Original subtitles

Just deal the cards.

I'll be right back.

Erin, is that you?

Erin?

Go away Bobby. I want to be alone.

Bobby?

(Sound of screams)

Becky? Becky?

Bobby! Oh Erin thank God!

You're hurt!

I'm fine. Fine. It's just a scratch.

You okay?

What is happening?

Who is doing all this?

Some fucking…

Johnny Baxter wanna be

Where is everyone else?

They're all gone.

It's going to be okay.

Just call the cops.

We're going to be fine.

You hear me?

Look so we're good, right?

Look, I love you.

I love you.

And I will spend the rest of my life showing you.

Okay?

Where'd you get that?

Are they the knives?

I don't know. Hell..

I'll check..

You put the chair against the door.

You got through it. We need every second we can get right now.

And Erin-

lock the door this time.

I should check the other doors.

Dammit!

There's nothing here we can use as a weapon.

I guess this is it

What are we gonna do?

Is there a basement? I don't know.

Well, I mean, there's got to be, right?

Isn't that like a state law or something like that?

You really need to get out

and keep running in to hit a paved road or a house.

I'm not leaving without you. I'll be right behind you.

Then come with me. But someone has to distract him.

Ok and buy us some time.

Just come with me. Just listen. For once.

Just listen!

Please!

You keep it.

Just in case.

Go

Come find me, I'll be right behind you. Right behind you.

Alright, motherfucker.

I'm gonna get you motherfucker!

Bobby. Aiden? It's me.

Are you ok?

My head really hurts.

What the fuck?

Bobby?

Bobby?

Erin, there is a basement.

We need to go.

No, it's just a scratch.

We need to go.

No, no, no, no, no, no.

Oh, oh, oh.

Does that angle look right to you?

I don't know.

You're the detective.

How tall do you think he thinks he is?

6'2 if I remember correctly. You know him?

Aiden Miller. Running back for the Grizzlies.

Damn good one, too.

You know he ran a 70-yard touchdown on the last game.

Damn shame.

Uh huh.

Picked a box, found these

black hoodie, red ski mask.

Isn't that what Johnny Baxter wore back in the day?

Baxter is an urban legend.

That's actually a misconception.

Johnny Baxter was a college student back in the seventies.

Heard his girlfriend was sleeping around with some buddies of his-

he went on a rampage one night. Never caught him.

You think Johnny Baxter did this?

Maybe?

A 70 year old man who hasn't been seen in 50 years?

Did this?

I've heard crazier things happen.

Right. Well, maybe the-

girl got a good look at the killer.

What girl?

The one who survived.

Richards!

You should drink. I'm not thirsty.

You need to hydrate.

If you don't, I'll have to start an I.V.

and I don't think you want that right now.

Miss? I'm Detective Hawkes.

I'm so sorry this happened to you.

I'm not the one that needs an apology.

Of course.

But you still had to go through..

All of this.

No one should have to experience

what happened here.

I'd like to ask you a few questions.

We'll start out real easy.

Okay?

What's your name? Erin Severson

And this cabin-

is it yours?

No, Scotty's.

Well, his parents.

A few of us came up here to celebrate

shows first weekend

Show?

Sweeney Todd High School.

I'm Mrs.

Lovett.

Irony, huh?

How many of you came up here?

Just me and Bobby,

Lisa, Scotty,

Peter,

Aiden and Becky.

Seven, I guess.

How did this start?

Bobby and

I had a fight.

I stepped outside to get some fresh air

and before I know it,

all my friends are dead, and Bobby.

Who's Bobby?

Lindstrom.

He's the vic in the living room.

My boyfriend.

And the killer?

You get a good look at him?

After I found Bobby, I saw him.

It's okay.

It's okay.

Just take a breath.

I thought he was going to kill me.

But he just looked at me.

He just left.

He left?

Do you know him?

He was wearing a mask.

Did he say anything to you?

Would you recognize his voice? No.

Why didn't he kill me?

He could have done it.

I wouldn't think about that right now.

Sometimes-

there are no reasons.

Just be grateful that-

I'm alive?

When everyone else is dead?

Where's my daughter?

Erin?

Mr. Severson, it's a pleasure to meet you. Listen, just get out of my way.

Are you hurt?

Listen, you didn't say anything to the police, did you?

I just want to go home. Oh, I know, baby.

I know.

Is she hurt?

What? My daughter. Is she injured?

Physically? No.

Officer, is she being detained?

It's Detective actually and…

No, but she'll need to.. Okay, we're leaving.

Erin is our only witness that we have.

She'll have to answer some more questions.

Uh huh well look, you follow proper protocol

and you'll have no issues with me.

Take care,

Erin.

We found another body.

You uh, you still trying to quit smoking?

Yeah.

How's that going for you?

Candies helping.

You know,

too much sugar can cause type two diabetes,

especially at your age

Richards, with a lack of sleep,

a newborn baby and my wife telling me the same thing,

get off my back.

Is that a cleaver?

That's a pretty jacked up way to go.

Who would do this?

A real sicko.

We should call the mental hospital.

Make sure they're not missing one of theirs.

How many victims do we have so far?

Three at the cabin.

And this guy so far, so 4 total.

That means we have two more to find.

Looks like it's going to be a long day.

Erin honey?

Are you asleep?

I made breakfast.

French toast, your favorite.

I can make something else if you want.

I don't know what I want.

Well, there are plenty of options, so just let me know.

Oh, and I called

Dr. Samuels

she'll stop by this afternoon. Why?

I really think it would be helpful

to talk to someone about it.

What if I don't want to talk?

Then you can just listen.

Bro. Bro, you're going to get shot. Epic, man.

Fucking idiots.

Can you believe it? Baxter's back?

It's crazy but awesome at the same time.

Yeah. Awesome.

Hey have you talked to Erin yet?

Not yet.

She must be a basket case.

The only survivor.

Can you believe it?

Not..really.

Damn shame about Bobby.

You know, a lot of people died that night.

Not just Bobby.

Right.

Anyway, like I said, man, she must be a basket case.

This is Tabby Dozier.

And I'm reporting live from Gold River Road.

Behind me is the neighborhood

where the sole survivor from this weekend's massacre lives.

That's 18-year-old Erin Severson.

She was fortunate.

Unlike six other Elm River students who were slaughtered Saturday night,

and that does include Bobby

Lindstrom, a local hero and quarterback for the Mustangs.

Investigators are not releasing much details right now,

but we have learned that Johnny Baxter

might have returned just in time for Halloween.

How are you feeling?

How do you think I'm feeling?

I don't know.

That's why I asked.

How would you feel?

To be honest, I don't know.

I've never been in a situation like you just experienced.

But I am here to listen and help.

Even though I can't imagine being able to sum up the emotions

you're feeling right now with something pithy, like,

fine or not good.

Bobby was supposed to be right behind me.

Your boyfriend?

What happened is not your fault.

If you want to blame someone

blame who did it.

Have you ever lost anyone?

A handful of friends.

My grandparents.

You close with any of them?

Not really, no.

Bobby and I were together since eighth grade.

That's a long time.

I've known him pretty much my whole life.

I'm going to prescribe you

some new medication. Why?

I worked so hard to get off of them.

I don't want to start again.

They make me sick.

I'm going to prescribe you some new medication.

Let's try Citalopram.

It's an antidepressant.

And then Lorazepam.

It'll help you sleep.

Can I go back to school?

I think it's best if you take a few extra days off and rest.

I'm not tired.

I want to go back to school.

Well, I can't tell you not to go, but I advise against it,

especially with new medication.

Take some time to grieve.

Only time will heal.

And what if it doesn't?

It will.

It always does.

How do you know?

You say you've never lost anyone close to you.

Are you okay?

This is fucked up.

Are we done here?

Dr. Samuels? Yes.

If you need anything, call me.

Otherwise, I'll see you next week.

I wanted to come here yesterday, but my parents are being annoying.

How did you find out?

Are you kidding?

It's all over the news.

Everyone was talking about it.

The whole school is full of Johnny Baxter wannabes.

Nothing this big has happened here since-

well since Baxter? Yes.

I'm sorry I wasn't there.

Everyone else died.

You probably would have been killed, too.

I'm glad you weren't there.

It must have been awful.

I can't believe Bobby is gone.

How are you holding up?

How do you think?

I'm fine.

Really, I am.

Is it true about what happened?

What do you mean? Is what true?

That Baxter didn't kill you even though he had the chance.

What kind of bullshit is that?

Who's saying that?

Becky's brother heard it from his cop Uncle.

I mean, yeah, it's true.

He could have killed me.

Then why didn't he?

How can you fucking ask her that?

I honestly don't have the answer.

I asked Bobby to come with me.

If he had, maybe he..

Well he wanted to protect me.

Of course he wanted to protect you.

He loved you.

Sounds like Bobby.

Always looking after everyone.

But you should know what they're saying. What are they saying?

I say it's just some bitchy bitties

with nothing better to do than gossip.

What are they saying?

I told them to get their facts straight.

What are they saying?

That-that you and the killer were in it together.

That you killed Bobby so you can be together.

What?

I have no idea who that guy was.

It's just some gossips.

But you have to admit, it's suspicious that you were the only survivor.

So because I wasn't killed.

Now I'm the killer?

Nobody actually believes that.

But you know Elm River.

They want everything to be dramatic.

Just give it two days. It'll pass.

I'm just repeating what they are saying.

Next time, don't.

Whatever you need, Erin.

I'm here.

I'm your person.

Very funny.

How long did it take you to come up with that?

Hey, it's just a joke.

Don't kill anyone over it.

Oh, haha!

Can't believe you came to school already.

Why wouldn't I? Cause of everything.

Erin hasn't done anything wrong.

Killer girl.

Back to school already? Very mature.

Who you gonna chop up next, Erin?

So violent.

Assholes!

What is wrong with you people?

Six of our friends are fucking dead!

Yeah, especially Bobby.

Bobby didn't even know you existed, skank!

Are you sure about this?

I can handle it.

Look, it's Bobby's sister.

Should I go talk to her?

Eventually.

I should go give her my condolences, right?

I don't think that's going to do either of you any good.

Jenny. Hi.

How are you holding up?

I'm late for class.

She's so weird.

I don't think she ever liked me.

Who wouldn't like you?

Brad. Hi, how are you doing?

I know, you must have heard that a million times already.

Is there anything I can do?

Can you turn back time?

Make it somehow this never happened?

I wish.

Listen, if you ever need to talk

about anything you know just give me a call.

Thanks stud

but she's already got me.

Come on. We're late.

No interviews!

Go away!

Mrs. Severson, it's Detective Hawkes.

I'd like to talk to Erin.

Erin is not here.

She decided to go to school.

Soon?

I tried to keep her home. But

when that girl makes up her mind about something, there's no stopping her.

Yes, I got that feeling.

If you come back later, my husband will also be home.

You wouldn't happen to have some more coffee, would you?

I've been up all night long,

and I-

could really use a cup.

Sure.

Milk or sugar?

No milk.

Three sugars, please.

I gather

you've had a lot of reporters come by?

All day.

Can you do something about them?

The reporters?

No, not really.

They keep filming the house.

Isn't there laws against that?

Only if they're on your property.

Much appreciated.

Do you have any updates on Baxter?

Were you able to find him?

You mean the killer?

No. We haven't identified anyone yet.

How's Erin doing?

She says she's okay.

Is she?

She's strong.

She will get through this.

Of course.

Do you have any kids?

Yeah,

we just had our first.

She's six months.

Mackenzie.

She makes it very busy for us.

(nervous laugh)

How are you holding up?

I, uh..not that good

Actually.

I'm so sorry.

I can only imagine.

All you want to do is to protect your kids.

Nobody prepares you for this.

You feel..

Helpless

Detective Hawkes.

What are you doing here?

He stopped by to talk to Erin.

Is that so?

I didn't get to finish my interview the other day.

She's our only witness.

Witness or suspect?

Sure. The rumors have reached the department already.

I don't really listen to rumors.

The killer's still out there.

What are you doing to catch him?

That's why I was hoping to speak with Erin,

see if she remembered anything new?

If she does.

We'll call you.

Thank you

for the coffee

She's always been a drama queen.

I mean, have you seen her in the school musical?

Yeah, but she's not that good of an actress.

So if she was hiding anything,

she's way better than I realized.

The crazies always are.

What does that mean?

Oh, you didn't know? Erin's on medication.

Probably more than one.

No wonder she's losing it.

Oh, really?

Yeah.

At least so I hear.

Erin!

Erin. Oh, my gosh. How are you, sweetie?

So sorry about what happened.

(Erin vomiting)

Drama queen.

Feel better dear.

I'm here to finish what I started Erin! You've been a bad girl! You shouldn't have left Bobby!

You're going to pay for-

what you did!

(Josh and Todd laughing)

You should see the look on her face.

Good thing I got it on video, now everyone can see it!

What's going on?

Oh, my gosh.

Are you fucking serious psycho?

What the hell are you doing? Relax.

It was just a joke.

That's mine.

Confiscated for stupidity.

Whatever.

They're all over the school. I can just get a new one.

You fucking do that shit again

I'll kill you myself.

I'm so scared, killer girl.

Jerk!

Are you okay?

Do you need a ride?

I drove.

I'll be okay.

Okay.

I'll see you tomorrow.

Do you want me to stay?

I just need a minute.

I'll be okay.

Okay.

I'm your person.

(Josh and Todd laughing) These dudes…

Hey I'll be up in a few minutes. Okay?

Okay. Sounds good.

Very funny, Todd.

(gasps)

Jesus, bro.

You scared the shit out of me. What up Baxter?

You kill anyone today?

What's with the fake blood?

That would have been sweet earlier.

Do you have to work at the dinner table?

So Erin,

how was your day?

It was okay.

I got you another appointment with Dr. Samuels.

It's on Thursday.

Why? I just saw her.

You've been

through a lot.

It's good to talk about it.

Everyone wants me to talk about it.

But has it occurred to anyone that I might not want to?

Will you please stop butchering your food?

I..I didn't mean..

Look, I'm sorry, I uh

I think we've both said enough,

why don't we just finish our dinners?

I think I lost my appetite.

I'm going to take out the trash.

Honey, you don't need to do that.

It's okay Mom. I can do it.

Just give her some more time.

Jenny? What are you doing?

I heard what you did!

You killed them! Every one of them!

That's not true!

I didn't kill anybody!

Don't lie! I'm not lying!

You hated him!

Admit it! Who Bobby?

No. I loved him. I still do.

He was my everything!

It's okay.

Nobody's going to blame you.

I mean, not after what he did to you.

What do you mean? Bobby didn't do anything to me.

He deserved it.

Didn't he?

No. Why would you say something like that?

What?

You didn't know?

Know what?

She didn't know.

Jenny, what are you talking about?

What did Bobby do? She didn't know.

Jenny, What did he do?

What the hell is going on out here?

Nothing. We're just talking.

Wasn't that Bobby's

stepsister?

Come on, let's go inside.

I told you.

I told you. I told you.

I told you. She's nuts.

What do you think she meant about Bobby?

Are you kidding?

She's probably drunk or high or both.

I don't think so.

I think she was serious.

She said that Bobby did something and its ok if I hated him.

Sure, Whatever.

What's that supposed to mean?

I just feel like you're trying to make Bobby the bad guy.

Excuse me?

I mean, you could feel guilty about him dying and dealing with it

you're just making up shit to make this easier for you.

How could you say that?

I was kidding.

I'm sorry.

Erin.

You alright?

Yes, I'm fine.

I wish people would stop asking me that.

I don't know why this is locked.

We never lock this.

Oh my God! (students screaming) It's okay.

I got you.

Get the nurse!

I don't think she can do much.

Just get the nurse! Ok!

What did you do?

Why were you at school so late?

I have an after school program on Tuesdays.

It's over at six.

And after the prank in the bathroom.

What did you do? Prank?

They dressed up like the killer and attacked my daughter.

Okay, that's an assault.

After the boys confronted you,

what happened?

They left.

I left a few minutes later and came home.

I was there.

I can vouch for her.

And when you left school,

did you see anything? No.

No. And what time was that?

6:15? 6:30?

I don't know. Why?

Well, you were probably the last one to see him alive.

And what was that supposed to mean?

Are you insinuating my daughter was involved?

No one is saying that.

Right.

Okay. And what about Jenny Lindstrom?

What about her?

Told you she was around here last night, and she didn't seem all there.

You asked her where she was at the time

of the murders?

We haven't been able to find her.

Well maybe you should be out looking for her instead of questioning my daughter.

You know what?

Until you catch this killer, Erin won't be going back to school.

Dad! No objections Erin.

I've already called the school board.

School will be cancelled for the rest of the week.

Why's that? Cause there's a killer on the loose?

Tell me, Detective, what are you doing to find him?

Or her?

We're working on it.

Why don't you work on it?

Outside of my house?

Detective, if you need to talk to my daughter again.

I'll be expecting a warrant.

Hi. What are you doing here?

Ah, this..

This seemed like a better idea in my head.

Um, I wanted to see you.

Sorry.

And also, I thought you could use one of these.

Give me a minute.

What did the cops say?

School is closed. A.k.a.

They have no idea who the next victim would be or who the killer is.

Course I'm top of their list of suspects.

Listen, um

I just want you to know that

I know it wasn't you.

How do you know?

Cause I know you

Erin,

we've known each other since kindergarten.

That's like, forever.

Changed a lot since then. Yeah.

I mean, like, clearly

you've grown up and stuff, but

uh you're still the same girl who took my hand

and introduced me to everybody on my first day of school.

I completely forgot about that.

I didn't.

So is that why you came here tonight to tell me

I couldn't kill anybody?

That and invite you to a party.

What party?

Johnny Baxter

scavenger hunt party.

The first to find and kill the eight victims is the winner.

You're not serious? I'm serious.

It's this Saturday.

Are you actually going? Maybe.

I mean, it'll either be

totally epic or a complete waste of time.

Or bloody.

There's a killer on the loose.

Don't you think that's the first place he'll be? Exactly.

I think if

the killer's there, then you and I should be also

to catch the killer

and clear your name.

That's actually not a bad idea.

Yeah I might have those sometimes.

Not too bad

ideas.

Thanks. For what?

For everything.

Well, uh.

I, uh.

I guess I should get home before Mom

realizes I'm not there and calls the cops.

There's a killer on the loose.

Are you okay walking home alone?

I think I can handle it, but

I'll wait for you to get back inside.

It's literally right there.

Hey, you said it

there's a killer on the loose.

Good night.

Hey, Brad.

Yeah?

Instead of knocking on my window,

next time, you can just ring the doorbell.

Right.

I'll keep that in mind.

Anybody there?

I'm sorry. I'm sorry.

Problem?

I said I was sorry.

There's a killer on the loose.

No! Call the cops!

Are you all right?

It's Baxter! Call the cops!

And you say that Baxter did this?

Somebody that looked like him

Yeah.

Can you I.D. him?

What do you think?

So that's a no.

How's that feel?

It hurts.

Well.

It's stopped bleeding.

Stop, you're a stud.

Oh, my God. You're hurt. It's nothing.

I heard the sirens.

And I thought.. but I'm not, it's ok. I'm fine.

You two know each other?

He's a friend.

A friend, huh?

Don't move. Wait here.

I'll be right back.

We have to catch Baxter. You and me.

This Saturday.

You and me.

So how are the new meds?

Any side effects?

Yes. I'm tired and nauseated.

Those are common.

Why am I even taking them?

It'll take a little time, but they'll make you feel better.

Well, I feel worse than before.

So, I don't like you making me take them.

I feel you treat me like an enemy sometimes

I do?

It feels like it.

Well, I don't know you very well.

There's a killer out there. It could be you

for all I know.

You think it's me?

I don't know

No, not really.

And why is that?

You don't seem the killing type.

Maybe..

A little too vanilla.

Then who do you think it is?

It's probably a student.

Someone who's had enough.

Someone who's done

dealing with the pain and is just acting out.

Interesting theory.

Do you have any suspects?

A few.

Is Jenny Lindstrom one of them?

Why do you ask?

She attacked you.

I wouldn't call it an attack.

She's in pain.

She has every right to be angry.

I survived.

Her brother didn't.

Have you allowed yourself to cry?

What kind of question is that?

I'm just curious.

Have you?

So, Doctor, what do you think?

Who's the killer?

You treat plenty of the students at the school.

What's your theory?

You know I can't talk about other patients.

So, you do have a suspect?

Well, I guess that's our time.

I'll see you next week.

Bye Erin.

See you next week.

I have one more appointment today, right?

That's correct.

It's over the phone and she's going to call at 4PM. Ok,

why don't you just leave early for the day, then? I'll close up.

Are you sure?

Yes. Go ahead and spend some time with the twins.

Oh. Did you get their costumes done yet?

No, not yet.

What are they going as this year?

Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde.

The pictures are going to be epic.

Their costumes get cuter every year.

Thank you. Have a great evening.

Good night.

High functioning,

social and interpersonal skills.

Extremely smart, but excessively emotional

anger issues and seeking attention.

I'm leaning towards a possible diagnosis

of histrionic personality disorder.

Dr. Samuels.

Hello?

Hello?

Dr. Samuels.

I didn't mean to scare you.

I didn't know anyone else was here.

I was just in my office.

So you didn't just come through the front door?

No, I'm leaving.

Have a good night.

Good night.

Oh my God!

Oh no!

Oh no no no!

(screams)

(sound of stabbing)

(sound of stabbing)

What did the medical examiner say?

She was stabbed at least 20 times.

Maybe more.

By something narrow.

Maybe a

screwdriver?

Or an ice pick.

That's a good one, boss!

Cause of death is most likely blood loss from a ruptured aorta.

She'll confirm it. I didn't

realize so much would come from one person.

1.5 gallons.

That's 5 to 6 liters.

You can lose up to two and still survive.

Maybe three if you get lucky.

Clearly, she didn't.

That's enough, Richards.

Thank you.

And Brolin?

Keep it together.

You got it, boss.

Who saw her last?

The receptionist.

And when was that?

Oh, around 3:30.

Right after the last patient.

Who was that?

Oh, I didn't ask.

I'll go ask.

Rookies, huh?

So, uh what do you think? Sorry.

What do you think, boss?

Patient?

That would be a coincidence.

We can move the body.

Bring in the boys.

We're moving the vic.

You're not going to believe this.

I got a name.

Are you sure you're going to be okay, honey?

We can reschedule.

I'll be fine. Okay.

Go. We'll be back in about an hour.

Don't panic.

It's just me.

It's her.

Hi, honey. What did we forget?

Jenny, why do you have a gun?

It's for protection.

There's a killer on the loose.

Put the phone down.

Oh my God! Oh my God!

Don't worry.

I'm not going to hurt you.

I've come here to warn you.

Baxter is coming for you next.

It's okay. Just put the gun down and we can talk about it.

Richards.

So, you think Severson will talk to us?

Why wouldn't he?

You know, because we don't have a warrant.

He said he wanted a warrant.

Speak of the devil.

Mr. Severson,

what can I help you with?

It took some time, but I finally figured it out.

I finally found out who Bobby was seeing behind your back.

What?

Seeing behind my back?

He cheated on you, Erin.

He broke your trust.

No, Bobby wouldn't do that.

No, he did.

And I have proof.

And that's why Bobby's dead.

I know who the killer is.

Jenny. She's inside.

Go to the front. Wait for my signal

Richards.

No, I don't believe you.

I have a picture to show you, but you have to prepare yourself.

You're not going to like it.

I'm going in boss. Drop the gun!

No! What the fuck Richards!

Can I get you anything?

Are you hungry?

No Mom.

Mm hmm.

Alright. Well, keep me updated.

She's in surgery.

She's expected to survive.

So, it was Jenny.

She's the killer.

I don't think so.

She came here to warn me.

Bobby was seeing someone else.

Jenny found out.

She said she knows who the killer is.

Did she say who?

No. But she said she has a photo.

Well,

I'll check it out.

It isn't over yet.

Is it?

No. Unfortunately not.

But we are doing everything we can.

Don't worry.

We are not going to let you

out of our sight.

You're safe.

(music)

(song continues)

(music)

(song continues)

(music)

(song continues)

(music)

(music)

(song continues)

(music)

(song continues)

(music)

(song continues)

(music)

(song continues)

(music)

What is it, Richards?

Did you grab the photo?

(music)

(song continues)

(music)

(song continues)

(music)

Erin!

We heard about Jenny.

How are you?

I'm just great.

We can't believe she was the killer all this time.

Imagine killing her own brother?

Sick? Yeah.

Just as sick as accusing somebody of murder

with no actual evidence.

I need to speak with Erin. Now.

Come on in.

I can't believe this.

They're best friends.

We sent a unit to go pick her up.

But considering everything that's happened, I suggest you stay here until we find her.

I'll set up a patrol outside.

She's not here.

Erin's gone.

Do you know where she might have gone?

The party.

Look, stay here and lock the doors.

Be careful.

You believe her?

Jenny?

I think so.

She has no reason to lie.

I guess Bobby was seeing someone else.

Yeah.

I'm sorry.

I need another drink.

You know, if you're right about Jenny,

that means that the killer stopped.

You mean in here?

Look at this place.

It could be anyone.

Good evening Elm River High School!

It's time for what you've all been waiting for.

It's time for the Johnny Baxter scavenger hunt.

(applause) The rules are simple.

Find a victim with the flag and grab them.

The Baxter that collects the most flags is the winner!

Let the hunt begin! (applause)

I guess it's showtime.

Where's Irene? (music)

Are you going to wear this?

Are you serious?

I won't go that near the sweat infested flearag.

Cute Billy.

You almost look terrifying enough to scare a five-year-old.

Stop it, you weirdo!

(Leah screams)

(sound of screams)

(scary music)

Somebody! Please help me!

Leah. Leah? You ok? Oh my God.

Irene? Irene?

Is that Blake?

Is she dead?

It looks like it.

Is that blood?

Yeah. It's Leah's.

Baxter's here.

He's upstairs.

He was gone by the time I already got here.

There was nothing I can do.

Listen here, we got to go. What if you're the killer?

This could be an act. Erin.

Erin.

I saw him. You have to believe me.

He's, he's lying, Erin

Erin.

It's me.

You know me.

Take this.

You're gonna lock the door.

Come on, Brad.

Come on.

Don't open that door for anyone!

This is the party. Okay.

Gotcha!

Great. Thanks a lot.

Hope you break your neck.!

Damn kids man!

Where do they come up with this shit?

Fucking assholes!

How are you holding up?

I'm fine.

I would never let anything happen to you.

You know that, right?

(Irene screams)

It's Irene. Erin!

Wait.

Can we trust her?

Let's find out.

It's Blake.

She's dead!

Where have you been?

I had to go to the bathroom.

That's convenient. What's that supposed to mean?

You disappear,

right as Baxter starts another rampage?

Baxter's here?

Baxter's here. Ding-ding-ding!

We have a winner!

It's time that you and I had a talk.

No more lies!

What?

Erin deserves the truth, don't you think?

Then tell her the truth!

You're the one that slept with Bobby, aren't you?

You broke Erin's trust! Just say it! Just say it!

How do you know? How do you know?

Bobby told me.

Don't shoot!

It's just a costume.

Drop the weapon.

I'm just here for

the scavenger hunt.

It's fake.

Hey, is that real blood?

Yeah.

You should take the tech room.

Erin?

No, it's fine.

She's safe.

Get the fuck out of the way!

Asshole!

Watch your fucking mouth you piece of shit!

Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait.

I'm sorry.

I didn't mean it-

It just happened!

It just happened? Is that what you're about to say?

Because if it was, it's really funny.

Bobby said the same thing.

I'm sorry,

but it's

as if you tripped and fell right into his bed.

I'm sorry.

He wanted me to forgive him.

Can you believe that?

Instead, I killed him

Erin!

Surprise! It's me!

I'm the killer. Little tidbit.

You shouldn't fuck your best friend's boyfriend!

It has consequences.

It can cause lifelong trauma.

(Erin having flashback) There is a basement. You need to go.

Oh, no, no, no.

It's just a scratch.

You need to go.

No, no, no. No, no, no, no!

(Erin crying)

That you and the killer were in it together. That you killed Bobby so you can be together.

What?

I have no idea who that guy was. You have to admit

it's suspicious that you were the only survivor.

Very funny.

How long did it take you to come up with this?

It's just a joke. Don't kill anyone over it.

Are you fucking serious psycho?

What the hell is wrong with you? Hey relax.

It' was just a joke. Hey that's mine.

Not anymore, confiscated for stupidity!

Whatever!

They're all over the school, I can just get another one.

You do that again, I'll fucking kill you myself!

I'm so scared, killer girl!

Jerk!

It's okay.

It will only hurt for a second. Shit!

Fuck!

Fuck!

Fuck!

I trusted you.

Erin!

You in there?

Erin it's Dad. Erin!

Irene!

Stop! No!

Dad! Help!

Erin thank God! No! Wait! No!

What happened?

She attacked me.

She said she was in love Bobby

and that if she couldn't have him, no one could.

She is the killer daddy.

It's okay. It's okay. Right. You're safe now.

It's over. It's over.