Original subtitles

Give me the money. Give me the money.

Empty it out.

Hurry up, hurry up!

Come on, come on, come on, come on.

All of it. Put the money in the bag.

Put the money in the bag, come on.

- Take it easy, huh? - What're you doing?

I'm just getting a bag, okay?

All of it. Put the money in the bag.

Come on. Hurry up, I need table six.

Hey! Get back! Get back!

Get down!

There's a male with a gun, shooting people

at the Bel Aire Diner on 21st Street.

Early 20s, gray hooded sweatshirt and jeans.

Greatest superhero, including Marvel and DC?

- Mm-hmm. - Got to say Spider-Man.

Aw, Peter Parker's flawed.

That's what I like about him.

He makes mistakes, but he has good intentions.

Plus he's a native New Yorker.

I'll give you that.

Spidey represents.

But he's a one-woman man.

I don't think you have that in common.

That's only because I haven't met my Mary Jane yet.

- Oh. - Okay, what about you?

Wonder Woman.

She's hot, but come on,

what kind of superpowers does she actually have?

Uh, just superhuman strength and speed. Hello?

Plus she's got cool boots and magic bracelets.

I do dig that golden lasso.

Oh, my God!

Hey.

Police! Police! Clear the way, clear the way.

Everyone back up. Clear the way. Back up.

She was shoved in to traffic.

We're going to take care of you, okay?

But you can't move.

Central, 2-9, we are requesting a bus

at 13th and Washington. I have a woman

struck by a car at this location.

What happened?

Out of nowhere, this crazy guy just shoved her.

Did you get a good look at him?

He was in his, uh, 20s,

uh, green sweatshirt, jeans.

Which way did he go?

He ran that way, laughing the whole time.

Baez. Hey, Danny.

Hope this isn't gonna become a habit.

- Nice to see you, too. - Well, what do we got?

I've got a series of robberies in the 2-9

targeting young women.

This fits the pattern.

Young women being robbed is part of a pattern?

Well, two perps in broad daylight,

grabbing high-end bags,

and then assaulting the vic is the pattern.

Yeah, well, sounds like every other robbery

on this street to me.

I think we can handle it without a babysitter. Thank you.

Doesn't have to be a fight, Danny.

If it was a fight, you'd know.

All right. Look, who's the vic?

Grace Mitchell, Adam Reynolds.

They're boyfriend and girlfriend.

They were both robbed and assaulted?

No, she was robbed by the two guys,

he tried to step in, he got assaulted, too.

Great. Can we take it from here, boss?

Looking forward to not working with you.

Same.

Excuse me. Hey, can we have a word?

Sorry, no can do.

We need to transport them ASAP.

What hospital?

St. Benjamin's.

If this is stranger on stranger,

the city is worse off than I thought.

Call came in approximately 7:35 hours.

We responded immediately,

but she was DOA when we got here.

Who called it in?

The witness. Sophia Abetemarco.

15 years old. She's kind of shell-shocked.

She hasn't given a statement or anything.

Where is she now?

She's outside on the back of the bus.

Any other witnesses?

Just her. She was getting a private lesson.

No other students around.

Anthony, I came as soon as I heard.

Is she okay?

No, she's not okay.

Her ballet teacher, Miss Patty,

was gunned down right in front of her.

Is she hurt?

Not wounds you could see.

Hi, Sophia, how're you doing?

Are you okay?

I'm sorry this happened to you.

Did you happen to see anything?

Um, I...

No, she didn't see anything.

Okay. Well, maybe we can let Sophia answer?

Maybe you didn't hear me, Erin.

She didn't see anything.

- Dad? - Uh...

Hey, Malone, can you help me out over here?

Can you, uh, stand up and take your jacket off for me?

And then we'll give it to the officer.

Here. Now you got everything you need.

I'm taking Sophia home.

Anthony, uh...

Come on. The car's over there. Goodbye, Erin.

Officer Hayes.

Commissioner.

Have a seat.

DCPI Garrett Moore.

Yes, sir. I've seen you on the news.

And I'm Lieutenant Gormley.

Thanks for coming up so quickly.

As you know, I gave a full statement

to the detectives who responded.

Yeah, we talked to those guys,

and we watched the security footage.

So, you saw he had a gun,

started shooting it without warning.

We did. And you were off duty.

- I was. - But the guy

didn't come in shooting, though, right?

He went to the register first, and he told the owner

- to empty the drawer. - Yes.

And you observed that going down?

I did.

Could you walk us through what you did to stop it?

As I said in my report,

I just figured I'd let the crime go down,

give a good description after

to minimize people from getting hurt.

Well, once he opened fire,

I'm not sure who you were protecting

by not getting involved.

The report indicates you were armed.

Yes, but I was afraid if I fired,

I might hit an innocent bystander.

So instead you let one civilian die,

two others are clinging to life in the ICU,

one a 12-year-old boy.

I've said all there is to say in my report.

That's all, Officer Hayes. You're dismissed.

His answers are totally unacceptable.

Ask Baker to come in.

I want to take a hard look at that surveillance footage again.

I think we got a problem.

I was walking towards the High Line,

and out of nowhere, this guy just pushed me,

full force, into traffic.

Do you remember anything else?

I remember hitting the hood of the car.

Would you be able to describe him?

No. Honestly, I was too busy

taking in the buildings and all.

I had just arrived an hour before,

unpacked my bags and walked out to see the city.

I'm so sorry this happened to you.

From the time I was five,

I've wanted to come to New York City.

This is my graduation present from my parents.

You're here by yourself?

I have friends here.

I was supposed to meet them in the Village for drinks,

but I told them I couldn't make it.

Well, is there anyone we can call for you?

Can you call me a cab to take me back to Albuquerque?

Well, your injuries are minor at least.

So you can still enjoy the rest of your trip.

Are you serious?

I don't want to go anywhere

except home and away from here.

I never want to come here again.

I know, you could write an interim order,

call it the "Hero Clause."

That ought to get people lining up

to put their life on the line

every hour of every day

at a starting salary of 45,000.

I think the guy should get a serious rip.

I think he should be sent for retraining.

Well, I think he should be fired.

Well, clearly, I'm in the minority here.

You got that right.

I'm not one for fantasy.

I prefer my feet firmly planted.

What're you talking about?

Well, while you all weigh in

on what should happen to Officer Hayes,

you ought to go back and read

the Active Shooter Manual again.

It only mentions on-duty personnel.

There's no decision to make about Officer Hayes

because, technically, he did nothing wrong.

Give me a break, Garrett. He's a coward.

Morally? Ethically? Maybe you have a point.

Legally? Procedurally? None.

Why am I the only one willing to acknowledge this?

I'm not a cop. I'm sorry,

I missed the secret handshake on the way in.

Please, let's not go there again.

Sid, Abigail, give us the room.

You've got something to say, say it.

I believe I did.

I'm just trying to keep you

from firing someone without due cause,

and keeping your response to the press on point.

My response to the press is:

Officer Hayes dishonored his shield

and will be fired for dereliction of duty.

- Really, Frank? - That is my opinion.

You can't have an opinion.

This is about facts,

not about how you feel about Officer Hayes' actions.

I might not be a cop,

but I know how to separate the two.

Excuse me. Detective Reagan.

This is my partner Detective Baez.

We were wondering if we could ask you some questions

about the men who robbed and assaulted you.

Yeah, sure.

There was...

There was two of them.

Both wearing baseball caps.

Did they refer to each other by name,

or have any distinguishing features or marks?

Um, they were both in their late 20s, early 30s.

One Hispanic, one African-American.

I'd just paid the bill.

We'd just finished breakfast,

and I was just waiting for the credit card back.

And I told Adam I'd meet him outside.

It's a nice neighborhood, I wanted some air.

I had just got to the car

when one of them came up behind me

and, um, grabbed me and...

He tried to take my purse.

Did they have any weapons?

I don't know.

He just said, "Give me your bag, bitch."

And I said, "No."

Why should I hand over everything to that punk?

Mainly because he could've killed you.

Do you remember what happened next?

When I didn't let go, that's when he punched me in the face.

And then I came out and I rushed over to Grace,

but then the other guy, he grabbed me

and he threw me to the ground and just started stomping on me.

And the other one just kept...

he just kept kicking me.

Would you be able to sit with a sketch artist?

I'll do anything I can to get them off the street.

Absolutely. Same here.

Good, and we'll do everything we can to find them.

She's a real badass.

And lucky he didn't have a knife or a gun.

Well, I didn't say she was smart,

I said she's a badass.

Hard to see their faces with the baseball caps on.

I have footage from the other side of the street, too.

Can you zoom in on the phone?

Kind of blurry.

Yeah.

Hey, so you were right.

The assault on your two vics isn't part

of the pattern of assaults that we've been investigating.

Hmm, what do you know? Maybe you should

leave the investigating to us next time, huh?

Okay, so you don't want me to tell you about the cop

who just collared a guy in possession

of one of Grace Mitchell's credit cards?

That's great.

Tell your officer to hold him there

until we can get over there and question him.

Oh, you want a favor? I thought I was supposed to

leave the investigating to you.

Hey, how's Sophia?

She's upset, Anthony.

I'll talk to her.

Not right now. She's talking to a therapist.

A therapist? What're you talking about?

You know, just to help with what she saw.

Anthony, she hasn't been able to eat.

She's upset and agitated, and when I told Erin...

- You told Erin? - Well, she came by

to check on Sophia, and when I told her,

she suggested Sophia talk to a therapist.

And you didn't think to call me?

I just figured you knew

since it was coming from your office.

You went behind my back? Really?

What're you talking about?

You set Sophia up with a counselor, and, what,

you didn't think it was important to let me know?

Well, I thought Vivian would've told you.

Yeah, well, she didn't.

Look, I'm just trying to help.

Yeah, well, people always say that

right before they screw things up.

Look, Anthony, I don't think

you're looking at this the right way.

I'll tell you what I'm looking at:

a prosecutor who'll do anything to get an indictment.

That's not fair, and you know it.

I'm her father, Erin.

I'll decide what's best for my daughter.

You're just gonna victimize her all over again.

We have a suspect.

Who is he?

An ex-boyfriend of Miss Patty's.

We have surveillance video of him

leaving the ballet studio with blood on his shirt.

Okay, so that's case closed.

Not by a long shot.

We both know it's gonna take

more than that to prove he's guilty.

Sophia saw the murder.

We need her to come in and talk about what she saw,

hopefully ID him.

So this lunatic can go after her?

I will make sure she's protected.

Stop it, Erin.

You can't guarantee that, and you know it.

Okay, I can guarantee that if she doesn't come in

and talk about what she saw, he could go out

and hurt someone else, or even kill someone else.

Or Sophia could get killed.

Anthony, she is old enough to come in here

and answer some questions,

and I think that's what she needs to do.

I don't want to have to subpoena her.

Do what you need to do.

Hey.

- Ready to go? - Come here.

Take a look at this.

It's video footage from the traffic cam

where Sarah Longo was pushed.

I thought this was kicked upstairs to the squad.

Detective Giorgio likes me.

Yeah, you'll solve his case for him,

and he'll take all the credit.

I don't care about that.

It was put through facial recognition.

So, now all we do is cross our fingers.

I really want to get this guy off the street.

Me, too. Guy is pure evil.

- I feel bad for her, too. - I get that,

but honestly, she should be thankful

that she doesn't have worse injuries.

Don't tell me you're one of those people

that make themselves feel better about things

by imagining an even worse tragedy happening?

Yes, I am. I own that.

We got a match on facial recognition.

Okay, meet Michael Harris. Oh, serial offender.

Assault, possession of a weapon,

harassment, attempted murder.

Wow, that's great. Should we let the squad know?

We should go pick him up,

and then we'll let the squad know.

See? Sarah Longo is lucky after all.

We got your subpoena.

Are you kidding me?

Look, Anthony... Yeah, don't, okay?

Some friend you are.

Yeah, I am, and I'm hoping you eventually realize that.

You would have never done this to Nicky.

You would have never put her though this.

Yes, I would, and if I wasn't,

I would hope you would do something

to make me see the light.

Yeah, well, the difference is

I wouldn't interfere with how you parent your daughter.

This has nothing to do with parenting.

What do you think is going to happen

if you don't encourage Sophia to talk about what she saw?

You think it's just gonna magically disappear?

I'm trying to keep her safe.

So am I.By what,

putting her in front of a grand jury?

Look, Anthony,

I am going to prep her

in this office before she testifies

to make sure that she knows exactly what to expect.

Just get her in here.

You're interested in one thing and one thing only.

It's the right thing to do.

Yeah, keep telling yourself that, Erin.

Do you think I'm a hard ass?

I think it depends.

Not the answer I was looking for.

Well, if the situation warrants,

you can be... rightfully demanding.

How's that?

What's on your mind?

Anthony's 15-year-old daughter Sophia

was the only witness to a murder.

Okay.

And he doesn't want her cooperating.

And he...

thinks I only care about the case.

Well, Erin...

At the end of the day, you have to do

what you think's right,

even if it puts you at odds with...

...your most trusted confidante.

Are we still talking about me here?

Well, let's just say being a hard ass runs in the family.

Anything to do with the off-duty officer in the diner shooting?

Yeah. According to the guidelines,

he did nothing wrong, and Garrett thinks

every cop doesn't have to be a hero.

And that I have no right to demand that.

Well, except you had a son who made the ultimate sacrifice,

so, yeah, I think that qualifies you.

See? Now, there's the hard ass answer.

You assaulted Grace Mitchell and Adam Reynolds

and you stole their belongings.

Nah.

You got it all wrong, dude.

Okay, dude, then tell me what happened.

I found that card. On the street.

Right, you found it on the street,

and you just started using it.

Yeah. Finders keepers.

Finders keepers, huh? Well, well.

Oh, wow. Look what I found.

A cell phone belonging to Maurice.

But I guess it actually belongs to us now

because, well, finders keepers.

Hey, you can't see my phone.

Why not?'Cause it's mine.

Hmm. Well, you said yourself, finders keepers.

What don't we have CCS hack into this for us, okay?

Don't y'all need, like, a warrant or something?

Actually, we don't. Unless we have your permission.

Oh. Then you don't.

- Hmm. - You know this guy

has two felony convictions?

That's really bad news for him, isn't it?

Hey, I did my time.

- Right. - Oh, but did you know

that having two prior felony convictions

means that this time, this felony conviction

will get you mandatory 16 years to life.

- Mm-hmm. - What're you talking about?

What she's talking about is you're a three-time loser,

so the only thing standing between you

and 16 years is us.

And once we pick up your accomplice,

and he decides to cooperate, then he'll get the deal,

and you'll... Go up the proverbial creek.

You know which one that is right?

You made your point.

- You want to unlock the phone? - Mm-hmm.

I'll unlock it.

Carefully. Make sure you don't erase anything.

What time was the assault?

Um, 9:30.

What do you know? "She's on the way out now."

Sent at 9:29. That from your partner?

Nah, it's from the dude who paid us to do it.

What dude?

The chick's boyfriend. Adam.

Hi, Sophia, how you doing?

- A little nervous. - Okay.

Well, there's nothing to be nervous about.

I'm going to be here, and I won't ask you

to do anything that makes you uncomfortable.

And you don't have to answer anything

that makes you uncomfortable, either.

Okay, do you want to have a seat?

Emily's gonna help us out today.

Can I see you outside?

So, you can't be here, okay?

- Why not? - Because you're not

a D.A. investigator on this, you're a dad.

And you think I'm just going to leave her alone in there?

She's not alone, she's with me,

and she's with a paralegal. She'll be fine.

I don't know about this, Erin.

Anthony, I need to get her ready for the grand jury.

Okay? She will be safe and protected,

and I will send someone to get you when we're done.

Okay, let's get started.

You recognize him?

- No. - That's funny,

because he told us that you hired him

and his brother to rob your girlfriend.

And we've already got a subpoena

for your text messages.

You don't have anything.

Hmm, okay. Well, then maybe we should bring Grace in here

and she could tell us what happened herself.

My God, why would you bring her here?

I thought you didn't have anything to hide.

We'll just bring her in and show her Maurice's picture.

Of course, then we'll have to show her

the text messages between you and Maurice.

You know, the ones where you warned him

that she was coming out of the restaurant

just in time for him to rob her and assault her.

No, I'd never do anything

to hurt Grace, okay? Just the opposite.

Like hire two guys to rob her and beat her up?

They weren't supposed to really attack.

They were supposed to pretend to rob her.

Why?

So I could come out and stop the robbery,

and those guys were supposed to run away,

pretending to be scared of me.

Sacred of you? To what end?

I wanted to be a hero, you know?

She'd think I saved her,

and then she wouldn't want to break up with me.

You did this because you thought

she was going to break up with you?

One of her friends told me she was getting bored.

So, to spice things up, you hire a couple of criminals

to scare the crap out of her and beat her up?

I told you, they were never supposed to

lay their hands on her. I swear.

But then the guy, he tried to steal her bag,

and she fought back, she wouldn't give it up,

and then that's when they started hitting her for real.

So now it's her fault that she got beat up? Not yours.

No, it just...

It wasn't supposed to go down like that.

That wasn't the plan.

I tried to intervene,

I tried to get her to let it go,

but then they started...

punching and kicking me, too.

Some hero you are.

Thanks for coming up.

If this is a disciplinary meeting of some sort,

I'm not comfortable answering questions without my union rep.

Nah, you don't need your union rep.

Internal Affairs cleared you of any wrongdoing.

That's great news.

Congratulations.

He in? I need a word with him.

Not right now.

- That's Officer Hayes. - It is.

I didn't get a memo about the meeting.

The boss didn't think it was necessary.

So they said you did what you were required to do.

You called 911, and that is considered taking action.

And I gave a great description of the perp.

Absolutely right.

From your hiding place under the counter.

Excuse me?

Somehow you managed to do

the minimum you were required to do.

There's nothing that says I have to put my life on the line.

If I'd have fire, I could've been killed.

You're not exactly a guy

I'd want to be in a foxhole with.

We're not in a foxhole, we're in a city,

one that likes to crucify cops for any and every infraction.

If I'd have used my weapon and shot an innocent,

I'd be on the cover of the Post, labeled a murderer.

Instead of a coward?

I did what I had to.

You have no recourse.

You're absolutely right about that.

You're dismissed.

Oh, by the way...

Monday, you are to report to your new position

at Fleet Services.

Fleet Services? That's in Queens.

I live in Staten Island.

Is that a problem, Officer?

That's a rubber gun squad. You can't do that.

Actually, according to

the Patrol Guide you so revere...

I can.

Enjoy your new post.

So, we arrested him and now he's at Central Booking,

and he's awaiting arraignment.

And the judge will probably let him off

with no bail, like everyone else these days.

He has a record, so that will be taken into account.

Hey.

Which one's your favorite?

None.

I didn't go to any.

You haven't left your hotel room since the attack?

No.

Not that it's any of your business.

Okay.

Can I be left alone now?

Come on. Let's go.

She literally hasn't left her room since this happened.

I know. It is not our problem.

We're not ambassadors to every tourist

who gets taken for a ride

and then wants to blame the entire city.

Most of the time, all we see is the underside of the city,

and we never let it get to us.

Exactly. Congratulations to us.

Now, let's get back to work.

You know what? You're absolutely right.

- There you go. - Grace,

the D.A. said she can talk to you later today.

Do you want me to organize a ride home for you?

No, um... No, no, it's okay. I can...

I can walk from here. Thanks.

You son of a bitch!

You are nothing but a coward!

I'm sorry.

I hope you rot in prison.

Get him out of here.

Thank you for all your help.

Of course.

And thank you.

Congrats on closing your case.

You're welcome.

You know, he did help us close this case.

I'm aware of that. Thank you.

Then why do you always have to make it so awkward?

Why can't you just say, "Thank you?"

I will next time, okay, Mom?

I'm just saying,

he tried to make an effort with you.

It's nothing to do with any past disagreements we've had.

I think you're a little too old for a sibling rivalry.

It's not that either.

Well, what is it then?

You do realize when he was shot,

it was working one of our cases, right?

Yeah, but that was just a coincidence.

No, to you it was.

To me, it was my worst nightmare.

What, the fear of losing another brother?

Yeah.

It's more than that. You know...

I've seen my dad afraid once.

In my entire life, one time.

That was the night my brother Joe was killed.

34 years, I never saw him afraid.

And he's never been the same since.

It's understandable.

No, I know that, but I also made a promise that night

that I would do everything and anything in my power

to make sure he never had to experience that again.

Jamie being a cop and working with us, it just...

makes it a little difficult to keep that promise.

Because you think it's your job to keep him safe?

I don't know. I...

I know I can't do that.

It's just, when he works with us,

I just wish he would stay on the sidelines

and stay out of harm's way. That way...

That way, I can keep from disappointing my old man again.

Losing another brother on my watch...

But Jamie doesn't know that,

and to him, you just come across

as an ass most of the time. You really want that?

No.

Hey.

Hi.

You want a drink or something to eat?

No, I just popped by to tell you

that Sophia is definitely her father's daughter.

She gave great details on the murder,

and picked the suspect out from a double-blind photo array.

The ex-boyfriend?

Yeah, being arrested as we speak.

That's good.

But, you know, um...

...the most disappointing part of all this

is you didn't think

I had Sophia's best interests at heart.

Erin, look... No, you listen to me.

You're like family to me, and so is Sophia.

The fact that you didn't trust me,

or even questioned my motives,

well, that just...

...it hurt.

It hurt.

You ever add up how much money

you've put into this car over the years?

You can't put a price on nostalgia.

So true.

I had my first kiss in that car.

Kenny LeBrandy.

Joe taught me how to drive in this car. Hmm.

That would explain why you still can't make a U-turn.

You know, I went to my senior prom in this car.

With Marie Romano.

Ah, also known as "Double D" Marie.

Mm-hmm. Yeah, well,

I can tell you from experience, she wasn't.

Congratulations on, uh, closing the case against Adam Reynolds.

We charged him with conspiracy.

Wow. He gonna see any time?

First offense, three to five.

Good. Well, I couldn't have closed it without Jamie.

That's not true.

It is true.

Why are you being so nice, anyway?

Hmm, he's probably looking for someone

to take over his dish duty.

No, I'm not. I just...

realize that I can be a pain in the ass sometimes.

Sorry. Sometimes, or all the time?

I'm not talking to you.

Ah.

And arrogant.

Arrogant, yes. Arrogant.

And often ungrateful.

That's why nobody ever wants to apologize to a Reagan.

They make it impossible.

Wait, was this you apologizing?

Uh, did you hear an apology?

- I didn't hear one. - Definitely not.

It was.

And it is an apology.

That looked like it hurt. Are you okay?

- It still hurts. - Yeah.

I'm gonna go inside.

That... That was awkward.

You okay?

I'm okay. Sorry.

You really transferred the guy to Fleet Services?

He'll have a lot to think about on his commute.

That he will.

You're pretty ruthless. Just saying.

So I've been told.

Some might say a "hard ass."

I think you did the right thing.

- I agree. - A cop's still a cop,

it shouldn't matter what - suit of clothes he's wearing. - Well said.

I get you're looking at this through

your own ethical lens,

but won't there be blowback if you discipline him

when he didn't break any rules?

I didn't discipline him, I just transferred him.

A distinction without a difference.

Hey, some guys aren't cut out for patrol.

But, he wasn't on patrol. He was off duty.

A distinction without a difference.

I mean, you can train and you can prepare,

but you never know until you're in that moment

if you have what it takes or not.

I'm with Dad on this.

There's no room in the department for anybody

who's not willing to step up and act

when someone's life is on the line.

"Courage is not the absence of fear,

but the triumph over it."

"And the brave man is not he

"who does not feel afraid,

but he who conquers that fear."

Martin Luther King?

Nelson Mandela.

I still think it's harsh punishment

for inaction when you're off duty.

Well, you haven't seen harsh punishment from him

until you tried telling him you don't want to get up early

for Mass on a Sunday morning.

Hey, I was trying to build character.

Uh-huh.

Looking around the table, Francis,

I think it worked.

Amen to that.

Bless us, O Lord, and these thy gifts,

which we are about to receive, from thy bounty...

You did a great job. I'm so proud of you.

Thanks. It wasn't as scary - as I thought it would be. - Yeah.

Hi. Hi.

Sophia, this is Jennifer, Miss Patty's daughter.

Oh.

I just want to thank you so much

for coming forward like you did.

It was really brave.

I'm really sorry about your mom.

Thank you.

Hey, who was that?

Miss Patty's daughter.

Sophia did a great job

testifying in front of the grand jury.

You're free to take her home.

Thank you, Ms. Reagan.

- Erin, please. - Erin.

I know this wasn't easy, but you can go home

knowing you're helping to put a really bad man away.

Oh.

Come on, honey.

I got you one.

Officer Hayes is filing a grievance with the union.

Let him. He doesn't have a leg to stand on.

Optics aren't great. It'll look like punishment.

Which is exactly what you want.

I may not have walked a beat,

but I understand more than you think.

And what is it you think you understand, Garrett?

Why this case gets to you.

I understand that if you'd been the guy sitting in that diner,

you would have gotten involved.

I sense a parable.

And that diner owner and those two victims

would likely be having dinner with their own families tonight.

And maybe your family would be at your funeral.

Because that's how you roll.

It occurred to me that you expect Officer Hayes

to intervene.

You expected him to

put his life on the line without question.

There's no part of you

that doesn't understand why he didn't.

You think that's what cops do.

But you don't?

I get the theoretical,

but honestly, Frank,

do you really expect someone off duty

to possibly get themselves killed

as some sort of self-sacrifice to save innocents?

Yeah, I do.

There is the letter, and a spirit,

in the oath we take.

A good cop has to honor both.

All these years in, you still idealize the profession.

Oh, I turned in my rose-colored lenses

for readers a long time ago.

You're unique in how you look at the world,

I'll give you that.

Is that your way of saying I'm a dinosaur?

Sort of like the way you didn't invite me

to your meeting with Hayes as your way of saying

things are going to be done your way, protocol be damned.

I didn't invite you to the meeting

because it was a personnel matter.

Like hell. You didn't invite me

because I didn't agree with you.

I have never demanded consensus from you, Garrett.

No, but when a case gets under your skin,

you don't want to hear anything but your side.

But what do I know? I'm not a cop.

For what it's worth, I think you'd make a great cop.

Thank you.

But no, not by your standards.

I'd be the guy under the table dialing 911, too.

Maybe not, given the day.

Oh, absolutely. Any day.

We're both better off with me where I am,

the thorn in your side.

Not always.

But just enough.

Hi.

I do trust you.

It hasn't felt that way lately.

Look, I just wanted more than anything to protect her

from all the horrible stuff in the world,

and I felt like a failure because I couldn't.

But you can't protect her from this.

It's random, heat of the moment.

You're right.

And that's the logical way to look at it,

but I wasn't thinking logically.

Look, it's hard for you to understand,

with your family and all, but when I was growing up,

we didn't talk about things.

It was more like, ignore it and it'll go away.

Even "I love you" sounded more like,

"Have you checked the oil lately?"

I get it, I do,

but it doesn't mean you need to carry on the tradition.

I'm learning.

How's she doing?

Honestly, she's happier since she testified.

I mean, still traumatized,

don't get me wrong, but I can tell

she's proud of herself.

Feels like she made a difference, you know?

She did make a difference.

When the defense read her grand jury testimony,

they agreed to discuss a plea.

- Wow. That's great. - Yeah,

Sophia won't have to go through a trial.

Ah, that's such a relief, Erin.

I hope you can forgive me.

Well, that depends.

On what?

Dinner. I haven't eaten.

Well, how about if I take you to the best Italian meal

you ever had at Da Nico's on Mulberry Street?

Well, that sounds like a throw-down if I ever heard one.

My car's around the corner. I'll drive.

One question though:

have you checked the oil lately?

I don't understand. What're we doing here?

There's someone we'd like you to meet.

Oh, no, I don't want - to meet anyone. - Oh, no, no, no.

You're gonna want to meet her,

she's a real New Yorker.

She's seen worse than you happen in New York.

And she still loves the city with a passion.

The Statue of Liberty?

- You got it. - Really?

Our shields don't get us too much these days,

but it can still get us into certain landmarks

without having to wait.

I don't know what to say. Really...

I've never been on a boat before.

- What? - Wait till I tell my parents.

Wait. Should I get a New York hot dog before we go?

- Uh, yeah. - You got to get a New York hot dog,

- I suppose. - Okay.

- Yeah? - Hi.

What happened to Mr. "We are not ambassadors to every tourist"?

Yeah, I couldn't get my dad's voice out of my head.

How so?

He was from the Dominican Republic.

Came to New York in 1967.

Loved the city the minute he arrived.

So, every time a new relative came by,

he would drag us to every tourist attraction in Manhattan

because he wanted to make sure

everyone else loved it, too.

Oh, my God.

It's so beautiful.

How about you let that be your memory of New York City?

I will. And thank you.

Thank you both.

Hey, can I get a picture with you guys?

- Uh, yeah. - Of course you can.

I am a model, so of course.

Say, "Cheese."

- Cheese. - Cheese.

- There you go. - Thank you.

This is a really good thing you did today, Badillo.

Can't wait to tell the rest of the squad.

Oh, no. No way. You can't.

What? I have a reputation to uphold.

Okay, tough guy,

your secret's safe with me.

Thank you.

I bet your dad would be so impressed with you today.