1 00:00:01,349 --> 00:00:03,393 In the criminal justice system, 2 00:00:03,394 --> 00:00:06,397 the people are represented by two separate yet equally important groups. 3 00:00:06,702 --> 00:00:08,704 The police, who investigate crime, 4 00:00:09,052 --> 00:00:11,750 and the Crown Prosecutors, who prosecute the offenders. 5 00:00:12,099 --> 00:00:13,317 These are their stories. 6 00:00:19,106 --> 00:00:22,238 The killing of Yvonne Macy and her unborn child 7 00:00:22,239 --> 00:00:24,546 was an act of unparalleled evil. 8 00:00:25,547 --> 00:00:29,899 You and Darren Pearce left a young teacher to bleed to death 9 00:00:30,247 --> 00:00:33,641 after subjecting her to the most horrific 10 00:00:33,642 --> 00:00:35,426 and unprovoked attack. 11 00:00:37,167 --> 00:00:40,996 Billy Wells, the sentence I pass is that you be detained at 12 00:00:40,997 --> 00:00:45,522 Her Majesty's pleasure for a minimum of twelve years and until such a time 13 00:00:45,523 --> 00:00:49,092 as the home secretary is satisfied that you have been fully rehabilitated... 14 00:00:49,571 --> 00:00:52,704 - and no longer a danger. - No, please. 15 00:00:55,316 --> 00:00:56,404 No! 16 00:00:57,448 --> 00:00:58,449 No! Please! 17 00:01:01,887 --> 00:01:04,977 Time of death somewhere between six and seven, 18 00:01:05,456 --> 00:01:09,938 impact marks on the side of the car. Looks like whoever did this beat her head 19 00:01:09,939 --> 00:01:13,464 - against it till she was dead. - Nice. Right, thanks Joy. 20 00:01:16,859 --> 00:01:18,078 Do we know who she is yet? 21 00:01:19,514 --> 00:01:22,212 - Bag's missing, that was in the road. - Right... 22 00:01:23,953 --> 00:01:25,736 She's a doctor? 23 00:01:25,737 --> 00:01:28,653 Junior house officer. Alice Cullen. Been qualified six months. 24 00:01:31,265 --> 00:01:33,310 All those lives she could've saved, eh? 25 00:02:19,704 --> 00:02:21,836 The actual attack happened between the cars 26 00:02:21,837 --> 00:02:23,969 which is why it doesn't show up on the cameras. 27 00:02:24,666 --> 00:02:27,234 And no one saw anything? No one heard her scream? 28 00:02:27,495 --> 00:02:29,845 Pathologist reckons it was all over in a couple of minutes. 29 00:02:30,280 --> 00:02:33,543 And Ron, you reckon she knew her attacker? 30 00:02:33,544 --> 00:02:36,111 Her head was bashed in against her own car door 31 00:02:36,112 --> 00:02:38,592 'til she stopped breathing. Guv, I'd say that was personal. 32 00:02:38,593 --> 00:02:40,160 Anything missing from her handbag? 33 00:02:41,030 --> 00:02:43,554 Uniform found everything, except her keys. 34 00:02:50,344 --> 00:02:53,520 So whoever it was, uses her key to get in 35 00:02:53,521 --> 00:02:56,001 and then leaves all the stuff that would be easiest to shift. 36 00:02:56,741 --> 00:02:59,309 Well maybe she's got something worth more than money? 37 00:03:06,969 --> 00:03:07,839 Ronnie? 38 00:03:09,276 --> 00:03:10,190 Yeah? 39 00:03:19,416 --> 00:03:21,810 Looks like it wasn't just Alice that he killed. 40 00:03:23,290 --> 00:03:26,423 Post Mortem confirmed Alice was ten weeks pregnant. 41 00:03:27,772 --> 00:03:30,731 Forensics found a couple of dark hairs on her clothes, 42 00:03:30,732 --> 00:03:35,257 they've gone for DNA analysis. Any news on prints in her flat? 43 00:03:35,258 --> 00:03:38,086 Two sets all over the place. One confirmed as Alice's. 44 00:03:38,087 --> 00:03:41,132 A neighbor reckons she's got a fiancé who stays a couple of nights a week 45 00:03:41,133 --> 00:03:43,352 so we suspect the second set are his. 46 00:03:43,353 --> 00:03:46,530 Yeah he's here. He's waiting in reception with her parents. 47 00:03:47,618 --> 00:03:49,490 They did the formal ID this morning. 48 00:03:50,969 --> 00:03:54,843 Mrs. Cullen, can you think of anything in Alice's flat 49 00:03:55,235 --> 00:03:56,758 that someone may have wanted? 50 00:03:58,803 --> 00:04:02,242 Addicts break into doctors' flats, don't they? Looking for drugs. 51 00:04:04,287 --> 00:04:09,510 Does it matter what he took? There's only one thing we want back... 52 00:04:10,989 --> 00:04:12,991 and he can't give it to us. 53 00:04:17,735 --> 00:04:19,955 Did you know that Alice was pregnant? 54 00:04:22,523 --> 00:04:25,439 She called us the second they finished the scan. 55 00:04:26,004 --> 00:04:28,529 She couldn't keep it in a moment longer. 56 00:04:31,836 --> 00:04:33,751 Alice was our only child. 57 00:04:36,276 --> 00:04:37,929 We'll never be grandparents. 58 00:04:40,497 --> 00:04:41,455 Oh god... 59 00:04:49,593 --> 00:04:50,594 Mr. Nash, 60 00:04:52,074 --> 00:04:53,336 we're ready for you now. 61 00:04:56,600 --> 00:04:58,907 We were gonna meet in China Town to celebrate. 62 00:05:01,213 --> 00:05:02,563 I was gonna be a dad. 63 00:05:04,695 --> 00:05:05,870 Yeah I know, mate. 64 00:05:09,396 --> 00:05:12,573 - Do we have to do this now? - I'm sorry. 65 00:05:13,051 --> 00:05:14,531 Wha... what do you need mine for? 66 00:05:16,403 --> 00:05:19,709 It's just so we can sort the prints that should be in your fiancée's flat 67 00:05:19,710 --> 00:05:20,711 from those that shouldn't. 68 00:05:22,713 --> 00:05:24,106 Joe seems like a nice lad. 69 00:05:25,716 --> 00:05:28,284 They've been inseparable since Joe started at the hospital. 70 00:05:29,416 --> 00:05:31,113 - He's a doctor? - No... 71 00:05:32,723 --> 00:05:34,551 he's a hospital porter. 72 00:05:36,597 --> 00:05:37,728 But he's a nice lad? 73 00:05:39,382 --> 00:05:42,646 It's her last boyfriend you should be asking about, not Joe. 74 00:05:44,082 --> 00:05:45,083 And why's that? 75 00:05:50,698 --> 00:05:53,440 So Alice had six visits to casualty in the last two years. 76 00:05:56,399 --> 00:06:00,011 Last time, cracked rib, fractured cheekbone... 77 00:06:01,143 --> 00:06:02,927 We broke up two years ago. 78 00:06:03,580 --> 00:06:05,842 Well maybe you had some unfinished business? 79 00:06:05,843 --> 00:06:08,802 Is that why you shot down to London the minute she announced her engagement 80 00:06:08,803 --> 00:06:11,806 - in The Times? - We opened an office in the city. 81 00:06:12,372 --> 00:06:15,157 So what are you then? Merchant banker? 82 00:06:16,288 --> 00:06:17,681 Investment banker. 83 00:06:18,682 --> 00:06:20,728 And did you know Alice was living in London? 84 00:06:21,642 --> 00:06:24,687 Well her parents made sure no one in Edinburgh knew where they'd gone. 85 00:06:24,688 --> 00:06:26,908 Right so you did try to find her? 86 00:06:27,430 --> 00:06:30,520 I asked around. But I got over it. I moved on. 87 00:06:32,392 --> 00:06:33,741 You're in a relationship then? 88 00:06:35,525 --> 00:06:36,483 Several. 89 00:06:37,919 --> 00:06:39,399 It didn't bother you that Alice was getting engaged? 90 00:06:41,618 --> 00:06:43,272 I didn't lose any sleep over it. 91 00:06:43,838 --> 00:06:46,187 Oh come on? She was your favorite possession 92 00:06:46,188 --> 00:06:50,410 and she dumped you. And now she's ended up with some bloke, down here... 93 00:06:52,237 --> 00:06:53,369 having his kid. 94 00:06:55,415 --> 00:06:58,940 Yeah her mum reckoned it was all she'd ever wanted. Her own little family. 95 00:07:02,160 --> 00:07:05,511 Well it wouldn't've lasted. She'd have gone running home 96 00:07:05,512 --> 00:07:07,470 to daddy the minute she didn't get her own way. 97 00:07:08,515 --> 00:07:12,954 And what? You went after her, you know, to tell her she was making a mistake? 98 00:07:13,737 --> 00:07:16,436 Is that what you did? Wait outside the hospital? 99 00:07:17,219 --> 00:07:19,177 - Follow her into the car park? - No. 100 00:07:19,526 --> 00:07:22,180 And when she wouldn't talk to you, you tried to make her listen? 101 00:07:24,226 --> 00:07:27,447 I had a problem. But I've changed. 102 00:07:28,839 --> 00:07:31,798 Is that what you tried to show her in the car park how much you'd 'changed'? 103 00:07:31,799 --> 00:07:32,713 Look, 104 00:07:34,802 --> 00:07:37,457 I've had five k's worth of anger management. 105 00:07:37,718 --> 00:07:38,762 You've been done, mate. 106 00:07:41,417 --> 00:07:42,462 I didn't do this. 107 00:07:44,289 --> 00:07:45,855 Well then you won't mind us asking where you were on Sunday night 108 00:07:45,856 --> 00:07:48,119 between the hours of six and seven pm, will you? 109 00:07:50,600 --> 00:07:52,907 Showing my PA who's boss. 110 00:07:54,561 --> 00:07:58,955 His PA has confirmed that they were at it for the best part of two hours. 111 00:07:58,956 --> 00:08:00,175 I'm in the wrong job. 112 00:08:01,132 --> 00:08:02,699 Could she be covering for him? 113 00:08:04,658 --> 00:08:06,963 No 'cause the security guard puts them both in his office at the same time 114 00:08:06,964 --> 00:08:08,792 - Alice was killed. - What about the fiancé? 115 00:08:09,140 --> 00:08:10,445 Has he got a record? 116 00:08:10,446 --> 00:08:12,404 Nicking cars when he was a kid. Nothing since. 117 00:08:12,883 --> 00:08:15,973 Get Manchester to send his file anyway. Has he got an alibi? 118 00:08:16,234 --> 00:08:17,627 Claims he was in China Town. 119 00:08:19,455 --> 00:08:20,325 No? 120 00:08:20,848 --> 00:08:22,153 - Thank you. - Thanks. 121 00:08:24,416 --> 00:08:26,505 So no one remembers Joe Nash. 122 00:08:26,506 --> 00:08:31,248 Well that's 'cause he was never here, why don't we chase up his phone records. 123 00:08:31,249 --> 00:08:32,642 Find out where he really was. 124 00:08:33,121 --> 00:08:34,731 Right, well, 125 00:08:35,297 --> 00:08:38,647 Joe Nash made three phone calls on Sunday night. 126 00:08:38,648 --> 00:08:43,174 None of those calls was to Alice Cullen and none of them were from China Town. 127 00:08:43,958 --> 00:08:45,046 So who did he call? 128 00:08:46,700 --> 00:08:50,660 He called Daniela Renzo, psychiatric social worker. 129 00:08:51,052 --> 00:08:52,967 Right, so where you going? 130 00:08:53,402 --> 00:08:57,275 Well these three calls put Joe at the murder scene, 131 00:08:57,667 --> 00:09:02,192 half an hour before the killing, near Alice Cullen's flat 132 00:09:02,193 --> 00:09:03,455 at the time of the break-in. 133 00:09:04,892 --> 00:09:08,111 And finally up here at Daniela Renzo's gaffe just 134 00:09:08,112 --> 00:09:10,550 - in time for bed. - So he's having an affair? 135 00:09:12,421 --> 00:09:17,730 Let's put it to the test. Let's see how this grieving fiancé fancies appearing 136 00:09:17,731 --> 00:09:18,949 on the ten o'clock news. 137 00:09:25,652 --> 00:09:26,566 An appeal? 138 00:09:28,306 --> 00:09:30,047 Public see the heartache, they're more likely to come forward. 139 00:09:30,787 --> 00:09:32,267 Wouldn't her mum and dad be better? 140 00:09:32,702 --> 00:09:35,226 We think it'd be more emotional coming from you. 141 00:09:35,531 --> 00:09:36,924 I wouldn't be any good. 142 00:09:37,794 --> 00:09:39,666 Don't you want to help us catch whoever did this? 143 00:09:40,188 --> 00:09:43,844 Course I do but, all those people watching... 144 00:09:45,541 --> 00:09:48,283 I wouldn't know what to say. I'm sorry. You'll have to ask someone else. 145 00:09:53,288 --> 00:09:55,812 Joe's a client, nothing more. 146 00:09:57,509 --> 00:10:00,338 Right so he has psychiatric issues? 147 00:10:01,513 --> 00:10:04,777 Joe suffered, a severe childhood trauma. 148 00:10:04,778 --> 00:10:07,128 He still has nightmares, depression. 149 00:10:07,781 --> 00:10:10,348 What was his relationship like with his fiancée? 150 00:10:11,132 --> 00:10:13,046 You know I can't go into those sort of details. 151 00:10:13,047 --> 00:10:14,875 It's a little thing called client confidentiality. 152 00:10:15,179 --> 00:10:17,791 Well we're investigating a little thing called murder. 153 00:10:18,139 --> 00:10:21,533 Your client's fiancée was beaten to death in a car park on Sunday night. 154 00:10:23,100 --> 00:10:24,188 You didn't know? 155 00:10:26,930 --> 00:10:30,151 Oh, god. Poor Joe. 156 00:10:32,632 --> 00:10:33,981 He must be devastated. 157 00:10:36,984 --> 00:10:40,204 Well you know he was here. Sunday night. 158 00:10:41,771 --> 00:10:42,990 You see clients at home? 159 00:10:43,904 --> 00:10:44,861 Sometimes. 160 00:10:46,341 --> 00:10:48,648 Joe didn't want Alice to know about our appointments 161 00:10:48,952 --> 00:10:51,302 and it was easier to keep them quiet if he came to me. 162 00:10:51,607 --> 00:10:53,173 Why would he want to keep them quiet? 163 00:10:53,174 --> 00:10:55,306 I've been helping Joe for six years. 164 00:10:56,699 --> 00:10:57,961 He's known Alice for two. 165 00:10:59,615 --> 00:11:01,835 He just wasn't ready to share that part of himself with her. 166 00:11:02,226 --> 00:11:03,271 But they were getting married. 167 00:11:04,054 --> 00:11:06,100 And married men don't have secrets? 168 00:11:07,667 --> 00:11:09,624 The truth is, I think he was hoping 169 00:11:09,625 --> 00:11:12,672 he could get to a place where he didn't need to tell her. 170 00:11:13,281 --> 00:11:14,543 And what time did he arrive? 171 00:11:15,718 --> 00:11:16,676 Six. 172 00:11:18,590 --> 00:11:22,682 He called first... at about five thirty. 173 00:11:24,205 --> 00:11:26,163 He left about eight. 174 00:11:26,903 --> 00:11:30,341 But then if he was here, why would he need to call you twice after he left? 175 00:11:30,602 --> 00:11:31,691 He left his jacket. 176 00:11:33,431 --> 00:11:35,912 I was in the bath the first time he called. 177 00:11:36,521 --> 00:11:39,960 Look, I can vouch for Joe, he was here with me. 178 00:11:40,743 --> 00:11:42,178 If she was my social worker, 179 00:11:42,179 --> 00:11:43,920 I'd be calling her three times a night and all. 180 00:11:44,878 --> 00:11:47,575 And she gave him an alibi without us even asking. 181 00:11:47,576 --> 00:11:50,187 Yeah it's just a shame that it wasn't the same alibi that he gave us. 182 00:11:51,014 --> 00:11:54,147 So he says he's in China Town nibbling prawn crackers 183 00:11:54,148 --> 00:11:55,889 when actually he was nibbling something else. 184 00:11:57,455 --> 00:12:01,198 - I was ashamed, - of needing a social worker? 185 00:12:02,765 --> 00:12:05,333 Of needing a psychiatric social worker. 186 00:12:07,074 --> 00:12:08,205 I have a sleep disorder. 187 00:12:08,510 --> 00:12:09,685 Lucid dreaming? 188 00:12:11,339 --> 00:12:13,384 It was Dani's idea, so I could learn to control my nightmares. 189 00:12:14,516 --> 00:12:16,518 Kill the monster that's chasing you? 190 00:12:17,084 --> 00:12:18,346 Or turn it into a mouse. 191 00:12:20,696 --> 00:12:24,265 So you didn't meet Alice for dinner at all? You were with Dani? 192 00:12:24,569 --> 00:12:29,531 After my appointment with Dani, I went to the restaurant but was too late. 193 00:12:30,924 --> 00:12:35,102 I went to Alice's flat and she wasn't there so I came home. 194 00:12:36,103 --> 00:12:38,801 And then went all the way back to Dani's to collect your jacket? 195 00:12:39,454 --> 00:12:42,500 Yeah. My... my wallet was in the pocket. 196 00:12:45,460 --> 00:12:48,158 So, how were you going to pay for your Chinese? 197 00:12:49,377 --> 00:12:51,814 I didn't realize it was missing until I got to the restaurant. 198 00:12:54,295 --> 00:12:58,386 It's the sleep deprivation. It makes me confused sometimes. 199 00:13:00,997 --> 00:13:04,957 Look I know you've got to ask these questions but he's still out there 200 00:13:04,958 --> 00:13:07,177 isn't he? Whoever did this to Alice. 201 00:13:09,527 --> 00:13:11,181 I just want you to find him. 202 00:13:11,834 --> 00:13:13,357 Not enough to do an appeal? 203 00:13:14,968 --> 00:13:17,056 - Did you notice the way he dressed? - Yeah. 204 00:13:17,057 --> 00:13:20,102 - Smart shoes, no laces. Jeans, no belt. - Right? 205 00:13:20,103 --> 00:13:22,366 What about his bed? Hospital corners. 206 00:13:22,627 --> 00:13:24,454 A blanket folded in a neat square 207 00:13:24,455 --> 00:13:26,587 - on the end of it. - I know where you're going with this, Ron. 208 00:13:26,588 --> 00:13:28,851 Look he spent three months inside for nicking cars. 209 00:13:29,199 --> 00:13:31,418 He's not gonna get institutionalized after three months. 210 00:13:31,419 --> 00:13:33,900 - No, but-- - But he did have psych issues. 211 00:13:34,552 --> 00:13:37,511 So maybe he learnt that stuff on a psych ward not in a prison. 212 00:13:37,512 --> 00:13:40,732 Nah, nah. He's an ex-con mate. I can smell it a mile off. 213 00:13:45,781 --> 00:13:47,348 Ok cheers. 214 00:13:49,350 --> 00:13:52,701 Well if Joe Nash was ever a psychiatric in-patient, it wasn't in the UK. 215 00:13:53,006 --> 00:13:54,355 Maybe he was in a military prison. 216 00:13:54,746 --> 00:13:56,531 Or maybe he's just a neat freak. 217 00:13:57,488 --> 00:13:59,576 Daniela's landlord lives above her. 218 00:13:59,577 --> 00:14:00,926 I've got his number here somewhere 219 00:14:00,927 --> 00:14:02,885 he might remember if Joe was there that night. 220 00:14:05,496 --> 00:14:07,281 - This is weird. - What's that? 221 00:14:08,238 --> 00:14:11,851 Well according to this file from Manchester, 222 00:14:12,939 --> 00:14:14,679 when Joe Nash got nicked for TWOC-ing 223 00:14:15,376 --> 00:14:19,683 the arresting officer was Detective Sergeant Marvin Douglas. 224 00:14:19,684 --> 00:14:20,555 So? 225 00:14:21,991 --> 00:14:24,427 Well, Marvin Douglas was transferred back to London 226 00:14:24,428 --> 00:14:26,430 from Manchester six months before. 227 00:14:27,692 --> 00:14:28,693 How'd you know that? 228 00:14:30,260 --> 00:14:31,826 'Cause Marvin Douglas was an usher at my second wedding. 229 00:14:31,827 --> 00:14:33,698 Which took place a month after he got back. 230 00:14:34,177 --> 00:14:35,135 Look at this. 231 00:14:38,051 --> 00:14:40,792 Well, I mean could be a clerical error. Someone just bunged down the wrong name. 232 00:14:41,010 --> 00:14:42,707 That is Marvin's signature! 233 00:14:42,969 --> 00:14:45,449 He couldn't have signed it six months after he left, could he? 234 00:14:48,365 --> 00:14:50,585 Why would anyone tamper with the archive? 235 00:14:51,064 --> 00:14:54,022 Well you gotta admit it is a bit suspect? 236 00:14:54,023 --> 00:14:56,982 I tell you what's suspect, is a loving fiancé lying 237 00:14:56,983 --> 00:15:00,160 about where he was and refusing to take part in an appeal. 238 00:15:01,204 --> 00:15:03,163 I've just been talking to Daniela Renzo's landlord. 239 00:15:03,772 --> 00:15:06,600 He says he took in a parcel for her on the day of the murder. 240 00:15:06,601 --> 00:15:09,430 Tried to deliver it three or four times, only she was out all evening. 241 00:15:09,952 --> 00:15:13,129 So she wasn't in her flat having a session with Joe Nash at all. 242 00:15:14,000 --> 00:15:17,960 Bring 'em both in. She's either covering for him or they're both in it together. 243 00:15:44,334 --> 00:15:47,120 Joe, you need to start telling us the truth, son. 244 00:15:48,382 --> 00:15:51,863 Alright. I wasn't entirely honest with you before. 245 00:15:52,734 --> 00:15:55,824 Because I... I lied 'cause I knew what you'd think. 246 00:15:59,480 --> 00:16:02,309 Me and Alice, we were gonna meet at the restaurant 247 00:16:04,398 --> 00:16:05,312 but, 248 00:16:06,617 --> 00:16:11,318 we had a fight at work. And I got upset. 249 00:16:12,275 --> 00:16:15,278 So I rang Dani and she didn't answer. 250 00:16:16,236 --> 00:16:18,064 I left a message, you can ask her. 251 00:16:19,065 --> 00:16:20,544 So you never went to Dani's flat? 252 00:16:21,719 --> 00:16:23,156 Not until much later. 253 00:16:24,853 --> 00:16:29,205 I went round about ten thirty, I called her from outside 254 00:16:30,424 --> 00:16:33,035 but she said she was going to bed. She never let me in. 255 00:16:34,123 --> 00:16:35,995 And what did you and Alice argue about? 256 00:16:38,736 --> 00:16:40,390 It was just some stupid fight. 257 00:16:41,087 --> 00:16:44,003 - And was it about Dani? - No. 258 00:16:45,308 --> 00:16:47,093 But you fancied her though, didn't you? 259 00:16:47,876 --> 00:16:49,703 I mean she's a classy looking bird, 260 00:16:49,704 --> 00:16:51,748 who wouldn't? It's only natural. 261 00:16:51,749 --> 00:16:52,924 I've got Alice. 262 00:16:55,057 --> 00:16:56,885 Had Alice. 263 00:16:58,800 --> 00:17:01,194 And yet here we are trying to find out who killed her 264 00:17:01,455 --> 00:17:03,283 and you're not telling us everything. 265 00:17:04,588 --> 00:17:05,589 I can't... 266 00:17:06,547 --> 00:17:08,069 What did you argue about Joe? 267 00:17:08,070 --> 00:17:10,724 - Were you and Daniela sleeping together? - No. 268 00:17:10,725 --> 00:17:13,161 - Did Alice find out? - Can we stop this please? 269 00:17:13,162 --> 00:17:15,599 I mean did the fight get physical? I mean you hit her, 270 00:17:16,122 --> 00:17:18,167 she falls, you get angry. 271 00:17:18,776 --> 00:17:21,952 Listen Joe, we understand how these things happen, yeah? 272 00:17:21,953 --> 00:17:24,216 No, that's not me. I don't do that. 273 00:17:24,217 --> 00:17:26,045 Alright, ok, so then what did happen? 274 00:17:26,567 --> 00:17:29,960 I mean, look mate, if you don't tell us, then you can't really blame us 275 00:17:29,961 --> 00:17:31,920 for trying to fill in the blanks, now can you? 276 00:17:32,225 --> 00:17:34,878 I need some sleep. Can we... can we stop? 277 00:17:34,879 --> 00:17:38,231 - Joe what did you argue about? - Please don't do this. 278 00:17:40,624 --> 00:17:41,669 What was it? 279 00:17:47,370 --> 00:17:48,415 My diary. 280 00:17:50,025 --> 00:17:50,895 Your diary? 281 00:17:53,681 --> 00:17:55,030 I thought she'd understand. 282 00:17:55,335 --> 00:17:57,031 She said she was gonna bring it with her. 283 00:17:57,032 --> 00:17:58,338 She said it was in her bag. 284 00:18:00,296 --> 00:18:02,777 She said I disgusted her. 285 00:18:04,692 --> 00:18:06,085 She walked away from me. 286 00:18:06,824 --> 00:18:08,783 So you followed her into the car park, didn't you? 287 00:18:11,002 --> 00:18:15,268 Joe? And you grabbed her while she was getting into the car. 288 00:18:16,834 --> 00:18:17,922 Is that what happened? 289 00:18:22,449 --> 00:18:23,711 I never meant to. 290 00:18:25,539 --> 00:18:27,149 What did you do to her, Joe? 291 00:18:28,716 --> 00:18:33,112 She was on the ground... She was so scared... 292 00:18:36,593 --> 00:18:37,464 Go on. 293 00:18:39,205 --> 00:18:40,728 She was always picking on me... 294 00:18:41,903 --> 00:18:43,165 And so you killed her? 295 00:18:43,600 --> 00:18:45,472 There was so much blood on my shoes. 296 00:18:47,343 --> 00:18:49,084 I couldn't get it off me shoes. 297 00:18:50,172 --> 00:18:52,218 For the tape then please, Joe. 298 00:18:52,522 --> 00:18:57,136 Yeah. I never meant to. I... I should've stopped... 299 00:18:57,571 --> 00:18:59,964 I-- I'm sorry. I'm so sorry. 300 00:19:01,488 --> 00:19:02,576 It's alright Joe. 301 00:19:12,847 --> 00:19:15,458 You're more than just his social worker, aren't you? 302 00:19:18,896 --> 00:19:20,942 You have got no idea what you're asking. 303 00:19:22,639 --> 00:19:26,251 Joe Nash, I'm arresting you for the murder of Alice Cullen. 304 00:19:26,252 --> 00:19:29,254 You do not have to say anything but it may harm your defense 305 00:19:29,255 --> 00:19:30,777 - No-- - If you do not mention 306 00:19:30,778 --> 00:19:32,910 when questioned something you later rely on, in court. 307 00:19:33,433 --> 00:19:34,868 Joe would you like a brief now? 308 00:19:34,869 --> 00:19:36,739 - No you... you don't understand. - Anything you do say 309 00:19:36,740 --> 00:19:39,002 - may be given in evidence. - I'm not who you think I am. 310 00:19:39,003 --> 00:19:40,179 I'm not Joe Nash. 311 00:19:41,745 --> 00:19:45,052 They gave me the name Joe Nash, and this prehistory thing 312 00:19:45,053 --> 00:19:47,837 and then moved me down here. I've got a new passport, 313 00:19:47,838 --> 00:19:51,233 a national insurance number. The home office arranged it. 314 00:19:53,061 --> 00:19:55,846 I was assigned to help Joe manage his new identity. 315 00:19:58,806 --> 00:20:00,373 He's in witness protection? 316 00:20:03,158 --> 00:20:04,551 He's on life license. 317 00:20:07,031 --> 00:20:10,296 Fifteen years ago, when we were eleven, 318 00:20:13,299 --> 00:20:16,127 me and me mate, Darren Pearce, we... 319 00:20:19,435 --> 00:20:22,482 we killed our teacher. Yvonne Macy. 320 00:20:25,136 --> 00:20:27,530 We were released six years ago on a life license. 321 00:20:30,229 --> 00:20:31,621 I'm not Joe Nash. 322 00:20:34,668 --> 00:20:35,712 I'm Billy Wells. 323 00:20:44,678 --> 00:20:48,464 Joe Nash spent three months in the same YOI as Billy Wells. 324 00:20:49,683 --> 00:20:50,814 They shared a cell. 325 00:20:52,642 --> 00:20:55,732 But why would he claim to be Billy Wells if he's not? 326 00:20:56,994 --> 00:20:59,736 Nash has a long history of psychiatric illness. 327 00:21:00,389 --> 00:21:02,608 He's suffering from Delusional Disorder. 328 00:21:02,609 --> 00:21:04,566 I was there when he was interviewed. 329 00:21:04,567 --> 00:21:06,786 The police surgeon found him fit for questioning. 330 00:21:06,787 --> 00:21:08,353 I'm told those who suffer 331 00:21:08,354 --> 00:21:10,704 from Delusional Disorder appear as normal as you or me. 332 00:21:11,835 --> 00:21:15,012 You're a hundred percent certain that he isn't Billy Wells? 333 00:21:15,535 --> 00:21:16,579 Yes, I am. 334 00:21:18,059 --> 00:21:21,192 I've seen pictures taken of Billy Wells three weeks ago. 335 00:21:21,845 --> 00:21:25,284 He has a wife and child and a Rhodesian Ridgeback. 336 00:21:26,459 --> 00:21:28,547 Even though I can tell you categorically that 337 00:21:28,548 --> 00:21:30,898 Joe Nash is not Billy Wells, 338 00:21:31,594 --> 00:21:33,421 any hint of his claims in the media 339 00:21:33,422 --> 00:21:35,946 and the public will be crying conspiracy theory. 340 00:21:36,773 --> 00:21:39,775 And we'll be looking at a mistrial or grounds for appeal. 341 00:21:39,776 --> 00:21:43,214 The Home Secretary's also most concerned about this matter being aired in public. 342 00:21:43,563 --> 00:21:45,912 The Home Office is already under considerable pressure 343 00:21:45,913 --> 00:21:47,915 for a public referendum on the death penalty. 344 00:21:48,959 --> 00:21:51,614 There simply cannot be a trial. 345 00:21:52,136 --> 00:21:53,573 Is there any need for one? 346 00:21:54,269 --> 00:21:56,967 He's confessed. Presumably he's pleading guilty? 347 00:21:58,404 --> 00:21:59,709 Offer Nash a deal. 348 00:22:00,623 --> 00:22:03,495 He pleads manslaughter diminished responsibility 349 00:22:03,496 --> 00:22:04,758 and gets a hospital order. 350 00:22:06,281 --> 00:22:07,630 He could be out of a secure hospital in a few months. 351 00:22:08,239 --> 00:22:11,154 We'll make sure he needs Ministry of Justice approval 352 00:22:11,155 --> 00:22:12,635 for any future release. 353 00:22:13,549 --> 00:22:16,291 Ok. I'll put it to his brief. 354 00:22:17,640 --> 00:22:19,468 It's an honor to meet you like this, Mr. Steel. 355 00:22:19,990 --> 00:22:21,556 You did a talk at my uni. 356 00:22:21,557 --> 00:22:22,950 'Law claims against the state' 357 00:22:23,254 --> 00:22:24,343 Very inspiring. 358 00:22:25,996 --> 00:22:28,564 I loved that George Eliot quote you started your lecture with, 359 00:22:29,260 --> 00:22:31,393 'Falsehood is easy, truth so difficult'. 360 00:22:32,612 --> 00:22:34,309 'Course he was on the right side back then. 361 00:22:35,136 --> 00:22:38,443 It was watching him in action that made me choose defense. 362 00:22:38,444 --> 00:22:40,009 Well you can get my autograph later. 363 00:22:40,010 --> 00:22:42,665 Look Eli, I'll come straight to the point 364 00:22:43,318 --> 00:22:45,406 in light of your client's mental health issues, 365 00:22:45,407 --> 00:22:46,842 the Crown's prepared to accept a plea 366 00:22:46,843 --> 00:22:48,802 to manslaughter diminished responsibility. 367 00:22:49,106 --> 00:22:50,151 You're serious? 368 00:22:52,066 --> 00:22:53,458 You're a good man, Mr. Steel. 369 00:22:53,459 --> 00:22:54,764 He's in a generous mood. 370 00:22:54,982 --> 00:22:57,071 I'd say yes quickly before he changes his mind. 371 00:22:57,376 --> 00:22:59,942 I only got this case this morning but I'm sure my client 372 00:22:59,943 --> 00:23:02,250 won't be turning his nose up on an offer this good. 373 00:23:02,903 --> 00:23:05,035 - So we got a deal? - Deal. 374 00:23:10,345 --> 00:23:13,739 You are charged with manslaughter contrary to common law. 375 00:23:13,740 --> 00:23:17,395 The particulars of the offence are that you, Joseph Nash, 376 00:23:17,396 --> 00:23:20,268 unlawfully killed Alice Elizabeth Cullen. 377 00:23:20,703 --> 00:23:22,313 To this charge how do you plead? 378 00:23:22,966 --> 00:23:24,577 Guilty or not guilty? 379 00:23:26,579 --> 00:23:27,449 Not guilty. 380 00:23:46,207 --> 00:23:48,208 - I thought we had a deal. - I know. I know. 381 00:23:48,209 --> 00:23:50,340 So what the hell just happened in there? Did you plan this? 382 00:23:50,341 --> 00:23:52,648 No, I swear, I had no idea he was gonna do that. 383 00:23:52,953 --> 00:23:55,389 He confessed for God's sake. How can he plead not guilty? 384 00:23:55,390 --> 00:23:58,437 - I don't know. - He's your client. How can you not know? 385 00:23:58,872 --> 00:24:02,091 - How the hell did this happen? - I thought the deal was done and dusted. 386 00:24:02,092 --> 00:24:04,703 Believe me George, so did I. Eli gave me his word. 387 00:24:04,704 --> 00:24:07,707 - DPP will have a hernia! - Especially when she hears about this. 388 00:24:08,098 --> 00:24:10,449 It seems Eli's had a sudden change of heart. 389 00:24:11,406 --> 00:24:13,059 He's got to be joking? 390 00:24:13,060 --> 00:24:15,541 It's no joke. Eli's claiming Nash was coerced into confessing. 391 00:24:19,370 --> 00:24:20,633 Take the deal. 392 00:24:22,591 --> 00:24:25,115 You put this to a jury that confession will send you to prison for life. 393 00:24:25,638 --> 00:24:28,162 I don't deserve to be in prison. I'm innocent. 394 00:24:32,209 --> 00:24:34,472 First, you claim to be Billy Wells and you admit to killing Alice, 395 00:24:34,473 --> 00:24:37,998 now you're saying you're not Billy Wells, you're Joe Nash and you didn't kill Alice? 396 00:24:38,259 --> 00:24:40,303 He was confused when he made those claims. 397 00:24:40,304 --> 00:24:43,656 You know he was also frightened out of his wits by two heavy handed coppers 398 00:24:43,917 --> 00:24:46,048 determined to hear what they wanted to hear. 399 00:24:46,049 --> 00:24:49,226 I don't think you have any idea what'll happen if a jury hear the name Billy Wells 400 00:24:49,705 --> 00:24:52,490 Whether he calls himself Billy Wells or Joe Nash, 401 00:24:52,491 --> 00:24:54,667 the truth is he didn't kill Alice Cullen. 402 00:24:55,276 --> 00:24:57,495 Now I can't allow an innocent man to be locked up 403 00:24:57,496 --> 00:24:59,585 in a secure hospital for God knows how long. 404 00:25:00,629 --> 00:25:03,502 Now, I suggest you look at those confession tapes again, Mr. Steel, 405 00:25:03,850 --> 00:25:06,113 because those coppers took too much for granted. 406 00:25:08,071 --> 00:25:09,899 Joe never actually said he killed Alice. 407 00:25:14,817 --> 00:25:16,515 So you killed her, yeah? 408 00:25:17,341 --> 00:25:20,693 There was so much blood. I couldn't get it off me shoes. 409 00:25:21,607 --> 00:25:24,305 Okay, for the tape, please Joe. 410 00:25:24,610 --> 00:25:25,524 Yeah. 411 00:25:27,308 --> 00:25:30,311 I never meant to. I should've stopped. I'm sorry. I'm... 412 00:25:31,747 --> 00:25:32,705 so sorry. 413 00:25:34,837 --> 00:25:37,536 Eli's wrong. Joe admits killing Alice. 414 00:25:39,538 --> 00:25:40,495 Does he? 415 00:25:53,900 --> 00:25:55,335 "She was always picking on me. Darren didn't like it. 416 00:25:55,336 --> 00:25:57,033 I wanted her to stop but not like that. 417 00:25:58,339 --> 00:26:00,296 She was on the ground. 418 00:26:00,297 --> 00:26:04,911 She was so scared. There was so much blood. I couldn't get it off me shoes." 419 00:26:09,655 --> 00:26:14,660 This is Billy Wells' confession from 1997. 420 00:26:16,923 --> 00:26:19,490 Joe Nash isn't confessing to killing Alice Cullen. 421 00:26:21,188 --> 00:26:23,277 He's talking about the murder of Yvonne Macy. 422 00:26:23,843 --> 00:26:26,106 Joe did share a cell with Billy. 423 00:26:26,497 --> 00:26:28,977 Yeah but he didn't just tell the story, Alesha. 424 00:26:28,978 --> 00:26:31,328 He's using exactly the same words. 425 00:26:32,678 --> 00:26:34,593 You think he could really be Billy Wells? 426 00:26:51,740 --> 00:26:53,393 Look! Look at the shape of the eyes, 427 00:26:53,394 --> 00:26:55,048 the way his mouth curls down at the corners. 428 00:26:55,701 --> 00:26:58,920 You look at pictures of my best mate as a kid it could be me. 429 00:26:58,921 --> 00:27:00,530 You're seeing what you want to see, James. 430 00:27:00,531 --> 00:27:02,445 They're the same age, they're both from Manchester. 431 00:27:02,446 --> 00:27:05,144 Joe Nash moved to London within three weeks of Billy Wells' release 432 00:27:05,145 --> 00:27:07,016 - under a secret identity. - I don't know. 433 00:27:07,756 --> 00:27:10,192 Joe Nash's juvenile record has more holes than a sieve. 434 00:27:10,193 --> 00:27:12,369 The Home Secretary wants this kept out of court. 435 00:27:14,154 --> 00:27:16,504 I never had you down as a conspiracy theorist, James. 436 00:27:16,896 --> 00:27:19,246 There's just too many coincidences here. 437 00:27:21,204 --> 00:27:22,858 I don't want to be right, Alesha. 438 00:27:23,119 --> 00:27:25,861 Ok let's just say you are right. It doesn't change what he's done. 439 00:27:26,166 --> 00:27:30,779 Ok if he's Joe Nash then he's mentally ill and he should be in hospital 440 00:27:31,171 --> 00:27:34,434 but if he really is Billy Wells then he's got form 441 00:27:34,435 --> 00:27:36,566 and we need to charge him accordingly. 442 00:27:36,567 --> 00:27:39,961 We can adduce bad character evidence and make sure he stays locked up in prison 443 00:27:39,962 --> 00:27:41,616 for the rest of his life without parole. 444 00:27:45,751 --> 00:27:47,578 I just want to know one way or the other. 445 00:27:48,318 --> 00:27:51,234 His prints came back from NAFIS as belonging to Joe Nash. 446 00:27:51,931 --> 00:27:54,716 Did you ask NAFIS to double check them against Billy Wells' prints? 447 00:27:55,717 --> 00:27:57,413 If those prints match Billy Wells 448 00:27:57,414 --> 00:27:59,242 the Commissioner would be round here like a shot. 449 00:27:59,939 --> 00:28:03,725 Joe talked about a diary in his confession that it's not in evidence. 450 00:28:03,986 --> 00:28:08,208 No, it was never found. For all we know, Nash destroyed it. 451 00:28:09,122 --> 00:28:10,819 You've got Joe's DNA on file. 452 00:28:11,428 --> 00:28:13,343 Can you check it against Billy Wells' DNA? 453 00:28:14,344 --> 00:28:17,738 Fifteen years ago DNA profiles weren't saved digitally. 454 00:28:17,739 --> 00:28:19,784 Yeah I know but they must exist somewhere? 455 00:28:19,785 --> 00:28:23,613 I looked at Billy Wells file as soon as Joe Nash made his claim 456 00:28:23,614 --> 00:28:25,616 and there is no DNA profile. 457 00:28:27,183 --> 00:28:28,532 You don't think that's suspicious? 458 00:28:34,016 --> 00:28:36,105 We can't disclose those kind of details. 459 00:28:36,976 --> 00:28:38,847 These are special circumstances. 460 00:28:39,587 --> 00:28:43,198 We're talking about a psychiatric social worker specifically, allocated 461 00:28:43,199 --> 00:28:44,635 to Billy Wells on his release. 462 00:28:46,507 --> 00:28:48,814 Offenders like Billy Wells get new identities for their own protection. 463 00:28:49,684 --> 00:28:52,643 If we handed out the sort of information you're asking for 464 00:28:53,166 --> 00:28:55,994 we'd be putting the offender and the social worker at risk. 465 00:28:55,995 --> 00:29:00,564 We know he was working with Daniela Renzo, surely you can just confirm that? 466 00:29:00,913 --> 00:29:04,654 I'm sorry. Unless you get authority from the Home Secretary, 467 00:29:04,655 --> 00:29:06,047 it remains confidential. 468 00:29:06,048 --> 00:29:07,746 Fine we'll talk to the Home Secretary then. 469 00:29:08,268 --> 00:29:12,402 And he'll come back to me for advice, and I'll say no. 470 00:29:16,711 --> 00:29:18,582 We're going around in circles with this. 471 00:29:18,887 --> 00:29:21,715 You told the police you were assigned to help Billy Wells adjust 472 00:29:21,716 --> 00:29:24,371 to his new identity but no one seems to have any record of it. 473 00:29:24,719 --> 00:29:27,896 You'll need a signed letter from Joe giving full consent 474 00:29:28,201 --> 00:29:30,943 - before I disclose anything. - You talked to the police about it? 475 00:29:31,421 --> 00:29:32,771 You know that's different. 476 00:29:33,075 --> 00:29:36,426 Anyway, that was before I talked to Joe's barrister. 477 00:29:37,558 --> 00:29:41,083 I'm a witness for the defense. You can ask me whatever you like in court. 478 00:29:44,783 --> 00:29:47,524 Joe Nash has been moved to the vulnerable prisoner's wing. 479 00:29:48,699 --> 00:29:51,137 - He was attacked yesterday. - Is he all right? 480 00:29:51,659 --> 00:29:55,183 A few cuts and bruises. Apparently some new prisoner 481 00:29:55,184 --> 00:29:56,795 just went for him in the dinner queue. 482 00:29:57,186 --> 00:29:58,057 Do we know why? 483 00:29:59,319 --> 00:30:00,711 They reckon he saw Nash and just went crazy. 484 00:30:02,844 --> 00:30:04,324 Do you think he recognized him? 485 00:30:06,587 --> 00:30:09,242 That's why I need to speak to Joe Nash right now. 486 00:30:13,028 --> 00:30:14,813 You're Billy Wells, aren't you? 487 00:30:18,904 --> 00:30:22,733 Alice died in a car park outside her work, just like Yvonne Macy. 488 00:30:23,082 --> 00:30:25,214 - So? - Both were pregnant. 489 00:30:26,085 --> 00:30:27,260 That was my kid. 490 00:30:27,477 --> 00:30:29,609 Both died from repeated blows to the head. 491 00:30:29,610 --> 00:30:31,699 I'd never hurt Alice. I loved her. 492 00:30:33,353 --> 00:30:36,050 "She was on the ground. She was so scared. There was so much blood... 493 00:30:36,051 --> 00:30:38,444 I couldn't get it off my shoes." Who were you talking about Joe? 494 00:30:38,445 --> 00:30:39,967 - Who was on the ground bleeding - James! 495 00:30:39,968 --> 00:30:42,013 - Was it Alice or was it Yvonne? - I'm not the monster 496 00:30:42,014 --> 00:30:44,363 - that killed Yvonne Macy. - They both died in the same way Joe. 497 00:30:44,364 --> 00:30:47,148 No. It's different. What those boys did to that teacher was sick. 498 00:30:47,149 --> 00:30:49,629 No, no, no it is no different. Yvonne Macy was left bleeding to death 499 00:30:49,630 --> 00:30:52,153 in a car park, her head beaten over and over... 500 00:30:52,154 --> 00:30:53,938 Yeah with her knickers shoved in her mouth. 501 00:30:53,939 --> 00:30:56,202 You think I could do something sick like that? 502 00:30:56,942 --> 00:31:00,380 I'm not Billy Wells. You hear me. I'm not Billy Wells. 503 00:31:03,731 --> 00:31:04,993 Get me out of here, I wanna go back to me cell. 504 00:31:05,776 --> 00:31:07,386 Get me out! 505 00:31:07,387 --> 00:31:10,171 There were certain details defense and prosecution 506 00:31:10,172 --> 00:31:13,480 agreed to keep out of court to save the husband's feelings. 507 00:31:13,741 --> 00:31:16,875 But surely all the details of the offence were relevant to the trial? 508 00:31:17,136 --> 00:31:20,313 There were things those kids did that the press would've made a meal of. 509 00:31:20,574 --> 00:31:23,315 Painting them as would be rapists wouldn't have helped anybody. 510 00:31:23,316 --> 00:31:25,884 Just look at Billy Wells' file and answer me one question. 511 00:31:26,406 --> 00:31:28,974 Was Yvonne Macy found with her underwear in her mouth? 512 00:31:33,456 --> 00:31:36,590 I don't need to look. I know. 513 00:31:38,766 --> 00:31:39,767 It's true? 514 00:31:41,377 --> 00:31:43,423 It was never reported. It's not in the court transcript. 515 00:31:43,989 --> 00:31:46,860 The only way Joe Nash could know that sort of detail is if he was there 516 00:31:46,861 --> 00:31:48,080 when Yvonne Macy was murdered. 517 00:31:49,342 --> 00:31:51,605 Joe Nash is Billy Wells. 518 00:31:55,696 --> 00:32:00,047 The game's changed, George. Now we know Joe Nash is Billy Wells 519 00:32:00,048 --> 00:32:01,745 he needs to be charged accordingly. 520 00:32:02,398 --> 00:32:04,313 What difference does it make what his name is? 521 00:32:05,401 --> 00:32:07,577 He's done this before. Why should he get the soft option? 522 00:32:08,187 --> 00:32:10,536 He would never have got out of that hospital and you know it. 523 00:32:11,668 --> 00:32:13,105 And no one would ever be any the wiser? 524 00:32:15,542 --> 00:32:16,586 Is that so wrong? 525 00:32:18,153 --> 00:32:19,938 You don't think the public have a right to know the truth? 526 00:32:21,069 --> 00:32:22,636 And what do you think would happen then? 527 00:32:24,159 --> 00:32:25,595 I'm nobody's lapdog. 528 00:32:27,467 --> 00:32:30,426 I'm not gonna cover this up just so the Home Secretary saves face. 529 00:32:30,687 --> 00:32:32,863 You really think that's all this is about? 530 00:32:33,952 --> 00:32:34,953 Isn't it? 531 00:32:37,912 --> 00:32:39,087 If this gets out, 532 00:32:40,784 --> 00:32:43,787 the whole criminal justice system comes under fire. 533 00:32:45,093 --> 00:32:48,139 No child convicted at Her Majesty's pleasure 534 00:32:48,140 --> 00:32:50,532 will ever get the chance of release again. 535 00:32:50,533 --> 00:32:53,536 - This is about one case George-- - No it's not James, it's not. 536 00:32:54,973 --> 00:32:58,714 Sixty-seven percent of the public want to bring back the death penalty. 537 00:32:58,715 --> 00:33:01,152 There are MPs lobbying for that right now. 538 00:33:01,153 --> 00:33:03,110 This is the ammunition they need. 539 00:33:03,111 --> 00:33:05,984 We can't be governed by fear of the political fallout. 540 00:33:07,159 --> 00:33:09,726 It's not up to us to decide his fate. It's up to a jury. 541 00:33:10,075 --> 00:33:12,293 Assuming Billy Wells gets a jury trial. 542 00:33:12,294 --> 00:33:14,034 There's no risk of jury tampering here. 543 00:33:14,035 --> 00:33:15,819 There's a risk of trial by tabloid. 544 00:33:16,255 --> 00:33:18,604 Do you really think that we could find twelve good men 545 00:33:18,605 --> 00:33:21,564 and true who could try Billy Wells without prejudice? 546 00:33:21,825 --> 00:33:25,176 This is exactly the kind of case that could push the legislation 547 00:33:25,177 --> 00:33:26,482 into frightening territory. 548 00:33:27,962 --> 00:33:29,920 It could even spell the end of jury trials altogether. 549 00:33:31,748 --> 00:33:33,924 Are you asking me to be a part of a cover up? 550 00:33:36,449 --> 00:33:39,017 Sometimes the truth causes more harm than good. 551 00:33:42,759 --> 00:33:44,370 Talk to Eli Smart again. 552 00:33:45,240 --> 00:33:47,416 Maybe in the light of this new information 553 00:33:47,938 --> 00:33:50,028 you can persuade him to take the plea. 554 00:33:51,681 --> 00:33:56,817 Oh and James, do it before the DPP finds out what you've been up to, 555 00:33:57,426 --> 00:34:00,342 otherwise you could find yourself back in defense. 556 00:34:04,607 --> 00:34:06,478 You expect me to believe you didn't know? 557 00:34:06,479 --> 00:34:08,828 Look I swear, I thought he was loony tunes. 558 00:34:08,829 --> 00:34:11,223 - And now you know the truth? - It changes nothing. 559 00:34:11,614 --> 00:34:14,704 I was hired to defend Joe Nash and that's what I'm doing, 560 00:34:15,140 --> 00:34:17,141 regardless of who he used to be. 561 00:34:17,142 --> 00:34:20,493 This comes out, there is no way that he'll get a fair trial. 562 00:34:22,147 --> 00:34:24,540 It's in everyone's best interest to keep this out of court. 563 00:34:30,416 --> 00:34:32,809 Alright. I'll book a visit. 564 00:34:35,073 --> 00:34:36,596 Don't ask me how I got this. 565 00:34:42,123 --> 00:34:43,516 Billy Wells' prison records? 566 00:34:44,778 --> 00:34:46,345 I've flagged up the last section. 567 00:34:49,739 --> 00:34:51,915 It records identifying marks. 568 00:34:55,441 --> 00:34:59,271 Billy Wells has got a three-inch scar on his left arm from a suicide attempt. 569 00:35:01,490 --> 00:35:02,578 I'm not Billy Wells. 570 00:35:05,842 --> 00:35:06,887 Pull up your sleeve. 571 00:35:13,285 --> 00:35:14,460 Pull up your sleeve. 572 00:35:34,697 --> 00:35:36,221 I never tried to top meself. 573 00:35:38,048 --> 00:35:39,137 I wouldn't do that. 574 00:35:46,970 --> 00:35:48,885 Two lads held me down, 575 00:35:50,626 --> 00:35:53,151 cut me vein with a shiv and left me for dead. 576 00:35:57,546 --> 00:35:58,982 Everyone knew who I was. 577 00:36:00,680 --> 00:36:03,161 Used to leave nooses hanging in me cell... 578 00:36:05,075 --> 00:36:08,166 and when I didn't get the message, they tried to do it themselves. 579 00:36:13,867 --> 00:36:15,216 When I walked out of those gates, 580 00:36:16,522 --> 00:36:17,479 I vowed, 581 00:36:18,872 --> 00:36:21,135 I would never do anything to take me back there. 582 00:36:32,973 --> 00:36:33,974 Yes, 583 00:36:35,976 --> 00:36:37,020 I'm Billy Wells. 584 00:36:40,981 --> 00:36:42,374 But I've done my time. 585 00:36:45,420 --> 00:36:48,162 And I never killed Alice. 586 00:36:55,300 --> 00:36:56,388 Who killed her? 587 00:36:58,520 --> 00:36:59,956 Maybe it was one of those lads. 588 00:37:01,654 --> 00:37:05,527 Or maybe someone found out who I was and tried to frame me. 589 00:37:15,015 --> 00:37:17,539 The DNA evidence is gonna prove your guilt. 590 00:37:20,325 --> 00:37:22,631 Just take the deal while you still can... 591 00:37:24,198 --> 00:37:26,374 or you'll stay in prison for the rest of your life. 592 00:37:27,636 --> 00:37:29,072 I'm drowning in here. 593 00:37:30,335 --> 00:37:33,120 Don't you think I'd take the deal if I could? 594 00:37:34,556 --> 00:37:35,427 Billy... 595 00:37:37,080 --> 00:37:40,127 you do realize this is your last chance to change your plea? 596 00:37:43,304 --> 00:37:44,262 Find my diary. 597 00:37:45,785 --> 00:37:47,482 Read what prison did to me... 598 00:37:50,790 --> 00:37:52,879 and if you still think I killed Alice... 599 00:37:58,276 --> 00:37:59,973 I'll see you in court, Mr. Steel. 600 00:38:05,413 --> 00:38:06,501 Someone's got to have it? 601 00:38:07,807 --> 00:38:09,590 They searched Alice's flat and Joe's bedsit. 602 00:38:09,591 --> 00:38:12,201 You don't think it's gone the same way as Billy Wells' DNA? 603 00:38:12,202 --> 00:38:13,812 Ronnie and Matt supervised the search. 604 00:38:13,813 --> 00:38:15,641 If they found it, it would be in evidence. 605 00:38:16,294 --> 00:38:18,731 Would the diary have exposed Joe Nash as Billy Wells? 606 00:38:18,992 --> 00:38:20,646 Yeah according to Eli, 607 00:38:21,081 --> 00:38:23,604 it had every detail of coming to terms with his crime. 608 00:38:23,605 --> 00:38:26,260 Anyone who read it would know that he was Billy Wells. 609 00:38:31,700 --> 00:38:32,832 Why are you doing this? 610 00:38:35,051 --> 00:38:36,617 I don't understand. 611 00:38:36,618 --> 00:38:38,925 if you tell me what it is you're looking for, I can help. 612 00:38:47,499 --> 00:38:48,369 Matt! 613 00:38:57,509 --> 00:39:00,990 This is incredible. It tells us everything we need to know. 614 00:39:01,339 --> 00:39:04,516 He gave Alice the diary because he wanted her to know he was Billy Wells. 615 00:39:05,517 --> 00:39:07,562 Which would have threatened his new identity. 616 00:39:10,522 --> 00:39:13,176 Joe turned up in a right state, 617 00:39:14,352 --> 00:39:16,354 he said he'd had a fight with Alice. 618 00:39:17,964 --> 00:39:21,533 He gave me her keys and he begged me to get the diary back for him. 619 00:39:24,449 --> 00:39:26,276 Look, I had no idea he'd killed her. 620 00:39:31,238 --> 00:39:33,675 I went into the flat and I took the diary. 621 00:39:33,936 --> 00:39:36,068 Look it was stupid, but that's all I did. 622 00:39:36,069 --> 00:39:38,245 Charge me with theft if you like... 623 00:39:39,377 --> 00:39:40,856 You won't mind this, will you? 624 00:39:43,206 --> 00:39:44,643 Why would I? 625 00:39:55,175 --> 00:39:56,350 I crossed the line. 626 00:39:57,960 --> 00:39:59,962 I should never have allowed Joe to manipulate me like that. 627 00:40:00,659 --> 00:40:02,095 Joe was vulnerable. 628 00:40:03,313 --> 00:40:05,011 You were the one in the position of trust. 629 00:40:07,056 --> 00:40:09,188 You've no idea what it's like working that intimately with serious offenders. 630 00:40:17,676 --> 00:40:18,851 Mark this as urgent. 631 00:40:25,205 --> 00:40:27,686 We've got a DNA profile from the scene. 632 00:40:35,868 --> 00:40:38,435 - I'm not under arrest. - Sit down, Miss Renzo. 633 00:40:38,436 --> 00:40:40,742 - I'm free to go. - You're not going anywhere. Sit down! 634 00:40:53,886 --> 00:40:57,628 Twenty years I've worked in this job and I've never once got too close. 635 00:40:57,629 --> 00:41:00,153 And you never worked with a killer like Billy Wells before. 636 00:41:01,415 --> 00:41:02,460 Billy's no killer. 637 00:41:04,026 --> 00:41:06,201 It was Darren Pearce who killed that teacher. 638 00:41:06,202 --> 00:41:07,421 Billy didn't stop him. 639 00:41:09,379 --> 00:41:11,077 Billy watched his dad kick the shit out of his mum every day of his life. 640 00:41:11,991 --> 00:41:13,427 He was damaged. 641 00:41:13,688 --> 00:41:15,473 And along you came to fix him. 642 00:41:15,777 --> 00:41:17,038 He needed me. 643 00:41:17,039 --> 00:41:18,649 To get rid of anyone that came between you? 644 00:41:18,650 --> 00:41:20,086 Nobody came between us. 645 00:41:21,261 --> 00:41:24,307 He told me everything. 'Cause I was his lifeline. 646 00:41:25,134 --> 00:41:26,788 You didn't read his diary then? 647 00:41:29,922 --> 00:41:33,795 They were his private thoughts. I wouldn't do that. 648 00:41:34,404 --> 00:41:36,581 "I don't need Dani anymore. 649 00:41:38,017 --> 00:41:39,497 All I need is you Alice. 650 00:41:41,499 --> 00:41:44,327 I told her yesterday I want to stop the appointments..." 651 00:41:48,549 --> 00:41:51,683 Joe wrote those words in a message to Alice the day she died. 652 00:41:55,382 --> 00:41:57,339 He wouldn't have lasted five minutes without me. 653 00:41:57,340 --> 00:41:59,733 You blamed her for taking him away from you? 654 00:41:59,734 --> 00:42:01,126 No, you're wrong. 655 00:42:01,127 --> 00:42:03,345 - You were waiting for her in the car park. - No. 656 00:42:03,346 --> 00:42:04,999 If those hairs on her body are yours, 657 00:42:05,000 --> 00:42:07,524 you're gonna be psycho analyzing your cell mate in Cold Norton 658 00:42:07,525 --> 00:42:08,700 for the rest of your life. 659 00:42:13,966 --> 00:42:16,795 Okay, okay, okay I was there. But only to talk to her. 660 00:42:18,971 --> 00:42:20,320 They were making a mistake. 661 00:42:22,191 --> 00:42:23,279 She didn't love him. 662 00:42:24,672 --> 00:42:27,501 But he loved her, didn't he? 663 00:42:29,634 --> 00:42:31,549 They were getting married and you couldn't stand it. 664 00:42:32,201 --> 00:42:35,161 - She couldn't love Billy Wells. - But you could? 665 00:42:38,251 --> 00:42:40,644 - Is that what you went to tell her? - No I went to get the diary. 666 00:42:40,645 --> 00:42:41,950 But she didn't have it with her. 667 00:42:43,691 --> 00:42:46,606 I begged her to just give it to me but she wouldn't listen. 668 00:42:46,607 --> 00:42:47,695 So you attacked her? 669 00:42:49,392 --> 00:42:52,047 I grabbed her bag and she fell against the car door, she... 670 00:42:52,831 --> 00:42:55,529 hit her head, it was an accident. 671 00:42:56,399 --> 00:43:01,317 Alice's head was slammed against that car door over and over. 672 00:43:03,537 --> 00:43:05,147 It wasn't an accident, Daniela. 673 00:43:07,672 --> 00:43:09,543 Joe didn't ask you to get the diary for him. 674 00:43:10,892 --> 00:43:14,329 In fact, he trusted you so implicitly 675 00:43:14,330 --> 00:43:17,898 he never even suspected for one second that you killed the woman he loved! 676 00:43:17,899 --> 00:43:19,379 She said he was a monster... 677 00:43:20,772 --> 00:43:22,817 But you're the real monster, aren't you? 678 00:43:24,471 --> 00:43:27,038 You killed Alice, didn't you? Didn't you Daniela? 679 00:43:27,039 --> 00:43:28,823 I just wanted her to shut up. 680 00:43:32,479 --> 00:43:33,828 She didn't deserve him. 681 00:43:38,964 --> 00:43:44,360 He used to sit there on my sofa like a lost little boy 682 00:43:45,840 --> 00:43:50,628 and sometimes he sat so close to me I could smell the soap on his skin. 683 00:43:53,282 --> 00:43:56,677 I wanted to hold him, I wanted to tell him everything would be all right. 684 00:44:01,595 --> 00:44:06,861 I told him he couldn't marry someone who didn't know who he really was 685 00:44:08,515 --> 00:44:10,691 and he thought I wanted him to tell her. 686 00:44:11,213 --> 00:44:14,216 You knew better than anyone what prison did to Billy, 687 00:44:16,349 --> 00:44:19,438 but you were prepared to let him rot in there for the rest of his life 688 00:44:19,439 --> 00:44:20,962 just to save your own skin. 689 00:44:22,007 --> 00:44:26,359 I could've worked with him, made sure he was all right. 690 00:44:28,491 --> 00:44:29,667 Don't you mean control him? 691 00:44:31,799 --> 00:44:33,671 Keep him dependent on you? 692 00:44:36,761 --> 00:44:38,197 What sort of love is that? 693 00:44:39,764 --> 00:44:41,330 He'd be lost without me. 694 00:44:43,724 --> 00:44:46,814 Whatever happened in his life, good or bad 695 00:44:47,249 --> 00:44:50,513 it was me that he came running to. 696 00:44:51,427 --> 00:44:53,386 Did you know Alice was pregnant? 697 00:44:56,084 --> 00:44:57,085 That's... 698 00:45:03,439 --> 00:45:05,354 Maybe he didn't tell you everything after all. 699 00:45:08,227 --> 00:45:09,141 That's... 700 00:45:10,925 --> 00:45:13,711 Daniela Renzo, I am arresting you for the murder of Alice Cullen. 701 00:45:14,059 --> 00:45:17,278 You do not have to say anything but it may harm your defense 702 00:45:17,279 --> 00:45:19,194 if you do not mention when questioned... 703 00:45:31,380 --> 00:45:32,730 Billy Wells' release papers. 704 00:45:36,777 --> 00:45:37,952 He's a free man! 705 00:45:41,129 --> 00:45:44,176 Billy was found hanging in his cell two hours ago. 706 00:45:47,614 --> 00:45:48,789 He killed himself? 707 00:45:54,839 --> 00:45:57,145 You believe that if it helps you sleep at night.