1
00:00:08,964 --> 00:00:12,999
(theme music playing)
2
00:01:19,093 --> 00:01:23,715
- Synced and corrected by VitoSilans -
-- www.Addic7ed.com --
3
00:01:29,844 --> 00:01:32,145
(distant dogs barking)
4
00:01:33,615 --> 00:01:34,914
(car door closes)
5
00:01:35,016 --> 00:01:37,383
(footsteps approach)
6
00:01:42,290 --> 00:01:45,525
What we have here is the
same scenario as Andrea Cornish.
7
00:01:45,627 --> 00:01:46,926
Would you agree?
8
00:01:48,229 --> 00:01:50,463
So where's all the news trucks?
9
00:01:50,565 --> 00:01:53,933
Your basic uptown misdemeanor homicide.
10
00:01:58,340 --> 00:01:59,939
(camera flashes)
11
00:02:24,599 --> 00:02:27,767
What kind of knife was
used in this attack?
12
00:02:27,869 --> 00:02:30,336
One with a single-edged
non-serrated blade,
13
00:02:30,438 --> 00:02:32,572
approximately five inches in length.
14
00:02:32,674 --> 00:02:36,175
Something like... this one?
15
00:02:36,277 --> 00:02:37,844
Yes.
16
00:02:37,946 --> 00:02:42,415
And what about this wound
17
00:02:42,517 --> 00:02:45,718
on the defendant's hand?
18
00:02:45,820 --> 00:02:48,054
That cut is the
result of his hand slipping
19
00:02:48,156 --> 00:02:50,790
from the handle of the
knife onto the blade of the knife
20
00:02:50,892 --> 00:02:52,625
in the act of stabbing her.
21
00:03:14,616 --> 00:03:15,982
Your witness.
22
00:03:18,753 --> 00:03:20,219
Dr. Chester,
23
00:03:20,321 --> 00:03:23,689
did you hear Mrs. Weiss ask
you the total number of wounds?
24
00:03:23,792 --> 00:03:24,724
No.
25
00:03:24,826 --> 00:03:26,993
Me neither. I wonder why that is?
26
00:03:27,095 --> 00:03:29,362
Perhaps because we can see them.
27
00:03:29,464 --> 00:03:31,998
We can, that's true, and
they're hard to look at,
28
00:03:32,100 --> 00:03:33,533
but how many of them are there?
29
00:03:33,635 --> 00:03:35,668
- Twenty-two.
- And what does that tell you?
30
00:03:35,770 --> 00:03:38,004
It tells me she was stabbed 22 times.
31
00:03:38,106 --> 00:03:40,673
That's all? Such a
great number of wounds?
32
00:03:40,775 --> 00:03:43,676
Well, some people would say it
indicates a crime of passion.
33
00:03:43,778 --> 00:03:45,445
Chandra: That it was personal?
34
00:03:45,547 --> 00:03:48,714
That the killer had
something against the victim?
35
00:03:48,817 --> 00:03:49,949
Chester: Some would say.
36
00:03:50,051 --> 00:03:52,685
But not me, because I've
seen it both ways.
37
00:03:56,458 --> 00:03:59,392
This cut is very
important to the State's case.
38
00:03:59,494 --> 00:04:02,728
Any chance you could be mistaken
about what caused it?
39
00:04:02,831 --> 00:04:04,497
No.
40
00:04:04,599 --> 00:04:08,835
Have you ever made a mistake that
sent an innocent man to prison?
41
00:04:08,937 --> 00:04:10,336
No.
42
00:04:10,438 --> 00:04:14,240
Arthur Metz didn't go to prison
because of your testimony at his trial?
43
00:04:14,342 --> 00:04:16,375
You don't remember him?
44
00:04:16,478 --> 00:04:17,443
No, I do.
45
00:04:17,545 --> 00:04:19,612
So you remember that Mr.
Metz was later exonerated
46
00:04:19,714 --> 00:04:22,348
based on a
reexamination of your findings?
47
00:04:22,450 --> 00:04:24,917
My findings were
disputed, not disproven.
48
00:04:25,019 --> 00:04:26,853
I didn't say disputed or disproven,
49
00:04:26,955 --> 00:04:28,354
but whatever we want to call it,
50
00:04:28,456 --> 00:04:30,656
Mr. Metz is now a free man.
51
00:04:30,758 --> 00:04:32,925
Unless he's back in
prison for some other crime.
52
00:04:33,027 --> 00:04:35,595
He's not back in prison
for some other crime.
53
00:04:35,697 --> 00:04:37,763
And wasn't in prison
for some other crime
54
00:04:37,866 --> 00:04:40,099
before your testimony put him there.
55
00:04:40,201 --> 00:04:41,501
It wasn't a mistake.
56
00:04:41,603 --> 00:04:43,269
The appellate court disagreed.
57
00:04:43,371 --> 00:04:45,171
It had a different
interpretation, that's all.
58
00:04:45,206 --> 00:04:46,839
That's all we're talking about here,
59
00:04:46,941 --> 00:04:48,975
a different interpretation,
60
00:04:49,077 --> 00:04:51,177
to avoid you having to come back,
61
00:04:51,279 --> 00:04:53,112
like you had to with Mr. Metz.
62
00:05:27,015 --> 00:05:29,115
(door opens)
63
00:05:32,854 --> 00:05:35,288
Everything that goes
on in there is important.
64
00:05:35,390 --> 00:05:38,457
How Naz sits, what he
wears, what his eyes say,
65
00:05:38,560 --> 00:05:42,028
who's there to support him, who isn't.
66
00:05:42,130 --> 00:05:43,970
I know it's not easy to
look at those pictures,
67
00:05:44,032 --> 00:05:46,499
but the jury has to, and so do you.
68
00:05:46,601 --> 00:05:49,068
You can't get up and leave like that.
69
00:05:51,172 --> 00:05:53,539
An animal did that.
70
00:05:53,641 --> 00:05:56,642
Yeah. You're right.
71
00:05:57,912 --> 00:06:00,346
Did I raise an animal?
72
00:06:02,116 --> 00:06:03,349
What?
73
00:06:18,466 --> 00:06:19,932
(sighs)
74
00:06:21,302 --> 00:06:22,969
He wants to talk to you.
75
00:06:23,071 --> 00:06:27,073
If you get a call with the ID
unavailable, it's probably him.
76
00:06:41,189 --> 00:06:43,356
(indistinct chattering)
77
00:06:54,802 --> 00:06:56,902
(wings fluttering)
78
00:06:59,641 --> 00:07:03,109
(Muslim call to prayer
plays over speaker)
79
00:07:10,852 --> 00:07:14,487
(woman speaks foreign language)
80
00:07:24,899 --> 00:07:26,899
We talked to our lawyer.
81
00:07:27,001 --> 00:07:29,869
He said we won't get the
cab back no matter what.
82
00:07:29,971 --> 00:07:31,737
We're buying a new one.
83
00:07:31,839 --> 00:07:34,240
An old new one.
84
00:07:35,343 --> 00:07:36,976
That's great.
85
00:07:38,579 --> 00:07:40,413
It's ours.
86
00:07:40,515 --> 00:07:41,847
Not yours.
87
00:07:41,949 --> 00:07:44,317
What are you talking
about? It's mine too.
88
00:07:44,419 --> 00:07:45,818
No.
89
00:07:45,920 --> 00:07:49,455
The car we can't get
back is yours, not this one.
90
00:07:49,557 --> 00:07:50,723
This one is mine too.
91
00:07:50,825 --> 00:07:52,892
A third of the medallion is mine.
92
00:07:52,994 --> 00:07:55,094
You cannot operate any car without me.
93
00:07:55,196 --> 00:07:56,729
So sell us your third.
94
00:07:56,831 --> 00:07:58,464
You don't have the money.
95
00:07:58,566 --> 00:08:00,266
You don't have the money for anything.
96
00:08:00,368 --> 00:08:02,034
We have the money. We can get the money.
97
00:08:02,136 --> 00:08:04,170
It will solve your problems.
98
00:08:04,272 --> 00:08:05,705
You want it?
99
00:08:05,807 --> 00:08:09,842
I want what is right...
100
00:08:09,944 --> 00:08:12,978
Us working together, like always.
101
00:08:13,081 --> 00:08:14,513
No.
102
00:08:24,192 --> 00:08:25,124
Okay.
103
00:08:25,226 --> 00:08:26,392
Okay. Good.
104
00:08:26,494 --> 00:08:27,960
$75,000.
105
00:08:29,263 --> 00:08:31,664
It's worth $250,000.
106
00:08:31,766 --> 00:08:33,032
Why would I do that?
107
00:08:33,134 --> 00:08:35,735
Because that's all we are going to pay.
108
00:08:35,837 --> 00:08:39,305
And it will take us years
to work that off.
109
00:08:39,407 --> 00:08:41,107
I'll sell it to someone else.
110
00:08:41,209 --> 00:08:43,676
We are not going to
work with some deadbeat.
111
00:08:43,778 --> 00:08:47,880
Someone who pays the full
price is a deadbeat and you're not?
112
00:08:47,982 --> 00:08:49,348
We didn't put us here.
113
00:08:49,450 --> 00:08:50,683
You did, your son.
114
00:08:50,785 --> 00:08:53,886
Look what he has done to all of us.
115
00:08:58,926 --> 00:09:00,693
To all of us.
116
00:09:05,066 --> 00:09:07,400
You're thieves.
117
00:09:07,502 --> 00:09:09,602
I don't do business with thieves.
118
00:09:11,205 --> 00:09:16,342
You are the father of a killer.
119
00:09:38,299 --> 00:09:41,734
♪ ♪
120
00:09:58,786 --> 00:10:02,121
♪ ♪
121
00:10:11,532 --> 00:10:13,933
- (explosive shattering)
- (shrieks)
122
00:10:14,035 --> 00:10:17,403
- (tires skidding)
- (engine racing)
123
00:10:17,505 --> 00:10:19,638
(camera flashes)
124
00:10:24,979 --> 00:10:26,145
Weiss: What's that?
125
00:10:26,247 --> 00:10:28,247
It's a photo of the defendant's back
126
00:10:28,349 --> 00:10:29,482
taken at the precinct
127
00:10:29,584 --> 00:10:31,784
approximately an hour
after he was arrested.
128
00:10:31,886 --> 00:10:34,753
Detective, could
those scratches simply be
129
00:10:34,856 --> 00:10:37,890
the result of, I'll say, "lovemaking,"
130
00:10:37,992 --> 00:10:39,191
in your opinion?
131
00:10:39,293 --> 00:10:41,260
Well, I don't know, but I can tell you
132
00:10:41,362 --> 00:10:45,097
a considerable amount of his skin
was found under her fingernails.
133
00:10:45,199 --> 00:10:48,834
Other than that, you should ask Cupid.
134
00:10:48,936 --> 00:10:52,037
♪ ♪
135
00:11:03,451 --> 00:11:06,719
- You okay?
- Yeah, no problem.
136
00:11:06,821 --> 00:11:08,821
Taylor: You're doing great.
137
00:11:08,923 --> 00:11:13,559
Hey, isn't that the guy on the news?
138
00:11:13,661 --> 00:11:16,328
His daughter was killed by that cabbie?
139
00:11:16,430 --> 00:11:18,464
Stepdaughter.
140
00:11:18,566 --> 00:11:20,466
Did you know her?
141
00:11:20,568 --> 00:11:21,967
No.
142
00:11:23,571 --> 00:11:26,071
He must be pretty broken up, huh?
143
00:11:26,140 --> 00:11:28,040
What business is that of yours?
144
00:11:28,142 --> 00:11:30,543
I'm just saying.
145
00:11:32,280 --> 00:11:33,379
(beeping)
146
00:11:33,481 --> 00:11:35,080
Pick up the pace a bit.
147
00:11:40,021 --> 00:11:42,421
(indistinct conversation)
148
00:11:44,458 --> 00:11:45,291
Good.
149
00:11:45,393 --> 00:11:49,862
♪ ♪
150
00:11:51,866 --> 00:11:52,865
Hey.
151
00:11:52,967 --> 00:11:58,470
So, he's got a Visa, Mastercard,
and Amex, all maxed.
152
00:11:58,573 --> 00:12:01,206
If he files for bankruptcy,
it'll be the third time.
153
00:12:03,511 --> 00:12:05,311
I appreciate this.
154
00:12:05,413 --> 00:12:07,546
Criminal records I can get.
155
00:12:07,648 --> 00:12:10,316
Credit cards, they're tough.
156
00:12:10,418 --> 00:12:13,419
Yeah. I took a look at yours.
157
00:12:15,556 --> 00:12:17,089
I'm kidding.
158
00:12:17,992 --> 00:12:19,792
Oh, I also ran across this.
159
00:12:28,636 --> 00:12:30,970
You may want to talk to her.
160
00:12:33,541 --> 00:12:36,742
My first husband was a deadbeat too.
161
00:12:36,844 --> 00:12:38,744
Guess I've got a type.
162
00:12:38,846 --> 00:12:41,046
Yeah. My wife's got a type.
163
00:12:41,148 --> 00:12:42,448
I'm not it.
164
00:12:42,550 --> 00:12:43,616
(giggles)
165
00:12:43,718 --> 00:12:46,185
Look, I'm not stupid.
I knew what he wanted.
166
00:12:46,287 --> 00:12:47,753
And I knew what I wanted.
167
00:12:47,855 --> 00:12:50,522
He was young,
good-looking, I have money.
168
00:12:50,625 --> 00:12:53,359
Guess you could call that
some kind of prostitution,
169
00:12:53,461 --> 00:12:55,194
but worked for us.
170
00:12:55,296 --> 00:12:57,496
Until the night I had to call 911
171
00:12:57,598 --> 00:12:59,331
with his hands around my throat.
172
00:12:59,433 --> 00:13:01,200
Really?
173
00:13:01,302 --> 00:13:03,636
Cops were quick, thank God.
174
00:13:03,738 --> 00:13:05,204
Did you press charges?
175
00:13:05,306 --> 00:13:07,439
Oh, yeah. They hauled him off.
176
00:13:07,541 --> 00:13:10,275
Next time I saw him was across
the conference table
177
00:13:10,378 --> 00:13:11,644
with the divorce lawyers,
178
00:13:11,746 --> 00:13:13,245
both of whom I was paying for
179
00:13:13,347 --> 00:13:15,848
since he didn't have a dime to his name.
180
00:13:15,950 --> 00:13:17,950
Mine said, "Jeannie,
181
00:13:18,052 --> 00:13:19,852
"do you want to save some money?
182
00:13:19,954 --> 00:13:22,054
Give him 200 grand and walk away."
183
00:13:22,156 --> 00:13:25,758
Best legal advice I ever got.
184
00:13:25,860 --> 00:13:29,361
You know why divorce is so expensive?
185
00:13:29,463 --> 00:13:31,864
- Because it's worth it.
- Because it's worth it.
186
00:13:31,966 --> 00:13:33,565
(chuckling)
187
00:13:33,668 --> 00:13:34,800
Right.
188
00:13:34,902 --> 00:13:36,568
You know what he does?
189
00:13:36,671 --> 00:13:38,270
A personal trainer, apparently.
190
00:13:38,372 --> 00:13:40,873
I mean his real line of work.
191
00:13:40,975 --> 00:13:43,242
He's a trapeze artist.
192
00:13:43,344 --> 00:13:45,844
Swings from one old bag to another.
193
00:13:45,946 --> 00:13:48,313
Don't sell yourself short.
194
00:13:50,284 --> 00:13:51,684
I'm not.
195
00:13:51,786 --> 00:13:53,552
It was a joke.
196
00:14:01,896 --> 00:14:03,429
How you doing?
197
00:14:03,531 --> 00:14:05,197
I'm fine.
198
00:14:08,202 --> 00:14:10,069
Don't say it.
199
00:14:26,120 --> 00:14:29,388
How often did you buy amphetamines
from the defendant?
200
00:14:29,490 --> 00:14:31,457
They were just Adderall.
201
00:14:31,559 --> 00:14:34,259
Which we know now from earlier testimony
202
00:14:34,361 --> 00:14:36,929
is stronger than your
average amphetamine.
203
00:14:37,031 --> 00:14:39,765
How often did you buy it from him?
204
00:14:39,867 --> 00:14:43,368
Just mainly at finals.
205
00:14:43,471 --> 00:14:44,870
Mainly.
206
00:14:44,972 --> 00:14:46,605
So, at other times, too?
207
00:14:46,707 --> 00:14:51,643
No, just then and, you
know, maybe midterms,
208
00:14:51,746 --> 00:14:54,413
project deadlines,
209
00:14:54,515 --> 00:14:57,049
maybe once in a while for a party.
210
00:14:57,151 --> 00:14:58,884
So, a lot.
211
00:15:01,589 --> 00:15:03,689
You were his only customer?
212
00:15:11,699 --> 00:15:15,234
No. There were, you
know, some other friends.
213
00:15:15,336 --> 00:15:17,302
What did he charge?
214
00:15:17,404 --> 00:15:20,205
Ten dollars for a 10 milligram.
215
00:15:20,307 --> 00:15:22,207
You know where he got them?
216
00:15:22,309 --> 00:15:24,510
I think he had a prescription.
217
00:15:24,612 --> 00:15:27,112
You know what he paid to have it filled?
218
00:15:29,316 --> 00:15:30,582
No.
219
00:15:35,456 --> 00:15:37,055
Ten-dollar co-pay,
220
00:15:37,158 --> 00:15:39,057
insurance paid the rest.
221
00:15:39,160 --> 00:15:42,060
So, at his cost of 25 cents each,
222
00:15:42,163 --> 00:15:44,863
the $10 he was charging you
223
00:15:44,965 --> 00:15:50,302
comes to a 3,900% profit for him.
224
00:15:54,341 --> 00:15:57,142
What's your major in college, Amir?
225
00:15:58,913 --> 00:16:00,779
Business.
226
00:16:00,881 --> 00:16:03,315
Do you know what Mr. Khan's is?
227
00:16:04,585 --> 00:16:06,285
Business.
228
00:16:07,388 --> 00:16:10,756
Which of you, would you
say, is learning the most?
229
00:16:20,334 --> 00:16:21,600
I'm done.
230
00:16:28,542 --> 00:16:33,011
(soft ballad playing)
231
00:16:46,994 --> 00:16:49,261
I'm going to bed.
232
00:16:49,363 --> 00:16:50,996
Night night.
233
00:16:52,399 --> 00:16:54,633
(steam hissing)
234
00:16:54,735 --> 00:16:58,136
(soft wheezing)
235
00:17:08,816 --> 00:17:10,515
(soft wheezing)
236
00:17:13,454 --> 00:17:15,220
Fucking cat.
237
00:17:26,467 --> 00:17:29,301
Hey, Gooden!
238
00:17:29,403 --> 00:17:32,404
Hey, come here. Gooden!
239
00:17:33,574 --> 00:17:35,474
I have no idea who that is.
240
00:17:35,576 --> 00:17:38,710
Hey! Gooden, come over here!
241
00:17:39,980 --> 00:17:41,313
Come here!
242
00:17:41,415 --> 00:17:42,447
Hold on.
243
00:17:45,219 --> 00:17:47,019
I wanted to show you something.
244
00:17:48,255 --> 00:17:51,890
Check it out. No more sandals.
245
00:17:53,160 --> 00:17:54,826
How 'bout that?
246
00:17:54,929 --> 00:17:56,261
That's cool.
247
00:17:56,363 --> 00:17:57,796
I gotta go.
248
00:17:57,898 --> 00:17:59,564
Wait, Gooden.
249
00:17:59,667 --> 00:18:02,367
I wanna come over
later and give you something.
250
00:18:02,469 --> 00:18:03,535
What?
251
00:18:03,637 --> 00:18:05,070
A cat.
252
00:18:05,172 --> 00:18:07,272
Dad, I don't want a cat. I want a pit.
253
00:18:07,374 --> 00:18:09,341
You don't want a pit.
254
00:18:09,443 --> 00:18:12,444
Look, I gotta go, all right?
255
00:18:13,280 --> 00:18:15,147
Tell your mom about the cat.
256
00:18:24,325 --> 00:18:25,924
Huh.
257
00:18:34,001 --> 00:18:37,336
(loud chattering)
258
00:18:49,383 --> 00:18:50,849
Woman: Gate!
259
00:18:50,951 --> 00:18:52,951
(alarm buzzes)
260
00:18:54,388 --> 00:18:55,887
Come on.
261
00:18:55,990 --> 00:18:57,022
Let's go.
262
00:19:16,677 --> 00:19:18,310
Woman: How is he?
263
00:19:18,412 --> 00:19:20,379
He's fine.
264
00:19:22,549 --> 00:19:24,182
I'm so worried about him.
265
00:19:25,252 --> 00:19:26,718
He's fine.
266
00:19:29,690 --> 00:19:32,891
(police radio chattering)
267
00:20:06,287 --> 00:20:09,005
Coach: He didn't even look down
the stairs to see how Diaz landed.
268
00:20:09,029 --> 00:20:12,030
He just walked off like
he was going to class.
269
00:20:12,132 --> 00:20:13,632
- Did you talk to him?
- Oh, yeah.
270
00:20:13,734 --> 00:20:16,146
I grabbed him straight away, said,
"What the hell you do that for?"
271
00:20:16,170 --> 00:20:17,335
What did he say?
272
00:20:17,438 --> 00:20:19,271
Nothing.
273
00:20:19,373 --> 00:20:21,073
He just looked at me.
274
00:20:22,076 --> 00:20:24,342
Looked at you how?
275
00:20:24,445 --> 00:20:26,511
Like nonreactive.
276
00:20:26,613 --> 00:20:29,281
Like he had no idea what he'd done?
277
00:20:31,085 --> 00:20:32,884
In that neighborhood.
278
00:20:34,388 --> 00:20:35,887
Your witness.
279
00:20:38,459 --> 00:20:41,560
This incident took
place not long after 9/11.
280
00:20:41,662 --> 00:20:45,397
How would you describe the mood
of the student body at that time?
281
00:20:45,499 --> 00:20:49,067
Uh, for want of a better
word, I'd say patriotic.
282
00:20:49,169 --> 00:20:52,104
Okay. And in this patriotic atmosphere,
283
00:20:52,206 --> 00:20:54,806
how would you say the
Muslim students fared?
284
00:20:54,908 --> 00:20:57,042
It was tough on them, I'll be honest.
285
00:20:57,144 --> 00:20:59,711
Racist comments,
taunts, that kind of thing.
286
00:20:59,813 --> 00:21:02,080
Yeah, but Khan was the
only one at school
287
00:21:02,182 --> 00:21:05,150
who sent two students to
the hospital because of it.
288
00:21:12,693 --> 00:21:14,392
Two...
289
00:21:14,495 --> 00:21:17,529
His first week back after the
suspension for the stairs thing,
290
00:21:17,631 --> 00:21:21,299
he threw a full Coke can
at a kid in the cafeteria.
291
00:21:22,703 --> 00:21:24,236
Twelve stitches.
292
00:21:26,607 --> 00:21:28,173
In his face.
293
00:21:39,553 --> 00:21:41,086
Thank you.
294
00:21:44,124 --> 00:21:45,357
Judge: Mrs. Weiss.
295
00:21:46,627 --> 00:21:49,161
The State rests, Your Honor.
296
00:21:51,732 --> 00:21:56,535
(somber Mideastern music playing)
297
00:22:29,469 --> 00:22:31,203
(grunts)
298
00:22:34,541 --> 00:22:38,910
There you go. That's good. Come on.
299
00:22:39,012 --> 00:22:41,179
You okay?
300
00:22:41,281 --> 00:22:42,614
Yeah.
301
00:22:42,716 --> 00:22:44,583
You sure?
302
00:22:46,587 --> 00:22:47,752
No, no, no.
303
00:22:47,854 --> 00:22:50,222
No, just take it. Just take it.
304
00:22:50,324 --> 00:22:51,890
Where you going?
305
00:22:51,992 --> 00:22:53,325
Hey!
306
00:22:53,427 --> 00:22:55,327
Hey. Hey! What...
307
00:22:55,429 --> 00:22:57,028
What the...
308
00:22:57,130 --> 00:22:58,363
Aah!
309
00:22:58,465 --> 00:23:00,999
You think you're invisible?
310
00:23:01,101 --> 00:23:02,300
The invisible man?
311
00:23:02,402 --> 00:23:03,368
(gagging)
312
00:23:03,470 --> 00:23:07,739
You talk to my
coworkers, my friends, my ex,
313
00:23:07,841 --> 00:23:10,475
and you don't think I'll
find out about it?
314
00:23:10,577 --> 00:23:12,877
Seriously, get this off of me.
315
00:23:12,980 --> 00:23:16,014
Maybe I should have a little
talk with your ex-wife?
316
00:23:16,116 --> 00:23:17,849
Or your son?
317
00:23:17,951 --> 00:23:22,254
At that artsy-fartsy school of his.
318
00:23:25,492 --> 00:23:27,092
Oh, shit.
319
00:23:36,136 --> 00:23:37,969
Fuck.
320
00:23:38,071 --> 00:23:41,106
(grunting)
321
00:23:58,759 --> 00:24:01,993
(phone ringing)
322
00:24:15,175 --> 00:24:16,841
(line beeps)
323
00:24:24,217 --> 00:24:25,784
Man (on TV): They are strong swimmers,
324
00:24:25,886 --> 00:24:29,254
able to cross rivers five miles wide.
325
00:24:29,356 --> 00:24:32,824
The river offers this
tiger a place to bathe,
326
00:24:32,926 --> 00:24:34,959
hunt, or rather, fish...
327
00:24:35,062 --> 00:24:36,861
You talk to her?
328
00:24:36,963 --> 00:24:38,229
No.
329
00:24:38,332 --> 00:24:42,033
Man: Unlike most cats, tigers
are comfortable in water.
330
00:24:42,135 --> 00:24:44,836
This tiger clearly is.
331
00:24:44,938 --> 00:24:47,339
The river is...
332
00:24:47,441 --> 00:24:49,941
Box: You see that, right?
333
00:24:52,412 --> 00:24:55,714
That's recording us, and
it will be used in court.
334
00:24:55,816 --> 00:24:57,449
How do you think that's gonna come on?
335
00:24:57,551 --> 00:25:00,452
"She was nice, I liked
her, but I killed her anyway."
336
00:25:04,725 --> 00:25:07,926
Detective, what made
you so sure so quickly
337
00:25:08,028 --> 00:25:09,661
Nasir Khan was your man?
338
00:25:09,763 --> 00:25:11,629
The mountain of evidence.
339
00:25:11,732 --> 00:25:13,498
So why bother questioning him?
340
00:25:13,600 --> 00:25:17,836
Sometimes a suspect wants nothing
more than to confess.
341
00:25:17,938 --> 00:25:19,771
- Did he?
- No.
342
00:25:19,873 --> 00:25:22,574
So, that's when you charged him,
when you left the interview room?
343
00:25:22,676 --> 00:25:23,842
No.
344
00:25:23,944 --> 00:25:25,143
Why not?
345
00:25:25,245 --> 00:25:27,879
Sometimes the suspect needs
time to think things through.
346
00:25:27,981 --> 00:25:31,716
So, you gave him some time, and
he's sitting in the squad room pen,
347
00:25:31,818 --> 00:25:33,318
awaiting transfer downtown.
348
00:25:33,420 --> 00:25:34,652
That's when he confessed?
349
00:25:34,755 --> 00:25:36,354
If he had, we wouldn't be here.
350
00:25:36,456 --> 00:25:40,925
So, after the arrest, you gave him the
opportunity to confess and he didn't.
351
00:25:41,027 --> 00:25:44,462
Then 12 hours later, after you gave
him the opportunity to think about it,
352
00:25:44,564 --> 00:25:46,231
he didn't confess.
353
00:25:46,333 --> 00:25:49,667
Then when the DA gave him the
opportunity to accept just 15 years
354
00:25:49,770 --> 00:25:51,436
instead of a possible life sentence,
355
00:25:51,538 --> 00:25:53,638
he didn't confess.
356
00:25:53,740 --> 00:25:56,641
I don't know, 15 years sounds
like a pretty good deal to me,
357
00:25:56,743 --> 00:25:59,444
what with a mountain of
evidence, don't you?
358
00:25:59,546 --> 00:26:02,414
I'll take evidence over a confession
359
00:26:02,516 --> 00:26:04,582
any day of the week.
360
00:26:04,684 --> 00:26:07,585
Thank you, Detective.
361
00:26:13,960 --> 00:26:15,093
(door closes)
362
00:26:15,195 --> 00:26:18,263
(muffled voices chattering)
363
00:26:25,205 --> 00:26:29,407
(soft ballad playing)
364
00:26:40,387 --> 00:26:41,753
Hey.
365
00:26:41,855 --> 00:26:43,388
How you doing?
366
00:26:45,258 --> 00:26:46,858
Huh?
367
00:26:46,960 --> 00:26:48,893
- (purring)
- Yeah.
368
00:26:52,466 --> 00:26:54,499
(snoring softly)
369
00:27:05,145 --> 00:27:08,279
(purring)
370
00:27:12,686 --> 00:27:15,987
- (Stone grunts softly)
- (cat purring)
371
00:27:16,089 --> 00:27:21,025
- (traffic honking)
- (Stone wheezing)
372
00:27:23,029 --> 00:27:25,997
- (purring)
- (wheezing)
373
00:27:32,339 --> 00:27:33,972
Oh, fuck.
374
00:27:36,109 --> 00:27:37,775
Come on, let's go. Come on.
375
00:27:39,079 --> 00:27:40,144
Oh!
376
00:27:41,047 --> 00:27:43,181
All right, okay.
377
00:27:43,283 --> 00:27:45,183
(panting)
378
00:27:45,285 --> 00:27:46,885
(hoarsely) You stay in there.
379
00:27:49,556 --> 00:27:50,555
All right.
380
00:27:50,657 --> 00:27:53,291
(wheezing)
381
00:27:57,998 --> 00:27:59,697
♪ ♪
382
00:27:59,799 --> 00:28:01,432
(wheezes)
383
00:28:01,535 --> 00:28:02,867
You know, I was thinking,
384
00:28:02,969 --> 00:28:07,171
Since you were so right on
the money with my eczema,
385
00:28:07,274 --> 00:28:09,641
maybe you have something for my asthma?
386
00:28:09,743 --> 00:28:11,042
Get rid of your cat.
387
00:28:11,144 --> 00:28:13,378
Maybe some kind of root or fish oil,
388
00:28:13,480 --> 00:28:15,246
or something I could try?
389
00:28:15,348 --> 00:28:17,415
Get rid of your cat.
390
00:28:25,125 --> 00:28:27,692
I don't want to get rid of my cat.
391
00:28:32,632 --> 00:28:35,667
♪ ♪
392
00:29:32,792 --> 00:29:34,559
Chandra: Mr. Cutler,
393
00:29:34,661 --> 00:29:36,761
what do you do for a living?
394
00:29:36,863 --> 00:29:38,329
I'm a waiter.
395
00:29:38,431 --> 00:29:40,665
Any other sources of income?
396
00:29:43,069 --> 00:29:45,503
Occasionally I, uh...
397
00:29:45,605 --> 00:29:48,406
acquire things for friends.
398
00:29:48,508 --> 00:29:50,708
Would these occasional acquisitions
399
00:29:50,810 --> 00:29:52,510
include pharmaceuticals?
400
00:29:52,612 --> 00:29:55,380
Occasionally.
401
00:29:55,482 --> 00:29:58,950
Is the defendant one of your friends?
402
00:29:59,052 --> 00:29:59,984
No.
403
00:30:00,086 --> 00:30:02,353
What about Andrea?
404
00:30:02,455 --> 00:30:03,655
Yes.
405
00:30:03,757 --> 00:30:05,923
Did she visit you on October 24th
406
00:30:06,026 --> 00:30:09,293
wanting to acquire something?
407
00:30:13,233 --> 00:30:15,600
A quarter-gram of K and six Mollies.
408
00:30:15,702 --> 00:30:18,369
K, ketamine? Mollies, ecstasy?
409
00:30:19,973 --> 00:30:21,105
Yeah.
410
00:30:21,207 --> 00:30:22,687
And did you... I won't say, "sell"...
411
00:30:22,776 --> 00:30:24,876
- Provide them to her?
- Yeah.
412
00:30:24,978 --> 00:30:28,012
Something like this for the ketamine?
413
00:30:30,483 --> 00:30:32,316
Could have been.
414
00:30:33,753 --> 00:30:35,987
Thank you.
415
00:30:43,930 --> 00:30:46,664
I sit there every day. I
watch you fight for me.
416
00:30:46,766 --> 00:30:48,966
I think, "Why is she doing this?"
417
00:30:51,104 --> 00:30:53,516
I mean, it's not for the money
'cause you're not getting paid,
418
00:30:53,540 --> 00:30:55,740
I'm sure, at least not much.
419
00:30:55,842 --> 00:30:58,176
It's my job.
420
00:30:58,278 --> 00:31:00,078
And it's your right.
421
00:31:03,083 --> 00:31:04,582
Is that all?
422
00:31:06,186 --> 00:31:07,485
Yeah.
423
00:31:14,360 --> 00:31:18,029
My dad's the only person in
the world who believes me.
424
00:31:18,131 --> 00:31:20,698
Your mother does too.
425
00:31:20,800 --> 00:31:22,166
No.
426
00:31:32,479 --> 00:31:36,080
Well... I do.
427
00:31:48,428 --> 00:31:52,530
♪ ♪
428
00:32:23,730 --> 00:32:26,764
(panting)
429
00:32:30,770 --> 00:32:32,436
(mutters) Fuck.
430
00:32:34,207 --> 00:32:35,673
Officer.
431
00:32:39,512 --> 00:32:40,845
Thank you.
432
00:32:59,065 --> 00:33:00,364
(lamp clicks)
433
00:33:01,768 --> 00:33:02,834
(lamp clicks)
434
00:33:12,078 --> 00:33:13,811
This for "Law and Order"?
435
00:33:13,913 --> 00:33:15,079
What?
436
00:33:15,181 --> 00:33:16,247
Is this for "Law and Order"?
437
00:33:16,349 --> 00:33:18,182
I do a lot of props like this for them.
438
00:33:18,284 --> 00:33:20,318
Yeah, yeah, "Law and Order."
439
00:33:20,420 --> 00:33:22,286
(phone ringing)
440
00:33:26,192 --> 00:33:27,758
Yeah?
441
00:33:27,861 --> 00:33:29,360
I'm at the copy place.
442
00:33:29,462 --> 00:33:32,230
Living the vida loca of
a high-priced attorney.
443
00:33:33,766 --> 00:33:35,066
I'm waiting for them.
444
00:33:35,168 --> 00:33:37,168
I'm doing them. He's doing them.
445
00:33:37,270 --> 00:33:39,170
Okay? All right.
446
00:33:39,272 --> 00:33:40,905
All right. Bye.
447
00:33:43,209 --> 00:33:47,178
I don't know. Production assistants
are usually younger than you.
448
00:34:07,300 --> 00:34:09,634
Can you tell us, Dr. Katz,
what this photograph is?
449
00:34:09,736 --> 00:34:12,069
That's one of the
drawers of the bar cabinet
450
00:34:12,171 --> 00:34:14,372
on the parlor level of the brownstone.
451
00:34:16,976 --> 00:34:21,379
And we can see that its contents
are a corkscrew, a nutcracker,
452
00:34:21,481 --> 00:34:24,048
some cocktail napkins,
some swizzle sticks,
453
00:34:24,150 --> 00:34:26,317
and two knives.
454
00:34:26,419 --> 00:34:27,619
They look similar to this one.
455
00:34:27,654 --> 00:34:30,121
They're more than
similar. They're identical.
456
00:34:30,223 --> 00:34:32,089
They're all part of the same set.
457
00:34:32,191 --> 00:34:33,691
As is the missing one.
458
00:34:34,894 --> 00:34:36,327
The... Excuse me. The what?
459
00:34:36,429 --> 00:34:38,195
These knives are sold in sets of four.
460
00:34:38,298 --> 00:34:39,964
You can't buy them any other way.
461
00:34:40,066 --> 00:34:41,499
One is missing.
462
00:34:41,601 --> 00:34:43,281
Couldn't it be somewhere
else in the house?
463
00:34:43,336 --> 00:34:45,369
No, I checked everywhere.
It's not there.
464
00:34:45,471 --> 00:34:46,837
If this missing knife was there,
465
00:34:46,940 --> 00:34:50,007
presumably, it could cause the same
wounds to the victim as this one?
466
00:34:50,109 --> 00:34:51,309
Oh, of course.
467
00:34:56,516 --> 00:34:58,849
Dr. Katz, would you
agree with the medical examiner
468
00:34:58,952 --> 00:35:01,118
this was a defensive wound?
469
00:35:01,220 --> 00:35:02,586
No, because it isn't.
470
00:35:02,689 --> 00:35:04,722
That wound was made before the attack
471
00:35:04,791 --> 00:35:07,825
when the defendant and the
victim were playing a game.
472
00:35:07,927 --> 00:35:11,429
- A game?
- You know, like, uh...
473
00:35:11,531 --> 00:35:13,097
Please.
474
00:35:17,136 --> 00:35:18,569
Mumblety-peg?
475
00:35:18,671 --> 00:35:21,906
I don't know. Is that what it's called?
476
00:35:22,008 --> 00:35:23,341
Uh, okay.
477
00:35:23,443 --> 00:35:25,043
Okay, but I mean, I
don't play that game.
478
00:35:25,144 --> 00:35:26,677
I mean, who does? But if you did,
479
00:35:26,779 --> 00:35:28,779
wouldn't you put your hand this way?
480
00:35:28,881 --> 00:35:30,081
Palm down.
481
00:35:30,183 --> 00:35:31,649
Not necessarily.
482
00:35:31,751 --> 00:35:33,985
It seems more natural, if you ask me,
483
00:35:34,087 --> 00:35:35,664
if anything about this
game could be natural.
484
00:35:35,688 --> 00:35:40,558
It was natural for her this way.
485
00:35:40,660 --> 00:35:42,193
And she had played that game before.
486
00:35:42,295 --> 00:35:45,162
You can see the scars in Dr.
Chester's own photographs,
487
00:35:45,264 --> 00:35:47,331
on her hands and elsewhere on her body.
488
00:35:47,433 --> 00:35:49,233
Self-inflicted wounds.
489
00:35:49,335 --> 00:35:51,168
Why would anyone do that?
490
00:35:51,270 --> 00:35:54,905
Everyone knows it's not uncommon
among troubled people.
491
00:35:54,974 --> 00:35:57,808
Okay, but still, how can you
be certain this particular wound
492
00:35:57,910 --> 00:35:59,643
happened somewhere other
than the bedroom?
493
00:35:59,746 --> 00:36:01,445
Because of her skin cells
494
00:36:01,547 --> 00:36:03,681
in one of the
gouges of the coffee table.
495
00:36:03,783 --> 00:36:04,849
(grunts)
496
00:36:06,819 --> 00:36:09,286
Really? You saw that in the
crime scene unit's report?
497
00:36:09,389 --> 00:36:10,888
No. They didn't notice,
498
00:36:10,990 --> 00:36:12,790
or at least they
didn't note these skin cells,
499
00:36:12,859 --> 00:36:14,625
but they're in the table.
500
00:36:14,727 --> 00:36:17,828
So, if this is how this
wound occurred during this game,
501
00:36:17,930 --> 00:36:19,997
that could explain
how the victim's blood
502
00:36:20,099 --> 00:36:21,499
came to be on this knife?
503
00:36:21,601 --> 00:36:22,800
Yes.
504
00:36:27,306 --> 00:36:28,806
This is the basement level.
505
00:36:28,908 --> 00:36:30,174
Correct.
506
00:36:32,845 --> 00:36:35,012
- What's this?
- The front gate.
507
00:36:35,114 --> 00:36:36,380
I notice it's ajar.
508
00:36:36,482 --> 00:36:39,884
It's ajar because it doesn't
close. It hasn't for years.
509
00:36:42,622 --> 00:36:44,688
The rust on the latch shows that.
510
00:36:47,627 --> 00:36:48,626
And this?
511
00:36:48,728 --> 00:36:50,594
The front basement
door, which does close,
512
00:36:50,696 --> 00:36:53,364
but the crime scene detectives
noted that it was unlocked,
513
00:36:53,466 --> 00:36:57,501
as was a second-story
window on the garden side.
514
00:36:59,405 --> 00:37:00,905
Would it be possible for someone...
515
00:37:01,007 --> 00:37:02,785
Say, an intruder... To
get to that window, though,
516
00:37:02,809 --> 00:37:04,086
being a level up from the garden?
517
00:37:04,110 --> 00:37:05,976
Yes, there's a tree right there.
518
00:37:06,045 --> 00:37:07,078
This tree?
519
00:37:07,180 --> 00:37:08,045
- Mm-hmm.
- Okay.
520
00:37:08,147 --> 00:37:09,507
But how do you know it's scalable?
521
00:37:09,549 --> 00:37:13,451
Because I scaled it,
easily, and I'm pushing 70.
522
00:37:13,553 --> 00:37:15,319
You don't look it.
523
00:37:15,421 --> 00:37:17,221
I feel it sometimes.
524
00:37:17,323 --> 00:37:20,591
While you were scaling this
tree to the second-floor window,
525
00:37:20,693 --> 00:37:23,327
could you see the
basement-level kitchen?
526
00:37:23,429 --> 00:37:24,762
No.
527
00:37:24,864 --> 00:37:27,131
What if you came through
the gate that won't close
528
00:37:27,233 --> 00:37:29,767
and door that was unlocked
and went up the staircase?
529
00:37:29,869 --> 00:37:31,814
You could see someone in
the kitchen then, I imagine,
530
00:37:31,838 --> 00:37:33,048
since they're on the same level.
531
00:37:33,072 --> 00:37:35,239
No. I took a picture of this.
532
00:37:38,444 --> 00:37:42,780
That shows what you see of the
kitchen from the staircase.
533
00:37:45,551 --> 00:37:47,218
What kitchen?
534
00:37:47,320 --> 00:37:49,487
Exactly. What kitchen?
535
00:37:51,157 --> 00:37:52,656
Thank you, Dr. Katz.
536
00:37:53,926 --> 00:37:56,127
Judge: Your witness, Mrs. Weiss.
537
00:37:57,964 --> 00:37:59,063
(clears throat)
538
00:38:06,539 --> 00:38:07,771
Dr. Katz,
539
00:38:07,874 --> 00:38:09,673
it's a pleasure to meet you.
540
00:38:09,775 --> 00:38:10,941
And you.
541
00:38:11,043 --> 00:38:13,577
Me? Okay, thank you.
542
00:38:13,679 --> 00:38:15,846
But I'm not famous like you are.
543
00:38:15,948 --> 00:38:18,816
I'm not famous. No
pathologist is famous.
544
00:38:18,918 --> 00:38:21,585
Maybe I'm known in
certain professional circles,
545
00:38:21,687 --> 00:38:22,953
but that's about it.
546
00:38:23,055 --> 00:38:25,489
No one recognizes you on the street?
547
00:38:25,591 --> 00:38:30,528
If they do, maybe they saw my picture
on the back of one of my books.
548
00:38:30,630 --> 00:38:32,596
Or on TV?
549
00:38:32,698 --> 00:38:35,666
Since you've testified in
a lot of high-profile,
550
00:38:35,768 --> 00:38:37,968
sometimes televised trials.
551
00:38:39,872 --> 00:38:43,707
But in pathology, fame
plays no part, does it?
552
00:38:43,809 --> 00:38:46,911
Whether you're a New
York City medical examiner
553
00:38:47,013 --> 00:38:48,279
like Dr. Chester,
554
00:38:48,381 --> 00:38:50,714
who no one recognizes on the street,
555
00:38:50,816 --> 00:38:54,285
or an expert witness for O.J. Simpson.
556
00:38:54,387 --> 00:38:55,619
Chandra: Objection.
557
00:38:55,721 --> 00:38:56,921
To what?
558
00:38:57,023 --> 00:38:58,989
It's a compliment.
559
00:38:59,091 --> 00:39:00,724
Judge: Overruled.
560
00:39:04,263 --> 00:39:08,299
Is Dr. Chester, unknown as
he may be to the public,
561
00:39:08,401 --> 00:39:11,235
a good pathologist?
562
00:39:11,337 --> 00:39:15,372
Since I'm under oath, I'd
have to say, not in my opinion.
563
00:39:15,474 --> 00:39:16,874
You disagree with him?
564
00:39:16,976 --> 00:39:20,010
Not only about the victim's hand wound,
565
00:39:20,112 --> 00:39:22,479
but also...
566
00:39:22,582 --> 00:39:26,317
what he said about this knife wound
567
00:39:26,419 --> 00:39:28,152
on the defendant's hand?
568
00:39:28,254 --> 00:39:31,055
I do. Because it's
not a knife wound caused
569
00:39:31,157 --> 00:39:33,691
by his hand slipping from
the handle onto the blade.
570
00:39:33,793 --> 00:39:38,729
It was cut on a piece of
glass from the broken door pane.
571
00:39:38,831 --> 00:39:40,898
So, he doesn't know what
he's talking about?
572
00:39:41,000 --> 00:39:43,968
I'd like to find a nicer way to put it.
573
00:39:44,070 --> 00:39:47,338
How about like this.
574
00:39:50,409 --> 00:39:53,110
"Dr. Chester is a modern day giant
575
00:39:53,212 --> 00:39:55,446
in the field of forensic pathology.
576
00:39:55,548 --> 00:39:59,283
We'd all be well-advised to
try to emulate his wisdom
577
00:39:59,385 --> 00:40:01,885
and scientific exactitude."
578
00:40:01,988 --> 00:40:03,787
You know who said that?
579
00:40:05,691 --> 00:40:07,191
Me.
580
00:40:07,293 --> 00:40:10,261
- Where?
- A testimonial dinner.
581
00:40:10,363 --> 00:40:13,264
Your praise sounds so sincere.
582
00:40:13,366 --> 00:40:14,932
Are you saying it wasn't?
583
00:40:15,034 --> 00:40:17,134
You're asked to speak about someone,
584
00:40:17,236 --> 00:40:20,337
do you embarrass them by
saying what you really think?
585
00:40:20,439 --> 00:40:22,172
You could decline to speak.
586
00:40:22,275 --> 00:40:25,909
But that would have
embarrassed him just as much.
587
00:40:27,146 --> 00:40:29,813
So, what were you really thinking
588
00:40:29,915 --> 00:40:31,548
up there in front of all those people
589
00:40:31,651 --> 00:40:33,884
saying things you didn't
believe to be true
590
00:40:33,986 --> 00:40:35,552
in such a convincing manner?
591
00:40:35,655 --> 00:40:38,489
Honestly? Dessert.
592
00:40:38,591 --> 00:40:41,258
(spectators laughing)
593
00:40:47,733 --> 00:40:51,735
The knife you described
as missing from its set,
594
00:40:51,837 --> 00:40:53,203
do you know when it was bought?
595
00:40:53,306 --> 00:40:56,106
No, but I know it couldn't
have been later than 2008
596
00:40:56,208 --> 00:40:59,176
since that's when that
model was discontinued.
597
00:41:00,112 --> 00:41:02,646
I bought my husband an electric drill
598
00:41:02,748 --> 00:41:06,050
with an array of two
dozen drill bits in 2008.
599
00:41:06,152 --> 00:41:09,286
Admittedly, not the
most romantic birthday gift,
600
00:41:09,388 --> 00:41:10,888
but he's a happy putterer.
601
00:41:10,990 --> 00:41:13,424
Well, so am I. I'd find it romantic.
602
00:41:14,327 --> 00:41:17,094
- My point is...
- I think we already know.
603
00:41:19,231 --> 00:41:20,731
Dr. Katz...
604
00:41:20,833 --> 00:41:23,767
we've both been doing what
we do for a long time,
605
00:41:23,869 --> 00:41:26,670
and it's put us in
courtrooms for too many days.
606
00:41:26,772 --> 00:41:29,306
But as a result, we
know the rules of the court,
607
00:41:29,408 --> 00:41:32,443
and one of them is you
answer the questions I ask,
608
00:41:32,545 --> 00:41:34,311
not ones I don't.
609
00:41:35,247 --> 00:41:38,215
Sure. Okay.
610
00:41:38,317 --> 00:41:42,186
After six years, how many
of those 24 drill bits
611
00:41:42,288 --> 00:41:45,689
do you think are still in their case?
612
00:41:45,791 --> 00:41:47,224
None of them.
613
00:41:47,326 --> 00:41:48,492
None of them.
614
00:41:48,594 --> 00:41:50,194
My husband has lost them all.
615
00:41:50,296 --> 00:41:53,030
Then I know what you should
get him for Christmas.
616
00:41:53,132 --> 00:41:54,965
He doesn't deserve it.
617
00:41:55,067 --> 00:41:56,100
Okay.
618
00:41:56,202 --> 00:41:58,702
Now you can answer the
question I haven't asked
619
00:41:58,804 --> 00:42:01,171
'cause you know what it is.
620
00:42:01,273 --> 00:42:04,041
The missing fourth
knife, it could have been lost
621
00:42:04,143 --> 00:42:06,377
or chewed up in the garbage disposal,
622
00:42:06,479 --> 00:42:09,213
or thrown out at some point in time.
623
00:42:12,718 --> 00:42:14,518
And this.
624
00:42:14,620 --> 00:42:17,554
This wound on the victim's hand,
625
00:42:17,656 --> 00:42:20,023
which occurred, you say,
626
00:42:20,126 --> 00:42:23,394
during a game none of
us would want to play.
627
00:42:23,496 --> 00:42:26,296
But if we did, if you did,
628
00:42:26,399 --> 00:42:30,100
do you really think, as the
blood is running down your arm
629
00:42:30,202 --> 00:42:32,069
and pooling on the table,
630
00:42:32,171 --> 00:42:34,838
you'd feel like having sex?
631
00:42:34,940 --> 00:42:36,707
Or would you rather
632
00:42:36,809 --> 00:42:38,842
want to be rushed to the emergency room?
633
00:42:38,944 --> 00:42:41,011
Personally, the emergency room,
634
00:42:41,113 --> 00:42:44,248
but I understand there
were a lot of drugs involved.
635
00:42:48,020 --> 00:42:49,219
Okay.
636
00:42:49,321 --> 00:42:50,487
Thank you, Dr. Katz.
637
00:42:50,589 --> 00:42:53,624
It really has been a
pleasure meeting you.
638
00:43:02,535 --> 00:43:03,801
I'm confused.
639
00:43:03,903 --> 00:43:06,203
Is this yours?
640
00:43:06,305 --> 00:43:07,337
Yeah.
641
00:43:07,440 --> 00:43:10,507
Because it's gone
now. It's not in evidence.
642
00:43:10,609 --> 00:43:11,909
Well, I don't have it anymore.
643
00:43:12,011 --> 00:43:13,331
I know you don't have it anymore.
644
00:43:13,379 --> 00:43:15,813
You left it there, but
they should have it.
645
00:43:15,915 --> 00:43:18,415
Well, I had it. They
took it to the tombs.
646
00:43:18,517 --> 00:43:21,485
How could you have had
it then if it's here?
647
00:43:21,587 --> 00:43:23,921
Oh, because he gave
it back to me that night,
648
00:43:24,023 --> 00:43:26,323
in the squad room.
649
00:43:26,425 --> 00:43:28,392
Stone: Who did?
650
00:43:28,494 --> 00:43:30,661
Nasir: The detective.
651
00:43:39,038 --> 00:43:41,138
Box?
652
00:43:42,341 --> 00:43:45,275
♪ ♪
653
00:43:57,189 --> 00:43:58,889
Excited about the big night?
654
00:43:58,991 --> 00:44:00,357
Thrilled.
655
00:44:08,934 --> 00:44:10,200
Can I help you with that?
656
00:44:10,302 --> 00:44:11,969
You can move, that'd help.
657
00:44:28,888 --> 00:44:31,038
Do you swear or affirm
to tell the truth,
658
00:44:31,063 --> 00:44:33,314
the whole truth, and
nothing but the truth?
659
00:44:33,392 --> 00:44:34,625
Yes.
660
00:44:37,496 --> 00:44:38,862
Detective, welcome back.
661
00:44:42,067 --> 00:44:45,302
I heard you're about to retire.
662
00:44:45,404 --> 00:44:46,503
I heard that too.
663
00:44:46,605 --> 00:44:48,272
- Congratulations.
- Thank you.
664
00:44:48,374 --> 00:44:49,473
How long has it been?
665
00:44:49,575 --> 00:44:50,841
Thirty-three years.
666
00:44:50,943 --> 00:44:53,263
Well, you'll be sorely missed
by your colleagues, I'm sure,
667
00:44:53,312 --> 00:44:55,379
and by us, the public, too.
668
00:44:55,481 --> 00:44:57,581
We thank you for your service.
669
00:45:03,689 --> 00:45:05,722
Can you tell us in the
course of your investigation
670
00:45:05,824 --> 00:45:07,457
how many suspects you interviewed?
671
00:45:07,560 --> 00:45:10,193
One, the defendant.
672
00:45:10,296 --> 00:45:12,429
Not Trevor Williams?
673
00:45:13,699 --> 00:45:15,766
Yeah.
674
00:45:15,868 --> 00:45:17,701
This towelhead.
675
00:45:17,803 --> 00:45:22,739
He was a witness, so,
yes, of course, I spoke to him.
676
00:45:22,841 --> 00:45:25,576
As a result of that interview,
you didn't do any follow-ups?
677
00:45:25,678 --> 00:45:27,077
Nothing to follow up.
678
00:45:27,179 --> 00:45:29,947
You didn't interview Duane Reade?
679
00:45:30,049 --> 00:45:32,149
Someone at Duane Reade?
680
00:45:32,251 --> 00:45:34,318
An individual named Duane Reade.
681
00:45:34,420 --> 00:45:36,587
Is that a joke?
682
00:45:36,689 --> 00:45:38,522
No, but I'm sure he gets that a lot.
683
00:45:38,624 --> 00:45:41,692
He was with Mr. Williams when
he had words with the defendant
684
00:45:41,794 --> 00:45:43,994
and Ms. Cornish outsider
her home that night.
685
00:45:44,096 --> 00:45:45,562
But you didn't interview him?
686
00:45:45,664 --> 00:45:47,331
Mr. Williams said he was alone,
687
00:45:47,433 --> 00:45:49,866
so, no, I didn't interview
anyone he wasn't with.
688
00:45:49,969 --> 00:45:52,213
So you're unaware of Mr.
Reade's numerous
689
00:45:52,238 --> 00:45:54,161
convictions for aggravated assault?
690
00:45:57,242 --> 00:45:58,575
What about Royal Day?
691
00:45:58,677 --> 00:46:01,078
Who's he? A friend of Duane Reade's?
692
00:46:01,180 --> 00:46:02,613
The other eyewitness.
693
00:46:02,715 --> 00:46:05,015
Mr. Caval, who lives across the street
694
00:46:05,117 --> 00:46:07,918
who called in the break-in
was the other eyewitness.
695
00:46:08,020 --> 00:46:09,586
Chandra: No, he's another eyewitness,
696
00:46:09,688 --> 00:46:11,855
but, like Mr. Reade, not
the only other one.
697
00:46:11,957 --> 00:46:13,624
You didn't interview Mr. Day?
698
00:46:13,726 --> 00:46:17,561
Again, I don't interview
people I don't know about.
699
00:46:17,663 --> 00:46:19,162
You know about him. You've seen him.
700
00:46:19,264 --> 00:46:21,732
In the security
tapes at the Shell station.
701
00:46:27,039 --> 00:46:31,008
He too had an unpleasant encounter with
the victim and defendant that night.
702
00:46:31,110 --> 00:46:33,143
Are you sure you didn't interview him?
703
00:46:33,245 --> 00:46:36,246
Asked and answered.
704
00:46:39,118 --> 00:46:41,051
In your 19 years in homicide,
705
00:46:41,153 --> 00:46:42,753
how many crime scenes have you worked?
706
00:46:42,855 --> 00:46:45,722
I don't know. Three
hundred, give or take.
707
00:46:45,824 --> 00:46:48,225
And at these 300, give
or take, crime scenes,
708
00:46:48,327 --> 00:46:50,794
at any crime scene, it's
important, isn't it,
709
00:46:50,896 --> 00:46:53,797
that evidence is
examined, photographed, cataloged,
710
00:46:53,899 --> 00:46:55,766
and carefully stored?
711
00:46:55,868 --> 00:46:57,534
Obviously.
712
00:47:05,577 --> 00:47:07,044
What's that?
713
00:47:11,350 --> 00:47:12,816
An asthma inhaler.
714
00:47:12,918 --> 00:47:15,452
Any idea where it is?
715
00:47:15,554 --> 00:47:17,788
- You'd have to ask him.
- Who?
716
00:47:17,890 --> 00:47:19,823
The defendant. I gave it to him.
717
00:47:19,925 --> 00:47:21,825
What he did with it, I wouldn't know.
718
00:47:21,927 --> 00:47:24,061
I'm sorry, you gave it...
719
00:47:24,163 --> 00:47:26,229
Yeah. Should I say it again?
720
00:47:28,367 --> 00:47:30,300
I'm trying to understand this.
721
00:47:30,402 --> 00:47:32,242
You're saying you took
it from the crime scene,
722
00:47:32,337 --> 00:47:34,271
- and gave it to him?
- That's right.
723
00:47:34,373 --> 00:47:35,706
Why?
724
00:47:35,808 --> 00:47:37,641
Because he needed it.
725
00:47:37,743 --> 00:47:40,277
He was distressed. He was
having trouble breathing.
726
00:47:40,379 --> 00:47:42,279
So, instead of taking
him to the hospital,
727
00:47:42,381 --> 00:47:44,893
which is how it's supposed to work
when something like that happens,
728
00:47:44,917 --> 00:47:47,718
you removed evidence
from the crime scene?
729
00:47:47,820 --> 00:47:49,086
Yes, I did.
730
00:47:49,188 --> 00:47:51,288
Because it had been photographed
and logged,
731
00:47:51,390 --> 00:47:52,989
so there was no reason not to.
732
00:47:53,092 --> 00:47:56,393
Other than it runs counter to
standard police rules and practices
733
00:47:56,495 --> 00:47:59,696
regarding chain of evidence and
is grossly unprofessional?
734
00:47:59,798 --> 00:48:03,467
Which, with 33 years
experience, you would certainly know.
735
00:48:03,569 --> 00:48:04,968
He was suffering.
736
00:48:05,070 --> 00:48:07,637
My apologies for trying
to lessen his suffering.
737
00:48:07,740 --> 00:48:09,873
That's why you did it?
738
00:48:09,975 --> 00:48:12,342
Not because it didn't fit?
739
00:48:14,480 --> 00:48:16,513
I really don't know what that means.
740
00:48:16,615 --> 00:48:21,284
"If the glove don't
fit, you must acquit."
741
00:48:22,254 --> 00:48:24,321
An inhaler doesn't fit how we picture
742
00:48:24,423 --> 00:48:26,590
a crazed killer trying
to stab someone 22 times
743
00:48:26,692 --> 00:48:29,059
between hits off his Ventolin.
744
00:48:29,161 --> 00:48:31,094
No. That's not why.
745
00:48:31,196 --> 00:48:32,763
I told you why.
746
00:48:32,865 --> 00:48:35,065
I'm not saying you consciously
thought about it.
747
00:48:35,167 --> 00:48:37,100
I'm wondering if
maybe it was subconscious,
748
00:48:37,202 --> 00:48:40,570
if you were having doubts about
his guilt from the beginning.
749
00:48:40,672 --> 00:48:42,105
Subconscious?
750
00:48:42,207 --> 00:48:43,874
Mm-hmm.
751
00:48:43,976 --> 00:48:47,978
Well, if one could describe what
goes on in their sub-conscious mind,
752
00:48:48,080 --> 00:48:50,080
it wouldn't be sub-conscious, would it?
753
00:48:52,050 --> 00:48:54,684
So, I guess there's no
way for us to know.
754
00:48:54,787 --> 00:48:58,555
Unless you got Freud out
there waiting to be called.
755
00:49:05,164 --> 00:49:06,997
Judge: Mrs. Weiss.
756
00:49:07,099 --> 00:49:08,899
I have no questions.
757
00:49:11,503 --> 00:49:14,571
♪ ♪
758
00:49:20,312 --> 00:49:23,680
(loud chattering)
759
00:49:46,371 --> 00:49:49,606
(door alarm buzzes)
760
00:50:40,893 --> 00:50:42,759
(muffled disco music playing)
761
00:50:42,861 --> 00:50:44,327
♪ And you see me ♪
762
00:50:44,429 --> 00:50:46,463
♪ Somebody new ♪
763
00:50:46,565 --> 00:50:48,698
♪ I'm not that chained-up little person ♪
764
00:50:48,800 --> 00:50:50,367
♪ Still in love with you ♪
765
00:50:50,469 --> 00:50:52,969
♪ And so you felt like dropping in ♪
766
00:50:53,071 --> 00:50:55,005
♪ And just expect me to be free ♪
767
00:50:55,107 --> 00:50:56,306
♪ But now I'm saving... ♪
768
00:50:56,408 --> 00:50:59,309
- Hey! Here he is!
- (cheering)
769
00:50:59,411 --> 00:51:00,844
♪ Go on now go ♪
770
00:51:00,946 --> 00:51:03,213
♪ Walk out the door ♪
771
00:51:03,315 --> 00:51:04,915
♪ Just turn around now ♪
772
00:51:05,017 --> 00:51:08,051
♪ 'Cause you're
not welcome anymore ♪
773
00:51:08,153 --> 00:51:10,620
♪ Weren't you the one who
tried to break me... ♪
774
00:51:10,722 --> 00:51:12,289
What I'm gonna do now?
775
00:51:12,391 --> 00:51:15,058
Shit is all fucked up now.
776
00:51:16,428 --> 00:51:18,261
Shit was going good, too.
777
00:51:20,565 --> 00:51:23,466
What the fuck he do that for? He
ain't had to do nothing but sit there?
778
00:51:23,568 --> 00:51:25,001
You and his moms did everything.
779
00:51:25,103 --> 00:51:27,971
I didn't know him any better
than you. I don't know.
780
00:51:38,250 --> 00:51:39,449
(sighs)
781
00:51:41,520 --> 00:51:43,486
Freddie: There goes the party train.
782
00:51:43,588 --> 00:51:45,188
♪ Go on now go ♪
783
00:51:45,290 --> 00:51:47,123
♪ Walk out the door ♪
784
00:51:47,225 --> 00:51:49,392
♪ Just turn around now ♪
785
00:51:49,494 --> 00:51:51,528
"Off-duty." Like you
are most of the time.
786
00:51:51,630 --> 00:51:54,464
Ah!
787
00:51:54,566 --> 00:51:56,900
That's it. Ah, just kidding!
788
00:51:57,002 --> 00:51:58,935
Hey, we got you... We
got you something else.
789
00:52:00,872 --> 00:52:02,238
Here we go!
790
00:52:02,341 --> 00:52:04,641
(cheering)
791
00:52:08,313 --> 00:52:10,447
♪ I've got all my life to live ♪
792
00:52:10,549 --> 00:52:12,582
♪ And I got all my love to give ♪
793
00:52:12,684 --> 00:52:14,751
♪ I will survive... ♪
794
00:52:23,161 --> 00:52:25,428
You got something you wanna tell me?
795
00:52:27,532 --> 00:52:29,199
About Petey?
796
00:52:35,140 --> 00:52:36,506
Yeah.
797
00:52:40,979 --> 00:52:45,448
(applause)
798
00:52:45,550 --> 00:52:47,650
All: Yeah!
799
00:52:47,753 --> 00:52:50,887
♪ ♪
800
00:53:03,902 --> 00:53:06,169
(woman on TV) The only pleasure I have
801
00:53:06,271 --> 00:53:09,773
is knowing how much of a pound of flesh
802
00:53:09,875 --> 00:53:12,475
both of you clowns have had to pay
803
00:53:12,577 --> 00:53:14,177
for your decisions...
804
00:53:18,884 --> 00:53:23,987
(TV continues indistinctly)
805
00:53:24,089 --> 00:53:29,726
♪ ♪
806
00:53:51,016 --> 00:53:52,949
Yo, I need a new one.
807
00:53:54,252 --> 00:53:57,187
♪ ♪
808
00:54:00,125 --> 00:54:03,359
(TV playing indistinctly)
809
00:54:16,775 --> 00:54:19,976
(shouting)
810
00:54:29,654 --> 00:54:30,614
- Fuck!
- (alarm blaring)
811
00:54:30,689 --> 00:54:33,523
Send a squad to the
annex! Squad to the annex!
812
00:54:33,625 --> 00:54:36,960
(TV blaring indistinctly)
813
00:54:37,062 --> 00:54:39,729
(alarm blaring)
814
00:54:41,433 --> 00:54:43,032
Officer: Send a squad now!
815
00:54:43,135 --> 00:54:48,004
♪ ♪
816
00:54:52,611 --> 00:54:54,911
Officer: What's taking you so long?!
817
00:54:55,013 --> 00:54:57,847
♪ ♪
818
00:55:05,090 --> 00:55:09,692
(distant sirens blaring)
819
00:55:09,794 --> 00:55:13,663
- Synced and corrected by VitoSilans -
--