All language subtitles for Silent.Witness.S26E10.Southbay.Part.2.720p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTb

af Afrikaans
ak Akan
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bem Bemba
bn Bengali
bh Bihari
bs Bosnian
br Breton
bg Bulgarian
km Cambodian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
chr Cherokee
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
da Danish
nl Dutch
en English
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
ee Ewe
fo Faroese
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gaa Ga
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek
gn Guarani
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ia Interlingua
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
rw Kinyarwanda
rn Kirundi
kg Kongo
ko Korean
kri Krio (Sierra Leone)
ku Kurdish
ckb Kurdish (Soranî)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Laothian
la Latin
lv Latvian
ln Lingala
lt Lithuanian
loz Lozi
lg Luganda
ach Luo
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mfe Mauritian Creole
mo Moldavian
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
sr-ME Montenegrin
ne Nepali
pcm Nigerian Pidgin
nso Northern Sotho
no Norwegian
nn Norwegian (Nynorsk)
oc Occitan
or Oriya
om Oromo
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt-BR Portuguese (Brazil)
pt Portuguese (Portugal) Download
pa Punjabi
qu Quechua
ro Romanian
rm Romansh
nyn Runyakitara
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
sh Serbo-Croatian
st Sesotho
tn Setswana
crs Seychellois Creole
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhalese
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish
es-419 Spanish (Latin American)
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
tt Tatar
te Telugu
th Thai
ti Tigrinya
to Tonga
lua Tshiluba
tum Tumbuka
tr Turkish
tk Turkmen
tw Twi
ug Uighur
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
wo Wolof
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu
Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated: 1 00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:04,162 WWW.MY-SUBS.CO 1 00:00:00,879 --> 00:00:02,523 Enjoy your retirement, Bill. 2 00:00:02,547 --> 00:00:05,459 No-one alive or dead could say you haven't earned it. 3 00:00:05,484 --> 00:00:07,457 - To Bill. - To Bill! 4 00:00:07,481 --> 00:00:10,527 It might be a late one. I need to run Bill back to Southbay. 5 00:00:10,551 --> 00:00:11,458 Be safe. 6 00:00:11,482 --> 00:00:14,001 The deceased is a Carol Laing. 7 00:00:14,025 --> 00:00:17,735 That angry man outside is her ex, Sergeant Michael Laing. 8 00:00:17,825 --> 00:00:20,482 Chief Superintendent Bridget Laing is his mother. 9 00:00:20,506 --> 00:00:22,460 Is there anything you want to tell me? 10 00:00:22,484 --> 00:00:28,194 When Mike was 11 or 12, Bridget fostered both Andrew and his little sister, Lisa. 11 00:00:28,219 --> 00:00:31,733 You attacked her in her own bed whilst her son slept just across the hall. 12 00:00:31,758 --> 00:00:34,464 And when she fought back, you stabbed her through the heart. 13 00:00:34,489 --> 00:00:36,790 It's very obvious why my client's in custody. 14 00:00:36,791 --> 00:00:39,333 Because Southbay CID bears a grudge. 15 00:00:39,568 --> 00:00:45,479 Six months ago my police partner, PC Fred Woods, just disappeared. 16 00:00:45,504 --> 00:00:47,841 His car was found at Southbay Bridge. 17 00:00:47,842 --> 00:00:51,042 You know how many people go over the side there every year? 18 00:00:51,043 --> 00:00:52,803 Fred received a threat to life 19 00:00:52,804 --> 00:00:55,084 from Detective Super Intendent Ray Palmer. 20 00:00:55,085 --> 00:00:57,645 Why did you tell us you'd never been upstairs? 21 00:00:57,646 --> 00:00:59,566 Why did you lie to us? 22 00:00:59,567 --> 00:01:01,687 Something happened in this room. 23 00:01:05,500 --> 00:01:08,900 He said, "If you or your brother try to leave this room, I'll know." 24 00:01:08,901 --> 00:01:10,608 Are you sure it was a man? 25 00:01:11,022 --> 00:01:14,582 Kate Freeman, you're charged that on the 14th of August 26 00:01:14,583 --> 00:01:18,543 at Markland Avenue, Southbay, you did murder Carol Laing, 27 00:01:18,544 --> 00:01:20,557 contrary to common law. 28 00:02:06,597 --> 00:02:08,182 Tell me, Ryan... 29 00:02:09,440 --> 00:02:11,252 ..the man in the mask. 30 00:02:11,800 --> 00:02:14,029 Can you remember the colour of his eyes? 31 00:02:20,890 --> 00:02:23,199 But you said you thought you recognised him? 32 00:02:23,200 --> 00:02:26,079 I said I thought I'd heard his voice before. 33 00:02:26,080 --> 00:02:29,492 - If I recognised him, I'd tell you. - Of course. 34 00:02:30,871 --> 00:02:35,033 And he made no attempt to restrain you or bind your hands, 35 00:02:35,058 --> 00:02:36,318 nothing like that? 36 00:02:36,560 --> 00:02:39,010 No. Why? 37 00:02:40,120 --> 00:02:43,037 - Thank you, Ryan. - Can I have a word? 38 00:02:48,589 --> 00:02:51,348 Is there a reason you asked him if his hands were tied? 39 00:02:51,349 --> 00:02:53,189 The killer tied his mother's hands. 40 00:02:53,672 --> 00:02:54,651 What? 41 00:02:54,675 --> 00:02:56,946 Just a very specific question, that's all. 42 00:02:56,970 --> 00:02:58,005 You're reading too much... 43 00:02:58,029 --> 00:03:00,187 Yesterday, you were saying you didn't want anyone jumping to conclusions. 44 00:03:00,188 --> 00:03:01,809 - What did you mean by that? - Nothing. 45 00:03:01,834 --> 00:03:04,861 What conclusions are you afraid we'll jump to? The truth? 46 00:03:05,093 --> 00:03:07,735 Kate Freeman is facing life in prison. 47 00:03:07,736 --> 00:03:09,462 Not because she might be guilty, 48 00:03:09,463 --> 00:03:12,932 but because Southbay CID want to shut her up. 49 00:03:13,903 --> 00:03:15,716 - That's ridiculous. - Is it? 50 00:03:15,898 --> 00:03:20,793 Her partner questioned the lack of patrols in Harbour Fields and vanished without trace. 51 00:03:20,818 --> 00:03:23,391 How about you do your job and let me do mine? 52 00:03:23,392 --> 00:03:26,813 - Are you testing Ryan's pyjamas? - For fibres and DNA, as we speak. 53 00:03:26,814 --> 00:03:28,260 Everything all right? 54 00:03:30,854 --> 00:03:33,270 Ryan would like to get some things from his room. 55 00:04:06,744 --> 00:04:08,183 Hi. Meena. 56 00:04:08,184 --> 00:04:09,544 Lisa. 57 00:04:10,464 --> 00:04:13,048 - Is Andrew in? - No. 58 00:04:13,519 --> 00:04:16,115 He's not at work and I couldn't reach him on his mobile. 59 00:04:16,140 --> 00:04:18,761 He should be back by six, cos we're going to the cinema. 60 00:04:19,487 --> 00:04:20,636 OK. 61 00:04:22,939 --> 00:04:24,776 Can I come in and wait for him? 62 00:04:26,151 --> 00:04:27,431 Thank you. 63 00:04:32,624 --> 00:04:34,066 Is that Mike? 64 00:04:34,344 --> 00:04:35,745 On the left, yeah. 65 00:04:36,060 --> 00:04:38,109 Corsica, 2001. 66 00:04:38,134 --> 00:04:39,245 Good memory. 67 00:04:40,488 --> 00:04:44,616 Remember the good, forget the bad, that's my philosophy! 68 00:04:45,184 --> 00:04:47,422 We barely see Mike these days. 69 00:04:48,744 --> 00:04:51,666 Why's that, if you don't mind me asking? 70 00:04:52,664 --> 00:04:55,343 Andrew wasn't impressed he walked out on Carol. 71 00:04:55,344 --> 00:04:58,543 Mike being Mike, he didn't think it was anyone's business. 72 00:05:06,178 --> 00:05:07,218 Hi. 73 00:05:25,675 --> 00:05:27,195 Poor Andrew. 74 00:05:29,111 --> 00:05:31,431 He's taken Carol's death hard. 75 00:05:32,359 --> 00:05:33,959 Very hard. 76 00:05:33,984 --> 00:05:36,464 I didn't know him and Carol were close. 77 00:05:36,673 --> 00:05:38,543 They dated when they were kids. 78 00:05:38,544 --> 00:05:40,183 I was so jealous. 79 00:05:40,184 --> 00:05:43,104 Up until then, I always had his undivided attention. 80 00:05:44,464 --> 00:05:47,063 Carol had her 18th at the sailing club. 81 00:05:47,064 --> 00:05:48,823 Andrew organised it. 82 00:05:48,824 --> 00:05:50,903 He was good at organising things. 83 00:05:50,904 --> 00:05:52,743 What did I do? 84 00:05:52,744 --> 00:05:55,669 Threw the biggest meltdown I could muster. 85 00:05:56,864 --> 00:05:59,463 Andrew blew out the party to stay with me, 86 00:05:59,464 --> 00:06:03,270 and by midnight Mike and Carol were an item. 87 00:06:04,209 --> 00:06:07,080 I was so happy when they got together again recently. 88 00:06:07,105 --> 00:06:08,384 Andrew and Carol? 89 00:06:09,904 --> 00:06:11,111 Meena. 90 00:06:17,372 --> 00:06:18,943 What are you doing here? 91 00:06:18,944 --> 00:06:22,344 You blank me at work, ignore my calls, what am I supposed to do? 92 00:06:24,068 --> 00:06:25,584 What is it, Meena? 93 00:06:27,360 --> 00:06:29,583 I took a statement from Ryan Laing which, 94 00:06:29,584 --> 00:06:31,503 if corroborated, kills our case. 95 00:06:31,504 --> 00:06:32,639 In what way? 96 00:06:33,024 --> 00:06:34,664 In every way. 97 00:06:34,929 --> 00:06:37,451 As in Kate Freeman didn't do this. 98 00:06:41,333 --> 00:06:44,892 Ryan's testimony is compelling, but not a knockout blow. 99 00:06:44,893 --> 00:06:48,324 The CPS are too invested to drop the charges unless they have to. 100 00:06:48,849 --> 00:06:50,852 I say we focus on the timeline. 101 00:06:50,853 --> 00:06:54,549 It's central to showing the Crown's case is fundamentally flawed. 102 00:06:55,270 --> 00:07:01,168 OK, well, we know that the boys went to bed earlier than usual, 9:00pm, 103 00:07:01,193 --> 00:07:04,253 because they were going fishing with their dad at the crack of dawn. 104 00:07:04,254 --> 00:07:07,413 Dom Laing says that when he heard his mother arguing with Kate, 105 00:07:07,414 --> 00:07:10,536 his brother was watching the Spurs game on his phone with headphones. 106 00:07:10,537 --> 00:07:13,163 - What time did that game finish? - 9:30pm. 107 00:07:13,164 --> 00:07:16,972 A 9:00pm to 9:30pm window does fit with the pathology evidence. 108 00:07:16,973 --> 00:07:20,141 It's when Carol sustained the blow to the head downstairs. 109 00:07:20,165 --> 00:07:20,915 Yes. 110 00:07:20,939 --> 00:07:24,772 And now we hit the two-hour gap before the killer 111 00:07:24,773 --> 00:07:27,052 inflicts the fatal chest wound. 112 00:07:27,053 --> 00:07:30,692 And apart from a partial clean-up and moving Carol to the bedroom, 113 00:07:30,693 --> 00:07:32,531 here's where we're drawing the blank. 114 00:07:32,532 --> 00:07:34,566 Did they go away and come back? 115 00:07:34,567 --> 00:07:38,271 Or are we looking at two timeframes... 116 00:07:38,821 --> 00:07:40,545 ..and two offenders? 117 00:07:40,546 --> 00:07:43,692 I'm stuck on him carrying her upstairs. 118 00:07:43,693 --> 00:07:46,252 Why? What purpose did it serve? 119 00:07:46,253 --> 00:07:49,252 And after having done it, what possessed him 120 00:07:49,253 --> 00:07:51,972 to go into the boys' room and be seen? 121 00:07:51,973 --> 00:07:54,052 And he didn't just go into the room. 122 00:07:54,053 --> 00:07:58,212 He made physical contact with Ryan and he let him hear his voice. 123 00:07:58,213 --> 00:08:00,532 Again, all seriously odd. 124 00:08:00,533 --> 00:08:04,692 OK, 'seriously odd' sounds like we're doubting Ryan's account. 125 00:08:04,693 --> 00:08:07,532 We're establishing a factual sequence of events. 126 00:08:07,533 --> 00:08:09,812 How you then frame it is up to you. 127 00:08:09,813 --> 00:08:12,440 - I'm sorry, that's disingenuous. - Meaning? 128 00:08:12,465 --> 00:08:15,143 Meaning you're an expert witness for the defence. 129 00:08:15,168 --> 00:08:16,959 - You know the drill. - I thought I did. 130 00:08:16,960 --> 00:08:20,289 We refract all the evidence through the prism of Kate's innocence. 131 00:08:20,290 --> 00:08:23,218 We can't assume Kate's innocence without a grasp 132 00:08:23,219 --> 00:08:25,896 on the totality of that evidence. 133 00:08:25,954 --> 00:08:27,933 Take PC Woods' disappearance, 134 00:08:27,958 --> 00:08:30,572 it may or may not pertain to the Crown's case. 135 00:08:30,573 --> 00:08:32,252 We don't know. 136 00:08:32,253 --> 00:08:34,573 'Don't know' means 'no'. 137 00:08:34,815 --> 00:08:37,288 I get your impulse to find out what's happened to Woods, 138 00:08:37,289 --> 00:08:40,129 but it's pulling focus and threatening my ability 139 00:08:40,130 --> 00:08:43,012 to offer a clear, exculpatory narrative. 140 00:08:43,013 --> 00:08:47,730 OK. Let's start with the narrative, if only to move the conversation on. 141 00:08:51,067 --> 00:08:54,612 Ryan Laing saw and heard a male intruder. 142 00:08:54,613 --> 00:08:56,652 Not a woman, not Kate. 143 00:08:56,653 --> 00:09:00,157 So his brother was mistaken about hearing Kate? 144 00:09:01,034 --> 00:09:03,933 'Mistaken' being a charitable interpretation. 145 00:09:04,769 --> 00:09:06,858 And why did Southbay CID miss this? 146 00:09:07,113 --> 00:09:09,964 Because their myopic focus on Kate Freeman 147 00:09:09,989 --> 00:09:13,551 demonstrably blinded them to the key elements of the scene. 148 00:09:13,576 --> 00:09:14,784 Examples? 149 00:09:14,785 --> 00:09:17,376 The two hours gap the killer spent on site 150 00:09:17,401 --> 00:09:20,207 and the initial attack with the dumbbell downstairs. 151 00:09:21,536 --> 00:09:22,621 Sorry. 152 00:09:23,774 --> 00:09:25,054 Hello? 153 00:09:26,682 --> 00:09:28,807 Oh. Yeah, come on up. 154 00:09:33,213 --> 00:09:34,706 How can we help? 155 00:09:35,186 --> 00:09:38,586 Meena just brought me up to speed about Ryan. 156 00:09:40,001 --> 00:09:42,972 And... there's something we need to share as a matter of urgency. 157 00:09:42,973 --> 00:09:46,932 Sorry, do I infer you haven't shared his testimony with your superiors? 158 00:09:46,933 --> 00:09:48,693 - No, we have. - And? 159 00:09:50,213 --> 00:09:52,093 I'll get to that in a minute. 160 00:09:53,105 --> 00:09:56,974 About four months ago, West Yorkshire CID got in contact in... 161 00:09:57,307 --> 00:09:59,373 ..unusual circumstances. 162 00:09:59,586 --> 00:10:01,644 They'd had this spate of robberies 163 00:10:01,669 --> 00:10:03,613 targeting these cash in transit vans, 164 00:10:03,772 --> 00:10:06,452 carried out by a man in a black ski mask. 165 00:10:06,477 --> 00:10:08,612 He bound the driver with cable ties. 166 00:10:08,613 --> 00:10:10,932 Then he threatened them with a hunting knife. 167 00:10:10,933 --> 00:10:13,404 They had a strong suspect named Wes Carter, 168 00:10:13,429 --> 00:10:16,172 who they pulled in a few times but didn't have enough for a charge. 169 00:10:16,173 --> 00:10:18,132 Why did West Yorkshire get in touch? 170 00:10:18,133 --> 00:10:20,423 Because Wes Carter had moved down to Southbay, 171 00:10:20,424 --> 00:10:23,452 no doubt hoping for police interest in him to cool. 172 00:10:23,453 --> 00:10:25,884 Yorkshire must have been pretty sure he was their man. 173 00:10:25,885 --> 00:10:28,847 They were warning us to keep an eye and expect the worst. 174 00:10:28,848 --> 00:10:33,774 Now, clearly this man, Wes Carter according to Yorkshire CID, 175 00:10:33,799 --> 00:10:36,733 looks and sounds a lot like the man Ryan described. 176 00:10:40,848 --> 00:10:43,128 Don't take this the wrong way, but... 177 00:10:44,493 --> 00:10:46,252 ..why are you coming to us? 178 00:10:46,573 --> 00:10:47,813 I, er... 179 00:10:48,384 --> 00:10:52,262 We have been sidelined by Detective Super Ray Palmer. 180 00:10:52,765 --> 00:10:56,111 I took Ryan's statement and formally entered it in the file. 181 00:10:56,112 --> 00:11:01,052 We're here to ensure that this new avenue is fully explored. 182 00:11:01,053 --> 00:11:04,005 Sounds like you don't trust your colleagues in CID 183 00:11:04,006 --> 00:11:06,909 to do their job and we're the safety net. 184 00:11:07,960 --> 00:11:09,613 Insurance policy. 185 00:11:12,228 --> 00:11:15,308 Would you be kind enough to step out for a moment? 186 00:11:15,800 --> 00:11:16,855 Sure. 187 00:11:18,027 --> 00:11:19,716 We'll go wait in the lobby. 188 00:11:26,333 --> 00:11:28,812 We need to give the CPS pause for thought, 189 00:11:28,813 --> 00:11:31,372 make them aware how flawed their case really is. 190 00:11:31,373 --> 00:11:34,104 I don't want to play my best cards and leave nothing for the trial. 191 00:11:34,105 --> 00:11:35,588 I think it's worth the risk. 192 00:11:35,589 --> 00:11:37,835 I know someone in the CPS who can help, 193 00:11:37,836 --> 00:11:40,373 if I'm still on her Christmas card list. 194 00:11:42,735 --> 00:11:46,077 You told me Freeman's brief tapped Lyell for a second PM 195 00:11:46,102 --> 00:11:47,661 and a look at the forensics... 196 00:11:47,892 --> 00:11:48,979 And? 197 00:11:49,373 --> 00:11:53,572 You neglected to add their findings differ significantly from yours. 198 00:11:53,573 --> 00:11:54,892 That worries me. 199 00:11:54,893 --> 00:11:56,250 It shouldn't. 200 00:11:56,251 --> 00:11:59,365 It makes me think "ambush down the line in court". 201 00:11:59,573 --> 00:12:02,123 Now I'm hearing about a witness statement from Ryan Laing 202 00:12:02,124 --> 00:12:04,347 that essentially contradicts his brother's. 203 00:12:04,813 --> 00:12:07,646 It's led me to look deeper into the background of the case, 204 00:12:08,040 --> 00:12:09,486 specifically Kate Freeman. 205 00:12:09,487 --> 00:12:11,551 - I hear that after... - I don't believe this. 206 00:12:11,552 --> 00:12:14,175 I hear that after her partner disappeared, 207 00:12:14,176 --> 00:12:15,796 Kate was making trouble. 208 00:12:16,133 --> 00:12:17,864 Bandying stories about. 209 00:12:18,173 --> 00:12:22,194 Stories like Woods didn't take his own life and had enemies in CID. 210 00:12:22,224 --> 00:12:24,692 Key word there being "stories". 211 00:12:24,693 --> 00:12:27,172 Still, putting her on suspension might play like you're 212 00:12:27,173 --> 00:12:28,932 muzzling her to a jury. 213 00:12:28,933 --> 00:12:31,052 Christ, Bridget, it might play like that to me. 214 00:12:31,053 --> 00:12:33,692 Who's pouring poison in your ear, Alan? 215 00:12:33,693 --> 00:12:35,532 And Kate luring your son from the marital bed 216 00:12:35,533 --> 00:12:37,012 doesn't exactly simplify matters. 217 00:12:37,013 --> 00:12:39,181 Someone's put the frighteners on you, haven't they, eh? 218 00:12:39,182 --> 00:12:40,337 All right. 219 00:12:41,973 --> 00:12:44,341 Look, I understand your wariness. 220 00:12:44,981 --> 00:12:48,480 As you say, Kate Freeman is not a straightforward suspect. 221 00:12:48,481 --> 00:12:50,055 How do we move things forward? 222 00:12:53,253 --> 00:12:54,751 We get it all out in the open. 223 00:12:54,752 --> 00:12:57,316 - We do that in court, right? - I mean now. 224 00:12:58,158 --> 00:13:00,571 We hear both sides' evidence early doors 225 00:13:00,572 --> 00:13:04,574 so no-one can say the CPS rushed to judgment in charging Kate Freeman. 226 00:13:05,683 --> 00:13:08,133 Well, that's pretty unorthodox, isn't it? 227 00:13:10,522 --> 00:13:12,043 But not unprecedented. 228 00:13:18,761 --> 00:13:21,456 Thank you all for coming up to London today. 229 00:13:22,513 --> 00:13:27,640 Dr Burnett, can you clarify your interpretation of the pathology 230 00:13:27,665 --> 00:13:30,519 evidence with regard to sequence and timeframe? 231 00:13:30,613 --> 00:13:31,827 Gladly. 232 00:13:31,828 --> 00:13:33,812 We're looking at two distinct attacks. 233 00:13:33,813 --> 00:13:36,412 First the blow to the head and then, after a short delay, 234 00:13:36,413 --> 00:13:37,852 the fatal stab wound. 235 00:13:37,853 --> 00:13:39,484 How short a delay? 236 00:13:39,773 --> 00:13:41,573 5 to 15 minutes. 237 00:13:42,348 --> 00:13:45,693 How do you account for the accumulation of blood 238 00:13:45,694 --> 00:13:47,412 between the brain and the skull? 239 00:13:47,413 --> 00:13:48,844 Very easily. 240 00:13:48,845 --> 00:13:51,708 The stab wound was fatal, but not immediately so. 241 00:13:52,816 --> 00:13:54,603 I find that unlikely. 242 00:13:54,973 --> 00:13:59,532 For one, hilt bruising on the skin shows that the impact 243 00:13:59,533 --> 00:14:03,718 was exceptionally forceful and the wound is in a position where the 244 00:14:03,743 --> 00:14:06,212 internal haemorrhage was torrential. 245 00:14:06,213 --> 00:14:07,852 It would induce death swiftly? 246 00:14:07,853 --> 00:14:13,612 Mm. For two, grooving on the base of the brain suggests that Carol was 247 00:14:13,613 --> 00:14:17,990 alive for a longer period of time, possibly a couple of hours, 248 00:14:18,015 --> 00:14:20,456 between the initial head injury and the stabbing. 249 00:14:20,457 --> 00:14:22,612 Not the shorter time Dr Burnett's suggesting? 250 00:14:22,613 --> 00:14:23,296 No. 251 00:14:23,321 --> 00:14:26,921 Can you really exclude other causation for the grooving? 252 00:14:27,173 --> 00:14:29,664 Cardiac arrest, for example? 253 00:14:29,973 --> 00:14:32,385 You can't and you know you can't. 254 00:14:34,402 --> 00:14:38,328 In your report, you class the head wound 255 00:14:38,329 --> 00:14:40,492 as a "contrecoup injury", 256 00:14:40,493 --> 00:14:43,612 ie, one caused by the victim falling onto an object. 257 00:14:43,613 --> 00:14:46,443 Let me guess - you think it was a coup injury. 258 00:14:46,775 --> 00:14:50,012 I think Carol was struck by a moving object, yes, 259 00:14:50,013 --> 00:14:51,732 not the other way round. 260 00:14:51,733 --> 00:14:53,612 Based on what evidence? 261 00:14:53,613 --> 00:14:59,817 If this was a contrecoup, can you specify the object she fell onto 262 00:14:59,862 --> 00:15:03,507 that caused these distinctive marks? 263 00:15:04,387 --> 00:15:08,172 She sustained the injury in a struggle in the bedroom. 264 00:15:08,173 --> 00:15:11,932 There were any number of objects and corners she could have fallen on. 265 00:15:11,933 --> 00:15:14,369 Then you'd expect to find blood transfer, surely. 266 00:15:14,370 --> 00:15:17,258 Not if the killer wiped that object down. 267 00:15:17,283 --> 00:15:20,212 Dr Burnett... The absence of evidence is not evidence. 268 00:15:20,213 --> 00:15:22,892 For the avoidance of doubt, are you saying that you failed to 269 00:15:22,893 --> 00:15:25,332 identify the object that caused this injury? 270 00:15:25,333 --> 00:15:27,452 Look, I didn't process the scene. 271 00:15:27,453 --> 00:15:28,652 Jack did. 272 00:15:28,653 --> 00:15:29,693 What? 273 00:15:30,468 --> 00:15:34,476 Sadly, he didn't swab or photograph all of the potential edges 274 00:15:34,501 --> 00:15:37,607 and corners she could've fallen on, or close to all of them. 275 00:15:39,573 --> 00:15:40,852 I didn't finish processing 276 00:15:40,853 --> 00:15:43,338 because I was removed from the scene by Chief Superintendent Laing. 277 00:15:43,339 --> 00:15:46,599 That was later, you broke away from the scene of your own volition. 278 00:15:46,600 --> 00:15:48,141 What are you talking about, Bill? 279 00:15:48,142 --> 00:15:50,812 You were distracted and less than stringent 280 00:15:50,813 --> 00:15:52,532 in observing scene etiquette. 281 00:15:52,533 --> 00:15:54,287 Are you having a laugh? I did you a bloody favour. 282 00:15:54,288 --> 00:15:57,439 Perhaps it was the effect of meeting Kate Freeman outside. 283 00:15:58,171 --> 00:16:00,252 She made quite an impression on you. 284 00:16:03,277 --> 00:16:07,880 And you'd had so much to drink, I'm surprised you remember anything! 285 00:16:20,413 --> 00:16:21,526 Um... 286 00:16:23,930 --> 00:16:27,332 ..we'd like to present an alternative reading of the evidence, 287 00:16:27,333 --> 00:16:28,489 if that's all right. 288 00:16:28,490 --> 00:16:29,775 It's why we're all here. 289 00:16:30,050 --> 00:16:32,894 We believe we've found a second crime scene 290 00:16:32,950 --> 00:16:34,732 in the downstairs sitting room. 291 00:16:34,733 --> 00:16:38,097 Not only have we found Carol's blood on the floor, 292 00:16:38,098 --> 00:16:43,823 we matched the tiered pattern of her head wound to one of her dumbbells. 293 00:16:45,086 --> 00:16:48,947 Significantly, the other dumbbell is missing from the house, 294 00:16:49,200 --> 00:16:52,254 and, yes, they're sold as a pair. 295 00:16:52,727 --> 00:16:57,123 Expirated blood on the halfway landing and transfer of paint 296 00:16:57,124 --> 00:17:01,951 under Carol's toenails further proved that the attack unfolded 297 00:17:01,976 --> 00:17:05,395 in two locations and two timeframes - 298 00:17:05,396 --> 00:17:08,765 circa 9pm and circa 11pm. 299 00:17:08,766 --> 00:17:13,172 The Crown's investigation completely failed to unearth these basic 300 00:17:13,173 --> 00:17:14,466 elements of the scene. 301 00:17:14,586 --> 00:17:17,022 We've effectively had to do their job for them. 302 00:17:17,023 --> 00:17:20,130 And when we factor in Ryan's testimony that he saw 303 00:17:20,131 --> 00:17:21,965 a male intruder 304 00:17:22,213 --> 00:17:27,424 and Dr Burnett's inebriation, it adds up to one thing - 305 00:17:27,667 --> 00:17:31,094 you need to release Kate Freeman immediately. 306 00:17:49,402 --> 00:17:51,267 Why do you think Bill said all that? 307 00:17:56,653 --> 00:17:57,778 Velvy? 308 00:17:57,779 --> 00:17:59,628 I enlisted my botanist friend. 309 00:17:59,865 --> 00:18:03,452 Foliage in PC Woods's car is predominantly leaves 310 00:18:03,453 --> 00:18:04,974 from a black poplar. 311 00:18:04,975 --> 00:18:07,514 OK, rare, but not as rare as I'd like. 312 00:18:07,539 --> 00:18:11,471 Well, the good news is there's an arboretum of black poplars 313 00:18:11,472 --> 00:18:15,053 near one of the two roads that comes off Southbay Bridge. 314 00:18:15,209 --> 00:18:18,899 Now, as you know, speculation is something that I try to avoid. 315 00:18:18,900 --> 00:18:20,329 What do you think happened, Velvy? 316 00:18:20,330 --> 00:18:25,770 I think that Woods was killed and possibly buried at the arboretum. 317 00:18:26,093 --> 00:18:29,892 The killer then drove Woods's car to Southbay Bridge 318 00:18:29,893 --> 00:18:34,132 in the knowledge that - A, people jump off it, and - B, 319 00:18:34,133 --> 00:18:37,877 bodies that go in the water are often swept out to sea. 320 00:18:38,455 --> 00:18:40,653 Speculation suits you, Velvy. 321 00:19:15,890 --> 00:19:18,618 ..29. Looks like we've got an indication here. 322 00:19:24,875 --> 00:19:26,376 What is it? What've they found? 323 00:19:26,377 --> 00:19:28,468 Andrew, just give us a minute, yeah? 324 00:19:42,489 --> 00:19:47,041 Body is partly skeletal, partly adiopocere. 325 00:19:47,387 --> 00:19:50,721 Hair has fallen away, face is decomposed. 326 00:19:51,304 --> 00:19:55,410 Woods was last seen wearing an anorak with Man United insignia. 327 00:19:55,843 --> 00:19:57,639 Hands are bound behind his back. 328 00:19:58,309 --> 00:20:00,329 Looks like they used cable ties. 329 00:20:00,330 --> 00:20:01,639 The cash van guy? 330 00:20:01,640 --> 00:20:03,707 - Wes Carter. - Used cable ties, didn't he? 331 00:20:03,885 --> 00:20:05,453 What about Wes Carter? 332 00:20:11,982 --> 00:20:14,275 Meena! Wes Carter. 333 00:20:21,973 --> 00:20:23,773 Police. Open up! 334 00:20:26,090 --> 00:20:28,928 - I appreciate you doing this. - It's our job. 335 00:20:29,314 --> 00:20:33,379 After everything, asking Bill Burnett just felt wrong. 336 00:20:34,371 --> 00:20:35,731 Was there something else? 337 00:20:37,709 --> 00:20:40,748 Kate would like to sit in on the PM. 338 00:20:43,980 --> 00:20:46,533 It's OK with me, if it's OK with you. 339 00:20:47,588 --> 00:20:48,948 Are you sure? 340 00:21:04,333 --> 00:21:05,733 Have you said anything? 341 00:21:11,573 --> 00:21:13,892 - What are you doing here, Andrew? - Following a lead. 342 00:21:13,893 --> 00:21:15,172 A link, anyway. 343 00:21:15,173 --> 00:21:20,204 A link? Oh, let me guess, between Ryan's testimony about a masked man 344 00:21:20,229 --> 00:21:23,268 and a tip-off from West Yorks about a bloke doing over cash vans? 345 00:21:23,269 --> 00:21:27,452 We just found a body matching the clothes Woods was last seen wearing, 346 00:21:27,453 --> 00:21:29,812 about a mile from Southbay Bridge. 347 00:21:29,813 --> 00:21:31,893 Hands bound with cable ties. 348 00:21:32,243 --> 00:21:34,572 A rather more compelling link than a mask, 349 00:21:34,573 --> 00:21:35,971 wouldn't you say? 350 00:21:42,093 --> 00:21:43,573 There's nothing here. 351 00:21:44,472 --> 00:21:46,253 I'm not so sure, sir. 352 00:21:51,853 --> 00:21:53,881 Let's not tip this one over the floor. 353 00:21:56,133 --> 00:21:57,478 Cor. 354 00:21:57,585 --> 00:21:59,708 There's got to be at least two hundred grand here. 355 00:21:59,709 --> 00:22:01,984 We need to check this against the cash from the vans. 356 00:22:01,985 --> 00:22:03,134 Oh, no shit. 357 00:22:03,479 --> 00:22:04,748 Is there any more? 358 00:22:08,013 --> 00:22:09,387 Just this. 359 00:22:15,853 --> 00:22:17,302 Ventight. 360 00:22:17,952 --> 00:22:20,373 Same brand of tie we found on Woods. 361 00:22:24,989 --> 00:22:26,977 The deceased is an adult male, 362 00:22:26,978 --> 00:22:29,987 provisionally identified as Fred Woods. 363 00:22:30,653 --> 00:22:32,735 We're waiting for DNA confirmation. 364 00:22:32,933 --> 00:22:35,909 There's putrefaction, consistent with the body being 365 00:22:35,910 --> 00:22:38,763 deceased for a significant period of time. 366 00:22:38,764 --> 00:22:41,113 There's evidence of a broken neck. 367 00:22:41,532 --> 00:22:44,750 There is grit embedded in the skull that we'll be comparing 368 00:22:44,751 --> 00:22:48,070 to the sandstone boulders in the stream. 369 00:22:48,333 --> 00:22:52,172 So, what, he fell head first into the creek, 370 00:22:52,173 --> 00:22:55,394 cracked his skull on a boulder and broke his neck? 371 00:22:55,759 --> 00:22:58,931 Easy to imagine with his hands bound behind his back. 372 00:23:08,973 --> 00:23:12,812 So Fred's just lying there in the dark with a smashed skull 373 00:23:12,813 --> 00:23:18,267 and a broken neck, potentially still conscious or semi-conscious... 374 00:23:19,233 --> 00:23:22,168 ..and then he drowns? 375 00:23:22,437 --> 00:23:23,897 We can't say for sure. 376 00:23:24,343 --> 00:23:27,158 The C2 fracture could've been rapidly fatal, 377 00:23:27,435 --> 00:23:31,645 but we just don't know when decomposition's this advanced. 378 00:23:34,014 --> 00:23:38,093 We'd better catch this bastard, Ma'am, that's all I can say. 379 00:24:05,257 --> 00:24:07,489 Wes! Wes! Wes! 380 00:24:07,533 --> 00:24:09,133 Don't be fucking stupid! 381 00:24:11,160 --> 00:24:13,272 Head that way, cut him off. 382 00:24:59,733 --> 00:25:00,773 UH! 383 00:25:17,733 --> 00:25:19,373 Ah, sh... 384 00:26:45,767 --> 00:26:48,322 Here! OVER HERE! 385 00:26:52,533 --> 00:26:55,226 What happened? Walsh? 386 00:26:55,227 --> 00:26:57,120 I told him to stop. He wouldn't. 387 00:26:57,121 --> 00:26:58,893 Tried to push me over. 388 00:27:10,723 --> 00:27:13,986 We've matched the size and waffle-style tread 389 00:27:13,987 --> 00:27:15,923 of Nike trainers in your closet 390 00:27:15,947 --> 00:27:18,775 to the muddy print on PC Woods's brake pedal. 391 00:27:19,423 --> 00:27:22,076 We also DNA'd the head-rest inside Woods's car 392 00:27:22,077 --> 00:27:23,745 and scored a match... to you. 393 00:27:25,111 --> 00:27:28,091 The forensics tie you to the murder of a policeman, Neil. 394 00:27:28,092 --> 00:27:30,519 So now's the time to cooperate. 395 00:27:30,662 --> 00:27:32,402 Don't dig your hole any deeper. 396 00:27:34,422 --> 00:27:37,485 Look, I didn't kill anyone, all right? Nothing like that. 397 00:27:37,841 --> 00:27:38,788 OK. 398 00:27:39,065 --> 00:27:40,319 So what happened? 399 00:27:41,293 --> 00:27:44,372 I was paid to hassle a few residents in Harbour Fields. 400 00:27:44,373 --> 00:27:46,852 Protestors against the Goshawk Construction development? 401 00:27:46,853 --> 00:27:50,293 Numpties fighting against the compulsory purchase order. 402 00:27:50,380 --> 00:27:52,335 What did "hassling" them entail? 403 00:27:52,409 --> 00:27:54,786 A broken window here, a late night call there. 404 00:27:55,147 --> 00:27:56,526 A few slashed tyres. 405 00:27:56,653 --> 00:27:58,799 Then, when Wes came to stay, 406 00:27:59,280 --> 00:28:01,456 it's safe to say I was... 407 00:28:01,733 --> 00:28:03,999 ..able to bolster my services. 408 00:28:04,293 --> 00:28:05,522 Who paid you? 409 00:28:05,773 --> 00:28:06,737 Don't know. 410 00:28:06,738 --> 00:28:09,385 I mean, I assume Goshawk Construction, ultimately, 411 00:28:09,386 --> 00:28:10,495 somewhere down the line. 412 00:28:10,586 --> 00:28:12,194 How were you paid, then? 413 00:28:12,195 --> 00:28:15,992 Money was put into my account via a front called Standant LTD. 414 00:28:16,017 --> 00:28:17,467 A shell company? 415 00:28:17,468 --> 00:28:19,372 Yeah, I googled 'em. 416 00:28:19,373 --> 00:28:20,932 Based in the Virgin Islands. 417 00:28:20,933 --> 00:28:25,486 I only dealt with one bloke - called himself Marcus, via a burner. 418 00:28:26,836 --> 00:28:28,332 Caller unknown. 419 00:28:28,333 --> 00:28:29,829 So you can't help us? 420 00:28:30,443 --> 00:28:32,400 Can't help us help you? 421 00:28:33,605 --> 00:28:35,717 You've got to give us something, Neil. And the sooner the better, 422 00:28:35,718 --> 00:28:37,971 or this stops looking like cooperation 423 00:28:38,220 --> 00:28:39,448 and more like desperation. 424 00:28:39,449 --> 00:28:42,354 Bear in mind, your phone and laptop are being examined right now. 425 00:28:54,757 --> 00:28:57,972 Marcus told me and Wes to give Woods a scare, right, 426 00:28:57,973 --> 00:28:59,943 cos he'd been asking difficult questions at work. 427 00:28:59,944 --> 00:29:03,452 I didn't start out wanting to hurt him. He's a copper, right, 428 00:29:03,453 --> 00:29:04,619 I'm not daft. 429 00:29:04,620 --> 00:29:06,676 What, just roughed him up a bit? 430 00:29:06,893 --> 00:29:08,237 Wes did. 431 00:29:08,772 --> 00:29:11,428 He cable tied his hands while I showed him the money. 432 00:29:12,085 --> 00:29:14,091 Look, I thought he was going to go for it, 433 00:29:14,431 --> 00:29:20,003 but then he just belted it into the trees, that was that. 434 00:29:23,573 --> 00:29:25,267 Let's talk about Carol Laing. 435 00:29:25,892 --> 00:29:29,051 There's eyewitness testimony that places Wes at the scene. 436 00:29:29,413 --> 00:29:31,080 It points towards him killing Carol 437 00:29:31,081 --> 00:29:33,235 in the process of stealing her jewellery. 438 00:29:33,772 --> 00:29:36,236 Yeah, nice try. 439 00:29:36,508 --> 00:29:38,316 - He didn't do that. - How do you know? 440 00:29:38,341 --> 00:29:39,957 Cos I was his favourite uncle. 441 00:29:39,958 --> 00:29:41,440 He never kept anything from me. 442 00:29:41,441 --> 00:29:43,456 That's not exactly compelling, Neil. 443 00:29:44,470 --> 00:29:48,772 He 'fessed up to those cash vans robberies as soon as I asked him. 444 00:29:48,893 --> 00:29:52,223 And for that very reason, I asked him about the Laing woman. 445 00:29:52,308 --> 00:29:54,705 The fact you even had to ask him contradicts your statement 446 00:29:54,730 --> 00:29:58,494 that he spent the night fixing a leak at the pub, doesn't it, Neil? 447 00:30:00,244 --> 00:30:03,830 So, forgive us if we take everything you say with a pinch of salt. 448 00:30:11,426 --> 00:30:14,576 Detectives? I need to tell you something in confidence. 449 00:30:15,213 --> 00:30:19,766 According to Kate Freeman, Palmer threatened Woods 450 00:30:19,791 --> 00:30:23,391 when he asked why patrols were being diverted from Harbour Fields. 451 00:30:23,416 --> 00:30:25,172 Well, what did Palmer say to Woods? 452 00:30:25,173 --> 00:30:27,373 "There are faster ways to die than cancer." 453 00:30:29,906 --> 00:30:32,173 I'll have to pass that on to Police Conduct. 454 00:30:41,145 --> 00:30:43,735 There's massive trauma to the body and head, 455 00:30:43,736 --> 00:30:47,084 consistent with a significant fall onto a hard surface. 456 00:30:48,203 --> 00:30:50,992 There's damage to the side of the skull, consistent with him 457 00:30:50,993 --> 00:30:53,122 landing on his right side. 458 00:30:53,533 --> 00:30:55,709 There's a contusion to the forehead 459 00:30:56,013 --> 00:30:58,499 and some particles embedded in the wound. 460 00:31:09,373 --> 00:31:13,097 Contusions in the left upper frontotemporal region. 461 00:31:13,588 --> 00:31:16,039 Unusual, given the plane of impact. 462 00:31:16,493 --> 00:31:19,452 And it's inconsistent with Jack's account of grappling 463 00:31:19,453 --> 00:31:21,156 and fighting with the deceased. 464 00:31:21,505 --> 00:31:23,275 You spoke to Andrew in detail, 465 00:31:23,300 --> 00:31:25,872 do you think you could flesh out the scene for us? 466 00:31:26,013 --> 00:31:27,095 I'll try. 467 00:31:27,096 --> 00:31:30,819 He said he saw Carter walking up the path in a westerly direction? 468 00:31:30,844 --> 00:31:31,677 Yes. 469 00:31:31,678 --> 00:31:33,612 Andrew ran onto the path, ahead of him. 470 00:31:33,613 --> 00:31:35,838 He told him to stop, then Wes grabbed him 471 00:31:35,839 --> 00:31:37,573 and tried to shove him over. 472 00:31:38,583 --> 00:31:42,938 The front of Wes's T-shirt is bloody from his nose injury. 473 00:31:43,981 --> 00:31:47,773 I found what could be a handprint in the blood. 474 00:31:49,118 --> 00:31:52,446 I asked Andrew point-blank if he pushed Wes. 475 00:31:52,933 --> 00:31:55,492 He said he didn't remember but conceded that, yes, 476 00:31:55,493 --> 00:31:57,812 he could've pushed him in the altercation, 477 00:31:57,813 --> 00:32:01,172 because... he was in fear for his life. 478 00:32:14,853 --> 00:32:16,213 Come in. 479 00:32:24,372 --> 00:32:26,460 If I was to look at your bank account, Ray, 480 00:32:26,461 --> 00:32:28,875 would I find any unexplained payments? 481 00:32:28,876 --> 00:32:31,183 Specifically from some untraceable, 482 00:32:31,184 --> 00:32:35,453 bounced-around-the-world shell company called Standant LTD? 483 00:32:37,355 --> 00:32:39,195 I need an answer, I'm afraid. 484 00:32:57,350 --> 00:32:58,974 Oh, Ray, 485 00:32:59,286 --> 00:33:01,965 how could you be so bloody stupid? 486 00:33:01,990 --> 00:33:05,764 All I did was shift patrols away from Harbour Fields, that's it. 487 00:33:05,835 --> 00:33:07,191 Why was that so important? 488 00:33:07,192 --> 00:33:09,622 I don't know, to drive the crime stats up, I suppose. 489 00:33:09,623 --> 00:33:10,685 You suppose? 490 00:33:10,686 --> 00:33:13,179 Look, I had nothing to do with Fred Woods, all right? Nothing. 491 00:33:13,180 --> 00:33:15,144 But you threatened him, didn't you? 492 00:33:16,524 --> 00:33:17,688 I had a word. 493 00:33:17,689 --> 00:33:18,960 Big deal. 494 00:33:19,195 --> 00:33:20,473 "Big deal"? 495 00:33:20,811 --> 00:33:24,157 I placed Kate Freeman on fucking suspension 496 00:33:24,182 --> 00:33:27,253 because she came to me with nothing less than the truth! 497 00:33:27,504 --> 00:33:29,848 Can't believe you'd do this, Ray. 498 00:33:30,000 --> 00:33:31,716 Just for a bit of cash. 499 00:33:32,190 --> 00:33:36,637 They offered me a fortune to stop police operations in Harbour Fields. 500 00:33:36,638 --> 00:33:38,602 Let it go to the dogs. 501 00:33:38,650 --> 00:33:42,228 So some fucking property developer got it for a song. 502 00:33:42,229 --> 00:33:45,996 Listen, I knew Neil Carter was scaring the protestors at Harbour Fields, 503 00:33:45,997 --> 00:33:50,004 but I had no idea that his ex-para nephew was hitting town. 504 00:33:50,005 --> 00:33:52,262 I thought West Yorkshire dealt with this when he moved down. 505 00:33:52,263 --> 00:33:54,732 Yeah, well, they did. But Andrew Walsh took the call. 506 00:33:54,733 --> 00:33:57,379 - And...? - In his wisdom, he sat on it. 507 00:33:58,526 --> 00:34:01,181 Only him and Puri knew until this week. 508 00:34:04,750 --> 00:34:07,104 The Carol Laing inquiry is being wound down. 509 00:34:07,764 --> 00:34:11,307 We just wanted to say thank you for your critical involvement 510 00:34:11,308 --> 00:34:13,733 - and working in a pretty... - Wound down? 511 00:34:13,734 --> 00:34:16,590 Obviously, the Coroner's work is ongoing and there'll be an inquest... 512 00:34:16,591 --> 00:34:19,169 Because guilt is being ascribed to Wes Carter? 513 00:34:19,816 --> 00:34:22,567 I think that's premature. 514 00:34:22,750 --> 00:34:23,827 Well, with respect... 515 00:34:23,828 --> 00:34:25,254 Why do you think it's premature? 516 00:34:25,255 --> 00:34:29,490 There are things about Carol's murder that chime with Carter's MO. 517 00:34:29,491 --> 00:34:33,909 Lots of things - the mask, the knife, the black clothes, 518 00:34:33,910 --> 00:34:35,783 tying his victim's hands behind their back... 519 00:34:35,784 --> 00:34:38,018 But there are significant differences too. 520 00:34:38,019 --> 00:34:40,390 Carter never targeted private residences, 521 00:34:40,391 --> 00:34:44,335 he used cable-ties, and his booty of choice was cash, not jewellery. 522 00:34:44,470 --> 00:34:46,309 I still go back to the "why?" 523 00:34:46,310 --> 00:34:49,016 Why did he go into the boys' room and make contact? 524 00:34:49,017 --> 00:34:50,250 Why take that risk? 525 00:34:50,251 --> 00:34:51,885 He wanted to be seen and heard. 526 00:34:51,886 --> 00:34:54,588 Whoever grabbed Ryan Laing couldn't shut up! 527 00:34:54,589 --> 00:34:56,448 The only explanation is, 528 00:34:56,694 --> 00:34:59,964 he wanted Ryan Laing to give the testimony that he did. 529 00:34:59,965 --> 00:35:02,762 If we were in court that would definitely be deemed "conjecture". 530 00:35:02,763 --> 00:35:04,200 But we're not in court. 531 00:35:04,649 --> 00:35:07,049 If you're right, there's a problem. 532 00:35:07,505 --> 00:35:10,469 If the killer was trying to lead us to Wes, then... 533 00:35:10,470 --> 00:35:12,237 How did they get hold of the information? 534 00:35:12,238 --> 00:35:13,174 Hey? 535 00:35:13,870 --> 00:35:15,935 When West Yorkshire got in touch about Wes, 536 00:35:15,936 --> 00:35:20,078 we decided to keep the intel on a... strictly need-to-know basis. 537 00:35:21,910 --> 00:35:23,061 Why? 538 00:35:23,470 --> 00:35:24,549 Frankly? 539 00:35:24,550 --> 00:35:27,869 Cos Wes's uncle, Neil Carter, has a lot of mates in CID. 540 00:35:27,870 --> 00:35:29,477 From Ray Palmer down. 541 00:35:36,141 --> 00:35:38,352 It's Bridget. Need to go and update her. 542 00:35:38,960 --> 00:35:41,669 Ray Palmer's been suspended and I've replaced him. 543 00:35:41,830 --> 00:35:43,081 Acting DCI. 544 00:35:43,350 --> 00:35:44,390 Huh. 545 00:36:03,911 --> 00:36:05,591 I'm looking for my scarf. 546 00:36:06,542 --> 00:36:07,982 You seen it? 547 00:36:08,331 --> 00:36:09,718 What scarf? 548 00:36:09,768 --> 00:36:11,661 The gingham one I got in the sale. 549 00:36:15,422 --> 00:36:16,688 What? 550 00:36:20,528 --> 00:36:21,776 Doesn't matter. 551 00:36:28,397 --> 00:36:30,837 Could you zoom in on the knife, please, Velvy? 552 00:36:32,965 --> 00:36:34,567 It's a double-edged blade. 553 00:36:34,568 --> 00:36:35,979 Yes, it is. 554 00:36:36,288 --> 00:36:39,841 The stab wound looks symmetrical - both ends of the wound pointed, 555 00:36:39,866 --> 00:36:41,239 sharp, V-shaped. 556 00:36:41,240 --> 00:36:42,762 Key word there being "looks". 557 00:36:42,763 --> 00:36:45,964 We're actually looking at a single edged blade wielded with such 558 00:36:45,965 --> 00:36:48,467 force the skin behind the blunt edge split. 559 00:36:48,468 --> 00:36:51,503 Leaving something which looks V-shaped but isn't quite. 560 00:36:51,504 --> 00:36:53,553 One of the ends has a fishtail. 561 00:36:54,540 --> 00:36:57,715 So, if someone was trying to mimic Carter's MO, 562 00:36:57,963 --> 00:37:00,127 it was likely improvised, not planned. 563 00:37:00,128 --> 00:37:02,047 Otherwise you'd bring a double-edged blade? 564 00:37:02,048 --> 00:37:03,287 And cable ties. 565 00:37:03,288 --> 00:37:04,447 Both easy to source. 566 00:37:04,448 --> 00:37:06,110 What about the mask and the coat? 567 00:37:06,448 --> 00:37:08,792 Could've used Carol's gym leggings for the former, 568 00:37:08,793 --> 00:37:11,968 and Mike says he's missing a black coat from his closet. 569 00:37:12,744 --> 00:37:16,848 The brown particles I retrieved from the wound on Wes's forehead... 570 00:37:17,230 --> 00:37:21,668 it's bark from a Fraxinus excelsior, AKA the common ash. 571 00:37:21,669 --> 00:37:23,418 OK. How did it get there? 572 00:37:23,689 --> 00:37:25,418 No wood or trees down on the rocks. 573 00:37:25,419 --> 00:37:29,106 Suggesting contact was made before he fell. 574 00:37:30,525 --> 00:37:33,576 And with sufficient force to penetrate his scalp. 575 00:37:34,199 --> 00:37:35,472 What are you saying? 576 00:37:35,811 --> 00:37:39,287 I'm sorry, Meena, but the evidence is telling us 577 00:37:39,288 --> 00:37:41,419 that Andrew was the aggressor. 578 00:37:49,998 --> 00:37:53,536 What's all this? You're not going back to work? 579 00:37:54,831 --> 00:37:56,094 Not today. 580 00:38:10,528 --> 00:38:12,448 I'm worried about you. 581 00:38:12,807 --> 00:38:14,170 Drinking... 582 00:38:15,008 --> 00:38:16,448 ..missing work. 583 00:38:17,568 --> 00:38:19,168 It's Carol, isn't it? 584 00:38:21,248 --> 00:38:23,073 I don't want to talk about Carol. 585 00:38:27,795 --> 00:38:31,448 Let's talk about your scarf, where it could be. 586 00:38:31,707 --> 00:38:34,586 Oh, if I knew, I wouldn't be looking for it, would I? 587 00:38:36,728 --> 00:38:38,348 No, I suppose not. 588 00:38:41,710 --> 00:38:43,271 I'm not stupid. 589 00:38:44,848 --> 00:38:46,526 I can tell something's up. 590 00:38:47,388 --> 00:38:48,688 What is it? 591 00:38:50,936 --> 00:38:53,088 All right, be like that. 592 00:38:54,968 --> 00:38:56,587 I know what you did. 593 00:38:58,346 --> 00:39:00,728 I found your scarf at Carol's... 594 00:39:02,528 --> 00:39:03,928 ..in her blood. 595 00:39:24,568 --> 00:39:26,128 Carol? No... 596 00:39:28,168 --> 00:39:29,488 No! 597 00:39:49,368 --> 00:39:51,138 I understand. 598 00:39:51,806 --> 00:39:53,577 You weren't jealous. 599 00:39:55,078 --> 00:39:57,056 You were just scared of losing me. 600 00:39:59,773 --> 00:40:02,080 So, you removed the competition. 601 00:40:05,248 --> 00:40:06,658 It's OK. 602 00:40:07,688 --> 00:40:09,373 I'm want to take care of you 603 00:40:10,028 --> 00:40:11,605 and protect you... 604 00:40:13,744 --> 00:40:17,231 ..now and wherever we end up next. 605 00:40:20,474 --> 00:40:22,127 What are you talking about? 606 00:40:22,128 --> 00:40:23,968 Just tell me what happened. 607 00:40:25,592 --> 00:40:27,390 I did go and see Carol... 608 00:40:28,808 --> 00:40:30,377 ..but just for a coffee. 609 00:40:31,738 --> 00:40:33,934 Everyone thinks you're married to me, 610 00:40:34,963 --> 00:40:37,631 that I'm your ball and chain. 611 00:40:39,671 --> 00:40:43,111 I didn't want that to spoil things when you'd waited so long. 612 00:40:43,408 --> 00:40:48,967 What happened, Lisa? She took it the wrong way? You lost it? What? 613 00:40:48,968 --> 00:40:52,322 No. No, she was fine... 614 00:40:53,289 --> 00:40:55,341 She said she was touched... 615 00:40:56,679 --> 00:41:01,862 ..just a bit taken aback, you know, by me going round. 616 00:41:03,334 --> 00:41:06,728 She didn't deny there was something going on, but she said it was 617 00:41:06,808 --> 00:41:11,106 early days and Mike was still a big part of her life. 618 00:41:12,872 --> 00:41:14,208 But she said... 619 00:41:18,483 --> 00:41:21,715 ..she said she was hopeful for a future with YOU. 620 00:41:26,008 --> 00:41:27,482 And then I left. 621 00:41:29,166 --> 00:41:30,621 I went to the gym, 622 00:41:31,140 --> 00:41:32,724 popped to the supermarket... 623 00:41:33,590 --> 00:41:35,263 ..and I came home. 624 00:42:18,525 --> 00:42:20,648 All our years in foster care... 625 00:42:22,976 --> 00:42:24,527 I'm not making excuses... 626 00:42:24,528 --> 00:42:25,568 But? 627 00:42:28,288 --> 00:42:30,848 It's hard-wired in me, defending her... 628 00:42:33,067 --> 00:42:34,347 ..protecting her. 629 00:42:36,321 --> 00:42:40,179 All I could think was if she comes round and ID's Lisa, then it's over. 630 00:42:40,528 --> 00:42:42,313 And then it just came into my head. 631 00:42:43,475 --> 00:42:46,687 Earlier that day, I'd got an email from West Yorks asking 632 00:42:46,688 --> 00:42:49,818 if Wes was still keeping his nose clean. 633 00:42:53,930 --> 00:42:55,448 I knew what to do. 634 00:43:31,878 --> 00:43:35,231 Carol was dying anyway - you didn't need to stab her. 635 00:43:35,258 --> 00:43:36,925 You didn't need to do a thing! 636 00:43:37,457 --> 00:43:39,614 You've no idea how true that is. 637 00:43:40,478 --> 00:43:43,383 There was nothing stopping me rushing her to A&E. 638 00:43:44,230 --> 00:43:45,487 Nothing at all. 639 00:43:45,488 --> 00:43:46,688 So why didn't you? 640 00:43:47,515 --> 00:43:48,879 I saw Lisa's scarf 641 00:43:48,880 --> 00:43:50,936 and I jumped to the wrong conclusion. 642 00:43:52,488 --> 00:43:54,448 Lisa had nothing to do with it. 643 00:43:55,888 --> 00:43:57,648 She was at the gym... 644 00:43:58,728 --> 00:44:00,378 ..and then the supermarket. 645 00:44:00,379 --> 00:44:02,156 What about Wesley Carter? 646 00:44:02,568 --> 00:44:04,324 He dropped like a stone. 647 00:44:04,700 --> 00:44:06,274 I only hit him once. 648 00:44:07,768 --> 00:44:09,716 And I was hoping Lisa would be the same. 649 00:44:25,888 --> 00:44:27,275 Andrew! 650 00:44:27,448 --> 00:44:28,841 ANDREW! 651 00:44:29,208 --> 00:44:30,727 Andrew, come here. 652 00:44:30,728 --> 00:44:32,207 I'm going to kill you! 653 00:44:32,208 --> 00:44:33,767 I'M GOING TO KILL YOU! 654 00:44:44,048 --> 00:44:45,290 Where are we? 655 00:44:45,901 --> 00:44:47,283 Essentially? 656 00:44:47,760 --> 00:44:51,350 Sadly, we have no reason to doubt Andrew's version of events, 657 00:44:51,375 --> 00:44:54,127 especially in the light of him confessing to Wes Carter. 658 00:44:54,128 --> 00:44:58,168 He also directed us to a bin bag containing these items. 659 00:44:58,448 --> 00:44:59,928 Kitchen knife... 660 00:45:01,328 --> 00:45:02,928 Lisa's scarf... 661 00:45:04,799 --> 00:45:06,125 ..Mike's coat. 662 00:45:08,356 --> 00:45:11,751 But he says that he didn't see a dumbbell when he arrived 663 00:45:11,752 --> 00:45:14,468 at the scene and found Carol unconscious on the floor. 664 00:45:14,749 --> 00:45:17,567 As a detective, he said he looked for a weapon, 665 00:45:17,568 --> 00:45:19,768 but couldn't find a likely candidate. 666 00:45:20,271 --> 00:45:22,991 For what it's worth, I'm inclined to believe him. 667 00:45:24,219 --> 00:45:26,127 And we're sure Lisa's in the clear? 668 00:45:26,128 --> 00:45:28,853 We're sure - CCTV has her leaving the gym at 9.30, 669 00:45:28,854 --> 00:45:32,818 stopping in a supermarket, then entering her street just before ten. 670 00:45:33,263 --> 00:45:35,687 At least we've solved the mystery as to why the killer 671 00:45:35,688 --> 00:45:37,247 waited in the house for two hours. 672 00:45:37,248 --> 00:45:40,552 They didn't - we're dealing with two offenders. 673 00:45:40,991 --> 00:45:44,247 And it's important to stress that whoever hit Carol with 674 00:45:44,248 --> 00:45:46,528 the dumbbell used massive force. 675 00:45:46,847 --> 00:45:49,488 And regardless of what Andrew did later, 676 00:45:50,094 --> 00:45:53,220 it could have been a fatal injury, eventually. 677 00:45:53,308 --> 00:45:54,567 Attempted murder, 678 00:45:54,568 --> 00:45:55,848 at the very least. 679 00:45:55,950 --> 00:45:57,368 Something else, Ma'am. 680 00:45:57,369 --> 00:46:00,407 I trawled the notes from house to house with fresh eyes. 681 00:46:00,408 --> 00:46:03,327 A witness saw someone throw something over the sea wall 682 00:46:03,328 --> 00:46:07,167 in front of Carol's house between 9.15 pm and 9.30 pm. 683 00:46:07,168 --> 00:46:08,567 Jesus. 684 00:46:08,568 --> 00:46:11,751 Time and location fit with the attacker discarding the dumbbell. 685 00:46:11,928 --> 00:46:13,647 You want to search the shoreline? 686 00:46:13,648 --> 00:46:16,450 We'll cover it and whatever else you need. 687 00:46:28,688 --> 00:46:30,328 Hey, Hey! 688 00:46:39,928 --> 00:46:41,208 Let me see it! 689 00:46:50,728 --> 00:46:54,111 A bus passes twice an hour, cameras front and back. 690 00:46:54,528 --> 00:46:55,967 Check the timetable. 691 00:46:55,968 --> 00:46:57,608 If the last bus was on time, 692 00:46:57,848 --> 00:46:59,528 we could be in business. 693 00:47:00,648 --> 00:47:01,817 Oh... 694 00:47:02,008 --> 00:47:03,539 Here we go. 695 00:47:10,809 --> 00:47:12,447 That's not Mike Laing. 696 00:47:12,448 --> 00:47:13,599 Too slight. 697 00:47:14,151 --> 00:47:15,247 Kate Freeman? 698 00:47:15,248 --> 00:47:18,527 Look at their right hand when the bus passes and the lights hit. 699 00:47:18,528 --> 00:47:19,719 I'll call Puri. 700 00:47:21,094 --> 00:47:22,252 Wait. 701 00:47:22,253 --> 00:47:23,719 Let me have a crack at this. 702 00:47:23,720 --> 00:47:25,887 I've got some gait analysis software 703 00:47:25,888 --> 00:47:27,515 that I've been waiting to use. 704 00:47:52,048 --> 00:47:54,706 Sue said I should've packed it in at 60. 705 00:47:55,504 --> 00:47:59,301 The moral of that story is you should always listen to your wife. 706 00:47:59,408 --> 00:48:02,566 Who knows? I might actually enjoy retirement. 707 00:48:02,591 --> 00:48:04,408 Lisa, could you get some more onions? 708 00:48:04,973 --> 00:48:07,607 Cheer up, Bill, might never happen. 709 00:48:07,608 --> 00:48:08,834 Ignore him. 710 00:48:09,008 --> 00:48:10,491 There's drinks over there. 711 00:48:10,492 --> 00:48:13,031 There are more beers in the fridge, if they're not cold enough. 712 00:48:15,011 --> 00:48:16,448 Oh, Mum. 713 00:48:18,208 --> 00:48:19,783 You want me to get rid of him? 714 00:48:20,008 --> 00:48:21,048 Please. 715 00:48:22,488 --> 00:48:24,574 Don't... burn... the chicken wings. 716 00:48:32,820 --> 00:48:33,952 Kate! 717 00:48:37,048 --> 00:48:40,387 I just want to say, I really appreciate you coming. 718 00:48:41,151 --> 00:48:42,853 I'm happy to be here. 719 00:48:43,088 --> 00:48:45,768 We're not going to fix things overnight, but it's a start... 720 00:48:45,891 --> 00:48:47,121 It is. 721 00:48:47,455 --> 00:48:50,286 - What did I say about the wings?! - Sorry. 722 00:48:51,961 --> 00:48:54,190 Oh, shit, it's going to blow away! 723 00:48:59,168 --> 00:49:00,688 Do you need a hand, boys? 724 00:49:17,776 --> 00:49:20,386 I promise we'll come back to Granny's soon, all right? 725 00:49:22,048 --> 00:49:24,158 That's it, go on, in you get. 726 00:49:26,225 --> 00:49:27,807 Football practice? 727 00:49:27,808 --> 00:49:29,527 Yeah. I totally forgot. 728 00:49:29,528 --> 00:49:31,047 But that's Tuesdays? 729 00:49:31,048 --> 00:49:32,833 Yeah, well, they changed it. 730 00:49:33,314 --> 00:49:34,796 Don't ask me why. 731 00:49:37,957 --> 00:49:39,425 I'll come and get you later. 732 00:49:40,044 --> 00:49:41,848 No hurry, I can help clean up. 733 00:50:09,528 --> 00:50:10,568 Mike? 734 00:50:12,735 --> 00:50:14,951 Let's, um... Take it over here. 735 00:50:18,502 --> 00:50:19,809 Is Dom OK? 736 00:50:22,448 --> 00:50:24,048 What did you want to ask me? 737 00:50:25,128 --> 00:50:27,592 When you and Kate first came to the Lyell, 738 00:50:27,864 --> 00:50:29,393 the day after the murder, 739 00:50:29,418 --> 00:50:31,403 she had bruises on her right wrist. 740 00:50:31,428 --> 00:50:32,988 She said you made them. 741 00:50:33,047 --> 00:50:34,769 We'd been drinking. 742 00:50:35,208 --> 00:50:38,995 I was feeling low about being stuck in uniform. 743 00:50:39,305 --> 00:50:40,743 And I said that... 744 00:50:40,768 --> 00:50:44,063 the only way Mum was going to let me back in the CID was... 745 00:50:45,088 --> 00:50:46,692 ..if I moved home to Carol. 746 00:50:47,044 --> 00:50:48,399 And she lost it. 747 00:50:48,424 --> 00:50:50,114 She really, really lost it. 748 00:50:50,328 --> 00:50:52,207 Said that she was going to go and stay at a mate's 749 00:50:52,208 --> 00:50:54,328 but she'd had way too much to drink, and... 750 00:50:57,354 --> 00:50:59,348 ..I had to get her keys off her somehow. 751 00:51:05,448 --> 00:51:06,796 What is it, Mike? 752 00:51:09,768 --> 00:51:11,167 Dom's adamant... 753 00:51:11,168 --> 00:51:15,650 He's adamant that it was Kate's voice he heard speaking to his mum. 754 00:51:17,528 --> 00:51:19,168 And you believe him now? 755 00:51:20,688 --> 00:51:21,768 Dom? 756 00:51:23,048 --> 00:51:24,168 Come here. 757 00:51:30,488 --> 00:51:31,653 Look... 758 00:51:32,568 --> 00:51:34,288 I believe you, mate. 759 00:51:35,488 --> 00:51:39,113 I believe it was Kate's voice that you heard. 760 00:51:43,417 --> 00:51:46,425 Do you remember what they were arguing about, Dom? 761 00:51:47,015 --> 00:51:49,996 Do you remember any specific words? 762 00:51:55,848 --> 00:51:57,455 "Uniform". 763 00:51:58,631 --> 00:52:01,088 They were arguing about uniforms. 764 00:52:03,608 --> 00:52:05,368 Well done, mate. Go on. 765 00:52:10,312 --> 00:52:12,117 You gave Kate a scare. 766 00:52:12,596 --> 00:52:15,946 She knew how much you wanted to get back in CID. 767 00:52:16,570 --> 00:52:18,564 How much you missed the boys. 768 00:52:18,648 --> 00:52:22,317 So, the next day, hungover and paranoid, 769 00:52:22,318 --> 00:52:24,127 she confronts Carol. 770 00:52:24,128 --> 00:52:25,847 A pre-emptive strike. 771 00:52:26,354 --> 00:52:29,808 "If you went back, it wouldn't be for love. 772 00:52:31,804 --> 00:52:34,681 "It would be to get out of that bloody uniform." 773 00:52:36,048 --> 00:52:37,754 That sound plausible? 774 00:52:43,160 --> 00:52:44,667 Just in time. 775 00:52:44,668 --> 00:52:47,131 Come! Come! 776 00:52:58,560 --> 00:52:59,840 It all went! 777 00:53:00,035 --> 00:53:01,844 I normally make too much. 778 00:53:05,168 --> 00:53:07,186 Do you think Mike's OK? 779 00:53:08,008 --> 00:53:09,169 Yeah. 780 00:53:09,408 --> 00:53:12,253 I mean, under the circumstances. 781 00:53:13,118 --> 00:53:14,230 Why? 782 00:53:15,542 --> 00:53:17,337 Just him shooting off like that. 783 00:53:18,048 --> 00:53:19,455 I'm sure he's fine. 784 00:53:46,071 --> 00:53:47,452 Is Kate still there? 785 00:53:47,453 --> 00:53:48,872 You've got to keep her there! 786 00:53:49,288 --> 00:53:50,888 I'm still here, Mike. 787 00:53:57,259 --> 00:53:59,018 What's the matter? 788 00:54:18,248 --> 00:54:21,168 - Why...? - Funny you should ask, 789 00:54:21,975 --> 00:54:25,447 cos in so many ways, you were to blame. 790 00:54:25,448 --> 00:54:27,984 Do you know what, Kate? I'm not having this conversation with you. 791 00:54:27,985 --> 00:54:30,363 Don't fucking walk away from me. You know as much as I do, 792 00:54:30,364 --> 00:54:33,188 if Mike came back here, it's only cos of Bridget. Don't be fooled! 793 00:54:33,189 --> 00:54:36,253 Oh, what? You think he's that desperate to get out of uniform? 794 00:54:36,254 --> 00:54:38,564 Jesus, you don't know him at all, do ya? 795 00:54:38,628 --> 00:54:43,179 Cos if you did, you'd know that if he comes back, it's cos he wants to. 796 00:54:44,246 --> 00:54:47,047 You didn't really think you were the first, did ya? 797 00:54:47,048 --> 00:54:48,828 You didn't fall for that line, eh? 798 00:54:49,222 --> 00:54:51,634 You did! Wow, this is priceless! 799 00:54:51,635 --> 00:54:56,080 This is fucking hilarious! Let me guess. What was it? Kids? 800 00:54:56,612 --> 00:54:58,272 Mm? Nuptials? 801 00:54:58,555 --> 00:55:00,888 - You shut it... - Do you know what? 802 00:55:01,472 --> 00:55:03,767 I ALMOST feel sorry for you. 803 00:55:04,608 --> 00:55:05,688 Almost. 804 00:55:07,008 --> 00:55:08,844 I mean, he said you were thick... 805 00:55:09,669 --> 00:55:11,126 ..but Jesus Christ... 806 00:55:23,248 --> 00:55:25,607 Kate Freeman, I am arresting you 807 00:55:25,608 --> 00:55:28,701 on suspicion of the murder of Carol Laing in Southbay, Essex. 808 00:55:28,848 --> 00:55:30,647 You do not have to say anything, 809 00:55:30,648 --> 00:55:33,727 but it may harm your defence if you do not mention, when questioned, 810 00:55:33,728 --> 00:55:35,900 something which you later rely on in court. 811 00:55:54,488 --> 00:55:55,989 I can take her in. 812 00:55:56,622 --> 00:55:58,887 It's years since I felt a collar. 813 00:55:58,888 --> 00:56:00,528 I've missed it. 814 00:56:40,728 --> 00:56:42,594 - You OK? - Yeah. 815 00:56:43,780 --> 00:56:45,900 Been a nightmare, this whole thing, hasn't it? 816 00:56:46,088 --> 00:56:48,263 - Bill? - Bill. 817 00:56:50,008 --> 00:56:52,808 - Can you salvage it? - I don't know. It's... 818 00:56:53,968 --> 00:56:55,768 ..hard to get back, you know? 819 00:56:56,907 --> 00:56:58,587 You think you know someone. 820 00:57:03,768 --> 00:57:06,247 - Southbay's kind of grown on me. - Uh-oh! 821 00:57:06,248 --> 00:57:08,279 - Bank Holiday coming up... - Mm-hm. 822 00:57:08,304 --> 00:57:10,580 Fancy a long weekend back in Southbay? 823 00:57:10,605 --> 00:57:12,648 Mmmmmm... 824 00:57:13,648 --> 00:57:15,167 ..no. 825 00:57:15,168 --> 00:57:18,308 Why not? Come on, there's a beautiful beach. 826 00:57:18,309 --> 00:57:20,275 - Come on. - It's so romantic. 827 00:57:21,260 --> 00:57:23,980 You and I have different ideas of romance in that case. 828 00:57:40,168 --> 00:57:42,407 Do not throw me in! 829 00:57:52,704 --> 00:57:55,495 Sub extracted from file & improved by Se7enOfNin9 for MY-SUBS.com 63763

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.