,101
We asked the IDF why they targeted
Khaled Hamouda's family home.
363
00:24:45,101 --> 00:24:48,501
They did not respond
to this question.
364
00:24:48,501 --> 00:24:50,901
Khaled Hamouda and his surviving
family joined thousands of others
365
00:24:50,901 --> 00:24:52,781
taking refuge in the grounds
of his workplace,
366
00:24:52,781 --> 00:25:00,301
Kamal Adwan Hospital.
367
00:25:02,061 --> 00:25:04,421
For a week, the hospital
was bombarded, before being raided
368
00:25:04,421 --> 00:25:09,461
and then forcibly evacuated.
369
00:25:11,021 --> 00:25:16,021
The UN says Israeli soldiers
detained over 70 medics.
370
00:25:16,021 --> 00:25:18,381
Khaled was amongst them,
and was separated from his two
371
00:25:18,381 --> 00:25:19,301
surviving children.
372
00:25:21,901 --> 00:25:23,781
The Israeli Army said
they had detained 90
373
00:25:23,781 --> 00:25:25,741
terrorists during the raids -
including the hospital
374
00:25:25,741 --> 00:25:27,901
director, whom they claimed
was a Hamas operative -
375
00:25:27,901 --> 00:25:30,741
and again said that the hospital
was being used as a command
376
00:25:30,741 --> 00:25:32,061
and control centre.
377
00:25:42,221 --> 00:25:43,421
This is Kamal Adwan Hospital.
378
00:25:43,421 --> 00:25:45,301
They took us, we walk
all the street.
379
00:25:45,301 --> 00:25:46,381
Yeah.
380
00:25:46,381 --> 00:25:48,501
And they ask the doctors
to sit down there.
381
00:25:48,501 --> 00:25:49,581
Mm-hm.
382
00:25:49,581 --> 00:25:51,917
It's here where Khaled
was photographed.
383
00:25:51,927 --> 00:25:54,806
We thought they were genuinely going to
transport us to another place,
384
00:25:54,807 --> 00:25:58,046
because they kept us separated from civilians.
385
00:25:58,367 --> 00:26:01,606
But within an hour,
they mixed us with the civilians again.
386
00:26:07,568 --> 00:26:11,087
There was a soldier or an officer behind the camera
387
00:26:11,568 --> 00:26:17,287
who decides who goes right or left.
388
00:26:18,608 --> 00:26:22,887
I thought I was one of the lucky ones
to be told to go to the left.
389
00:26:22,888 --> 00:26:27,807
Of course, I say this sarcastically.
390
00:26:27,808 --> 00:26:29,967
As it turned out,
left was the side for detention.
391
00:26:32,461 --> 00:26:37,221
Khaled says he was taken to an
adjacent building and interrogated.
392
00:26:37,688 --> 00:26:39,887
Surprisingly, he became more interested
393
00:26:39,888 --> 00:26:42,167
when I said I am a surgeon at the
Indonesian Hospital.
394
00:26:42,608 --> 00:26:45,847
He shook has head and called for someone
to take me away.
395
00:26:47,128 --> 00:26:50,287
And he began to beat me.
396
00:26:54,221 --> 00:26:57,101
After eight hours, where he says
he and others were violently beaten,
397
00:26:57,101 --> 00:27:00,781
Dr Hamouda was then
transported to Israel.
398
00:27:00,781 --> 00:27:02,941
The forcible transfer of prisoners
across borders is prohibited
399
00:27:02,941 --> 00:27:07,821
under international law.
400
00:27:07,821 --> 00:27:11,181
The IDF told us that those found not
to be involved in terrorist activity
401
00:27:11,181 --> 00:27:16,821
are released as soon as possible.
402
00:27:17,368 --> 00:27:21,047
I was handcuffed and blindfolded
403
00:27:21,248 --> 00:27:23,727
and I was taken and thrown In the truck.
404
00:27:24,328 --> 00:27:27,447
It was an inhuman situation.
405
00:27:32,621 --> 00:27:34,981
Barely a week after his daughter
and wife were killed,
406
00:27:34,981 --> 00:27:37,581
Dr Hamouda was in Israeli detention.
407
00:27:37,581 --> 00:27:40,421
He says he was held in stress
positions, and on one occasion
408
00:27:40,421 --> 00:27:44,221
forced to grip barbed wire.
409
00:27:44,221 --> 00:27:46,621
Dr Hamouda has expressed support
for Hamas on social media,
410
00:27:46,621 --> 00:27:48,981
including the attacks on October
7th, and mourning a relative
411
00:27:48,981 --> 00:27:54,021
who was a senior Hamas commander.
412
00:27:54,821 --> 00:27:58,141
After three weeks,
he was released without charge.
413
00:28:01,621 --> 00:28:04,981
The IDF told us they rejected
the claims made on the use of black
414
00:28:04,981 --> 00:28:07,581
sites to avoid judicial oversight,
as well as claims regarding enforced
415
00:28:07,581 --> 00:28:12,061
disappearances, and that they follow
international and Israeli law.
416
00:28:28,461 --> 00:28:31,101
In the occupied West Bank,
we meet academic Dr Layth Hanbali,
417
00:28:31,101 --> 00:28:34,901
from the research centre
The Institute for Palestine Studies.
418
00:28:34,901 --> 00:28:37,061
He's been tracking Israel's attacks
on Gaza's healthcare system,
419
00:28:37,061 --> 00:28:38,461
using data collected
by the organisation
420
00:28:38,461 --> 00:28:42,421
Healthcare Workers Watch.
421
00:28:42,421 --> 00:28:44,781
They've documented the deaths
of 118 doctors, 65 of them
422
00:28:44,781 --> 00:28:50,221
killed in their own homes.
423
00:28:50,221 --> 00:28:52,381
We've heard of incidents
where doctors have been hit
424
00:28:52,381 --> 00:28:53,421
while in their homes.
425
00:28:53,421 --> 00:28:56,261
Are these just accidents?
426
00:28:56,261 --> 00:28:59,421
So, the Israeli Army claims to use
precise strikes in order to target
427
00:28:59,421 --> 00:29:00,821
identified either terrorists
or terrorist infrastructure,
428
00:29:00,821 --> 00:29:08,261
and that it aims to minimise
unintended casualties.
429
00:29:08,261 --> 00:29:11,541
And so, whether it's
because the Israeli Army has
430
00:29:11,541 --> 00:29:13,661
deliberately chosen to assassinate
those individuals, or because it
431
00:29:13,661 --> 00:29:16,341
doesn't care that it kills them
and it considers them collateral
432
00:29:16,341 --> 00:29:19,461
damage, it has made a choice to kill
them, whether it's collateral damage
433
00:29:19,461 --> 00:29:24,501
or whether it's assassination.
434
00:29:27,101 --> 00:29:30,381
The massive loss of expertise
will take years to rebuild.
435
00:29:30,381 --> 00:29:32,301
Structures can be built very
quickly, but healthcare
436
00:29:32,301 --> 00:29:36,581
professionals require years
to be trained.
437
00:29:36,581 --> 00:29:39,021
And so that's going to
have a massively detrimental effect
438
00:29:39,021 --> 00:29:44,021
on the health of the Palestinian
population for years to come.
439
00:29:52,421 --> 00:29:54,541
By January 2024, Gaza's Ministry
of Health calculated that
440
00:29:54,541 --> 00:29:55,981
over 23,000 Palestinians
had been killed...
441
00:29:55,981 --> 00:29:58,621
..and the UN estimated that 60%
of Gaza's homes had been
442
00:29:58,621 --> 00:30:03,661
damaged or destroyed.
443
00:30:07,621 --> 00:30:13,021
Only 13 out of Gaza's 36
hospitals were functioning.
444
00:30:13,021 --> 00:30:14,941
With Al-Shifa shut down,
the largest medical facility
445
00:30:14,941 --> 00:30:19,941
operating in Gaza was now
Nasser Hospital in the south.
446
00:30:30,621 --> 00:30:33,221
Our colleague Jaber Badwan has been
meeting the families of medics
447
00:30:33,221 --> 00:30:38,341
who have been killed,
detained or disappeared.
448
00:30:38,369 --> 00:30:40,408
This is what he'd wear for surgery.
449
00:30:41,101 --> 00:30:44,701
One of them is a missing surgeon
called Khaled Al Serr.
450
00:30:44,701 --> 00:30:49,021
He was taken from Nasser Hospital
by the IDF in March 2024.
451
00:30:50,741 --> 00:30:53,821
This is Khaled's mother, Kawther.
452
00:30:54,289 --> 00:30:58,048
Khaled is my youngest child,
453
00:30:59,009 --> 00:31:00,568
my sixth.
454
00:31:00,809 --> 00:31:03,848
He studied medicine in Gaza,
455
00:31:04,129 --> 00:31:05,688
and he was among the top students.
456
00:31:06,369 --> 00:31:11,768
Two months before the war started,
he was in the UK.
457
00:31:13,861 --> 00:31:15,221
This is Khaled's brother, Wael.
458
00:31:19,489 --> 00:31:21,808
What do you think happened to him?
459
00:31:22,649 --> 00:31:26,968
There were no traces of them or
anything connected to Khaled.
460
00:31:27,849 --> 00:31:30,968
We had many frightening thoughts.
461
00:31:32,649 --> 00:31:37,488
There are many people who lost their loved ones
and their children,
462
00:31:38,249 --> 00:31:40,648
they may find them buried somewhere...
463
00:31:41,809 --> 00:31:44,168
or thrown onto another street.
464
00:31:49,129 --> 00:31:52,008
My darling, I miss you,
I miss hugging you,
465
00:32:00,621 --> 00:32:03,821
We travelled to Egypt in September
2024 to meet a doctor who'd been
466
00:32:03,821 --> 00:32:05,981
with Khaled Al Serr at Nasser
Hospital.
467
00:32:05,981 --> 00:32:07,621
Ahmed Moghrabi was the only
reconstructive surgeon
468
00:32:07,621 --> 00:32:11,181
left in southern Gaza.
469
00:32:11,181 --> 00:32:12,621
OK.
470
00:32:12,621 --> 00:32:14,501
Hello, my friend, again
from the operating room.
471
00:32:14,501 --> 00:32:17,661
I have one child, two years old.
472
00:32:17,661 --> 00:32:19,701
You were in Nasser
with Dr Khaled Al Serr.
473
00:32:19,701 --> 00:32:20,461
Can you tell me about him?
474
00:32:22,329 --> 00:32:30,328
Dr Khaled Al Serr is one of the best
doctors at our hospital.
475
00:32:31,169 --> 00:32:36,289
He did his best to serve the
hospital until the last minute.
476
00:32:38,090 --> 00:32:41,969
Today this case, I have operated
on a three-year-old child
477
00:32:42,570 --> 00:32:45,809
who got shot with a small shrapnel.
478
00:32:46,370 --> 00:32:50,249
We have been besieged by Israeli
tanks surrounding all the hospital,
479
00:32:52,250 --> 00:32:55,729
from all directions, we are
forbidden from going outside.
480
00:32:57,621 --> 00:33:00,021
The Israeli Army had
surrounded Nasser for weeks.
481
00:33:00,021 --> 00:33:01,701
Like thousands of other
Palestinians, Dr Moghrabi
482
00:33:01,701 --> 00:33:05,301
and his family were sheltering
at the hospital.
483
00:33:05,301 --> 00:33:08,461
EXPLOSIONS
484
00:33:08,461 --> 00:33:12,461
They are bombing.
485
00:33:12,461 --> 00:33:14,581
The IDF began striking
the hospital and its vicinity
486
00:33:14,581 --> 00:33:18,701
and cutting off supplies.
487
00:33:18,701 --> 00:33:21,101
It's a really crime,
it's a really crime.
488
00:33:21,101 --> 00:33:25,200
They attacked a very populated area.
489
00:33:25,210 --> 00:33:29,049
Dead bodies of these children, see?
Massacre, massacre.
490
00:33:34,181 --> 00:33:37,781
Displaced people here
cannot cross this road.
491
00:33:37,781 --> 00:33:39,901
Ahmed Moghrabi filmed people
being targeted by Israeli snipers
492
00:33:39,901 --> 00:33:43,781
at the hospital gate.
493
00:33:43,781 --> 00:33:45,021
It's a child.
494
00:33:45,021 --> 00:33:46,901
ON VIDEO: As you see,
just dead body.
495
00:33:46,901 --> 00:33:48,381
So that's the entrance of Nasser.
496
00:33:48,381 --> 00:33:49,421
This is the entrance.
497
00:33:49,421 --> 00:33:52,421
Right.
498
00:33:52,421 --> 00:33:54,781
Dr Moghrabi captured this moment
after an armed drone shot
499
00:33:54,781 --> 00:34:01,141
a nurse on his ward.
500
00:34:04,810 --> 00:34:08,209
I turned my camera towards him.
501
00:34:08,210 --> 00:34:12,529
The other nurses heard him
screaming and they ran to him.
502
00:34:12,530 --> 00:34:14,849
He was shot in the right side of his chest.
503
00:34:19,261 --> 00:34:20,461
Allahu Akbar.
504
00:34:20,461 --> 00:34:23,301
During this period, hospital staff
told us that at least 14 people
505
00:34:23,301 --> 00:34:26,421
were killed by snipers or drones.
506
00:34:26,421 --> 00:34:29,781
A mass grave was dug for them
and the many others who had died
507
00:34:29,781 --> 00:34:33,541
in the hospital grounds -
just as in Al-Shifa.
508
00:34:40,941 --> 00:34:42,341
The Israeli military
said Nasser Hospital
509
00:34:42,341 --> 00:34:45,341
was being used to hide hostages.
510
00:34:45,341 --> 00:34:47,941
A number of freed hostages say
they were held at Nasser
511
00:34:47,941 --> 00:34:51,781
until they were released.
512
00:34:51,781 --> 00:34:53,381
Did you ever see any hostages
being held at Nasser?
513
00:34:56,730 --> 00:34:59,929
I didn't see any Israeli hostages.
514
00:35:00,690 --> 00:35:05,609
When I arrived, I went to the operating theatre
and stayed working from there.
515
00:35:05,690 --> 00:35:11,089
Even if doctors in any hospitals
like in al-Shifa, Nasser or others
516
00:35:11,930 --> 00:35:14,289
dealt with the hostages and treated them...
517
00:35:14,290 --> 00:35:19,929
does that mean for saving the life of
a hostage or treating one,
518
00:35:19,930 --> 00:35:23,049
you should be killed or interrogated?
519
00:35:24,861 --> 00:35:27,181
On February 15th, both
Doctors Moghrabi and Khaled Al Serr
520
00:35:27,181 --> 00:35:29,301
were working when Israeli forces
shelled and then finally
521
00:35:29,301 --> 00:35:34,341
raided the hospital.
522
00:35:35,530 --> 00:35:41,809
I started looking for my wife and kids,
523
00:35:42,450 --> 00:35:44,929
and found the third floor was full of smoke.
524
00:35:48,061 --> 00:35:49,541
Khaled Al Serr was on the ward.
525
00:35:49,931 --> 00:35:54,090
A few minutes ago they warned
the hospital through loudspeakers
526
00:35:54,091 --> 00:35:57,290
to evacuate before they blow it up.
527
00:35:57,931 --> 00:36:01,690
Three rooms filled with patients
were blown up, and the ceiling fell on them.
528
00:36:04,211 --> 00:36:08,770
Dr Khaled was one of the doctors...
529
00:36:09,531 --> 00:36:13,050
insisting on staying in the hospital
until the very last minute.
530
00:36:18,101 --> 00:36:18,941
Dr Moghrabi fled with his family.
531
00:36:19,011 --> 00:36:21,850
I said when I get the chance,
I'm going to go for it.
532
00:36:23,571 --> 00:36:27,290
They are going to raid the hospital
and either detain or kill us.
533
00:36:28,371 --> 00:36:32,170
That was the first time I took off my scrubs.
534
00:36:34,981 --> 00:36:38,341
Dr Moghrabi says he and his family
had to pass through an Israeli Army
535
00:36:38,341 --> 00:36:39,981
checkpoint where soldiers
were searching out medical
536
00:36:39,981 --> 00:36:42,821
staff, amongst others.
537
00:36:43,971 --> 00:36:48,570
I warned everyone not to say that I am a doctor.
538
00:36:48,931 --> 00:36:54,570
When it was our turn, I went with my wife and
children and stood in front of the camera.
539
00:36:56,171 --> 00:37:00,130
I was surprised that the Israeli soldier
told us to pass.
540
00:37:03,661 --> 00:37:05,541
Dr Moghrabi believes
that he and his family
541
00:37:05,541 --> 00:37:07,221
managed to escape only
because he removed his scrubs.
542
00:37:13,901 --> 00:37:16,541
After days of continuous war
in Gaza, the Israeli Army invaded
543
00:37:16,541 --> 00:37:21,541
the hospital by soldiers
and by tanks, bulldozers.
544
00:37:23,661 --> 00:37:25,821
They displaced all the healthcare
workers and all patients
545
00:37:25,821 --> 00:37:30,821
from all the buildings to be
condensed into one department.
546
00:37:35,181 --> 00:37:37,301
Inside the hospital,
Dr Khaled Al Serr was filming
547
00:37:37,301 --> 00:37:39,421
the patients who remained.
548
00:37:39,421 --> 00:37:44,101
Israeli soldiers then
rounded people up.
549
00:37:44,101 --> 00:37:49,101
Like in other hospital raids,
Palestinians are stripped and bound.
550
00:37:50,821 --> 00:37:55,381
Even patients still
in their beds are zip-tied.
551
00:37:57,781 --> 00:38:00,221
The IDF said that it had
arrested around 200 people,
552
00:38:00,221 --> 00:38:05,261
including what it described
as terrorists who posed as medics.
553
00:38:06,901 --> 00:38:09,261
According to the Ministry
of Health in Gaza, 70 medics
554
00:38:09,261 --> 00:38:12,781
were detained during the raid.
555
00:38:12,781 --> 00:38:15,621
The IDF withdrew, while Dr Al Serr
and the remaining staff tried
556
00:38:15,621 --> 00:38:20,661
to keep the hospital running.
557
00:38:23,061 --> 00:38:28,101
But weeks later, they raided again.
558
00:38:29,821 --> 00:38:34,421
This time, Dr Khaled
Al Serr was taken.
559
00:38:38,341 --> 00:38:40,741
According to the UN,
the attacks on the hospitals we've
560
00:38:40,741 --> 00:38:42,661
investigated appear to follow
a pattern of assault
561
00:38:42,661 --> 00:38:47,661
that the Israeli Army has been
replicating across Gaza.
562
00:38:48,421 --> 00:38:50,341
This United Nations report,
published in December 2024,
563
00:38:50,341 --> 00:38:54,701
sets out the pattern
generally being used.
564
00:38:54,701 --> 00:38:59,101
First, the Army strikes hospital
buildings and surroundings.
565
00:38:59,101 --> 00:39:01,501
Then it besieges the hospital with
ground troops, preventing access
566
00:39:01,501 --> 00:39:06,541
and blocking medical supplies.
567
00:39:06,701 --> 00:39:09,861
It raids the hospital,
often using tanks and bulldozers.
568
00:39:09,861 --> 00:39:11,581
It detains medical staff,
patients and displaced people
569
00:39:11,581 --> 00:39:15,621
sheltering in the hospital.
570
00:39:16,901 --> 00:39:19,341
It then forces anyone
remaining to leave.
571
00:39:19,341 --> 00:39:20,981
And finally, Israeli troops
withdraw, effectively rendering
572
00:39:20,981 --> 00:39:26,021
the hospital non-functional.
573
00:39:27,781 --> 00:39:30,661
It is a war crime to attack civilian
hospitals unless they're used
574
00:39:30,661 --> 00:39:33,501
to commit acts harmful to the enemy,
but even then, any response
575
00:39:33,501 --> 00:39:38,541
must be proportionate.
576
00:39:40,261 --> 00:39:44,381
In response to the UN report,
Israel said, "Hamas has chosen
577
00:39:44,381 --> 00:39:45,781
to methodically abuse
the protection of
578
00:39:45,781 --> 00:39:47,261
medical facilities.
579
00:39:47,261 --> 00:39:48,901
Hamas embeds its tunnel
system and infrastructure
580
00:39:48,901 --> 00:39:51,301
within the premises."
581
00:39:51,301 --> 00:39:55,981
And so Israel says their operations
are therefore "legally justifiable".
582
00:40:04,901 --> 00:40:07,061
As we're gathering testimonies
from medics and their families
583
00:40:07,061 --> 00:40:08,981
in Gaza about how they're
being targeted, we're
584
00:40:08,981 --> 00:40:10,861
also collecting evidence
about what happens once they're
585
00:40:10,861 --> 00:40:15,901
brought here to Israel.
586
00:40:18,181 --> 00:40:20,101
In the occupied West Bank,
lawyer Khaled Zabarga
587
00:40:20,101 --> 00:40:25,101
is representing ten detained
healthcare workers from Gaza.
588
00:40:28,132 --> 00:40:34,611
I will be visiting three prisoners from Gaza.
589
00:40:35,292 --> 00:40:37,171
This is prison of the army.
590
00:40:38,661 --> 00:40:40,581
His clients are being
held in Ofer Prison.
591
00:40:40,581 --> 00:40:43,181
For the first seven months
of the war, Israel prevented lawyers
592
00:40:43,181 --> 00:40:46,341
communicating with detainees.
593
00:40:46,341 --> 00:40:48,981
Now they can apply to visit
after 90 days of detention,
594
00:40:48,981 --> 00:40:53,061
but very few applications
have been approved.
595
00:40:53,612 --> 00:40:59,331
Usually, the first visit is difficult because
it happens after a long period of being cut off.
596
00:41:00,132 --> 00:41:06,411
The prisoner will ask many questions about
his family and children.
597
00:41:07,132 --> 00:41:09,651
So the first visit is always difficult.
598
00:41:15,741 --> 00:41:20,741
We can't go in with him, but this
is footage from inside the prison.
599
00:41:20,892 --> 00:41:22,000
We're done.
600
00:41:22,010 --> 00:41:22,452
PRISONER SCREAMS
601
00:41:22,452 --> 00:41:23,731
There are the terrorists inside.
602
00:41:24,092 --> 00:41:25,701
They are resisting.
603
00:41:25,711 --> 00:41:27,621
On the anniversary
of the October 7th attacks,
604
00:41:27,621 --> 00:41:30,781
Israel's Channel 13 filmed a raid
on Ofer Prison by the Israel Prison
605
00:41:30,781 --> 00:41:35,781
Service, in what they said
was a search for weapons.
606
00:41:36,532 --> 00:41:39,211
Another terrorist being brought inside.
607
00:41:40,932 --> 00:41:42,771
They are all terrorists who participate
in the massacre.
608
00:41:42,772 --> 00:41:45,811
All of them have blood
on their hands.
609
00:41:49,461 --> 00:41:51,341
Later that evening,
we met with Khaled Zabarga
610
00:41:51,341 --> 00:41:54,501
on his return from Ofer Prison.
611
00:41:54,501 --> 00:41:56,581
He said his client showed signs
of physical and mental torture.
612
00:42:00,092 --> 00:42:04,571
He sand some detainees were stripped
and sexually assaulted.
613
00:42:04,572 --> 00:42:12,051
They used sticks and forced them
614
00:42:12,052 --> 00:42:17,491
into the detainees' anus
and caused an internal bleed.
615
00:42:17,852 --> 00:42:28,492
Other detainees had broken skulls and
other parts, clue to the beating and torture.
616
00:42:28,493 --> 00:42:39,252
The detainee also sand that after being tortured
he saw other prisoners die before his eyes.
617
00:42:39,973 --> 00:42:44,212
As a result of their torture, they died.
618
00:42:47,781 --> 00:42:50,701
We put these allegations to the IDF,
and they didn't respond.
619
00:42:58,501 --> 00:43:01,101
There had been no sightings
of Khaled Al Serr, the missing
620
00:43:01,101 --> 00:43:04,861
surgeon from Nasser Hospital...
621
00:43:04,861 --> 00:43:07,021
..until this video was posted
of a hospital administrator
622
00:43:07,021 --> 00:43:08,901
called Ahmed Al Kel,
who had just been
623
00:43:08,901 --> 00:43:10,221
released from prison.
624
00:43:13,333 --> 00:43:16,492
One of my colleagues
next to me called Khaled [Al-Serr],
625
00:43:16,493 --> 00:43:19,852
his beard was plucked with pliers
in front of my eyes...
626
00:43:20,333 --> 00:43:21,292
his beard was plucked.
627
00:43:21,773 --> 00:43:24,532
He is one of hundreds I know of.
628
00:43:30,021 --> 00:43:33,221
Like thousands of Palestinians,
the two men had been transferred
629
00:43:33,221 --> 00:43:36,541
from black sites in Gaza
to detention centres in Israel.
630
00:43:36,541 --> 00:43:41,541
Khaled Al Serr had been held at
a military base called Sde Teiman.
631
00:43:51,061 --> 00:43:53,421
That, in the distance,
is the Sde Teiman military facility.
632
00:43:53,421 --> 00:43:55,141
We're not going to get any closer.
633
00:43:55,141 --> 00:43:57,541
Now, originally, it was a military
base and vehicle warehouse,
634
00:43:57,541 --> 00:44:00,221
but after the 7th October Hamas
attacks, it was quickly converted
635
00:44:00,221 --> 00:44:04,701
into an interrogation site housing
hundreds of Palestinian prisoners.
636
00:44:04,701 --> 00:44:09,701
It's now become notorious after
reports of torture, rape and abuse.
637
00:44:15,781 --> 00:44:18,141
Israel's Channel 12 broadcast
a leaked video purporting to show
638
00:44:18,141 --> 00:44:22,901
a gang rape at Sde Teiman.
639
00:44:22,901 --> 00:44:25,501
The victim's injuries were
so severe, he was taken to hospital
640
00:44:25,501 --> 00:44:29,141
for emergency surgery.
641
00:44:31,621 --> 00:44:33,541
When nine soldiers were arrested,
ultranationalist Israelis stormed
642
00:44:33,541 --> 00:44:37,461
Sde Teiman demanding their release.
643
00:44:39,701 --> 00:44:43,501
Five of those soldiers
were later charged with abuse.
644
00:44:43,501 --> 00:44:44,621
CHANTING
645
00:44:44,621 --> 00:44:46,261
Some Israeli politicians
debated whether the rape
646
00:44:46,261 --> 00:44:48,821
of prisoners should be allowed.
647
00:44:49,893 --> 00:44:54,252
Is it legitimate to insert a stick into a person's rectum?
648
00:44:54,253 --> 00:44:56,812
Yes. If he is a Hamas militant everything
is legitimate. Everything!
649
00:44:56,813 --> 00:44:58,572
Everything!
650
00:45:07,981 --> 00:45:10,101
There's been hardly any
testimony from soldiers
651
00:45:10,101 --> 00:45:12,461
stationed at Sde Teiman,
but we've found one soldier willing
652
00:45:12,461 --> 00:45:13,981
to talk about what he saw.
653
00:45:13,981 --> 00:45:16,061
But he says he can only
do this anonymously
654
00:45:16,061 --> 00:45:21,101
because he feels under threat.
655
00:45:24,341 --> 00:45:26,741
Even before going there,
I had heard rumours of what...
656
00:45:26,741 --> 00:45:29,141
..you know, what was done
to detainees there, with either
657
00:45:29,141 --> 00:45:31,021
people bragging about physically
abusing them or sort
658
00:45:31,021 --> 00:45:36,061
of joking about it.
659
00:45:38,461 --> 00:45:40,821
They would say, like,
to me that I would have
660
00:45:40,821 --> 00:45:45,101
to physically abuse detainees.
661
00:45:45,101 --> 00:45:47,421
Can you tell me about
the detainees who were doctors
662
00:45:47,421 --> 00:45:48,501
or healthcare workers?
663
00:45:48,501 --> 00:45:51,341
There were a lot of detainees that
were known to be detained
664
00:45:51,341 --> 00:45:55,261
from the hospitals in Gaza.
665
00:45:55,261 --> 00:45:57,861
And the main reason, I was told,
that they were detained
666
00:45:57,861 --> 00:46:00,061
is that they possibly witnessed
hostages either being transported
667
00:46:00,061 --> 00:46:05,061
to places or being given care
in hospitals in Gaza.
668
00:46:09,821 --> 00:46:11,501
Did you ever witness
detainees being abused?
669
00:46:11,501 --> 00:46:15,261
Yeah.
670
00:46:15,261 --> 00:46:17,621
Soldiers that were enthusiastic
to get their hands on detainees.
671
00:46:17,621 --> 00:46:19,661
What do you mean by that?
672
00:46:19,661 --> 00:46:22,861
Even among commanders,
one of the incidents in which, like,
673
00:46:22,861 --> 00:46:26,021
one of the soldiers which had beaten
a detainee, he wouldn't shut up
674
00:46:26,021 --> 00:46:28,581
about it, and I recall
the commander being in on it
675
00:46:28,581 --> 00:46:33,621
and showing his respect for that.
676
00:46:36,261 --> 00:46:38,421
From what you're saying,
it sounds like this behaviour
677
00:46:38,421 --> 00:46:39,821
wasn't just tolerated,
it was encouraged.
678
00:46:39,821 --> 00:46:43,261
Yeah, yeah.
679
00:46:43,261 --> 00:46:45,901
In those sort of circles,
people that guard the detainees sort
680
00:46:45,901 --> 00:46:48,261
of view themselves as fighters
or something, and I think
681
00:46:48,261 --> 00:46:53,261
this whole experience
was still viewed as pretty just.
682
00:46:58,741 --> 00:47:01,461
What do you think about that now?
683
00:47:01,461 --> 00:47:03,541
I mean, it was shocking.
684
00:47:03,541 --> 00:47:07,941
I'm deeply ashamed.
685
00:47:13,461 --> 00:47:18,461
CHILDREN CHATTER
686
00:47:18,581 --> 00:47:20,021
Our producer,
Jaber Badwan, interviewed several
687
00:47:20,021 --> 00:47:21,901
medics who'd been held
at Sde Teiman, then
688
00:47:21,901 --> 00:47:26,941
released back into Gaza.
689
00:47:31,221 --> 00:47:32,421
Walid Khalili is a paramedic.
690
00:47:32,421 --> 00:47:37,181
This is him at Al-Shifa
hospital in 2023.
691
00:47:38,221 --> 00:47:40,861
The Palestine Red Crescent Society
says 27 of their paramedics have
692
00:47:40,861 --> 00:47:45,861
been killed while on duty
since October 2023.
693
00:47:48,021 --> 00:47:50,381
34 of their ambulances have been
taken out of service
694
00:47:50,381 --> 00:47:53,541
due to Israeli attacks.
695
00:47:53,541 --> 00:47:55,661
Walid Khalili was arrested
while on a rescue mission
696
00:47:55,661 --> 00:47:57,541
and taken to Sde Teiman,
and later transferred
697
00:47:57,541 --> 00:48:00,821
to another prison.
698
00:48:01,374 --> 00:48:07,573
When I arrived at Sde Teiman prison,
I was in a bad way, my ribs were broken.
699
00:48:08,294 --> 00:48:12,013
But inside during interrogation they would
continuously beat me.
700
00:48:12,294 --> 00:48:14,013
I went into a room,
701
00:48:14,134 --> 00:48:15,813
he took off my boxers and put diapers on me.
702
00:48:16,734 --> 00:48:18,533
I was in diapers the whole time.
703
00:48:19,494 --> 00:48:24,253
They hung me up, everyone was hung up,
704
00:48:24,654 --> 00:48:26,613
blood flowing from everyone.
705
00:48:27,734 --> 00:48:29,933
They started torturing me, they electrocuted me...
706
00:48:29,934 --> 00:48:31,973
“Say that you are Hamas! You are Hamas!”
707
00:48:34,694 --> 00:48:35,613
Like this.
708
00:48:35,614 --> 00:48:38,133
You see how I'm sitting?
709
00:48:39,174 --> 00:48:40,893
When it was time to eat, it was like this.
710
00:48:43,054 --> 00:48:46,773
For the duration of my detention,
my hands were bound all the time.
711
00:48:49,175 --> 00:48:52,574
Some people had their hands amputated.
712
00:48:59,935 --> 00:49:03,094
She should be 4kg for her age.
713
00:49:04,335 --> 00:49:09,574
And she needs 400ml of milk every day.
714
00:49:10,901 --> 00:49:12,421
Dr Saeed Marouf is a paediatrician.
715
00:49:12,421 --> 00:49:14,101
He's back treating Gaza's
wounded and malnourished
716
00:49:14,101 --> 00:49:16,381
children at Nasser Hospital,
now partially functioning.
717
00:49:21,055 --> 00:49:23,774
How much weight has he lost?
718
00:49:26,621 --> 00:49:29,781
According to the United Nations,
much of Gaza has been on the brink
719
00:49:29,781 --> 00:49:34,365
of famine because of Israel's severe
restrictions on aid.
720
00:49:34,375 --> 00:49:36,014
You'll get better...
721
00:49:36,015 --> 00:49:38,254
Tell me what you want, we'll get it for you.
722
00:49:38,615 --> 00:49:39,814
Grapes and mangoes.
723
00:49:40,095 --> 00:49:41,374
Did you hear what he said?
724
00:49:41,535 --> 00:49:43,174
He wants grapes and mangoes.
725
00:49:46,541 --> 00:49:50,941
Dr Marouf was detained for 45 days,
mostly at Sde Teiman.
726
00:49:52,055 --> 00:49:53,974
Tell me what happened, in detail?
727
00:49:54,335 --> 00:49:58,534
He'd tell us to sit on our knees for the whole day.
728
00:50:00,415 --> 00:50:01,574
“Sit on your knees!”
729
00:50:02,175 --> 00:50:07,214
You can bear it for half an hour, maybe two
but not 40 or 50 days or two months,
730
00:50:07,895 --> 00:50:08,894
It destroys you.
731
00:50:09,735 --> 00:50:12,694
We were blindfolded and handcuffed
for the whole time.
732
00:50:15,855 --> 00:50:16,574
It's very difficult.
733
00:50:16,855 --> 00:50:19,814
Doctor, I can see the difficulty you're dealing with.
734
00:50:20,175 --> 00:50:21,294
It's tough...
735
00:50:24,135 --> 00:50:25,494
It was really tough...
736
00:50:28,455 --> 00:50:29,534
bear with me.
737
00:50:40,061 --> 00:50:42,701
General Surgeon Issam Abu Ajwa
and his whole team were taken
738
00:50:42,701 --> 00:50:47,701
from the operating theatre
in Al-Ahli Baptist Hospital.
739
00:50:51,341 --> 00:50:53,821
He makes shocking allegations
about his 137 days in Sde Teiman.
740
00:50:56,255 --> 00:51:01,374
One of the interrogators would
bring the toilet cleaning brush,
741
00:51:02,215 --> 00:51:04,214
and tell me, “I want to brush
your teeth with it.”
742
00:51:04,215 --> 00:51:05,814
And he broke my front teeth, here.
743
00:51:08,495 --> 00:51:15,534
Another interrogator got some pliers
and pulled my fingernail out.
744
00:51:17,381 --> 00:51:20,261
Dr Abu Ajwa makes a shocking
allegation that others have told us
745
00:51:20,261 --> 00:51:22,621
- that some Israeli medics refuse
to treat Palestinian prisoners
746
00:51:22,621 --> 00:51:27,661
and even physically abuse them.
747
00:51:29,735 --> 00:51:34,574
Some paramedics, especially the doctors,
were violent towards us.
748
00:51:35,975 --> 00:51:37,534
I experienced this myself.
749
00:51:38,415 --> 00:51:47,014
On one occasion, due to the pain,
I was not able to move at all,
750
00:51:47,015 --> 00:51:49,334
I asked for the doctor again.
751
00:51:49,335 --> 00:51:53,974
The doctor came and he literally told me,
752
00:51:53,975 --> 00:51:57,734
“You're a criminal, and you have to die.”
753
00:51:58,135 --> 00:52:02,294
He then started to hit me on my legs.
754
00:52:02,695 --> 00:52:10,175
Then he said, “If you ask for me again,
I am going to end your life.”
755
00:52:10,776 --> 00:52:15,455
I told him, “At the end of the day
you are a doctor.”
756
00:52:15,776 --> 00:52:19,215
He replied, “I am a doctor, but you are a criminal.”
757
00:52:26,341 --> 00:52:28,981
We spoke to Israeli medics
who confirmed that some doctors had
758
00:52:28,981 --> 00:52:31,581
mistreated Palestinian detainees,
but they were all too scared to go
759
00:52:31,581 --> 00:52:37,421
on camera for fear of retribution.
760
00:52:40,501 --> 00:52:42,861
Finally, one doctor who'd been
stationed at Sde Teiman's field
761
00:52:42,861 --> 00:52:44,541
hospital, among others,
agreed to meet on
762
00:52:44,541 --> 00:52:49,501
condition of anonymity.
763
00:52:49,501 --> 00:52:52,141
I remember at least one case
where a very painful procedure
764
00:52:52,141 --> 00:52:57,101
was being done and the patient
got no consent.
765
00:52:57,101 --> 00:52:59,261
Things were not explained
to him in his language,
766
00:52:59,261 --> 00:53:03,741
so he didn't know what was going on.
767
00:53:03,741 --> 00:53:07,741
And, to the best of my knowledge,
no painkillers were administered
768
00:53:07,741 --> 00:53:10,261
to him around that procedure.
769
00:53:10,261 --> 00:53:12,381
And I was there.
770
00:53:12,381 --> 00:53:14,501
I saw that happening,
and I saw him screaming,
771
00:53:14,501 --> 00:53:18,941
and I saw no-one stopping it.
772
00:53:18,941 --> 00:53:20,821
And why do you think
this was happening?
773
00:53:20,821 --> 00:53:25,541
Why weren't they using
anaesthetic on this patient?
774
00:53:25,541 --> 00:53:28,381
Well, I think that was retribution.
775
00:53:28,381 --> 00:53:32,701
Like, that was a way
to inflict pain.
776
00:53:32,701 --> 00:53:37,261
So the scary part is how
I could not recognise that.
777
00:53:37,261 --> 00:53:40,901
When I saw that, and I recognise how
I have normalised the fact that even
778
00:53:40,901 --> 00:53:42,781
those patients are defined
and are called just
779
00:53:42,781 --> 00:53:47,901
by a five-digit number.
780
00:53:47,901 --> 00:53:52,901
They don't have a name,
they don't move.
781
00:53:54,461 --> 00:53:57,621
They are blindfolded, so you do not
look at them in the eyes.
782
00:53:57,621 --> 00:54:00,421
So you're taking a lot
of the humanity and the empathy that
783
00:54:00,421 --> 00:54:01,501
you might feel away.
784
00:54:01,501 --> 00:54:04,661
So there is no doubt that,
in many ways, I am an accomplice,
785
00:54:04,661 --> 00:54:09,661
as well as an Israeli physician,
to how we have been treating Gazans.
786
00:54:14,141 --> 00:54:16,301
Were you given any guidelines,
or were you briefed
787
00:54:16,301 --> 00:54:20,621
about the parameters
within which you could work?
788
00:54:20,621 --> 00:54:22,981
The only guidelines that we see
is about, like, keeping
789
00:54:22,981 --> 00:54:25,701
ourselves anonymous.
790
00:54:25,701 --> 00:54:28,101
Just because they wouldn't
want their names coming out to,
791
00:54:28,101 --> 00:54:30,021
let's say, foreign countries
and foreign journalists just
792
00:54:30,021 --> 00:54:35,701
because they might be liable,
potentially, of war crimes.
793
00:54:35,701 --> 00:54:37,181
What happens if you speak out?
794
00:54:37,181 --> 00:54:42,181
Well, I might be
viewed as a traitor.
795
00:54:42,181 --> 00:54:44,581
So in this atmosphere,
where people are scared to speak
796
00:54:44,581 --> 00:54:49,581
out, do you think this
is causing a cover-up?
797
00:54:51,941 --> 00:54:54,301
I don't even think that
in the Israeli society, there
798
00:54:54,301 --> 00:54:56,261
is a need for a cover-up these days.
799
00:54:56,261 --> 00:55:00,461
You can do almost whatever you want
when it comes to Gazans.
800
00:55:00,461 --> 00:55:02,821
Honestly, I think that's how
the Israeli society has been
801
00:55:02,821 --> 00:55:07,781
dehumanising Palestinians for years.
802
00:55:07,781 --> 00:55:09,181
It didn't start on October 7th.
803
00:55:09,181 --> 00:55:14,181
It's nothing new.
804
00:55:15,861 --> 00:55:18,261
The IDF and the Israel Prison
Service did not respond
805
00:55:18,261 --> 00:55:22,861
to the allegation that Israeli
doctors mistreated detainees.
806
00:55:22,861 --> 00:55:27,621
But the IDF said detainees can
request medical care.
807
00:55:30,501 --> 00:55:34,261
Dr Khaled Hamouda had also been
detained at Sde Teiman.
808
00:55:34,261 --> 00:55:36,141
His detention had coincided
with another doctor -
809
00:55:36,141 --> 00:55:39,261
the surgeon from Al-Shifa Hospital,
Adnan Al Bursh.
810
00:55:44,177 --> 00:55:46,896
I immediately noticed him.
He was with a group of doctors.
811
00:55:47,581 --> 00:55:48,901
What was Adnan's state of mind like?
812
00:55:51,221 --> 00:55:52,497
Did he look healthy to you?
813
00:55:52,507 --> 00:55:53,936
Not at all.
814
00:55:54,297 --> 00:55:58,936
It was clear he had been beaten and tortured.
815
00:55:59,137 --> 00:56:02,936
So much so that I used to take him to the
toilet and bring him back.
816
00:56:03,457 --> 00:56:07,456
He told me that he was assaulted on
his way here from the hospital.
817
00:56:07,457 --> 00:56:11,736
Likely in similar conditions to when I was detained,
and repeatedly beaten.
818
00:56:11,937 --> 00:56:16,416
I believe that Dr Adnan was treated differently
from the other detainees and even doctors,
819
00:56:17,097 --> 00:56:21,216
maybe because he was the Head of
Orthopaedics at al-Shifa Hospital.
820
00:56:24,421 --> 00:56:27,021
In mid-April, Dr Adnan Al Bursh
was transferred to Ofer Prison.
821
00:56:27,021 --> 00:56:28,981
He died on the day of his arrival.
822
00:56:34,301 --> 00:56:36,261
What did you think when you heard
Adnan had died in prison?
823
00:56:38,977 --> 00:56:42,856
I don't lake the word died.
He was murdered, he was killed.
824
00:56:43,737 --> 00:56:46,576
In one way or another it was
as a result of torture.
825
00:56:52,861 --> 00:56:55,261
Testimony from other prisoners
provided to an Israeli human rights
826
00:56:55,261 --> 00:56:57,861
group describes prison guards
beating Dr Al Bursh and throwing him
827
00:56:57,861 --> 00:57:00,741
to the ground before his death.
828
00:57:00,741 --> 00:57:03,381
The Israel Prison Service says
it is not aware of any
829
00:57:03,381 --> 00:57:06,541
of the claims made in this film,
and the IDF says they act
830
00:57:06,541 --> 00:57:08,861
in accordance with international
law, and the abuse of detainees
831
00:57:08,861 --> 00:57:13,901
is strictly prohibited.
832
00:57:18,341 --> 00:57:20,181
Israeli documents show that
65 Palestinians have died
833
00:57:20,181 --> 00:57:25,221
in its detention since October 2023.
834
00:57:25,861 --> 00:57:28,501
Along with Adnan Al Bursh,
there are at least three other
835
00:57:28,501 --> 00:57:29,941
healthcare workers -
Dr Iyad al-Rantisi,
836
00:57:29,941 --> 00:57:34,661
head of obstetrics at
Kamal Adwan Hospital,
837
00:57:34,661 --> 00:57:39,661
Dr Ziad Al-Dalou from
Al-Shifa Hospital,
838
00:57:40,221 --> 00:57:45,261
and paramedic Hamdan Abu Anaba.
839
00:57:53,701 --> 00:57:55,581
In October 2024, Israeli forces
launched another ground
840
00:57:55,581 --> 00:58:04,901
invasion of northern Gaza.
841
00:58:04,901 --> 00:58:06,821
They issued evacuation orders
to the remaining 400,000
842
00:58:06,821 --> 00:58:14,781
Palestinians and cut
all aid reaching them.
843
00:58:14,781 --> 00:58:19,781
Once again, Kamal Adwan, Al-Awda,
and the Indonesian Hospitals came
844
00:58:20,261 --> 00:58:23,541
under attack, and the UN
Secretary-General warned
845
00:58:23,541 --> 00:58:28,541
the world it needed to act
to prevent ethnic cleansing.
846
00:58:32,421 --> 00:58:35,861
But the plan to clear
northern Gaza was delayed.
847
00:58:35,861 --> 00:58:38,261
The director of Kamal Adwan
Hospital, Dr Hussam Abu Safiya,
848
00:58:38,261 --> 00:58:43,261
was one of several doctors refusing
to leave his patients.
849
00:58:47,021 --> 00:58:50,101
Here he is standing next
to Dr Mohammed Obeid.
850
00:58:51,418 --> 00:58:55,657
What the people of northern Gaza
are facing is a real genocide.
851
00:58:55,658 --> 00:58:59,097
The health system
has completely collapsed.
852
00:59:04,261 --> 00:59:05,861
Allahu Akbar.
853
00:59:05,861 --> 00:59:10,861
In late October, following another
raid, an Israeli drone strike
854
00:59:11,141 --> 00:59:12,221
killed his son, Ibrahim.
855
00:59:12,221 --> 00:59:12,981
The next day, he spoke
to Al Jazeera.
856
00:59:13,978 --> 00:59:17,617
Everything that we've built, they've burned.
857
00:59:18,178 --> 00:59:22,737
They've burned our hearts
and killed my son.
858
00:59:31,021 --> 00:59:32,701
After more than two
months under attack,
859
00:59:32,701 --> 00:59:36,581
and with the hospital in flames,
it was forced to finally close.
860
00:59:36,581 --> 00:59:38,981
Israel says it detained over
200 militants in the area,
861
00:59:38,981 --> 00:59:41,141
but the hospital says Israel
detained many healthcare workers,
862
00:59:41,141 --> 00:59:46,181
like Dr Abu Safiya.
863
00:59:51,221 --> 00:59:54,381
This is the last time he was seen
in Gaza by his colleagues,
864
00:59:54,381 --> 01:00:00,781
walking towards an Israeli tank.
865
01:00:00,781 --> 01:00:03,381
Dr Abu Safiya was taken
to Sde Teiman, and is now
866
01:00:03,381 --> 01:00:07,661
being held in Ofer Prison.
867
01:00:07,661 --> 01:00:11,301
Israel accuses him of
having a rank in Hamas.
868
01:00:11,301 --> 01:00:13,221
In March 2025, an Israeli
court classified him
869
01:00:13,221 --> 01:00:15,141
as an unlawful combatant,
and ordered his continued
870
01:00:15,141 --> 01:00:20,141
imprisonment without
charge or trial.
871
01:00:21,021 --> 01:00:23,901
His lawyer says he's not a terrorist
and that he's been held
872
01:00:23,901 --> 01:00:25,541
in solitary confinement,
shown signs of torture,
873
01:00:25,541 --> 01:00:30,581
and denied proper medical care.
874
01:00:31,061 --> 01:00:32,741
Having worked through four
separate hospital sieges,
875
01:00:32,741 --> 01:00:34,621
Dr Mohammed Obeid was taken
by Israeli soldiers
876
01:00:34,621 --> 01:00:39,461
on October 26th, 2024.
877
01:00:39,461 --> 01:00:41,181
He is still being held.
878
01:00:41,181 --> 01:00:44,501
Over a year after his death,
the body of Adnan Al Bursh has not
879
01:00:44,501 --> 01:00:47,901
been returned to his family in Gaza.
880
01:00:56,701 --> 01:00:59,341
After more than six months
in detention, Dr Khaled Al Serr,
881
01:00:59,341 --> 01:01:01,261
the surgeon who stayed
on at Nasser Hospital
882
01:01:01,261 --> 01:01:06,261
through the worst,
returned to his family.
883
01:01:12,021 --> 01:01:14,621
Like all of those doctors we've
spoken to detained by Israel,
884
01:01:14,621 --> 01:01:19,661
he was released without charge.
885
01:01:21,941 --> 01:01:26,021
And like all of those doctors,
Khaled Al Serr says he was tortured.
886
01:01:28,781 --> 01:01:33,781
Dr Al Serr was released a year
after the war began.
887
01:01:34,941 --> 01:01:37,821
A war in which over 1,500 healthcare
workers have reportedly been killed,
888
01:01:37,821 --> 01:01:42,821
including at least 50
highly qualified specialists.
889
01:01:44,741 --> 01:01:49,741
A war in which Gaza's healthcare
system has been destroyed.
890
01:02:01,461 --> 01:02:03,621
In May 2025, the IDF struck
the European Hospital,
891
01:02:03,621 --> 01:02:06,781
saying it killed Hamas military
chief Mohammed Sinwar.
892
01:02:06,781 --> 01:02:11,781
In June, it issued an edited video
it said showed a tunnel under
893
01:02:15,541 --> 01:02:18,501
the hospital where Sinwar and other
militants died, and gave a media
894
01:02:18,501 --> 01:02:23,541
tour to some journalists.
895
01:02:27,981 --> 01:02:31,461
Also in May, Israeli government
minister Bezalel Smotrich
896
01:02:31,461 --> 01:02:34,461
vowed to destroy Gaza.
897
01:02:36,179 --> 01:02:39,218
What does victory in Gaza look like?
898
01:02:40,059 --> 01:02:41,858
Gaza will be totally destroyed.
899
01:02:42,019 --> 01:02:46,178
Simply because it's entirely terrorist infrastructure
above and below the ground.
900
01:02:51,179 --> 01:02:52,378
So simply completely destroyed.
901
01:02:56,339 --> 01:03:00,498
The civilians are concentrated south of the morag axis
in the humanitarian zone.
902
01:03:02,579 --> 01:03:04,898
Without Hamas or terrorism.
903
01:03:09,979 --> 01:03:13,178
From there they are beginning to leave
in large numbers to third countries.
904
01:03:13,179 --> 01:03:18,338
This is an event that will change the reality and
history of Israel for decades to come.
72680
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.