Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:03,954 --> 00:00:05,354
[narrator] Devastating wars.
2
00:00:07,034 --> 00:00:08,754
Pitiless rulers...
3
00:00:10,994 --> 00:00:13,954
in pursuit of power over centuries.
4
00:00:17,994 --> 00:00:22,314
When Russia takes up arms,
the world holds its breath.
5
00:00:32,394 --> 00:00:35,634
[foreboding theme music playing]
6
00:00:43,754 --> 00:00:47,514
[narrator] The Kremlin: for centuries,
the center of Russian power.
7
00:00:48,594 --> 00:00:50,194
In magnificent St. George's Hall,
8
00:00:50,274 --> 00:00:53,834
a reception is held
to honor war veterans.
9
00:00:53,914 --> 00:00:58,114
They served under Stalin, and
still mourn the loss of his empire.
10
00:00:59,034 --> 00:01:01,914
As does their leader, Vladimir Putin.
11
00:01:04,474 --> 00:01:08,554
Flashback to the year 2000.
Putin springs a surprise.
12
00:01:08,634 --> 00:01:13,394
He wants to reintroduce
Stalin's national anthem from 1944.
13
00:01:13,474 --> 00:01:16,154
[indistinct chatter in Russian]
14
00:01:17,274 --> 00:01:20,834
[narrator] According to Putin,
the USSR's old national anthem
15
00:01:20,914 --> 00:01:23,234
will reconcile the past and present.
16
00:01:24,394 --> 00:01:27,274
Even in 2000, he was thinking
17
00:01:27,354 --> 00:01:32,994
the Soviet Union
would probably return somehow.
18
00:01:33,074 --> 00:01:35,394
[choir singing national anthem]
19
00:01:35,474 --> 00:01:37,074
[narrator] This is a real surprise.
20
00:01:37,154 --> 00:01:39,874
The guests don't quite know
what to make of it.
21
00:01:39,954 --> 00:01:42,874
The tune is familiar,
but the words are new.
22
00:01:45,714 --> 00:01:47,794
Now it's about love
for the fatherland,
23
00:01:47,874 --> 00:01:50,634
not, as in Stalin's time,
love for the Party.
24
00:01:52,674 --> 00:01:56,074
[man] In the 20th century, Stalin
is the most successful Russian ruler.
25
00:01:56,674 --> 00:01:59,234
And Putin admires that.
26
00:02:01,234 --> 00:02:03,034
[narrator] Is it just symbolism?
27
00:02:03,114 --> 00:02:06,554
Or does Putin see himself
as Stalin's successor?
28
00:02:08,514 --> 00:02:11,474
Is he planning to resurrect
the Soviet empire?
29
00:02:21,554 --> 00:02:23,594
[indistinct shouting in German]
30
00:02:24,634 --> 00:02:26,754
[narrator] November 1989:
31
00:02:26,834 --> 00:02:28,554
the fall of the Berlin Wall.
32
00:02:28,634 --> 00:02:30,714
Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev,
33
00:02:30,794 --> 00:02:34,034
head of the Soviet government
and of the Party,
34
00:02:34,114 --> 00:02:38,114
has permitted a peaceful revolution
in East Germany.
35
00:02:40,634 --> 00:02:45,194
More than half a million Soviet
soldiers are stationed in the DDR.
36
00:02:45,274 --> 00:02:47,554
They remain in their barracks.
37
00:02:55,474 --> 00:02:58,754
The end of Soviet dominance
is now only a matter of time.
38
00:02:59,314 --> 00:03:02,834
Gorbachev tries desperately
to keep on top of events.
39
00:03:04,834 --> 00:03:06,314
[crowd cheering]
40
00:03:08,434 --> 00:03:12,274
[narrator] In March 1990,
the Soviet star falls in Vilnius.
41
00:03:12,354 --> 00:03:15,234
Lithuania proclaims independence.
42
00:03:15,314 --> 00:03:18,114
The Kremlin responds with tanks.
43
00:03:19,354 --> 00:03:22,394
[man screaming]
44
00:03:22,474 --> 00:03:25,794
[narrator] The Soviet Union
uses force for the last time.
45
00:03:25,874 --> 00:03:29,954
14 Lithuanians die,
more than 700 are hurt.
46
00:03:30,034 --> 00:03:31,914
[man and woman talk indistinctly]
47
00:03:39,274 --> 00:03:40,674
[man 2] This deployment was a last
48
00:03:40,754 --> 00:03:42,474
desperate attempt to
use military power
49
00:03:42,554 --> 00:03:46,914
to maintain, at least in part,
the unity of the Soviet Union.
50
00:03:48,874 --> 00:03:52,674
[narrator] The three Baltic states,
Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania,
51
00:03:52,754 --> 00:03:54,754
leave the empire first.
52
00:03:55,594 --> 00:03:57,514
Following uprisings in Georgia,
53
00:03:57,594 --> 00:04:01,514
it, too, declares independence
and elects a new president.
54
00:04:02,954 --> 00:04:04,674
[muffled explosion]
55
00:04:05,554 --> 00:04:08,954
[narrator] But now,
citizens loyal to Moscow take up arms.
56
00:04:09,034 --> 00:04:11,954
Chiefly in two pro-Russian regions.
57
00:04:12,034 --> 00:04:15,594
Hundreds die in clashes
with the new presidential guard.
58
00:04:22,594 --> 00:04:23,994
August 1991:
59
00:04:24,074 --> 00:04:30,154
a coup against Gorbachev to prevent
the adoption of a new "Union Treaty."
60
00:04:30,234 --> 00:04:33,674
By granting wide-ranging freedoms
to individual republics,
61
00:04:33,754 --> 00:04:37,274
Gorbachev still hopes
to save the Soviet Union.
62
00:04:37,354 --> 00:04:41,474
But the conservative plotters are
too attached to the old Soviet state,
63
00:04:41,554 --> 00:04:44,954
and so speed its ultimate demise.
64
00:04:47,114 --> 00:04:49,354
It was mainly the people
who wanted to hold on
65
00:04:49,434 --> 00:04:51,474
to the idea of the Soviet Union.
66
00:04:51,554 --> 00:04:53,994
People from the KGB
and the military, too.
67
00:04:54,074 --> 00:04:56,554
That is, the hardliners.
68
00:04:58,354 --> 00:05:01,874
[narrator] Boris Yeltsin, president
of the Russian Soviet Republic,
69
00:05:01,954 --> 00:05:03,314
is the man of the hour.
70
00:05:03,394 --> 00:05:05,354
He opposes the coup.
71
00:05:05,434 --> 00:05:08,554
He appears to be standing
up for democracy.
72
00:05:08,634 --> 00:05:11,594
[crowd chanting in support of Yeltsin]
73
00:05:11,674 --> 00:05:13,234
[speaking indistinctly]
74
00:05:13,314 --> 00:05:15,234
[narrator] Mikhail Gorbachev resigns.
75
00:05:15,314 --> 00:05:19,954
Yeltsin attacks him, because Gorbachev
refuses to abandon the Soviet Union.
76
00:05:20,034 --> 00:05:22,194
For Yeltsin, it's already history.
77
00:05:22,274 --> 00:05:26,634
He dissolves the Communist Party,
and then the Soviet state itself.
78
00:05:26,714 --> 00:05:28,794
The Red Flag is no more.
79
00:05:31,714 --> 00:05:33,314
After the three Baltic states,
80
00:05:33,394 --> 00:05:37,234
eleven other Soviet republics
declare their independence.
81
00:05:37,874 --> 00:05:41,874
The Soviet Union shrinks
to the Russian Federation.
82
00:05:47,154 --> 00:05:49,514
Russian troops
leave the former East Germany.
83
00:05:49,594 --> 00:05:52,634
Weapons and soldiers return to Russia.
84
00:05:56,834 --> 00:05:59,154
The government of
newly unified Germany
85
00:05:59,234 --> 00:06:02,154
pays Moscow 12 billion Deutschmarks.
86
00:06:02,234 --> 00:06:04,394
The money doesn't
flow to the military.
87
00:06:04,474 --> 00:06:07,674
It's used to save the whole country
from bankruptcy.
88
00:06:12,634 --> 00:06:15,754
Ukraine, Belarus and Kazakhstan
hand over to Russia
89
00:06:15,834 --> 00:06:18,914
the nuclear weapons
stationed on their territory.
90
00:06:18,994 --> 00:06:22,314
In exchange, the Kremlin
guarantees their full sovereignty
91
00:06:22,394 --> 00:06:24,954
and the inviolability
of their borders.
92
00:06:27,874 --> 00:06:31,074
The military budget
in the final years of the Soviet Union
93
00:06:31,154 --> 00:06:35,234
is between 200 and
250 billion dollars.
94
00:06:35,314 --> 00:06:38,034
In the 1990s, annual
Russian expenditure
95
00:06:38,114 --> 00:06:40,874
drops to less than
20 billion dollars.
96
00:06:46,634 --> 00:06:50,914
The euphoria for Yeltsin
and the new freedoms doesn't last.
97
00:06:50,994 --> 00:06:53,234
The economy hits rock bottom.
98
00:06:53,314 --> 00:06:57,234
Russians associate democracy
with crisis and decline.
99
00:07:06,634 --> 00:07:10,554
For centuries, the Caucasus,
with its ethnic and religious mix,
100
00:07:10,634 --> 00:07:13,394
has been a focus of political turmoil.
101
00:07:16,514 --> 00:07:18,794
Georgia is now independent.
102
00:07:18,874 --> 00:07:22,674
Moscow is determined that Chechnya,
in the northern Caucasus,
103
00:07:22,754 --> 00:07:25,554
will remain inside
the Russian Federation.
104
00:07:28,394 --> 00:07:32,514
In December 1994, the Russian army
marches in to Chechnya.
105
00:07:35,114 --> 00:07:38,274
They're there to fight the separatists
who've declared independence.
106
00:07:38,354 --> 00:07:42,314
But why does Yeltsin unleash this war,
and why now?
107
00:07:43,754 --> 00:07:46,714
The powerful Security Service
plays a crucial role.
108
00:07:50,394 --> 00:07:54,594
[Felshtinsky] The first Chechen War
was organized by the KGB, by the FSB.
109
00:07:54,674 --> 00:07:58,474
These people thought Russia
shouldn't develop in a democratic way.
110
00:07:58,554 --> 00:08:02,434
It must become involved
in a political provocation, in a war.
111
00:08:04,354 --> 00:08:06,154
[narrator] The war
runs out of control.
112
00:08:06,234 --> 00:08:10,074
The troops are unmotivated,
their weapons obsolescent.
113
00:08:10,154 --> 00:08:13,474
Yeltsin faces massive criticism.
114
00:08:13,554 --> 00:08:16,594
[woman] I put a lot of blame
on Yeltsin's war in '94,
115
00:08:16,674 --> 00:08:18,394
because that was
completely unnecessary.
116
00:08:18,474 --> 00:08:22,074
Yeltsin himself said, "You take
all the independence you want."
117
00:08:22,154 --> 00:08:23,994
So they said,
"Fine, we want to be independent."
118
00:08:24,074 --> 00:08:28,394
As they've been wanting for the whole
history of Russia since the czars.
119
00:08:28,994 --> 00:08:31,634
And he said, "Oh, no, no,
I don't really mean it for you."
120
00:08:34,594 --> 00:08:36,634
Hundreds of soldiers
are taken prisoner.
121
00:08:37,354 --> 00:08:40,674
It's months before they're reunited
with their mothers.
122
00:08:40,754 --> 00:08:43,034
Many are less than 20 years old.
123
00:08:43,114 --> 00:08:46,754
Some have only just been redeployed
from East Germany.
124
00:08:48,634 --> 00:08:51,474
[Klein] The troops in Chechnya were
mainly conscripts and elite units.
125
00:08:51,554 --> 00:08:53,394
The high numbers of dead conscripts
126
00:08:53,474 --> 00:08:56,594
caused Yeltsin very serious
political problems at home.
127
00:08:59,154 --> 00:09:02,034
[narrator] Thousands of soldiers
are killed on both sides.
128
00:09:06,674 --> 00:09:09,754
[Litvinenko] I interrogated
a young boy, 17 years old.
129
00:09:09,834 --> 00:09:12,954
By the way, he was a clever,
widely read boy.
130
00:09:13,034 --> 00:09:16,154
I asked him only one question:
why did you go to fight?
131
00:09:16,754 --> 00:09:19,834
He said: "I hate this war,
and I don't want to fight."
132
00:09:19,914 --> 00:09:22,274
"I fight because all my classmates
are fighting."
133
00:09:22,354 --> 00:09:24,314
"I remember some films about World War
134
00:09:24,394 --> 00:09:26,594
II, when the whole
class went to fight."
135
00:09:30,474 --> 00:09:34,034
[narrator] Litvinenko
was then an army officer in Chechnya.
136
00:09:34,114 --> 00:09:37,874
Later he becomes
a career officer in the KGB.
137
00:09:42,114 --> 00:09:47,874
In 1995, many victims of the
Chechen War disappear in mass graves.
138
00:09:47,954 --> 00:09:51,514
Separatists talk of a genocide
against the civilian population.
139
00:09:52,594 --> 00:09:56,594
The result is Islamist terrorism
in Russia.
140
00:09:56,674 --> 00:09:59,914
In the run-up
to the 1995 presidential election,
141
00:09:59,994 --> 00:10:02,034
Yeltsin agrees a ceasefire.
142
00:10:02,114 --> 00:10:06,114
Russian troops withdraw,
leaving behind scorched earth.
143
00:10:06,194 --> 00:10:08,394
Yeltsin was extremely unpopular.
144
00:10:08,474 --> 00:10:11,794
Democrats stopped supporting him.
145
00:10:11,874 --> 00:10:16,594
Actually, Yeltsin
should be investigated
146
00:10:16,674 --> 00:10:19,834
for war crimes
committed by the Russian army.
147
00:10:21,834 --> 00:10:25,434
[narrator] To the surprise of many,
Yeltsin is re-elected.
148
00:10:28,274 --> 00:10:30,514
But he has lost the Chechen War
149
00:10:30,594 --> 00:10:33,354
and is making no
progress with the West.
150
00:10:34,194 --> 00:10:35,954
[military band playing grand salute]
151
00:10:45,314 --> 00:10:46,914
[indistinct conversation]
152
00:10:46,994 --> 00:10:49,274
[narrator] Back in July 1990,
153
00:10:49,354 --> 00:10:52,394
German Chancellor Helmut Kohl
visits the Caucasus.
154
00:10:53,034 --> 00:10:57,314
He's here to seize an opportunity
offered by the fall of the Wall:
155
00:10:57,394 --> 00:10:59,794
German reunification.
156
00:10:59,874 --> 00:11:02,714
Mikhail Gorbachev makes a concession:
157
00:11:02,794 --> 00:11:06,194
a united Germany can stay in NATO.
158
00:11:08,194 --> 00:11:10,634
The Soviets, however,
receive a verbal assurance
159
00:11:10,714 --> 00:11:13,954
that NATO won't expand
any further eastwards.
160
00:11:14,754 --> 00:11:18,914
The existence of this promise
remains in dispute to this day.
161
00:11:20,914 --> 00:11:23,234
It isn't mentioned
in the Two Plus Four Treaty
162
00:11:23,314 --> 00:11:25,074
on German reunification.
163
00:11:28,234 --> 00:11:30,314
Of course they didn't put it in,
164
00:11:30,394 --> 00:11:32,834
because they thought that handshake,
165
00:11:32,914 --> 00:11:35,434
you know, how they
do it in the old world,
166
00:11:35,514 --> 00:11:37,194
is just going to be good enough.
167
00:11:37,754 --> 00:11:39,994
There is no document recording this.
168
00:11:40,074 --> 00:11:43,194
It was "free-thinking"
in the euphoria of reunification
169
00:11:43,274 --> 00:11:44,834
at the end of the Cold War.
170
00:11:49,154 --> 00:11:51,314
[woman 2] George Bush was clear.
171
00:11:51,394 --> 00:11:53,754
"They didn't win the
Cold War, we did."
172
00:11:56,834 --> 00:11:58,274
Good morning, everybody.
173
00:11:58,354 --> 00:12:01,314
[narrator] At the 1997
NATO summit in Madrid,
174
00:12:01,394 --> 00:12:03,794
Poland, Hungary and Czechoslovakia,
175
00:12:03,874 --> 00:12:08,554
former members of the Warsaw Pact,
are invited to join the Alliance,
176
00:12:08,634 --> 00:12:10,914
seriously upsetting Moscow.
177
00:12:13,154 --> 00:12:15,394
The then US Secretary of Defense
178
00:12:15,474 --> 00:12:18,554
was opposed
to the eastward extension of NATO.
179
00:12:18,634 --> 00:12:22,234
Much too risky. Danger of escalation.
180
00:12:22,314 --> 00:12:25,954
We shouldn't rub
Russia's nose in it too hard
181
00:12:26,034 --> 00:12:29,474
in the time of its
post-imperial decline.
182
00:12:33,074 --> 00:12:35,994
[narrator] NATO sweeps
all reservations aside.
183
00:12:36,074 --> 00:12:39,434
With the accession of Poland,
the Czech Republic and Hungary,
184
00:12:39,514 --> 00:12:43,154
Alliance territory
has shifted to the east.
185
00:12:43,234 --> 00:12:44,834
[military trumpets playing]
186
00:12:44,914 --> 00:12:47,594
[narrator]
Did Bill Clinton trick Yeltsin?
187
00:12:48,514 --> 00:12:50,234
[Neitzel] Nobody tricked anyone.
188
00:12:50,314 --> 00:12:51,634
Russia was weak.
189
00:12:51,714 --> 00:12:55,394
Russia didn't veto it,
didn't say, "Absolutely no way!"
190
00:12:55,474 --> 00:12:57,234
Maybe they could have delayed it.
191
00:12:57,314 --> 00:12:59,914
Maybe they could have come up
with a stronger counteroffer.
192
00:12:59,994 --> 00:13:02,234
The Russians didn't do that in '97.
193
00:13:03,754 --> 00:13:06,554
[narrator] The conflict
over NATO's eastward expansion
194
00:13:06,634 --> 00:13:10,234
will affect Russia's relations
with the West for years to come.
195
00:13:19,914 --> 00:13:23,114
February 1999, the Kremlin.
196
00:13:23,194 --> 00:13:26,514
President Yeltsin
at an awards ceremony for officers.
197
00:13:27,234 --> 00:13:31,394
The only man in civilian clothes
is Vladimir Putin.
198
00:13:31,474 --> 00:13:33,074
He has risen fast.
199
00:13:33,794 --> 00:13:36,914
Once a KGB lieutenant-colonel
in East Germany,
200
00:13:36,994 --> 00:13:39,074
he was deputy mayor in St. Petersburg,
201
00:13:39,154 --> 00:13:42,194
before moving to the center
of power in Moscow.
202
00:13:43,234 --> 00:13:47,994
Now, Putin is head of the FSB,
successor to the KGB.
203
00:13:48,634 --> 00:13:52,474
His Petersburg team has come with him
to the Security Service.
204
00:13:54,874 --> 00:13:56,154
[suspenseful music playing]
205
00:13:58,914 --> 00:14:03,394
I understood who was in control
of the Federal Security Service.
206
00:14:03,474 --> 00:14:07,754
It was Putin and his friends.
They were running the country.
207
00:14:07,834 --> 00:14:10,394
I realized we couldn't keep silent.
208
00:14:10,474 --> 00:14:13,434
So my friends and I
held a press conference.
209
00:14:15,514 --> 00:14:19,394
[narrator] Litvinenko and others
publicly accuse their employers,
210
00:14:19,474 --> 00:14:21,354
the FSB, and thus Putin,
211
00:14:21,434 --> 00:14:24,594
of ordering political murders.
212
00:14:26,234 --> 00:14:28,594
He says he himself
received such an order,
213
00:14:28,674 --> 00:14:30,714
which he refused to carry out.
214
00:14:32,594 --> 00:14:37,754
Fearing the FSB's wrath, Litvinenko
and his family flee to London.
215
00:14:43,074 --> 00:14:47,234
The interviews he recorded there
in 2001 and 2002
216
00:14:47,314 --> 00:14:49,954
give a unique insight
into Putin's career,
217
00:14:50,034 --> 00:14:52,954
from someone
who knew and worked with him.
218
00:14:56,434 --> 00:14:59,434
In November 2006, FSB agents lure
219
00:14:59,514 --> 00:15:03,354
Litvinenko to London's
Millennium Hotel,
220
00:15:03,434 --> 00:15:06,954
where they poison him
with radioactive polonium.
221
00:15:07,794 --> 00:15:10,794
Weeks later, he dies a painful death.
222
00:15:12,474 --> 00:15:14,834
[discordant electronic music playing]
223
00:15:21,514 --> 00:15:23,074
[narrator] Shortly before
Litvinenko's death,
224
00:15:23,154 --> 00:15:27,834
the journalist Anna Politkovskaya
is murdered in Moscow.
225
00:15:27,914 --> 00:15:31,074
She has repeatedly
sharply criticized Putin.
226
00:15:32,034 --> 00:15:35,914
Political murder has always been
the stock-in-trade of the KGB.
227
00:15:35,994 --> 00:15:39,394
Now it sees a renaissance
with Putin's FSB.
228
00:15:42,274 --> 00:15:45,714
Under Putin, the FSB
takes over some of the army's role.
229
00:15:45,794 --> 00:15:48,394
In particular, border security.
230
00:15:51,594 --> 00:15:56,794
In the Yeltsin years, the army shrinks
from five million to 1.7 million.
231
00:15:57,634 --> 00:16:03,554
The FSB's ranks
swell from 100,000 to 288,000.
232
00:16:07,034 --> 00:16:10,794
The Russian army
is only partly operational.
233
00:16:14,034 --> 00:16:16,994
There's too little money
to develop new weapons.
234
00:16:17,074 --> 00:16:18,994
And Yeltsin hasn't learned any lessons
235
00:16:19,074 --> 00:16:21,154
from the military
disaster in Chechnya.
236
00:16:29,034 --> 00:16:30,554
In August 1999,
237
00:16:30,634 --> 00:16:33,674
he appoints Vladimir Putin
his new prime minister.
238
00:16:34,594 --> 00:16:37,394
Putin is hardly known outside
Moscow and St. Petersburg.
239
00:16:37,474 --> 00:16:42,234
It's not clear how he can win
the upcoming parliamentary election.
240
00:16:43,474 --> 00:16:48,154
It seems the FSB has a plan
to boost his popularity.
241
00:16:51,954 --> 00:16:53,754
Immediately following his appointment,
242
00:16:53,834 --> 00:16:55,834
and presumably with
Yeltsin's approval,
243
00:16:55,914 --> 00:16:58,394
Putin starts a new war in Chechnya.
244
00:16:59,274 --> 00:17:02,754
Russia beaks the 1996 ceasefire.
245
00:17:05,354 --> 00:17:08,194
Putin flies to
Chechnya in a fighter jet.
246
00:17:08,274 --> 00:17:09,554
That goes down well.
247
00:17:09,634 --> 00:17:12,154
The previously anonymous politician
248
00:17:12,234 --> 00:17:15,554
is leading the nation's fight
against terrorism.
249
00:17:18,074 --> 00:17:23,034
A few weeks later, a Moscow housing
estate is shaken by terrorist blasts.
250
00:17:23,114 --> 00:17:25,794
More than 300 people are killed.
251
00:17:30,994 --> 00:17:34,274
Putin immediately blames
Chechen terrorists.
252
00:17:36,314 --> 00:17:38,514
It's the escalation he needs.
253
00:17:41,914 --> 00:17:46,234
[Felshtinsky] This was the first
major terrorist attack in Russia.
254
00:17:46,314 --> 00:17:49,234
And everybody was frightened.
255
00:17:49,314 --> 00:17:54,154
Everybody was expecting more and more
buildings to be blown up.
256
00:17:54,234 --> 00:17:57,274
And on 23 September,
257
00:17:57,354 --> 00:18:01,634
a local militia found
an explosive device
258
00:18:01,714 --> 00:18:04,754
in an apartment building in Ryazan.
259
00:18:06,234 --> 00:18:09,354
[narrator] The night before,
local residents had seen strangers
260
00:18:09,434 --> 00:18:11,394
dragging sacks into the building.
261
00:18:12,034 --> 00:18:14,234
The police make three arrests.
262
00:18:14,314 --> 00:18:16,634
The men are apparently FSB agents.
263
00:18:17,834 --> 00:18:20,194
In the cellar of the
building, the police
264
00:18:20,274 --> 00:18:22,674
find sacks with
explosives and a timer.
265
00:18:24,474 --> 00:18:28,194
But then two days later, Moscow
comes up with a different explanation.
266
00:18:28,274 --> 00:18:32,314
It was a security test, and the sacks
contained nothing but sugar.
267
00:18:33,474 --> 00:18:37,434
[narrator] Was the FSB really ready
to blow up Russian citizens
268
00:18:37,514 --> 00:18:40,394
to polish Putin's image
as an anti-terrorist?
269
00:18:41,674 --> 00:18:43,514
Ryazan was not a training exercise,
270
00:18:43,594 --> 00:18:45,274
but an attempt to commit
an act of terrorism.
271
00:18:45,354 --> 00:18:47,874
They were caught red-handed.
272
00:18:47,954 --> 00:18:50,714
The FSB is a terrorist organization.
273
00:18:51,794 --> 00:18:54,074
My assumption is that it was the FSB.
274
00:18:54,154 --> 00:18:55,514
I wouldn't put it past them.
275
00:18:55,594 --> 00:18:59,074
Above all, I wouldn't put it past
Putin to sacrifice his own people
276
00:18:59,154 --> 00:19:00,994
to have the justification for a war
277
00:19:01,074 --> 00:19:03,594
and stabilize his own position
inside the country.
278
00:19:03,674 --> 00:19:05,394
I wouldn't put it past him at all.
279
00:19:08,914 --> 00:19:11,314
[narrator] Putin immediately
orders bombing raids
280
00:19:11,394 --> 00:19:13,834
on the Chechen capital, Grozny.
281
00:19:13,914 --> 00:19:15,714
He says he'll hunt
down the terrorists,
282
00:19:15,794 --> 00:19:19,314
if necessary, "Even in the shithouse."
283
00:19:19,394 --> 00:19:21,674
He gets the headlines he wants.
284
00:19:21,754 --> 00:19:24,274
Russian troops proceed
with the utmost brutality,
285
00:19:25,114 --> 00:19:26,874
even against civilians.
286
00:19:26,954 --> 00:19:29,474
[dramatic music playing]
287
00:19:34,754 --> 00:19:36,274
This way of waging war
288
00:19:36,354 --> 00:19:39,514
against the civilian population
has a long tradition.
289
00:19:40,794 --> 00:19:43,914
It has a lot to do with the way
the army has been trained
290
00:19:43,994 --> 00:19:48,474
to maintain the government's authority
inside the country, by force.
291
00:19:54,194 --> 00:19:58,874
This violent, brutal policy
was applied in Putin's Chechen War
292
00:19:58,954 --> 00:20:02,394
in the way the city of Grozny
was virtually razed to the ground.
293
00:20:06,034 --> 00:20:08,354
We see that the brutality
of this form of war
294
00:20:08,434 --> 00:20:11,194
is in part the result
of a failure of leadership.
295
00:20:11,274 --> 00:20:15,074
But it is also a consciously
accepted form of lawlessness,
296
00:20:15,154 --> 00:20:16,874
a lack of accountability,
297
00:20:16,954 --> 00:20:20,834
because any crime committed will
not be punishable in Russia itself.
298
00:20:21,554 --> 00:20:24,234
And finally, this
brutality is adopted as
299
00:20:24,314 --> 00:20:27,114
a conscious form of
psychological warfare
300
00:20:27,194 --> 00:20:30,274
to undermine the resistance
of the civilian population
301
00:20:30,354 --> 00:20:32,354
and of the enemy's military.
302
00:20:34,274 --> 00:20:37,634
[narrator] Putin regularly visits
the troops in Chechnya.
303
00:20:37,714 --> 00:20:40,914
He praises the fighters
and distributes gifts.
304
00:20:41,434 --> 00:20:44,634
At home, his popularity soars.
305
00:20:44,714 --> 00:20:47,594
The FSB's plan is succeeding.
306
00:20:49,314 --> 00:20:51,674
The people wanted a leader like that.
307
00:20:51,754 --> 00:20:52,994
They got it.
308
00:20:53,074 --> 00:20:54,434
They supported him.
309
00:20:54,514 --> 00:20:58,274
They killed people in Chechnya,
and everybody kept silent.
310
00:21:09,514 --> 00:21:11,474
[narrator] At the end of 1999,
311
00:21:11,554 --> 00:21:15,154
Yeltsin resigns
and makes Putin acting president.
312
00:21:15,234 --> 00:21:18,114
With that, he takes over
the nuclear codes.
313
00:21:18,754 --> 00:21:20,874
But Putin hasn't yet
achieved his goal.
314
00:21:20,954 --> 00:21:24,874
He has to win the presidential
election of March 2000.
315
00:21:24,954 --> 00:21:26,834
[suspenseful music playing]
316
00:21:32,554 --> 00:21:36,954
The KGB were making a decision
that clearly they needed a figurehead.
317
00:21:37,034 --> 00:21:39,994
They needed somebody
who was going to take over the reins,
318
00:21:40,074 --> 00:21:41,154
but be manipulated by them.
319
00:21:41,234 --> 00:21:44,394
And this person that they chose
was Vladimir Putin.
320
00:21:44,474 --> 00:21:47,714
Vladimir Putin was a mere
lieutenant-colonel. He was a nobody.
321
00:21:47,794 --> 00:21:52,474
This was very clearly a carefully
planned change, a transition of power,
322
00:21:52,554 --> 00:21:56,634
so that the KGB/FSB
could regain its prominence
323
00:21:56,714 --> 00:21:59,674
and its dominance in Russia
after Yeltsin was gone.
324
00:21:59,754 --> 00:22:03,074
They became successful,
unfortunately for all of us.
325
00:22:03,154 --> 00:22:08,674
And now we are dealing with the
problem created by that success.
326
00:22:11,554 --> 00:22:14,874
[narrator] A reception for the heads
of the armed forces at the Kremlin:
327
00:22:14,954 --> 00:22:17,834
one of Putin's
first official engagements.
328
00:22:17,914 --> 00:22:19,634
He promises to strengthen the army,
329
00:22:19,714 --> 00:22:21,834
to give them more respect
330
00:22:21,914 --> 00:22:23,434
and more money.
331
00:22:27,634 --> 00:22:29,154
[Neitzel] Russia's political capital
332
00:22:29,234 --> 00:22:31,154
rests on the strength
of its armed forces.
333
00:22:31,234 --> 00:22:35,194
That was important in the
czar's empire, in the Soviet Union,
334
00:22:35,274 --> 00:22:37,954
in the Cold War,
and it's still important now.
335
00:22:38,594 --> 00:22:40,474
Why is Russia still important?
336
00:22:40,554 --> 00:22:43,314
Certainly not because of
its moribund economy.
337
00:22:43,394 --> 00:22:45,314
For its natural resources, sure,
338
00:22:45,394 --> 00:22:48,154
but also because of its military,
its nuclear weapons.
339
00:22:50,434 --> 00:22:53,074
[narrator] Election night, March 2000.
340
00:22:53,714 --> 00:22:57,274
Putin has won the presidential
election in the first round.
341
00:23:00,754 --> 00:23:02,234
[speaking in Russian]
342
00:23:02,314 --> 00:23:04,514
[narrator]
Where is he taking the country?
343
00:23:11,514 --> 00:23:12,754
The swearing-in ceremony,
344
00:23:12,834 --> 00:23:16,794
extravagant as anything
from the time of the Romanovs.
345
00:23:16,874 --> 00:23:18,914
A new czar is born.
346
00:23:20,834 --> 00:23:24,594
Among the guests, somewhat lost:
Mikhail Gorbachev.
347
00:23:27,234 --> 00:23:30,354
[Sebag Montefiore] Putin channels
a lot of ideas and ambitions
348
00:23:31,234 --> 00:23:32,274
from the Romanov dynasty.
349
00:23:32,354 --> 00:23:35,914
In many ways,
he's very similar to Nicholas I,
350
00:23:35,994 --> 00:23:40,434
who outwitted the
West for 20 or 30 years
351
00:23:40,514 --> 00:23:43,474
and really embraced
internally the ideas
352
00:23:43,554 --> 00:23:46,434
of Orthodoxy, nationality and empire.
353
00:23:46,514 --> 00:23:48,674
So he takes what he needs
354
00:23:48,754 --> 00:23:52,914
from both the Romanov empire
and the Stalinist empire.
355
00:23:54,354 --> 00:23:58,594
This connection to the tradition
of the Russian empire before 1917
356
00:23:58,674 --> 00:24:00,114
is another twist again,
357
00:24:00,194 --> 00:24:02,914
on his view that the collapse
of the Soviet Union
358
00:24:02,994 --> 00:24:07,754
was the greatest geopolitical
disaster of the 20th Century.
359
00:24:07,834 --> 00:24:09,834
[crowd murmuring]
360
00:24:09,914 --> 00:24:13,754
[narrator] The young president
arouses plenty of enthusiasm.
361
00:24:13,834 --> 00:24:17,194
It feels like the
beginning of a new age.
362
00:24:21,394 --> 00:24:23,034
At the same time in Chechnya,
363
00:24:23,114 --> 00:24:27,274
they're still filling mass graves with
the victims of Russian aggression.
364
00:24:27,914 --> 00:24:32,274
More than 150,000 civilians
and 25,000 soldiers
365
00:24:32,354 --> 00:24:35,194
were killed in the Chechen Wars.
366
00:24:37,194 --> 00:24:39,994
Putin guarantees the
autonomy of Chechnya
367
00:24:40,074 --> 00:24:44,834
and installs an indigenous president,
Akhmad Kadyrov, in Grozny.
368
00:24:45,594 --> 00:24:50,474
After his murder in 2004,
his son Ramzan takes his place.
369
00:24:52,354 --> 00:24:57,274
Ramzan still controls most of Chechnya
as Moscow's brutal proxy.
370
00:24:58,314 --> 00:25:01,834
[speaking in Chechen]
371
00:25:13,634 --> 00:25:17,114
[narrator] An international
memorial ceremony at sea.
372
00:25:18,554 --> 00:25:20,554
On August 12, 2000,
373
00:25:20,634 --> 00:25:23,394
a few months after
the presidential election,
374
00:25:23,474 --> 00:25:26,434
Russia's nuclear submarine Kursk sinks
375
00:25:26,514 --> 00:25:29,274
when one of its own
torpedoes explodes.
376
00:25:30,354 --> 00:25:33,154
The Kursk was the pride
of the Russian navy.
377
00:25:33,234 --> 00:25:36,154
All 118 crew die.
378
00:25:38,034 --> 00:25:40,914
[Neitzel] The Kursk goes down
in 100 meters of water.
379
00:25:41,674 --> 00:25:43,754
If they had raised
her upright, she would
380
00:25:43,834 --> 00:25:45,914
have reared 60 meters
out of the water.
381
00:25:45,994 --> 00:25:48,314
She's 160 meters long!
382
00:25:48,394 --> 00:25:50,434
And the Russians don't
have the capability
383
00:25:50,514 --> 00:25:52,634
to free their own
sailors trapped inside.
384
00:25:53,154 --> 00:25:57,234
It's really disastrous for the public
image of Russia's armed forces.
385
00:26:01,514 --> 00:26:03,234
[narrators] Wives and
mothers of the crew
386
00:26:03,314 --> 00:26:05,354
wait and hope for rescue.
387
00:26:09,674 --> 00:26:12,354
But Putin refuses help from abroad.
388
00:26:13,274 --> 00:26:16,954
He only meets bereaved relatives
eleven days after the accident.
389
00:26:22,074 --> 00:26:23,794
[Kusber] Empathy for
those who perished,
390
00:26:23,874 --> 00:26:25,674
and their families,
isn't his strength.
391
00:26:26,994 --> 00:26:30,794
Silence about the dead is a tradition
that reaches far back,
392
00:26:30,874 --> 00:26:32,794
at least into Soviet times.
393
00:26:35,634 --> 00:26:38,994
[narrator] Murmansk,
base of the Russian northern fleet.
394
00:26:39,074 --> 00:26:43,394
Nearby, a graveyard for dozens
of nuclear submarines.
395
00:26:44,194 --> 00:26:46,314
Radioactive scrap.
396
00:26:47,674 --> 00:26:49,074
At the turn of the new century,
397
00:26:49,154 --> 00:26:52,714
Russia's navy is in
catastrophic shape.
398
00:26:55,154 --> 00:26:57,474
[Klein] It's a metaphor for the state
of the armed forces
399
00:26:57,554 --> 00:27:01,314
after almost two decades
of failure to modernize.
400
00:27:01,394 --> 00:27:03,954
Those reforms that did take place
were really cuts,
401
00:27:04,034 --> 00:27:06,554
in soldiers' wages,
if they were paid at all,
402
00:27:06,634 --> 00:27:09,794
and out of date,
inadequately maintained equipment.
403
00:27:11,634 --> 00:27:14,114
[narrator] In the first decade
of the Putin era
404
00:27:14,194 --> 00:27:17,274
military expenditure
continuously rises:
405
00:27:17,354 --> 00:27:20,874
from about ten billion dollars
in the year 2000
406
00:27:20,954 --> 00:27:24,394
to more than 50 billion in 2009.
407
00:27:26,114 --> 00:27:29,634
New weapons
like short-range Iskander missiles
408
00:27:29,714 --> 00:27:33,394
are to bring Russian forces
up to the level of the West.
409
00:27:34,434 --> 00:27:36,234
But a significant part
of the military budget
410
00:27:36,314 --> 00:27:39,874
is absorbed by endemic corruption.
411
00:27:44,034 --> 00:27:45,674
June 2001.
412
00:27:45,754 --> 00:27:49,674
The first meeting between the new man
in the Kremlin and a US president.
413
00:27:50,634 --> 00:27:53,674
George W. Bush is delighted.
414
00:27:53,754 --> 00:27:55,434
I looked the man in the eye.
415
00:27:56,194 --> 00:27:59,154
I found him very straightforward
and trustworthy.
416
00:28:00,114 --> 00:28:04,034
I was able to get a sense of his soul.
417
00:28:04,114 --> 00:28:06,554
[Khrushcheva] George
Bush looked in his
418
00:28:06,634 --> 00:28:09,314
eyes and saw his soul,
which is bizarre,
419
00:28:09,394 --> 00:28:12,274
because Putin's eyes are the most
impenetrable you can ever imagine.
420
00:28:12,354 --> 00:28:14,834
[Felshtinsky] He was young.
He was unknown.
421
00:28:14,914 --> 00:28:20,354
And this played a
positive role for him,
422
00:28:20,434 --> 00:28:25,754
being accepted by the Western
community, the Western leaders.
423
00:28:27,834 --> 00:28:29,594
[narrator] In September 2001,
424
00:28:29,674 --> 00:28:33,634
Putin addresses the
Bundestag in Berlin. In German.
425
00:28:33,714 --> 00:28:36,914
His presentation of a new Russia,
open to the world,
426
00:28:36,994 --> 00:28:39,034
receives a standing ovation.
427
00:28:39,114 --> 00:28:40,554
A new beginning.
428
00:28:41,234 --> 00:28:44,514
Or a coldly calculated
piece of make-believe.
429
00:28:45,194 --> 00:28:48,034
[Richie] The real
Putin is an FSB thug.
430
00:28:48,114 --> 00:28:49,954
He always was, and he always will be.
431
00:28:50,034 --> 00:28:55,074
Once you're in a security service
apparatus of that kind of government,
432
00:28:55,154 --> 00:28:58,314
and you do the sorts of things that
he was even doing in East Germany,
433
00:28:58,394 --> 00:28:59,954
which is about infiltration and
434
00:29:00,034 --> 00:29:02,154
manipulation and
propaganda and spying.
435
00:29:02,234 --> 00:29:05,754
And these people learn
from the very beginning
436
00:29:05,834 --> 00:29:08,514
to disguise their real feelings
and their real intentions.
437
00:29:08,594 --> 00:29:10,834
[band plays military march]
438
00:29:10,914 --> 00:29:15,634
[narrator] On the memorial day
for victory over Nazi Germany in 2002,
439
00:29:15,714 --> 00:29:18,634
Putin dispenses
with a big display of weaponry.
440
00:29:18,714 --> 00:29:21,834
It's more of a festival
for army veterans.
441
00:29:22,514 --> 00:29:25,634
In any case, the Red Army
doesn't have much new to show.
442
00:29:25,714 --> 00:29:28,034
The atmosphere is almost peaceful.
443
00:29:33,034 --> 00:29:37,074
Just two years later,
Putin reveals Russia's latest weapons
444
00:29:37,154 --> 00:29:38,514
at a Moscow air show.
445
00:29:39,554 --> 00:29:41,154
The US Air Force gets an invite,
446
00:29:41,234 --> 00:29:45,954
to see first-hand the renewed strength
and confidence of Russia's military.
447
00:29:52,394 --> 00:29:54,874
Putin is massively re-arming.
448
00:29:55,554 --> 00:29:58,634
That goes for Russia's
nuclear arsenal too.
449
00:30:11,434 --> 00:30:14,874
Ukraine's president,
Putin's ally, Leonid Kuchma,
450
00:30:14,954 --> 00:30:16,634
is reaching the end of his term.
451
00:30:17,994 --> 00:30:20,594
Two men are competing
to be his successor:
452
00:30:21,314 --> 00:30:24,154
Moscow loyalist Viktor Yanukovych
453
00:30:24,794 --> 00:30:27,914
and opposition candidate
Viktor Yushchenko.
454
00:30:29,154 --> 00:30:32,114
Yushchenko has distanced himself
from Moscow.
455
00:30:32,194 --> 00:30:35,114
He wants to lead Ukraine
towards the West.
456
00:30:35,194 --> 00:30:37,754
He wants his country to join NATO.
457
00:30:41,034 --> 00:30:48,394
Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Bulgaria,
Romania, Slovakia and Slovenia
458
00:30:48,474 --> 00:30:50,834
all recently joined NATO.
459
00:30:51,714 --> 00:30:55,514
From Russia's perspective,
Ukrainian membership must be thwarted
460
00:30:55,594 --> 00:30:56,754
at all costs.
461
00:30:58,794 --> 00:31:00,594
That includes assassination.
462
00:31:00,674 --> 00:31:02,434
Unknown persons try to poison
463
00:31:02,514 --> 00:31:05,074
pro-Western candidate
Viktor Yushchenko.
464
00:31:06,594 --> 00:31:09,354
Doctors in a specialist
Vienna clinic save his life.
465
00:31:11,474 --> 00:31:15,514
Badly scarred,
he returns to the campaign in Kyiv.
466
00:31:17,634 --> 00:31:21,714
[Felshtinsky] By now it is known
that it was Russian operatives
467
00:31:21,794 --> 00:31:23,914
who were behind this attempt,
468
00:31:23,994 --> 00:31:27,234
and that they escaped back to Russia.
469
00:31:27,314 --> 00:31:31,554
And Russia, of course,
refused to extradite them.
470
00:31:32,914 --> 00:31:35,594
[narrator] Yushchenko gains
a strong sympathy vote.
471
00:31:35,674 --> 00:31:38,554
He wins the election
against Yanukovych
472
00:31:38,634 --> 00:31:39,754
and against Moscow.
473
00:31:39,834 --> 00:31:42,074
[speaking in Ukrainian]
474
00:31:42,154 --> 00:31:44,114
[crowd cheers]
475
00:31:45,994 --> 00:31:47,074
[military command]
476
00:31:48,914 --> 00:31:51,394
[narrator] January 2005:
477
00:31:51,474 --> 00:31:53,994
the new Ukrainian
president is sworn in.
478
00:31:56,394 --> 00:32:00,434
But his much-vaunted "orange
revolution" gets bogged down.
479
00:32:02,674 --> 00:32:04,674
Ukraine is still corrupt,
480
00:32:04,754 --> 00:32:06,354
and polarized.
481
00:32:06,434 --> 00:32:08,114
[suspenseful music playing]
482
00:32:08,194 --> 00:32:10,514
[narrator] In February 2007,
483
00:32:10,594 --> 00:32:14,634
Putin travels to the European
Security Conference in Munich.
484
00:32:16,434 --> 00:32:18,914
The tone of his speech
is extremely blunt.
485
00:32:24,354 --> 00:32:27,194
The West is ignoring
Russia's interests.
486
00:32:28,074 --> 00:32:30,634
Is this the New World Order?
487
00:32:32,394 --> 00:32:35,074
[narrator] He complains once more
about the broken promise
488
00:32:35,154 --> 00:32:37,874
not to expand NATO eastwards.
489
00:32:37,954 --> 00:32:39,954
[Felshtinsky] He took his mask off
490
00:32:40,034 --> 00:32:43,594
and started to be angry and ugly.
491
00:32:43,674 --> 00:32:47,394
But this goes again
with the KGB training.
492
00:32:47,474 --> 00:32:51,554
They're nice if it's
needed to be nice.
493
00:32:51,634 --> 00:32:55,874
They are terrible
if it's needed to be terrible.
494
00:32:55,954 --> 00:33:01,554
And they are dangerous and ready
to kill if it's demanded from them.
495
00:33:03,154 --> 00:33:06,234
[narrator] Putin is most concerned
about the alleged dangers
496
00:33:06,314 --> 00:33:07,954
to Russia's security.
497
00:33:08,554 --> 00:33:11,474
But in fact, it's all about
the survival of his regime.
498
00:33:12,754 --> 00:33:15,554
This secret group photo from 2008
499
00:33:15,634 --> 00:33:20,474
shows the top officials of the FSB,
Russia's de facto rulers.
500
00:33:21,674 --> 00:33:25,034
Security in Russia
is not defined as national security,
501
00:33:25,114 --> 00:33:27,234
but the security of the regime.
502
00:33:27,314 --> 00:33:30,394
Everything is seen through the lens
of the security of the regime,
503
00:33:30,474 --> 00:33:32,674
of Putin and the people around him.
504
00:33:44,954 --> 00:33:46,954
[narrator] Abkhazia and South Ossetia,
505
00:33:47,034 --> 00:33:50,034
two pro-Russian provinces of Georgia,
506
00:33:50,114 --> 00:33:52,434
are fighting for their independence.
507
00:33:55,994 --> 00:33:59,674
In August 2008,
a Russian army invades Georgia
508
00:33:59,754 --> 00:34:03,194
to help South Ossetia
fight Georgian troops.
509
00:34:03,954 --> 00:34:07,074
It's also a demonstration of power
aimed at NATO,
510
00:34:07,154 --> 00:34:09,914
which has long been eyeing
Georgia and Ukraine
511
00:34:09,994 --> 00:34:12,754
as future members of the Alliance.
512
00:34:14,434 --> 00:34:18,194
They said both countries will be
NATO members one day, but not when.
513
00:34:18,274 --> 00:34:21,114
It was clear to Russia's leaders:
this must be hindered,
514
00:34:21,194 --> 00:34:23,834
doesn't fit the image
of Russia as a great power,
515
00:34:23,914 --> 00:34:25,954
with spheres of influence
that it controls.
516
00:34:29,234 --> 00:34:32,714
[narrator] Once the war is over,
the Kremlin recognizes Abkhazia
517
00:34:32,794 --> 00:34:35,634
and South Ossetia
as independent states.
518
00:34:35,714 --> 00:34:38,474
The same policy
they'll later use in Ukraine.
519
00:34:39,674 --> 00:34:42,474
Russia's attack on Georgia
is mainly conducted
520
00:34:42,554 --> 00:34:45,314
through Abkhazian
and Ossetian territory.
521
00:34:46,034 --> 00:34:50,114
This was the first time
since the collapse of the Soviet Union
522
00:34:50,194 --> 00:34:53,194
when the Russian
forces were used abroad.
523
00:34:54,274 --> 00:34:55,674
Nothing happened.
524
00:34:55,754 --> 00:34:59,994
The West did not
react to this invasion.
525
00:35:00,074 --> 00:35:04,354
And for Putin this was an invitation
to proceed further.
526
00:35:06,554 --> 00:35:10,434
[narrator] The limited international
reaction to the invasion of Georgia
527
00:35:10,514 --> 00:35:14,834
encourages Putin to consider
further expansion of his power
528
00:35:15,634 --> 00:35:16,754
by force.
529
00:35:21,074 --> 00:35:23,994
After a few days,
Putin's army withdraws from Georgia.
530
00:35:25,434 --> 00:35:26,794
Losses are high.
531
00:35:26,874 --> 00:35:30,754
An estimated 1,500
deaths on either side.
532
00:35:32,314 --> 00:35:35,994
Russians realized that they may have
won a quick victory, in five days,
533
00:35:36,074 --> 00:35:38,434
but not because
their forces were superior,
534
00:35:38,514 --> 00:35:41,354
but because they so far
outnumbered their enemy.
535
00:35:41,434 --> 00:35:44,754
They used that as an excuse
to carry out military reforms
536
00:35:44,834 --> 00:35:46,914
that had been shelved for a long time.
537
00:35:50,994 --> 00:35:53,354
[Neitzel] They massively reduce
the number of conscripts
538
00:35:53,434 --> 00:35:55,514
and start professionalizing the army.
539
00:35:56,154 --> 00:36:00,154
There are still conscripts,
but the army is mainly career soldiers
540
00:36:00,234 --> 00:36:02,394
who can carry out
high-tech operations.
541
00:36:03,994 --> 00:36:06,274
A lot of money is
invested in the navy,
542
00:36:06,354 --> 00:36:08,594
in the air force and in special ops.
543
00:36:10,994 --> 00:36:15,034
[narrator] After the Georgian war,
Russian military expenditure increases
544
00:36:15,114 --> 00:36:17,434
from 51 billion dollars a year
545
00:36:17,514 --> 00:36:21,954
to more than 80 billion dollars
in 2013 and 2014,
546
00:36:22,034 --> 00:36:23,994
just before the attack on Ukraine.
547
00:36:25,194 --> 00:36:27,594
From 2008 to 2014,
548
00:36:27,674 --> 00:36:31,034
Russia's armed forces became
a central element of foreign policy,
549
00:36:31,114 --> 00:36:32,954
with talk of "heavy metal diplomacy,"
550
00:36:33,034 --> 00:36:35,194
coercive diplomacy
using military means.
551
00:36:38,474 --> 00:36:40,954
[narrator] Russia invests
in "heavy metal,"
552
00:36:41,754 --> 00:36:44,514
a modern army
for the conflicts of the 21st century.
553
00:36:51,714 --> 00:36:56,394
And from 2007,
Russia also practices cyber warfare.
554
00:36:59,514 --> 00:37:02,554
When computer
networks in Estonia crash,
555
00:37:02,634 --> 00:37:06,354
it's the first known foreign
deployment of Russia's cyberforces.
556
00:37:12,794 --> 00:37:16,234
The enemy is the West,
and it must be fought at every level.
557
00:37:17,074 --> 00:37:19,834
That's not just an issue
for the Russian military,
558
00:37:19,914 --> 00:37:21,954
but for the whole of Russian society.
559
00:37:23,154 --> 00:37:25,834
So there are media offensives,
cyber warfare
560
00:37:25,914 --> 00:37:27,754
and other new techniques that didn't
561
00:37:27,834 --> 00:37:29,954
play a role in the
Soviet Union's wars,
562
00:37:30,034 --> 00:37:31,914
or those of the czarist empire.
563
00:37:36,234 --> 00:37:37,674
[narrator] Putin also seeks the
564
00:37:37,754 --> 00:37:39,754
support of the Russian
Orthodox Church,
565
00:37:41,074 --> 00:37:43,874
led from 2009 by Patriarch Kirill.
566
00:37:45,314 --> 00:37:47,194
He is one of the chief influencers
567
00:37:47,274 --> 00:37:50,594
for a revived "greater
Russian Empire."
568
00:37:53,114 --> 00:37:56,994
[Kusber] Patriarch Kirill talks
of the so-called "Russian World."
569
00:37:57,074 --> 00:38:00,794
Which makes him more or less
the chief ideologue of Putin's regime.
570
00:38:02,314 --> 00:38:06,274
The concept goes well beyond
Russia's current political borders.
571
00:38:06,354 --> 00:38:08,394
Ukraine is part of it.
572
00:38:09,274 --> 00:38:10,714
So is Belarus,
573
00:38:10,794 --> 00:38:14,034
and so are the regions with
a high proportion of Russian speakers.
574
00:38:14,114 --> 00:38:18,114
In the Baltic states, around
Kaliningrad and other places.
575
00:38:21,034 --> 00:38:24,834
[narrator] From 2013,
Putin starts to claim these countries
576
00:38:24,914 --> 00:38:27,634
as part of Russia's
sphere of influence.
577
00:38:32,674 --> 00:38:35,074
It's not about this or that region.
578
00:38:35,154 --> 00:38:37,714
I believe it's about Putin
putting down markers.
579
00:38:38,954 --> 00:38:41,634
"I'm against the West.
I have a different system."
580
00:38:41,714 --> 00:38:43,914
"And I don't want to be bound up
in your world."
581
00:38:43,994 --> 00:38:46,394
"I'm creating another world."
582
00:38:48,274 --> 00:38:50,314
[narrator] Even if its economy and the
583
00:38:50,394 --> 00:38:52,714
size of its population
don't justify it,
584
00:38:52,794 --> 00:38:55,154
Putin's Russia wants
to be a superpower
585
00:38:55,234 --> 00:38:57,154
on equal footing with the USA.
586
00:39:05,714 --> 00:39:08,154
[crowd singing national songs]
587
00:39:08,234 --> 00:39:11,154
[narrator] End of November 2013.
588
00:39:11,234 --> 00:39:15,354
Demonstrations on the Maidan,
Kyiv's central square.
589
00:39:16,074 --> 00:39:19,074
Ukraine's political self-image
has shifted.
590
00:39:19,154 --> 00:39:23,114
Away from Moscow,
towards the EU and NATO.
591
00:39:25,754 --> 00:39:29,354
But Viktor Yushchenko has been
replaced as Ukrainian president
592
00:39:29,434 --> 00:39:31,234
by Viktor Yanukovych.
593
00:39:31,954 --> 00:39:35,994
The puppet of the Kremlin rejects his
predecessor's Cooperation Agreement
594
00:39:36,074 --> 00:39:37,314
with the EU.
595
00:39:39,434 --> 00:39:44,714
[Gloger] Yanukovich is pro-Moscow and
against the EU Association Agreement.
596
00:39:44,794 --> 00:39:48,994
The people of Kyiv and the Ukraine
want to free themselves from Moscow.
597
00:39:49,074 --> 00:39:52,074
They know their country is imperfect
and corrupt.
598
00:39:52,154 --> 00:39:54,394
But they want to go their own way.
599
00:39:56,914 --> 00:40:00,674
[narrator] As the weeks pass,
the protests on the Maidan grow.
600
00:40:00,754 --> 00:40:03,834
Young people occupy the square
day and night,
601
00:40:03,914 --> 00:40:08,034
as if anticipating a decisive battle
for the future of their country.
602
00:40:09,234 --> 00:40:11,074
[dramatic music playing]
603
00:40:13,954 --> 00:40:16,994
The Russian leadership
see this as a plot,
604
00:40:17,074 --> 00:40:19,154
a conspiracy by Western states to
605
00:40:19,234 --> 00:40:21,874
surround Russia with
pro-Western regimes
606
00:40:21,954 --> 00:40:25,074
whose final aim
is to force regime change in Russia.
607
00:40:26,514 --> 00:40:29,954
[narrator] Nothing less
than the whole of Russia is at stake.
608
00:40:30,034 --> 00:40:31,914
Putin is in no doubt about that.
609
00:40:32,554 --> 00:40:34,394
[Neitzel] "We don't believe
Ukraine belongs to the West."
610
00:40:34,474 --> 00:40:37,394
"Ukraine is Russian. A clear
red line is being overstepped."
611
00:40:37,474 --> 00:40:39,914
"If you don't understand that,
there will be war."
612
00:40:41,514 --> 00:40:46,634
[narrator] The "war"
begins on February 18, 2014.
613
00:40:46,714 --> 00:40:50,914
Snipers from Ukraine's special forces
start to pick off demonstrators.
614
00:40:51,994 --> 00:40:53,954
But some of the
insurgents are armed too,
615
00:40:54,034 --> 00:40:55,994
and they fire back.
616
00:40:56,074 --> 00:40:58,274
[gunfire]
617
00:41:01,554 --> 00:41:06,714
[Felshtinsky] Putin was offering
to Yanukovych to use force.
618
00:41:06,794 --> 00:41:09,034
And that's why, with
some Russian help,
619
00:41:09,114 --> 00:41:13,794
some snipers started to shoot
at the crowd.
620
00:41:16,714 --> 00:41:19,514
[Kusber] It's very likely
that at that moment,
621
00:41:19,594 --> 00:41:23,154
Russian security service specialists
were working as agents provocateurs
622
00:41:23,234 --> 00:41:24,914
to stir up violence.
623
00:41:25,994 --> 00:41:28,514
But it's also true that weapons
were used on the Ukrainian side.
624
00:41:39,234 --> 00:41:42,274
[narrator] More than 80 people die
in the massacre on the Maidan.
625
00:41:45,514 --> 00:41:49,714
Yanukovych calls fresh elections
to defuse the conflict.
626
00:41:51,354 --> 00:41:55,754
Days later, he decamps to Russia
and is relieved of office.
627
00:42:00,394 --> 00:42:02,994
Immediately after the shooting
on the Maidan,
628
00:42:03,074 --> 00:42:05,994
the Russian army
occupies Ukraine's Crimea.
629
00:42:12,034 --> 00:42:16,194
Putin uses the power-vacuum
left by Ukraine's political U-turns
630
00:42:16,274 --> 00:42:17,754
to seize Crimea.
631
00:42:18,554 --> 00:42:21,634
Crimea is
geostrategically significant.
632
00:42:21,714 --> 00:42:25,514
And it's important for propaganda
and ideological reasons too.
633
00:42:25,594 --> 00:42:28,514
Crimea is the "Pearl of the Empire."
And he gets it back.
634
00:42:31,114 --> 00:42:33,234
[narrator] Crimea
has been Russian territory
635
00:42:33,314 --> 00:42:36,594
since Catherine the Great's victory
over the Ottomans.
636
00:42:37,914 --> 00:42:40,954
But in 1954, after Stalin's death,
637
00:42:41,034 --> 00:42:43,754
then Soviet General Secretary
Nikita Khrushchev
638
00:42:43,834 --> 00:42:47,594
gifted Crimea
to the Soviet Republic of Ukraine.
639
00:42:50,874 --> 00:42:53,634
Russian soldiers
with no insignia on their uniforms,
640
00:42:53,714 --> 00:42:55,954
so-called "Green Men,"
641
00:42:56,034 --> 00:42:59,314
meet almost no resistance in Crimea.
642
00:43:01,994 --> 00:43:04,634
[Felshtinsky] There was no fighting
for Crimea,
643
00:43:04,714 --> 00:43:09,154
because even Ukrainians knew
that Crimea is a Russian territory.
644
00:43:09,234 --> 00:43:13,834
I mean, it was just considered
to be Ukrainian territory by mistake.
645
00:43:15,194 --> 00:43:17,954
That doesn't alter the fact
that in international law
646
00:43:18,034 --> 00:43:20,034
it was an illegal annexation.
647
00:43:20,114 --> 00:43:23,914
Crimea is the territory
of the sovereign state of Ukraine.
648
00:43:28,714 --> 00:43:30,594
[narrator] In Ukraine's Donbas region,
649
00:43:30,674 --> 00:43:33,634
pro-Russian separatists
soon start shooting
650
00:43:33,714 --> 00:43:36,394
at Ukrainian soldiers and militiamen.
651
00:43:37,154 --> 00:43:38,794
Russia provokes skirmishes
652
00:43:38,874 --> 00:43:42,394
to extend the territory
held by pro-Moscow fighters.
653
00:43:43,714 --> 00:43:47,194
[speaking in Russian]
654
00:43:48,834 --> 00:43:52,314
[narrator] Russia occupies Crimea
in February 2014,
655
00:43:52,394 --> 00:43:56,074
at the same time launching a proxy war
against Ukraine
656
00:43:56,154 --> 00:43:59,954
in the regions of Luhansk
and Donetsk in the Donbas.
657
00:44:05,554 --> 00:44:07,674
[Felshtinsky] Prior to 2014,
658
00:44:07,754 --> 00:44:10,794
Ukrainians did not
have an army at all.
659
00:44:10,874 --> 00:44:14,154
The fighting, which took place later
660
00:44:14,234 --> 00:44:17,954
in spring and summer
of 2014 in Donbas,
661
00:44:18,034 --> 00:44:21,394
was conducted mainly by volunteers
662
00:44:21,474 --> 00:44:25,474
who actually, you know,
didn't know how to fight.
663
00:44:27,154 --> 00:44:30,954
[narrator] Once again, international
reaction to the occupation of Crimea
664
00:44:31,034 --> 00:44:33,274
and the war in Donbas is muted.
665
00:44:33,834 --> 00:44:36,674
The West again allows Putin
to believe he can pursue
666
00:44:36,754 --> 00:44:39,794
expansionist policies without risk.
667
00:44:41,074 --> 00:44:44,634
Looking back, it should have been
a much more robust response
668
00:44:44,714 --> 00:44:48,634
to make it clear this annexation
would carry a far higher price.
669
00:44:48,714 --> 00:44:51,874
I would argue, if those sanctions
670
00:44:51,954 --> 00:44:55,874
would be on the level
which we see now,
671
00:44:57,034 --> 00:45:00,274
the invasion of February '22
would never happened.
672
00:45:02,954 --> 00:45:05,034
[narrator] The only notable
Western reaction
673
00:45:05,114 --> 00:45:09,794
came in President Barack Obama's
speech at a conference in The Hague.
674
00:45:12,914 --> 00:45:16,394
Russia is a regional power
675
00:45:17,274 --> 00:45:21,234
that is threatening
some of its immediate neighbors.
676
00:45:23,514 --> 00:45:25,754
Not out of strength,
but out of weakness.
677
00:45:27,194 --> 00:45:29,074
[narrator] Putin's reply is a huge
678
00:45:29,154 --> 00:45:31,554
parade bristling with
military hardware.
679
00:45:32,674 --> 00:45:36,154
At the night-time rehearsal,
all the weaponry the army has to offer
680
00:45:36,234 --> 00:45:37,914
crosses Red Square.
681
00:45:38,794 --> 00:45:40,994
Including ballistic missiles.
682
00:45:56,394 --> 00:45:57,434
Aleppo.
683
00:45:58,074 --> 00:45:59,754
In September 2015,
684
00:45:59,834 --> 00:46:03,794
the Russian Air Force
intervenes in Syria's civil war.
685
00:46:04,874 --> 00:46:08,514
It's a great-power gesture
with devastating consequences,
686
00:46:08,594 --> 00:46:11,074
especially for the
civilian population.
687
00:46:11,874 --> 00:46:14,754
Officially, the campaign
is part of the international struggle
688
00:46:14,834 --> 00:46:16,914
against Islamic fundamentalists.
689
00:46:17,794 --> 00:46:21,514
In reality, Putin is also propping up
the Assad regime
690
00:46:21,594 --> 00:46:25,154
against armed opposition
supported by the US.
691
00:46:25,234 --> 00:46:28,794
[speaking in Russian]
692
00:46:30,474 --> 00:46:33,194
The Russians used Syria,
first to bomb their way back
693
00:46:33,274 --> 00:46:35,034
onto the international stage,
694
00:46:35,114 --> 00:46:38,354
and then to gain significance
on the international stage.
695
00:46:39,034 --> 00:46:41,554
And, of course, they also used it
to test their weapons
696
00:46:41,634 --> 00:46:42,994
and to gain experience.
697
00:46:43,874 --> 00:46:46,554
[male voice speaking in Russian]
698
00:46:46,634 --> 00:46:49,114
[narrator] Putin and his generals
follow the campaign
699
00:46:49,194 --> 00:46:50,594
on a giant screen.
700
00:46:51,194 --> 00:46:54,154
He allows Western cameras in to watch.
701
00:46:58,394 --> 00:47:02,754
The whole world must see how powerful
Putin's Russia has become.
702
00:47:02,834 --> 00:47:05,754
[general speaking in Russian]
703
00:47:06,594 --> 00:47:09,554
[Neitzel] It's very clear
this is no longer just about Syria.
704
00:47:09,634 --> 00:47:13,154
It's about a confrontation
with a heavily armed NATO.
705
00:47:15,914 --> 00:47:18,234
The basic idea is to
demonstrate Russia's
706
00:47:18,314 --> 00:47:20,514
ability to fight a 21st century war.
707
00:47:20,594 --> 00:47:25,354
On the one hand a hybrid war,
but also a great war against the West.
708
00:47:28,234 --> 00:47:30,194
[narrator] In Syria, the Russians
709
00:47:30,274 --> 00:47:33,034
deliberately target
the civilian population.
710
00:47:33,914 --> 00:47:35,234
This is a war crime.
711
00:47:35,874 --> 00:47:39,274
Exactly as in Chechnya,
20 years before.
712
00:47:44,394 --> 00:47:45,674
[shouting]
713
00:47:45,754 --> 00:47:48,434
[Richie] If you look at Chechnya,
if you look at Georgia,
714
00:47:48,514 --> 00:47:51,234
if you look at Syria
and also Ukraine in 2014,
715
00:47:51,314 --> 00:47:55,434
the way in which these
military attacks and conflicts
716
00:47:55,514 --> 00:48:00,394
were carried out with utmost brutality
should have been a sign to all of us
717
00:48:00,474 --> 00:48:01,874
that this is not a
man who you're going
718
00:48:01,954 --> 00:48:03,434
to sit around a
negotiating table with.
719
00:48:03,514 --> 00:48:04,914
If he's capable of this sort of thing,
720
00:48:04,994 --> 00:48:06,834
he does not stand for the sorts of
721
00:48:06,914 --> 00:48:09,194
values that that we
claim to stand for.
722
00:48:12,554 --> 00:48:14,714
[narrator] The provocations increase.
723
00:48:14,794 --> 00:48:19,954
NATO AWACS monitor more airspace
infringements by Russian fighters.
724
00:48:26,514 --> 00:48:29,834
Russia stations new missiles
at Kaliningrad,
725
00:48:29,914 --> 00:48:31,874
directly on NATO's borders.
726
00:48:35,394 --> 00:48:38,074
Russia's hypersonic Avangard missile
727
00:48:38,154 --> 00:48:41,674
is a weapon for which
there is supposedly no defense.
728
00:48:44,794 --> 00:48:47,714
A great confrontation
seems inevitable.
729
00:48:47,794 --> 00:48:50,354
Putin seeks divine support.
730
00:48:50,434 --> 00:48:53,674
In June 2020, he consecrates
a new cathedral
731
00:48:53,754 --> 00:48:55,434
dedicated to Russia's military.
732
00:48:57,754 --> 00:49:00,634
[Kusber] Near Moscow, there is
a cathedral for the Russian army
733
00:49:00,714 --> 00:49:03,114
with an illustrated historical record
734
00:49:03,194 --> 00:49:07,394
linking past wars,
including before 1917,
735
00:49:07,474 --> 00:49:09,794
with the tasks
awaiting the military of the future.
736
00:49:10,994 --> 00:49:15,394
There are empty spaces
for commemorations of future battles.
737
00:49:16,794 --> 00:49:18,434
[religious chanting]
738
00:49:18,514 --> 00:49:21,914
[narrator] The church glamorizes war
and glorifies crimes,
739
00:49:21,994 --> 00:49:24,154
like the bloody purges under Stalin
740
00:49:24,234 --> 00:49:27,354
that claimed the lives
of millions of Russians.
741
00:49:31,834 --> 00:49:35,034
Putin, his defense minister
and Patriarch Kirill
742
00:49:35,114 --> 00:49:37,034
attend the consecration.
743
00:49:37,874 --> 00:49:42,074
Construction cost more
than 75 million euros.
744
00:49:42,954 --> 00:49:45,514
[male voice singing religious chants]
745
00:49:46,394 --> 00:49:48,234
[somber music playing]
746
00:49:49,114 --> 00:49:52,474
[narrator] A mural commemorating
the "repatriation" of the Crimea,
747
00:49:52,554 --> 00:49:55,594
paying homage to
Putin and his coterie,
748
00:49:55,674 --> 00:49:58,994
is still incomplete
at the time of the consecration.
749
00:50:01,914 --> 00:50:03,634
[Richie] He wants
to go down in history
750
00:50:03,714 --> 00:50:06,194
as a figure like Peter the Great
or like Stalin.
751
00:50:06,274 --> 00:50:09,354
For him, his own ego
and his own individual importance
752
00:50:09,434 --> 00:50:12,954
in his mythical idea
of the world history
753
00:50:13,034 --> 00:50:14,714
is more important than the reality.
754
00:50:14,794 --> 00:50:17,874
I very much fear
a Hitler in the bunker parallel,
755
00:50:17,954 --> 00:50:21,794
that he's just not going to be able
to see reality.
756
00:50:24,994 --> 00:50:29,274
[speaking in Russian]
757
00:50:30,474 --> 00:50:33,194
[band plays military march]
758
00:50:33,274 --> 00:50:36,074
[narrator] Russia
wants its empire back.
759
00:50:36,154 --> 00:50:40,394
That's been the goal of ex-KGB officer
Vladimir Putin
760
00:50:40,474 --> 00:50:42,274
for more than 20 years.
761
00:50:47,794 --> 00:50:49,394
[siren sounds in the distance]
762
00:50:50,634 --> 00:50:53,634
[narrator] Kyiv, February 24th, 2022.
763
00:50:53,714 --> 00:50:54,954
Air raid sirens.
764
00:50:55,514 --> 00:50:59,474
Russia is attacking Ukraine
in a full-scale invasion.
765
00:50:59,554 --> 00:51:01,634
People try to find places of safety.
766
00:51:02,314 --> 00:51:04,634
There's chaos on
the roads and streets.
767
00:51:07,994 --> 00:51:10,594
Putin calls it
a special military operation
768
00:51:10,674 --> 00:51:12,554
for the liberation of Ukraine.
769
00:51:13,354 --> 00:51:15,634
And he threatens the West.
770
00:51:15,714 --> 00:51:18,234
[speaking in Russian]
771
00:51:35,434 --> 00:51:37,634
[Felshtinsky]
This war is not about Ukraine.
772
00:51:37,714 --> 00:51:42,954
It's his major battle
to control the world.
773
00:51:45,594 --> 00:51:48,154
[narrator] It is Putin's third war.
774
00:51:48,234 --> 00:51:51,394
With severe Russian
losses from day one.
775
00:51:53,314 --> 00:51:57,434
But in Russia's wars,
casualties have never counted.
65005
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.